Substation Maintenance Inspection List
Substation Maintenance Inspection List
Substation Maintenance Inspection List
DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 1 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 1 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
PURPOSE
This procedure describes the methods used to perform Visual and Operational (V&O) Inspections of
electrical substations used in the distribution of electricity.
V&O Inspections, are performed with the apparatus in service, and are used to:
Verify the security of fences, gates etc. that prevent entry of the public, and provide a legal
record of their inspection.
Detect any hazards to company employees or the public.
Verify that animal protection measures are present and in good condition.
Detect abnormal conditions before the apparatus is damaged or a customer outage occurs.
Collect data (counter readings, fault operations etc.) used to prioritize individual apparatus
inspections.
Collect data (regulator travels, load readings, relay targets etc.) used for system operation
purposes.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and other Supervisors supervising inspection and maintenance activities
Substation and other Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities
REFERENCES
Liberty Utilities Employee Safety Handbook and Procedures
EP-14 Oil Filled Electrical Equipment Management
LU-EOP G022 Substation Security Entry, Notification, and Documentation
Manufacturer’s Installation, Operating, and Maintenance manuals for the specific equipment to be
inspected
Manufacturer’s operating manuals for the specific test equipment to be used.
DEFINITIONS
Inspect- An assessment of Liberty Utilities facilities for the purpose of determining
the condition of the facility and any associated components.
System Operator- An authorized person, who directs, controls, monitors, and operates the
electric system and its associated apparatus.
Qualified Person- A person knowledgeable in the construction and operation of electric
power generation, transmission, substation, and/or distribution apparatus
involved along with the associated hazards in specific duties pertaining to
electric operations.
Qualified Worker- Workers shall be trained in and familiar with the safety related work
practices, safety procedures and other safety requirements that pertain to
their respective job assignments. Workers shall also be trained in and
familiar with any other safety practices, including applicable emergency
procedures (such as pole top/bucket rescue). Qualified workers shall be
trained and competent in:
II-001
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 2 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 2 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
PROCEDURE CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1. TEST EQUIPMENT REQUIRED. ........................................................ 2
2. MATERIALS REQUIRED. ................................................................. 2
3. INITIAL SUBSTATION ENTRY ........................................................... 2
4. INSPECT YARD ............................................................................. 3
5. NOTIFY THE SYSTEM OPERATOR.................................................... 3
6. REPORTING AND CORRECTING PROBLEMS AND DISCREPANCIES ...... 3
7. CONTROL HOUSE ......................................................................... 4
8. YARD INSPECTION ........................................................................ 7
9. OIL LEAK REPORTING ................................................................... 9
10. APPARATUS INSPECTIONS ........................................................... 10
11. FINAL CHECKLIST ....................................................................... 14
13. APPENDIX A – TROUBLE REPORTING............................................ 14
14. RECORD OF REVISIONS ............................................................... 15
II-002
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 3 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 3 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
II-003
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 4 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 4 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
a.) After the V&O Inspection, record all abnormal problems found in the Log Book, with red
pen, and whether they were corrected or not.
II-004
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 5 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 5 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
7.10.1 Check both lines alive (load ammeters, line alive lights).
7.10.2 Check timers reset
7.10.3 Check that the sequence timers in normal position
7.10.4 Check transfer scheme auto
a) Record any auto transfer switches that are manual or off, and tagged.
b) Report any auto transfer switches that are manual or off, and not tagged to the System
Operator.
7.10.5 Check air break/circuit breaker/circuit switcher status (open or closed).
II-005
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 6 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 6 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
II-006
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 7 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 7 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
7.20.1 Verify local and System Operator phone numbers are posted and correct.
7.20.2 Verify that the emergency telephone list is posted and clearly visible at each telephone
location.
7.21 Cleanliness and General Condition -
7.21.1 Clean control house floors and sanitary facilities, empty wastebaskets and dust as
necessary.
7.21.2 Inspect control house for water leaks.
7.21.3 Check for signs of animal entry into control house.
7.22 Turn on yard lights, so they can be checked during the Yard Inspection.
II-007
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 8 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 8 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
8.4.2 Signs are easily readable (not faded, damaged or inside of fence fabric).
8.5 Substation yard security problems shall be corrected or reported immediately to supervisor.
8.6 Vandalism related problems should be specifically recorded as such, and reported to
supervisor. Break-ins should be reported to local police.
8.7 Yard Lights
8.7.1 Check all yard lights working. (Yard lights should have been turned on during control
house inspection.)
8.7.2 Repair broken bulbs, glass fixtures, spot light heads, or other lighting that needs attention.
a.) If work cannot be completed safely and while maintaining safe work clearances or if
special equipment such as a bucket truck is needed, note on the V&O report.
8.8 Vegetation/Climbing Aids
8.8.1 Check for any growth of trees or vegetation in fence and gate areas that animals or people
could use to climb over the fence.
a.) Cut or record for the Arborist to have removed.
8.8.2 Record vegetation growth within the substation that requires spraying or removal
8.8.3 Check for stored material (either side of fence)
8.8.4 Check for new or added structures/buildings, neighbors, fences, walls, etc., any other
encroachments
II-008
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 9 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 9 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
Station Transformer
Circuit Breakers and Circuit reclosers
Regulators
Capacitors
Reactors
9.1.2 Leaks from small apparatus that do not appear on inspection checklist should be recorded
in comments section.
9.2 Oil Leak Status Codes
9.2.1 Oil leaks are categorized as follows:
a.) Clean - Apparatus is dry and shows no evidence of oil leaks.
b.) Repaired – A leak is found and repaired, note the repairs made.
c.) Weep - Anytime the external surface of a piece of apparatus is wet with oil. Note the
location and, if possible, cause of the leak.
II-009
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 10 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 10 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
f.) Leak - Oil is running off or about to run off the external surface of containers or
electrical apparatus. Required Action immediately contact supervisor and environmental
program manager.
9.3 Leaks categorized as Leak require immediate action to stop the leak or contain the released
oil
9.4 Leaks from PCB Equipment
9.4.1 If a leak is discovered from equipment classified as over 500 ppm PCB cleanup must
begin within 48 hours (40 CFR 761.30(a)(1)(x).
9.4.2 The inspection records must also include:
a.) The location of the leak;
b.) The estimate of fluid released;
c.) The date and description of any cleanup, containment, repair or replacement;
d.) The results of any containment (for example, was containment successful or not).
e.) The daily inspection results required for uncorrected, active leaks (refer to
Environmental Procedure EP-14).
f.) The records must be available for inspection by the EPA and must be maintained for
at least three years after disposal of the equipment.
9.5 Load Reading
9.5.1 Record any load reading that is requested by engineering on a monthly basis. This
will be saved in the public folder so engineering can access the data.
II-010
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 11 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 11 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
10.1.5 Record any ground relays that are off and tagged and check with System Operator
for SCADA tags.
10.1.6 Inspect Mechanical (69) Trip toggle switch for correct position. Should be in the
normal position unless in abnormal state.
10.1.7 Listen for abnormal humming or buzzing coming from the Breaker.
10.1.8 Inspect animal guards for good condition. Document any spots that are missing
animal guards or need to be installed/replaced.
