Cables Types and Design: Prepared By: Roger Nicholls August 2006
Cables Types and Design: Prepared By: Roger Nicholls August 2006
Cables Types and Design: Prepared By: Roger Nicholls August 2006
August 2006
DMS#: 1148541v1
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
CABLE TYPES AND DESIGN
CONTENTS
Page
2. HISTORY............................................................................................................ 2
6. ELECTRICAL LOSSES.................................................................................. 19
DMS#: 1148541v1
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
CONTENTS Cont’d
Page
9. CONCLUSIONS ............................................................................................... 30
DMS#: 1148541v1
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
CABLE TYPES AND DESIGN
1. CABLE APPLICATIONS
Overhead lines are the most economical method for the transmission and distribution
of electrical energy. Where environmental, practical or technical considerations
dictate, the transmission and distribution systems are undergrounded by the use of
insulated cables. Cable designs vary enormously to meet the diverse requirements of
voltage, current and location, but generally, consist of three main components. These
are a low resistance conductor to carry the current, insulation to isolate the conductors
from each other and from their surroundings and an outer sheath for mechanical
protection of the cable.
The early problems of designing and manufacturing serviceable cables have been
overcome, so that today, cables are a viable and practical method of transporting
electrical energy. The evolution of the design, materials and manufacturing processes
has enabled cables to match electrical system requirements and transmission voltages.
Cable production is now an established art and generally standardised throughout the
world. Differences, which occur, are due to national standards and material
preferences, especially at the higher voltage ranges.
DMS#: 1148541v1 -1 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
2. HISTORY
Following the early experiments with electricity and the application of conducting and
insulating materials for telephony, attention turned to the development of
underground cables for transmitting electrical power. Materials that were available in
the 1880s included copper for conductors and paper, silk, Indian rubber, oils, varnish
and bituminous compounds for insulation. Voltage and current capabilities were low
as compared to modern cables.
Steel Pipe
2.5 in OD
Impregnated Paper
Sheet Insulation
0.5 in Thick
Outer Insulation
Hollow Copper
Tube 13/16 in OD
Copper Tube
Fig 1.1
Pipe cable designed by Sebastian de Ferranti in 1888
The introduction of three phase systems at the turn of the century saw the introduction
of three core belted cables. These were essentially cables constructed with a belt of
insulation around three insulated cores.
DMS#: 1148541v1 -2 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
Fig 1.2 Paper Insulated AC Belted Cable (Top Conductor at Peak Potential)
As the demand for higher voltages and ratings increased, so the sizes of the
conductors and the thickness of the insulation were increased. The concentration of
the flux levels and the resulting high stress levels in the insulation at the points of
contact of the adjacent cores, caused failures in this type of construction.
In 1914, Hochstadter increased the thickness of the core insulation and added
perforated metallic tapes around the outside of each core insulation. The insulating
belt was discarded so the metallic tapes were in contact with the metal sheath. The
individual screens distributed the stresses radially and evenly and eliminated the
concentration of electrical stresses at the points of contact.
By the 1920s, overhead lines were reaching a voltage of 200kV. Screened cables
were limited to about 30kV as insulation failures occurred at higher voltages due to
the limitations of the available materials and designs of the cables.
DMS#: 1148541v1 -3 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
Fig 1.3 Three-Core Belted (Left) and Screened (Right) Cables
Emanueli in Italy found that cable voltages could be increased by impregnating the
paper insulation with low viscosity oil. The oil was allowed to permeate into and out
of the cable insulation during the operation cycles. The cables were provided with an
oil duct in the conductor, which at intervals along the route, was connected to riser
tanks. Gravity was sufficient to make the cable absorb oil from the tanks while
providing capacity to accommodate changes in oil volume during the heating and
cooling. This landmark invention ensured that gas or air cavities, which caused local
discharges leading to cable insulation failure, could not form in the paper tapes.
Further improvements were obtained by increasing the pressure of the oil to the cable
insulation. Robinson in 1936 provided the scientific explanation of the breakdown of
viscous compound impregnated cables. The Emanueli patent for a central oil duct
dates to 1917, which illustrates how technology often drives ahead of scientific
analysis and theory.
In the 1920s, the use of inert nitrogen gas to impregnate the paper insulation was
found to have similar properties to oil by retarding insulation breakdown. The
increase of gas pressure (up to 1400 kPa) reduced the mean free path of electrons and
hence, the ionisation in the voids. It provided an incentive to develop gas pressure
assisted cables in competition with the self-contained pipe oil filled cables. Various
types of gas filled cables were developed, but the design was later abandoned as the
sheaths and supply pipe work had to retain the high gas pressures. The upper limit of
the nitrogen gas ionisation level is 138kV.
