61365annualreport Icai 2019 20 English
61365annualreport Icai 2019 20 English
61365annualreport Icai 2019 20 English
4]
Appeared and Passed Appeared and Passed Appeared and Passed Both
Group I only Group II only Groups/ Either of the Groups
Appeared Passed Appeared Passed Appeared Passed
Intermediate 45857 6716 73091 15932 17061 324
(IPC)
Intermediate 51755 9153 41350 13109 25794 4413
Final (Old) 25022 4610 36945 8762 15560 1187 (Both
Groups)
2729 (Either of
the Group)
Final (New) 8894 1500 6529 1146 11092 2313 (Both
Groups)
2101 (Either of
the Group)
Appeared and Passed Appeared and Passed Appeared and Passed Both
Group I only Group II only Groups/ Either of the Groups
Appeared Passed Appeared Passed Appeared Passed
Intermediate 30571 3695 54489 10952 10678 164
(IPC)
Intermediate 69886 15719 45449 8122 31856 4578
Final (Old) 27409 7384 37589 8679 8021 817
Final (New) 27861 4830 26972 7593 15003 2268
Appeared Passed
Foundation Examination, May 2019 30971 5753
Foundation Examination, November 2019 87084 30563
Besides the above, the Common Proficiency Test [CPT] was held successfully on June 16th, 2019 across the
country and abroad at 250 examination centres respectively. The total numbers of candidates who
appeared and passed in the CPT are as under:
Appeared Passed
th
CPT held on June 16 , 2019 20303 5764
During the year, Post Qualification Course in Information Systems Audit – Assessment Test (ISA –AT) was
held successfully on June 29th, 2019 all over the country in 63 Examination centres. Another Information
Systems Audit – Assessment Test was held successfully on December 28 th, 2019 all over the country in 66
examination centres.
The total numbers of candidates, who appeared in these examinations and passed, were as follows:
Appeared Passed
th
ISA – AT held on June 29 , 2019 3215 1038
th
ISA – AT held on December 28 , 2019 2785 1122
130 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
Insurance and Risk Management Technical Examination was held successfully in November, 2019 all over
the country. The total numbers of candidates, who appeared in these examinations and passed, were as
follows:
Appeared Passed
IRM – Technical Examination, Nov. 2019 49 21
International Taxation-Assessment Test (INTT-AT) for members was held successfully in May and
November, 2019. The total numbers of candidates, who appeared and passed in this examination, were as
follows:
Appeared Passed
INTT – AT held in May, 2019 297 76
INTT – AT held in November, 2019 185 44
The examinations of Post Qualification Courses in Management Accountancy Course (MAC) (Part-1),
Corporate Management Course (CMC) (Part-1), Tax Management Course (TMC) (Part-1), and International
Trade Laws and World Trade Organization (ITL & WTO) (Part-1), were also conducted in November, 2019.
During the year Advanced ICITSS were successfully conducted as per details given below:
Date of Test No. of Cities No. of Exam Centres No. of Students
03.03.2019 89 112 10105
27.04.2019 102 122 11030
17.05.2019 67 71 3570
28.07.2019 90 103 8656
01.09.2019 89 98 7300
06.10.2019 73 79 4277
20.10.2019 68 71 2705
05.01.2020 102 125 10737
16.02.2020 101 121 9568
The Institute has continuously been improving its Examination Process right from the question paper
setting stage upto declaration of results so that the integrity and sanctity of the examination system which
is well known for around seven decades, are maintained and further strengthened and developed.
The Institute‘s examinations test the conceptual understanding as well as practical application of each of
the topics covered in the CA curriculum so that the students could meet the expectations of the
stakeholders of the profession. By focusing on analytical abilities of the students and by avoiding
predictability of questions, Institute‘s examinations continue to ensure that those qualifying are well
groomed professionals.
Special Examination: Arising out of the Mutual Recognition Agreement / Memorandum of Understanding
entered with the foreign professional accounting body, the Special Examination for the members of The
Institute of Certified Public Accountants in Australia (CPA Australia) desirous of membership of ICAI were
successfully conducted from June 17th to 20th, 2019 in New Delhi.
Web-Interface on Students Exam Life Cycle Management:-
ICAI embarked on an integrated web-interface called Student Exam Life Cycle Management Project, wherin
CA students using a single user ID and password, can access various examination related services,
including application for duplicate marksheets / pass certificates/transcripts, change of
centre/medium/group, downloading admit cards, checking results, and applying for verification/seeking
certified copies of answer books post result etc. from exam to exam.
New Examination Centres:- With a view to facilitate students to appear in the examination centres as
nearer to their place of residence/ articled training as possible, new examination Centres were opened as
follows:
New examination centres for CA Foundation, Intermediate, Intermediate (IPC) and the Final (Old and New)
opened:
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 131
With effect from November 2019 examination onwards : examination centres were opened at Darbhanga
(Bihar), Davangere (Karnataka), Bahadurgarh (Haryana), Bulandshahr (Uttar Pradesh), Dibrugarh (Assam),
Jharsuguda (Odisha), Kadapa (Andhra Pradesh), Kancheepuram (Tamil Nadu), Kurukshetra (Haryana) and
Raniganj (West Bengal),
Further, examination centres at Ambikapur (Chhattisgarh), Raigarh (Chhattisgarh), Balotra (Rajasthan) and
Kalaburgi (Gulbarga) (Karnataka) were opened for Foundation Examinations only.
4.4 Disciplinary Directorate
The Disciplinary Directorate, the regulatory wing of ICAI, has been established to investigate into
matters of Professional and/or Other Misconduct alleged against members, received either in the form of a
―Formal Complaint in Form I‖ or through the ―Information‖ route as provided under the Chartered
Accountants (Procedure of Investigations of Professional and Other Misconduct and Conduct of Cases),
Rules, 2007.
Under the disciplinary mechanism, a mandatory duty has been cast upon the Disciplinary
Directorate of ICAI to look into any alleged lapses/irregularities committed by its members across the
country so as to lay down a strong foundation of credibility to the future members joining the profession.
While, most of the members of the profession are providing selfless dedicated services through their
professional expertise and experience to the society and world at large, yet through its robust Disciplinary
mechanism there is a constant need to caution and to correct the negligible few who inadvertently fall on
the wrong side of the law.
In terms of the amendments made in the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 in the year 2006, the
disciplinary mechanism of ICAI underwent certain important and path-breaking changes in the provisions
of procedures for conduct of disciplinary cases so as to speeden up the process of disposal of disciplinary
cases. Accordingly, as on date, the disciplinary mechanism functions through its two quasi-judicial arms
constituted as per the provisions of the Chartered Accountants (Amendment) Act, 2006 namely (i) Board of
Discipline (under Section 21A) and (ii) Disciplinary Committee (under Section 21B).
The disciplinary mechanism and the processes involved are designed in such a manner which
ensures transparency and thereby, enhances the confidence of the stakeholders and the public at large
and at the same time give fair and equitable justice to the members charged with allegations of
Professional and/or Other Misconduct.
During the current Council year 2020 - 2021, a new bench of the Disciplinary Committee has been
constituted and thus with the four Benches of the Disciplinary Committee i.e. Bench I, Bench II, Bench III
and Bench IV and the Board of Discipline, it is expected to have an expeditious disposal of cases under
enquiry apart from the consideration of the Prima Facie Opinion formed by the Director (Discipline). In
addition, the Disciplinary Committee under Section 21D headed by the President, ICAI has also been
constituted to look into any residual old cases that are/may be referred back by the Council.
The amendments relating to appearance of the parties/witnesses through video conferencing
before the Disciplinary Committee/Board of Discipline have already been made in the Chartered
Accountants (Procedures of Investigations of Professional and Other Misconduct and Conduct of Cases)
Rules, 2007. Thereafter, the meetings of Board of Discipline and Benches of Disciplinary Committee have
been held through video conferencing apart from the physical meetings.
(I) Salient initiatives/achievements during the current year:
Constitution of an additional bench of the Disciplinary Committee under Section 21B of the
Chartered Accountants Act 1949 with a view to sustain the process of expeditious disposal of cases
under enquiry and consideration of the Prima Facie Opinions formed by the Director
(Discipline).Further, the nomination of Shri Arun Kumar, IAS (Retd.) and Ms. Nita Chowdhury, IAS
(Retd.) as Government Nominee to the Disciplinary Committee (Bench IV) for the term of three
years of 24th Council or till further Orders, whichever is earlier; has also been received.
Initiation of E-hearings; resulting in saving the time and energies of the members of the Board of
Discipline/ Disciplinary Committee besides being economical. Out of the total 12 meetings of the
Disciplinary Committee held till 30th June 2020 during current council year i.e., 2020-21, 11 have
been held through Video Conferencing. Now, members of the Committees will not have to travel
to different places for hearing. Parties to the cases will also have an option to attend Board of
Discipline (BOD)/Disciplinary Committee (DC) hearing through Video Conferencing to be held at
respective Regional Offices.
132 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
a) No. of meetings of the Board of Discipline held during the aforesaid period 36
inception, has been constantly working in this direction by formulating new Accounting Standards as well
as revising the existing Accounting Standards from time to time with the objective to bring the Standards in
line with the International Accounting Standards (IAS)/ International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS),
as issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB). The ASB with a view to provide
guidance on the uniform applications of the Accounting Standards in increasingly complex business
environment, also issues various guidance material from time to time.
The following are the major activities initiated/completed by the Accounting Standards Board during the
year under Report:
(I) Upgrading Financial Reporting Standards:
Amendments / New Ind AS
In order to remain converged with IFRS Standards issued by IASB, following amendments in
Ind AS have been submitted to Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA), Government of India for
notification under section 133 of the Companies Act, 2013:
Definition of Business Amendment to Ind AS 103, Business Combinations
Definition of Material: Amendments to Ind AS 1, Presentation of Financial Statements and
Ind AS 8, Accounting Policies, Changes in Accounting Estimates and Errors
Interest Rate Benchmark Reform (IBOR): Amendments to Ind AS 109, Financial
Instruments, and Ind AS 107, Financial Instruments: Disclosures
Covid-19 Related-Rent Concessions: Amendments to Ind AS 116, Leases.
The above amendments are yet to be notified by the MCA.
Conceptual Framework under Ind AS corresponding to Conceptual Framework issued by IASB
has been issued which is applicable for standard setting activities from April 1, 2020.
Continued its efforts to revise the existing Accounting Standards to bring them nearer to Ind ASs and in
this regard following developments on Exposure Drafts of revised Accounting Standards issued by the ASB
took place:
Exposure Draft of Accounting Standard (AS) 34, Interim Financial Reporting
Exposure Draft of Accounting Standard (AS) 17, Leases
Exposure Draft of Accounting Standard (AS) 41, Agriculture
(II) COVID-19 Disruptions ICAI Accounting and Auditing Advisory
Advisory titled ―Impact of Corona Virus on Financial Reporting and the Auditors Consideration :
To guide the preparers and auditors in the challenging economic and operating environment
caused by COVID-19 global pandemic, a comprehensive Advisory titled ―Impact of Corona Virus
on Financial Reporting and the Auditors Consideration‖ highlighting few important areas of Ind
ASs and ASs issued by the Accounting Standards Board jointly with Auditing & Assurance
Standards Board.
Addendum to Accounting and Auditing Advisory ―Impact of Coronavirus on Financial Reporting
and the Auditors Consideration‖ issued in April 2020 - An Addendum to Accounting and Auditing
Advisory issued to provide additional guidance in relation to estimation of impairment loss for
financial instruments under Expected Credit Loss approach. The guidance is also given on
considerations to be made in respect of loan moratorium. The guidance has been developed on
the basis of IFRS 9 ECL advisory issued by the International Accounting Standards Board
(IASB).
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on India Accounting Standards (Ind AS) issued in May 2020
– FAQs containing 49 questions issued to provide application guidance in certain areas of
accounting in the context of contraction in economic activity, disruptions in financial markets
and a series of actions by government, monetary and prudential authorities. The guidance
offered in the FAQs is applicable for financial year ending March 31, 2020. A weblink at ASB
webpage on ICAI website created specifically dedicated to cover the Accounting Guidance on
COVID-19.
Webcasts conducted - Three webcasts were conducted on COVID-19, its Impact on Financial
Statements on March 30, 2020 and Panel Discussion of Accounting and Auditing Issues on
Coronavirus (COVID-19).
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 135
guidance to the members in the implementation of Standards on Auditing, the Board also brings out
Implementation Guides to those Standards. The following is a comprehensive overview of important
achievements of the Board till date:
(I) Representations/ suggestions to Ministries, Regulators
The Board submitted a representation to RBI regarding interpretation of certain points related to
RBI circular no. RBI/2019-20/186/DOR.No.BP.BC.47/21.04.048/ 2019-20 dated March 27, 2020
w.r.t. COVID 19 – Regulatory Package.
The Board submitted revised formats of Long Form Audit Report (LFAR) for banks and bank
branches to RBI.
The Board submitted ICAI recommendations on Revised Standards on Auditing (SAs) 800, 805 and
810 to NFRA.
The Board submitted to SEBI, the ICAI Views on ―Consultative Paper on policy proposals with
respect to resignation of statutory auditors from listed entities‖ issued by SEBI.
SEBI issued a Circular dated March 29, 2019 containing formats for limited review/ audit report of
listed entities. The Board aligned the audit report formats given in the Circular with SA
700(Revised) and submitted to SEBI. Based on the same, SEBI issued a revised Circular dated
July 19, 2019.
(II) Publications issued
The Board issued the following publications for benefit of the members at large:
Guidance Note on the Companies (Auditor‘s Report) Order, 2020.
Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs) on Engagement and Quality Control Standards.
Guidance Note on Audit of Banks 2020 edition.
Implementation Guide to SA 570(Revised), Going Concern.
Implementation Guide to SA 720(Revised), The Auditor‘s Responsibilities Relating to Other
Information.
Background Material for Audit Training Workshops and Seminars 2019 edition.
Ready Referencer on Engagement and Quality Control Standards.
Practitioner‘s Guide to Audit of Small Entities (Revised 2020).
(III) Other Technical Accomplishments
The Board issued auditing guidance on following aspects to help the members in conducting
audits under the COVID–19 situation:
Going Concern – Key Consideration for Auditors amid COVID–19.
Physical Inventory Verification - Key Audit Considerations amid COVID-19.
Auditor‘s Reporting - Key Audit Considerations amid COVID-19.
Subsequent Events - Key Audit Considerations amid COVID-19.
The Board jointly with the Accounting Standards Board issued an Advisory for the members
―ICAI Accounting and Auditing Advisory - Impact of Coronavirus on Financial Reporting and the
Auditors Consideration‖.
The Board issued ―Compendium of Auditing Guidance Issued by Auditing and Assurance
Standards Board on Various Aspects amid COVID-19‖.
The Board issued an Addendum to the Guidance Note on Audit of Banks 2020 edition to provide
guidance to the members on the circulars issued by RBI on COVID 19 - Regulatory Package
dated March 27, 2020 and COVID 19 Regulatory Package - Asset Classification and
Provisioning dated April 17, 2020.
The Board submitted its comments on ―Discussion Paper on Audits of Less Complex Entities:
Exploring Possible Options to Address the Challenges in Applying the ISAs‖ issued by IAASB for
public comments.
140 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
for consistent reporting across all locations. It is free for 3 years upto 5 Users per CA Firm and 25
Customers (Single Entity and Single Location). The details are available at
https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
Board Module for Secretarial Compliances- This Platform comprehensively covers the
activities carried out by the Secretarial Function. It is free for 3 years upto 05 Users per CA
Firm and 25 Private Companies (Single Entity). The details are available at
https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
Payroll Processing and Labour Compliance- It has designed an end to end automated
solution to prepare regulatory compliance documents under Labour Laws in India. It is also
integrating the Labour Compliance product with Payroll software to eliminate the
requirement for manual inputs. Accordingly, basic payroll processing capabilities will also
be available in future. It is free for 3 years upto 05 Users per CA Firm and 25 Customers
with employee strength < 25 (Single Entity & Single Location). The details are available at
https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
Compliance Audit- This Compliance Product can also be used for generating compliance
checklist for specific customer. These details can be generated by updating the customer
details in terms of type of company, industry, state in which located, etc.These checklists
can then be used to carry out compliance audits covering law of the land for customers. It
is free for 3 years upto 5 Users per CA Firm and 25 Customers (Single Entity and Single
Location). The details are available at https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
Practice Management Tool- It has a flexible workflow wherein CA Firms will be able to use
digital workflows to manage assignments. It will facilitate all ―Touch Points‖ between the
Teams and with the Customers via the Platform itself and all data / documents could be
securely shared within the Platform itself. This will help CA Firms to manage data privacy
and access controls. It is free for 3 years upto 05 Users per CA Firm and 25 Customers.
The details are available at https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
Papilio Software-It is a secure cloud based collaboration software for Chartered Accountants.
Being on the internet, Papilio can be accessed from anywhere. Papilio also has a mobile
app, thus enabling users to collaborate from anywhere, and anytime. It is free for Life less
than 5 users as per Terms & Conditions. The details are available at
https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
Tally.ERP 9 Gold Software-ICAI along has worked out a special pricing for Multi-User version
software. The same shall be governed by a set of principles and guidelines. The details of above
are available at https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
Antivirus software at Special price for Members & Students of ICAI-An arrangement made by
the Committee in order to enable members to have access to antivirus software, has tied
up with Quick Heal technologies for providing access at a special discounted price. The
details are available at https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
Practice Management Software for members in practice & CA Firms of ICAI: -The Committee
has arranged the practice management software for members in practice / firms, in form
of cloud software designed for managing the Professional Practice in an effective way. It is
free as per Terms & Conditions. The details are available at https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
GST Annual Returns (GSTR-9 & 9C) software- The Committee has worked an arrangement for ‗GST
Software (Annual Returns)‘ for Members in Practice and CA Firms. It is free of cost as per Tems &
Conditions. The details are available at https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
EFF factor software for the Practitioners/CA Firm of ICAI: The Committee has worked an
arrangement for EFF factor software for the practitioners/CA firms. The details are
available at https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
CORDL Practice Management software - The details are available at
https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
XBRL Software-The Committee has arranged the ‗XBRL Filing Software (C&I and Cost &
Accounting Taxonomy)‘ for Practicing Chartered Accountants & CA Firms of ICAI. The
same is free of cost to CA Practitioners & Firms under terms & Conditions. The details are
available at https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 143
‗All –in-One‘ software – A cloud based Accounting and Compliance solution- Cloud based ‗All-
in-One‘ software, One Stop Solution for all Accounting, Compliance, Return Preparation
and Filing needs of Chartered Accountants in Practice & CA Firms. The said software is free
of cost for three users for 3 years as per terms & conditions to CA Practitioners & Firms.
The details are available at https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
(IV) Insurance Schemes
LIC Group term Insurance- The Committee arranged in the form of specially designed Group
Term Insurance through the LIC for Members of ICAI. The Term Insurance policy will cover
death due to any reason.
Health Insurance- New India Flexi Floater Group Mediclaim Policy is a floater policy in which the
proposer can cover self, spouse and dependent children under a single floater sum insured.
Motor Insurance- A MOU with New India Assurance Co. Ltd for Motor Vehicle Insurance has
been arranged by the Committee. The Motor Vehicle Insurance is basically designed for the
members having value added features such as Unique Offer of 65% discount on OD for both
Private car and two Wheeler etc.
Professional Indemnity Insurance- The professional indemnity section covers for awards and
settlements of claims, as well as the costs incurred in investigating, defending or settling a
claim made against you.
Office Protection Shield Policy- The Insurance Company indemnify against liability as tenant of
the office premises for damages to the building and fixture and fittings.
Personal Accident Policy- This policy is basically designed to offer some sort of compensation to
the insured person who suffers bodily injury solely as a result of an accident which is external,
violent and visible.
House Holder Insurance- This policy protects home against various risks/perils. Its Coverage is
extended to the building and contents of home including Furniture, Fixtures, Fittings, Domestic
Appliances, Jewellery etc.
The details of Insurance Schemes are available at https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/
(V) Capacity Building Measures:
MOU with World Bank for Procurement Audit -The Committee entered a MoU with the World
Bank for the arrangement of Knowledge enhancement of the Members of ICAI in Procurement
Audit & thereof. This aforesaid arrangement with the World Bank offer procurement training
with the Joint Certification basis to the participants of the training programme. These trainings
are meant to enhance the capacity of ICAI members to participate in procurement
opportunities in Bank funded Projects for various assignments including external/internal
audits; procurement audits/post reviews, and other consultancy assignments for firms and
individual members of ICAI.
Virtual Certificate Course on Preparation of Appeals, Drafting of Deed & Documents and
Representation before Appellate Authorities and Statutory Bodies -The certificate course on
Preparation of appeals, Drafting of Deed & Documents and Representation before Appellate
Authorities and statutory bodies is developed for the knowledge enhancement of the effective
drafting skills of members and acquaints the members with the legal provision pertaining to
appearances before various authorities. The details of the course are available at
https://resource.cdn.icai.org/50996ccbmp210718-0420.pdf.
Virtual Certificate Course on Wealth Management and Financial Planning (WMFP) -The
Committee has launched the Certificate Course on Wealth Management and Financial Planning
for enhancing new career opportunities for the members. The details of the course are
available at https://resource.cdn.icai.org/35876ccbcaf25359-wmfp-details.pdf
Revised Minimum Recommended Scale of the fees for the Professional Assignments done by
the Chartered Accountants for Class ‗A‘ & Class ‗B‘ & Class ‗C‘ cities- The Committee has
prepared a Brochure on Revised Minimum Recommended Scale of the fees for the Professional
Assignments done by the Chartered Accountants for Class ‗A‘ , Class ‗B‘ & & Class ‗C‘ cities. The
details of above are available at https://cmpbenefits.icai.org/wp-
content/uploads/2020/02/Details-download.pdf
144 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
International Arena & RERA, Code of Ethics for Members in Practice, Precautions while doing
Company Audits during the Year 2020 for Members in Practice-in light of Covid-19.
