C 677798-l 1-k Electricpowerengineering
C 677798-l 1-k Electricpowerengineering
C 677798-l 1-k Electricpowerengineering
01 June 2018
Addis Ababa
ii
A Proposal for training and research partnership between Addis Ababa Institute of Technology, Addis
Ababa University (AAU), Chalmers and KTH Universities of Sweden in collaboration with ABB: 2018-2023
and
Submitted by:
Submitted to:
Sponsoring organization
Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency
Sida/Stockholm
Addis Ababa
iii
Contents
Title Page
Summary: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering 1
General Description of the PhD Program 2
Sustainability Analysis 22
Benefits/Beneficiaries 25
Risk Analysis 31
Budget summary 32
References 33
Attachments: 35
- Curricula Vitae of Professors involved
- Memorandum of Understanding between AAU and Chalmers,
KTH
- Publications of Professors and some Email exchanges
0
Summary: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Addis Ababa University (AAU) and Swedish Universities (KTH Royal Institute of Technology and Chalmers
University of Technology) are to work together in running Electrical Power and Control Engineering PhD
programs in the School of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Addis Ababa University. AAU is a degree-
granting university and its professors are to be main supervisors for all PhD candidates while KTH and Chalmers
professors are co-supervisors. PhD student supervisors and co-supervisors are to work together on student
recruitment, student’s work planning and progress assessment through annual meetings and continuous
correspondence. The Swedish professors will also support the Ethiopian professors in supervision capacity
building facilitation for training and relevant seminars. Swedish universities’ professors are to support the
programs by block teaching, as an external examiners, and by providing research space and facilities for the PhD
candidates under their supervision and their Ethiopian counterpart professors according to an agreed upon schedule
during the students’ study period. The program will accept four students in 2018 and eight students in 2019
enrolling twelve students over the five-year project period. Qualified female candidates are encouraged to apply
and be part of the PhD candidates. At the end of the project, all the 12 enrolled students are expected to graduate
improving staff profile of the universities’ in the country. Furthermore, 12 dissertations and more than 12 scientific
papers, which are relevant to the real challenges of the country in the power and control area are expected to be
produced by the PhD candidates.
There is dire need for teaching and research staff for more than 30 relatively newly established public universities
in Ethiopia, which are at the moment dependent on expensive expatriate staffs. Ethiopia, as a country, is working
hard to be an electric power pool of East Africa; exploiting its high renewable energy potential. It has 45GW
hydropower potential, 5GW of geothermal, and a tremendous solar energy potential. At the moment, only 10% of
the hydro and less than 0.1% of other potential resources have been developed with a total installed capacity of
4GW. During the present growth and transformation plan (GTP-II) of Ethiopia (2015/16-2020/21) it is planned to
increase the installed generation capacity by fourfold to 17GW. More than 30 public universities are tasked to
produce manpower for this huge expansion of the sector. Therefore, production of high level educated manpower
for the electric energy sector, in general, and teaching and research staff for the public universities and high-level
professionals for the expanding electric energy system in particular, is imperative to be addressed by this project.
To ensure the relevance of research and education to the industry, Ethiopian electric utility operators (Ethiopian
Electric Utility EEU and Ethiopian Electric Power EEP) and ABB are part of this project. EEU and EEP
participate in identifying relevant research projects, availing facilities and data for researchers and contributing
financial and in-kind resources as required. Similarly, ABB is to receive and supervise students (industry
internship) for a period of time, up to one year depending on time schedule to be agreed on by the student
supervisors and the company. Power systems, High Voltage Engineering, Power system control, development and
testing activities at ABB’s facilities in Ludvika and/or Vasteras are to be used for this purpose.
In parallel to running the PhD program, the laboratory facility at Electrical and computer engineering of Addis
Ababa University is to be equipped replicating facilities at the similar Swedish professor´s laboratories as a
capacity building for the sustainability of the programs.
1
General Description of the PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Electrical Power and Control Engineering refers to four main components of electrical power systems, namely,
electric power generation, transmission, distribution and its conversion at the consumer end. Bulk electric power is
generated at the generation plants and transmitted to load centres, like our homes, through transmission and
distribution systems. At the consumers’ premises, the electrical power is converted to other forms of energy like
mechanical using electric motors, light using lamps, heat using stoves, etc. The PhD programs in Electrical Power
and Control Engineering deals with the science and art of making this system safe, efficient, reliable, and
sustainable.
There are emerging and continuous challenges for research in the Ethiopian Electric Power System and control
Engineering area. Today, renewable energy based distributed generation systems are connected to the electric
network, most of the time to the consumer side distribution systems, requiring power flow in two directions as
compared to the conventional power flow (one direction flow, generation-transmission-distribution-consumption).
Deployment of renewable electricity have also, as the result of the energy resource intermittency, brought
challenges related power converters [i], power protection and control, etc. There is also energy storage devices
involved [ii]. Conventional power system control and automation has also changed from the traditional relay based
system to computer, programmable logic controllers and supervisory control data acquisition system
interconnection. Transmission system voltage level is continuously increasing to improve efficiency, but
demanding further research and knowledge of insulation materials. In Ethiopia, the voltage level has increased
from its maximum of 220kV until few years ago, to 500 kV at the moment. Globally, more than 750kV is
becoming common. Furthermore, the high-voltage-direct-current (HVDC) transmission lines, which also involve
static converters [iii], demand development of electric materials. There is also flexible alternating current
transmission systems [iv] (FACTS) technology for power flow control [v,vi], reactive power compensation and
stability control functions [vii]. A smart grid, according to [viii], is a digitally enabled electric grid that gathers,
distributes and acts on information about the behaviour of all components in order to improve the efficiency,
reliability, and sustainability of electricity services. Evolutionary step in the grid’s design, planning and operation,
one that adopts new design concepts and innovative technologies that can be integrated into a modern
infrastructure is needed [ix]. Efficiency and appropriate conversion control of electric drives, the major electric
power consuming devices, in manufacturing, process, transportation, etc. industries in conjunction with electric
power processors (static converters) and energy storage devices are other areas of research.
All these changes in the electrical power industry are affecting reliability, safety and efficiency of electric power
generation, transmission, distribution and utilization, which are to be addressed by the research projects of this
proposal.
Cooperation with Swedish Universities like Chalmers and KTH is essential for experience sharing and to run the
programs at the highest quality level possible and to build capacity.
2
1.1 Background
Addis Ababa University is working hard to expand its PhD programs and research activities to support the
country’s fast growing economy in availing qualified manpower and research outputs. The demand for PhD
graduates in engineering fields, especially in Electrical Power and Control Engineering has become crucial
recently, with the country’s present and planned activities to expand its electric energy sector and the demand for
teaching staff in more than thirty public universities recently established. However, the School of Electrical and
Computer Engineering at Addis Ababa University, which is the oldest in the country in the field, is not in a
position to fill this gap alone. Shortages of experienced professors for PhD student supervision in the area and luck
of appropriate laboratory facilities are identified as major limiting factors. Finding partner universities abroad to
share experience, staff and research facilities at initial stages of the PhD program in Electrical Power and Control
Engineering has been sought to be one of the best ways to launch and sustain a quality PhD program.
The Addis Ababa University School of Electrical and Computer Engineering has been working on the draft PhD
curriculum in Electrical Power and Control Engineering for the last one-year involving professors from different
universities in the area. Professor Sul, from Seoul National University (South Korea) and Professor Hoffman
Heath, from University of Michigan (USA) have reviewed and commented on the draft curriculum. Swedish
partner university professors; Professor Stanislaw Gubanski and Professor Erik Ahlgren (both from Chalmers)
have also reviewed and given their comments. The curriculum is now approved by the School of Electrical and
Computer Engineering Council and by Addis Ababa Institute of Technology and is ready to admit students. This
proposal is prepared by Addis Ababa University, Chalmers and KTH to be submitted to SIDA for funding the
cooperation sought to run the PhD program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering and to build capacity of
the School of Electrical and computer engineering during 2018/19 to 2021/2022 in human resource and laboratory
facility for sustainability of the program.
3
1.2 Scope of the Project
The project admits four PhD candidates in the year 2018 and additional eight PhD candidates in 2019 to work on
the research areas listed in section 1.5 below, which are to be refined and focused by supervising professors and
the student. Each PhD candidate student is to be supervised by a main supervisor, a professor from Addis Ababa
University, and one co-supervisor from a Swedish university within a relevant research area. This results in a total
enrolment of about 12 PhD candidates who are expected to graduate over the five-year project period.