At higher voltages, fluid filled or what was previously known as oil filled cables,
replaced the mass-impregnating compound with low viscosity mineral oil. Pressure
tanks at the cable ends and typically at joint locations were required to provide a
constant pressure of fluid. The design has been refined over time and the concept is
essentially used in modern fluid filled cables. Fluid filled cables for use on 275kV
systems were developed in the 1960s, following by 400kV in the 1970s. Cables for
1,100kV systems and above are presently being developed.
DMS#: 1148541v1 -4 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
The quality of paper tapes for use in oil-filled cables has improved to meet voltage
and stress requirements. With the increase in electrical stress, the dielectric losses of
an oil-filled cable has increased to about 20 to 25% of the total loss on a typical
400kV 50Hz cable. In the late 1980s, low-loss tapes manufactured from a laminate of
polypropylene between two layers of paper were developed. Although more
expensive, the low-loss insulation reduces dielectric losses and is extensively used in
high voltage applications above 200kV.
Polymeric cables using polyethylene (PE) for the insulation was developed in the
1950s. It has replaced natural and synthetic rubber insulation used in the manufacture
of most low voltage cables. However, the inclusion of voids, impurities and a low
conductor operating temperature of 70˚C made PE unattractive for use in medium and
high voltage cables. During the 1960s and 1970s, various methods were developed
for upgrading the thermal performance of PE. The most significant advance was the
cross-linking of the polyethylene molecule chains, which allowed the conductor
operating temperature to be increased ˚C.90 These are known as ‘cross linked
polyethylene’ (XLPE) polymers.
Early XLPE insulated cables were installed in significant quantities in America and
Japan with little knowledge of the operating characteristics or manufacturing
limitations. Within a few years of operation, many of these cables failed due to
insulation failure caused by water trees and material contamination. By the 1970s,
XLPE cables had improved enormously as more became known about the material
itself. Today, 400kV cables with XLPE insulation are in regular service and are being
tested at higher voltages in research establishments.
DMS#: 1148541v1 -5 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
3. CABLE TYPES
3.1 General
Wiring cables and solid dielectric low voltage distribution cables (1kV or less) have
relatively low electrical and mechanical stresses. The insulation thicknesses are
generally governed by the mechanical requirements and properties of the materials
and not by the insulation requirements. The manufacturing processes are simple and
highly automated and therefore not considered further in this discussion.
High voltage distribution and transmission cables are more complex and require
special design and more complicated manufacturing processes owing to the greater
electrical stresses.
Materials for use as cable insulation should have the following properties:
• Low losses.
• Immune to chemical attacks and deterioration over the cable working life and
temperature range.
The main types of insulation materials available for AC transmission cables, which
comply with some of the above properties, are shown in the following chart and
descriptions.
DMS#: 1148541v1 -6 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
Polymeric PVC PVC Less than 6
Insulation Silicon / rubber EPR
PE PE 30 to 200
XLPE XLPE 30 to over 400
Paper has good electrical insulating properties only when dry and impregnated with
suitable fluids and compounds to prevent moisture adsorption. Paper in tape form is
lapped onto the cable conductor with the edges butted together. Successive layers are
applied overlapping the butt joints until the required insulation thickness is obtained.
It is important that the voids at the butt joints are filled with insulating compound or
fluid to prevent electrical discharges occurring.
The paper insulation is dried by applying heat and vacuum before introducing the
insulating compound. This ensures that all voids and the paper matrix are filled by
the insulating compound or fluid.
Compounds used for solid type distribution cables are usually based on paraffinic or
naphthenic mineral oils. Resins are usually added to the oil base to improve
impregnation and increase the viscosity over the cable working temperature range.
The use of compounds to impregnate the paper insulation is in common use for cables
up to about 33kV. Above this voltage, partial discharges can be initiated in any voids
not fully filled by the compound.
Fluid filled or what used to be known as oil filled, cables overcome this problem by
maintaining the liquid impregnant at a continuous positive pressure. This ensures that
the voids in the insulation remain filled at all possible operating conditions and
enables higher electrical stresses to be used.
DMS#: 1148541v1 -7 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
a) Internal Pressure
The fluid in a paper insulated cable may be kept under pressure by external tanks.
