Pérez-Aronsson (2019)
Pérez-Aronsson (2019)
Pérez-Aronsson (2019)
EDUCARE
2019: 4
"Oh what fun, now immigrants are starting school!" Young people's experiences of
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
fanny.perez.aronsson@buv.su.se
This article criticizes the idea of schools as institutions of anti-racist knowledge and values, as well as schools
as institutions of equal opportunity for all students, by examining how youths retell experiences of racism
within the Swedish education system in online discussion forums. The study focuses on youths' experiences of racism in
meetings with teachers, in particular, as teachers are positioned as representatives of schools and
often regarded as carriers of anti-racist knowledge and values to be taught to their pupils. Using a
phenomenological approach, the study focuses on how pupils attempt to reproduce institutional lifelines promoting school
success and upwards social mobility and how such attempts are interrupted by teachers,
all the while forcing the pupils to embody a “happy diversity”. The article uses netnographic data from two online forums for
racialized youth to highlight their experiences as shared online in a “safe space”, created specifically for them, and how such
spaces constitute an alternative educational space beyond the limitations and regulations of their everyday school environments .
1 Introduction
The school system has long held a position as children and young people's primary educational arena, with one
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
national. The school as an institution is also expected to have compensatory effects and offer one
equal education for all (Martinsson 2014). In connection with the emergence of new media is added
additional responsibility for schools and teachers to teach students to be source-critical of what they read
social media (cf. Lindqvist & Thorslund 2008). Young people's internet use, from uploading
selfies to the risk of sexual violence, has also led to moralizing debates about how the internet affects
adolescents' mental health and safety (Greyson et. al. 2014), which are partly met in discussions about
use of mobiles and social media in school. At the same time, Stanley and Weare (2004) believe that
the potential of the internet for increased democratization and participation of society has been overestimated
ambiguous consequences, especially for young people's political involvement and knowledge transfer. The
this article aims to make visible young people's experiences of racism and marginalization in school such as
they are expressed on separatist online forums, focusing on the relationship with teachers, based on the following
research questions:
• How can young people's recounted experiences of racism in school be understood on the basis of one
phenomenological approach?
• How does the specific platform shape how these experiences are expressed?
Previous research on racism in schools shows, among other things, that schools automatically (re) create
difference based on societal principles along gendered, racialized and classified boundaries. This
takes place, for example, through the creation of the ideal school student, where socio-economic conditions and
norms regarding gender and ethnicity make it difficult for certain groups to live up to the requirements set.
Categorizations such as "Swedish" and "immigrants" condition one's opportunities to create oneself as
student, where the latter group's identity is characterized by a problematic “non-Swedishness” (León Rosales
2010; Jonsson 2015). The creation of certain groups as problematic affects opportunities to meet
the demands placed on students, at the same time as stories about those who have succeeded in overcoming theirs
circumstances (through, for example, school success and class trips) are praised and Swedishness is portrayed
as something desirable (Lundström 2007; Jonsson 2015). The idea of success linked to one
making Swedishness is found not only in school, but in society at large (Mattsson 2001), but
gets a central role in the school's everyday practice (Lundström 2007). This article aims to contribute
further to this research by further highlighting young people's experiences of racism in school, with
starting point in how these experiences are highlighted and discussed on two different online forums.
77
Machine Translated by Google
EDUCARE
It is important to mention here that the school's activities are regulated by both international agreements,
as UN declarations and conventions (such as the Convention on the Rights of the Child), as national law,
for example, the Education Act and the Discrimination Act. The Education Act (2010) states, among other things, that all students
shall “be ensured a school environment that is characterized by security and study peace” (Chapter 5, §3) and that
[…] Everyone who works in education should promote human rights and actively
counteract all forms of abusive treatment ”(Chapter 1, §5). The Discrimination Act (2008) describes
ethnicity, where "national or ethnic origin, skin color or other similar condition"
included (Chapter 1, §5), as one of the grounds for discrimination. Arneback and Jämte (2017) believe that
The school's work against racism is not a negotiable issue, but that the basic idea of
the equal value of all human beings sets limits on how tolerant the school can be towards the expression of
racist values. Furthermore, they believe that the school is not a value-neutral place and that it is within
the school's mission to create a safe and equal environment for all students accommodates a resident,
anti-racist attitude for which all staff are responsible. The school must both convey and shape
democratic values, and the staff must act in line with the values and have a
obligation to distance oneself from values that are contrary to this and to act against racism (Arneback
Although work against racism is rarely mentioned explicitly in texts about the school's mission, it says
Arneback and Jämte (2017) that this is part of the work with equal treatment and against discrimination.
Racism is given a broad meaning here, from a "biologically" based racism to a more culturally based,
where racist expressions are motivated by perceived differences based on culture and religion (Arneback
& Jämte 2017). As biologically based racism has been condemned, especially since others
World War II, a “new” form of racism that is more culturally based has emerged (Modood
2015). Whether this form is really new or has existed much longer than the biological one
racism, and thus rather recurred, or existed in parallel with the biological, is something that
discussed in racism research. Cultural racism refers to those who are built on cultural differences
which are understood to be so extreme and essentially different that different cultures become incompatible with each other.
While biological racism is “the antipathy, exclusion and unequal treatment of people on the basis
of their physical appearance or other imputed physical differences ”(Modood 2015, p. 155) så
the ‘civilized’ norm of the majority society and believe that they are culturally different, in order to
78
Machine Translated by Google
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
suspect and demand a cultural assimilation from groups that are also exposed to biological
racism. This form of racism has the effect of marginalizing and alienating groups such as
moving mainly from overseas countries to the old European colonial states
(Modood 2015).
