The Battle of The Smooth Criminal-2
The Battle of The Smooth Criminal-2
The Battle of The Smooth Criminal-2
Avery Hamilton
Professor Leonard
English 1201
13 February 2020
“Annie are you okay?” In 1988, Michael Jackson produced the song “Smooth Criminal”.
About 20 years later in 2009, Alien Ant Farm came out with a remix of the song with the same
name. Michael Jackson and Alien Ant Farm both sang the same lyrics in their versions of the
song "Smooth Criminal", but the music videos are focused on completely different messages to
Michael Jackson starts off his music video by running into a gangster club. As he enters,
everyone becomes very tense. He starts to frantically search the club. This leads him into fights
with the gangsters. As he defeats them, he breaks out into dance montages. The mood is still
serious. On the other hand, Alien Ant Farm’s video is a tribute to Michael Jackson. The music
video is placed at a wild backyard party. The band is centered in a fighting ring. The mood is
Michael Jackson's video has a strong message; he will do anything to make sure Annie is
okay. He is risking his life by getting into fights with gangsters. He didn’t miss one inch of the
club unsearched. He is doing nothing but his best to find Annie. This makes the song go from
Alien Ant Farm’s video also has a strong message. The message is to show respect for
Michael’s hard work. They did this by incorporating many things. One of the first images is a kid
doing Michael inspired moves with a mask on. The drummer is wearing the icon glove. They
Hamilton 2
also get a chair that the lead singer sits in that is a giant Michael inspired glove. The band
continued to make many more small hints that the message was to give homage to the king of
pop.
Both videos appeal to completely different audiences. Michael’s rhythm and beat is more
geared for the pop genre, while Alien Ant Farm’s video adds more of an intense guitar, making it
more for the rock genre. The music videos also appeal to different audiences. Michael’s video is
based in an intense bar with high stakes. This makes it more for the dramatic and serious side of
the song. The Alien Ant Farm’s setting is a crazy party with people cheering and being happy.
This makes for the more upbeat and fun side. Both have their purpose for why they chose that
feel. Michael’s video was based on the need to find Annie. The Alien Ant Farm’s video is based
Pathos was the key to understanding the message. The lyrics makes us have an emotional
attachment to the safety of Annie. He first hooks us by saying “He came into her apartment. He
left the bloodstains on the carpet”. We are immediately emotionally involved. The chorus “Are
you okay Annie?”, makes us feel concerned for Annie’s sake. Michael's music video only adds
to the pathos. The scenes of him fighting and searching, only make us more invested in the safety
of Annie. Overall, pathos makes the audience be able to connect to the song and the original
music video.
Even though they both have the same lyrics, the music videos appeal to different
audiences with different messages. Michael’s was about finding Annie with a pop beat. Whereas
Alien Ant Farm’s was about paying respects to the original song with a rock beat. Also, the
music videos offer different moods. One is more serious and urgent and the other is more upbeat
and fun. Overall, both artists made different beats and music videos to attract different people.
Hamilton 3
Hamilton 4
Works Cited
“Michael Jackson - Smooth Criminal (Official Video).” YouTube, uploaded by Michael Jackson,