Pilotage Pre-Planning Guide: Part 4 - Mooring and Unmooring
Pilotage Pre-Planning Guide: Part 4 - Mooring and Unmooring
Pilotage Pre-Planning Guide: Part 4 - Mooring and Unmooring
planning guide
PART 4 – MOORING
AND UNMOORING
Foreword 7
About Danpilot 9
1. Preface 11
1.1 Other guides 12
5. Mooring in general 21
5.1 Types and designs of port areas 21
5.2 Types and designs of quays 23
5.3 Tanker terminals 25
5.3.1 Safety of moorings - Tankers 25
5.4 Types and design of fenders/bollards/hooks/winches on quays 26
5.4.1 Fender type 26
5.4.2 Example of fenders 29
5.4.3 Example of ships bollard, Bits and rollers. 29
5.5 Forces impacting the ship; wind, current and passing ships. 31
5.5.1 Example showing calculation of wind impact 33
5.5.2 Example showing the link between underkeel clearance
and forces impacting the ship 36
5.5.3 General terms in connection with mooring 37
5.6 Lines and wire / forces and elasticity 39
5.6.1 Different mooring materials 39
5.6.2 The elasticity of mooring materials 40
5.6.3 A detailed description of the characteristics of the mooring types41
5.6.4 Abilities of the mooring materials 42
5.7 Ideal mooring 44
5.7.1 Agreement of mooring-plan 45
5.8 Modern mooring methods 45
5.9 Determination of the number of mooring lines 46
5.9.1 SOLAS determination of terms 47
5.9.2 DNV’s guideline on the subject 49
5.9.3 Calculation of the EN number 49
5.9.4 Example of calculation for a panmax 49
6. Communication 55
7. Safety and safety recommendations. 57
7.1 Lines breaking 59
7.2 Heavy lifts 59
7.3 Heaving lines and things that may “fall down” 60
7.4 Examples of objects that may cause accidents 61
7.4.1 Examples of mooring objects that often cause accidents
- seen from ashore 61
7.4.2 Examples of mooring objects that often cause accidents
- seen from the ship 62
7.5 10 Rules of thumb for the crew on board the vessel (Seahealth) 63
Dear Reader
Firstly, I wish to thank you for selecting DanPilot as your service provider, we are
honored by the confidence vested in us.
By working with DanPilot for your transit pilotage through Danish waters, I wish
to assure you that you are in the most capable hands at all times, and that the Pilot
boarding your vessel is a highly skilled and experienced master mariner, with an
in-depth knowledge of the areas you will be navigating together.
Danish waters can be tricky to navigate, and are subject to intense traffic, crossing
ferries, low and variable draughts and strong currents. This is why the IMO official-
ly recommends making use of a Pilot when navigating through Great Belt for any
vessel with a draft of 11.0 m or more, or through Sound for tankers with a draft of
7.0 m or more. Fortunately, many vessels make use of a Pilot even with less draft
than the IMO Recommendation, in order to ensure themselves and their cargo a
safe and smooth transit through the Danish waters.
When boarding, the Pilot will bring along a “PPU” – Portable Pilot Unit – which is
a state-of-the-art navigation solution, ensuring that your vessel will navigate
through the optimal routing during transit. All our pilotages (more than 20.000 per
year) are stored, and the data is used for further education of our Pilots and optimi-
zation of the routings through Danish waters.
7
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
To ensure that we are capable of meeting the ever rising demands, DanPilot are
continuously investing in upgrading of our fully-owned fleet of pilot boats, and the
coming years from 2017-2019 will see delivery of a large number of new pilot boats,
designed with the purpose of delivering maximum performance year round, re-
gardless of weather and location.
As a Not For Profit organization, owned fully by the Danish State, our mission is
to safeguard the environment, and all vessels and crews passing through Danish
waters.
Being the only pilotage provider in Denmark having obtained ISO 9001 certifi-
cation for quality, DanPilot is your guarantee for the highest level of professional
services, and strict adherence to regulations regarding training, certification and
resting hours – all with the sole purpose of giving our customers the optimal safety.
It is my hope that you will be fully satisfied with the services rendered onboard your
vessel by our Pilot, and I invite any comments at any time as well as any suggestions
on how DanPilot can continue to improve our services towards you – our customer.
