Chapter-Vii Additional Studies
Chapter-Vii Additional Studies
Chapter-Vii Additional Studies
CHAPTER–VII
ADDITIONAL STUDIES
1.
7.2 PUBLIC CONSULTATION
Public hearing is yet to be conducted.
7.3 RISK ASSESSMENT
Industrial accident results in great personal & financial loss. Managing these accidental risks in today's
environment is the concern of every industry, because either real or perceived incidents can quickly
jeopardize the financial viability of a business. Many facilities involve various manufacturing processes
that have the potential for accidents which may be catastrophic to the plant, work force and
environment or public. The main objective of the risk assessment study is to propose a comprehensive
but simple approach to carry out risk analysis and conducting feasibility studies for planning &
management of industrial prototype hazard analysis in Indian context.
Fire
Fire can be observed in the boiler area, rice husk/coal storage yard, fuel spillage, electrical rooms,
transformer area etc. due to accidental failure scenario.
Explosion
Explosion may lead to release of heat energy & pressure waves. Table below shows tentative list of
damages envisaged due to different heat loads.
Electrocution
Fatal Accident due to carelessness during working hours may lead to electrocution.
Table 7.2
List of damages envisaged at various heat loads
S. Heat loads Type of Damage Intensity
No. (kW/m2) Damage to Equipment Damage to People
1. 37.5 Damage to process equipment 100% lethality in 1 min.
1% lethality in 10 sec
2. 25.0 Minimum energy required to ignite wood 50% Lethality in 1 min. Significant injury
in 10 sec
3. 19.0 Maximum thermal radiation intensity --
allowed on thermally unprotected
equipment
4. 12.5 Minimum energy required to melt plastic 1% lethality in 1 min
tubing
5. 4.0 -- First degree burns, causes pain for
exposure longer than 10 sec
6. 1.6 -- Causes no discomfort on long
exposures
Source: World Bank (1988). Technical Report No. 55: Techniques for Assessing Industrial Hazards. ,
Washington, D.C• The World Bank
Temperature sensitive alarm and protective relays to make alert and disconnect equipment
before overheating is to be considered
Danger from excess current due to overload or short circuit is to be prevented by providing
fuses, circuit breakers, thermal protection
(B) Fuel storage
Rice husk/coal handling unit/Agency will be at minimum 500 meters away from the
residential area, school/colleges, Historical Monuments, Religious Places, Ecological
sensitive area as well as forests area.
Rice husk/coal handling unit will be located at a minimum 500 meters away from the
Railway line, Express ways, National Highways, State Highways and District Roads and from
water bodies like River, Nala, Canal, Pond etc.
The unit will have adequate water supply through pipe/ surface water before selection of
the site. Rice husk/coal storage unit is to be ensured for stacking of Rice husk/coal in heaps.
Adequate dust suppression measures will be provided to prevent fugitive emission and also
risk of fire. Similar measures will also be adopted for loading/unloading operations.
Rice husk/coal ash will be transported in covered and closed vehicles/conveyors so that
there is no chance of spillage during transportation.
Fire fighting measures will be provided to avoid any fire case
Measures will be taken to control the air pollution during loading/handling of the Rice
husk/coal.
(C) Precautionary Measures for Falling material
Safety helmets to be used to protect workers against falling material
Barriers like toe boards or mesh guards is to be provided to prevent items from slipping or
being knocked off the edge of a structure
An exclusion zone will be created beneath areas where work is taking place.
Danger areas are to be clearly marked with suitable safety signs indicating that access is
restricted to essential personnel wearing hard hats while the work is in progress.
(D) Safety measures for storage & handling of alcohol
Handling and storage of alcohol will be done as per prescribed norms. The alcohol will be
directly fed to the storage area and no manual handling will be involved which reduce the
risk of spillage in the storage area. Following precautionary measures would be taken for
safety:
(a) Handling and storage measures
(i) Keeping away from oxidizers, heat and flames.
(ii) Care will be taken for avoidance of spillage, skin and eye contact
(iii) Well ventilation and use of approved respirator if air contamination is above acceptable
level will be promoted.
