Comprhensive 20 Plants
Comprhensive 20 Plants
Comprhensive 20 Plants
COIN DS/6412006-2007
COMPREHENSIVE INDUSTRY
DOCUMENT ON VERTICAL
SHAFT KILN BASED MINI
CEMENT PLANTS
0^CLEAN
COMPRHENSIVE INDUSTRY
DOCUMENT ON VERTICAL
SHAFT KILN BASED MINI
CEMENT PLANTS
lc
Published By: Dr. B. Sengupta, Member Secretary, Central Pollution Control Board, Delhi - 32
Printing Supervision & Layout: P.K. Mahendru and Mrs. Anamika Sagar
Composing & Laser Typesetting : Mohd. Javed
Printed at: DSIIDC Ltd.
ATJT fDT
:. (1TI cl,1 WT
w
)
gufgurru
Central Pollution Control Board
I. Th. 9t , w.. (A Govt. of India Organisation)
3T1 Ministry of Environment & Forests
Phone : 22304948 / 22307233
J. M. MAUSKAR, IAS
Chairman
FOREWORD
The Central Pollution Control Board has published several industry specific documents,
called Comprehensive Industry Documents (COINDS), envisaging the environmental
issues and preventive measures. The present document on vertical shaft kiln based mini
cement plants is in continuation of the series of COINDS. A Study was undertaken by
Central Pollution Control Board through National Council for Cement and Building
Materials, in which depth examination of selected vertical shaft kiln based mini cement
plants was conducted.
This Report provides detailed information on number of units in the country, their
locations, capacities, manufacturing process, emissions generated, present status of
pollution control measures and also the recommendations for abatement and control of
pollution. This will enable the vertical shaft kiln based mini cement plants need to install
proper pollution control devices and to operate them to achieve the intended objective of
pollution control.
I would like to express my sincere appreciation for the work done by the team of NCBM,
headed by Dr. L.K. Janakiraman. I also appreciate the efforts made by my colleagues Sh.
P.K. Gupta, Environmental Engineer and Sh. J.S. Kamyotra, Additional Director for
coordinating and finalizing the Study under the guidance of Dr. B. Sengupta, Member
Secretary, CPCB.
We in CPCB hope the Study will be useful to the vertical shaft kiln based mini cement
plants, regulatory agencies, research organizations and to all interested in pollution
control.
Page No.
1.0 INTRODUCTION
2.0 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
3.0 GROWTH OF MINI CEMENT PLANTS
4.0 WORLD SCENARIO OF MINI CEMENT 2
5.0 COMPARISION OF LARGE AND MINI CEMENT PLANTS 3
6.0 CEMENT MANUFACTURING TECHNOLOGIES 5
TO TYPES OF MINI CEMENT PLANTS IN INDIA 16
s.0 TYPES OF MINI CEMENT PLANTS IN CHINA 27
9.0 TYPES OF MINI CEMENT PLANTS IN COUNTRIES
OTHER THAN CHINA AMD INDIA 2.7
Page No.
Fig 1: Fluid Bed Process 7
Fig 2 (a): Material flow in Reba Process 10
Fig 5: Flow Sheet of Black Meal Vertical Shaft Kiln Cement Plant 15
Fig 7A; Flow Sheet of 200 TPD Vertical Shaft Kiln of M/s Dalmia Cement
(Bharat) Ltd. 23
Fig 7B: Process Flow Sheet of M/S Saboo Tiny Cement Plant 25
Page No.
EXHIBITS
Page No.
2 Out of 333, only 193 VSK based mini cement plants are in operation having
operating capacity of 3.47 million tones per annum.
3 Mini cement plant is basically air polluting industry. The air pollution is mainly in
the form of particulate matter emission.
4 To assess the present environmental scenario of Indian Vertical Shaft Kiln (VSK)
based Mini Cement Plants, a questionnaire was prepared and sent to 279 VSK
Mini Cement Plants.
The Mini Cement Plant clusters were divided into two regions namely southern
region and northern region. Two plants from southern region and six plants from
northern region were selected for the study. The two plants in A.P are based on
CRI -MVSK technology having the installed capacity of 200 TPD with two VSKs of
100 TPD each. Six plants selected in Behror, Rajasthan are based on Saboo
VSK Technology having the installed capacity ranging from 20 to 50 TPD.
5 In-depth study was pursued in eight plants. The data in these plants were
collected with respect to history of the plant, manufacturing process and flow-
sheet, sources of air pollution, stack emission monitoring, analysis of particulate
mater for particle size distribution, raw materials quality and its effect on air
pollution, pollution control devices adopted and their design, economics, noise
pollution etc.
Ambient air quality monitoring was conducted for RSPM, SPM, 50 2 and NO X in
up wind and down wind direction. The value of RSPM, SPM, SO2 and NO X in the
up wind direction is 280, 641, 12 and 7 µg/m 3 respectively. The value of RSPM,
SPM, SO2 and NO X in the Down wind direction is 310, 899, 14 and 8 µg/m 3
respectively.
8 In plant no.2, Air Pollution Control Devices were provided only in raw mill and
cement mill sections. The particulate matter emission from raw mill, cement mill,
VSK no. 1 and VSK no. 3 is 153 mg/Nm 3 , 67 mg/Nm 3 , 167 mg/Nm 3 and 73
mg/Nm 3 respectively.
Ambient air quality monitoring was conducted for RSPM, SPM, 50 2 and NO in
up wind and down wind direction. The value of RSPM, SPM, SO2 and NO in the
up wind direction is 142, 910, 7 and 6 µg/m 3 respectively. The value of RSPM,
SPM, SO2 and NO in the Down wind direction is 275, 1205, 9 and 7 µg/m 3
respectively.
9. In plant no. 3, the average value of particulate matted emission from VSK is
119 mg/Nm 3 . Ambient air quality monitoring was conducted for RSPM, SPM,
SO2 and NO in up wind and down wind direction. The value of RSPM, SPM,
SO2 and NO in the up wind direction is 151, 170, BDL and 34 µg /m 3
respectively. The value of RSPM, SPM, SO2 and NO in the Down wind
direction is 194, 205, BDL and 65 µg/m 3 respectively.
10 In plant no. 4, the average value of particulate matter emission from VSK is 226
mg/Nm 3 . Ambient air quality monitoring was conducted for RSPM, SPM, SO2 and
NO, in up wind and down wind direction. The value of RSPM, SPM, SO2 and NO x
in the up wind direction is 144, 507, 17, and 52 µg/m 3 respectively. The value of
RSPM, SPM, SO2 and NO in the Down wind direction is 158, 674, 27 and 66
µg/m 3 respectively.
11 In plant no. 5, the average value of particulate matter emission from VSK is 370
mg/Nm 3 . Ambient air quality monitoring was conducted for RSPM, SPM, SO2 and
NO in up wind and down wind direction. The value of RSPM, SPM, SO2 and NO X
in the up wind direction is 258, 454, 9, and 33 µg/m 3 respectively. The value of
RSPM, SPM, SO2 and NO X in the Down wind direction is 415, 900, 12 and 61
µg/m 3 respectively.
12 In plant no. 6, the average value of particulate matter emission from VSK is 473
mg/Nm 3 . Ambient air quality monitoring was conducted for RSPM, SPM, SO2 and
NO X in up wind and down wind direction. The value of RSPM, SPM, SO2 and NO
in the up wind direction is 121, 238, 15 and 116 µg/m 3 respectively. The value of
RSPM, SPM, SO2 and NO in the Down wind direction is 218, 452, 10 and 150
µg/m 3 respectively.
13 In plant no. 7, the average value of particulate matter emission from VSK is 112
mg/Nm 3 . Ambient air quality monitoring was conducted for RSPM, SPM, SO 2 and
NO in up wind and down wind direction. The value of RSPM, SPM, SO2 and NO,,
in the up wind direction is 137, 410, 10 and 128 µg/m 3 respectively. The value of
RSPM, SPM, SO2 and NO in the Down wind direction is 162, 426, 16 and 153
µg/m 3 respectively.
14 In plant no. 8, the particulate matter concentration at inlet and out let of dust
settling chamber of VSK is 584 and 104 mg/Nm 3 respectively. Ambient air quality
monitoring was conducted for RSPM, SPM, 502 and NO in up wind and down
wind direction. The value of RSPM, SPM, SO2 and NO in the up wind direction is
177, 967, BDL and 155 µg/m 3 respectively. The value of RSPM, SPM, SO 2 and
NO in the Down wind direction is 289, 1313, BDL and 164 µg/m 3 respectively.
15 Few CRI -MVSK (Cement Research Institute of India - Modern Vertical Shaft Kiln)
cement plants are having pollution control devices in all the sections while other
technology based VSK plants are not having pollution control devices in all the
sections. These plants are having only open type bags as pollution control
devices in all the sections, which needs to be modified.
16 As a guideline following pollution control devices are suggested for various
sections of VSK based mini cement plants subject to compliance of emission
standards:
a) Crushing and raw materials proportioning section - Bag Filter.
b) Raw mill section - Twin cyclone and Bag Filter
c) Homogenising Silo - Bag Filter
d) Nodulizer - Bag Filter
e) VSK stack - Cyclone
Clm
1.0 INTRODUCTION
The capacity of a mini cement plant based on Vertical Shaft Kiln (VSK)
technology is limited to 300 TPD or 99000 TPA and the capacity of a mini cement
plant based on Rotary Kiln (RK) technology is limited to 900 TPD or 2,97,000
TPA (For the plant based on RK technology, the capacity has been enhanced
from 600 TPD or 1,98,000 TPA to 900 TPD or 2,97,000 TPA vide notification no.
20/99 — Central Excise dated 7 May 1999). These plants are mainly based on
vertical shaft kiln technology (VSK). At present there are 333 VSK mini cement
plants of capacities ranging from 20 - 300 TPD of various technologies located in
different parts of the country. During the various operation of cement
manufacturing, dust is emitted which poses problem of air pollution. Majority of
these plants are located in clusters in Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Madhya
Pradesh and Rajasthan. Rests of the plants are distributed in the other parts of
the country as shown in Exhibit — 1.
The present study of VSK mini cement plant deals with manufacturing process,
identification of sources of dust emission, stack emission monitoring, analysis of
particulate matter for particle size distribution, air pollution control devices
adopted, ambient air quality monitoring and section wise suggestions for dust
control system.
1
plant became operational in early 1981, whereas the first (200 tpd) mini cement
plant based on rotary kiln technology went on stream in 1982. In addition, some
VSK plants mostly in small-scale sector came up, whose plant and machinery
were supplied by M/s. Shree Engineers, Jodhpur.
Cement Plants
Originally Set up In operation
SI. Technology Nos. Installed Nos. Installed Production
No. Capacity Capacity (MTPA)
MTPA (MTPA)
1 Rotary Kiln 31 4.003 24 3.411 2.388
2 CRI -MVSK 101 3.354 30 1.179 0.825
3 RRL-VSK 31 0.286 - - -
The Chinese cement industry has seen a rapid growth over the last five decades.
The production of cement was less than 3 Million tonnes in 1952, but in 1999 the
total production of cement reached 573 Million tonnes. Thus, China, accounting
for about one third of the global cement production ranks first in the world today
in terms of cement output.
The total installed capacity of the Chinese cement industry is estimated at 700
Million tonnes from over 7000 cement plants, which means that the average
capacity of each cement plant is about 1,00,000 tonnes per annum. In China,
K
the cement industry has a multiple ownership structure and a major part of the
industry belongs to the Ministry of Agriculture under its Administration of Town
and Village Industrial Enterprises (TVIE). The cement plants belonging to this
sector are small and based on Vertical Shaft Kilns (VSK), which traditionally have
consumed high levels of raw materials, fuel and power and therefore cause
serious environmental pollution.
During the last five years, there have been planned efforts to look at the energy
and environmental issues of these plants with the help of international
organizations like UNIDO, IVAM Environmental Research and University of
Amsterdam. These international bodies have undertaken the study for cleaner
production technology and energy conservation measures in these cement
plants.
As previously mentioned, the Chinese cement industry still uses the VSK process
as its principal technology. However, in the last two decades, there has been the
introduction of modern preheater and precalciner kiln systems at medium and
large sized plants. The sum total effect has been the existence of a mix of
technologies and there are now over 13,000 VSK plants in China.
Currently, the modern large cement plants with precalciner technology cover less
than 10 percent of the total cement output of the country. About 12 percent of
the output comes from a plethora of small and medium size rotary kiln plants.
The total output from the VSK plants constitutes about 78 percent. According to
a regulation issued in 1997, the VSKs with a capacity of 44,000 tonnes per
annum or less were to be discontinued by the end of 2000, barring only a few
regions where the deadline is 2005. By the end of 1999, it had been officially
reported that the VSK plants with an aggregate production capacity of about 20
Million tones per annum had been closed down. The production and distribution
of Vertical Shaft Kiln (VSK) mini cement plants worldwide are given in Table 3.
Cement is one of the most important building materials. The total cement
production in the world reached 1950 million tonnes in 2003. A major percentage
of this total production is from large-scale plants with capacities ranging from
2000 to 20,000 tpd and transported to the place of use in bulk or bags.
Large capacity plants are appropriate for deriving the benefits from economies of
scale in locations where:
3
Capital-intensive technology is preferable from socio-economic
considerations.
3 Iraq 1 2 292
4 Bhutan 3 4 74
5 Indonesia 1 2 110
6 Lao Peoples Dem
1 1 65
- Rep.
7 Nepal 4 5 150
8 Germany 2 15 1200
9 Italy 1 1 60
10 Slovak Republic 1 4 150
11 France 5 20 1500
12 Russia 1 6 310
13 China 107 221 25202
14 USA - - -
15 Australia - - -
16 Madagaskar 1 2 200
17 European Union - - 400
18 CEMBUREAU - - 400
19 Central America - -
20 South America - - -
Mini cement plants are appropriate for other areas particularly in cases like :
4
Areas where local and regional market will absorb the production of a mini
cement plant only and that industrial size plants could not operate at
economic production rates.
Socio -economic consideration justifies a Labour intensive technology
rather than a capital intensive one.
The various technologies, which have been tried for adoption in mini cement
plant, are:
5
So when the technical and economical threshold is reached for any given
technology line, other technology lines may still give technically feasible and
economically viable results.
The conventional rotary kiln is normally uneconomical below 300 to 600 tpd and
so the technology lines like Sintergrate and Reba evolved, but they could not
succeed due to inherent defects.
A brief process description for all these technological lines which were tried or
adopted for manufacture of cement in small scale are given in the following
sections:
Of these the fluidised bed or Pyzel process is the least popular because the
number of plants working on this process are extremely few even on global basis
and not much is known except for some broad principles of working. This
process, invented by Robert Pyzel, has been developed in USA by Fuller. A 100
tpd pilot plant based on this technology is reported to be in operation on
experimental basis for the last six years with M/s. Scientific Design Company,
New York, USA. (Fig. 1)
The plant consists of a fluidised bed reactor; raw meal consisting of finely ground
feed mixture is pneumatically conveyed to the fluidised bed alongwith fuel and
preheated air. The temperature of the fluidised bed is maintained at
approximately 1315°C by introducing the fuel directly into the fluidised bed.