Changes in fluid volume due to temperature variations are accommodated by the
tanks, which maintain constant pressure in the cable to prevent void formation.
b) External Pressure
Paper insulated cables without a sheath may be installed in steel pipes, which are
filled with oil and pressurised. Three single core screened cables without sheaths are
bound together with a non-magnetic skid wire and installed in one pipe. The skid
wire protects the cable cores against damage while being pulled through the pipe.
On completion of the installation, the steel pipes are evacuated and then filled with
insulating oil of low viscosity. The fluid pressure can be maintained at a higher
pressure than the internal pressure cables. Thus, the thickness of the paper insulation
may be reduced without reducing the reliability of the cable. This leads to an
economical type of cable construction for the mid-transmission voltage range.
The disadvantage of pipe type cables is that bends must be kept to a minimum and
jointing of the pipes is time consuming. In addition, the equipment to maintain the
high fluid pressure is also complicated. However, steel pipes do afford good
mechanical protection for the cables although protection against corrosion must be
provided.
Gas filled cables generally require a reinforced lead sheath to retain the internal gas
pressures. Relatively large clearances between the insulation and sheath are required
to permit the migration of the gas along the length of the cable. The main attraction
of this type of cable system is the relative simplicity of the ancillary equipment and
jointing procedures. Owing to the lower permissible electrical design, stress and
thicker metal sheaths, gas filled cables are inevitably more expensive than equivalent
fluid filled cables. Extruded polymeric cables are a more effective option.
DMS#: 1148541v1 -8 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
b) External Gas Pressure
These cables have either a heavy outer gas retaining sheath or a steel pipe similar to
the fluid filled pipe system, but are self-contained. They are generally uncompetitive
with other types of pressure assisted cables and do not have any technical advantages.
Nearly all cables for new installations up to 150kV are now of the extruded polymeric
types. Polymeric insulated cables have been in commercial use at 400kV for
approximately 12 to 15 years.
The operating electrical stresses for polymeric insulation are kept lower than for fluid
filled cables, consequently the insulation thickness is greater. All cables above 30kV
are single core due to limitation of the extrusion processes. One advantage is that the
auxiliary equipment required for the pressure assisted paper insulated cable systems is
not required. The lack of any insulating fluid is also a factor in situations where the
effects of fire in confined spaces or leaks causing an environmental impact have to be
considered.
PVC polymers cannot be extruded without the addition of plasticisers, lubricants and
fillers. They are generally suitable as insulation of domestic and industrial wiring
cables up to 6kV due to high electrical losses. Some manufacturers use PVC as fillers
in the cable oversheath.
Polyethylene (PE) and cross linked polyethylene (XLPE) are the most commonly
used polymeric insulant. The low dielectric losses of polyethylene make it an
attractive proposition as compared to impregnated paper and other polymers.
The melting point of XLPE is higher than PE allowing the cable to be safely operated
at continuous temperatures of 90ºC instead of 70 or 80ºC.
Paper insulated cables can theoretically be designed for voltages exceeding 1,100kV,
but the increase in dielectric losses with voltage limit the useful current rating of the
DMS#: 1148541v1 -9 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
cable. Thus, at a voltage of over 850kV, the paper insulated cable has little or no
rating capacity if it is naturally cooled.
To overcome this limitation, polypropylene paper laminate (PPL) has been developed
as a replacement for paper insulation. It consists of a film of polypropylene coated on
both sides with a layer of paper. The laminate has the same physical properties as
paper and can be used in the same lapping machines for the manufacture of PPL
cables. The laminate permits cables to be designed for voltages exceeding 1,100kV
while retaining a useful current rating. Other advantages are higher impulse strength
and lower permittivity. The material is more expensive than paper and is generally
only used at voltages above 250kV or in special installations.
Fig 3.1 Variation of Current Rating with Operating Voltage for Paper and PPL
Insulated Cables with Conductor Size of 2500mm2.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 10 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
4. CABLE COMPONENTS
4.1 Insulation
a) Impregnated Paper
Paper for cable insulation consists of long cellulose fibres derived by chemical
treatment of wood pulp. The paper is generally of 2-ply form with thickness, density
and impermeability being adjusted according to cable type and voltage. The thickness
of the paper is normally from 65µm to 200μm with a density varying from 650 to
1,000kg/m3. As the actual fibre density is in the order of 1,500kg/m3, a considerable
volume of space within the fibres is available for filling with an insulating compound.
The impermeability or porosity of the paper can be adjusted to suit the final
mechanical and electrical properties.