Inspection
Fire alarm panel (electrical) will cover the entire plant. The inspection group will periodically
inspect fire extinguishers in fire stations and machines and other places.
The groups will display emergency telephone number boards at vital points. The group will
regularly carry out general inspection for fire.
Procedure for extinguishing fire
The following steps will be taken during a fire accident in the system:
As soon as the message is received about fire, one of the systems will be diverted to the
place of the fire accident along with a staff member.
Simultaneously plant fire station will be informed by phone or walkie-talkie for fire brigades
and fire stations of nearby area.
In the meanwhile, the pipe system will be operated to obtain maximum pressure on output.
In case cables are within the reach of fire, power supply will be tripped and the cables
shifted.
Fire fighting with water
Adequate and reliable arrangement is required for fighting the fire with water such as:
Provision for fire brigade and fire hydrant.
Arrangement of pipelines along and around all vulnerable areas.
Provision of valves at appropriate points to enable supply of water at the required
place/area or divert the same to another direction/pipe line.
Provision of overhead tanks which will be providing water during power failure and it would
work by the gravitational force.
Sources of water for fire fighting
The following two sources of water have been considered for firefighting:
Overhead tank
Raw water reservoir
Fire fighting with fire extinguishers
To deal with fire-other than carbonaceous fires, which can be dealt with by water suitable fire
extinguishers are required to do the job effectively. It is therefore necessary to keep adequate
number of extinguishers in readiness at easily approachable places. Adequate number of fire
stations would be provided.
Further, other spray groups from the system will be diverted to the spot.
In case of fire in the belt, belt will be cut near the burning portion to save the remaining
parts.
After extinguishing the fire, the area will be well prepared for reuse.
Foam System for fire fighting will be provided to control fire from the alcohol storage tank.
The foam thus produced will suppress fire by separating the fuel from the air (oxygen) and
hence avoiding the fire & explosion to occur in the tank. Foam would blanket the fuel
surface smothering the fire. The fuel will also be cooled by the water content of the foam.
The foam blanket suppresses the release of flammable vapours that can mix with the air.
This is the phase when impact is almost over and efforts are concentrated on rescue and relief
measures.
Relief Phase
In this phase, apart from organization and relief measures internally, depending on severity of the
disaster, external help are also to be summoned to provide relief measures (like evacuations to a
safe place and providing medical help, food clothing etc.). This phase will continue till normalcy is
restored.
Rehabilitation Phase
This is the final and longest phase. During which measures required to put the situation back to
normal as far as possible are taken. Checking the systems, estimating the damages, repair of
equipment and putting them again into service are taken up. Help from revenue/insurance
authorities need to be obtained to assess the damage, quantum of compensation to be paid etc.
above objective an all-statutory and insurance requirement of Tariff Advisory Committee (TAC) of
India. The complete fire protection system will comprise of the following.
Fire Fighting Facility: Available in existing unit and will be maintained in future.
System description of fire fighting system
The entire fire safety installation shall be compliant with the most stringent codes / standard for
the entire complex to ensure the highest safety standard and uniformity of system. Further,
before property is operational, the fire protection shall be fully operated and tested under
simulated conditions to demonstrate compliance with the most stringent standards, codes and
guidelines.
A) Fire pumping system
The fire pumping system shall comprise of independent electrical pumps for hydrant and sprinkler
system, diesel engine driven pump & jockey pump for hydrant & sprinkler system.
Electrical pump shall provide adequate flow for catering requirement of hydrant system. Diesel
engine driven fire pumps shall be provided for ensuring operation & performance of the system in
case of total electrical power failure. Jockey pumps shall compensate for pressure drop and line
leakage in the hydrant and sprinkler installation. Provision of PRS/ orifice plate shall be made in
sprinkler riser to restrict pressure on sprinkler system.
Individual suction lines shall be drawn from the fire reserve tanks at the basement level and
connected to independent fire suction header. The electric fire pumps, diesel engine driven fire
pumps and the jockey pumps shall all draw from this suction header.
Delivery lines from various pumps shall also be connected to a common header in order to ensure
that maximum standby capacity is available. The sprinkler pump shall be isolated from the main
discharge header by a non return valve so that the hydrant pump can also act as standby for the
sprinkler system. The ring main shall remain pressurized at all times and Jockey pumps shall make
up minor line losses. Automation required to make the system fully functional shall be provided.
