Yu Ping
Yu Ping
Yu Ping
Author: Ping Yu
Title: The Implementation of Integrated Marketing
Communications in the Automotive Industry
Number of Pages: 40 pages + 1 appendices
Date: 2 November 2022
The objective of this thesis was to investigate how automotive brands are
implementing Integrated Marketing Communication (IMC) to enhance their brands
and ensure customers purchase their products or services.
Qualitative research was the fundamental methodology used in this thesis. The
preliminary data were gathered by conducting online semi-structured interviews with
marketing communication experts who provided knowledge of the implementation of
an IMC strategy within the automotive industry.
The key findings were that IMC required the car brand’s message to be consistently
conveyed to target audiences across all channels to ensure consumers recognized
the brand. The information transferred via different channels should be
complementary. The application of marketing communication instruments should
combine the automotive enterprise's overall strategy with the local strategy.
Customer databases play a vital role in IMC. Currently, vehicle firms still collect
consumer contact information from the dealer side. Therefore, auto companies
should prepare to build their customer databases to tailor segmentation and read
customer behaviors for the future.
1 Introduction 1
1.1 Background 1
1.1 Research objectives and questions 2
1.2 Structure overview 2
2 Literature review 4
3 Research methodology 25
6 Conclusion 34
References 37
Appendices 41
List of Tables
1 Introduction
1.1 Background
The purpose of IMC for manufacturers and distributors is to deliver the same
message and activities to their audiences through different channels to
strengthen their brand. Therefore, the objective of the thesis was to investigate
how automotive brands are implementing IMC to enhance their brands and
ensure customers purchase their products or services. The study aimed to
identify if an IMC strategy can help manufacturers and dealers establish an
effective communication connection with consumers so that consumers better
understand the actual value of cars. Moreover, additional research questions
were investigated to aid this study:
• What is IMC?
This thesis has six parts: introduction, IMC literature review, research
methodology, limitations of the thesis, discussion and findings, and conclusion.
The introduction describes the background of IMC and states research
objectives and questions to determine the study’s direction and scope. The
literature review formulates the definition and characteristics of IMC, the
communication process, brand positioning, customer databases, the marketing
communications tools and IMC's practice to achieve a preliminary theoretical
knowledge of IMC. The study methodology provides research designs and the
data collection approach to consider the reliability of the thesis. The discussion
presents the research findings through interviews with marketers who
3
2 Literature review
Based on the marketing strategy, the third layer is the integrated marketing mix,
including product, price, place, and promotion (4Ps). According to Kotler et al.
(2017: 263-305), the marketing mix is a collection of controllable elements that
enterprises can use to influence buyers’ decisions. The four variables in the
marketing mix help a business develop a unique selling point and build a brand
image. Product strategy refers to how a company achieves its marketing goals
by providing various tangible and intangible products suitable for consumer
needs to the target market. It includes the combination and application of
controllable elements such as styles, varieties, quality, specifications,
packaging, trademarks, features, brands, and different service measures
associated to the product. The promotion strategy is an approach for
enterprises to stimulate consumers’ desire to purchase their products through
various means of information dissemination. Pricing strategy refers to an
enterprise achieving its marketing objectives by setting prices and changing
prices according to market discipline, including discount prices, allowances,
payment terms, commercial credit, and pricing techniques. Place strategy can
combine and apply controllable factors such as distribution-related channel
coverage, commodity circulation links, intermediaries, network settings, storage
and transportation.
In the late 1990s, the idea of IMC attracted extensive interest and attention in
academia. In 1993, the world’s first IMC monograph, “Integrated Marketing
Communication”, co-authored by Northwestern University Professors Don
Schultz, Stanley Tannenbaum, and Robert Lauterborn, was published in the
United States. It marked the formation of the theoretical concept of integrated
marketing. (Kliatchko 2005) There are many studies on the definition of IMC.
The following paragraphs are the influential definitions of IMC research in the
academic community, as Table 1 presented.
