Green Logistics' Directions in The System of Urban Sustainable Development
Green Logistics' Directions in The System of Urban Sustainable Development
Green Logistics' Directions in The System of Urban Sustainable Development
net/publication/330853912
CITATIONS READS
0 756
4 authors, including:
Tetiana Obydiennova
Ukrainian Engineering Pedagogics Academy
12 PUBLICATIONS 6 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Olena Anatolievna Karlova on 04 February 2019.
Abstract
The main aim of the paper is to develop the green logistics’ direction for the urban sustainable development’s
maintenance. The importance of green logistics in the system of urban sustainable development is revealed in
the paper. The author identifies a city as a logistics system which is the path breaker in the implementation of
scientific and technological progress. The author notes that urban green logistics is an aggregation of logistical
approaches to optimize directions of material flows, vehicles, natural, financial, information, energy and human
resources with the use of advanced technologies in process of decision making by local governments to create
an environment within which provided the population, increased efficiency of urban and reached a condition
to minimize the negative effects of human intervention in the ecosystem of the city. Principles of the urban
green logistics are defined. Foreign experience of urban green logistics solutions is analysed. Directions of
urban green logistics development are proposed.
JEL Classification: O18.
Keywords: Green Logistics, Urban Sustainable Development, the Principles of Green Logistics, Green
Logistics’ Directions.
1. Introduction
Analysis of current trends in urban sustainable development shows that new technologies have caused
new social relations. Anthropogenic impact is close to objective limits, unresolved environmental problems
limit the development of many industrial branches. In many works devoted to environmental economics
paradigm of maximizing social welfare is traditionally dominating. Industrial enterprises are the most active
consumers of the natural resources in the national economic complex, causing many problems with the use
787 International Journal of Applied Business and Economic Research
Maryna Averkyna, Olena Karlova, Olena Kirian and Tetiana Obydiennova
of natural resources and negative impact on the environment. These negative trends affecting the urban
sustainable development. Nowadays, sustainable development is one of the most important commitment
engaged by most of the countries in the world (A. Scipioni, A. Mazzi, M. Mason, A. Manzardo, 2009).
The concept of sustainable development was formulated in response to a growing awareness that there
are several important relationships between processes such as social and economic development, global,
regional and local environmental problems, increase in population and urban built-up area a (Malkina-Pykh,
2002). At the international level, the first World Summit on Sustainable Development at Rio de Janeiro
in 1992 established Agenda 21 and suggested that all countries around the world formulate economic
policies with a minimum impact on the environment, and encourage social promotion of individuals and
the community (UN, 1992a). Maintenance of the sustainable development of cities requires developing of
green logistics’ directions.
Green logistics is a form of logistics which is calculated to be environmentally and often socially
friendly in addition to economically functional. It describes all attempts to measure and minimize the
ecological impact of logistics activities. This includes all activities of the forward and reverse flows of
products, information and services between the point of origin and the point of consumption. It is the
aim to create a sustainable company value using a balance of economic and environmental efficiency
(R. Saroha, 2014).
“Green logistics” − the term containing costs, yet did not appear on financial reports and on the
environment and society (A. Kumar, 2015). According to Rodrigue et. al., (2012), the term “green logistics”
is defined as supply chain management practices and strategies that reduce the environmental and energy
footprint of freight distribution, which focuses on material handling, waste management, packaging and
transport while according to Mesjasz-Lech (2011), green logistics consists of all activities related to the eco-
efficient management of the forward and reverse flows of products and information between the point of
origin and the point of consumption whose purpose is to meet or exceed customer demand. S. Lee, R. Klassen
(2008) describe green logistics as Green Supply Chain Management that can be defined as an organizations
activity taking into account environmental issues and integrating it into supply chain management in order
to change the environmental performance of suppliers and customers, while according to A. Sibihi, R.
Eglese (2009), green logistics activities include measuring the environmental impact of different distribution
strategies, reducing the energy usage in logistics activities, reducing waste and managing its treatment. From
the sustainable development point of view, green logistics can be defined as, “producing and distributing
goods in a sustainable way, taking account of environmental and social factors”.
