Psychodynamic
Psychodynamic
Psychodynamic
MODULE –I
Dialectical Behaviour Therapy was developed by Dr. Marsha Linehan, a Professor of Psychology and adjunct
Professor of Psychiatry and Behavioural Sciences at the University of Washington.
Dr. Linehan approaches her scientific research and development from a perspective that is relatively uncommon in the
sciences: one based in spirituality. She has trained with a number of spiritual leaders and influential thinkers,
including a Zen master.
Stages of DBT
Pre-treatment Stage-Orientation & Commitment
Individual Therapy
Group Therapy
Telephonic Crisis Intervention
Therapists’ Consultation Groups
Individual Therapy
Special attention is provided to self-destructive or potentially self-harmful behaviours.
These behaviours are targeted not only because they are inherently worrisome, but also because they can seriously
disrupt the treatment process and undermine treatment goals.
So the idea is to keep the client alive and safe.
To reduce the behaviours that interfere with the therapy
To improve the quality of life of the client
Behaviors interfere with the therapy Improve the Moment “IMPROVE” Skills
1. Reporting late for the session Imagery;
2. Cancelling the sessions Meaning;
3. Not being prepared for the session Prayer;
4. Avoiding discussing difficult topics Relaxation;
5. Taking phone calls during the session One thing at a time;
6. Therapist pushing the client Vacation;
7. Therapist invalidating the client Encouragement.
Behaviors that interfere with quality of life Emotion-regulation
1. Substance Abuse Identifying and labelling emotions;
2. Financial Difficulties Identifying obstacles to changing emotions;
3.Lack of Social Support Reducing vulnerability to “emotion mind;”
4. Inappropriate housing Increasing positive emotional events;
Treatment targets from highest to Increasing mindfulness to current emotions;
lowest Priority Taking the opposite action;
1. Suicidal Behaviors & Self-harm Behaviors Applying distress tolerance techniques
2. Behaviors that interfere with the therapy Interpersonal Effective Skills
3. Life –crisis situation Objectiveness Effectiveness “DEAR MAN” Skills
4. Maintaining treatment gains Describe;
5. Other goals that the client identifies Express;
Skill training in the groups Assert;
Distress- tolerance Reinforce;
Emotion Regulation Mindful;
Interpersonal effectiveness Appear confident;
Mindfulness Negotiate.
Distress Tolerance Skills Relationship Effectiveness “GIVE” Skills
Crisis Survival “ACCEPTS” Skills Gentle;
Activities Interested;
Contributing Validate;
Comparisons Easy manner.---relaxed and comfortable.
Emotions Self-Respect Effectiveness “FAST” Skills
Pushing away Fair;
Thoughts Apologies / no apologies;
Sensations Stick to value;
Self-Soothing Skills Truthful.
See Why Mindfulness
Hear Taking Control of your Mind
Smell Improving emotion regulation
Taste Increasing behavior control
Touch Improving concentration and Memory
Engaged in Life
A pattern of Behavioral , emotional and Cognitive instability & dysregulation
Emotional dysregulation gets the reflection in .
a. . Highly reactive emotional responses
b. Relationships are chaotic, intense and marked with difficulties
Behavioral dysregulation
a. extreme and impulsive behaviors
b. Attempts to injure, mutilate or kill themselves
c. Substance abuse
d. Promiscuity
Cognitive dysregulation-
Brief nonpsychotic forms of thought dysregulation-depersonalization, de-realization and delusions
Cognitive rigidity
Poor problem-solving
Sense of self Dysregulation-
Having no sense of Self
Feeling empty
Doesn’t know who he or she is
Patterns in BPD
Emotional Vulnerability-
High sensitivity
High Intensity
Slow return to emotional baseline
Self-invalidation-
Fail to recognize their own emotional responses, thoughts , beliefs and behaviors
Unrealistically high standards and expectations of Self
Intense shame, self-hate and Self-directed anger.
Unrelenting Crises-
Pattern of frequent stressful, negative environmental events (dysfunctional life style as well as inadequate
environment ).
Inhibited Grieving-
Tendency to inhibit negative emotions especially associated with grief and loss
To overcontrol negative emotional responses especially anger (either overexpression or under-expression of anger
Active Passivity –
passive interpersonal problem-solving style
active attempts to solicit problem-solving from others
learned helplessness
Hopelessness
Apparent Competence-
tendency to appear deceptively more competent than they actually are .
Suicidal Attempts –A cry for Help
Suicidal attempts are not manipulative actions but cry for help, reflection of frantic suicidal ideation and ambivalence
over whether to continue with life or not.
Desire to be helped or rescued
Manipulation-a major source of invalidation
Time care and attention
Biosocial Theory
Dysfunctional environment +Biological irregularities
Biological irregularities- Genetic influences (serotonin transporter gene 5-HTT) to disadvantageous intrauterine
events and early childhood environment
Invalidating environments –fail to teach
How to label and regulate emotions
How to tolerate distress
How to trust their own emotional responses as valid interpretation of the events
Interpersonal Therapy
A variant of Cognitive Behaviour Therapy
Given by Gerald Klerman and Myrna Weissman
Successful results for the people suffering from depression or dealing with relationship issues
Techniques of the therapy
Identification of the emotion
Expression of Emotion
Dealing with emotional Baggage
Interpersonal Problem Areas
In IPT, the therapist selects one of four interpersonal problem areas as the focus for treatment. The four IPT problem
areas are:
Grief or Complicated Bereavement
Role Dispute
Role Transition
Interpersonal Deficits
Grief is chosen as a problem area when the onset or maintenance of the depressive episode is associated with the
death of a person close to the patient.
Role Dispute is chosen as a problem area when the onset or maintenance of the depressive episode is associated with
an unsatisfying interpersonal relationship characterized by non-reciprocal role expectations between the two parties.
Role Transition is chosen as a problem area when the onset or maintenance of the depressive episode is associated
with difficulty coping with changes in current life circumstances. Role transitions may occur in many domains
including employment, relationship status, physical health, living conditions, socioeconomic status, etc. The transition
is conceptualized as moving from one social role to another social role (i.e., from a student to an employee, from
military to civilian status, from single to married, etc).
Interpersonal Deficits is chosen as a problem area when there is no clear acute interpersonal event associated with
the onset or maintenance of the depressive episode and the individual describes a long standing history of
impoverished or contentious interpersonal relationships. Although many patients seeking IPT treatment have deficits
in interpersonal functioning, the interpersonal deficits category is reserved for cases where no other treatment focus is
apparent. Not surprisingly, patients with chronic impairment in social functioning who lack the life events on which
IPT focuses fare worse in IPT.
Phases/ Steps of the therapy
Assessment
Initial Session
Middle Session
Terminal Session
Maintenance Session
Structure and Duration of Sessions
12 to 16 one hour sessions that usually occur weekly.
The initial sessions are devoted to information gathering and clarifying the nature of the patient's illness and
interpersonal experience.
The patient's illness is then formulated and explained in interpersonal terms and the nature and structure of the IPT
sessions are explained.
This phase of treatment concludes with the composition of the "interpersonal inventory" which is essentially a register
of all the key relationships in the individual's life.
Sessions 3 - 14 are devoted to addressing the problematic relationship areas and there is little focus upon the specific
illness process apart from enquiries as to symptom severity and response to treatment modalities.
The final sessions 15 - 16 focus upon termination, which is usually formulated as a loss experience.
Techniques
Clarification.
Communication analysis
Interpersonal incidents
Use of affect
Role playing
Problem solving
Homework
Use of therapeutic relationship
Communication analysis.
Help patient – identify their communication pattern – see the contribution they make to difficulties in communication.
Motivate patient to communicate more effectively
BPD
A pattern of Behavioral , emotional and Cognitive instability & dysregulation
Emotional dysregulation gets the reflection in .
a. . Highly reactive emotional responses
b. Relationships are chaotic, intense and marked with difficulties
Behavioral dysregulation
a. extreme and impulsive behaviors
b. Attempts to injure, mutilate or kill themselves
c. Substance abuse
d. Promiscuity
Cognitive dysregulation-
Brief nonpsychotic forms of thought dysregulation-depersonalization, de-realization and delusions
Cognitive rigidity
Poor problem-solving
Sense of self Dysregulation-
Having no sense of Self
Feeling empty
Doesn’t know who he or she is
IPT for Borderline Personality Disorder
Emotional dysregulation – Interpersonal Incidents, Use of affect, Role plays, Communication analysis
Cognitive dysregulation –Problem-solving, clarification, communication analysis,
Behavioral dysregulation- Use of affect, Problem-solving and Role plays
Self dysregulation – Use of affect, Use of therapeutic relationship
IPT for Trauma
Lack of sense of Safety- interpersonal Incidents, Use of affect, Clarification
Lack of Faith in people- interpersonal Incidents, Use of affect, Clarification
Lack of Trust - interpersonal Incidents, Use of affect, Clarification
Emotional dysregulation- Interpersonal Incidents, Use of affect, Role plays, Communication analysis
Cognitive distortions related to the theme of the event- –Problem-solving, clarification, communication analysis,
Clarification
IPT for Anxiety Disorder
Fear of Judgement/ Evaluation
Fear of Unknown/ Uncertainty
Emotionally Overwhelming
Cognitive distortions
Escapism/avoidance-problem-solving, use of affect, communication analysis
Unhealthy Communication –communication analysis, clarification and role plays
IPT for Depression
Cognitive dysregulation - All or nothing Thinking, Maximizing –minimizing, Personalization, Jumping to conclusion,
Overgeneralization –problem solving, clarification and communication analysis, cognitive-error identification,
Homework.
Emotional dysregulation- Sadness, Guilt, Use of affect, interpersonal incidents, Communication analysis, Role-plays,
Homework.
Behavioral dysregulation –Use of Affect, Communication analysis, Role plays, Homework.
Social dysregulation in the form of social withdrawal-Interpersonal incidents ,Use of affect, Relationship-inventory,
Communication analysis, Use of therapeutic relationship, Homework.
MODULE –II
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy
Relational Frame Theory
-the core of human language and cognition is the ability to learn to relate events under arbitrary contextual control.
Suppose a child has never before seen or played with a cat. After learning “C-A-T” → animal, and Now suppose that
the child is scratched while playing with a cat, cries and runs away. Later the child hears mother saying, “Oh, look! A
cat.” Now the child again cries and runs away, even though the child was never scratched in the presence of the
words “Oh, look! A cat.” Indeed, in this example, the oral name never was trained in the presence of the
animal.
Such effects may help explain why, for example, people can have an initial panic attack while “trapped” in a
shopping mall, and soon find that they are worrying about being “trapped” in an open field or on a bridge. What
brings these situations together is not their formal properties in a simple sense, but the verbal/cognitive activities that
relate these events.
Developed by Steven C. Hayes.
ACT has been used effectively to help treat workplace Stress , exam anxiety, Social anxiety, depression, obsessive
compulsive disorder, chronic pain and substance abuse.
FEAR
F—Fusion--- with your thoughts
E-Evaluation----of Experience
A-Avoidance– of your Experience
R-Reason---giving reasons for your behaviour
Healthy Alternative is to ACT
ACCEPT--- your reactions and be present
CHOOSE--- a Valued Direction
T- TAKE ACTION- Implementation
Techniques
Cognitive De-fusion
Acceptance
Mindfulness
Observing the Self
Values
Committed Action
MODULE I
Psychotherapy is the treatment given to mentally and emotionally disturbed people through psychological techniques.
It is also called clinical intervention because in this method clinical psychologist use their professional capacity and try
to influence and bring given changes in the behaviors of individuals in concern.
Wolberg (1967): “Psychotherapy is a form of treatment for problems of an emotional nature in which a trained person
deliberately establishes a professional relationship with a patient with the object • of removing, modifying or retarding
existing symptoms, • of mediating disturbed patterns of behaviour, and • of promoting positive personality growth and
development.
(Rotter): “Psychotherapy … is plJennyed activity of the psychologist, the purpose of which is to accomplish changes
in the individual that make his life adjustment potentially happier, more constructive, or both.”
J. D. Frank (1982) elaborates this general theme as follows: “Psychotherapy is a plJennyed, emotionally
J. D. Frank (1982) elaborates this general theme as follows: “Psychotherapy is a plJennyed, emotionally charged,
confiding interaction between a trained, socially sanctioned healer and a sufferer. Psychotherapy also often includes
helping the patient to accept and endure suffering as an inevitable aspect of life that can be used as an opportunity for
personal growth.”
The psychodynamic approach to therapy focuses on unconscious motives and conflicts in the search for the roots of
behaviour (Shedler, 2010). It likewise depends heavily on the analysis of past experience. The roots of this perspective
reside in the original psychoanalytic theory and therapy of Sigmund Freud.
Fisher “Psychotherapy is a plJennyed and systematic application of psychological facts and theories to the alleviation
of large variety of human ailments and disturbances, particularly those of psychogenic origin”.
Objectives of Psychotherapy
Psychotherapy aims towards, changing mal adaptive behaviour pattern.
Minimising or eliminating environmental condition that may be causing or maintaining such behaviour.
Improving interpersonal and other competences.
Resolving handicapping and disabling inner conflicts and alleviating personal distress.
Modifying inaccurate assumption about oneself and one’s world and fostering a clear cut sense of oneself identity and
opening of pathways to a more meaningful and fulfilling existence.
The chief objective of psychotherapy is to rid the patients of symptoms which make his life a burden to him, and it is
the duty of the psychiatrists to help the patients regain his self confidence and to strengthen his personality so that he
can solve his own problems and adjust with the environment.
Goals are the outcomes intend to achieve, whereas objectives are the specific actions and measurable steps that need
to take to achieve a goal.
The Ultimate goal and some mediate goals of psychotherapy
Ultimate goals- The ultimate goal is what the psychologist wants to achieve at last. Some of the ultimate goals are
Removing the symptoms.
Freeing the person to be self-actualizing.
Restoring earlier level of functioning.
Helping the patient find personal meaning and values.
Mediate goals- They are not less important than ultimate goal. The mediate goals define the needs which are necessary
to move the patient towards ultimate goal.
Releasing pend-up feelings.
Conditioning or reconditioning of particular responses.
Examining ones values and concepts.
Muscular relaxation.
Becoming aware of unconscious impulses.
There are THREE FUNDAMENTAL PROCESSES in psychotherapy that will facilitate reaching these goals.
