Organic Certification Requirements
Organic Certification Requirements
Organic Certification Requirements
The Texas Department of Agriculture’s Organic Certification Program certifies food and
fiber crops produced under an organic farming system of ecological soil management
that relies on building humus levels through crop rotations, recycling organic wastes,
and applying balanced mineral amendments. Organic crops are produced without the
use of synthetic pesticides, synthetic fertilizers and synthetic herbicides.
Certification Classifications
Organic- requires three years without the use of prohibited materials
Transitional- applies to crops harvested beginning 12 months after the last application of
a prohibited material, until three-year requirement is met.
Certification Requirements
Requirements for all applicants:
Submit a completed application form (TDA Q696) with all required supporting
documentation.
Pay applicable fees
On-site inspection to verify compliance
Residue testing of producers
Program review and evaluation
Soil management
Maintenance of good soil health is the foundation of organic production. One of the
most highly touted means of achieving good soil health is through increasing soil
organic matter. Since most Texas soils contain 1% or less organic matter, this can be a
long term, highly challenging process. High soil temperatures can cause rapid
decomposition of applied organic matter, requiring large volume applications over long
periods of time. Studies have shown that it is unreasonable for a grower to expect to
increase soil organic matter by more than 1% (2). For instance, an acre of dry soil six
inches deep weights approximately 2,000,000 pounds. To increase the soil organic
matter content by 1% will require the application of 20,038 lbs/A (460 lbs/1000 2 feet).
Unfortunately most organic matter sources contain 25% or more ash (inorganic matter).
Consequently, to achieve a 1% increase of actual organic matter with a source
comprised of 50% moisture and 25% ash, 80,000 lbs/A would need to be applied and
incorporated into the soil profile (2). To further challenge a producer, this will be needed
on an annual basis! It is understandable how such volume application can pose real
delivery, distribution and handling problems. Fortunately, benefits from applied organic
matter can be achieved at much lower rates. As little as 8712 lbs/A applied organic
matter has been shown to improve soil tilth, and, 21,780 lbs/A, improved plant growth
(2). Much of the response to applied organic matter is in its ability to improve; water
retention and infiltration rate, soil aggregate stability, cation-exchange capacity, soil
biological activity, as well as, serve as a reservoir for organic acids and plant nutrients
such as nitrogen. The end result is a more favorable soil microclimate for plant root
development and function. This in turn results in improved plant growth and yield (17).
However, large quantities of organic matter may stimulate soil borne pathogens and
insects such as wireworm, cabbage maggot, and whitefly that can cause serious
damage to crops.
The primary element of concern in vegetable production is nitrogen. Not only is this
element normally required in large quantities to satisfy most crop needs, it is highly
mobile in the soil and is easily lost due to leeching. As a result, nitrogen levels can be
undergoing almost constant changes in the soil. This is especially true for light, sandy
soils and in high rainfall areas. Unfortunately, soil tests generally are not reliable
indicators for nitrogen availability or nitrogen fertilizer requirements(11). With organic
production where nitrogen fertilization or availability is depended upon decomposition of
organic matter and/or fixation by living organisms, soil test for this element may be even
less reliable then with conventional production. However, through experience gained
from supplemental fertilization and crop response, soil testing can be a helpful tool for
nitrogen need determination. Table 4 contains information useful in interpreting soil test
results.
A complement to soil analysis for monitoring plant nutrient status during the growing
season is tissue analysis. Tissue for analysis can be taken any time during the growing
season. If results show deficiencies of a given nutrient is present in the plant(s), a
grower can then take steps to correct the situation by adjusting his fertility program.
Table 6 lists the ratio of these elements found in tissue samples across plant types
(fruit, vegetables, and ornamentals). Based on this data, N, P, K is found in all
horticultural plant species in a 5-1-2 ratio. Where possible, soil nutrient availability
should be in this ratio as well. The data for soil removal by a given yield of vegetable
crops follows this ratio to a certain extent, Table 4 of the appendix. Unfortunately, most
organic fertilizer sources, Table 5 of the appendix, do not allow for the precision of
supplying in the normal removal rates for vegetable crop nutrients or in the ratio shown
in Table 6. In addition, the actual percentage of N, P, and K contained in the usual
organic sources is low. Consequently, huge volumes of these materials are needed to
meet the crop demands.
Cation exchange capacity (CEC) determines availability of nutrients in soils. Cations are
positively charged particles(ions) of elements, the most important of which are Ca, Mg,
Fe, NH4, Na and H2. Clay soil particles and organic matter have negatively charged
ions. As a result, the cations of the various plant nutrients can be attached to and held
on the surface of these soil particles. CEC is a measure of the quantity of cations that
can be absorbed or held by a soil. Soil organic matter has a very high CEC. Thus, soils
with high organic matter typically have a higher CEC than soils with low organic matter.
These soils also typically can store and supply nutrients to plants more readily than soils
with a low organic matter content. Table 7 lists the typical CEC of some soil texture
classes (27).