The paper is applied to the cable conductor in tape form with layers being lapped until
the required insulation thickness is obtained. This can vary from 0.6 to over 30mm
according to the cable voltage and the electrical stresses. The surface finish of the
paper is highly important, as individual layers must be able to slide over each other
when bending the cable. Thickness and tensile strength of the paper tapes may be
increased towards the outside of the insulation to improve the bending performance.
The insulation thickness may be reduced by using high-grade paper (75µm thick)
adjacent to the conductor where the electrical stresses are highest. However,
insulation grading is only used for special applications, as the manufacturing costs are
significantly greater.
b) Polymeric Insulation.
In tonnage terms, synthetic polymers have replaced natural materials such as paper,
mineral oils and natural rubbers for the insulation of distribution and wiring type of
cables and the over sheathing of cables in general. Polymers can be readily varied in
chemical composition to suit specific electrical, mechanical and thermal requirements.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 11 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
c) Polypropylene Paper Laminate
Polypropylene paper laminate (PPL) is a low loss dielectric material used in tape
form. It consists of a layer of extruded polypropylene bonded between two thin layers
of insulating paper with a total thickness in the order of 100µm. The lapping of the
laminate onto the conductor and the impregnating processes are similar to the
techniques used for paper oil insulated cables.
The polypropylene tape has a lower dielectric loss angle and permittivity and has a
higher operating temperature and mechanical strength as compared to paper. When
combined with paper, PPL has a lower permittivity (typically 2.7 as compared to 3.4)
lower dielectric loss angle (0.0008 as compared to 0.0023) and higher impulse
strength.
PPL is more expensive than paper and generally it is only economic to use as cable
insulation at voltages above 250kV where dielectric losses are critical. (See Fig 3.1)
Paper has good electrical insulating properties only when dry. Impregnation with
suitable fluids and compounds help to prevent or reduce moisture absorption. During
manufacture, the cable insulation is usually heated to 120°C and a vacuum applied to
remove both air and moisture from the paper fibres.
Impregnants for solid type distribution cables is based on refined thickened mineral
oil. The increase in viscosity, in some types approaching a wax or gel, prevents
draining from the paper insulation.
4.2 Conductors
Stranded copper was at one time almost universally used for cable conductors.
Aluminium is a viable alternative and its use is often determined by cost and weight
savings. However, the cost saving has to be offset by the lower conductivity of
aluminium which requires a larger cross-sectional area for a given conductivity.
The nominal cross-section of a cable conductor is the area of the cross-section of one
strand in a plane perpendicular to its length multiplied by the number of strands.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 12 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
The equivalent cross-section is the cross-section of a solid conductor of the same
length as the cable and having the same resistance at the same temperature.
The actual cross-section is greater than the nominal cross-section, but the equivalent
cross-section is less because of the increase in resistance due to spiralling.
Manufacturers have to be careful when fabricating conductors for cables to make sure
that the cross-section is adequate to meet the required specifications for resistance and
area. Work hardening and reduction in the strand cross-section due to compacting
and shaping multi-strand conductor can also occur during the fabricating process.
4.3.1 General
• Mechanical protection for the insulation used in the construction of cables, which
are mechanically weak.
• To prevent the migration of the insulating compounds and fluids out of the papers.
a) Metal Armour
For lead sheathed paper insulated power distribution cables, the armouring usually
consists of galvanised steel wire or steel tape. The armour is laid over a bed of
bituminised tape to act as a cushion and to contribute to corrosion protection.
For cables above 11kV, XLPE insulation requires an earthed screen, usually of copper
wires and an outer sheath impervious to water.
b) Metallic Layer
A metallic layer is required for additional protection against water ingress, mechanical
damage, to retain the insulation compounds and to provide a path for fault currents.
The layer may consist of various materials, ranging from a metallic laminate used in
conjunction with screening wires to various sheaths of lead, aluminium, copper and
stainless steel. Lead sheaths are extruded directly over the cable while sheaths of
copper, aluminium, copper and stainless steel sheaths are formed from strip
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 13 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
continuously welded into a tube over the insulation, which is then corrugated. This
enables the cable to be bent for winding onto drums and for installation.
Additional copper wire screens are used where the fault current requirements exceed
the capacity of the metallic sheath.
Bedding and binding layers of tape(s) may be installed over the conductor and under
the sheath components to prevent any intrusion of the screen or conductor wires into
the insulation. Water blocking tapes are also placed under the sheath to prevent
longitudinal migration of water under the sheath should it be perforated or damaged,
to reduce the length of cable that has to be cutback for repair.
c) Oversheath
The oversheath or outer covering prevents corrosion of the metallic sheath and
electrically isolates it from ground. This enables routine voltage tests to be applied
between the metallic sheath and ground to detect any damage to the integrity of the
cable oversheath.