The project also incorporates capacity building in laboratory equipment and Ethiopian professors PhD supervision
capacity to ensure the sustainability of the PhD program after the project period. The relevant laboratories facilities
and equipment at the Swedish Universities will be replicated in Addis Ababa University Electrical and Computer
Engineering, step by step, over the five-year period. Partner Swedish universities shall arrange trainings on PhD
and research project supervision for Ethiopian professors involved in this project.
Though the demand for PhD study in Electrical Power and Control Engineering might be high, the quality can be
maintained by limiting the number of students, to a total of twelve, in line with the limited number of local
professors, laboratory facilities and experience. This number is also considered to be manageable for the Swedish
partner universities to host at their laboratories without overburdening.
On the other hand, School of Electrical and Computer Engineering, AAU, shall work towards meeting the demand
for study in the field mobilizing other local and international funding and partnering universities in parallel.
Ethiopia is working hard to reduce poverty and to be a middle-income country by 2025. Its economy is growing by
double digits every year over the last decade. In order to sustain the economic growth and increase electricity
4
access from its low level of 15%, huge electric power system projects are under construction while others are
under design and in planning phases.
Diverse and many Mega-Projects are presently under construction in Electric Power generation, transmission,
distribution system towards Ethiopia’s intension to be power-pool of East Africa. It is working on the Great
Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) hydro electric power generation plant construction on Blue Nile river with
installed capacity of 6000MW, Gilgel-Gibe-III hydro electric power plant on Omo river with installed capacity of
1800MW, Adama Wind farm II with installed capacity of 150MW, Corbetti Caldera geothermal independent
power plant envisaged by Reykjavik Geothermal, a U.S.-Icelandic private developer an installed capacity of
1000MW [x] and more as mega-projects.
The country has ambitious plans to become a carbon-neutral economy by 2025. In its effort towards this, in its first
five years Growth and Transformation Plan (GTP-I, 2010/11-2014/15) it has planned to increase the installed
electric power generation capacity from about 2000 MW in 2010 to 10,000 MW in 2015 [xi] all from renewable
energy sources. It has planned to attain installed capacity of 30000MW by 2020 all from renewable energy. Its
unexploited renewable energy potential is tremendously huge. For example, hydropower potential is estimated to
be 45,000 MW out of which only about 4,000 MW is exploited (2016). Exploitation of wind, solar and geothermal
potentials is also planned to expand in the same rate.
Ethiopian Electric Grid is already connected to neighbouring countries, The Sudan and Djibouti for electric energy
export. Connection to Kenya’s electric grid is underway through the 1.5 Billion USD High Voltage Direct Current
(HVDC) transmission line (under construction). Extensions of the Ethiopian electric grid to Somalia, South-Sudan
and beyond are under plan.
Knowhow and skills in new technologies like high voltage direct current (HVDC), smart grid, and flexible
alternating current transmission systems (FACTS), digital control systems and electric drives are required to
support the sector in research development, design, and construction; commissioning, operation and maintenance
of these investments. Pool of engineers with such qualities can be availed through PhD degree studies in Electrical
Power and Control Engineering with strong research support. Research and development is required to enhance the
quality of the PhD education and the sector in general for quality, efficient and sustainable electric energy
development and supply both for local and export to neighbouring countries as envisaged in the GTP.
Electrical power engineering, one of core electrical Engineering discipline, is explosively expanding engineering
area. Traditionally, electrical power engineering refers to the design analysis and operation of electrical system
comprising generation, transmission distribution up to the utilization level. Safe, efficient and clean utilization of
electric energy is also becoming an important component of electrical power engineering and control engineering.
The traditional Electrical Power Engineering is changing with the advent of power electronics, digital computers
and communication systems.
5
Today, the conventional concentrated generation plants like steam turbine and hydropower based generation plants
have expanded to include renewable energy based distributed generation (DG) systems. The distributed generators
can be connected in the distribution systems and sometimes require the power flow in two directions changing
approach of the protection and control of power systems. Distributed generators, like wind farms and PV solar
farms, bring challenges like intermittency or power as the result of the energy resource intermittency and nonlinear
power converters [xii], etc. There is also energy storage devices involved [xiii]. Electrical drives, which normally
consume more than 60% of electric power, are also affecting the power system both positively and negatively.
Their energy conversion efficiency, starting and stopping disturbance are continuously improving. On the other
hand, static-switch based inverters/converters generated harmonics are propagating back into power systems. The
harmonics are causing additional loses, malfunctioning of equipment and environmental pollution, etc.
Conventional power generation control and automation has changed from the traditional relay based system to
computer, programmable logic controllers and supervisory control data acquisition system interconnection.
The transmission system is also changing continuously. The high voltage level is continuously increasing. In
Ethiopia from its maximum of 220kV until few years has reached 500 kV at the moment. Globally, more than
750kV is becoming common. Furthermore, the high voltage direct current transmission lines which again involve
static converters [ xiv] and materials. There is also flexible alternating current transmission systems (FACTS) [xv]
technology for power flow control [xvi,xvii], reactive power compensation and dynamic and static stability control
functions [ xviii]. Smart grids are recent technology integrating power systems, communication and computer
technologies together creating new research area. A smart grid according to [xix] is a digitally enabled electric grid
that gathers, distributes and acts on information about the behaviour of all components in order to improve the
efficiency, reliability, and sustainability of electricity services. At the moment there is this concept and only pilot
level smart grid in few developed countries. Evolutionary step in the grid’s design, planning and operation is
needed, one that adopts new design concepts and innovative technologies that can be integrated into a modern
infrastructure [xx]. The distribution systems used to connect the transmission system with consumers. Now, the
trend is to connect distributed generation [xxi] systems to distribution systems allowing power flow in both
directions.
There are also challenges at the electric energy consumption level. The ever increasing demand for efficient power
conversion from electrical to other desired forms, minimizing the negative effect of electric appliances like
electrical drives on power systems and electric energy storage systems are demanding further research and
development.
The followings are possible PhD students’ project areas in electrical power Engineering and control, which are
relevant to the electrical power system of Ethiopia and the professors involved in supervision. Some additional
relevant research projects, which are in the priority area of the country, can be further formulated by the involved
professors as required.
6
Swedish University Addis Ababa
University
A detail classification of the severity of natural and industrial pollution in the areas of planned
new investments is thus the task of this project. Meteorological information and environmental
pollution parameters (ESDD and NSDD – pollution type, distribution and number of pollution
emitting sources) and levels need both to be collected and analysed as part of the work to create
this map. Considerations must even be given to forecasts on economic developments and their
possible impact on air contamination, as the latter may change with time. It is also necessary to
develop suitable measurement methodology and devices for robust on-line monitoring of the
desired data and their reliable communication over large distances to the analysis centre.
7
4 Investigation of the impact of desert and Stanislaw Gubanski Getachew Biru
agricultural environments (sand storms,
high temperature and insulation, fertilizer
pollution, crop burning pollution, etc) on
long term stability and flashover
performance of outdoor insulation
materials.
5 High voltage equipment adapted and to be Stanislaw Gubanski Mengesha Mamo
developed to the special tough ambient
conditions in Ethiopia and Eastern Africa
High voltage equipment like transformers and accessories, substation switchgear, transmission
system and accessories, etc have to be designed considering the operating ambient condition for
their safe, reliable and efficient operation. However; ambient conditions in different parts of the
world are mostly different. Therefore, equipment designed for an ambient condition in particular
area can be either be unnecessarily over designed expensive equipment, or the contrary, under-
designed so that it is unsafe and/inefficient for another ambient condition. Ethiopia is located in
tropical region with no freezing temperature but varying humidity, altitude, temperature and rain
distribution in time and space. Therefore, high voltage equipment design and adaption for peculiar
ambient conditions of Ethiopia need be studied.
The aim of this project is to study design and performance characteristics of major electrical
equipment under Ethiopian ambient conditions.
6 Modernization of Ethiopian Distribution Stanislaw Gubanski Getachew Bekele
network
The power distribution network in Ethiopia is overwhelmed with different problems such as
voltage drop (during peak and/or off-peak hours), frequent interruptions, high power loss (23% of
the generated electricity according to a report by Ministry of Water and Energy), distribution
network branch failure, etc. This is in addition to insufficient power generation (only 26%
coverage). It is understood that one major problem of the distribution network is that the network
is too old and very traditional and is believed to be the main cause of the interruptions. But that is
not the only problem, poor power quality, customer behaviour, bad network topology, etc. are
also concerns.
