Great Indian Mathematicians of Post-Christian Era: April 2010
Great Indian Mathematicians of Post-Christian Era: April 2010
Great Indian Mathematicians of Post-Christian Era: April 2010
net/publication/305200319
CITATIO READS
NS
14,478
0
1 author:
Bhowmik Subrata
Tripura University
40 PUBLICATIONS 20 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Bhowmik Subrata on 12 July 2016.
Here our aim is to know some history of our Indian Mathematicians in the
post- Christian era. But it will be a little injustice if we do not first recall the history of
Mathematics in very very short maner of Pre-Christian Era, that will help us to pride to
our History of Mathematics and our Indian Mathematicians.
The History study of the Mathematics in Indian and the history of
Indian Mathematicians is a highly prestigious matter for us as Indians. Mathematics is the subject,
if its manuscript or its written document, specially in detail is not available, then it is very
much difficult to know how much the history contributed in this subject, it is the mater of regret for
us that - for India that happened, either there is no information about the documents or documents
was destroyed or not available. Form the ancient time, it is better to say from the Harappa and
Indus Valley Civilization (mature period 2600–1900 BC) the subject Mathematics was
highly studied by us and also that was also used in practical also, this can be easily understand from
their high developed engineering and in their practical life, it impossible without high development
in mathematics – geometry, number system etc. But we have no document to know upto what level
they were developed.
After Harappa and Indus Valley Civilization the Vedic age came, we have
some documents of that time, and from that the SulvaSutras is the most important mater of our
pride. There are lots of SulvaSutras of different Asramas in Vedic age, some of most important
are Bauddyayan SulbaSutra(800 BC) the oldest, Katyayan SulbaSutra(500 BC),
Apastan SulbaSutra(400 BC), Manav SulbaSutra(500-200 BC) etc. Some of the
SulvaSutras was destroyed by the time, so lots of informations have lost. These SulvaSutras are
rich of geometry, we will be surprise to know that almost all the theorems of Euclidean Geometry
(around 300 BC) was already in the SulvaSutras, The Elements of Euclid (323–283 BC)
contains only 467 theorem, but only in Bauddyayan SulbaSutra(800 BC) there are 525 geometric
theorems which is much more that the Euclids Elements(around 300 BC) long before the
Elements. So we can imagine if we include all the theorems of SulvaSutras what will be the
number, there are lots of SulvaSutras of different Asrramas, some of them is not also
available. The well known Pythagorean theorem as we know discovered by Pythagora(570-
495 BC) was already in Bauddyayan SulbaSutra(800 BC) in the form of following form:
“Deerghacaturashrashya crayarajjhuh parshyamanee tirjanmanee ca
jatpritthagbhute kurutostudubhayang koroti ”
that is: “Whatever (area) the length and breath of a rectangle produce separately, the
diagonal of the rectangle produce that (area).”
As our aim is to catch the Post-Christian ear, we are not going in detail of the History
of Mathematics of Pre-Christian era, let us stop here.
India is studying Mathematics and Astronomy from its far ancient time. But
the growth of Mathematical and Astronomical sciences during the post-Christian era is the
most glorious chapter in India. India gave birth a series of great mathematicians in this period. Here
we will take some of their names.
ARYABHATA
(476-550)AD
The great Indian Mthematician-Astronomer, Aryabhata was born in 476 AD
at Pataliputra (near Patna) and at the young age 23 wrote his famous book on Astronomy,
Aryabhatiya. He made the discovery that the earth rotates round its axis, but thousand year later
Galileo(1564-1642) and Copernicus(1473–1543) have to suffer a lot only to uttering this
truth and even they were in the position to stop their scientific study and research, but no such thing
happened in Indian with Aryabhata. His other scientific contribution include: discovery of
trigonometric sine, accurate evaluation of π, perfection of decimal system of numbers, evaluation
of AP and GP series and square and cube root of numbers, accurate calculation of number of days
in solar year(upto seventh decimal point which is better than Ptolem’s[about 85 –
165
AD]figure), discovery of the causes of solar and lunar eclipses, prediction of duration and angular
extent of eclipse etc.— a long list indeed.