10.1.9 Check for breaker heater functionality. DO NOT TOUCH WITH BARE HANDS.
10.1.10 Record counter from relay control and update counter card with necessary
information (targets and cause). Only update counter card when there is a change to the
count number.
10.1.10 Record relay targets and reset.
10.1.11 Check indicator lights for open/closed status and replace bulb if needed.
10.1.12 Take voltage reading and perform a load test on the batteries through external or
internal test when available. Loss of more than 3 Volts on load test is a Fail.
A) Record tests as PASS/FAIL on inspection sheet.
B) Failed battery load test should be replaced immediately.
10.1.13 Record breaker position as open or closed. Abnormal states should be reported to
System operator or Supervisor.
10.1.14 Check and record oil level and document any leaks that are found. Refer to leak
status 9.2.1 for leak categorization.
10.3 Transformer
II-011
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 12 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 12 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
II-012
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 13 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 13 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
10.6 Capacitors
10.6.1 If capacitor bank is controlled via Circuit Breaker please refer to 10.1 for
inspection procedure.
10.6.2 Inspect capacitor bank for any bushing damage, all ground are properly
connected and secure, and any animal guards are not missing. Note any spots that
should have animal guards for future install.
10.6.3 Record the switch position (Open/Close).
10.6.4 Record counter from the switch position or control counter if available.
10.6.5 Record control operation if automatic or in manual. Call System operator if
capacitor bank is in abnormal configuration.
10.6.6 If available check the controlling relay for accurate clock time and any alarms
indicated. Record and report any alarms with the System Operator.
10.6.7 Visually inspect the capacitor bank for any bulging, oil leakage or blown fuses.
111111X11
II-013
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 14 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 14 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
II-014
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 15 of 73
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.06.2
Procedure Page 15 of 14
SUBSTATION VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL
Version 1.1 – 11/20/18
(V&O) INSPECTION
12.3.1 These troubles are reported to the System Operator and the person in charge of the
substation. They shall also be noted on the V&O form and station logbook in red
and scheduled for repair at a later date.
12.4 Examples of Not Immediately Fixable Trouble:
a) Surge Arrester blown
b) Broken operating rods on disconnects
c) Damaged bus support insulators
12.5 Fixable Trouble
12.5.1 Fixable items should be repaired as they are discovered during the V&O Inspection. This
insures that the station is maintained in the best possible operating condition and
prevents unnecessary return trips. The items fixed should be noted on the V&O
Report and in the station logbook.
12.5.2 Examples of Fixable Trouble
a) Low Battery electrolyte
b) Replacing blown lamps
c) Installing missing covers
d) Installing signs
e) Installing new locks
f) Cleaning and repairing oil leaks
g) Changing recloser batteries
h) Replacing control fuses
I) Changing nitrogen bottles
j) Changing Silica Gel turned pink or white
II-015
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 16 of 73
Substation Maintenance Doc. # SMP401.07.1
Procedure Page 1 of 5
Testing Circuit Breakers Version 1.0 – 4/01/2020
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describes the methods used to perform Visual and Operational, Thermographic,
Mechanism, Diagnostic, and Acceptance Testing on all Circuits Breakers used in electrical substations.
PURPOSE
Scheduled equipment testing and inspections are necessary to protect both the public and electric
utility workers, prevent unnecessary customer outages, and maximize equipment operating life. This
procedure lists special tools and equipment required, unusual hazards, and methods used, to inspect
and test Circuit Breakers.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and Qualified Managers supervising inspection and maintenance activities
Substation and Qualified Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities
REFERENCES
Liberty Utilities Employee Safety Handbook and Procedures
LU SMP 499.10.2 Substation Work Area Identification Procedure
LU SMP 400.06.2 V&O Inspection Procedure
LU SMP 400.07.1 Thermographic Inspection
Substation Breaker/Recloser Testing Guidance Document
ANSI/NETA (MTS) Maintenance Testing Specifications 2019
Manufacturer’s Installation, Operating, and Maintenance manuals for the specific equipment to
be inspected and maintained.
Manufacturer’s operating manuals for the specific test equipment to be used.
DEFINITIONS
Inspect- An assessment of Liberty Utilities facilities for the purpose of determining the
condition of the facility and any associated components.
System Operator- An authorized person, who directs, controls, monitors, and operates the
electric system and its associated apparatus.
Qualified Person- A person knowledgeable in the construction and operation of electric power
generation, transmission, substation, and/or distribution apparatus involved
along with the associated hazards in specific duties pertaining to electric
operations.
Qualified Worker- Workers shall be trained in and familiar with the safety related work
practices, safety procedures and other safety requirements that pertain to
their respective job assignments. Workers shall also be trained in and
familiar with any other safety practices, including applicable emergency
69 Switch- Switch turned off by operating the mechanical trip mechanism. This switch is
in the closing circuit and prevents the breaker from being closed until it is
reset.
Contact Erosion- During vacuum circuit breaker operation small amounts of metal are
vaporized off of the contacts. A mark or measurement on the operating rod
indicates when the erosion is sufficient to require the contacts (new vacuum
bottle) to be changed.
PROCEDURE CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1.0 Test Equipment Required ....................................................................... 3
2.0 Materials Required.................................................................................. 3
3.0 Unusual Hazards .................................................................................... 3
4.0 Visual and Operational Inspection .......................................................... 4
5.0 Major Maintenance ................................................................................. 4
6.0 Reporting ................................................................................................ 5
7.0 Acceptance Testing ................................................................................ 5
8.0 Testing Schedule .................................................................................... 5
3.1 Electrical
Care should be taken when handling and operating on or inside Circuit Breakers. Units
should be tested and grounded before any work starts. In-service units will have either
120v or 208v operating inside the controls and wiring. Make sure the manufacturer
manual is referenced and voltage testing is made during any testing or troubleshooting.
Bench testing or acceptance testing units will have to have control power voltage
backfeed to it. Be sure to wear all proper P.P.E. when handling and operating.
3.2 Mechanical
Circuit Breakers have many mechanical moving parts that can cause injury when not
handled safely. Always make sure everyone is clear of all moving parts before operating.
If the Circuit Breaker is equipped with a closing spring make sure the spring is de-
energized before any work is started. This can be accomplished by removing control
power and operating the breaker manually until the spring is completely de-energized.
4.0 Visual and Operational Inspection
4.1 Please refer to SMP 400.06.02 for all steps regarding V&O Inspection
5.0 Major Maintenance
5.1 Insulation testing
5.1.1 Using the Megohmmeter to test bushing, with the recloser in the open position to
test bushing – ground and bushing – bushing (same phase). Document all test
results using Liberty Utilities approved forms.
5.1.2 Test Lightning Arrestors for insulation breakdown.
5.2 Contact Testing
5.2.1 Use Microhmmeter for contact testing on each phase. Check the manufacturer’s
manual for specific tolerances if not available vacuum bottle results should be
with 10% of each phase. Check for any significant contact erosion. Document all
test results using Liberty Utilities approved forms.
