Readership and Readers Perception of Omani Newspapers
Readership and Readers Perception of Omani Newspapers
Readership and Readers Perception of Omani Newspapers
Abstract
Readership of print newspapers has been the focus of many studies and
analyses because of the advancement of online journalism, information
technologies and socio-economic changes in recent years. This study
focuses on the perception and readership of Omani newspapers in the age of
globalization. It investigates people's reading habits and their attitudes
towards the content and layout of 9 dailies and several free weekly tabloids.
This survey study was conducted on 747 subjects selected on the basis of the
non-probability convenience sample from Muscat, the capital of Oman. The
results indicated that only 5.5% of the respondents said they don't read
newspapers. The salient reasons for not reading newspapers were the
availability of other media sources and lack of time to read newspapers. Most
readers of Omani newspapers are males with diploma and university degrees
who work in the public sector. Hard copies are still popular in Oman, since
only 3% read the online version of newspapers. Reading frequency was
found to correlate with the type of content and professionalism aspects more
than the appearance and presentation (layout & design) of Omani
newspapers. The images of private newspapers are more favorable than
those of the public ones. However, readers' views about certain newspapers
were found to be subjective and judgmental. News was the most frequently
read type of content and Omani newspapers were found to cover local news
better than other topics.
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Some existing and dominant media players in the market alongside scholars,
tend to perceive new information and communication technology as a threat.
For nearly two decades, most of the available literature speculated a
competitive relationship between print media and digital media, because the
latter is often seen in the context of replacement, challenge and threat.
Sulaiman Saleh (2002) identified four challenges posed by new information
technology to print journalism; death of some newspapers, reduction in
circulation, decrease in advertising revenue and emergence and popularity of
electronic journalism.
Nevertheless, many Arabic newspaper titles have also closed down across
the region. Kuwait’s Awan and Bahrain's Alwaqt ceased their operations in
1
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
2010, only two years after their inception. Egypt’s El Badeel, which was
launched in 2006, closed down in July 2009. Groupe Maroc Soir, a major
Moroccan publishing company, also closed down in 2009 two of its titles,
Assabahia and Assada El Massaia. Similarly, the Daily Star in Lebanon, the
only English language newspaper, has been battling a difficult financial
situation since January 2009 when it closed down before re-launching, and
continues to have an uncertain future (Dubai Press Club, 2010: 26). Certain
measures have also been taken by publishers in the Arab world. Saudi
Arabia's Al Majalla and UAE sport magazine Super became purely online
publications in 2009. Other print media industries in the Arab region have
downsized their operation and went through a redundancy plan (Op cit: 27).
It might be argued that the recent decline in advertising revenue can mainly
be attributed to the global economic crisis, which has affected many industries
including print media since late 2007. Until 2006, US newspaper revenues
were flat and their pre-taxation earnings were 8% of total revenue (State of
the news Media, 2007). However, experts say that, despite the problems of
falling advertising revenues and pressure from new competitors, the global
newspaper industry is far from facing an apocalypse (World Association of
Newspapers, December 2009). On the other hand, Sulaiman Zaid (2009: 24)
argued that electronic journalism will not be able to catch up with the print
media before the year 2017. He added that, if newspapers continue to
increase annually by 3%, it will even be far longer for the electronic journalism
to take over the lead. A recent report published by Dubai Press Club gave
support to this assertion. Global advertising revenue made by the internet
2
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
during the years 2008, 2009 and 2010 accounted for 10, 12 and 14 percent,
respectively. In contrast, the shares of newspapers for the same years were
25, 23 and 22 percent. By 2013, the share of the internet is projected at 18%
while that of the newspapers is 19% (Dubai Press Club, 2010: 22). These
projected figures are showing a steady trajectory in the internet's share of
advertising revenue at the expense of print media allotment. According to the
World Association of Newspapers (3 August 2010), the Middle East is the only
region where newspaper advertising revenue remained stable. Other regions
showed a decline ranging from 2.9% in Latin America to 18.7% in Eastern
Europe.
In terms of readership, the 2008 World Press Trends report published by the
World Association of Newspapers revealed that more than 532 million people
buy a newspaper every day while the number in 2003 was 486 million.