At the same time, racism is still understood by many primarily on the basis of the biologically based form,
themselves as anti-racists, while expressing racist values of a more culturally based one
form (Blaut 1992; Balibar 2008; Modood 2015). Color-blind anti-racism (Bonilla-Silva 2003,
Hübinette & Lundström 2011) describe how an anti-racist attitude characterized by color blindness,
ie to claim that you do not see a difference in people based on, for example, skin color, makes the speech itself
about race and racialization (here understood as social processes where people are attributed racial affiliation
based on ideas of what race is, and thus “racized”), and by extension racism, is made impossible. The
results in the notion of an anti-racist school and "color-blind classrooms", creating an active
silence about race, racialization and racism where whiteness is reproduced as the norm, which has consequences
for those students who are identified as norm-breakers (Martinsson 2014; Jonsson 2015; Arneback & Jämte
2017). With this color-blind attitude, the accusation of racism becomes the problematic act -
rather than the existence of racism - as it makes visible the failure of the color-blind anti-racism
(Ahmed 2004). Based on Sara Ahmed's (2012) research on diversity work in particular
universities and colleges, the school's values can also be understood as a non-performative act,
an institutional act of speech, which speaks of, to and (in) the school's activities without
necessarily say something about what this practice looks like. With non-performative (speech) actions
thus refers to statements that say something, but do something else. Documents such as
equal treatment plans and values thus claim that a school represents and works
based on specific principles, and can both function as something the business strives to fulfill
and something that the business claims to do, but the very existence of the document does not imply that these
norm-critical pedagogy. The tolerance pedagogy rests on ideas of respect and tolerance towards
each other and have been criticized for reproducing ideas of normality and deviation, where it
79
Machine Translated by Google
EDUCARE
the normative group is encouraged to tolerate the deviant (Bromseth & Darj 2011), although
tolerance pedagogy is under development and its proponents have taken on board the criticism that
directed towards the perspective, among other things by highlighting the importance of not stigmatizing individuals
children (cf. Lundberg 2017), Arneback & Jämte believes that there is a view of children in e.g.
the materials and methods of tolerance pedagogy where children are seen as developing while the adults,
ie school staff, are assumed to be reasonably fully developed (Martinsson & Reimers 2014;
Arneback & Jämte 2017). Basic work as a matter of knowledge transfer, there
school staff are assumed to be fully developed in their values, and are therefore seen as a superior
group that is expected to transfer their knowledge to a subordinate group, becomes central in discussions about
standard constructions. This happens when teachers' position as knowledge bearers implicitly positions children
as either bearers of bad values or empty objects waiting to be filled with values,
and which must therefore be nurtured by the school (Martinsson 2014). In this article, I build on
this problematization of the teacher as the obvious carrier of, for example, anti-racist or
norm-critical values, and the associated view of children where students become people in need of
management and development. This is done by making visible young people's experiences of racism from teachers in
school, experiences that rather reinforce some students' experiences of exclusion in school, in direct
opposition to the Education Act's section that students must “be assured of a school environment that is characterized by
security and study peace ”(Chapter 5, §3). By studying material from online forums for
young people who are racist are also made visible by the alternative channels that young people use to share
experience and knowledge among themselves, beyond what I will call a school without spaciousness.
The study adopts a phenomenological approach to analyze young people's experiences of school and racism.
Gender scientist Signe Bremer considers bodies as experienced, created and creative, that is, we
experience and are experienced by the world through our bodies (Bremer 2011). The body is what it is
enables our knowledge of the world, and our knowledge is directly linked to our embodiment
these with queer theory and postcolonial theories, where the living body becomes a starting point for
understand how different bodies are understood as strange and familiar and out of place
or out of line ”(Ahmed 2006, pp. 10-11). Ahmed uses the concept of orientation to
describe how bodies move along lines, always facing something and away from something else, and that
80
Machine Translated by Google
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
these lines are something that is constantly reproduced (Ahmed 2006). These lines can be understood partly as
lifelines, partly as institutional lines, which are intertwined in, for example, the reproduction of
school success as a desirable and highly valued line to follow to become a "successful" adult.
Orientation, however, is not just about how we follow these lines, but also how bodies fit in
rum (Ahmed 2006). This embodiment can be understood through the concept of convenience: to follow
the line, to be (correctly) oriented and linear, is to be perceived as comfortable and experience comfort
(at ease). A comfortable body is one that is perceived as normal and therefore invisible, becomes one in
the quantity, for example through a reproduction of previous normative lines and orientations (Kipfer
2007). A body that is perceived as disoriented or non-linear, on the other hand, becomes uncomfortable and deviant,
and thereby incomprehensible and visible (Ahmed 2007). School success is understood here as the result of one
institutional line that creates the productive citizens that the school is expected to nurture, and
school success is partly based on the cultural understanding of (upward) class travel as
desirable (Sohl 2014), partly from the idea that education is a forward-looking movement that
us forward as individuals and society, where lack of education constitutes a stagnation. I ungas
stories about school and racism, education can also be understood as a strategy to avoid racism
Furthermore, Ahmed is interested in the character the stranger (the stranger or the alien). Ahmed mean
that it is in encounters with each other that bodies make sense and become alive, and that the stranger is one
constitutive figure for the creation of both collective and individual identity. The stranger is someone
who hesitate at boundaries, not only for the human and non-human, but for example
at the border of who belongs in a national space. The stranger can therefore also hold one
and distance) within a country. The stranger's position can also vary, on the one hand the stranger can
conceptualized as a dangerous figure, in, for example, what Sara Ahmed calls a “stranger
danger ”discourse, on the other hand understood in the form of a welcome diversity, within one more
multicultural discourse, both related to the idea of the stranger as an immigrant. What makes that
these discourses are similar to each other is that alienation is still crucial in the creation of one
collective, it is the stranger's difference from the norm that fills the norm with meaning (Ahmed 2000).
Based on the idea of alienation, the experience of being comfortable and understandable is understood as a relief,
where the invisibility that comprehensibility enables enables movement (Ahmed 2006; Kipfer 2007).
