Petroleum and Adulteration: A Forensic Guide For Crime Investigators
Petroleum and Adulteration: A Forensic Guide For Crime Investigators
Petroleum and Adulteration: A Forensic Guide For Crime Investigators
Petrol, kerosene and diesel are petroleum products obtained from fractional distillation of
crude oil in refineries. These contain different compounds of carbon and hydrogen called
hydrocarbons. From refinery, they are transported to a supply point normally by pipeline and
then to petrol pumps by tankers.
In order to fetch undue profit, petrol and diesel are adulterated with cheaper solvents despite
strict government restrictions. Sometimes, fake petrol and diesel are prepared by mixing
cheaper solvents with dye and other ingredients. Kerosene meant for public distribution is
specially coloured with blue dye. Colouring of kerosene serves double purpose: first, to
differentiate it from normal kerosene and, second, if used for adulteration, the colour of the
petrol and diesel will change, thus, making adulteration difficult. However, people have
developed the method of removing the blue dye of kerosene and then, using it for adulteration.
The other way of fetching undue high profit is to give short delivery by manipulating in
dispensing unit of petrol pump. Recently, it has come to the knowledge that some petrol
pumps are using some chip and manipulating the mother board fitted in the dispensing
machine. It can be operated by remote control device to give short supply.
(i) While transporting the petroleum products from supply point to retailer by tanker
lorry driver and his associates.
(ii) By the retail dealer after receiving supply and mixing in tank.
Petroleum and petroleum products are covered under Section 2 (a) (viii) of Essential
Commodities Act of 1955, amended from time to time. All orders and notifications are issued
by the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas in exercise of powers conferred by Section 3
of the said Act.
256
NICFS A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators
CHAPTER 11
(1) If any such person contravenes any order made under Section 3,-
(i) In the case of an order made with reference to clause (h) or clause (i)
of sub-section (2) of that section, with imprisonment for a term which
may extend to one year and shall also be liable to fine, and
(ii) In the case of any other order, with imprisonment for a term which
shall not be less than three months but which may extend to seven
years and also be liable to fine: Provided that the court may, for any
adequate and special reasons to be mentioned in the judgment, impose
a sentence of imprisonment for a term of less than three months;
(b) Any property in respect of which the order has been contravened shall be
forfeited to the government;
(c) Any package, covering or receptacle in which the property is found and any
animal, vehicle, vessel or other conveyance used in carrying the commodity
shall, if the court so orders, be forfeited to the government.
(2) If any person to whom a direction is given under clause (b) of sub-section (4)
Section 3 fails to comply with the direction, he shall be punishable with
imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than three months but which may
extend to seven years and shall also be liable to fine:
Provided that the court may, for any adequate and special reasons to be mentioned
in the judgement, impose a sentence of imprisonment for a term of less than three
months.
(2A) If any person convicted of an offence under sub-clause (ii) of clause (a) of
sub-section (1) or under sub-section (2) is again convicted of an offence under the
same provision, he shall be punishable with imprisonment for the second and for
every subsequent offence for a term which shall not be less than six months but
which may extend to seven years and shall also be liable to fine:
Provided that the court may for any adequate and special reasons to be mentioned
in the judgment impose a sentence of imprisonment for a term of less than six
months.
257
A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators NICFS
CHAPTER 11
(2B) For the purposes of sub-sections (1), (2) and (2A), the fact that an offence under
sub-clause (ii) of clause (a) of sub-section (1) or under sub-section (2) has caused
no substantial harm to the general public or to any individual, shall be an adequate
and special reason for awarding a sentence of imprisonment for a term of less than
three months, or six months, as the case may be.
(3) Where a person having been convicted of an offence under sub-section (1) is again
convicted of an offence under that sub-section for contravention of an order in
respect of an essential commodity, the court by which such person is convicted
shall, in addition to any penalty which may impose on him under that sub-section,
by order, direct that person that shall not carry on any business in that essential
commodity for such period, not being less than six months, as may be specified by
the court in the order.
As per the order GSR 729(E) dated 19 December, 2005 of Ministry of Petroleum and
Natural Gas:
(i) High Speed Diesel means any hydrocarbon oil, excluding mineral colza oil and
turpentine substitute, which meets the requirements of Bureau of Indian Standards,
specification no. IS1460 and is suitable for use as fuel in compression ignition
engines.
(ii) Motor Spirit means any hydrocarbon oil, excluding crude mineral oil, which
meets the requirements of Bureau of Indian Standards specification no. IS 2796.
(iii) Adulteration means the introduction of any foreign substance into motor spirit or
high speed diesel illegally or unauthorizedly with the result that the product does
not conform to the requirements of the Bureau of Indian Standards specification
no. IS 2796 and IS no. 1460 for motor spirit and high speed diesel, respectively or
any other requirement notified by the central government from time to time.
(iv) Malpractices shall include the following acts of omission and commission in
respect of motor spirit and high speed diesel:
(a) Adulteration,
(b) Pilferage,
(c) Stock variation,
(d) Unauthorized exchange,
258
NICFS A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators
CHAPTER 11
(h) Over-charging,
As per the order GSR 518(E) dated 5 June, 2000 of Ministry of Petroleum and Natural
Gas:
Naphtha is liquid hydrocarbon with 90 per cent volume distillation, by ASTM D-86 distillation
method, of 190 degrees centigrade or less.
