Jurnal Reading Radimas Lingga Yuwaka
Jurnal Reading Radimas Lingga Yuwaka
Jurnal Reading Radimas Lingga Yuwaka
Oleh :
Radimas Lingga Yuwaka
(22360101)
Preseptor :
dr. Silman Hadori, Sp. Rad, MH.Kes
Journal Reading
Penyaji, Pembimbing,
FULL PAPER
Objective: Literature related to the imaging of COVID-19 appearance and consolidation together was in 36%.
pneumonia, its findings and contribution to diagnosis While peripheral and central co- distribution of the
and its differences from adults are limited in pediatric lesions (55%) were frequently observed, the involvement
patients. The aim of this study was to evaluate chest of the lower lobes (69%) was significant. In four cases,the
X-ray and chest CT findings in children with COVID-19 coexistence of multiple rounded multifocal ground-glass
pneumonia. appearance and rounded consolidation were observed.
Methods: Chest X-ray findings of 59 pediatric patients Conclusion: COVID-19 pneumonia imaging findings may
and chest CT findings of 22 patients with a confirmed differ in the pediatric population from adults. In diag-
diagnosis of COVID-19 pneumonia were evaluated nosis, chest X-ray should be preferred, CT should be
retrospectively. requested if there is a pathologic finding on radiography
Results: COVID-19 pneumonia was most commonly that merits further evaluation and if clinically indicated.
observed unilaterally and in lower zones of lungs in chest Advances in knowledge: Radiological findings of
X-ray examinations. Bilateral and multifocal involvement COVID-19 observed in children may differ from adults.
(55%) was the most observed involvement in the CT Chest X- ray should often be sufficient in children
examinations, as well as, single lesion and single lobe avoiding additional irradiation, chest CT needs only be
(27%) involvement were also detected. Pure ground- done in cases of clinical necessity.
glass appearance was observed in 41%, ground- glass
between Mar 11 and Apr 20, 2020. Permission from the Ethics mild, moderate and severe, according to the findings observed
Committee of Bakirkoy Dr. Sadi Konuk Training and Research in CT examination. For classification, both lungs were divided
Hospital was obtained (2020/153) and consent forms were taken into three parts as upper, middle and lower. Scoring was made
from the parents of cases. The patients were between 0 and 17 according to the volumetric involvement in each field. If the
years of age. Real-time fluorescence polymerase chain (RT-PCR) involvement was 0–25%, it was scored as one point, for 25–50%
test and imaging (chest X-ray or chest CT) were performed two points, 50–75% 3 points and 75–100% four points. Scores
at the time of application. The demographic features, clinical were summed up as 1–6 points, 7–11 points and 12 and above,
features and radiological images of the cases with the diagnosis and they were evaluated as mild, moderate and severe involve-
of COVID-19 infection confirmed by RT-PCR was obtained ment, respectively.8
from the electronic medical record system, and chest X-ray and
chest CT images were evaluated using Picture Archiving and
Communication Systems (PACS). Radiological evaluation was Statistical analysis
performed by a pediatric radiologist who has 10 years of experi- All statistical analysis was performed using Statistical Package
ence in pediatric chest imaging. All cases confirmed as Covid-19 for Social Sciences software v. 24.0.
by RT-PCR were classified clinically as mild, moderate, severe
and critical.5,7 RESULTS
Patients information
Imaging techniques 59 patients with Covid-19 pneumonia diagnosis confirmed by
PA (posteroanterior) or AP (anteroposterior) chest X-rays were RT-PCR test and with clinical findings had chest X-ray imaging.
performed on digital X-ray machines that perform automatic The mean age of these patients (34 boys, 25 girls) was 9 years
exposure at radiation doses suitable for children (Samsung, (range 54 days–15 years of age). The ages of 22 patients (15 boys,
XGEO GC80, South Korea- SITEC, DIGIRAD- FP/M, South 7 girls) who underwent chest CT imaging ranged from 6 months
Korea). to 17 years, with an average age of 12.3 years. 16 (27%) of the
patients with chest X-ray also had chest CT examination. six
All chest CT examinations were performed on 128 and 256 patients got only chest CT imaging. There were approximately
multislice CT devices (Siemens Somatom Sensation, Siemens, 3.2 ± 3.6 days between the dates of first symptom seen and
Erlangen, Germany) without contrast medium. Chest CT param-
imaging (0–10 days).
eters were 120 kVp, 140 mAs, 5 mm collimation, 1.35:1 pitch, a
pulmonary kernel (B70f) and a mediastinal kernel (B30f), recon-
In the clinical classification of these patients, 52 patients were
struction slice thickness of 1.00 mm and high spatial resolution
evaluated as having mild disease, while 10 patients had moderate
algorithm. The procedure was performed in younger children
and 3 patients had severe disease. All of the patients with mild
while calm, in older children while holding breath.
disease were followed- up with home isolation, all the patients
with moderate disease were hospitalized in the general ward and
Chest X-ray analysis three patient with severe disease were admitted into the intensive
The parameters used in the evaluation of chest X-ray were: care unit (ICU). Only, one of the patients who has the diagnosis
a) whether it is normal or pathological, b) the affected lung of cerebral palsy with severe disease needed to be intubated. One
side (unilateral–bilateral), c) the number of lesions (single– of the patients who was admitted to the intensive care unit had a
multiple), affected lung zone, d) other findings (pleural effusion, diagnosis of chronic renal failure.
lymphadenopathy).
