Insight—141 Shakespeare Does Roofs

insulated. In the winter the air outside is cold. Yup. Cold

air is not capable of holding much moisture. So bringing

Insight cold air into your attic does not remove moisture unless
there is heat loss from the building. The heat loss warms
up the incoming cold air giving it the ability to pick up

Shakespeare
moisture and carry it to the outside. All of the attic
ventilation ratio’s – 1 to 300, 1 to 150 were based on little
or no insulation. The code now calls for R-60 in attics.
There is no effective heat loss from the building into the

Does Roofs attic. It gets worse, the relative humidity of the outside air
is very high – vapor pressure is low – hygroscopic
materials like wood, plywood and OSB “see” relative
humidity not vapor pressure. Venting highly insulated
roofs in cold climates actually makes them wet. LOL.

An edited version of this Insight first appeared in the ASHRAE Journal. You want to have some fun, ask a Canadian about how
well the CHIP program worked in the 1980’s. Oops…has
By Joseph W. Lstiburek, Ph.D., P.Eng., Fellow to be an old Canadian. CHIP was the short form for
ASHRAE “Canadian Home Insulation Program” that came out of
the first energy crisis. Everyone got a couple of hundred
To vent, or not to vent…that is the question: dollars to insulate attics. Guess what? The attics got
Whether ‘tis nobler in the mind to suffer colder. Stopped the heat from getting into the attic, but
The slings and arrows of outrageous moisture, not the moisture. Roofs rotted (Photograph 1 and
Or to take arms against them Photograph 2). More oops. To stop the moisture we
And by opposing end them. To rot – to rust, needed to air seal the attic ceilings. Canadians did it first,
To rust perchance to scream - ay, there’s the rub. and best (Photograph 3). Even more oops. Moved the
moisture problem to the building underneath because air
change in the building was reduced. It sometimes got real
With apologies to the Bard of Avon, after several decades bad, caused spillage and backdrafting of combustion
of dealing with roofs I have come to the answer to the appliances and folks died from carbon monoxide
roof vent question: do not vent…except. Great answer, poisoning. Had to install sealed combustion or power
eh? vented combustion appliances and provide controlled
mechanical ventilation.
Vented roofs blow off more than unvented roofs. Vented
roofs burn more than unvented roofs. Vented roofs are
energy inefficient compared to unvented roofs. Vented
roofs cause moisture problems south of the Mason-Dixon
Line and east of Interstate 35 in Texas. Venting a roof in a
hot-humid and mixed humid climate is a very, very bad
idea.

The only time you should vent a roof is to control

ice-damming. And when I do a vented roof to control
ice-damming I install the vented roof over the top of an
unvented under-roof.

The original reasons to vent roofs were pretty reasonable.

In cold climates roofs were vented to control moisture
Photograph 1: Roof Rot – OSB does not come that color when it
accumulation and…yes…to control ice-damming. In hot comes from the factory.
climates roofs were vented to increase thermal comfort.

In cold climates roof venting controlled attic moisture

accumulation only in poorly insulated attics. Let me repeat
that to have it sink in. Roofs needed to be poorly
March 2023 © Building Science Corporation 1
Insight—141 Shakespeare Does Roofs

occupied space and removing inside air up through the

attic to the exterior. This worked before we had
something called air-conditioning. With air conditioning
venting roofs sucked air conditioned air out of the
building. The only way to not suck air conditioned air out
of the building when venting the roof is to air seal the attic
ceiling. Yup, ended up with spillage and backdrafting in
the U.S. Civilians had a better understanding than most
experts. When they installed attic turbine vents
(Photograph 4), they found that their air conditioning bill
would go up. They had a simple fix (Photograph 5).

Photograph 2: More Roof Rot – Frost on nails and roof sheathing.

Photograph 4: Turbine Vents – Typically lead to increased air

conditioning bills.

Photograph 5: Civilian Solution – Plastic garbage bag

handles the turbine vent problem.

You want to have some fun, ask an American about how

well the Weatherization program worked in the 1990’s.
Oops…has to be an old American. Pretty sure Canada
Photograph 3: A Young Guy – Yes, me in 1982 pointing out
exported the technology to the U.S. to get even for
how to seal attic ceilings.
Canada-US Free Trade Agreement. Weatherization folks
discovered controlled ventilation and combustion safety.
In hot climates, back in the day, you were not actually
venting the roof, you were venting the building under the
roof through the roof bringing in outside air to the
March 2023 © Building Science Corporation 2
Insight—141 Shakespeare Does Roofs

Even if you air seal the attic ceiling, and you handle (Figure 1). An unvented conditioned roof solves this
combustion safety, and you provide controlled ventilation problem (Figure 2).
in the occupied space, venting a roof in a hot-humid and
mixed humid climate causes moisture problems because
the air outside is humid. Note the “humid” in
“hot-humid” and “mixed humid” climate.