According to Marcus Thiell (2011), the framework for green logistics will comprises green transport;
green warehousing; green packaging; green logistics data collection and management; waste management,
while according to D. Rogers (1998), the general character of the green logistics system is employing
advanced technology and equipment to minimize environmental damage and increase the utilization
of the resources. Reserve logistics is covering transportation, warehousing, and value added services in
the context of redistribution of end-of life products and residuals along with their collection, product
inspection, dismantling and separation, reprocessing of secondary materials and products, and distribution
into productive processes (K.-I. Voigt, 2004).
In our view, urban green logistics is an aggregation of logistical approaches to optimize directions of
material flows (including flows of waste and secondary resources for treatment), vehicles, natural, financial,
information, energy and human resources with the use of advanced technologies in process of decision
making by local governments to create an environment within which provided the population, increased
efficiency of urban and reached a condition to minimize the negative effects of human intervention in the
ecosystem of the city.
The basic principles of urban green logistics’ are:
1. System approach. Treating city as a system is the main feature of urban green logistics. The
maximum effect can be obtained only when urban material flows are optimized throughout the
supply chain, not only within individual enterprises.
2. The principle of rational localization of production facilities. Production facilities should be
placed as close as possible to the city which provides skilled laborers, while being distanced
791 International Journal of Applied Business and Economic Research
Maryna Averkyna, Olena Karlova, Olena Kirian and Tetiana Obydiennova
enough from the urban sanitary protection zone, with regards to urban perspective development
plans.
3. The principle of logistical coordination. Processing management of material flows in the city,
it is necessary to ensure coherence in time for all parts of the logistics chain. This principle
involves the development of coordinated plans for management of material flows within the
city and beyond, the development of standards and technical conditions for logistics operations,
forecasting supply inventories and capital goods without creating congestion in the city system
and the minimum acceptable level of impact on the ecosystem.
4. The principle of stability and adaptability. Logistics system performing its functions in a relatively
wide range shall not adversely affect the sustainability of the city.
Applying principles of green logistics in the system of the city mainly depends on local authorities
that the active interaction with other entities to initiate the formation of new institutional framework of a
new urban model, where economic, social and environmental factors are combined. Since the economic
impact assessment of the ecological state of the city and its population is crucial.
When adapting green logistics there could be some inconsistencies that might arise. The issue is that
green logistics is supposed to be environmental friendly, but logistics in itself is not very green because of
pollution and waste that it creates. So when adapting green logistics there are some paradoxes that arise
as given below (R. Saroha, 2014):
∑ Cost: Companies wants to get the cheapest way to do things but at the same time they should
choose options that are green, which sometimes are more costly to the company. The purpose of
logistics is to minimize costs, notably transport costs. The cost-saving strategies that are pursued
by logistics operators are often at variance with environmental considerations.
∑ Time/Flexibility: The modern integrated supply chains and JIT provide adjustable and competent
physical distribution systems but on the other hand extended production, distribution and retailing
models are consuming more space, energy and generate more emissions (CO2, particulates, NOx,
etc.).
∑ Reliability: At the heart of logistics is the overriding importance of service reliability. Its success
is based upon the ability to deliver freight on time with the least threat of breakage or damage
while the least polluting modes are generally regarded as being the least reliable in terms of on-
time delivery, lack of breakage and safety. Ships and railways have inherited a reputation for
poor customer satisfaction, and the logistics industry is built around air and truck shipments...
the two least environmentally-friendly modes.
∑ Warehousing: A reduction in warehousing demands is one of the advantages of logistics. This
means however, that inventories have been transferred to a certain degree to the transport system,
especially the roads. Inventories are actually in transit, contributing still further to congestion and
pollution. The environment and society, not the logistical operators, are assuming the external
costs.
∑ E-commerce: The explosion of the information technology has led to new dimensions in retailing
- e-commerce. However, changes in physical distribution systems by e-commerce have led to
higher levels of energy consumption.
International Journal of Applied Business and Economic Research 792
Green Logistics’ Directions in the System of Urban Sustainable Development
Due to the practice of foreign countries, the emphasis of implemented logistics solutions was moved
to overcoming such phenomena as air pollution by particulate matter of diesel fuel, nitrogen oxides,
hydrocarbons, noise, road networks, and transport over saturation.