Control imaging was not performed in any of the clinically mild
Chest CT analysis and moderate cases. The patients in the intensive care unit were
The basic data used in a detailed analysis and evaluation of the followed up with a chest X-ray.
imaging appearance of each of the identified lesions were: a)
the affected lung side (unilateral–bilateral), b) the number of
lesions (single–multiple) b) the affected lung lobe and segments, Chest X-ray evaluation
c) the affected lung field (peripheral–central–mix), d) lesion Lung findings were detected in 27 (46%) of the patients who
density e) lesion size, f) additional findings (prominent inter- underwent chest X-ray imaging.Table 1 It was unilateral in 15
stitium, prominent vascular structures within the lesion, halo (55%) and bilateral in 12 (45%) patients. Of the lesions, 13 were
sign, inverted halo sign, pleural effusion, lymphadenopathy). single (48%) and 14 were multiple (52%). No significant change
The distribution of affected lung was classified as the upper lobe was observed between right and left lung involvement. The lower
of the right lung, middle lobe of the right lung, lower lobe of the zones were the most commonly affected areas. The right lower
right lung, upper lobe of the left lung, lingular segment of the left zone was involved in 15 patients (56%) and the left lower zone
lung, lower lobe of the left lung. Lung field distribution was eval- was affected in 16 patients (59%). The right middle zone was
uated as peripheral (1/3 outer region of the lung), central (inner affected in nine cases (33%) and left middle zone in seven cases
2/3 of the lung) and mixed (peripheral and central involvement (26%). Localized increase in density was observed in 27 patients
together). Density of the lesions were evaluated as pure ground- while a diffuse increase in density was observed in cases who
glass opacity (GGO), a mixture of GGO-consolidation, and were admitted to the intensive care unit. Pleural effusion and
pure consolidation. In addition, the severity were classified as lymphadenopathy were not identified.(Figure 1)
2 of 7 birpublications.org/bjr Br J Radiol;93:20200647
BJR Palabiyik et al
Figure 1. Chest X-ray imaging of COVID-19 pneumonia in children.(a) Female, 11 years old. Chest X-ray showed localized density
is observedin the left lung lower zone. (b) Male, 13 years old. Chest X-ray showed scattered densities in bilateral lung lower zones.
(c) Male, 5 years old. Chest X-ray showed scattered densities in bilateral lung middle and lower zones. (d) Male, 9 years old. Chest
X-ray showed scattered round multiple densities in bilateral lung middle and lower zones.
3 of 7 birpublications.org/bjr Br J Radiol;93:20200647
Imaging of COVID-19 pneumonia in children BJR
Figure 2. Chest CT imaging of COVID-19 pneumonia in children. (a) Male, 15 years old. Chest CT showed multiple GGO and thick-
ening of interlobular septa in the inferior lobe of the bilateral lung, located peripherally. (b) Female, 17 years old. Chest CT showed
single GGO in the inferior lobe of the left lung located peripherally. (c) Male, 15 years old. Chest CT showed single GGO in the
superior lobe of the left lung located centrally. (d) Female, 16 years old.Chest CT showed multiple scattered round GGO in the
inferior lobe of the bilateral lung.(f) Female, 13 years old. Chest CT showed multiple GGO and consolidation in the right lower lobe.
(e) Male, 13 years old.Chest CT showed diffused consolidation in the left lower lobe. GGO, grond glass opacity.
are limited in pediatric patients.There have been few studies, with finding in chest X-ray was a unilateral increase in density. The
small numbers, evaluating the findings related to chest X-rays.6 lower zones were the most affected area. In 13 of 27 patients
However, COVID-19 pneumonia is clinically mild in children, (48%) with pathology in the chest X-ray, chest CT was required.
therefore mostly chest X-ray is performed in pediatric patients. Though the pathology was observed in the remaining cases,
Chest CT is performed if there is a pathologic finding on radiog- chest CT was not performed since there was no clinical require-
raphy that merits further evaluation and if clinically indicated. ment. Xia et al18 performed chest CT examination in 20 children
Imaging findings have been reported to be different from adults with COVID-19 pneumonia without chest X-ray images. They
and may be atypical.13–17 report that due to RT-PCR’s low application and positivity rate
in pediatric population, detection and characterization of lesions
In pediatric cases, it is essential to use the least radiation- on the chest X-ray were low in mild cases, and the diagnosis
containing test possible for diagnosis in accordance with the could be missed. Therefore, they emphasized that chest CT will
principles of radiation protection and ALARA. Chest X- ray provide early initiation of the treatment as well as early isolation
imaging is mostly preferred for the diagnosis of pneumonia in of these cases with typical findings even in RT-PCR negativity.
children. However, there are few studies on the use of chest X-ray Although the consensus is that without accompanied consolida-
and its findings in COVID-19 pneumonia in the literature. In tion in chest X-ray, the ground-glass appearance may be diffi-
our chest X-ray examinations, we have observed abnormal find- cult to detect and can be overlooked. We think that, especially in
ings in 46% of cases diagnosed with COVID-19 pneumonia. All pediatric cases, if a child is well then omitting a CT and missing
of the cases with a mild illness were treated on an outpatient basis a few areas of ground-glass change is not of any clinical signifi-
without the need for additional imaging. The most common cance. It is important to protect especially pediatric cases from
Figure 3. Male, 8 years old intubated. Chest X-ray and CT showed diffuse consolidation.
4 of 7 birpublications.org/bjr Br J Radiol;93:20200647
BJR Palabiyik et al
Figure 4. Male, 6- month-old. Chest X-ray and CT showed multiple round-shaped GGO with round multiple consolidation areas.
Table 2. Chest CT findings with COVID-19 pneumonia in chil- unnecessary radiation.If there is a clinical requirement along
dren with lung findings, chest CT examination will be appropriate.
Findings Number of patients (%)
There are limited number of studies about thorax CT findings
Pulmonary lesions of COVID-19 pneumonia in pediatric patients. Li19 and Lui20
Normal 3 (14%) et al reported in their chest CT studies with five children each
that scattered ground-glass appearance was the most common
Patological 19 (86%)
finding, similar to in adults. Chang et al.21 in their meta-analysis
Affected lung side reported that ground-glass appearance was the most common
Unilateral 7 (32%) finding in children, followed by patchy consolidation.
Bilateral 12 (55%)
Xia et al18 reported bilateral involvement as 50%, ground-glass
Number of lesions appearance as 60% and a combination of ground glass appearance
Single 6 (27%) and consolidation as 50% in their study on 20 patients. Li et al19
Multiple 12 (55%) in their study reported frequent bilateral and multifocal involve-
ment in chest CT of 22 pediatric patients and stated that unlike
Diffuse 1 (5%)
in adults, pure consolidation and combination of ground-glass
Affected lung field appearance and consolidation were observed more frequently,
Peripherally 7 (32%) interlobular septal thickening and crazy paving appearance were
less and affected fewer lobes. Duan et al22 stated that chest CT
Mixture 12 (55%)
findings may be atypical and low in specificity in pediatric cases.