The materials used for the oversheath may consist of PVC, PE and high-density
polyethylene (HDPE). The latter material is used to provide a hard finish to the cable,
preventing minor damage to the cable. The oversheath may also provide protection
against termites and aggressive chemical environments. Termite protection can be
obtained by installing a double brass over-lapped tape or an extruded nylon sheath.
As an alternative, an insecticide compound can be included in the oversheath material
but has limited effect and the environmental impacts have to be considered. A
protective outer (sacrificial) layer is required to preserve the brass tape and nylon
termite barrier from damage during installation.
To facilitate the oversheath voltage integrity test, the outer most layer of the sheath is
made conductive to ensure that the full length of the cable sheath is tested. This is
particularly important where the cable is not in direct contact with the ground as
would occur in tunnels, ducts and buildings. This is usually accomplished by
applying graphite or extruding a semi-conductive layer over the sheath.
d) Special Applications
When cables are installed in structures, tunnels and confined spaces, the flammability
and combustion properties of the materials used in the fabrication of the cables have
to be taken into account. The use of fire and smoke retardant materials should be
investigated and used if a hazard exists.
Submarine cables need to be armoured to withstand high tensile loads during and after
laying and to provide resistance to impact and abrasion. The design of the armour has
to take into account the method of coiling the cable for transport to site and the
resistance of the cable to withstand twisting forces. In addition, the cables have to
withstand the external water pressure as well as internal pressures due to thermal
cycles.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 14 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
5. ELECTRICAL STRESSES
The thickness of the cable insulation has to be a minimum for economy, bending and
heat dissipation but be thick enough to withstand the voltages applied to it without
breakdown. The insulating thickness is dependent on the dielectric strength of the
medium.
Electrical stress is the measure of voltage (kV) applied across the insulation (mm). It
should be noted that both operating and transient voltages have to be considered in the
establishment of electrical stress for the particular design of a cable. Paper cables for
example, have a maximum design stress in the range of about 7.5kV/mm at 33kV to
15kV/mm at 400kV.
Impulse conditions are more onerous and sets the thickness of the insulation. The
ratio of the basic impulse level to the operating voltage decreases with the operating
voltage level, as shown by 33 and 400kV cable, which have ratios of 10:1 and 6:1
respectively.
The stress levels for paper insulation are well established with predictable results.
Typical relationships between cable voltage and insulation thicknesses for paper
insulated cables are illustrated in the following chart.
66 12 10
132 18-22 12
275 22-32 15
400 25-32 15
The voltage breakdown of polymeric insulation is highly dependant on the purity and
cleanliness of the material. Therefore, polymeric insulation is thicker (for example at
400kV 25 to 35mm instead of 20mm for paper cables) and the stress levels are kept
lower.
By the nature of the construction of cables, the insulation around the cable conductor
is exposed to electrical stresses. Electrical stress is inversely proportional to the
conductor diameter and insulation thickness and is a maximum at the conductor
surface reducing with distance from the conductor.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 15 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
The electrical stress in a single core and screened multicore cables may be expressed
as follows, assuming uniform distribution and permittivity:
q
Ex =
2π x Eo Er
q R
From V = log e ( )
2π E o E r r
Stress at radius x is
V
Ex = (kV/mm)
R
x log e ( )
r
where:
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 16 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
It should be noted that the stress is a maximum at the conductor surface.
V
Maximum stress =
R
r log e ( )
r
V
Minimum stress =
R
R log e( )
r
The above assumes that the conductor is perfectly circular and that the uneven surface
of the strands is considered to be a smooth cylinder. This is accomplished in practice
by covering the conductor with carbon paper tape for paper-insulated cables or an
extruded layer of semi-conducting polymer for polymeric cables.
The conductor cross-sectional area is determined by the circuit and system fault
current requirements as well as the maximum operating temperature of the cable
components. High electrical stresses may occur in high voltage cables with small
load current requirements. In this case, the conductor diameter has to be increased, or
in the case of fluid filled cables, the central fluid duct could be enlarged while
maintaining the required area of the conductor. Alternatively, aluminium could be
used in place of copper to gain an increase in conductor diameter.
The permittivity of paper cables insulation can be varied by using thin, high quality
papers adjacent to the conductor. This grading of the insulation enables higher
stresses to be used and reduces the insulation thickness. This also improves the
bending properties of the cable.