The Committee organized 26 national conferences, seminars, workshops and residential
programmes for the capacity –building measures of practitioners on Goods and Services Taxes
(GST), Auditors engagement in Procurement post review for World Bank Funded projects on 31st
January, 2020, Companies Act & Income Tax, NRI Taxation and GST, Emerging Challenges in GST
& Direct Taxes¸ Tax Audit & ICDS, UDIN, Capital Gain Taxation & Forensic Audit at Odisha, New
Delhi, Anantapur, Bhyander, Gorakhpur, Ongole, Gurgaon, Visakhapatnam, Udaipur, Thane,
Ranchi, Mangaluru, Asansol, Vijayawada, Indore, Amritsar, Bilaspur, Bhubaneswar, Kollam, Shridi,
Mussoorie Tirupati etc during the year wherein many members participated in the programmes.
The Committee organized 2 and 4 batches of 30 CPE hours Virtual Certificate Courses on ‗Wealth
Management and Financial Planning‘ and ‗Preparation of appeals, Drafting of Deed & Documents
and Representation before Appellate Authorities and statutory bodies‘ in the month of April-June,
2020 and April-July, 2020.
5.6 CPE Directorate and Centralised Distribution System (CPED&CDS)
The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) through its Continuing Professional Education (CPE)
Directorate implements such measures using tools of learning, physical and virtual that may provide
sufficient opportunity to all Members of the Institute to keep abreast of current knowledge in their core
areas of competence and Professional Development.
Continuing Professional Education Directorate (CPED) keeps its Members updated with the recent
advancements in existing and newly emerging areas of specialized learning in offline/online mode via
numerous initiatives; and supports in fulfilment of their mandatory CPE Hours requirements through
Structured & Unstructured Learning Activities.
In the Council year 2019-20, the CPE Directorate was constituted in place of CPE Committee, in which E-
learning was made a part of CPE Directorate. Thereafter, in the Council year 2020-21, CPE Directorate &
Centralised Distribution System (CDS) is constituted with the evised Terms of Reference of CPE
Directorate.-
Significant Achievements and Recent Initiatives of the CPE Directorate :
(I) Robust Members’ Learning & Development Mechanism :-
To ensure the compliance of various guidelines, rules and Directions, as issued by the Council and
CPE Directorate for organising of CPE event by the CPE POUs, the CPED has adopted stronger and
stricter regulatory mechanism for regulating and overseeing the organisation of CPE Programmes.
Also, the CPE POUs are being monitored and supervised throughout the year for their continuous
improvement and better functioning.
(II) CPE Statement:-
Contemporary with Global requirements & Practices, the CPE Credit Hours requirements for various
categories of members as applicable for the current block of 3 years (1-1-2020 to 31-12-2022) are
as under:-
Category of Members CPE Hours requirement
Members (aged less than 60 years) who are 120 (out of which minimum 60 CPE hours
holding Certificate of Practice (except all should be of Structured learning)
those members who are residing abroad) -minimum 20 CPE credit hours of
structured learning in each calendar year
Members (aged 60 years & above) who are 90 (either structured or unstructured
holding Certificate of Practice learning)
- minimum of 20 CPE credit hours either
Structured or Unstructured Learning in
each calendar year
Members (aged less than 60 years) who are 60 (either structured or unstructured
not holding Certificate of Practice; and all the learning)
members who are residing abroad (whether -minimum 15 CPE credit hours either
holding Certificate of Practice or not) structured or unstructured learning in
each calendar year
146 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
Exemptions to Members:
A member is exempted only for the particular calendar year during which he gets his
membership for the first time.
The following class of members are exempted from CPE credit hours requirement:
All the members (aged 60 years and above) who are not holding Certificate of
Practice.
Judges of Supreme Court, High Court, District Courts and Tribunal
Members of Parliament/MLAs/MLCs
Governors of States
Centre and State Civil Services
Entrepreneurs (owners of Business (manufacturing) organizations other than professional
services)
Judicial officers
Members in Military Service
Temporary Exemptions:
(i) Female members for one Calendar year on the grounds of pregnancy.
(ii) Physically disabled members on case to case basis having permanent disability of not
less than 40% and above (Supported with medical certificates from any doctor
registered with Indian Medical Council with relevant specialisation as evidenced by Post
Qualifications (M.D., M.S. etc.).
(iii) Members suffering from prolonged critical diseases/illnesses or other disability as may
be specified or approved by the CPED. (Supported with medical certificates from any
doctor registered with Indian Medical Council with relevant specialisation as evidenced
by Post Qualifications (M.D., M.S. etc.)
A member or class of members to whom the CPED may in their absolute discretion grant
full/partial exemption specifically or generally on account of facts and circumstances of the
case which in their opinion prevent such person(s) from compliance with the requirements of
CPE as specified in the Statement.
(III) IT Initiatives undertaken during the lockdown period:-
Webinars
Post Covid-19 situation, the public gatherings were prohibited; therefore all physical CPE
Seminars were cancelled and in view of the same all Regional Council/Branches and Foreign
Chapters were allowed first time to organize webinars for grant of Unstructured CPE Hours
only during the lock down period. However, from 19th May, 2020 onwards webinars were
allowed to be organized by Central Committees only.
Virtual CPE Meeting
Grant of Structured CPE hours were allowed to the participants of the Virtual CPE Meetings
(VCM) (from 17.05.2020 onwards) which may be organised by Central Committees, Regional
Councils, Branches, Foreign Chapters, CPE Study Circles, CPE Study Chapters & CMI & B Study
Circles in controlled online environment to avoid any hardship being faced by members.
CPED has decided that out of 20 hours Structured CPE hours which is mandatory to be
completed by Members below 60 years holding COP, in each calendar year, 10 Structured CPE
hours can be granted through online mode (either through Digital Learning Hub or through
above Virtual CPE meetings including mandatory CPE hours on ―Code of ethics‖ and ―Standard
on auditing‖) till 31st August, 2020.
Refresher Course
The Central Committees, Regional Councils and Foreign Chapters were allowed to organize
maximum 5 days Refresher Course in Online mode on a particular topic with maximum 3 CPE
hours learning in a day.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 147
Holding of AGM through Video Conferencing (VC) or Other Audio Video Solutions (OAVS) by
CPE/CMI & B Study Circles and CPE Study Chapters
CPED had issued procedure for holding AGMs by CPE/CMI & B Study Circles and Chapters
through Video Conferencing (VC) or Other Audio Video Solutions (OAVS) for convening
elections of Convenor and Deputy Convenor/Appointment of Auditors etc. due to the impact of
COVID-19.
(IV) Other initiatives taken during the lockdown period:-
CPED implemented the decision with regard to mandatory completion of 2 Structured CPE
Hours, each on the topics related to ―Standards on Auditing‖ and ―Code of Ethics‖ (total 4
Structured CPE Hours out of 20 Structured CPE Hours) during every Calendar year, from
Calendar Year 2020 onwards in Online/Virtual mode for the Categories of members who
are required to complete minimum 20 Structured CPE Hours in a Calendar year (COP
Holder). This may be completed any time during the year in Online/Virtual mode.
The last date for submission of audited annual accounts by the CPE Study Circles and CPE
Study Chapters for the financial year 2019-20 has been extended now till 15th July, 2020
from 15th May, 2020, to ensure its compliance by the CPE Study Circles & CPE Study
Chapters in present COVID-19 situation.
The last date for submitting of self-declaration form online on CPE Portal by the Member for
claiming of Unstructured CPE Hours for the Calendar year 2019 has been extended till 30th
June, 2020 from 31st May, 2020.
(V) Spreading Wings Globally:-
7 CPE International Study Tours were organised internationally by the CPE POUs at Switzerland,
Bali, Muscat, Malaysia, Dubai.
(VI) Brand and Capacity Building:-
The ICAI has all along endeavoured to keep its members aware of and abreast with the
professional and technological changes that are taking place, around the globe through the
process of continuous skill honing by way of classroom teaching, e-Learning mode, In-house
Executive Development Programmes, Webcasts, Awareness programmes, Seminars, Conferences
etc. Few of the milestones are as follows:
National Level CPE Programmes and other important Events
8906 CPE Programmes were organised for the Members across the country (includes 1204 CPE
Programmes in Virtual mode from 13th March, 2020 to 30th June, 2020), by the CPE
Programme Organising Units of ICAI on various topics of professional interest.
CA Day Virtual National Summit
Three-day Virtual National CA Summit 2020 on the topic ―Transforming the Future: Enabling
Excellence, Augmenting Trust‖ (providing credit of 9 unstructured CPE hours) was organised
from 29.06.2020 to 01.07.2020 on the occasion of CA day.
Refresher Courses
7 Virtual CPE Meetings (VCMs) in form of Refresher Courses were organised by Central
Committees/Board on various topics i.e., FEMA, Accounting Standards, Income Tax Appellate
Proceedings, Advanced Excel & Data Dashboard, Data/Forensic Analytics using CAAT
Tools, Practical Guide to ISA & Data Analysis and Visualisation with Microsoft Excel Power
Tools and Power BI (from 13.3.2020 to 30.6.2020)
National Level Programmes and other Important Events
Types of CPE Programme organised- 150 Live Webcasts/Webinars by various POUs of ICAI,
167 Certificate Courses for the Members by Central Committees of ICAI, 92 Post-Qualification
Courses by the Central Committees of ICAI, 19 National level by Central Committees/Board of
ICAI and hosted by the Regional Councils/Branches of ICAI, 16 Batches of Pre-registration
Education Course by ICAI RVO, 13 Batches of Pre-registration Education Course by IIIPI.
Opening of New CPE Programme Organising Units (POUs)
3 more CPE POUs were opened for helping the members in mofussil/remote areas of the
country to undergo CPE activities in their nearby places, reaching to a strong network base of
613 CPE POUs in India and Abroad.
148 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
Representation on certain issues in the Companies Fresh Settlement Scheme, 2020 sent to MCA
in May, 2020.
Reply to the Letter received from MCA pertaining to the issues with regard to Computation of net
profit under section 198 of the Companies Act, 2013 for computing CSR liability submitted in
January, 2020
ICAI Suggestions on the Recommendations made by High Level Committee on CSR-2018
submitted in January, 2020
ICAI Suggestions on the Report of the Company Law Committee formed by the Ministry of
Corporate Affairs submitted in November, 2019
ICAI Recommendations on what shall/ shall not constitute Management Services under Section
144 of the Companies Act 2013 were submitted to MCA in June, 2019.
ICAI Suggestions on the Recommendations of the Committee on Corporate Governance under
Shri Uday Kotak Committee on the following issues submitted to MCA in June, 2019.
Strengthening role of ICAI – Recommendations w.r.t enforcement/disciplinary process of the
ICAI.
Strengthening of reporting on Internal Financial Controls
Greater transparency on audit quality indicators
Strengthening the independent functioning of the Quality Review Board (QRB) Current
Regulatory Provisions.
ICAI suggestions on the practices followed by UK, US, Australia and Singapore for appointment of
Internal auditor as external auditor and vice-versa after cessation of the tenure were submitted to
MCA in June, 2019.
ICAI Comments/ Suggestions on the provisions of CSR in the Companies Act 2013, Companies
(CSR Policy) Rules, 2014 and Circulars issued concerning CSR submitted to High Level Committee
on CSR constituted by MCA in May, 2019.
Representation regarding improving Governance in Companies
Request to waive off additional fee for filing ADT- 1 where Form GNL- 2 has already been filed by
the companies for the period 1st April, 2014 to 19th October, 2014, with respect to filing of the
ACTIVE form submitted to MCA in April, 2019.
MCA has issued clarification and waived off fee for filing Form ADT- 1 till 15.06.2019.
(II) Facilitating the Law making process for the Companies Act, 2013
ICAI is a member of the Committee formed by MCA to discuss Stakeholders Suggestions on
the Consultation Paper on Audit Independence and Accountability.
ICAI is a member on Governing Council of National Foundation for Corporate Governance
(NFCG).
ICAI is a member of Secretarial Standards Board (SSB) constituted by the Institute of Company
Secretaries of India (ICSI) for the year 2019-20
ICAI is a member of the Committee for drafting Appendix to the Investigation Manual of
Serious Fraud Investigation Office
ICAI is a member of the Company Law and Corporate Governance Committee of PHD Chamber
of Commerce and Industry
ICAI is a member of the Group to examine the Companies (Acceptance of Deposit) Rules, 2014
ICAI is a member of the Sub-Group (2) to examine the suggestions pertaining to streamlining
the Companies Act, 2013.
ICAI is a member of the Working Committee for streamlining working under the Companies
Act, 2013
ICAI is a member of Group for Scope of Limited Review and Related Procedure constituted by
SEBI.
150 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
Guidance Note on Division I – Non Ind AS Schedule III to the Companies Act, 2013 (Revised July,
2019 Edition)
Guidance Note on Division II – Ind AS Schedule III to the Companies Act, 2013 (Revised July, 2019
Edition)
Frequently Asked Questions on the Companies Act, 2013- Revised July, 2019 Edition
Guidance Note on Division III to Schedule III to the Companies Act 2013 for NBFC that is
required to comply with Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS )
Frequently Asked Questions on the Companies Fresh Start Scheme and LLP Settlement Scheme,
2020 (Original and Modified).
Frequently Asked Questions on the Scheme for relaxation of time for filing forms related to
creation or modification of charges under the Companies Act, 2013.
(V) Other initiatives
The Committee prepared Frequently Asked Questions on the queries received from participants
during the webcast to give more clarity on the issues and submitted the same to the Ministry of
Corporate Affairs. The Ministry of Corporate Affairs has issued the FAQ‘s on eForm INC 22A as
prepared on the basis of FAQs submitted by the Committee. FAQs are hosted on Ministry of
Corporate Affairs website at the following link: http://mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/active.html
The Committee prepared Frequently Asked Question on based upon the amendments Section 135
(Corporate Social Responsibility) of the Companies Act, 2013.
The Committee has invited suggestions/comments from members on various provisions of the
Companies Act, 2013 and Rules thereunder.
Publications of Corporate Laws & Corporate Governance Committee uploaded on the ICAI Digital
Learning Hub- ICAI had processed Digitization of member publications on the ICAI's Digital
Learning Hub (https://learning.icai.org/elearning) an integrated Learning and knowledge eco-
system, it is envisaged that the said publications are to be made available to members as an "as
on date" updated information. In this regard, the publications that have been issued by CL&CGC
have been uploaded on the Portal and are enabled for view of members.
(VI) Programmes/Conferences/Webcast
The Committee organised 7 live Webcasts/Webinar on Economy and Governance-Post COVID 19,
―ICAI Leadership Summit – Post COVID 19 Scenario‖, Analysis and key features of Company Fresh
Settlement Scheme 2020 & Revised LLP Settlement Scheme, 2020, MCA E- Form DPT- 3 -
Compliance and other aspects, Salient features of Companies Amendment Act, 2019, MCA E- Form
Active (Active Company Tagging Identities and Verification) INC-22A - Compliance and other
aspects during the year.
The Committee also conducted seven programmes across the country for creating awareness about
the MCA E- Form Active (Active Company Tagging Identities and Verification) INC-22A, Conference
on ‗Effective Board Dynamics‘ for Directors & Aspiring Directors, training programme for the IAS
Officials of the Government of Tami Nadu and 21 Training/ Awareness Programmes on the
Companies Act, 2013 across the country during the year
(VII) Updates for professional development of members relating to Corporate Laws
The Committee regularly issues series of update for members towards professional development which
includes updates on the Corporate Laws. The 22nd issue of update upto 31st May, 2020 is uploaded on
ICAI Website.
Further, the following Announcements/ analysis have been prepared by the office and on approval
from Chairman CL&CGC have been uploaded on ICAI website.
Further relaxations by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs till September 30, 2020 for conduct of
Board meetings to approve its financial statements through VC or OAVM and registration of
Independent Directors in the Independent Directors Data Bank by CL&CGC ICAI
Scheme for relaxation of time for filing forms related to creation or modification of charges under
the Companies Act, 2013
Clarification on holding of Annual General meeting through video conferencing or other audio-
visual means by CL&CGC ICAI
152 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
Submission of representation to Chairman, CBDT requesting to extend the due date of filing
Income-tax returns for the AY 2019-20.
Submission of representation to Hon‘ble Finance Minister regarding concerns of the Institute
with reference to the letter dated July 18, 2019 submitted by the Institute of Cost
Accountants of India requesting to amend the definition of ―Accountant‖ in the Explanation
appended to section 288(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961.
Submission of representation to the CBDT regarding ICAI‘s inputs for identification of
topics/areas related to Direct Taxes for creation of new Tax Payer Information (TPI) Series
Brochures.
Submission of representation to Chairman, CBDT regarding request to take up issues faced
by tax- payers leading to unnecessary hardships.
Submission of representation to Hon‘ble Finance Minister regarding concerns of the Institute
with reference to the letter no. ICSI:PFP:2019 dated August 2, 2019 submitted by the
Institute of Company Secretaries of India requesting to amend the definition of ―Accountant‖
in the Explanation appended to section 288(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961.
Submission of representation to the CBDT requesting for extension of time for submission of
Tax Audit Reports and related returns from September 30, 2019 to November 30, 2019.
Submission of representation to the CBDT regarding ICAI‘s Inputs on Income-tax Rules,
1962.
Submission of representation for request to provide special relaxations to the assessees
based at Jammu and Kashmir.
Submission of representation regarding concerns of ICAI w.r.t. Circular No. 24/2019 dated
09.09.2019 issued by the CBDT regarding procedure for identification and processing of cases
for prosecution under Direct Tax Laws.
Submission of representation to the CBDT regarding ICAI‘s Inputs on draft Notification
proposing amendments in Form No. 10B and Rule 17B.
Submission of representation to the CBDT regarding further Inputs on Income-tax Rules,
1962.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 153
Excel (Data Analytics), Forensic Analytics using CAAT Tools, Practical Guide to IS Audit,
Technology, DISA 3.0 Implementation, Quick Walkthrough - DISA Syllabus 2.0 and tips to crack
ISA AT exam, Data Analytics Simulation on CBS Files, Self Assessment tool for Practicing Firms at
Hyderabad, Kanpur, Indore, Ahmedabad, Patna, New Delhi during the year.
Refresher Course/Virtual CPE Meeting – Session- on Advance Excel and Data Dashboard/ VCM-
Data Analytics Using CAAT Tools/Practical Guide to ISA/ Data Analysis and Visualisation with
Microsoft Excel Power Tools and Power BI.
First time conduct of online DISA Eligibility Test and FAFD Assessment Test. Further first time
inhouse Online FAFD Assessment Test was conducted through ICAI Digital Learning Hub.
Digital Practice Webinar Series
Cybersecurity for Accountants – Concepts and Tools
Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning Shaping Fintech Landscape
5 days Refresher Course/Virtual CPE Meeting- Session on Data Analysis and Visualisation with
Microsoft Excel Power Tools and Power BI
(IV) Blockchain Technology for Professional Accountants
The Board has launched five days training programme on Blockchain Technology for Professional
Accountants which would provide introduction to blockchain technology and develop use cases in different
industries. The course also covers future of blockchain technology in terms of innovation in enabling
transparent accounting ecosystem, and its potential to transform current auditing practices. The board had
already successfully conducted 12 Programs during the year.
(V) Post Qualification Course on Information Systems Audit
Post Qualification Course on Information System Audit (DISA), conducted by the Board, was started in the
year 2001 to upskill Chartered Accountants in Information Systems Audit which was in increasing demand.
DISA course combined technology, information assurance and information management expertise that
enabled a DISA qualified Chartered Accountant to become trusted Information Technology advisor and
provider of Information Security Assurance services. From 2001 till date more than 29,000 members have
qualified this Course. DISA was also conducted at Institute of Chartered Accountants of Sri Lanka and
Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nepal. With a view to benchmark DISA qualification to international
standards, the Board is in the process of taking American National Standards Institute (ANSI) Certification.
Digital Accounting and Assurance Board had also updated the syllabus for the Post Qualification Course on
Information Systems Audit. Total 105 batches organized during the year.
Launching of revised Course of Information Systems Audit (DISA 3.0) on the occasion of CA day, 01st July
2020.
Organized 6 days virtual Train the trainer program for DISA 3.0 with an objective to give walkthrough to
all the faculties about the revamped syllabus.
(VI) Certificate Course on Forensic Accounting and Fraud Detection
The Board conducts ―Certificate Course on Forensic Accounting and Fraud Detection‖, and till date around
6,400 members have qualified this Course. The objective of this specialized Course is to help the chartered
accountants attain skill of utilizing accounting, auditing, CAATs/ Data Mining Tools, and investigative skills
to detect fraud/ mistakes. 55 batches had been conducted during the year.During COVID-19 the Board had
conducted 14 Batches of the FAFD Certificate course through virtual mode in which more than 1200
members completed the training
(VII) Workshops/ Summits/ Training Sessions on Emerging Technologies conducted by the
Board
During the year Board had conducted more than 25 Workshops/ Seminars/ Conferences/ Training
Programmes on Emerging Technologies.
(VIII) MOU between ICAI and Gujarat Forensic Sciences University (GFSU) for carrying out
joint advanced practical training in Financial Forensic Auditing and Fraud Investigation
The Board has entered an MOU with Gujarat Forensic Sciences University, Gandhinagar for organizing
Advanced Practical Training in Financial Forensic Auditing and Fraud Investigation for the members of ICAI.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 157
In view of the provisions of clause (11) of part I of the First schedule to the Chartered Accountant
Act, 1949, it is not permitted for members in practice to engage in Derivatives transactions on
stock exchange since it is not any kind of investment but more likely a business.
It is permissible for member in practice to hold Honorary post of executive member/office bearer
in a political party.
It is not permissible for a partnership Firm not registered with the Institute to undertake
professional assignments, even if it comprise only of members in practice.
It is not permissible for a member to undertake the assignment of certification , wherein the client
is relative of the member. The "relative" for this purpose would refer to the definition mentioned in
Accounting Standard (AS) -18.
It is not permitted for members to engage in share trading, however, they may hold shares for
the purpose of investment.
5.12 Expert Advisory Committee (EAC)
The EAC was constituted by the Institute in the year 1975 to give guidance to members of the Institute
and other stakeholders on accounting, auditing and allied matters in accordance with the Advisory Service
Rules. The accounting professionals are often exposed to intricate and complex issues related to financial
reporting. Keeping this in mind, the Expert Advisory Committee (EAC) reply to the queries received from
the members of the Institute.