The study of the problems and the development of better systems to alleviate such problems is an
immediate and demanding research area. For example, the followings can be research areas:
· Development of appropriate guideline for grouping customer according to the electrical
load distribution and, if it should be, identification of the least priority loads to be shaded and/or
a mechanism that could automatically re-route power, and shift loads during high demand times
through automation and smart grid concept
· Modelling of the distribution network for a modernized long term application and
sustainability with the insertion of DGs at optimal and key locations within the distribution system
and thereby improve reliability indices of the distribution network
7 Rural Electrification Stanislaw Gubanski Getachew Bekele
Electrification of Off-grid remote areas from renewable energy resources such as wind/solar/
hydro etc. in a form of DG to supply modern electricity to those who have no access of electricity
and thereby raise the electricity coverage of the country. The research should also consider load
forecasting and future integration of the microgrid with the national grid.
8 Power System Studies research for the Stanislaw Gubanski Getachew Biru
unique Ethiopian condition with large new
generation installations connected via,
often, weak interconnectors to secure a
8
long-term planning regime
9
Even if the central grid is to provide the bulk of electrification of Ethiopia there will be large
areas of the country which are either situated too far from the expanded central grid and/or with
too low population density and an, at least initially, too low electricity demand for central grid
expansion to be feasible during a foreseeable future. For these areas there might be other
renewables based electrification options and which of these options that are best depends on local
resource availability and demand structure. There are a number of factors determining optimal
electrification planning of these areas. Cost-efficiency is a central aspect but not the only one.
Thus, the aim of this project is to determine first where the boarder should be between grid and
off-grid electrification. Which supply, transmission and demand characteristics should be
determining? Second, how is efficient electrification of off-grid areas best carried out? What are
the main obstacles today? Are there primarily technological, resource, economic or other
constraints; and how can these be overcome in an efficient way?
This could be divided into two projects as indicated by the two core questions above.
In Ethiopia wind power of more than 320 MW has been integrated to the national grid. The Integration
of the wind power to the mostly hydropower grid has to take into account uncertainty about hourly/daily
wind power generation. Hence, in order to use the hydropower as efficiently as possible, one would
need to solve a considerable stochastic optimization problem. There is currently a lot of research in this
field of integration. There could also be unique challenges for the Ethiopian grid system (especially
concerning the linking between long-term and short-term planning) which may require additional
research. This research can be taken by a PhD student and can be considered as a research project.
10
Bulk Electric power is transmitted over a long distance using high voltage direct current (HVDC)
transmission lines. The HVDC is usually between two AC systems having AC/DC/AC converters
on its two ends. It can be between bulk generation stations and distant grid, between two separate
grids, or from grid to bulk load canters. Depending on the nature of systems on either side of the
HVDC its effect on the system stability and power quality varies. Ethiopia has embarked on
HVDC construction between Ethiopian power grid and Kenya power grid for electric energy
export of up to 2000 MW.
The aim of this project is to model and understand the present and near future electric power grid
systems and investigate the effect of the HVDC on the two systems and vice versa. The two
systems stability, power quality and even efficiency are related to the HVDC’s electric power
converter-generated non-linearity in the current and voltage systems, high frequency component
voltage/currents generated and possible resonance frequencies of the systems. The understanding
the interaction of the HVDC and the power systems under normal and abnormal conditions with
possible suggestions for its reliable, efficient and safe operation is expected outcome of this
project.
11
instable operation of the grid.
Ethiopia struggles with frequent electrical power outages, which heavily affect the development of
the country in a negative manner. In institutions like Addis Ababa University, there are power cuts
several times per week, which could last for several hours each time (Bergman and Enocksson,
2015). The university has a tremendous role in educating the future capacity for Ethiopia’s built-
up at the same time as the power cuts makes it more difficult to develop teaching activities which
depend on electricity, i.e. computers in education, laboratory exercises etc. Companies come to a
halt during the time they have no access to electricity. Air-conditioning units stop working, and
people become un-productive. Halt in human capacity and production is a large threat for
development, and thus there is a large need to reduce the power outages.
There are several reasons for power outages for example technical failure in parts of the electrical
grid system or that the demand exceeds the electricity production so that certain areas need to be
disconnected to maintain the frequency of the electric grid. Technical failures will not be further
discussed here. The interesting part is how to balance the demand and production of a grid to
increase the service for all connected customers. There are three parts of importance in this
balance: 1) Production 2) Transmission and 3) Consumption, where consumption is the feedback-
loop controlling the production, via the transmission. In an electric grid with fewer high-voltage
lines, there are more transmission losses, for Ethiopia, 15 % of the power produced is lost, i.e.
power not being paid for by customers (Worldbank, 2015). It can either be a technical
transmission loss due to the infrastructure of the electric grid or it can also be electricity “theft”,
customers connected who are not paying for the service.
For a country like Ethiopia, still in large need of increasing the power production to the electrical
grid and extending the grid to a larger part of the population, it is necessary also to evaluate the
current consumption of electricity. At the same time as there are many power outages, the open-up
of energy intensive industries is increasing rapidly.
The cement industry grows yearly in many African countries, due to increased capacity building
of infrastructure, such as buildings. The industry is necessary for all developing countries to
develop since it provides important construction materials to the society as well as many job
opportunities. At the same time, it is very energy intensive. Except from being a large user of
fossil fuels for providing necessary process heat, it also puts large stress on an already overloaded
power grid.
In Kenya, 60% of the electricity produced in the country is used by 10 cement industries placed
around the capital Nairobi (Cheruto, 2014). The country has identified that there is an urgent need
to increase the energy efficiency within these industries, to put relief to the electricity grid.
In Ethiopia, the cement industry is growing yearly. Recently, Dangonte Cement Inc has opened a
new cement factory outside Addis Ababa producing 2.5 million tonnes cement products per year
(Forbes, 2015).
In average, the electrical energy need for a cement factory is 110-120 kWh/ton (Madlool et al,
2013), which corresponds to 300 GWh el/year for the factory mentioned above. Within a cement
factory, electrical energy is used for clinker crushing and grinding (40% of total el), material
transport inside factory and auxiliary equipment such as kiln motors, combustion air blowers and
pumps. (Brunke et al, 2014)
A typical cement factory uses in average 30 MW of electrical power, and with a number of such
factories in a country, the momentary power use from the electrical grid might be very high
causing instabilities in the grid. Momentary, when a machine is started after having a stoppage,
the needed start-up power exceeds the average power being used during normal operation of the
machine. These factories may contribute greatly to power cuts for other customers in the national
grid due high momentary need of power.
It is not only during production that any factory needs power, also during temporary production
12
stops there is need for energy. For example, a steam boiler cannot be closed down and started up
for short periods of a couple of hours, and thus needs to run all the time whether or not there is a
temporary production stop. By this, energy is wasted. Depending on the management and
maintenance program of the production facility, as well as the age of the facility, the unplanned
productions stops may be frequent. (Birru et al, 2015)
For minimizing impact of the factory on the national grid, it is necessary to both find optimal
operation of the individual factory, both from production and energy perspectives and then how
the different factories interact in the national power grid. With factory and system planning, it is
possible to both have the factories working smoothly and at the same time reducing the time for
power cuts in the grid for other customers than the factory.
We thus propose a PhD project which is to involve two PhD candidates focusing on a sustainably
cement industry for Ethiopia.
23.1 PhD Candidate 1: This PhD candidate should have electro-mechanical engineering background,
with specialization in production and manufacturing technologies. The overall aim with the PhD
project is to propose optimized production processes for the Ethiopian cement industry, which
maximizes product quality and minimizes the use of materials and energy, with focus on electrical
energy. Lean is part of methods used.
23.2 PhD Candidate 2: This PhD candidate should have electro-mechanical engineering background,
with specialization in energy auditing and system planning. The overall aim with the PhD project
is to propose the optimal energy and power use for each individual cement industry in Ethiopia as
well as the combined planning for these factories to minimize the load on the national grid.
The two PhD candidates should co-operate closely, and their primary work tools should be
various modeling environments as well as close co-operation with the cement factories
themselves. The PhD students should spend time at the different cement factories in Ethiopia as
part of their PhD program. The outcome of the project is not only for use for the electrical power
sector of Ethiopia, but also for the cement industry itself, which may reduce the specific energy
use, and at the same time improve the production process and product quality.