He is the first person who gave the accurate value of π up to four decimal places which
is 3.1416, no other one have done such achievement in that century.
Aryabhata was the pioneer to introduce the concept of ‘Bijganita’ or Algebra. .
Aryabhata is the first person who invented the modern method of finding square root,
but this was started by the western mathematicians long long after the Aryabhata, this was staterd
by Catanio(1546 AD) and Cataldi(1613 AD) in the west first.
Aryabhata was also the first person who gave the general integral solution of
linear Diophantine equation ax+by=c in his Aryabhatiya, which was also first started by
west long long after him.
He had been truly the first and the foremost mathematical genius, produced by
the human race and a forerunner of Newton and other European mathematicians who were to be
born more than thousand years later.
Varahmihira(505-587)
One treatise which Varahamihira summarises was the Romaka-Siddhanta which itself
was based on the epicycle theory of the motions of the Sun and the Moon given by the Greeks in
st
the 1 century AD. The Romaka-Siddhanta was based on the tropical year of Hipparchus and on
the Metonic cycle of 19 years. Other works which Varahamihira summarises are also based on the
Greek epicycle theory of the motions of the heavenly bodies. He revised the calendar by
updating these earlier works to take into account precession since they were written. The
Pancasiddhantika also contains many examples of the use of a place-value number system.
Another important contribution to trigonometry was his sine tables where he improved
those of Aryabhata giving more accurate values. It should be emphasized that accuracy was very
important for these Indian mathematicians since they were computing sine tables for applications to
astronomy and astrology.
The Jaina school of mathematics investigated rules for computing the number of ways in
which r objects can be selected from n objects over the course of many hundreds of years.
n
They gave rules to compute the binomial coefficients Cr which amount to
n
Cr = n(n-1)(n-2)...(n-r+1)/r!
n
However, Varahamihira attacked the problem of computing Cr in a rather different
way. He wrote the numbers n in a column with n = 1 at the bottom. He then put the numbers r in
rows with r = 1 at the left-hand side. Starting at the bottom left side of the array which
n
corresponds to the values n = 1, r = 1, the values of Cr are found by summing two
entries, namely the one directly below the (n, r) position and the one immediately to the
left of it. Of course this table is none other than Pascal's triangle for finding the binomial
coefficients despite being viewed from a different angle from the way we build it up today. For
example a short table with n=5 is shown below:
r 1 2 3 4 5
n
1 1
2 2 1
3 3 3 1
4 4 6 4 1
5 5 10 10 5 1
BHRMAGUPTA(598-668)AD
Brahmagupta was born in Ujjain. After Aryabhata and Varahamihira, substantial advancements
in Indian mathematics and astronomy were due to Brahmagupta in sevent century He born in
598 AD near Multan. Brahmagupta flourished in Ujjain where he wrote the astronomical treatise:
Brahmasphutasiddhanta(628 AD) and Khandakhadaka(664 AD). He was an opponent of
Aryabhata’s theory that earth rotates round the sun. However, he substantially improved
Aryabhata’s method of astronomical calculation and computation of latitude and longitude.
In his Brahmaphutasiddhanta, he extensively dealt with the properties of cyclic
quadrilateral and trapezium and the relationbetween their sides, diagonals and area.
Aryabhata have prepared the sine table, Brahmagupta , in his Khandakhadaka stated a
new method to find out the intermediate sine values from the Aryabhata’s sine tabe values, after
one thousand year Newton(1642-1727) and other mathematicians rediscovered this theory by the
name of “Theory of Interpolation”, but very few knows this fact, this was due to the fact that no
one after him took interest in this method.