Lesion density They reported that ground-glass appearance might be more
GGO 9 (41%) localized and lower in density and interlobular septal thickening
might be less in children. However, as their severity increased,
GGO ve consolidation 8 (36%)
they reported that ground-glass appearance became multiple
Consolidation 1 (5%) consolidations,enlarged and increased in density.
White lung 1 (5%)
Similar to other studies, pneumonia was most frequently bilat-
Affected lung lobe
eral and multifocal in our series. However, single lesion and
Right upper lobe 9 (8%) single lobe involvement were observed in 27% of the cases. Pure
Right middle lobe 11 (9%) ground-glass appearance and combination of consolidation and
Right lower lobe 31 (26%)
ground-glass appearance were approximately equal. In the evalu-
ation of the distribution of lesions that had not been evaluated in
Left upper lobe 8 (7%) previous studies, a combination of peripheral and central config-
Lingular segment 9 (8%) uration was observed more frequently in pediatric patients, in
Left lower lobe 50 (55%) contrast to adults. In addition, 69% of the lesions observed in the
cases were in the lower lobes, and the most common involvement
Scoring of radiological findings
was in the left lower lobe. Although the number of cases was low,
Mild 9 (41%) remarkable multiple multifocal round ground-glass and round
Moderate 9 (41%) pneumonia-like consolidation areas were observed together, in
four cases. In cases, similar to adults, interlobular septal thick-
Severe 1 (5%)
ening, prominent vascular structures within the lesion and
5 of 7 birpublications.org/bjr Br J Radiol;93:20200647
Imaging of COVID-19 pneumonia in children BJR
halo sign were seen. White lung appearance was detected in an imaging might be normal at the beginning of the disease. Coin-
intubated patient in ICU as in the study of Sun et al.23 Also, for fection was reported as 40% by Xia et al.18 However, none of our
the first time, we classified the CT findings according to their cases supported findings of coinfection. Xia et al18 and Duan et
severity in children as Chung et al did in the adults.8 There was al22 reported that pleural effusion may be seen in severe cases.
no correlation between COVID-19 pneumonia clinical and Pleural effusion and lymphadenopathy were not observed in any
radiological scores. of our cases.
Li et al24 reported that the reason for less lobe involvement and The clinical studies about the use of lung ultrasound find-
less prevalence in children may be due to mild inflammatory ings in pediatric patients with COVID-19 pneumonia are very
response due to low immune response. They considered that limited.25,26 Musolino et al reported thatlung ultrasound can be
the reason for accompanying consolidation to ground- glass used to support diagnosis in the evaluation of suspicious cases or
appearance may be due to progression of pneumonia related to for follow- up patient.25 The most common lung ultrasonography
the low rate of the immune response. However, the reason may findings were confluent B lines, thick irregular pleural lines and
be due to the inadequate development of the Kohn and Lambert subpleural consolidations, as in adult studies..27–29 In our study,
channels between the alveoli due to immaturity, just as in round we did not use ultrasound to evaluate patients.
pneumonia. In four cases followed in our cases, we detected the
findings of multiple round ground-glass appearances and round Our study has some limitations. Firstly, the number of cases was
consolidation findings. low in both chest X-ray and chest CT examination. In addition,
cases with negative RT-PCR but who were likely covid positive
Duan et al22 reported that although RT-PCR is positive, imaging due to symptoms and close family contact plus abnormal chest
may not show any findings. In our chest radiography, more than X-ray or CT findings were excluded from the study. It is known
half of our cases (54%) and three chest CT imaging were normal. some who test negative with RT-PCR can be false negative cases
However, as it is known from adult cases, it is known that the with abnormal chest CT findings.11–13
REFERENCES
1. Coronaviridae Study group of the 520–5. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crad. coronavirus disease 2019: a meta-analysis..
International Committee on taxonomy of 2020.04.010 Radiology 2013; 432020.
viruses. the species severe acute respiratory 7. Dong Y, Mo X, Hu Y, Qi X, Jiang F, Jiang Z, 13. Zimmermann P, Curtis N. Coronavirus
syndrome-related coronavirus: classifying et al. Epidemiology of COVID-19 among infections in children including COVID-19:
2019-nCoV and naming it SARS-CoV-2. Nat children in China. Pediatrics 2020; 145: an overview of the epidemiology, clinical
Microbiol 2020; 5: 536–44. e20200702. doi: https://doi.org/10.1542/peds. features, diagnosis, treatment and prevention
2. World Health OrganizationWHO Director- 2020-0702 options in children. Pediatr Infect Dis J 2020;
General’s remarks at the media briefing on 8. Chung M, Bernheim A, Mei X, Zhang N, 39: 355–68. doi: https://doi.org/10.1097/INF.
2019-nCoV on 11 February 2020. 2020World Huang M, Zeng X, et al. Ct imaging features 0000000000002660
Health Organization, Geneva. Available of 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV. 14. Qiu H, Wu J, Hong L, et al. Clinical and
via. Available from: https://www.who.int/ Radiology 2020; 295: 202–7. Epub 2020 epidemiological features of 36 children with
dg/speeches/detail/who-director-general- Feb 4. doi: https://doi.org/10.1148/radiol. coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19. Lancet
s-remarks-at-themedia-briefing-on-2019- 2020200230 Infect Dis 2020; 3099.): 30198–5pii: S1473-.
ncov-on-11-february-2020. 9. Zhu J, Zhong Z, Li H, Ji P, Pang J, Li B, et al. 15. Tagarro A, Epalza C, Santos M,
3. Cai J, Xu J, Lin D, Yang Z, Xu L, Qu Z, Ct imaging features of 4121 patients with Sanz-Santaeufemia FJ, Otheo E, Moraleda C,
et al. A case series of children with 2019 COVID-19: a meta-analysis. J Med Virol et al. Screening and severity of coronavirus
novel coronavirus infection: clinical and 2020; 92: 891–902. doi: https://doi.org/10. disease 2019 (COVID-19) in children in
epidemiological features. Clin Infect Dis 1002/jmv.25910 Madrid, Spain. JAMA Pediatr 2020;08
2020;: pii: ciaa198: . doi: https://doi.org/10. 10. Güneyli S, Atçeken Z, Doğan H, Altınmakas Apr 2020. doi: https://doi.org/10.1001/
1093/cid/ciaa198 E, Atasoy Kayhan Çetin, Atasoy KC. jamapediatrics.2020.1346
4. CDC COVID-19 Response Team Radiological approach to COVID-19 16. Zhu L, Wang J, Huang R, Liu L, Zhao H,
Coronavirus disease 2019 in children-United pneumonia with an emphasis on chest CT. Wu C, et al. Clinical characteristics of a case
states. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep, Diagn Interv Radiol 2020;: 323–3230 Apr series of children with coronavirus disease
, 2020; 69: 422–6. 2020 Apr 10;February 2020. doi: https://doi.org/10.5152/dir.2020. 2019. Pediatr Pulmonol 2020; 55: 1430–2.
