Screening Forms For Waste To Energy PDF
Screening Forms For Waste To Energy PDF
Screening Forms For Waste To Energy PDF
1
Please refer to attached checklist of EIS Contents
Page 1 of 14
EIS SCOPING AND SCREENING FORM FOR THE PROPOSED WASTE-TO-ENERGY (WtE) PROJECTS
Sections / Page
Contents Acceptable? REMARKS
Subsections #
conditions (PAGASA)
b.)Summarize and discuss comparison of environmental impacts
of each alternative for facility siting and technology selection
c)Discuss the consequences of not proceeding with the project or
no project option
1.4. Project a) General layout of facilities;
Components b) Maps showing in particular, the location and boundaries of
project area including its support facilities (ie. municipal waste
storage, wastes segregation facilities area, ash disposal
facility), and proposed project buffers
c) Identification and descriptions of major components such as
specifications, capacity, number and safety features. Major
components of WtE (thermal process) includes:
1. Combustor/oxidation chamber
2. Boiler
3. Turbine
d) Identification and description of support facilities (eg. waste
segregation facilities, wastes storage area, fuel handling
system) and infrastructure requirements such as water supply,
storm water drainage, sewerage, telecommunications, safety
devices/emergency facilities, and similar facilities
e) Identification and description of pollution control devices and
waste management system:
THERMAL PROCESS
Air Pollution Control Facility, for
1. PM (Particulates), any of the following or any combination
hereof:
✓ Electrostatic Precipitator (ESP)
✓ Baghouse Filter
✓ Fabric Filter with Teflon Membrane
✓ Multicyclone
✓ Gas and Particulate absorption tank equipped with
filter medium
2.SOx
Provision of series of wet scrubber and/or Limestone slurry
injection in the flue gas to control SOx emission
3.NOx
Air and temperature control, flue gas recirculation or provision
of catalytic converter to control NOx emission
Page 3 of 14
EIS SCOPING AND SCREENING FORM FOR THE PROPOSED WASTE-TO-ENERGY (WtE) PROJECTS
Sections / Page
Contents Acceptable? REMARKS
Subsections #
The proponent shall ensure that the discharge from the
centralized WTF shall conform with the effluent standards for the
following parameters: Temperature, pH, COD, TSS, BOD5, Fecal
Coliform, Ammonia, Nitrate, Phosphate, Oil and grease,
Surfactants
3.1. Process/ a) Description of the technology to be used in waste to energy
Technology project
o Process Flow Sheet (showing material and energy balance
including waste streams)
o Storage Protocol (e.g. municipal solid waste handling and
transport)
o Heating Value of Feedstock (Ultimate and proximate
analyses of the municipal solid waste as fuel that will be used
and the corresponding evaluation)
b) Description of facilities (ie. boiler, combustion/oxidation
chamber, turbine and pollution control facilities, etc.) It should
include the rated capacity, actual capacity (net and gross),
Volume of waste to be processed, specifications and number
of facilities to be used, efficiency of the facilities.
c) Description of Facilities Operations (e.g. waste segregation
facility operations, temperature of combustion chamber and
stack, operating hours, expected emission at stack)
d) Description of maintenance and monitoring of facility
(description and installation of CEMS, monitoring wells and
other monitoring devices/equipment)
3.2. Project Size a) Total power generating capacity in Megawatts (MW) and Tons
per day feedstock
• Decommissioning/Abandonment/Rehabilitation
- projected life of the project and alternatives for the future use
of the project area which should be consistent with long term
zoning and land use development plan of the municipality;
Page 4 of 14
EIS SCOPING AND SCREENING FORM FOR THE PROPOSED WASTE-TO-ENERGY (WtE) PROJECTS
Sections / Page
Contents Acceptable? REMARKS
Subsections #
- Abandonment Plan (general) to include management plan for
the projected cumulative/long term project impacts such as
remediation of contaminated soil and water resources, land
restoration, proper dismantling/abandonment of facilities/
equipment and other necessary activities
3.4. Manpower Tabulate (in matrix form) the following per project phase (pre-
construction, construction, operation and maintenance):
• Manpower requirements;
• Expertise/skills needed;
• Nature & estimated number of jobs available for men and
women, (if sited in IP ancestral land, include IPs in manpower
requirements);
• Scheme for sourcing locally from host and neighboring LGUs
See Table 3 for the checklist of key environmental impacts which shall be subjected to
assessment. The assessment shall done using the prescribed approach/method and
in relation to the corresponding baseline characterization in the primary and secondary
impact areas (as determined using the Guidelines in Annex 2-2 of the Revised Procedural
Manual (RPM) for DAO 2003-30 or succeeding issuances). The sampling and measurement
plan used shall be discussed. Likewise, the assessment should be done for the
various phases of development (i.e. pre-construction, construction and operation) and
should consider climate change projections and disaster risks based on existing
natural hazard information. For all maps, include overlays of project area footprint,
show sensitive/critical receptors and sampling points for baseline data (indicate
geographical coordinates). In conclusion, the residual and cumulative impacts shall be
assessed.