The Specific heat consumption reported without any heat recovery system is
2600 Kcal/kg of clinker and with heat recovery system 1046 Kcal/kg of clinker.
Energy requirement for production of clinker alone by the fluidised bed reactor is
55 Kwh/t as against 20-25 Kwh/t of clinker in case of rotary or shaft kilns.
Fuels like gas, oil, coal, anthracite and coke could be used in this process.
This process stands a good chance for a promising market in USA as there are
very strict environmental protection specifications regarding oxides of sulphur
and nitrogen. At the same time special `low alkali' cement specifications
0
-•- HOT KILN GAS
SIZE RECYCLE
CLINKER
REFRACTORY
LINING
CLINKER OVERFLOW
CARBON STEEL
SHELL
CAST REFRACTORY
PRE HEATED
AIR AIR PLENUM
RAW FEED
FUEL
7
necessitate the rejection of large quantity of dust in rotary kiln burning operation.
This dust with high alkali content can be used as a cement raw mix in the Pyzel
reactor.
The specific advantages of Pyzel process have been claimed where there is (a)
high alkali problem; (b) strict environmental protection regulations regarding
oxides of sulphur and nitrogen from exit gases; (c) disposal problem of kiln dust
with high alkali content; and (d) using different fuels like gas, oil, coal, anthracite
and coke.
The high investment cost for the heat recovery systems and stringent controls
through an elaborate instrumentation and automation and non-availability of
highly skilled personnel for the operation of the reactor, go against the very
philosophy of mini cement plant. Due to the inherent technological problems in
stabilising the operation of plants based on the above process and also due to
the reported high investment cost per annual tonne of installed capacity, mini
cement plants based on the above technology have not been reported to be a
commercial success anywhere in the world.
8
limestonne and coals with high ash content. No commercial plants are known to
be in operation in the world on this technology. (Fig. 2)
,
The raw meal and crushed coal are then extracted from respective bins
according to requirement and conveyed to a drum type nodulizer. In addition, the
noduliser is also fed with 15% of —5mm size burnt clinker to form core of nodules
and 15% water spray. The nodules are conveyed by a belt conveyor to moving
sinter bed made of cast iron grate base. A 75 mm thick layer of + 5 mm and —10
mm burnt clinker is first spread over this bed and then the fresh nodules fall over
this. The sinter bed passes through various zones over some distance where
suction is maintained through ID fan. Light diesel oil is fired over the bed in hood
fixed about 200 mm above the bed height and the resulting clinker is discharged
through a rotating arm type breaker in red hot condition over an open pan type
horizontal conveyor where it undergoes cooling. (Fig. 3)
Here the kiln feed and fuel preparation requires crushing and grinding operations,
like:
- Crushing of limestone and additives in a hammer mill or 2-stage, viz., jaw
crusher and hammer mill to —15 mm size.
- Storing the crushed raw materials in storage yard/bins.
- Proportioning and grinding the raw materials in a roller/ball mill.
- Homogenising and storage of raw meal in blending and storage sections.
- Fuel, viz, coal (VM 25-30%) is pulverised in a separate section (combined
coal drying-cum-grinding section).
Blended and homogenised raw meal is then fed to the suspension preheater of
counter current type, where it is preheated and partially calcined by the kiln hot
gases passing in counter current. Raw meal enters the kiln at a temperature of
700°C - 800°C. The exit gases from the preheater are then passed through the
dust collection system and discharged to atmosphere. Dust collected is recycled.
Pulverised coal mixed with primary air is fired from the lower end of the rotary kiln
through coal burners. Secondary air is supplied through clinker cooler to make
up for the combustion air. A flame at around 1660°C is maintained. This heat
er
GRANULATING TABLE
CHAMBER-2
PREHEATING SHAFT
GRATE
GRATE
CALCINATION ZONE
GRATE
UPPER PUSH CAR
SINTERING ZONE
GRATE
LOWER PUSH CAR
CLINKER COUNTER CURREN
SHAFT COOLER
COOLER DISCHARGE
EXHAUST GAS
EXHAUST
rfI
GAS FAN o
-s py A
6 - FAN -CALCINATING ZONE
° 2
FAN SINTREING ZONE
--^ FRESH AIR
^^ COOLER FAN
° FRESH AIR
LU
F-
cez Q
W W
Y W cx
Z ^ l_7
LJ
Of
W
LO
cx
J
U-
N=
J J
ia O
<U-
11
the material as the kiln rotates at 1 to 2 rpm. Various chemical reactions
(Calcination, sintering, cooling) takes place as the material temperature goes
upto 1440°C. Hot gases having transferred the heat to material escape in
counter flow i.e. from lower- end to upper end through suspension preheater and
dust collectors to atmosphere. Clinker is discharged into clinker cooler, which
may be rotary, planetary or moving grate type. Clinker is then transported to
storage yard and finally ground with gypsum. Control is maintained through
various control instruments and inspection of burning conditions. (Fig. 4)
The use of vertical shaft kiln process for cement manufacturing dates back to the
year 1824 when Portland cement was invented. However, because of its non-
continuous operation, this process was found uneconomical and produced
clinker of non-uniform quality.
This is the most popular type of process used for manufacture of cement through
Modern Vertical Shaft Kiln in which the fuel (usually low volatile coal or coke
breeze) is interground with the raw mix for efficient and uniform burning. Most of
the cement plants using Vertical Shaft Kiln like CRI — Modern Vertical Shaft Kiln,
Vertical Shaft Kiln supplied by M/s. Loesche of West Germany etc are mainly
based on the black meal process.
In this process, the vertical shaft kilns are fed with raw mix of appropriate
composition in the form of nodules. The feed operation usually requires crushing
of limestonne to about -15 mm size in storage bins, proportioning of raw
materials and grinding in a roller or ball mill, homogenizing and nodulizing in pan
type nodulizer. The successful operation of shaft kiln, to a great extent, depends
upon the size of nodules, their uniformity, porosity and thermal stability. The
noduliser consists of an inclined disc or pan rotating about its axis. Raw meal is
charged into noduliser by means of screw conveyor and water is sprayed, while
all the parameters are maintained at optimum conditions. A specially designed
rotating scraper continuously cleans the bottom and the collar of the drum of the
raw meal deposited. The nodules slide down the chute and are •charged in the
12
AIR LACK
FEEDER
SECONDARY AIR
BLOWER
CEMENT CYCLaN
MILL
BUCKET
ELEVATOR
LOADING
1
BAGGING R
BRANDING
The vertical shaft kiln in which the nodules are converted into clinker consists of
a cylindrical shell with conical portion at the top and lined with refractory bricks.
The sintering is normally complete within the conical portion, which is specially
designed to accommodate for shrinkage of nodules. The various zones of
reaction starting from the top of the kiln are; the drying zone, the calcining zone,
the sintering zone and the cooling zone. The combustion air supplied by Roots
blower ascending from below in the cooling zone absorbs heat from the
descending clinker. The whole kiln charge composed of unburnt nodules and
clinker rests on a flat grate rotating slowly at the bottom of the kiln and mounted
over the kiln shaft. The grate is driven with the help of variable speed motor in
order to control the discharge rate of clinker. The clinker is finally taken out of
kiln bottom with the help of a triple air lock mechanically (or hydraulically)
operated discharge gates or Gamma Ray controlled Material Block Tube System
used in Modern Vertical Shaft Kilns. (Fig. 5)
A variation of the Black Meal process as proposed by Dr. Steven Gottlieb is `Coal
Slurry Process' the main difference being in the method of feed preparation. The
method requires the raw meal to be ground `white', i.e. without fuel. The fuel
(coal with volatile matter upto 16-18%) is ground separately in a wet ball mill to
make slurry with about 50% moisture. The 'white meal' and the `coal slurry' are
separately stored in hoppers over the noduliser platform and are pumped at
controlled rates (through flow meters) into a double paddle mixer to mix the feed
continuously and discharge into the standard noduliser where practically no or
very little water is added to give final shape to the nodules. These nodules are
charged and burnt in the vertical shaft kiln in the same manner as in the case of
"Black Meal' process.
The main advantage claimed by this process is that by wetting of the coal
particles before nodulising, the retention time for the volatile component of the
fuel is increased, thereby allowing this to travel to a zone where adequate
oxygen is available to complete the combustion of the volatile matter within the
bed — thereby permitting a higher volatile content in the coal when compared to
that used in the 'Black Meal' process.
This process, which is a slight variation of the black meal process, has been
reportedly tried out in a number of cement plants in China. In this process about
50% of the total fuel required is interground with the raw meal and the balance is
added later prior to nodulisation. This has been based on the assumption that
the heat requirement at the periphery of the bed in a VSK is usually more by
14
WEIGH BRIDGE
LIMESTONE ADDITIVE
STORAG E
HOPPER
HOPPER HOPPER HOPPER HOPPER
TABLE ^ TABLE TABLE TABLE TABLE
FEEDER FEEDER FEEDER FEEDER FEEDER
BELT CONVEYOR
BUCKET ELEVATOR
FAN
kW MILL
SCREW
CONVEYOR BUCKET ELEVATOR
L P BLOWER
BLENDING SILO
H P BLOWER
SC 1jJ
CONVEYOR 1
BUCKET ELEVATOR
RAW MEAL HOPPER
SCREW CONVEYOR
NODULISER 4--WATER
EXHAUST VERTICAL SHAFT
KILN
ROOTS
BLOWER
CLINKEI
TABLE I HOPPER
FEEDER
CEMENT Q CEMENT
SILO
LOADING BUCKET
ELEVATOR
WARE PACKING &
HOUSE BRANDING
16
SP
MATERIA
WITH GAMMA
=R
UrU v ilw
ARRANGEMENT
GENERAL ARRANGEMENT
CRI MODERN VERTICAL SHAFT KILN
FIG. L
17
I) Safety measures including carbon-monoxide alarm system and electrical
interlocking of drives have been provided in order to protect the manpower
and equipment which include a special alarm for combustion air failure to
prevent any flame shoot out due to carbon-monoxide formation.
m) Dust collection system with stacks is incorporated in all the sections like
crushing, raw mill, blending, cement mill and cement packing which will
ensure a very clean and dust free environment in the CRI -MVSK cement
plant. In addition, modern and proper dust collection arrangements at all
transfer points including proper ventilation of tunnels and a specially
designed low cost dust limitator in the MVSK chimney have been provided.
A typical flow sheet for mini cement plant based on CRI- Modern Vertical Shaft
Kiln is shown in Figure 7. The process is explained below:
CRI -MVSK technology is based on the black meal process in which all the raw
materials, viz, limestonne, clay fuel (coke breeze, pet coke, Jhama coal or any
suitable low volatile coal) and other corrective materials are ground together to a
fineness of 10% retained on 170 mesh as in dry process and intimately blended
to satisfy the chemical requirements for the raw meal. The homogeneous raw
meal is formed into nodules of the desired size by adding water in a pan
nodulizer and fed into the vertical shaft kiln through a revolving feed hopper. As
the material passes down the kiln, it is dried heated and then burnt into clinker.
The clinker is then cooled and discharged from the kiln by a rotary grate at the
bottom of the kiln through a triple air lock discharge device or gamma ray
}
controlled Material Block Tube (MBT). The combustion air to the kiln, which is
provided by a Roots blower, also serves the purpose of cooling the clinker and
thus avoids wastage of heat. The clinker then passes to a cement mill where it is
ground with about 5% gypsum to produce cement of standard quality.
The details of RRL Technology are not available since even a single plant is not
in operation.
18
THIS DRAWING IS PROPERT OF NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR CELTENT -'
A4O BUILDING MATERIALS. AND ITS COPY RIGHTS SOLELY WITH
NCB.. IT SHOULD NOT BE COPIED. REPRODUCED. LOANED OR DISPOSED ..
OF WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION OF N C B.
7.3 M/S Dalmia Cement (Bharat) Ltd.
A mini cement plant of 170 tpd based on the Gottlieb Coal Slurry Process is
presently under operation in India at M/s. Dalmia Cement (Bharat) Ltd. at
Dalmiapuram. Although the production of cement from the plant is reported to be
satisfactory, the plant has not been able to achieve the advantage of using the
high volatile Indian coal used by other rotary kiln cement plants and is reported to
be using low volatile coal/coke breeze as being used by other VSK plants in India
based on the black meal process. Thus the additional investment incurred by the
plant due to separate coal slurry grinding and handling system has not given the
expected returns.
7.3.1 Process
A 200 tpd vertical shaft kiln was installed at M/s Dalmia Cement (Bharat) Ltd,
Dalmiapuram during 1982 and it is now working satisfactorily. This VSK is
operating on 'coal-slurry' process. It is an imported technology supplied by Dr.
S Gottlieb of Australia. A detailed study of this VSK starting from quarry to
cement stage is explained below.
The limestone is being brought from open cast mines — Kallakudi, Vadugarpet,
Kovandakurichi and Perianagalur by means of locos and lorries. The limestone
will be dropped into the hopper by means of winches or electrical hoist depending
upon the case. The uncrushed limestone will be fed into Double Swing Hammer
Mill, supplied by. FLS., Copenhagen, through a laminated conveyor. This mill is
being driven by 2 HT motors (3.3 KV). The crushed limestone will be carried by
means of inclined belt conveyor to the limestone storage yard.
The crushed limestone, clay and additives if required will be fed into the
respective hoppers by means of EOT crane. These raw materials through the
weigh feeder dropped into `Loesche' mill which is supplied by West Germany.
The capacity of the mill is 52 tonnes per hour. This mill is consisting of 2 rollers
kept over a moving thick metallic pad. The raw materials come in between the
moving pad and the rollers will be ground to the required fineness. These rollers
can be moved up and down by means of hydraulic pressure. The white meal
thus produced in this `Loesche' mill will pass through ESP and this will be fed into
the top of the blending silo of the double decker silo by means of flexo pump.
The corrected white meal will be dropped into the storage silo.
The white meal from the storage SP 10 will be pumped into VSK hopper through
Flexo pump. The capacity of this hopper is 400 tonnes. The white meal will be
fed into the boot of an elevator by means of double screw conveyor. The output
of the elevator is fed into the sieve screw conveyor. The capacity of elevator is
17 tonnes per hour and the capacity of sieve screw conveyor is 15 tph. The
foreign bodies will be removed in the sieve screw conveyor. The output of the
sieve screw conveyor will be fed into the weigh feeder where the quantity of white
meal will be weighed and fed into double shaft paddle conveyor. The rate of
white meal feeding is 11 tph. A special provision is provided underneath the
weigh feeder so that 95% of white meal will go to double shaft paddle conveyor
and the remaining 5% of white will be used for surface conditioning in the
noduliser.