12-April 2. 20260 doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/ppul.24767
5. Tezer H, Bedir Demirdag T, disease 11. Ai T, Yang Z, Hou H, et al. Correlation of 17. Castagnoli R, Votto M, Licari A, Brambilla
Ncoronavirus. COVID-19) in children. Turk chest CT and RT-PCR testing in coronavirus I, Bruno R, Perlini S, et al. Severe acute
J Med Sci 2020; 50(SI-1): 592–603. disease 2019 (COVID-19) in China: a report respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2
6. Lu Y, Wen H, Rong D, Zhou Z, Liu H. of 1014 cases. Radiology 2006; : 422020 . (SARS-CoV-2) infection in children and
Clinical characteristics and radiological 12. Kim H, Hong H, Yoon SH. Diagnostic adolescents: a systematic review. JAMA
features of children infected with the 2019 performance of CT and reverse Pediatr 2020;22 Apr 2020. doi: https://doi.
novel coronavirus. Clin Radiol 2020; 75: transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction for org/10.1001/jamapediatrics.2020.1467
6 of 7 birpublications.org/bjr Br J Radiol;93:20200647
BJR Palabiyik et al
18. Xia W, Shao J, Guo Y, Peng X, Li Z, Hu D, and meta-analysis. J Formos Med Assoc 2020;. 2020; 46: 2094–8. doi: https://doi.org/10.
Gou Y, et al. Clinical and CT features in - 6646: 30143–1pii: S0929. 1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2020.04.026
pediatric patients with COVID-19 infection: 22. Duan Y-N, Zhu Y-Q, Tang L-L, Qin J. Ct 26. Gregorio-Hernandez R, Escobar-Izquierdo B,
different points from adults. Pediatr features of novel coronavirus pneumonia Cobas-Pazos J, Martinez-Gimeno A. Point-
Pulmonol 2020; 55: 1169–74. doi: https://doi. (COVID-19) in children. Eur Radiol 2020; Of-Care lung ultrasound in three neonates
org/10.1002/ppul.24718 30: 4427–33. doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/ with COVID-19. Eur J Pediatr 2020;: 1–7.
19. Li W, Cui H, Li K, Fang Y, Li S. Chest s00330-020-06860-3 27. Volpicelli G, Gargani L. Sonographic signs
23. Sun D, Li H, XX L, et al. Clinical features of and patterns of COVID-19 pneumonia.
computed tomography in children with
severe pediatric patients with coronavirus Ultrasound J 2020; 12: 22. doi: https://doi.
COVID-19 respiratory infection. Pediatr
disease 2019 in Wuhan: a single center’s org/10.1186/s13089-020-00171-w
Radiol 2020; 50: 796–9. doi: https://doi.org/
observational study. World J Pediatr 2020;. 28. Sultan LR, Sehgal CM, Laith RS, Chandra
10.1007/s00247-020-04656-7
24. Li B, Shen J, Li L, Yu C. Radiographic and MS. A review of early experience in lung
20. Liu M, Song Z, Xiao K. High-Resolution
clinical features of children with coronavirus ultrasound in the diagnosis and management
computed tomography manifestations
disease (COVID-19) pneumonia. of COVID-19. Ultrasound Med Biol 2020;25
of 5 pediatric patients with 2019 novel Indian Pediatr 2020; 57: 423–6pii: May 2020. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
coronavirus. J Comput Assist Tomogr 2020; S097475591600156. doi: https://doi.org/10. ultrasmedbio.2020.05.012
44: 311–3. doi: https://doi.org/10.1097/RCT. 1007/s13312-020-1816-8 29. Yasukawa K, Minami T. Point-Of-Care
0000000000001023 25. Musolino AM, Supino MC, Buonsenso D, lung ultrasound findings in patients with
21. Chang TH, JL W, Chang LY. Clinical Ferro V, Valentini P, Magistrelli A, et al. Lung COVID-19 pneumonia. Am J Trop Med Hyg
characteristics and diagnostic challanges of ultrasound in children with COVID-19: 2020; 102: 1198–202. doi: https://doi.org/10.
pediatric COVID-19: a systematic review preliminary findings. Ultrasound Med Biol 4269/ajtmh.20-0280
7 of 7 birpublications.org/bjr Br J Radiol;93:20200647
Diterjemahkan dari bahasa Inggris ke bahasa Indonesia - www.onlinedoctranslator.com
BJR https://doi.org/10.1259/bjr.20200647
KERTAS LENGKAP
1Departemen Radiologi Anak, Universitas Ilmu Kesehatan, Rumah Sakit Pelatihan dan Penelitian Bakirkoy Dr. Sadi Konuk, Istanbul, Turki
2Departemen Radiologi, Universitas Ilmu Kesehatan, Rumah Sakit Pelatihan dan Penelitian Bakirkoy Dr. Sadi Konuk, Istanbul, Turki
3Departemen Infeksi Anak, Universitas Ilmu Kesehatan, Rumah Sakit Pelatihan dan Penelitian Bakirkoy Dr. Sadi Konuk, Istanbul, Turki
Objektif:Literatur terkait pencitraan pneumonia COVID-19, penampilan dan konsolidasi bersama-sama berada di 36%.
