Forensic Odontology
Forensic Odontology
Forensic Odontology
CONTENTS
• Introduction (Definition)
• History of Forensic odontology /India
• Aim of forensic odontology
• Personal identification methods
• Dental Identification
• DNA identification
• Palatal rugae identification
• Dental Profiling
• Crime Investigation by Bite marks, lip prints
• Denture marking
• Forensic in disaster management
• Case reports
• Recent advances forensics
• Conclusion
INTRODUCTION
• Forensic Odontology or Forensic Dentistry is that branch of forensic medicine
which, in the interest of justice, deals with the proper handling and examination of dental
evidence and with the proper evaluation and presentation of the dental findings. - Kieser-
Neilson (1970)
• Dr. Oscar Amoedo was considered as the father of the forensic odontologist. The
thesis done by him entitled 'L' Art Dentaire en Medicine Leagale' to the faculty of
medicine earned him a doctorate. This book is the first comprehensive text on forensic
odontology.
HISTORY
• Garden of Eden – Eve convinced Adam to put a bite mark in apple. The history of bite
mark evidence (forensic dentistry) began with the eating of forbidden fruit by Adam in
the Garden of Eden.
• 66 AD - Emperor Nero’s wife, who was identified after her death through unique
arrangement of her teeth. Nero’s mistress Sabina ,got Nero’s wife killed by her soldiers
and demanded to see her head in a dish (identified by a black anterior tooth)
• 1193 - First forensic identification in India – Jai Chand, a great Indian monarchy was
destroyed by Muhammad’s army. His body was identified by his false anterior teeth.
• 1758 - Peter Halket was killed during French and Indian war in a battle near Fort
Duquesne. Halket son identified his father’s skeleton by an artificial tooth.
• 1775 - Paul Revere – identified victims of a revolutionary war by their teeth; Also,
identified the body of Joseph Warren by identifying a walrus tusk used as a pontic for
missing maxillary canine.
• 1897 - Dr. Oscar Amoedo – Paper titled - The role of the Dentists in the identification
of the victims of the catastrophe of the Bazar de la Charite, Paris in 4th May, 1897 .The
bodies of those killed in the fire were brought to the industrial place for dental
identification.
• 1977 - Bodies of Hitler and his wife Eva Braun – identified using dental records with
radiographs and prostheses. Finally, remnants of a bridge were identified in the pieces of
Hilter's jaw because of the unusual form of reconstruction and evidence of periodontal
diseases.
• 1985 - Forensic examination of biological samples - application of the ABO blood
group system for human identification .Jeffreys et al - investigated radioactive molecular
probes that could identify certain highly sensitive regions of DNA that processed a type
of DNA “fingerprint” (determining immigration problem).
• 2001 - World trade center disaster in the U.S.A on September 11, 2001 - Deoxyribo
Nucleic Acid (DNA) extracts from tooth brushes of the victims were used in
identification of some victims
INDIA
• May 21, 1991- Rajiv Gandhi Assassination.
• It compared with the assassination of John F Kennedy of USA.
• In the investigation out of 18 bodies, 17 bodies inclusive of Rajiv Gandhi body were
identified.
• The one body of dismembered parts which was correlated with skin, absence of body
hair, same nail polish color on fingers and toe nails, and finally concluded that it was a
female, who was the human bomb.
• Dr. P. Chandrasekaran, Director, Tamil Nadu Forensic Science Laboratory, Madras-
stated that DNA found in the charred muscle pieces and the skull on the suicide bomber,
Dhanu showed identical pattern
VEERAPPAN IDENTITY
• The trademark of Veerappan was the handlebar moustache on his face, which was
missing when he was shot dead by Special Task Force personnel in Dharmapuri District
of Tamil Nadu.
• Experts of forensic - confirmed by the study of the external ear.
• Dr. P. Chandrasekaran, studied the structures of the external ear from ante and
post-mortem photographs of Veerappan, compared them and confirmed that it was
sandalwood smuggler
AIM OF FORENSIC ODONTOLOGY
• Total of all characteristics of teeth and their associated structures which, while not
individually unique, when considered together provide a unique totality - Acharya and
Taylor
• Eliciting the ethnicity/population affinity
• Age estimation in both the living and dead
• Presenting evidence in court of law as expert witness
• Analysis and investigation of bite marks, found on human tissue, animal tissue, and
inanimate objects/foodstuffs
• Assisting the sex of skeletonized remains.