Once a crop’s nutrient needs are determined, the next decision to be made is designing
an effective fertility program is what source for nutrients best fit the overall production
system. The nutrient sources most often used in organic production are: green manure
and cover crops; manure; compost; and sludge. Availability and cost usually determines
which of the above is used on a given crop. However, a sound fertility program will
include green manure and cover crops in combination with one or more of the other
sources. Green manure and cover crops containing a N-fixing legume are the most
economical and beneficial means of supplying nutrient (11). These crops are usually
planted in rotation with economic or cash crops and serve to improve soil tilth and water
holding capacity as well as to replenish soil nitrogen and other nutrients (17). A green
manure crop is so called because it is one, which is planted for the purpose of plowing
into the soil while still green and prior to harvest maturity. Depending upon species,
some green manure crops may require as many as 120 – 160 days of growth in order to
fix 100 – 200 lbs N/A. Research suggest that available N from a green manure crop will
increase over a 4-6 week period following soil incorporation and then return to pre-
incorporation levels. Therefore, crops following a green manure crop may need to
receive supplemental applications of N from another organic source such as compost or
manure tea (11). Legumes are the green manure crops of choice due to their efficiency
in fixing N. These crops can add as much as 30 –125 lbs N/A if properly grown and
managed (2). Suggestions for green manure crops, seeding rates and N contributions
can be found in the following Table 11.
Table 11. Green manure crops for use in enhancing soil health.
Seeding rate Nitrogen value (lbs/ton dry
Crop Season Type
(lbs/A) matter)
Buckwheat Summer 75 Non legume 14
Crimson clover Winter 15 Legume 45
Rye Winter 75 Non legume 21
Cowpea Summer 90 Legume 60
Sorghum Summer 75 Legume 46
Sudan grass Summer 25 Non legume 28
Vetch Winter 30-50 Legume 62
Wheat Winter 75 Non legume 20
Source: Growing Vegetables Organically. George Boyhanon, Darbie Grandberry, W.
Terry Kelly and Wayne McLaurin. Univ. Georgia Cooperative Extension Service B1 011.
A cover crop is one which is usually planted during the cropping season in which a field
is usually left fallow. Such crops may or may not be harvested as a cash crop. Although
non legume cover crops do not contribute much N, they can trap it and mine other
nutrients from deep with in the soil profile and bring them to the surface where they can
then become available to the following cash crop once they are plowed into the soil
(11). Some research also suggests that cover crops maybe key to the development of
humic acid fractions of the soil. Increasing humus in soils is one of the primary precepts
of organic production. Decomposing organic matter can also contribute P, K, S, Ca, and
Mg to the soil nutrient pool. An additional benefit of green manure and/or cover crops is
that they tend to reduce N leeching (17).
The use of cover crops, however, can have some adverse effects in cropping systems.
They can serve to deplete soil moisture supplies, limit options for cropping sequences,
and temporarily immobilize plant nutrients, increase pest problems and increase
production cost. Therefore, the key to effective and profitable use of such crops lie in
creative management designs to enable a producer to take advantage of their benefits
within a rotation without missing income opportunities as a result of a missed cash
cropping season (17). Animal waste or manure is the oldest fertilizer source used by
man to produce a crop. These waste products are still widely used today and are the
backbone of organic fertilization programs. The more commonly used manure and their
relative nutrient content can be found in Table 5 in the appendix. Although manure is a
good organic fertilizer it should be remembered that the use of fresh manure is to be
avoided. Ammonia is released during the decomposition of fresh manure, which can be
injurious to plants (25). In addition, fresh manure contains a large quantity of moisture
which cause problems in handling and uniformity of distribution in a field. It also tends to
increase the cost of transportation and handling. Aged manure is a better choice but
problems with uniformity of distribution still occur. Therefore, properly composted
manure is the most desirable choice for use in crop production. The composting
process, if properly employed, reduces the moisture content and kills most of the
harmful bacteria. Pulverization of the composted organic fraction reduces transportation
costs and improves uniformity of distribution. Although compost is a relatively
economical source of plant nutrients, composts can be quite variable in nutrient content
depending upon the source and materials used in the process. This situation can prove
to be a challenge to a producer in determining its composition and to determine how to
use it effectively (11). Properly composted animal waste is essential to prevent human
health problems. Research has confirmed that the human pathogen, Esehercichia coli
0157:W7 contaminated soil from contaminated manure can be transmitted to produce
grown on this soil (28).