To develop trust or a “therapeutic alliance" with r therapist. During this period the treatment goals are defined and
mutually agreed upon. The purpose at this point is to fashion a method of doing therapy that fits best with r
personality.
In the second phase or “working through" process, the emphasis is on resolving confusions about past experience, and
developing ideas about what want and who are. The desired outcome is to trust r intuitive process, feel unobstructed
about the direction r life is taking, and to advance r efforts to enjoy a more healthy and productive life. The expected
outcome from psychotherapy should be that feel more “at home" in the world, more accepting of themself and with
their life choices.
The third or termination phase of therapy is to evaluate progress, solidify what have learned, resolve any remaining
conflicts, and hopefully feel satisfied with life and themself.
All three phases are essential to maintaining the psychological gains.
The more interested and involved clients are in therapy the more positively it will progress.
Psychotherapy can at times evoke anxiety, fear, anger, frustration, loneliness and dependency feelings.
Unpleasant realities if faced, can be worked through.
The emphasis is in replacing fantasy, myth, and untruths with reality.
Reality and truth can at times, be painful, but will ultimately lead to more personal happiness and healthier
relationships. The goal of psychotherapy is not to change , change is a choice, but it is to build awareness, compassion,
understanding, respect, empathy and acceptance toward themself and others.
Different approaches to psychotherapy
Psychologists generally draw on one or more theories of psychotherapy.
A theory of psychotherapy acts as a roadmap for psychologists: It guides them through the process of understanding
clients and their problems and developing solutions.
Approaches to psychotherapy fall into five broad categories:
Psychoanalysis and psychodynamic therapies. This approach focuses on changing problematic behaviors, feelings, and
thoughts by discovering their unconscious meanings and motivations. Psychoanalytically oriented therapies are
characterized by a close working partnership between therapist and patient. Patients learn about themselves by
exploring their interactions in the therapeutic relationship. While psychoanalysis is closely identified with Sigmund
Freud, it has been extended and modified since his early formulations.
What is psychodynamic therapy used in?
anxiety
panic disorders
post-traumatic stress disorder
personality disorders, such as borderline personality disorder
stress-related physical ailments
physical symptoms that lack a physical basis
persistent feelings of isolation and loneliness
prolonged sadness
sexual difficulties
Long term abuse (Physical/ mental)
Cognitive therapy. Cognitive therapy emphasizes what people think rather than what they do.
Cognitive therapists believe that it's dysfunctional thinking that leads to dysfunctional emotions or behaviors. By
changing their thoughts, people can change how they feel and what they do.Major figures in cognitive therapy
include Albert Ellis and Aaron Beck.
Humanistic therapy. This approach emphasizes people's capacity to make rational choices and develop to their
maximum potential. Concern and respect for others are also important themes.
Humanistic philosophers like Jean-Paul Sartre, Martin Buber and Søren Kierkegaard influenced this type of therapy.
Three types of humanistic therapy are especially influential. Client-centered therapy rejects the idea of therapists as
authorities on their clients' inner experiences. Instead, therapists help clients change by emphasizing their concern,
care and interest.
Gestalt therapy emphasizes what it calls "organismic holism," the importance of being aware of the here and now and
accepting responsibility for rself.
Existential therapy focuses on free will, self-determination and the search for meaning.
Integrative or holistic therapy.
Many therapists don't tie themselves to any one approach. Instead, they blend elements from different approaches and
tailor their treatment according to each client's needs.
Who can be considered for Psychodynamic therapies?
Depression with reactive affect (Reactive depression describes symptoms of depression that occur in response to an
external problem or stressor. There are a range of “normal” responses to stressful situations, but reactive and
situational depression often describe emotional difficulties that exceed this range. In some cases, people with these
symptoms are diagnosed with an adjustment disorder, which is a generalized condition used to define mental health
symptoms believed to be stress-related.)
Somatisation (Somatisation is a maladaptive functioning of an organ system, without underlying tissue or organ
damage, or where the symptoms are disproportionate to the underlying structural cause. It occurs as a result of
complex psychosocial factors, and symptoms are not under voluntary control. Throwing up from anxiety, having a
headache due to stress, or feeling physically weak after trauma are all examples of somatization. But these instances
are typically situational and temporary. Somatization becomes a clinical issue when it causes prolonged and severe
distress.)
Personality disorders (works best for Narcisstic, dependent type personality )(excluding Paranoid personality disorder,
Antisocial personalities, Borderline, schizotypal)
Not for Psychotic disorders
high risk situations (comorbid ones etc)
Psychodynamic therapies are good for gaining insight
Note that: if dynamic psychotherapy is successful, initially , the patient usually becomes worse before they become
better.
The psychodynamic processes are ‘painful’. Also termed as “ Psychosurgery”.
Psychosurgery as this therapy is about changing the patients on fundamental basis. So they can confronted with their
unconscious sense and deliberately pull it out to the conscious self.
This therapy is for : * Insight generation .* ; *Someone to talk to*, *Understanding oneself, * exploring themselves
*intrapsychic
pertaining to impulses, ideas, conflicts, or other psychological phenomena that arise or occur within the psyche or
mind
extrapsychic
pertaining to that which originates outside the mind or that which occurs between the mind and the environment.
INTRAPSYCHIC CONFLICT :Opposing forces and the clash of them within the psyche, it is a psychoanalytic theory
such as wishes, agencies or conflicting drives. It is also called inner conflict. Conflict among id-ego-superego
NEUROTIC CONFLICT : neurotic conflict is intrapsychic conflict which leads to persistent maladjustment and
emotional disturbance.
id : Pleasure principle, ex: infant crying for food. This remains infantile throughout the person’s lifetime irrespective
of increasing age.Operated in the unconscious mind
ego: Part of ego that has been modified wrt the outer world. Reality principle.
superego:emerges around 5 years of age. Internalisation of parental and societal rules.Civilizes person’s behaviour.
The intrapsychic process refers to affect, cognition, and conation, as outlined by Freud in his early works (Arieti
1967). In his early writings, Freud assigns significant responsibility to affects as powerful and dynamic forces. ... An
additional aspect of the intrapsychic process relates to cognition.
The clash of opposing forces within the psyche, such as conflicting drives, wishes, or agencies. Also called inner
conflict; internal conflict; intrapersonal conflict; psychic conflict.
An example of negative intrapsychic process might be stress over social responsibilities, conflict with social
rules/regulations, conflict of morals, or a crisis of faith.
Say a father was a being an adult during the Great Depression of the 1930s. ... Such a person often destroys himself in
the process, because if his parents observe him being successful in spite of drinking, this would exacerbate the conflict
in his parents and destabilize them.
Psychodynamic therapy is based on the following key principles:
Unconscious motivations — such as social pressure, biology, and psychology — can affect behavior.
Experience shapes personality, which can, in return, affect an individual’s response to that experience.
Past experiences affect the present.
Developing insight and emotional understanding can help individuals with psychological issues.
Expanding the range of choices and improving personal relationships can help people address their problems.
Freeing themselves from their pasts can help people live better in the future.
Types of Psychotherapies
Cognitive-Behavioural Therapy (CBT): CBT assists to identify and challenge thinking patterns that are unhelpful
which may be contributing to unpleasant emotions. Providing strategies that help in the management of emotions is at
the core of CBT.
Interpersonal Therapy (IPT): IPT is designed to help manage interpersonal difficulties. This can help r family and by
helping all in achieving effective communication. IPT can also help to develop social well-being. This works by
putting the focus on unresolved grief, role conflicts, role transitions and social isolation.
Long Term Psychodynamic Psychotherapy. Sometimes the above short term approaches don’t work because the
problems are more deeply rooted. In such cases psychoanalytic psychotherapy might be recommended. Learn more
about psychoanalytic psychotherapy.
Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy: Mindfulness is all about changing r state of mind, so instead of focusing on
future worries or past regrets, opening r mind to the present moment with openness, curiosity and flexibility. Easier
said than done! Mindfulness is a skill that can be developed through practice; meditation is just one way amongst
many of cultivating mindfulness.
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT): ACT is a new form of cognitive and behavioural therapy which can
assist to better manage negative emotions and help to live a more meaningful life.
What is Counselling
Counselling, which is also known as talk therapy, consists of a single conversation or a series of conversations, taking
place between a psychologist and his client. It is a broadly used term in psychiatry, which goes hand in hand with
treatments used for the enhancement of mental health.
Counselling is also considered to be a specific kind of therapeutic approach, which will help an individual to overcome
unnecessary emotions and behavioural patterns.
The main objective of counselling is to make the client expose his distressing issues to a professional who has a deep
knowledge about the human mind so that the client receives support to adjust himself in order to perform day to day
activities in a normal and efficient manner
According to some health professionals, counselling should mainly focus on one problem at a time, thereby finding
solutions in a logical way of thinking. In this case, a counsellor must show empathy towards the client, so that the
client will feel comfortable to expose his true feelings, which will be very important in finding the most appropriate
mode of therapy.
What is Psychotherapy
Psychotherapy, in contrast, is an evolutionary procedure which will support the client to develop a rational and clear
vision about his long-standing attitudes, recurrent emotions, ways of thinking, behaviour, and personality, which might
have resulted in current issues, in the quality of life and relationships with others.
Psychotherapy is also known to go deep into a particular matter in order to reveal the root cause that causes the related,
disturbed perspective of life. Ultimately, the client will relieve himself by taking the control of his life to himself and
developing self-awareness, rather than getting triggered by unconscious impulses and simulations.
Psychotherapists are also aware of the individual’s inner beliefs, body and inner child, which might have made a
negative impact on troublesome experiences.
However, all these methods of revealing a person’s past life and his nature will eventually result in an effective and
healing relationship between the client and psychotherapist which will be beneficial in creating a mentally healthy
person.
Corey keyes ‘ Dual continuum model’
Difference Between Counselling and Psychotherapy
Time
Counselling: Counselling is a short term process, which focuses on one individual issue at a time, thereby finding a
process to overcome it.
Psychotherapy: Psychotherapy is a long-term process, which involves long periods of working with clients in order to
uncover the foundation of the problem and address it in the most efficient direct or indirect mJennyer.
Patients
Counselling: Counselling usually deals with clients with good coping skills who are fit enough to think rationally and
find solutions to their problems by themselves when a little supporting hand is provided by the counsellor.
Psychotherapy: Psychotherapy mainly involves individuals who are dependent on the psychotherapist to gain control
over their personality, mind, emotions and behavioural patterns. They might also need therapy from time to time with
breakthrough periods, depending on the condition.
Methods
Counselling: Counselling also addresses issues in a less in-depth manner
Psychotherapy: Psychotherapists have intense and extensive knowledge about psychological theories and modalities of
treatments. They will make clients dig into their past experiences, in order to understand their human development,
cognitive and behavioural patterns, thereby enabling them to explore themselves, identify as strong individuals and get
rid of negative senses, self-believes, and external stimulations.
Similarities
There are many similarities between counseling and psychotherapy, and even with the distinction, counseling often
includes some psychotherapy and psychotherapy often includes some counseling. Similarities include:
Development of a healing, safe, and therapeutic relationship between a therapist and an individual
Effectiveness for a wide range of people, both adults and children
Understanding a person's feelings and behaviors, and addressing issues with the goal of improving a person's life
A psychotherapist may be a better option if:
problems that are significantly impacting your life and relationships
coping with past trauma, or if you believe situations in the past may be playing a role in your current issues
present issues are chronic or recurring concerns
chronic medical condition (such as autoimmune disease, cancer, etc.) that is affecting your emotional well-being
diagnosed mental health condition such bipolar disorder or a major anxiety disorder
one has seen a counselor and their issues aren't improving even though they have been actively working on solutions
MODULE II
History of Psychoanalytic Therapy
Freud initially suggested that mental health problems arise from efforts to push inappropriate sexual urges out of
conscious awareness (Freud, 1895/1955).
Later, Freud suggested more generally that psychiatric problems are the result of tension between different parts of the
mind: the id, the superego, and the ego.
The Case of Anna O
The case of 21 year old, pseudo named Anna O (real name Bertha Pappenheim) marked a turning point in the career of
Sigmund Freud. It even went on to influence the future direction of psychology as a whole. Psychoanalysis was on the
verge of beginning.
Anna O. suffered from hysteria, a condition in which the patient exhibits physical symptoms (e.g., paralysis,
convulsions, hallucinations, loss of speech) without an apparent physical cause. Her doctor (and Freud's teacher) Josef
Breuer succeeded in treating Anna by helping her to recall forgotten memories of traumatic events.
Her symptoms were, language disorders, visual impairments, hallucinations,right sided paralysis, Neuralgia(facial
muscular impairments), hydrophobia,speech problems.
During discussions with her, it became apparent that she had developed a fear of drinking when a dog she hated drank
from her glass. Her other symptoms originated when caring for her sick father.
She would not express her anxiety for her his illness but did express it later, during psychoanalysis. As soon as she had
the opportunity to make these unconscious thoughts conscious her paralysis disappeared.
Free association came into being after Anna/Bertha decided (with Breuer's input) to end her hypnosis sessions and
merely talk to Breuer, saying anything that came into her mind. She called this method of communication "chimney
sweeping" and "talking cure" and this served as the beginning of free association.
Tranference : Transference: A phenomenon characterized by unconscious redirection of feelings and desires from one
person to another, especially of those unconsciously retained from childhood toward a new object. In psychotherapy,
free association was used to identify transference, which aided in revealing the hidden unconscious.
Josef Breuer successfully treated her by helping her identify forgotten memories of traumatic events which caused fear
and anxiety – a phobia of drinking due to a feared dog who once drank from her glass, an anxiety of illness from
caring for her ill father. After identifying these causes, symptoms subsided. Sigmund Freud, a friend of Joseph Breuer,
was fascinated by this, and so investigated the case, eventually writing Studies in Hysteria (1895). In it, he proposed
the three levels of the human psyche, and revolutionized psychology. However, Freud was not just advancing an
explanation of a particular illness. Implicitly he was proposing a revolutionary new theory of the human psyche itself.
In Studies in Hysteria , book by Freud (1895), Freud proposed that physical symptoms are often the surface
manifestations of deeply repressed conflicts.
Historical records since showed that when Breuer stopped treating Anna O. she was not becoming better but
progressively worse.[2] She was ultimately institutionalized: "Breuer told Freud that she was deranged; he hoped she
would die to end her suffering".