81
Machine Translated by Google
EDUCARE
Because this article focuses on young people's experiences of racism at school, of course
the stranger as a figuration mainly in relation to ideas about the ideal student and which bodies are moving
(and how) in school, not least in relation to nationality. To make the equivalent visible as often
is made between Swedishness and whiteness, ie ethnicity / nationality and race (Hübinette & Lundström 2011),
and thereby understand why some students read as strangers in school are used here
the concept of racism. Being racist describes the process by which people attribute to each other
racial affiliation based on our cultural ideas about links between race, nationality and ethnicity. A body
which is racized as non-white in a Swedish context undergoes a process of “marked racization” and
becomes foreign, while bodies that are read as white pass "unmarked" because they are understood as
How we are racialized affects how we are perceived and our ability to reproduce different lifelines or
institutional lines. In this article, institutional lines are primarily linked to the idea of
school success as a desirable lifeline and to the school as an institutional environment with the mission to
enable a reproduction of this lifeline for all students, through ideals as equality within
the school system. From a phenomenological perspective, the school's mission is to even out differences between
different children's conditions are thus understood as a way to straighten out and straighten out the discomfort, and that
With this phenomenological approach, the article contributes to further problematizing the school as
a place that works for equality and equality for all children, where differences are smoothed out and everyone gets
opportunity for, among other things, social mobility, and in addition problematize the linear and forward-looking,
above all by highlighting young people's experiences of not being allowed to be part of the linear and on which
The material analyzed here is part of a larger project on identity creation in separatist
online forums. In addition to a phenomenological approach, I therefore also start from a netnographic approach in
the study. Netnography (Kozinets, 2015) means that researchers adapt their ethnographic
starting points for the specific environment that, for example, online forums constitute, and differ from
traditional ethnographic fieldwork, among other things in terms of access to the material, ethical
the dilemmas that may arise and not least the role of the researcher in the creation of the material. In this
82
Machine Translated by Google
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
section, I will partly present what the material consists of, its scope and when it was collected
in, partly some of the ethical issues that arose during the work.
The material for the study comes from two different online forums, hereinafter referred to as forums A and
forum B in the material discussion, which is described by the moderators as being created by and for
people who are racist and have separatist guidelines, ie. that only persons who are racist may
actively participate in the forum. How to decide who is racialized and who is not, and therefore
not allowed to participate in the forum, is an ongoing discussion between the participants. At the same time means
this is not that the forums are closed. On the one hand, they are so open and accessible that anyone can
read the material, and others other than those who belong to the target group are encouraged to read and absorb what
written, through, among other things, direct addresses in posts written by moderators and "thread starters". However
comments are deleted that indicate that the person who wrote them is not part of the target group, continuously by
forum moderators1. Since the moderators partly approve the so-called "thread starters", a
process that I have not had insight into, partly have the opportunity to delete comments as they mean
contravenes the forum's guidelines, this affects who has the opportunity to post and who
posts that were left at the time of collection. This also means that it is only certain stories
which is shared with forums, while other experiences are made invisible.
Prior to the material collection, the moderators of the forums were contacted with information about the project
purpose and issues as well as ethical approaches. The moderators were also urged, if necessary
time and energy on their part, ask questions about the project. In accordance with an approved test at
The Regional Ethics Review Board in Stockholm, and a number of similar studies, have informed
consent from individual participants was not collected. This is partly because there are a lot of participants
anonymous and that others use aliases, where in many cases it would mean so extensive
intrusion on their privacy to try to identify them that this option was also considered
as unethical. When it was judged to be ethically problematic to seek consent from the moderators å
on behalf of others, this was not something that was requested either, but in contact with the moderators
they were offered the opportunity to decline participation for the entire forum. All material was anonymized in
connection with the collection, and which quote comes from which forum is not identified in the article
1 Karin Hagren Idevall (2015) shows in her study of a separatist Instagram account the linguistic strategies used
to justify commenting even though you are aware that you are not part of the target group, and how this is treated.
83
Machine Translated by Google
EDUCARE
time period but which was considered particularly sensitive in terms of participants' anonymity, such as
participants who write about living with a protected identity were not collected.
The material is mainly written by young people in their late teens, where the majority went to high school
or had recently taken the student when the material was written. The material included in the article was published
at both forums during the period January to June 2017 and were collected during the subsequent ones
months. In total, the material consists of 507 posts written by 44 young people or "thread starters", ie.
those who started discussions with a post and thus started a forum thread. The focus is on 22
thread starters on each forum, however, the number of posts is somewhat uneven due to the different thread starters
degree of activity (268 posts from forum A versus 239 posts from forum B).
After the material was collected, a first manual coding of the material was done, where the posts
were sorted into one or more broad categories based on content, such as "school", "racism" and
"Activism". Based on this initial categorization, close readings of all themes were conducted, there
coding was slightly adjusted, and recurring patterns were mapped. Then 42 of these 507 posts
focusing on experiences of the school, written by 18 thread starters, the school as a general theme became clear
already early in the analysis process. In the majority of cases where thread starters have written about the school so have
they wrote between 2 and 4 posts, a total of 13 out of 18. This high prevalence of posts on the specific
the topic led to a growing interest in what and who was mentioned when the young people discussed
school. In reading these posts, there was a greater focus on meetings with teachers in the school,
rather than with other students, partly that meetings with teachers or other students were described in a noticeable way
different ways. While other students' practice of racism in school was largely described as
values you brought with you from home, rather than values you carried yourself, were presented by teachers
racism as more telling to them as individuals. Based on these early patterns where the school and teachers
highlighted as problematic, the research questions formulated for this article, in order to be able to
Then almost half of all thread starters start discussions about their experiences in school, with one
high response in the form of comment, this means that school is a topic that is discussed often and by
many participants in the forums. This may partly be due to the age of the participants, as the school is a large one
part of their everyday life, but may also be due to the fact that the school is a place where their presence is partly made up of
coercion due to compulsory schooling and therefore means that they are in a potentially vulnerable and vulnerable
position. The target group for the forums thus means that a great focus on the school is relatively given, without
84
Machine Translated by Google
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
In the capacity of being the material from separatist online forums, where conversations take place between peers
without the direct participation of a researcher, the material becomes a complementary source to the school ethnographies
and interview studies done on racism in school and everyday racism. However, the material is not