B) Fire hydrant system
Internal and external standpipe fire hydrant system shall be provided with landing valve, hose
reel, first aid hose reels, complete with instantaneous pattern short gunmetal pipe in the
Complex.
The internal diameter of inlet connection shall be at least 80 mm. The outlet shall be of instant
spring lock type gunmetal ferrule coupling of 63 mm dia. for connecting to hose pipe. Provision of
flow switch on riser shall be made for effective zone monitoring. The flow switch shall be wired to
FAP and shall indicate water flow on hydrant of the identified zone.
Recessed cupboard/ fire hydrant cabinet shall be strategically located for firefighting
requirement. Location of cabinets shall be accessed as per compartmentation plan in consultation
with the Architect. Provision of fire man's axe shall be made for internal hydrant.
External hydrant shall be located within 2 m to 15 m from the building to be protected such that
they are accessible and may not be damaged by vehicle movement. A spacing of about 45-50 m
between hydrants for the building shall be adopted. Details of fire hydrant system are as follows:
Piping: Mild Steel pipes (heavy class) as per IS: 1239 shall be provided throughout the complex.
Pipes buried below ground shall be suitably lagged with 2 layers of 400 micron polythene sheet
over 2 coats of bitumen.
External Hydrants: External hydrants shall be provided all around the Complex. The hydrants shall
be controlled by a cast iron sluice valve or butterfly valve. Hydrants shall have instantaneous type
63 mm diameter outlets. The hydrants shall be double outlet with CI duck foot bend and flanged
riser or required height to bring the hydrant to correct level above ground.
For each external fire hydrant two numbers of 63 mm dia. 15 m long controlled percolation
hose pipe with gunmetal male and female instantaneous type couplings machine wound
with GI wire, gunmetal branch pipe with nozzle shall be provided.
Each external hydrant hose cabinet shall be provided with a drain in the bottom plate.
Each hose cabinet shall be conspicuously painted with the letters "FIRE HOSE".
Internal Hydrants: Internal hydrant shall be provided on each landing and other locations as
required by NBC with double headed gunmetal landing valve with 100 mm diameter inlet,
with shut off valves having cast iron wheels. Landing valve shall have flanged inlet and
instantaneous type outlets.
Instantaneous outlets for fire hydrants shall be standard pattern and suitable for fire hoses.
For each internal fire hydrant station two numbers of 63 mm dia. 15 m long rubberized
fabric lined hose pipes with gunmetal male and female instantaneous type coupling
machine would be with GI wire, fire hose reel, gunmetal branch pipe with nozzle shall be
provided.
Standard fire hose reels of 20mm diameter high pressure rubber hose 36.5 m long with
gunmetal nozzle, all mounted on a circular hose reel of heavy duty mild steel construction
having cast iron brackets shall be provided. Hose reel shall be connected directly to the wet
riser with an isolating valve. Hose reel shall be mounted vertically.
Each internal hydrant hose cabinet shall be provided with a drain in the bottom plate. The
drain point shall be led away to the nearest general drain.
Each internal hydrant hose cabinet containing items as above shall also be provided with a
nozzle spanner and a Fireman's Axe. The cabinet shall be recessed in the wall.
Each hose cabinet shall be conspicuously painted with the letters "FIRE HOSE ".
Hose Reel: Hose reel shall be heavy, 20 mm dia, length shall be 36.5 meter long fitted with gun
metal chromium plated nozzle, mild steel pressed reel drum which can swing up to 170 degree
with wall brackets of cast iron finished with red and black enamel complete.
Sprinkler system
Elaborate automatic sprinkler system shall be provided. The system shall be suitably zoned for its
optimum functional performance.
The sprinkler system shall be provided with control valves, flow and tamper switches at suitable
location and shall be connected to control module of the fire alarm system for its monitoring and
annunciation in case of activation.
Sprinkler type along with its quartzite bulbs rating shall be selected based on the requirement of
the space and shall be specified accordingly. Inspector's test valve assembly with sight glass shall
be provided at remote end with discharge pipe to drain outlet / pipe.
