MVEDA Remote Work White Paper
MVEDA Remote Work White Paper
MVEDA Remote Work White Paper
REMOTE WORKING
OPPORTUNITY THEN
In a matter of months, a microorganism crippled economies worldwide, vastly disrupted international supply changes,
and pivoted the concept of a company’s workforce defined by its offices and its home community. Around the United
States, companies have been forced to shift to remote work. The results of this shift have been well documented.
NEWSWEEK: 54% WANT TO PERMENANTLY WORK FROM BUSINESS INSIDER: MAJOR CITIES ARE EXPECTED TO HAVE
HOME1 “URBAN FLIGHTS” AND RURAL AREAS CAN BENEFIT2
IBM surveyed 25,000 people nationwide and 54 percent of them Despite major tech companies quickly shifting to work-from-
want to continue working from home indefinitely, 75 percent home opportunities for their employees, many moved to their
want to work from home occasionally, and 40 percent said urban apartments, which are void of space for any type of home
employers should have an opt-in policy for working from home. office environment. Lower cost real estate of other locations
becomes attractive to remote workers.
-May 5, 2020
-May 14, 2020
FORTUNE: COMPANIES ARE RAPIDLY INCREASING THEIR CNBC: THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC WILL BE THE PIVOT POINT FOR
REMOTE WORKFORCE3 REMOTE WORKING4
Job search engine Adzuna has been tracking US-based remote “‘The coronavirus is going to be a tipping point. We plodded
working job listings online. They found the number of recent along at about 10% growth a year for the last 10 years, but I
listings, 4.5 million, is a 270% increase since 2017. Also of foresee that this is going to really accelerate the trend,’ Kate
interest, they highlighted that employers are increasingly Lister, president of Global Workplace Analytics, told CNBC.”
looking outside of geographic boundaries to find their needed
-March 23, 2020
talent.
-April 7, 2020
THE ATALANTIC: “THERE’S NO POINT IN COMMUTING IN THE PITCHBOOK: VC FIRMS ARE RECONSIDERING THEIR
FIRST PLACE”5 TRADITIONAL URBAN LOCATIONS6
The South Korean CDC has developed a number of The strength of the urban core allowed for VCs to pull
recommendations that will completely reshape the office companies together for collaboration. The COVID-19 pandemic
environment and limit in-person interactions. With all of the forced that physical network to work remotely, and it is forcing
new methods on inhibiting contact, workers and companies will venture capital firms to shift both their physical operations and
be enticed to switch to remote working. their geography for investments to be away from these
environments
-May 22, 2020
-May 26, 2020
BuzzFeed News broke the story of Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey notifying employees by email “that they’d be allowed to work from home
permanently, even after the coronavirus pandemic lockdown passes.” Other tech companies also made the switch to remote working—
including Google, Facebook, Amazon, and Microsoft. Twitter has further cancelled all travel and in-person events company-wide through the
end of the year, with only “assessments” for what would happen in 2021. “Twitter human resources head Jennifer Christie told BuzzFeed
News the company would ‘never probably be the same’ in the structure of its work.”
OPPORTUNITY NOW
From the beginning of the pandemic, companies and governments shifted to accommodate continued operations.
Over one year later, companies are examining their continued remote work opportunities and more are announcing
that it is a working arrangement that will stay.
BLOOMBERG BUSINESSWEEK: CA’S PROP 22 IS RESHAPING MICROSOFT 2021 WORK TREND INDEX: “TALENT IS
EMPLOYMENT RELATIONSHIPS8 EVERYWHERE IN A HYBRID WORK WORLD”9
In recent months labor groups have met with gig companies to Examining 30,000+ people in 31 countries using Microsoft 365
discuss compromises that would create some form of collective and LinkedIn, Microsoft found that hybrid work will be critical for
bargaining for gig workers. They point to Prop 22’s passage as attracting and retaining diverse talent. Also, despite reports of
an expressed preference for bargaining rights over employment longer work periods and exhaustion, employees report a want for
status continued hybrid and remote work going forward.
SITE SELECTION GROUP: JOB CREATION WITHIN GEOGRAPHIC WALL STREET JOURNAL: REMOTE WORK IS MOVING
BOUNDARIES ARE SHIFTING10 WORKFORCE OUT OF BIG CITIES11
There are currently 9 statewide remote worker attraction “[As] much as a quarter of the 160-million-strong U.S. labor force
programs in the US found in Georgia, Virginia, Michigan, New is expected to stay fully remote in the long term, and many more
Jersey, Kansas, Vermont, Tennessee, Hawaii, and Colorado. are likely to work remotely a significant part of the time. … A Pew
Local municipalities have created their own incentives packages Research survey in November found that about 5% of Americans
for remote workers, too. These include Tulsa, OK, Shoals, AL, had moved [recently] as a result of the pandemic—after only
Savannah, GA, and Northwest Arkansas. 9.3% moved for any reason in all of 2019.”