PERSONAL IDENTIFICATION
AGE
Estimate by Development Of Skull And Bone
SEX
Skull Shape – Males Larger Skull With Sqaure Orbit, Females-smaller ,Round Skull With
Minimal Supra Orbital Ridge And Vertical Forehead
SOCIO-ECONOMIC STATUS
Quantity / Quality And Presence / Absence Of Dental Treatment
OCCUPATION
Carpenter – Characteristic Groove by Holding Pin between Teeth
DIETARY HABITS
High Alcoholic - Erosion of Teeth
ANCESTARY BACKGROUND
Determine Race between Three Groups – Skull Appearance – Caucasoid , Mongoloid ,
Negroid
DENTAL IDENTIFICATION
• Human dentition are never the same in any two individual
• Morphology and arrangement of teeth vary from person to person
• Although teeth are relatively resistant to environmental insult after death, during life they
are susceptible to physiologic and pathologic change.
• 2 forms of post-mortem dental identification.
i) Comparative Dental Identification , ii) Reconstructive Identification.
COMPARATIVE DENTAL IDENTIFICATION
• Oral Autopsy
• Obtaining dental records
• Comparing post mortem and Ante-mortem dental data
• Writing a report and drawing conclusion
Dental evidence such as dental caries, missing teeth, restored teeth, prosthesis, alterations in
shape of teeth such as taurodontism, talons cusp, developmental defects such as amelogenesis
imperfecta, dentinogenesis imperfecta, changes in colour of teeth like dental flurosis collected
from human remains is compared with previous records for establishing identity of the decedent.
ORAL AUTOPSY
Autopsy – necropsy or post-mortem examination – involves examining deceased with
dissection to expose the organs to determine the cause of death.
Systematic Protocol- Critical Examination of external features of the body
- Sex, Ethnicity, Build, Wounds , Scars , Tattoos , Body piercing.
Oral examination:
- Rigor mortis , Livor mortis , Decomposition ,Post-mortem artefacts
• Griffiths & Ballamy - Radiography of the incinerated bodies – obtained by removing
tongue and contents of floor of the mouth “tunnelling fashion” beneath the chin;
• A thorough examination of soft tissue injury, paraoral hard tissue fractures and presence
of foreign bodies undertaken;
• All information pertaining to body – entered into modified Interpol post-mortem
odontogram/dental form
Comparing post and ante-mortem dental data
• Following post-mortem examination and transcription of ante-mortem data 2
odontograms are compared.
• Acharya and Taylor – single point of concordance between post and ante-mortem data –
sufficient to establish identity - considering course, uniqueness of such a feature and
circumstance of the case;
Ante - and Post mortem dental data match with each other
Positive Identity proven beyond reasonable doubt (radiographs)
Identification
High level of concordance between the 2 sets of data; lack R/G support
Probable Cannot confirm identity
Identification
• 1985 - Alec Jeffreys, UK, first developed DNA profiling along with Peter Gill and David
Werrett.
• The UK today maintains DNA profiles of nearly 7% of its citizens, representing the
largest population proportion in the world
• Largest DNA database was set up by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). The
database contains more than 12 million offender profiles, more than 2.5 million arrestee
profiles and 750,000 forensic profiles.
DNA Based Technology (Use and Regulation) Bill, 2017
• Only for identification
• DNA Profiling Board – Monitoring DNA lab
• DNA data bank - Stroage of DNA profile
• Penalties – Imprisonement- 3years
RECENT METHODS IN GENETIC IDENTIFICATION:
Microarray techniques:
- The nucleic acids of the target are hybridized to high-density microarrays containing
several thousand oligonucleotides immobilized on chips or beads
- Use: Sequencing and resequencing, identification of the individual
Next generation genome sequencing:
- Permits analysis of several hundred loci or even the entire genome by producing
enormously parallel sequencing.
- used for both genome and transcriptome analysis
PALATAL RUGAE IN FORENSIC
• The rugae pattern on the deceased’s maxilla or maxillary denture – compared to old
dentures recovered from decedent’s residence or treating dentist.
• The pattern of these rugae can be used as definitive method in post-mortem cases and is
considered special to an individual.
• Palatal rugae in every individual maintain the shape and consistency throughout life
• Rugae patterns are unique to every individual; seldom change shape with age and
reappear after trauma or surgery;
• Palatal rugae resist decomposition;
• Primary Rugae - > 5mm
• Secondary Rugae - 3-5mm
• Fragment Rugae -< 3mm
• Straight , Curved , Wavy , Circular
SEX DIFFERENTIATION:
- Morphology of skull and mandible
- Tooth measurements & DNA Analysis of teeth
- Sex determined from necrotic pulp tissue stained by Quinacrine mustard for fluorescent
Y chromosome (teeth of males).
