Microeconomic Foundations of CBA

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 19

Microeconomic Foundations of CBA

Lecture 2 SPM9716: Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA)


Textbook: Chapter 3

Dr. ir. Zenlin Roosenboom-Kwee


z.roosenboom-kwee@tudelft.nl

Challenge the future 1


Course Outline & Schedule

Challenge the future 2


Lecture 2 Learning Objective

To review the microeconomic and


welfare economic underpinnings of CBA
(assuming perfect competition)

Challenge the future 3


Key assumptions in Chapter 3

• The presence of perfect competition


• Many buyers and sellers in the market (no influence to prices)
• Easy entrance and exit
• Homogeneous goods
• No transaction costs
• Information is perfect
• Private CB = Social CB

• Chapter 4 the presence of various forms of market failure

Challenge the future 4


Demand Curves
Figure 3-1 Consumers’ Total Benefits and Consumer Surplus
Approximation of
WTP in CBA

• Ordinary demand curve q = f(p)


• Inverse demand curve p = f -1(q)

Societal marginal benefits (MB)

Challenge the future 5


Figure 3-2 Change in Consumer Surplus Due to a Price
ABC area:
deadweight loss

(a) Decrease (b) Increase

Challenge the future 6


Demand Curve & Consumer Surplus
If the demand curve is linear

1
∆ =− ∆ − ∆ (∆ )
2
Still a good approximation even if the
demand curve is not linear

If the demand curve is not linear




(∆ )
∆ =− ∆ − ∗
2

Challenge the future 7


Taxes and Leakage
• Taxes
• Governments use tax to raise funds for projects
• This results in a reduction in CS called deadweight loss (DWL)
triangle ABC in Fig.3-2(b)

• Leakage
• The ratio of the deadweight loss to the total tax revenue raised

• Small leakage

Challenge the future 8


Exercise 3.1
Income; initial income
= $40,000
quantity price

• An individual demand function: q = 6 - 0.5p + 0.0002I

a. At what price will demand fall to zero (choke price)?


b. If the market price is $10, how many will be demanded?
c. At a price of $10, what is the price elasticity of demand for
gizmos?
d. At a price of $10, what is the consumer surplus?
e. If price rises to $12, how much consumer surplus is lost?
f. If income were $60,000, what would be the consumer surplus
loss from a price rise from $10 to $12?

Challenge the future 9


Figure 3-3 Individual Firm’s Supply Curve

Below the AVC, the


firm would shut down

Challenge the future 10


Figure 3-4 Market Supply Curve

Challenge the future 11


Exercise 3.2

• At the current market equilibrium, p = $40, q=10 units, price


elasticity of supply = 2.0

a. Find supply schedule (supply function)


b. Calculate PS
c. Price falls from $40 to $30, what is ∆PS?
d. What fraction of the lost producer surplus is due to the
reduction in the quantity supplied and what fraction is due
to the fall in price received per unit sold?

Challenge the future 12


Figure 3-5 Social Surplus (NSB)
Ignoring government surplus

Reflects MC

Equilibrium
point

Perfect
competition Reflects MB
maximizes
social surplus

Challenge the future 13


Profits and Factor Surplus

• Focus & assumption so far: short-run changes and some


inputs are fixed
• In practice, fixed costs can change in CBA projects
• Producer surplus (PS) is captured by some particular factors
of production (e.g. productive plot of land) or Ricardian rents
factor surplus (FS)
• PS = π + FS where π = economic profits

• Social surplus and changes in social surplus:

Challenge the future 14


Government Surplus and
Allocative Efficiency
• Thus far, we have ignored changes in government surplus
(GS)

• When GS is non-zero:

In a competitive market, the NSB of a project


equals the change in the sum of CS and PS,
plus the net change in government revenue

Challenge the future 15


Figure 3-6 Target Pricing Example

“Target” price Government subsidy: area PTdePD


∆CS: area P*bePD
∆ PS: area PTdbP*
∆ GS loss: area PTdePD
∆ DWL: area bde

Challenge the future 16


Marginal Excess Tax Burden (METB)

• METB is the ∆DWL that results from raising an additional


dollar of tax revenue

• Example from Exhibit 3-2: It costs $1.63 to transfer one


dollar from higher-income people to lower-income people
• METB = $0.63 (efficiency cost)

• When METB is taken into account:

Challenge the future 17


Measuring Changes in Welfare

• CBA focuses on allocative efficiency


• Welfare concerns allocative efficiency and equity
• Measuring welfare from measuring social surplus (or change
in social surplus) by “weighting” each of the different types of
surplus:

• In practice, weights can be unclear


• Sometimes, they are assumed to equal unity
• Except the weight on government which is assumed to equal
1+METB, yielding equation: ∆SS = ∆CS +∆PS + (1+METB)∆GS

Challenge the future 18


Lecture 2 Summary

• CS is important in CBA due to ∆CS as a close approximation


of the WTP

• Any policy intervention by government in a perfectly


competitive market reduces SS and creates a DWL

• The ∆DWL resulting from raising an additional money of tax


revenue is called METB

• CBA focuses on allocative efficiency while welfare focuses on


allocative efficiency and equity

Challenge the future 19

You might also like