5.3 Mechanical Check
5.3.1 Check all moving parts and lubricate as recommended by manufacturer
5.3.2 Operate the CB manually using the manual controls and 69 trip control.
5.3.3 Fully discharge the closing spring and manually charge.
5.3.4 Measure Contact wipe or contact wear as applicable. Use a caliper to check
contact movement compared to recommended manufacturer standards. This is
to inspect for any contact erosion.
5.3.5 Any distribution Breakers taken out of service should have stainless hardware
replaced where needed as well as any tap connections cleaned and re-greased.
Check with equipment manufacturer’s manual for proper grease and lubrication
recommendations.
5.4 TTR
5.4.1 Using TTR test the CTs if available at the current tap settings.
Document all test results using Liberty Utilities approved inspection forms.
6.0 Reporting
6.1 All testing should be reported and documented using Liberty Utilities approved
inspection forms for Circuit Breakers.
6.2 All reports should be given to the Supervisor in a timely manner for review and
recordkeeping. All reports should be saved in the proper testing folder on the (W) Drive.
7.0 Acceptance Testing
7.1 All above test should be completed for acceptance testing. This should be done to insure
equipment is in good working condition after delivery from manufacturer. Any defects or
issues should be brought to the attention of the Supervisor for immediate action.
7.2 DC Hipot testing
7.2.1 Check with manufacturer’s manual before running test. When running this test it
is considered a Go, No-go test. Only use for vacuum bottles when applicable.
8.0 Testing Schedule
8.1 To maintain proper working and functional equipment Liberty Utility has decided that all
major maintenance should be performed on a 4 year cycle until such times where that
needs to be changed.
8.2 If a miss operation under a fault condition occurred, basic testing should be performed
on the breaker. This would include an insulation and contact test, and a control relay
test.
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describes the methods used to perform Visual and Operational, Thermographic,
Mechanism, Diagnostic, and Acceptance Testing on Distribution Line Reclosers (Pole Top Reclosers).
PURPOSE
Equipment inspections are necessary to protect both the public and electric utility workers, prevent
unnecessary customer outages, and maximize equipment operating life. This procedure lists special
tools and equipment required, unusual hazards, and methods used, to inspect Distribution Line
Reclosers (PTR).
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and other Managers supervising inspection and maintenance activities.
Substation and Qualified Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities.
REFERENCES
Liberty Utilities Employee Safety Handbook and Procedures
Liberty Utilities Overhead Construction Standards – Section 12 Protection
LU EOP D011 Inspection/Maintenance and Installation of Distribution Line Reclosers
LU SMP 499.10.2 Substation Work Area Identification Procedure
LU SMP 400.06.2 V&O Inspection Procedure
Substation Viper S – Specific Testing Guidance - Checklist
ANSI/NETA (MTS) Maintenance Testing Specifications 2019
Manufacturer’s Installation, Operating, and Maintenance manuals for the specific equipment to
be inspected and maintained.
Manufacturer’s operating manuals for the specific test equipment to be used.
DEFINITIONS
Inspect- An assessment of Liberty Utilities facilities for the purpose of determining the
condition of the facility and any associated components.
System Operator- An authorized person, who directs, controls, monitors, and operates the
electric system and its associated apparatus.
Qualified Person- A person knowledgeable in the construction and operation of electric power
generation, transmission, substation, and/or distribution apparatus involved
along with the associated hazards in specific duties pertaining to electric
operations.
Qualified Worker- Workers shall be trained in and familiar with the safety related work
practices, safety procedures and other safety requirements that pertain to
their respective job assignments. Workers shall also be trained in and
69 Switch- Switch turned off by operating the mechanical trip mechanism. This switch is
in the closing circuit and prevents the breaker from being closed until it is
reset. On a distribution line recloser it is a yellow trip handle. To reset
handle must be placed back to the normal position.
Contact Erosion- During vacuum circuit breaker operation small amounts of metal are
vaporized off of the contacts. A mark or measurement on the operating rod
indicates when the erosion is sufficient to require the contacts (new vacuum
bottle) to be changed.
PROCEDURE CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1.0 Test Equipment Required ........................................................................ 3
2.0 Materials Required ................................................................................... 3
3.0 Unusual Hazards ..................................................................................... 3
4.0 Visual and Operational Inspection ........................................................... 7
5.0 Major Maintenance .................................................................................. 7
6.0 Reporting ................................................................................................. 7
7.0 Acceptance Testing ................................................................................. 8
8.0 Testing Schedule ..................................................................................... 8
3.1 Electrical
Care should be taken when handling and operating on or inside Distribution Line
Reclosers. Units should be tested and grounded before any work starts. In-service units
will have either 120v or 208v operating inside the controls and wiring. Make sure the
manufacturer manual is referenced and voltage testing is made during any testing or
troubleshooting. Bench testing or acceptance testing units will have to have control
power voltage backfeed to it. Be sure to wear all proper P.P.E. when handling and
operating test equipment and Distribution Line Recloser (PTR).
3.2 Mechanical
Distribution Line Reclosers have many mechanical moving parts that can cause injury
when not handled safely. Always make sure everyone is clear of all moving parts before
operating. If PTR is equipped with a closing spring make sure the spring is de-energized
before any work is started. This can be accomplished by removing control power and
operating the breaker manually until the spring is completely de-energized.
1- Identify all potential hazards in work area. Looking outside the equipment being worked
on (as seen in figure above).
2- Review equipment manual for all hazards. All new equipment or equipment that workers
are unfamiliar with should involve a safety stop to review its operations.
3- Review wiring diagram to determine what is going to be energized at the time of testing
4- Remove secondary connectors off of the junction box going to each transformer, should
have the same look as pictured below.
5- Disconnect the secondary connection on the Transformers they are located on the
picture below. (This will create a visual air gap that will prevent any potential back feed
when the control is energized).
6- Connect 120VAC power at terminal block and open fuseblocks as shown above
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describes the methods used to perform Visual and Operational, DGA and TCG, In
Service, Diagnostic, Acceptance, Thermographic, and other inspections on large, power transformers
used in electrical substations.
PURPOSE
Scheduled equipment inspections are necessary to protect both the public and electric utility
workers, prevent unnecessary customer outages, and maximize equipment operating life. This
procedure lists special tools and equipment required, unusual hazards, and methods used to
inspect large power transformers.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and other Managers supervising inspection and maintenance activities
Substation and Qualified Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities
REFERENCES
Liberty Utilities Employee Safety Handbook and Procedures
LU SMP 499.10.2 Substation Work Area Identification Procedure
LU SMP 400.06.2 V&O Inspection Procedure
LU SMP 400.07.1 Thermographic Inspection
Manufacturer’s Installation, Operating, and Maintenance manuals for the specific equipment to be
inspected.
Manufacturer’s operating manuals for the specific test equipment to be used.
DEFINITIONS
DGA- Dissolved Gas Analysis – Analysis of the gases in insulating oil. Used
for early detection of transformer problems and after suspected
internal faults. DGA tests can detect overheating, corona and arcing,
seal failure and water.
LTC- Load Tap Changer – Tap changer capable of operation while the
transformer is energized and under load. Operates automatically to
compensate for changes in source voltage and load current to
maintain constant voltage to customers.