Single chamber tubular mill is used in M/s DCB Ltd, Dalmiapuram for coal
grinding. The capacity of this mill is 8 TPH. 50% coal or coke breeze and 50%
water will be fed into this mill. The output of this coal mill is called 'coal slurry'
which will be fed into the storage tank 'T 1 '. This coal slurry will be transferred
from tank 'T 1 ' into tank `T 2 ' by means of pump. The capacity of tank 'T2' is 60 to
80 tonnes. From the tank `T 2 ' the coal slurry is fed into the tank `T 2 A', situated at
a height of 8.6 m from the ground, by means of an elevator. From the tank `T 2A',
this coal slurry is pumped into tank 'T 3 ' ( called constant level tank) situated at a
height of 23.7 m from the ground by means of pump. From tank `T 3 ' the coal
slurry will be fed into double shaft peddle conveyor.
The white meal and the coal slurry will be thoroughly blended by means- of the
paddles of the double shaft paddle conveyor. This slurry will be fed into the
noduliser drum.
7.3.1.4 Noduliser
Controlled amount of water will be added and the pellets will be formed in the
drum. The size of the pellets is 10 to 16 mm. There is a provision provided for
the white meal coating — surface conditioning — over the pellets.
Thus the pellets formed in the noduliser drum will be fed into the kiln through
rotary feeder. This is imported equipment. This rotary feeder can be moved up
and down and also left and right side by operating the controller. The nodules
will be distributed uniformly in the kiln.
These nodules are thus distributed uniformly in the kiln and the kiln is kept
changed to a constant level and operates continuously. The material is first dried
in the enlarged upper portion and then falls slowly to the narrow portion.
Decarbonisation takes place at about 950 ° C and the final burning of the clinker
21
takes place at 1450 ° C. The clinker thus formed will be cooled in the lower part of
the kiln before it reaches the discharge gate.
By adjusting the speed of rotation of the grate, the amount of clinker discharged
and thus the rate of burning can be controlled. The type of grate is flat grate.
This grate consists of 6 segments of opening size 95 x 95 mm,
The discharge gate is provided with a triple gate air lock mechanism to prevent
loss of drought and production of dust. The discharge is automatic and the parts
of which are actuated hydraulically. The rotary feeder, discharge gate
mechanism and the king shaft assembly are all imported equipment and their
total cost is approximately one crore.
7.3.1.9 Blower
Thus the clinker formed in VSK will be fed into the vibrating screen I. From there
this will go to clinker yard through vibrating screen II. This clinker will be fed in to
the cement mill hopper by means of EOT crane. Clinker and gypsum will be fed
into the 3 compartment tubular mill where these materials will be ground and the
output of this mill be fed into the cement silos through flexo pump. Earlier Dalmia
Cement (Bharat) Ltd, provided a clinker crusher underneath the discharge gate
and now they removed it since there is not much of lumps.
The flow sheet of 200 tpd VSK of M/s Dalmia Cement (B) Ltd is shown at Fig.
7A.
In India, any industry for which the cost of plant and machinery does not exceed
Rs 1,46,00,000 comes under the definition of `Small Scale Industry (SSI)' and is
offered certain concessions. Keeping this primarily in view, certain individuals /
small organisations have downscaled the VSK technology so as to offer such
plants under the SSI. Such plants are in the size range of 5 to 20 tpd and are
22
Di o
gil m
LU
LU
Q
a
0
LliE 0
9> J
i
II ^ ^
If I
IIi
^ ÓN
W ó
N W
r--- jj ^ 1N
II ^
J
Li
III U
ÍÍÍ
O á 1^3
H
23
popularly known as Tiny Cement Plants. In this direction, an individual called Mr.
D.P. Saboo of Jodhpur in Rajasthan has put in considerable efforts, and has put
up about 25 nos. of such tiny plants; most of these being based on high grade
limestonne deposits in the state of Rajasthan. The investment cost in such
plants have been brought down by resorting to in-house fabrication of machinery
as well as by elimination of certain equipment from the process line and resorting
to manual operation.
However, unfortunately, the tiny cement plant concept in India has taken a
dangerous turn with a large number of other individuals/spurious organisations
having entered the field of fabricating and supplying these plants, which are in
fact poorly copied version of certain proven technologies without the provision of
requisite technical back-up. This has already resulted in setting up of a few such
tiny cement plants, which have since become sick and have discontinued
production.
Brief Process of Manufacture of Portland Cement from Saboo VSK Tiny Cement
Plant is given below.
Limestone, Breeze Coke, Clay (Red-burning clay of Village Potters) and other
additives, as required, are crushed and stored automatically in different silos,
wherefrom they are again taken out in the desired proportions by a weigh-
batcher. They are further conveyed to a pre-blender and the blended materials
are thoroughly ground in an open-circuit Ball Mill to form homogenized Raw
Meal, from where it is conveyed through an elevator to blending silos and later to
a storage silo. This raw meal is subsequently lifted to the hopper of a noduliser,
where nodules are formed.
These nodules travel downwards into the kiln through a Rotary Chute and find an
access to the pre-heating zone followed by calcinations and clinkering zones,
wherein drying, pre-heating, calcining and sintering take place, leading to
conversion of nodules into clinker. This clinker, as received from the kiln through
the cooling zone, is subsequently mixed with gypsum in suitable proportion for
further grinding in the cement mill to produce the finished product, i.e pure
Portland Cement.
The flow sheet of Saboo VSK Tiny Cement Plant is shown at Fig. 7B.
This 60-tpd plant is based on Lurgi Sinter Grate Process. This requires use of
light diesel oil as a fuel in addition to the low volatile coal already contained in the
nodules. The cement production at the plant has never exceeded 55% of the
installed capacity. The cost of fuel is as high as Rs 700 per tonne of clinker.
Apart from the high cost of production, the plant also finds it difficult to cope with
frequent breakdowns and quite involved maintenance is required due to
complicated machinery. The electrical energy consumption per tonne of cement
24
DAw kirAl VAfn
MILL
BUCKET
ELEVATOR
STORAGE
SILOS
WEIGH
BATCHER
BUCKET
ELEVATOR
RAW MILL
(OPEN CIRCUIT BALL MILL)
BUCKET
ELEVATOR
BLENDING
SILOS
BLOWER
BUCKET
RAW MEAL SECTION ELEVATOR
SURGE SILO SCREW CONVEYOR
WATER SURLY
SCREW CONVEYOR
Cat? NODUUZER
SABOO V S K
GYPSUM
KILN SECTION
BLOWER
CLINKER YARD
0 0
I
• WEIGHING
• NOT SUPPLIED
25
produced is as high as 208 Kwh. The heat consumption per kg of clinker
production is also as high as 2404 Kcals.
Since the above plant is not in operation for the last 1 1/2 decades and also the
equipment are obsolete in nature, plant is not able to provide data in this regard.
Use of small rotary kilns has been adopted by many countries for cement
manufacture in small scale by downscaling the conventional rotary kilns. In
India, there are about 31 nos. of rotary kiln based mini cement plants under
operation and about another 5 nos. under implementation; most of these being
designated as 200 tpd in order to derive incentives offered by the Government of
India in terms of rebate in excise duty (which has since been discontinued) and a
free market. However, most of these plants are using kilns of 3 m dia and 40 or
45 m length — which under Indian conditions are rated as 300 tpd. One of the
major reasons for this has been the fact that the machinery
fabricators/consultants did not find it technically appropriate to further reduce the
kiln dimensions in view of anticipated problems relating to higher refractory
failure.
Thus, although a few mini cement plant based on the rotary kiln technology have
been set up in India as well as other countries of the world, mainly because of
the reason that this technology is a direct down-scaling of the conventional rotary
kilns which are technically well established, the cost of production and the
investment cost per annual tonne of installed capacity in such plants are found to
be exceptionally high due to the scale effects. Moreover, if one attempts to make
these small rotary kiln plants economically viable, then certain process and
operations have to be eliminated and the degree of sophistication of
instrumentation and process control systems would have to be lower which
would amount to sacrificing some of the modern features which are essential for
satisfactory performance and economic operation. Due to the inherent techno-
economic disadvantages of mini cement plants based on rotary kiln as compared
to those based on Modern Vertical Shaft Kiln — like higher investment cost,
higher operating cost, higher energy consumption, higher pollution etc; the
Government of India, as a matter of policy, is not encouraging any further setting
up of mini cement plants based on rotary kiln technology.
26
The process flow sheet of Small Rotary Kiln is shown in Fig. 7C.
China uses minor variations in the process with the vertical shaft kiln technology.
There are some plants which use black meal process as in India, there are
others which use semi-black meal process in which only a part of the total coal
required is interground with the raw meal and the balance is added in coarse
fraction later prior to nodulisation. Some plants use compound mineralizers also
for lowering the firing temperature. Different types of discharge grates have been
used in the vertical shaft kiln, like roller grate, flat grate, conical grate,
reciprocating grate etc. Non-mechanised kilns use stationary grate. Since the
Chinese plants, because of this design and operational features, emit sizeable
amounts of dust, dust collection equipment like electrostatic precipitators, bag
filters, etc. is being installed. The smallest and the largest sizes of mechanized
vertical shaft kilns in China have diameters of 1.7 metres and 3.6 metres
producing about 35 tonnes per day and 300 tonnes per day against design
capacities of 45 tonnes per day and 380 tonnes per day respectively.
A number of mini cement plants in China have been facing problems of non-
uniform cement quality, poor management and operational skills, higher cost of
production, high heat consumption, environmental pollution, etc. The
Government of China has therefore decided to slowly disband the old non-
mechanised plants numbering about 2000 and take up modernization of those
plants which can produce cement of good quality through mechanization (at the
rate of about 300 plants a year).
Although the latest information regarding the exact number of mini cement plants
operating in different parts of the world are not available. Table 3 shows a global
survey of vertical shaft kilns under operation in different countries.
So far as mini cement plants based on CRI -MVSK technology are concerned,
M/s. Penden Cement Authority of Bhutan, have installed a 50 tpd CRI -MVSK
plant at Gomtu and later expanded it to 100 tpd by installation of another 50 tpd
CRI -MVSK line. One more cement plant of M/s. Lakhi Cements Pvt. Ltd. 100
TPD CRI -MVSK cement plant installed at Gomtu, Bhutan. One mini cement
plant of 160 TPD capacity based on Vertical Shaft Kiln of size 2.4 metre dia and
8-metre height supplied by M/s. Loesche, West Germany is already under
operation at the works of M/s. Himal Cement Company, Nepal. Another mini
cement plant of 30-tpd capacity based on CRI -MVSK is presently in operation at
Anboo-Khaireni in Nepal. This plant purchased 100 TPD (2x50 TPD) CRI -MVSK
cement plant of Penden Cement Authority and expanded upto 200 TPD.
27
WE HOUSE BAGGING &
BRANDING
28
M/s. Loesche of West Germany have supplied more than 14 mini cement plants
based on black meal VSK process in more than nine countries. The first multiple
VSK plant supplied by M/s. Loesche had gone into operation in 1955 at the
cement plant of M/s. Portlandzemtnfabrik Blaubeuren Gebr. Spohn Ag at
Blaubeuren, Germany. Later on M/s Loesche have supplied plants based on
VSK to various countries like Japan, New Zealand, Austria, Spain, Italy, Nepal,
Brazil, Madagascar and Indonesia. In the latest design of 400 tpd (2x200 tpd)
plant at Kupang in Indonesia, pre-blending techniques for controlling of the
variation in quality of limestonne and clay were employed. Different fuels of
various mixtures have been used at Paggau ranging from anthracite dust to coke
breeze and petrol coke, the application of which in all the cases have been
reported to be a success.
In addition to above, M/s Maerz Ofenbau of Zurich also supplied mini cement
plants based on VSK technology on turnkey basis. M/s. Maerz are the exclusive
licencee for the manufacture of Prerov machinery designed mini cement plants
with as many as 16 cement shaft kilns operating in different parts of the world.
The heat consumption in these plants is claimed to be about 900-Kcal/Kg clinker.
As already explained, in the black meal process, the cement raw materials are
interground with the fuel and the resultant raw meal is blended and then
converted into nodules of sufficient uniformity, strength and porosity in an
inclined disc type noduliser by the addition of required quantity of water. The
nodules are fed to vertical shaft kiln where the pyroprocessing takes place.
29
g) All the flanges of the kiln, bottom hood cup, chutes, discharge gates etc.
should be properly sealed so that the combustion air does not leak
through the gaps between the joints.
The kiln should be filled with either the clinker already manufactured, or
limestonne chips or brickbats upto a level of 1-1.5 metres from the conical
portion. Care should be taken that the material is dust free and while filling the
refractory lining is not damaged. In order to remove the dust, the roots blower
has to be run for about 15 minutes after every 1-metre depth of new material is
loaded or better if the blower is run continuously while the kiln is loaded with the
chips or clinker. After-every 2 metres depth of new material has been loaded, the
grate is set in motion, to ensure that the material is moving down the shaft
evenly. Above this material, about 100 kg of dry firewood is now stacked
uniformly over this bed in two or three layers. The chimney damper has to be
opened partly and the air by-pass valves/ball valves are to be kept open in the
kiln air duct. The firewood so spread would be lighted up using torches and after
an incandescent bed is formed, steam coal is charged into the kiln. There will be
an uniform incandescent bed of fire after few minutes. Now charging of the
nodules can commence. One should refrain from adding a new charge of
nodules until the edges of the fire can be just seen. When the bed level reaches
to about 50 cm. below the conical portion, the discharge gate is to be operated
slowly.
Stabilised kiln operation as obtained after the initial lighting up may now be
continued under the following instructions:
M
10.4 Kiln Controls
10.4.1 Feed
Strict controls should be observed on the preparation of feed right from the raw
material stage. The table feeders/weigh feeders should be monitored
periodically so that the component ratios conform to the values for raw mix
design. Blending operation is carried out till a uniform blending with the desired
T C content is obtained. The T C in raw mix should not vary beyond ± 0.20% of
the desired value.
The nodules should be checked for appropriate size, porosity, moisture and
strength on hourly basis. The feed rate and discharge rate should be
synchronised to maintain constant bed level.
The combustion air can be regulated by adjusting the valve on by-pass pipe.
The measurement is done with the help of two instruments provided on the
burner's platform; one from the orifice plate to give combustion air flow and the
other connected at the bottom for measuring the pressure at the inlet to the kiln
which gives an idea of the bed resistance. If during a normal operation both the
instrument readings are constant, the burner should understand that the kiln is
filled with properly burnt clinker. In case the inlet pressure varies the burner gets
indication that the bed resistance is varying and necessary corrective action
should be applied.
Under stabilized operating conditions, the discharge and feed rates should be
synchronised to maintain constant bed level. If there are too big lumps or too
loose a clinker near the grate, the discharge rate will fall or increase. Depending
on the case, immediately the grate speed is to be changed; otherwise the bed
level would rise or burning zone would collapse destroying the entire kiln
operation in next few hours. Intermittent discharge is not desirable. The rotary
grate speed should not be abruptly changed and it should be done gradually step
by step.