Please feel free to contact me anytime.
Yours Sincerely
8
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
About DanPilot
Established more than 450 years ago, pilotage is an ancient profession in Danish
waters. In the beginning, many small providers were present in the market, which
were later merged to 3 separate companies.
In 2006, the remaining 3 companies were merged into one; DanPilot, and in June
2013 DanPilot assumed the responsibilities of the Danish State Pilotage Service as
directed by the Act on DanPilot (Parliament Act no. 600 of 12 June 2013), DanPi-
lot is an independent state-owned company, responsible for pilotage in all Danish
waters and ports.
With the primary mission of safeguarding the environment, and ensuring safe pas-
sage for all vessels operating in Danish waters, DanPilot conducts more than 20.000
pilotages each year and is highly regarded by our customers for our expertise and
service.
Currently serving more than 60 ports and transit pilotage through all Danish straits
and waters, DanPilot is a dedicated full service provider, capable of delivering Pilot
anywhere in Denmark on a short notice and at a competitive cost.
Our 170+ highly skilled and experienced marine Pilots are all master mariners with
extensive experience from the international merchant fleet, backed with a solid
knowledge of the local waters and ports, delivering the optimal safety and efficient
9
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
operation of your vessel. Our Pilots are continuously subjected to extensive training
and knowledge sharing to ensure that we are always up-to-date on the latest infor-
mation. In addition, we operate our own fleet of capable pilot vessels, making cer-
tain that we can deliver a Pilot anywhere at any time, regardless of weather and sea.
Always available 24/7/365, we are always at the ready to assist your vessel, whether
for port pilotage or transit pilotage.
Due to the above, we are confident in our vision to be the most reliable pilot service
in Europe, and to promise to you that
10
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
1. Preface
With this guide, Danpilot wants to discuss various aspects of mooring operations
seen from the perspective of the ship as well as the person ashore and in relation
to the pilot's tasks during mooring, which include communication with external
operators - in other words, all aspects of the mooring operation, the ship/quay/
terminal, crew on board and mooring personnel ashore as a complete co-operation
in connection with a mooring operation on arrival or departure from a given quay/
terminal.
The guide is primarily for internal use for port pilots, but it may also be used extern
ally as inspiration for other interested parties. The guide should also be regarded
as a guideline for the way in which we deal with the subject of ”mooring” during
pilotage operations, i.e. advice and recommendations for the master and crew and
communication with mooring personnel on the quay/terminal.
The guide does not cover the entire subject of mooring since there are already a
multitude of guides and material on the subject. Reference is made to all these
11
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
guides and regulations in the last section of this guide. OCIMF (Oil Companies
International Marine Forum), P and I clubs, IMO and others have published com-
prehensive material on mooring. However, it should be mentioned that mooring
operations are rarely seen as a combined operation where the ship/persons ashore
carry out a joint task.
Quote from Foreword MEG4 Fourth Edition 2018, Steve Clinch MNM (MEG;Mooring
Equipment guidelines, OCIMF)
“Each year many seafarers and terminals operators are injured, or worse, when
mooring lines fail under tension. In the ten years between 2007 and 2016 the Ma-
rine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) received 37 such reports. In five years
between 2009 and 2014, another major maritime nation recorded more than 90
accidents in its ports involving broken mooring lines, with two lives lost. That these
statistics are reported by just two of the many maritime authorities around the
world suggest a much larger problem, which has been reflected by recent extensive
discussions within the industry and at the International MRITIME Organization
(IMO)”
Other guides
In addition to this guide, Danpilot has also prepared other guides, and reference
is made to pre-planning guide I - Transit, and pre-planning guide II- Ports, which
include a description of best practice for BRM, good communication and other
mooring-related information.
12
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
2. Danpilot’s recommendations
for Danish ports/terminals
13
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
5) All mooring bollards and hooks/winches must bear clear indication of SWL and
be in a good state of maintenance and fully functional.
6) Fendering on the quays must be designed to withstand the forces by which the
types of ships that come alongside the quay impact the quay structure and by
which the ship is exposed from current/wind etc.
7) The port must state the maximum permitted speed by which the ship must come
alongside the quay with indication of ship size etc.
8) Berth length must be designed for the type of ship to come alongside/depart
from the quay and, where required, maximum limitations must be stated.