SOUTH FLORIDA BUSINESS JOURNAL: EMPLOYEES EXPECT PwC: REMOTE WORK WILL CHANGE COMMERCIAL REAL
CONTINUED REMOTE WORK12 ESTATE IN THE NEXT 12 MONTHS13
Surveying over 7,000 employees across 12 countries, Citrix and Physical office space in large cities will shrink and serve as a hub
OnePoll found that, “Almost 75% of respondents said they for office locations outside of large cities. Additionally, real
would consider relocating to a different city if they didn't have estate needs are expected to increase to accommodate social
to commute to a physical office. A previous survey of 2,000 U.S. distancing needs. Remote and hybrid workers will have more
workers found that 25% said they had already left their city, or opportunities outside of major urban areas.
planned to do so, because of their ability to work remotely.”
-January 12, 2021
-March 19, 2021
Qumo Corporation was a live and on-demand video software company based in Minnesota with offices in India and London. In late 2020,
they made a decision to shutter all offices for a fully remote operation. The company found success in recruiting a Chief Marketing Officer and
a Chief Revenue Officer from San Francisco and Portland, Oregon, respectively. “Qumu CEO TJ Kennedy said the company's permanent work-
from-home policy has given the company a competitive advantage in recruiting. ‘In the past, we may have only hired people who lived near
one of our four offices," Kennedy said. "Now that's a much more wide open view and gives you a different pool of talent and capability.’"
INTRODUCTION
The COVID-19 pandemic is causing worldwide economic disruption. Through advancements in technology and investments in IT infrastructure,
the world has become more prepared for remote work opportunities, but had not previously embraced this workforce concept broadly. The
recent pandemic has forced many companies and communities to reexamine their approach to remote work.
At MVEDA, our focus on this economic-base industry concept in response to COVID-19 has brought the follow opportunities into focus for Doña
Ana County communities and their residents. We strongly believe that alignment of resources to developing a diverse remote working
community will help anchor our communities and their economies in stability against future pandemic concerns.
BACKGROUND
In April 1982, Jack Niles predicted, “Telework and telecommuting are likely to increase at an accelerating rate over the next decade. By 1990,
there may be as many as 10 million telecommuters” due to new advances in technology.15 According to the US Census 2019 American
Community Survey, 5.7 percent of workers in the United States (over 8.9 million) 16 and older reported working at home. In New Mexico, 5.1
percent reported working from home. These figures show an upward trend from 2010, when nationwide 4.3 percent of workers and 4.9 percent
of workers statewide reported working at home.16
The US Bureau of Labor Statistics tracks work-at-home with an additional distinguishing factors. Of the population surveyed in the United States
ages 15 and older between 2017-2018, 28.8 percent of all 144.2 million workers could work from home. In fact, 24.8 percent of all workers
reported working from home over that time period. 82.9 percent of all that worked at home hold full-time positions. Over 72 percent of those
that worked at home have a Bachelor’s degree or higher. Of those who worked at home, 42.7 percent had weekly earnings greater than the
75th percentile of full-time wage and salary workers. The top 3 industries within which the greatest number of workers reported working at
home include: education and health services (8.8 million workers); professional and business services (7.9 million workers); and financial
activities (4.8 million workers). Also noted, slightly more than 1 out of every 3 people that work at home report having a child under the age of
18. Of those, 79.1 percent have a child or children under the age of 13. 17
Gallup Inc., a U.S.-based analytics and advisory firm, published the State of the American Workforce report for 2017.18 Within the report, Gallup
found that, “Only one-third of U.S. employees are engaged in their work and workplace (page 6).” This disengagement is what motivates many
employees to find work elsewhere. Disengagement is also leading to new methods of achieving full-time work. “[I]f employees can’t find an
exceptional job that complements other aspects of their life or, at a minimum, pays enough to make the 8-to-5 grind worthwhile, they can
create their own job category. They might work 20 hours a week at a contracted office gig, 20 as a ride-hailing service driver and 10 as a
freelancer (page 6).”
All of this highlights a number of trends that have led to a different style of working. Technological advancements and job fulfillment are only
two of many reasons why more people are turning to remote work opportunities. However, in many ways, this type of work has been largely
overlooked by the economic development community. Because remote work covers a broad scope of work skills, industries, and growing
applications, it is difficult for traditional economic development work to create mechanisms of support for this type of work. However, there are
some options for New Mexico.
INCOME TAX ISSUES
Despite the growing trend and demonstrated desire by the public to do remote work, there are a number of barriers established in policy that create
“pinch points” for companies and their employees. The following is brief, but not summative, examination of those remote working concerns.
