ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Organization of Contents in Intended Junior Secondary Science

Curriculum of Bangladesh: An Explorative Study
Kalyani Bain1, Mohammad Nure Alam Siddique2*
1
Institute of Education and Research, Khulna University, Khulna, Bangladesh, 2Institute of Education and Research, University of Dhaka, Bangladesh
*Corresponding Author: siddique.mna@du.ac.bd

ABSTRACT
This study explored the organization of contents in the junior secondary science curriculum of Bangladesh. The research questions of
this study focus on how science content is sequenced and integrated in the intended curriculum. Document analysis within a qualitative
approach has been followed to conduct this study. Both junior secondary science curriculum and textbooks have been analyzed to address
the research questions. This study finds that the current science curriculum at the junior secondary level is not well-organized in terms
of sequencing and integration. No principle of sequencing content is followed in most cases. It is noted that in the case of intergrades
vertical sequencing, “spiral sequencing” is partially followed in a few cases. This study also finds that the current science curriculum
does not integrate the content adequately. Intradisciplinary integration, i.e. integrating different subdisciplines of science, has been tried
but the level of integration is not adequate rather it is very low. This study recommends that curriculum developers make efforts to make
the content better organized in both curriculum and textbooks by following the principles of sequencing and integration.

KEY WORDS: science curriculum; curriculum content; organization of content; sequence; integration

INTRODUCTION authors).” The curriculum also aimed at providing “the

C
foundation for pursuing science education at a higher level”
ontent is one of the four main elements of a
(p. 25, translated by authors). It is clearly evident that the
curriculum along with objectives, methods, and
curriculum aims at preparing students for higher study to
evaluation. Organization of content in the curriculum
become science professionals. One the other hand, the
is considered very important to achieve the stated goals and
curriculum also set objectives such as:
objectives of curriculum (Edith Cowan University, 2001) and
• To acquire necessary life skills and attitude for ensuring
it should be done in a manner that content does not seem to be
personal and social security and for overcoming adverse
segmented (Ehsan, 1997). Links ought to be established across
life situation by practicing science
learning areas whenever it is possible and practicable to do
• To become scientifically tempered, rational, and free of
so as the University of Alabama’s Center for Communication
superstitions (NCTB, 2012. p. 26, translated by authors).
and Educational Technology asserts that this approach makes
a positive impact on the achievement of students (Alberta These objectives suggest that the curriculum also aimed at
Education, 2007). In a similar way, the Education Bureau developing scientifically literate citizens. Therefore, it can be
of Hong Kong (2016) has highlighted the importance of said that the current junior secondary science curriculum has
appropriate and logically sequenced content and has described tried to balance the two competing aims of science education.
it as one of the important aspects of effective and successful
Scientifically literate students are expected to grasp the broad
learning. Malamed (2016) and Friedlander (2014) both
integrating ideas of science that are necessary to understand
asserted that a meaningful logical sequence helps students to
and explain the scientific phenomena (organization for
comprehend and retain the content better.
economic cooperation and development [OECD], 2003).
Fensham (1985) argued that two competing aims of science However, our experience suggests that students in Bangladesh
education are dominant in science curricula; they are preparing have a discrete understanding of nature and natural phenomena.
specialist manpower and scientifically literate citizenry. In For example, we have seen that undergraduate science students
Bangladesh, a new curriculum was finalized in 2012 and have an excellent understanding of the biological process
implemented in 2013. The junior secondary science curriculum involved in the digestion of the consumed food, but they fail
(i.e. Grades six-eight) aimed at “familiarizing students with to explain chemical process involved in producing energy
modern concepts of science and scientific process to educate in our body. Then the questions arise: Why do students fail
them with advanced science education (National Curriculum to have an integrated and holistic understanding of science
and Textbook Board [NCTB], 2012. p. 25, translated by concepts? Is it anyway linked with how science content is