9) The water depths at the quays and basin must be taken regularly and the official
water depths in the nautical chart must be correct and must be used as a basis for
calculation of max. draught on arrival/departure.
14
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
2) Danpilot’s recommendation that all personal safety equipment for mooring per-
sonnel must always be in order during the operations.
15
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
16
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
During the mooring operation on departure or arrival, the pilot will often act as a
liaison between the ship’s master/bridge team and the people on the quay.
It is therefore important that the pilot creates good communication between the
ship's crew and the people on the quay. As in all other situations involving bridge
team, an effort must be made to ensure that communication is based on the theory
of ’closed loop communication’ in order to minimise sources of error and
misunderstanding of a given notification/order.
4.1 On arrival
Before coming alongside a quay/terminal, the pilot must review any rules and
practices that apply when coming alongside the specific quay/terminal with the
ship's master/bridge team. In Denmark, the ports are obliged to prepare rules
applicable to the port. In addition to the mandatory rules, most major ports also
have other information on the port and the quays.
17
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
• Wind
• Current
• Tides
• Surges from passing ships
• Waves/swell
• Ice
• Changes in draft, trim or list.
18
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
19
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
20
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
5. Mooring in general
The mooring operation depends greatly on the location of the port and its exposure
to weather forces. Here are a few examples of port set-ups. Ports facing the open sea
are particularly exposed. Quays located so that other ships pass by moored ships are
also exposed to any suction from these passing ships.
21
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
22
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
The following information should be available to ports and terminals via web access:
Wind direction
Wind force
Water level
Temperature
A current meter should also be available at ports where the current affects mano-
euvring and mooring
(Wind direction) (Wind speed) (Water level) (Temperature)
23
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
24
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
The above criteria are intended to cover conditions that could readily be encounte-
red on worldwide trade, but they cannot possibly cater for the most extreme combi-
nation of environmental conditions at every terminal. At exposed terminals, or
those where for some reason the criteria are likely to be exceeded, the ship’s
mooring restraint should be supplemented with appropriate shore-based equip-
ment.
Although responsibility for the adequate mooring of a tanker rests with the master,
the terminal has an interest in ensuring that vessels are securely and safely moored.
Cargo hoses or arms should not be connected until both the terminal representative
and the master are satisfied that the ship is safely moored.
25
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
*) As a vessel makes contact with the berth and its movement is suddenly stopped
by the fenders, the mass of water moving with the vessel adds to the energy posses-
sed by the vessel This is called “Mass Factor” and the weight of the water is generally
called “Additional Weight”
26
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
27
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Figure 5 – different types of fenders and their energy absorption ability. Source: PIANC
Different types of energy absorbing elastic deformation rubber unit. Source: PIANC
28
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
29
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Mooring points
30
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Types:
T head
Stag horn
Sing le Bitt
Double Bitt
Sing le Bitt 360°
Kidney
Tricorn
Cleats
5.5 Forces impacting the ship; wind, current and passing ships
The forces impacting the ship are wind and current and places where ships are
alongside the quay and are passed by other ships at “small” distances. These also
impact moored ships.
The wind impact depends on the wind force and the wind direction in relation
to the total surface of the ship. This is called the ship's total wind area. Below are
some theoretical and static examples. The current impact also depends on force and
direction in relation to the ship/quay. Furthermore, the relationship between the
water depth and the ship’s actual draught is also a significant factor – the smaller the
distance, the greater the force.
31
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
The table below (figure 7) includes some ’rough’ guidelines for impact caused by
wind (60 knots and current 3 knots ahead or 0,75 knots abeam).
32
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Figure 8 – Velocity of the wind as a function of the altitude and the relief
Of course, ports that are surrounded by buildings etc. have some protection with
respect to wind impact – this correlation may be seen above in figure 8.