Within this PhD project, two departments at KTH Royal Institute of Technology will co-operate
namely Department of Energy Technology and Department of Production Engineering.
The PhD candidates are proposed to work in sandwich modality, where part of the PhD studies are
conducted at KTH and the other part in Addis Ababa University. For PhD candidate 1, supervisors
will be available at the Department of Production Engineering and for PhD candidate 2,
supervisors are available at Department of Energy Technology.
During the course of the PhD programme, a yearly seminar with the Ethiopian cement industry
will be arranged at Addis Ababa University. The supervisors from KTH as well as the PhD
candidates will be present for the energy dialogue with the industry partners.
Addis Ababa University, the oldest and largest university in Ethiopia, have School of Electrical and Computer
Engineering, which have been producing manpower for the power sector for the last 60 years. It has been training
electrical engineers at first-degree level since its establishment in late 50th. It has also launched M.Sc. degree
programs in early 1990th in Control and Communication Engineering areas. In 2007, it launched additional M.Sc.
13
programs in Electrical Power Engineering in cooperation with Ethiopian Electric Power Corporation and has been
graduating about 20 graduates, on average, in Electrical Power Engineering area every year since then.
Today, the department of Electrical and Computer Engineering has been upgraded to a School level and is running
one undergraduate program, five masters degree (Electrical Power, Control, Communication, microelectronics and
Computer Engineering) programs and two doctorate level programs. The doctorate programs are in Commuter
Engineering and Communication Engineering. Now, it is high time to launch a PhD program in Electrical Power
Engineering and do research to support the Electric Power Engineering sector and to create an opportunity for MSc
graduates to proceed to a PhD program.
Trends in number of yearly applicants for the post graduate study in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
indicates that there is high students demand for Electric Power and Control area for doctorate degree. On the other
hand, number of local professors and laboratory facility for Electrical Power and Control Engineering, including in
school of Electrical and computer Engineering, AAU are limited. This situation demands cooperation with
Universities Swedish Universities, which have sufficient experience and system in running PhD programs in
Electrical Power Engineering for the quality of the program.
School of electrical and computer engineering has the following staffs in electrical power and control area whose
CVs are attached at the end of this document.
2.6.2.1 Addis Ababa University
S.No. Name Qualification Area Academic Rank
1 Mengesha Mamo PhD Power Electronics Associate
and Drives Professor
2 Getachew Bekele PhD Energy Technology Associate
Professor
3 Dereje Shiferaw PhD Control Assistant Professor
Engineering
4 Getachew Biru PhD Electrical Power Assistant Professor
Engineering
2.6.2.2 Chalmers
.No. Name Qualification Area Academic Rank
1 Stanislaw Michel Gubanski PhD High Voltage Professor
Engineering
14
3 Massimo Bonjiorno PhD Power Electronics Professor
The following basic laboratories which can be used for the PhD programs are already in the laboratories of
electrical and computer engineering.
If the launching and running of PhD program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering is not to happen soon,
the alternative is sending PhD candidates abroad as it is the case today. This is costly, as the government/student
has to pay tuition fee, accommodation and travel costs of the candidates in foreign currency. On top of this, the
probability of losing the PhD graduates in brain drain is extremely high.
According to some study results, the problem of brain drain has reached quite disturbing proportions in some
African countries, with Ethiopia ranked first in the continent in terms of rate of loss of human capital, followed by
Nigeria and Ghana [ xxii, xxiii]. A recent study presented at the National Symposium on Ethiopian Diasporas
15
(2011), Ethiopia has lost 75% of its skilled professionals during the previous ten years [xxiv]. Though no statistics
exists quantifying the brain drain discriminating along disciplines, it is expected that the engineering fields are the
worst. More than 90% of academic staffs from school of Electrical and computer engineering, who left for their
PhD studies to Europe and North America in the last 10 years didn’t come back after they completed their study.
The PhD program in Electrical Power Engineering at Addis Ababa University is expected to decrease the brain
drain and the heavy cost of studying abroad. On the other hand, the quality of the education and exposure to high
standard professors, research facilities and organization will be guaranteed through cooperation with Swedish
Universities. The associated capacity building, in supervision capacity and laboratory facility would also be major
building block for sustainability of the program.
1.8 Expansion of Higher learning Institutions in Ethiopia and the need for Academic staffs
in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
The number of public universities in Ethiopia has increased from 2 in 1991, to more than 33 in 2015, due to the
higher education expansion and distribution policy of the government of Ethiopia. Most of these universities have
engineering faculties having electrical power engineering study programs in the first-degree level and few at the
second-degree level. They want to improve their staff profile and hence need local PhD study programs for their
academic staffs locally.
The country is trying to cope with this need by arranging sandwich PhD programs with German Universities,
home-grown PhD programs through consortia with interested professors from different Universities. However, the
output from these arrangements in Electrical Power and Control Engineering is none until now and may result few
in the future. Therefore, this project can supplement these effort and result staffing of the universities with teaching
and research manpower at PhD level including the need for school of electrical and computer engineering at Addis
Ababa University.
16
2. Outline of the Project Work
The cooperation between Addis Ababa University and Swedish Universities is sought for the envisaged capacity
building. The experience of Swedish universities in the area can be utilized in staff exchange, student exchange,
laboratory facilities sharing, co-advising, co-publications, teaching material sharing, block and online teaching
through videoconferencing etc. Up-to-date research laboratories, which can be used for students’ research and
research and development for the sector, can be put in place in cooperation and support from SIDA and relevant
industries like ABB, Ethiopian Electric Utility and Ethiopian Electric Power.
Through such cooperation the quality of education and research in the PhD program sought and research output to
support the electric energy sector can be kept at the highest possible level from the outset. The publication profile
of Addis Ababa University is also to increase in collaboration with partner Swedish Universities.
Addis Ababa University shall launch the Electrical Power and Control Engineering PhD program in academic year
2018/19. An announcement to recruit candidates to the program will be publicized before academic year 2018/19.
It has been agreed that student’s supervisors (both Ethiopian and Swedish) shall interview candidates and select
best ones based on their academic merits and preparedness and motivation for fulfilment of research task.
2.2 Student Exchange between Addis Ababa University and Swedish Universities
The PhD program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering, to be launched in 2018 is new in AAU. AAU
professors in the area are also new in PhD student supervision. Research facilities for the PhD dissertation are to be
built and equipped step by step. Under these circumstances, it is necessary to send students to Swedish Universities
to elevate the quality of PhD education in the new PhD program.
Accordingly, a PhD student in electrical and control engineering travels to work at co-advisor professor’s
laboratory in Swedish University, at least two times during his/her study. However, the duration and frequency of
individual student shall be decided based on their research work requirement by the supervisors yearly planning
meeting. On average, students are planned to stay in Swedish University for two years in total, during their four-
year study period.
During their first visit to Sweden University, the PhD candidate is to get exposure to PhD students in the Swedish
University and understand scope of work required of him/her as a PhD candidate and to set their dissertation
objectives and prepare and defend their proposal. The student can meet PhD candidates at his/her level, who are
working to develop their dissertation proposal and senior candidates, who are working on scientific papers for
conference/journal and/or their final dissertation. During this time, the student also works on their seminar courses;
participate on seminars and/or regular meetings and take relevant courses from their host university.
During subsequent visits, intensive literature access, simulation software, experimental systems, are required to
obtain data and to analyse the data. These are better available at hosting university in Sweden. The student is also
17
required to write and submit papers for professional conferences and journals, which can be done more
conveniently in the hosting University in Sweden.
During their stay in AAU, the students do their course work, necessary data collection, analysis, scientific paper
write-ups and all other PhD student duties. They are engaged as full time PhD students. They may be required to
teach once course, which is roughly 25% of fulltime duty.
Second Batch 8 8 8 8 4
Graduates 4 8 12
Beneficiaries over five year project 12
It will be worked to encourage and include qualified female PhD candidates in to the admission plan.
2.3.1 Teaching
The professors in Addis Ababa University cannot deliver all the courses to be taught in the PhD program due to
their limited number and specialization area. Therefore, the Swedish side will support PhD course delivery, either
by teaching block courses at AAU, providing courses by videoconferencing or by inviting PhD students to their
universities in Sweden.
Guest professors from other cooperating universities like University of Michigan, USA, and University of
Dasburg, Germany, can also deliver courses.
Addis Ababa University PhD programs require at least one external examiner from a university abroad in addition
to the local examining board. This is one of quality assurance mechanisms for the program. Evaluation of the PhD
dissertation work of the students from a professional outside AAU helps to gauge the quality of the education with
respect to international perspective/level.