156 Science Education International   ¦  Volume 28  ¦  Issue 2

 Bain and Siddique: Curriculum Content

organized in the curriculum? With these questions in our mind University, 2001). Organization of content (architectonics) in
we explored the organization of content in the existing junior a curriculum is an important part of any curriculum. The two
secondary science curriculum of Bangladesh. According to most important aspects of organization of content in curriculum
Ehsan (1997), after implementing a new curriculum, it needs are (Print, 1993; Ehsan, 1997):
to be reviewed, analyzed, and evaluated. Curriculum analysis • Sequence of curriculum content
and review is one key to improving the quality of education as • Scope of curriculum content.
it sets the groundwork for the further development by analyzing
the current situation (National Council for Curriculum and Sequence of Curriculum Contents
Assessment, 2005). At present, it has been planned that the Ehsan (1997) referred to the sequence of curriculum as the
curriculum will be revised to include the junior secondary vertical organization of content. Print (1993) and Edith Cowan
grades of six, seven, and eight in the compulsory primary University (2001) defined the sequence as the order in which
education. This study aims to inform curriculum authority, content is presented to learners. Conventionally, it has been
curriculum developers, textbook writers, secondary science preferable that content should be sequenced by following
teachers, and other stakeholders about the organization logical approach (Edith Cowan University, 2001). The
of content in junior secondary science curriculum so that principles of sequencing content described by Print (1993 as
necessary actions can be taken for improving organization of cited in Edith Cowan University, 2001) are: Simple to complex,
content in the future curriculum. prerequisite learning, whole to part, and chronology. These four
principles have become increasingly acceptable as the criteria
This article reports partial findings of a larger study. The purpose
for sequencing contents.
of the larger study was to explore the organization of contents
in current junior secondary science curriculum of Bangladesh. If the sequence of content involves revisiting key concepts
Specifically, the study aimed to find out how science contents multiple times for further development of the concepts, it
are sequenced and integrated in intended curriculum as well is called spiral sequencing (Figure 1). Spiral sequencing is
as to explore how teacher’s classroom practice is influenced based on Bruner’s (1960) learning theory (Johnston, 2012;
by their views and understanding on different aspects of Rhalmi, 2011).
organization of contents. However, considering the word
Based on Bruner’s (1960) work, Johnston (2012) described the
limit for the article, we present the answers of two research
following three key features of spiral sequencing:
questions that focus on the organization of science content in
1. The student revisits a topic, theme, or subject several
the intended curriculum. The research questions are:
times throughout their school career.
1. How is science content sequenced in the intended junior
2. The complexity of the topic or theme increases with each
secondary curriculum?
revisit.
2. How is science content integrated within the discipline
and with other disciplines? 3. New learning has a relationship with old learning
and is put in context with the old information.
Intended curriculum in this study includes curriculum
document and science textbooks for grade six, grade seven, Scope of Curriculum Content
and grade eight published by the NCTB. The term scope refers to the breadth and depth of content within
the curriculum at any one time. Sometimes scope is referred
to as horizontal organization or “integration” (Edith Cowan
LITERATURE REVIEW University, 2001; based on Print, 1993). Print (1993) refers
We can consider that curriculum has three main forms, tiers to integration as one of the guiding concepts that is helpful
or levels – intended, implemented, and attained curriculum. in determining scope. In this study, only integration has been
The formal intended curriculum is the most common idea of studied as the scope of curriculum contents.
curriculum and it comprises the formal statements of rationale,
aims, intended list of content or concepts to be known, or Integration can generally be defined as a curriculum approach
competencies or skills to be mastered in programs of study and that purposefully draws together knowledge, skills, attitudes,
demonstrated in assessment (Gilbert, 2012). The intended or and values from within or across subject areas to develop a
specified curriculum has a focus on the aims and concepts of more powerful understanding of key ideas (Alberta Education,
what is to be taught, that is, the curriculum which is planned 2007). The New Zealand Ministry of Education (Fraser, 2010)
and expressed through the curriculum framework and other describes integration as a broad education that makes links
formal documents (Gilbert, 2012). According to Porter and within and across learning areas. In its simplest conception,
Smithson (2001), the intended curriculum refers to such policy integration is about making connections (Drake and Burns,
tools as curriculum standards, frameworks, or guidelines that 2004). Curriculum integration can be of different types and
outline what teachers are expected to deliver. approaches. It is shown in the following continuum (Figure 2).
As stated, content is one of the four main elements of a Alberta Education (2007) and Drake and Burns (2004)
curriculum along with objectives, methods, and evaluation describe intradisciplinary and multidisciplinary integration
(Nicholls and Nicholls, 1988, as cited in Edith Cowan as following.

Science Education International   ¦  Volume 28  ¦  Issue 2 157

 Bain and Siddique: Curriculum Content

Figure 1: A curriculum concept spiral from the Manhattanville Music Curriculum Project (Edith Cowan University, 2001. p. 70-71)

Figure 2: Curriculum integration continuum (Manitoba Education and Training, 1997 as cited in Alberta Education, 2007)

Intradisciplinary understanding of a central phenomenon. A qualitative approach

Content from multiple subdisciplines within a discipline (in was taken for this study since as it aimed to explore and get
case of science discipline contents from biology, chemistry, a detailed understanding of organization of content in the
physics, astronomy, environmental science, health, etc.,) are intended junior secondary science curriculum, which was the
integrated to help students obtain a more comprehensive central phenomenon of the study.
understanding. Data have been collected from curriculum documents and
Multidisciplinary textbooks. Textbooks along with the curriculum documents
Content from multiple disciplines are organized around a have been used because textbooks are the de facto curriculum
theme. The theme then addresses learning outcomes from in Bangladesh (Siddique, 2007) since the NCTB develops
multiple disciplines including science (Figure 3). and publishes a single textbook for each of the subjects. The
existing science curriculum for junior secondary level selected
parts of the textbook for grades six, seven, and eight were
METHODOLOGY used as the source of data since they are rich in information
Creswell (2012) asserted that qualitative research is the most that are needed to answer the research questions of this study.
suitable approach for exploring and developing a detailed The selection of these documents is in line with arguments by