33
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Wind area in sq m
1000 2000 4000 5000 6000 8000 9000 10000 12000 13000 14000 16000
2,06 0,3 0,6 1,3 1,6 1,9 2,6 2,9 3,2 3,8 4,2 4,5 5,1
5,14 2 4 8 10 12 16 18 20 24 26 28 32
8,23 5,1 10,2 20,5 25,6 30,7 41 46,1 51,2 61,4 66,6 71,7 81
m/sek
KWind = k * A * V²
K = Wind force in tonnes
k = Constant depending on the ship and direction of the wind
A = Windage area in sq.meters
V = Relative velocity of the wind in m/sec
Average k
k= 0,52 * 10-4 for a beam wind and
k= 0,39 * 10-4 for a longitudinal wind
Example of % rising of wind effect from 8 m/sec to 11 m/sec
8² = 64 and 11²= 121 = 89% increasing
34
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
35
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
36
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
37
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Figure 12a – Illustrative explanation of general term for a tanker mooring set-up
38
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Characteristics og each kind of synthetic line, compared to steel wire with the same
diameter
HMPE Polyamide
High Modulus Polyethylene, Dynema, Nylon
Spectra 30% as strong as steel wire
Similar to steel for strength and stretch Does not float, stretches more readily
Light, floats on water than other fibres
Melting point 150°C Melting point 215-250°C
Aramid Polypropylene
Kevlar 60% as strong as polyester
75% as strong as steel wire Floats, reasonably durable and cheap
Heavier than HMPE and does not float Melting point 165°C
Melting point 425°C
Polyester
Dacron, Terylene
30% as strong as steel wire
Heavier than HMPE and does not
float but is flexible and durable
Melting point 250°C
Polyolefin
30% as strong as steel wire
Light, floats on water
Melting point 170°C Figure 13 – Different mooring materials compared to
steelwires – Source: Seahealth, Denmark
39
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Fig. 14 shows the elasticity (elongation) of the same mooring types as a function of
minimum breaking load.
40
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Brand new 100% Retaining Strength
approx 60%
Retaining strength Retaining Strength
approx 85% approx 50%
Retaining Strength
Retaining Strength approx 45%
approx 70%
Polyamide
Also known as nylon will sink in water and will also absorb water-adding weight to
the rope. This sinking might pose a problem as the rope could get entangled with
a propeller. The absorbed water will reduce the MBF (Minimum Breaking Force,
which is the force required for equipment failure) by 20%. Polyamide mooring lines
also have large elasticity, which may result in a large backlash, which can be
dangerous. The material does have high heat resistance, a low elongation and
excellent strength-to-weight ratio.
41
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Polyester
The mechanical characteristics resemble that of nylon rope, but it is more resistant
to water. The density of polyester is relatively high, but the absorbing capacity is
higher than that of polyamide lines. This will make it more suitable for absorbing
large force variation. Also, it is very durable in both wet and dry conditions, which
makes it quite expensive.
Steel cables
Steel cables are used where the circumstances allow or demand it, such as mooring
wires for tankers and bulk carriers, towing wires for fishing and tugboats. The cable is
strong, cheap, has little elongation under tension and has a high wear resistance. The
disadvantages of steel cable are that they are heavy and will suffer from corrosion.
42
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
As is evident from the drawing below (Figure 16), it is very important to ensure that
the correct number of mooring lines have been used to moor the ship and to be
aware that both the vertical and the horizontal angles of the mooring lines affect the
restraint capacity, i.e. what they are able to withstand.
43
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
This mooring is based on a typical tanker terminal but the maximum angles that are
recommended here may of course also be used for non-tanker terminal (not
tankers). For ordinary quays, it will probably be very difficult to observe the follow-
ing requirements. However, it is recommended that this is used as a good guideline
for non-tanker terminals.
44
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Mooring-plan to be agreed
before final approach
We are gradually seeing more types of equipment that have replaced mooring lines.
Under references, we have included a random selection of these possibilities. In Da-
nish ports, we have not yet seen any significant progress in this area but only a few
ferry terminals that use such systems.
45
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
In Figure 21 below, the ship itself (the barge) has been provided with mooring
equipment to replace the traditional lines/wire).
46
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
For oil tankers, chemical tankers, bulk carriers and ore carriers the total number of
head, stern and breast lines should be taken as:
n = 8.3·10-4 · A1 + 4
The total number of head, stern and breast lines should be rounded to the nearest
whole number.
As can be seen, the working group does not quite agree with OCIMF's new book
MEG4 on designations, and the final outcome has been postponed to the next
meeting of the IMO on the subject.
There is also news on ”tow” vs. swl – see below. This is a subject that has been
discussed countless times, but the ships continue to moor as they have always done
– although it is incorrect and results in a much smaller indication of swl (now tow).