In contrast, Lucy Freeman reports that Anna O.-Bertha P. made a remarkable recovery following her treatment. Their
talking therapy had helped her rid herself of every symptom manifesting from repressed events and emotions. Breuer
left Ms. Pappenheim on the eve of their final session convinced she was completely cured.
She later recovered over time and led a productive life. The West German government issued a postage stamp in
honour of her contributions to the field of social work.
Free association is a technique used in psychoanalysis which was originally devised by Freud out of the hypnotic
method of his mentor and coworker, Josef Breuer. The importance of free association is that the patients spoke for
themselves, rather than repeating the ideas of the analyst; they work through their own material, rather than parroting
another's suggestions.
Transference: A phenomenon characterized by unconscious redirection of feelings and desires from one person to
another, especially of those unconsciously retained from childhood toward a new object. In psychotherapy, free
association was used to identify transference, which aided in revealing the hidden unconscious.
Psychoanalysis before Freud:
Franz Anton Mesmer (1734–1815) :Because of his rather unusual techniques, Mesmer strongly opposed by the
medical establishment. Mesmer is widely regarded as the father of hypnosis, a state in which extremely suggestible
subjects sometimes appear to be in a trance.
Jean Charcot (1825–1893) studied hypnosis and influenced Sigmund Freud to consider psychosocial approaches to
psychological disorders.
In 1885 a young man named Sigmund Freud came from Vienna to study with Charcot. After returning from France,
Freud teamed up with Josef Breuer (1842–1925), who had experimented with a somewhat different hypnotic
procedure. While his patients were in the highly suggestible state of hypnosis, Breuer asked them to describe their
problems, conflicts, and fears in as much detail as they could. Breuer observed two extremely important phenomena
during this process.
First, patients often became extremely emotional as they talked and felt quite relieved and improved after emerging
from the hypnotic state.
Second, seldom would they have gained an understanding of the relationship between their emotional problems and
their psychological disorder. In fact, it was difficult or impossible for them to recall some details they had described
under hypnosis. In other words, the material seemed to be beyond the awareness of the patient.
A close second was their discovery that it is therapeutic to recall and relive emotional trauma that has been made
unconscious and to release the accompanying tension. This release of emotional material became known as catharsis.
A fuller understanding of the relationship between current emotions and earlier events is referred to as insight.
INSIGHT:
The Psychoanalytic Insight ,By Ioan Lungu ; insight means : "the ability to see and understand clearly the inner nature
of things, especially by intuition".
significance of the sentence "inner nature of things’
In psychoanalysis, the "insight" is a sort of "clear understanding", but this is related to a kind of a feeling of liberation
as from a psychical burden.
This "psychical burden" represents what we could call a psychological inner fact.
Clarifying this inner psychological fact is the task of psychoanalysis, more precisely of the interpretation of the
symptoms.
‘Freud’s Iceberg Theory’ uses the imagery of an iceberg to separate these ‘3 levels of consciousness’ :Three levels of
the human mind
Conscious Surface-level thoughts, consisting of those thoughts that are the focus of our attention now. We are aware
of these thoughts. In the iceberg model, this level is seen as the visible part above water -- the tip of the iceberg.
Preconscious : The preconscious consists of all which can be retrieved from memory. We will or can become aware of
these thoughts through accessible memory, as these thoughts move from sub-conscious to conscious mind. In the
iceberg model, this level is the segment just beneath the surface of the water, ready to rise up above the surface at any
time.
Unconscious: The most significant level of the mind, the place of deep- seated motives that are most responsible for
shaping behavior and personality. Acts as a repository of primitive wishes and impulse kept at bay and mediated by
the Pre-conscious. A primary assumption of Freudian theory is that the unconscious mind governs behavior to a
greater degree than the individual suspects. Indeed, the goal of psychoanalysis is to make the unconscious conscious.
Conscious: I am feeling angry right now.
Preconscious: I must be angry because I lost my tennis match yesterday.
Unconscious: My culture has instilled in me the belief that winning is part of being successful in life.
conscious mind :awareness of something, being able to call it to mind, it would seem simple enough to qualify only
those events we can recall as the activities of the human mind.
The two functions that the capabilities of the conscious mind can address are:
Its ability to direct focus.
Its ability to imagine which is not real
subconscious is the storage point for any recent memories needed for quick recall, such as what your telephone
number is or the name of a person you just met. It also holds current information that you use every day, such as your
current recurring thoughts, behavior patterns, habits, and feelings.
subconscious mind serves as the minds random access memory (RAM)
The unconscious mind is where all of our memories and past experiences reside. These are those memories that have
been repressed through trauma and those that have simply been consciously forgotten and no longer important to us
(automatic thoughts). It’s from these memories and experiences that our beliefs, habits, and behaviors are formed.
Theoretical Background
The Id : primary component of personality.
The id is the only component of personality that is present from birth.
This aspect of personality is entirely unconscious and includes instinctive and primitive behaviors.
The id is driven by the pleasure principle, which strives for immediate gratification of all desires, wants, and needs.
If these needs are not satisfied immediately, the result is a state anxiety or tension. For example, an increase in hunger
or thirst should produce an immediate attempt to eat or drink.
The id is very important early in life because it ensures that an infant's needs are met. If the infant is hungry or
uncomfortable, they will cry until the demands of the id are satisfied. Growinng infants are ruled entirely by the id,
there is no reasoning with them when these needs demand satisfaction.
However, immediately fulfilling these needs is not always realistic or even possible.
If we were ruled entirely by the pleasure principle, we might find ourselves grabbing the things that we want out of
other people's hands to satisfy our own cravings.
This behavior would be both disruptive and socially unacceptable.
According to Freud, the id tries to resolve the tension created by the pleasure principle through the use of primary
process thinking, which involves forming a mental image of the desired object as a way of satisfying the need.
*Although people eventually learn to control the id, this part of personality remains the same infantile, primal force
throughout life.
*It is the development of the ego and the superego that allows people to control the id's basic instincts and act in ways
that are both realistic and socially acceptable.
The Ego :Reality Principle “I”
According to Freud, The ego develops from the id and ensures that the impulses of the id can be expressed in a
mAnner acceptable in the real world.
The ego functions in the conscious, preconscious, and unconscious mind.
The ego is the component of personality that is responsible for dealing with reality.
The ego operates based on the reality principle, which strives to satisfy the id's desires in realistic and socially
appropriate ways.
The reality principle weighs the costs and benefits of an action before deciding to act upon or abandon impulses.
In many cases, the id's impulses can be satisfied through a process of delayed gratification—the ego will eventually
allow the behavior, but only in the appropriate time and place.
As a metaphor, Freud compared the id to a horse and the ego to the horse's rider. The horse provides the power and
motion, while the rider provides direction and guidance. Without its rider, the horse may simply wander wherever it
wished and do whatever it pleased. The rider gives the horse directions and commands to get it to go where the rider
wants it to go.
The ego also discharges tension created by unmet impulses through secondary process thinking, in which the ego tries
to find an object in the real world that matches the mental image created by the id's primary process.
Imagine that are stuck in a long meeting at work. Find yourself growing increasingly hungry as the meeting drags on.
While the id might compel to jump up from your seat and rush to the break room for a snack, the ego guides to sit
quietly and wait for the meeting to end.
**Instead of acting upon the primal urges of the id, spend the rest of the meeting imagining yourself eating a meal.
Once the meeting is finally over, can seek out the object were imagining and satisfy the demands of the id in a
realistic and appropriate manner.
The Superego “ above I”
The last component of personality to develop is the superego.
According to Freud, the superego begins to emerge at around age five.
The superego holds the internalized moral standards and ideals that we acquire from our parents and society (our sense
of right and wrong).
The superego provides guidelines for making judgments.
**The superego has two parts:
The ego ideal includes the rules and standards for behaviors that the ego aspires to.
The conscience includes information about things that are viewed as bad by parents and society. These behaviors are
often forbidden and lead to bad consequences, punishments, or feelings of guilt and remorse.
If There Is an Imbalance?
The basic dilemma of all human existence is that each element of the makes demands upon us that are incompatible
with the other two. Inner conflict is inevitable
Ego failing to balance id and superego:intrapsychic conflict
Freud’s conflict model
Self in not unified. Self is not a single entity
Self is not rational
They components (id, ego, super ego) may be in conflicting position with one another
They will compete during events in life
In cases of Neurosis and psychosis, the severity of intrapsychic conflict is enormous and severe with rumination
patterns.
Id (irrational + emotional + demanding+ strong)
Ego (Rational+ Real + delay gratification) (ego develops from the id during 3 – 5 years during the phallic stage of
psychosexual development.)
Superego ( Morality + ego ideal + conscious ) (develops during early childhood 5- 6 years ,when the child identifies
with the same sex parent)
(Superego steps in when Mom or cops (authoritative figure) aren’t around)
What is Psychoanalytic?
(Principles)
Psychological problems are rooted in the unconscious.
Treatments focus on bringing the repressed conflict to consciousness.
Personality is largely influenced by childhood experiences.
Individuals employ defense mechanisms against threatening information from the unconscious.
The mind is composed of the id, ego, and superego.
Dreams are the royal road to the unconscious.
All tension is due to the increase of libido and that all pleasure is derived from its discharge.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Psychoanalytic Therapy
Psychoanalysis was once the only type of psychotherapy available, but presently the number of therapists practicing
this approach is decreasing around the world. Psychoanalysis is not appropriate for some types of patients, including
those with severe psychopathology or mental retardation. Further, psychoanalysis is often expensive because treatment
usually lasts many years.
Perhaps the greatest disadvantage of psychoanalysis and related approaches is the lack of empirical support for their
effectiveness. The limited research that has been conducted on these treatments suggests that they do not reliably lead
to better mental health outcomes (e.g., Driessen et al., 2010).
And, although there are some reviews that seem to indicate that long-term psychoanalytic therapies might be
beneficial (e.g., Leichsenring & Rabung, 2008), other researchers have questioned the validity of these reviews.
Nevertheless, psychoanalytic theory was history’s first attempt at formal treatment of mental illness, setting the stage
for the more modern approaches used today.
Difference between Psychodynamic and Psychoanalytic
Theorists
Psychoanalytic perspective refers to theories and therapeutic methods which are based on the original works of Freud,
who coined the term “psychoanalysis” in 1896. On the other hand, psychodynamic perspective refers to the therapeutic
approach and theories developed by Freud and supported by his followers such as the neo-Freudians (Jung, Adler,
Horney, Erikson, Klein, etc.).
Focus
Psychodynamic perspective generally deemphasizes ‘libodo ‘ and gives more importance to the influence of social
environment. On the contrary, the psychoanalytic perspective gives more importance to the influence of the libido.
Therapy
Psychodynamic therapy is an in-depth form of talk therapy which is usually delivered once a week (APA, 2017).
Aside from looking into the unconscious and past experiences, this approach also considers the impact of the external
world. This is also known as “insight-oriented therapy” which is the oldest type of modern therapy (Embogama,
2016). In comparison, psychoanalytic therapy usually takes place several times a week with the patient on a couch
(APA, 2017). It is based on Freud’s psychoanalytic theories and is generally more intensive and lasts longer than
psychodynamic therapy.
What is Psychodynamic?
Psychodynamic perspective refers to the therapeutic approach and theories developed by Freud and supported by his
followers such as the neo-Freudians (though they disagreed with some of his concepts); they generally deemphasized
sex and gave more importance to the influence of social environment. Some of them are:
Carl Jung
Jung was a Swiss psychiatrist who was Freud’s protégé. His theory is called “Analytical Psychology”; he met Freud
in 1907, they were impressed with each other’s work and developed a close friendship. In fact, Freud viewed Jung as
his intellectual heir. However, Jung broke away from Feud in 1913 due to their differing concepts. He thought that
Freud’s theory of the unconscious was too negative and incomplete. For instance, Jung proposed that there was a
deeper and transpersonal form of unconscious called the “collective unconscious” which is manifested by universal
symbols. Freud then dismissed Jung’s interest in myths as being unscientific.
Alfred Adler
Adler was an Austrian psychiatrist, his theory is called “Individual Psychology”. He was the first president of the
Vienna Psychoanalytical Society; hence, he was a part of Freud’s inner circle of colleagues. Instead of sexual and
aggressive urges, Adler believed that we are driven by feelings of inferiority in childhood and that people should be
studied as a whole. Because of his disagreements with Freud, Adler left the society, taking one third of the members
with him.
Karen Horney
Horney was a German psychoanalyst who also questioned some of Freud’s theories. She is credited for her feminist
psychology
When the International Psychoanalytical Association formed in 1910 Jung became president at the request of Freud.
However in 1912 while on a lecture tour of America Jung publicly criticized Freud’s theory of the Oedipus
complex and his emphasis on infantile sexuality. The following year this led to an irrevocable split between them and
Jung went on to develop his own version of psychoanalytic theory.
Alfred Adler (1870-1937), world renowned philosopher and psychiatrist, stressed the need to understand individuals
within their social context. During the early 1900's, Adler began addressing such crucial and contemporary issues as
equality, parent education, the influence of birth order, life style, and the holism of individuals. Adler believed that we
all have one basic desire and goal: to belong and to feel significant.
Adler developed the first holistic theory of personality, psychopathology, and psychotherapy that was intimately
connected to a humanistic philosophy of living. His lectures and books for the general public are characterized by a
crystal clear common sense. His clinical books and journal articles reveal an uncommon understanding of mental
disorders, a deep insight into the art of healing, and a great inspiration for encouraging optimal human development.
The expressive therapies are based on the assumption that people can heal through the various forms of creative
expression. Expressive therapists share the belief that through creative expression and the tapping of the imagination,
people can examine their body, feelings, emotions, and thought process.
Expressive Therapy
A therapeutic garden is a plant-dominated environment purposefully designed to facilitate interaction with the healing
elements of nature.
Horticultural therapy techniques are employed to assist participants to learn new skills or regain those that are lost.
Horticultural therapy helps improve memory, cognitive abilities, task initiation, language skills, and socialization. In
physical rehabilitation, horticultural therapy can help strengthen muscles and improve coordination, balance, and
endurance. In vocational horticultural therapy settings, people learn to work independently, problem solve, and follow
directions. Horticultural therapists are professionals with specific education, training, and credentials in the use of
horticultural for therapy and rehabilitation.