158 Science Education International   ¦  Volume 28  ¦  Issue 2

 Bain and Siddique: Curriculum Content

Patton (1990) that when information rich cases are selected

for study in depth, purposeful sampling can be powerful and
logical. Details of science curriculum and textbooks used as
data source are as follows:
a. National Curriculum and Textbook Board (NCTB).
(2012). National Curriculum 2012-Secondary Science
(in Bengali). Dhaka: NCTB.
b. Tapan, S., Rahman, S., Haider, S.M., Jahanara, Q.A.,
Rahman, S.M.H., Siddique, M.N.A., Khaleque, M.A.,
& Ahmed, G.A. (2016a). Science: Class Six. Dhaka:
National Curriculum and Textbook Board.
Figure 3: Multidisciplinary integration
c. Tapan, S., Rahman, S., Haider, S.M., Jahanara, Q.A.,
Rahman, S.M.H., Siddique, M.N.A., Khaleque, M.A.,
& Ahmed, G.A. (2016b). Science: Class Seven. Dhaka: Level of Explanation
National Curriculum and Textbook Board. integration
d. Tapan, S., Rahman, S., Haider, S.M., Jahanara, Q.A., Level 1 Discrete factual information
Rahman, S.M.H., Siddique, M.N.A., Khaleque, M.A., Level 2 Confined to one subdiscipline of science
& Ahmed, G.A. (2016c). Science: Class Eight. Dhaka: Level 3 Integrating/linking among multiple subdisciplines of
science, but not adequately
National Curriculum and Textbook Board.
Level 4 Linking among multiple subdisciplines of science and
Collection and Analysis of Data for comprehensive understanding level of integration is
adequate
Bowen (2009) stated that document analysis is useful
Level 5 Integrating among different subdisciplines of science
for collecting qualitative data from written documents. and integrating science with other disciplines but not
Hence, document analysis was used as the method to adequately
collect and analyze data from the current junior secondary Level 6 Completely theme/concept based; integrating among
science curriculum and textbooks. A checklist was used different subdisciplines of science and integrating Science
with other disciplines adequately for total comprehensive
for exploring the sequence of content in the curriculum understanding
and textbooks. The four principles of sequencing content
described by Print (1993 as cited in Edith Cowan University, Figure 4: Rubric for integration
2001) - simple to complex, prerequisite learning, whole to
part, and chronology - were used as the components of the
checklist. For exploring the status of spiral sequence in the
junior secondary curriculum, four key questions (KQ) were
developed based on Bruner (1960) and Johnston (2012). The Figure 5: Discrete factual content-completely integrated content
KQs were: continuum
1. Does the concept appear in multiple grades (within the
junior secondary grade)?
2. Has the learning from previous grade(s) on the same Table 1: Decision on spiral sequence based on response
concept been referred in the textbook? against KQs
3. Has the learning from previous grade(s) on the same Type of response Decision
concept been used as the base of future learning? Yes against all 4 KQs Truly spirally sequenced
4. Have the breadth and complexity of the concept been Yes against most of the KQs Spirally sequenced
increased from the previous grade? Yes against 2 KQs and no against 2 KQs Partially spirally sequenced
No against most of the KQs Not spirally sequenced
The decision about whether content was spirally sequenced or
No against all 4 KQs Not spirally sequenced at all
not was determined based on the responses against the KQs KQ: Key questions
(Table 1).
For exploring how science content is integrated within the Findings
discipline and with other disciplines the following rubric was In this study, the dimensions of sequence of content explored
used. The rubric was prepared based on Alberta Education were: sequence of content within a chapter, sequence among
(2007) and Drake and Burns (2004) (Figure 4). chapters within a grade, vertical sequence of content from one
grade to another (inter-grades sequence), and spiral sequence.
For summing up the existing situation of integration in
the junior secondary science curriculum, a continuum was No principle is followed in most cases when sequencing
used which has “discrete factual content” and “completely contents within a chapter from the document analysis, it was
integrated content” as the two ends of it (Figure 5). found that in most cases no principle of sequencing of content

Science Education International   ¦  Volume 28  ¦  Issue 2 159

 Bain and Siddique: Curriculum Content

Table 2: Chapters where no principle of sequencing content is followed

Grade Name of the chapter
Six Living World (grade six, 2nd chapter) No principle described by Print (1993) is followed in sequencing
contents within a chapter
Photosynthesis (grade six, 5th chapter)
Food and nutrition (grade six, 13th chapter)
Seven External morphology of plants (grade‑seven, 3rd chapter)
Respiration (grade seven, 4th chapter)
The use of energy (grade seven, 7th chapter)
Change in surrounding and various incidents (grade seven, 11th chapter)
Eight Diffusion, osmosis, and transpiration (grade eight, 3rd chapter)
Coordination and secretion (grade eight, 5th chapter)
chemical reactions (grade eight, 8th chapter)
Food and nutrition (grade eight, 13th chapter)