Average readership was estimated at more than 1.7 billion each day (World
Association of Newspapers, 2 June 2008). The report in 2009 revealed an
3
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
This quick review of the state of newspapers in the world shows that US print
media have been hardest hit. In 2005, American newspaper circulation fell
2.8% amongst dailies and 3.4% amongst Sunday newspapers, according to
the 2007 report published by the State of the News Media website. American
print advertising revenue showed a continuous decline from $42,209 million in
2007 to $22,795 million in 2010, whereas the decline in the online advertising
revenue between the two
years was very marginal, from $3,166 in 2007 to $3,042 in 2010
(State of the News Media, 2011). The decline in US newspaper advertising
revenue can mainly be attributed to the recent economic crisis and the
migration of consumers to the online platforms, which have just exacerbated
the status of some newspapers and forced them to close down. News & Tech
website estimated the decline in 2010 at 5 to 10%, with a remarkable
improvement from the 22% decline in 2009. The decline in advertising
revenue is expected to be in the margin of 2% in 2012, the time when the US
economy is also expected to recover from the crisis (News & Tech, June 14,
2010).
The impact of new digital media especially the internet on print journalism is
indisputable. However, this impact is not imminent and does not follow the
same pace across all countries of the world. The focus on the death of some
newspapers and the decline in advertising revenue and readership in the USA
and some European countries have dominated the scene and overlooked the
4
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
growth that newspapers are experiencing in other parts of the world. In many
countries, circulation figures are steadily increasing, readership is not severely
affected by the digital news sources and the decline in advertising revenue
has affected print and digital media alike because of the economic crisis since
2008. From the beginning of the 20th century, the issue of influence and
competition between electronic media, then radio, and print media has been
widely debated. Yet, newspapers continued to grow and continued to have
their audience. The fact that every single medium has its own merits and
characteristics allows different media to complement each other. Competition
in a free and open market is inevitable, but it is the duty of the newspaper
industry to become proactive and to work towards meeting the needs of its
readers in this age of globalization.
In 1970, Sultan Qaboos bin Said took the throne (an is still in power) and
started the renaissance of modern Oman. His modern vision and openness
5
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
to the world brought in many positive changes to the country, including the
growth and expansion of the media sector. As a result, the first newspaper to
appear in Oman was the privately owned Alwatan, established by the Al-
Taee family in 1971. The government started its own newspaper, Oman, in
1972, and several other new newspaper titles started to emerge erratically
over the years with a very a long interval between one another. However, this
trend has changed since 2006, as four dailies and more than 10 free weekly
tabloids have come into existence.
Five out of the nine daily newspapers are in Arabic and four are in English.
The English Muscat Daily, published by Apex Press and Publishing, is the
newest in the market, it appeared in October 2009 and is published from
Saturday to Wednesday. Oman’s three other English dailies are the Times of
Oman, Oman Observer and Oman Tribune. The most recent Arabic dailies
are Alr'oyah, which was launched in 2009 by Arro'yah Establishment for
Press and Publishing and Azzaman in 2007. The remaining Arabic dailies,
Alwatan, Oman and Alshabiba are the oldest. The free weekly tabloids are
published both in English and in Arabic. The first free weekly tabloid was
introduced to Oman by Apex Press and Publishing, which launched The
Week, an English tabloid, in 2003 and its Arabic version, Al Isbou’a, in 2006
(MediaSource, 2011:45). Muscat Press and Publishing House launched its
own free weekly tabloids in 2007, namely Hi (English) and Al Youm Al Sabe
(Arabic).
newspaper publishers with the exception of Apex which hired BPA Worldwide
to audit its two tabloids. Most of the claimed circulations are exaggerated by
the newspapers in order to attract advertisers. However, according to Dubai
Press Club (2010: 135) total dailies circulation in Oman is estimated at
274,000 copies sharing an advertisement market of US $85 million. Table 1
gives details about all dailies while Table 2 gives details about most free
weekly tabloids in Oman.
Table (1)
Omani Daily Newspapers
Table (2)
Omani Free Weekly Tabloids
7
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Three of the above mentioned free weekly tabloids are purely commercials,
specializing in classified advertizing. These are Waseet (broaker), I'elanak
(your ad) and Zedni (get me more). AlMalaib (playgrounds) and
Koooorawabas (just football) focus on sport issues besides advertisements.
The remaining free tabloids try to provide diverse editorial content but most of
their pages, especially Futoon, are occupied by advertisements.
Oman was launched in 1972 by the Omani government under the supervision
of the Ministry of Information. Oman was published weekly every Saturday
until 1975, and began to appear daily only in 1982. Oman publishes a
number of supplements focusing on sport, culture, economy, health, family
and arts. In addition, it publishes special supplements for some Ministries
such as Ruaa (vision) for the Ministry of Higher Education, Na'mal (we work)
for the Ministry of Manpower, Haytuna (our life), for the Ministry of Social
Welfare and Nafithah Tarbawayiah (Window for education), for the Ministry of
Education. In 2009, Oman updated its electronic version to become the first
interactive newspaper website in Oman. Nearly 95% of employees are
Omanis. Both Oman and Observer follow the same editorial policy as they
are considered the mouthpiece of the Omani government.