There are two different forms of income taxes here to discuss that discourage residents of states from obtaining remote working positions. On the
corporate side of state income taxes, we are dealing with individual state apportionment methods. Specifically, the discussion is centered around a
state’s “nexus,” or whether a state has the power to tax a business. This authority is often established by a business having either property, sales, or
employees within a state’s jurisdiction—a “three-factor formula” brought about by the Uniform Division of Income for Tax Purposes Act. With
remote working, where a company may have primary operations in one state, but elect to hire staff in another, the state where the employee is
working may elect to tax the company for business conducted within its jurisdiction. New Mexico recently passed some changes to move away from
this apportionment method for headquarters and manufacturers, which may now elect an apportionment that triple-weights only the sales of the
company within New Mexico. However, this apportionment does not benefit companies that hire New Mexico residents as remote workers.
The other form of income tax is on the individual—personal income tax. Some states enforce a “convenience of the employer rule” whereby the
home state of the company, if it has a personal income tax rate, may tax an employer on wages paid to an individual regardless of whether or not
that individual’s work was performed within the state. If the worker’s home state has an income tax, the worker may be required to pay both the
company’s state of origin personal income tax and the state rate where they performed the work. According to Ilya Lipin (2010), five states—
“Delaware, Nebraska, New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania—[use] the aforementioned taxation methods by employing the convenience versus
necessity test.”19 On April 18, 2016, Congress introduced some legislation to address this interstate double taxation of the remote worker titled the
“Multi-State Worker Tax Fairness Act,” but the legislation was referred to the US Senate Committee on Finance and never moved from there. In
Comptroller of the Treasury of Maryland v. Wynne, the United States Supreme Court held that full credit must be granted for income tax paid to
other government entities. While providing some relief and direction for taxpayers, this did not overrule the gap taxpayers are burdened with if the
credit does not resolve the liabilities of governments.
Complicating the personal income tax component further, there are local jurisdictions around the country that also impose income tax rates. In
2019, the Tax Foundation found, “Local income taxes are imposed by 4,964 taxing jurisdictions across 17 states, with a heavy concentration in Rust
Belt states, particularly Ohio and Pennsylvania.”20 In all, 190 counties, 3,816 municipalities, 954 school districts, and 4 special districts all impose
some form of local income tax. While some may be very minimal and insignificant to impact remote working and others are only imposed on
interest and dividend income, this does add another layer of consideration for companies considering a remote workforce.
To date, 16 states and the District of Columbia have enacted varying income tax reciprocity agreements with other states that allow remote workers
to not worry about this additional taxation. Additionally, some states, like Connecticut, have implemented personal income tax credits to offset the
negative impacts of this additional tax. New Mexico has neither reciprocity agreements nor an offsetting credit for remote workers on the books.
TYPES OF
REMOTE WORK
RECRUITING REMOTE WORK EMPLOYERS RESHORING REMOTE WORK TALENT RETAINING EMPLOYERS
A key component of economic development is NMSU’s alumni base is a group of talent that is Following a model similar to Colorado’s in-
growing the base of employers that have sales familiar with Las Cruces. With many programs state enticement for remote working
from other locations and hire people locally. offered throughout the country right now, the opportunities, residents of Doña Ana County
The new payroll generated reduces the effects community must upfront sell the quality of life may look to more urban environments of El
of local leakage and supports community and livability of a community over others Paso and Albuquerque. Both of these areas,
growth. offering similar benefits. Alumni, as former with larger concentrations of employers could
residents, are familiar with the assets of the offer hybrid and fully remote work options
With this in mind, there are employers community. Additionally, there are plenty of with employers that are currently
globally shifting to recruitment of a remote anecdotes about college towns not having reconsidering their real estate needs and
workforce. By identifying those companies, enough job opportunities available for recent employment diversification.
communities can grow job opportunities for a graduates to entice them to stay (aka, “brain
variety of residents with smaller investments drain”). For New Mexico, this approach allows for
than traditional methods of employer urban and rural locations to partner on
recruitment. Focusing on the alumni network (including workforce initiatives for the benefit of
upcoming graduates), we can examine two employers that has previously not been
One approach, then, is to develop options: explored.
partnerships with a number of remote work
employers and screens candidates for ) Recruit alumni back who are remotely Under Colorado’s Location Neutral
deficiencies. Once candidates are identified, working with W2, 1099, and digital Employment Incentive (LONE), companies in
the work of the partnerships should also team business/freelance opportunities. urban environments that hire Colorado
potential candidates with services to resolve ) Encourage seniors pursuing career residents in rural locations receive a tax credit
identified needs. options to ask potential employers for between $2,500-$5,000 for each job they
remote work opportunities to stay in keep within the state.