as described by Print (1993) was followed within a chapter in

the explored parts of the junior secondary science curriculum. Table 3: Probable sequence of content if “whole to part”
In addition, in only a few cases, were some of the principles principle is followed
followed or partially followed. Whole Part – where the modification
takes place
No reflection of any principle of sequencing content described
Modifications in plants Modified roots
by Print (1993) was found in the following chapters (Table 2). • Purpose/nature of modification
For example, the chapter named “external morphology of Modified stems
plants”’ (grade Seven, 3rd chapter) has the teaching sequence: Modified leaves
• Lesson - 1: Modifications of main root
• Lessons - 2-4: Modified adventitious roots
• Lessons - 5-7: Modified stems Table 4: Sequence of content in the chapter “external
• Lesson - 8: Modified leaves. morphology of plants” where “whole to part” was
followed as the principle
This sequence does not seem to be consistent with any of the
Whole Part Principle of
principles of sequencing content as described by Print (1993). sequencing
However, this content could be sequenced by the principle
External Root
“whole to part” where modifications in plants as a whole is morphology of a • Different parts of a root
presented first, and then, modification of different parts of the flowering plant • Classification of roots
plant in detail is presented (Table 3). including the
• Role of root
example of chili
It has been found that in only a few cases were some of the plant (Capsicum
principles followed in sequencing content within a chapter. frutescens)
One of the sequences “whole to part” was followed quite
explicitly in the chapters named “external morphology
of plants” (grade six, 4th chapter), “digestive system and Stem
blood circulation system” (grade seven, 5th chapter), “lower • Different parts of a stem
organisms” (grade Seven, 1st chapter), and “classification of • Classifications of stem
animal kingdom” (grade eight, 1st chapter). In these chapters, • Role of stem Whole to Part
content was presented as a broad theme first, and then, different Leaf
parts of the theme were discussed in detail. For example, • Different parts of a leaf
• General role of leaves
in the chapter “external morphology of plants” (grade six,
• Classifications of leaves
4th chapter), the morphology of an ideal flowering plant was
Importance/necessity of root,
presented first and then various aspects of different parts stem and leaf in human life,
(i.e. root, stem, leaf) of it were discussed in detail (Table 4). empathy toward plant and animal

In some cases, principles were followed partially. In the chapter

named “the structure of atom” (grade eight, 6th chapter), some electron configuration and use of isotopes are discussed in the
parts of it reflected “prerequisite learning” and “whole to part” later in the chapter, these topics build upon the earlier material
as the principles of sequencing content. In the beginning of presented. Similarly, electron configuration material is referred
the chapter, electrons and isotopes are discussed and when to again when properties of elements are discussed. Consistent

160 Science Education International   ¦  Volume 28  ¦  Issue 2

 Bain and Siddique: Curriculum Content

with the principle “whole to part,” the atom is discussed as a From Table 5, it is clear that even chapters that belong to same
whole and later the electron is discussed in detail. However, subdiscipline of science were discrete from each other in most
this sequencing is not reflected in the entire chapter. cases. For example, at grade seven there are five chapters
on biology; these chapters are not linked to each other as
Most of the Chapters within a Grade are Discrete from illustrated in Table 6.
Each Other and No Pattern of Sequencing Them is Found
In the document analysis, this study tried to uncover if there Each of the above-mentioned chapters has a different focus
was any pattern of sequence among the chapters within a grade. (theme). There is no direct linking among them nor do they
The junior secondary science curriculum included content from present a holistic view of the living world. As a result, no
biological science, physical science (physics and chemistry), pattern of sequence among these chapters was found.
earth and space science, and environmental science. Some Sometimes Principles are Followed and Sometimes They
sort of a general pattern was found in the science curriculum are Not when Sequencing Contents Vertically from one
and textbooks. Chapters on biological science were placed Grade to Another (Intergrades Sequence)
at the beginning, chapters on physical science (physics and Sometimes principles of sequencing content described by
chemistry) were in the middle and then at the end, chapter(s) Print (1993 as cited in Edith Cowan University, 2001) were
on environmental science was included. Other than this, no followed in intergrade vertical sequence in the explored parts
pattern of sequencing the chapters within a grade was found of the junior secondary science curriculum while sometimes
and most the chapters seemed to be discrete from each other. none of these principles were followed. In the cases presented
Table 5 presents the detailed analysis on sequencing among in Table 7, some of the principles were followed and so the
the chapters of the Science curriculum of grade eight. sequence seems logical.