8
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
ARro'yah is the fifth Arabic daily. It was started in 2009, by Hatim Altaee, a
member of the Al Taee family that owns Alwatan. ARro'yah was thought to
be the first business newspaper. However, the newspaper covers far-fledged
topics ranging from politics to health and beauty. It also dedicates a section
to youth news and activities, especially those of college and university
students.
9
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Literature Review:
Makkawi (1991) conducted one of the earliest survey studies on 300
university students in order to find out their uses of different mass media. He
found that students spent more time watching TV than reading newspapers or
magazines, which were ranked fifth and sixth, respectively. Books, radio and
audiocassettes were ranked second, third and fourth.
Al-araimi (2002), studied readers' perceptions of Oman daily. The study was
conducted on 200 readers of the newspaper selected purposively from the
city of Muscat. Income, age and education of the readers correlated
negatively with their image of the newspaper. For example, the higher the
age and income, the less positive the image of Oman daily. However, the
10
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Al-Mukhaini (2006) studied the uses of Omani newspapers and the resulting
gratifications amongst Omani readers. He conducted his study on 400
respondents aged 18 years and above from the city of Muscat. Similar to the
findings of Al-abd (1995), Al-Mukhaini found that the majority (60%) of
respondents frequently read newspapers. However, his study indicated a
preference shift in which Alwatn has become more preferred and frequently
read than Oman. This result lends support to the assertion made by Al-
Uraimi (2002: 42) that Oman daily was suffering from sharp decline in both
readership and advertising revenue because of advertisers' and readers'
11
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
43% read newspapers daily with 80% of them reading for an hour or less per
day, 29% read magazines more than once a week and 54% use mobile
applications daily. It was also found that office hours are the peak time for
reading newspapers and magazines. This result indicates that nearly half
(43%) of the daily users of the internet also read newspapers, while the least
used media are radio and magazines.
AlShehri & Gunter (2002) conducted a survey study among 800 readers of
Arabic electronic newspapers. Arabs prefer reading the print version of their
favorite newspapers to the electronic one. For example, while only 10.6% of
the respondents reported reading the electronic version of Al-Hayat, 16%
said they read the print copy of the paper. In fact, 63% of the sample were
not willing to pay fees for reading online newspapers. This result was also
reached by Skogerbo & Winsvold (2011) who studied young Norwegians use
of print and online newspapers. Among the daily readers, 80% read the print
versions while only 5% read the online ones. Moreover, AlShehri & Gunter
(2002) also found that the popularity of the internet versions is drawn mainly
from the popularity of the hard copy. Most Arab readers of the electronic
newspapers were predominantly male, young to middle-aged adults and
business professionals or students in higher education.
Elvestad & Blekesaune (2008) used the data of the European Social Survey
(ESS) of 2004/5 to conduct a comparative multilevel analysis on newspaper
reading in 23 European countries. The overall sample of the ESS survey was
32,765. The results indicated that Irish, Norwegians and Finnish, respectively
spend more than 40 minutes a day reading newspapers. The European
countries that have the highest number of non-readers were, in descending
order, Greece, Spain, Belgium and Portugal. The analyses indicated that
gender, age, education and income were strong predictors of the time spent
on reading newspapers in most European countries. Men spent more time
reading newspapers than women. Age, education and income correlated
positively with time spent reading newspapers.
Raeymaeckers (2002) studied young Belgians, aged between 16-18 years
old, reading habits and attitudes towards newspapers. The study found that
young Flanders (n=1200) spent more time watching TV and listening to radio
than reading magazines, books and newspapers. Only 19% of the
respondents read newspapers on a daily basis, 18% read them regularly and
20% never read newspapers. The study also found that male respondents
spend more time reading newspapers than females and they read them
frequently. This result lends support to the findings of Makkawi (1991) an, Al-
Shaqsi (2011) in which young adults are found to spend more time viewing TV
than reading newspapers and books.