Schultz et al. (1993) point out that IMC is a persuasive communication planning
process that takes different forms for existing and potential consumers. Its
purpose is to influence the behaviour of selected communication audiences
directly. According to Duncan and Evereet (1993), the American Association of
Advertising Agencies defines IMC as a marketing communication concept
emphasising added value. The philosophy highlights the integrated strategic
application of communication instruments such as direct marketing, advertising,
and sales promotion to provide a clear, consistent, and effective communication
impact (Eagel & Kitchen 2000).
It is feasible to synthesise a definition that will fit this thesis's aim based on
examining the above research IMC's definitions. IMC is a management process
that focuses on selected target audiences and integrates relevant audience
points of marketing communications activities to achieve greater message
consistency. The impact of IMC is more significant than the integration of
marketing communications mix or promotional elements. It involves the
management and organisation of all agencies, from analysing and planning to
implementing and controlling all marketing communications, promotional tools,
messaging and media for maximum cost-effectiveness and increased sales.
From the above definitions, Pickton and Broderick (2005: 28-30) summarize the
4Cs model as the characteristic of IMC, including consistency, coherence,
continuity and complementarity.
Effective brand positioning establishes the direction and goals for IMC. What
kind of brand value does integrated marketing want to achieve? What kind of
cultural information is spread out to consumers? Marketing communications are
the voice of the brand (De Pelsmacker, Geuens and Bergh 2021: 46). Brand
positioning is the foundation of marketing communications. The effectiveness of
brand positioning is reflected in consumers accepting and resonating with the
information transmitted by the brand (De Pelsmacker et al. 2021: 68). Without
the overall image design of the brand in advance, corporate marketing will lose
its direction.
Brand positioning aims to match the blank spots in the target consumer’s
mental model and make a deep impression in their minds. Therefore, studying
consumer behavior is a priority for businesses. As far as brand positioning is
concerned, consumer research focuses on the following three aspects:
Brand positioning is not about investigating what competitive brands are doing
but asking: How do consumers perceive competitors’ brands in their minds? Do
11
consumers perceive the difference between a brand and its competitors? What
is the difference? Do consumers care about this difference? (Houraghan 2022)
E D
Source Receiver
n Medium e
c c
o Message
o
d d
e e
Noise
Feedback
The field of perception of the recipient has an impact on the decoding process,
which depends on the receiver’s perceptions, experiences, attitudes and values
(Blythe 2000: 2). The more overlap between the sender’s and receiver’s ‘field of
perception’, the more likely they will comprehend each other (Egan 2007: 30-
34).
A good customer database allows users to query the status of customer orders
and track customer changes and needs. Therefore, the customer database
management system improves the ability of the sales representative
14
responsible for customer service to communicate with the customer. (Kotler &
Keller 2016: 662-663) These service representatives can find out what
customers have ordered and what problems they have encountered. Such
knowledge helps them serve customers warmly and attentively, which in turn
increases customer retention. To improve the effectiveness of marketing
communications, companies should figure out how to optimise to utilise their
customer database. Marketing professionals need to recognise the role of
customer databases in the following areas (Blythe 2000: 167):
• How much does the business have to pay for IMC to attract a new
consumer?
• Does the business keep in touch with target customers when it conducts
IMC strategies?
• What resources does the company have to obtain data on current and
potential customers?
The database can record customer history. If the buyers confirm their identity,
enterprises will establish their brief profiles. Then businesses are able to
personalise conversations for individual customers based on the consumers’
specific situations or requirements. If customer feedback, such as complaining,
complimenting, or asking, is properly quantified, it will help companies design
new products, solve problems, and develop IMC strategies. The database
reveals market changes. If a business continues to pay attention to its buyers, it
will inadvertently acquire consumers’ changing interests and tastes. (Shimp &
Andrews 2012: 412-414)
15
Customer databases are an essential resource for IMC. The database needs to
focus on customer categorisation information, for example, new expectations
and loyalty, and use this information to remind users. The brand positioning and
market segmentation of products will rely on customer data analysis. Fully
grasping data and analysing effective results can directly guide customer
service operations to receive higher buyer satisfaction. (Fill 2009: 635-638) The
high satisfaction will undoubtedly drive a new round of sales behaviour,
enabling enterprises to create higher returns. Databases can create customers
and integrate integrated marketing communications with other business plans to
make companies more competitive (Shimp & Andrews 2012: 414). Therefore,
the customer database is a strategic hub that penetrates every enterprise
business unit.