Table 5: Sequence of chapters within grade eight

Grade eight
Subdiscipline of Chapter no and name Focus of the chapter(s) Comments on organization
science
Biology (mainly) 1. Classification of animal kingdom Classification Different chapters have got different
2. Growth and heredity of living organism Process and systems in living beings focus (theme); no direct linking has been
3. Diffusion, osmosis and absorption found. No pattern of sequence (among these
chapters) is found
4. Reproduction in plants
5. Coordination and secretion
Physical science 6. The structure of atoms Atom, atomic, and mass number, Each chapter is discrete from each other in
isotope, distribution of electrons, ions most cases and no pattern of sequence (among
7. The earth and gravitation Gravitation, gravity, acceleration due these chapters) is found
to gravity, mass and weight Dry cell as a source of electrical energy
8. Chemical reaction Classification and contributions of and electrolysis in discussed in chapter 8.
chemical reaction in our life, energy Electricity is then described in detail in
transformation chapter 9
9. Electric circuits and current electricity AC, DC flow; resistance, voltage In chapter 8 when explaining transformation
difference, circuit, ammeter, of energy through chemical reaction, reaction
voltmeter between alkaline substance and acidic
substance is discussed. And in chapter 10,
10. Acid, base and salt Properties and use of acid, base, salt
properties of acid and base (alkali) and reaction
and neutral substances (including
between them are presented in detail.
reactions)
11. Light Refraction, total internal reflection,
how optical fibers, magnifying glass,
spectacles, camera, and eye work
Earth and space 12. The outer space and satellites Outer space and the universe, natural Discrete from others
science and artificial satellite
Biology 13. Food and nutrition Food, nutrition, nutrition value, and This chapter is quite discrete from the others.
prevention of malnutrition‑related Although sometimes chemical reactions (which
diseases involve presence of different food components)
are included, they are not linked to the
chapter 8 (chemical reaction)
Environmental 14. Environment and ecosystem Environmental components and This chapter seems to be discrete. Though it is
science types, food chain, food web, placed at the end of the textbook, any link with
flow of energy in the ecosystem, other chapters is hardly found
role of ecosystem in maintaining
environmental balance

Science Education International   ¦  Volume 28  ¦  Issue 2 161

 Bain and Siddique: Curriculum Content

For example, “morphology of plants” is included in both “Spiral Sequencing” is Followed in a Few Cases but Only
grades six and seven textbooks. In the grade six textbook, Partially
morphology, i.e., different parts (root, stems, and leaves) of Intergrade vertical sequence was not spirally sequenced in
an ideal flowering plant are presented and discussed in detail. most cases in the explored parts of the junior secondary science
On the other hand, various types of modification of different curriculum. “Spiral sequencing” was followed in a few cases
parts (root, stems, and leaves) of a plant are presented in but only partially. As mentioned earlier, spiral sequencing
the grade seven textbook. The content of grade seven are involves revisiting key concepts multiple times and using
comparatively more complex than that of grade six. Hence, learning from the previous grades as the base for further
the principle of “simple to complex” was followed from one development of the concepts. None of the explored parts was
grade to the next. In the cases presented in the Table 8, none truly spirally sequenced as none of them have affirmative
of the principles were found and so the sequence does not responses against all of the KQs of spiral sequencing mentioned
seem logical. in the methodology. Some of them are only partially spiral
For example, in the curriculum photosynthesis (5th chapter), sequenced (as they have affirmative responses against some
respiration (4th chapter) and diffusion, osmosis, and absorption of the KQs) while some of them are not spirally sequenced at
(3rd chapter) are included in grade six, grade seven, and grade all (as they have negative responses against most of the KQs).
eight, respectively. This sequence does not look logical as The status of the explored parts of the curriculum in terms of
absorption of water and minerals takes place and they are spiral sequencing is shown in Table 10.
transported to leaves first; then photosynthesis happens;
Let us consider an example, “food and nutrition” as a concept
finally, using the food produced in the photosynthesis energy
is included in grade six and grade eight. The responses against
is produced in the respiration process. Therefore, it would
the KQs of spiral sequencing are shown in Table 11.
be more logical if the content was sequenced by following
“chronology” principle; see Table 9 for what this sequence Hence, it was found that “food and nutrition” has affirmative
could be like. responses against KQs 1 and 4 and negative response against

Table 6: Five chapters of biology subdiscipline in grade seven

Subdiscipline of science Chapter no Chapter name Focus of the chapter(s)
Biology 1 Lower organisms Discussion on structure and characteristics of living beings
2 Cellular organization of plants and animals
3 External morphology of plants
4 Respiration Biological process and system
5 Digestive system and blood circulation system

Table 7: Principles of sequencing contents in case of vertical sequence

Grade six Grade seven Grade eight Principles being followed
Morphology of plants External morphology of plants Simple to complex
Food and Nutrition Food and nutrition Simple to complex
Structure of matter (partial) The structure of atoms Simple to complex (partially) pre‑requisite
learning (partially)
Change in surrounding and various incidents Chemical reaction Simple to complex

Table 8: Vertical sequence with no principle of sequencing contents

Grade six Grade seven Grade eight Principles being followed
Photosynthesis Respiration Diffusion, osmosis and
absorption
Living world Lower organisms Classification of animal
kingdom
Let us know motion, force and simple Use of energy
machines (partially, very little) No principle described by print is found
Sensory organs (partially, very little) Coordination and secretion
Digestive system and Not applicable (as it appears in only one grade
blood circulation system within junior secondary level)