This literature review has indicated that all readership studies in Oman except
Alabd (1995) used Omani subjects, whereas this study uses a more
heterogeneous sample including Omanis and non-Omanis. Moreover, since
2006, several free and paid newspaper titles have emerged, but there is little
information available about the characteristics of their readers and their
reading habits. Previous studies in Oman and elsewhere have also pointed to
several variables that influence reading habits such as, gender, age,
education and income. Therefore, it is important to examine the role these
variables play in the current study. It was also found that readers' attitudes
towards a given newspaper were influenced by the content and layout of that
paper. These factors are also considered in this study. It is worth noting that
some newspapers in Oman have already changed their layout and design and
reduced the dimension of their paper in an endeavor to attract readers.
Study Problem:
The previous discussion showed that at a time when many publications in the
USA and Europe closed down, went online or took certain measures in order
to survive competition and recession, new newspaper titles appeared in
Oman. Since 2006, 8 new dailies and a number of free weekly tabloids have
emerged. Overall, there are more than 15 daily and weekly newspapers in
both the Arabic and English languages available to a population totaling
3,173,917 people, according to the population statistics of 2009 published by
the Ministry of National Economy. Oman has a high proportion of young
people with over 72% of the Omani population (n= 2,017,559) aged between
0 – 29 years. In 2003, the illiteracy rate amongst Omanis aged between 15-
45 years, was 9.1% (Ministry of National Economy, 2003). Non-Omanis
account for 36.43% (1,156,358) of the total population. Most of the
expatriates come from the Indian subcontinent and about 36% of them work in
the construction field, which does not require any form of Arabic or English
language proficiency (Ministry of Manpower, 2009:53). The age group (30 –
44) accounts for 34.3% of the expatriates population, followed by the age
15
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
group (15 – 29) with approximately 33%. Thus, in light of these figures and
recent development in the newspaper industry, accompanied by the lack of
any robust readership study in Oman, there is a need to investigate readers'
perception of Omani newspapers and their reading habits.
Objectives:
The main purposes of this study are to explore audience reading habits of
newspapers and readers' attitudes towards the editorial content and layout
characteristics of daily newspapers. It also investigates the role of some
socio-economic factors in the issue of readership and perception.
The significance of this study stems from the fact that it is the first study in
Oman that uses Omani and non-Omani subjects. It also covers dailies and
free weekly publications while previous studies focused only on one or the
other. Moreover, this study is the most recent, since all readership studies in
Oman were conducted before 2006, the year when many new dailies and free
publications were just starting to emerge.
Limitation:
Research Questions:
With reference to the aims of this study and to the literature review, the study
seeks to answer the following research questions:
16
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Methodology:
This study is based on a survey questionnaire to investigate readership and
readers' perceptions of Omani newspapers. The following section discusses
readership measurement, the data gathering instrument and its variables.
Measuring Readership:
17
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
purposes of this study, these ways are not discussed in detail, but their
general principles are used to outline how readership is operationally defined
and measured. In this study, the question of readership is examined by a set
of questions aiming at finding out:
1- Whether or not the respondent reads newspapers.
2- The name of the paper he/she reads most.
3- The frequency of reading his/her favourite newspaper, as well as
other newspapers.
4- The days when and the places where reading is happening, and the
means by which the reader gets a copy of the newspaper.
5- The content he/she reads most and forms of writing he/she prefers in
the newspaper.
Sample Characteristics:
The study used a non-probability sample, namely convenience, since no
sample frame has been identified for the population. Subjects were selected
based on their existence in the places where questionnaires were distributed,
19
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Of the 747 respondents in this study, 62% were males and 38% were
females. Their ages range from 15 to over 40 years old. Omanis account for
87.6% of the sample, while foreigners, including Arabs, Asians and
Europeans, account for 12%. The age group 21-30 years comprises 45%,
and the age group 31-40 comprises 30.7%. Most of the respondents (29%)
fell in the middle-income category (551 – 850) Rial Omani (RO) a month (1
RO = US$ 2.6), and 20% in the low income category (250 -550 RO). More
than 62% of the respondents have diploma and university degrees, 11% have
postgraduate degrees, and more than 25% have high school diplomas or less.
Nearly 48% of the subjects work in civil government institutions, 22% in the
private sector, 19% as students and 6% in the military sector.
Results:
Only 5.5% of the total sample (n= 747) said they didn't read daily newspapers,
and half of those (2.7%) worked in the public sector. The most important
20
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
reasons for not reading newspapers were the availability of other media
sources, hate of reading and not finding newspapers as interesting,
respectively. Most readers of daily newspapers are males (63%), their ages
range between 21 – 35 (65%) from low and middle income background
(48.8%), who have diploma and university degrees (62.8%) and worked in the
public sector (48%).