Accordingly, the reasons were identified that have shaped above listed problems:
- chaotic placement of a large number of loading/unloading terminals through the city (e.g. 6200
points only in central part of Madrid);
- poorly designed routes for transferring of material resources in the city, which leads to constant
stopping and starting while the internal combustion engine works in most non-economic
regime;
- inefficient use of transport resulting in insufficient loading of the last trips in public transport;
- transferring of material resources in the city are made of heavy diesel vehicles used of release;
- transferring of material resources in the city made in hours of maximum load of the road
network.
In overcoming the above problems, city authorities have taken the following measures (Gerasymchuk
Z.V., Averkyna M.F., 2012):
- in Copenhagen (Denmark) it was identified a clear list of areas and pints where stops of commercial
trucks for unloading are permitted;
- in Stockholm (Sweden) was created urban distribution centers located outside the city, material
resources to the distribution centers received heavy traffic and in the city they are carried by
trucks carrying up to 3.5 tones, routes which, upon the request of the final recipients, so that
calculated from center truck proceeded to the city the most loaded;
- in Stockholm, Gothenburg, Malmö and Lund (Sweden) areas are limited traffic of trucks over
the age of 8 years;
- in Barcelona (Spain) streets with heavy traffic and constant commercial activities have separate
lane accesible for traffic from 8.00 to 10.00 and from 17.00 to 19.00, accessible for loading and
unloading operations from 10.00 to 17.00, and accessible for parking from 19.00 to 8.00;
In Rotterdam (Netherlands) and Osaka (Japan) transport companies are stimulated to greater use of
transport in hybrid and electric trucks in the construction, so that they are able to operate in areas prohibited
for vehicles with combustion engines;
- in Zurich (Switzerland) it is introduced the use of existing networks of electric (trolley) transport
for garbage collection for disposal;
- in Barcelona (Spain) it is offered to transfer urban material resources at night, during which there
is two trips - at 23.00 and at 5.00, which by their loads equivalent to seven trips during peak
times.
Some companies implemented principles of green logistics. DHL is an international logistic company,
active in over 220 countries across the globe. It is also part of the world’s leading postal and logistics Group,
Deutsche Post DHL, encompassing three different divisions: DHL Express, DHL Global Forwarding,
Freight and DHL Supply Chain. Since 2009, DHL is focused on Corporate Social Responsibility and
sustainability, having developed the following programs: PPGoGreen, dedicated to environment protection;
PPGoHelp, dedicated to disaster management; PPGoTeach, dedicated to the spread of education in the
world. In terms of sustainability, DHL believes that sustainable and environmental-friendly services can
contribute to long-term competitiveness improvement. Thus, sustainability will also have a positive influence
on new customers’ acquisition and on existing ones retention. The most important sustainable actions
are related to the optimization of transport routes, the use of vehicles with alternative drive systems, and
energy-efficient warehouses. DHL offers a great number of green products and services oriented to CO2,
and greenhouse gas emissions reduction, according to a general logic of green optimization. Concluding,
the company believes that environmental protection and business success are not only compatible, but
also closely related (S. Cosimato, O. Troisi, 2014).
IKEA is a global furniture store that provides “cheap furniture that as many as possible can afford”.
Ikeas company view of green logistics is firstly to remove the wooden pallets from the entire supply
chain. Instead of wooden pallets they are using Paper/cardboard pallets and so called ledges. Underneath
these ledges there are a plastic leg underneath the goods. Because of this approach they are dramatically
decreasing transportation, CO2 emissions, PP/LL can be packed with less space than with normal wooden
pallets. Also IKEAs Iway monitoring system steer transport partners to use low Co2 equipments. The
Iway monitoring system is IKEAS own measuring system. The goals for IKEA within green logistics are
as the following (https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/green-logistics-its-significance-modern-day-systems-
prashant-dedhia):
- 2012 60% total flow integrated to non wooden pallets;
- 2014 100% of total flow integrated to non wooden pallets;
- 2015 all transport partners are fulfilling the Iway standards.
B. Beskovnik, L. Jakomin (2010) point that the European green logistics initiative is very strong and
very well positioned at macro level. A vast number of different decisions and goals were performed in the
last fifteen years. Consequently, environmental issues, tasks and goals are incorporated in the European
institutions, enabling EU to give proposals and constantly measure the adoption of proposals in all member
states. Moreover, the European green logistics policy made a step forward, with the goal of developing
a model of European sustainable logistics. This concept covers three main fields: society, economy and
environment, with different activities:
1. Society: Safety, health, access, equity.
2. Economy: Employment, competitiveness, efficiency, growth, choice.
3. Environment: Air quality, noise, land use, biodiversity, waste and climate changes.
We develop the direction of green logistics for maintenance of the urban sustainable development
consider that city is a logistic system, features maintenance of the urban sustainable development, the basic
principles of urban green logistics and the study of foreign experience in applying the principles of green
logistics (Figure 1).
International Journal of Applied Business and Economic Research 794
Green Logistics’ Directions in the System of Urban Sustainable Development
85%$1*5((1/2*,67,&6
,GHDRIJUHHQORJLVWLFV
2UJDQL]DWLRQRIORJLVWLFIORZLQWKHXUEDQVXEV\VWHPIRUUHGXFWLRQWKHQHJDWLYHEXUGHQ
%DVLFJUHHQORJLVWLFV¶GLUHFWLRQV
7KHPDLQWDVNVJUHHQORJLVWLFV¶
&RRUGLQDWLRQRIWKHWLPHDOOSDUWVRIWKHORJLVWLFVFKDLQ
2SWLPL]DWLRQRIPDWHULDOIORZVWKURXJKRXWWKHVXSSO\FKDLQEDVHGJUHHQWHFKQRORJLHV
2UJDQL]DWLRQRIUDWLRQDOGLVWULEXWLRQRISURGXFWLRQLQWKHFLW\DQGPHWURSROLWDQDUHD
5HVXOW
0DLQWHQDQFHRIWKHXUEDQVXVWDLQDEOHGHYHORSPHQW
The developing main green logistics’ directions to maintenance of rational consumption of socio-
ecological and economic resources of the city, reproduction of socio-ecological and economic resources
of the city, socio-ecological and economic security. Institutional support for green logistics in the urban
system is necessary for providing green logistics’ directions in cities.
4. Conclusions
The study of foreign experience in the green logistics application one can argue that the role of institutional
support of green logistics in the system management has become crucial. It is noteworthy that for most
cities in Ukraine are characterized by use of the green logistics’ direction. One of the major reasons for
this is lack of institutional support green logistics in the system of the city. That is why the mechanism
responsible for implementing of the green logistics’ directions in the city doesn’t exist.
The main factor of institutional support for green logistics on the stage of market transformation is the
institutions that form a coherent system, with interacting elements. In order to implement the institutional
potential it is necessary to eliminate misuse of institutions, to overcome the lack of institutions, to transform
the institutional framework into determining factor in sustainable development.
Summarizing, one could argue that crucial to maintaining sustainable development are using directions
of urban green logistics. However, the realities of current trends show that in all cities in Ukraine is no
mechanism for implementing green logistics’ directions in the city that negatively affects the urban sustainable
development. Therefore it is necessary to develop a mechanism for institutional support of urban green
logistics in the city.
795 International Journal of Applied Business and Economic Research
Maryna Averkyna, Olena Karlova, Olena Kirian and Tetiana Obydiennova
References
Averkyna M.F. (2014). Functioning performance features of a city as a logistics system. Actual Problems of Economics. no
10 (160) : 210–213.
Bai X. (2003). The process and mechanism of urban environmental change: an evolutionary view. International Journal of
Environment and Pollution, no 19 (5) : 528–541. doi: https://doi.org/10.1504/ijep.2003.004319
Beskovnik B., Jakomin L. (2010). Challenges of Green Logistics in Southeast Europe. Promet – Traffic&Transportation, Vol.
22, No. 2 : 147-155
Cosimato S., Troisi O. (2014). The Influence of Green Innovation in Logistics Competitiveness and Sustainability. The
DHL Case Study. 17th Toulon-Verona International Conference. Excellence in Services : 95-111.
Gerasymchuk Z.V., Averkyna M.F. (2014). Theoretical and methodological foundations for maintaining of sustainable
development of the cities and metropolitan agglomeration. Scientific Bulletin of National Mining University. no 5 (143)
: 134–141.
Gerasymchuk Z.V., Averkyna M.F. (2012). Institutional support for urban green logistics. Actual Problems of Economics. no
11 (137) : 161–168.