The grading of the insulation of polymeric cables is not possible as the polymer is
homogeneous and is extruded in a single process. However, by using super clean
high quality materials, free of impurities and voids, the stress level can be increased
thus reducing the thickness of the insulation. Refinements in quality of the insulating
material, has enabled some manufacturers to reduce 132kV cable insulating thickness
to typically 14mm instead of 20mm.
In the early days of electrical power transmission, cables were constructed with three
paper insulated cores surrounded by an outer belt of insulation. The ratio of the
insulation thicknesses were in proportion to the phase to phase and phase to earth
voltages.
For voltages up to about 22kV, the belted type of construction for three phase cables
has relatively low electrical stresses for the type of insulating paper used at the time.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 17 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
Further voltage increases initiated insulation failures necessitating a different design
of cable construction. See Fig. 1.2 Paper Insulated Belted Cable.
To eliminate the weakness of the belted cable with its unequal distribution of
electrical stresses, a cable with each core surrounded by an earthed metallic screen
was developed. This design of cable, first patented by Hochstadier in 1914, ensured
that the stresses are essentially radial between the conductor and the screen. Three
phase paper insulated cables for use above 15kV are now screened.
Similarly, polymeric cables for 3.8/6.6kV and above have screened cores and nearly
always have circular cores. The screens are formed by extruding a semi-conducting
polymer over both the conductor and the insulation. For high voltage cables, the three
layers are extruded simultaneously before passing into the cross linking and curing
stages. A perfectly smooth interface is obtained between the insulation and semi-
conducting layers thus avoiding potential areas of high electrical stress. It is also
important that the layers are bonded together, otherwise the cable components would
become detached and move during installation and load cycles. This could lead to
joint and termination failures.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 18 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
6 ELECTRICAL LOSSES
6.1 General
The three components of the cable, the conductor, the insulation and the outer
metallic layer(s) all have losses due to the load and induced currents which generate
heat. These losses should be kept to a minimum as the resulting heat reduces the
rating of the cable and has to be dissipated to the surrounding medium.
The majority of the conductor losses are due to the resistance of the conductor. They
are proportional to the square of the current and the resistance (I2R) of the material.
Other losses in AC cables are caused by the uneven distribution of current within the
strands of the conductor. This is due to two effects known as “skin effect” and
“proximity effect”.
The magnetic flux generated by the load current in the conductor is the greatest in the
centre of a conductor. The self-induced back e.m.f. reduces the current density in the
centre of the conductor. This concentrates the current at the surface of individual
strands as well as the outer layers of the conductor. This is known as the skin effect
and results in an increase in the effective resistance of the conductor. The magnitude
of the skin effect is influenced by the system frequency, the size and diameter of the
conductor and the conductor load current.
The proximity effect increases the effective resistance of the cable conductor and is
associated with the magnetic fields linking the conductors of the cable. Parameters
such as the spacing between the phases, the diameters and shape of the conductors
and the installation formation (i.e. flat or trefoil) have to be taken into account.
Skin and proximity effects may be ignored for small conductors (typically less than
150mm2) carrying low currents. They become increasingly significant with larger
conductors and higher currents and is often technically and economically desirable to
design conductors to minimise them. One method applied to conductors above
800mm2 is to group the conductor strands into four or more insulated segments. The
strands within each segment as well as the segments are continuous rotated. The
insulation between the segments is usually a single layer of paper. This disperses the
current more evenly throughout the conductor reducing the skin and proximity effects.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 19 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
Where
Where
C = ε r/ 18 loge(D/d) (µF/km)
Where
εr = relative permittivity
D = diameter over the insulation (m)
d = diameter over the conductor (m)
Sheath losses occur in AC single core cables when the magnetic field induces eddy
currents in the cable sheath and longitudinal current currents in the sheath circuit.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 20 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
Eddy currents are induced in the sheath by the close proximity of the conductor
current(s). Due to the unequal distribution of the flux, the resulting induced emfs
cause currents (eddy currents) to flow in various sections of the cable.
The total of eddy currents over the sheath cross-section is zero, but they do give rise
to local heating of the sheath.
3ω 2 dm 2
Se = I 2 [ ( ) x 10 −8 ] (Watt / km per phase)
Rs 2 S
Where:
For single-core lead sheathed cables, the losses are normally small as compared with
the conductor losses, but are considerably higher with aluminium-sheathed cables
when they are in close proximity.
A current will flow in the sheath of a single-core cable if the sheath is bonded to earth
or to other sheaths at more than one point. This is because the sheath and return path
form a closed loop, which is cut by the conductor current flux. The magnitude of the
flux is dependant of the spacing between the cables or between the sheath and the
mean return path of the current through the earth.