The following is based on the “Revised SOLAS regulation II-1/3-8 and associated
guidelines (MSC.1/CIRC.1175) and new guidelines for Safe mooring operations for
all ships.
SDC 6/3 25 October 2018
47
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Determination of terms:
Line Design Break Force (LDBF) means the minimum force at which a new, dry,
spliced mooring line will break. This is for all synthetic cordage materials.
Ship Design Minimum Breaking Load (MBLSD) means the minimum breaking
load of new, dry, mooring lines for which shipboard fittings and supporting hull
structures are designed in order to meet mooring restraint requirements.
Working Load Limit (WLL) means the maximum load that a mooring line should
be subjected to in operational service, calculated from the relevant environmental
mooring restraint requirement.]
Towing and mooring arrangements plan means the plan as described in section 5 of
the annex to the Revised guidance on shipboard towing and mooring equipment
48
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Appendix B
Equipment number
49
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
NOTES:
1. When calculating h, sheer and trim should be ignored, i.e. h is the sum of free-
board amidships plus the height (at centreline) of each tier of houses having a
breadth greater than B/4.
2. If a house having a breadth greater than B/4 is above a house with a breadth of
B/4 or less, then the wide house should be included but the narrow house ignored.
4. The equipment length of the ships is the length between perpendiculars but
should not be less than 96% nor greater than 97% of the extreme length on the
Summer Waterline (measured from the forward end of the waterline).
50
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
2. Calculation of "H"
a = D - Ts = 20.9 - 13.8 = 7.1 m Σhi = 2.9 + 2.8 x 4 = 14.4 m (heights of accommoda-
tion decks) H = a + Σhi = 7.1 + 14.1
H= 21.2 m
3. Calculation of "A"
Main Hull = 216.362 x 7.1 = 1,536.17 sq.m On Upper Deck = 15.2 x 2.9 = 44.08
sq.m On A-Deck = 24.8 x 2.8 = 69.44 sq.m On B-Deck = 15.2 x 2.8 = 42.56 sq.m On
C-Deck = 15.2 x 2.8 = 42.56 sq.m Nav.Deck = 14.8 x 2.8 = 41.44 sq.m Engine casing
(upper) = 8.4 x 2.9 = 24.36 sq.m Engine casing (B) = 7.2 x 3.9 = 28.08 sq.m
Total of "A" = 1,828.69 sq.m
1. Principal Particulars
51
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
2. Calculation of "H"
a = D – Ts
= 20,9 – 13,8
= 7,1m
∑
H = a + hi
= 20,9 – 13,8
3. Calculation of "A"
52
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
53
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
54
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
6. Communication
Closed loop
Loop
Why would we like the communication between the ship and persons ashore to take
place according to the above model?
When orders are given on the bridge of a ship between the bridge team and the
pilot, it always takes place by means of this method - this minimises misunderstand
ing of orders. During manoeuvring, many persons have to be kept informed and it
is therefore important to keep the communication as short and clear as possible and
to clearly indicate if something has not been understood properly.
55
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Here is a list of the persons with whom the pilot communicates during operations.
56
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
We often focus on the things that go wrong and analyse them. We also have a
chapter on subjects that often cause accidents so we are in no way an exception.
We would, however, like to promote the more recent approach to the subject of
safety - looking at the many times when things go well and why, and to learn from it.
Fortunately, at most ports, the persons involved in mooring operations know what
they are doing and things therefore usually go well. However, we cannot omit to
mention that sometimes episodes occur that are regarded as near misses, for
example linesmen standing too close to weight-bearing lines/wire. We therefore
recommend that snap-back zones are taken seriously and that the persons in
question keep an appropriate distance from weight-bearing lines/wire, wait and
agree when it is “safe” to start an operation at a mooring site. IMO International
ship and port facility security code ans SOLAS Amendments of 12 december 2002
Arrival
The pilot notifies the mooring personnel as early as possible of the plan for the
coming arrival at a given quay. The number of mooring lines that are expected to
be used and the order and types of lines/wire on the ship. It is also agreed/notified
57
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
whether a heaving line or messenger will be used, and it is agreed whether a line
boat will be used. Depending on the line types, it is agreed whether one or two
lines can be fed at a time. Everything is repeated and confirmed, see Chapter 6. The
linesmen notify the pilot/ship if they observe anything in the quay area that may
interfere with the mooring. The mooring operation should proceed at a calm pace
both on board and ashore, especially during the winter half of the year where it may
be slippery on the ship and ashore The ship’s final position at the quay must often
be relatively exact (especially tankers loading/unloading via hard arm - Chiksan),
and the linesmen (on terminals, it is often the terminal staff who assign the position
and, in some ports, the port’s port assistants) inform the pilot/ship of the distance
in metres from the position until the ship is correctly positioned in relation to the
designated berth.
