Arabic and English Consonants: A Phonetic and Phonological Investigation
Arabic and English Consonants: A Phonetic and Phonological Investigation
Arabic and English Consonants: A Phonetic and Phonological Investigation
ISSN: 2203-4714
Vol. 6 No. 6; December 2015
Flourishing Creativity & Literacy
Australian International Academic Centre, Australia
Abstract
This paper is an attempt to investigate the actual pronunciation of the consonants of Arabic and English with the help of
phonetic and phonological tools like manner of the articulation, point of articulation, and their distribution at different
positions in Arabic and English words. A phonetic and phonological analysis of the consonants of Arabic and English
can be useful in overcoming the hindrances that confront the Arab EFL learners. The larger aim is to bring about
pedagogical changes that can go a long way in improving pronunciation and ensuring the occurrence of desirable
learning outcomes.
Keywords: Phonetics, Phonology, Pronunciation, Arabic Consonants, English Consonants, Manner of articulation,
Point of articulation
1. Introduction
Cannorn (1967) and Ekundare (1993) define phonetics as sounds which is the basis of human speech as an acoustic
phenomenon. It has a source of vibration somewhere in the vocal apparatus. According to Varshney (1995), Phonetics
is the scientific study of the production, transmission and reception of speech sounds. It studies the medium of spoken
language. On the other hand, Phonology concerns itself with the evolution, analysis, arrangement and description of the
phonemes or meaningful sounds of a language (Ramamurthi, 2004). Phonology, according to Simpson (1972), is the
statement or description of the lingual stoically relevant suprasegmental features, the phonetic system, Allophones, their
distribution and the phonological structure. Ekundare (1993) simply puts phonology as “The study of the properties of
the sound system of a language which speakers have mastered or internalized by the time they are competent users of
it”.
However, the entire sound system works towards the production of what we know as language. Language has been
variously defined. Some of these definitions are listed here:
‘Language is a system of conventional spoken or written symbols by means of which human beings, as
members of a social group and participants in its culture, communicate.’—Encyclopedia Britannica
‘Language is the expression of ideas by means of speech sounds combined into words.’—Henry Sweet (an
English phonetician and language scholar).
‘Speech is the representation of the experience of the mind.’—Aristotle (Greek philosopher).
‘A language is a system of arbitrary vocal symbols by means of which a social group cooperates.’—Bloch and
Trager (American linguists).
‘Language is undoubtedly a kind of means of communication among human beings. It consists primarily of
vocal sounds. It is articulatory, systematic, symbolic and arbitrary.’—Derbyshire
2. Literature Review
One of the very early EFL studies on Egyptian learners gives an enlightening insight into the problem area of
suprasegmentals for Arabic speaking English learners. Richard Beym in English as a Foreign Language in Egypt
(1956) has this to say about Arabic speaking learners of English: “In teaching Arabic speakers to speak English one
must consider intonational patterns. The intonational pattern that Arabic speakers use in their own language are often
carried over into English… This is due to the fact that some important phonological aspects of the foreign language has
not been presented to the Arabic speakers”.
Further, and more significantly for the current study, he says: “Spoken Arabic…has no gliding pitches except in the
terminal syllable of an utterance. The continuum of pitch sequences in Arabic is not a smooth flow, one leading into the
next, producing a jump like sequence. This Arabic phenomenon produces (when carried over) a choppy, sing song
English. With rare exception, such supra-segmental phonemes of English are not taught…
A major phonetic stumbling block in teaching English to the Arabic speakers is the problem of avoiding non-
permissible variations in vowel quality. In spoken Arabic the emphatic consonants (sometimes called velarized or
retroflex consonants) have a strong influence upon preceding or following vowels…In attempts to produce the vowel
sound in “sear” when sating “sir”. The cause of this coloration (a phonemic distinction in English) is that the English
word is heard to begin with what is recognized by the Arabic speaker as the non-emphatic spirant consonant.
Numerous studies have been conducted ever since in different languages the world over to measure and analyse the
interference of the mother tongue on English in L2 or EFL speakers. In a larger context, such studies enable the L2 or
ALLS 6(6):146-152, 2015 147
EFL teaching community to identify and check the areas of interference and bring the EFL speaker’s language closer to
that of the native speaker. In fact in the United States, where a Master’s Degree is offered in TESOL, topics in
Phonology represent important opportunities for preparing language teachers to meet the speech intelligibility needs of
L2 learners. John M. Murphy (1997) aptly highlighted the significance of learning sound systems in an article based on
a survey of these courses.