REFERENCES
1) Fink, J., Newsweek. (May 4, 2020). 54 Percent of Americans Want to Work Remote Regularly After Coronavirus
Pandemic Ends, New Poll Shows. Retrieved from https://www.newsweek.com/54-percent-americans-want-work-
remote-regularly-after-coronavirus-pandemic-ends-new-poll-shows-1501809.
2) Canales, K., Business Insider. (May 14, 2020). An 'urban flight' from the San Francisco Bay Area could be
accelerated as more people work remotely in the future and flock to less expensive US cities. Retrieved from
https://www.businessinsider.com/pandemic-urban-flight-people-leaving-silicon-valley-coronavirus-2020-5.
3) Fisher, A., Fortune. (April 7, 2020). As work from home becomes the norm, companies get more comfortable
hiring fully remote employees. Retrieved from https://fortune.com/2020/04/07/remote-work-from-home-jobs-
hiring-coronavirus.
4) Jacobson, L., CNBC. (March 23, 2020). As coronavirus forces millions to work remotely, the US economy may have
reached a ‘tipping point’ in favor of working from home. Retrieved from https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/23/
what-coronavirus-means-for-the-future-of-work-from-home.html.
5) Thompson, D., The Atlantic. (May 22, 2020). Social Distancing Is Not Enough. Retrieved from https://amp-
theatlantic-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/amp.theatlantic.com/amp/article/611953.
6) Davis, A., PitchBook. (May 26, 2020). VC poised for another shakeup as workers abandon tech hubs. Retrieved
from https://pitchbook.com/news/articles/vc-poised-for-another-shakeup-as-workers-abandon-tech-hubs.
7) Kantrowitz, A., BuzzFeed News. (May 12, 2020). Twitter will allow employees to work at home forever. Retrieved
from https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/alexkantrowitz/twitter-will-allow-employees-to-work-at-home-
forever.
8) Eidelson, Josh, Bloomberg Businessweek. (February 17, 2021). The Gig Economy Is Coming for Millions of
American Jobs. Retrieved from https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2021-02-17/gig-economy-coming-
for-millions-of-u-s-jobs-after-california-s-uber-lyft-vote.
9) Anders, George, et al., Microsoft. (March 22, 2021). 2021 Work Trend Index: Annual Report—The Next Great
Disruption is Hybrid Work—Are We Ready? Retrieved from https://ms-worklab.azureedge.net/files/reports/
hybridWork/pdf/2021_Microsoft_WTI_Report_March.pdf.
10) Rendziperis, Kelley, Site Selection Group. (March 23, 2021). Economic Incentives for a Remote Workforce.
Retrieved from https://info.siteselectiongroup.com/blog/economic-incentives-for-a-remote-workforce.
11) Florida, Richard and Ozimek, Adam, The Wall Street Journal. (March 5, 2021). How Remote Work Is Reshaping
America’s Urban Geography. Retrieved from https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-remote-work-is-reshaping-
americas-urban-geography-11614960100.
12) Portero, Ashley, South Florida Business Journal. (March 19, 2021). Survey: For employees, there's no going back
after a year of remote work. Retrieved from https://www.bizjournals.com/southflorida/news/2021/03/19/citrix-
survey-shows-how-a-year-of-r.html.
13) PwC. (January 12, 2021). PwC’s US Remote Work Survey. Retrieved from https://www.pwc.com/us/
remotework.
REFERENCES
14) Jones, Carter, Minneapolis / St. Paul Business Journal. (March 22, 2021). Remote work policy is boon to Qumu as
it hires out-of-state executives. Retrieved from https://www.bizjournals.com/twincities/news/2021/03/22/qumu
-work-from-home-executive-hires.html.
15) Niles, J. (April 1982). Teleworking: Working closer to home. Technology Review, 85(3), 56-62.
16) U.S. Census Bureau. (2019). Commuting characteristics by sex, 2019 American Community Survey 1-year
estimates. Retrieved from https://data.census.gov/cedsci/table?
t=Commuting&g=0100000US_0400000US35&tid=ACSST1Y2019.S0801&hidePreview=false.
17) U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2018). Table 1. Workers who could work at home, did work at home, and were
paid for work at home, by selected characteristics, averages for the period 2017-2018. Retrieved from https://
www.bls.gov/news.release/flex2.t01.htm.
18) Gallup, Inc. (2017). State of American workforce report. Retrieved from https://www.gallup.com/
workplace/238085/state-american-workplace-report-2017.aspx.
19) Lipin, I., J.D., LL.M. & The Tax Advisor. (2010). A practitioner’s guide to the taxation of telecommuting. Retrieved
from https://www.thetaxadviser.com/issues/2010/feb/apractitionersguidetothetaxationoftelecommuting.html.
20) Walczak, J. & The Tax Foundation. (2019). Local income taxes in 2019. Retrieved from https://taxfoundation.org/
local-income-taxes-2019.