Departure
In the same way as arrival, the pilot/ship/linesmen agree on the order in which the
mooring lines will be cast off. The ’single up principle’ is often used, but in this con-
nection it should be mentioned that if you single up to 1/1 ahead and astern, and
the ship is exposed to forces of wind/current, the remaining lines suddenly have to
withstand great forces involving a risk of breaking unless you have tugs or the ship's
own manoeuvre components to compensate for the brief but significant impact on
the mooring lines.
As the mooring lines become slack and an order has been given to let them go asho-
re the linesmen will advise both ahead and astern when the lines are “free” of the
water and especially astern when the propeller is ready, i.e. no mooring lines in the
water or near the propeller/thrusters.
58
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
59
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
The below chart shows the height of an object and a given dropped height as a fun-
ction of the weight of the object. When focusing on these two parameters, it may be
seen that even relatively light objects may cause great personal injury.
60
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Inadequate assessment of tidal situation and effect of bow thruster, tug and propel-
ler wash when sending lines away.
Failure to recognise risk of line boat getting trapped between ship and quay, par-
ticularly with onshore wind or tide.
Ropes being paid out from winch drums getting trapped and heaved back in, in-
stead of paying out.
Sending heavy lines or wires as first lines ashore, often with vessel still moving
alongside the berth.
Not watching what's happening on the jetty, due to having an inadequate number of
personnel on bow/stern, making assumptions and failing to warn.
Failure to appreciate the risk to shore personnel working within the snap-back zo-
nes on the jetty.
Heaving in lines at high speed without warning the shore crew, or while they are
still in an unsafe position.
Not allowing shore crew enough time to get a jammed rope off the bollard before
starting to heave it in.
61
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Failure to give due regard to difficulties in both taking and letting go wire ropes with
fibre tails and Mandel shackles.
Failure to consider safety of both ship and shore mooring crew when:
a. Unberthing as the number of lines is reduced and risk of failure increases on
remaining lines;
b. Springing a ship off the berth.
Linesmen berthing/unberthing
Poor overview, crossing line, lines in mess on mooring boat, line thrown without
telling linesmen, strong current, mess on the quay, line caught in fender, bad
lighting, poor communication between pilot & captain & tug, line comes off bollard
– steep angle, line round propeller, several lines on same bollard.
Work processes:
Lack of communication and planning
Poor wire/line handling
Crew qualifications:
Lack of knowledge about the hazards of the job
Unclear instructions
Lack of information
Lack of supervision (supervisor involved elsewhere)
Small, untrained deck crew
Ineffective on-board mooring training, without identifying and understanding
the dangers associated with snap-back zones
62
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
concentration:
Stress and fatigue
Weather:
Icy, slippery deck
7.5 10 Rules of thumb for the crew on board the vessel (Seahealth)
Always wear the correct personal protective equipment (PPE), which is an impor-
tant part of proper preparation considering that PPE is the last line of defence.
Always consider whether you are in a snap-back zone and never stand on either an
open line or a closed bight of line.
Keep an eye out for all members of the team. If you think they are in an unsafe posi-
tion, alert them.
All operations need to be carried out calmly without rushing about. Rushing leads
to slips, trips and falls.
Never lose sight of what is going on around you and have an escape route from any
likely danger (that is, avoid being trapped against the bulwark or other obstacle
when a line parts).
63
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Always put an eye onto a bollard or bitts by holding the eye either on its side or by a
messenger line to avoid getting fingers trapped against the bollard if the line sud-
denly snaps tight.
Never heave blindly on a line when no one is watching what is happening at the
other end.
Never try to be heroic by jumping onto a line that is clearly running over the side
and out of control as you are likely to go overboard with it.