10.4.4 Temperature
A normal kiln operation is also judged from, in addition to the above, the
temperatures of flue gases, clinker, burning zone, cooling zone and also of the
kiln shell from outside. The temperature of the kiln is judged from the
thermocouple based temperature indicators and also crosschecked by touching
the kiln shell around periphery at various heights to feel the uniform temperature
gradient. The desired temperature profile for a VSK is shown in Fig. 8.
31
10.5 Kiln Disorders
10.5.1 Bridging
When the clinker produced is so lumpy that it does not contain any loose
material, there are chances that the lumps form a bridge and rest over the sides
of the conical portion of kiln resulting in rise in fire bed. In such a case the feed
should either be slowed down or stopped and air reduced. The bed should be
given some disturbance in clearing the sides and poking from burner's platform.
If necessary the roots blower should be stopped and then the feed. The bed
should be able to descend with some effects. The cause should be investigated
and the process parameters immediately rectified in order to avoid repetition of
this.
Sometimes if the clinker produced is suddenly too loose it would pass through
the bigger lumps and get discharged quickly. Even red-hot yellow nodules
(clinker) may discharge representing that at a certain position there is no bed to
support the burning zone. The burning zone seems to collapse and loose fire. In
such a condition, the grate speed should be reduced or it should be stopped, to
reduce discharge for some time and the burning zone built up slowly even though
the level may rise. The discharge may be reduced till the trouble is overcome.
The underburnt clinker may be separately stocked and appropriately blended
with the good clinker at the time of grinding after ascertaining a suitable
proportion. The kiln process parameters should be immediately attended to.
This may be a result of maintaining the bed level too low inside the cone.
Sometimes a big lump may be noticed in the burning zone, which is very strong
and as big as kiln internal diameter. This may not descend. This generally
occurs due to melting on account of a very high temperature there. The raw mix
composition should be immediately examined and feed should be accordingly
corrected. The fuel with low ash fusion or too much of fuel will cause this. The
lump so formed should be broken with poking rods and grate speed should be
adjusted to ensure its descent. At the same time too much poking should be
avoided. The lumps that descend though big, give no trouble as they would get
crushed and discharged as soon as they reach the rotary grate.
Achieving the rated output at high and consistent quality clinker is the real task
for the burners. For this all the input parameters are to be maintained at an
optimum level and the kiln operations should be monitored continuously. Even a
32
slight disturbance to any of the input parameters for a short duration will
destabilize the steady state and disturb the entire process.
The CRI -MVSK Simulator is a device, which shows the working of complete
vertical shaft kiln section of a cement plant without any physical connections to
the plant, wherein all the inputs, the process as well as the output are
electronically generated within a computer. The simulator through a specially
developed software programme simulates the actual operating conditions of a
vertical shaft kiln cement plant on an ordinary desktop IBM-PC compatible
computer. A mimic diagram of the vertical shaft kiln section of a cement plant is
displayed on the computer screen with all values of process parameters, which
keep on changing with respect to time just as in an actual plant. The operator
can adjust or change any process parameter as per his wish and see the effect
of the same on the plant operation. All the disturbances normally encountered in
the kiln operation either due to changes in raw materials / fuel quality and / or
improper operation can be created on the simulator and the operator can be
trained to effectively deal with such situations. Working on CRI -MVSK simulator
does not require any knowledge of working on a computer terminal or computer
programming.
The simulator consists of a colour graphic monitor, which shows the live mimic of
the nodulizer — vertical shaft kiln section. The operation data on vertical shaft
kilns based on CRI -VSK Technology are given in Table 4.
Table 4: Operation Data on Vertical Shaft Kiln based on CRI -MVSK Technology
33
9 Quality of air NM3/kg of fuel 10
10 Litre weight gm/cc 1080 to 1180
11 Resistance time hrs. 8 to 10
12 Rotary grade speed rph 0.2 to 5
13 Chimney draft mm WG 1 to 3
14 Maximum size of clinker lump mm 100
15 Energy consumption
15.1 Clinker (upto kiln section) Kwh per tonne of clinker 80 to 90
15.2 Cement grinding alone Kwh per tonne of cement 30 to 40
(Only cement mill section)
Raw materials to be used in Vertical Shaft Kiln mini cement plants and their
consumption factors (material balance) per tonne of clinker and cement are given
below in Table 5.
The electrical energy consumption for various sections and thermal energy
consumption of Vertical Shaft Kiln mini cement plants are given below:
The electrical energy requirements for different sections are given below in Table
6.
34
Table 6: Electrical Energy Reuirement
Indepth study was conducted at 8 VSK mini cement plants including identification
of sources of air pollution (stack & fugitive), stack emission monitoring,
constituent of flue gases in terms of 0 2 , CO2, CO and N2 etc, pollution control
technology adopted, annual operation and maintenance cost, water requirement
and ambient air quality monitoring.
Most of the VSK mini cement plants are not equipped with pollution control
devices in all the sections due to the involvement of capital cost especially in
Saboo and RRL VSK mini cement plants. A few CRI -MVSK cement plants of
higher capacity are only having pollution control devices in all the sections of unit.
Many VSK mini cement plants are closed except the plants located in Jammu &
Kashmir and North Eastern region.
The study was conducted at 2 VSK cement plants in Andhra Pradesh and 6 VSK
cement plants in Rajasthan. The indepth studies conducted in all the 8 VSK mini
cement plants are given in the subsequent paragraphs.
13.1 Plant - I
13.1.1 History
The above plant is put up in order to utilize the slag generated by their steel
plant, situated in the same premises. The quality of granulated slag generated by
their steel plant is as per Bureaau of Indian Standards. The slag consumption
was upto 50% depending upon the quality of clinker produced.
Actual production from VSK (average) on the day of monitoring was 85 TPD.
CRI — MVSK technology is based on the black meal process in which all the raw
materials, viz, limestonne, clay, fuel (coke breeze, Jhama coal or any suitable
low volatile coal) and other corrective materials are ground together to a fineness
of 10% retained on 170 mesh as in dry process and intimately blended to satisfy
the chemical requirements for the raw meal. The homogeneous raw meal is
formed into nodules of the desired size by adding water in a pan nodulizer and
fed into the vertical shaft kiln through a revolving feed hopper. As the material
passes down the kiln, it is dried, heated and then burnt into clinker. The clinker is
then cooled and discharged from the kiln by a rotary grate at the bottom of the
kiln through a triple airlock discharge device or gamma ray controlled material
Block Tube (MBT). The combustion air to the kiln, which is provided by a Roots
blower, also serves the purpose of cooling the clinker and thus avoids wastage of
heat. The clinker then passes on to a cement mill where it is ground with about
5% gypsum to produce cement of standard quality.
0
Table 7: Sections Causing Air Pollution
The stack emission monitoring was conducted at all the important sections and
details are given in Table 8 and 9.
37
Table 9: Other Stacks Emission Monitoring Results
The efficiency of bag filters in raw mill and cement mill was found to be 92%
and 95% respectively.
The ambient air quality monitoring results are given in Table 10.
38
13.1.6 Analysis of Particle Size Distribution of Particulate Matter
The particle size analysis of the dust collected in thimbles at the VSK Kiln is as
given below:
The plant is using 5 component mixes for clinker manufacture. The raw
materials used are two type of limestonne high & low grade, clay, Iron dust and
coke breeze. The chemical composition of the above materials and the raw meal
is given in Table 11. The raw materials consumption factor per tonne of cement
is given below:
Limestonne - I 0.50
Limestonne - II : 0.89
Clay : 0.07
Additive : 0.03
Coke breeze : 0.18
Compressive strength
39
Soundness
To study the effect of different raw materials proportions on clinker quality and
particulate matter emissions, using the same quality raw materials and only
changing the raw mix design (RMD), stack emissions were measured.
The present RMD had been changed to new RMD having following Modulii
values and increased liquid content which is given below:
SM AM LSF %LC
1.55 0.66 0.88 36.88
When the material with new RMD was fed to the kiln, the quality of clinker was
improved, the stack emissions were observed as given below:
Thus, it is observed that if the kiln is fed with proper nodules of optimum RMD
and proper process parameters are strictly followed as per the norms, particulate
matter emission from VSK is well below the stipulated norms.
The air pollution control devices installed in various sections are given in Table 7.
The design parameters like fan capacity, drive hp, no. of bags in various sections
alongwith the capacity of equipment are given in Table 12.
40
Table 12: Design Parameters of Air Pollution Control Devices installed at
Various Sections
13.1.10 Economics
The capital cost of air pollution control devices along with its maintenance cost
per annum for various sections are given in Table 13.
Table 13: Capital and Operation & Maintenance Cost of Air Pollution
Control Devices
41
The limit stipulated by Andhra Pradesh Pollution Control Board for particulate
matter emission is 115 mg/Nm 3 . Ambient air quality standard for SPM is 500
µg /M 3 .
Detrimental and unpleasant sound energy transmitted from one area to another
is classified as "Noise". The noise is generated in various sections has been
measured as shown in Table 14. The major sources of noise generation are raw
mill and cement mill. The distance between source of noise and point of
measurement is approximately 3 m. About 3 persons were working near each
mill. The location of noise measurement is indicated in the plant layout and
shown at Exhibit — 3.
Water required for a 200-tpd CRI -MVSK cement plant is 200 KUday for the
process and domestic purpose. The water quality of the plant is shown in
Table15.
Table 15: Water Quality
pH 5.5-9.0
Suspended Solids : 200 mg/I
Total dissolved solid 2100 mg/I
42
13.2 Plant - 2
13.2.1 History
5. Nodulisation -
6. VSK -
7. Clinker discharges -
8. Clinker tunnel -
43
13.2.4 Stack Emission
The stack emission monitoring was conducted at all the important sections and
details are given in Table 17 and Table 18.
The dust concentration at raw mill bag filter inlet was measured to estimate
the efficiency of the dust collector which was found to be 87.3%.
The Ambient Air Quality was monitored in down wind and up wind directions. The
ambient air quality monitoring results are given in Table 19.
44
Table 19: Ambient Air Quality
The particle size analysis of the dust collected in thimbles at the VSK Kiln is as
given below:
The plant is using 6 component mixes for clinker manufacture. The raw
materials used are two types of limestonnes, coke breeze, clay, iron ore and
bauxite. The chemical composition of the above materials and the raw meal is
given in Table 20.
The raw materials consumption factor per tonne of cement is given below:
Limestone - 1.28
Coke Breeze - 0.21
Clay - 0.09
Iron Ore - 0.025
Bauxite - 0.058
45
The cement quality obtained is shown below:
Compressive Strength
3 days :270-330 Kg / cm2
7 days :340-360 Kg / cm 2
28 days: > 480 Kg / cm 2
The raw mix design adopted by the plant is properly implemented with
appropriate process parameters.
The process parameters of Vertical Shaft Kilns (Kiln 1 & Kiln 2) are given below:
Kiln 1 Kiln 2
a) Nodule Size (mm) : 8-12 8-12
b) Moisture (%) : 13-14 13-14
c) Fuel in Kiln Feed (%) : 13.0-13.50 13.0-13.50
d) Rotary Grate Speed : 600-800 600-800
(Dyno drive rpm)
e) Clinker Temperature (°C) : 65-85 65-85
f) Bed level from top (mm) : 300-500 300-500
The pollution control devices installed in various sections are given in Table 16.
The design parameters like fan capacity, drive hp, no. of bags in various sections
alongwith the capacity of equipment are given in Table 21.
13.2.10 Economics
The capital cost of air pollution control devices along with its operation and
maintenance cost per annum for various sections were not made available. It
was informed that 32 & 22 Nos. of polyster needle woven bags per annum were
changed in Raw Mill & Cement Mill Pnu-jet bag filters respectively.
The noise measurements taken at various locations in the plant are shown in
Table 22. The major sources of noise generation are raw mill and cement mill.
The distance between source of noise and point of measurement is
approximately 3m. The numbers of persons working near the mills are 3 each.
46
The location of noise measurement is indicated in the plant layout and shown at
Exhibit-5.
Water required for the plant is 200 KUday mainly for the process purposes.
Water is used for nodulisation, raw mill trunion bearing cooling and cement mill
shell cooling.
47
13.3 Plant - 3
13.3.1 History
Saboo VSK Technology based on black meal process in which all Raw Materials
viz. Limestone, Clay, Coke Breeze, and Iron ore are ground together to a
fineness of 10% residue on 170 mesh (90µ) as in dry process and immediately
blended to satisfy the chemical quality requirement for the Raw Meal. The
homogenous Raw Meal is formed into nodules of desired size (6 to 12 mm
diameter) by adding water in a pan noduliser and fed into Vertical Shaft Kiln
through revolving feed hopper inside VSK arrangement. As the material passes
down the kiln, it is dried, calcined and burnt into clinker. The clinker is then
cooled and discharged by a rotary grate at the bottom of the kiln. through
discharge arrangement. The combustion air is supplied through Roots Blower,
also serves the purpose of cooling the clinker and thus avoids wastage of heat.
The cooled clinker then passes on to cement mill where it is ground with about
5% Gypsum to manufacture Cement of Standard Quality.
48
Table 23: Sections Causing Air Pollution
Flue gas analysis was carried out with "Flue Gas Analyser". The flue gas
analysis indicates presence of Carbon Monoxide to the extent of about 4091
ppm. The flue gas analysis for 02, CO2, CO and N 2 is given at Annexure II.
Fugitive dust emissions were measured near Raw Mill and are given in Annexure
II. Ambient air quality monitoring was carried out in upwind and downwind
directions and results are given in Annexure II.
Particle size distribution of the collected dust in thimbles (VSK Flue Gas) was
carried out and the values are given in Annexure II.
49
13.3.7 Raw Materials
The plant is using 4 component mixes for clinker manufacture. The raw
materials used are limestonne, clay, coke breeze and Iron ore. The raw mix
design followed by the plant is given below.
Limestonne = 73%
Clay = 12%
Coke breeze = 13%
Iron Ore = 2%
The raw materials consumption factor per tonne of clinker and cement are given
below in Table 24.
Noise levels were monitored at varius sources in the plant and are given in
Annexure II. The distance between source of noise and point of measurement is
approximately 3 m. The number of persons working near the sources is 3 each.
50
The average quantity of water required for this VSK cement plant is 10,000 litres
/ day as reported by the plant.
