Sense of Belonging: Fraternities provide a sense of belonging and brotherhood to their members.

This is
particularly important for students who are away from home and may be feeling homesick or lonely.
Joining a fraternity can give students a sense of community and support, which can help them adjust to
college life and form lasting friendships. Leadership Development: Fraternities offer many opportunities
for members to develop their leadership skills. Members may hold leadership positions within the
organization, plan events, and engage in community service projects. These experiences can help students
develop important skills such as communication, organization, and teamwork, which can be beneficial in
future careers. Networking: Fraternities often have extensive alumni networks, which can be valuable for
members when they graduate and enter the workforce. Alumni may offer job opportunities, career advice,
and mentorship to current members, which can help them succeed in their chosen field. Community
Service: Many fraternities engage in community service projects and philanthropy, which can have a
positive impact on society. These projects provide opportunities for members to give back to their
communities and make a difference in the lives of others. Academic Support: Fraternities often require
members to maintain a certain GPA and offer resources for academic support, such as study groups and
tutoring. This can help members perform better in their studies and achieve their academic goals
Negatives: Hazing: Hazing is a common practice in many fraternities in the Philippines and has resulted
in numerous injuries and deaths. In 2017, a law was passed in the Philippines to strengthen the anti-
hazing law and impose stricter penalties for hazing-related deaths and injuries. (Source: CNN Philippines,
"New anti-hazing law imposes stricter penalties for deaths, injuries," 2017) Violence: Fraternities in the
Philippines have been linked to violent incidents, including physical assaults and altercations with rival
fraternities. For example, in 2020, a member of a fraternity in Cebu City was shot and killed during a
confrontation with members of a rival fraternity. (Source: Philippine Daily Inquirer, "Cebu City police
hunt fraternity members after shooting," 2020) Discrimination: Some fraternities in the Philippines have
been accused of discrimination against certain groups, including women and LGBTQ+ individuals. For
example, in 2019, a fraternity at the University of Santo Tomas was criticized for a video that showed
members making derogatory comments about women and members of the LGBTQ+ community. (Source:
ABS-CBN News, "UST fraternity criticized over derogatory comments vs women, LGBT community,"
2019) Horacio Castillo III: In 2017, Horacio Castillo III, a law student at the University of Santo Tomas
(UST), died after allegedly being subjected to hazing by members of the Aegis Juris fraternity. Castillo's
death sparked widespread outrage and led to the passage of the Anti-Hazing Act of 2018, which imposed
stricter penalties for hazing-related deaths and injuries. Guillo Servando: In 2014, Guillo Servando, a
freshman basketball player at De La Salle-College of St. Benilde, died after allegedly being subjected to
hazing by members of the Tau Gamma Phi fraternity. Servando's death led to calls for stronger anti-
hazing laws and greater efforts to prevent hazing in schools and universities. Mark Andrei Marcos: In
2012, Mark Andrei Marcos, a student at the University of the Philippines, died after allegedly being
subjected to hazing by members of the Lambda Rho Beta fraternity. Marcos' death led to protests and
calls for justice, and highlighted the need for greater awareness and education about the dangers of
hazing. Physical Assault: Fraternities in the Philippines have been linked to incidents of physical assault
and violence against both members of other fraternities and non-members. These incidents can result in
serious injuries or even death. Sexual Assault: Fraternities have also been linked to incidents of sexual
assault, including rape and sexual harassment. These incidents can have serious physical and
psychological effects on the victims. In 2018, a female student at the University of the Philippines
Visayas accused a member of the Upsilon Sigma Phi fraternity of raping her during a fraternity initiation
ceremony. The accused member was charged with rape and the fraternity was suspended by the university
pending an investigation. In 2019, a female student at the Polytechnic University of the Philippines
accused several members of the Tau Gamma Phi fraternity of sexually assaulting her. The accused
members were charged with rape and the fraternity was suspended by the university. In 2020, a female
student at the Central Mindanao University accused a member of the Alpha Phi Omega fraternity of
raping her. The accused member was arrested and charged with rape.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
You mentioned the 1987 Constitution, Articl II, Section 23. Correct? Do you believe that fraternities and
sororities promote the welfare of the Nation? If so, How? What are your references. Do we need
fraternities for these programs when other organization exist for these sole reasons? Why should we rely
on these fraternities? You mentioned that the KKK was a fraternity. What is your basis for claiming this?
Who is this Colonel Kennon? You mentioned that humans have the natural desire to associate with each
other for a common purpose. What if those same group of people are hurting each other and those of their
rivalry fraternities, is it still protected under the constitution? You strongly advocated the brother for the
fraternities. If some fraternities still practice some form of hazing, don't you agree that it contridicts the
essence of brotherhood?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Anti hazing act There is hazing because there is fraternities 58 people died allegedely - 1954 leny villa
1991 castillo 2017 1995 anti hazing law people moved to ban these as long as there are fraternities there
are hazing (questionable) the only thing can stop this is prohibiitng fraternities as a whole
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~Fraterneities allegedly requires their members to surrender their time. Fraternities have strict
requirments. Frat wars, members are involved in these even if they do not wish to partake. Fraternities
promote sterotyping and discrimination. Fraternities promote violence and consumption Reported hazing
cases. If fraternities are not banned, incedents such as violence or consumptions are bound to happen.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Hazing and initation practices Several high case profile of hazing cases Elitism in Fraternities fraternities
represent a group of identy which comes at an expense of individuality. fraternities can put pressure on
member which can be limiting or oppresive
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
There is no need for us to prohibit
It is created as a place to foster academic, community service, and social initiatives and is based
on the principles of friendship, leadership, scholarship, and philanthropy.
Friendship. Fraternities provide social places for students to
On February 4, 2019, in Abu Dhabi, Pope Francis and Grand Imam of Al-Azhar Ahmad Al-Tayyeb, signed the
Document on Human Fraternity to highlight the "need for a sense of fraternity amongst all men and women
of goodwill" worldwide. (PNA, 2022)