In an EFL study in Japan, Riney et al. (2000) studied Segmentals and Global Foreign Accent. They investigated the
relationship between global foreign accent and a more discrete feature of pronunciation- the substitution of the Japanese
flap [ɾ] for English liquids [r] and [l]. The principal finding was a strong negative correlation between percentages of
Japanese flap substitutions and accent ratings. In simple words it meant that when speech samples where the English
liquids were substituted by the Japanese flap were rated for accentedness, the outcome was not significant. The
discussion, however, addressed debate over teaching segments versus supra-segments and related pedagogical priorities.
In another article on modification of the sound of a word or morpheme when juxtaposed with another, especially in
fluent speech, Elizabeth Zsiga (2011) presents the results of an acoustic study of nasal assimilation and gestural overlap
at word boundaries in Korean and Korean-accented English. Twelve speakers of Seoul Korean recorded phrases
containing obstruent# nasal and obstruent# obstruent sequences in both Korean and English. Nasalization of the word-
final obstruent, predicted by the rules of Korean phonology, occurred in 93% of obstruent# nasal sequences in Korean
and in 32% of such sequences in Korean-accented English, a rate of application higher than that reported in most other
studies of external sandhi alternations in nonnative speech. Acoustic analysis found categorical nasalization in the L1
Korean productions, but both categorical and gradient nasalization, along with a high degree of inter- and intra-speaker
variation, in the L2 English productions.
3. Speech sounds: A research problem
Whereas for the layperson there are two classifications of speech sounds or phonemes of English: vowels and
consonants literature on the subject classifies them into a larger number of categories. According to Trager and Smith as
quoted by Varshney, there are forty five phonemes for English. These are:
9 simple vowels
3 semi vowels
21 consonants
4 stresses
4 pitches
1 plus juncture
3 terminal juncture In Arabic, however, the number of consonant phonemes or sounds is 28 and of vowel sounds is a
mere 3 (or 6 if we also count all of the longer and shorter sounds). Further, the feature of length applies to both
consonants and vowels in Arabic whereas it applies only to the vowel sounds in English. As opposed to English, Arabic
is rich in three particular sounds, viz. uvular, pharyngeal and pharyngealized.
Speaking of historical linguistics, English and Arabic belong to two different language families. This may account for
the diverseness of the two languages. English, much like German, Flemish, Dutch and Norwegian, belongs to the
Germanic group of Indo European family of languages. Arabic is a member of the Afro Asiatic or Hamito Semitic
family of languages: a family that flourished in north Africa and southwestern Asia. It shares the dias with Egyptian,
Berber, Cushitic and Chad.
Given these facts, it is not surprising that English poses a major challenge for the average Arabic speaking learner.
However, it is a challenge that can be overcome with identification of sound differences between the two languages.
4. Articulators
Articulators are those organs of speech which take part in the production of speech sound. We describe them in
categories; active articulators (mobile articulators) like, tongue, lower lip etc. and passive articulators (immobile
articulators) like- upper lip, teeth, hard palate, soft palate, uvula, pharynx, alveolar ridge etc.
Arabic consonants
Point Bilabial Labiodentals Dental Alveolar Palate- Palatal Velar Uvular Pharyng Glottal Labio-
alveolar eal velar
Manner
References
Adetunji, B., Waheed, R.O. (2010). Phonetic and Phonology in Comparative analysis of Arabic and English Language.
Nigerian Journal of Research and Production 17(2).
Al-Hattami, A.A. (2010). A Phonetic and Phonological Study of the Consonants of English and Arabic. Language in
India,10.
Al-Saqqaf, A.H., Vaddapalli, M.K. (2012). Teaching English Vowels to Arab Students: A Search for A Model and
Pedagogical Implications. International Journal of Educational Science and Research, 2.
Cannor, J.D.O. (1967). Better English pronunciation. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Ekundare F. (1993). Phonetics: An introductory handbook. Ibadan: Commercial Printing Works.
Ramamurthi, L. (2004). A History of English Language and Elements of Phonetics. Chennai: Macmillan India Limited.
Roach, P. (2009). English Phonetics and Phonology: A Practical Course. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sethi, J., Dhamija, P.V. (2010). A Course in Phonetics and Spoken English. New Delhi: PHI Learning Pvt. Ltd.
Simpon J.M. (1972). Notes on phonology: Ordinary class in linguistics and Phonetics, Scotland: University of Glasgrow
Press.
Syal, P., Jindal, D.V. (2013). An Introduction to Linguistics. New Delhi: PHI Learning Pvt. Ltd
Varshney, R L. (1995). An Introductory Textbook of Linguistics and Phonetics. Bareilly: Student Store