162 Science Education International   ¦  Volume 28  ¦  Issue 2

 Bain and Siddique: Curriculum Content

2 and 3. Hence, it was considered as only partially spiral social science, humanities, mathematics, and language, was
sequenced. not included in any of the chapters explored in this study.
The position of each chapter investigated in the integration
On the other hand, for example “energy” as a concept is
analytical rubric is showed in the Table 13.
included in grade six and grade seven. In grade six, energy
is included in the chapters named “let us know motion” and It is clear from the Table 13 that most of the chapters
“force and simple machines”, and in grade seven there is a (8 chapters in total) belong at level-3 of the analytical
chapter named “use of energy.” In this case, the responses rubric which indicates integrating multiple subdisciplines
against the KQs of spiral sequencing are shown in Table 12. of science but not adequately. For example in the chapter
“lower organisms” (grade seven, 1st chapter), it tried to link
Therefore, it was found that “energy” as a concept has negative
microbiology with a number of various subdisciplines of
responses against KQs 2, 3, and 4, so it was considered as not
science such as health science (role of virus and bacteria as
spirally sequenced.
pathogen for various diseases), agriculture (role of bacteria in
Integration among multiple subdisciplines of science has been nitrogen fixation), environmental science (role of bacteria in
tried but level of integration is not adequate rather very low decomposing dead bodies and organic waste), etc. However,
and integrating science with other disciplines is not found in all of these were only mentioned in the textbook; none of the
any of the chapters. links were explored sufficiently. There was scope for doing
so as it would have helped the students to understand more
As mentioned earlier, “integration” refers to a curriculum
comprehensively. Integration within this chapter seemed to
approach that purposefully draws together knowledge, skills,
be superficial and not adequate; so it was placed at level 3 on
attitudes, and values from within or across subject areas to
the analytical rubric.
develop a more powerful understanding of key ideas (Alberta
Education, 2007). Intradisciplinary and multidisciplinary Some of the chapters (4 chapters in total) were assessed at
approaches of curriculum integration in the junior secondary level-2 of the analytical rubric which indicated being confined
science curriculum were explored in this study. In most of to one subdiscipline of science. For example, the chapter
the chapters examined from the junior secondary science named “chemical reaction” (grade eight, 8th chapter) was
curriculum and textbooks, it is found that linking among confined to chemistry only; the chapter never went beyond
multiple subdisciplines of science was tried but the level the topic of chemistry.
of integration is not adequate rather it was very low (which Rest four chapters were assessed at level-4 of the analytical
indicates level 3 of analytical rubric). As for the other rubric which meant integrating/linking among multiple
chapters, either they are confined to one subdiscipline of subdisciplines of science and the level of integration was
science (level 2) or involve integrating/linking among multiple adequate. For example in the chapter named “respiration,”
subdisciplines of science adequately (level 4). It was found zoology and botany were integrated when respiration in
that linking/integrating science with other disciplines such as living world was discussed. Similarly, zoology and health
science were integrated when common diseases of the
Table 9: Probable vertical sequence of content if respiratory tract were discussed. All of the mentioned content
“chronology” was followed as the principle and links among the different subdisciplines of science
were discussed thoroughly. Integration within this chapter
Grade 6 Grade 7 Grade 8 seemed to be adequate; so it was placed at level 4 on the
Diffusion, osmosis, and absorption Photosynthesis Respiration analytical rubric.

Table 10: Status of different chapters in terms of spiral sequencing

Grade six Grade seven Grade eight Status in terms of spiral
sequencing
Morphology of plants External morphology of plants Partially spirally sequenced
Food and nutrition Food and nutrition Partially spirally sequenced
Structure of matter The structure of atoms Partially spirally sequenced
Change in surrounding and various Chemical reaction Partially spirally sequenced
incidents
Photosynthesis Respiration Diffusion, osmosis, and absorption Not spirally sequenced
Living world Lower organisms Classification of animal kingdom Not spirally sequenced
Let us know motion, force and simple Use of energy Not spirally sequenced
machine (partially)
Sensory organs (partially, very little) Coordination and secretion Not spirally sequenced
Digestive system and blood Not spirally sequenced
circulation system