- Amelogenin or AMEL is a major protein- Female has two identical AMEL genes
whereas the male has two different AMEL genes.
- Maxillary sinus width , length by CT
Whittaker et al. found the method slightly less reliable than they had claimed but were still able to
determine sex in about 70% of cases.
Dange et al. have claimed that sexing is possible up to 4 years after death.
1) VISUAL METHOD
Different in tooth size
Canine Dimorphism.
2) MICROSCOPIC METHOD
Barr body & DNA analysis
3) ADVANCED
PCR & Amelogenin
DENTAL AGE ESTIMATION
INDICATORS OF AGE:
• Beyond young adulthood the problem becomes considerably more difficult.
• Six criteria of ageing in individual teeth was developed by Gustafson:,
• Attrition , Amount of secondary dentine and cementum , Root resorption , level of
Periodontal attachment , Dentin translucency.
• Age – (11.43+ 3.63X) years
• The degree of error using this method lies somewhere between + 3.7 years and + 7 years
depending upon the experience of' the investigator.
AMINO ACID RACEMIZATION
• Amino acid two different configuration ( D or L)
• Living organism keeps L configuration , if organisms dies control over the configuration
ceases , and the ratio of D and L moves from a value near 0 towards an equilibrium value
near 1. it is called racemization.
• Helfman and bada first suggested , age estimation by aspartic acid racemization
• Accurate within ± 3 years of actual age.
AMELOGLYPHICS:
• Tooth prints are pattern formed by the enamel rod ends at the crown surface of the tooth;
• Manjunath et al. recorded enamel rod pattern using acetate peel technique;
• Involved left maxillary canine and first premolar in 30 male and 30 female volunteers –
categorized tooth print into 8 patterns – showed no teeth had similar pattern.
• Enamel rod pattern - Showed gender variations
• Aid in person identification.
DISADVANTAGES DENTAL IDENTIFICATION
• Discrepancy if person had additional dental treatment in time interval between the dates
of antemortem and postmortem dental records
• Poor quality of antemortem records , if Patient treated in emergency basis with no record
• Inability to locate and obtain suitable antemortem records
• Deceased person is not of same area
• Large variety of tooth nomenclature in different parts of the world
BITE MARKS IN CRIME INVESTIGATION
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AND CHILD ABUSE:
• Child abuse is a non-accidental trauma tried on a child by a caretaker - the head and
facial areas are frequently offended
• In abuse cases, human bite marks are mainly seen and followed by other injuries;
• Bites from adults will often only mark one arch while a child who has bitten will
frequently mark with both arches
• The WHO differentiates four types of violence; Sexual, Neglect, Physical and
Psychological.
•
The shape of
curvature
Bite marks analysis by Kouble and
• No of tooth marks
Craig
• Horizontal &
Vertical diameter
• Depth of
depression
• Distances between
two teeth
• Orientation of each
tooth
DIRECT INDIRECT
The model of suspects’ teeth is compared to a Use of transparent overlays to record a
life size photograph of the actual bite mark. suspect’s biting edges by free-hand tracing the
Direct comparison is made between dental occlusal surfaces of a dental model onto an
models, photographs or finger print powder lift acetate sheet
models.
The “fingerprint powder lift” technique involves dusting the bitten skin with fingerprint
powder
and using fingerprint tape to transfer the bite marks onto a sheet of acetate.
SALIVA SWAB:
• Saliva deposited in the skin may have WBC and sloughed epithelial cells - source of
DNA - enable direct link to suspect
• Methods of detection of dried saliva stains:Chemicals and enzymes , Lasers and
ultraviolet light , Fluorescent spectroscopy
IMPRESSION
• Vinyl polysiloxane , dental acrylic & plaster
• Incisal or • Equipment
• Simple occlusal Intensive
• Suspects
instruments edges of • Image
model –
like vernier suspect’s perception
directly
calliper or teeth traced technology
placed on
computer into clear • Additional
bitemark
software acetate and colouring of
photograph or
• Copared with super images, pseudo
on bite mark
suspect’s imposed on three dimension
itself
dental model bite mark imaging all of
photograph which improves
accuracy.
• Usually at crime scene lip prints are usually found, which can provide a direct link to the
suspect.
• Lipsticks have been developed in recent years that do not leave any visible trace after
contact with the glass surface, clothing or cigarette butts.
• They are referred as persistent lip prints for the permanence. However, they are invisible;
they can be lifted by using materials such as aluminum powder and magnetic bonds
DENTURE MARKING
Scratching or engraving an identity mark onto the
surface of the denture using a spirit based pen before
Surface Marking covering them with a denture based acylic.