3. Environmental Management Plan
4. Environmental Risk Assessment (ERA) & Emergency Response Policy and Guidelines
Page 5 of 14
EIS SCOPING AND SCREENING FORM FOR THE PROPOSED WASTE-TO-ENERGY (WtE) PROJECTS
Sections / Page
Contents Acceptable? REMARKS
Subsections #
The level of coverage and type of document required shall first be determined based on
Annex 2-7e of RPM for DAO 2003-30.
6.2 Environmental •
Discussion on the necessity of putting up an EGF. If deemed
Guarantee and necessary, present a proposed amount of EGF indicating the
Monitoring Fund basis for the estimate (per guidelines in annex 3-6 of RPM for
Commitments DAO 2003-30)
• Discussion on Establishment of MMT for ECP (DAO 2017-15)
and corresponding EMF
7. Decommissioning / Abandonment /Rehabilitation Policy
Present the organizational scheme of the proponent including line of command and
reporting procedures as well as manpower complement and relationships with other
operating departments. The basis of the proposed amount of EGF shall be discussed
in this section in relation to compliance with existing guidelines.
Page 6 of 14
ECC APPLICATION SCREENING FORM FOR PROPOSED WASTE-TO-ENERGY PROJECTS
Table 3. Key Environmental Impacts to be included in the Assessment and Formulation of Management and Monitoring Plan to be reflected in the EIS
During scoping: Unless otherwise specified as agreed during scoping, all items listed are required. Write specific instructions ( if any) on the ✓ For completeness during procedural screening; page
blanks/spaces provided numbers should be provided upon submission of the EIS
Required Assessment Baseline Impact Mgmt. Monitoring
List of Key Impacts Baseline Data Parameter Requirements Conditions Analysis Plan Plan
Methodology/Approach Remarks
Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓
I. Land
1.1 Land Use and Classification
1.1.1 Impact in terms of Description & Map showing the project area in relation to Assessment of the compatibility
compatibility with existing land use existing land use. of the proposed project vis-a-vis
1.1.2 Impact on compatibility with Identify ECA where the project is located or near the project actual land use and the approved
classification as an area. comprehensive land use
Environmentally Critical Area plan/zoning classification
(ECA) Identify areas vulnerable/susceptible to natural hazards where
the project is located or near the project area (include map/s).
1.1.3 Impact in existing land Identify areas in or near the project area which are under Identify and assess project
tenure issue/s CARP or with CADC / CADT / CALC/ CALT where the project impact in terms of land tenure
is located or near the project area and corresponding existing issues (e.g. informal settlers, IPs
issues area etc.)