There are food safety issues arising from the use of manure in that animal feces contain
high levels of human pathogenic organisms which can be transferred to crops on which
it is used. Aged or properly composed manure tends to reduce the risk from the use of
animal waste materials. However, it is important that all farms using manure follow good
agricultural practices to reduce any microbial risk that may exist (22). These include:
In addition to animal waste, commercial composting operations often utilize other waste
products such as plant debris, tree and shrub trimmings, discarded food, and food
processing waste. The actual elemental content of these products will determine the
nutritive value of the resulting compost. As a result, consistency in nutritive value often
becomes a problem. Poor quality or immature compost can tie up N in the soil and
decrease N availability to plants (11). C:N ratio of a compost is an important
consideration. During composting microorganisms require carbon for growth and energy
for protein synthesis. Decomposition of organic matter wastes depends on proper
balance of C and N. Rapid decomposition occurs when C:N ratio is between 15 and
35:1. Favorable ratio results in the loss of NH4(ammonia) while higher ratios can slow
the process (19). Other factors affecting proper composting are; temperature, pH, and
oxygen supply, Optimum composting conditions are: moisture content between 40 – 60
%; temperatures between 55 – 600 C; pH 5.0 – 9.0, and, 30 % free air content.
Compost quality factors include age, moisture content, particle size, pH, salt
concentration and purity (volume of sand, soil and other non-organic materials).
A misnomer surrounding the use of organic verses inorganic fertilizer is that the organic
sources are better for plant growth and the environment. Claims are often made that
plant responses are more dramatic with the use of organic sources. In actuality, the
source of N etc is irrelevant to a plant. For instance, N has to be in a certain form,
nitrate (NO3) or ammonium (NH4), before it can be taken up by plants. Consequently, if
an organic source is used the N has to be converted to the nitrate form just as it has to
be when inorganic forms are used. Table 12 lists the essential elements for plant growth
and their forms available to green plants (24). Noticed improvement in plant response
with inorganic forms is really due to the effect of organic matter on soil tilth, aeration and
water holding capacity of the soil (25) and not to N. Once in the plant the source of N
has no baring on the use of this element in growth. In some instances, natural or
organic sources can actually contain dangerous levels of contaminants such as salts,
boron and heavy metals. Such contaminants can have a disastrous effect on plant
growth and yield. With regard to environmental friendliness of organic or inorganic
sources, organic sources have just as high a potential to cause N leaching into the
ground water as does inorganic sources. What determines the rate of leeching is the
quantity and use patterns of the fertilizers (17).
Often times during the production of a crop, additional N is required during the growing
season. Supplemental N can be applied in a side or top dressing with a good quality
compost. Another method of supplying supplemental N during the growing season is
through the application of manure tea. The use of this product may or may not have
merit in large scale farming operations. Adding an organic source such as chicken
manure or steamed bone meal to water, stirring the mixture for several days, and then
draining off the liquid makes manure tea. The tea is then applied to crop either as a soil
drench , band or injected through a drip irrigation system. The basic formula for the
above is three pounds of manure/25 gallons of water (2).
Sewage sludge has also been used as a organic fertilizer. Sludge is the solid material
removed from sewage treatment plants. It generally is available in three forms; raw,
digested, and, activated (previously treated sludge that has been aerated so that
aerobic decomposition can occur) (32). Of these only the activated sludge should be
considered for use in limited situations in agricultural crop production. The risk of
contaminating food with human pathogen is a major concern with these products. Table
13 contains a listing of organic sources for elements other than N.
Table 13. Organic nutrient sources for essential elements other than
nitrogen.
Essential Elements Sources
P (phosphorous) Poultry liter, colloidal, soft and hard rock phosphate
K (potassium) Cover crops, mined granite, greensand, basalt, feldspar, langbeinite and
Ca, Ng, S Potassium sulfate
Micronutrients Kelp and sea weed extracts and powders, dolomite, gypsum, keiserite,
(Bo, Cu, Fe, Mn, Mo, langbeinite, limestone, rock phosphate, and, oyster, clam and crab shells
&Zn)
Liquid or powdered seaweed extract, kelp meal, rock powders
Certain meat processing industry by-products such as blood and bone meal have also
been touted as organic fertilizers. However, these material also have serious food
safety issues regarding their use due to the potential transmission of certain diseases to
humans.
New organic farming operations and/or transition fields (those previously used for
conventional crop production) may initially experience nutrient deficiencies when using
organic fertilization systems until the nutritional benefits from these systems begin to
become available. In these situations there are other materials approved for use. Table
7 of the appendix lists some suggested products approved for use in Texas by TDA.
There are other growth enhancing products being used that are not fertilizers but are
auxin or hormonal in nature. Kelp and other see weed extracts fall into this category.
Test results, however, with many of these products have shown marginal benefits from
their use.
Most conventional farming operations follow very intensive soil preparation activities
such as mold board plowing, disking and bedding. Unfortunately, intensive tillage can
be counter productive to an organic farming system due to its negative impact on soil
organic matter content. Long-term tillage practices can reduce soil carbon 30 – 50 %
(17). Consequently, in organic production where soil organic matter is the key
component , conservation tillage may be a better alternative. Conservation tillage is a
practice in which at least 30 % of the soil surface is covered by residue from a previous
crop. The biggest draw back to this practice is a concern of potential weed buildup and
some allopathic responses. However, if properly managed, these problems can be
minimized.