Beden Imajına Feminsit Bir Terapi Yaklaşımı
Beden Imajına Feminsit Bir Terapi Yaklaşımı
Beden Imajına Feminsit Bir Terapi Yaklaşımı
To cite this article: Mary Bergner , Pam Remer & Charles Whetsell (1985) Transforming
Women's Body Image, Women & Therapy, 4:3, 25-38, DOI: 10.1300/J015v04n03_04
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the
information (the “Content”) contained in the publications on our platform.
However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no
representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or
suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinions and views expressed
in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors, and are not the
views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content should
not be relied upon and should be independently verified with primary sources
of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions,
claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities
whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection
with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes.
Any substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-
licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly
forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://
www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
Downloaded by [University of New Hampshire] at 15:47 04 March 2015
Transforming Women's Body Image:
A Feminist Counseling Approach
Mary Bergner
P a m Remer
Charles Whetsell
Downloaded by [University of New Hampshire] at 15:47 04 March 2015
The negative self-view that many women have toward their own
bodies has been identified as an important issue for feminist thera-
pists and researchers (Gilbert, 1980; Hutchinson, 1983). In a study
by Hutchinson (1983), nearly all of the 122 women sampled had
held or currently held a negative body image. Very little research
has been done on women's body image and most counseling in-
tervention approaches have focused on changing the body itself
(through exercise or dieting) rather than helping women learn to ap-
preciate the bodies they have.
Prior research on body image has had a primarily androcentric
orientation because it has failed to give adequate weighting to the
unique socialization women undergo (Brodsky & Hare-Mustin,
1980). One important aspect of a woman's social learning is the
equation of physical attractiveness with self-worth, with attractive-
ness being culturally derived and determined by others in the envi-
ronment (Greenspan, 1983).
The different perspectives of men and women in relating to their
bodies is illustrated in a study by Gold and Berger (1978). They
found a positive correlation between physical attractiveness and
popularity for elementary school-aged girls while for same-aged
boys popularity was linked to athletic performance. Similar findings
have been obtained in research on adolescents and young adults
(Lerner & Brackney, 1978; Morse, Gruzen & Reis, 1974; Musa &
Roach, 1973). These studies concluded that a lack of attractiveness
is a social liability for females significantly more than for males in
this culture.
Mary Bergner. Pam Remer and Charles Whetsell are faculty in the College of Education
at the University of Kentucky.
Women & Therapy, Vol. 4(3). Fall 1985
O 1985 by The Hnworth Press. Inc. All rights reserved. 25
26 WOMEN & THERAPY
Thus, body image, the value laden thoughts and feelings about
one's body (Hutchinson, 1981), is derived from cultural influences,
and as such is an internalized representation of cultural norms
(Wooley & Wooley, 1980). From a social learning theoretical
perspective, the individual woman internalizes these social values in
the form of self-statements and cognitions which she believes
originate within herself and which she experiences as objective reali-
ty. Negative self-evaluation and feelings arise from what may ap-
pear as individual problems, but which actually originate from the
socio-political environment of the woman. Feminist writers such as
Hutchinson (1981, 1983) and Greenspan (1983) argue that this is the
etiology of negative body image since the vast majority of women in
our culture are at odds with their bodies.
Hutchinson (1981) has researched the efficacy of a visuo-kines-
thetic imagery intervention in changing the negative body image in
physiologically and psychologically healthy women. The majority
of the women in her study saw themselves and their bodies in a sig-
nificantly more positive way as a result of the treatment.
The .investigators of the present study sought to improve female
subjects' self-esteem and body image through three different group
counseling treatments (Visual, Kinesthetic and Visual-kinesthetic)
based on the cognitive restructuring principles of Rational Behavior
Therapy (Maultsby, 1984) and on social-learning principles (Ban-
dura, 1977). In the present study body image was defined as the
mental representation of embodiment which encompasses feelings,
attitudes and beliefs about the body (Hutchinson, 1981). These
thoughts and feelings are value laden and tend to cluster into a total
body cathexis which describes the degree of satisfaction or dissatis-
faction with the body (Jourard & Secord, 1955).
The purpose of this present paper is to describe these group
counseling interventions for negative body image in women and
outline the more salient body and sex-role issues that emerged for
the women in the groups. In addition, results of the differential im-
Bergner, Remer, and Whetsell 27
METHOD
Downloaded by [University of New Hampshire] at 15:47 04 March 2015
Subjects
Three eight-week-long small groups were run concurrently
wherein women were given the means to restructure their sex-role
stereotyped thoughts and feelings about their bodies in ways that
were more personally useful to them. All the subjects joined the
groups voluntarily in response to posters which wereentitled "Trans-
forming Body Image," and all subjects perceived themselves as
having negative body images. Four-fifthspf the subjects fell within
the desired healthy range of weight for their height (National Center
for Health Statistics, 1980). Four subjects (less than one-fifth) were
not within their weight range and were more than 20 pounds over-
weight. The 24 subjects were Caucasian women ranging in age from
21 to 63 with a median age of 36. Twelve were married and 12 were
employed outside the home. The subjects were randomly assigned
to one of the three treatment groups or to a waiting list control
group.