without restrictions. The forum's focus on racism and racism undoubtedly shapes experiences
who are highlighted and who feel that they have stories to share, and the forums' linguistic and
discursive norms further contribute to regulating who participates, what experiences are considered
legitimate and how these experiences are described. The material can thus contribute to further perspectives on
racialization processes in school environments, through stories from young people who themselves identify it as
they have experienced as racism, while the range of experiences is limited by the forums
The article uses the term racization as this term is the one most commonly used in the material
and which reappears as a framing concept for those who actively participate in the forums. The choice to
use the same concept as the participants are twofold, and partly based on an ethical approach
to respect their self-identification and their own collective categorization. In addition to this ethical
choice, the concept of racism, and theories concerning it, are used to understand the worldview projected by the participants
forum with alias, so many thread starters present themselves with their nickname. At the same time, others choose
thread starters to remain completely anonymous, and participate without aliases or any name. They quoted
Young people's online activities have been the subject of moral panic, especially in the mass media
also in research, not least current issues of integrity and security, but also young people
political engagement (Greyson et.al. 2014). Online forums for political discussions can both be seen as
an opportunity for young people to become politically aware and engaged (Kamau 2016; Steele 2018) or
as an obstacle to young people engaging in formal, political processes (Stanley & Weare 2004;
Fuchs 2013). In this article, the virtual space is highlighted mainly based on how its function works
young people in their everyday lives are formulated on the forums, and how this function is put in relation to theirs
experiences of the school, without speculating on the question of whether these forums have consequences for
85
Machine Translated by Google
EDUCARE
This article presents a number of experiences of racism in Swedish schools, divided into three
teman. The first, to embody diversity, discusses how a view of diversity can be positive
promote alienation and help students feel vulnerable in their schools. The second, broken
lines and forward movements, make visible how students feel that they are limited in their possibilities
to reproduce the institutional lines that the school advocates, in the form of school success. The third
and the last theme, the spatial dimensions of colonialism, analyzes how the school as an insecure space can
Sam: I went to a school in the inner city where a lot of the students came from the upper class. A very
white school where the exceptions were adopted like me (but still: brown bodies but white in mind). When
I started the second ring, a teacher proudly told me at the gathering in the dining room that OH SO FUN,
now immigrants have started at the school! Fun that we get to have them !!! 1! 1 !! It was so uncomfortable,
the way he said it. That they were not their own people but an exotic "color click" we could watch, like
In the story above, Sam describes his experience of how teachers talk about different groups of students in the school
a way that is perceived as unpleasant. In the example, Sam experiences that the teacher expresses that it is
a positive change that it has started immigrant students at school. This positive view of
"Immigrant students" express a positive attitude towards diversity and the teacher seems to consider that
this means something good for the school. For Sam, on the other hand, this statement is perceived as unpleasant, that
the new students are something to look at, "like animals at the zoo". As the teacher is portrayed in Sams
narrative, it becomes clear that the "immigrant students" are considered to be something other than the ordinary students,
not least because they are referred to precisely as "immigrants" who they "now" received at school, and who did not
considered to have been there before. Ahmed (2000) believes that the idea of the stranger is a prerequisite
to create relationships. The stranger occurs in a variety of discourses, where the stranger can
attributed to different character traits and charges, but where it, regardless of whether it is seen as something positive
or negative, is characterized by the fact that it is a stranger who differs from a normative idea of one
clearly "we". Difference is something that exists in other bodies, which becomes diversity (Ahmed 2009). IN
In the example above, the school constitutes a clear (white) "we", which according to Sam consists primarily of white,
upper-class students, from whom the "immigrant students" are perceived to differ. Even when they are produced as
86
Machine Translated by Google
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
something positive for the school, then the positive consists of them being something else, something new that the school is not
had before. Sam feels that the "immigrant students" are thus understood based on their difference from
other students, and therefore it is made clear how a happy diversity discourse presupposes that they are understood exactly as
strangers, in the same way as they would if their arrival had instead been understood as something
Sam further expresses that he experiences it as if the new students "were not their own people",
which is also reinforced by the teacher's comment that it is "fun that we can have them". "Immigrant students"
is therefore perceived as something positive in the capacity of being able to add something as people who differentiate
from the majority, but also by becoming an object or a symbol for the school to "have". The
The presence of new students can therefore be understood as a symbol of the school's general mission to be
inclusive and equal for all have succeeded. The presence of "immigrant students" can thus say
symbolize successful mobility within cities, where aspects such as free school choice are considered to be possible
diversity and mobility (Lundström 2007). The idea of diversity can be understood as “a politics of feeling
good ”, an orientation that makes us feel that we have succeeded in the diversity mission or
the task of creating an equal school, but which hides the inequalities that remain (Ahmed 2009,
p. 44).
Then the students are considered to contribute something both in the school environment in general, for the benefit of other students and for
teachers, and more specifically for the school's profile and as a symbol of successful mobility, this can be understood
as that the "immigrant students" get embodied diversity, ie. that their individual bodies receive
represent and be the diversity, which is separate from the (white) majority, and also gives the school
diversity. Individuals thus "are" diversity, rather than diversity being understood as something
which arises in relationships between different people and is thus found in the student group in general (Ahmed
2009). Their mere presence as strangers gives the school the opportunity to show that it is for equality
and anti-racism, and their presence is presented as something positive. At the same time, this is happy
diversity conditional, it requires that those who embody diversity also buy it and
confirms the school's success stories. Ahmed says that “through diversity, the organization is
represented 'happily' as 'getting along' […] your arrival is thus a happy occasion for the
organisation. But you have to smile […] if your arrival is a sign of diversity, then you are a success
In the experience that is retold, however, the uncomfortable fact that the new students are not allowed to be is made visible
his own characters and Sam also notices that he himself is different from it
87
Machine Translated by Google
EDUCARE
ordinary student group to some extent in the capacity of being adopted. In this way he himself takes one
position of alienation in order to distance oneself from the teacher's positions and instead criticize the alienation-
creating process to which the new students are exposed. The rendering of the event will be in
the context of the forums a story about how different student groups are distinguished from each other and how this
reproduces racist norms in school. At the same time, sharing the experience also gets one
Community-building function in the forums through the confirmation provided by other participants;
and the "we" that continues to be created based on the sharing of similar experiences and understanding
Among the young people's stories, there are also experiences of being made a stranger yourself
Izza: When we sat and discussed racism in English, my English teacher always checked
me, she wanted me to answer. Enough that it is difficult to talk about racism with white
people in Swedish, now I would take it in ENGLISH as well. My English teacher always diminished
my feelings.