13.3.13 Manpower
13.4 Plant - 4
13.4.1 History
7. Future Expansion No
8. Types of cement OPC
Manufactured
Saboo VSK Technology based on black meal process in which all Raw Materials
viz. Limestonne, Clay, Coke Breeze, and Iron ore are ground together to a
fineness of 10% residue on 170 mesh (90).L) as in dry process and immediately
blended to satisfy the chemical quality requirement for the Raw Meal is formed
into nodules of desired size (6 to 12 mm diameter) by adding water in a pan
noduliser and fed into Vertical Shaft Kiln through revolving feed hopper inside
VSK arrangement. As the material passes down the kiln, it is dried calcined and
burnt into clinker. The clinker is then cooled and discharged by a rotary grate at
the bottom of the kiln through discharge arrangement. The combustion air is
supplied through Roots Blower, also serves the purpose of cooling the clinker
and thus avoids wastage of heat. The cooled clinker then passes on to cement
51
mill where it is ground with about 5% Gypsum to manufacture Cement of
Standard Quality.
8. Clinker Tunnel -
Flue gas analysis was carried out with "Flue Gas Analyser". The flue gas analysis
indicates presence of Carbon Monoxide in traces. The flue gas analysis for 02,
CO2, CO and N2 is given at Annexure Ill.
52
13.4.5 Ambient Air Quality
Fugitive dust emissions were measured at Jaw Crusher and are given in
Annexure III. Ambient air quality monitoring was carried out in upwind and
downwind directions and results are given in Annexure Ill.
Particle size distribution of the collected dust in thimbles (VSK Flue Gas) was
carried out and the values are given in Annexure lil.
The plant is using 4 component mixes for clinker manufacture. The raw materials
used are limestonne, clay, coke breeze and Iron ore. The raw mix design
followed by the plant is given below.
Limestonne = 75%
Clay = 8.75%
Coke breeze = 12%
Iron Ore = 3.75%
The raw materials consumption factor per tonne of clinker and cement are given
belowin Table 26.
Consumption Factor
SI. No. Raw Materials Per tonne of Per tonne of
clinker cement
1 Limestonne 1.250 1.188
2 Clay 0.150 0.143
3 Coke Breeze 0.210 0.200
4 Iron Ore 0.063 0.060
53
d) Clinker Temperature (°C) - 50-80
e) Bed Length from top (mw) - 300-500
Noise levels were monitored at various sources in the plant and are given in
Annexure III. The distance between source of noise and point of measurement is
approximately 3 m. The number of persons working near the sources is 3 each.
The average quantity of water required for this VSK cement plant is 15,000 Ilitres
/ day as reported by the plant.
13.4.13 Manpower
13.5 Plant - 5
13.5.1 History
Saboo VSK Technology based on black meal process in which all Raw Materials
viz. Limestonne, Clay, Coke Breeze, and iron ore are ground together to a
fineness of 10% residue on 170 mesh (90.t) as in dry process and immediately
54
blended to satisfy the chemical quality requirement for the Raw Meal. The
homogenous Raw Meal is formed into nodules of desired size (6 to 12 mm
diameter) by adding water in a pan noduliser and fed into Vertical Shaft Kiln
through revolving feed hopper inside VSK arrangement. As the material passes
down the kiln, it is dried, calcined and burnt into clinker. The clinker is then
cooled and discharged from the kiln through discharge arrangement. The
combustion air is supplied through Roots Blower, also serves the purpose of
cooling the clinker and thus avoids wastage of heat. The cooled clinker then
passes on to cement mill where it is ground with about 5% Gypsum to
manufacture Cement of Standard Quality.
55
Flue gas analysis was carried out with "Flue Gas Analyser". The flue gas
analysis indicates presence of carbon monoxide in traces. The flue gas analysis
for 02, CO2, CO and N 2 is given at Annexure IV.
Fugitive dust emissions were measured near raw mill section and the values are
given in Annexure IV. Ambient air quality monitoring was carried out in upwind
and downwind directions and results are given in Annexure IV.
Particle size distribution of the collected dust in thimbles (VSK Flue Gas) was
carried out and the values are given in Annexure IV.
The plant is using 4 component mixes for clinker manufacture. The raw
materials used are limestonne, clay, coke breeze and Iron ore. The raw mix
design following by the plant is given below.
Limestonne = 72.40%
Coke Breeze = 12.00%
Clay = 12.30%
Laterite = 3.30%
The raw materials consumption factor per tonne of clinker and cement are given
below in Table 28.
Consumption Factor
SI. No. Raw Materials Per tonne of Per tonne of
clinker cement
1 Limestonne 1.216 1.155
2 Clay 0.202 0.192
3 Coke Breeze 0.210 0.200
4 Iron Ore 0.055 0.052
56
13.5.9 Process Parameters of VSK
Noise levels were monitored at various sources in the plant and are given in
Annexure IV. The distance between source of noise and point of measurement is
approximately 3 m. The number of persons working near the sources is 3 each.
The average quantity of water required for this VSK cement plant is 15,000 litres/
day as reported by the plant.
13.5.13 Manpower
The total manpower deployed at this plant, as reported by them, is 12 staff and
18 contract labours.
13.6 Plant - 6
13.6.1 History
Saboo VSK Technology based on black meal process in which all Raw Materials
viz. Limestonne, Clay, Coke Breeze, and laterite are ground together to a
fineness of 10% residue on 170 mesh (90µ) as in dry process and immediately
blended to satisfy the chemical quality requirement for the Raw Meal. The
homogenous Raw Meal is formed into nodules of desired size (6 to 12 mm
diameter) by adding water in a pan noduliser and fed into Vertical Shaft Kiln
through revolving feed hopper inside VSK arrangement. As the material passes
down the kiln, it is dried, calcined and burnt into clinker. The clinker is then
cooled and discharged by a rotary grate at the bottom of the kiln through
discharge arrangement. The combustion air is supplied through Roots Blower,
also serves the purpose of cooling the clinker and thus avoids wastage of heat.
The cooled clinker then passes on to cement mill where it is ground with about
5% Gypsum to manufacture Cement of Standard Quality.
Flue gas analysis was carried out with "Flue Gas Analyser". The flue gas
analysis indicates presence of carbon monoxide in traces. The flue gas analysis
for 02, CO2, CO and N2 is given at Annexure V.
Fugitive dust emissions were measured near Jaw Crusher and are given in
Annexure V. Ambient air quality monitoring was carried out in upwind and
downwind directions and results are given in Annexure V.
Particle size distribution of the collected dust in thimbles (VSK Flue Gas) was
carried out and the values are given in Annexure V.
The plant is using 4 component mixes for clinker manufacture. The raw
materials used are limestonne, clay, coke breeze and Iron ore. The raw mix
design followed by the plant is given below.
Limestonne = 72%
Coke Breeze = 11%
Clay = 13%
Laterite = 4%
The raw materials consumption factor per tonne of clinker and cement are given
belowin Table 30.
Consumption Factor
SI. No. Raw Materials Per tonne of Per tonne of
clinker cement
1 Limestonne 1.210 1.150
2 Clay 0.185 0.178
3 Coke Breeze 0.220 0.209
4 Iron Ore 0.065 0.062
59
13.6.9 Process Parameters of VSK
Noise levels were monitored at various sources in the plant and are given in
Annexure V. The distance between source at noise and point of measurement is
approximately 3 m. The numbers of persons working near the sources are 3
each.
The average quantity of water required for this VSK cement plant is 5,000 litres /
day as reported by the plant.
13.6.13 Manpower
The total manpower deployed at this plant, as reported by them, is 8 staff and 9
contract labours.
13.7 Plant-7
13.7.1 History
1. Name of Plant Plant —7
2. Location Behror, Rajasthan
3. Installed Capacity 50 TPD
Actual output obtained 27 TPD
(Average) on the days of
monitoring
4. Year of Commissioning 1990
5. Technology Adopted Semi Dry Process
Saboo VSK Technology
6. Actual Cement Production 10,990 Tonnes / Annum
7. Future Expansion No
8. Types of cement Ordinary Portland Cement
Manufactured
60
13.7.2 Manufacturing Process and Flow Sheet
Saboo VSK Technology based on black meal process in which all Raw Materials
viz. Limestonne, Clay, Coke Breeze, and laterite are ground together to a
fineness of 10% residue on 170 mesh (90µ) as in dry process and immediately
blended to satisfy the chemical quality requirement for the Raw Meal. The
homogenous Raw Meal is formed into nodules of desired size (6 to 12 mm
diameter) by adding water in a pan noduliser and fed into Vertical Shaft Kiln
through revolving feed hopper inside VSK arrangement. As the material passes
down the kiln, it is dried, calcined and burnt into clinker. The clinker is then
cooled and discharged by a rotary grate at the bottom of the kiln through
discharge arrangement. The combustion air is supplied through Roots Blower,
also serves the purpose of cooling the clinker and thus avoids wastage of heat.
The cooled clinker then passes on to cement mill where it is ground with about
5% Gypsum to manufacture Cement of Standard Quality.
61
• Flue gas temp. (°C) = 123
• Exit gas velocity of flue gas (m/sec) = 1.6319
• Flow rate (m 3 /hr) = 3392
Stack flue gas analysis was carried out with "Flue Gas Analyser". The flue gas
analysis indicates presence of carbon monoxide in traces. The flue gas analysis
for 02, CO2, CO and N2 is given at Annexure VI.
Fugitive dust emissions were measured near raw mill and are given in Annexure
VI. Ambient air quality monitoring was carried out in upwind and downwind
directions and results are given in Annexure VI.
Particle size distribution of the collected dust in thimbles (VSK Chimney Flue
Gas) was carried out and the values are given in Annexure VI.
The plant is using 4 component mixes for clinker manufacture. The raw
materials used are limestonne, clay, coke breeze and Iron ore. The raw mix
design followed by the plant is given below.
Limestonne = 77.10%
Coke Breeze = 15.70%
Clay = 4.30%
Laterite = 2.90%
The raw materials consumption factor per tonne of clinker and cement are given
below in Table 32.
62
The specific thermal energy consumption is 1248 Kcals/Kg of clinker, whenever
there is no power supply, the plant is being operated with Diesel Generator set.
Noise levels were monitored at various sources in the plant and are given in
Annexure VI. The distance between source of noise and point of measurement is
approximately 3 m. The numbers of persons working near the sources are 3
each.
The average quantity of water required for this VSK cement plant is 14,500 litres
/ day as reported by the plant.
13.7.13 Manpower
The total manpower deployed at this plant, as reported by them, is 12 staff and
28 contract labours.
13.8 Plant - 8
13.8.1 History
63
6. Actual Cement Production
5,121 Tonnes / Annum
7. Future Expansion No
8. Types of cement
Ordinary Portland Cement
Manufactured (OPC)
Saboo VSK Technology based on black meal process in which all Raw Materials
viz. Limestonne, Clay, Pet Coke and Laterite are ground together to a fineness of
10% residue on 170 mesh (90µ) as in dry process and immediately blended to
satisfy the chemical quality requirement for the Raw Meal. The homogenous
Raw Meal is formed into nodules of desired size (6 to 12 mm diameter) by adding
water in a pan noduliser and fed into Vertical Shaft Kiln through revolving feed
hopper inside VSK arrangement. As the material passes down the kiln, it is
dried, calcined and burnt into clinker. The clinker is then cooled and discharged
by a rotary grate at the bottom of the kiln through discharge arrangement. The
combustion air is supplied through Roots Blower, also serves the purpose of
cooling the clinker and thus avoids wastage of heat. The cooled clinker then
passes on to cement mill where it is ground with about 5% Gypsum to
manufacture Cement of Standard Quality.
64
chamber and 64 to 184 mg/Nm 3 after dust setting chamber. Particulate matter
emission rate varies from 0.85 to 1.02 Kg/hr before dust setting chamber and
0.10 to 0.13 Kg/hr after dust setting chamber. SO2 ,concentration in the flue gas
analysis varies from 7 mg/Nm 3 to 8 mg/Nm 3 . The details of the stack (VSK
chimney) are given below:
Flue gas analysis was carried out with "Flue Gas Analyser". The flue gas
analysis indicates presence of carbon monoxide in traces. The flue gas analysis
for 02, CO 2 , CO and N 2 is given at Annexure VII.
Fugitive dust emissions were measured near Jaw Crusher and are given in
Annexure VII. Ambient air quality monitoring was carried out in upwind and
downwind directions and results are given in Annexure VII.
Particle size distribution of the collected dust in thimbles (VSK Chimney Flue
Gas) was carried out and the values are given in Annexure VII.
The plant is using 4 component mixes for clinker manufacture. The raw
materials used are limestonne, clay, coke breeze and Iron ore. The raw mix
design followed by the plant is given below.
Limestonne = 74.70%
Pet Coke = 8.70%
Clay = 13.30%
Laterite = 3.30%
The raw materials consumption factor per tonne of clinker and cement are given
below in Table 34.
65
Table 34: Raw Materials Consumption Factor
Consumption Factor
SI. No. Raw Materials Per tonne of Per tonne of
clinker cement
1 Limestonne 1.27 1.207
2 Clay 0.15 0.143
3 Coke Breeze 0.22 0.209
4 Iron Ore 0.06 0.057
Noise levels were monitored at various sources in the plant and are given in
Annexure VII. The distance between source of noise and point of measurement
is approximately 3 m. The numbers of persons working near the sources are 3
each.
The average quantity of water required for this VSK cement plant is 15,000 Its /
day as reported by the plant.
13.8.13 Manpower
The total manpower deployed at this plant, as reported by them, is 10 staff and 9
contract labours.
66
14.0 EMISSION STANDARDS FOR CEMENT SECTOR
The emission standards for cement plants notified under the Environment
Protection Act, 1986 are given below in Table 35.
Emission Limit(mg/Nm 3 )
The emission standards for new cement kils including grinding units is given
below.
The basic mechanism of removing particulate matter from gas stream may be
classified as:
1. Gravitational Settling
2. Centrifugal Impaction
3. Inertial Impaction
4. Direct Interception
5. Diffusion
67
velocity of gas (or) air stream. The gas is directed from the dust generating
equipment into the large volume settling chamber, where the velocity drops low
enough to let large dust particles drop out by gravity. Dust settling chambers are
sometimes equipped with deflectors, to charge the direction of gas flow and so to
shorten the settling path of particles, improving collection efficiency. Because of
the simple construction, gravity-settling chambers are the lowest in cost, but at
the same time also the least effective dust collection devices.
15.2 Cyclones
15.2.1 Operation
Cyclones are low cost dust collectors, without moving parts, and can be
furnished with refractory linings for high temperature upto 1800°F.
The pressure drop of cyclones is in the range from 1.2 to 6.5 inches water
column and depends on
- The temperature of the gas;
- The size of the cyclone; and on
- The inlet velocity of the gas.
Design proportions of a cyclone dust separator are given in Fig. 9.
FIG. 8 SCHEMATIC OF GRAVITY SETTING CHAMBERS
A A
A
L
--I
GAS
Bc =
De =
He
Lc =
Sc =
Zc =
Jc =
DUST OUT
Operational problems in cyclone are more due to process factors rather than
constructional aspects. Some of the operational problems in cyclone are given
below.
i) Plugging of cyclone either in inlet duct, cyclone body or in exit duct.