•It has been shown that even prosthesis like dentures can be used to identify deceased
individuals - denture marking
• The identification mark should be specific ,be simple & should be fire and solvent
resistant.
- Victims of fatal accidents, misplaced dentures in hospitals, nursing homes, as well as
patients suffering from any psychiatric problems such as traumatic or senile loss of
memory
FORENSIC IN DISASTERS
• Involves examining and comparing of hundreds, thousands of ante- and post- mortem
data
• According to Clark, 50% of identification in disasters are from dental evidence;
• Division of dental section:
COMPARISON AND IDENTIFICATION
• Manual or Computer aid
• Computer software programmes – IDENTIFY, ODONTID, CAPMI, IDIS;
Recently “Plass Data DVI System Internationale;
• These programmes- sort data, bring down the number to few likely post and
antemortem data;
• Final identification done manually.
ANTEMORTEM UNIT
• No common system of tooth numbering around the world;
• Restorations are named by the letter of tooth surface involved;
• Regional dental association to implement standardized code for various tooth
surfaces
• Locating dental records of victim (communication with police, dentist and
relatives of victim)
POSTMORTEM UNIT –
• At disaster site, a sketch to be made of the scene
• Location of body recovered – noted
• Definitive dental examination- after photography, finger printing and medical
autopsy
• Unit responsible for processing the radiographs; photography of teeth
• Teeth and Jaw specimen removed from the body and labelled.
• The four main steps are there; finger printing, body tagging and bagging, forensic
pathology, and forensic dentistry.
• Forensic dentistry team was sub-divided into two parts; dental examination and dental
radiology.
• Prosthodontist can play an important role in forensic dentistry team
DISASTERS – TSUNAMI
• Transport accidents –Dental identification required;
• Aircraft accidents - Fire and trauma are severe;
• Dental examination confounded – heat and flames have fragmented tooth enamel, and
soot and smoke have been deposited on teeth;
• The 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami is probably the most eminent example on the success of
Forensic Odontologists in identifying large number of victims in short time. More than
92% of non-Thai is been identified out of which 80% were identified by dental
formation.
AIR CRASH
• It occurred in which all the passengers died along with the crew at the distance about 8
miles away from the coast of California.
• All the bodies except a few were fragmented. Out of 88 victims, eighty-five was
identified, and 65 persons were eventually identified by conventional means.
• Conventional means include the routine examination, dental comparisons, tattoos and
fingerprints. 23 victims were identified by DNA testing.
• Many fragment of the body was found by the fisherman, navy and the use of fishnets.
Impersonating face and figure prints is easy but it is nearly impossible to impersonate the dental
record. Indian court - Decision on juvenility of Mohammed Ajmal Kasab, the lone survivor of
Mumbai terror attacks of 26/11;The court had ordered a radiologist and forensic dentist to
examine Kasab, and it was proved that he was not a juvenile.
REFERENCES
• Shafer, Hine, Levy. Textbook of Oral Pathology. 7th ed. Elsevier ;2012
• Saranya V, Malathi. N. Forensic Odontology: A Brief Review. SRJM2014;7:22-28
• Balachander N, Babu NA, Jimson S, Priyadharsini C, Masthan K. Evolution of forensic
odontology: An overview. J Pharm Bioall Sci 2015;7:S176-80
• Anoop Jain, Ramesh Chowdhary. Palatal rugae and their role in forensic odontology.
Journal of Investigative and Clinical Dentistry 2013;4:1–8
• Manjunath K1, Sivapathasundharam B, Saraswathi TR. Analysis of enamel rod end
patterns on tooth surface for personal identification-ameloglyphics. J Forensic Sci
2012;57:789-93
• Garg Y, Bhaskar DJ, Agali CR, Garg K. Forensic Dentistry: An Aid in Criminal
Investigation. Int J Dent Med Res 2015;1(6):160-163.
• Saxena S, Kumar S. Saliva in forensic odontology: A comprehensive update. J Oral
Maxillofac Pathol 2015;19:263-5.
• Arora KS, Kaur P. Role of forensic odontology in the Indian Armed Forces: An
unexplored arena. J Forensic Dent Sci 2016;8:173
• B Rai, S Anand. Role of Forensic Odontology in Tsunami Disasters. The Internet Journal
of Forensic Science.2006 ;2(1)
• Acharya AB. Role of forensic odontology in disaster victim identification in the Indian
context. J Dent Specialities, 2015;3(1):89-91