More than 41% of the respondents read newspapers during the weekdays,
23.4% during the weekends and 35.6% daily. In line with this result, 43.5%
said they read newspapers at work and 49.6% at home, whereas only 6.8%
said they read newspapers in public places. Most of the respondents (42.2%)
get their copies for free at work, 32.2% buy them from news stalls or vendors,
7% borrow them, 6.4% obtain them through annual subscription and 5.3%
read them in public places, such as cafes. What is worth noting here is that
only 3% read the electronic version of their favourite newspapers, a case that
explains why print copies are popular in Oman and are not challenged by the
new information technologies. Hard copies of newspapers in the Arab World
are still popular because of low internet penetration and high internet charges
(Alshehri & Gunter 2002; Nemeth 2006). Moreover, Arabs use the internet
mainly to browse their emails, search for information about their hobbies and
connect with others through social networking sites (Spot on PR & Effective
Measure 2010). The Arab diasporas are found to browse the electronic
version of either their national or popular newspapers more than those who
reside in their home countries (Negm, 2005).
Respondents were asked to name their most read and favourite newspaper.
The results showed that amongst Arabic dailies, Alwatan was favoured by
49.6% of the respondents, followed by Oman (27.2%) and Alshabiba (9.5%).
The new Arabic titles, namely ARro'yah (vision) and Azzaman (time), claimed
only 3% and .7%, respectively. Amongst the English dailies, Times of Oman
was favoured by 5.4% of the respondents followed by Tribune (2.7%). The
least read newspapers were the newly launched Muscat Daily and
Observer. Table 3 shows that Alwatan is more frequently read (61%) than
any other newspaper, followed by Oman. On the other hand, Times of
21
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Oman is the most frequently read amongst English dailies. Both Oman and
Alshabiba are more read occasionally.
Table 3
Reading frequency of dailies based on valid percents
Always Occasionally Don’t Read Total
N % N % N % N %
Alwatan 390 61.3 212 33.3 34 5.3 636 100
Oman 225 36.7 337 55 51 8.3 613 100
Alshabiba 121 20.3 363 60.9 112 18.8 596 100
Azzaman 30 5.7 141 26.6 359 67.7 530 100
Times of Oman 56 11.2 121 24.2 322 64.5 499 100
Observer 21 4.4 116 24.5 337 71.1 474 100
Tribune 10 2.3 65 14.8 364 82.9 439 100
Crosstabulation analyses of the whole sample reveals that both Alwatan and
Oman appeal to the same readers. Their predominant readers are Omani
males within the age group 21-30 years who work in the public sector and
have a university degree.
22
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Opinion & Analysis 161 23.9 421 62.6 91 13.5 673 100
Interviews 171 25.8 381 57.1 114 17.1 667 100
Investigative 187 28.4 348 52.8 124 18.8 659 100
Reporting
Caricatures & 290 43.8 266 40.2 106 16 662 100
Comics
Daily Columns 227 34.4 316 48 116 17.6 659 100
Classified Ads 191 28.5 333 49.7 146 21 670 100
Letters to the editor 135 21.2 266 41.7 237 37.1 638 100
Puzzles 173 25.4 266 39.1 241 35.4 680 100
Table 5 shows that older age groups, 31 years and above, read news, daily
columns and classified ads more than younger age groups. The differences
in their mean scores are statistically significant at 99% level. Younger age
groups, however, read caricatures & comics and puzzles more than older
ones.