According to Izza's story, it is a teacher who starts a conversation about racism, which could be understood
encourage students to discuss racism (Bromseth & Darj 2011). The teacher's attempt to get some students
participating in a discussion can further be understood as an attempt to let students take a seat and make theirs visible
experiences of racism, but according to Izza's reproduced experience of the situation, the lesson becomes instead
unpleasant and pointing. By making an individual student visible in a conversation about racism, with one
invitation to the student to participate and share, Izza feels that she is marked as different in
relation to the other students and is expected to express herself in a question based on who she is expected to
be. Like the previous example with the "immigrant students", Izza's experience can be understood
as that she is made a stranger, when she experiences that her body is separated from the others, is done
Sociologist Sarita Srivastava (2006) believes, in her study of anti-racist work in feminist
associations, that conversations about racism like these rather serve as a way for the whites in the context
to process their feelings than as a way to solve racism problems in the specific environment, in this
case school. People who are exposed to racism experience an expectation to share theirs
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
awareness-raising conversations for whites where they are given the opportunity to process their own possible feelings of guilt
around racism. Contributing with their thoughts and experiences does not satisfy the student who experiences
that it is exposed to racism (Srivastava 2006). Instead, Izza experiences that she gets her own feelings
diminished, while at the same time feeling that she is still expected to participate actively. By
participate in a conversation about racism where her own feelings are made central but at the same time ignored, can
Izza's story is understood as another way of expecting bodily diversity (Ahmed 2009).
Both testimonies above show the importance of alienation in young people's experiences and
retelling of school memories where teachers worked anti-racist, as some students feel that they are done
Students also experience that they are expected to contribute something other than other students because of theirs
alienation and they are distinguished from the others. The stories describe the experience that
The "immigrant students" and the student with experience of racism are expected to contribute something in particular
due to the positions in which they are placed by the teachers, as assumptions are made partly about theirs
migration experiences, partly about their experiences of racism. In both examples, the young people tell about
the experience of the students being divided into different groups, one we and they , where some students form one
invisible neutrum, like the white upper-class students who make up the regular student body at school,
while some student bodies are second-edged, even when they are also hailed in their deviation. This alienation
becomes a continued condition for a forward-looking movement on a more societal level, as their presence gets
represent a functioning, tolerant and inclusive school system, and it enables a continued
In the stories above, diversity is presented as something that is perceived as positive, including young people
experiences of racism or with an “immigrant background” are considered to contribute to the school environment and
learning through their mere presence. Although diversity is understood as positive, these experiences are described in
terms of discomfort, something that makes certain student bodies as deviant and distinct from those
"Ordinary" students. The forums also share experiences where teachers do not seem to share this picture
positive diversity as the teachers in the previous stories, but point out students in a way that is experienced
89
Machine Translated by Google
EDUCARE
Bilan: My schooling has been a pure roller coaster. I'm in my second year of high school now
but during certain periods I had constant problems with teachers or those with me rather.
My whole schooling during primary school has been about something having happened to someone
teacher. From a very early age, I have worked hard, been ambitious and tried to do my best in basically
everything. I know that many people probably recognize that racist young people in school are not
taken seriously and / or treated much more differently than white children in school (in many cases). If
you are blatte and take up space, you will be silenced really quickly, you have a great personality as
fills an entire room, you should calm down so as not to take up too much "space". The smallest thing
that makes you stand out from the crowd makes you the "messy" typical blatte student. Do not even @ 2
me on this because I know exactly what I'm talking about because I also have many other racists
myself have been through this. I myself have witnessed how non-racist children who are in any way
problematic are not taken seriously at all by teachers , get a kind frivolous reprimand when they do
something wrong. Anyway, it's not like the other way around, like for what? I talk about everything from
grades, school work and even the treatment of teachers, etc. where many injustices occur
completely unconscious to others. Many people may think that this is just imagination, but it is not
somewhere. Especially if you have had to go through it yourself during your early / late upbringing or
are simply observant and ask about experiences around the school from a POC
perspective. 13 year old I honestly thought I would never be portrayed in a negative stereotypical way
because that was not how I was at all? I'm a good student? But that was until my English teacher
Here Bilan talks about her experience of her attempt to be a good, ambitious student
repeatedly met with resistance from teachers. She believes that she is instead perceived as
someone who takes up a lot of space, and experiences that she is then "silenced" and reduced to a "messy
typical blatte student ”in the classroom. By highlighting that she "tried to do my best" and means
that many probably recognize themselves in her experience, Bilan shows that she, like it
dominant notion in school policy debate, sees school success as something desirable
and a key to a successful adulthood, but meetings with teachers are perceived as an obstacle to
realize this, rather than an opportunity for success. Ahmed's (2007) interpretation of Frantz Fanons
phenomenological exploration of blackness, which explains how different bodies stretch and take
2 By "do not even @ [at] me on this" Bilan means that there is no point in "tagging" her, ie insert Bilan's alias so that she
is notified of answers, and in the long run that there is no points for trying to start a critical discussion with her about topics
as she "knows exactly what [she] is talking about".
90
Machine Translated by Google
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
space in or fills space, shows how our ability to move is affected by the presence of other bodies. Fanon
describes how he becomes aware of his movements only when he gets a white man's gaze on him when he
should do something as mundane as smoke a cigarette, and describe this awareness as one
negative or negative activity that limits the body's ability to take place. Fanon becomes aware
about the movement required to reach the cigarettes, and how these are coded and racified with the white one
the man's gaze on himself. This means that the gaze interrupts or disturbs his ability to move, then his
movements are racist in this meeting and gain their significance (Ahmed 2007). From this perspective on
relational physicality, it is possible to read how Bilan feels that her way of taking a seat is racist,
and her movements are thus characterized by ideas about how different bodies take place. Balance sheet behavior in
the classroom, which she herself believes is part of being an ambitious student and doing her best,
she experiences being perceived by teachers as exaggerated and messy, and places her in the position of
messy "blatteelev". The idea of the messy student has traditionally been associated with boys, and which
group these boys are supposed to belong to (eg boys who have developed an anti-plug culture, boys
with neuropsychiatric diagnoses) has shifted over time, and in recent years, confusion has become increasingly prevalent
to be associated with “suburban boys” and “immigrant boys” (Jonsson 2015). The messy boy who
story exists in opposition to the ideal student, and embodies all the behavior that
considered wrong in school. In addition to ideas about how the ideal student should behave, the perceived one is strengthened
the messiness in Bilan's story that she also violates ideals around femininity, then messiness
coded as something (some) boys engage in, and especially a crime a school-sanctioned femininity
(Lundström 2010; Sohl 2014). The school-sanctioned femininity is strongly associated with this
a white middle-class ideal where girls balance between being good, active students in the classroom
and at the same time meet the requirements of silence, kindness and self-discipline. Bodies that are not racialized
whites are attributed in contrast to whites an aggression and intimidation, something that is also coded as one
masculine behavior, an idea that can contribute to Bilan experiencing her way of taking a seat in
the classroom becomes a particularly visible transgressor and is perceived as messy rather than good
Based on Ahmed's theory of orientation, Bilan's idea of a school success as something is also made visible
which leads her forward, along with a desirable lifeline, where she is focused on embodying
a caring school ideal. The car experiences itself fulfilling this endeavor, by doing its best and
perform at school, but experiences that she in the meeting with teachers is interrupted or disturbed in her movements
and in their attempts to reproduce a normatively desirable line of life or institutional line.