Fire extinguishers
Portable fire extinguishers of water (gas pressure), Carbon di-oxide, foam type, Dry chemical
powder and FM-200 or clean agent type shall be provided as first aid fire extinguishing appliances.
These extinguishers shall be suitably installed in the entire areas as per IS: 2190.
The appliances shall be so installed over the entire sections, that a person is not required to travel
more than 15 m to reach the nearest extinguisher. These shall be placed or hanged on wall in a
group on several suitable places.
Fire pump
The fire pump shall be horizontally mounted, variable speed type. It shall have a capacity to
deliver and developing adequate head so as to ensure a minimum pressure at the highest and the
farthest outlet. The pump shall be capable of giving a discharge of not less than 150 per cent of
the rated discharge, at a head of not less than 65 per cent of the rated head. The shut off head
shall be within 120 per cent of the rated head.
The pump casing shall be of cast iron and parts like impeller, shaft sleeve, wearing ring etc. shall
be of non-corrosive metal like bronze/brass/gun metal. The shaft shall be of stainless steel.
Provision of mechanical seal shall also be made.
Bearings of the pump shall be effectively sealed to prevent loss of lubricant or entry of dust or
water. The pump shall be provided with a plate indicating the suction lift, delivery head,
discharge, speed and number of stages. The pump casing shall be designed to withstand 1.5 times
the working pressure.
Foam System for Fire Fighting
Aqueous Film-Forming Foams (AFFF) based on combinations of fluoro-chemical surfactants,
hydrocarbon surfactants, and solvents will be used as foam agent. These agents require a very
low energy input to produce a high quality fire fighting foam.
Foam concentrate will be stored in a bladder tank system. In AFFF systems a bladder tank
containing a nylon reinforced elastomeric bladder is used to store the foam concentrate. System
water pressure is used to squeeze the bladder providing fire fighting foam concentrate, at the
same pressure, to the proportioned.
An aqueous film will be formed on the surface of the alcohol by the foam solution as it drains
from the foam blanket.
This film is very fluid and floats on the surface of most alcohol. This gives the AFFF unequaled
speed in controlling the spill fire.
First Aid
A first aid centre with adequate facilities shall be provided. It shall be maintained round the clock
by a compounder cum dresser and a doctor. An Ambulance shall also be provided at site to carry
affected people to hospital.
Security
The security requirements of the company premises shall be taken care of by CSO assisted by a
Fire In charge. The team, apart from the normal security functions will manage the role required
during a disaster management operation as a part of the crisis control team.
Safety
The safety wing led by a Safety Manager will meet the requirement of emergencies round the
clock. The required safety appliances shall be distributed at different locations of the plant to
meet any eventualities. Poster/placards reflecting safety awareness will be placed at different
locations in the plant area.
Evacuation Procedure
As the major hazard is only due to fire, which has more or less localized impact so no mass
evacuation, procedures are required. Evacuation would involve only the people working very
close to the fire area.
Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)
This equipment is used mainly for three reasons; to protect personnel from a hazard while
performing rescue/accident control operations, to do maintenance and repair work under
hazardous conditions, and for escape purposes. The list of Personal Protective Equipment
provided at the facility and their locations shall be available in ECC.
Effective command and control accomplish these functions necessitates personal trained in this
On-site Disaster Management Plan with adequate facilities and equipment and equipment to carry
out their duties and functions. These organizations and the facilities required to support their
response are summarized in the following subsections.
Personal protective equipment play a vital role in overcoming major disastrous situation saving
life during onsite emergency. List of recommended Personal Protective equipment (PPE) is given
below.
Table 7.3
Summary of recommended personal protective equipment according to hazard onsite
Objective Workplace Hazards Suggested PPE
Eye and face Flying particles, molten metal, Safety glasses with side-shields, protective
protection liquid chemicals, gases or shades, etc.
vapors, light radiation
Head Falling objects, inadequate Plastic helmets with top and side impact
Mock Drill
As per the Industrial Major Accident Hazard Rules,
Mock drills of the on-site emergency plan will be conducted every month.
