EFAPP LAS 7 (AutoRecovered)
EFAPP LAS 7 (AutoRecovered)
EFAPP LAS 7 (AutoRecovered)
Department of Education
Region V
SCHOOLS DIVISION OF SORSOGON
BULAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
WHAT IS A REVIEW/CRITIQUE? When you read the word critique what usually comes into your mind?
Maybe for some people it always means to criticize, to look for the negative characteristics of a text, a
person, or an art or just to describe what you are reading/seeing. But writing a critique is more than just
giving the bad/ugly characteristics of a person, art, or thing. There are still more and that is what you are
going to learn for today.
REVIEW/CRITIQUE ● This is a specialized form of writing in which a critic or a reader evaluates any of the
following:
a. a scholarly work (academic books and articles)
b. a work of art (performance art, play, dance, sports, film, exhibits)
c. designs (industrial designs, furniture, fashion designs) d. graphic designs (posters, billboards,
commercials, and digital media
There are different things that can be evaluated by a critic or a reader. But in this module, the focus is
for you to be able to write an objective/balanced review/critique of a work of art, event, or program.
1. Planning – outline ideas, research about it and plan ways on how to write it
2. Drafting – write down all ideas
3. Revising – focus on the content of the essay. Make sure to fulfill the goal of the writing task. If a
rubric is given rewrite the paper based in the criteria
4. Editing – focus on the grammatical and spelling errors
5. Proof Reading – final stage of the process. Focus on surface errors such as punctuations and
formatting
● Value Communicated
1. Sound critical judgement – This pertains to giving description of the object without value
judgements. It also means that you must give your assessment or judgement to an object by carefully
assessing or evaluating it.
2. A fair and balanced assessment of situations or events, people and things.
● Basic Content
a. The content should answer the following questions:
1. What is your impression upon seeing the artwork?
2. What is the title and who is (are) the artist(s)?
3. Describe the subject mallllllllllllllllllotter. What is it all about? Are there recognizable
images?
4. Describe the elements of the work. What style did the artist use?
5. If the work has subjects or characters, what are the relationships between or among
them?
6. How does the work relate to other ideas or events in the world and/or in your other
studies?
b. May take the form of a reflection, an appeal, a protest, a tribute or denunciation, a
speculation. c. In general, the content would include the following topics:
1. For human situations:
● A brief description of the event
● People involved, their roles and contributions
● Other driving force/motivation, it may be out in the open, hidden, or
unsuspected
● Implications and consequences
● Assessment and predictions
2. For cultural affairs, people, works, performances:
● The central purpose of the event, product, or art
● The means, devices, strategies employed to achieve the purposes
● An evaluation of the achievement. Is it a success or failure?
TAKE NOTE! For artwork and other media, you should use speculative verbs like evoke, create, appear, &
suggest. You should make sure to describe it to the reader and describe the material in simple terms.
Also, take note the coherence and cohesion of ideas in your paragraph. After writing, make sure to
check your grammar, spelling and punctuation marks.
After answering the questions and reading the text, did you notice how the critique was constructed?
Let us try to know and understand how the text was constructed.
Note: Maybe you will wonder why there are more than three paragraphs. It is simply because we can
write a review/critique with more than the usual three paragraphs. You can have the introduction, body,
and conclusion of the paragraph in more than one paragraph. Just like what is done in the text that you
have read.
ART REVIEW/CRITIQUE
How was it Written
1. Introduction – the text started with the introduction of how the artists view art
and how art became the way for artists to present their political, social and
religious views. It ended with the thesis statement. Focusing how Pablo Picasso
created visual argument.
2. Body – in this part the writer included all the necessary information that relates
to the thesis statement or focus of the review/critique.
3. Conclusion – here, the writer gave a summary of all the evidences presented.
The writer ended the text by giving the essence of why Picasso made the
painting.
Do you want to learn more about writing a review/critique? Let us proceed to another example of a
critique. Now this text is a critique of an event. While reading the text, take note of how the critique was
written just like what you did on the first example. This review/critique is still like the first one. The only
difference is that this is a review/critique of an event.
(5) Kennedy’s imitators have failed to appreciate that the words in his address were only part of its
magic. There is also the brilliant weather, Jackie Kennedy’s wardrobe. Robert Frost’s poem and the
president-elect who had devoted almost as much attention to his appearance as his words darkening his
tan in Palm Beach and fussing over the cut of his suit and the arrangement of dignitaries on the
platform.
(6) They have failed to appreciate something else, something that is nearly impossible to replicate. It
was Kennedy’s life-and his close calls with death-that gave that speech its power and urgency. Those
who study the speech would do well to pay less attention to the words and more attention to how he
wrote the speech and to the relationship between its words and Kennedy’s character and experience.
(7) Kennedy composed the most memorable and poetic lines of his inaugural during a flight from
Washington to Palm Beach 12 days before his inauguration. He summoned his secretary Evelyn Lincoln
into his private compartment on his plane, the Caroline, and told her that he wanted to dictate some
“ideas” for his inaugural.