Plugging of inlet duct can occur when dust agglomerates due to fineness
or presence of moisture particularly when temperature falls below due
point of gas. Plugging of cyclone body occurs when hopper is plugged
and dust level rises in cyclone.
ii) Erosion in cyclone is caused by impingement and rubbing of dust
particles on cyclone wall due to high dust loading, high inlet velocity and
coarse dust particles.
Multicyclones are enclosed units arranged in banks for parallel flow with feed gas
from a plenum chamber and with a common dust discharge hopper; multicyclone
units can contain upto 400 individual cyclones.
The pressure drop across the fabric filter is about 100-125 mmWG and the
collection efficiency is as high as 99.99% depending on the type of fabric used. It
is a constant efficiency dust collector and minor variations in process parameters
affect the performance of fabric filter. Bag house filter media and cleaning system
constitute basic components of the fabric filter.
71
CLEAN AIR INTAKE OF DUST
DISCHARGE LADEN AIR
ACCESS DOORS
The following advantages makes the fabric filters the best choice in many cases.
15.5.1 Operation
The basic function of wet scrubbers is to provide contact between the scrubbing
liquid, usually water, and the particulate to be collected. This contact can be
achieved in a variety of ways as the particles are confronted with so called
impaction targets — which can be wetted surfaces or individual droplets.
Whether the particles encounter wetted surfaces as in packed Scrubbers or
individual droplets as in spray scrubbers, the basic mechanism are the same as
73
.EAN GAS
MECHANISM
SAGS
DUSTY GAS
ON
DUST OUTLET
74
in filters; inertial impaction, interception and diffusion. Generally impaction and
interception are the predominant mechanisms for particles of diameter above 0.3
µm, and for particles of diameter below 0.3µm, diffusion begins to prevail. In
addition, diffusiophoretic deposition and electrostatic precipitation also effect
particle collection. Diffusiophoretic deposition can be significant when mass
transfer within the scrubber, caused by condensation of water vapour from the
gas onto a cold liquid surface, exerts a force upon the particles and causes them
to get deposit on the surface.
There are many scrubber designs presently available where the contact between
the scrubbing liquid and the particles is achieved in a variety of ways the major
types are
i) Spray Towers
ii) Centrifugal scrubbers
iii) Packed beds and plate columns
iv) Venturi Scrubbers
Each type of design has a certain range of applicabitty. Thus low energy
scrubbers such as spray towers are most often used to handle particles largely
about 5-10 µm in diameter.
The effectiveness of the conventional spray tower ranges from 94% for 5 µm
particles to 99% for 25µm particles.
75
CLEAN GAS OUT
II
MIST EL
WATER IN
0 SPRAYS
0
° ° o
0 0 00
DIRTY GAS IN
^ o 0
SLURRY OUT
76
16.0 SOURCES OF AIR POLLUTION
16.1 Introduction
Pollution control aspects are being given increasing attention in recent years.
Mini cement plant is basically air polluting industry. Air pollution, which basically,
can be caused by both particulates and gaseous pollutant, the CRI — MVSK
cement plant operation ensures negligible emission of the latter such as NO etc
as optimised operating conditions of the kiln generally prevents emission of such
gases. The generation of particulates, however, is inherent in the manufacturing
process and the associated unit operations, which is controlled by the application
of dust collectors wherever required. The operation of vertical shaft kiln, which is
the heart of process, is such that less emission takes place as the shaft kiln itself
acts as an effective filter.
The manufacturing process involved in the VSK mini cement plants essentially
consists of the following steps:
• Mining and crushing of limestonne (and additives, if necessary) ;
• Proportioning of raw materials and fuel based on raw mix design;
• Grinding and blending to obtain fine homogenised black meal;
• Preparation of nodules ;
• Feeding the nodules to vertical shaft kiln wherein the drying, preheating,
calcining and sintering takes place resulting in the formation of clinker;
• Clinker cooling in the kiln;
• Grinding of clinker and gypsum in controlled proportion to produce ordinary
portland cement;
• Storage, packing and despatch of cement.
16.3.1 Mining
Mostly mini cement plant sector does not have its own captive mines. They buy
limestone mostly from other agencies. Wherever captive mines are there, mining
is generally carried out manually. The level of dust generation during drilling /
blasting and loading of limestonne is generally low. Dust suppression techniques
such as water spray are generally found adequate.
riA
coke breeze, additive are stored in hoppers. These materials are extracted from
individual hoppers and are conveyed to the raw grinding section. A single
cyclone/fabric filter is mostly used to collect dust from both the crushing as well
as raw materials proportioning section and sometimes separate dust collectors
for these two sections are also recommended depending on the specific
situation.
Depending upon the raw material characteristics, air swept ball mills or vertical
roller mills are usually employed for the intergrinding of raw materials and fuel. In
both the cases, cyclones and fabrics filters are used to keep the emission low.
Raw meal is extracted from the noduliser feed hopper and is fed to noduliser
where water is also sprayed to form nodules. In order to collect dust from
noduliser a fabric filter is used.
The system design and the technology used in the CRI - Modern vertical shaft
kiln (CRI - MVSK) have adequate in built provision to restrict dust emission from
chimney. This is a unique feature performed by the MVSK, which in addition to
clinkerisation also reduce the dust generation significantly. The green bed of
moist nodules, which are constantly distributed on the top by the rotary feeder,
would trap most of the dust particles and only allow gases into the stack. In fact
when CRI — MVSKs are operated as per the norms and procedures, the emission
levels are very much within the stipulated norms. In addition, the principle of
natural draft, which is employed in the system, further ensures very little
entrainment of dust particles and even the small particles which may get into the
gas stream, would settle down on the bed due to gravity as the velocity is very
less in the stack.
Whilst, in general the operational experiences have proved that the kilns based
on CRI — MVSK technology do not pose any problem in regard to dust emission,
a dust collector of simple design has been developed by NCB which has been
successfully installed in CRI — MVSK cement plants. The flue gases from the
VSK is made to pass through the dust settling chambers, wherein the dust
particles get settled in the chamber, the dust so collected can be re-used in the
process.
7a
16.3.6 Clinker Handling
Clinker discharged from MVSK through triple air lock discharge gas / material
block tube is crushed in a jaw crusher. Clinker and gypsum stored in separate
hoppers are extracted to feed to the grinding mill. A fabric filter is used to collect
dust from discharge gate / material block tube, clinker crusher and clinker and
gypsum extraction points beneath their respective hoppers.
In mini cement plants based on CRI -MVSK technology, generally open circuit
tube mills are employed for cement grinding. The mill works on overflow
principle and the product is directly conveyed to the storage silo. Fabric filters
are used to facilitate dust collection to ensure very low emissions.
Specific instances of fugitive dust generations include dust blown by wind from
raw materials stockpile, dust caused by vehicular traffic within the factory, dust
leakage from conveyors, conveyor transfer points, silos, storage hoppers and
packers etc. Good house keeping, proper maintenance, wetting of dusty areas,
use of enclosed storage wherever feasible etc would eliminate fugitive dust.
79
SI.
Section Type of Dust Collector
No.
4 Noduliser Bag filter with proper metallic
casing, stack height and stack
monitoring requirement
6 Clinker Crusher and Discharge Tube Bag filter with proper metallic
casing, stack height and stack
monitoring requirement
The above air pollution control devices are indicative in nature. Cement Plant
may explore the possibilities of other devices also. The important thing which
is to be kept in mind is that in all the cases the plant has to meet the
prescribed emission standards.
80
Annexure
Jharkhand
81
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
7 Shri Nim Dorji,
Managing Director
Penden Cement Authority 1983 100
P.O.Gomtu, - 734401
Siliguri R.M.S. (VIA)
Bhutan
82
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
13 Sh. Sunil Aggarwal
Managing Director
Prominent Cement Pvt. Ltd., 1984 100
1-12/C Gandhi Nagar,
Gwalior 474002
Madhya Pradesh
18 Sh. G. Karisiddappa
Managing Director
Shiva Minerals & Cement Inds. P. Ltd., 1985 100
409, 1s t Floor, 12` h Cross,
Sadashivanagar,
Bangalore — 560080
83
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
19 The Managing Director,
Lakshmi Cements I& Ceramics Inds. Ltd.,
Ittigehalli 1985 100
Mattodu Hobli,
Hosadurga Taluq,
Karnataka
Tehsil Jabera
-
Distt. Damoh,
-
Madhya Pradesh
24 Sh Manjunath
Managing Director
Bhagya Cement Pvt. Ltd., 1985 20
Village Nalwar
—
Chittapur Taluk
Gulbarga District,
Karnataka.
84
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
25 Sh. Ashok Babu
Works Manager (A)
Annapurna Cements Pvt. Ltd., 1987 200
Samela Village,
Asifabad Taluq,
Adilabad Distt,
Andhra Pradesh
85
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity 1
Commissioning (tpd)
31 Sh. S.R. Sehgal
Managing Director
Calcar Producuts Pvt. Ltd., 1987 100
Bhupdeopur, Kharasia Taluq,
Raigarh Distt.
Madhya Pradesh — 496661
36 Managing Director
Marls Cements Pvt. Ltd.,
Dodda Byladakere 1986 30
Hosadurga Taluk
Chitradurga District,
Karnataka
86
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
37 The Managing Director
Devshree Cement Limited,
Kharia Mithapur 1988 100
Jodhpur Distt.
Rajasthan
39 Sunder Thakur
Executive Director
Varun Cements Pvt. Ltd., 1985 200
B-105, HIG Colony,
Indore — 452008
Madhya Pradesh
87
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
43 Sh,. Shalig Ram Parita
Managing Director
Balaghat Cements (P) Ltd., 1988 200
119, 1st Floor
Malviya Nagar,
Bhopal — 462003
Madhya Pradesh
88
Si. No. Plant's Name and Address. Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
49 The Managing Director
Seetharam Cements Ltd.,
Plot No. 79, Panaji Road, 1987 100
Mehboob Nagar District,
Pin 509216
—
Madhya Pradesh
59 Sh. N. Indorewala
Managing Director,
Suvidha Commercial Co. (P) Ltd., 1985 50
250 Maulana Azad Road (North)
Bombay 400008
—
62 Sh. A. Sennimalai
Vice President
Dharani Cements Limited, 1987
1 Venus Colony
Second Street,
Aiwarpet,
Madras — 600018
91
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
67 The manaaina Director
Madurai Cements Ltd.,
14712A/1 IA, Melur Main Road, 1987 300
2 Floor,
Near K. K. Nagar Arch.
Madurai — 625020
72 Sh. G. Kallappa
Managing Director
Hemavathi Cements Pvt. Ltd., 1990 30
5 & 6 SSB Mutt Bldg.,
Tankbund Road,
Bangalore 560009
92
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
73 Sh. L.R. Jajee
Managing Director
Gitanjali Cements (P) Ltd., 1990 30
8-120 Cloth Bazar,
Gulbarga 585102,
—
Karnataka
Andhra Pradesh
Assam.
93
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
_ Commissi oning 1__ (tpd) ,_l
79 P.S.G. Krishnan
Managing Director
Rekha Cements & Chemicals Ltd., 1991 100
Basava Nivas
29/1 K.H. Road
Bangalore — 560027
81 Sh. Mehmood-ul-Hassan
Managing Director
J. & K Minerals Ltd., 1990
The Bund
Srinagar 190001
J & K.
94
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Com mission ing _ td
85 Sh. B. Arya,
Managing Director,
Damoh Clinker (P) Ltd., 1992 50
Peter's Bungalow,
Civil Ward 3
Damoh 470661
—
87 Sh. Phuntsho
General Manager
Lakhi Cement Project 1993 100
C/o. Penden Cement Authority
Gomtu,
Bhutan
Nagaland
Meghalaya.
95
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
91 Sh. D.K. Chetiya
Managing Director
Umrangso Cements Ltd., 1993 100
Khanapara
Narangi Road,
Guwahati 781022
Assam.
92 Sh. J.D.Agrawal,
Managing Director
Quality Cement Industries Ltd., 1994 100
Sr. MIG No. 3, Sector- A,
Indrapuri
Bhopal — 462021
96
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (t pd)
97 Sh. Arvind Bandwalkar
Managing Director
Bandwalkar Cements Pvt. Ltd. 30
'TRIMURTI'
Shahu Nagar
Ichalkaranji — 416115
Karnataka
Madhya Pradesh
Orissa.
101 Sh. G.P. Agarwal
Vandana Cements Pvt. Ltd.,
Dainik Bhaskar Bhawan - 100
4/54, Press Complex, A-B Road,
Indore 452008
—
Madhya Pradesh
97
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
104 Sh. Ashtaq Ahmed,
Managing Director
Trumboo Cement Industries (Pvt.) Ltd. 1999 200
2 Floor, Baba Building
Poloview, Srinagar
Jammu & Kashmir
98
A 2 : CEMENT RESEARCH INSTITUTE OF INDIA MODERN VERTICAL SHAFT
KILN (CRI -MVSK) CEMENT PLANTS UNDER IMPLEMENTATION
100
SI. Plant's Name Location, District Capacity
No. and State (tpd)
22 Janpriya Cements Pvt. Ltd. (Expansion) Neem-ka -Thana 100
Sikar
Rajasthan
101
SI. Plant's Name Location, District Capacity
No. and State (tpd)
35 Kalinga Cement Ltd. (Expansion) Birmitrapur 50
Sundergarh
Orissa
102
SI. Plant's Name Location, District Capacity
No. and State (tpd)
47 Dhrungadhara Chemicals Ltd. Dhrungadhara 150
Sundarnagar
Gujarat
103
B SABOO VSK CEMENT PLANTS IN OPERATION
:
3 Shri S. S. Dadi
Modern Cement Co. Pvt. Ltd.
Vill : Chikhodra, Taluka : Godhra April 1985 50
Distt. Panchmahal
(G ujarat)
6 Sh. S. Sriniwasan,
Modern Portland Cement Co. Pvt. Ltd.,
Viii. Chikhodra, Taluka — Godhra Jan. 1989 30
Distt. Panchmahal
(Gujarat)
item]
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
8 Mr. I. M. 5hekh
Star Cement Company
C/o. Royal Ice Factory Dec. 1992 50
Sikari Mohalla, Godhra
Distt. Panchmahal.
(Gujarat)
Site Vanakpur
:
14 Shri R.P.Agarwal
Monchu Cements Ltd.
3103, Sangtrushan Street, 1997 50
Pharganj
New Delhi (Site: Vill- Dhulawat)
105
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year ofapacity
Commissioning (tpd)
15 Shri P. C. Gandhi
Satyashree Cement Udyog
Bhungarni, Distt. Paonta Sahib Dec. 1985 30
Himachal Pradeh.
i<(II•
Si No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
22 Shri G.D. Naidu
Seshasaila Cements Pvt. Ltd.
49/8, 4 th Main, 16 th Cross Oct. 1988 20
Malleshwaram,
Bangalore.