A detailed report of the mock drill conducted will be made immediately available to all the
concerned authority
Also, Major Fire and Minor Fire mock drills will be conducted once in three months and one month
respectively.
Training
On job training to the engineers on various stages of risk analysis and preparedness during emergency to
reflect in the operation of terminal, especially from the safety stand point. The fire team belonging to the
fire fighting department is to be intensively trained for the use of all equipment and in various fire
fighting methods for handling different types of fires.
Either way, the plan must identify an emergency coordinating officer who would take overall command
of the off-site activities. Consideration of evacuation may include the following factors:
In the case of a major fire but without explosion risk (e.g. an oil storage tank), only houses close to
the fire are likely to need evacuation
If fire is escalating very fast it is necessary to evacuate people nearby as soon as possible
In acute emergency people are advised to stay indoors and shield themselves from the fire.
Humanitarian Arrangements
Transport, evacuation centers, emergency feeding, treatment of injured, first aid, ambulances,
temporary mortuaries.
Public Information
Dealing with the media-press office
Informing relatives, etc.
Assessment
Collecting information on the causes of the emergency
Reviewing the efficiency and effectiveness of all aspects of the emergency plan.
Role of local authority
Local Authorities like Panchayat, Sabha, Samiti, municipalities can help in combating emergency
situation after assessing the impact scenario in rescue phase.
Role of police
Police are to assist in controlling of the accident site, organizing evacuation and removing of any
seriously injured people to hospitals.
Co-ordination with the transport authorities, civil defense and home guards
Co-ordination with army, navy, air force and state fire services
Arrange for post mortem of dead bodies
Establish communication centre with easy contact with ECC
Role of Fire Brigade
The fire brigade is to be organized to put out fires and provide assistance as required during
emergency.
Media
The media is to have ready and continuous access to designated officials with relevant
information, as well as to other sources in order to provide essential and accurate information
to public throughout the emergency and to avoid commotion and confusion.
Efforts will be made to check the clarity and reliability of information as it becomes available,
and before it is communicated to public.
Public health authorities will be consulted when issuing statements to the media concerning
health aspects of chemical accidents
Members of the media are to facilitate response efforts by providing means for informing the
public with credible information about accidents involving hazardous substances
Role of health care authorities
Hospitals and doctors must be ready to treat all type of injuries to causalities during emergency.
Co-ordinate the activities of Primary Health Centers and Municipal Dispensaries to ensure
required quantities of drugs and equipment
Securing assistance of medical and paramedical personnel from nearby hospitals/institutions
Temporary mortuary and identification of dead bodies.
(2) Noise
A) Risks involved
Hearing impairment, hypertension, increase pulse rate
Annoyance, Tinnitus, Sleep disturbances
C) Management measures
Proper maintenance of machineries
Installation of compressors and turbine in closed buildings
Regular monitoring of noise level
Display of noise level with permission level
Display instruction to use of PPEs at high noise level area
Periodic health checkup for audiometry for the person working in high noise area.
(3) Heat stress
A) Risks involved
Co-gen plants operate at high temperatures up to 800⁰ C
B) Management Measures
Schedule hot jobs for the cooler part of the day
Monitor workers who are at risk of heat stress
Provide rest periods with water breaks
Use of personal protective equipment
(4) Electrical Hazards
A) Risks involved
Electric shock, electric burns, fires and explosions
Persons falling from height, dropping of tools and object
B) Causes of hazards
Insulation failure, equipment failure, poor maintenance.
Wrong work methods, substandard material and workmanship
Unauthorized personal & lack of training and knowledge, etc.
C) Management Measures
Proper earthing will be done as per IS 3043
Low Voltage Supply will be ensured
Isolating Transformers
Double Insulated Tools
Over Load Protection
Protection Against Leakages (G.F.C.I.)
Flame- Proof Equipment
Lightning Protection
Protection against Static Electricity and safe use of ladders and scaffolds
(5) Fire and Explosion
A) Risks involved
Fire catching in store, go down, conveyors, cable tunnel, oil storage area, fuel storage yard,
transformers and HT/LT substation etc.