(8) He had in hand a draft written by his principal speechwriter, Ted Sorensen. Throughout his campaign,
Kennedy had often carried a Sorensen speech to the stage only to abandon much of it in favor of his
own off-the-cuff remarks. He did this again during the Palm Beach flight, and dictated several pages of
his own material. It is in Evelyn Lincoln’s shorthand loops and squiggles, then that one first reads version
of “Let every nation know, whether it wishes us well or ill, that we shall pay any price, bear any burden,
meet any hardship,” and “ Let the word go forth from this time and place, to friend and foe alike, that
the torch has been passed to a new generation of Americans born in this century, tempered by war,
disciplined by a hard and bitter peach proud of our ancient heritage.”
(9) Kennedy revised his inaugural in Palm Beach, without the assistance of the focus groups or
speechwriting teams that have become de rigueur. He read it aloud to his wife, rewrote some passages
on sheets of yellow legal paper and consulted with Ted Sorensen. He did not need much help revising
his dictation because it was essentially autobiographical. It told his story, and that of his generation:
‘born in this century,” “tempered by war, “disciplined by hard and bitter peace.”
(10) Behind this structure lay five pivotal moments in his life: his travel through Europe on the eve of
World War II, his experiences in the Pacific n 1943, his visit to the devastated post-war Berlin in 1945, his
tour through Asia as a young Congressman in 1951, and his encounter with the abject poor during the
1960 West Virginia primary. All but one of these had occurred overseas, a reminder that he was not only
the most widely traveled man ever to become president, but Kennedy had a strong emotional
connection with the passages inspired by his own experiences. Throughout his political career he had
sometime chocked up at Memorial Day and Veterans Days ceremonies when speaking about those who
had lost their lives in World War II. Among the passages he had dictated on the flight was this one:
“Since this country was founded, each generation of Americans has been summoned to give testimony
to its national loyalty. The graves of young Americans who answered the call to service surround the
globe.”
(11) Numbered among these young Americans, of course, where his brother, Joseph Kennedy Jr., his
brother-in-law Billy Harington, and PT-109 crewmen Andrew Kirksey and Harold Marney. These two
sentences, a tribute to their as a sacrifices, would prove to be the emotional turning point of his
inaugural, the moment when his voice assumed a passion he seldom revealed, inspiring 11 the audience
at the Capitol, touching even the hearts of his opponents, and according to accounts from the time,
sending half frozen tears rolling down cheeks.
(12) It is possible that the future president will evoke a similar reaction with an inaugural address,
uniting Americans in a common purpose, and opening a new era of idealism, optimism and national
happiness. But to accomplish this, he must do more than others have done simply paraphrase or echo
Kennedy. Instead he will have to deliver an inaugural that so clearly engages his emotions, and so
convincingly represents a distillation of the spiritual and philosophical principles guiding his life, that it
will, in the end, awaken the deep emotional response from the American people, too.
After reading the text you must now answer the questions below. Write your answers in your notebook.
Source: English for Academic and Professional Purposes:Reader
After answering the questions and reading the text, did you pay attention to how it was written? In the
next page, you can see another infographic that briefly explains the parts of the review/critique you
have just read.
You are about to write your own review/critique. But before that, let us try doing this activity. The
picture below is a painting by Pablo Picasso, “The Weeping Woman”. Like Guernica Picasso used cubism
in this painting. Before you write your own review/critique, you must first have a plan on what to write.
For this activity, you are going to make an outline in preparation for your writing task later.
Source: https://www.tate.org.uk/art/artworks/picasso-weeping-woman-t05010
Directions: In module 5 you were taught how to construct a Topic outline and a Sentence outline.
Choose one from the two types of outline. Then, construct your own outline before writing your review
on “The Weeping Woman”. You can use a separate sheet of paper for your output.
PRACTICE TASK 2:
In this activity, you are going to begin trying to write your review/critique of the painting. An article is
given to you to give you an idea about the painting. Read the article below before you proceed to the
task.
Pablo Picasso is recognized as one of the most important figures in 20th century western art. He created
more than 20,000 artworks in a variety of media including painting, sculpture, printmaking, drawing and
ceramics.
Picasso showed an early talent for art, and made lifelike portraits as a teenager. However, after settling
in Paris in his early twenties he adopted more modern approaches to making art. Between 1908 and
1911 he and fellow artist Georges Braque ‘invented’ a style called Cubism which took a radical, new
approach to the representation of space and form.
In 1937, Picasso completed his iconic mural Guernica, a chilling depiction of the bombing of the Basque
town of Guernica during the Spanish civil war, which resulted in the slaughter of many defenceless
civilians.
Picasso painted Weeping Woman in October 1937 only a few months after he completed the mural. It is
one of a series of images of weeping women that have been linked to the figure of a grieving mother in
Guernica who clasps her dead child to her chest.