Instrumentation
All subjects were given the Jourard-Secord Body-CathcxislSelf-
Cathexis Scale (BCISC) (Secord & Jourard, 1953) two weeks prior
to the start of the groups and again during the last week of treatment.
The BCISC scale consists of 110 items. The 54 body-cathexis items
measure the degree of satisfaction with aspects of physical appear-
ance and performance. The 56 self-cathexis items measure satisfac-
tion with self. The instrument yields body-cathexis, self-cathexis
and total cathexis scores.
Treatments
All three groups were co-led by the first and third authors. One
leader was a female counseling psychology graduate student who is
training to be a feminist therapist and has had special training in Ra-
28 WOMEN di THERAPY
Interventions
Week One. The first group session opened with each woman shar-
ing her hopes and expectations for the group. Common themes were
poor self-esteem based on negative body image, anger at the media
for its continued message that worth equals physical attractiveness,
lack of bodily confidence, and sexual dysfunction related to poor
body image.
A didactic section ofs each group included information-giving
regarding the nature of self-talk, how it arises in response to specific
events, and how it leads to particular emotional states (Maultsby,
1984). The group then did an exercise which focused group atten-
tion on the self-talk elicited when their bodies were under observa-
tion either by themselves or by others. This was accomplished dif-
ferently for each group, depending on their representational system
focus, through the use of mirrors (Visual), stage performance (Kin-
esthetic) or video-recording equipment (Visual-kinesthetic).
Week Two. The group sessions began with a processing of the
homework assignments. The didactic portion focused on how choice
of language (i.e., thinking) can shift attributions from inside to out-
side, thus effecting a change in perceived locus of control from in-
ternal to external. Next, each member imagined herself in several
different life situations (e.g., nursing mother, young athlete, busi-
nesswoman, old woman) and noticed what assumptions arose about
30 WOMEN & THERAPY
ing available in the area should hey choose to continue their work.
RESULTS
way, they also believe they should be able to control how they look
and often experience the profound guilt and depression inherent in
the double bind of "I have to but I can't ." This phenomena was
observed in our group members across several issues, including
body weight, body height, aging, sexuality, and physical perfor-
mance.
Many group members found it difficult or impossible to actually
focus on themselves in a mirror or on a video tape. They experienced
a marked inability to describe objectively what they were seeing and
Downloaded by [University of New Hampshire] at 15:47 04 March 2015
DISCUSSION
Congruent with Hutchinson's (1983) finding that a majority of
her sampled women had or had had a negative body image, 80% of
the subjects in the current research were within the desired weight
Downloaded by [University of New Hampshire] at 15:47 04 March 2015
Table 1
Means and Scandard Deviations for Cachexis Inventory Across Treatment GroupS
d
Visual Group a Kinesthetic Group Visual-Kinesther ic Group Control Group
Pretest Posttest Pretesc Posttest Pretest Posttest Pretest Posttest
Measure M SD H SD M SD M SD I4 SD M SD M SD H SD
Body Cathexis 3.01 .32 3.67 .34 3.03 .38 3.29 .23 2.89 .49 3.27 .50 3.09 .14 3.23 .41
Self Cathexis 2.85 .59 3.61 .64 3.09 .09 3.41 .51 2.97 .73 3.62 .51 3.31 .42 3.04 .45
Total Cathexis 2.94 .45 3.64 .43 3.06 .22 3.35 .35 2.93 .46 3.45 .43 3.2 .28 1 .38
Bergner, Remer, and Whetsell 37
REFERENCES
Bandura. A. (1977). Social learning Theory. Englewwd Cliffs. N.J.: Prcntice-Hall.
Brodsky. A. & Hare-Mustin, R. (1980). Psychotherapy and women: Priorities for research.
In A. Brodsky & R. Hare Muslin (Eds.). Women andps)~cholherapy. New York: Guil-
ford Press.
Gilbert. L.A. (1980). Feminist therapy. In A. Brodsky & R. HarcMustin (Eds.). Womrnand
psyct~olherap)~.New York: Guilford Press.
Gold, D. & Berger, C. (1978). Problcm-solving pcrfarmancc of young boys and girls as a
function of task appropriateness and sex identity. SEX Roles. 4pJ. 183-193.
Greenspan. M . (1983). A new approach ro Women and 7herapy. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Hutchinson. M . (1981). The effect of a treatment based on the use o f guided visuo-kinesthe-
tic imagery on the alteration of ncgalivc body-cathcxis women. Unpublished doctoral
dissertation. Boston University.
Hutchinson. M . (1983). Transforming body-image: Your body, friend or foe? Women &
Therap),. 1 . 59-67.
Jourard. S. & Secord.. P. (1955).
. . Bodv-cathcxis
,
A b n o r m l and Social Psychology, 50. 243-246.
-
and Ihc ideal female Reure. J o u m l of
Lemer. R. & Brackney. B. (1978). The importance of inner and outer body parts attitudes in
the self-conccpt of late adolescents. Sen Roles. 4(2), 225-238.
WOMEN & THEFAPY
S T A T E : Z I P :- _ _
Send this f o r m to: THE HAWORTH PRESS. Inc.,
2 8 East 2 2 n d Street. N e w York. NY 10010