Would you agree that there is any other laws or body higher than the Philippine constitution?
Then why would you question the recognition of the Philippine constitution to the fraternity
groups in the Philippines?
I firmly believe that this case is no longer debatable for it is already written in the Philippine
constitution and no man is higher than that.

Section 13
Youth patriotism n nationalism
Physical moral spiritual
Examples in line with the provisions
The constitution recognizes fraternities but if these fraternities abide the law, they are
punishable by the law.
Violative to what is stated in the constitution
Fraternity group from UP (Who was the founder? Why did they developed such fraternity
group? What is their major purpose or objective?)

Triskelion : believes in the power of reason rather than the use of force as a reason
Tau Gamma Phi: to serve and excel in all fields of human endeavor
According to the Philippine constitution Filipinos have the right to fraternity
Anti hazing law was made to control the hazing cases in fraternities because there are members
who do not understand their goals. These Anti Hazing law was made to control but these law
does not necessarily mean that they are against fraternity

Why should we continue supporting fraternity

Do fraternity really are working for the best of our community?
Their goals are aligned to the provisions of the Philippine Constitution

Would you agree that fraternity is synonymous to hazing?

You have mentioned the case of _____ from Tau Gamma Phi Fraternity. How familiar are you
with this fraternity? You know that they are composed of more than 800 thousand Filipino
members? So you would say that these 800 thousand Filipinos, as the members of these
fraternity, would commit rape right? Or would you agree that these one suspect did not able to
understand the goal of his fraternity and had just made a personal crime for himself?
Why would you mention the name of then fraternity if out from the 800 thousand members it is
only one person who made the crime?
Would you agree that their goal is to rape or kill people? Then I need you to prove that all the
members of these fraternities have raped of killed a person already?
Joel Villanueva has become a mentor of _______ and he is now a (domino effect) ex: chief
justice _________
Prove that fraternity is really a strong support system forging better individuals in the society.