The examining professor comes to AAU for upto 5 days, including transit. The examiners are expected in the
fourth and fifth year of the project (2020/21 and 2021/22).
The examination board is established for each PhD student and one external examiner for each student results in an
average of four professors per year for the last two project years.
18
2.4 Ethiopian Professors Visiting Swedish Universities
Ethiopian Professors visit their students at Swedish University for about one month per year. The visit is necessary
to discuss on the plan of PhD students’ research projects, for the professors to get training and experience in PhD
student supervision from Swedish University counterpart, to participate on seminars delivered by the AAU
students and other Swedish University students to regulate the work quality of their students back home and on
visit to the Swedish University.
Ethiopian professors would travel to Swedish universities to take courses on PhD supervision according to the
schedule available in the universities. The courses are to take about six weeks in Chalmers. Four Ethiopian
professors would take the course once during the project period.
Paper presentation at international conferences is one of the quality assurance mechanisms for the PhD program
and research output of the student in the program. The student can get feedback from experts in the area to further
refine their work and output. They also develop confidence and hence prepare themselves for high-level
professional contribution.
So, it is recommended for each student to attend two professional conferences with contribution of papers during
their PhD study period. Their professor has to accompany them during one of the conference presentations as co-
authors so that the comments from peers be understood and taken care of in subsequent works towards the PhD
dissertation. A conference participation, which usually is for three to four days, can take five to seven days
including flights.
Student Dissertation works are encouraged to be practical oriented, with some hardware system testing and data
collection requirement. For this, project specific components and setup are required. Average of 2,000 USD is
required for each PhD candidate research work for his/her dissertation over the four years of study. This fund is
mainly required for purchase of laboratory kits, and components of experimental system. The amount is mostly
required during second-third year of the PhD program, when building experimental set up and data collection is
expected.
Living cost in Addis Ababa is a challenge for students to focus on their research, dedicating their time, while
research and development requires fulltime dedication. However, the students usually search for extra job outside
the university to pay their bills.
19
Through research assistantship, the students can be given work in their research laboratories in the new laboratory
equipment installation and commissioning. There are jobs in their research laboratories, which require manpower
anyway, and contribute to the quality of the research in the laboratory. Students can mentor/tutor and support their
juniors on use of equipment, operation and maintenance of research facilities, etc.
Advantage of this arrangement is twofold. One it helps the students to be close to their study and research activity.
Second, it improves quality of research. AAU shall facilitate these as much as possible.
During the project period laboratory facility in Electrical Power Engineering will be established. The aim of the
laboratory facility is to equip the laboratories with up-to-date research and development equipment to attract the
academia and the industry to work together on present and future needs of the industry in the sector and sustain the
PhD program after the project period. In the long run, it will ensure the sustainability of the program. These
facilities can be used for the present project as required in addition to facilities at Swedish professor laboratories,
however, the aim of the laboratory facilities is for sustainability of the program and hence to be used after the
project period at AAU. Addis Ababa University shall follow the following (2.8.1 to 2.8.4) to establish and equip
the laboratories and report to SIDA and request detailed budget each year.
Partner Swedish University Professors support in specification and order of equipment, devices, and systems of the
centre of excellence to be imported.
20
Proper installation, commissioning and training on the laboratory equipment for its proper and effective and
efficient operation is an important step of the establishment.
The partner university/institution technical staffs support in installation, commissioning and training of AAU staffs
when ever there is expertise and need.
PhD students’ industry interaction and understanding of the real working environment is an essential component to
elevate the quality of education and research work. Towards this end, ABB has agreed to receive and supervise
students for a period of time, up to one year, based on schedule to be agreed on by the student supervisors and the
company. On average, ten PhD students stay at ABB for an average of six months each, over the project period.
Power systems, High Voltage Engineering, Power system control, development and testing activities at ABB’s
facilities in Ludvika and/or Vasteras are to be used for this purpose.
The students’ industry stay at ABB would be part of the students four-year PhD program. ABB shall provide
working environment and supervision. Students’ leaving cost during the internship will be covered by SIDA.
The PhD study should be relevant to the local industry from its basic design. Towards this end, Ethiopian electric
utility companies; namely, Ethiopian Electric Utility (EEU) and Ethiopian Electric Power (EEP) are part of the
process of this project. Both have committed to be part of the education and research. Specifically, they have
participated and agreed in
21
3. Sustainability Analysis
3.1 Stakeholders for the Project
Stakeholders in PhD program in electrical power and control engineering and capacity building in research
laboratory in electrical power engineering are government of Ethiopia (ministry of education, ministry of industry,
ministry of water irrigation and energy, ministry of science and technology, …), the public and privet enterprises in
the sector (Ethiopian Electric Utility operator, electrical material and equipment manufacturing companies, …) and
the public at large. Mobilization and consorted effort of the stakeholders is essential for the success during the
project period and for sustainability afterwards.
The commitment of Ethiopian government for education and especially focus on engineering education, the fast
expanding Ethiopian economy and the focus on industrialization are also impetus for the sustainability of the
project.
The employment opportunity for highly qualified professionals in the expanded higher education system in the
country as teaching and research professors, as designers, research and development engineers in ever increasing
electrical energy sector in the country further guarantees the sustainability of the education and research envisaged
in this project.
At the moment, the sector is at its infant stage except the electric utility operator. However, there are companies
evolved in manufacturing of electric cables, electric machines, transformers, reactive power compensators, etc. In
the long run, the sector industry is expected to support the PhD program research and center of excellence in
funding the research activities and employment of the graduates.
AAU will work to bring the sector industry on board through workshops seminars, exhibitions etc. from the outset,
so that, they can contribute their share towards the sustainability of the programs.
Addis Ababa University has grown to a student population of about 50,000 and in the last 60 years beginning with
less than 100 students and few programs. It has diversified disciplines to more than 70 running under a dozen of
colleges and institutions. Starting from only undergraduate programs it has developed hundreds of Masters and
PhD programs. Through these years, it has developed its capacity through scholarly cooperation with universities
abroad, developing its staff capacity, and cooperation with other stakeholders. The school of Electrical and
Computer Engineering, being unit of AAU have been sharing this exercise of sustaining initiatives in expansion
and upgrading of its programs and research projects. Therefore, the staffs of the school of electrical and computer
engineering involved in the project have commitment for success and sustainability of this project even after the
22
completion of the project. The school shall also strengthen its staff in electrical power and control engineering
from the graduates of this project as chain effect.
23
4. Major Outcomes and Outputs
4.1 Outcome one: Addis Ababa University capacity built to run a quality Electrical Power and Control
Engineering PhD program
o About eight graduates from the program in 2020/21 and 2021/22 academic years
o Laboratory facilities built to run Electrical Power Engineering and control at school of
Electrical and Computer engineering of Addis Ababa University
4.2 Outcome two: Local Industry Problems Solved University-industry cooperation in solving real industry
problems strengthened. Research outputs of the PhD students contributing in filling knowledge and
skill gaps in the electric power energy sector in Ethiopia and contribute to the knowledge base
• Outputs leading to the outcome
o Eight dissertations (research outputs) focusing on local problems produced.
4.3 Outcome three: Ethiopian and Swedish people-to-people, government-to-government relations and
economic cooperation increases and Electrical Energy sector investment expand contributing to
poverty eradication through job creation in the sector and Swedish investors are encouraged to invest
in Ethiopian energy sector enhancing people to people relation.
o Four Ethiopian professors and more than eight PhD students visit Sweden
24
5. Benefits/Beneficiaries
All partners of the proposed cooperation and the scientific community in general are beneficiaries. The cooperation
between Addis Ababa University and Swedish Universities enhance scholarly activities of the universities;
research, teaching and learning with improved quality and quantity of outputs. It can also extend to enhancing
technological and economical cooperation of the two countries. It triggers more people to people relation between
Sweden and Ethiopia. The graduates of the program, during the project period, will gain knowledge about Sweden
and its people building attachments for future cooperation. This can benefit both Ethiopia and Sweden.
About twenty PhD candidates are to be enrolled in the PhD program and are the primary direct beneficiaries of the
program. They will get quality education and upgrade their education in their home country improving their social
status and income.
The School of Electrical and Computer Engineering will build its capacity to run quality PhD program in Electrical
Power and control Engineering program and strengthen its industry cooperation. It will build both human and
laboratory capacity to sustainably run the program. Its academic staffs can also be PhD candidates resulting higher
staffs profile.