The opinions given by the Committee are published as a Compendium of Opinions. So far, thirty-six
volumes of the Compendium have been published. The role of EAC has always been vital in strengthening
sound accounting and auditing practices especially keeping in line with the expectations of the various
stakeholders.
(I) Expert Opinions
The Committee replies to the queries on issues pertaining to accounting and/or auditing principles under
specific situations/circumstances in the form of Opinions. However, it does not reply to queries which
involve legal interpretation of various enactments. The Committee accepts the queries in accordance with
Advisory Service Rules framed for this purpose. The Committee also does not answer queries which
concern a matter pending before the Disciplinary Committee of the Institute, any court of law, the Income-
tax authorities or any other department of the Government. These Rules are available on the web-site of
the ICAI, at its hyperlink, http://www.icai.org/new_category.html?c_id=142 or can be obtained from the
Institute‘s Head Office at New Delhi.
The services rendered by EAC have been lauded by Regulators and other Government authorities, such as,
Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA), Comptroller and Auditor General of India (C&AG), Securities and
Exchange Board of India (SEBI) etc. These Regulators/authorities seek its opinion whenever they are
posed with any complex issues related to accounting and auditing principles.
The opinions expressed by the Expert Advisory Committee are based on the facts supplied and considering
the relevant legal position and the accounting/auditing principles prevailing on the date the Committee
finalises the opinion.
(II) 42 opinions issued during the period
The Committee has finalised 40 opinions on the queries referred on various accounting issues by the
members of the Institute such as Amortisation of leasehold land, provision for pay revision, classification of
spares, Cash Basis Accounting by AIF, Creation of deferral account balances, Valuation of inventories of
iron ore fines, Principal Vs. Agent classification under Ind AS 115, Disclosure of feedstock subsidy,
Amortisation of stamp duty and registration charges pais/payable towards execution of mining lease deeds,
Non-recognition of deferred tax assets on provision for warranty, replacement, inventory and doubtful
debts and claims, Accounting treatment for- project insurance, employee benefits expenses/rent
expenses/travelling expenses/housekeeping expenses incurred doe construction of project, security deposit
under RGGLVY, embedded derivatives in non financial host contracts as per IND As 109, leasehold land,
Dedicated Freight Corridor Concession Agreement etc and 2 opinions on different accounting issues
received from the Regulators/ Government authorities.
(III) Webcast on “Contemporary issues under Ind AS opined by the EAC”
In order to disseminate knowledge and information and to create awareness amongst the members and
other stakeholders with regard to the services rendered and also on the opinions issued by the
Committee, a Webcast on ―Contemporary issues under Ind AS opined by the Expert Advisory Committee‖
was organised on April 15, 2020. The Webcast was a huge success with the total IPs of 4923 and total
viewers hits of 15634.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 159
Changes in Accounting Policies, AS 9: Revenue Recognition, AS 11: The Effects of Changes in Foreign
Exchange Rates, AS 20: Earning per Share, AS 13: Accounting for Investments and AS 26: Intangible
Assetshave been published in the Institute‘s Journal, ‗The Chartered Accountant‘, in the issue of April,
2019, May 2019, June 2019, August 2019, September 2019, October 2019, November 2019 and December
2019 respectively.
(IV) Empowering Members and Capacity Building
To enhance the knowledge of members on review skill as well as the latest developments taking place in
accounting standards, standards on auditing and other financial reporting requirement, the following
activities were undertaken during this period:
Webcast on Commonly found Non-Compliances-The Board initiated to organize series of webcasts on
commonly found non-compliances observed in the financial statements by the Board on regular basis.
In view of the same, 9 Live Webcasts were organized on Commonly Found Non-compliances on AS 15,
AS 3, AS 2, AS 18, Companies Act, 2013, AS 22, CARO, AS 5, AS 9, AS 11, AS 20, AS 13 and AS 26 and
were well attended by members.
Webinars on Commonly Observed Errors in Application of Accounting Standards-In preparation of
financial statements under Accounting Standards, various errors are commonly observed in context of
application of Accounting Standards. Accordingly, a webinar on ‗‘Commonly Observed Errors in
Application of Accounting Standards‘‘ has been conducted on 15-18 June, 2020, jointly with ASB, to
enhance the knowledge of members of the ICAI in the area of application of Accounting Standards.
Empanelment of Technical Reviewers-To conduct the detailed review of IND-AS based Financial
Statements, the Board is in the process of empanelling more Technical Reviewers having expertise in
Ind AS (IFRS).
5.14 GST and Indirect Taxes Committee (GST & IDTC)
(I) Input/ Representation/presentation to/before the Government: The Committee has
submitted following inputs/ presentations/ representations to/before the Government:
Suggestions on GST Annual Return and Audit Certificates for the Year 2017-18 on 12th September,
2019.
The Committee supported GSTN in drafting an e-invoice standard.
Pre-Budget Memorandum, 2020
Presentation before Hon‘ble Finance Minister on Return filing issues made on 16th November,
2019.
Presentation before the Officials of the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs highlighting
the suggestions contained in Pre-Budget Memorandum, 2020 made on 5th December, 2019.
Representation for providing relaxation to the taxpayers under GST due to COVID – 19 was
submitted on 18th March, 2020.
Representation to extend the due date of payment by further 60 days in the said SVLDR Scheme
was submitted on 20th March, 2020.
Representation highlighting the difficulties being faced by the Registered Person in filing GST
Annual Return for financial years 2018-19, who had not filed their Annual Return for financial years
2017-18 was submitted on 27th February, 2020.
Representation for providing separate login facility to CA for filing Reconciliation Statement in Form
9C in line with Income Tax Audit was submitted on 3rd March, 2020.
Representation requesting the withdrawal of sub-rule 4 to Rule 36 from retrospective effect was
submitted on 3rd March, 2020.
Representation for Permitting availment of input tax credit pertaining to Financial Year 2018-19 till
due date of filing of Annual Return was submitted on 3 rd March, 2020.
Representation for providing facility for mentioning UDIN in all the forms/Certificates to be
certified/ issued by CAs was submitted on 3rd March, 2020.
Representation for extending date for filing GST Annual Return and Audit submitted on August 21,
2019.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 161
Representation for correcting technical glitches in filing of Annual Return & Audit i.e. Form 9/ 9C
submitted on June 13, 2019.
Representation for extending date for filing of statement by a Composition Supplier and payment
of tax for the quarter ending June 30, 2019 submitted on July 17, 2019.
Representation for inclusion of CA Member in the GST Grievance Redressal Committee
Representation for change in Jurisdiction of Daman and Dadra & Nagar Haveli from GSTAT Mumbai
to GSTAT Surat Area Bench was submitted on 30th Dec, 2019.
(II) Publication – A research Initiatives: The Committee brought out/revised following publications
on GST and other Indirect Taxes:
Handbook on Registration under GST - 1st Edition – May, 2020
Handbook on E-way Bill under GST - 1st Edition – April, 2020
Handbook on Annual Return under GST - 1st Edition – May, 2020
Handbook on Refund under GST - 1st Edition – April, 2020
Handbook on TDS provision under GST - 1st Edition – May, 2020
Handbook on Interest, Late Fee and Penalties under GST - 1st Edition – May, 2020
Handbook on Advance Ruling under GST - 1st Edition – May, 2020
Handbook on Reverse Charge under GST - 1st Edition – May, 2020
Handbook on Casual Taxable Person under GST - 1st Edition – May, 2020
Handbook on Invoicing under GST - 1st Edition – May, 2020
Handbook on Job Work under GST – 3rd Edition – May, 2020
Guide to CA Certificates in GST - 1st Edition – February, 2020
Handbook on Exempted Supplies under GST- 2nd Edition – February, 2020
Background Material on GST– 8th Edition – November, 2019
Bare Law on GST Acts and Rules – 4th Edition - October, 2019
Technical Guide on GST Audit - 2nd Edition – May, 2019
Background Material on Sabka Vishwas (Legacy Dispute Resolution) Scheme, 2019– 1st Edition –
October, 2019
BGM on training programme for Government officials – Oct, 2019
(III) E-initiatives
Course on Reconciliation Statement, Audit & Appeals and conversion -The Committee organised
an online five days Course on Reconciliation Statement, Audit & Appeals from 25 th April to 3rd
May, 2020 which was subscribed by 1600 members.
Certificate Course through Virtual classes-A batch of the virtual classes was organised for
incomplete batch of the Course at Gwalior and Surat from 18 th May, 2020 to 1st June, 2020.
Further, two new batches of the Course were organised in June, 2020 which were attended by
200 participants.
Series of Live webcast on GST - Committee organized a Five days Live Webcasts Series on GST
which was on an average viewed by 10,000 members.
LIVE Webcasts -With a view to update the members and taking the benefit of technology, the
Committee has been regularly organising LIVE Webcasts, which can be viewed by members from
their workstation/home with a click of mouse. During the period, the Committee has organised 16
Live Webcast for the benefit of members at large.
Recorded video on GST Annual Return-The Committee has recorded video on all the Table of GST
Annual Return and hosted 30 videos for the benefit of members at large.
-The Committee has hosted 75 short video on various aspects of GST recorded in the Council
Year 2018-19 on the ICAI common portal
https://learning.icai.org/LX/contents/content_home?current_community_id=idtc -gst-2019-
746-1666&content_player=true.
162 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
leadership and the ability to deliver the best. 25 Awardees were felicitated by the august hands of Shri
Piyush Goyal, Hon‘ble Minister of Railways & Commerce and Industry. Jury panel under the chairmanship
of Shri Kishore Biyani, Founder, Future Group selected the awardees.
To add value to the event, Leadership Summit 2020, a multi-track summit was organized on the same day.
It was designed and formulated in a manner to update the knowledge of the members on Contemporary
and path breaking topics, which were of relevance to their professional domain and interest.
(IV) PROGRAMMES ORGANISED:
Various programmes, including seminars, live webcasts, interactive meets, CFO Meets, etc., were organized
on contemporary topics i.e Formation of New Industrial Policy, FTP, FEMA-Foreign Investment, FDI, ODI:
Policy, Regulations & Way Forward, Risks, Covid-19 Impact on self, Industry, Economy & Stock Market,
ICAI Leadership Summit – Post COVID 19 Scenario, FEMA, The World and India- Post COVID 19,
Navigating the path to Professional Success at Raipur, Gururam, Alleppey, Thiruvananthapuram, Noida,
Ghaziabad, Chandigarh, Bengaluru, Nagpur, Aurangabad and Coimbatore during the year .
(V) OTHER INITATIVES
New CPE Study Circles for Members in Industry -CMI&B has formed Cyber Hub CPE Study Circle of
Indus Towers Limited Ltd for Members in Industry of ICAI.
Launching of Mentorship Portal-CMI&B has launched Mentorship Portal (https://mentorship.icai.org)
on 14th January, 2020 for facilitating the growth and development of the CAs by building bridges
between emerging and established professionals.
Publication-CMI&B has launched Quick Insight on GST- Banking Sector on 14th January, 2020 at 13th
ICAI Award function.
5.18 Peer Review Board (PRB)
The Peer Review Board was established in 2002, recognizing the need to ensure the quality of services
provided by practicing Chartered Accountants.The Peer Review is aimed to ensure that in carrying out the
assurance service assignment, the members of the Institute (a) comply with Technical, Professional and
Ethical Standards as applicable including other regulatory requirements thereto and (b) have in place
proper systems including documentation thereof, to amply demonstrate the quality of the assurance
services. The Peer Review is conducted of a Practice Unit by an independent evaluator known as a Peer
Reviewer.
The requirements of two regulators - SEBI and C&AG, in recognition of the Board‘s endeavor are stated
below:-
SEBI with effect from April 1, 2010, has made it mandatory for the listed entities, that limited
review/statutory audit reports submitted to the concerned stock exchanges shall be given only by
those auditors who have subjected themselves to peer review process and who hold a valid
certificate issued by the ‗Peer Review Board‘ of the Institute.
C&AG has recognized Board‘s work; as it seeks details from the CA firms about their Peer Review
Status in the application form for allotment of audit for Public Sector Undertakings. Furthermore,
from last few years, the C&AG annually seek details from ICAI of those firms which have been
issued certificate by the Board.
ACTIVITIES/ INITIATIVES:
(I) Peer Review of Practice Units:
Continuous efforts are being made to enhance the scope of peer review making it more effective
and also to have more practicing units being peer reviewed. The planned efforts of the Board
coupled with effective performance of the Peer Reviewers inspired the practice units to continually
improve the quality of services that they render to the society at large. Greater emphasis is being
given on proper selection of samples and effective review. The Peer Review Board has considered
and issued 11855 Peer Review Certificates till June 30, 2020.
(II) Training & Empanelment of Peer Reviewers:
To ensure that there is consistency and uniformity in carrying out reviews, the Board imparts
training to the Reviewers before assigning them the practice units for review. Board has organized
211 Peer Review training programmes all over India since inception, out of which 21 Training
programmes have been held during the year. Peer Review Board has empanelled and trained 6073
Peer Reviewers since inception.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 167
Futuristic plans: Going forward, the Board plans to update the Peer reviewers and the trainers
with the revised Peer Review Process. With this objective, the Board will organise the following
online programmes:
Train the Trainer : To train the existing trainers
Train the existing Reviewers - Trainers to train the existing Reviewers
To conduct training for prospective reviewers and also organize empanelment tests for them.
(III) National Conference/Live webinars
Three National Conferences at Ghaziabad, Jabalpur and Noida have been organised, during the
year. Six webinars have been organised during the year on the topics Audit Documentation with
Special Emphasis on Bank Audit, Documentation to be maintained for Statutory Audit,
Documentation for Peer Review Process, Small & Medium Practice Units – How to make best use of
Peer Review and Audit Documentation and Reporting in Peer Review Process.
(IV) Revision of Various Publications of the Board
The following existing publications of Peer Review Board have been revised:
The Statement on Peer Review has been revised by the Board and approved by the Council in its
Meeting held in April 2020. The same has become effective from 1 st July, 2020.
The Peer Review Manual : The publication has been Revised by the Board to incorporate various
Changes made in the Statement on Peer Review. The various formats of Declaration of Practice
Unit, Reviewer, Questionnaire, Annexures etc. have been revised and form Part of Appendix of the
Manual. Recommended checklists pertaining to Accounting Standards, Standards on auditing have
been updated and checklist of Ind AS has been added. The Manual has been made more user
friendly by introducing effective picturesque flowchart to have a better understanding of Step by
step Peer Review Procedure, Onsite and offsite Procedures, Process Flows etc.
Handbook on Advisories: An amalgamation of the existing publications ‗Handbook on Advisories for
Practice Units‘, ‗Handbook on Advisories for Peer Reviewers‘ and ‗FAQs‘ has been made. The recent
changes made by the Board regarding the Peer Review Process, sample size, fees of Peer Review,
Illustrative Time schedule, etc. have been incorporated in the handbook. The Handbook is a guide
for the Peer Reviewers as well as the Practice Units as it contains advisories for them as well as a
plethora of frequently asked questions.
(V) Revision of fees for Peer Review
In exercise of the power vested in the Peer Review Board by the Statement on Peer Review, the
Board at its 64th meeting held on 4th June, 2020 has revised fees for Peer Review including
honorarium and TA/DA for reviewer and his qualified assistant. Prior to revision, the fees for Peer
Review varied from Rs 15000 to Rs 1,00,000 depending upon the Average gross receipts/ Revenue
from assurance service Clients of Practice Unit (Per Annum) for the period under review. The upper
limit has been increased to Rs. 5,00,000 for Practice Units having Average gross receipts/
Revenue from assurance service Clients above Rs. 30 crore p.a. The revised fee structure is
hosted on the website at https://resource.cdn.icai.org/24073revised_cpr_prb.pdf
(VI) Revision of Sample selection Criteria
The Board at its 64th meeting held on 4th June, 2020 has also revised the criteria of minimum
sample selection for the reviewers. The Revised sample selection criteria is hosted on the website
at https://resource.cdn.icai.org/60093prb-sample-review.pdf . Minimum sample to be selected by
the reviewer is based on the Level of Practice Unit as well as average gross receipts/ revenue from
assurance service Clients of Practice Unit (Per Annum) for the period under review.
(VII) Development of online forms for collating Data from Peer Reviewers and Practice
Units for System update
For better transparency and good governance an online form has been developed for collating
current data of existing Practice Units (PUs) and empanelled Peer Reviewers (REs). Mass mails will
be sent to these PUs and REs with a request to fill their particulars in the form. The form is also
intended to capture the expression of interest from the Empanelled Peer Reviewers to ascertain
whether they wish to continue to act as Reviewers and categorisation of Reviewers into LI and LII
category. Likewise, the data of PUs will also be captured to categorise them into LI and LII
firms.The data so collated is intended to be pushed in the new software being developed for the
Peer Review Board to automate the Peer Review process.
168 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
(VIII) Utilizing social media platform for creating awareness about the importance of the
Peer Review
Creatives with short taglines have been developed and designed to create awareness about the
importance of Peer Review Process through social media platform.
(IX) Peer Review software
The peer review process will shortly be steered through a software.
(X) Grant of Extension regarding validity of Peer review Certificate in wake of COVID-19
In the wake of COVID -19 spurt and the extension of nation wise lockdown as well as partial reliefs
granted by various State Governments in phased manner, members were facing hardships in
getting the Peer Review Process completed. Accordingly, the Peer Review Board has hosted an
Announcement dated 30.3.2020 on the website at
https://resource.cdn.icai.org/58882prb47971.pdf and also has granted further extensions by
hosting a new Announcement dated 29.5.2020 regarding ‗Further extensions regarding the validity
of Peer Review Certificate in the wake of COVID -19 spurt across the country‘ on ICAI website at
https://resource.cdn.icai.org/59761prb48614.pdf
5.19 Professional Development Committee (PDC)
The Committee was established in 1962 with the mission to explore and develop opportunities for the use
of the professional talents and skills of Chartered Accountants in different sectors of the world of business.
The Committee in its efforts to explore the unchartered areas for professional opportunities interact with
the Central and State Government, Regulatory Authorities, other agencies etc. requesting them to avail the
expertise of the Chartered Accountants and utilize their services in various areas.
Since 2019, the Committee has been looking into the areas of Co-operatives and NPO sectors to equip
members and other stakeholders to find a new niche for themselves and as well as maintaining and
developing the core competencies in the Co-operatives and NPO sectors.
With a view to enhance skill sets of Chartered Accountants in the existing and new areas, it also organizes
webinars, seminars, workshops on contemporary areas of interest.
(I) Meetings with various Regulators on matters for professional relevance
RBI on ―Cyber Security Framework”: The representatives from ICAI met the team of CSITE Cell of
Department of Banking Supervision, RBI on 18th April 2019 in Mumbai for the
additional certification by Statutory Auditors for the first time on ―Cyber Security Framework‖. On
acceding to ICAI‘s request, RBI advised SCAs on the methodology to be followed by them to
assess the level of compliance by banks in this regard and advised that the Certificate in this
regard may be submitted by SCAs along with the Long Form Audit Report (LFAR).
Meeting held with RBI: The Chairman and Vice Chairman, PDC had a meeting with Shri R
Subramanian, Chief General Manager-in-Charge, DBS, Smt. Divya S Daur, General Manager, Audit
Regulation Section in the month of June, 2019 wherein issues relating to strengthening concurrent
audit of banks, Reduction in Statutory Central Auditors by Public Sector Banks, Policy of Rotation
and Resting in Statutory Bank Branch allotment etc faced by various Auditors while conducting
Bank Audits were discussed with them.
Meeting held with NABARD: The Chairman and Vice Chairman, PDC had a meeting with Shri K
Raghavendra Rao, CGM, Ms. Sarita Arora, CGM and other officials of NABARD on 3 rd June, 2019.
During the meeting, several concerns relating to the profession like gaps in audit, divergence in
Audit and Inspection Report, LFAR and Auditors' Qualification and adherence to Accounting
Standards etc. were discussed. Various matters such as upward revision in audit fee of Regional
Rural Banks (RRBs), separate fee for tax audit, limited number of branches to be allotted to one
auditor and consideration of Sole Proprietorship firm for the allotment of audit etc. were also
discussed on which NABARD has expressed their positive response.
Meeting with officials of Indian Banks‘ Association Chairman and Vice Chairman, PDC had a
meeting with Shri K. Eswar, Sr. Advisor of IBA on 3 rd June, 2019 wherein the stringent criteria as
mentioned in the tender floated by them for empanelment of Forensic Audit and extension of its
date was discussed. The responses so received by IBA till that time was sufficient, hence,
requirement was felt by them to withdraw or extend the said tender.Further, to emphasize upon
the utilization of the Software for Selection and Allotment of Bank Branch Audit so developed by
ICAI by all the banks with joint efforts, IBA has agreed to arrange for the demonstration by ICAI
wherein all the banks would attend.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 169
Representation to State Bank of India-During the year 2019, State Bank of India was taking the declaration
from the Statutory Branch Auditors for not having appointed as statutory central/branch auditors in any
private sector/foreign bank during the current year. ICAI represented to SBI as the Auditor/Audit Firm can
do Branch Statutory Audit of a Public Sector Bank simultaneously with Statutory Audits of 4 Private Sector
Banks and 4 Foreign Banks. SBI acceded to our request.
(VII) Appointment of Statutory Auditor of Jammu and Kashmir Bank
ICAI vigorously pursued with RBI for maintaining the past practice of the appointment of Statutory Auditor
of Jammu and Kashmir Bank Ltd for the year 2018-19 by the office of C & AG. Accordingly, the
appointment of auditors was done by C &AG only.
(VIII) Tender Monitoring Group
The Tendering of Professional Services has always been an area of concern. PDC has taken up the various
issues including the evaluation criteria in Tendering with CVC at various point of time. It has been observed
that sometimes organizations float the tenders without mentioning any Minimum Fees or quote very low
minimum fees. On the other hand, it was necessary to monitor the adherence of the Council Guidelines
and decisions by the Members of ICAI while responding to the tenders related to Minimum Fees and
maintenance of Cost Sheets.