Geroliminis N. A review of green logistics schemes used in cities around the world: [Internet recourse] / access mode:
http://www.metrans.org/nuf/documents/geroliminis.pdf.
Green Logistics & its Significance in Modern Day Systems: [Internet recourse] / access mode: https://www.linkedin.com
/pulse/green-logistics-its-significance-modern-day-systems-prashant-dedhia.
Jedliński M. (2014). The position of green logistics in sustainable development of a smart green city. Procedia – Social and
Behavioral Sciences 151 : 102–111.
Paul R. Murphy, Richard F. Braunschweig, D. Charles Green logistics: Comparative views of environmental progressives,
moderates, and conservatives. Journal of Business Logistics. [Internet recourse]. - access mode: http://findarticles.
com/p/articles/ mi_qa3705/is_199601/ ai_n8748499/
Kumar A. (2015). Green Logistics for sustainable development: an analytical review. IOSRD International Journal of
Business. Volume 1, Issue 1, April 2015, Pages 07-13.
Li Feng, Liu Xusheng, Hu Dan, Wang Rusong, Yang Wenrui, Li Dong, Zha Dan (2009). Measurement indicators and an
evaluation approach for assessing urban sustainable development: A case study for China’s Jining City. Landscape
and Urban Planning 90 (2009) : 134–14.
Lee, S.Y. and Klassen, R.D. (2008). Drivers and Enablers That Foster Environmental Management Capabilities in Small- and
Medium-Sized Suppliers in Supply Chains, Production and Operations Management Society, Vol. 17, No. 6 : 573-586.
Malkina-Pykh, I.G. (2002). Integrated assessment models and response function models: pros and cons for sustainable
development indices design. Ecol. Indic. 2, 93–108.
Mesjasz-Lech, A. (2011). Forecasting of demand for direct production materials as the element of supply logistics of
thermal power plants. LogForum 7, 2, 5 : 51-61.
Moroz О. Experience of nymechchyny in creation of regional logistic centers: [Internet recourse] / access mode: http://
www.nbuv.gov.ua/portal/soc_gum/en_re/2008_5_4/zbirnnuk_RE_4_398.pdf.
Rituraj Saroha (2014). Green Logistics & its Significance in Modern Day Systems. International Review of Applied Engineering
Research. Volume 4, Number 1 (2014), : 89-92.
Rogers, D.S., Tibben-Lembke, R.S. (1998). Going backwards–reverse logistics trends and practices. Reno, NV: Reverse
Logistics Executive Council. Downloaded from www.rlec.org/reverse.pdf.
Rodrigue J-P., Slack B., Comtois C. (2001). Green logistics (the paradoxes of), The handbook of logistics and supply chain
management; [A.M. Brewer, K.J. Button, D.A. Hensher]. – London : Pergamon. : 339-350.
Sbihi A., Eglese, R. (2007). The relationship between vehicle routing and scheduling and green logistics - a literature survey
(Management Science Working Paper Series). Lancaster University: The Department of Management Science.
Smirnov І.G. (2002). “Green logіstics”: ecology-geografy dimension. Ukrainian geography magazine. No. 2 : 49–52.
Scipioni A., Mazzi A., Mason M., Manzardo A. (2009). The Dashboard of Sustainability to measure the local urban
sustainable development: The case study of Padua. Municipality. ecological indicators 9: 364–380.
Thiell, M., Zuluaga, J.P., Montañez, J.P., & van Hoof, B. (2011). Green Logistics: Global Practices and their Implementation
in Emerging Markets. In Z. Luo (Ed.), Green Finance and Sustainability: Environmentally-Aware Business Models and
Technologies (pp. 334-357).
UN, 1992a, Agenda 21, United Nations, General Assembly, Rio de Janeiro. http://www.un.org/esa/sustdev/documents/
agenda21/english/agenda21toc.htm.
Voigt K.-I., Thiell, M. (2004). Industrial reverse logistics systems–a model-based analysis of alternative organizational
forms using the example of the automotive industry. In Prockl, G., Bauer, Pflaum, A., & Müller-Steinfahrt, U. (Eds.),
Entwicklungspfade und eilensteine moderner Logistik – Skizzen einer Roadmap (pp. 389– 418). Wiesbaden
Xin Guan (2015). Green logistics development and evaluation of the carbon footprint. VAASA 2015. 96 p.