The electrical energy sector in Ethiopia is beneficiary of the project; because, it can obtain qualified pool of
electrical power engineers for employment, research outputs to improve their services and production, etc. They do
also get place of interaction with academia for research and development on their products and services.
Ethiopia as a country benefits as the human capacity building is key component of development plan it has in
electrical energy sector. It will be part of its drive to have a carbon free economy in 2025 being a middle-income
country. The Electrical Power and Control Engineering PhD program supported by necessary laboratories is
critical for the success and sustainability of the transformational growth plan of Electric power generation,
transmission, distribution in Ethiopia including the export to neighbouring countries.
The launching of the PhD and research facility also builds Ethiopia’s capacity to design, construct, operate,
maintain, supply materials and parts of electrical power system benefiting millions of Ethiopians in general, and
create education/research/technical service opportunity for hundreds of students, professionals in particular.
25
The project capacities Ethiopia to utilize its renewable energy resources instead of fossil fuel as its economy
expands. This will be a significant contribution to the green gas effect of the world.
The research output from the PhD programs can also contribute to the knowledge base of the world in the field of
electrical power engineering through the research activities.
Partner universities benefit from the cooperation in scholarly activates with their counterparts in Addis Ababa
University in co-publication, students and staff exchange, and in the establishment of in-depth long-lasting
research and education collaboration with one of the major African universities.
26
6. Quality Assurance Mechanism
The PhD programs in Electrical Power and Control Engineering are the first of their kind in Ethiopia. Addis Ababa
University, as the oldest university in the country wants to be a model for other public universities in Ethiopia
keeping the highest possible quality. That is why partnering with highly experienced Swedish universities like
Chalmers and KTH is required. Towards this end, quality is taken care of throughout the process of the education
and research.
The PhD program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering is to be the first in the country demanding high
level of quality foundation for future expansion. The PhD education and research quality is assured by continuous
activities beginning from student recruitment to graduation.
Student requirement will be based on official announcement to attract potential candidates for merit-based
competition.
Students are required to present their second-degree credentials in relevant field of study to demonstrate
educational preparedness to be a candidate. After pre-selection is done based on all AAU requirements, the main
supervisor and assistant supervisors will make oral examinations and select the best candidates for the respective
projects.
6.1.1 Student recruitment is based on public announcement and transparent competition. Oral or written
examination is used to select students with best capacity and demonstrated academic achievement.
6.1.2 Well-prepared project plan Public presentation and defense for the dissertation.
6.2.1 Students’ progress is evaluated every year (based on their study and progress plan) to proceed
to the next year and the next year work plan depends on the student’s performance.
Experienced professors, co-advisors, from Chalmers and KTH are involved in the student’s
evaluation and next step decision. Further more, for each student’s project, reference group
comprising relevant industry personnel and supervisors review their work with brief note to be
filed in students file twice a year.
6.2.2 Not less than one scientific paper on peer-reviewed journal and not less than two papers on
peer-reviewed scientific conference proceeding are required for graduation.
6.3 Graduation
Final dissertation defense will be public and external examiner professor from abroad will be
invited.
27
7. Logical Framework Analysis
The following is a Result Based Management Logical Framework (RBM Log frame) for the project to be
supported by Swedish International Development Agency (SIDA), to launch and run a PhD program in the field of
Electrical Power and Control Engineering with laboratory facilities in School of Electrical and Computer
Engineering, Addis Ababa University.
28
Chalmers on technology 60% of scientific regularly relevant
peer-reviewed and papers submitted taken. indices.
journals/confer knowledge for peer-reviewed Almost none. The industry. Survey to be
ence needs journal/conferenc done.
proceedings e publication Yearly report
published, Knowledge accepted, of the
and Project.
Eight PhD technologies 100% graduation
students transferred to from enrollment
complete their the industry
industry as human
internship at embedded
ABB, and/or patent
2 PhD
candidates from
industry
graduate
Specific Objective 3: Global Challenges in the Electrical Power area with staff and student exchange
between AAU, KTH, Chalmers and ABB
Number of Scholarly Number of None at the Record of Report review.
international cooperation courses delivered moment. publications
conference/jour between by professors is collected as
nal papers Co- AAU, KTH from KTH and part of report.
publications, and Chalmers Chalmers,
enhanced,
Number of
Contribution students hosted at
to human Chalmers and
knowledge KTH,
base Number of PhD
students who did
their internship at
ABB
29
Professors understandin exchange is
travel to g each other. part of report
Ethiopia while to be
a number of compiled.
Ethiopian Few. Documents at Survey.
Professors and Ethiopian
PhD students investment
travel to Authority.
Sweden Tourism Number of Few. Document Document
from Sweden professors from relevant review.
increase included tour of government
Ethiopia to their agencies like
travel. immigration
office.
Assumptions:
• Government plan which focus on electric energy sector changes
Such changes would be temporary. PhD program and research in electrical power can still be
sustained serving the east African community which has huge renewable energy potential and
development plan. Hence the sustainability and employability of the graduates remains high.
30
8. Risk Analysis
S. No. Possible Risk Mitigation
1 Students may decide to stay Most PhD candidate students are coming from public universities
in Sweden or move to other academic staffs. These public universities have regulations, which
third country instead of allow them to have their staffs (with their guarantor) sign
completing their education commitment to come back to their universities and serve for a
and serving their country certain number of years after graduation.
Attachments of the candidate to Ethiopia like employment, family,
etc are considered in addition to academic preparedness to recruit
students. Furthermore, tthrough the design of the program, the
students will spend most of the study time in Ethiopia and all PhD
subjects will be strongly related to the Ethiopian context and to
Ethiopian stakeholders.
2 Staffs involved in the project Joint supervision is an advantage to overcome such risk. In case of
may change career or cease an Ethiopian professor quits, an assistant professor can replace
quite from participation in him/her with Swedish professor’s stronger support. In case of
the project due to other Swedish professor inability to continue he/she may recommend
reasons someone from his/her laboratory.
Involve assistant and associate professors in AAU academic staffs
in the area to build their supervision capacity as much as possible.
3 PhD candidates may not Ethiopian professors and local utilities companies can work
have time to work on their together to give research assistantship to the candidates to support
project while in Ethiopia. students’ cover their living cost in Ethiopia.
Periodic annual assessment and documentation of PhD candidates’
progress by supervisors and dissertation committee could be used.
4 Some partners of the project We have to continue working on bring other stakeholders in the
like ABB, Ethiopian Utility electric energy sector including equipment and material
companies may change their manufacturers, contractors and consultants.
commitment
31
Date: February 28, 2018
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in
Chalmers and KTH together with ABB
Sweden:
PhD Sandwich training in Sweden: supervision cost is at 250,000 SEK/ student/
1
year. There are four students in 2018/19, twelve students in 2019/20,
2020/2021, 2021/22 and eight students in 2022/23 academic years.
Budget Budget Budget Budget
Budget 2021/22
2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2022/23
Other costs Sweden (must be PhD Sandwich industry stay allowance: This is PhD students' living cost during
specified) 3 their industry stay (at ABB). The cost is 16000 SEK/student/month. There are two
students staying at ABB for six months every year.
Workshops 0.00
10,000.00 10,000.00 10,000.00 10,000.00
Coordination costs 100000 100000 100000 100000 100000
Sub-total 100,000.00 110,000.00 110,000.00 110,000.00 110,000.00
32
Date: February 28, 2018
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in
Chalmers and KTH together with ABB
Sweden:
PhD Sandwich training in Sweden: supervision cost is at 250,000 SEK/ student/
1
year. There are four students in 2018/19, twelve students in 2019/20,
2020/2021, 2021/22 and eight students in 2022/23 academic years.
Budget Budget Budget Budget
Budget 2021/22
2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2022/23
Audit Swedish University Workshop participants include PhD students at Chalmers and KTH, Ethiopian and
Audit of yellow fields
(annual) Swedish supervisors, and other people invited (e.g. from ABB). Costs include
meeting room, lunch, and travel Stockholm - Gothenburg by train for PhD
Audit (annual)
students.
Costs for Swedish side coordination (2 weeks annual salary + 1 extra AAU
Sub-total 0.00
journey annually)
Trips for Sandwich Students Trip Sandwich student: This is to cover the students' round trip air ticket and
Reimbursable Cost 4 visa processing fees at the rate of 9900 SEK/student. There are four students
Student round-trip to Sweden 2018/19, twelve students 2020 through 2021/22 and eight students in 2022/23
39,600.00 118,800.00 118,800.00 118,800.00 79,200.00 academic year.