2.5.1 Advertising
The first primary instrument is advertising, an essential promotional tool and the
most widely recognized form of marketing communication. According to De
Pelsmacker et al. (2021: 200), advertising can be defined as the use of various
media by an organization or individual to transmit its goods, services, or ideas
to achieve the effect of promotion. It can reach many audiences with basic
16
statements that help recipients interpret what a product is and what its principal
purpose is.
People purchase cars for rational and emotional reasons. Consumers like
specific attributes of car, for example, gas consumption and accessories, but
they may also like the vehicle's appearance and the car's image. The more
benefits a brand provides to audiences, the more competitive advantage the
brand has. (Pickton & Broderick 2005: 604-606) Marketers should also pay
attention to brand value. In other words, other selling points should be based on
brand value as the core content. (Fill 2009: 496) One of the core values of the
Swedish vehicle brand Volvo is ‘safety’ (Volvo 2022). Target audiences can
receive the safety message from the Volvo brand in different advertisement
There are two types of PR, proactive and reactive. Proactive PR is formulated
based on the company's marketing goals, which are characterized by attacking
rather than defending. The main scope of proactive PR is applied when
launching a new product or upgrading products. Proactive PR is integrated with
other IMC tools to increase product visibility, credibility, and news value.
(Pickton & Broderick 2005: 549-557) Viewers have a certain degree of
scepticism about the guiding tendency of advertising content because
advertising is paid. However, a publicity event has greater credibility because it
is free. (Moloney 2006) The selected models of vehicles by magazines such as
Auto Trends greatly influence potential vehicle buyers. Even niche media can
have a significant impact on audiences. For example, Pontiac was awarded the
Best Domestic Car by MotorWeek in Las Vegas in 2003. The show was 30
minutes long and aired on about 300 public radio stations. Chrysler also heavily
promoted the Jeep Cherokee, awarded by the 4-Wheel & Off-Road magazine. It
has become a common way for auto companies to brag about their
performance. (Belch & Belch 2009: 550)
The use of social engagement is an important task in proactive PR. Its purpose
is to bridge the dialogue between business and society (Kotler and Keller 2016:
631). There are many specific forms of participation, such as public welfare
activities and donation. It is conducive to forming a good public image of the
enterprise. The COVID-19 Donation Match, launched in response to Ford Motor
Company employees volunteering during the pandemic, has supported relief
efforts in 20 countries. (Dearborn 2020) The action has brought the relationship
20
with consumers closer so that audiences can recognize the brand for the first
time.
difficult to monitor the effect this has on their audiences. Even if a company
invests resources and time into composing a press release, procuring
appropriate photographs, and engaging in conversation with journalists, there is
no assurance that their story will be published. In contrast to advertising,
enterprises are unable to fully control how the media portrays their industry,
when and where their message will appear. (Hurley 2022)
The third primary tool is direct marketing. While promotional mix tools such as
advertising and PR effectively shape the brand image and transmit a message,
direct marketing can directly communicate with consumers to generate
immediate behavioural responses (Kotler & Keller 2016: 657). According to
Blythe (2000: 160), the American Direct Marketing Association (ADMA) defines
direct marketing: as an enterprise that directly releases a product or service
message to target audiences for profit through the combination and optimization
of diversified media to seek a direct response from consumers. Direct marketing
is a marketing approach that comprehensively utilizes various media to control
marketing effects accurately. It focuses on the input-output ratio and strategy of
marketing effect. (Fill 2009: 624-626)
The biggest difference between direct marketing and other IMC tools is the
utilization of media, including direct mail, the Internet, etc. Direct mail refers to
the medium of advertising by selectively sending print advertisements directly to
users through the mailing network. Some common forms include catalogues,
manuals, price lists, postcards, brochures, corporate publications, posters, and
samples. (Pickton & Broderick 2005: 627) The marketer can freely address the
particular groups of customers, posting time and advertising content. Direct mail
advertising for the automotive industry is crucial for driving consumers to
service centres, websites, aftersales marketing suppliers, and dealerships. In
automotive aftersales marketing, marketers often offer coupons or special
discounts to consumers through direct mail advertising to encourage them to
return to the dealership for routine maintenance and services on the vehicle.