To address such issues related to Tendering, a Group for ―Monitoring the Tendering issues‖ was formed by
PDC during the year to monitor and standardize the tenders floated by the organizations, to monitor the
evaluation of the tenders related to professional services, to develop a mechanism for monitoring and
analyzing the responses of the members and referring the deviations at appropriate levels. During the year,
various representations were sent from time to time to the respective organizations in respect of hardships
/ violation of guidelines, etc.
(IX) Cooperatives & NPOs:
For the year 2020-21, the Groups on Cooperatives & NPOs have been formed in all the 5 regions with
nodal control under PD Committee broadly with the aim to suggest Suitable reforms in the statutes,
Promote uniform accounting framework, to formulate guidelines for state-wise auditors empanelment
creating the opportunities for CAs in the areas of Cooperatives and NPOs.The Committee has also
conducted Certificate Courses on Cooperatives and NPOs to update the members of ICAI on these subjects
and enabling them to take up the related assignments.
(X) Draft revised norms for empanelment of C&AG
C & AG in order to review the present arrangement for empanelment of CA firms and to fine tune the
allotment of PSEs audits to the empanelled CA firms has drafted the revised norms and had sought the
inputs of ICAI which were submitted vide letter dated 10 th October, 2019. The Institute represented on the
revised norms so finalized and hosted by the o/o C & AG for the empanelment of CA Firms in the month of
January, 2020.
(XI) State Level Coordination Committee (SLCC)
The Reserve Bank of India holds quarterly meetings of State Level Coordination Committee to regulate
Non-Banking Financial Companies (NBFCs) and deposit accepted activities of incorporated bodies (UIBs) at
each of their regional offices. Such meetings are convened by Regional Director of respective regional
office of RBI and attended by Principal Secretary/Secretaries of various departments such as Finance,
Home, Law etc. of respective states, National Housing Board (NHB), Securities Exchange Board of India
(SEBI), Registrar of Companies (RoC), Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDA),
Registrar of Chit Fund, Department of Chit Fund and The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
(ICAI). More than 20 meetings were held during the year and were attended by the representatives of
ICAI.
(XII) Women Entrepreneurship Platform- Niti Aayog
Under the MoU with Niti Aayog, ICAI is a knowledge partner and has to provide a channel for resolving the
queries of the general public/entrepreneurs at their WEP Portal specifically in the areas of Taxation, Audit,
Accounting, Statutory Compliance, Regulatory Assessment of Business and Business Validation Processes.
The online WEP platform is under final stages of development and ICAI will be providing the names of
approx. 10 members for answering to the online queries on their platform.
(XIII) MOUs with IIMs:
ICAI has entered into the MoU with IIM Jammu in the month of Feb., 2020 for conducting various
Management and Finance programmes for CAs. Further, the MoU with IIM-Ahmedabad was also for
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 171
conducting residential training programme for Chartered Accountants. Under the MoU with IIM-A, various
residential courses have been conducted during the year 2019-20.
Interactive Meet-Upskilling & Up-scaling of the CA Firms
In order to provide a platform for the said brainstorming sessions on the vital issues for CAs in practice in
today‘s context and for sustenance in the future, the Professional Development Committee organized an
―Interactive Meet-Upskilling & Upscaling of the CA Firms‖ on 9th November 2019 in New Delhi wherein
detailed discussions were held on areas of professional development. Further the said meet was also
organized in Chennai on 25th November, 2019.
(XIV) Joint Awareness Programme under SLCC, RBI with Economic Offences Wing (EOW)
The Professional Development Committee jointly with Economic Offences Wing, New Delhi organized Joint
Awareness Programme on 4th December, 2019 in New Delhi with State Level Coordination Committee
wherein Smt. Padmini Singla, IAS, Secretary Finance, Shri O.P. Mishra, IPS, Addl. CP, EOW, Smt. Sumeet
Kapoor, CGM, PFRDA, Shri Ajay Kumar, Regional Director, RBI have also addressed.
(XV) PD Portal
The PD Portal (www.pdicai.org) so developed by PDC, provides the members of ICAI with the information
that they need to enrich their own practice and provide value added services to their clients. Further, it lists
down all the tenders available to Practising CAs for the creation of Professional Opportunities. The Portal
provides a separate section for Committee‘s activities. All related information as to MEF Application,
Webinars & Upcoming events, communications made with different regulatory authorities are placed on the
portal.
5.20 Committee on Public and Government Financial Managament (CP&GFM)
The Committee on Public & Government Financial Management (CP&GFM) strives to assist Central & State
Governments and Local Bodies in successful implementation of the accounting reforms and public finance
management. The Committee primarily focuses on capacity building of the finance officials of various tiers
of Government in India by various means such as organising workshops, developing relevant e-training
modules, etc., apart from formulating Accounting Standards for Local Bodies (ASLBs). This is an initiative of
ICAI to meet its social obligations by providing professional services of CAs beyond corporate sector and to
the public at large, by being true to its role of being a partner in nation building.
Important Activities undertaken
(I) Publications issued by the Committee:
Compendium of Accounting Standards for Local Bodies - Volume II
Status Paper on Accrual Accounting Reforms in Local Bodies in India: Overview (Revised)
(II) Issuance of Accounting Standards for Local Bodies (ASLBs):
The Conceptual Framework for General Purpose Financial Reporting by Local Bodies and 12 accrual
basis ASLBs approved by the Council of ICAI were issued during the Council Year 2019-20 and
released as Compendium of ASLBs : Volume II.
(III) Comments/suggestions submitted on the following:
Exposure Draft 67 on ‗Collective and Individual Services and Emergency Relief (Amendments to
IPSAS 19) to International Public Sector Accounting Standards Board.
Agenda of meeting of Public Sector Financial Management Committee (PSFMC) of CAPA held on
April 27, 2020, apart from existing PSFM publication.
GASAB documents/draft Standards:
Agenda of 35th Board meeting of GASAB held on 3rd February, 2020.
Due Process of GASAB
IGAS 2, ‗Grants-in-Aid‘
IGAS 3, ‗Loans & Advances‘
Disclosure Statement on ‗Recipients of External Assistance‘
Draft on ‗Correction of Prior Period Adjustment‘
Disclosure Statement on Contingent Liabilities
172 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
Video Bytes of President & Vice-President, ICAI- The messages of President & Vice-President
were shot on the occasion of CA Day & packaged in a video clip. The clip was then shared
with all RCs & Branches to play during the CA Day celebrations.
(II) Webinars
Two webinars were organized on Mind Matters addressed by Sri Sri Ravi Shankar, Spiritual Leader and
Building Positivity amidst COVID -19 crisis addressed by Sister BK Shivani, Spiritual and Motivational
Speaker, Brahma Kumaris World Spiritual University which were also promoted through all ICAI social
media platforms and mass mail / sms were forwarded to all India Members/ Students to attend the live
session. The program was appreciated and attended by many members and students.
(III) Press Conference
The newly elected President & Vice-President, ICAI addressed a Press meet on February 13, 2020 at New
Delhi. The Editors / correspondents of major financial dailies, News wire agencies, Online media & Tv
channels were invited and attended the Press meet. The President shared the latest updates on
Disciplinary Mechanism, Accounting Standards and the ICAI Agenda for the coming months with the
media. The President also interacted with the correspondents and answered their queries. The news was
widely covered by the media.
(IV) ICAI Mailer
To keep the members informed of the latest initiatives of ICAI, an HTML mailer on ICAI MoU with IIM
(Jammu) was forwarded to the Central Council Members, all India Members & MPs( Lok Sabha). It was
decided that the important information would be sent to the members and stakeholders on regular basis
through mailers. For the purpose, PR Committee and Digital Re-Engineering & Learning Directorate worked
towards getting the creatives developed.
(V) Brand building through publishing advertisement. / advertorial/ article in Magazines
Towards brand building of ICAI & CA profession, it has been decided that ICAI initiatives and achievements
shall be covered by way of advt. / advertorial / articles / write ups. For Till date, the following
advertisements and advertorial were published:
In - flight Magazines –Spice Route & Go Getter
An advertisement promoting ICAI was published in India Today along with an advertorial about
establishment of ―Centre for Audit Quality‖ by ICAI
An advertorial on ICAI ( double spread ) in the Coffee Table Book (CTB) - ―India Tomorrow" brought
out by India Today for the Annual Conclave attended by the eminent dignitaries
A short article on recent initiatives of ICAI was published in the Spice Route magazine.
An advertisement was published by ICAI saluting these frontline warriors in a leading Publication to
acknowledge the untiring efforts of nurses during this current COVID 19 pandemic,.
An advertisement was designed & published in major publications in order to update the members/
students/ public at large and showing ICAI commitment to Govt. initiative for supporting Janta
Curfew announced on March 22nd,2020.
Two Digital banners were hosted on .com/ mobile app/wap platforms of shortlisted publications for a
duration of 15 days for publicizing the provisional registration in Foundation Course
(VI) Other Initiatives
All major initiatives taken by the Institute were promoted through Social media in addition to
print/electronic & online media.
The Media was constantly apprised about the latest developments regarding the curriculum,
profession, visit of foreign delegations, other activities and events, etc. through the issue of Press
Releases.
The potential & scope of Chartered Accountancy Profession in today‘s dynamic context was
promoted by way of articles as well as through interactive meetings/releases issued to the press at
the national/regional level and through various TV Channels.
Provided logistic support to various departments within ICAI, to the Regional Offices and Branches
with a view to developing a communication link between ICAI and its offices/related organizations.
As part of the PR exercise, organized appropriate coverage in Print and Electronic Media for
different Seminars/ Programmes/ Events of ICAI.
176 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
(III) Schemes
ICAI Doctoral Scholarship Scheme 2020- This scheme is open to all the members of the Institute
who are pursuing PhD to provide scholarship to the eligible candidates with outstanding academics
record with an inclination and commitment to undertake academic in the areas of research such as
Auditing, Taxation, Commerce, Management and Accounting Discipline. The scholarship of Rs.
50,000 per month for 3 years will be given for 5 scholars every year.
ICAI Research Projects Scheme 2020- This scheme encourages our experienced members and
researcher scholar or faculty of reputed academic institutes to take up research projects which will
be benefiting our whole society at large. Maximum amount of Rs. 10 lacs as reimbursement
expense will be given.
(IV) Conference/Webinars/Virtual Meetings
The Committee organised Confernece/Webinars/Virtual meetings on Excellence in Financial Reporting,
Techniques in Research Methodology, Research on the sickness and remedies for the MSME Industries,
Role of CAs in Healthcare Industry, Professional Ethics – Scope for Research, Crypto-Currencies: An option
for Investment, Research led Professional Opportunities in Capital Market, Pragmatic Way to Research
Proposal writing during the year.
(V) Publications released during the year
Glossary of Terms used in Financial Statements
Handbook on Accounting Treatment under Goods & Service Tax (GST)
Technical Guide on Accounting for Motion Picture Films
5.23 Committee on Capital Markets and Investors' Protection (CCM&IP)
The Committee on Capital Market and Investors Protection provides suggestions on various Bills,
Regulations, Notifications, circulars and other documents relating to capital market for submission to the
Government/Regulator. Besides this the Committee regularly interacts with Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
and Indian Banks Association for example, relating to Depositors, Non-performing Assets Management,
Bank operation and supervision, issues relating to securitisation, Non-Banking Finance companies – NBFCs
(Department of Non-Banking Finance companies of RBI), Regulatory authority of Co-operative Banks,
Strategies / recommendations relating to their investment patterns, Securities and Exchange Board of India
e.g., matters relating to Primary and Secondary Markets, Take-Overs, Amalgamation, Mergers, (tax-
havens, Participatory Note, hot-money, corporate governance regulatory compliances etc.), Mutual Funds,
Foreign Institutional Investors, Intermediaries, Securities Laws etc, Forward Markets Commission (FMC)
including NCDX and MCX, Stock Exchanges on the issues relating to Capital Markets and Investors
Protection.
The Committee held the following activities during the year:
With the aim to emerge as the preferred partner in the Nation Building and to spread awareness
among public at large about the do‘s and do not‘s of investing their money in financial securities
and to promote financial literacy, the Committee organizes Investor Awareness Programmes under
the under the aegis of Investor Education and Protection Fund (IEPF) of the Ministry of Corporate
Affairs. through various Resource Persons and Programme Organizing Units (Regional Councils,
Branches, Study Circles, Study Chapters and Study Groups) through its various POU's.
The Committee had organized 623 IAP‘s in the year 2019-20 across India wherein total 32,300
people including 10,766 women participants were educated.
Till date, more than 6223 Investor Awareness Programmes on PAN India basis have been
conducted through ICAI educating more than 3,36,150 people of India including 1,12,050 women
participants.
The Committee had organised State Level Conferences on Investor Education and Awareness at
Bhubaneshwar and Dharamshala under the aegis of Investor Education Protection Fund Authority
(IEPFA).
29 Investor Awareness Programmes were conducted by the Regional Councils and Branches of
ICAI.
The Committee is entrusted with the task of conducting Certificate Course on Forex and Treasury
Management.
178 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
The Committee has successfully conducted 55 Batches offline of the Certificate Course on Forex
and Treasury Management course. During the period, committee has successfully completed 2
batches of the Certificate Course on Forex and Treasury Management, wherein total 46 Members
of ICAI has enrolled in the said Certificate Course.
The Committee declared the result of an evaluation test held on 23 rd and 24th November 2019 of
past batches of Forex and Treasury Management Certificate Course on 11 th February, 2020.
The Committee organised a Training programme on International Finance for ONGC executives, as
per the MOU from 16th to 18th December, 2019 for the CA. executives of Oil and Natural Gas
Corporation Ltd at BKC Mumbai.
The Committee organized Seminars, Workshop/National Conference/Webcast for the professional
enhancement of members on RRC on Capital Market, New Paradigms of Competitiveness-
Positioning CA‘s for tomorrow‘s Challenges at Chail, HP and Ludhiana durimg the year.
5.24 Audit Committee
The Constitution of Audit Committee of the Institute is governed by the Council. Audit Committee reviews
the reporting process and disclosure of financial information of the Institute to ensure that the financial
statements are true and fair. It appoints auditors for the various units of the Institute, reviews the audit
reports, takes follow up and recommends appropriate actions on the reports submitted by the Auditors of
various units of the Institute. It ensures the independence and integrity while appointing auditors at
various units of the Institute. The Audit Committee operates through five Regional Audit Committees
located at each of its Regional Councils.
5.25 Digital Re-Engineering and Learning Directorate (DR&LD)
Significant Achievements/Initatives
ICAI Digital Learning Hub- ICAI has enriched Digital Learning Hub with E-book and video lectures
on various topics. Continuous learning of Chartered Accountants is ensured through DLH along
with provision of CPE Hours. There is no fee associated to access the DLH as of now. New course
hubs and courses have been launched on Digital Learning Hub and many more are in the pipeline.
ICAI Digital Learning Hub Link is- https://learning.icai.org/iDH/icai/home
Launch of New and Improved Website ICAI.org-The website ICAI.org has been revamped to bring
a new look and feel and make it in sync with the changing times and technology to further
enhance the experience of all stakeholders. New Website will bring Easy to search content,
compatibility with cross Browsers, Cross Devices, and faster content access.
Trademark Registration has been done for ICAI Digital Learning Hub and ICAI Mobile App.
ICAI has started for the first time ever the Certificate courses in online mode (virtual live classes)
which is assisting the members in anywhere learning.
Webinars on contemporary and emerging topics and Meetings are being held through new VC
Technologies.
Cost Saving Initiatives for ICAI i.e working on configuring VIP (Citrix) on the Internet, to remove
VPN connectivity in Branches/Regional offices etc, being done.
ICAI Mobile App ICAI Now and ICAI Social Media Platforms have been instrumental in
Popularization of various ICAI‘s events, Key ICAI Achievements and Initiatives on no cost basis
amongst students, members and other stakeholders of ICAI.
ICAI Internal Note Portal – Portal has been launched for making the Internal note approval process
paperless and to effectively streamline the Internal note approval process
COVID 19 - Resource Page- Compilation of Important Announcements has been hosted on
Website, Mobile App and Social Media for CA Members, Students & ICAI Employees in the wake of
Coronavirus COVID-19 which is updated regularly.
Webinar was organized on ‗Future of Profession Post Covid19 – Virtual Accounting Firms‘ which
delved on a range of topics i.e Technology Enabled Virtual Firm – Tools, Technology and
Infrastructure, Managing Works and Teams Remotely – Roles, Responsibilities and Reporting,
Adopting Cloud Computing Strategy for Data Management, Cybersecurity – Mitigating Risks of
Virtual Environment and Support Clients from Anywhere, Anytime.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 179
Concept paper on the findings of the Peer Review of Valuation Reports-The Valuation Standards
Board along with ICAI Registered valuers Organisation has prepared a Concept paper on the
findings of the Peer Review of Valuation Reports.The concept paper has been prepared with a view
to help the Registered valuers to understand the process as well as to know about the findings of
the Peer Review of the Valuation Reports and key takeaways.The Concept Paper is available on the
website at the following link:https://icairvo.s3.amazonaws.com/media/documents/
Findings_of_Peer_review_workshop_14022020.pdf
Outreach programme of ICAI Valuation Standards with SAFA countries-In order to create
awareness regarding the ICAI Valuation Standards and also promote for adoption of ICAI Valuation
Standards for transparency and uniformity across SAFA Countries, the Board had proposed for
active engagement with SAFA countries for adoption of ICAI Valuation Standards. The SAFA Board
at its 58th meeting on consideration of the ICAI proposal to organize outreach programmes on
valuation Standards issued by ICAI in SAFA countries, had in principle agreed to the same.The
Board has planned for support in implementation of ICAI Valuation Standards in SAFA Countries by
undertaking the followings:
By preparing the Educational Material, Guidance Notes on practical aspects,Frequently
Asked Questions, Interpretations, publications etc.
By organising programmes on the valuation standards to create awareness on various
requirements of Valuation Standards.
Will provide the format of valuation report so that the Reporting is uniform and
comparable.
(V) Publications
Valuation: Professionals‘ Insight- Series-4
Valuation: Professionals' Insight Series 3 in July 2019
Publications that have been made live on Digital Learning Hub are as follows:-
ICAI Valuation Standards 2018
Frequently Asked Questions on Valuation
Technical Guide on Valuation (Revised 2018 edition)
Valuation: Professionals‘ Insight- Series 1
Valuation: Professionals‘ Insight- Series 2
(VI) Webcast/Programme
Live Webcast: NBFCs and Valuation under COVID- 19 conditions and Impact on Valuation -The
Valuation Standards Board of ICAI had organized a Live Webcast on ―NBFCs and Valuation under
COVID- 19 conditions‖ on 5th June, 2020.The webcast was addressed by President, ICAI along
with Vice President ICAI, Chairman, and Vice Chairman, VSB and eminent panelists.The webcast
was attended by more than 15000 members and hosted at the following link:
http://ecpl.live/icai/vsb/05062020/
Live Webcast to discuss the Draft Valuers Bill, 2020 - Ministry of Corporate Affairs had set up an
eight-member Committee of Experts to examine the need for institutional framework for regulation
and development of valuation professionals and the Committee has prepared and submitted the
Draft Valuers Bill, 2020. The Government-appointed committee of experts has proposed an
institutional framework for valuers by way of setting up the National Institute of Valuers.In order to
discuss further the various aspects of the Draft Valuers Bill, 2020, the Valuation Standards Board
had organized two webcasts in the month of April and May, 2020, wherein the provisions were
explained by officers of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI).The webcast was
addressed by Chairman and Vice Chairman VSB and Shri Sudhaker Shukla, Whole Time Member,
IBBI along with other officials of IBBI.The webcast were well received by the stakeholders and was
attended by more than 10000 participants and is available at the
link:http://ecpl.live/icai/rvo/27052020/and http://ecpl.live/icai/rvo/28042020/
Webcast on ―Valuation Standards & Code of Ethics for Registered Valuer ‖.-Valuation Standards
Board jointly with ICAI RVO conducted a webcast on ―Valuation Standards & Code of Ethics for
Registered Valuer‖ on 19th April, 2019. The purpose of the webcast was to provide knowledge to
the large number of audiences regarding valuation standards to be followed and the code of ethics
to be complied while taking up a specific valuation assignment.The webcast was addressed by Dr.
Navrang Saini, Whole time member, Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI).The webcast
182 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
was viewed by more than 4000 members and is available at the link:
http://ecpl.live/icai/19042020/
Answers to the Questions raised during the Live Webcast on ―Valuation and Valuation Standards
Compliance and other aspects under various Laws‖ -Based on the Questions raised during the Live
Webcast on ―Valuation and Valuation Standards Compliance and other aspects under various Laws‖
held on 19th April, 2020, the office had prepared answers for the questions.The same have been
hosted on ICAI website and are available at the link:
https://resource.cdn.icai.org/59538vsb48459.pdf
Awareness Programme on ICAI Valuation Standards 2018 to be conducted by Regional Council and
Branches- The Valuation Standards Board had conducted half a day awareness programmes on
ICAI Valuation Standards 2018 jointly with the Regional Councils and Branches so that our
members are fully equipped with the Valuation Standards and conduct valuations in accordance
with ICAI Valuation Standards, 2018.
5.29 Taxation Audits Quality Review Board (TAQRB)
Continuing with its commitment to serve the nation and in order to improve the reporting of compliances
under various taxation laws (both Direct as well as Indirect), the Taxation Audits Quality Review Board has
been constituted by the Council Year in the year 2018-19. It is envisaged that the reviews carried out by
the Board, will ensure that the members will exercise greater diligence while certifying the various reports
prescribed under direct and indirect taxation and in the long-run would improve the overall reporting and
certification done by them.
ACTIVITIES/ INITIATIVES:
(I) Status of Review of Tax Audit Reports selected during the Council Year 2018-19:
The Board had selected 100 companies during the Council Year 2018-19 for review of their tax audit
reports pertaining to Assessment Year 2017-18 on suo motto basis. In this regard, 95 tax audit reports
have been received from the tax auditors. Preliminary Review of these reports has been completed by
the Technical Reviewers empanelled with the Board. Out of these, 91 preliminary review reports have
been assigned to Taxation Audits Quality Review Groups constituted under the convenorship of various
Board members for undertaking secondary review of the reports. Reports of these Groups are being
considered by the Board wherein the Board has decided:
To issue advisory letter to the auditor in respect of certain aspects.