Something that should be obvious is not always obvious.

Vented roofs blow off more than unvented roofs.
Significant air pressure differences act across buildings due
to the action of wind. In general building assemblies
experience positive wind pressures on the windward side
and negative wind pressures on the leeward side. This
includes sloping roof assemblies. Attic spaces that are
ventilated typically have soffit ventilation. Soffit
assemblies are not able to withstand high wind events.
When soffit assemblies collapse in high wind events, wind
can enter the attic space on the windward side pressurizing
the attic space. When this attic positive air pressure is
coupled with the negative pressure on the exterior surfaces
of the leeward side of the building the air pressure
Figure 1: Vented Roofs - Vented roofs are energy inefficient
difference across roof sheathing and roof cladding compared to unvented roofs. This is particularly the case where
elements such as shingles, tiles, and metal roofing ductwork and mechanical systems are located in vented attics.
significantly increases. This significant air pressure Ductwork leaks and leads to negative air pressures, energy costs and
part load moisture problems.
increase can lead to loss of the roof structure. Roof
assemblies that are not vented resist high wind events
more effectively than vented roof assemblies because there
is less risk of soffit collapse.

As noted earlier, vented roofs burn more than unvented

roofs. We were here before (BSI-129: Wildfire). With
respect to wildfires the issue is burning embers. Roofs are
particularly prone to burn ember exposure – both from
the perspective of the roof covering and from the
perspective of roof venting.

Entry of burning embers is a concern in urban regions

with higher risk of wildfire occurrence. Homes built in
regions designated as Urban Wildland Interface Zones are
at a high risk for fire exposure. Wildfires burn with speed
and intensity that often lead to a high percentage of homes
lost in these communities. However, the ignition of homes
is typically not caused directly by flames but rather by
Figure 2: Unvented Roof - An unvented conditioned roof solves the
ignited embers becoming airborne and entering vented problem of duct leakage and negative pressure.
roof assemblies. Obviously, unvented roofs do not have
this issue. For decades, one of the arguments for venting roof
assemblies is to “prevent shingles from being cooked”.
Also, as noted earlier, vented roofs are energy inefficient This has been discounted in many papers. A good piece of
compared to unvented roofs. This is particularly the case work was done by Rudd in 2005 (Journal of Building
where ductwork and mechanical systems are located in Physics, October 2005). Rudd found that “the
vented attics. Ductwork leaks and leads to negative air summertime average daily temperature of roofing materials
pressures, energy costs and part load moisture problems is nearly unchanged whether vented or unvented, while

March 2023 © Building Science Corporation 3

Insight—141 Shakespeare Does Roofs

short-term peak temperature increases are not more than 7

degrees F.” It is also obvious that the color of the roofing
layer is more significant regarding temperature than
venting or not venting.

Now to the “except” part. The only time you should vent
a roof is to control ice-damming (Photograph 6). We
were here before (BSI-046: Dam Ice Dam). Ice dams
happen when the outside temperature is below freezing,
the roof deck temperature is above freezing and there is
snow on the roof. The warm roof deck causes the snow
on top of the roof deck to melt and the melt water runs
down to the edge of the roof where the water freezes
leading to a buildup of ice and a back-up of water – hence
the term “dam”.
Figure 3: Vented Over Roof Over an Unvented Under Roof Roof -
Note that the air intake for the vented “over-roof” is at the facia and that
the overhang is insulated compensating for cladding thermal plumes
due to incident solar radiation.

Whew! Had to get all of this off my chest. Venting

therapy.

Photograph 6: Classic Ice Dam – Can be prevented and controlled

with ventilation.

The strategy to control ice dams is fundamentally

straightforward – keep the roof deck below freezing when
the outside temperature is below freezing. The best
approach – the classic approach - to ice dam control is the
vented roof. Keep heat from the interior from getting to
the roof deck and then remove any heat that gets there
using ventilation. So you want/need a vented roof to
control ice-damming. Having said that, I installed the
vented roof over the top of an unvented under-roof
(Figure 3). What about the issue with the entry of
burning embers? Operable vents that are closed when a
wildfire event occurs.

March 2023 © Building Science Corporation 4

Insight—141 Shakespeare Does Roofs

Bibliography

Lstiburek, J.W., “Learning from Mistakes”, ASHRAE

Journal, February 2010

Lstiburek, J.W., "BSI-046: Dam Ice Dam", February 2011

Lstiburek, J.W., "BSI-129: Wildfire", February 2022

Rudd, A., “Field Performance of Unvented Cathedralized

Attics in the USA, Journal of Building Physics , Vol 29,
No. 2, October 2005
https://buildingscience.com/sites/default/files/migrate/p
df/PA_Rudd_Journal%20of%20Building%20Physics%20
Unvented%20Cathedralized%20Attics.pdf

March 2023 © Building Science Corporation 5