Group-I (QCBS - 80:20)

Selection of Independent Engineer for Development of ‘Ganga Expressway’ (Group-I)

in the State of Uttar Pradesh on DBFOT (Toll) basis under PPP”
Lowest
Technical Financial Financial Combined Highest Firm with Highest
Firm Financial
Score Proposal Score Score Score Score
Proposal
Aarvee Associates Architects Engineers & Consultants Pvt. Ltd.
95.45 317052300 68.66 90.09
in association with Medhaj Techno Concept Pvt. Ltd.
AYESA Ingenieria y Arquitectura, S.A.U (AYESA) JV FP
92.95 332232819 65.53 87.47
Project Management Consultancy Services Pvt. Ltd. (FP India)
Chaitanya Projects Consultancy Pvt. Ltd. In JV with ISAN
91.34 247802648 87.85 90.64
Corporation.
Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Pvt Ltd. in
Association with Design Line Consultancy Services & E5 98.32 298210500 73.00 93.26
Planning & Services LLP.
Lion Engineering Consultants Pvt. Ltd. in JV with Bloom
95.08 217703300 100.00 96.06
Companies, LLC. Lion Engineering
MSV International INC. 96.32 254700000 85.47 94.15 Consultants Pvt.
Rites Limited in JV with M/s Voyant Solutions Private Limited 217703300 96.06 Ltd. in JV with
and in association with M/s Segmental Consulting &
402773090 54.05 84.16
Bloom
91.69
Infrastructure Advisory (P) Ltd & M/s Eclat Engineering Companies, LLC.
Consultants
SA Infrastructure Consultants Pvt Ltd. JV ALTINOK
Consulting Engineering Inc. and in Association with Uphham 96.72 286503692.6 75.99 92.57
International Corporation
SAI Consulting Engineers Private Limited (SAI) in JV SATRA
92.44 373665795 58.26 85.60
Services and Solutions Private Limited (SATRA)
SHELADIA Associates, Inc., USA in association with M/s
Infinite Civil Solutions Pvt. Ltd. And M/s PNT Designs (Pvt) 93.18 339434797 64.14 87.37
Ltd.
STUP Consultants Pvt. Ltd. in association with Avaloz
75.52 332583300 65.46 73.51
Consultant India Pvt. Ltd.
 Group-II (QCBS - 80:20)
Selection of Independent Engineer for Development of ‘Ganga Expressway’ (Group-II)
in the State of Uttar Pradesh on DBFOT (Toll) basis under PPP”
Technical Lowest Financial Financial Combined Highest Firm with Highest
Firm Financial Proposal
Score Proposal Score Score Score Score
Artefact Projects Ltd. in JV with Dhruv
Consultancy Services Ltd in Association with 91.05 216902500 100.00 92.84
Global Infra Solution.
AYESA Ingenieria y Arquitectura, S.A.U
(AYESA) JV FP Project Management 92.49 3330245812 6.51 75.29
Consultancy Services Pvt. Ltd. (FP India)
Chaitanya Projects Consultancy Pvt. Ltd. In JV
91.34 247802648 87.53 90.58
with ISAN Corporation.
Feedback Infra Pvt. Ltd. in Association with P K
94.29 2781955350 7.80 76.99
Engineers.

Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Pvt

Ltd. in Association with Design Line Consultancy 97.62 294865560 73.56 92.81
Services & E5 Planning & Services LLP.

LEA Associates South Asia Pvt. Ltd. in MSV International

216902500 94.09
Association with Pioneer Infra Consultants Pvt. 95.2 327996000 66.13 89.39 INC.
Ltd. (PCPL)
MSV International INC. 96.32 254700000 85.16 94.09

Rites Limited in JV with M/s Voyant Solutions

Private Limited and in association with M/s
90.69 403506405 53.75 83.30
Segmental Consulting & Infrastructure Advisory
(P) Ltd & M/s Eclat Engineering Consultants

SA Infrastructure Consultants Pvt Ltd. JV

ALTINOK Consulting Engineering Inc. and in
96.78 283985483.6 76.38 92.70
Association with Uphham International
Corporation
SHELADIA Associates, Inc., USA in association
with M/s Infinite Civil Solutions Pvt. Ltd. And 93.18 341124397 63.58 87.26
M/s PNT Designs (Pvt) Ltd.
 Group-III (QCBS - 80:20)
Selection of Independent Engineer for Development of ‘Ganga Expressway’ (Group-III)
in the State of Uttar Pradesh on DBFOT (Toll) basis under PPP”
Lowest
Technical Financial Financial Combined Highest
Firm Financial Firm with Highest Score
Score Proposal Score Score Score
Proposal

Aarvee Associates Architects Engineers & Consultants Pvt.