To flag common errors being committed by the members for the purpose of spreading
awareness to improve the quality of tax audits.
(II) Selection of reports during the year 2020-21
The Board had decided to select 104 reports (100 for Tax audit + 4 GST) for the FY 2018-19 (AY 2019-20)
during the year 2020-21. The Board has selected less number of audit reports for GST since GST law is in
its nascent stage. The Board decided to select more report once the law establishes.
(III) Request to CBDT and CBIC for nomination on TAQRB
Considering the fact that the intent of formation of TAQRB is to improve the reporting of compliances
under the taxation laws, the Chairman, CBDT and Chairman, CBIC have been requested to nominate a
special invitee from CBDT and CBIC respectively for participating in the meetings of the Taxation Audit
Quality Review Board of ICAI for the period ending 11th February, 2021. It is envisaged that active
participation of the nominees of Central Board of Direct Taxes and Central Board of Indirect Taxes and
Customs in this exercise would add qualitative value to the activities being undertaken.
(IV) Common Errors in Tax Audit
While considering the reports the Board has come across certain observations which would require
attention of members. The Board has decided that in due course these observations/ issues can be
compiled by the Board and be published as ―Common errors in Tax audit‖ and also various programmes
will be held to spread awareness about the errors being conducted.
5.30 Committee on Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (CI&BC)
The Committee on Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code of ICAI has been constituted to give specific focus on
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Laws. It is an emerging area and it has created a new professional opportunity
for the members. The Committee aims to bring in awareness about this new area of practice in the
Insolvency Resolution sphere to the members at large and facilitates in educating the members on the
practical aspects and procedures of the Law.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 183
contribute professionally as per their ease and pace and also become financially independent. A
mass email was sent to all the women members across the country, enlisting various professional
opportunities available at various department/Committees of ICAI e.g. Development of case
studies for BOS, Resource person for Investor awareness programs, in Examination department
etc.
(III) WMED organized a live webcast on the theme ―CA‘s in Excellence: Women perspective‖ on to
discuss Professional Opportunities for Today's Women Accountants: In & Beyond Borders and
Leadership during times of Complexity and Uncertainty. The live webcast had eminent speakers i.e.
CA R M Vishakha ,Ms Parveen Mahmud from Bangladesh and CA Dr. Reeta Shah, so as to motivate
and inspire women members.
(IV) Portal for women members (https://womenportal.icai.org/ ) - Women Portal provides women
members a medium through which they can post their requirements and can explore flexi working
options available for them based on region/branch. It also aims to provide a common platform to
women members to update their knowledge and share their views and concerns.
Success stories of women members: To inspire women members to set and achieve
higher goals, Directorate has invited success stories from women members and
uploaded on Women portal.
Women at ICAI Platform: To recognize the presence of women members, Directorate
has uploaded updated details of women members associated with ICAI.
(V) To commemorate International Women‘s Day i.e. 8th March 2020, the Women Members
Empowerment Directorate undertook following activities;
Video bytes of President ICAI and Vice President ICAI were recorded and sent to all the branches
across India to be telecasted during the women members programme for motivating and inspiring
women members across the country. The said video recordings were also uploaded on the social
media platform of ICAI for the benefit of all the stakeholders at large.
A draft press brief to be released in local newspapers on 8th March was forwarded to all the
branches across the country, to widely publicize and promote the various initiatives of ICAI
conducted under the aegis of Women Members Empowerment Directorate.
Various social media creative‘s were created and uploaded on social media platforms of Women
Members Empowerment Directorate to publicize and promote ICAI‘s initiatives towards women
members empowerment.
WMED initiatives brochure with the theme ―Empowering Initiatives to augment Women‘s
Contribution to the Accountancy profession for inclusive Growth‖ was conceptualised and
published. Along with ICAI initiatives for women members, the brochure also contains details about
women empowering schemes of Govt. of India.
(VI) Women Centric Programmes: In response to the WMED mass email were sent to branches to
promote and conduct events for the benefit of women members at large. Some of the programmes
were organised by branches under the aegis of WMED on Professional Opportunities for Women
Chartered Accountants, Women‘s Seminar Prerana 2020, Women Centric Programme, Work Life
Balance for CA Women, Women CPE Seminar, Women Empowerment Programme and
International Women‘s Day,
6. COMMITTEE FOR EXPORT OF CA SERVICES & WTO (CECAS & WTO)
The Government of India identified accountancy sector as one of the Champion Sector which can catapult
trade in services to newer attar. With the increase in the global trade in services, it has been a natural
corollary that it has propelled the opportunities for Chartered Accountant professionals involved in various
facets, through professional practice or employment. Manifested by presence of a great number of
members of Institute in different countries, the efforts of the Committee, since its inception in the Council
year 2018-19 in this direction would not only bring goodwill and develop brand image, but also supplement
Government of India‘s Initiative on increasing share of Trade in Accountancy & related services being
identified as Champion Sector as also bring panorama of opportunities for the Indian CAs in the WTO
regime.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 185
German Language Learning Courses through Goethe Institut Max Mueller Bhavan (official German
culture Institute and promotes learning of German language in India) - 3 batches with 25
candidates.
French Language Learning Course through Alliance Française De Delhi - 3 batches with 22 candidates.
Japanese Language Learning Course through the Japan Foundation-1 batch with 17 candidates.
Survey for seeking preference for foreign language course from ICAI Members and
Students
The Committee has launched the survey for assessing the demand for foreign language. Till date, the
Committee has received 12655 responses as per details given below:
no more registrations for the above mentioned courses. The last examination in respect of the
above mentioned Certificate course was held in May- June, 2019 and result was declared in the
month of October, 2019.
The Committee has recently launched PQC- Diploma on Management & Business Finance Course
(DMBF) in the year 2019 to impart the nuances of finance amongst the members of the Institute.
1st batch of DMBF was commenced at various location i.e Delhi, Mumbai. Hyderabad & Bengaluru
with 62 participants.
(II) INITIATIVES FOR MEMBERS
The Committee revamped the Course Structure of PQC-Diploma on Management & Business Finance
course (DMBF) .The Committee bring outs/develops the study material (i.e total 33 Modules
distributed under six subjects i.e Strategic Management, Capital Structuring and Investment
Management, Capital and Financial Markets, Forex and Treasury, Banking and Risk Management.
The Committee has collaborated with Jamnalal Bajaj Institute of Management Studies (JBIMS),
Mumbai to conduct the one-week Residential training program (mandatory part of Course
Curriculum) which will give practical insights to the members on management concepts ,
leadership skills and decision making for carrying out their management functions more efficiently
and effectively. However, due to spurt of COVID- 19, The Residential Program for the DMBF 1st
batch participants were organised through online modein the month of July, 2020 by way of three
weekends sessions i.e 6 days in association with JBIMS.
Committee has collaborated with Manipal Global Education Service, Bengaluru (covering 11 Modules)
for development of e- Learning platform (80 hours e- learning training is mandatory) for the
current batch participants and was launched on 28th June, 2020.
(III) Webinars/ VCM
The Committee organised Webinar/Virtual CPE Meeting on NPA Identification and Management, Queries
Discussion: NPA Identification and Management, Cost Management Strategies for Economy Revival, Role of
CAs in Strategic Management of Organisation.
7.2 ICAI establishes Centre for Audit Quality to boost Indian firms' global standing
Over the years, ICAI has been tirelessly working towards providing quality education & internationally
benchmarked training for students; continuous professional development of members in niche & emerging
areas; Improving Quality of Financial Reporting and Assurance functions through strong framework of
standard-setting and enforcement.
The purpose of independent audit is to provide confidence to the users of audited financial statements in
the quality of financial reports, in particular their reliability. Improving audit quality and the consistency of
audit execution is essential to maintain confidence in the independent assurance, provided by the auditors.
As part of ICAI's drive to continue to benchmark the accountancy profession against the best available
global practices, we have already converged to global standards on disclosure and assurance while keeping
Indian interests in high stead. The future of the profession lies in its ability to change, evolve and adapt to
the changing environment, which is a central element of the reforms and of the ICAI's mission is its
standard-setting role. ICAI, recognizing the fact that high level ―quality framework‖ provide the foundation
for development of a proficient, high quality accountancy profession, has moved to set up a ―Centre for
Audit Quality‖ at Jaipur Centre of Excellence.
The Centre for Audit Quality will aim at the continuous investment in the contemporary education and
training for prospective accountants and/or auditors, developing guidance and training programmes to
assist audit teams and offices to undertake effective root cause analysis, conducting group learning
sessions to discuss identified causes of findings and the solutions to be implemented, establishing Audit
quality indicators, thus will work for Audit Quality Maturity Model. The Audit Quality Maturity model will
initiate a process of laying out a voluntary self-evaluation matrix for accounting firms to gauge their
relative maturity level as regards audit quality pertaining to Audit and Accounting related functions being
rendered by them. The CAQ would enable the Institute to have discussion on the qualitative aspects of the
audit function and to provide a conducive environment for doing research projects in the field.
CA. Atul Kumar Gupta, President, ICAI said ―India is on the cusp of a huge data revolution. It has become
essential to advocate the position of the auditors to the various stakeholders to fill in the expectation gaps.
In such changing times, a Centre for Audit Quality can play an important role that would further build
Investor‘s confidence and develop Public trust at large‖.
The Centre of Quality will aim for:-
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 189
The Residential Meet was inaugurated at the august hands of CA. Suresh P. Prabhu, Hon‘ble Member of
Parliament and Prime Minister‘s Sherpa to G7 and G20. He appreciated the new efforts and initiatives taken
by ICAI in keeping pace with the digital revolution and making the profession ready for future. During his
address he advised ICAI to take steps to strengthen the administrative set up of ICAI so that the same can
meet the expectations of the stakeholders at large. Hon‘ble Suresh Prabhu ji also addressed the Members
on 2nd February on the implications of Climate change and steps that can be taken for preventing future
erosion. The residential Meet was also graced by the presence of CA. Thomas Chazhikadan, Hon‘ble
Member of Parliament on 2nd February who addressed the members in public service on issues of relevance
to the profession. He also dwelled upon some of the aspects of the Union budget.
The Residential meet was also addressed by Guests of Honour Hon‘ble Mr. Justice (CA.) Bhargav D. Karia,
Judge, Gujarat High Court on day 1 and Hon‘ble Mr. Justice (CA.) Dr. Vineet Kothari, Senior most Judge of
Madras High Court and Hon‘ble Mr. Justice (CA.) Dinesh Mehta, Judge, Rajasthan High Court on day 2. The
residential meet dwelled upon technical sessions on How to Enhance Public Trust and Confidence by CA.
190 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
Arun Kumar Gujarathi, Hon‘ble Ex. Speaker of Maharashtra Legislative Council, Climate Change Financing
by CA Praveen Garg IAS, Additional Secretary & Financial Advisor, Ministry of Environment, Forests and
Climate Change, Positive strengths of CA profession amongst the Government, Regulators, Media,
Members, Students and other Stakeholders by CA. Deepak Kumar Kedia, IPS and Role of ICAI as
Professional Accountancy Body for a Future Ready Profession by CA. Mahaveer Singhvi, IFS, Joint
Secretary (Counter Terrorism) MEA, Government of India. A session on Managing Oneself was addressed
by Dr. CV Ananda Bose IAS(Retd.) Principal Advisor, Heritage Project, Government of India and Chairman,
UN Consultative Body. Habitat Alliance.
An Open House Discussion was also organised wherein the Members in Public Service shared their views
on positioning of Accountancy Profession in Nation Building. There were several suggestions from Members
on improving the audit quality, enhancing the scope of article ship, guidelines on minimum fees regime,
participation of ICAI in environmental cause improving he communication skills of the students, providing
them guidance to opt for the civil services .
(III) Webcasts
The Committee organised Webcasts on Chartered Accountants- ―How to Enter Civil Service for Nation
Building‖ and ―Oxygen Debit…..Carbon Credit, Environment is our Business‖ on the occasion of World
Environment Day.
7.4 Legal Directorate
The following important activities were undertaken by the Legal Directorate:
The Legal Co-ordination Group discussed and submitted to the Council the draft Amendments to the
Disciplinary Mechanism under the CA Act, 1949. The Council in its Meeting held in August, 2019 approved
this Draft Amendment for submission to the Government. Accordingly, draft Amendments pertaining to
disciplinary mechanism in the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 were forwarded to the Ministry of
Corporate Affairs on 27.08.2019.
Total number of cases disposed of by the various High Courts under Section 21(6) of the Chartered
Accountants Act, 1949 during the period from 1.4.2019 to 31.3.2020 is 1.
Total number of pending cases in various Courts as on 30.06.2020
1. List I- Reference Cases filed under Section 21 (5) Of the Chartered 178
Accountants Act, 1949 pending before different High Courts
- 168
List I - Special Leave Petition (SLP)/Appeal filed against the Judgment
of the High Court in Reference Cases pending in the Supreme Court -
10
2. Writ Petitions filed arising out of disciplinary action under Section 21 of 148
the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949
Rendering effective legal assistance in the form of legal opinions, studies and reports, as required
from time to time by the Council /Executive Committee / various Non-Standing Committees and
departments of the Institute.
Providing appropriate legal advice on diverse range of substantive and procedural questions of law
arising in administrative functioning of the Institute to firmly secure the interest of ICAI, as required
by the operational departments.
Supervising and overseeing the review, negotiations, drafting and vetting of contracts, tender
documents and other legal documents, as required by the operational departments and various
committees of ICAI.
Serving on various Standing and Non-standing Committees, Study groups and task force, as required,
to take care of legal niceties in framing of policies.
Advising in the matters of taking recourse to legal remedies whenever necessary and assisting the
operational departments and committees in preparing reply to legal notices received.
7.5 Infrastructure Development Committee (IDC)
In the year 2014, Infrastructure Development Committee was formed as a non-standing Committee
of the Institute. This Committee formulated Infrastructure policy for Branches and Regional
Councils/offices. Since 2014, the ICAI has a robust infrastructure policy in place, which ensures
financial prudence and discipline. The policy defines what all facilities can be provided, composition of
local Infrastructure Committees, policy and procedure for acquisition of land/ building, indicative area,
permissible grant from Head Office, powers and delegation vested with various authorities within the
Institute. Since the policy itself defines the financial powers, all infrastructure projects from the year
2014 onwards are being approved by IDC, instead of the Finance Committee. Since formulation of
Infrastructure policy, the ICAI has initiated following projects:
Purchase of new Construction proposals approved Gifted
Infrastructure Property
Kannur, Jalandhar, Jabalpur, Ajmer, Surat, Hubli, Bhopal, Bengaluru
Goa, Gurugram, Moradabad, Rajamahendravaram, Centre of Excellence Gifted Property
Pali, Agra, Gorakhpur, Karnal, Jaipur, Bathinda, Bareilly, Jodhpur, Raipur,
Kishangarh, Latur, Patiala, Kannur, Ghaziabad, Goa, Moradabad,
Ujjan, Ratlam and Ahmedabad Guntur, Agra, Gurugram and Rohini
Out of total 164 Branches set up by the ICAI so far, 99 branches are having their own premises
which include 14 Branches (presently functioning from Rented Premises) who have procured land on
which construction is either commenced or construction is under-way. 16 Branches (functioning from
own premises) have procured land where either construction has started or construction is under-
way. 51 Branches do not own either land or building. The Region-wise break-up as on 21st July, 2020
is as under:
Remarks
S. No. Particulars WIRC SIRC EIRC CIRC NIRC Total
1 Total Nos. of Branches 35 45 13 47 24 164
2 Nos. of Branches having own premises 21 33 6 29 10 99
3 Nos. of Branches having land on which 1 1 0 7 5 14
construction is started or yet to be
started (functioning from rented
premises)
4 Nos. of Branches having land on which 5 2 1 7 1 16
construction is started or yet to be
started besides the own premises
(functioning from
own premises)
5 Total nos. of Branches having neither 13 11 7 11 9 51
land nor building
192 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
ICAI to host the World Congress of Accountants on November 18-21, 2022 in Mumbai, India
WCOA is held every four years under the auspices of the International Federation of Accountants (IFAC),
the worldwide organization for the accountancy profession and is one of the most prestigious global events
of Professional accountants where about 6000 delegates gather and exchange views on accounting & allied
areas. ICAI, being a member of IFAC, had bid to host the WCOA 2022 and after rigorous assessment won
the bid to host the WCOA in November 18-21, 2022 Mumbai.
(III) Delegations visiting ICAI
A delegation from CPA Australia comprising Ms. Deborah Leung, Head of International, Mr. Mark
Chau, Regional General Manager Business Development International and Mr. Leslie Leow,
Regional Manager – MESA, visited ICAI HO on 30th April 2019 to discuss the renewal of Mutual
Reciprocity Agreement (MRA) between ICAI and CPA Australia which expired in September 2019
besides dwelling on issues of bilateral cooperation including exploring the Joint Study on
Sustainable Development Goals and role of Accountants, and holding Joint Seminars/Workshops on
Corporate Governance, Blockchain, Artificial Intelligence etc.
Dr. In Ki Joo, President, IFAC and Mr. Russell Guthrie, CFO &Executive Director, IFAC had visited
ICAI to be a part of the ICAI Platinum Jubilee celebrations on July 01, 2019. The celebrations were
inaugurated by Shri M. Venkaiah Naidu, Hon‘ble Vice President of India. Discussions were also held
for successful conduct of WCOA 2022 on November 18-21, 2022 in Mumbai, India and had a
meeting with the Chairman and Vice Chairman of ESB, AASB and IASB.
194 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
A delegation from Kenya Accountants and Secretaries National Examinations Board (KASNEB) &
Institute of Certified Public Accountants of Kenya (ICPAK) visited ICAI on 7th November 2019 to
discuss on possibilities of availing technical support from ICAI in various technical and professional
issues.
Mr. Alan Johnson, Deputy President and Mr. Russell Guthrie, Chief Financial Officer, IFAC
addressed the International Conference at Mumbai. Coinciding with their visit, they had also visited
the venue for WCOA 2022, i.e. Jio World Centre on 5th December 2019 and had discussions with
the President & Vice President on the preparations of the World Congress of Accountants 2022
(WCOA 2022) at Mumbai.
A delegation from CPA Australia led by Mr. Andrew Hunter, CEO, CPA Australia had visited Mumbai
on December 3, 2019 and had met with ICAI leadership to discuss on the renewal of the MRA
between ICAI & CPA Australia. Various issues of mutual interest to both the Institutes were also
deliberated upon.
(IV) Conferences/Programs
ICAI- CPA Australia Joint Information Sessions -ICAI and CPA Australia jointly organized a series of
workshops in June , September, November 2019 and February 2020 in different Tier I and Tier II
cities creating awareness about the opportunities in Australia after qualifying CPA Australia exams
through MRA route.
International Networking Event organized by Vancouver Chapter of ICAI during the sideline of IFAC
Council meeting-Key meetings of IFAC, CAPA, CAW were held in Vancouver, Canada in the month
of November 2019. In conjunction with such meetings, the British Columbia, Vancouver Chapter of
ICAI had organized an International Networking event wherein Board Members of CAPA
participated. The events were attended by President IFAC, President CAPA and President SAFA as
well and gave wide mileage to ICAI.The Networking Dinner organized by the Chapter on November
11, 2019 provided an exclusive opportunity to enhance the brand CA image at the global stage and
also to promote the WCOA 2022 to be held in India. The event also witnessed the august presence
of President, IFAC, CAPA and SAFA. CA. Atul Kumar Gupta, Vice President, ICAI had given a
presentation on the UDIN initiative of ICAI which elucidated on the concept and advantages of this
initiative at the IFAC Council on November 13, 2019 which was attended by the representatives of
175 member bodies in 130 countries. This initiative of ICAI was highly appreciated by the IFAC
Council.
ICAI International Conference ―Accountancy Profession: Catalyzing Reforms, Creating Values, on
December 6-7, 2019 in Mumbai-The ICAI mega International Conference on ―Accountancy
Profession: Catalyzing Reforms, Creating Values, was successfully held on December 6-7, 2019 in
Mumbai, the financial capital of India. The Conference witnessed a plethora of speakers both of
national as well as international eminence from Government, Industry and Accounting profession
including Mr. Alan Johnson, Deputy President, IFAC; CA. Suresh Prabhu, Hon‘ble Member of
Parliament (Rajya Sabha) & Prime Minister's Sherpa to G 7 and G 20 and CA. Thomas
Chazhikadan, Hon‘ble Member of Parliament (Lok Sabha). The Conference witnessed overwhelming
response with over 1200 delegates attending the event and was very well appreciated by all the
delegates.
ICAI Global Webinar on the topic "Impact of COVID 19 pandemic on the Reporting and Assurance
on April 13, 2020-The International Affairs Committee organised the Global Webinar on "Impact of
COVID 19 pandemic on Reporting and Assurance‖ in April 2020 with the focus to address the
challenges that COVID-19 outbreak has impulse on Global Economies and specially addressing the
challenge being faced by Professionals & Corporates across the globe on accounting, reporting and
assurance perspective. The Webinar was addressed by global leaders including: CA. Suresh
Prabhu, Hon‘ble MP(Rajya Sabha)& Prime Minister‘s Sherpa to G 7 & G 20 ; Dr. In Ki Joo,
President, IFAC; Mr. Florin Toma, President, Accountancy Europe; Mr. Salvador Marin, President,
European Federation of Accountants & Auditors for SMEs (EFAA); Mr. Wan Tin, President, ASEAN
Federation of Accountants; Mr. Tom Seidenstein, Chair, IAASB ; Mr. Alan Johnson, Deputy
President IFAC and Mr. Arjuna Herath, Chair, PAODC , IFAC.The Webinar was also addressed by
representatives of other Professional Accountancy Organisations (PAOs)/International
Organisations like: Chartered Accountants Worldwide (CAW); South Asian Federation of
Accountants (SAFA); The Edinburgh Group; CPA Canada; CPA Australia; CPA Malaysia; Institute
of and Indonesia Chartered Accountants.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 195
Global Webinar on the topic "Risk Diversification Strategies - Opportunity for Global Manufacturers
in India - Post COVID-19" on 30th April, 2020-The COVID-19 pandemic is posing critical challenges
to global economies and it will have lasting impact for many nations. Most nations have already
started initiatives to realign their investment and supply chain strategy for building their
economies, through the path to normal economic growth paradigm will be tough. As the world
emerges out of COVID-19, dawn of new economic order will occur with shifting of global
investments, manufacturing and supply chains. This would require India to rebuild its economy in
the post pandemic era. To make India ready and contribute towards economic development, ICAI
organized a Global Webinar on the topic ―Risk Diversification Strategies – Opportunity for Global
Manufacturers within India – COVID-19‖ on 30 April, 2020. The webinar witnessed e-presence of
CA. Piyush Goyal, Hon‘ble Minister of Commerce and Industry & Minister of Railways, CA. Arun
Singh, Hon‘ble Member of Parliament. The webinar has an eminent panel of speakers Dr. Rajiv
Kumar, Vice Chairman, NITI Aayog, Shri Rajkiran Rai G, MD & CEO, Union Bank of India, Shri
Satish Marathe, Director, Reserve Bank of India, CA. Gopal Krishna Aggarwal, Economist, CA. Rajiv
Kumar Singh, Independent Director, Union Bank of India and CA. Umesh Chandra Pandey, Former
Independent Director, Engineers India Ltd., who shared their views on the topic followed by
Questions and Answers session from Chapters abroad with Hon‘ble Minister CA. Piyush Goyal.
Meeting with Chapter Representatives through Video call to seek suggestions on Future
Investment Policy in India to attract Overseas investment on May 14, 2020 -The International
Affairs Committee organised an interactive meeting of ICAI leadership with ICAI overseas Chapters
to seek their suggestions on Future Investment Policy in India to attract Foreign Investment on
May 14, 2020.
Awareness session for ICAI members to promote MoU with the Institute of Chartered Accountants
of England and Wales (ICAEW) on 27th and 30th June 2020-With the initiative to promote the MoU
and Pathway scheme signed between ICAI and the Institute of Chartered Accountants of England
and Wales (ICAEW), both Institutes jointly organised Webinar ―Your passport to the world: ICAI
members' opportunity to join ICAEW‖ on 27th and 30th June 2020‖respectively. The 2 Webinars
were attended by more than 400 ICAI members.
Webinar in collaboration with Edinburgh Group on June 27, 2020-The International Affairs
Committee and Committee for Members in Practice organized an ICAI-Edinburgh Group Global SMP
Webinar on Future Ready SMP - Vital for Global Economy on the eve of International SMP Day on
June 27, 2020. The webinar had the e-presence of Ms. Monica Foerster, Chair, SMP Committee of
IFAC; Mr. Eamonn Siggins, Chair, Edinburgh Group & CE, CPA Ireland; Ms. Keddie Waller, Head of
Public Practice, CPA Australia; Mr. Mark Edmondson, President & CEO, INFLO; CA. Satish Kumar
Gupta, Chairman, Committee for Members in Practice, ICAI & Chair, SMP Committee of SAFA..
(V) Technical Co-operation to under developed countries
ICAI‘s assistance to NBAA Tanzania, ICA Nepal and CPAPNG under mandate of MoUs signed with them
ICAI support to NBAA, Tanzania-ICAI had signed a technical co-operation MoU with the National
Board of Accountants & Auditors, Tanzania to establish mutual co-operation in accounting and
allied areas. In order to carry forward the mandate of the MoU, ICAI has undertaken the Review of
syllabus of NBAA; Detailed evaluation and revision of study material of NBAA and procurement and
delivery of books for NBAA.
ICAI support to CPAPNG-ICAI & CPAPNG are going to sign a bilateral co-operation MoU and in
pursuance thereof, ICAI has received a request from CPAPNG to improve their course curriculum
for their CPA Module. ICAI has undertaken this evaluation/study to improve their modules. Earlier,
ICAI had extended its support to CPAPNG in attaining full membership of IFAC. ICAI had
completed the due diligence process and submitted its report to IFAC for consideration. IFAC at its
Council Meeting held on November 13, 2019 has granted CPAPNG its full membership. In
pursuance thereof, Mr. Yuwak Tau, Executive Director, CPAPNG had expressed gratitude on behalf
of CPAPNG to ICAI at the ICAI International Conference in Mumbai.
ICAI support to ICA Nepal-ICAI provided technical assistance to ICAN in further strengthening their
examination systems wherein officers from ICAN visited ICAI to peruse the examination system
and discuss various activities related to smooth conduct / flow of Examinations.
Technical Co-operation Agreements-ICAI is also associated in providing framework of Technical
Cooperation to countries that lack the accountancy infrastructure. It has signed Technical Co-
operation Agreement with Kuwait Accountants and Auditors Association (KAAA) and Saudi
196 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
Organization for Certified Public Accountants (SOCPA) in the current year and following are the
Institutes with which ICAI is having technical collaboration agreements for institutionalization of
accounting profession in these countries.
• College for Banking & Financial Studies, Oman
• Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nepal
• Bahrain Institute of Banking and Finance (BIBF)
• National Board of Accountants & Auditors, Tanzania
• Institute of Certified Public Accountants of Kenya (ICPAK)
• Kuwait Accountants and Auditors Association (KAAA)
• Saudi Organization for Certified Public Accountants (SOCPA)
The Technical co-operation agreements with CPA Afghanistan and Higher Colleges of Technology,
UAE have been approved by the Government of India and are expected to be signed soon.
ICAI signs MoU with Kuwait Accountants and Auditors Association (KAAA)-The Institute of
Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) signed the Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the
Kuwait Accountants and Auditors Association (KAAA) in Kuwait on November 21, 2019.Signing of
the MoU between ICAI & KAAA would facilitate both institutions working together to strengthen the
accounting, financial and audit knowledge base in Kuwait. Under the MoU, ICAI would offer
technical programs to the employees of Kuwait Government/Ministries/KAAA members and Kuwait
Nationals in collaboration with KAAA.
Memorandum of Understanding between ICAI and Saudi Organisation for Certified Public
Accountants (SOCPA)-ICAI and the Saudi Organization for Certified Public Accountants (SOCPA)
had signed an MOU in 2014. The MoU was due for renewal and post the approval of the Union
Cabinet of India, ICAI & SOCPA signed the MoU on January 27, 2020 during the opening
Ceremony of Saudi Accountants Forum at Riyadh.The MoU promotes mutual co-operation
framework in the areas of corporate governance, technical research and advice, quality assurance,
forensic accounting, issues for Small and Medium-sized Practices (SMPs), Islamic finance,
Continuing Professional Development (CPD) and other subjects of mutual interest related to
accountancy profession.
(VI) Working for building blocks
Offering access of ICAI‘s e-Learning platform to the members of SAFA member bodies and other
accounting bodies with whom ICAI has entered into MoU / MRA and proposes to enter into MoU/MRA in
future-ICAI's Digital Learning Hub is an integrated Learning Management System (LMS) which facilitates
access to courses and professional contents in multiple formats(videos/presentations and interactive
content) which can be used in self-paced way to professionals of International Accounting Bodies/Forums.
The same was appreciated by the SAFA member bodies and SAFA had requested if ICAI could share these
with the SAFA member bodies.
As a goodwill gesture, ICAI has offered its unique Digital Learning Hub with SAFA countries and
accountancy bodies with which ICAI has entered into MRA/ MoU at a very nominal rate of USD 1 p.a. as
against USD 200 p.a.
Further, ICAI in the extraordinary emergent circumstances; as a proactive measure, has decided to share
these digital resources to support smaller PAOs to enable them to provide online CPD learning to its
members. The proposal of ICAI has been highly appreciated by IFAC and has posted the ICAI proposal of
offering ICAI Digital Learning Hub to smaller PAOs on the IFAC website. The Digital Learning Hub has also
been shared with the members of International Panel on Accountancy Education and they have also
appreciated this initiative of ICAI. About 100 members of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nepal
(ICAN) have already started using the ICAI' digital platform to continue enhancing their professional
knowledge.
7.7 Working Committee on World Congress of Accountants (WCOA)
The Council has formulated a non standing Committee i.e. Working Committee on World Congress of
Accountants from the current Council year for completing the different tasks for organizing the World
Congress of Accountants (WCOA) 2022 scheduled to be held on 18th Nov 2022 to 21st Nov 2022 at JIO
World Centre BKC, Mumbai.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 197
3 to 4 11,919 15,54,126
5 to 7 8,898 13,98,989
8 to 10 4,833 10,28,096
To SAFA, IFAC, AOSSG-SAFA has formed a task force to implement UDIN in SAFA Member Bodies.
The first meeting of the taskforce was held on July 29, 2019 in Colombo, Sri Lanka wherein a
detailed presentation on UDIN was given. ICA Bangladesh, ICA Pakistan & ICA Nepal have
requested for the technical assistance of ICAI to implement UDIN in their respective member
bodies.
A presentation on ―Impact Analysis on UDIN‖ was made at 11 th Annual General Meeting of Asian Oceanian
Standard Setters Group (AOSSG) at Goa held in the month of Nov., 2019 where more than 27 Countries
representatives were present.During the International Networking Meet organised by British Columbia,
Vancouver Chapter of ICAI in Nov., 2019, a presentation was made to IFAC Council on the UDIN initiatives
of ICAI which elucidated on the concept and advantages of this initiative and was highly appreciated by the
IFAC Council.A presentation on UDIN was given to ICA Bangladesh on 15th February 2020 wherein the
concept was highly appreciated.
(X) Release of Publications:
FAQS on Unique-Document Identification Number-A Publication on FAQS on Unique Document
Identification Number (UDIN) was released in the month of November, 2019
Report on UDIN-UDIN Directorate had released a report on Annual Function on 7th Feb., 2020.
Starting from the conceptualization, implementation; the report also depicted various data of
UDINs based on information punched by the members as well as way forward.
(XI) Generation of Bulk UDIN on Certificates-A provision for generating UDIN in bulk for
Certificates has been incorporated in UDIN Portal in the month of June 2020. Using this facility
now the members will be able to generate UDIN in bulk i.e upto 300, for various types of
Certificates in one go. It can be done through uploading of excel file.
(XII) UDIN- a Catalyst for Regulator
It is envisaged that gradually UDIN will become a tool for regulating the Profession and enforcing the
guidelines and laws effectively. Few such areas are stated as below:
Remittances/flow of money overseas as per FCRA/FEMA
Check on utilization of Govt. Sponsored Schemes
Evaluation of GDP growth vis-à-vis Assesse
Number of Tax/Company Audits permissible to CAs
Enforce ICAI Rules/Regulations/Guidelines effectively through UDIN
For Communication with Previous Auditor through UDIN
7.11 International Placement Directorate
The International Placement Directorate has been de-merged this year from Committee for Export of CA
Services & WTO wherein the Overseas Campus Placement was undertaken for two consecutive years, for
placement of Chartered Accountants and Accountants overseas.
Accounting and finance sector is identified as one of the 12 Champion Sectors for export promotion by
Hon‘ble Prime Minister of India. International Placement Directorate is an initiative under the Champion
Sector, is aimed to make potential employers, Chartered Accountants and accountants meet for global
opportunities under ICAI institutional framework and would provide a unique opportunity to overseas
employers to recruit Indian CAs and accountants.
INITIATIVES
Directorate is working on the International Placement Online Portal which will work 24*7 for Indian
Chartered Accountants to work overseas which will enter the UAT phase and will be launch soon.
Directorate is approaching to Commercial wing of all the Indian Mission abroad by writing them for
support and assistance in promotion of Indian Accounting Profession globally and will discuss
further modalities after receipt of confirmation from them.
Directorate had requested all the Chapters of ICAI abroad to share the list of Internationally
recognised HR Consultants in their jurisdiction to whom Directorate will contact individually or
routed through Chapters so that they can share the list of perspective companies who will hire
Indian Chartered Accountants abroad.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 201
Compilation of data and preparation of Financial Statements for FY 2017-18 & 2018-19 and Balance
Sheet as on 31.03.2018 & 31.03.2019 for Indian Railways, and Conducting studies on data/system
shortcomings observed at the Roll Out Stage during compilation of Financial Statements for FY
2015-16 and 2016-17 and its improvements – ICAI ARF has been awarded the said project which is
inclusive of following 5 studies:
Framework on Applicability of Ind AS on Accrual Based FS of Indian Railways
Pilot Study to reconcile Rolling Stock Data of NR with Railway Board as on 31.03.2017
Pilot study to develop mechanism for identification of lease assets and owned assets at Northern
Railway
Pilot Study to develop framework for Clearance of CWIP and transfer to FAR to be undertaken over
NR based on the CWIP data received in FA-13 as on 31st March 2017
Pilot Study to reconcile investment made by Indian Railways in various subsidiaries, associates
companies and joint ventures as on 31st March 2017.
Work has been initiated on all of these.
ICAI ARF published Concept Paper on Audit Committee for Municipal Bodies and submitted the
same to the Minister and Secretary to Ministry of Housing & Urban Affairs of Government of
India, Chief Minister and Minister of Urban Development/Municipal Administration of all the
States, Finance Commission and NITI Aayog for their consideration.
7.15 ICAI Registered Valuers Organisation
ICAI Registered Valuers Organisation is a section 8 Private Company formed by the Institute of Chartered
Accountants of India to enrol and regulate Registered Valuers or valuer member as its members in
accordance with the Companies (Registered Valuers and Valuation) Rules, 2017, and functions incidental
thereto.
(I) Educational Course (50 hours) by ICAI Registered Valuers Organisation which is a
precondition to become Registered Valuer:
In the initial phase, ICAI Registered Valuers Organisation has been focusing on building its membership
base and conducting 50 hours of educational course for its valuer members which is a precondition
for becoming Registered Valuers and preparing Educational material for the Educational Course.
In this direction, from June, 2018 onwards, ICAI RVO has conducted the 43 batches for the 50 hours
training across the country.
As on August, 2020, 3000+ members have been trained by ICAI RVO for its Educational course of 50
hours.
(II) Online Classes of Educational Course (50 hours) by ICAI Registered Valuers
Organisation which is a precondition to become Registered Valuer:
Due to the outbreak of COVID-19, conducting the classes of Educational Course through Online mode
has been allowed by IBBI.
ICAI RVO has conducted 3 online batches and trained 500+ members.
(III) Registration of Registered Valuers with IBBI for the Asset Class Securities or Financial
Assets:
The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India under the Asset Class Securities or Financial Assets has
registered 1183 Registered Valuers as on 31st July, 2020 out of which, 635 Registered Valuers are ICAI
RVO members which contributes to 54% of the membership.
(IV) Study Modules for Educational Course by ICAI RVO:
Four Study Modules for Educational Course have been prepared to help the members who enrols with ICAI
RVO for the Educational Course, in understanding the subject better
Module 1 covers in detail Overview and Concepts of Valuation
Module 2 covers in detail Valuation Approaches and Methods
Module 3 covers Judicial Pronouncements
Module 4 covers Relevant laws & Regulations as per the Syllabus
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 203
Study Group Meetings for Insolvency Professionals by IIIPI - IIIPI has participated in various
meetings of Study Groups of Insolvency Professionals to address issues and concerns in the
Insolvency Resolution process.
Learning Management System of Indian Institute of Insolvency Professionals of ICAI - IIIPI jointly
with ICAI, has designed a Learning Management System to enable the professionals to prepare for
the Limited Insolvency Examination to become an IP.
IIIPI Weekly Newsletter - IIIPI Weekly Newsletter, giving the details of important events and
developments relating to the Insolvency Profession are being hosted on the website.
National Conference - National Conference on ―on Resolving Insolvency in India‖ in association with
ASSOCHAM India, CII.
Association with ASSOCHAM and EIRC - Conference and Seminars were extensively organized in
association with ASSOCHAM and EIRC and seminars were conducted to touch the different aspects
of IBC and unfold operational facts and understanding.
IP Conclave - IBBI Insolvency Professionals Conclave was organized by IIIPI on 29th Feb 2019 with
EIRC-ICAI.
Webinar & Web conferences – IIIPI has organized various Webinars and Web-Conferences in
association with IFC, IBBI, to keep IPs updated with the latest amendment, notification or circular or
change in process in context to IBC making the interface interactive to lead to a proper
communication, effect due to Covid 19 and address to their queries.
Workshops in association with IBBI - IIIPI frequently organizes workshops and advanced trainings in
association with IBBI pan India for the IPs.
Grievance Redressal - A total of 83 Grievances were dismissed or dealt with during 01.04.2019 to
30.06.2020 by the Grievance Redressal Committee of IIIPI.
Online Utilities - IIIPI has developed various online utilities functional in its website www.iiipicai.in to
capture the status of insolvency & liquidation assignments which includes:
Uploading of Public Announcements.
Filing of relationship disclosures
Uploading the details of Fees and other expenses incurred in CIRP and Liquidation
IIIPI made Enrolment application Form Online
Submission of Half Yearly Return
Developed payment gateway to facilitate members of IIIPI to pay all types of fees online
IIIPI is in the process of developing an integrated ERP package, a single window facility for its
members.
8. OTHER MATTERS
8.1 Chartered Accountants’ (CA) Day – 1st July, 2020
On 1st July, i.e. CA Day, ICAI completed 71 years of its glorious existence. Owing to the Covid-19 pandemic
and to abide with the government guidelines to avoid large gatherings, CA Day function was organised in a
Virtual Mode. As part of the celebrations a 3 Day Virtual CA Summit on ―Transforming the Future: Enabling
Excellence, Augmenting Trust‖ was organised from 29th June 2020 to 1st July 2020. It was indeed a great
honour for the profession that Shri Om Birla, Hon‘ble Speaker of Lok Sabha, addressed the members and
students on July 1, 2020. The 3 day Summit, wherein different sessions were scheduled covering entire
gamut and varied areas of contribution profession is making to the society at large, were addressed by
galaxy of speakers from all walks of life sharing their rich experience with the audience.
8.2 Central Council Library
The Central Council Library of the Institute caters to the information requirements of its stakeholders. Its
aim is to provide comprehensive and upto date collection of primary and secondary print and non-print
material to the present and anticipated members/students, research scholars and officials of ICAI. Library
has assumed greater responsibilities of serving committees, departments in imparting knowledge and
valuable information through books, e-books, journals, magazines, on-line databases, print newspapers as
well as e-newspapers. Central council library is responsible for updating and providing journals and books
required for the various committees work.
206 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
The Central Council Library is fully computerized and working through Liberty- library management
software. Library material including database of Books, Journals & Articles can be searched through
Subject, Author, Title, Topic, Keyword, & Publisher wise. These records are available on Internet Online
Services www.icai.org under ―Central Council Library‖-online search OPAC-Liberty for the books, Journals,
articles etc. in the library.
Under the Column ―Accountants Browser‖, an index of articles relevant to accounting profession are
published every month in the journal ―The Chartered Accountant‖. The ―Accountants Browser‖ is an index
of important/Professional Articles with archives of past articles. Reference service from library is also
provided to the Researchers & Scholars, faculties, students and members.
A number of online databases have been acquired by the Library, details of which are available on
www.icai.org – Central Council Library. These On-line knowledge databases have been installed in the
Central Council Library and can be accessed in-house only, to facilitate the search for required material by
the Members, Faculties and Research Scholars. Several e-journals have also been subscribed in the Library.
Details of the new resources added in the Central Council library at Head office and Noida office library
respectively for the financial year 2020 – 21 are as follows:
CENTRAL COUNCIL LIBRARY (H.Q).
S.NO. Title Figures
1. Journals (Print)- national & International 31
2. Online Resources 19
3. No. of new arrival Books added during the period 708
CENTRAL COUNCIL LIBRARY SEC.62, NOIDA
S.NO. Title Figures
1. Journals (Print) - national & International 15
2. Online Resources 12
3. No. of new arrival Books added during the period 202
Central Council Library is regularly updating its resources to provide the professional Members, students,
faculties & other stakeholders with the latest and upto date knowledge and information.
8.3 Editorial Board
The Editorial Board is a non-standing committee of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI)
with a MISSION to convey regularly to the members the professional knowledge, matters of interest of
profession through the journal `The Chartered Accountant‘. The reach and impact of the Journal can be
gauged by its circulation figure which stands about 3,10,000 that comprises of e-journal and printed
copies.
A ‗Brand Ambassador‘ of ICAI and the most visible indicator of the Institute‘s profile for the members,
students and external audiences, The Chartered Accountant today matches the global standards of
professional Journals. The Editorial Board is continuously moving ahead in its mission to keep the ICAI
members and other readers of the journal up-to-date on the knowledge domain of accounting profession-
as well as disseminate information on various developments that are taking place in ICAI.
Following are the most significant achievements of the Editorial Board during the period 1 st April 2019 to
31st March 2020:
(I) Initiatives towards Partner in Nation Building
Editorial Board has undertaken a number of initiatives towards partnering in Nation Building by way of
knowledge upgrade and dissemination through its monthly journal, The Chartered Accountant, as well as
otherwise. Some significant initiatives in this regard are as under:
(A) Publication of Articles of National/Professional interest:
About 215 articles/features of national-professional-economic interest were published in the ICAI‘s journal
The Chartered Accountant in coordination with various government organs, ICAI Committees, Member
authors and other stakeholders.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 207
9. MEMBERS
9.1 Membership
During the year ended 31st March, 2020, 15,540 new members were enrolled by the ICAI bringing the total
membership to 3,07,238 as on 1st April, 2020.
During the year ended 31st March 2020, 642 associates were admitted as fellows, in comparison to the
figure of 6,752 in the previous year.
Total Members as on 1.4.2020
9.2 Convocation
Since November 2008, the Institute has been organizing Convocation to confer membership certificates to
newly enrolled members. ICAI has successfully organized 1st round of ―Convocation 2019‖ for the newly
enrolled members covering the period from May, 2019 to October, 2019 on 3 rd, 4th & 5th January, 2020 at
following nine places under five Regional Offices:-
1. Ahmedabad 6. Kolkata
2. Mumbai 7. Jaipur
3. Pune 8. Kanpur
4. Chennai 9. New Delhi
5. Hyderabad
STATISTICS MEMBERS
AS ON 01/04/2020
FELLOWS : In Full Time Practice 82953
In Part-time Practice 2705
Not in Practice 13825
99483
FELLOWS ASSOCIATES
In Practice In Practice
Region Full Time Part Time Not In Total Full Time Part Time Not In Total Grand Total
Practice Practice
Western 24118 782 3960 28860 18279 1567 54439 74285 103145
Southern 17491 700 3304 21495 8632 1019 28754 38405 59900
Eastern 7804 232 1259 9295 3683 335 11717 15735 25030
Central 16744 375 1898 19017 11915 705 25833 38453 57470
Northern 16796 616 3404 20816 10859 905 29113 40877 61693
TOTAL 82953 2705 13825 99483 53368 4531 149856 207755 307238
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 211
[
10. BOARD OF STUDIES
Board of Studies of the Institute is responsible for the administration of the Chartered Accountancy
curriculum and imparting theoretical instruction to Students who are undergoing Chartered Accountancy
course. Significant initiatives and achievements of the Board during the period are mentioned below:-
10.1 Board of Studies (Academic)
Initiatives towards Partner in Nation Building
(I) New Scheme of Education and Training
Value Added Study Material: The revised value added edition of the Study Materials was released
this year and also webhosted at BoS Knowledge Portal. Moreover, in the year 2020, a Group has
been constituted for further Quality Enhancement of the Study Material and it has been made error
free in the first phase and the work of further addition and updation is being done in the second
phase.
Questions and Case Studies for Practice: In order to prepare students for their forthcoming
examinations, Questions for Core Papers and Case Studies for Elective Papers were uploaded on
the ICAI‘s website.
Subject-specific webcasts in elective subjects at Final level: The webcasts were delivered by BoS
faculty before May and November examinations, wherein select case studies on elective papers
were discussed at length and the students queries were addressed on real time basis.
Subject-specific Revision Capsules: Released subject-specific revision capsules every month in the
Student Journal ―The Chartered Accountant Student‖. These capsules facilitate effective revision of
the topics, especially the day before the examination.
Revision Test Papers for all papers under old and new schemes were uploaded and printed for the
convenience of students. Questions include MCQs and descriptive questions assessing different
skills – knowledge and comprehension, application and analysis and evaluation and synthesis.
MCQ based Assessment : In order to hone the analytical and comprehension skills of students and
to have an objective assessment of their performance in the examination, an assessment system in
30% of the questions asked in the examination of Select Papers (given in the table below) would
be multiple choice based questions of 1 and 2 marks. This system was put in place for May, 2019
examination for both Intermediate and Final levels under both the old and new scheme of
education and training. Model MCQs were webhosted at the BoS Knowledge Portal for each
subject.
212 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
and skills worldwide, to conduct an independent benchmarking study for evaluating the comparability of
the ICAI Intermediate and Final levels in the context of the UK and UAE education systems.
UK NARIC evaluated ICAI qualification comparable to specific Regulated Qualifications Framework levels of
UK and UAE. This benchmarking of the CA qualification would strengthen the position of ICAI members
and help corporates gain a better understanding on the relevance and standing of the CA qualification. It
would also provide opportunities for higher studies and enhanced professional opportunities for ICAI
members/ semi qualified professionals in UK, Middle East and other foreign jurisdictions accepting NARIC
evaluation.
Other Initiatives for Students
Mock Test Papers
Mock Test Papers Series-I for July, 2020 examination was conducted online in May, 2020 through BoS
Knowledge Portal. The mock test of each paper was uploaded as per the schedule and its answers were
uploaded after 48 hours so that the students could check and verify their answers.
Special Counseling Sessions
Special Counseling Sessions were organized in each subject after the conduct of Mock Test Papers from 1st
to 10th June, 2020 to guide the students as to how they have to attempt the questions in the examination.
Computer Based Test for Assessment of Practical Training
Online MCQ-based tests are conducted for students after completion of first and second year of practical
training. Eleven such tests for both levels have been conducted on September 23, October 21, December
2, December 30, 2018, February 3, March 10, April 21, July 7, September 8, December 8 and December
29, 2019 covering around 1,13,000 students at both levels.
One day Orientation Course for the Faculty/Coordinators and their HoDs of approved
Accredited Institutions
The Board organized ―One day Orientation Course‖ for the Faculty/Coordinators and their HoDs of
approved Accredited Institutions on August 30, 2019 at Chennai. Such Orientation Course was organized as
per ―National Policy for organizing Oral Coaching Class by Accredited Institutions‖ approved by the Board
to promote intra and inter-institutional interaction and provide an opportunity to experience the standard
methodology/pedagogy of teaching. 31 participants from Accredited Institutions participated in that
programme.
Reading Room Portal
170 Libraries/Reading Rooms/Additional Reading Rooms are functional to provide conducive reading
atmosphere for CA students across the country. The students can login to the Reading Room Portal by
entering with their Username and Password and register anytime anywhere. The other features of the
reading room portal are as under:-
Features of Portal
Securing seat by paying fees at the Centre.
Flexible registrations for the students for a day/ a month.
24 x 7 online services available.
Confirmation of the seat within 24 hrs of Payment.
Updated information available on the Portal to help students to register.
Monthly Interaction with Regional Councils, Branches and Students
Monthly interaction of Chairperson, Vice-Chairman and Director, BOS has been initiated with Regional
Councils, Branches and students through webcast so that the connect with them can be strengthened.
BoS has compiled and uploaded Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on Institute‘s website relating to
various academic and other initiatives of the BoS.
Toll Free Helpline
The Board initiated Toll-free Help line service 18001211330 as a Student Support Initiative from May 11,
2017 to redress queries/grievances of CA students from across the country. Till date, close
to 2.5 Lakh queries have been addressed from students all over the country
216 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
(II) 5962 and 5122 Students were trained in Virtual MCS and Advanced ITT since April 01, 2020 to June
30,2020.
11. CAREER COUNSELLING DIRECTORATE
This Career counselling Committee was formed in the month of February, 2015 with an objective
to promote the Commerce Education with special focus on CA course among Secondary, Senior/ Higher
Secondary, Graduate/Post Graduate students as well as other stakeholders in India and abroad. In the
Council year 2018-19, the Career Counselling Group was formed and then it is converted into Career
Counselling Directorate on 12th February 2020. The Directorate is continuously promoting the Commerce
education with special focuss on the most Reputed, Respected, Recognised and Globally Trusted profession
of Chartered Accountancy.
The Directorate conducts various programmes including Quiz, Debate competitions throughout the year to
gauge the Skills, Abilities and Knowledge of students, identify their talent and encourage them towards
Commerce Education. The Directorate is making effective use of social media platforms like Facebook,
Twitter, Google+, Youtube & Linkedin, facilitating creating buzz, post updates, starting discussions,
sharing links, promotional campaigns, promote blogs/feeds, posting of photos & documents, creating
twitter handler, customised for contact form/ registration form for the same etc. to achieve the objectives.
There are 2815 resource persons across India who are empanelled for carrying out the Career Counselling
programmes in all almost every part of the country.
The following activities were conducted during the period from 1st April 2019 to 30th June 2020:-
The Directorate organised more than 1000 career counselling programmes in India and 13 programmes at
overseas chapters of the ICAI for the benefit of the students. The challenge of spurt of ongoing COVID-19
pandemic is converted into an opportunity by organising 93 programmes through virtual online mode. 4
Mega Career Counselling Programmes were organised during the period at Paladi, Ahmedabad, Bellary
Karnataka, Ernakulam and Kanchipuram. 3 Commerce Champ Programmes were conducted at Jaipur,
Lucknow, and Siliguri.
The Directorate for the first time organized the ICAI Commerce Quiz 2020 through online mode on 29 th
June 2020 for the students from class IX to XII in 4 levels separately. There were total 48343 registrations
of which 46054 registrations are from India and 2289 from other countries. Cash prizes worth Rs. 820000
will be presented to the winners of the Quiz.
Country Class IX Class X Class XI Class XII Grand Total
India 3882 6511 12250 23411 46054
Outside India 665 593 525 506 2289
Grand Total 4547 7104 12775 23917 48343
The Directorate is working continuously in promotion of commerce education in India and abroad and wish
to organize more programmes in the next year to reach to the students of every part of India.
12. REGIONAL COUNCILS AND THEIR BRANCHES
The ICAI has five Regional Councils, namely Western India Regional Council, Southern India Regional
Council, Eastern India Regional Council, Central India Regional Council and Northern India Regional
Council with their Headquarters at Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata, Kanpur and New Delhi respectively.
Currently it has 164 Branches, 34 Chapters outside India and 15 Regional Libraries all over In dia.
Award for Best Regional Council, Best Branch of Regional Council, Best Students‘ Association and Best
Branch of Students‘ Association.
These awards are given by the ICAI every year. The awards are given on the basis of overall
performance and established norms. For the year 2019, these Shields were awarded at the Annual
Function held on 7th February, 2020 to the following winners:-
1. Best Regional Council
First Prize : Western India Regional Council
Second Prize : Southern India Regional Council jointly with
Eastern India Regional Council
220 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
MEMBERS
(From 1st April, 1950)
TABLE II
STUDENTS REGISTERED
(From 31st March, 2009)
Foundation New Intermediat
During the IPCC &
as per new Final Final CPT PCC e ATC Total
year IIPCC
CRET
2009-10 - 24,172 - 1,67,073 1,860 80,745 - 3,376 2,77,226
2010-11 - 57,175 - 1,55,217 329 67,984 - 1,906 2,82,611
2011-12 - 47,515 - 1,61,712 - 85,053 - 2,099 2,96,379
2012-13 - 45,102 - 1,61,084 - 1,02,406 - 2,615 3,11,207
2013-14 - 39,348 - 1,54,742 - 96,285 - 3,209 2,93,584
2014-15 - 36,950 - 1,41,241 - 66,570 - 881 2,45,642
2015-16 - 31,669 - 1,25,140 - 77,962 - 1,249 2,36,020
2016-17 - 27,611 - 1,07,392 - 81,886 - 1,430 2,18,319
9,788 14,05 63,693
2017-18 26,291 73,804 - 22,657 - 2,10,289
6
45,048 27,96 53,654
2018-19 - - - - - 1,26,668
6
63,228 67,09 87,949
2019-20 - - - - - 2,18,267
0
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 225
• Conclude on the appropriateness of the management‘s use of the going concern basis of accounting
and, based on the audit evidence obtained, whether a material uncertainty exists related to events or
conditions that may cast significant doubt on the Institute‘s ability to continue as a going concern. If
we conclude that a material uncertainty exists, we are required to draw attention in our auditor‘s
report to the related disclosures in the financial statements or, if such disclosures are inadequate, to
modify our opinion. Our conclusions are based on the audit evidence obtained up to the date of our
auditor‘s report. However, future events or conditions may cause the Institute to cease to continue as
a going concern.
We communicate with those charged with governance regarding, among other matters, the planned scope
and timing of the audit and significant audit findings, including any significant deficiencies in internal
controls that we identify during our audit.
Other Matters
a) The Institute has authorized a large number of Chapters in India and abroad. The Institute has
represented to us that since these Chapters are separate entities, their accounts are not required
to be consolidated.
b) We did not audit the financial statements of the Institute‘s Decentralized offices, Computer
Centers, Students Associations, Regional Councils and their Branches (Collectively known as
Branches) whose financial statements reflect total assets of Rs. 1,00,156 Lakhs, total revenue of
Rs. 19,171 Lakhs and net cash flows/ (outflow) amounting to Rs. 224 Lakhs as considered in the
financial statements. The financial statements of these branches have been audited by other
auditors whose reports have been furnished to us by the management. Our Opinion on the
financial statements, in so far as it relates to the amounts and disclosures included in respect of
these Branches is based solely on the reports of the other auditors.
Our opinion on the financial statements, and Regulatory Requirements below, is not modified in
respect of the above matters with respect to our reliance on the work done and the reports of the
other auditors and the financial statements certified by the management.
Report on Other Regulatory Requirements
Further, we report that:
a) We have obtained all the information and explanations which to the best of our knowledge and
belief were necessary for the purpose of our audit;
b) In our opinion, proper books of account have been kept by the Institute so far as appears from our
examination of those books and proper returns adequate for the purpose of our audit have been
received from the decentralized offices, computer centers, students‘ associations, Regional Councils
and their branches.
c) The Institute‘s Balance Sheet, Statement of Income and Expenditure, and Cash Flow Statement
dealt with by this Report are in agreement with the books of accounts.
For Shah Gupta & Co. For Ravi Rajan & Co LLP
Chartered Accountants Chartered Accountants
Firm Reg. No. 109574W Firm Reg. No.009073N/N500320
Sd/- Sd/-
CA. Rajeev Bansal CA. Deepak Gupta
Partner Partner
Membership No. 088598 Membership No. 516002
UDIN:20088598AAAABO5581 UDIN:20516002AAAACN8820
Place: New Delhi
Date: 24th September, 2020
228 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
Sd/- Sd/-
CA. Rajeev Bansal CA. Deepak Gupta
Partner, Membership No. 088598 Partner, Membership No. 516002
th
New Delhi, 24 September, 2020.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 229
II EXPENSES
a) Seminars and training programmes 21 5,012 4,505
b) Employee benefit expenses 22 15,017 14,695
c) Printing and stationery 5,585 5,517
d) Professional fees paid to examiners and consultants 10,220 9,557
e) Depreciation and amortisation expense 9-10 3,392 2,688
f) Other expenses 23 24,527 25,044
Total expenses 63,753 62,006
Sd/- Sd/-
CA. Rajeev Bansal CA. Deepak Gupta
Partner, Membership No. 088598 Partner, Membership No. 516002
New Delhi, 24th September, 2020.
230 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
Notes:
Cash and Cash Equivalents represent cash on hand and balances with banks (Refer Note. 17).
For and on behalf of the Council
Sd/- Sd/-
CA. Rajeev Bansal CA. Deepak Gupta
Partner, Membership No. 088598 Partner,
Membership No. 516002 New Delhi, 24th September, 2020.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 231
vi) Income from investments of Earmarked Funds is added to Earmarked Funds. The income is
allocated based on opening balances of the respective earmarked funds on weighted average
basis.
vii) 25% of the Information Technology Training (ITT)/Advance Information Technology Training
course Fee received during the year is transferred to Other Reserves for replacement of
computers and other ITT centre infrastructure.
viii) A sum equal to depreciation for the year (excluding amount transferred to the ITT Reserve) is
transferred to Sinking Fund for repair and replacement of assets.
2.07 Property, Plant and Equipment
Property, Plant and Equipment is recognised when it is probable that future economic benefits associated
with the item will flow to the Institute and the cost of the item can be measured reliably. Property, Plant and
Equipment are carried at cost less accumulated depreciation and accumulated impairment losses, if any.
The cost of Property, Plant and Equipment comprises its purchase price net of any trade discounts and
rebates, import duties and other taxes (other than those subsequently recoverable from the tax authorities),
directly attributable expenditure on making the asset ready for its intended use. Other incidental expenses
and interest on borrowings attributable to acquisition of qualifying Property, Plant and Equipment up to the
date the asset is ready for its intended use are also capitalised.
2.08 Intangible Assets
Intangible assets are carried at cost less accumulated amortisation and accumulated impairment losses, if
any. The cost of intangible assets comprises its purchase price net of any trade discounts and rebates,
import duties and other taxes (other than those subsequently recoverable from the tax authorities), directly
attributable expenditure on making the asset ready for its intended use, other incidental expenses and
interest on borrowings attributable to acquisition of qualifying assets up to the date the asset is ready for its
intended use. Subsequent expenditure on tangible assets after its purchase / completion is capitalised only
if such expenditure results in an increase in the future benefits from such asset beyond its previously
assessed standard of performance.
2.09 Capital Work in Progress
Expenditure incurred on construction of assets which is not ready for their intended use is carried at cost
less impairment, if any, under Capital Work-in-Progress. The cost includes the purchase cost including
import duties, non-refundable taxes, if any, and directly attributable costs .
2.10 Depreciation and amortisation
A). Depreciable amount for assets is the cost of an asset, or other amount substituted as cost. Depreciation
on Property, Plant and Equipment is provided on the written down value method at the following rates as
approved by the Council based on the useful life of the respective assets.
Class of Property,Plant and Equipment Rate of Depreciation
i) Buildings 5%
ii) Lifts, electrical installations and fittings 10%
iii) Computers 60%
iv) Furniture and fixtures 10%
v) Air conditioners and office equipments 15%
vi) Vehicles 20%
vii) Library books 100%
B) Carrying amount of Leasehold land is amortised over the shorter of the lease term or its useful life.
C) Intangible assets, consisting of Computer software, is amortised over its estimated useful life on straight
line method over three years.
2.11 Revenue recognition
The Revenue is recognised as follows:
i) Distance education fee received from the students is recognised pro-rata over the duration of the
respective courses.
ii) Class room training fee comprises fee received for Management Communcation Skills Course
("MCS"), Integrated Course on Information Technology & Soft Skills ("ICITSS"), Advanced
Integrated Course on Information Technology & Soft Skills ("AICITSS") and Orientation Programme
("OP").The income for classroom training and coaching classes is recognised when services are
rendered and related costs are incurred.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 233
iii) Examination fee is recognised as revenue when the Institute renders the related service i.e when
the examinations are conducted.
iv) Seminar fee is recognised as revenue when the Institute renders the related service i.e when the
seminars are conducted.
v) Membership fee comprising of annual membership fee (including fee for certificate of practice and
restoration fee) and entrance fee is recognised as under:
a) Annual membership fee (including fee for certificate of practice) is recognised as income when
it becomes due for the year. Restoration of membership fee is recognised when it is
received.
b) Entrance Fee:
- One third of entrance fee collected at the time of admission as associate member is recognised
as income in the year of admission and the balance is recognised in Infrastructure Reserve.
- Entrance fee collected at the time of admission of person as fellow member is recognised in
Infrastructure Reserve.
vi) Student registration fees is recognised when student is admitted for the course.
vii) Student Association income is recognised when student is admitted for the course.
viii) Revenue from post qualification and certificate course is recognised in the period in which services
are rendered.
ix) In case of cancellation before commencement of the Certificate/ Post Qualification Course/Diploma
Course, 10% of the fee is deducted and in case the course has commenced, no fee is refunded but
the member will be given an option to attend remaining part of the course in subsequent batches.
2.12 Other income
a) Income from sale of publications are recognised when the risk and rewards are transferred to the
buyer which normally coincide with delivery of goods. Income includes consideration received or
receivable, net of discounts and other related taxes, (if any).
b) Income from students news letter and journal subscription is recognised on pro-rata basis over the
period of subscription.
c) Income from campus interviews and expert advisory fee are recognised when services are
rendered and related costs are incurred.
d) Interest Income is recognised on a time apportionment basis.
2.13 Investment
a) The Institute’s investments comprise of instruments in the form of domestic government securities
issued by Central and State Governments, fixed deposits with nationalised banks domiciled in
India and shares in Not-for-Profit entities.
b) Investments are classified as current and long term investments in accordance with AS 13
Investments. Current investments are those that are readily realisable and intended to be held for
not more than one year from the date on which such investments are made. A long term
investment is an investment other than a current investment.
c) Investments are initially recorded at cost and the cost includes acquisition costs such as brokerage,
fees and duties. Accrued interest paid at the time of purchase is setoff against first
receipt of interest.
d) At each balance sheet date, current investments are carried at lower of cost and fair value. The fair
value is determined on an individual basis. The Long term investments are carried at cost.
However, the provision for diminution in value is made to recognise the decline in value, other than
temporary, of investments. The premium paid at the time of purchase is amortised over the
remaining maturity of the investments. Amortisation of premium is adjusted against the income
under head ‘Interest from Investments.’.
2.14 Foreign Currency Transaction
Transactions in foreign currencies are accounted at the exchange rates prevailing on the date of
the transaction.
Foreign currency monetary items outstanding at the balance sheet date are restated at the year-
end rates. Non-monetary items are carried at historical cost.
234 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
Exchange differences arising on settlement / restatement of foreign currency monetary assets and
liabilities are recognised as income or expense in the Statement of Income and Expenditure.
2.15 Employee benefits
Employee benefits include provident fund, gratuity fund, compensated absence, long service
awards, pension scheme and post-employment medical benefits.
i) Short term employee benefits
The undiscounted amount of short-term employee benefits (ie. salary, allowances, exgratia etc)
expected to be paid in exchange for the services rendered by employees are recognised
during the year when the employees render the service. The short-term employee benefits are
expected to occur within twelve months after the end of the period in which the employee
renders the related service.
The cost of short-term compensated absences is accounted as under :
a) in case of accumulated compensated absences, when employees render the service that
increase their entitlement of future compensated absences; and
b) in case of non-accumulating compensated absences, when the absences occur.
ii) Post-employment benefits
Post-employment benefits are the benefits to employees, other than termination benefits,
which are payable after the completion of employment. Accounting of post-employment
benefits depends upon the classification of relevant plans as either defined benefit plan (DBP)
or defined contribution plan (DCP). The post-employment benefit plans where the Institute
pays fixed contributions into a separate entity or fund and it will have no obligation to pay
further contributions if the separate entity or fund does not hold sufficient assets to all
employee benefits relating to employee service in the current and prior period. On the other
hand, post-employment benefit plans other than those classified as DCP are classified as DBP.
a) Defined Benefits Plans
For defined benefit plans in the form of gratuity and post retirement pension, the cost of
providing benefits is determined using the Projected Unit Credit Method, with actuarial
valuations being carried out at each balance sheet date. Actuarial gains and losses are
recognised in the Statement of Income and Expenditure in the period in which they occur. Past
service cost is recognised immediately to the extent that the benefits are already vested and
otherwise is amortised on a straight-line basis over the average period until the benefits
become vested. The retirement benefit obligation recognised represent the present value of the
defined benefit obligation as adjusted for unrecognised past service cost, as reduced by the
fair value of scheme assets. Any asset resulting from this calculation is limited to past service
cost, plus the present value of available refunds and reductions in future contributions to the
schemes. Gratuity liability is funded with Life Insurance Corporation of India.
The contribution towards provident fund scheme to The Institute of Chartered Accountants of
India Provident Fund Trust ('the Trust') is considered as defined benefit plan and charged as an
expense based on the amount of contribution required to be made and when services are
rendered by the employees. The Trust is managed by the governing body elected by the
Institute.
The present value of the defined benefit obligations are ascertained by an independent actuary
as per the requirements of Accounting Standard (AS) - 15 Employee Benefits.
b) Pension scheme
The Institute offers its employees benefits in the form of pension. The present value of the
obligation as at the balance sheet date is recognised based on the actuarial valuation.
c) Post retirement medical scheme benefit to retired employees and spouse
The Institute offers employee benefits to its retired employees in the form of medical scheme.
iii) Other Long-term employee benefits
Compensated absences which are not expected to occur within twelve months after the end of
the period in which the employee renders the related service are recognised as a liability at the
present value of the defined benefit obligation as at the balance sheet date less the fair value
of the plan assets out of which the obligations are expected to be settled.
2.16 Leases
The Institute classifies the leases as Finance and Operating Lease for accounting and disclosure
purposes. The leases where the Institute assumes substantially all the risks and rewards of the
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 235
ownership are classified as finance leases. The leases where the lessor and not the Institute
assumes substantially all the risks and rewards of the ownership are classified as operating leases.
Lease rental under operating leases are recognised in the statement of income and expenditure on
straight-line basis over the lease term. In case of Finance Lease, assets are capitalised at lower of
fair value of the leased asset and present value of minimum lease payments. The lease payments
are apportioned between the finance charge and repayment of lease liability. Leased assets are
depreciated over the shorter of lease term or useful life of the asset.
2.17 Impairment of Property, Plant and Equipment and intangible assets
The carrying value of assets at each balance sheet date are reviewed for impairment. If any
indication of impairment exists, the recoverable amount of such assets is estimated and impairment
recognised, if the carrying amount of these assets exceeds their recoverable amount. The
recoverable amount is the greater of the net selling price and their value in use. Value in use is
arrived at by discounting the future cash flows to their present value based on an appropriate
discount factor. When there is indication that an impairment loss recognised for an asset in earlier
accounting periods no longer exists or may have decreased, such reversal of impairment loss is
recognised in the statement of income and expenditure
2.18 Taxes on income
The Institute has been granted exemption from Income Tax under section 10(23C)(iv) and Section
11 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. As such no provision for income tax is made and no provision for
deferred tax asset and liability is considered necessary.
2.19 Assets held for Earmarked and Other Funds
Earmarked fund and others funds in the form of deposits with banks maturing after a period of
twelve months from the date of balance sheet are classified as non-current and others are
classified as current. These are available for use freely at the discretion of the Council except to the
extent of total of the earmarked, employee benefit funds.
2.20 Provisions and Contingencies
A provision is recognised when there is a present obligation as a result of past events and it is
probable that an outflow of resources will be required to settle the obligation in respect of which a
reliable estimate can be made.
Contingent liability is a possible obligation that arises from past events and the existence of which
will be confirmed only by the occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more uncertain future events
not wholly within the control of the Institute, or is a present obligation that arises from past event
but is not recognised because either it is not probable that an outflow of resources embodying
economic benefits will be required to settle the obligation, or a reliable estimate of the amount of
the obligation cannot be made. Contingent liabilities are disclosed and not recognised.
Contingent assets are neither recognised nor disclosed.
Balance at the beginning of 75,233 82,207 42,682 38,343 6,072 5,700 3,769 1,989 1,27,756 1,28,239
the year
Add: Appropriation from 12,743 13,916 - - - - 1,874 1,780 14,617 15,696
Statement of Income
and Expenditure
Transfer from / (to) - - - - - - - - - -
General Reserve,
Infrastructure Reserve
and Other Reserve
Transfer from / (to) (10,000) (20,890) 3,446 4,339 - - - - (6,554) (16,551)
Earmarked Funds
Admission fees and allocated - - - - 604 387 - - 604 387
Entrance fees
(Utilization)/Addition - - 2 - (3) (15) (49) - (50) (15)
Balance at the end of 77,976 75,233 46,130 42,682 6,673 6,072 5,594 3,769 1,36,373 1,27,756
the year
* Others comprises Library Reserve, Class Room Training Reserves, Foreign Currency Translation Reserve (Dubai branch) etc.
236 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
THE INSTITUTE OF CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS OF INDIA NOTES FORMING PART OF THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
As at March 31, As at March 31, As at March 31, As at March As at March 31, As at March 31, As at March 31, As at March 31, As at March 31, As at March 31,
31,
2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019
Balance at the 2,677 2,479 924 854 33,608 29,713 280 265 186 167 2,138 - 923 789 21,166 - 6,689 5,103 68,591 39,370
beginning of
the year
Appropriation - - - - 6,391 5,818 - - - - 1,076 2,138 81 80 1,303 276 1,500 1,500 10,351 9,812
from
Statement of
Income and
Expenditure
Utilised - - - - - - (23) (19) (5) (4) - - (8) (10) - - - (2) (36) (35)
during the
year
2,886 2,677 997 924 39,221 33,608 289 280 10,231 186 3,384 2,138 1,069 923 24,150 21,166 8,374 6,689 90,601 68,591
Balance at
the end of
the year
Note
1. Total earmarked funds of ₹ 90601 Lakhs (Previous year ₹. 68,591 Lakhs) are held in fixed deposits and Government Securities (See Note 12 & 13)
2. Rs. 1,500 lakhs have been appropriated to finance estimated expenditure Rs.4,500 Lakhs for the World Congress of Accountants to be held in the year
2022. (See Note No.24.15)
( ₹ in Lakhs)
NOTE # 5: OTHER LONG-TERM LIABILITIES As at March 31,
2020 2019
Fees received in advance
i) Education fees 2,103 1,579
ii) Journal subscription 9 12
Total 2,112 1,591
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 237
b) Other liabilities
i) Capital Creditors 28 15
ii) PF, ESIC and Professional tax payable 254 109
iii) Withholding taxes 534 540
iv) GST Payable 724 784
v) Security and earnest money deposit 773 816
vi) Others 805 482
Buildings 2020 38,735 1,958 (49) 40,644 9,002 1,633 - 10,635 30,009
2019 31,800 7,005 (70) 38,735 7,766 1,584 (348) 9,002 29,733
Lifts, 2020 2,312 124 (2) 2,434 1,267 122 - 1,389 1,045
electrical
2019 2,183 118 11 2,312 1,157 115 (5) 1,267 1,045
installations
& fittings
Computers 2020 5,417 2,052 (208) 7,261 5,102 880 (203) 5,779 1,482
2019 5,233 260 (76) 5,417 4,948 239 (85) 5,102 315
Furniture 2020 4,835 209 (1) 5,043 2,417 252 (2) 2,667 2,376
and
2019 4,572 455 (192) 4,835 2,221 244 (48) 2,417 2,418
fixtures
Air 2020 5,626 265 (11) 5,880 3,412 351 (6) 3,757 2,123
conditioners
and 2019 5,387 322 (83) 5,626 3,135 354 (77) 3,412 2,214
office
equipments
Total 2020 84,221 7,719 (855) 91,085 23,215 3,360 (215) 26,360 64,725
2019 75,563 9,576 (918) 84,221 21,200 2,660 (645) 23,215 61,006
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 239
55,200 55,200 - -
Book
57,730 61,305 2,508 -
Value (A)
2,571 6,109 2,517 -
Market 55,200 55,200 - -
57,771 61,309 2,517 -
Value
Quoted
Unquoted(Book
value) - - - 2,910
- 2,497 2,499 -
B. State Government Securities - 1,506 1,501 -
Quoted Securities : - - - 1,003
1 07.86 Rajasthan Uday 2019 3,836 3,870 - -
2 8.01% Rajasthan Uday SDL 2020 1,518 1,527 - -
3 8.18% Andhra Pradesh SDL 1,003 1,004 - -
2020 4 8.20% Punjab SDL 2019 3,048 3,058 - -
5 8.39% Rajasthan Uday Bond 2021 2,032 2,038 - -
6 8.39% Rajasthan Uday SDL 2022 2,543 2,557 - -
7 8.44% Uttar Pradesh Uday 2023 - 1,510 1,501 -
8 8.45% Karnataka SDL 2024 508 511 - -
9 8.45% Karnataka SDL 2024 506 510 - -
10 8.45% Punjab SDL 2023 - - - 1,004
11 8.49% Andhra Pradesh P SDL 2020
12 8.62% Maharashtra SDL 2023 14,994 20,588 5,501 4,917
13 8.75% West Bengal GS 2022
14 8.85% Punjab SDL 2019
SGS
(i)
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 241
NOTE # 13: Assets held for Earmarked and As at March 31, As at March 31,
Others Funds 2020 2019 2020 2019
Non- Non- Current Current
current current
a) Cash on hand 45 42
b) Balances with banks in savings and current accounts 8,703 8,670
Total 8,748 8,712
NOTE # 19: SEMINAR INCOME For the year ended March 31,
2020 2019
a) Members 2,929 2,889
b) Students 587 695
c) Non members 770 711
d) E-Learning income 3 17
NOTE # 20: OTHER INCOME For the year ended March 31,
2020 2019
a) Interest income
i) on bank deposit held in general funds 2,957 2,783
ii) from investments 5,490 5,613
iii) on bank deposits held for earmarked funds 4,987 2,866
iv) on loans to employees 89 70
b) Sale of publications 1,123 933
c) News letters 110 106
d) Journal subscription 232 277
e) Campus interview 433 970
f) Expert advisory fee 39 53
g) Provision no longer required written back 255 445
h) Miscellaneous income 609 481
i) Income Support Services 7,904 5,335
Less:- Expense Support Services (7,904) (5,335)
j) Prior period income 1,810 969
Total 18,134 15,566
NOTE # 21: SEMINARS AND TRAINING For the year ended March 31,
PROGRAMMES 2020 2019
a) Members 3,705 3,441
b) Students 1,212 943
c) Students activity expenses 77 83
d) E-Learning expenses 18 38
NOTE # 22: EMPLOYEE BENEFIT EXPENSE For the year ended March 31,
2020 2019
a) Salary, pension and other allowances 14,116 12,912
b) Contribution to provident and other funds 758 1,616
c) Staff welfare expenses 143 167
NOTE # 23: OTHER EXPENSES For the year ended March 31,
2020 2019
a) Postage and telephone 2,378 2,743
b) Rent, rates and taxes 5,572 5,542
c) Domestic Travelling 2,421 2,212
d) Overseas expenses:
i) Overseas travelling 232 110
ii) Membership fees for foreign professional bodies 635 573
iii) Others 201 160
e) Repairs and maintenance 2,894 2,589
f) Class room training expenses 5,523 5,187
g) Advertisement and publicity 349 278
h) Meeting expenses 1,191 1,182
i) Merit scholarship 195 189
j) Audit fees : Head office 15 11
: Other 37 39
offices 36 35
k) Payments from earmarked funds 1039 1,213
l) GST expenses - 4
m) Provision for doubtful advances 564 1,084
n) Prior period expenses 1,245 1,893
o) Other expenses
Total 24,527 25,044
24.04 Out of the fee received from the students towards Students Registration Fee, a sum of ₹ 250 per
student in respect of students registered after 1st April, 2009, is remitted to Chartered Accountants
Students Benevolent Fund.
24.05 Leasehold land includes ₹ 6.17 lakhs paid for the plot of land in Indraprastha Estate, New Delhi
(adjacent to existing head office) allotted by Land and Development Authority, New Delhi for which
execution of Memorandum of Agreement and Lease Deed is in progress.
24.06 The Institute had initiated a process for digitization of entire activities by undertaking a project
referred as 'Project Parivartan'. For this purpose, Institute had appointed a global integrated service
provider (vendor) supervised by a globally reputed project management consultant at a total cost of
₹ 3,981 lakhs. A sum of ₹ 867 lakhs was incurred up to March 31, 2015.
Since the service provider did not carry out the development of digitization as per the requirement
even after extended periods, the Institute cancelled the contract and encashed the bank guarantee
of ₹ 295 lakhs in the month of June 2015 and the balance amount of ₹ 572 lakhs was written off in
the year ended March 31, 2015.
The vendor submitted a proposal requiring the Institute to pay ₹ 807 lakhs including the amount
encashed Bank Guarantee which has been rejected by the Institute and the agreement with service
providers in February, 2017. No communication has been received from the vendors after contract
was terminated.
During 2018-19, Institute had sent a legal notice dated 31.10.2018 to the vendor requiring it to pay
an amount of ₹ 2,140.79 lakhs along with applicable interest towards loss incurred on account of non
execution of the project. The vendor in its response dated 20.03.2019 has contested that claim of
Institute is time barred.
The opinion from the legal advisor has been placed before the Competent Authority for further
necessary direction in the matter.
24.07 Land measuring 225 sq. mtrs area of ICAI Bhawan Faridabad, had been acquired by DMRC in
January 2013 for which, Faridabad branch had requested for another piece of land, adjacent to the
branch in compensation against the acquisition by DMRC. The matter is currently under
consideration by Haryana Urban Development Authority.
24.08 A detailed review of the various reserve funds and earmarked funds created in the earlier years and
related earmarked investments has been taken up to restructure these funds as per the present
requirements and functioning of the Institute.
24.09 In the case of inter unit accounts relating to income and expenditure heads, the unreconciled
differences aggregate to ₹ 464 Lakhs in debit and ₹ 478 Lakhs in credit, Net difference being ₹ 14
Lakhs. Pending completion of reconciliation, the amount of net difference of ₹ 14 Lakhs has been
included under 'Provision for Inter branch reconciliation account' in Trade Payable.
In the case of inter unit accounts relating to assets and liabilities, the unreconciled differences
aggregate to ₹ 2842 Lakhs in debit and ₹ 3004 Lakhs in credit. The net difference of ₹ 162 Lakhs
has been included under 'Provision for Inter branch reconciliation account' in Trade Payable.
24.10 In view of the Management, the study circles, study chapters and overseas chapters are separate
entities and their accounts are not consolidated.
24.11 Steps have been taken to carry out physical verification of fixed assets and reconciliation with books
balances at the Head office and the Branches.
24.12 The Branch Employees Scheme 2006 has been replaced by new Branch Employees Scheme 2014
which has been approved by the Central Council but not yet implemented. Since 2014-15, a
provision of ₹ 700 lakhs per year is being made in the accounts adding upto ₹ 4200 lakhs as on
March 31, 2020. The shortfall / excess of provision will be determined when the revised scheme is
fully implemented.
Some of the branches have deducted PF contribution from the branch employees. Pending approval
of the registration of the 5 Regional Provident Fund Trust from the Income Tax Department, the
amount of PF along with matching employer contribution of ₹ 103 lakhs could not be deposited with
the PF Trust. However, the aforesaid funds have been invested in separate fixed deposit.
[भाग III—खण्ड4] भारतकाराजपत्र:असाधारण 247
24.13 Consequent to revision of salary and allowances of employees effective 1.1.2016 and 1.7.2017
respectively, a total provision of ₹ 5360 lakhs was made up to financial year 2018-19. Pending final
review and decision on this matter, ₹ 1,071 lakhs have been paid to the employees as advance till
FY 2018-19.
24.14 An amount of ₹ 987 Lakhs (₹ 1213 Lakhs) including ineligible input tax credit, input credit attributable
to exempted supplies and ₹ 52 lakhs of interest on delayed payments has been charged off to the
Income and Expenditure Account as ‘GST Expenses’. GST payable at the end of the year of ₹ 724
Lakhs (₹ 784 Lakhs) has been included under other liabilities (Note No.8) and amount of ₹ 2032
Lakhs (₹ 1230 Lakhs) as GST input credit recoverable has been shown under ‘Loans and Advances
(Note No.14)
24.15 As per the estimates made in FY 2018-19, the Institute is likely to incur an estimated expenditure of
₹ 4,500 Lakhs for holding World Congress of Accountants in the year 2022 in India. It was decided
that out of surplus of the year 2018-19 and next two years, ₹ 1,500 Lakhs will be appropriated to a
separate close ended fund to meet the financial requirements to organize the conference. The
expenditure incurred each year will be debited to designated account ‘Expenditure on WCOA -2022’
and an equivalent amount will be transferred to the appropriation account from the said fund every
year.
24.16 During the year, Institute has earmarked ₹ 10,000 lakhs towards creation of separate fund for the
need based & economically weaker section Scholarships under Student Skills Enrichment Board
(Board of Studies- Operations) and allocated investments of ₹ 10,000 lakhs for meeting scholarship
expenses from its Interest Income of the above fund.
24.17 During the year, the detailed listings of advance fee received from members amounting to ₹ 2,366
Lakhs out of ₹ 3,112 Lakhs and fee for distance education ₹ 9,471 Lakhs received from the students
was reconciled and the necessary accounting effect taken in the books of accounts.The balance of ₹
746 lakhs is advance from members pertaining to earlier years which is under reconciliation.
24.18 As per Regulation 197 of The Chartered Accountants Regulations 1988, the auditors of the Council
are required to compare the actual income and expenditure with the budget estimates approved by
the Council and submit a report to the Council on the material departures. Steps are being taken to
comply with this requirement in the near future.
24.19 The Institute is in the process of receiving information from vendors regarding their status under the
Micro Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 and hence disclosure relating to
amounts unpaid as at the period end together with interest paid or payable under this Act has not
been given.
24.20 During the year, ₹ 1076 lakhs (10% of Annual and Certificate of Practice Fee) [P.Y. ₹ 2138 lakhs
being 20% of Annual and Certificate of Practice Fee] out of Membership Fee received was
transferred to the Members Benevolent Fund.
24.21 Other expenditure includes ₹ 156 lakhs (₹ 114 lakhs) being the reimbursement of costs incurred by
Quality Review Board constituted under section 28-A of The Chartered Accountants Act, 1949.
Other expenses also include contribution of ₹ 60 lakhs (₹ 60 lakhs) made to the Appellate Authority
constituted under Section 22 of the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949. Expenses of the Quality
Review Board and the Appellate Tribunal are required to be borne by the Institute. Other expenses
also include grant of ₹ 15 lakhs (₹ 15 lakhs) made to Extensible Business Reporting Languages
(XBRL) .
24.22 COVID-19 pandemic has been rapidly spreading throughout the world, including India. Government
of India have been taking significant measures to curb the spread of the virus including imposing
mandatory lockdowns and restrictions in the activities. Consequently, as per the directions of
Government of India, Institute had also partially closed down its physical operations, and facilitated
the students to pursue the Chartered Accountancy Course though online mode and also used this
opportunity to educate / upgrade the knowledge about various regulations/ regulatory requirements
through regular conduct of webinar for various topics/ streams relating to its profession for its
members.
As the lockdown was declared in the last week of March 2020, the revenue for the quarter ended
March 2020 has not been materially impacted because major activities for FY 2019-20 were
248 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART III—SEC. 4]
completed by then. Continued lockdowns and considering the safety of the students in these critical
conditions, ICAI decided to defer the May 2020 examination to the next cycle November 2020, which
will marginally impact the financials. ICAI is exploring all options for students to catch up on this
lapsed examination attempt.
The ICAI is monitoring the situation closely taking into account directives from the Government.
Management believes that it has taken into account all the possible impacts of known events arising
from COVID-19 pandemic and the resultant lockdown will not affect the going concern, and no
implication to its property, plant and equipment, intangible assets, and the net realisable values of
other assets.
However, given the effect of these lockdowns on the overall economic activity in India, the impact
assessment of COVID-19 on the above-mentioned financial statement captions is subject to
significant estimation uncertainties given its nature and duration and accordingly, the actual impact
in future may be different from those estimated as at the date of approval of these financial
statements. ICAI will continue to monitor any material changes to future economic conditions and
consequential impact on its financial results
Disclosure under Accounting Standards
25 Employee Benefits
Defined Benefit plans
The Institute has recognised an amount of ₹ 676.50 lakhs for the year ended March 31, 2020
(Previous year ₹ 858.14 lakhs) towards contribution to Provident Fund.
The Institute has provided the following defined benefit plans to its
employees Gratuity : Funded
Post retirement Pension : Non-Funded
Compensated Absence: Non-Funded
25.1 Details of the Gratuity Plan are as follows ( ₹ in Lakhs)
Description 2019-20 2018-19 2017-18 2016-17
1. Reconciliation of opening and closing
balances of obligation
a. Obligation as at beginning of the year 3,905 3,298 2,510 2,358
b. Current service cost 279 266 1,102 202
c. Interest cost 272 239 176 166
d. Actuarial (gain)/loss 208 442 (204) 44
e. Benefits paid (661) (340) (286) (260)
f. Obligation as at end of the year 4,003 3,905 3,298 2,510
Investment details
5. % invested % invested % invested % invested
a. Others - Funds with Life Insurance
100 100 100 100
Corporation of India
Assumptions
6.
a. Discount rate (per annum)
6.75% 7.62% 7.65% 7.45%
b. Estimated rate of return on plan
7.62% 7.65% 7.45% 7.45%
assets (per annum)
c. Rate of escalation in salary
Basic 3% : Basic 3% : Basic 3% : Basic 3% :
d. Attrition rate DA 6% DA 6% DA 6% DA 6%
e. Mortality table 2% 2% 2% 5%
IAL 2012-14 IAL 2012-14 IAL 2006-08 IAL 2006-08
Ultimate Ultimate Ultimate Ultimate
4. Assumptions
a. Discount rate (per annum) 6.75% 7.60% 7.50% 7.30%
b. Mortality table LIC 1996-98 LIC 1996-98 LIC 1996-98 LIC 1996-98
Ultimate Ultimate Ultimate Ultimate
26 Segment Reporting
The Institute's operations are confined to "regulation of the profession of Chartered
Accountancy" and predominantly spread in India. Hence all its operations fall under single
segment within the meaning of Accounting Standard (AS) - 17 Segment Reporting.
27 Previous year's figures have been regrouped / reclassified wherever necessary to correspond
with the current year's classification / disclosure.
Sd/- Sd/-
CA. Rajeev Bansal CA. Deepak Gupta
Partner, Membership No. 088598 Partner, Membership No. 516002
New Delhi, 24th September, 2020.
Uploaded by Dte. of Printing at Government of India Press, Ring Road, Mayapuri, New Delhi-110064
and Published by the Controller of Publications, Delhi-110054.