Science Education International   ¦  Volume 28  ¦  Issue 2 163

 Bain and Siddique: Curriculum Content

Table 11: Response against KQs in case of “food and Table 13: Position of different chapters in the integration
nutrition” analytical rubric
No Key question Response (in the case Grade Name of the chapter Position
of food and nutrition) in the
KQ‑1 Does the concept appear in multiple Yes integration
grades (within junior secondary analytical
grade)? rubric
KQ‑2 Has the learning from previous No Six Living world (2nd chapter) Level 3
grade (s) on the same concept been Morphology of plants (4th chapter) Level 3
referred in the textbook?
Photosynthesis (5th chapter) Level 4
KQ‑3 Has the learning from previous No
Food and nutrition (13th chapter) Level 4
grade (s) on the same concept been
used as the base of future learning? Seven Lower organisms (1st chapter) Level 3
KQ‑4 Have the breadth and complexity of Yes External morphology of plant (3rd chapter) Level 2
the concept been increased from the Respiration (4th chapter) Level 4
previous grade? Digestive system and blood circulation Level 2
KQ: Key question system (5th chapter)
Use of energy (7th chapter) Level 3
Change in surrounding and various Level 3
Table 12: Response against KQs in case of “energy” incidents (11th chapter)
Eight Classification of animal kingdom (1st chapter) Level 2
No Key question Response (in the
Diffusion, osmosis and absorption (3rd chapter) Level 3
case of energy)
Coordination and secretion (5th chapter) Level 3
KQ‑1 Does the concept appear in multiple Yes
grades (within junior secondary grade)? The structures of atoms (6th chapter) Level 3
KQ‑2 Has the learning from previous grade (s) No Chemical reaction (8th chapter) Level 2
on the same concept been referred in the Food and nutrition (13th chapter) Level 4
textbook?
KQ‑3 Has the learning from previous grade (s) No
on the same concept been used as the base DISCUSSION
of future learning?
KQ‑4 Have the breadth and complexity of the No
This study found that in most cases no principle of sequencing
concept been increased from the previous content as described by Print (1993) was followed within a
grade? chapter in the explored parts of the junior secondary science
KQ: Key question curriculum. In only a few cases were some of the principles
followed or partially followed. It was noted, any pattern of
As noted earlier the linking or integrating of science with other sequencing the chapters within a grade was minimal as most the
disciplines such as social science, humanities, mathematics, chapters seemed to be discrete from each other. In the case of
and language, was not included in any of the chapters explored intergrade vertical sequencing, some principles of sequencing
in this study. Nevertheless, there was scope for this type of content as described by Print (1993) were followed while in
integration (multidisciplinary) in some cases. For example, some cases none of them is followed. “Spiral sequencing” was
the importance of donating blood (humanities and a social attempted in only in a few cases. Therefore, it could be said
responsibility-related issue) could have been included in the that the science content in the junior secondary curriculum
chapter “digestive system and blood circulation system” and was not well sequenced.
the misuse of atoms and isotopes as weapons (humanities and Research literature acknowledges the importance of well-
a social responsibility-related issue) could have been included sequenced content and puts emphasis on this. Edith Cowan
in the chapter “the structure of atom.” University (2001) described the principles described by Print
Integration Continuum (1993) as “logical approach” and “increasingly acceptable
From Table 13, it is clear that most of the chapters belong criteria for sequencing content.” The Education Bureau of Hong
at level 3 of the analytical rubric while only few of them Kong (2016) emphasized an appropriate and logical sequence
belonging to level 4 or level 2. Hence, the current junior of content and has described it as one of the important aspects
secondary science curriculum could be placed on the of effective and successful learning. According to Malamed
continuum “discrete factual content” to “completely integrated (2016) and Friedlander (2014) a meaningful logical sequence
content” as seen in Figure 6. helps students to comprehend and retain the content better.
According to Johnston (2012) spiral sequencing is beneficial as
The current junior secondary curriculum was placed almost knowledge is reinforced and solidified each time the students
at the middle (a little bit closer to the discrete factual content revisit the subject matter, it allows logical progression from
end) of the continuum because it does not reflect complete simplistic ideas to complicated ideas, involves activating prior
integration. knowledge, or building new learning on prior learning. He

164 Science Education International   ¦  Volume 28  ¦  Issue 2

 Bain and Siddique: Curriculum Content

Figure 6: Position of current junior secondary science curriculum on a Discrete factual content - Completely integrated content continuum

added that spiral sequence incorporates many research based CONCLUSION

approaches from cognitive science that have been linked to
The findings of this study have implications for curriculum
improve students’ performance and produce learning gains for
development and teachers’ practice. From this study, it was
almost all students. Spiral sequence ensures understanding of
found that the content of the current junior secondary science
full formal concept as it involves active learning of students
curriculum and associated textbooks were not organized
and use of prior experience to fit new information into the
properly. If science content was organized properly in the
preexisting structure (Rhalmi, 2011).
curriculum and presented in the corresponding textbook
This study found that in most of the chapters, linking among accordingly, students would learn science in a more organized
multiple subdisciplines of Science was tried, but the level of and holistic way. National Curriculum and Textbook Board
integration was not adequate rather it was very low. For the in Bangladesh has been given the responsibility to prepare
other chapters, either they were confined to one subdiscipline a holistic curriculum for newly designed primary education
of science or involved integrating multiple subdisciplines of which is now up to grade eight. Therefore, there is a good
science adequately. This study found that integrating science opportunity now to develop a well-sequenced and well-
with other disciplines such as social science, humanities, integrated science curriculum for students from grade one to
mathematics, and language, was not included in any of the grade eight. The findings of this study will help curriculum
chapters explored in this study. These finding are not in line with developers’ effort to organize content in the next curriculum
recent literature since recent literature considers integration by following the principles of sequencing and integration.
as very important. According to Program for International Then, textbook writers would need to present content in the
Student Assessment’s (PISA) suggestion, scientifically literate textbook by following the same principles.
students are expected to grasp the broad integrating ideas
Teachers may find the findings of this study helpful for
of Science that are necessary to understand and explain the planning and conducting their teaching as it informs them
scientific phenomena (OECD, 2003). According to Alberta about different aspects of organization of content and the
Education (2007), there are several benefits of curriculum importance of them.
integration like when curriculum is organized in a holistic
way rather than in fragmented pieces, it better reflects how
students’ brains process information and it better reflects the RECOMMENDATIONS FOR FUTURE
real world and the way children learn at home and in the RESEARCH
community. According to the University of Alabama’s Center Intradisciplinary and multidisciplinary integration were
for Communication and Educational Technology (2005 as explored in this study. There are other two types of integration:
cited in Alberta Education, 2007), through intradisciplinary Interdisciplinary integration and transdisciplinary integration.
integration, teachers expect students to understand the The existing status as well as scope of these types of
connections between the different subdisciplines and their integrations in the Bangladesh context should be studied in
relationship to the real world. The University of Alabama the future research. A new framework (i.e., four KQs of spiral
reported a positive impact of intradisciplinary integration sequence, rubric, and continuum for determining the level of
on students’ achievement. On the other hand, the National integration) was used in this study. Future research could be
Curriculum Board of Australia (2009) and The Curriculum done to determine the effectiveness of this framework.
Development Council of Hong Kong (2002) described
multidisciplinary integration as important and explicitly
emphasis this type of integration. Alberta Education (2007) REFERENCES
Alberta Education. (2007). Primary Programs Framework-Curriculum
described integration as important as it enables students to
Integration: Making Connections. Alberta: Alberta Education.
develop a unified view of the curriculum to broaden the Bowen, G.A. (2009). Document analysis as a qualitative research method.
context of their leaning beyond single subject areas and Qualitative Research Journal, 9(2), 27-40.
involves the development of key skills and understandings Bruner, J. (1960). The Process of Education. Cambridge, MA: The President
and Fellows of Harvard College.
that transcend individuals. Since the current junior secondary Drake, S.M., & Burns, R.C. (2004). Meeting Standards through Integrated
science curriculum does not reflect integration adequately; it Curriculum. Alexandria: Association for Supervision and Curriculum
does not help or promote students’ holistic learning. Development (ASCD).