DETC- De-energized (No Load) Tap Changer – Tap changer that is only
operated while the transformer is de-energized. Set at installation and
rarely changed.
Oil Screen Test- Laboratory test of transformer oil, usually a quart sample, for low
dielectric, particles, contaminants, inhibiter, degradation, acids, PCB’s
and water.
Surge Arrestor Lightning arrester. Used to protect transformers and other equipment
from high voltage transients caused by lightning and system
disturbances.
PROCEDURE CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1.0 Test Equipment Required ....................................................................... 3
2.0 Materials Required.................................................................................. 3
3.0 Unusual Hazards .................................................................................... 3
4.0 Visual and Operational Inspection .......................................................... 3
5.0 Major Maintenance ................................................................................. 4
6.0 Reporting ................................................................................................ 5
7.0 Acceptance Testing ................................................................................ 5
8.0 Testing Schedule .................................................................................... 5
7.0 Reporting
7.1 All testing should be reported and captured on test device software or on Transformer
testing report.
7.2 All reports should be given to the Supervisor in a timely manner for review and
recordkeeping. All reports should be saved in the proper testing folder on the (W) Drive.
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describes the methods used to handle insulating oil, in compliance with environmental
regulations, during the installation, maintenance, and removal, of substation apparatus.
PURPOSE
Substation activities frequently involve the addition, removal and temporary storage of mineral oil dielectric
fluid (MODF), or other insulating oils. Oil spills are both damaging to the environment and costly and reflect
negatively to the company.
This procedure lists the equipment required, unusual hazards, and methods used, to add, remove and
temporarily store insulating oil used in electrical substation apparatus.
Oil handling shall be conducted and/or supervised by personnel, who are familiar with the operation and
maintenance of the electrical apparatus, the substation's SPCC Plan, Liberty Utilities Environmental
Procedures and Hazard Communication Program.
ACCOUNTABILITY
1. Standards, Policies, and Codes
A. Update procedure as necessary.
B. Provide appropriate guidance to field personnel when requested for a specific work related task.
2. Electric Distribution Operations
A. Ensure that the procedures in this SMP are implemented.
B. Ensure that all personnel are trained in this procedure.
C. Provide feedback regarding effectiveness of the procedure and revision input as necessary.
3. Liberty Utilities Employees and Contractors
A. Demonstrate an understanding of the procedure in this SMP.
B. Comply with the requirements of the procedures in this SMP.
C. It is the workers responsibility to read and fully understand and follow the manufacturer’s
instruction manual and specifications before operating any equipment.
4. Liberty Utilities Environmental
A. Provide feedback regarding effectiveness of the procedure and revision input as necessary.
B. Approval of any changes to this procedure.
COORDINATION
Transportation department for moving skid mounted tanks and tanker trailers.
Environmental department for site cleanup and equipment removal disposal procedures.
REFERENCES
Liberty Utilities Employee Safety Handbook and Procedures
Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations
Environmental Procedure No. 1, Waste Management
Environmental Procedure No. 5, Release Response
Environmental Procedure No. 14, Electrical Equipment Management
Environmental Procedure No. 15, Reporting of Environmental Incidents
Environmental Guidance Documents for the Specific State
SPCC Plan for the Substation
PROCEDURE CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1. TEST EQUIPMENT REQUIRED. ...................................................................... 4
2. SPECIAL TOOLS REQUIRED. ......................................................................... 4
3. MATERIALS REQUIRED. ............................................................................... 4
4. SPECIAL SAFETY EQUIPMENT REQUIRED. .................................................... 4
5. UNUSUAL HAZARDS .................................................................................... 5
6. APPARATUS TO BE REMOVED FROM SERVICE AND JUNKED ......................... 5
7. PCB AND PCB CONTAMINATED OIL............................................................ 5
8. OIL SPILLS ................................................................................................... 5
9. OIL SAMPLING ............................................................................................. 6
10. TRANSPORTATION OF OIL AND OILY DEBRIS ............................................... 6
11. TEMPORARY STORAGE OF OIL ..................................................................... 7
12. PERMANENT STORAGE OF OIL ................................................................... 10
13. TRANSFERRING AND FILTERING OIL .......................................................... 10
14. SUBSTATIONS WITH HAZARDOUS WASTE GENERATOR ID’S. .................... 12
15. RETURN OF RENTAL TANK TRAILERS (MSDS AND BILL OF LADING) ....... 12
16. APPENDIX A - MATERIAL LIST................................................................... 13
17. APPENDIX B - PCB CLASSIFICATION AND TESTING ................................... 14
18. APPENDIX C - TANK/TANKER INSPECTION AND FORM............................... 16
19. APPENDIX D – PRINTABLE BILL OF LADING .............................................. 17
20. APPENDIX E –BILL OF LADING INSTRUCTIONS .......................................... 18
21. APPENDIX F – INSTRUCTIONS FOR OBTAINING MSDS SHEETS .................. 19
22. RECORD OF REVISIONS .............................................................................. 19
3. Materials Required.
3.1 Clor-N-Oil 50 Test Kit.
3.2 Plastic trash bags for oily debris.
3.3 55 gallon drums for used oil filters and/or oily debris.
3.4 Spill control kit. Verify at substation and complete. (Andax Barrel Pac)
3.5 Oil absorbent pads. Item no. 8830-5482700.
5. Unusual Hazards
PCB contaminated and PCB oil is considered to be a suspected human carcinogen, and may
also cause allergic reactions if in contact with skin.
Oil that has been exposed to arcing may produce vapors that are above the explosive level. If
these vapors are exposed to static discharge or other ignition source an explosion may occur.
Flowing insulating oil is capable of generating static charges which may cause sparks and result
in fires or explosions. All substation equipment being worked on and all pumps, tanks, drums and
other oil handling equipment must be grounded to station ground. If oil is being handled in
locations other than substations all equipment should be bonded together and connected to
system or earth ground. All oil handling hoses must contain a grounding wire, and any pickup or
discharge pipes used must be metal. Splashing oil will also create static charges. The ends of
discharge pipes and hoses should below the oil level in tankers and drums.
Caution should be used on and around equipment where oil may have spilled. All oil spills must
be reported immediately. Spilled oil or oily surfaces shall be cleaned as soon as possible. When
working on top of apparatus, the surface shall be kept clean at all times to reduce the potential for
slipping hazard.
Caution should be used to maintain clearance to energized equipment when working on top of oil
tankers in substation yards. Portable tanks or tankers should be located in a manner which
minimizes exposure to electrical and other hazards.
8. Oil Spills
8.1 Required notifications
1) Requirements vary by state.
2) All spills to water require regulatory notification.
3) Some states require notification of spills of any size.
4) If you are not absolutely certain of the applicable requirements contact your Supervisor
and Environmental Engineer.
8.2 Containment
1) If oil is inadvertently spilled the first priority is to contain the spill to minimize
environmental damage.
8.3 Cleanup
1) Once the spill is contained cleanup should be started.
2) Your Supervisor District Environmental Engineer should be immediately notified of all
spills to ensure the cleanup meets company and regulatory standards.
