Case Analysis. (15 Points: 3 Items X 5 Points)
Case Analysis. (15 Points: 3 Items X 5 Points)
Case Analysis. (15 Points: 3 Items X 5 Points)
J borrowed P75,000.00 from A by using the latter’s credit card (to be paid on installment basis) to pay
for the former’s emergency hospitalization. J promised that he will pay the monthly charge every month
every time the bill arrives. Not long after, J severally used A’s credit card details without him knowing to
shop online in various occasions. J accumulated a debt of P100,000.00 in total. However, he did not pay
a single monthly amortization. When A knew, he confronted J of his incapability to pay his obligations. J
went into hiding and eventually flew to Germany. J’s debt accrued interest amounting to P50,000.00
making his total debt amount to P150,000.
The thing that J has to give to A is generic or indeterminate in character. It means that J can't be
determined specifically from things of the same class, which means that a thing can't be determined
explicitly from things of the same class .A can replace or give anything as long as it is of equal or greater
value than his debt. If J failed to perform his obligations on time, and he didn't comply with such a
requirement.
J is compelled to pay P150,000,00.00 to A because that is the total amount owed. The amount that J
received from A's credit card, including interest.
Because on what J did to A, he is liable for fraud because he left the money on the table country and flee
to Germany to hide in order to flee or evade the authorities. His obligation was fulfilled.