1.1.4 Impairment of visual Visually significant landforms/ landscape/structures (if any) Identify and assess impact of the
aesthetics that can be potentially impacted by the project project on these visually
significant
landforms/landscape/structures
1.1.5 Land pollution due to
improper storage of wastes
1.2 Geology/ Geomorphology
1.2.1 Inducement of landslides Slope and Elevation/ Topographic Map Identify and assess project
due to change in surface impact in terms of the changes in
land form/ topography/ hazard maps (NAMRIA, NDRRMC, MGB, PHIVOLCS, surface
During scoping: Unless otherwise specified as agreed during scoping, all items listed are required. Write specific instructions ( if any) on the ✓ For completeness during procedural screening; page
blanks/spaces provided numbers should be provided upon submission of the EIS
Required Assessment Baseline Impact Mgmt. Monitoring
List of Key Impacts Baseline Data Parameter Requirements Conditions Analysis Plan Plan
Methodology/Approach Remarks
Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓
earthworks on the project
facilities
1.3 Pedology
1.3.1 Potential soil erosion • Summary of Soil Investigation Report on soil type and Describe capability of the land to
quality accommodate the proposed
• Soil map showing soil types, sampling stations, development
topography, streams, built-up areas, and planned project
features
• Water erodibility potential
• Riverbank stability
1.3.2 Change in soil quality/fertility Laboratory results on soil sample analysis for N, P, K, pH, Assess the impact of the project
due to improper collection of organic matter, micronutrients and trace metals e. g. Pb, Hg, activities on soil quality and
generated ash, leachate and As, Cd, Cr hexavalent fertility
potential leak of fuel oil
1.4 Terrestrial Ecology
1.4.1 Loss of vegetation and • Map showing land cover; sampling sites; location of Quadrat sampling for flora to
habitat due to site clearing observed important, endangered, and keystone species; cover all land cover types (please
ecologically sensitive sites; planned land development works show locations in a map);
• Flora and fauna species inventory or survey report to cover Use of mist nets, traps, transect
species listing, abundance, richness, dominance, diversity,
walk for fauna
evenness, ecological status, and uses;
• Historical occurrences of pest infestation, forest/grass fire Identify and assess project
and/or similar incidences impact in terms of vegetation
During scoping: Unless otherwise specified as agreed during scoping, all items listed are required. Write specific instructions ( if any) on the ✓ For completeness during procedural screening; page
blanks/spaces provided numbers should be provided upon submission of the EIS
Required Assessment Baseline Impact Mgmt. Monitoring
List of Key Impacts Baseline Data Parameter Requirements Conditions Analysis Plan Plan
Methodology/Approach Remarks
Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓
Note: Per existing DENR - FMB
regulations, replacement of trees
shall follow the following ratio:
1:50 (50 trees for 1planted tree
cut), and 1:100 (100 trees for 1
naturally growing tree cut)
2. THE WATER
2.1 Water Quality
2.1.1 Degradation of groundwater Physico-Chemical characterization of ambient water : Identify and assess project
quality due to leachate from
ash disposal facility
✓ Temperature impact in terms of degradation of
groundwater and surface water.
✓ pH Use DENR standard methods
✓ COD and procedures for sampling and
analysis.
2.1.2 Degradation of surface water
✓ TSS
quality due to improper ✓ BOD5
handling of municipal solid
waste during
✓ Fecal Coliform
transport/delivery (nearest ✓ Ammonia
body of water 1km radius ✓ Nitrate
from the project site)
✓ Phosphate
✓ Oil and grease
✓ Surfactants
During scoping: Unless otherwise specified as agreed during scoping, all items listed are required. Write specific instructions ( if any) on the ✓ For completeness during procedural screening; page
blanks/spaces provided numbers should be provided upon submission of the EIS
Required Assessment Baseline Impact Mgmt. Monitoring
List of Key Impacts Baseline Data Parameter Requirements Conditions Analysis Plan Plan
Methodology/Approach Remarks
Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓
3.1 Meteorology/ Climatology
3.1.1 Impact on local micro-climate Monthly average rainfall and temperature of the area; Identify and assess project
e.g. local temperature (for Climatological normals/extremes; Wind rose diagrams; impact in terms of change in the
thermal process only) Frequency of Tropical cyclones local micro- climate change. Also
discuss effects of climate change
using PAGASA medium to long
term projections
3.1.2 Contribution in terms of Data on Greenhouse gasses (i.e. carbon dioxide, nitrous Estimate projected greenhouse
greenhouse gas emissions oxide) gases (GHG) (i.e. carbon dioxide,
nitrous oxide) using IPCC
guidelines; include mitigation
and/or sequestration program to
off-set GHG emissions.