Lalla(About
720-790 AD)
In the eight centuary, Lalla amended Aryabhata’s work. Lalla's most famous work was
entitled Shishyadhividdhidatantra. This major treatise was in two volumes. The first volume, On
the computation of the positions of the planets, was in thirteen chapters and covered topics such as:
mean longitudes of the planets; true longitudes of the planets; the three problems of diurnal
rotation; lunar eclipses; solar eclipses; syzygies; risings and settings; the shadow of the moon; the
moon's crescent; conjunctions of the planets with each other; conjunctions of the planets with the
fixed stars; the patas of the moon and sun, and a final chapter in the first volume which forms a
conclusion. The second volume was On the sphere. In this volume Lalla examined topics such as:
graphical representation; the celestial sphere; the principle of mean motion; the terrestrial sphere;
motions and stations of the planets; geography; erroneous knowledge; instruments; and
finally selected problems.
Mahavira(800
-870 AD)
Mahavira, the Jain mathematician was the notable commentator of Brahmagupat’s idea
during the ninth century. In his Ganitasarasangraha, he was concerned with the properties
of right-angled triangles, area and circumferance of ellipse, geometric progression series and so on.
He used his mathematical knowledge in various calculation on excavation and shadows.
Mahavira was of the Jaina religion and was familiar with Jaina mathematics. The
only known book by Mahavira is Ganita Sara Samgraha( 850 AD). It consisted of nine chapters
and included all mathematical knowledge of mid-ninth century India. It provides us with the bulk
of knowledge which we have of Jaina mathematics and it can be seen as in some sense providing
an account of the work of those who developed this mathematics. There were many Indian
mathematicians before the time of Mahavira but, perhaps surprisingly, their work on mathematics
is always contained in texts which discuss other topics such as astronomy. The Ganita
Sara Samgraha by Mahavira is the earliest Indian text which we possess which is devoted entirely
to mathematics. Ganita Sara Samgraha contaims: Terminology, Arithmetical
operations, Operations involving fractions, Miscellaneous operations, Operations involving the rule
of three, Mixed operations, Operations relating to the calculations of areas, Operations
relating to excavations, Operations relating to shadows.
Among topics Mahavira discussed in his treatise was operations with fractions including
methods to decompose integers and fractions into unit fractions. For example
2 1 1 1
/17 = /12 + /51 + /68.
Mahavira also attempts to solve certain mathematical problems which had not
been studied by other Indian mathematicians. For example, he gave an approximate
formula for the area and the perimeter of an ellipse.
SRIDARA(870-930)
Sridhara was possibly of Bengle. Sridhara is known as the author of two mathematical
treatises, namely the Trisatika (sometimes called the Patiganitasara ) and the Patiganita.
However at least three other works have been attributed to him, namely the Bijaganita, Navasati,
and Brhatpati. Information about these books was given the works of
Bhaskaracharya(writing around 1150), Makkibhatta (writing in 1377), and Raghavabhatta
(writing in 1493). Sridhara's gave the well known rule for solving quadratic equations
popularly known as sridharacharya’s formulas, as:
“ Caturahata borgosomoi rhupoiah paksadwayang gunhayet⏐
abyakto borgorhupoiryuktaoo pokshoo toto mhulom
⏐⏐”
2
in modern mathematical language: If the quadratic equation is ax + bx + c = 0, then his
2 2
steps to solve it as: Step I: 4a x + 4abx + 4ac = 0
2 2
Step II: (2ax + b) + 4ac = b
2
Step III: 2ax + b = ±√( b - 4ac)
−b 2
(b −4ac). )/2a
Step IV: ( -b ±
but it is still under question, whether he have taken both the roots or not.
Manjula(10th
Century AD)
Manjula, the author of Laghumanasa(932 AD), Siddhantsekhara(1039 AD) extended
the concepts of Indian astronomy and mathematics. Manjula was aware about the knowledge of the
modern mathematics calculus, and the claim that it is discovered by Isac Newton(1642-1727) and
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz (1646-1716) is totally wrong.