9. Oil Sampling
9.1 Care shall be taken to assure that oil is not released into the surrounding environment.
9.2 Appropriate spill control shall be used. This can be accomplished with absorbent pads, plastic
drop cloths, drip pans or pails.
9.3 Used oil and oily debris.
1) Used oil shall be placed in closed containers.
2) Oily debris shall be placed in plastic bags or drums.
3) In New Hampshire used oil and oily debris shall be returned to a facility that has an EPA
ID number.
a) Exception locations with an EPA ID number.
9.4 Threaded pipe plugs shall be reinstalled using Teflon tape. Steel and galvanized pugs should
be replaced with brass plugs.
9.5 Valves and pipe plugs shall be inspected to verify they are sealed and leak free.
9.6 Apparatus that was sampled shall be completely inspected for leaks.
1) If leaks are found they should be repaired, if possible. Leaks that can not be
immediately repaired should be contained with absorbent pads or other appropriate
measures.
2) Notify your Supervisor of any leaks that were repaired or need repair.
9.7 The apparatus and work area shall be left clean and free of oil stains.
a) While containing oil, portable storage containers (barrels, bladders, and portable
tanks) and tanker trailers shall have means of secondary spill containment unless
they are being used as part of a continuous process.
b) Double walled tanker trailers satisfy the requirement for secondary containment.
c) General containment is the minimum required for portable storage containers being
used as part of a continuous process. General containment requirements are usually
met by the presence of trap rock at a substation. Sized secondary containment
(usually 110%) is required on impervious surfaces.
d) A continuous process is the uninterrupted process of filling or removing oil from
electrical apparatus.
Work must be in process 24 hours a day to be considered a continuous
process. Normal, short work breaks, lunch etc., are allowed.
If the apparatus will be returned to service the process normally starts
when hoses are set up for oil removal and ends when oil hoses are
removed after oil filling.
If the apparatus is being drained he process normally starts when hoses
are set up for oil removal and ends when oil hoses are removed after oil
removal.
When vacuum filling power transformers the process starts when starting to
pull vacuum and ends when the transformer is at its normal oil level.
If the portable storage container or tanker trailer contains more than
residual oil it must be removed the same day the process ends or
secondary containment will be required. Residual oil is that oil that remains
after normal procedures are used to empty the container or trailer.
Oil brought to the site before the day an oil filling or removal process starts
requires secondary containment.
e) Such containment should be in accordance with SPCC Plan requirements, if
applicable.
f) If the Substation's containment structures (berms, trenches, or pits) can not be used,
then other temporary means of containment, such as, containment boom, portable
berms, or over pack drums must be used.
g) When sized secondary containment is required it must be sufficient to contain the
entire capacity of the largest single container. The secondary containment must be
impervious and sized sufficiently to account for precipitation (usually 110%). This
requirement is usually met with portable, drive-on spill containment specifically
designed for tanker trailers. Heavy plastic and hay bales or other suitable berms may
also be used.
h) If tankers or containers are empty, or only contain residual oil, they are in a
transportation function and not subject to SPCC. Contact the Environmental
Department to determine the containment requirements.
11) When not actively transferring oil, portable oil containers shall have all bungs, covers
and valves properly gasketed, closed. Valves shall be properly plugged.
12) Storage of oil which is not going to be reused must always be managed as a hazardous
waste as follows:
a) In New Hampshire - Only if the oil will not be recycled by burning for energy
recovery.
b) Management as a hazardous waste may require additional requirements for labeling,
inspections and containment. Consult with the Environmental Department.
11.2 Portable (skid mounted) fiberglass or metal tanks.
1) Portable storage tanks are used to transfer medium quantities of oil within substations.
Typical sizes are 500 to 1200 gallons.
11.3 Portable bladder and pillow type containers.
1) Portable bladder and pillow type containers are used to transfer oil within substations.
Sizes range from 100 to tens of thousands of gallons.
2) Portable bladder and pillow type containers should only be used for short term storage
and processing of oil.
3) Inspections - Monthly leak inspections are required for bladder and pillow type
containers containing oil when left at a substation. Refer to Appendix C. Tank/Tanker
Inspection and Form
11.4 Tank trucks and tanker trailers (tractor trailer).
1) Tank trucks and tanker trailers are used to transfer large quantities of oil within
substations and to transport oil over the road. Typical sizes are 5000 to 7500 gallons.
2) Trucks or trailers containing oil shall be parked where they are not likely to be backed
into or hit by other vehicles. A light hit may collapse landing gear on loaded tanker
trailers.
3) Wheels on trucks or trailers containing oil shall always be chocked when parked.
4) In addition to the tank compartment inspection, all accessories and attached equipment
shall be inspected to be in good working order.
5) Tanker trailers landing gear.
a) Landing gear on tanker trailers may not be rated to support full load. Additional
support may be required. The Transportation Department or trailer vendor can verify
the ratings of the landing gear and advice on additional support procedures.
b) Landing gear pads shall be placed on cribbing or steel plates to ensure there is
adequate weight distribution.
c) The rear compartment of a tanker trailers must be loaded first and emptied last.
Tanker trailers may “nose dive” if loaded improperly.
6) Inspections - Monthly leak inspections are required for tankers containing oil when left at
a substation. Refer to Appendix C. Tank/Tanker Inspection and Form.
11.5 Small tank trailers (tow behind).
1) Small tank trailers are used transfer medium quantities of oil within substations. Typical
sizes are 300 to 800 gallons.
2) Wheels on trailers containing oil shall always be chocked when parked.
3) Tongue supports shall be placed on cribbing or steel plates.
TRANSFORMER OIL Less than 50 ppm PCB 50 ppm and over PCB
HEALTH 1 1
FLAMMABILITY 0 0
REACTIVITY 0 0
PERSONAL PROTECTION B C
B - Glasses and Gloves C - Glasses, Gloves and Protective Clothing
x not transferring oil, all drum openings must be properly sealed closed. Drums used for oil storage should be covered with a tarp to keep water from
accumulating on top of, or entering the drum.
5) Oil expands contracts with temperature changes. Three to five inches of air space
should be left at the top of the drum to allow for expansion.
5) The size of any temporary oil storage containers shall be verified to be adequate for the
quantity of oil.
6) Proper venting of apparatus and temporary oil storage containers shall be verified, prior
to starting oil transfer operations, to prevent equipment damage or oil spills.
7) The substation SPCC spill kit (Andax Barrel Pac) should be located and checked to be
complete.
8) An Andax Pac 44 spill kit, or equivalent, equipment shall be at the work site.
9) Filtering equipment and temporary oil storage containers shall be located as close as
possible to the apparatus being maintained.
10) The following steps are to be taken prior to commencement of oil transfer:
a) Check all apparatus, equipment and temporary oil storage container fittings and
valves for evidence of leaks. If leaks are found, correct prior to starting transfer
operation.
13.2 Hoses and hose connections.
1) Oil hoses shall be tested for electrical continuity between metal end fittings before each
use. Hoses failing test shall not be used
2) Threaded connections shall be made using Teflon tape or gaskets and tightened to
prevent leaks.