temuan dan kontribusinya terhadap diagnosis serta Sementara co-distribusi perifer dan sentral dari lesi (55%)
perbedaannya dengan orang dewasa terbatas pada pasien sering diamati, keterlibatan lobus bawah (69%) signifikan.
anak. Tujuan dari penelitian ini adalah untuk mengevaluasi Dalam empat kasus, koeksistensi beberapa tampilan ground-
temuan rontgen dada dan CT dada pada anak dengan glass multifokal bulat dan konsolidasi bulat diamati.
pneumonia COVID-19. Kesimpulan:Temuan pencitraan pneumonia COVID-19
Metode:Temuan rontgen dada dari 59 pasien anak dan mungkin berbeda pada populasi anak-anak dari orang dewasa.
temuan CT dada dari 22 pasien dengan diagnosis pneumonia Dalam diagnosis, rontgen dada harus lebih disukai, CT harus
COVID-19 yang dikonfirmasi dievaluasi secara retrospektif. diminta jika ada temuan patologis pada radiografi yang
memerlukan evaluasi lebih lanjut dan jika diindikasikan secara
Hasil:Pneumonia COVID-19 paling sering diamati secara klinis. Kemajuan dalam pengetahuan:Temuan radiologis
sepihak dan di zona bawah paru-paru pada pemeriksaan COVID-19 yang diamati pada anak-anak mungkin berbeda dari
rontgen dada. Keterlibatan bilateral dan multifokal (55%) orang dewasa. Rontgen dada seringkali cukup pada anak-anak
adalah keterlibatan yang paling banyak diamati dalam untuk menghindari penyinaran tambahan, CT dada hanya
pemeriksaan CT, serta, lesi tunggal dan keterlibatan lobus perlu dilakukan dalam kasus kebutuhan klinis.
tunggal (27%) juga terdeteksi. Penampilan groundglass murni
diamati pada 41%, ground-glass
antara 11 Maret dan 20 April 2020. Izin dari Komite Etik ringan, sedang dan berat, sesuai dengan temuan yang diamati pada
Rumah Sakit Pelatihan dan Penelitian Bakirkoy Dr. Sadi pemeriksaan CT. Untuk klasifikasi, kedua paru-paru dibagi menjadi
Konuk diperoleh (2020/153) dan formulir persetujuan tiga bagian atas, tengah dan bawah. Skoring dibuat sesuai dengan
diambil dari orang tua kasus. Para pasien berusia antara volumetrik keterlibatan di masing-masing bidang. Jika keterlibatan
0 dan 17 tahun. Tes dan pencitraan rantai fluoresensi adalah 0-25%, itu diberi skor sebagai satu poin, untuk 25-50% dua
polimerase (RT-PCR) real-time (rontgen dada atau CT poin, 50-75% 3 poin dan 75-100% empat poin. Skor diringkas sebagai
dada) dilakukan pada saat aplikasi. Gambaran 1-6 poin, 7-11 poin dan 12 dan di atas, dan mereka dievaluasi sebagai
demografis, gambaran klinis dan gambaran radiologis keterlibatan ringan, sedang dan berat, masing-masing.8
dari kasus dengan diagnosis infeksi COVID-19 yang
dikonfirmasi dengan RT-PCR diperoleh dari sistem rekam
medis elektronik, dan gambar rontgen dada dan CT dada
dievaluasi menggunakan Pengarsipan Gambar dan Analisis statistik
Komunikasi Sistem (PACS). Evaluasi radiologis dilakukan Semua analisis statistik dilakukan dengan menggunakan software
oleh ahli radiologi pediatrik yang memiliki pengalaman Statistical Package for Social Sciences v. 24.0.
Tabel 1. Temuan Rontgen Dada dengan Pneumonia COVID-19 pada Ketika karakteristik kepadatan lesi dievaluasi, penampilan ground-
Anak glass murni diamati pada sembilan kasus (41%), ada konsolidasi
murni dalam satu kasus (5%) dan penampilan ground-glass dan
Temuan Jumlah pasien (%)
konsolidasi diamati bersama dalam delapan kasus. (36%).Gambar 2
Lesi paru Dalam kasus dengan perjalanan yang parah (5%), penampilan "paru-
Normal 32 (54%) paru putih" terdeteksi.Gambar 3Tanda halo pada lima pasien (23%),
penebalan interstisial pada delapan kasus (36%), vaskularisasi yang
Patologis 27 (46%)
menonjol dalam lesi pada delapan kasus (36%), dan atelektasis pada
Sisi paru yang terkena
satu kasus (5%) diamati. Kami mendeteksi empat pasien (18%) di
Sepihak 15 (55%) mana beberapa penampilan ground-glass berbentuk bulat diamati
dengan beberapa area konsolidasi bulat.Gambar 4Tidak ada efusi
Bilateral 12 (45%)
pleura atau limfadenopati yang terdeteksi.
Jumlah lesi
Gambar 1. Pencitraan rontgen dada pneumonia COVID-19 pada anak.(a) Perempuan, 11 tahun. Rontgen dada menunjukkan densitas lokal
diamati di zona bawah paru kiri. (b) Laki-laki, 13 tahun. Rontgen dada menunjukkan kepadatan yang tersebar di zona bawah paru bilateral. c.
Laki-laki, 5 tahun. Rontgen dada menunjukkan densitas yang tersebar di zona tengah dan bawah paru bilateral. (d) Laki-laki, 9 tahun. Rontgen
toraks menunjukkan densitas multipel bulat yang tersebar di zona tengah dan bawah paru bilateral.
Gambar 2. Pencitraan CT dada pneumonia COVID-19 pada anak. (a) Laki-laki, 15 tahun. CT dada menunjukkan beberapa GGO dan penebalan
septa interlobular di lobus inferior paru bilateral, terletak perifer. (b) Perempuan, 17 tahun. CT dada menunjukkan GGO tunggal di lobus inferior
paru kiri yang terletak di perifer. c. Laki-laki, 15 tahun. CT dada menunjukkan GGO tunggal di lobus superior paru kiri yang terletak di tengah. (d)
Wanita, 16 tahun. CT dada menunjukkan GGO bulat multipel tersebar di lobus inferior paru bilateral. (f) Wanita, 13 tahun. CT dada menunjukkan
beberapa GGO dan konsolidasi di lobus kanan bawah. (e) Laki-laki, 13 tahun. CT dada menunjukkan konsolidasi menyebar di lobus kiri bawah.
GGO, opasitas kaca grond.
terbatas pada pasien anak. Ada beberapa penelitian, dengan jumlah temuan di rontgen dada adalah peningkatan densitas unilateral.
kecil, mengevaluasi temuan terkait dengan rontgen dada.6 Zona bawah adalah area yang paling terkena dampak. Pada 13
Namun, pneumonia COVID-19 secara klinis ringan pada anak-anak, oleh dari 27 pasien (48%) dengan patologi di rontgen dada, CT dada
karena itu sebagian besar rontgen dada dilakukan pada pasien anak. CT diperlukan. Meskipun patologi diamati pada kasus yang tersisa,
dada dilakukan jika ada temuan patologis pada radiografi yang CT dada tidak dilakukan karena tidak ada persyaratan klinis. Xia
memerlukan evaluasi lebih lanjut dan jika diindikasikan secara klinis. dkk18melakukan pemeriksaan CT dada pada 20 anak dengan
Temuan pencitraan telah dilaporkan berbeda dari orang dewasa dan pneumonia COVID-19 tanpa gambar rontgen dada. Mereka
mungkin atipikal.13–17 melaporkan bahwa karena aplikasi RT-PCR yang rendah dan
tingkat kepositifan pada populasi anak, deteksi dan karakterisasi
Dalam kasus pediatrik, penting untuk menggunakan tes yang lesi pada rontgen dada rendah pada kasus ringan, dan diagnosis
mengandung radiasi sesedikit mungkin untuk diagnosis sesuai dengan dapat terlewatkan. Oleh karena itu, mereka menekankan bahwa
prinsip proteksi radiasi dan ALARA. Pencitraan sinar-X dada sebagian CT dada akan memberikan inisiasi awal pengobatan serta isolasi
besar lebih disukai untuk diagnosis pneumonia pada anak-anak. Namun, awal kasus-kasus ini dengan temuan khas bahkan dalam RT-PCR
ada beberapa penelitian tentang penggunaan rontgen dada dan negatif. Meskipun konsensusnya adalah bahwa tanpa disertai
temuannya pada pneumonia COVID-19 dalam literatur. Dalam konsolidasi pada rontgen dada, tampilan ground-glass mungkin
pemeriksaan rontgen dada kami, kami telah mengamati temuan sulit dideteksi dan dapat diabaikan. Kami berpikir bahwa,
abnormal pada 46% kasus yang didiagnosis dengan pneumonia terutama dalam kasus pediatrik, jika seorang anak baik-baik saja
COVID-19. Semua kasus dengan penyakit ringan dirawat secara rawat maka mengabaikan CT dan kehilangan beberapa area ground-
jalan tanpa perlu pencitraan tambahan. Yang paling umum glass change tidak signifikan secara klinis.
Gambar 3. Laki-laki, 8 tahun diintubasi. Rontgen dada dan CT menunjukkan konsolidasi difus.
Gambar 4. Laki-laki, 6 bulan. Rontgen dada dan CT menunjukkan GGO berbentuk bulat multipel dengan area konsolidasi multipel bulat.
Tabel 2. Temuan CT dada dengan pneumonia COVID-19 pada anak radiasi yang tidak perlu. Jika ada persyaratan klinis bersama
dengan temuan paru-paru, pemeriksaan CT dada akan sesuai.
Bilateral 12 (55%)
Xia dkk18melaporkan keterlibatan bilateral sebagai 50%, penampilan
Jumlah lesi ground-glass 60% dan kombinasi tampilan ground-glass dan
Lajang 6 (27%) konsolidasi 50% dalam penelitian mereka pada 20 pasien. Li dkk19
dalam penelitian mereka melaporkan keterlibatan bilateral dan multifokal yang
Beberapa 12 (55%)
sering pada CT dada dari 22 pasien anak dan menyatakan bahwa tidak seperti
Membaur 1 (5%)
pada orang dewasa, konsolidasi murni dan kombinasi tampilan ground-glass
Lapangan paru yang terkena dan konsolidasi diamati lebih sering, penebalan septum interlobular dan
Secara periferal 7 (32%) tampilan paving gila lebih sedikit dan terpengaruh. lebih sedikit lobus. Duan
dkk22menyatakan bahwa temuan CT dada mungkin atipikal dan spesifisitas
Campuran 12 (55%)
rendah pada kasus anak. Mereka melaporkan bahwa tampilan ground-glass
Kepadatan lesi mungkin lebih terlokalisasi dan kepadatannya lebih rendah dan penebalan
GGO 9 (41%) septum interlobular mungkin lebih sedikit pada anak-anak. Namun, ketika
tingkat keparahannya meningkat, mereka melaporkan bahwa tampilan ground-
konsolidasi GGO 8 (36%)
glass menjadi beberapa konsolidasi, membesar dan meningkat dalam
Konsolidasi 1 (5%) kepadatan.
Paru-paru putih 1 (5%)
Mirip dengan penelitian lain, pneumonia paling sering
Lobus paru yang terkena
bilateral dan multifokal dalam seri kami. Namun, lesi
Lobus kanan atas 9 (8%) tunggal dan keterlibatan lobus tunggal diamati pada 27%
Lobus tengah kanan 11 (9%) kasus. Penampilan ground-glass murni dan kombinasi
Lobus kanan bawah 31 (26%)
konsolidasi dan tampilan ground-glass kira-kira sama.