Initiation or initiation rites refer to ceremonies, practices rituals, or other acts., whether formal
or informal, that a person must perform or take part in order to be accepted into a fraternity,
sorority, or organization as a full pledge member. (RA 11053)
RA No 11053 (Anti-Hazing Act of 2018)
Is an act regulating hazing and other forms of initiation rites in fraternities, sororities, and
organizations and providing penalties, therefore. Section 4. Only initiation rites or practices that
do not constitute hazing shall be allowed.
DECLARATION OF PRINCIPLES AND STATE POLICIES (Article II)
Section 13. The state recognizes the vital role of the youth in nation-building and shall promote
and protect their physical, moral, spiritual, intellectual, and social well-being. It shall inculcate in
the youth patriotism and nationalism, and encourage their involvement and civic affairs.
“Initiation Rites” shall refer to ceremonies, practices, rituals, or other acts, whether formal or
informal, that a person must perform or take part in order to be accepted into a fraternity,
sorority, or organization as a full-fledged member. It includes ceremonies, practices, rituals, and
other acts in all stages of membership in a fraternity, sorority, or organization. ( GUIDELINES FOR
INITIATION RITES APPLICATIONS OF ENROLLED ORGANIZATIONS/CLUBS)

Fraternities in the Philippines are social organizations of men in different colleges and
universities in the Philippines having common purpose, interests, and activities. A fraternity is
defined as a group of people united in a relationship, having some common interests, activity,
and purpose. It is a brotherhood, as the members usually say, of people at a college or
university usually characterized by Greek letters. For members, fraternity means brotherhood,
unity, friendship, trust and acceptance. It means meeting new people, sharing interests and
accepting others' as well. It helps inbuilding confidence and character because they believe that
a fraternity gives a certain kind of protection. It gives the feeling of security and importance. It is
somewhat comparable to gangs as they are both organization of people. However, gangs usually
lack purpose and acceptance to communities. Usually linked with violence because members
tend to compete with each other. Unlike in fraternity, members have this humility to help each
other out and protect each other from an outsider.

Fraternities and sororities were created as a place to foster academic, community service, and
social initiatives that are unique to each chapter. Fraternity and Sorority life is based on the
tenets of friendship, leadership, scholarship, and philanthropy.

The heart of fraternity

Until now
Benefits

Collegiate
APO Group
Scouting principle
Binay

3 Principle
Leadership service friendship
Brothers n sister support
Continuous service

Republic Act No. 11053 (lawphil.net)

DECLARATION OF PRINCIPLES AND STATE POLICIES (Article II)
Section 13. The state recognizes the vital role of the youth in nation building and shall promote
and protect their physical, moral, spiritual, intellectual, and social well-being. It shall inculcate in
the youth patriotism and nationalism, and encourage their involvement and civic affairs.
Important people who became part of the fraternities
RA No 11053 (Anti-Hazing Act of 2018)
An act regulating hazing and other forms of initiation rites in fraternities, sororities, and
organizations and providing penalties therefore.
Section 4. Only initiation rites or practices that do not constitute hazing shall be allowed.

Tau Gamma Phi is one of the largest fraternities in the Philippines in terms of membership.

https://www.philstar.com/other-sections/letters-to-the-editor/2009/02/11/438900/tau-
gamma-civic-minded-peace-loving-fraternity
https://www.facebook.com/110798529600839/posts/origin-and-history-of-philippine-
fraternities-2017in-all-times-and-among-all-nat/661792574501429/
https://www.philstar.com/the-freeman/opinion/2018/02/24/1790917/are-fraternities-and-
sororities-corrupting-government