22
Postcards are widely used in automotive direct mail campaigns because they
cost a reasonable amount to mail. As shown in Figure 5. the Toyota postcard
was mailed in summer of 2021. A top offer is highlighted in bold black letters
against a white background. The benefits are laid out in an easy-to-understand
bullet point format. The copy in the flash provides additional details about the
promotion. (Bobnak 2021)
Nissan mails loyalty in June 2021 very well. Two models are highlighted in the
huge photograph that spans the front of the postcard. The ‘Private Offer’
23
2022) Marketers must be certain that the mailing list comprises those who have
agreed to receive marketing communication from the enterprise.
25
3 Research methodology
The methodology part includes the way of doing research and the fundamental
terminology associated with it to find out a correct approach to collect and
analyse data. The concept of research is any systematic, objective, and
structured investigation to make informed and timely judgments. It is carried out
by an individual or group with expertise and scientific approaches and performs
an open, honest and impartial study. (Sontakki 2009: 6)
The research process can be broken down into four steps, as Figure 7 presents.
The starting point of a research procedure is defining marketing problems and
setting objectives. This drives the whole process to ensure that the study
targets the correct issue. The second step is formulating a research plan to
collect the necessary academic knowledge to accomplish the study objective. It
outlines the steps required to gather the data needed to construct a study that
tests the assumptions of interest, determines viable solutions to research
issues, and provides the data required to make decisions. The third stage is
data collection. There are many sources of information that businesses can
utilise and proactively seek out. Data can be divided into preliminary research
and secondary research. Preliminary data is the original data collected by the
26
Exploratory, descriptive, and causal research are the three primary types of
research design. Exploratory research refers to collecting preliminary data to
point out the hypotheses and obtain the idea of solving the problem. Descriptive
research is a quantitative description of various market elements and corporate
marketing. Causal research investigates the mutual causal relationship of many
factors in marketing. (Kotler et al. 2017: 110)
In order to gather relevant data for this thesis, both exploratory and descriptive
research approaches will be applied. The primary purpose of exploratory
research is to provide information to help investigators recognize and
understand the problems they face. Descriptive research studies phenomena,
questions, and facts utilizing observation, investigation, and interview.
Qualitative research was the fundamental methodology used in this thesis, for
example, collecting relevant books, journals, and magazines, to interpret the
subject. The goal was to conduct interviews with two marketing communication
professionals with a comprehensive insight into the automotive industry's
marketing communication process to ensure that the data would be highly
relevant to the topic.
Gill, Stewart, Treasure, and Chadwick (2008) outlined the notion of semi-
structured interviews, which are vocally delivered surveys in which preset
questions are asked in response to comments that need more clarification. As a
result, they are reasonably fast and simple to conduct, and they may be
beneficial when specific issues need to be clarified. This study sought in-depth
interviews to learn about the professionals’ perspectives on corporate,
business, and marketing issues. Online semi-structured interviews were
organized as a qualitative approach to get knowledge and insight into applying
the IMC strategy in the automotive industry. The semi-structured interviews
were videotaped with the permission of marketing communication specialists to
be analyzed in detail. The conversations were summarized and provided in
written form. According to Sreejesh, Mohapatra and Anusree (2014: 48-50), a
semi-structured interview provides some freedom throughout the interview. The
interviewer’s responsibility in this form of interview is to ensure that the only
research relevant questions and topics are covered. In this method, the
interviewer will be able to schedule a specific time for each question and have
the flexibility to adjust to the various replies.
28
The question list is located in the thesis's appendix. There are three parts to the
list. The first section, including questions 1-3, focuses on general questions
about the development of marketing and IMC. The goal is to understand the
interviewees' knowledge of the subjects and review how the subjects have
changed over time in their views and see if this correlates with the changes
noted in the literature. The second section, including questions 4-7,
concentrates on the communication process, brand positioning and IMC
strategy. The purpose is to get an insight into what marketing communication
plans, strategies, and follow-ups are in a vehicle marketing campaign. The third
section, including questions 8-10, focuses on marketing communication
instruments. The objective is to obtain information on how marketing
communication tools are integrated to achieve sales goals.