3.2 Air Quality (& Noise)
3.2.1 Degradation of air quality Characterization of ambient air quality: Use DENR standard methods
✓ TSP and procedures for sampling and
analysis.
✓ PM10
✓ SOx Identification and assessment of
impact of the project to the
✓ NOx identified parameters including
Sampling site map odor
o At least two sampling stations (upwind and
downwind)
During scoping: Unless otherwise specified as agreed during scoping, all items listed are required. Write specific instructions ( if any) on the ✓ For completeness during procedural screening; page
blanks/spaces provided numbers should be provided upon submission of the EIS
Required Assessment Baseline Impact Mgmt. Monitoring
List of Key Impacts Baseline Data Parameter Requirements Conditions Analysis Plan Plan
Methodology/Approach Remarks
Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓
- Settlements map public access and housing
Change/conflict Right of way options for displaced settlers
Census of population / property that will be displaced /
disturbed For project with displacement/
disturbance of properties/settlers,
Housing ownership profile / availability of housing/ number of change/conflict in land ownership
informal settlers and change/conflict right of way,
formulate resettlement framework
plan or RAP
4.2 In-migration Identify and assess project
impact due to in-migration
Proliferation of informal settlers patterns including proliferation of
informal settlers
4.3 Cultural/Lifestyle change Demographic data on Indigenous People (if any) and existing Identity and assess project
(especially on Indigenous People, Culture/Lifestyle that may be significantly affected impact in terms of
if any) Culture/Lifestyle that may be
affected and/or introduced
4.4 Impacts on physical cultural Inventory and description of the value/importance of physical Identify and assess all potential
resources cultural resources: Movable or immovable objects, sites, project impacts on physical
structures, groups of structures, and natural features and cultural resources in an
landscapes that have archaeological, paleontologic, historical, integrated manner, and identify
architectural, religious, aesthetic, or other cultural and address risks in
significance. terms of institutional capacity and
• Physical cultural resources may be located in urban or commitment in managing
During scoping: Unless otherwise specified as agreed during scoping, all items listed are required. Write specific instructions ( if any) on the ✓ For completeness during procedural screening; page
blanks/spaces provided numbers should be provided upon submission of the EIS
Required Assessment Baseline Impact Mgmt. Monitoring
List of Key Impacts Baseline Data Parameter Requirements Conditions Analysis Plan Plan
Methodology/Approach Remarks
Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓
safety (Government and Private) threats to public health and safety
due to project impacts.
Statistical data / information related to public services:
• Morbidity and mortality rates (infants and adults - 5-year Analysis of the aggravation as a
trend) result of project implementation
of the existing diseases profile.
• Common diseases in the area including endemic diseases;
• Environmental Health and Sanitation Profile Relate discussions on air quality.
4.6 Generation of Local Socioeconomic data: Identify and assess local benefits
Benefits from the project • Main sources of Income of the project in terms of
• Employment rate/profile enhancement of employment and
Enhancement of • Sources of livelihood livelihood opportunities
employment and livelihood • Poverty incidence
opportunities • Commercial establishments and activities
• Banking and financial institutions
Increased business
opportunities and associated
economic activities
4.7 Traffic congestion Road network/ systems Assess the traffic impact of
transfer of municipal solid waste
Existing transportation/ traffic situation to project site in consideration of
During scoping: Check (✓) required/applicable items; items with ✓ are automatically required; write specific instructions (if any) on ✓ For completeness during procedural screening; page
the blanks/spaces provided. numbers should be provided upon submission of the EIS
Level of Coverage & CONTENTS OF ERA AS PART OF EIS Remarks/ Monitoring
ERA ERP Plan REMARKS
Type of Risks For the identified safety risks in column 1 Specific Scoping Instruction/s Page ✓ Page ✓ Page ✓
2. 2.
3. Project Proponent:
4.
Resource Person Project Preparer/Consultant: