Burden of Public Debt

The Burden of Internal Public Debt ↓
1. Internal debt trap
One of the bad effects of internal debt is the interest paid by the government. Such interest
payments increase public expenditure and may become a cause for fiscal deficit. If internal
public debt is not checked and kept within limits, it may take the country to the worst position
called 'Internal Debt Trap'.
2. More burden on poor and weaker sections
Internal debt provides opportunities for the rich and higher middle class to earn a higher rate of
interest from the state on their lending. At the same time the pobr suffer a lot due to the tax
burden. The government levies taxes to repay interest on public debt. But the tax burden does not
necessarily fall on the rich unless it is progressive in nature. In the case of indirect taxes, the
burden is felt more by the poor than the rich.
3. Increasing interest burden
Public borrowing may become costlier for the government especially when it resorts to public
borrowing by issuing bonds and debentures. Such bonds and debentures carry a high rate of
interest to the extent of 15 percent. The impact of such interest payments may develop
manifold and still worsen in the future if the government stick to the same policy of borrowing in
the years to come.
4. Unjustified transfer
The servicing of internal debt involves transfers of income from the younger to the older
generations and from the active to the inactive enterprises.
The government imposes taxes on enterprises and earnings from productive efforts for the
benefit of the idle, inactive, old and leisurely class of bond holders. Hence work and productive
risk taking efforts are penalised for the benefit of accumulated wealth. This adds to the net real
burden of debts.
5. Indirect real burden
Internal debt involves an additional indirect real burden on the community. This is because the
taxation required for servicing the debts reduces the tax payer's ability to work and save and
affects production adversely. The government may also economise social expenditure thereby,
reducing the economic welfare of the people.
Taxation will reduce the personal efficiency and desire to work. Thus there would be a net loss in
the ability and desire to work. The creditor class will also not have any incentive to work hard
due to the prospect of receiving interest on bonds. This would further cause a loss to production
and increase the indirect burden of debt.
The Burden of External Public Debt ↓
External debt is beneficial in the initial stages as it increases the resources available to the
country. But its repayment & servicing creates a burden on the debtor country.
1. External debt trap
The external debt creates direct money burden. This is because; it involves transfer of funds from
the debtor country to foreign citizens. The degree of burden depends upon the interest rate, and
the loan amount. The loans are normally to be paid in foreign currency. Therefore, the funds are
mostly transferred from export earnings or by raising more funds from foreign markets.
Borrowing by way of additional loans would put extra burden on the country. The situation may
become so worse, that the country may be caught in the external debt trap. It may have to borrow
from foreign markets to repay the interest amount and it would be very difficult to repay the
principal amount.
2. Direct real burden
The external debt may also result in direct real, burden. The citizens of the debtor will have to
suffer loss of economic welfare to the extent of repayment of principle amount and interest
burden. The foreign currency earned through exports would have been utilized to import better
goods and technology. Which would have increased the economic welfare of the citizens of the
debtor country. But because of external debt repayment, they have to restrict their welfare which
the imported goods would have provided. In other words, the citizens of debtor country are
deprived of imported goods and service to the extent till the loans and interest amount is repaid.
3. Decline in expenditure to public welfare programmes
When the government spends a significant portion of its resources towards the payment of
foreign debt it reduces the government expenditure to that extent which otherwise would have
been spent for public welfare programmes.
4. Decline in the value of nation's currency
The repayment of external debt involves an increase in the demand for the currency of the
creditor country. This will raise the exchange rate of the creditor country's currency, and
aggravate the problem of foreign exchange crisis.
The creditor country may also be adversely affected if it is induced to import more from the
debtor country. This may hinder the growth of their domestic industries and cause
unemployment.
5. Burden of unproductive foreign debt
The magnitude of external debt burden depends upon whether the debt is incurred for productive
purposes or for unproductive purposes. If it is incurred for unproductive purposes, it will create
a greater burden and sacrifice on the citizens of the debtor country.
6. Political exploitation
In recent years, it was found that the lending countries who dominate international organisations
like World Bank & international monetary fund use the lending opportunity as an instrument to
exploit the borrowing countries economically & politically.
Shifting The Burden of Public Debt ↓
When resources for government expenditure are generated through taxation, the present
generation bears the burden but when resources are generated through public debt, the future
generation pays the interest & principal and thus bears the burden. Thus in the case of public
debt the burden falls on the prosperity. Payment of such projects out of taxation would be
unjustified as it would put burden on the present generation while benefit would accrue to the
future generations. In future when the time for payment of interest & principal comes, the
government will have to tax people to pay money to bond holders. The future tax payers will pay
future bond holders. It would merely imply diversion of funds from one set of people to another
within the country. However, it will involve direct real burden as the classes of tax payers &
bond holders are likely to be different. The burden of taxation is likely to be heavy on general
mass while the benefit will accrue to small rich class of bond holders.
Whether the burden of public debt is borne by future generations or not may also depend upon
many factors. The loan raised for productive purposes may not create burden on future
generation since it will create assets and will add to productive capacity of the economy. This
would not only increase income for present generation but also for the posterity. If it is used for
unproductive purposes or emergencies like war it will shift burden on future generation.
Whether the burden will shift or not also depends on whether the present generation pays off
debts by sacrificing current consumption or investment. If it is done by reducing current
consumption, future generation will not bear the burden. But if it is done by reducing investment
the future generation will bear the burden.
If loans are short term it can be repaid by the current generation. This will not shift the burden. In
case of long term loans shifting of burden will depend upon whether the loan is self liquidating
or deadweight.
It may be concluded from the above analysis that shifting of the burden of public debt from
present to future generations may be possible, but it depends of various factors.

Burden of Public Debt

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Burden of Public Debt

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Burden of Public Debt

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

The Burden of Internal Public Debt ↓

1. Internal debt trap

2. More burden on poor and weaker sections

3. Increasing interest burden

5. Indirect real burden

The Burden of External Public Debt ↓

1. External debt trap

2. Direct real burden

3. Decline in expenditure to public welfare programmes

4. Decline in the value of nation's currency

5. Burden of unproductive foreign debt

Shifting The Burden of Public Debt ↓

You might also like