Sub total 39,600.00
118,800.00 118,800.00 118,800.00 79,200.00
Ethiopian Professors visit to Ethiopian professors visit to Sweden: Four Ethiopian professors visit Sweden
Sweden Reimbursable Cost 5 each year for an average of two weeks to plan students work and review the
previous work, seminar participation, etc. Round trip air ticket with visa
Air tickets
39,600.00 39,600.00 39,600.00 39,600.00 39,600.00 processing fee is 9900 per professor, accommodations is 250USD*6.064= 1516
SEK/day/professor, per-diem is USD (70+92.5)*6.064= 985.4 SEK/day/professor.
Accommodations All rates are calculated according to AAU regulations. There is also a bonus of
90,960.00 90,960.00 90,960.00 90,960.00 90,960.00
50USD*6.064=303.2 SEK per travel.
Per diem
59,427.20 59,427.20 59,427.20 59,427.20 59,427.20
Tuition fees
33
Date: February 28, 2018
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in
Chalmers and KTH together with ABB
Sweden:
PhD Sandwich training in Sweden: supervision cost is at 250,000 SEK/ student/
1
year. There are four students in 2018/19, twelve students in 2019/20,
2020/2021, 2021/22 and eight students in 2022/23 academic years.
Budget Budget Budget Budget
Budget 2021/22
2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2022/23
Tuition fees
9,000.00 9,000.00
Laboratory Equipment: Laboratory equipment specification, procurement and
Sub total 279,243.20
279,243.20 7 installation is planned over the project period. Expert the budget includes
laboratory equipment purchase, training on the equipment purchased usage and
maintenance, expert support for specification and procurement, travel for
Audit AAU (annual) Audit of green fields trainings, equipment installation and commissioning costs. Breakdown for each
year will be prepared and submitted to SIDA every year for the subsequent year.
Audit (annual) 9,300.00
12,000.00 18,000.00 36,000.00 20,000.00
Sub-total 9,300.00 12,000.00 18,000.00 36,000.00 20,000.00
34
Date: February 28, 2018
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in
Chalmers and KTH together with ABB
Sweden:
PhD Sandwich training in Sweden: supervision cost is at 250,000 SEK/ student/
1
year. There are four students in 2018/19, twelve students in 2019/20,
2020/2021, 2021/22 and eight students in 2022/23 academic years.
Budget Budget Budget Budget
Budget 2021/22
2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2022/23
35
Date:
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Sweden: Chalmers and KTH together with ABB Chalmers KTH
Notes
Other costs Sweden
Coordination costs 100000 37500 25000 37500 Notes 2 week salary + 1 extra journey for coordinatior
Sub-total 100000
Audit Swedish University (annual) Audit of yellow fields
Audit (annual)
Sub-total 0.00 100,000.00
36
Date:
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Sweden: Chalmers and KTH together with ABB Chalmers KTH
Tuition fees
Tuition fees
9,000.00 9,000.00
Sub total 279,243.20 279,243.20
Notes Four Ethiopian professors to take research training and PhD supervision capacity
building course at Chalmers. Two professors in 2019 April.
37
Date:
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Sweden: Chalmers and KTH together with ABB Chalmers KTH
Notes
Other costs Ethiopia (Must be specified)
Laboratory Equipment 0.00 0 0.00
Dissertation Examination 0.00 0 0.00
Publication and international conf. stay 0.00 0 0.00
Workshop Organization 10,000.00 10000
Professors Professional conf. participation 125,252.00 62626 62,626.00
Coordination cost 14,400.00
3600 3600 3,600.00 3600
Sub Total 149,652.00
3600 66226 66,226.00 13,600.00
Notes Four Ethiopian professors participate in one professional conference each year.
Total costs (Excluding AAU OH) 2,243,782.40 368,587.20 686,826.00 647,226.00 541,143.20
Total cost Sweden Sandwich 1,576,000.00 175,000.00 581,000.00 581,000.00 239,000.00 788000 788000
100,000.00
Total Cost Swedish University 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Subject to full cost compensation, OH, social
costs etc.
All lines need to be specified and
Total cost AAU 667,782.40 193,587.20 105,826.00 66,226.00 302,143.20
38
Date:
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Sweden: Chalmers and KTH together with ABB Chalmers KTH
1,091,342.784 1,232,573.504
39
Date:
PhD Program in Electrical
Name of Project: Power and Control
Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Chalmers and KTH
Sweden: together with ABB Chalmers KTH
40
Date:
PhD Program in Electrical
Name of Project: Power and Control
Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Chalmers and KTH
Sweden: together with ABB Chalmers KTH
41
Date:
PhD Program in Electrical
Name of Project: Power and Control
Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Chalmers and KTH
Sweden: together with ABB Chalmers KTH
Notes
Other costs Ethiopia (Must be
Subject to OH?
specified)
Laboratory Equipment 18,000.00 9000 9000
Dissertation Examination 0.00
Publication and international conf.
0.00
stay
Workshop Organization 10,000.00 10000
Professors Professional conf.
125,252.00
participation 62626 62626
Coordination cost 14,400.00 3600 3600 3600 3600
Sub Total 167,652.00 66,226.00 12,600.00 75,226.00 13,600.00 167,652.00
Laboratory facility selection and specification with some samples to be purchased.
Notes
Total costs (Excluding AAU OH) #REF! #REF! #REF! #REF! #REF! #REF!
42
Date:
PhD Program in Electrical
Name of Project: Power and Control
Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Chalmers and KTH
Sweden: together with ABB Chalmers KTH
Total cost Sweden Sandwich 4,344,000.00 1,086,000.00 1,086,000.00 1,086,000.00 1,086,000.00 2534000 1810000
Includes OH, social fees ect.
Total Cost Swedish University 110,000.00 0.00 0.00 10,000.00 0.00 110,000.00
Subject to full cost compesation,
OH, social costs etc.
43
Date:
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Sweden: Chalmers and KTH together with ABB Chalmers KTH
44
Date:
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Sweden: Chalmers and KTH together with ABB Chalmers KTH
45
Date:
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Sweden: Chalmers and KTH together with ABB Chalmers KTH
Notes
Other costs Ethiopia (Must be
Subject to OH
specified)
Laboratory Equipment 800,000.00 800,000.00
Dissertation Examination 0.00
Publication and international conf.
125,252.00
stay 62626 62626
Workshop organisation 10,000.00 10000
Professors Professional conf.
125,252.00
participation 62626 62626
Coordination cost 14,400.00 3600 3600 3600 3600
Sub Total 1,074,904.00 66,226.00 866,226.00 128,852.00 13,600.00 1,074,904.00
Notes
Total costs (Excluding AAU OH) 5,855,691.20 1,381,619.60 1,877,226.00 1,454,245.60 1,042,600.00
Total cost Sweden Sandwich 4,344,000.00 1,161,000.00 1,011,000.00 1,161,000.00 1,011,000.00 2534000 1810000
Includes OH, social fees, etc.
46
Date:
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Sweden: Chalmers and KTH together with ABB Chalmers KTH
Total Cost Swedish University 110,000.00 0.00 0.00 10,000.00 0.00 110,000.00
Subject to full cost compensation,
OH, social costs etc.
47
Date:
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Sweden: Chalmers and KTH together with ABB Chalmers KTH
Quarter 2021/2022 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
48
Audit Swedish University (annual) Audit of yellow fields
Audit (annual)
Sub-total 0.00
Notes
Other costs Ethiopia (Must be Subject to OH?
49
specified)
Total costs (Excluding AAU OH) 7,624,195.20 1,306,619.60 2,436,878.00 2,357,219.60 1,423,478.00
Total cost Sweden Sandwich 4,344,000.00 1,086,000.00 1,086,000.00 1,086,000.00 1,086,000.00 2,534,000.00 1,810,000.00
Includes OH, social fees, etc.
Total Cost Swedish University 110,000.00 0.00 0.00 10,000.00 0.00 110,000.00
Subject to full cost compensation, OH,
social costs etc.
