Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 17 views

    Activity 4 Magpayo

    Uploaded by

    VALERIANO TRISHA
    The document compares 5 different versions of the Cry of Balintawak from the Philippine Revolution. It notes differences in dates and details between eyewitness and secondary sources. The student finds the secondary source from Santiago Alvarez to be the most accurate as it gathered information from multiple primary sources.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Activity 4 Magpayo

    Uploaded by

    VALERIANO TRISHA
    17 views3 pages
    The document compares 5 different versions of the Cry of Balintawak from the Philippine Revolution. It notes differences in dates and details between eyewitness and secondary sources. The student finds the secondary source from Santiago Alvarez to be the most accurate as it gathered information from multiple primary sources.

    Original Title

    ACTIVITY-4-MAGPAYO

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document compares 5 different versions of the Cry of Balintawak from the Philippine Revolution. It notes differences in dates and details between eyewitness and secondary sources. The student finds the secondary source from Santiago Alvarez to be the most accurate as it gathered information from multiple primary sources.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    17 views3 pages

    Activity 4 Magpayo

    Uploaded by

    VALERIANO TRISHA
    The document compares 5 different versions of the Cry of Balintawak from the Philippine Revolution. It notes differences in dates and details between eyewitness and secondary sources. The student finds the secondary source from Santiago Alvarez to be the most accurate as it gathered information from multiple primary sources.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    You are on page 1of 3

    Magpayo, Erika Faith M.

    BSN 2Y - 9

    1. Create a comparative chart to note the differences & similarities in the 5 versions of the story of the Cry of the Revolution.
    2. Which version is the most accurate in your own opinion and why?

    CRY OF THE REVOLUTION ( DIFFERENCES)

    A. PIO VALENZUELA B. SANTIAGO C. GREGORIA DE D. THE GUARDIA E. GUILLERMO MASANGKAY


    ALVAREZ JESUS CIVIL

    ● PRIMARY SOURCE. ● SECONDARY ● PRIMARY ● PRIMARY ● PRIMARY SOURCE.


    ● An eye witness SOURCE. SOURCE. SOURCE. ● An eye witness
    ● Not an ● An eye witness ● An eye witness
    eyewitness

    AUGUST 26, 1896. AUGUST 23, 1896 AUGUST 25, 1896 AUGUST 24, 1896, AUGUST 26, 1896

    The “cry” was staged at It was 12 o'clock noon The first “cry” it The first “cry” occurred The historic first rally of the
    Balintawak. when the occurred near Caloocan at Balintawak on Philippine Revolution of 1896
    meeting adjourned on August 25, 1896 August 25, 1896 occurred at the rustic barrio of
    AUGUST 26, 1896 amidst loud cries of Balintawak, a few kilometers
    "Long live the Sons of north of the city of Manila, on
    In the memoirs, he claim that the the Country (Mabuhay August 26, 1896,
    “cry” was held at pugad lawin ang mga Anak ng
    Bayan)!
    August 23, 1896
    AUGUST 23, 1896

    The first place where some 500 At kabesang melchora, Andres Bonitacio and Bonifacio and his On August 26th a big meeting
    members of katipunan met on at a place called Other katipuneros left followers hurriedly fled was held in
    August 22, 1896, was the house Sampalukan, barrio of the town after some to the nearby town of Balintawak, at the house of
    and yards of Apolonio Samson at bahay Toro, days. It was then Caloon on August 23, Apolonio Samson, then the cabeza
    Kangkong. Katipuneros met that the uprising began, 1896 of that barrio of Caloocan.
    together with the first cry for
    freedom on
    August 25, 1896.

    Where over 1,000 members of August 24, 1896 Bonifacio moved to the
    the katipunan met and carried There were about barrio of balintawak,
    out considerable debate and 1,000 katipuneros… followed by 200 men
    discussion on August 23, 1896 from caloocan

    Discussion on whether or not the On August 25, 1896,


    revolution against the spanish the big meeting was
    government should be started on held in barrio
    On August 29, 1896, balintawak. 5,000
    members attendee

    CRY OF THE REVOLUTION ( SIMILARITIES)

    ● THEY ARE ALL PRIMARY SOURCE EXCEPT FOR THE SANTIAGO ALVAREZ ACCOUNT.
    ● THEIR TITLE WAS EITHER CRY OF BALINTAWAK OR PUGAD LAWIN.
    ● THE KATIPUNAN GATHERED ON AUGUST 24, 1896, AND THE ACCOUNT OF SANTIAGO ALVAREZ AND THE GUARDIA
    CIVIL WERE THE SAME.
    ● THE ACCOUNT OF PIO VALENZUELA AND GUILLERMO MASANGKAY ON AUGUST 26, 1896 WAS THE SAME, AND IT
    WAS THE FIRST CRY OF BALINTAWAK.
    ● THEY HAVE SAME MONTH AND YEAR WHICH IS AUGUST 1896

    2. Which version is the most accurate in your own opinion and why?
    - The account delivered by Santiago Alvarez impresses me as the most accurate. We all know that was a secondary
    source, which means he wasn't present at the time or didn't see what was really going on. However, he gathered all
    available information from those who are participating in or had a chance to observe the occurrence. By gathering
    data and facts from a variety of sources. He might make a more thorough and better version.

    You might also like