Dalam evaluasi distribusi lesi yang belum dievaluasi pada
Lobus atas kiri 8 (7%)
penelitian sebelumnya, kombinasi konfigurasi perifer dan
Segmen Lingular 9 (8%) sentral lebih sering diamati pada pasien anak, berbeda
Lobus bawah kiri 50 (55%) dengan orang dewasa. Selain itu, 69% dari lesi yang
diamati dalam kasus berada di lobus bawah, dan
Skoring temuan radiologis
keterlibatan yang paling umum adalah di lobus kiri
Ringan 9 (41%) bawah. Meskipun jumlah kasusnya rendah, beberapa
Sedang 9 (41%) area konsolidasi seperti ground-glass multifokal dan
pneumonia bulat yang luar biasa diamati bersama-sama,
Berat 1 (5%)
dalam empat kasus. Dalam kasus,
tanda halo terlihat. Penampilan paru-paru putih terdeteksi pada pasien pencitraan mungkin normal pada awal penyakit. Koinfeksi dilaporkan
yang diintubasi di ICU seperti dalam studi Sun et al.23Juga, untuk pertama sebesar 40% oleh Xia et al.18Namun, tidak satu pun dari kasus kami
kalinya, kami mengklasifikasikan temuan CT menurut tingkat yang mendukung temuan koinfeksi. Xia dkk18dan Duan dkk22
keparahannya pada anak-anak seperti yang dilakukan Chung et al pada melaporkan bahwa efusi pleura dapat terlihat pada kasus yang
orang dewasa.8Tidak ada korelasi antara skor klinis dan radiologis parah. Efusi pleura dan limfadenopati tidak diamati dalam kasus
pneumonia COVID-19. kami.
Li dkk24melaporkan bahwa alasan keterlibatan lobus yang lebih sedikit Studi klinis tentang penggunaan temuan USG paru pada pasien anak
dan prevalensi yang lebih rendah pada anak-anak mungkin disebabkan dengan pneumonia COVID-19 sangat terbatas.25,26Musolino et al
oleh respons inflamasi ringan karena respons imun yang rendah. Mereka melaporkan bahwa USG paru dapat digunakan untuk mendukung
menganggap bahwa alasan untuk konsolidasi yang menyertai diagnosis dalam evaluasi kasus yang mencurigakan atau untuk pasien
penampilan ground-glass mungkin karena perkembangan pneumonia tindak lanjut.25Temuan ultrasonografi paru yang paling umum adalah
terkait dengan rendahnya tingkat respon imun. Namun, alasannya garis B konfluen, garis pleura tebal tidak teratur dan konsolidasi
mungkin karena perkembangan saluran Kohn dan Lambert yang tidak subpleural, seperti pada penelitian orang dewasa.27–29Dalam penelitian
memadai antara alveoli karena imaturitas, seperti pada pneumonia bulat. kami, kami tidak menggunakan ultrasound untuk mengevaluasi pasien.
Dalam empat kasus yang diikuti dalam kasus kami, kami mendeteksi
temuan beberapa penampakan ground-glass bulat dan temuan Penelitian kami memiliki beberapa keterbatasan. Pertama, jumlah kasus
konsolidasi bulat. rendah pada pemeriksaan rontgen dada dan CT dada. Selain itu, kasus
dengan RT-PCR negatif tetapi kemungkinan positif covid karena gejala
Duan dkk22melaporkan bahwa meskipun RT-PCR positif, pencitraan mungkin dan kontak keluarga dekat ditambah temuan rontgen dada atau CT yang
tidak menunjukkan temuan apa pun. Dalam radiografi dada kami, lebih dari abnormal dikeluarkan dari penelitian. Diketahui beberapa yang dites
setengah kasus kami (54%) dan tiga pencitraan CT dada normal. Namun, seperti negatif dengan RT-PCR dapat menjadi kasus negatif palsu dengan temuan
yang diketahui dari kasus dewasa, diketahui bahwa CT dada yang tidak normal.11–13
REFERENSI
1. Kelompok studi Coronaviridae dari Komite 520–5. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crad. penyakit coronavirus 2019: meta-analisis..
Internasional tentang taksonomi virus. spesies 2020.04.010 Radiologi2013;432020.
coronavirus terkait sindrom pernafasan akut yang 7. Dong Y, Mo X, Hu Y, Qi X, Jiang F, Jiang Z, dkk. 13. Zimmermann P, Curtis N. Infeksi virus corona
parah: mengklasifikasikan 2019-nCoV dan Epidemiologi COVID-19 di kalangan anak-anak pada anak-anak termasuk COVID-19:
menamakannya SARS-CoV-2.Mikrobiol Nat2020;5: di Tiongkok.Pediatri2020;145: e20200702. doi: gambaran umum epidemiologi, gambaran
536–44. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds. 2020-0702 klinis, diagnosis, pilihan pengobatan dan
2. Pernyataan Direktur Jenderal WHO pada pencegahan pada anak.Pediatr Menginfeksi Dis
media briefing 2019-nCoV pada 11 Februari 8. Chung M, Bernheim A, Mei X, Zhang N, Huang J2020; 39: 355–68. doi:https://doi.org/10.1097/
2020. 2020World Health Organization, M, Zeng X, dkk. Fitur pencitraan Ct dari novel INF. 0000000000002660
Jenewa. Tersedia melalui. Tersedia dari: coronavirus 2019 (2019-nCoV. Radiologi2020; 14. Qiu H, Wu J, Hong L, dkk. Gambaran klinis dan
https://www.who.int/ dg/speeches/detail/ 295: 202–7. Epub 2020 4 Februari. doi:https:// epidemiologis dari 36 anak dengan penyakit
who-director-generals-remarks-at- doi.org/10.1148/radiol. 2020200230 coronavirus 2019 (COVID-19).Lancet
themedia-briefing-on-2019-ncov-on-11- Menginfeksi Dis2020;3099.): 30198–5pii: S1473-.
february-2020. 9. Zhu J, Zhong Z, Li H, Ji P, Pang J, Li B, dkk. Fitur 15. Tagarro A, Epalza C, Santos M, Sanz-Santaeufemia FJ,
3. Cai J, Xu J, Lin D, Yang Z, Xu L, Qu Z, dkk. pencitraan CT dari 4121 pasien dengan Otheo E, Moraleda C, dkk. Skrining dan tingkat
Serangkaian kasus anak-anak dengan infeksi COVID-19: meta-analisis.J Med Virol 2020;92: keparahan penyakit coronavirus 2019 (COVID-19)
coronavirus novel 2019: fitur klinis dan 891–902. doi:https://doi.org/10. 1002/ pada anak-anak di Madrid, Spanyol.JAMA Pediatri
epidemiologis.Clin Menginfeksi Dis 2020;: pii: jmv.25910 2020;08 Apr 2020. doi:https://doi.org/10.1001/
ciaa198: . doi:https://doi.org/10. 1093/cid/ 10. Güneyli S, Atçeken Z, Doğan H, Altınmakas jamapediatrics.2020.1346
ciaa198 E, Atasoy Kayhan etin, Atasoy KC.