95.45 342780250 61.78 88.72
Ltd. in association with Medhaj Techno Concept Pvt. Ltd.

AYESA Ingenieria y Arquitectura, S.A.U (AYESA) JV FP

92.49 333429991 63.51 86.69
Project Management Consultancy Services Pvt. Ltd.
Chaitanya Projects Consultancy Pvt. Ltd. In JV with ISAN
91.34 247802648 85.46 90.16
Corporation.
Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Pvt Ltd. in
Association with Design Line Consultancy Services & E5 97.62 298210500 71.01 92.30
Planning & Services LLP.
LEA Associates South Asia Pvt. Ltd. in Association with
96.93 307446000 68.88 91.32 Lion Engineering
Pioneer Infra Consultants Pvt. Ltd. (PCPL) Consultants Pvt. Ltd.
Lion Engineering Consultants Pvt. Ltd. in JV with Bloom 211762300 95.32
Companies, LLC.
94.15 211762300 100.00 95.32 in JV with Bloom
MSV International INC. 95.81 256700000 82.49 93.15 Companies, LLC.
Rites Limited in JV with M/s Voyant Solutions Private
Limited and in association with M/s Segmental Consulting &
91.03 397498270 53.27 83.48
Infrastructure Advisory (P) Ltd & M/s Eclat Engineering
Consultants
SA Infrastructure Consultants Pvt Ltd. JV ALTINOK
Consulting Engineering Inc. and in Association with 96.72 282979077 74.83 92.34
Uphham International Corporation
SHELADIA Associates, Inc., USA in association with M/s
Infinite Civil Solutions Pvt. Ltd. And M/s PNT Designs (Pvt) 93.97 342908071 61.75 87.53
Ltd.
 Group-IV (QCBS - 80:20)
Selection of Independent Engineer for Development of ‘Ganga Expressway’ (Group-IV)
in the State of Uttar Pradesh on DBFOT (Toll) basis under PPP”
Lowest
Technical Financial Financial Combined Highest
Firm Financial Firm with Highest Score
Score Proposal Score Score Score
Proposal
Aarvee Associates Architects Engineers &
Consultants Pvt. Ltd. in association with Medhaj 95.45 341550642.5 66.69 89.70
Techno Concept Pvt. Ltd.
AYESA Ingenieria y Arquitectura, S.A.U (AYESA)
JV FP Project Management Consultancy Services 92.45 333482849 68.31 87.62
Pvt. Ltd. (FP India)
Chaitanya Projects Consultancy Pvt. Ltd. In JV with
91.34 247802648 91.93 91.46
ISAN Corporation.
M/s Dhruv Consultancy Services Ltd. In JV with
Artefact Projects Ltd. in Association with Global 96.44 227796500 100.00 97.15 M/s Dhruv
Infra Solution. Consultancy Services
Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Pvt Ltd. Ltd. In JV with
227796500 97.15
in Association with Design Line Consultancy 98.32 294865560 77.25 94.11 Artefact Projects Ltd.
Services & E5 Planning & Services LLP. in Association with
Rites Limited in JV with M/s Voyant Solutions Global Infra Solution.
Private Limited and in association with M/s
91.03 397498270 57.31 84.29
Segmental Consulting & Infrastructure Advisory (P)
Ltd & M/s Eclat Engineering Consultants
SA Infrastructure Consultants Pvt Ltd. JV ALTINOK
Consulting Engineering Inc. and in Association with 96.78 281483520.2 80.93 93.61
Uphham International Corporation
SHELADIA Associates, Inc., USA in association
with M/s Infinite Civil Solutions Pvt. Ltd. And M/s 93.97 342974489 66.42 88.46
PNT Designs (Pvt) Ltd.