50
Date: February 28, 2018
Name of Project: PhD Program in Electrical Power and Control Engineering
Reporting Period:
Collaborating Institutions in Sweden: Chalmers and KTH together with ABB Chalmers KTH
51
journey for
coordinator
Sub-total 110,000.00 0.00 0.00 10,000.00 0.00 110,000.00
52
Notes
Other costs Ethiopia (Must be
Subject to OH?
specified)
Laboratory Equipment 1,200,000.00 600000 600000
Dissertation Examination 200,000.00 200,000.00
Publication and international conf. stay 250,504.00 125252 125252
Workshop organization 10,000.00
10,000.00
Professors Professional conf.
125,252.00
participation 62626 62626
Coordination cost 14,400.00 3600 3600 3600 3600
Sub Total 1,800,156.00 66,226.00 728,852.00 3,600.00 1,001,478.00 1,800,156.00
Notes
Total costs (Excluding AAU OH) 5,159,343.20 990,819.60 1,418,852.00 938,193.60 1,711,478.00
Total cost Sweden Sandwich 2,960,000.00 790,000.00 690,000.00 790,000.00 690,000.00 1,850,000.00 1,110,000.00
Total Cost Swedish University 110,000.00 0.00 0.00 10,000.00 0.00 110,000.00
Subject to full cost compensation, OH,
social costs etc.
53
Student
no. PhD Students
Expected
Name of supervisor in Name of Ethiopian Date of graduation
2018 Sweden Swe. institution supervisor admission date
Supervisor No.1
1 Name of student: S Gubanski Chalmers Mengesha Q3 2021/2022
Notes (courses, thesis title, articles Etc.)
Project No. 1 as listed in proposal
2 Name of student: M Amelin KTH Getachew Bekele Q3 2021/2022
Notes (courses, thesis title, articles Etc.)
Project No. 15 as listed in proposal
3 Name of student: E Ahlgren Chalmers Getachew Bekele Q3 2021/2022
Notes (courses, thesis title, articles Etc.)
Project No. 11 as listed in proposal
4 Name of student: L Söder KTH Mengesha Mamo Q3 2021/2022
Notes (courses, thesis title, articles Etc.)
Project No. 16 as listed in the proposal
2019
5 Name of student: M Bongiorno Chalmers Mengesha Mamo Q3 2022/2023
Notes (courses, thesis title, articles Etc.)
54
Student
no. PhD Students
Notes (courses, thesis title, articles Etc.)
55
9. Budget Summary
Budget attached on Excel sheet.
References
[i ] V. Ćuk, J.F.G. Cobben, W.L. Kling, and R.B. Timens, “Analysis of Current Transients Caused by Voltage
Notches” Proceeding of IEEE-PES-2011
[ii] A. M. O. Haruni, M. Negnevitsky, and M. E. Haque, and A. Gargoom, “Control Strategy of a Stand-Alone
Variable Speed Wind Turbine with Integrated Energy Storage System Using NPC Converter”, Annual
conference IEEE-PES-2011
[iii] Piotr Biczel, Andrzej Jasi ń ski, Jacek Lachecki “Power Electronic Devices in Modern Power Systems” ,
EUROCON 2007 The International Conference on “Computer as a Tool” Warsaw, September 9-12
[iv ] Bhavya Gudimetla Sercan Teleke Juan Castaneda, “ Application of Energy Storage and STATCOM for
Grid Quality Issues”, Proceeding of annual meeting of IEEE-PES-2011
[v] D. Tom Rizy, Senior Member, Yan Xu, Member, IEEE, Huijuan Li, Member, Fangxing Li, Senior
Member, Phil Irminger, Student Member “Volt/Var Control Using Inverter-based Distributed Energy
Resources” Proceeding of the IEEE-PES, 2011
[vi] KATHERINE MARGARET ROGERS B.S., University of Texas, 2007 “POWER SYSTEM CONTROL
WITH DISTRIBUTED FLEXIBLE AC TRANSMISSION SYSTEM DEVICES”, Thesis, University of
Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2009
[vii] Lingling Fan, Zhixin Miao, Dale Osborn, “AC or DC Power Modulation for DFIG Wind Generation with
HVDC Delivery to Improve Interarea Oscillation Damping” Proceeding of IEEE-annual conference, 2011
[viii] Mel Olken, “Smart grid technology a global approach to its challenge”, IEEE Power and Energy Magazine,
volume 10, November 4 Julay/August 2012
[ix] Miladen Kezunovic, Vijay Vittal, Sakis Meliopoulos and Tim Mount, “The Big Picture Smart Research for
Large-scale Integrated Smart Grid Solutions” IEEE Power and Energy magazine volume 10, Nov 4,
July/August 2012
[x] http://oilprice.com/Alternative-Energy/Geothermal-Energy/Ethiopia-to-Build-Africas-Largest-Geothermal-
Plant.html, Mekuria Lemma (Ethiopian Electric Power Strategy & Investment Head), POWER AFRICA
[xi] Ministry of Finance and Economic Development, Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia, Growth and
Transformation Plan (2010/11-2014/15) Volume I, November 2010, Addis Ababa
56
[xii ] V. Ćuk, J.F.G. Cobben, W.L. Kling, and R.B. Timens, “Analysis of Current Transients Caused by Voltage
Notches” Proceeding of IEEE-PES-2011
[xiii] A. M. O. Haruni, M. Negnevitsky, and M. E. Haque, and A. Gargoom, “Control Strategy of a Stand-Alone
Variable Speed Wind Turbine with Integrated Energy Storage System Using NPC Converter”, Annual
conference IEEE-PES-2011
[xiv] Piotr Biczel, Andrzej Jasi ń ski, Jacek Lachecki “Power Electronic Devices in Modern Power Systems”,
EUROCON 2007 The International Conference on “Computer as a Tool” Warsaw, September 9-12
[xv ] Bhavya Gudimetla Sercan Teleke Juan Castaneda, “ Application of Energy Storage and STATCOM for
Grid Quality Issues”, Proceeding of annual meeting of IEEE-PES-2011
[xvi] D. Tom Rizy, Senior Member, Yan Xu, Member, IEEE, Huijuan Li, Member, Fangxing Li, Senior
Member, Phil Irminger, Student Member “Volt/Var Control Using Inverter-based Distributed Energy
Resources” Proceeding of the IEEE-PES, 2011
[xvii] KATHERINE MARGARET ROGERS B.S., University of Texas, 2007 “POWER SYSTEM CONTROL
WITH DISTRIBUTED FLEXIBLE AC TRANSMISSION SYSTEM DEVICES”, Thesis, University of
Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2009
[xviii] Lingling Fan, Zhixin Miao, Dale Osborn, “AC or DC Power Modulation for DFIG Wind Generation with
HVDC Delivery to Improve Interarea Oscillation Damping” Proceeding of IEEE-annual conference, 2011
[xix] Mel Olken, “Smart grid technology a global approach to its challenge”, IEEE Power and Energy Magazine,
volume 10, November 4 Julay/August 2012
[xx] Miladen Kezunovic, Vijay Vittal, Sakis Meliopoulos and Tim Mount, “The Big Picture Smart Research for
Large-scale Integrated Smart Grid Solutions” IEEE Power and Energy magazine volume 10, Nov 4,
July/August 2012
[xxi ] Julio Romero Agüero, Steve J. Steffel, “Integration Challenges of Photovoltaic Distributed Generation on
Power Distribution Systems”, Proceeding of IEEE-PES-2011
[xxii] “Africa’s Health-care Brain Drain.” New York Times, 13 August 2004.
http://www.globalpolicy.org/socecon/develop/aids/2004/0813braindrain.htm
[xxiii] “From Brain Drain to Brain Gain: Africa’s Age nda for Training, Retaining and Using its Human
Resources Effectively.” Synthesis of papers presented at the Regional Conference on Brain Drain and
Capacity Building in Africa. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 22-24 February 2000.
http://www.braingain-instruments.nl/docs/Ngu-AfricaBrainGain.doc
57
Other references
[1] Ministry of Education, “The education and Training policy and its implementation”, February, 2002,
Ethiopia
[2] SAGE publications, “Expanding Higher Education …”, pp 550-560, November 2011
[3] Ministry of Science and Technology, “National Science, Technology and Innovation Plolicy”, October 2010,
Addis Ababa
[4] Loet Leydesdorff, “The Knowledge based Economy and the Triple Helix Model”, University of
Amisterdam, Amsterdam School of Communications research, http://www.leydesdorff.net
[5] Concept Note for Sida Grant Renewal to Addis Ababa University, October 2014
Attachments:-
- Curricula Vitae of Professors (10 )
- Memorandum of Understanding between AAU and Chalmers, KTH (2)
- Recent Email Exchanges (1)
- Publications of Professors (9)
58