3) Quick connect couplings shall be made with gaskets in place. The locking tabs shall be
secured with tie wraps or tape.
4) Appropriate spill control shall be used at each apparatus, equipment or hose connection.
This can be done by placing absorbent pads, plastic drop cloths, drip pans or pails under
each connection.
13.3 Pumps filter presses and filters.
1) Pumps and filter presses shall be grounded to the substation ground. If oil is being
handled in locations other than substations all equipment should be bonded together
and connected to system or earth ground.
13.4 Transformer Bushings
1) All transformer bushings should be bonded together and connected to the transformer
tank or system ground prior to pumping oil.
13.5 The following should be monitored while oil is being pumped.
a) The ends of discharge pipes and hoses should below the oil level in tankers and
drums to prevent splashing of oil which will create static charges.
b) Fluid levels to prevent over-filling of drums, portable storage tank, tanker or electrical
apparatus. Storage containers require adequate head space for expansion of oil due
to temperature changes.
c) Apparatus, hoses, and equipment connections for oil leaks. If leaks are observed,
immediately stop transfer operation until leaks can be corrected.
13.6 Before disconnecting hoses.
1) Each valve shall be checked to determine that it is in the proper position (open or
closed).
2) If PCB fluid was processed, flush equipment and hoses with non-PCB oil.
3) During the removal of hoses, care shall be taken to ensure that oil remaining in the hose
is contained. Hoses shall be drained of oil before storage.
4) All valves shall be inspected to verify that plugs and connections are sealed and leak
free. Threaded pipe plugs shall be reinstalled using Teflon tape. Steel and galvanized
plugs should be replaced with brass plugs.
13.7 Apparatus that was worked on shall be inspected for any additional leaks.
1) If leaks are found they should be repaired, if possible. Leaks that can not be
immediately repaired should be contained with absorbent pads or other appropriate
measures.
2) Notify your Supervisor of any leaks that were repaired or need repair.
13.8 The apparatus and work area shall be left clean and free of oil stains.
4) Clor-N-Oil 500 Test Kit – Test results are 500 or over ppm.
a) Attach a PCB Label on the apparatus.
b) Draw a sample for lab testing. See Laboratory Testing.
c) Notify the O&M Supervisor at once.
d) Notify the Local Environmental Engineer.
17.4 Laboratory Testing
1) Using the method described in the Oil Handling Procedure, Section 9.0; obtain a 4
ounce oil sample from the apparatus. If the apparatus has multiple compartments a
sample from each compartment is required (i.e. three tank OCB or LTC compartment).
2) Label each sample with the substation name, apparatus Reference Number,
dispatcher’s designation, and apparatus serial number. Each compartment requires
individual identification (i.e. three tank OCB as A, B and C or transformer with LTC as
LTC and main tank).
3) Obtain a "D" Number from Substation O&M Services PCB Coordinator and send the
sample to a company approved lab.
4) The lab test results will be sent to Substation O&M Services PCB Coordinator and the
appropriate label and memo will then be issued to the field location.
BILL OF LADING
Shipper No.
Carrier No.
Date
TO: FROM:
Consignee Shipper Liberty
Street Street
Destination Origin
Route
N/A N/A RESIDUE – Mineral Oil Dielectric Fluid N/A N/A N/A
TANK WASH
RECEIVED, subject to the classifications and lawfully filed tariffs in affect on the date of issue of this Bill of Lading, the property described
above in apparent good order, except as noted (contents and condition of contents of packages unknown), marked, consigned, and destined as
indicated above which said carrier ( the word carrier being understood throughout this contract as meaning any person or corporation in
possession of the property under contract) agrees to carry to its usual place of delivery at said destination , if on its route, otherwise to deliver to
another carrier on the route to said destination. It is mutually agreed as to each subject to all the bill of lading terms and conditions in the
governing classification on the date of shipment.
Shipper hereby certifies that he is familiar with all the bill of lading terms and conditions in the governing classification and the said terms and
conditions are hereby agreed to by the shipper and accepted for himself and his assigns.
PER PER
3
4
3 Enter the Street Address - Ex. 152 New Scotland South Road
The driver picking up the tanker will fill out the remaining required items on
the Bill of Lading
Substation Maintenance Procedure – # SMS 430.20.2 Liberty Utilities
INTRODUCTION
This procedure has been developed to ensure proper work areas are established in substations for
maintenance, construction, or high-voltage testing activities.
PURPOSE
Equipment and Equipment Bays in substations can appear similar. Work areas must be properly
identified for the equipment to be worked on. Setting up a proper work area is accomplished by marking
a boundary between the designated work area and the energized area through the use of a tape
barricade, flags, and approved barriers.
The purpose of this procedure is to establish a work practice that shall be followed b y employees, to
ensure specific steps are taken, before work is performed in a substation, to identify areas which have
been identified for work entry and areas that shall not be entered.
This procedure defines work area identification for work in electrical substations.
Applications of barricades, flags, or signs are to be installed as directed by the person in charge of the
work and as indicated on the Job Brief. The preferred method is to obtain the Clearance, if required,
install the appropriate work area identification materials at ground level, and test de-energized and
ground apparatus to be worked on. Install additional red flags in elevated positions to further delineate
energized circuits or apparatus as necessary. Minimum Approach Distances shall be observed at all
times.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and other Supervisors supervising inspection and maintenance activities.
Substation and other Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities.
COORDINATION
Not Applicable.
REFERENCES
Liberty Utilities Employee Safety Handbook and Procedures
LU-EOP G014 - Clearance and Control
LU-ENG-SUB001 Chain Link Fence
LU-ENG-SUB003 Substation Grounding
DEFINITIONS
Not Applicable.
TRAINING
Technical Training Course
On-The-Job-Training
Annual Expert Training
DOCUMENT CONTENTS
Table of Contents
II-054
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 55 of 73
1.0 GENERAL
1.1 This procedure must be utilized when work is to be performed on equipment switched out
and tagged in accordance with the Clearance and Control Procedure EOP G014 in an
energized substation. It shall also be utilized when construction or maintenance activities
need to be delineated from energized equipment or when construction is being performed
in close proximity to energized equipment and tagging under the provisions of EOP G014
are not used. Exceptions to this procedure are work activities such as routine operations
or inspections, (switching, V&O Inspection, or readings) that are being performed that do
not require a formal tagging procedure.
1.2 Only qualified employees shall determine the work area boundary designations and the
required location of the barriers and/or barricade to be installed.
1.3 The Qualified person in charge of the work at the job site shall be responsible for the
compliance with this procedure.
1.4 Only qualified employees may install work area barricades (cones, tape, and flags) for the
designated work and/or test area.
1.5 Before beginning work, there will be a documented Job Brief during which boundaries of
the established work areas, test areas, and the associated hazard areas will be reviewed.
1.6 When installing barricades, employees must observe minimum clearances. Refer to the
Employee Safety Handbook for the Minimum Approach Distance Tables
1.7 For work on equipment switched out and tagged under the EOP G014 procedure, in an
isolated area of an energized substation, modification of this procedure is permitted with
the approval of an appropriate management representative and the lead person. Any
modification shall be documented on the Job Brief.