Manjula in his Laghumanasa represented the infinitesimal increment of the functions
like u = v ± e sinθ as du = dv ± e (cos θ) dθ , which clearly shows the knowledge of calculus in
Manjula.
Bhaskaracharya
(1114-1185 AD)
Bhaskarachary born in Vijayapura. It is said that Bhaskaracharya was the last
astronomer-mathematician of repute produced by ancient India. His Sidhantasiromoni(1150 AD)
was divided into four part: Lilavati (rule of arithmetic), Vijaganita (on algebra, root extraction),
Grahaganitadhya (motion of planets) and Golodhyaya (on calculation of sphere).
Bhaskaracharya advanced the concept of Bijganit or algebra. He dealt on
algorithm, zero and its use, unknown quantities, surds, the pulverized or ‘kuttaka’, solution of
quadratic equations and of certain equation of third and fourth degree.
H.T.Colebrooke in his book “Algebra, with arithmetic and mensuration from
Sanskrit of Brahmagupta and Bhaskaracharya”(London, 1817) writes:
“ The point in which the Hindu Algebra appear particularly distinguished from
Greek, are, besides a better and more comprehensive algorithm, first, the management of equation
involving more than one unknown term, the second the resolution of equation of higher order,
anticipating a modern discovery in the solution of biquadratic, third, general methods for the
st nd
solution of indeterminate problem of 1 and 2 degree, and lastly, application of algebra to
astronomical investigation and geometrical demostration.”
2 2
The full solution of Pellian equation ax +e=y and its more general form
2 2
ax +bx+c=y was given by Bhaskara, who developed the “cyclic” method. H.Hankel wrote in his
‘Zur Geschichte der Mathematik’ of this method: “It is beyond all praise; it is certainly the finest
thing achieved in the theory of numbers before Lagrange.”
We can be proud to know that, Newton’s(1642-1727) invented gravitational force was already
spelt out by our Bhaskarachary in his ‘Siddhantosiromoni’ 500 years beforeN“ Akristishakti
Mohee tatha yatkhasthang guru swabhimukhang yashakya │
Akriswatee tatpatateeb bhati somee somontatakwa patatwiyang khe││”
That is: “The earth has attraction power, due to this power heavy mater in the air
comes down to the earth by attraction. With the attractions of the planets and the stars in all the
direction, it is uncertain, where the earth will fall down.”
The modern mathematics “Differential Calculus” , as we know invented by Isac
Newton(1642-1727) and Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz (1646-1716), clear work was already in the
work of Bhaskaracharya, almost 500 years ago from the time of so known
western mathematicians discovered that. But the work stopped in the beginning, after him no one
th
looked at that. But the actual beginning was started by Manjula(10 Century AD), but clear
concept has been seen in the work of Bhaskaracharya. Not only “Differential Calculus”
there are lot of Mathematical concepts that has already been discovered by our Indian
Mathematicians hundreds and thousands years ago from their rediscovery in the west, but we are so
uninterested about our Mathematicians that we only know the name of the western
Mathematicians who rediscovered the old concept as the real discoverer. It is a matter of regret for
us.
To calculate the regular motion of the planets he applied “Tatkalika” method or by
“Tatkalika goti” or instantaneous velocity—he subdivide the a day into infinitesimal time
length “Muhurta” or moment and differentiate the situation of a planet in each two consecutive
“Muhurta”. By “ Tatkalika goti” at a moment means the speed at that moment. For that purpose he
knew the differential of sine function. For that his formula was in his word:
“Bibarddhaswa koti jyagun strijyaharah phalang dorjyayontarang│”
Bhaskara also goes deeper into the 'differential calculus' and suggests
the differential coefficient vanishes at an extremum value of the function, indicating deep
knowledge of “Differential Calculus”.