Table 5
ANOVA on age & reading different forms of writings
23
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Classified Ads 1.83 2.14 2.01 2.21 2.07 .71 333.98 5.64 .001
ь ª ª
Puzzles 2.45 1.97 1.64 1.69 1.90 .77 407.20 27.21 .000
ª ь ь ь
Table 6
ANOVA on education & different forms of writings
Table 7
ANOVA on Income & reading different forms of writing
Low= (R.O. 100-550) middle= (R.O. 551 – 1150) high= (R.O. 1151 & above)
24
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Opinion & Analysis 1.96с 2.14ь 2.31ª 2.11 .60 233.90 15.00 .000
Daily Columns 2.05ь 2.21ª 2.28ª 2.17 .71 315.33 5.22 .006
Investigative Reporting 1.89ь 2.21ª 2.21ª 2.10 .68 291.85 15.74 .000
Letters to the editor 1.99ª 1.77ь 1.77ь 1.84 .74 338.06 5.87 .003
Puzzles 2.10ª 1.78ь 1.62ь 1.86 .76 369.44 20.56 .000
* R.O. (1 Rial Omani = $2.6)
Table 8
ANOVA on readers' overall satisfaction with newspaper coverage of different topics
(mean scores with the same subscripted letters= no significant differences)
25
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Culture 3.40 3.33 3.54 3.06 3.36 1.03 658.3 1.84 .13
0 5 8
Current affairs 3.28 3.20ь 3.74ª 3.18 3.27 1.19 891.9 3.61 .01
8 9 3
Opinion Anal. 3.27ª 3.29ª 3.62ª 2.13ь 3.26 1.12 791.1 13.9 .00
4 0 7 0
Religion 3.43 3.19 3.15 3.31 3.26 1.14 808.2 2.04 .10
2 2 8
Art & Artists 3.02ь 3.20ь 3.92ª 2.63ь 3.19 1.18 841.8 12.4 .00
3 2 4 0
Games/puzzle 2.95 2.85ь 3.39ª 3.06 2.95 1.19 884.1 3.52 .01
s 4 4 5
Medicine 2.86 2.79 2.79 3.06 2.82 1.23 934.4 .57 .63
1 2 7
The results also show that gender, age, ethnic group and income were
significant factors in predicting readers' satisfaction. The results in Table 9
show that females were more satisfied than males with newspapers' coverage
of local news, culture, games & puzzles, religious and medical topics. The
differences between the mean scores of males and females in these topics
are statistically significant (p<.05).
Table 9
t-test on gender & readers' satisfaction with newspapers coverage of different topics
26
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Table 10
ANOVA on Age and readers' satisfaction with newspapers coverage of different topics
(mean scores with the same subscripted letters= no significant differences)
Age, 1= (10-20yrs), 2= (21-30yrs), 3= (31-40yrs), 4= (41+yrs)
Topics Means of age groups SD SS F Sig
1 2 3 4 Total Total Total
Local News 3.90 4.13ª 4.00 3.71ь 4.01 .951 632.88 5.03 .002
Arab News 3.90 4.13 4.00 3.71 4.01 .951 552.96 3.68 .012
Inter. News 3.63 3.65 3.47 3.27 3.55 1.06 768.72 3.65 .018
Opinion Anal. 3.10 3.45ª 3.22 2.76ь 3.26 1.14 886.71 8.71 .000
Business 3.64ª 3.48ª 3.55ª 2.91ь 3.46 1.07 759.69 7.57 .000
Art & Artists 3.40ª 3.36ª 3.03ь 2.71с 3.19 1.22 983.33 8.25 .000
Current affairs 3.84ª 3.33ь 3.14ь 2.97ь 3.30 1.21 993.96 9.49 .000
Sport 4.15ª 3.78ь 3.63ь 3.53ь 3.75 1.05 757.12 6.52 .000
Culture 3.62ª 3.49 3.19ь 3.03ь 3.36 1.03 719.01 8.25 .000
Games/puzzles 3.45ª 3.12ь 2.69с 2.78с 2.99 1.20 976.96 11.27 .000
Religious 3.84ª 3.34ь 3.09ь 3.01ь 3.29 1.15 894.76 10.86 .000
Medical 3.36ª 2.89ь 2.69ь 2.62ь 2.86 1.26 1072.95 7.12 .000
27
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Table 12
ANOVA on ethnic group and readers' satisfaction with newspapers coverage of different
topics
(mean scores with the same subscripted letters= no significant differences)
Ethnic group: 1= Omanis 2= Arabs 3= Asians
Topics Means by ethnic groups SD SS F Sig
Omanis Arabs Asians Total Total Total
N=618 N= 42 N= 32 N= 692
Local News 4.05ª 4.00ª 3.25ь 4.01 .96 630.93 10.98 .000
Arab News 3.61ª 3.67ª 3.13ь 3.59 .89 545.66 4.64 .010
Inter. News 3.58ª 3.60ª 2.81ь 3.55 1.06 760.56 8.23 .000
Opinion Anal. 3.32ª 3.43ª 1.93ь 3.26 1.14 874.59 22.96 .000
Business 3.50ª 3.67 2.47ь 3.46 1.07 758.41 14.67 .000
Art & Artists 3.24ª 3.05 2.50ь 3.20 1.22 968.80 4.42 .005
Sport 3.80ª 3.76ª 3.07ь 3.77 1.05 744.37 7.10 .001
Based on income, readers from the middle income category ($1430 – 2990)
are more satisfied than other groups with their favorite newspapers' coverage
of Arab and international news, opinion and analysis, business news, ads and
medical topics. The differences between the mean scores of the three income
categories are statistically significant. However, readers from the low income
category appeared to be more satisfied than other groups with newspapers'
coverage of cultural topics.