1.8 For Mobile Substation installations where the minimum clearance to unguarded live parts
to personnel on foot cannot be maintained following established electrical clearance
tables, additional barricades such as vinyl fencing or barricade tape, along with signs that
indicate overhead energized conductors, is required
1.9 The applicable section of this procedure shall be followed for work activities that require
the installation of temporary fencing to ensure protection to the general public.
2.1 Barriers – A barrier is a physical obstruction that is intended to prevent contact with
energized lines or equipment. Electrical Barriers purchased shall be manufactured for this
intent.
2.2 Barriers should be used, where necessary, between workers and exposed energized
equipment on all electric construction or maintenance work.
2.3 Barriers should be used, where necessary, to protect energized equipment from contact
with tools or materials that may cause damage to equipment and where such contact
might cause injury to workers working nearby.
2.4 Rubber blankets may be used as barriers, provided that care is taken to keep the blankets
from being cut by sharp objects. Rubber blankets should only be used on jobs of short
duration, since corona cutting of the rubber may take place when the blankets are placed
immediately adjacent to energized equipment. Barriers shall be kept clean, dry, and used
appropriately.
Substation Maintenance Standard – # SMS 499.10.2 Liberty Utilities
II-055
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 56 of 73
2.5 Rubber Gloves shall NEVER be used as a substitute for a barrier or covering to protect
against contact with ends of cables, pot-heads, bushings, etc.
2.6 A temporary barrier shall never be held in place by another employee, by hand, while work
is in progress. This does not exclude the existing practice for the use of barriers attached
to a live line tool.
2.7 See Figure 3 and Figure 4 for more details.
3.0 BARRICADES
Barricading is the use of a visual warning intended to indicate a hazard and to limit access to the area.
Employees shall identify the work area through the use of tape and flags. By “OUTLINING” the work
area, employees will be able to judge more accurately the proximity of themselves or other personnel to
energized equipment.
3.1 Tape Barricade
3.1.1 Approved Barricade tape should be used to outline the work area boundary. The
use of Barricade Tape minimizes the possibility of workers misinterpreting the
work area boundaries and the location of adjacent energized equipment.
3.1.2 Barricade Tape should be tied in place on the structure, where possible.
Illustrations show examples that will fit typical situations of substation
construction and/or work activities that must be done at those locations.
3.1.3 When used at ground level or working surface, Tape Barricade should be placed
between three (3) and five (5) feet above the ground or any surface on which
workers may be located. In the event that there are no structures to attach the
tape, traffic cones or other suitable supports may be used as a support for the
tape.
3.1.4 Under certain weather conditions, such as high winds, the use of tape barricade
may be limited with local substation supervisor approval, when the use of the
tape barricade creates a greater hazard at the job site.
3.1.5 Tape Barricades are not to be used as substitutes for barriers.
3.1.6 Yellow flags shall be used to identify the entry/exit point of the designated work
area. Multiple entry/exit points are acceptable.
3.1.7 Barricade tape shall not be crossed by personnel.
3.1.8 Barricades shall be located no closer than the minimum approach distance plus
the reach of a worker and the length on any conductive tool that might be used in
the work area.
3.1.9 In certain applications, (i.e. Mechanism Inspection), the use of a cone or clip on
yellow flag at the work area can be used in lieu of full barricade tape installation.
3.2 Barricade Flags
3.2.1 Red Flags shall be used as necessary to further identify any energized
equipment located within the work area and/or test area.
3.2.2 Red Flags shall be located no closer than the minimum approach distance plus
the reach of a worker and the length on any conductive tool that might be used in
the work area.
II-056
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 57 of 73
3.4.5 Gates for temporary fencing or removable panels shall be either hinged or
removable panels attached with connecting hardware or hinges at top and
bottom aligned such that they cannot be removed from outside the fence or lifted
off the hinge pins.
3.4.6 Temporary fence posts shall be embedded a minimum of 2.5 feet into
undisturbed earth. End, corner, and pull posts may need deeper embedment
based on soil conditions. Posts may be embedded in concrete. Drive anchor
assemblies are acceptable. Post spacing shall not exceed ten feet. Fabric shall
be pulled tight utilizing tension bars and bands to secure the fabric.
3.5 Grounding
3.5.1 Install a 9/16 inch 19 strand Copperweld wire along the length of the fence on the
station side (to deter theft).
3.5.2 Wire shall be bonded to each and every post, every other post for portable
panels.
3.5.3 Gates shall be bonded to the Copperweld wire via a braided flexible copper
conductor.
3.5.4 At gate crossings, the Copperweld wire shall be buried six inches below the
ground surface.
3.5.5 If soil conditions allow, a ground rod shall be driven every 20 feet and bonded to
the Copperweld wire.
3.5.6 Where the fence joins an existing substation fence, the copperweld wire shall be
bonded to the station ground grid.
3.6 Signs
3.6.1 Temporary fence shall have signs installed per Substation Maintenance Bulletin
SMB 499.06.H.001 Substation Signs.
3.6.2 Install "Danger-High Voltage Within-Keep Out" Signs per specified installation
guide.
II-058
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - Liberty
Page 59 of 73
3.6.3 The unhinged side of single gates one (1) foot from gate post on each side of
fence at least every 50 feet.
3.6.4 Danger Signs (Item ID 8830-0810029) and No Trespassing Sings (Item ID 8830-
5483190) may be obtained through the Liberty Utilities storeroom.
Figure 3 – Section 1 Work Area Boundary Designations Diagrams for use of Tape Barricades and Flags
Figure 4 – Section 1 Work Area Boundary Designations Diagrams for use of Orange Vinyl Fence
4.1 In the event that energized equipment is directly above the work area and creates an
electrical hazard, additional precautions shall be taken.
4.2 Using extension ladders or step ladders, red flag(s) shall be placed at or below the safe
boundary point on the ladder. The red flag shall not be crossed over.
4.3 When the red flag(s) are placed on structures or ladders, do not violate approach
distances in establishing a safe work zone from overhead energized circuits or apparatus.
4.4 Red Flags used to identify energized hazards overhead, shall be installed prior to working
from lifts, work platforms, aerial equipment, or other means that allow work from an
elevated position.
4.5 Additional red flag(s) may be placed on structures for added awareness to further identify
circuits or apparatus that are energized above.
4.6 Additionally, signs indicating energized circuits overhead (Figure 5) shall be placed at
appropriate locations to remind employees of the energized hazards above.
4.7 In places where red flags cannot be installed on structures, signs may be used in place of
red flags with the concurrence from supervision.
4.8 See Figure 6 & Figure 7 for more details.
Figure 6 – Section 2 Identifying Aerial Hazards Diagram for use of Tape Barricades and Flags
5.1 This section applies to temporary testing with test equipment that operates at voltages
greater than 600 volts. All test sets and cables shall be located within the boundaries of
the test area. Any vehicle containing active (energized) test equipment shall also be within
the boundaries of the test area and grounded.
5.2 If employees are present within the test area during testing, an observer shall be
designated and capable of implementing the immediate deenergization of test equipment,
if so designed, for safety purposes.