Science Education International   ¦  Volume 28  ¦  Issue 2 165

 Bain and Siddique: Curriculum Content

Creswell, J.W. (2012). Educational Research: Planning, Conducting, and curriculum Review Phase 1. Dublin: NCCA.
Evaluating Quantitative and Qualitative Research. 4th ed. Boston: National Curriculum and Textbook Board (NCTB). (2012). National
Pearson Education Inc. Curriculum 2012-Secondary Science (in Bengali). Dhaka: NCTB.
Edith Cowan University. (2001). Curriculum Theory and Practice- National Curriculum Board. (2009). Shape of the Australian Curriculum:
Unit Notes (Based on Materials Originally Developed by Professor Science. Melbourne: National Curriculum Board.
Murray Print). Perth: Edith Cowan University. Nicholls, A., & Nicholls, S.H. (1978). Developing a Curriculum: A Practical
Education Bureau-The government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Guide. London: George Allen and Unwin.
Region. (2016). Guiding Principles for Quality Textbooks. Hong Kong: Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, OECD. (2003).
Education Bureau. Literacy Skills for the World of Tomorrow: Further Results from PISA
Ehsan, M.A. (1997). Curriculum Development: Principle and Method. 2000. Paris: OECD.
Dhaka: Chatrabondhu Library. Patton, M.Q. (1990). Qualitative Evaluation and Research Methods. 2nd ed.
Fensham, P.J. (1985). Science for all: A  reflective essay. Journal of
Newbury Park: Sage Publications.
Curriculum Studies, 17(4), 415-435.
Porter, A.C., & Smithson, J.L. (2001). Defining, Developing and Using
Fraser, D. (2010). Curriculum Integration. Wellington: New Zealand
Curriculum Indicators. Philadelphia: Consortium for Policy Research
Council for Educational Research.
in Education, University of Pennsylvania.
Friedlander, J. (2014). Sequencing Contents. Memphis: Southwest Tennessee
Community College. Print, M. (1993). Curriculum Development and Design. 2nd ed. St. Leonards:
Gilbert, R. (2012). Curriculum Planning in a Context of Change: A Literature Allen & Unwin.
Review. New Zealand: Victoria University Wellington, Department of Rhalmi, M. (2011). Implication of Bruner’s Learning Theory on
Education and Early Childhood Development. Teaching. Available from: http://www.myenglishpages.com/articles_
Johnston, H. (2012). The Spiral Curriculum. Florida: Education Partnerships, learningtheories. [Last accessed on 2017 Jun 19].
Inc. Available from: https://www.eric.ed.gov/?id=ED538282. [Last Siddique, M.N.A. (2007). Existing and Proposed Science Curricula of
accessed on 2017 Jun 19]. Grades IX-X. In: Bangladesh: A Comparative Study. (Master’s Thesis,
Malamed, C. (2016). 10 Ways to Organize Instructional Contents. Available Faculty of Education, Monash University.
from: http://www.theelearningcoach.com/elearning_design/how-to- The Curriculum Development Council. (2002). Science Education-Key
organize-content. [Last accessed on 2017 Jun 19]. Learning Area Curriculum Guide (Primary 1-Secondary 3). Kowloon:
National Council for Curriculum and Assessment (NCCA). (2005). Primary Education Department.

166 Science Education International   ¦  Volume 28  ¦  Issue 2