91
Machine Translated by Google
EDUCARE
Ahmed (2007) believes that institutions take shape according to what fits within them, and believes that many
institutions can therefore be understood as white, shaped by the bodies that are usually accommodated and gathered
within them. In the material, it is mainly the young people themselves who call their schools white, however
even in cases where it is not done, the school can still be understood as a white institution then the Swedish
the education system was designed based on the idea of a monocultural society where whiteness constituted one
prevailing norm (Tesfahuney 1999; Lundström 2010; Martinsson 2014). About the Swedish school
understood as a white institution, it means that the school room that students move in is also oriented around
whiteness, which therefore becomes invisible to whites. To then move, like a person being racized, in these whites
Ahmed therefore describes rooms as moving through "a sea of whiteness". The movement is characterized by it
self-awareness that Fanon (1967) experiences in Black skins, white masks, and bodies that are racist
as non-whites therefore do not have the same ability to extend into space as white bodies have,
the movement is slower at the same time as it involves a disorientation of the room itself (Fanon 1967;
I move slowly in the world, accustomed now to seek no longer for upheaval. I progress by
crawling. And already I am being dissected under white eyes, the only real eyes. I am fixed.
Having adjusted their microtomes, they objectively cut away slices of my reality. I am laid bare.
[…] I slip into corners, I strive for anonymity, for invisibility. Look, I will accept the lot, as
long as no one notices me! (Fanon 1967, p. 116)
The car therefore experiences that she is perceived as taking up more space in the room than other students, and
this occupancy of the room is also perceived as somewhat disturbing and uncomfortable, at the same time as she
herself feels that her ability to move is limited. Just like in the previous examples of diversity
as something positive, bodies stand out in rooms where they are seen as "out of place", which is also further
reproduces the whiteness of space (Ahmed 2000; 2007). Ahmed (2007) believes that one's ability to follow
institutional lines are affected by other lines that one also follows. The young people experience that just
racialization as non-white implies a fixation of how they are expected to behave and what lifelines they can
follow, and by extension therefore also implies a perceived inability to follow an institutional line,
although other aspects such as class also come into play (cf. Sohl 2014). To be able to make school success
and following institutional lines also means an opportunity to be able to take the position as a manager
ideal student, an invisible but desirable position. Fanon (1967) makes visible the experience of adapting his
movements and make them less visible, by “slip into corners, strive for anonymity” (p. 116),
92
Machine Translated by Google
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
and Bilan experiences that her movements are perceived by teachers as larger and more disturbing than others
pupils. Through the experience of being understood as "messy", Bilan experiences that she thus
denied the position as an ideal student and the possibility of being perceived as neutral, invisible in the crowd
and successful. The equality and opportunity that the school is expected to constitute, and which is perceived to be
successful by the teachers in the first examples, is therefore perceived to be limited to certain student bodies.
For other young people, this fixation as a "messy immigrant child" becomes a stamp as well
points to other shortcomings in school, for example when it naturalizes the concentration difficulties that
Alex has:
Alex: My schooling was not easy. Being someone with a bit of "interesting" descent, letters to use in jokes,
concentration difficulties so I never received the support that a Swedish child received. Due
my last name, I was seen as a standard messy immigrant child who had no chance of becoming as good
or smart as the Swedish children. Teachers have been calling me stupid. Idiot.
Also in this story, the narrator, Alex, remembers experiences of a distinction from Swedish children,
which Alex thinks would have gotten help with his concentration difficulties and behavior if it were
those in question. Here, Swedish children's difficulty concentrating can be understood as a minor
interruptions in the reproduction of the institutional line, through which it is possible to rectify - through
special support - to orient them in the right direction, so that they too can reproduce a forward direction
movement. But for "immigrant children", as Alex himself calls it, this is not experienced as much as
an interruption in their attempt to reproduce an institutional line, but rather means the possibility
that they could do so is not even intended. The lifelines that so-called "immigrant children"
are expected to follow are instead perceived to be completely different, and institutional lines such as school success are something
which Alex experiences being orientated away from when they are fixed as just "immigrants" and strangers.
Alex experiences that her body is perceived as so foreign in the room that she never got it
"The support that a Swedish child received", and that he thus feels that the same attempt is not made
on the part of teachers to try to straighten him in the same line as the others, but he continues to be “out
of place ”and disoriented (Ahmed 2006). Here also comes the idea of a stranger discourse,
where Alex experiences that her body exists as a constitutive opposite to the Swedes
the children, her body is expected to take up too much space and be uncomfortable and disruptive, which in turn
93
Machine Translated by Google
EDUCARE
also constructs the Swedish children as comfortable and caring. Alex believes that her behavior
not understood as difficulty concentrating, but instead on the basis of ideas about her cultural background,
and through this her behavior is naturalized as normal (for him) but disturbing.
The naturalization of some students' behavior as something culturally bound can be understood as part of
the cultural racism that Modood (2015) describes. Alex thus feels fixed in a way that
makes it impossible to correct and correct him in the same institutional lines as he experiences
that her classmates may follow. The experience that Alex shares would, like Sams, too
"Interesting" descent, "difficult" surname and to be perceived as "standard messy immigrant child"
who have been subjected to negative discrimination in relation to the children Alex identifies as Swedish,
experiences that readers are expected to understand and identify with. The experiences that are shared and
confirmed on the forums thus contributes to internal demarcations regarding which stories are seen
In both stories above, these experiences are highlighted as typical, something that everyone who is racist
can recognize themselves in. Ahmed (2007) believes that the existence of non-whites is characterized by this very negation,
that they are not white, their bodily creation is marked by what they can not do, by one
movement restriction while whiteness is instead characterized by opportunities. In a Fanonian sense, success is
and forward movement therefore a matter of bodily privileges, an ability to move through
the world without being disoriented, fixed or having their movements interrupted. Some bodies are stuffed in theirs
movements by making them visible in themselves, and being racized as non-white or as “immigrants
student ”, regardless of whether this is done on the basis of a successful diversity discourse or on the basis of the experience of them
as messy and disturbing, means that, as young people recount their experiences,
In the stories above, young people testify about the racism, abuse and discrimination they have faced
in school, from other students as well as teachers. In the forums, however, it is not only these negatives
Idil: How do I survive high school these days? First of all, I choose my battles.
Sure, it's fat hard to hear problematic things that people just throw out, but I have
94
Machine Translated by Google
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
taught me not to spend so much time on it because I do not feel bad about it later.
Has also begun to terminate contact with people who do not understand the oppression I or
others go through. It saves soooo much time, energy, anger & frustration. Gets exhausted by the thought
of having to hang out with people who do not understand me or my anger. […] Think
It's fat important to surround yourself with people who understand you no matter what, especially when
you do not even have to say anything. We can look at each other and understand exactly what we mean
or feel.
Once, every two weeks, I also go to [a separatist group's] meetings, to rant and
hear other people's experiences. Fat nice to organize and discuss with people who understand you. You
are told that other high school students have gone through the same things that you & know exactly
then that one is not alone in the struggle. Last but not least, it's okay not to want to get involved with people
you do not like or who you think do not understand you. Personally, I think it's easiest
to hang out with people I know back me up. You CAN finish high school if you are yourself and
goes with problematic people. It's about having to believe in yourself and stand up for yourself
what's right. Everyone needs pepper every now and then but do not think you are alone !! You are strong.
The story describes a number of strategies for coping with everyday life at school. Idil tells how she
has learned to choose her battles, but also that she can terminate contact with people who
she experienced not sharing her opinions or experiences. To interact with other people in the school
she says it involves a balance between confrontation and distancing. Here constitute
The "joy killer" (Ahmed 2009) a possible position for Idil, both by confronting and so on
wise "kill the joy" in, for example, a classroom, but also by terminating the contact and
This social exclusion can also give rise to one's own isolation, depending on the environment one
is in. The possibility of excluding people with whom you do not agree presupposes
a strong social network in general, and Idil turns to the reader at the end of his story to
remind him that he is not alone. "You CAN finish high school if you are yourself […] everyone needs pepper every
now and then but do not think you are alone !!" Although the school can be experienced as one
socially disadvantaged environment, the reader is reminded that the separatist space exists as support, both in its
physical as well as virtual form. The virtual space where these experiences are shared is experienced here as one
opportunity for those who do not have like-minded people in their physical environment that Idil has.
95
Machine Translated by Google
EDUCARE
In the forums, the sharing of these experiences has multiple functions. On the one hand, the stories form one
opportunity to make visible and process experiences of racism, and they get a community building
function for the participants in the forums. The alternation between Idil's own strategies, and a described "I",
and the personal appeal of an imagined "you", the reader, further contributes to creating a community on the
forums for those who recognize themselves in what Idil and the others are telling. Although
others can read what is written, so the forum's guidelines regulate who is allowed to participate actively, and create
therefore a security regarding which voices can and may be heard. Separatist rooms of various kinds
is described in Idil's report as a direct opposite to the school, as spaces where you can share
experiences of like-minded people, where you can discuss without feeling questioned. Idils
description of separatist rooms, however, also shows a view of who is expected to participate and be
themselves in these rooms, namely those who "understand" and "have gone through the same things". These
formulations both open up for the reader to contribute their own stories of racism in school
and limits which voices are expected to be heard in the forums. By further writing that “everyone
need pepper every now and then but do not think you are alone !! ” Idil shows that this is also a function
as separatist spaces and forums can fill, and again demonstrates the positive, community-building
Based on the young people's experiences of being made a stranger and exposed to racism in school can
the school is also understood as a colonial space, a mirror of the surrounding society and its
values, where bodies that are racized as non-whites are also fixed, limited, and where ideas about
race, racism and racism are constantly reproduced (Kipfer 2007). The separatist room is experienced
thus as a respite from school, something that is safe and permissive in contrast to the school environment. IN
these rooms, it is then possible to move and extend in a different way, the rooms and the conversations
are for and shaped by the young people, rather than the white rooms where they are constantly characterized by
his lack of whiteness (Fanon 1967; Srivastava 2006; Ahmed 2007). Idil's story also shows that
her use of the virtual space does not limit her involvement in association life
beyond the internet, when the separatist group Idil visits every other week also engages in opinion-forming activities
the youth on the forums do not constitute the use of the forums as an obstacle to other political
commitment, but rather a tool for mobilizing young people who experience oppression in their everyday lives.
96
Machine Translated by Google
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
Reducing human beings to their physical appearance - and the historical weight of past racism tied up in
objectification makes it impossible to escape bodily confinement and denies the possibility of freedom.
In the article, several experiences of racism in school have been highlighted and analyzed with the help of one
phenomenological approach. Here, the idea of teachers as anti-racist knowledge bearers and
knowledge communicators, and thereby the idea that the school is an equal environment where everyone has the same
opportunities to "succeed". Instead, students' experiences of different forms of racism from are made visible
especially teachers, both in situations where diversity is understood as something positive, racism is discussed
generally and where the student himself experiences that they are pointed out as a problem in the classroom.
knowledge mediators should be problematized, as these can also carry prejudices that do not have
"Cured" neither during their own schooling nor during the teacher training that is expected to prepare
them to teach children about tolerance and anti-racism. The stories shared on the forums about racism in
the school is predominantly about teachers who are perceived as racist and shows how this racism continues
perceived as an obstacle for the young people in their schooling. At the same time, the stories are shared
on the forums limited in their selection: as I mentioned earlier in the presentation of material entails
the forum's focus on racism that it is mainly negative experiences that are highlighted. Teachers are attributed in
the stories a position that mainly adult Swedes, while the teachers who themselves share
young people's experiences or create a positive school environment are rarely made visible. In the youth
stories, teachers are perceived to limit students' mobility, which in turn can be interpreted as a break in
their attempts to reproduce desirable lifelines and make them visible as deviant strangers.