Es = IXm
Where:
The mutual inductance M between the conductor and sheath is given by:
2S
M = 0.2 log e ( ) (mH / km)
dm
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 21 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
The impedance of the sheath Zs (Ω / km) is given by:
Zs = (Rs2 Xm2)½
Es
Is =
( Rs x Xm 2 ) 1 / 2
2
IXm
= (A)
( Rs x Xm 2 ) 1 / 2
I 2 Xm 2 Rs
Is 2 Rs = (Watt / km)
Rs 2 x Xm 2
Therefore, the total sheath losses due to circuit and eddy currents are:
Xm 2 3w 2 dm
2
I Rs[ 2 2
x ( 2 ( ) x 10 −8 )]
Rs x Xm Rs 2 S
The heat generated by losses in the conductor, insulation and the sheath has to pass
into the surrounding medium. Since the maximum temperature of the cable
components normally dictates the maximum current carrying capacity of a cable,
efficient cables should have components with minimum losses and low thermal
resistivity.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 22 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
7 MECHANISM OF INSULATION BREAKDOWN
Mechanical damage to the insulation and the ingress of moisture is the major cause of
cable failures. Poor workmanship during the installation of the joints and
terminations are the next most common cause of failure. Poor accessory designs,
which contributed to early failure rates, have been virtually eliminated by modern
knowledge, materials and experience. Disregarding failures due to dig-ins and faulty
jointing, the failure of a cable installation during service is dependent on the type of
insulation. These are discussed as follows:
The three basic reasons for failure of paper insulated cables are due to ionisation
within the insulation, thermal breakdown, and excessive transient voltages.
In an ideal cable, the whole volume contained within the sheath should be completely
free of voids. During installation and during the thermal cycling of the cable under
service conditions, the main components move at different rates. This movement can
cause voids to form within the cable. If voids are present in areas of high electrical
stress, the gas in the void will ionise. The early belted types of cable were particularly
susceptible to this type of failure mainly due to the areas of high stress, which
occurred between the cores.
With voltages above 33kV, gaseous ionisation in the voids could be initiated by the
migration of the compound resulting from loading and steep inclines.
Once ionisation occurs, the resulting ionic bombardment forms a carbon path between
the fibres of the paper tapes. If permitted to continue, the path grows forming a
carbon track or tree until the failure of the insulation occurs.
Another method of controlling ionisation is to fill the voids with a high pressure inert
gas (high pressure gas filled cable). The cable has to be kept pressurised at all times
to prevent ionisation.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 23 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
Ionisation within voids is prevented in pipe type compression cables by the
application of external pressure to the cable. This method is used generally for
medium voltage three core or three single core cables all contained within a steel pipe.
The intervening space within the pipe is filled with either low viscosity fluid or inert
gas under pressure.
b) Thermal breakdown
The dielectric loss angle for fluid impregnated paper insulation has a minimum value
in the region of 50 to 60ºC. During operation, the increase in the cable temperature
increases dielectric loss and conductor resistance (I2R) resulting in greater heat
generation. This results in an increase in temperature gradient of the surrounding
material and rate of heat dissipation. If the rate of rise of heat generation is greater
than the rate of heat dissipation, the temperature of the cable will continue to
increase, resulting in overheating and electrical failure.
Modern papers used in paper insulated cables are selected to have comparatively
small DLA variations with temperatures over the operating range. However, some
older cables, which have been exposed to high load levels, have been known to fail.
Other sources of indirect cable heating, such as other services causing hot spots or
failure of a cable sheath bonding system, which if left undetected, could allow high
circulating sheath currents to cause a thermal breakdown to occur.
Due to the rapid introduction of PE and XLPE cables into service in the early 1980s,
the limitations of these materials were not fully understood. Premature insulation
failures occurred as a result of internal electrical discharges and water treeing caused
by poor quality insulation materials and poor design of the sheath. Present polymeric
cables now incorporate an impervious barrier to prevent any contact between the
insulation and water which may be present in the outside environment.
Water trees are another phenomenon observed in early polyethylene insulated cables
and refer to the shape and nature of growth of conducting channels from voids,
contaminants and defects occurring in the insulation. The water trees grow in the
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 24 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
direction of the electrical field and have the effect of increasing local electrical stress.