As per the order GSR 584(E) of 1993 of Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas:
Kerosene means a middle distillate mixture of hydrocarbons meeting BIS specification no.
IS 1459 of 1974 with important characteristics of flash point at a minimum of 35 °C and
smoke point at a minimum of 18mm.
Subsidised kerosene sold through public distribution system (PDS) is blue in colour while the
market priced kerosene is colourless.
(i) Kerosene
(ii) Naphtha
259
A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators NICFS
CHAPTER 11
According to the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas order GSR 729 (E) dated 19
December, 2005:
(1) Any gazzetted officer of the central or the state government or any police officer not
below the rank of Deputy Superintendent Police duly authorized, by general or special
order of the Central Government or the State Government, as the case may be, or any
officer of an oil company, not below the rank of sales officer, may, with a view to
securing compliance with the provision of this order, or for the purpose of satisfying
himself that this order or any order made there under has been complied with or there
is reason to believe that all or any of the provisions of this order have been and are
being or are about to be contravened-
(a) enter and search any place or premises of a dealer, transporter, consumer or any
other person who is an employee or agent of such dealer or transporter or consumer;
(b) stop and search any person or vehicle or receptacle used or intended to be used for
movement of the product;
(c) take samples of the product and seize any of the stocks of the product and the
vehicle or receptacle or any other conveyance used or suspected to be used for
carrying such stocks and thereafter take or authorize the taking of all measures
necessary for securing the production of stocks or items so seized before the
Collector or District Magistrate having jurisdiction under the provisions of the
Essential Commodities Act, 1955 and for their safe custody pending such
production;
(d) inspect, seize and remove with, such aid or assistance as may be necessary, books,
registers, any other records or documents of the dealer, transporter, consumer or
any other person suspected to be an employee or agent of the dealer, transporter or
consumer;
(2) While exercising the power of seizure provided under above sub-clauses (c) and (d)
the authorized officer shall record in writing the reasons for doing so and a copy of
such recording shall be provided to the dealer, transporter, consumer or any other
concerned person, as the case may be.
(3) The provisions of section 100 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974),
relating to search and seizure shall, as far as may be, apply to searches and seizures
under this order.
260
NICFS A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators
CHAPTER 11
According to the Ministry of Law and Justice (legislative department) order dated 14 January,
2010 The Legal Metrology Act, 2009 (No. 1 of 2010):
‘Legal Metrology Officer’ means Additional Director, Additional Controller, Joint Director,
Joint controller, Deputy Director, Deputy Controller, Assistant Director, Assistant Controller
and Inspector appointed under sections 13 and 14.
(c) Closures for containers; only screw caps Figure 11.2: (left to right): Rectangular
aluminium container, wooden box for
should be used for metal cans to packing, circular aluminium container
provide a vapour tight closure seal.
(ii) 2 drops of MS are poured on a good quality filter paper and observation is recorded
after 2 minutes.
261
A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators NICFS
CHAPTER 11
(iii) An oily stain left on filter paper indicates the presence of higher boiling petroleum
fractions in MS.
Oily stain
Penalty for use of non-standard weight or measure: Whoever uses or keeps for use any
weight or measure or makes use of any numeration otherwise than in accordance with the
standards of weight or measure or the standard of numeration, as the case may be, specified
by or under this Act, shall be punished with fine which may extend to Rs. 25,000 and for the
second or subsequent offence, with imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months
and also with fine.
Penalty for alteration of weight and measure: Whoever tampers with, or alters in any way,
any reference standard, secondary standard or working standard or increases or decreases or
262
NICFS A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators
CHAPTER 11
alters any weight or measure with a view to deceiving any person or knowing or having
reason to believe that any person is likely to be deceived thereby, except where such alteration
is made for the correction of any error noticed therein on verification, shall be punished with
fine which may extend to Rs. 50,000 and for the second and subsequent offence with
imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than six months but which may extend to one
year or with fine or with both.
Weight and measurement (W&M) department seals metering unit (display) and totalizer unit
with sealing wire and lead seal which is embossed by W&M inspector. In the following cases
seal may be treated as tampered:
(i) The embossed seal of W&M is changed.
(ii) Sealing wire is found broken and rejoined.
(iii) Change in fitting/gear inside the dispensing unit with the intention of manipulating
delivery.
Lead seal
Figure 11.6: Metering (display) unit sealed with lead seal and sealing
263
A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators NICFS
CHAPTER 11
(ii) Tampering with E-prom chips and cards by replacing them with spurious
chips/cards available in the market:
E-prom chips or the cards are available in the market and they can be replaced in place
of the original one in order to manipulate the discharge. A second E-prom chip can also
be added parallel to the original one which may be activated by a dual switch while de-
activating the original.
264
NICFS A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators
CHAPTER 11
(vi) Modifying the disk with more holes for manipulation of short delivery
By modifying the disk (where the disk and proximity switches are used as the primary
transducer) with more holes than the original one, the delivery can be manipulated.