27 Sh. O. P. Mittal,
Polyport Cement
138, Sneh Nagar, Jan. 1990 100
Indore, Madhya Pradesh
28 Shri Y. Singh
Chitrakut Cement Pvt. Ltd.,
128, Chanakyapuri April 1993 50
Semaria Chowk
Satna (M.P.)
(Site: Rewa)
107
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
31 Shri R.B. Agarwal
Hasi Cement Pvt. Ltd.
Cotton Market Road Jan. 1987 30
Amravati
Maharashtra
108
St. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
38 Shri N.K. Agarwal
Krishna Cement Pvt. Ltd.,
H-3, Civil Township Oct. 1984 40
Rourkela
(Orissa)
109
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
45 Shri P.K. Saraf,
Kanak Cement Pvt. Ltd.
OCL Approach Road Feb. 1992 50
Rajgangpur (Orissa).
110
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
54 Shri G.S. Agarwal
Solar Cements Pvt. Ltd.
Vill. Barodara June 1984 20
Post — Lachmangarh
Distt. Sikar
(Rajasthan)
111
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
61 Shri S.N. Sharma
Om Shiv Shakti Cement Pvt. Ltd.
F-15, Industrial Area Oct. 1985 20
Sikar
(Rajasthan)
63 S.V. Dujodwala
Maruti Cement Pvt. Ltd.
Dujodwala Sadan, Bajaj Road Nov. 1985 20
Sikar (Site : Khandela)
Rajasthan
112
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
68 Shri Umesh Dhoot
Silver Cements Pvt. Ltd.
C/o. Gulab Dass Jaggnath Agencies 20
Nahata Building, Chopasni Road Closed
Jodhpur (Site : Abu Road)
Rajasthan
71 S.G. Saboo
Saboo Minerals Pvt. Ltd.
Marudhar Industrial Area June 1985 50
Basni, II-Phase,
Jodhpur
Rajasthan
113
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
75 Shri Mukesh Gajaraia
Unilinks Cements Pvt. Ltd.
Vill. Kiverli, By Pass Road July 1988 30
Abu Road,
Rajasthan
77 Shri Vinodji
Durga Cement Pvt. Ltd
Vill. Bhujela, P.O. Bharrja Feb. 1990 30
Distt — Abu Road
Rajasthan
114
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning t d
82 Shri Duli Chanji
Superfine Cement Pvt. Ltd.
E-32 Industrial Area Sept.1991 50
Mertacity, Distt. Nagaur
Rajasthan
115
Si. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
89 Shri Yoaesh Pal Tanari
Jyoti Cement Pvt. Ltd.
F-68, E-70, Industrial Area March1992 50
Behror
Rajasthan
92 Shri R. Prakash
Javeline Cement Pvt. Ltd:
E-21 1, Greater kailash-I I June 1992 50
New Delhi —110048
(Site : Sujangarh)
116
SI. No. Piss Nam. and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning
96 Shri Shreechand Jain
Bothra Contractors & Builders
E-121, Shastri Nagar July 1992 50
Jaipur (Site: Beewar)
Rajasthan
117
SI. No. T Plant's Name and Address Year of
Com missi oning
Capacity
118
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
110 Shri Ram Prasad Dhoot
Rajasthan Cement Udyog
RIICO Industrial Area April. 1993 50
Phulera, Distt. Jaipur
Rajasthan
Rajasthan
119
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning t d
117 Shri Girish Gupta
Gupta Cements Pvt. Ltd.
22, New Rajdhani Enclave, Vikas Marg April. 1994 50
New Delhi (Site: Chirawa)
120
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
124 Shri B.L. Maheswari
Sarvottam Cement Pvt. Ltd.
Charkara, Nokha Nov.. 1993 50
Distt. Bikaner (Site: Nokha)
Rajasthan
121
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
131 Shri V.B. Agarwal
Gujarat Filaments Limited
1005, Raheja Centre June 1995 140
Nariman Point
Bombay — 400021
(Site : Kotputli)
122
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
138 Shri R. Agarwal
Namo Cement Pvt. Ltd.
77, N.S. Road, Jan 1994 50
Suite No. S-8, 4 th Floor
Calcutta (Site: Kotputli)
123
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
145 Shri Prem Sheth
Vikram Cement Pvt. Ltd.
4/283, Vishnupuri Aug.1987 50
Kanpur
Uttar Pradesh
124
125
I. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
159 M/s. Pankaj Cements Pvt. Ltd.
416, Kucha Brijnath
Chandni Chowk Dec. 1993 50
New Delhi
126
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
169 M/s. Katni Cement Pvt. Ltd.
M.P. 1993 50
127
I. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
128
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
192 M/s. Jayshree Cement
Rajasthan March1993 50
Bhavnagar Distt.
Bambhori Village,
Erandon Tq.
129
SI. No. I Plant's Name and Address I Year of
Commissioning
Capacity
(tod)
202 M/s. Pithe Cement & Ind. Ltd.
Prithvipura Village 100
(Bilara Jaitaran Highway)
Jaitaran Tehsil, Pali Distt.
130
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Year of Capacity
Commissioning (tpd)
212 M/s. Bangur Cement Pvt. Ltd.,
Abu Road, 50
(Rajasthan)
131
C1 : REGIONAL RESEARCH LABORATORY (RRL) VSK MINI CEMENT PLANTS IN
OPERATION
SI. No. IP
lant's Name and Address Capacity (t pd)
1 Kutch Cements Pvt. Ltd.,
Hari Kripa
Station Road, Bhuj
Kutch — 370001 25
(Gujarat)
132
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Capacity (tpd)
133
SI. No. Plant's Name and Address Capacity (tpd)
134
C 2: REGIONAL RESEARCH LABORATORY (RRL) VSK CEMENT PLANTS UNDER
IMPLEMENTATION
135
SI. No. IP
lant's Name and Address Capacity (tpd)
9 Swastic Cement Industries Pvt. Ltd.
Thakar Chambers 25
Bedi Gate, Jamnagar —1
(Gujarat)
136
a>
L.
U N N
3 ^ÓM
rr
>COM NT-
0 .O -0Q N(N
C E CD
E C C_
p 3 M M M
r c
C
O D- r r J
r N 0)Ó ^^
E O r N m O r-
L a N f^
(N
O N N N N N
E
t0 c^6 CO
U _ D r r _
c1 m
Cu 3 N C
E
Q L Oe-_ Ot- CO C)
M c W ^t ^ A S CO o . Do (0
C1 - 1* p ^CNNN fB Co Y^ r0)á- co
N 00 C) O 4) 000
O 0 ^m U) C (0
emu-) rU)k-0N t- >000rrrco-
M
0 0
Z
a
C Cu
L E
á M M en 0 E Z s 5 Z
ó .. E E E
M
C
O
°' m E^zU EI
-- .-
0
C
C
0
U) ^ ï
.9 0
N O ^I
W fl ^
o- m L
O
U .3 ^ >
• L co fu
O =
U~ C Q Q
a 2E 0
mf°cu N^ D C L E
U (^ O ' N C N O '2 N O 0.,
O
t4 E Ó
NQ E = ^•, N zo> in ,C 2 co m
Q (4 O —
O -a Ó Q N O•• U Cu to -- • V L O !0
y- ^CD.CO c>L..^ VCCO E Lo3:0
O O C L v- y y_ C- a)0 O O W 0 d) O O O N
O O N O t6 •^ U •. Co O O ^C +S O> LL _V N O
ECuCCRy0 ^^^ ^^^CiNS N KUcoE <n <p'E'`00 N
Z J a- E >- W LL Q Q o- UJ L- J C7 N O Z U) J 0 C7 C7 Q W W V)
rNM 000 I^
HHHHHHWWW1
137
C u^ co
Y W
O o
U Ó
m 00 v
-, C)
a)
d
Cl) Q
C my O
ó cri
CO N — 6)
o 2
0
4-
0
O N 3m
Cu
O
ii
O C 1 d)
O 1rn 4-
^- O CJ
L
N N _ LL m
E O
N a0 CO
Cl) D-
0
U 0
00
0
di
L.
L- oo^N L
N ^
m
O Urn p
C
O ^
O -,)
00
00)
o0)
E Y
°p mn
0) C)CD i ÓO ^N
- tt^ - 0co0 co e- r- ó MCO r-.-
W =
N
o 0
E
c U U
C C
u
0
1 2LQ
E UCu
a)
C
C
^N
Co
<
U) c
a) 2>
0
O 'o -JV. - '
0
N
d
a >C pa) 0)
a^ vC
U O O Cu
U)
C V W (1)
( N
C N Q C O
., w Cu C 0 3
L N °' Ó E o Q%
L +^ Ó t)
o
mQ) t
N =0U > F- 2
U) C O U C
fC ^0
m ._
- Q. _ O +. Rf
00 o N` v It
0)000 Z I- U 0O u^ . Z o0OWO<
v
M
6 .Q U N
0) p
-
r
r
N
CM
CU
- U Dm 'acD
138
co N N
p C C N O m
O e-- D ^- M M M
T
+ LU- >.(O ^-
0
O
°- - O N 0
-
Lt) m
N a) N O I- N
E f T- N N LAC) N N N
O Y -0
O U O O
fB N C a
N
bO U) Ow- o,- E M N
-LC) ❑ C m t(4 N Co WN r (iG^QOMM 0
L ^'E ^Y^- D Cn D Yór-ó^i m
dI
O O O a) O °- O U) co N
0 (1WU) r- (I)I---UO >OM) - - -C) -
Z
C o
a) L L
ME v^, zZ V ZE
0
á EEZE"
ca
0
c ry M E
0 E cm
U, o cL
E 0
w ^C
a)
LL
Q) m> L a)
-
C U O m QL
E o = O a)
ooac ^U o
^^ L
a) 0 •0 ._. tea) ^° L ui
U C U3 O N E
C 0 0 E ó U (^ O `^ N C a 0 N m 0,
Z o>
j y
W Q - O (^ w <n •- ca
NU "O ° L
Q N
c us
o O c .`- C a)0
E L j
o a c am ,
O= W o o o U)
U j •>
t- N M In CO
fl _
f`
139
p Yn
Ó
O> Q Qi
4^
• Q
M t/) ' °' Q
ij
p h O
O O 2
((0 _ O))
00^ = n
.. tV
0
ó0 00 r-
ov (°
4-
ccm- LL
CN OO O gr 0
Y C ,LO
o cq W rn .c co
O oC
Cl) -
—y C) C) O ó
Q Co
0
N O Urn
O f^ N u^ ó ^ YI
Np 0 ^ 0 00 O ó^^ ,n C)
0 2 =
O •• 00
o 8 CO rn
0 ÓN a n i O r W c
(n CD
\E o No N0 }U
U v^
c: U U L I
o \
vj
C C
_ YC"'
IY uj to
U N
1 Q
OWO
co
E
a
CC Co
L
UY
ó Q N`
(>
c_
Cl)
'' `.• v;0
~ w n 0co
a a U O
rn a^
>c o E
E cca ^
d D 0)
c aD a) _ W O
Q U
•
•ca c
U) D L C O E >
M W ^C
O _ •C ' C V
c U)
O ÓW
N O C •N C U O >` m II
cn c vC
W ` O . 2- O m •-
O = —1 «. cC N ca ca
o «. i-
I1 i 2
N O O N Q)
U)O00ZI-00JLL D- Z IZUO WUQ
O ^L+ c O O O a, áII C _V
it
O^
^3 S] U -i
N r 0 N ^C S] V p N O i l'
co .— r r m Q ^r
* ^c
140
C
> N f` N N
> 0) C1)
0
0 c 0co N c 0O M (N O
cri c4 `n
Ir cnv 3
` D : M M M
Q^ co
GOO 000 OOM
C-) 0 N 0
D a- o) C O
Ó N M CD W)
m M^ QT- i.( NN N
- N C C
0 3
LO C ^ OWa^ _ 0 ^N D^
Q M ^ml^ O11*00L) l[)
Hr
CV c O
M VYM 0 N- 0CAO QjOrÓN
Y Nr I^
u)O O) O O 0 o U) CO _
O (N U) - U?F- Q
Q. > O 00 r r r (O r
Z
N
4-
tQ
C c
r) M
c
0
E E \ \
EEEE^c
O
N ó á Q-
Ë
W (D 00 0 0
O,
vi
o V N (o> _E
O \
E
0 v<
mQc
2 3 c
^o
L Q - CD
O V c _ O O OO
W L O
^=v °- c° CL
toa 0 c E
D
c^ 0E^ 0 GCD ^-acu`) 0 w
Q)
O_
Ll. Q
E
O O .O
` ỳ O > to L ._. ^C CD Co
Q N O (.) V) V ^. O N
O o vim- y Q- c 5 U)2 : W 0 0 ó j
E CD
c`^^0 =3 ^^ ^ ^ ^c 0 CV X0 Evi:n^'^^ N
Z J EE-0 >-0 LL Q <s- O u) Z u J i( (D D- W W O
•
-0 _ U = — - •_ > >
HN M to (p ti
141
LO
0 Y ti
Q -
ó d:
rn o I) a)
-,rn Q-
Q
O
0)o O
O N 2
(ON —0)
°O 0I G ^
V O
^,
O
pp
Q O W
o
(N— c') 9.-
LL O)
N OOP O
0— O
Lfl W
= C
OM 0 0 U ó
O MI O O
^ Urn
LU to O L
^n m
ch
-
O OD'
0
O O r
O
(f) (t)
EY
2 =
040 ai
('1 C)
r'-. r NMM O 7 M I ^
0) rTó'o N- rT
W c
O
O
E
á^ U^ E C^ RUU
C> ^^ ^^ C C
vi vi —
U ^
<
Da)rn
E
C
C
Q
0 U
cv U ^
ó
-0 C 3 co
u
-JU ._
N Q
a > a)
o a)
E
OC
w^
O
^,
O O
.r 2
Cl)
Di
Q U
Co
isi
O
C O E
-a
O O
>
-0
N
O0Q
0 w2
v O m m W N C U >= II
O C O U = m
LL a> O 2 0 +. C
O :r (B Q} {B {0
N O O N O O
EiiÍV
_ 0 _^^L
00
(/)ODUZF- UO3lia Z ao0w
C <C ia O
11 c 2
U
Oc
N J2 U á N — O T N ci3 Q j O Q
t,-'
co T T T
M Q V
.k 4k
142
h
L Y
(\J
X N r O N
C) >+r r >,O r
C
C
0 o
^ 0 Q N N r r L
co
E ( 3 ^t o N
O r r M M M
r U) 7+ ^- CO A O O
O U) N O r
l- ó [ D
O
LA !Q c CO
O O .o
N N N'0 O N • O
E > r Co M M N N N
C N N - r
Y C C_
f°
fQ N C C 4)
N C
o 9) 0 EEQ
O>0 O>0
O 0 c cO ^ ►1^
I -L() O m
.. r C O N CO r
o Orr U .t~ O
D Y^5 '0
cD C/)°)co
Oo rn O 4) 0 aio
0 Q_MN r(/)I--Qi N > OOrrrL()r
Z
C
U
M ^ L E
ó. C
o
^ M U
N
E L Z
Z -c V^
y-. E E E
O
N EZ E
C)
C
0 0
N
.9
N
N
L Q-
W U) 0 U)
LL
Co
L
LL U L
0 0 a) (a
U
Q
O > C Q 0 .2 .^
Co
Q- Q 'c
c`o cu o _ ^. 3 c 1)
./
L
g ca ; L
U
.52 aai ó CI) L e v^ :? E
^^^°E3 v ^c^ `-'Q) 0
M g
cáá '3 a2
C E O L j Z O> N L . t0 O
L Q N O O O .. () CC to V L O t0
-a O
0r _
^ ^ y oó- .'. caQ
a^O u)L E C Q)
L o O 5 .O
c c...