Experience-based evidence
There is clear, usage-based evidence of the positive effects of expressive therapies in helping treat children and adults
who've experienced trauma, cancer patients, people with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), dementia and more.
Creative therapies have also been shown to improve concentration, lower anxiety and possibly prevent suicide.
Some form of creative therapy has been practiced by cultures throughout the ages as a way to provide relief from acute
emotional distress.
As neuroscience unfolds more about the mind/body connection, practitioners point to the benefits of engaging in a
creative process that helps promote healing. Studies tracking brain changes during these engagements point to an
alteration in brain function, which may contribute to the relearning of key skills and mental, emotional, and physical
healing.
THE ORIGINS OF FORMAL ART THERAPY
The formal practice of art therapy has its origins in the mid-20th century Europe, with the coining of the term being
attributed to British artist Adrian Hill in 1942.
At a time where thousands suffered in sanatoriums from tuberculosis, it was observed that drawing and painting was a
creative outlet for patients that provided them the freedom their confines did not.(A sanatorium (or sanitorium) is
a medical facility for long-term illness, most typically associated with the treatment of tuberculosis (TB) in the late-
nineteenth and early-twentieth century before the discovery of antibiotics.)
The practices in art therapy soon spread to mental hospitals through the work of Edward Adamson, who observed and
further studied the connection between artistic expression and emotional release. The British Association of Art
Therapists was founded in 1964.
Goals of Expressive Therapies
The goal of Expressive therapy is to promote healing and reveal hidden conflicts in a patient
Providing insight
Representation of verbal description through art, dance and music.
The focus of treatment is getting to know the feelings that are associated with the patient's aesthetics being that
auditory and visual stimuli are often used as a mental and emotional outlet.
The art symbolizes the client’s experiences, such as trauma or fear
The goal isn't to diagnose the final product but allow the patient to express themselves in a manner that they are
comfortable with.
individual has no obligations in analyzing their own work because the goal is to help them by discussing the art in a
non-judgmental manner and supportive setting.
When is Expressive Therapy Used?/Indications
Expressive Therapy is a broad category and can be used to treat various conditions by helping the patient familiarize
themselves with their own emotions and expressions. Treatment may be used when a patient is dealing with
depression, anxiety, stress, self esteem issues, interpersonal relationship conflicts, learning problems and eating
disorders. The outlet can help clients who have been diagnosed with dementia, Alzheimer's, chronic conditions,
trauma and addiction.
The sessions vary depending on the outlet type. If it is art therapy the client will either draw or paint images that
reflect their thoughts. Music therapy consists of singing, writing songs or playing instruments.
Clients may also listen to music to bring out positive emotions being that sounds can help many cope with depression
and worry. Sessions may consist of poetry and writing in which the individual can express their emotions on paper
instead of verbally. If the session is a form of dance it will help people cope with any physical or mental illnesses
through movement. This is a way to improve physical health as well. Drama therapy consists of improvising or acting
for the purpose of expressing emotion and coping
ART THERAPY
Techniques used in art therapy can include:
Collage
Coloring
Doodling and scribbling
Drawing
Finger painting
Painting
Photography
Sculpting
Working with clay
As clients create art, they may analyze what they have made and how it makes them feel. Through exploring their art,
people can look for themes and conflicts that may be affecting their thoughts, emotions, and behaviors.
RESEARCH AND INNOVATION IN THE FIELD
It’s been widely studied and observed how art therapy is effective to treat trauma, abuse, grief, anxiety, and eating
disorders. It is a helpful tool to alleviate stress through major life transitions and eases pain and suffering associated
with mental, physical and emotional diseases.
By working to bring the conscious, unconscious and subconscious into expressive and tangible forms, the creative
processes involved in art therapy have been praised for their ability to encourage personal growth, mindfulness, and
self-discovery.
Students’ response
When was the last time you picked up a paintbrush or a colored pencil?
Maybe it’s been a while, but what about the last time you doodled on your notebook during a meeting/ class?
For many of us, when we think of art, we tend to think it’s not for us. Perhaps we think we aren’t very creative, but
there’s more to it than merely being ‘good at drawing.’
Allowing our brains the freedom for free expression, even by doodling, can have a wonderful impact on how we
process, retain, and share information.
Naumburg wrote several influential books on the topic of art therapy, believing that when creative pursuits are seen as
another form of expression, they can be used in conjunction with traditional communication to unearth repressed and
unconscious memories and emotions.
Her work led others to begin exploring the field, building its reputation within the psychological community,
including:
Florence Cane,((1882-1952) was a Progressive art educator who worked to release the inner artist in each child) an art
educator who began to use teaching methods that encouraged artistic expression and emotional creativity.
Edith Kramer (Edith Kramer (1916–2014) was an Austrian social realist painter, a follower of psychoanalytic theory
and an art therapy pioneer) who developed a more process-oriented art therapy approach based on psychotherapy
ideas of the ego and that promoted the development of identity.
Elnor Ulman (Elinor Ulman, 81, adjunct professor emeritus of art therapy at George Washington University)
established the first journal in the United States dedicated to art therapy, alongside one of the first training programs
for psychologists wishing to train in art therapy.
A Brief History of Art Therapy
history of art therapy For centuries, art and drawing have been used all over the world as tools for communication,
storytelling, self-expression, and social interaction.
As far back as there have been humans, there has been art. Just think of the original cave drawings.
Art as a therapy practice was only accepted more recently. The term ‘Art Therapy’ was coined in 1942 by Adrian Hill,
a British artist, who attributed painting and drawing to his recovery from tuberculosis. However, the benefits of the
practice of art for emotional health go back further than this.
In 1915, Margaret Naumburg, often referred to as the Mother of Art Therapy, established the Walden School in New
York. Naumburg believed that children should be allowed creative freedom and that allowing them to pursue subjects
that interested them would enable healthy development.
Indications of ART therapy
Effective use in PTSD and beyond
PTSD is defined as “an anxiety disorder that can develop after exposure to a terrifying event or ordeal in which grave
physical harm occurred or was threatened." PTSD affects all aspects of a person's life, from jobs to relationships.
Children who suffer from PTSD can have difficulty in school and experience behavioral issues, isolation, and phobias.
In a study of PTSD sufferers, Joshua Smyth, PhD, at Pennsylvania State University, related the need for, and evidence
of, results with what he calls “alternative therapies” that provide access to sufferers’ experiences without directly
recalling these experiences verbally.
reducing the severity of depression (which often accompanies PTSD), and/or improving quality of life. The
documented impact of the creative arts therapies on symptoms of trauma and post-traumatic stress disorder has
inspired two national summits on arts and health in the military
Claire reflects on her experience of art therapy, adolescent trauma and emotional dysregulation
At the age of 17 years old, Claire accessed art therapy for approximately 9 months. Claire started art therapy within a
community service, after being discharged from several consecutive Inpatient Units...
Individual art therapy session
Art therapy postcard activity
Most people would probably agree that it’s easier to express or recognize hurts and regrets when there’s the distance
between yourself and the problem. This is why the postcard activity can be a good self-discovery exercise that helps
answer the question, “What would I say to someone if I didn’t have to do it face-to-face?”
This activity can be used in one-to-one or group therapy sessions. Here’s how to conduct the activity:
Print out the postcard by following the link above or simply create a postcard-style template to use. One side can be
completely blank for drawing, and one side can be laid out with some lines for writing.
Ask participants to reflect on a situation or person they feel or felt frustrated, angry, upset, or sad about. Spend a
moment simply thinking about and reflecting on what happened, how it felt, and what they would like to let the person
know about how the experience made them feel.
On the blank side of the postcard, ask participants to draw or create a visual representation of how they felt or still feel
about the experience. Explain that there is total freedom with this, and they can create anything they like with any
materials.
On the lined side of the postcard, participants can write what they would like to say if they could.
Use what they draw and write to explore their emotions further and discuss how they might begin to work toward a
healing resolution.
Color your feelings
This set of three worksheets includes exercises for children to express their emotions or define the things they care
about. It’s a very quick and easy exercise that can help participants create helpful visual representations of the things
they value.
The worksheets include an empty outline of a heart.
Here’s how to use it.
You will need:
The printed worksheets
Markers and colored pencils
Glitter, sequins, and glue (if desired)
Process:
Ask participants to take a moment to reflect on the things that make their heart happy. What things make them feel
good? What words would they use to describe these things? What images and colors come to mind when they think
about these things?
2. Provide participants with the worksheets and ask them to fill the heart with what they have just been thinking and
talking about. They can create these in any way they like, focusing on one thing or filling the heart with as many
things as they want.
3. Use what they create as a discussion point to help them better understand the things that make their heart happy.
How often do these things happen for them? How can they and you work together to create more of these happy
moments?
Drama therapy
Drama therapy is the intentional use of drama and/or theater processes to achieve therapeutic goals.
Drama therapy is an embodied practice that is active and experiential. This approach can provide the context for
participants to tell their stories, set goals and solve problems, express feelings, or achieve catharsis. Through drama,
the depth and breadth of inner experience can be actively explored and interpersonal relationship skills can be
enhanced.
How Does Drama Therapy Work?
Drama therapy uses play, embodiment, projection, role, story, empathy, distancing, witnessing, performance, and
improvisation to help people make meaningful change.
A drama therapist first assesses a client's needs and then considers approaches that might best meet those needs.
Drama therapy can take many forms depending on individual and group needs, skill and ability levels, interests, and
therapeutic goals. Processes and techniques may include improvisations, theater games, storytelling, and enactment.
Many drama therapists make use of text, performance, to enrich the therapeutic and creative process. The theoretical
foundation of drama therapy lies in drama, theater, psychology, psychotherapy, anthropology, play, and interactive and
creative processes.
Who Can Benefit from Drama Therapy?
Drama therapy is for everyone across the lifespan. You do not have to be “good” at acting to benefit from drama
therapy!
Client populations may include persons recovering from addiction, dysfunctional families, developmentally disabled
persons, abuse survivors, prison inmates, homeless persons, people with AIDS, older adults, behavioral health
consumers, at-risk youth, and the general public.
Drama therapists work in a variety of mental health and community settings. Below are some possible examples of
locations where drama therapists can be found:
Mental Health Clinics
Schools
Hospital Medical Units
Hospital Mental Health Units
Substance Abuse Treatment Centers
Adult Day Treatment Facilities
Correctional Facilities
Community Centers
After School Programs
Programs for Older Adults
College Counseling Centers
Research studies
A Drama Therapy Approach with Female Prisoners Recovering from Addiction, Wesley et al.
Female prisoners in recovery may anticipate defeat when projecting possibilities for their future hopes and dreams.
These clients often identify with and attach to the role of prisoner and addict. This article describes a 12-week group
treatment program, titled by the author as “Prayerformance.” In this work, female prisoners in recovery have an
opportunity to connect spiritually and psychologically by using techniques like role play, improvisation, spontaneity
training, storytelling, character development, mask work, and movement.
Dramatherapy for mentally disordered offenders: changes in levels of anger , Riess et al.
The aim of this study was to examine changes in levels of anger associated with a therapeutic theatre project. The
population consisted of mentally disordered patients in a maximum security hospital, all of whom had a history of
major violence. The subjects were being treated on a ward that specializes in psychotherapeutic interventions. Twelve
young adult male patients, defined by structured interview for personality disorder and clinical diagnosis for mental
illness, participated in a week-long dramatherapy project. They were evaluated using self-report questionnaires both
before and after the week, as well as at three-month follow-up. Levels of anger significantly reduced from before to
after the theatre week. This improvement was maintained at three-month follow-up. There was an associated increase
in the frequency of attempts to control the expression of anger. It is concluded that a dramatherapy project within a
psychotherapeutic environment may be an effective therapeutic modality for reducing anger levels in young mentally
disordered offenders.
Music Therapy
Music therapy is the use of music to address the physical, emotional, cognitive, and social needs of a group or
individual. It employs a variety of activities, such as listening to melodies, playing an instrument, drumming, writing
songs, and guided imagery.
Music Therapy is the clinical & evidence-based use of music interventions to accomplish individualized goals within a
therapeutic relationship by a credentialed professional who has completed an approved music therapy program. Music
therapy interventions can address a variety of healthcare & educational goals:
Promote Wellness
Manage Stress
Alleviate Pain
Express Feelings
Enhance Memory
Improve Communication
Promote Physical Rehabilitation
Types of music therapy
Cognitive behavioral music therapy (CBMT): This approach combines cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) with
music. In CBMT, music is used to reinforce some behaviors and modify others. This approach is structured, not
improvisational, and may include listening to music, dancing, singing, or playing an instrument.
Community music therapy: This format is focused on using music as a way to facilitate change on the community
level. It’s done in a group setting and requires a high level of engagement from each member.
Vocal psychotherapy: In this format, you use various vocal exercises, natural sounds, and breathing techniques to
connect with your emotions and impulses. This practice is meant to create a deeper sense of connection with yourself.
The Bonny method of guided imagery and music (GIM): This form of therapy uses classical music as a way to
stimulate the imagination. In this method, you explain the feelings, sensations, memories, and imagery you experience
while listening to the music.
How is Music therapy session progressed
During a music therapy session, you may listen to different genres of music, play a musical instrument, or even
compose your own songs. You may be asked to sing or dance. Your therapist may encourage you to improvise, or they
may have a set structure for you to follow.
You may be asked to tune in to your emotions as you perform these tasks or to allow your feelings to direct your
actions. For example, if you are angry, you might play or sing loud, fast, and dissonant chords.
You may also use music to explore ways to change how you feel. If you express anger or stress, your music therapist
might respond by having you listen to or create music with slow, soft, soothing tones.
Music therapy is often one-on-one, but you may also choose to participate in group sessions if they are available.
Sessions with a music therapist take place wherever they practice, which might be a:
Clinic
Community health center
Correctional facility
Hospital
Private office
Selected studies are based on relational and rehabilitative music therapy approaches or concern music listening
interventions. Most of the studies support the efficacy of MT and other musical interventions on mood, depressive
syndromes, and quality of life on neurological patients.Effects of music and music therapy on mood in neurological
patients (Raglio et al. 2015)
Some other forms of expressive therapies:
Dance/movement therapy: Dance therapy is based on the notion that the mind and body are related. It uses
psychotherapeutic movement as a process that helps to improve the emotional, physical, and cognitive integration of
the person in treatment.
Play therapy: Play therapy uses therapeutic play to help people resolve psychological difficulties and achieve optimum
development.
Some other forms of expressive therapies:
Sand play therapy: This is a creative form of therapy that uses a sandbox and miniature models to help clients explore
deeper layers of their own inner personal beings. Clients construct a series of “sand pictures” to integrate various
aspects of their personality and emotional functioning.
An integrated arts approach (also known as intermodal or multimodal therapy): This approach combines two or more
of the above expressive therapies to encourage psychological growth and the development or facilitation of personal
relationships
Therapeutic Effects of Expressive Therapies
Expressive therapies use the creative process as a means of therapeutic intervention or change. The creative process
can be utilized through creation, interpretation, reflection, discussion, and so forth. Individuals who actually create art,
poetry, music, or are involved in dance or play therapy are not evaluated on the quality of their final product but
instead are expected to use the creative process to foster change and to help reach therapeutic goals.
Several aspects of the creative process associated with expressive therapies contribute to this process, such as:
Self-expression: All of the expressive arts activities/strategies/techniques encourage individuals to engage in self-
exploration through self-expression. Some sources suggest that using the arts as a part of therapy may actually speed
up the process of self-exploration and allow individuals to experience themselves from a different perspective point.
Expressing oneself through dance, poetry, art, etc. may help to make sense of one’s past experience and act as a
catharsis (a term used in therapy for self-realization and the release of emotional burdens). Self-expression in most of
these techniques typically involves the use of some form of verbal expression or reflection; however, it can also
involve body movement as in dance, visualization as in painting or sculpting, and even tactile/real expression during
play.
Therapeutic Effects of Expressive Therapies
sense of active participation: These methods are all action-oriented methods by which clients explore issues and
communicate their feelings and thoughts. These are not passive techniques. These techniques require individuals to
invest energy in them and be committed to experiencing them. They are also sensory in nature in that they utilize
different sensory modalities.
The establishment of mind-body connections: These techniques are designed to facilitate the capacity of the mind to
influence body functions and symptoms, and vice versa. These forms of expression are effective in helping to cope
with stress and in establishing meaningful ways of communicating one’s issues. In addition, some of them are physical
forms of expression, such as dance and play, and have the benefit of promoting health and wellness.
Imagination: According to the book Foundations of Expressive Arts Therapy: Theoretical and Clinical
Perspectives expressive therapies are founded on the notion that imagination is a healing agent inherent to all forms of
self-expression. Often, the word creativity is used to describe the function of expressive therapies, and this includes the
notion of imagination.
Improvisation
How Do Expressive Therapies Assist in Substance Use Disorder Treatment?
There are a number of specific effects found for different types of expressive therapies used as adjunctive therapies in
the treatment of substance use disorders. According to the book The Use of Creative Therapies with Chemical
Dependency Issues:
Expressive therapies may be useful in decreasing denial in individuals with substance use disorders.
Expressive therapies are potentially useful in reducing opposition to treatment for individuals with alcohol use
disorders and other substance use disorders.
Expressive therapies help to disseminate issues with shame and regret that are associated with past substance usage.
Expressive therapies have been shown to help individuals engage in seeking and participating in treatment.
Expressive therapies are useful in developing communication skills, self-esteem, and personal insight, and they offer
variety in the therapeutic process.
Expressive therapies can be used to help motivate individuals to change.
There are several considerations involved with choosing to use expressive therapies as an intervention in
psychopathology or specifically as a substance use treatment program:
First, it is important to understand that the use of any techniques or materials in expressive therapy should be practical
for the individuals involved and should be appropriate for the age, maturity level, and ability of the people using them.
Many individuals may not feel artistic or may not feel that activities, such as acting, are appropriate for them, and
these people should not be forced into using these techniques.
Using any form of interpretive process discussion regarding any individual’s performance or work in a group setting
with the person’s peers should be undertaken with great care.
The goal is not to criticize someone’s artwork, acting, etc. but to discuss the creative process and the experiences that
went into the expression. It is extremely counterproductive to critique a person’s art, acting, etc.
Those who do not wish their work to be viewed by others should have their wishes respected by therapists.
Expressive therapies can only be administered by individuals trained specifically in the type of expressive therapy
being used.
Contraindications to using expressive therapies
There are some contraindications to using expressive therapies. Individuals with severe cognitive issues
severe psychological issues such as psychosis
physical disabilities, or neurological problems may not be appropriate to involve in expressive therapies and may not
benefit from them.
Patients at the disorganized end of the diagnostic spectrum, such as neurotic patients may have inability to integrate
their thought processes; behavior disorganization manifests as self-contradictory or inconsistent behavior
Clients who are unable to emotionally integrate the cognitive awareness
No one should ever be coerced/compelled into participating in expressive therapies.
These therapies should not be used by individuals who are not specifically trained and certified in their use, and this
includes licensed therapists. Licensed therapists should only use these techniques if they have been specially trained in
them.
Criticisms of Expressive Therapy
There isn't a guarantee that creative therapies help treat those who suffer from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder because
there isn't enough controlled trials that have been conducted.
Studies haven't revealed what type of patient suffering from trauma would benefit the most from aesthetic therapy.
Some experts believe that there isn't enough consistency in terms of art therapy and symptoms that are related to
trauma.
Some researchers believe that the studies lack controlled conditions although the majority of the patients in the group
improve.
On the upside Expressive Therapy conducts safe and controlled interactions. The interactions may not be fully
explained because there is a lack of a controlled condition.
Many experts criticize treatment because it isn't always clear as to what components of therapy lead to success.
MODULE IV
Psychodynamic individual psychotherapies are described as a continuum that extends from supportive to expressive
psychotherapies (Gabbard, 2005)
Psychoanalysis, includes approaches that accomplish personality change by analyzing the relationship between the
therapeutic couple and insights derived from the exploration of unrecognized feelings, thoughts and conflicts
(Luborsky, 1984)
the aim of supportive psychotherapy is not to change the patient’s personality but to help the patient cope with
symptoms, conscious conflicts or transient problems
Several authors have suggested different definitions of supportive intervention, but all agree that this kind of treatment
helps to improve patient self-esteem, maximizes patient adaptive skills, and restores ego functions, maintaining or
reestablishing a consistent level of functioning, given the patient’s personality and life circumstances (Dewald, 1971;
Ursano & Silberman, 1996).
Although in real clinical practice, psychodynamic therapists use a mix of supportive and expressive approaches, there
are substantial differences regarding the indications for use of supportive therapy. They range from the classical view
that supportive therapy should be prescribed for “low functioning” patients, to the view that this intervention should be
used with “high functioning patients” to scaffold ego functions
supportive therapies help the patient see things more clearly by sustaining reality, and testing and challenging
unrealistic ideas. The clinician must help the patient to regulate a wider range of affects, and to talk about his/her inner
life in a more consistent way.
Therapeutic actions need to be characterized by affective mirroring and interpersonal warmth (Markowitz, 2008).
The supportive intervention should help the patient socialize better with others by strengthening control over socially
unacceptable behavior and encouraging more consistent ways of relating to others (Misch, 2000)
Supportive Psychotherapy
Supportive psychotherapy can serve as the first bridge out of social isolation and marginalization and addresses
personality issues, such as deficits in character structure and defense mechanisms.
Supportive psychotherapy occurs in almost every doctor-patient encounter and is the psychotherapy provided to the
vast majority of patients who are seen in psychiatric clinics and mental health centers.
Intra and extra psychic
In the late 19th century, Freud began to develop the techniques of psychoanalysis, which served as a foundation for all
the other psychotherapeutic modalities
Most of Freud’s patients were members of the upper classes of society and had significant ego strengths, and their
problems were mainly intra-psychic.
In contrast, many of the patients seen by psychiatrists and residents today suffer from extra-psychic problems, such as
poverty, social and political oppression, and abuses of power in relationships that threaten to overwhelm their coping
capacities.
For these patients, supportive therapy is the treatment of choice.
Supportive psychotherapy is a dyadic (of or consisting of a dyad; being a group of two) treatment that uses direct
measures to ameliorate symptoms and to maintain, restore, or improve self-esteem, ego functions, and adaptive skills.
It was developed in the early 20th century, and its objectives are more limited than those of the psychodynamic
therapies.
This therapeutic modality focuses especially on developing adaptive capacities that take into account the patient’s
limitations, including:
Personality issues, such as deficits in character structure and defense mechanisms
Native ability (eg, impaired reality testing, decreased cognitive functioning, lower IQ, learning disabilities)
Problems associated with life circumstances (eg, lower levels of education, low socioeconomic status, limited social
support systems, problems related to migration)
The connection between mental illness and poverty
There is a 2-way connection between mental illness and poverty. Poverty increases the risk of mental illness, and
mental illness is often a person’s path into poverty. In 1965, the sociologist Oscar Lewis published the controversial
document “The Culture of Poverty,” in which he argued that to adapt to their environment, people who live in poverty
for a long time develop a series of coping mechanisms that become engrained and paralyzing and that affect the
individual, the family, the slum community, and the community in relation to society.
Supportive therapy can serve as the first bridge out of social isolation and marginalization, since the 2 most important
elements of supportive therapy are the therapeutic alliance, which allays(diminishes) anxiety, helps support the
patient’s healthy defenses, and enhances adaptive skills; and conversational style.
This style avoids analytic abstinence and engages the patient in a collaborative discussion that decreases the power
differential.
Supportive therapy is also the treatment of choice in individuals with severe personality disorders, at least in the initial
phases of treatment.
Many individuals with personality disorders resent and fear the power differential that results from a more analytic
stance, given that many of them have experienced abuses of power in early life.
If the power differential is not addressed early in the treatment, it can destroy the therapeutic relationship.
Power differential means the difference in power between persons in positions of authority and those individuals in
subordinate positions that result in a vulnerability on the part of the subordinate.
5 Goals of SP
Directing client to make a better adjustment to reality.
In expressive psychotherapy (EP), this is done by strengthening the ego. In contrast, SP accepts the ego more or less as
it is and aims to improve adaption by modifying the demands made upon the ego
clients are encouraged to expose themselves to less stressful situations (external reality), to be less self-critical (super
ego) and wherever possible to repress instinctual demands.
SP aims at symptom reduction, reduction of anxiety, enhances self-esteem, by encouraging positive transference
SP focus on the conscious material, with avoidance of regression during the therapy and encouragement of use of
mature defense mechanisms and adaptive coping mechanisms.
Positive transference in SP
in psychoanalysis, a patient’s transfer onto the analyst or therapist of those feelings of attachment, love, idealization,
or other positive emotions that the patient originally experienced toward parents or other significant individuals during
childhood
negative transference
in psychoanalysis, a patient’s transfer onto the analyst or therapist of feelings of anger or hostility that the patient
originally felt toward parents or other significant individuals during childhood.
Setting and Plan of action
Flexible sessions : one time /week or less
As per need of the patient :Short / intermittent sessions or Long term
Face to Face sessions
Formation of therapeutic alliance
Analysis of transference contraindicated
Focus on conscious external events
Regression in patients discouraged
Patient Population for Supportive Psychotherapy
Character disorders(Character disorder/ Personality disorder --characterized by socially undesirable behavior, as poor
control of impulses or inability to maintain close emotional relationships, and by absence of anxiety or guilt.)
Latent or manifest psychoses ( affecting a person's ability to tell what is real and not real, to act normal, and to think
clearly )
Acute crises
Physical illness
Requisite in patients suitable for SP : Some degree of motivation is needed to enable therapeutic alliance
Basic Goals
Reintegration of self and ability to cope
Stabilization or restoration pf preexisting equilibrium
Strengthening of defenses
Better adjustment and acceptance of pathology
Symptom relief and environmental restructuring as primary goal
Goals of SP
In terms of ingredient, the common factors of psychotherapy, such as affective arousal, providing holding
environment, feeling understood by the therapist, being nonjudgmental, framework of understanding, therapeutic
alliance, optimism in improvement, and success experiences contribute to improvement.
SP basically involves respecting the clients with compassion, empathy, and commitment, irrespective of the fact that
therapist agrees or disagrees with the clients behaviors and thoughts. Basically, the supportive psychotherapist treats
the client, way they want to be treated.
Goals of SP
Another important aspect to understand is the spectrum of psychotherapy, which is considered to extend from SP to
EP, with supportive–expressive and expressive–SP
Clients who are most impaired are usually the candidates for SP, whereas those who are least impaired are considered
for EP.
Moderately impaired clients, who form the major bulk of the clinical load, are usually the candidates for supportive–
expressive and expressive–SP. In clinical practice, it is suggested that most clients will require supportive–expressive
psychotherapy.
Understanding supportive psychotherapy
Supportive psychotherapy stands in contrast to expressive therapies that seek to accomplish personality change
through analysis of the relationship; exploration of previously unrecognized feelings, thoughts, needs, and conflicts;
and development of insight.
The therapist takes into account the patient’s cognitive abilities, reality testing, thought process, capacity to organize
behavior, affect regulation, and capacity to relate to others in order to determine the patient’s location on the
continuum.
Understanding supportive psychotherapy
Purely supportive interventions are chosen for patients with disorganized behavior, thought disorder or cognitive
impairment, limited intelligence, and lower levels of education and socialization and for patients with personality
disorders.
With less impaired patients, expressive therapies are used. It is important for the therapist to be hopeful that the
impaired patient can eventually move across to more psychodynamic supportive therapy and beyond.
Major techniques
Free association contraindicated
Suggestion predominates
Abreaction useful ( expression and consequent release of a previously repressed emotion)
Confrontation : Leaman (1978) defined confrontation as “a direct technique in which the counselor challenges clients
to face themselves realistically.” This view of confrontation as an assertive counselor directed technique that is used to
force the client to look at their lives in an accurate and honest manner
Clarification a therapist's formulation, in clear terms and without indicating approval or disapproval, of a client's
statement or expression of feelings.
Interpretation in here and now
Psychoeducation
ADJUNCT treatment of SP is recommended during Family rehabilitative therapy ,hospitalization ,Patients prescribed
psychotropic drug (antidepressants, anti-anxiety medications, antipsychotics, and mood stabilizers.)
Supportive psychotherapy practice (techniques)
In contrast to more psychodynamic-oriented therapies, one must be careful not to be incisive(analytical/ direct) when
practicing supportive therapy with more vulnerable or regressed patients.
Clarifications, interpretations, and confrontations may embarrass the patient, increase the patient’s anxiety to a level
that he or she is incapable of modulating, and may reawaken memories of abuse. These interventions are more
appropriate for treating patients with neurotic defenses that are analyzed and examined and the conflicts underlying the
defenses identified.
A strong therapeutic alliance is fostered by conveying to the patient acceptance, interest, respect, and admiration for
his or her accomplishments, thus supporting the patient’s self-esteem. Conscious problems are addressed, and defenses
are questioned only when they are maladaptive. The patient is treated with honesty and respect.
Supportive psychotherapy practice (techniques)
Other important techniques used in supportive psychotherapy include behavior goal setting, encouragement, positive
reinforcement, shaping behavior, and modeling.
For change to take place in therapy, interpretive work needs to occur with the patient’s increasing capacity for self-
reflection, but modeling by the therapist provides some of the first and most fundamental building blocks for change.
Supportive therapy may include educating the patient and family members about the illness and about the patient’s
potential and limitations, establishing realistic goals, addressing issues in the life of the patient that will reduce stress
and anxiety, and helping the patient and the family improve their adaptive skills. It may also include limit setting and
appropriate reward and punishment with children, and helping the patient, the family, and others involved to
understand the patient’s functional and cognitive limitations.
Supportive psychotherapy
Indications
MODULE V
Brief Psychodynamic Psychotherapy
Psychodynamic therapy focuses on unconscious processes as they are manifested in the client's present behavior. The
goals of psychodynamic therapy are client self-awareness and understanding of the influence of the past on present
behavior.
In its brief form, a psychodynamic approach enables the client to examine unresolved conflicts and symptoms that
arise from past dysfunctional relationships and manifest themselves in the need and desire to abuse substances.
The theory supporting psychodynamic therapy originated in and is informed by psychoanalytic theory. There are four
major schools of psychoanalytic theory, each of which has influenced psychodynamic therapy. The four schools are:
Freudian, Ego Psychology, Object Relations, and Self Psychology.
Freudian psychology is based on the theories first formulated by Sigmund Freud in the early part of this century and is
sometimes referred to as the drive or structural model. The essence of Freud's theory is that sexual and aggressive
energies originating in the id (or unconscious) are modulated by the ego, which is a set of functions that moderates
between the id and external reality. Defense mechanisms are constructions of the ego that operate to minimize pain
and to maintain psychic equilibrium.
Ego Psychology derives from Freudian psychology. Its proponents focus their work on enhancing and maintaining ego
function in accordance with the demands of reality. Ego Psychology stresses the individual's capacity for defense,
adaptation, and reality testing
Object Relations psychology was first articulated by several British analysts, among them Melanie Klein, W.R.D.
Fairbairn, D.W. Winnicott, and Harry Guntrip. According to this theory, human beings are always shaped in relation
to the significant others surrounding them. Our struggles and goals in life focus on maintaining relations with others,
while at the same time differentiating ourselves from others. The internal representations of self and others acquired in
childhood are later played out in adult relations.
Self Psychology was founded by Heinz Kohut, M.D., in Chicago during the 1950s. Kohut observed that the self refers
to a person's perception of his experience of his self, including the presence or lack of a sense of self-esteem. The self
is perceived in relation to the establishment of boundaries and the differentiations of self from others (or the lack of
boundaries and differentiations)
Kohut postulated that persons suffering from substance abuse disorders also suffer from a weakness in the core of their
personalities--a defect in the formation of the "self." Substances appear to the user to be capable of curing the central
defect in the self.
Psychoanalysis and Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy
Differences and similarities
Therapeutic situation. Patients in analysis lie on a couch with the analyst seated behind out of the patient’s field of
vision. In psychoanalytic psychotherapy, patients and analysts are seated face-to-face.
Basic rule ‘free association’. Both psychoanalysis and psychoanalytic psychotherapy employ the basic rule of free
association whereas, for example, counselling does not. Patients are asked to communicate whatever thoughts,
imaginings, memories occur to them and whatever feelings may be aroused in them during each session.
Frequency. Psychoanalysis has a frequency of three to five sessions per week. Psychoanalytic psychotherapy has a
frequency of one to three sessions per week. Frequency is a function of the depth and intensity of the therapeutic work
needed.
Transference. Transference consists of the repetition of neurosis generating conflicts with parents and siblings in the
patient’s relation to the therapist. It occurs in and is useful therapeutically in both psychoanalysis and psychoanalytic
psychotherapy.
Non-judgemental evenly suspended attention. Analysts and psychoanalytic psychotherapists are non-judgemental.
Their orientation is one of attentive listening to the patient no matter where the patient’s associations may lead and
whatever the patient’s transference thoughts and feelings may be. The patient’s sexual and aggressive feelings and
emotions are especially important.
6.Interpretation. Analysts and psychoanalytic psychotherapists seek to improve their patient’s self-understanding by
interpreting psychological defences that inhibit their ability to become aware of the motivations of their attitudes,
beliefs, relations and actions – the inner sources of their symptoms, inhibitions and moods. Analysts and
psychoanalytic psychotherapists interpret these motivations to facilitate their becoming less conflicted and more
maturation.
Psychoanalysis and Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy
Freud’s discovery and development of psychoanalysis as theory and therapy of psychological disorders was
historically ground breaking. The psychodynamic psychotherapies derive from psychoanalysis. There are differences,
but there are significant similarities.
Psychoanalysis in particular has two meanings. First, it is a theory for understanding clinical presentations, and
perhaps even people in general. It is also used to describe a form of intensive psychotherapy in the most classic sense,
which involves long-term treatment, often for years. The treatment takes place several times a week, with the patient
on a couch and conducted by a therapist who is a certified psychoanalyst.
Theoretical
Classical Freudian theory is the mainstream orientation though modified
These theoretical differences do not alter the basic clinical similarities between psychoanalytic psychotherapy and
psychoanalysis: free associations, transference, non-judgmental attention and their interpretation.
The differences have to do with frequency, duration and the therapeutic set-up.
Psychoanalytic theory, in part developed based on the intensive form of therapy ,guides the practice of psychodynamic
therapy to a large extent, but not completely.
Psychodynamic therapy is psychoanalytic for the most part and makes assumptions about how the mind works that are
based on psychoanalytic theory. It entirely omits the concept of ‘ libido’ from its structure.
It is mostly delivered once per week and takes place face-to-face. The therapist may not be a certified psychoanalyst,
but is someone who trained in psychoanalysis or psychodynamic therapy and considers that his or her therapeutic
orientation.
Practitioners of brief psychodynamic therapy believe that some changes can happen through a more rapid process or
that an initial short intervention will start an ongoing process of change that does not need the constant involvement of
the therapist. A central concept in brief therapy is that there should be one major focus for the therapy rather than the
more traditional psychoanalytic practice of allowing the client to associate freely and discuss unconnected issues
(Malan, 1976).
In brief therapy, the central focus is developed during the initial evaluation process, occurring during the first session
or two. This focus must be agreed on by the client and therapist. The central focus singles out the most important
issues and thus creates a structure and identifies a goal for the treatment.
In brief therapy, the therapist is expected to be fairly active in keeping the session focused on the main issue. Having a
clear focus makes it possible to do interpretive work in a relatively short time because the therapist only addresses the
circumscribed problem area
Types / Models of Brief psychodynamic psychotherapy
10 major approaches to short-term psychodynamic psychotherapy are used.
These approaches differ depending on the extent to which they
use expressive or supportive techniques,
focus on acute or chronic problems,
have a goal of symptomatic change or personality change, and
pay attention to intrapsychic or interpersonal dynamics.
Types / Models of Brief psychodynamic psychotherapy
Mann's Time-Limited Psychotherapy (TLP)
Davanloo's Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy (ISTDP)
SE Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy
The Vanderbilt Approach to Time-Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy (TLDP)
Sifneos' Short-Term Anxiety-Provoking Psychotherapy (STAPP)
The Vanderbilt Approach to Time-Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy (TLDP)
Short-Term Dynamic Therapy of Stress Response Syndromes
Brief Adaptive Psychotherapy (BAP)
Dynamic Supportive Psychotherapy
A Self-Psychological Approach
Interpersonal Psychotherapy (IPT
Mann's Time-Limited Psychotherapy (TLP)
The goal of treatment in TLP is to diminish as much as possible the client's negative self-image through resolution of
the central issue (Mann, 1991). Symptoms are reduced or eliminated as a byproduct of the process.
TLP works via two main components of the treatment: the therapist's identification of the central issue and the setting
of the termination date at the start of treatment.
The central issue is always conceptualized in terms of the client's chronic and presently endured pain, resulting from
painful life experiences. This pain is a privately held, affective statement about how the client feels about himself.
Change comes about through the identification and exploration of the painful feelings about himself and through the
feelings of loss surrounding termination. This model has a set treatment length of 12 sessions and promotes working
through of termination issues.
Bullying is a significant, damaging, and common event in children's school and home life (Maxwell & Carroll-Lind,
1996; Farrington, 1993; Olweus, 1993; Rigby, 1997; Slee, 1993). As a phenomenon, it began to be investigated in the
1970s when Professor Dan Olweus in 1978 surveyed schools in Scandinavia in response to several children suiciding
reportedly as a result of being bullied (Farrington, 1993; Peters, McMahon, & Quinsey, 1992; Tattum, 1993; Rigby,
1996). Since then studies conducted in many countries have investigated the phenomena of school children's bullying
including Spain, Portugal, Scotland, Holland, Ireland, Canada, USA, France, Japan, Australian and New Zealand
(Farrington, 1993; Byrne, 1994). Recent studies have shown that bullying directly effects 15% to 50% of school
children around the world (Farrington, 1993; Olweus, 1993; Clark & Kiselica, 1997). Australasian figures are among
the highest with 10% of New Zealand school children being bullied a week (Maxwell & Carroll, 1996) and
approximately one in every seven Australian children being bullied weekly (Rigby, 1997; Healey, 1995; Nott &
Connor, 1990). Bullying behaviour occurs in all schools globally, regardless of the composition of students or type or
location of school (Tattum, 1993). Children's reactions to bullying differ depending on age, gender or the child's own
coping skills - but the more frequent the bullying the more affected children are likely to be (Rigby, 1997). Studies
clearly show that bullying effects can last into adulthood. Adults who were bullied as children tend to display much
lower self-esteem and higher levels of depression than adults who were not bullied (Olweus, 1993; Clark & Kiselica,
1997). Sem-4/MACLP20C/2021-2022/Even/188298 **Based on above excerpt, what do you think is a suitable choice
of therapeutic intervention?
Oedipus complex
The following are some examples that could be a sign of the complex: a boy who acts possessive of his mother and
tells the father not to touch her. a child who insists on sleeping between parents. a girl who declares she wants to marry
her father when she grows up
Sifneos' Short-Term Anxiety-Provoking Psychotherapy (STAPP)
STAPP is a focal, goal-oriented psychotherapy that is usually practiced in 12 to 15 sessions and sometimes fewer
(Nielsen and Barth, 1991).
During the first session, the therapist and client agree on a clear psychodynamic focus, rather like a treatment contract.
The foci that respond best to STAPP are unresolved Oedipal conflicts, separation issues, and grief may also be
acceptable.
Change comes about through the client's learning to resolve an emotional core problem, essentially problemsolving.
Resolving the problem promotes a feeling of well-being and a corresponding positive change in attitude
Davanloo's Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy (ISTDP)
In ISTDP, therapeutic techniques are used to provoke emotional experiences and, through this, to facilitate corrective
emotional experiences or the positive reenactments, in therapy, of past conflictual relationships (Laikin et al., 1991).
Change comes about by bringing to consciousness these past unresolved conflicts through intense emotional
experiences, reexperiencing them in a more cognitive way, and linking them to current symptoms and problematic
interpersonal patterns.
Extensive use of analysis of the transference relationship also helps to bring the unresolved conflicts to the client's
consciousness so that they can then be explored and resolved.
the ISTDP therapist is an active advocate of change rather than a neutral observer as in traditional analysis. The
attitude of the ISTDP therapist is that the patient's time is irreplaceable and comprehensive change is possible in a
reasonable, cost-effective time frame.
ISTDP has common roots with classical psychoanalysis aimed at treating patients with psychoneurosis
(environmentally acquired mental illness). Both treatments focus on unconscious mental processes (perceptions, past
events, feelings about events, and distorted beliefs) as the cause of neurotic disorders. What distinguishes practitioners
of ISTDP is that we believe that psychological treatment should be both:
Comprehensive and efficient-- (usually under 40 hours) to
Remove symptoms
Change character traits when necessary
Brief Psychodynamic psychotherapy
time limit exerts pressure on the therapy process and creates an expectancy effect, which can have both positive and
negative consequences. Additionally, time limits can be associated to therapists taking on a more directive role in
therapy. Results show that a time limit is anything but a neutral intervention; it is a technique that complexly interacts
with therapy processes on multiple grounds.
Techniques in Brief Psychodynamic psychotherapy ( and Psychodynamic therapies)
Formulation
Transference and resistance interpretations
Offering support
Central issue
current relevance
(b)past issue
Transference interpretation
Clarification
Confrontation of defenses for underlying beliefs ( despite emergence of anxiety)
Explore past conflicts
Explore ego defenses
Explore resistances
CCRT core conflictual relationship theme (SE brief psychodyn. Therapy)
Formulation: A psychodynamic formulation is an hypothesis about the way a person thinks, feels, and behaves, which
considers the impact and development of unconscious thoughts and feelings. Psychodynamic formulations do not offer
definitive explanations; rather, they are hypotheses that we can change over time.
The problems that bring people to mental health treatment are often caused by thoughts and feelings that are out of
awareness – that is, that are unconscious. This is called a psychodynamic frame of reference. A news story gives a
report
of what happened; a psychodynamic formulation offers an hypothesis of why things happened
Construction of psychodynamic formulations by using three steps:
DESCRIBING the patient’s problems and patterns
REVIEWING the patient’s developmental history
LINKING the problems and patterns to the history using organizing ideas about development
Why is she behaving this way?
Why does he think that about himself?
Why is she responding to me like this? Why is that his way of dealing with stress?
Why is she having difficulty working and enjoying herself?
What is preventing him from living the life he wants to lead?
we use this understanding to help patients develop capacities that were not fully formed during their earlier years:
Example: Ms B, a brilliant student, is unable to think highly of her accomplishments. Raised in foster care, she never
received praise for her talents.
Understanding this, her therapist is able to help her to believe that her perception of herself is not always aligned with
her abilities.
Over time, she is able to develop new ways of managing her self-esteem.
Transference interpretation is classically defined as making something conscious to the patient that was previously
unconscious—specifically, that the patient's attributions of certain qualities to the therapist derive from past figures
Find transference during a case:
“Ms. A,” a 23-year-old single female with borderline personality disorder, came to her therapist’s office and reported
an embarrassing episode in which she had shouted at a clerk in a retail store because he would not accept her credit
card as payment for the merchandise she wished to buy. She noted that everyone was staring at her when she shouted,
and she felt that she had made a spectacle of herself. She said she would not have shouted except that the clerk was
rude with her.
*Her psychotherapist asked for clarification: “Was it a policy of the store not to accept credit cards, or was it a matter
that he would not accept your credit card?”
The patient felt that the therapist was suggesting she had overreacted and became furious at him: “What difference
does it make? Even if it was the policy of the store and not directed at me, he still should have been courteous!”
The patient’s irritation then escalated to an explosion of rage in which she screamed at him, “You’re not interested in
empathizing with my feeling of being humiliated—only in figuring out how I caused the whole incident! It’s clear that
you don’t care about me, and you’re only interested in getting all the money you can from my trust fund! Sometimes I
think you try to make me worse by irritating me just so you can keep me in treatment longer!”
The therapist attempted to explain that he was not suggesting that she was to blame for anything, but only asking for
information about the details of the situation.
The therapist paused for a minute and said, “It seems to me that the same thing that happened in the store is happening
here with me. You’re attributing to me some malevolent (negative) intent that isn’t at all where I’m coming from. You
make yourself miserable by reading things into interactions that aren’t really there.”
He is encountering intense transference anger based on what he feels is a misperception on the part of the patient.
Some research demonstrates that patients with borderline personality disorder, in contrast with comparison subjects,
attribute negative qualities to neutral faces, which they may regard as threatening
Analysis of Resistance
The word resistance is most commonly recognized when talking about the flow of electrical current or a military or
political movement. In psychology, specifically in psychotherapy, resistance has a very similar meaning. Resistance in
psychotherapy is often defined differently by different counseling and therapeutic psychologists, but ultimately
involves a client's unwillingness to change and grow within therapy.
There are countless reasons why clients can be resistant within a therapeutic relationship. People of all cultures,
natures, and personalities visit psychologists, each with their own reasons for entering therapy. Some people may be
ordered or referred by a third party to enter therapy.
Since they are not there of their own will, these clients are often reluctant to be there and can show very obvious
resistance to the process.
Most clients begin therapy on their own, for physical health reasons, mental health reasons, and general wellness.
Regardless, many clients show some sort of resistance to the emotional pain that change demands.
Clients can be unwilling and opposed to change even if it is what they desire, as change can be difficult, emotionally
painful, or scary.
Analysis of Resistance
Resistance is loosely defined as a client's unwillingness to discuss a particular topic in therapy.
For example, if a client in psychotherapy is uncomfortable talking about his or her father, they may show resistance
around this topic. While the client may be comfortable talking about other family members, they might change the
subject every time their father comes into the conversation. If the therapist continues to probe this topic, the client may
even show resistance by missing therapy appointments or discontinuing therapy.
Analysing the Resistance
Resistance can take many forms in psychotherapy and affect a client's behavior in many ways. The following is a list
of some forms of resistance which a client may use to keep from dealing with certain topics with their therapist.
Silence or minimal discussion with the therapist
Wordiness or verbosity
Preoccupation with symptoms
Irrelevant small talk
Preoccupation with the past or future
Focusing on the therapist or asking the therapist personal questions
Discounting or second-guessing the therapist
Seductiveness
False promises or forgetting to do what is agreed upon
Not keeping appointments
Failing to pay for appointments
Dealing with Resistance
In psychotherapy, resistance is considered a normal, and sometimes helpful, process. All psychologists and licensed
therapists are trained to deal with the different forms of resistance in their clients. Therapists consider it important to
detect resistance to psychotherapy and interpret why it is occurring. If the therapist can detect and deal with resistance,
they can use it to diffuse the resistance.
The definition of humanism is a belief that human needs and values are more important than religious beliefs or any
ideology . An example of humanism is the belief that the person creates their own set of ethics.
Humanism is, instead, more of a pragmatic philosophy — humans are not necessarily good or evil but they do have
the capacity to do both. It is important then that our social, political, and philosophic institutions be set up in such a
way that we can encourage the good while discouraging the evil
Humanists believe that human experience and rational thinking provide the only source of both knowledge and a
moral code to live by. They reject the idea of knowledge 'revealed' to human beings by gods, or in special books.
Humanism stresses the importance of human values and dignity. It proposes that people can resolve problems through
the use of science and reason. Rather than looking to religious traditions, humanism instead focuses on helping people
live well, achieve personal growth, and make the world a better place
Four characteristics of humanistic psychology
Curiosity – stoic philosophy, the Greek tragedies
A free mind – imaginative , creative , flow ,experimentation .
Belief in moral goodness –The diary of Anne frank , kafka . Camus and Sartre .
Belief in the human race- social issues abolitionists , anti colonial movement , race and gender issue, Franz Fanon –
wretched of the earth .
Humanistic psychology rejects a rigorous scientific approach to psychology because it sees it as dehumanizing and
unable to capture the richness of conscious experience.
As would be expected of an approach that is 'anti-scientific', humanistic psychology is short on empirical evidence.
Humanism is a philosophy or a way of thinking about the world. Humanism is a set of ethics or ideas about how
people should live and act. Humanists prefer critical thinking and evidence (rationalism and empiricism) over
acceptance of dogma or superstition.
Maslow's theory argues that humans have a series of needs, some of which must be met before they can turn their
attention toward others. Certain universal needs are the most pressing, while more “acquired” emotions are of
secondary importance.
There is little evidence that need structures are organized as Maslow proposed, that unsatisfied needs motivate, or that
a satisfied need activates movement to a new need level.
The major problem with Maslow's hierarchy-of-needs theory is that it cannot be verified empirically, because there is
no proper method to measure accurately how satisfied one level of need must be before the next higher need becomes
operative.
Maslow considered only a narrow segment of the human populationThe theory assumes that all people experience
these needs in the same order, failing to recognize cultural and individual differences. In collectivist societies, for
example, social needs may be considered more important than physiological needs.
Maslow's hierarchy of needs continues to be widely popular and mostly well-accepted, but the available evidence does
not necessarily support Maslow's theory.
Importance of the individual in humanistic psychology
The leading question in this case is "What does it mean to be existing as a human being?" This question leads out in a
number of directions.
There is a pressing question concerning what is right and wrong in a world of moral chaos.is it relative ?
There is the daunting issue of what constitutes a meaningful way of life in a world in which all talk of purposes has
become obscure.
There is a realization that the human concerns and human experience count in a world that has proven to be mostly
unknowable. This corresponds to a suspicion of the reductionistic and over-confident ways of science, philosophy, and
metaphysics and also expresses continuity with the instincts of literature, poetry, and art.
The imperative to "be an individual!" takes on great importance as a way of orienting human life in a world described
by these other considerations.
How did humanistic psychology affect the world view?
It changed the way people viewed their life and work – man is not capital
Being rebellious – antiauthoritarian , cults , extreme life styles , movements , experimentation with drugs
Becoming spiritual , holistic , and compassionate
It shows them that they can not be restrained to their social class
They learned that they can achieve a personal best ,their optimal potential .
Humanistic therapy in education
Humanistic teaching believe that knowledge and feelings go hand-in-hand in the learning process. Story
telling ,awareness education ,
Cognitive and affective learning are both important to humanistic viewpoint .
Lessons and activities should focus on the whole student and their being and emotions , not one or the other.
Education vs training
the courage to be – Paul Tillich
Tillich’s formulation expresses this point beautifully: he speaks of our anxiety due to the "threat of non-being." The
forms of non-being are many and various and each prefigures the ultimate loss of being that is death and the ultimate
contingency of being that is birth. Both the chance events and extreme situations of life make evident the threat of
non-being and cause of anxiety.
Being human is finding oneself "thrown" (Heidegger) into a world with no clear logical, ontological, or moral
structure.
We hide from death, from uncertainty, from ourselves, from Being-Itself (Tillich) with enormous creativity but with
self-destructive consequences.
Extreme situations make our hiding impossible and so they often become the focus for philosophical and literary
reflection on human anxiety.
Importance of choice
We see this preeminently in Kierkegaard and Nietzsche. But it is perhaps most colorfully expressed by Karl Rahner
who described human beings as one giant decision (in his case, for or against God).
We are constituted by our decisions.
We cannot appeal to systems of law or convention or tradition as decisively furnishing instructions for life choices;
every choice has to be personally appropriated.
In fact, being human sometimes involves decisions that transcend the realm of moral and conventional concerns.
Views of Eric Fromm
Neo-Freudian and humanistic psychoanalyst
Ran away from Nazism and came to united states in 1933
Social factors in determining personality
Dialectical humanist
Marxist influence in his writing - Mixing Marxism with psychoanalysis creates a strange combination
Later Eastern influences in his writing came into prominence
According to Eric Fromm, man has only one problem “How to overcome his separateness ,how to achieve
union ,how to transcend one’s individual life and find oneness. theme in all major religions and myths .
We all encounter a terrible sense of isolation that we can not escape from as we begin to experience ourselves as
a separate being and feels a deep need to unite himself with his fellow men and the world .ex. In every culture
ostracism and tankhaiya
Parallel between developmental of the individual and the human race. both begin with a sense of deep peace and
belongingness.
The individual felt it with mother. The race feels protected as long as it feels a part of nature .western man under
wing of church s primary ties were not disrupted .
Allport contributed to the trait theory of personality, and is known as a "trait" psychologist. He did not believe that
people can be classified according to a small number of trait dimensions, maintaining that each person is unique and
distinguished by peculiar traits.In one of Allport's own articles, Concepts of Trait and Personality (1927), Allport
states that traits are "habits possessed of social significance" and become very predictable, traits are a unit of
personality. Allport states that the personality of a person is the single most unique thing about a person.
1. Cardinal trait - These traits are rare but is the trait that dominates and shape a person's behavior. These are the ruling
passions/obsessions, such as a need for money, fame, etc.
2. Central trait - These traits are general characteristics found in some degree in every person. These are the basic
building blocks that shape most of our behavior although they are not as overwhelming as cardinal traits. They
influence but do not determine behavior. An example of a central trait would be honesty.
3. Secondary trait - These traits are the bottom tier of the hierarchy and are not as apparent as central traits. Secondary
traits are characteristics seen only in certain circumstances (such as particular likes or dislikes that a very close friend
may know). They must be included to provide a complete picture of human complexity.
A concept of the self—which is consistent, unique, and central in the individual—that was developed by Gordon W.
Allport .
The proprium incorporates body sense, self-identity, self-esteem, self-extension, rational thinking, self-image,
propriate striving, and knowing.
stages of development
Patterned individuality – a specific term on what is everyone’s uniqueness not recognized by others . An Idea of
Emerson
Personality is the unique way in which the person works out his survival .it is not frozen but a static or complete
but remains a dynamic entity throughout life
Self is the central point of focus in the psychology of personality .
Self develops in stages by developing from child’s short term to long term goals of the adult .
Proprium – a concept that distinguishes the animal from the man , child from adult and healthy from the sick”
Traits – chief units of personality structure . Have actual existence. More generalized than a habit .
Mature personality according to Allport
Has a unified philosophy of life
Lives with zest and autonomy
Has a greatly extended sense of self and is accepting of others
Cooperation ,not competition is the essence of life
Gordon W. Allport
People it seems are busy leading their lives in the future ,,whereas psychology for the most part is busy tracing
them into the past .
Humanistic therapy is a mental health approach that emphasizes the importance of being your true self in order to lead
the most fulfilling life. ... Humanistic therapy also involves a core belief that people are good at heart and capable of
making the right choices for themselves.
Negotiation of a contract by formally or informally asking, “ you and I can work through it together .”"Where do we
go from here?"
Empathic understanding of the others frame of reference and subjective experience. ross
Respect for the client's cultural values and freedom to exercise choice .
Exploration of problems through an authentic and collaborative approach to helping the client develop insight,
courage, and responsibility .
Exploration of goals and expectations, including articulation of what the client wants to accomplish and hopes to gain
from therapy .
Clarification of the helping role by defining the therapist's role but respecting the self determination of the client
Assessment and enhancement of client motivation as choice . Both collaboratively and authentically
Demonstration of authenticity by setting a tone of genuine, authentic encounter
Humanistic therapy is a mental health approach that emphasizes the importance of being your true self in order to lead
the most fulfilling life. It's based on the principle that everyone has their own unique way of looking at the world. This
view can impact your choices and actions.
One of the greatest strengths of humanistic psychotherapy is that it emphasizes individual choice and responsibility.
Humanistic psychology satisfies most people's idea of what being human means because it values personal ideals and
self-fulfillment.
Carl Rogers 3 core conditions- The first three conditions are empathy, congruence and unconditional positive regard.
These first three conditions are called the core conditions, sometimes referred to as the 'facilitative conditions' or the
'client's conditions’.
Jayne & Ray's (2015) findings, it is safe to say that therapists can show they are being empathetic to their client by
matching the client's body language and mirroring their verbal style, as well as allowing the client to speak in a way
such that they feel they are really being listened to.
Incongruence is a humanistic psychology concept developed by Carl Rogers which suggests that unpleasant feelings
can result from a discrepancy between our perceived and ideal self. The perceived self is how an individual views
themselves and the ideal self is how an individual wishes they were.
unconditional positive regard-According to Rogers, unconditional positive regard involves showing complete support
and acceptance of a person no matter what that person says or does. The therapist accepts and supports the client, no
matter what they say or do, placing no conditions on this acceptance.
The two main figures responsible for the development of existential therapy are Viktor Frankl and Rollo May. Frankl
and May were strongly influenced by existential philosophy. Both Frankl and May believed that there is a meaning to
all things in life.
Later RD Laing came and elaborated with his work on schizophrenia and mental disorders .
Existential therapy focuses on the anxiety that occurs when a client confronts the conflict inherent in life. The role of
the therapist is to help the client focus on personal responsibility for making decisions, and the therapist may integrate
some humanistic approaches and techniques.
Existential therapy tries to help people find meaning and purpose in their lives. It seeks to end the fear of the
unknown.
A therapist actively encourages patients to use their capacity to make choices and to develop their lives as a way to
maximize their existence, or their reason for being.
Existentialism as a therapy –main features
Hostility to abstract theory for obscuring the roughness and untidiness of daily life
Oscillates between religious thought and atheism
Introduced subjectivity when philosophers emphasized essentialism , objectivity and rationality as a reaction to
medieval ages
freedom
Authenticity
The others
According to existentialism
No difference between essence and existentialism
Man must create his own essence
Father of existence is nothingness
There is no God and no absolute standard of ethical conduct
Each human being must chose what we all must chose to be
Ensoi – existence of something which exists in itself and poursoi –the existence of human beings who project
themselves to values and aims
A branch of knowledge characterized by the fundamental character of subjective processes
to delimit the entire realm of human experiences –perception , fantasy
All beliefs in truth of any kind are suspended
Human being are left with their subjective experiences
In phenomenology one speaks of pure subjectivity and pure experience
Existentialists found two themes in Greek tragedy in conflict with each other Dionyasian passion and ecstasy
and Appolinian serenity and calm they contradict each other .
The task of therapy is to unite the two forces
Uniting the above two will lead to ubermensch – the noble compassionate superman
R .D laing’s theory of existentialism
A sane response to an insane situation. This is Laing's comment about what "going crazy" entailed. Applying Gregory
Bateson's concept of the double bind, in which anything a person does leads to one or another kind of punishing
consequence, he observed that some children are faced with the dilemma of having an identity defined for them that is
fundamentally different from who they experience themselves to be. Their alternatives are to either give up the
parental approval and caretaking they need to survive, in order to be truly themselves, or to give up their own sense of
their identity and comply with parental demands. Faced with this dilemma, most people choose to give up their own
identities and adopts those that are handed to them by parental figures. In some people faced with this situation, the
response is to "go crazy." This is analogous to being inside a tunnel which represents what are normally considered
"sane" thoughts, actions, and feelings, finding that moving in either direction leads to painful experiences (giving up
self, or giving up the other), and in response breaking through the ceiling of the tunnel into what is considered
insanity. (I think, although I am not certain, that this analogy is mine rather than Laing's.)
Family resistance: Laing notes that he often finds that what he thinks is going on in a family bears almost no
resemblance to what anyone in the family experiences or thinks is happening. Often "there is concerted family
resistance to discovering what is going on, and there are complicated stratagems to keep everyone in the dark."
(politics of the family, p. 77)
Metaphors for a family. "The family may be imagined as a web, a flower, a tomb, a prison, a castle," writes Laing. We
may be more aware of our image of the family than of the family itself.
Complementarity: "That feature of relatedness whereby the other is required to fulfill or complete the self.“
Confirmation: Some sign of recognition by another person that is relevant to an evocative act. This may include
disapproval. "Every relationship. . . implies a definition of self by others and other by self. . . A person's 'own' identity
can never be completely abstracted from his identity-for-others." (Self and Others)
Interest in the subjective experience of the schizophrenic. Given his own background, Laing was able to perceive how
pathetically limited and inadequate the conventional psychiatric definitions of schizophrenia are. They are largely
"looking at" from outside, and capture little of the schizophrenic's own experience. Laing tried to capture the structure
of the schizophrenic experience in "The Divided Self," written when he was only twenty-eight years old. Later he
would characterize that early work as too much in an "us-them" mode. His later work explored the nature of
relationships and the workings of schizophrenogenic families. He also included many observations on the way in
which school and other social institutions imprison both children and adults in situations that confuse them about their
own thoughts and feelings, induce them to think they have the socially approved thoughts and feelings that others
want them to, and as a consequences drive them crazy.
Treatment of the schizophrenic. Laing established a treatment facility in a London suburb which housed, I think, about
fifteen or twenty schizophrenic patients and several live-in psychiatric staff persons. (I'm not sure about that number.)
Patients were given no drugs, They were provided with support in the form of daily group therapy, individual therapy,
and ongoing interaction with staff. Staff members were careful to accept the subjective validity of the schizophrenic's
experience of the world. In addition, there was reality-testing in the form of feedback from other group members. No
drugs were administered. In Laing's view, drugs make it more difficult for a person to think and therefore interfere
with the kind of personal work that can lead to true recovery. I read one case history of a member of the psychiatric
staff who shared a room with one patient who defecated in the room and often screamed apparently uncontrollably.
Laing's approach took the existential view that each person, including the schizophrenic is ultimately responsible for
his or her own behavior, and ultimately his or her own recovery. He viewed his role as that of providing conditions
that would facilitate that recovery. For a time there were a number of treatment facilities around the world that
followed the Laingian model. To the best of my knowledge, today it has been largely abandoned, both because it is
very expensive in terms of professional time and effort and drugs are cheaper and can be administered by poorly paid
ward personnel, and because the psychiatric establishment is committed to a medical model rather than an existential
model.
Delusional structures involve a severe mismatch in mapping. In very disturbed people, one finds what may be
regarded as delusional structures, still recognizably related to family situations. The re-projection of the 'family' is not
simply a matter of projecting an 'internal' object onto an external person. It is superimposition of one set of relations
onto another: the two sets may match more or less. Only if they mismatch sufficiently in the eyes of others, is the
operation regarded as psychotic. That is, the operation is not regarded as psychotic per se.
Induction: Projection is done by one person as his own experience of the other. Induction is done by one person to the
other's experience. One does not tell him what to be, but tells him what he is. Such attributions, in context, are many
times more powerful than orders (or other forms of coercion or persuasion.)" One is told one is good, bad, evil, pretty,
sexy, etc.
What the parents tell a child "he is, is induction, far more potent than what they tell him to do. . . . These signals do
not tell him to be naughty; they define what he does as naughty. In this way, he learns that he is naughty, and how to
be naughty in his particular family."
"It is not sufficient to say that my wife introjects my mother, if by projection, and induction, I have maneuvered her
into such a position that she actually begins to act, and even to feel, like her, [perhaps] without ever having met her."
(Politics of the family, 78-9, 119-20))
Paradoxical orders: If correctly executed, they are disobeyed. If they are disobeyed, they are obeyed. "Be
spontaneous." "Don't do what I tell you to."
We have rules against knowing certain rules. "Rule A: Don't. Rule A1: Rule A does not exist. Rule A2: Rule A1 does
not exist."
Psychiatrists as mind-police: "If a and B are incongruent, the mind police (psychiatrists) are called in. A crime
(illness) is diagnosed. An arrest is made and the patient taken into custody (hospitalization). Interviews and
investigations follow. A confession may be obtained (patient admits he is ill, displays insight). . . . The sentence is
passed (therapy is recommended). He serves his time, comes out, and obeys the law in the future." This is how the
"official story of psychiatric consultation, examination, diagnosis, prognosis, treatment. . . is often experienced."
(politics of the family, p. 74)
The situation has to be discovered: "We can never assume that the people in the situation know what the situation is.
There is no a priori reason to believe or disbelieve a story anyone tells us. Different people usually have different
stories about a situation. A psychiatric "history" of the situation is a sample of the situation. It is a story, one person's
way of defining the situation. "Few psychiatrists are experts in sorting out these stories. They are experts in construing
situations of a few standard psychiatric myths." (politics of the family, p. 33-4)
Mapping: A person "maps" some accepted social definition of reality onto his or her experience and then acts as if that
map reflects his or her experience. Or else feels terribly oppressed and unseen, if the personal experience is very
different from the "mapped" pseudo-experience.
Rollo May and his work
May determined that human beings fear death because we cannot comprehend our own lack of existence. However,
May believed that facing these feelings of anxiety and fear was a necessary experience if personal growth and
meaning were to be achieved in life.
What are the four givens of existence?
It was Irvin Yalom who defined the four “givens” of the human condition—death, meaning, isolation, and freedom,
that have formed the cornerstone of modern-day existential therapy, and a method of psychotherapy that enables
clients to face these givens head-on and so move towards living a more “authentic” and free existence.
Existential therapy is good for treating those facing issues of existence, for example, those with a terminal illness,
those contemplating suicide, or even those going through a transition in their life.
existential therapy would suggest that people with addiction disorder are dealing with anxiety and fear because of one
of the essential givens. But, they didn't find a resolution that left them reassured. They then turned to substance use
and misuse.
In Client-Centered Therapy especially values the work in the here-and-now of the therapeutic situation, and the
relationship as most effective therapeutic means; whereas an existential perspective highlights people's orientation
towards the future, their being directed towards and influenced by what is to come.
Existentialism is a philosophical theory that people are free agents who have control over their choices and actions.
Existentialists believe that society should not restrict an individual's life or actions and that these restrictions inhibit
free will and the development of that person's potential.
According to existentialism
Existence is always particular and individual -my existence, your existence, his existence, her existence.
Existence is primarily the problem of existence (i.e., of its mode of being); it is, therefore, also the investigation of the
meaning of Being.
Existentialism is a philosophy that emphasizes individual existence, freedom and choice. ... It holds that, as there is no
God or any other transcendent force, the only way to counter this nothingness (and hence to find meaning in life) is by
embracing existence.
Existentialism can be thought of as the twentieth-century analogue of nineteenth-century romanticism. The two
movements have in common the demand that the whole fabric of life be recognized and taken into account in our
thinking and acting. As such they express a form of resistance to reductionist analyses of life and its meaning for
human beings. But there are also significant differences.
Existentialism is typically focused on individual human lives and the poignant inevitability of suffering and choice for
each individual whereas romanticism tended to be more oriented to the whole of nature and saw human beings as a
part of that wider picture. Furthermore, romanticism flourished before the wars and genocides of the twentieth century
whereas existentialism is born amid those horrors.
From one point of view, the existentialists divide roughly between writers (most famously, perhaps, Albert Camus)
and philosophers. The philosophical existentialists divide roughly between the atheistic and the religious. Søren
Kierkegaard (1813-1855) ["the ultimate anti-Christianity Christian"] is often considered to be the father of them all,
but Friedrich Nietzsche ["the ultimate anti-Christ philosopher"] is a crucial figure at the origins of the developing line
of atheistic existentialism. Religious existentialists included both Jews such as Martin Buber (1878-1965) ["the
Protestant Jew"] and Christians such as Paul Tillich (1886-1965) ["the Christian crypto-atheist infatuated with Being
and God"]. Other religious existentialists include Karl Jaspers, Gabriel Marcel, and Karl Rahner. The atheistic
existentialists include Martin Heidegger (1889-1976) ["the non-Christian atheist infatuated with Being and time"],
though he denied that he was an existentialist, and Jean-Paul Sartre (1905-1980) [the ultimate atheist infatuated with
Being and nothingness]. It is quite a cast of characters. And the classifications make less sense the better you know
them, not least because it is hard to disentangle theism and atheism in the context of existential reflection on human
life. The plan here is to examine a few themes commonly treated by existentialists and then to examine the thought of
Kierkegaard more closely.
Gestalt therapy
Gestalt therapy emphasizes what it calls "organismic holism," the importance of being aware of the here and now and
accepting responsibility for yourself. Existential therapy focuses on free will, self-determination and the search for
meaning.Originated in Frankfurt ,Germany
Postulates of gestalt
The whole is primary and has properties different from sum of its parts
The whole dominates the part and is the primary reality.
The whole is not the sum , product or even a simple function of its parts but whose character depends upon itself
Personality – P=T+F+B
Detailed organization and inter-relationship of things
Centralistic ,importance of organization in memory
Accepted introspection but canged its character .
features of gestalt therapy
Laws of science were laws of systems .
The whole in psychology like physics or chemistry required laws of its own . Psychology needs to do the same
Phenomenological - phenomenology is the study of “phenomena”: appearances of things, or things as they appear in
our experience, or the ways we experience things, thus the meanings things have in our experience. Phenomenology
studies conscious experience as experienced from the subjective or first person point of view .
Overuse of past experience as a explanatory concept or therapeutic change of a person
Learning and problem solving as restructuring of the perceptual field
Gestalt theory emphasizes that the whole of anything is greater than the sum of its parts. That is, the attributes of the
whole are not deducible from analysis of the parts in isolation. The word Gestalt is used in modern German to mean
the way a thing has been “placed,” or “put together.” There is no exact equivalent in English.
The key concepts of gestalt therapy
figure and ground –person and behavior are separate . Position and behavior
balance and polarities – splits within , with others or between wants
Awareness – partial vs total .what is happening now ? What do you experience as I say this
present‐centeredness -
unfinished business – with significant others , with yourself
personal responsibility -
Internal processing occurs through focusing inwards .
Gestalt therapy seeks to resolve the conflicts and ambiguities that result from the failure to integrate features of the
personality. The goal of Gestalt therapy is to teach people to become aware of significant sensations within themselves
and their environment so that they respond fully and reasonably to situations.
Gestalt Therapy rejects the dualities of mind and body, body and soul, thinking and feeling, and feeling and action.
According to Perls, people are not made up of separate components, this is, mind, body and soul, rather human beings
function as a whole.
Essentials concepts of a gestalt session
Therapeutic contract
Owning an aspect of the self you haven’t accepted /owned /are not aware of
Top dog /underdog are trying to compete within and see the contradiction within
Take personal responsibility –from it to I
role of imagination - role reversal
Exaggeration makes you see the absurdity of the situation
Comfort and discomfort
Gestalt's theory of change is known as the paradoxical theory of change because it is based on the apparently
paradoxical premise that people change by becoming more fully themselves not by trying to make themselves be
something or someone they are not: 'Change occurs when one becomes what he is, not when he tries to be someone
else .
What is unfinished business in psychology?in therapy and counseling, the personal experiences that have been
blocked or tasks that have been avoided because of feared emotional or interpersonal effects.
In Gestalt psychology when any aspect of one’s life is left hanging it is called unfinished business. Some common
experiences that are attached to unfinished business are abuse suffered at the hands of primary caregivers, difficult
endings of romantic relationships, and deaths of important people.
Take total responsibility for yourself. It's ultimately up to you to take the necessary actions to help move you forward.
Grieve the loss. Take plenty of time to do this.
Gather your strengths.
Make a plan for the immediate future. Determine what's most important for you moving forward.
Create a ritual.