Sample size and time constraints were the significant limitations of this thesis.
The goal was to conduct semi-structured interviews with more professionals to
gain a comprehensive insight into how IMC is implemented in the automotive
industry. While the author would like to run as many interviews as possible for
the Bachelor’s thesis, time limitations prevented this. It is essential to
acknowledge that the sample size utilized in this thesis is insufficient to deliver
data that could support any generalizations regarding the entire automotive
industry.
Both interviewers clearly defined the marketing, which is consistent with Figure
1. Marketing is the process of promoting and selling a product or service to
consumers, including market analysis and advertising. Marketing is one of the
most parts of every organization. It comprises activities like carrying out market
research, setting up business and market segmentation, creating product
descriptions, establishing webpages, and enhancing customer services. Many
businesses employ marketing tactics to accomplish their objectives, such as
promoting themselves and increasing product sales. Products and Services,
Place, Price, and Promotion (4P) are the four main elements of the marketing
strategy.
like to do towards the consumers during the life cycle of the car ownership, it
depends on whether they have the customer content or the data about the
General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). According to Burgess (2020),
GDPR is the world's strongest set of data privacy standards. It expands
individuals' rights to access their data and restricts how businesses may use
this information. Vehicle companies should be prepared well when GDPR
arrives, as they can no longer use customer contact information collected from
dealership networks. Obviously, car companies can segment buyers into a
more refined market, and analyze and compare the level of customer
satisfaction and competition in each segmentation, so as to recommend the
most suitable products or services to consumers. Car companies can segment
buyers into a more refined market, and analyze and compare the level of
customer satisfaction and competition in each segmentation to recommend the
most suitable products or services to consumers.
Another significant change is the kind of customers who are more educated
than 15 years ago in automotive marketing. Consumers already beforehand
have gathered so much information about vehicles from the Internet that
previously was not that available and they might already have a pre-list of
brands in their hands. Therefore, marketing communication specialists focused
more on digital and social media assets during the pandemic.
It is easy to get results from sales data when the communication activity is
focused on the product. However, a customer satisfaction-related action is less
measurable. When the unsubscribe rate is higher than the company’s
benchmark in digital direct marketing, it does not mean the firm has lost the
buyer. Auto businesses can try to send follow-up emails to keep consumers
engaged outside of email, for example, offering other methods (e.g., Twitter or
Instagram) to subscribe or asking the reason for the unsubscribing.
34
6 Conclusion
In this thesis, the author studies the position and role of IMC from the structure
of marketing strategies (Figure 1) and sorts the evolution of IMC to interpret the
concept of IMC comprehensively. An IMC strategy aims to produce and deliver
a unified, persuasive sales message across all marketing intended promotional
channels to engage the consumers. IMC serves as the voice of a brand and
enables interaction with consumers. The fundamental objective of IMC is to
enhance brand equity.
orientation and tactical continuity. The orientation of the strategy shows that all
physical and psychological elements in a marketing strategy should be
consistent, which can combine the overall strategy and local strategy of the auto
enterprise. Continuity of tactics means that all information communicated in
different media through different marketing communication tools should be
related and serve a common goal.
When a brand can communicate with its target audience more than once
through different marketing communication approaches, the messages start to
connect with its consumers. A consumer is more likely to identify and trust a
brand if its message is consistently conveyed across all channels. An IMC
approach allows for such a reliable supply. Without IMC, the audience has a
disconnected brand experience, and the intended message is less likely to
transfer.
that due to the shortage of semiconductors in the market, the vehicle models
cannot be launched on time. All employees and stakeholders of the vehicle
company need to know this information in order to coordinate with the new car
sales department to refine its own department’s product market communication
plan.
37
References
Bartosik, M. 2019. Volvo “Volvo XC60 with large animals detection system”
[online] Available at: <https://www.adruby.com/print-ads/volvo-volvo-xc60-large-
animals-detection-system> [Accessed 20 October 2022]
Belch, G. and Belch, M., 2009. Advertising & Promotion an Integrated Marketing
Communication Perspective. 8th edition. McGraw Hill.