FacebookHYPERLINK "https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F
%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-
horacio-castillo-iii-hazing%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social" HYPERLINK
"https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation
%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-horacio-castillo-iii-hazing
%2FHYPERLINK "https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F
%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-
horacio-castillo-iii-hazing%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social"&HYPERLINK
"https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation
 %2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-horacio-castillo-iii-hazing
%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social"text=Aguirre%20opposes%20complete
%20ban%20on%20fraternitiesHYPERLINK "https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https
%3A%2F%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-
fraternities-horacio-castillo-iii-hazing
%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social"&HYPERLINK
"https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation
%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-horacio-castillo-iii-hazing
%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social"via=rapplerdotcomHYPERLINK
"https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation
%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-horacio-castillo-iii-hazing
%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social"&HYPERLINK
"https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation
%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-horacio-castillo-iii-hazing
%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social"utm_source=tw_shareHYPERLINK
"https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation
%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-horacio-castillo-iii-hazing
%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social"&HYPERLINK
"https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation
%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-horacio-castillo-iii-hazing
%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social"utm_medium=social"HYPERLINK
"https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation
%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-horacio-castillo-iii-hazing
%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social"TwitterHYPERLINK
"https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation
%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-horacio-castillo-iii-hazing
%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social" HYPERLINK
"https://www.rappler.com/nation/182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-horacio-
castillo-iii-hazing/"HYPERLINK "https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F
%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-
horacio-castillo-iii-hazing%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social"CopyHYPERLINK
"https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation
%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-horacio-castillo-iii-hazing
%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social" HYPERLINK
"https://www.rappler.com/nation/182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-horacio-
castillo-iii-hazing/"HYPERLINK "https://facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F
%2Fwww.rappler.com%2Fnation%2F182647-aguirre-opposes-complete-ban-fraternities-
horacio-castillo-iii-hazing%2F&utm_source=fb_share&utm_medium=social" URL
Justice Secretary Vitaliano Aguirre II, a member of the Lex Talionis fraternity, says the
1987 Constitution protects people's right to form associations

MANILA, Philippines – Justice Secretary Vitaliano Aguirre II said fraternities cannot be

completely banned because they are part of Filipinos’ constitutional right to form
associations.
Aguirre said the right to organize and the fight against violence should be taken into
consideration in discussing the issue.
the University aims to create an environment that promotes constructive meaningful interaction among
students, fraternities, sororities and other student organizations; Whereas, in order to nurture that
environment, there is a need for the University to promulgate and strictly implement policies, guidelines,
rules and procedures which are responsive to the dynamics of interaction among fraternities, sororities
and other student organizations;
A fraternity is an organization of male students with shared interests, principles, and purpose.
Fraternities encourage academic excellence among its members who are also expected to help their
brothers with academic needs. Fraternities have been established from decades ago; You’ll find some of
the oldest and most prestigious frats in many state universities and top higher education institutions
around the country. Thus, the academic support that you can gain from being part of a big organization
like a fraternity can prove to be beneficial.
Joining a fraternity can also help in building an instant network. This network gives an edge to young
professionals who are starting their careers as many opportunities can spring from having a lot of
connections. It’s no secret that fraternities have alumni in powerful positions in government, business
and judiciary among others.

Many students find that membership in a chapter gives them opportunities to

develop valuable skills they have not been able to find elsewhere. Sometimes,
joining a fraternity or sorority is an excellent way for some students to meet
people, get more acclimated to campus life, gain important leadership skills,
have fun, contribute to the community, and/or establish life-long friendships.
 it may serve as a guide for future generations to advance a culture of mutual respect in the awareness of the
great divine grace that makes all human beings brothers and sisters,” the preface of the document read.