O O .- O N O ^C U c Rf = ^C ^ O> L U
N X U U E Vi 0 U) ttí
E U U G) rte+ "L' 2 c :(` U (n ,i N
ECo
Z^a^^a LL< <a.. wU)LL. ^0 u)Z(n^bC OQ wWU)
O Q U
r NM Ln w 1^
143
U,
o) O
U)
7 Q)
L
Q)
Q
0) O áZ
Ó O O 0
CO N 0) 2
N 3 ^c^c
^ O
a)
O
O
O In
NCO LL r
Ó LL•-o
c
N IO
óos
C
w0
O -m
U) C
U 0
Ln O
00
^0rn L
WI
0
m
r N
OVA
m rn
n
00
0) E_ — Y
OD O In
O I^ Cp M
N O O r- O 0) (V d-an O N N. 0 0 W c
- ,. ,
J N^ 0 o
N } U
E
Y ^
U b-
1 Q
❑ N
• - rn
U
Cr_
U)
L Q
ca UY
o
o Q)
E--
❑ U Q U
> a) .n n
co
a)C) =o E
O
a)(D2
0
C
Q WW
V • ❑ w c
/L C ❑ L ^-
3 a^`^
L
Va)
^ w o
.. Qi 0 c -o o
_ CO
m
II
1
o— o •N c U >
LL
-
(i N
C
C
_ > - a)
:^ q> e .L
0
Vi
:^ C --
L
Qi
Rf tC
V
m .-
II 6 ^
OU
0)O D O ZI- UVJLLo.. Z 000w0<
_U
Ox
o
O O r r r m Q 0r
144
>U) a >C ^
C7 Q 0 N 00 C
to
E 3 3 C
O Di— Ds— E MM M
Cl)
CO
O Cl)
c N N V
o
ci O D
o cn
O C
> N
N L- e- O ~
N
_
N O
C M M 00 D T- E N N N
Yj C C
NfC c^
N C
3
C
U
C
2 p o 0
^^^ pm 0 >,r r >N U)^ O
C O CO N N (^ O O h
CL-- ^'^ V.Y^p c Q >^MNC+00
F- CD -00)(00 M
amu-) — U)F-0co U M N
0
Z
cv
C C ^I
E
á C M M ó= E V Z
0
ca C
2
^ZE.
C
0 o <
a CC
Q E
U0
.
N
9
— a
W O0
`Q^ Cu_
CD Cu
>
EW
O Q ^>
o
C
= O E2 ,-.
145
10 c
ó ^
0)o on-
00
-) 0) = 0)
ó ri o
(0 (N — Q)
ar-
Q N 1
O
^ O
c
LL 0
O
o
NC) L Q) wt
<n Y
N IO
C) L
U
_E
O wo) '
(D^
o
o
("1
^°
o^
,n
° 0)
Urn
N
a>
E
E N
N
O M y 0 c- 4)
'U
o o Io
.() 0 00 °o o v WI
0)clQo
ocoo
-
m r-^r^`o
- Nd °Qr-
00 ^^
NNN.. --
t, ._
_ _ó .-
2
y U
o
Yc o
o \ a - c.E 0c
2 vi U
o .^
0
w
r U)
cn >
C 0 '
o
Q á^ o
I- ai O n v0 EU m
a f
> 0 c
O U N ^
e)
N U ° C
.^
O ^ i
c ^ N .^-L Q W
Q 'U 4- N C L o^
U
c
w W O
°' L •-'
ó Z3
m O
(V L a0 (/} - _
O o— O N CO C >
° C O U -I--
W ` >- N 2 o +• C
al
N
N E '^ O O U C ii
N N QÍ ° = N
L (O ^O O O ^ cC C
cnODUZ f-00Jwa Z n.UOwC)<
0
t0 ^ U ^ (Í ^
J i
O ^ N R3 ^ U ^ 0
r r r m <
x U
146
as
x >+CO `-
> ^M M (1) O
C (7 p Q r- 0) -o C O
C >
j O C C_
E w CD
E O
D N r L- Q N N
O >, O O ^J 00
C) ENO 00CD E 'tM
ó DI - Cm m oor-
. O
E Q r --
O
N OE ^in .-
N ti
N
>o 0 L
co M M ca O
- i0 ` C0 U) MM
3 3 D o d o
°
1 >, 0
Q^--Lo^
3
Qr J
c
E_
pp O N mNN
00
0
E
C
O
^-^
N
Mí° U)I
pm
C
V YN
Uuï
>N^
Rf (N
•aN•CO
'j-
N
0 m
I^ U
Y
>
to tt
>0T-
d'O
O
r-
O
Z
C
ca
á I-
y-. C ri ri U E
O O E E Z co
M
0
C 0
N0 a-
E
O
W
vCl)i O p
i
d rn c
N m p
a Q O> UN
co >
O m> C C 0 N
Ó
ma)m U ¢^^^ 2 =N
l- ^ M ~C-^0
> O
ó v, a? E
c O t^4 0 w
c to E c`j CN
^- (flUiZ0 .-.
N _ =C E 2O O U) c cn
E Q O O Ó , Q<D •• U c a ca
C C U
_ N N Q f0 C N C O ky C
p .. O O N
a) U) (C _O U > ^ O
p W :_.
O N O to
O - (a U) U E i0 ûa- p t0 0 p •0 p c6 ii
Z Jo-a1-Q u.< <o- ac') LL - ^U' cnZcO1 JbO a. W W
>
LTh LUH fl HH
147
ó
ai
$o
_4)
N- 4-
= 0
C,.) $ ^ 2 rn
aY N NCU C
LL
QÍ
O N- 0
E
C
90
N h LL
L
L
ó^Wc N =_
C
N y O o0 ó U. -
ó F M
rO 0Uáá M EE
r 49 r- 0)
`. O ^U
Co O ^^m; Ó
0
2
^csr0^ ^Ó^ó ^ ííÓ
-QNÓÓI-00) ráó - o tt)c) N- i-
C N N <
\ á V .0
Eó J y O O >'-CuE
-
o a _c UO
c c ^c L
Cu
Z N C U
rn ^ Ua
E f U)
a>
E
o
C `_O
C
Cu t)
ón Q) (UW
E_
N ^
ca a v0 jo s3
t
a 0 caa^
N
^a
CU i L l N c c
c_
E
>^
^L c
G
OO cO ..
ctt L N o
U
=co c
ái>`
O
Cl)
Jz
r NO O N W 5
y V 'y
^ .^ ^ J m 0
U)000ZF- 0O...Iti0
!Cu O
U} O
Z
7•r ._ =
C
O
O O
IZUOWO<
O o c I-
L C ^0 l0
Cu C
c
m ^
O0
0 r N V
co r r r CDQ =á
148
Exhibit - 1
N
JMMU a KASHMIR .
©(
NAHAL
vnAOEaN
PtJ4JAB i
UTTARANCNAL
HARYANA *
T O
ARUNAC
u1TAR PRADESH
RAJA8T AN
®©
118
ASSAY 1
© 5 N LAND
HAR 4
r
ANSPU
2@ I N D I A cNATn GAxN 1 O
**
OWISA
MANARASHTRA
ANDHRA PRADESH
DO ^®
KARNATAKA
7 TANS. NADU
Z Y ©^ r,
LEGEND
0 Mini cement plants in operation
❑ Mini cement plants Installed
( NOT TO SCALE)
n O1
C
co
1 z
0 0 G) áá om
co
, Z Ó
9
D O O
Z
z P ^^ 0
CI) xmv
m ll
Q n
Z
r- _ O
p ^^ C
Z
1 Y
!g r y ^I
[__-i l
I
O
m
r. --- ------------------ ^---J l~ Ill
rn m^ m
Z
I2 Á^
y 9.
S
F
m
m
.-1
2 m^ I T
0
z
c CE
oÓ °o
0 0
z I
TM
0 o l O
EX HIBIT - 3
* LOCA11ON OF NOISE
RD4O Z ó
MFA"' d• 14 V a
ROUGH PUW-N T S oN
.o—.oz—a.v0a
0
Z W
Z
0
05
ow
U)
L] =
__
W
:3
s
0
•O mV •O
ó
N
b
N
1
3Y W
0 0
II c)
0
mm
O 0
4
m w 0 m
U
Z_
dZ
SO
* N
INYId
1331S 01 W
a
a
3i
Z
I 01
I
1*
(3NOI_
0 N
OZ
O
O I____ 5
V)
I 151
I
7N15 DRAWMC 15 PROPERTY OF NA1 ONAL COUNCIL FOR CENENi
&ND 8U1W IIc "TEnM S. AND US cOPe RIGHTS 8aEtr WITH
Nca R MDU.~ NOT sE COPIED. REPRODUCED. LOANm OR DISPOSED
OFF WITHOUT WRMEN PERU ON OF N C B.
ó °o
m =
Z v 1 D a
4- A
ó L— 1 e
S[
C 1
`^ z ^
m D
^ m m
Z
n
Z 9 m SIC
m o Bg m
p o C Z ^^ S
cr m v°
N
O O ^^^
rn ó
m
z m F
1 __
N a 9 4
1 ^ Í
1 ---------------------------------i g 1
EXHIBIT - 5
* LOCATION OF NOISE
MEAURF]AENTS
ROUGH PLAN-N T S
153
EXHIBIT-6
z
0
.n
zw
^
zw g
>v
s
N y^
I(
O ^
Q Y
a=a; a Q er
ó
r'
5
y
Y
gZ
g
l
O I—
W W
4
I te r' wo
+^+ Z
2
U
(L
PQ
e r ^O
a z
0
• r d 5
co
O
Z
^ o
ce^ y i w
Z
m
U
154
EXHIBIT 7
UI
W
79
1I
U
1 ~03 ^ C?
1138 , z
W ^ W o
Yd
O
, 1Z IW
Um i-Dans WD a
r
a.3ada+
AV13
ë3ddOH w U)
W 3ma8
rd i
~
aO1VATU W
—
iiHane W
L
[ ]
w
. ^^ D
W C7
S g
r i3„^3
w
ols
5NlOrC^18 0
Z
a0is a3aaOH (1333 Ó
n3snnooH ^,
W 9 QO Z `
r Y 0 0
j 0
v ^ri _ to tea+ r, 0
Y
(^
US Y 3^ á W 1- V
0 ^Wo mW a 0
_L_
Y y
11M
®v ^á 1 GP1^
D.ó Li
-1
O UW I
AaC1LVaOEN1
j1 ^^ ] Li ^-
-- -
155
UI EXHIBIT-B
0
o
oz
ZW g
z^ a!
zo, m 1@
^
o W
Id
SJ
^ F 5 O
Z m
J
Y3 ó
m
a
^j e i—
ó
ó
,^ Z
Cl)
'r O a^^ Z
(S^ J ' 2
Eo
ii- ______
0
i T U) UI
® Z ^^ 52
á
W
w
O
C,
M _
z
v
156
EXHIB1T-0
Y
U
W ® W
Í5
W 9 z
m ,
C.
Ir QNTR
015
w
z
il3ddOH 03 4 y
W W O
Za
cox Y< a
x
x W
a
o0 ? ta o ' ^G1 3 ^i O
b V g LOOS
^^
ci
wfl d
MNVL ë31Y*
157
DWIBIT 10
TJTii1 I
LLL V T L4 --'
39 t, g n.
[1 4
L II gil ó
W
2
_______ I J
7
á
lei z
158
DWIBtT 11
Z
01 1
13M3f18
0
AY13
3Zi^ëB X100 I-
L1
A311Otl1
w
Y ^CYI^
w
U)
O
Z
LL
1 ! 0
is
100N
0
! !
Ó
J
®^ b yaraa
( 1
o U
AtlULY^1061r1
[3LJ
159
W EXHIBIT-12
P5
.L 1 ci
________________
má 5 € a
gil 0
W
=
^-
W
á ^
0
z
r 3 Ó
13
U
_W 0(,
i l a C)
co
160
EXHIBIT 13
a 1130
cc,
w^W cWi
133n8
a3ddCH
]ra,s3wn -
3adoH
AVE
3^
S
a3ddOH
3ma8 X107 •
a3T701
U
- F-
^^ ^ a0lvn^o W
13i^.^n8
^^ Z a3dLLH
W
N
I.L
U)
W
als
N$ON3B O
Z
3ddOH O33
a3srna0N O
Y fY100N
á O
O
J
W
U om. y
T
0 p Gi
^aauVaOevi
)INl a31VM
t1Ï
161
w EXHIBIT-14
Ó
.^s
______________
Zw
d
Zx
i m
___ •1
in
O Z J
gil > o
cn
^ ^ O
^ f 2
9O
ó Ci
a Ó V)
_____
p mei Q
Z
O
Z
T
162
{
EXHIBff-15
000E9 -I
W ® U
Ç )
0
3d4OH
3N0153nn
~O
AVK1
il3ddpH w U)
„^►^ ^- z
w
,lM , • i °y U)
uá
ORS
U)
z
W ,^N á Ó
- "°°" 0
N 2 ^
^ w L3
[, p
Ei
O
®W _ • Tun
a 1N3pm
0
Lu
wv w ^á
W
O
AtlQi1Rl08111
MNYl I31VM
163
W E»IIB(T 18
2 toW
o
G
/41 p ^ a S m
J m
J /^ {___
ó
0 ó
w w 1 U)
1 :
W W
0 W U.
1 Z
!
U
^ dpi
O_
W
o N
R W U
á
W
g z
U m Co
164
EXHIBIT-,l
pj U
1+L W
i
W W
3NO F fl
aaddOH _
AV
1 ë3ddCH W
3Z33 1 U-
Lii
> • A3Tlpy1 Z
QLVA3
w
s1 0ti
U1fl
-ninCr I /^
V
w,
13n ,
OILS 11 U)
^tlOKïIB
Z
Y
2 ^
W
^^1f100N
Z_
^i
^a
0
Z
O
ISIS
LI
g
l^ Éa
jW
r
<K IIIN
Yl _J
O
II33
V W ^+
E< V
p LI
~Vtl081/1
Y
)
J
165