Branding Strategy Insider. 2022. The Birth of Brand Image. [online] Available at:
<https://www.wired.co.uk/article/what-is-gdpr-uk-eu-legislation-compliance-
summary-fines-2018> [Accessed 23 June 2022]
Dearborn, M., 2020. Ford employee donation match program contributes more
than $ 1 million to Covid-19 relief worldwide. [online] Available at:
<https://media.ford.com/content/fordmedia/fna/us/en/news/2020/08/13/ford-
employee-donation-match-program.html> [Accessed 28 April 2022]
Duncan, T. and Moriarty, S., 1997. Driving Brand Value: Using Integrated
Marketing to Manage Profitable Shareholder Relationships. 1st edition. McGraw-
Hill.
Freeport Press. 2015. Nissan Exec on One Big Mistake Marketers Make.
[online] Available at: <https://freeportpress.com/nissan-exec-on-one-big-
mistake-marketers-make/> [Accessed 2 November 2022]
Gaille, B. 2016. 16 Pros and Cons of Direct Marketing. [online] Available at:
<https://brandongaille.com/16-pros-and-cons-of-direct-marketing/> [Accessed
29 May 2022]
Gill, P., Stewart, K., Treasure, E. and Chadwick, B., 2008. Method of data
collection in qualitative research: interviews and focus groups. British Dental
Journal. 204: 291-295. DOI: https://www.nature.com/articles/bdj.2008.192
Harris, T., 1993. The Marketer’s Guide to PR: How Today’s Companies Are
Using the New Public Relations to Gain a Competitive Edge. John Wiley and
Sons.
Jolley, D., 2010. Hyundai builds brand with extended world cup sponsorship.
[online] Available at:
<https://europe.autonews.com/article/20101208/ANE/101209865/hyundai-
builds-brand-with-extended-world-cup-sponsorship> [Accessed 29 April 2022]
Kotler, P., Armstrong G., Harris, L.C. and Piercy, N., 2017. Principles of
Marketing. 7th European edition. Harlow: Pearson Education Limited.
Kotler, P. and Keller, K.L., 2016. Marketing Management. 15th edition. Harlow:
Pearson Education Limited. [E-book] [online] Available at:
<http://dspace.vnbrims.org:13000/jspui/bitstream/123456789/5050/1/Marketing
%20Management%2015th%20Edition%20by%20Philip%20Kotler%20%28%20
PDFDrive%20%29-2.pdf> [Accessed 22 March 2022]
Leurquin, E. 2014. Volvo: V40 with automatic braking [online] Available at:
<https://www.adruby.com/print-ads/volvo-v40-automatic-braking-system>
[Accessed 20 October 2022]
Moloney, K., 2006. Rethinking Public Relations. 2nd edition. London: Routledge.
Porcu, L., Del Barrio-García, S. and Kitchen, P. J., 2012. How integrated
marketing communications (IMC) works? A theoretical review and an analysis
of its main drivers and effects. Comunicacion y Sociedad, 25 (1): 313-348. DOI:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258207498_How_Integrated_Marketin
g_Communications_IMC_works_A_theoretical_review_and_an_analysis_of_its
_main_drivers_and_effects
Redi, M., 2002. Building strong brands through the management of integrated
marketing communications. International Journal of Wine Marketing, 14 (3): 37-
52. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/eb008745
40
Schramm, W., 1955. How Communication Works in the Process and Effects of
Mass Communications. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
Schultz, D. and Schultz, H., 2004. IMC: The New Generation. Mc Graw-Hill.
Waterhouse, S. 2013. Volvo XC90 – Take adventure with you. [online] Available
at: <https://www.adruby.com/print-ads/volvo-xc-90-take-adventure-you>
[Accessed 20 October 2022]
41
Appendix 1
Appendices
Section 1
1. What does the term marketing mean to you? How has marketing
changed over your career?
2. Have you heard of integrated marketing communication (IMC)?
Could you give your definition?
3. Do you see a difference between IMC and general or traditional
marketing or how do you see the connection between the two?
Section 2
Section 3