Never run more than one line around a fairlead sheave as the lines chafe through
more quickly and the sheave is really only strong enough to take the load of a single
line under tension.
Never use any equipment that is obviously faulty. If you notice damage, then it
should be reported and an alternative arrangement for the mooring line used.
Never let go of a mooring line under heavy load without determining first why the
load is so heavy and then taking the proper precautions if it must be let go.
64
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
65
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
66
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
67
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
The European members of the IBLA are also members of the European Boatmen
Association, called EBA.
• http://ibla.info/certifications/
Mooring – do it safely
• http://www.marinedocs.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/Mooring-Do-It-Sa-
fely.pdf
2 Legislation – Danish
Heavy lifts
• https://amid.dk/media/1756/d-3-1-loeft-traek-skub20pdf.pdf
Workplace assessment
• https://arbejdstilsynet.dk/da/arbejdspladsvurdering
68
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Safety in mooring
• https://www.iadc-dredging.com/ul/cms/terraetaqua/docu-
ment/4/8/5/485/485/1/article-safety-in-mooring-143-2.pdf
OCIMF – guide-to-purchasing-high-modulus-synthetic-fibre-mooring
• https://www.ocimf.org/media/53251/guide-to-purchasing-high-modu-
lus-synthetic-fibre-mooring-lines-februar.pdf
69
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
Video – Longview
• https://www.fleetmon.com/maritime-news/2018/22881/snapped-mooring-li-
ne-bulk-carrier-killed-1-wounded/
Mooring accident
• https://www.nautinst.org/en/forums/mars/mars-2012.cfm/mooring%20Accidents
70
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
5 Guidelines
Safety folder for mooring
• http://operasjonsmanual.norog.no/selskapspesifikke/equinor/Englis-
h/B/B-09%20Safety%20folder%20for%20mooring%20operations.pdf
Forebyg arbejdsulykker
• https://amid.dk/media/3610/kvikguide_ulykker.pdf
Vejledning af havnesikring
• https://www.trafikstyrelsen.dk/~/media/Dokumenter/11%20Havne/Vejled-
ning%20om%20havnesikring.pdf
71
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
6 Practical guidelines
Master’s guide – Berthing
• http://www.standard-club.com/media/24148/AMastersGuidetoBerthing2ndedi-
tion-2.pdf
Mooring speeds/ships/quay
• https://static1.squarespace.com/static/55bc3028e4b002b451bfd436/t/
55c31853e4b0a0eb283c28e9/1438849107353/Berthing+Velocities+and+Brols-
ma%27s+Curves.pdf
Closed-loop communication
• https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closed-loop_communication
72
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
The ShoreTension
• https://shoretension.com/
The ShoreTension
• https://shoretension.com/
73
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
I http://www.trykteamepub.dk/epub/DanPilot_Transit_Passage_Plan/
II http://trykteamepub.dk/epub/DanPilot_Habour_Plan/
III www.seahealth.dk/en
IV
https://www.ocimf.org/meg4.aspx
V
https://rules.dnvgl.com/docs/pdf/dnvgl/ru-ship/2017-01/DNVGL-RU-SHIP-
Pt3Ch11.pdf
VI Revised solas regulation II-1/3-8 and associated guidelines (MSC.1/CIRC.1175)
and new guidelines for safe mooring operations for all ships
SDC 6/3 25 October 2018
https://www.ukchamberofshipping.com/documents/1448/SDC_6-3_-_Safe_
Mooring.pdf
VII https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQixvZxvupM
VIII
http://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Facilitation/docs/FAL%20related%20non-
mandatory%20instruments/FAL.6-CIRC.11-REV.1.pdf
IX
http://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Facilitation/docs/FAL%20related%20non-
mandatory%20instruments/FAL.6-CIRC.11-REV.1.pdf
X
https://issuu.com/aktofylakas/docs/imo_standard_marine_communication_
phrases
XI
https://www.trafikstyrelsen.dk/DA/Havne-og-VVM/MaritimSikring/pre-ar-
rival-information.aspx
XII
http://eum.nu/files/Denmark,-Port-Facility-Number.pdf
74
PILOTAGE PRE-PLANNING GUIDE
75
Mission: - Safeguarding
our customers’ vessels
and the environment