FRATERNITY IN UNIVERSITIES AND COLLEGES SHALL NOT BE PROHIBITED NECESSITY

A pleasant _____ to our guests, adjudicators, and fellow debaters. According to the 1987 Constitution,
Article II, section 23, the state shall encourage non-governmental, community-based, or sectoral
organizations that promote the welfare of the nation. Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary defines fraternity as a
group of people associated with or formally organized for a common purpose, interest, or pleasure. (More
fraternity meaning). We firmly believe that FRATERNITY IN UNIVERSITIES AND COLLEGES
SHALL NOT BE PROHIBITED. Fraternities have existed long ago. Humans always have that natural
desire to associate with each other for a common purpose – either for social, philosophical, political,
religious, charitable, mutual-benefit or business purposes (Sarmiento, 2018). In the history of the
Philippines for instance, Katipunan, founded by the anti-Spanish Filipinos in Manila in 1892 was built for
the common purpose of gaining independence through revolution, it was the first documented fraternity in
Philippine history (Colonel Kennon, 1901). The presence of fraternities as associations in the community
plays a crucial role in promoting the welfare of the nation. With common goals of friendship, leadership,
service, and philanthropy, fraternity serves as a strong support system forging better individuals in society
(Rappler, 2017). Welfare of the nation, Service, Friendship, Leadership, Philanthropy. Mayor Teves,
National Chairman of Triskelion Alumni Organization said that Tau Gamma Phi, the largest fraternity
group in the Philippines, provides socio-civic projects such as medical and dental missions, bloodletting
with the Philippine National Red Cross, feeding of indigents in different barangays nationwide, gift
giving to the poor children, scholarships, and training, and a lot of humanitarian projects in the
community. Tau Gamma Phi conducted successful bloodletting project in Hacienda Heights village
Covered court in 2020, and the recent conclude Feeding program at Lambug Elementary School, A
project by Badian Chapter, Cebu Southwest Council last March 19, 2023. Alpha Phi Omega also held a
reading literary session among the grade 3 learners of Severo Abeto Elementary School at Sooc Arevalo
Iloilo City last march 5, 2023. Leadership. Fraternities encourages the youth to be involved in leadership
and extracurricular ativities by increasing the numberof available leadership opportunities (Kuh & Lyous,
1990). Honorable Joel Villanueva, current member of Triskelion Fraternity, was chosen by more than 18
thousand Filipinos as a senator of the Philippines in the year 2016 up to the present. This is only the
manifestation of the trust of Filipinos to frat members, that they could be a great leader of their own
country. Frienship. According to the published article of Rappler in 2017, brotherhood is an important
aspect of what fraternity life stands for. It is the soul of the fraternity that binds its members together and
allows them to strive towards greater goals. These are only some of the accomplished projects of ov a
hundred registered fraternity groups in the Philippines. Even today, Tau Gamma Phi`s official Facebook
Page shows that there are more than 800 thousand Filipinos that are members of their fraternity and the
number continues to increase. The real essence of every fraternities` mission or goals can be seen clearly
in the development of society. Banning fraternities would only mean sacrificing all their goals or missions
of bringing out the best from the people and for the people.
https://lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2011/sep2011/gr_165287_2011.html#:~:text=Absolute%20Sentencia
%20Expositore%20Non%20Indiget,explanation%20of%20it%20is%20required.

Speaker 1
Argument – anti-hazing address the problem
Facts (salilig died because not recognized by the school)
Moot and academic

JULIE
Human rights
RA 8049
RA 11053
1987 Philippine Constitution
No of school that prohibits fraternities
Fraternity cases where did those cases took place

• Harm
• Prohibition
• Harm, hazing, deaths, merit based hazing, frat wars
• SEC Security and Exchange Comission (recognizes) LGU, barangays
Necessity
• Prohibition won`t solve the problem
• Prohibition is not the solution
 • It is not necessary to prohibit
Parens Patrie Doctrine
Absoluta
New case
Hazing cases
Academic freedom
Right to associate
Positive impact, exceptional leaders, data of senators
Oblation
Sections supporting fraternities

Benefit
Freedom to associate
Proper implementation

Fraternity, public clamor

Well can you share a bit about your stand

What specific org recognizes frats

Why is it not necessary

Proposition is not necessary because harm will not be solved

If by yes you mean,

prohibition of frats r not necessary
deaths occur outside the school
not practicable - senators

recorded abuses - unrecorded abuses

school will form more unlegitimate org
father of the citizens - states has responsibility to protect from harm
prohibition is useless

You r saying that the implementation of anti hazing law

House bills (pushes prohibition)
death cases
english clubs ban

Prohibiting - are you saying that the state shall not encourage
importance of consti