4. Tim Tanggap COVID-19 CDC Penyakit virus Pendekatan radiologi untuk pneumonia 16. Zhu L, Wang J, Huang R, Liu L, Zhao H, Wu C,
corona 2019 di anak-anak-Amerika Serikat. COVID-19 dengan penekanan pada CT dada. dkk. Karakteristik klinis dari rangkaian kasus
MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep, , 2020;69: 422– Diagnosa Interv Radiol2020;: 323–3230 Apr anak dengan penyakit coronavirus 2019.
6. 2020 10 April; 12 Februari-2 April. 2020. doi:https://doi.org/10.5152/dir.2020. Pediatr Pulmonol2020;55: 1430–2. doi:https://
20260 doi.org/10.1002/ppul.24767
5. Tezer H, Bedir Demirdag T, penyakit 11. Ai T, Yang Z, Hou H, dkk. Korelasi pengujian CT 17. Castagnoli R, Votto M, Licari A, Brambilla
Ncoronavirus. COVID-19) pada anak-anak.Turk dada dan RT-PCR pada penyakit coronavirus I, Bruno R, Perlini S, dkk. Infeksi parah
J Med Sci2020;50(SI-1): 592–603. 2019 (COVID-19) di Cina: laporan 1014 kasus. sindrom pernapasan akut coronavirus 2
6. Lu Y, Wen H, Rong D, Zhou Z, Liu H. Radiologi2006; :422020 . (SARS-CoV-2) pada anak-anak dan remaja:
Karakteristik klinis dan gambaran radiologis 12. Kim H, Hong H, Yoon SH. Kinerja tinjauan sistematis.JAMA Pediatri2020;22
anak-anak yang terinfeksi virus corona baru diagnostik CT dan sebaliknya Apr 2020. doi:https://doi. org/10.1001/
2019.Klinik Radiol2020;75: reaksi berantai transkriptase-polimerase untuk jamapediatrics.2020.1467
18. Xia W, Shao J, Guo Y, Peng X, Li Z, Hu D, Gou Y, dan meta-analisis.J Formos Med Assoc2020;. 2020;46: 2094–8. doi:https://doi.org/10.
dkk. Gambaran klinis dan CT pada pasien anak - 6646: 30143–1pii: S0929. 1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2020.04.026
dengan infeksi COVID-19: poin berbeda dari 22. Duan YN, Zhu YQ, Tang LL, Qin J. Ct fitur 26. Gregorio-Hernandez R, Escobar-Izquierdo B,
orang dewasa.Pediatr Pulmonol2020;55: 1169– novel coronavirus pneumonia (COVID-19) Cobas-Pazos J, Martinez-Gimeno A. USG
74. doi:https://doi. org/10.1002/ppul.24718 pada anak-anak.Eur Radiol2020; 30: paru Point-Of-Care pada tiga neonatus
4427–33. doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/ dengan COVID-19.Eur J Pediatr2020;: 1–7.
Oleh:
Radimas Lingga Yuwaka, S.Ked
(22360101)
Preseptor:
dr. Silman Hadori,Sp.Rad., MH.Kes
Gambar 4. Laki-laki, 6 bulan. Rontgen dada dan CT menunjukkan GGO berbentuk bulat
multipel dengan area konsolidasi multipel bulat.
Diskusi
Temuan yang paling umum adalah gambaran ground-glass multifokal yang
terletak di perifer mulai dari lobus bawah, disertai dengan penebalan pada septa
interlobularis, struktur vaskular yang menonjol.
Ada beberapa penelitian mengevaluasi temuan terkait rontgen dada.
Namun, pneumonia COVID-19 secara klinis ringan pada anak-anak, oleh karena itu
sebagian besar rontgen dada dilakukan pada pasien anak. CT dada dilakukan jika ada
temuan patologis pada radiografi yang memerlukan evaluasi lebih lanjut dan jika
diindikasikan secara klinis.
Diskusi
Dalam pemeriksaan rontgen dada kami, kami telah mengamati temuan
abnormal pada 46% kasus yang didiagnosis dengan pneumonia COVID-19 dan temuan
di rontgen dada paling umum ditemukan peningkatan densitas unilateral.
CT dada dilakukan jika ada temuan patologis pada radiografi yang
memerlukan evaluasi lanjut dan jika diindikasikan secara klinis temuan paling umum
ground-glass multifokal yang terletak di perifer mulai dari lobus bawah, disertai dengan
penebalan pada septa interlobularis, struktur vaskular yang menonjol, tanda, lalu
temuan di rontgen dada adalah peningkatan densitas unilateral.
Diskusi
Keterlibatan bilateral dan multifokal yang sering pada CT dada
dari pasien anak bahwa tidak seperti pada orang dewasa, konsolidasi murni
dan kombinasi tampilan ground-glass dan konsolidasi diamati lebih sering,
penebalan septum interlobular dan tampilan paving lebih sedikit lobus.
Diskusi
Bahwa alasan keterlibatan lobus yang lebih sedikit dan prevalensi yang
lebih rendah pada anak-anak mungkin disebabkan oleh respons inflamasi ringan
karena respons imun yang rendah.
Temuan ultrasonografi paru pada anak yang paling umum adalah garis
B konfluen, garis pleura tebal tidak teratur dan konsolidasi subpleural, seperti pada
penelitian orang dewasa.
Kesimpulan
Dalam empat kasus yang diikuti, didapatkan temuan
beberapa penampakan ground-glass bulat dan temuan konsolidasi bulat.
Bahwa meskipun RT-PCR positif, pencitraan mungkin tidak
menunjukkan temuan apa pun. Dalam radiografi dada lebih dari
setengah kasus (54%) dan tiga CT dada normal. Namun, diketahui
bahwa pencitraan mungkin normal pada awal penyakit. Koinfeksi
dilaporkan sebesar 40%. Namun, tidak satu pun dari kasus yang
mendukung temuan koinfeksi.