28
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Table 13
ANOVA on ethnic group and readers' satisfaction with newspapers' coverage of different
topics
(mean scores with the same subscripted letters= no significant differences)
Income: 1= low (R.O*. 100-550), 2= middle (R.O. 551 – 1150), 3= high (R.O. 1151 &
above)
Topics Means by income SD SS F Sig
1 2 3 Total Total Total
N= 233 N=294 N=139 N= 666
Arab News 3.44ь 3.71ª 3.62 3.59 .90 608.88 5.59 .004
Inter. News 3.39ь 3.63ª 3.57 3.53 1.05 716.83 3.49 .031
Opinion Anal. 2.97ь 3.45ª 3.32ª 3.26 1.13 829.54 12.13 .000
Business 3.24ь 3.63ª 3.43 3.44 1.06 716.76 8.73 .000
Culture 3.46ª 3.35 3.16ь 3.35 1.03 684.63 2.63 .027
Ads 3.33ь 3.79ª 3.78ª 3.62 1.12 811.20 12.92 .000
Medicine 3.01 2.76 2.69 2.83 1.26 1015.86 3.62 .027
* R.O. (Rial Omani). 1 Rial Omani = $2.6
29
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
In light of these findings, it can be argued that the more readers are satisfied
with a newspaper's coverage of certain topics, the more frequently they read
the form of journalistic writing that relates to these topics, and vice versa. So
the frequency of reading certain journalistic writings can be taken as an
indicator of readers' satisfaction with certain topics.
these items in a 5-point scale (excellent, very good, good, fair & weak), where
excellent was rated 5 and weak 1.
Table 14
ANOVA on readers' view of the design and layout of newspapers:
Topics Means SD SS F Sig
Oman Alwatan Alshabiba Times Total Total Total
Layout & 3.90 4.00ª 4.21ª 2.50ь 3.97 .966 588.30 4.71 .003
Design
Pictures 3.81 3.81 3.86 3.50 3.80 .985 609.99 1.21 .304
Graphics & 3.48ª 3.50ª 3.57ª 2.88ь 3.47 1.041 675.42 3.99 .008
comics
Paper 3.64 3.55 3.75 3.22 3.58 1.102 753.64 2.13 .096
Quality
Printing 3.73 3.86 3.77 3.41 3.78 1.015 648.64 2.29 .078
Quality
Font size & 3.79 3.84 3.86 3.79 3.82 .993 618.70 .17 .920
Types
Headlines 3.73ь 3.84 4.16ª 4.06 3.85 .984 611.42 3.60 .013
.
Readers' Image of The Professionalism of Omani Newspapers:
Every newspaper has its own image, which can sometimes become either a
brand or a stigma. The images engraved in the minds of the readers affect
newspapers' credibility and readership. There are a number of image
characteristics assigned to newspapers, mostly relating to professionalism
derived from news values. Readers' might develop an image about a
newspaper as a result of a direct experience but they might also rely on
stereotypes and indirect experiences. However, readers' image of Omani
newspapers was examined through the subjects' responses to six
professional values and characteristics; censorship, credibility, responsibility,
sensationalism, audacity and timeliness.
31
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Table 15 shows that Oman daily cultivated the highest percentage for
censorship. About 62% of the respondents believe that censorship is widely
practiced in Oman. This result conforms with the finding of Al-ariami (2002).
The fact that Oman is a government newspaper and has always been
perceived as the mouthpiece of the government might have influenced
respondents' views. In terms of credibility, 40% of the respondents found
Alwatan a credible newspaper but fewer than 25% said the same thing about
Oman. In terms of responsibility, 39.2% of the respondents believe that
Alwatan is a responsible newspaper followed by Oman with 37.1%. The
differences between Oman and Alwatan in this respect are marginal. About
37% of the respondents viewed Alshabiba as a sensational newspaper, and
35.2% said the same about Alwatan. Respondents also viewed Alwatan as
a courageous newspaper in reporting news that is not in line with the
mainstream media and policy. Slightly more than 39% and 25.4% found
Alwatan and Alshabiba to be so, respectively. Alwatan was also viewed as
a timely newspaper in covering events with 47% of the respondents indicating
this, followed by Alshabiba with 25.7%.
In sum, Alwatan was viewed more positively than other newspapers. From
respondents perspectives, it is viewed as a credible, responsible, courageous
and timely newspaper. This result would also explain why Alwatan is more
frequently read than any other newspapers. On the other hand, Oman was
singled out as the most censored newspaper.