The process is not necessarily confined to highly stressed insulation and the
mechanism is not fully understood.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 25 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
8 OTHER TYPES OF CABLES
8.1 DC Cables
The first electrical supply systems were based on DC distribution and many of the
early cables were constructed accordingly. The development of modern electrical
supply systems in the first half of this century was based exclusively on AC
transmission, mainly due to the easy transformation between generation, transmission
and distribution voltages.
By the 1950’s DC voltage was again used in certain circumstances for long
transmission lines as HV equipment became available. The advantages of DC
systems include improved system stability, unity power factor, lower losses and line
costs. The high cost of the terminal frequency changing equipment has to be offset
against the savings in the cable costs. For DC transmission links to be economic, the
route length has to be at least 80km long.
Submarine cables are an interesting case to consider. The high capacitance of cables
results in comparatively high AC charging currents. As capacitance is proportional to
the length of cable, there is a critical length at which the charging current equals the
thermal current rating of the cable. At this length, the cable has no capacity for
transfer of power. On land, shunt reactors can be used at intervals along the route of
an AC cable. However, this is not practical for submarine cables and hence AC
submarine transmission systems have significant length limitations. In DC
transmission, the charging current only occurs during switching on or off and
therefore has no effect on the continuous current rating of the system. This explains
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 26 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
why DC transmission has been so widely used for long (typically 30km or longer)
submarine crossings.
a) Conductors
The DC resistance of the conductor can be up to 20% less than the equivalent AC
cable conductor due to the lack of skin and proximity effects. In addition, there is no
need from a ratings point of view to use the more complex Milliken construction for
large conductor sizes.
b) Insulation
The stress distribution of DC cables is dependent on the geometry of the cable and the
insulation resistivity. It should be noted that the resistivity is highly dependent on
temperature and to a lesser extent on electrical stress because these increase the
mobility of the charge carriers.
c) Sheaths
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 27 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
d) Accessories
Designs are similar to those used for AC cable systems. However, special care has to
be taken when assembling terminations and joints as the DC field attracts dust
particles.
Gas insulated lines (GIL) make use of gas insulated substation technology. This
consists of non-ferrous single-phase trunking sections joined together with bolted
flanges and a tubular conductor supported by non-conducting supports. High-
pressure inert gas such as sulphur hexafluoride (SF6) provides the insulating medium.
The second generation of GIL design uses site welded enclosure joints to reduce the
insulating gas losses and an insulating gas mixture of nitrogen and 10% to 20% SF6.
Pressures are increased to 8 to 9 bar.
The relatively high cost of the GIL systems limits the use to short distances and is
found in applications that require high current transfer, typically over 4,000A.
Corrosion problems and the expansion due to temperature variations have
accommodated in the design of the system. Pure SF6 is an electronegative gas, which
at atmospheric pressure has an electrical breakdown strength approximately 60%
greater than nitrogen. To improve the electrical strength further, the gas is used under
pressure, typically 3 to 5 bar.
Due to the large volume of SF6 gas required in a GIL, the environmental problems of
leakage or a major escape of the gas has to be considered.
In the mid 1980s, high temperature superconductors (HTS) were developed which had
an apparent zero resistivity at the unprecedented high temperature range of 90 to
120K. This enabled liquid nitrogen to be used as the cooling medium. This resulted
in much lower costs for the coolant, refrigerators and the thermal insulation of the
cable.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 28 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
Fig 8.1 Super Conductive Cable
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 29 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2
9 CONCLUSIONS
Existing designs of cable for load requirements of up to about 3 GVA would appear to
be economical for the foreseeable future. For higher power ratings in the range of 3-5
GVA, gas insulated lines or superconducting cables based on high temperature super
conducting (HTS) technology are theoretically feasible.
For high voltage applications, impregnated paper insulation is technically feasible for
voltages up to 1,100kV. Due to the high dielectric losses and the consequential loss
of current rating in AC cables at high voltages, paper / polypropylene laminate
insulation is preferred.
Polymeric cables for high voltage AC system applications, are presently restricted to
XLPE and voltages in the range of 400 to 500kV. They are attractive for long cable
lengths and high voltages due to the low dielectric loss and permittivity. However,
the service reliability of XLPE at 500kV and above still has to be proved.
Optical fibres can be incorporated under the cable sheath of polymeric insulated
cables. The fibres can be used to determine the real-time temperature of the cable, the
detection of excessive moisture levels under the sheath and also for communications
and protection functions. While the fibres are readily installed during manufacture of
the cables, the method of extracting the fibres out of the joints and terminations has to
be properly engineered.
DMS#: 1148541v1 - 30 -
File#: TLS/80/1(33)V2