Weeping Woman is an iconic image of unspeakable grief and pain, representing universal suffering. The
fragmented features and the use of acid green and purple heighten the painting’s emotional intensity.
The model for the Weeping Woman was Picasso’s partner Dora Maar, a passionate, strong, and
intelligent woman. The painting is also often seen as reflecting their complex and often stormy
relationship. In every artwork there are different emotions that can be felt.
We want to know how you felt after seeing the painting and reading the article: What are the emotions
conveyed by the painting? ______________________________________________________________
Directions: After reading the article about the painting, you are now asked to write an introduction for
your review/critique paper. Take note of the guidelines given to you in the learning concepts. Use a
separate sheet of paper for your output.
INTRODUCTION SCORE
1. The introduction identifies 54321
the thesis statement or the
focus of the review/critique
2. The introduction contains 54321
basic info on the painting.
3. The introduction uses a 54321
“hook” to grab the reader’s
attention, and it logically
connects to the topic.
4. The introduction provides the 5 4 3 2 1
reader with sufficient
background information on the
topic and presents clearly how
the information is connected to
the thesis statement.
TOTAL
You will be graded according to this rubric:
Comments:_________________________________________________________________
PRACTICE TASK 3: Directions: You are now done with your introduction. Now, you need to write the
body of your paper. Again, you must take note of the guidelines discussed in the learning concepts. Use
a separate sheet of paper for your output. You will be graded according to this rubric:
BODY SCORE
1. The body contains a thorough 5 4 3 2 1
analysis and interpretation of
the work of art.
2. The body gives evidences to 5 4 3 2 1
discuss the thesis statement or
main point of the paper.
3. The body identifies points to 5 4 3 2 1
describe the work Such as the
elements used in the work of
art and its relationship to other
ideas and events in the world.
TOTAL
Comments: ____________________________________________________________________
PRACTICE TASK 4: Directions: Finally! You are off to the last part of your paper. Now, you need to write
your conclusion. Again, please take note of the guidelines discussed in the learning concepts. Use a
separate sheet of paper for your output. You will be graded according to this rubric:
CONCLUSION SCORE
1. The conclusion summarizes 5 4 3 2 1
the writer’s main points.
2. The conclusion provides 5 4 3 2 1
recommendation
3. The conclusion contains the 5 4 3 2 1
summary of the key reasons
identified during the critical
evaluation, why this evaluation
was formed.
TOTAL
Comment: ___________________________________________________________________________
VII. EVALUATION
Directions: Imagine that you were asked to give a review/critique of a work of art that you have seen in
an art gallery or an event/performance that you have been to. Write a 3-paragraph review/critique of
your chosen work of art or event/performance. Remember that you must only choose one. Again, take
note of all the guidelines in writing a review/critique. Use a separate sheet of paper for your output. You
may follow the steps in the writing process for you to have an excellent output. You will be rated
according to this rubric.
CONTENT SCORE
1. Central idea is well developed 5 4 3 2 1
and clarity purpose is exhibited
throughout the paper
2. There is enough evidence of 5 4 3 2 1
critical, careful thought and
analysis or insight.
STRUCTURE
1. The paper presented 5 4 3 2 1
coherence and cohesion of
ideas.
2. It has effective , smooth and 5 4 3 2 1
logical transitions.
LANGUAGE AND STYLE
1. It has accuracy in grammar, 5 4 3 2 1
spelling and punctuation.
2. Writer’s tone is clear, 5 4 3 2 1
consistent, and appropriate for
intended audience
TOTAL
ADDITIONAL ACTIVITY
ACTIVITY 1: Directions: Most of the students nowadays want to be a vlogger. Imagine you are a vlogger
who gives reviews on products, movies, arts, and others. For your task, create your own vlog for a day
showing your review/critique on the art, event, or performance you have chosen for your post-test. Post
it on your google classroom or in any platform used in your class. Isn’t it great to share your ideas to the
world?
CRITERIA FOR GRADING:
CONTENT – 25
ORGANIZATION – 15
PRESENTATION – 10
TOTAL – 50
ACTIVITY 2: (THIS IS FOR THOSE STUDENTS WHO DOESN’T HAVE MOBILE PHONES, FOR VIDEO
RECORDING OR ACCESS TO THE INTERNET) Directions: On a white cartolina, create a comic strip wherein
you are one of the speakers, sharing your review/critique of the work of art, event, or performance that
you have chosen in the evaluation.
REFERENCE
Osila, A.M. A. (2021). “Write an Objective/Balanced Review of a Work of Art, Event or
a Program”. English for Academic and Professional Purposes Module, Quarter 1-
Module 7. DepEd Region V.
MYCA G. DE GUZMAN
RUSHELLE C. FUNDANO
ARLYN R. GOJIT
AILEEN E. PAREDES
Subject Group Head
Noted:
MARIVIC A. AŇONUEVO
ASP II – SHS Academics
Approved:
SALVE E. FERRERAS
Principal III