B) Management Measures
Suitable fire extinguisher, fire hydrant system and fire buckets. Fire tender will be kept ready at
plant main gate.
Oil and flammable gases storage area will be fenced and declared as Fire Hazardous Area-No
Smoking Area”
Permit and safety instruction to use welding / gas cutting in the area of oil storage, fuel storage.
Predictive interlock in transformers to give alarm and trip the system
Adequate height of brick walls for separation of all transformers, soak pits for storage of oil
leakages from transformers
(6) Other Hazards
A) Risks involved
Silo/tank and building collapse
Slipped and fall from working at height
Failure of lifting tools, tackles and pressure vessel
Occupational injuries
Hit by moving, flying or falling object
B) Management Measures
Structural soundness of buildings
Permit to work at height with work instruction to use safety belts etc.
Testing of all lifting tools, tackles and pressure vessel.
Safe working pressure will be maintained in air receiver.
Safe working load for cranes and ropes etc.
Good housekeeping & speed limit of 20km/hr in plant area.
Display of emergency number at all suitable location.
Fire tender, ambulance and emergency staff ready at the plant main gate at all the time.
First aid kits will be kept at the site and training provided.
Use of mobile while driving, alcohol, smoking etc. will be banned in proposed distillery area.
Proper illumination in office (250 to 300 LUX), plant area (100 to 150 LUX) and road area (20 to
30 LUX).
basis to observe any contraction due to exposure to dust and noise and corrective measures will be
taken accordingly.
Vocational training programme will also be conducted. Under vocational training the workers will be
given training related to all safety and health aspects pertaining to their vocation and thereafter every
quarter special training courses/ awareness programme for Malaria eradication, HIV and health effects
on exposure to dust, heat, noise, chemicals will be organized for employed person.
Periodical medical camps with specialized doctors of various disciplines will also provide the
specialized medical assistance to employees as well as neighbouring communities.
A. Pre placement and periodical health status
Pre / Post-employment checkup will be carried out and following tests will be conducted:
BMI (Body Mass Index)
Chest x ray PA view
Vision testing (Far & Near vision, color vision and any other ocular defect)
ECG
Haemogram (examination of the blood)
Blood Pressure & Blood Sugar Fasting
Serum Cholesterol
Renal Function Test (Blood Urea, Serum Creatinine)
Liver Function Test (S. Bilirubin, Alk. Phosphatase, SGOT and SGPT)
Urine (Routine and Microscopic)
Complete physical examination
Post-employment occupational health check-up such as lung function, audiometry, CBC, Blood
Sugar, Lipid Profile etc.
Medical records of each employee will be maintained separately and will be updated as per
finding during monitoring.
Medical records of the employee at the end of his / her term will be updated.
B. Frequency of Medical Examination
Once in a year
C. Personal protective devices and measures
Industrial Safety helmets, Crash helmets
Face shield
Goggles
Safety Shoes & Rubber Gumboots: Safety shoes are mandatory to be worn by all the employees
and rubber gumboots will be provided to person who handles sulphuric acid. Full suit having hand-
gloves, goggles, helmet and aprons will be provided.
Face Shield Helmet: The people deputed for welding work will be provided with face shield
helmet.
Ear muffs and Ear Plugs
Periodic safety audits both internal and external, review and implementation of
recommendations
Aspirin tablets.
Potassium permanganate crystals.
First aid boxes will be kept in every department for emergency. First aid training will be organized for
the employees.
7.4.9 Plan and Fund allocation for Occupational and Safety Hazards
Plan and fund allocation to ensure the occupational health and safety of all contracts and sub-contract
workers is given in table below.
Table – 7.5
Proposed fund allocation for occupational and safety hazards PLEASE PROVIDE BUDGET FOR OHS
S. Description Amount (Rs. In lacs per annum)
No.
1. Doctor's Retainer Fee(including staff)
2. Medicine Expenses
3. Health Checkup Exp.
4. Ambulance Expenditure
Total Amount in (Rs.)
7.5 Conclusion
It is concluded that there will be no major risk involved due to proposed project. Proper precautionary
measures will be taken to minimize risks. Personal Protective Equipment (PPEs) will help to minimize
the health hazards and accidental casualties.