The school is instead perceived as a place without spaciousness, where bodies are regulated and limited in different ways
way, the school becomes "a world without spaciousness" (Fanon 1963, p. 39). In addition, it can be high
the presence of teachers as racists in young people's stories show the discrepancy between how one
teachers are expected to behave and how it is then in reality. Teachers who are perceived as racist
thus constitutes a betrayal of the adult world regarding the security and opportunity provided by the school
is expected to consist of and means that the students feel that they themselves must find strategies outside
The function of the separatist rooms appears most explicitly in the last story from Idil, there
separatism is identified as a concrete strategy for dealing with everyday school life. Separatist rooms
97
Machine Translated by Google
EDUCARE
is described here as something other than school, characterized by understanding, recognition and equality. except that
separatist rooms are perceived to be able to constitute a breathing space where young people can share theirs
experiences, the rooms also offer a possible educational arena outside the school, where young people own
experiences of racism are at the heart of knowledge production in a way that does not construct them
as strangers in their own world. In both Idil's and the others' stories, the sharing fills
experiences a community-building function outside the school, where you can talk to like-minded people
which one experiences understands and encourages one. The separatist guidelines that govern who
actively participating, but allowing everyone to read, also contributes to a perceived shift in which voices
who have the opportunity to speak and how, as well as what perspectives are presented, compared to
the young people's recounted experiences of their everyday school life. The separatist guidelines contribute to
a perceived security in the questioning of racist norms in school, at the same time as the forums
Relative openness to other readers also means that these voices are given a greater reach than in a closed one
group. With this article, I have wanted to show how young people continue to experience school as one
environment where they are made into strangers based on ideas of racism and alienation, in line with the past
research (Lundström 2007; León Rosales 2010; Jonsson 2015) and show that function
separatist spaces outside the school can fill for both the formation of knowledge about racism and racism
as for community building for the young people who apply to the forums.
References
3: 2.
University Press.
Ahmed, S. (2009) Embodying diversity: problems and paradoxes for Black feminists, Race Ethnicity
Arneback, E. & Jämte, J. (2017) Countering racism in preschool and school. Stockholm: Nature & Culture.
Balibar, E. (2008). "Racism revisited: sources, relevance and aporias of a modern concept." Modern
98
Machine Translated by Google
Fanny Pérez-Aronsson
Blaut, JM (1992). "The theory of cultural racism." Antipode: A Radical Journal of Geography, 23, 289-
299.
Bonilla-Silva, E. (2003) Racism without Racists: Color-Blind Racism and the Persistence of Racial Inequality
Bremer, S. (2011). Body lines. Gender, transsexualism and the body in stories about gender correction. Halmstad:
Bromseth, J. & Darj, F. (2010) Norm-critical pedagogy: power, learning and strategies for change. Uppsala:
Fanon, F. (1963) Wretched of the Earth. (C Farrington, trans.) New York: Grove Press.
Fanon, F. (1967) Black skin, white masks. (CL Markmann, trans.). New York: Grove Press.
Fuchs, C. (2013). "Social media and capitalism." Olsson, Tobias (Ed.) Producing the internet. Critical
Greyson, D., Agosto, D., Meyers, E., Subramaniam, M. & Abbas, J. (2014) “Understanding
Conference presentation at ASIST 2014, November 1-4. Seattle: Association for Information
Hübinette, T., Lundström, C. (2011) 'Sweden after the Recent Election: The Double-Binding
Power of Swedish Whiteness through the Mourning of the Loss of “Old Sweden” and the
Passing of “Good Sweden” ', NORA - Nordic Journal of Feminist and Gender Research, 19: 1, 42-52.
Jonsson, R. (2015) Worst in class. Stories about messy boys in the inner city and suburbs. Stockholm:
Ordfront.
Source, LF (2009). A being of two leaves - on the founding signficance of the lived body. I Janne
Bromseth, Lisa Folkmarson Käll & Katarin Mattsson (Eds.), Body claims (pp. 110-133). Uppsala:
Kamau, SC (2016) “Engaged online: social media and youth civic engagement in Kenya.”
Mutsvairo, Bruce (Ed.) Digital activism in the social media era. Critical reflections on emerging trends in
Kipfer, S. (2007) Fanon and space: colonization, urbanization and liberation from the colonial to
the global city. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 25: 4, 701-726.
León Rosales, R. (2010) At the hottest frontier of the future: on masculine student positions in a multiethnic school.
99
Machine Translated by Google
EDUCARE
Lindqvist, J. & Thorslund,. (2008) Young people's privacy online. A guide for parents, educators and others
Lundberg, E. (Eds.) (2017). Tolerance mechanisms - an anthology. Stockholm: Forum for living
history.
Lundström, C. (2007) Swedish latinas: race, class and gender in the geography of Swedishness. Gothenburg: Macadam.
Lundström, C. (2010). ”'Concrete bodies': young latina women transgressing the boundaries of
race and class in white inner-city Stockholm. ” Gender, Place and Culture, 17 (2), 151-167.
Martinsson, L. (2014) "Values - standardized for liberation." Martinsson, Lena & Reimers, E.
Mattsson, K. (2001) (O) geographies of similarity: the market, research and the Others. Uppsala: Uppsala
University.
Sohl, L. (2014). Knowing their class: women's rising class trips in Sweden. Doctoral dissertation.
Srivastava, S. (2006) “Tears, Fears and Careers: Anti-Racism and Emotion in Social Movement
Organizations. ” The Canadian Journal of Sociology / Cahiers canadiens de sociologie, 31 (1), 55-90.
Stanley, JW & Weare, C. (2004) “The Effects of Internet Use on Political Participation: Evidence
from an Agency Online Discussion Forum ”. Administration & Society, 36 (5), 503-527.
Steele, CK (2018) “Black bloggers and their varied publics: the everyday politics of black discourse
Svensson, T. (2017) “White men on the border: on vitified underclass masculinity in Dan Andersson
Chi-mo-ka-ma. ” Hübinette, T. (Ed.) Race and whiteness: Swedish race relations yesterday and today. Grove:
Student literature.
100