Table 15
Valid percents on respondents' perceptions of Omani newspapers
Newspape Censorshi Credibility Responsibilit Sensationalis audacity Newness
r p y m
N % N % N % N % N % N %
Oman 330 61.7 13 24. 198 37.1 50 9.6 88 17. 13 25.
6 9 1 8 7
Alwatan 151 28.2 29 40 209 39.2 104 35.2 20 39. 25 47
9 3 3 3
Alshabib 21 3.9 70 12. 63 11.8 193 36.9 13 25. 87 16.
a 8 1 4 2
Azzaman 6 1.1 8 1.5 16 3 60 11.5 55 10. 18 3.3
7
Observer 8 1.5 14 2.6 13 2.4 12 2.3 13 2.5 8 1.5
32
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Hard copies of newspapers are still popular in Oman since only 3% of the
sample reads the online version of their favourite newspaper. However, this
result was expected because previous studies indicated that the internet in
Oman is not commonly used to browse newspapers (Nagm & Alrawas 2004,
Al-Shaqsi 2011). Most newspaper readers are males with college and
university degrees. The privately owned Alwatan is favoured and read more
than other newspapers followed by Oman. Perhaps, the image of Oman in
the minds of the readers as dashed in censorship, might have affected its
readership. However, when readers' image or view about the professionalism
of Oman was correlated with the frequency of reading, a different result was
observed. Frequent readers of Oman were less likely to see the newspaper
as dashed in censorship. This means that occasional readers and non-
readers of Oman were advancing a subjective judgment, based on their
previous encounters with the newspaper regardless of any editorial changes
the paper has made in the recent years.
News was the most read form of journalistic writing followed by caricatures &
comics and daily columns, respectively. However, when socio-economic
factors were examined, statistically significant differences were observed.
33
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
readers is that private newspapers are more freer than the public ones in their
coverage and reporting. This is not true from a legal perspective, but private
newspapers are not strictly obliged to reflect the official viewpoints in all
matters as do the public ones. The results of this study indicated that readers
in general perceived Oman (public) as dashed in censorship more than other
newspapers by a sizable difference. The private Alwatan was seen as
credible, responsible, courageous and timely in its coverage and reporting.
Alshabiba, (private) was perceived as a sensational newspaper. These
results encourage future researches to thoroughly examine and study the
factors that shape readers' perceptions and images of different media in
Oman.
References:
(Audience Dialogue, 26 June 2006). "Glossary of Media Research Terms".
http://www.audiencedialogue.net/gloss-media.html#readership. Date visited
8/8/2011.
Al-Ghabshi, Aysha. (2002). Omani Women Uses of Different Media and the
Resulting Gratifications. A Master degree dissertation (in Arabic), College of
Communication, Cairo University, Egypt.
35
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Al-Shaqsi, Obaid. (2011). "Uses & Gratifications Resulting from Using Mobile
phones amongst Omani Youth". A paper accepted for publication in the
Egyptian Public Opinion Journal.
Baskette F., Sissors J & Brooks B. (1992). The Art of Editing, 5th ed.
Macmillam inc., NY, USA.
Dubai Press Club. (2010). Arab Media Outlook 2009-2013. ISBN 978-9948-15-
422-8.
Dubai, UAE. http://www.fas.org/irp/eprint/arabmedia.pdf
Effective Measure & Spot on PR (July 2010). Media Consumption & Habits of
MENA Internet Users. Date Visited 20 May 2011. http://www.spotonpr.com/wp-
content/uploads/2010/07/MENAInternetSurvey22Jul10.pdf
MediaSource (2011). "Middle East Media Guide, pdf file", Visited on 4 August
2011. http://www.middleeastmediaguide.com/downloads/newspapers.pdf
36
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
Nemeth, Titus. (2006). The Current State od Arabic Newspaper Type and
Typography. An MA Dissertation Submitted to the Dept. Of Typography &
Graphic Communication, University of Reading, UK
News & Tech. (14 June 2010). Report: Newspaper Outlook Stable for Now.
http://www.newsandtech.com/dateline/article_2dc16a8e-6f22-11df-8c27-
001cc4c002e0.html,.
Skogerbo, Eli & Winsvold, Marte. (2011). "Audience on the Move? Use and
Assessment of Local Print and Online Newspapers." Sage, 26 (3). 214-229.
37
Global Media Journal Spring 2013 – Al-Shaqsi
38