He also gives the well known results for sin(a + b) and sin(a - b). There is also
evidence of an early form of Rolle's(1652 – 1719) theorem;
“ if f(a) = f(b) = 0 then f '(x) = 0 for some x with a < x< b,”
in Bhaskara's work.
Madhava(1350-1425)AD
Madhva of Sangamagramma (near Cochin), Kerala. All the mathematical writings of Madhava
have been lost, although some on astronomy have survived.
However his brilliant work in mathematics has been largely discovered by the reports of other
Keralese mathematicians such as Nilakantha(1444 – 1544)
ca⏐
tyadina kritah⏐”
2 4
cos θ = 1 - θ /2! + θ /4! - ...
3 5
and θ = tan θ - (tan θ)/3 + (tan θ)/5 - ...
-1 3 5
tan θ = θ - θ /3 + θ /5 - ...
Perhaps even more impressive is the fact that Madhava gave a remainder term for his series
which improved the approximation. He improved the approximation of the series for π/4 by
adding a correction term Rn to obtain
Rn = 1/(4n) or
2
Rn = n/(4n + 1) or
2 3
Rn = (n + 1)/(4n + 5n).
Madhava also gave a table of almost accurate values of half-sine chords for twenty-four arcs
drawn at equal intervals in a quarter of a given circle.
Here we should recall the Jaysthadev(1500-1610 AD) for one purpose that
the well known Taylor’s series discovered by(Taylor 18 August 1685- 30
November
1731) was already in the Yuktibhasha of Jaysthadev. But we are not going details of him.
Srinivasa Aiyangar
Ramanujan(22 Dec 1887-26 April
1920)
each successive term represents a solution of the problem, previously Mohalanobis fonnd
the first solution by trial and error method in a few minutes that mached with the first term of the
Ramanujans solution, that amazed Mahalanobish—What a mathematical genius.
Ramanujan spent his last days bedridden and sick, but the great mathematical brain was far from
being inactive, it can be felt by an event with his mentor Hardy(Godfrey Harold Hardy,
1877-1947, a great British Mathematician):
Once Hardy came over to visit Ramanujan in his bedside, Hardy said “I say, Srinivas, I thought
the number of the taxi I came in was a very dull one. It was 1729”. Without even a moment’s
hesitation, Ramanujan replied, “No, maybe not. It is not a dull number in the very least. It is the
lowest number that can be expressed in two different waysas the sum of two cubes!”—What a
genius the ‘Ramanuja’.
3 3 3 3
Later on this number become famous as ‘Ramanujan Number’.(1947=10 +9 =12 +1 ). There are lots of
incident that proved every time an immeasurable genius ness of Ramanujan.
Ramanujan gave lots of formulae for the value of π, and some of remarkable formulas
are:
π 2 2 4 4 6 6
⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ⋅⋅⋅⋅⋅⋅⋅
=
2 1 3 3 5 5 7
12
π= log ⎡(2 2 + 10 )(3 + 10 )⎤
190 ⎣ ⎦
24 log ⎡ 10 + 11 2 10+7 2⎤
π = ⎢ + ⎥
142 ⎢⎣ 4 4 ⎥⎦
3 3 3
2 ⎛1⎞ ⎛1 .3 ⎞ ⎛1 .3 .5 ⎞
=1⎜−5⎟ ⎜ +9⎟ ⎜ −13⎟ +⋅⋅⋅⋅⋅⋅
π 2 ⎝ ⎠ 2.4⎝ ⎠ ⎝2.4.6⎠
1 ⎡1103 27493 1 1 .3 53883 1.3 1 .3 .5 ⎤
= 2 22 + ⋅ ⋅ + ⋅ ⋅ +⋅⋅⋅⋅⋅⋅
π 99 996 2 42 9910 2.4 42.83
Ramanujan died, but his work still flourishing the knowledge of different branches of
science, expanding the research in the field of science. In his very short life span, in a unfavorable
environment for his development, with a very much poor family background and with a very ill
health, he did so much work that can’t be imagine.
View publication stats