In all above cases the short delivery can be manipulated without breaking the seal of Legal
Metrology.
Note: In case of suspected above manipulations and tampering, officer from Weight and
Measurement Department should be called, who would check for manipulations and take
further necessary action.
Samples are to be drawn from nozzle (s) of the dispensing units from all tanks of both MS
and HSD by authorized officer of oil companies and other departments.
All the inspecting officials shall bring their own aluminium containers and plastic seals and
sealing wire with wooden boxes for drawing samples. They will pay for the cost of samples
collected by them and obtain cash memo for the same.
Motor Spirit/Gasoline/Petrol
Six samples of 1 litre each from each tank of the retail outlet should be collected.
265
A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators NICFS
CHAPTER 11
(i) Two samples are to be retained by the dealer or transporter or concerned person
under acknowledgement with instructions to preserve the sample in his safe custody
till the testing or investigations are completed.
(ii) Two samples are to be retained by the concerned oil company or department.
(iii) Two samples are sent to the laboratories authorized for testing.
Wherever the laboratory is not equipped for the testing of Octane number, then the second
sample should be sent to the laboratory where CFR engine is available for Octane number
test.
Note: In case there is requirement of finding Cetane number then one additional sample is to
be collected. Thus, in such a case, four samples of 1 litre each should be collected.
266
NICFS A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators
CHAPTER 11
Collect three samples of 1litre each as mentioned under MS/HSD from tank lorry.
Search of site:
(i) Preparing fake MS and HSD: Collect all the chemicals and solvents used in preparation
of fake MS and HSD and pack each of them in separate packet and container.
(ii) Processing conversion of PDS blue coloured kerosene into colourless kerosene: Collect
three samples of 1litre each and separately collect chemicals used in making kerosene
colourless.
267
A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators NICFS
CHAPTER 11
(ii) Random numbered plastic seals, sealing wire (both can be obtained from oil
companies) and pliers are to be used for sealing of all sample containers.
(iii) Details of seal (seal no. and colour) should be indicated on sample label as well as
on forwarding letter.
(iv) While applying sealing wax, naked flame should be kept away from the petroleum
vapors.
(v) DCP type fire extinguisher should be kept at easy access.
(vi) Facsimile of the seal should be indicated on sample label as well as on forwarding
letter.
Labelling of sample
(iv) The sample label should be jointly signed by the authorized officer
who has drawn the sample and the dealer or transporter or concerned
person or his representative (with their names below the signature). Figure 11.9:
Aluminum
(v) The sample label should contain the following information:
container sealed
(a) Product’s name (MS/HSD) and labelled
268
NICFS A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators
CHAPTER 11
Dispatch of sample
The authorized officer shall forward the sample of the product taken within 10 days to any of
the laboratories mentioned below or to any other such laboratory when it may be notified by
the government in the official gazette for this purpose, for analyzing with a view to checking
whether the density and other parameters of the product conform to the requirements of
Bureau of Indian Standard specifications No. IS 2796 and IS 1460 for motor sprit and high
speed diesel, respectively.
The laboratories mentioned below shall furnish the test report to the
authorized officer within twenty days of receipt of sample at the
laboratory for appropriate action.
269
A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators NICFS
CHAPTER 11
(iv) Kochi Refinery LTD., Refinery Laboratory, Post Ambalamugal, Kochi-682302, Kerala;
(v) Mangalore Refinery and Petrochemicals Ltd. Refinery Laboratory, Kuthethoor, P.O.
Katipalla, Moodapadav, P.B. no. 2, Mangalore 574149, Karnataka;
(vi) Numaligarh Refinery Limited, refinery Laboratory, Numaligarh, Assam; and
(vii) Reliance Petroleum Ltd., Refinery Laboratory, Moti Khavdi (Vill.), Digvijaygram
(PO) Jamnagar (Dist)-361140, Gujrat.
270
NICFS A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators
CHAPTER 11
11.4 Queries
From Forensic Science Laboratory/Central Forensic Science Laboratory/other authorized
laboratories:
For Kerosene
(ii) Whether it is PDS kerosene or kerosene or whether PDS blue kerosene is converted
to colourless kerosene.
(iv) If HSD is fake, give the name of the chemical(s) used in preparing it.
271
A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators NICFS
CHAPTER 11
Source: www.indiankanoon.org/doc/19098275/
272
NICFS A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators
CHAPTER 11
Source: www.indiankanoon.org/doc/80120/
273
A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators NICFS
CHAPTER 11
References
1. Essential Commodities Act 1955, Delhi, 2005.
3. Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas order GSR 729(E), Controller of Publications,
Delhi, 19 December, 2005.
4. Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas order GSR 518(E), Controller of Publications,
Delhi, 5 June, 2000.
5. Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas order GSR 584(E), Controller of Publications,
Delhi, 1993.
6. Ministry of Law and Justice order dated 14 January, 2010 The Legal Metrology Act,
2009 (No. 1 of 2010), Controller of Publications, Delhi.
274
NICFS A Forensic Guide for Crime Investigators