5.3 Temporary test areas shall be barricaded with yellow/black tape barricade and yellow flags
to identify the safe entry/exit point. Placement of barricades shall be based on the
applicable minimum approach distances associated with the nominal test voltage(s)
applied to the equipment (Allow for increased voltages stepped up from applied voltages).
During an active test, yellow/black barricade tape shall be placed across the safe
entry/exit point to prevent inadvertent entry into the active test area.
5.4 As an alternative to the use of a barricade tape, the test area may be guarded by one or
more test observers stationed such that the complete active test area (all equipment that
will be energized as a part of the test) can be monitored.
5.5 A work area boundary may be used as a test area boundary provided that during an active
test, barricade tape is placed across the safe entry/exit point to prevent inadvertent entry
into the active test area.
5.6 If the original work area boundary is to be used by the test crew, one of the following
options shall be used:
5.6.1 Original work crew may be asked to stop work and exit work area in order for
tests to be completed.
5.6.2 Test crew may set up an additional work area boundary within the original work
zone established and ensure entry point is closed during active tests.
5.7 Prior to the initial application of test voltage, the person in charge of the test shall conduct
routine safety checks and shall verify at the following conditions:
5.7.1 Work area identification is properly installed or as modified and documented on
the Job Brief.
5.7.2 System test status signals, if used, are in operable condition (i.e. strobe).
5.7.3 Test power disconnects are clearly marked and readily available in an
emergency, (i.e. safety switches).
5.7.4 Ground connections are clearly identified.
5.7.5 Required personal protective equipment is being used.
5.8 See Figure 8 for more details.
Solidly drawn lines indicate taped off work zone areas. Yellow Flags are used to indicate the work area
entry/exit path. Work area entry path must be closed during active tests. Red Flags may be placed on
Structures for added awareness to further identify energized circuits or apparatus.
- g
I - . .
_ _ -ꞏ- /
.ꞏ. PathlliJuring. GATE
ꞏ Active e5<t
11
[1
l! il
C _=--_=--_=--_=--_=--_=--_=--_ /
CORRIDIJFl:
•-=-_=--_=--_=--_=--_=--_=--_=--_
Q.gf!::I Q.O!i. _
--------1
Q Q I Q I
I I
Figure 8 - Section 3 Temporary Test Areas Diagrams for use of Tape Barricades, Cones, and Flags
If a need is identified to establish a designated material or equipment storage area for stored assets
within substation yards, the following shall be followed:
6.1 Substation Management shall be contacted to establish designated storage areas and
bonding requirements of stored assets within Substation yards
6.2 Per OSHA regulations and internal procedures, no materials or equipment shall be stored
under energized bus, energized lines, or near energized equipment, if it is practical to
store them elsewhere. When materials or equipment are stored under energized lines or
near energized equipment, applicable clearances shall be maintained; and extraordinary
caution shall be exercised when moving materials near such energized equipment.
6.3 Stored assets shall be a minimum of ten (10) feet from the perimeter fence.
6.4 Stored assets such as power transformers, circuit breakers, connex containers, roll offs,
metal conductor reels, or other metallic objects with a large footprint, shall be bonded to
the substation ground grid.
6.5 Other stored small or miscellaneous assets (i.e. conduit) that may be isolated from the
substation yard with pallets, cross arms, planks, or timber, need not be bonded to the
substation ground grid.
6.6 A minimum of a #2 bonding wire shall be used for bonding of stored assets to the
substation ground grid.
6.7 Designated Storage Area signs (Figure 9) shall be placed around the perimeter of the
designated storage area. Generally, signs should be no more than fifty (50) feet apart and
should face into the designated storage area.
6.8 If the site selected cannot meet electrical hazard clearances, it must be deemed a
temporary storage site and a qualified person must be present to observe the
loading/unloading process. A temporary storage area is not placarded.
The Standard Barricade materials to be used with Substation work area identification are:
The following optional materials may be purchased separately to facilitate the installation of the
standard work area identification materials within this procedure.
INTRODUCTION
Thermographic Inspection is a quick and cost effective means to detect common electrical
problems that result in an abnormal temperature.
It is one of the most important tools used in preventive maintenance.
PURPOSE
The purpose of this standard is to provide temperature guidelines for Thermographic
Inspection.
Thermographic Inspection detects abnormal operating temperatures of substation apparatus,
while in service, long before discoloration is visible.
ACCOUNTABILITY
COORDINATION
Not Applicable
REFERENCES
Liberty Utilities Employee Safety Handbook and Procedures
Flir Camera Operating Manual
DEFINITIONS
Not Applicable
TRAINING
Flir Thermographic Camera Technical Training Course
On-The-Job-Training
Annual Expert Training
DOCUMENT CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1.0 GENERAL ...............................................................................................................................2
1.0 GENERAL
2.0 SCHEDULE
2.1 Each substation should have an overall Thermographic Inspection at least once a year.
Preferably at peak load periods.
2.2 Any apparatus that shows signs of excessive temperature should be corrected in
accordance with the temperature guidelines below.
2.3 Such apparatus requires a Thermographic Inspection Report be filled out for corrective
action.
3.1 Liberty Utilities has defined the following temperature increases, above reference
temperature, as a guideline for scheduling repair.
3.2 Reference temperature is the temperature of similar devices, such as another phase of the
apparatus or another jaw of a set of disconnects.
3.2.1 For load tap changers it is the comparison between the tap changer
compartment tank skin temperature, and the transformer main tank skin
temperature.
3.3 During an inspection:
3.3.1 A report of all objects exhibiting a temperature of 5°C higher than the reference
temperature is to be recorded.
3.3.2 In a three phase system, for example, when one phase has 5°C variation, it
would be reported; but if all three phases have a 5°C rise, it would not be
considered abnormal.
4.0 TABLES
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describes the process used for the release and transportation of mobile substation
equipment.
PURPOSE
Movement of mobile substation equipment requires heavy rigging and hauling equipment and
expertise, and compliance with state and federal regulations.
Requirements vary by state, and whether emergency response or normally scheduled operations are
involved.
Use of this procedure ensures that proper communication, with sufficient detail, occurs to ensure
mobile substation equipment is transported in a timely manner. It is particularly important to minimize
response time in emergency situations.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation Work Methods shall:
Coordinate the utilization of all mobile substation equipment.
Verify the intended purpose and applicability for the intended location.
Substation Maintenance & Construction and Substation Work Methods Supervision shall:
Plan and request mobile substation equipment for both normal and emergency work
Equipment Operators/Riggers shall:
Transport mobile substation equipment to specified sites based on the priority level specified by
Substation Maintenance & Construction.
Obtain required permits and insure compliance with DOT and state requirements.
Annual permits obtained by Fleet Services
General/Emergency permits obtained by Supervisors of Equipment Operators/Riggers.
COORDINATION
Not Applicable.
REFERENCES
Not Applicable.
DEFINITIONS
M&C - Maintenance & Construction
TRAINING
Not Applicable.
DOCUMENT CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1.1 Priority levels for the transportation of mobile substation equipment are:
1.1.1 Priority Level 1 - Mobile substation equipment must be moved immediately with
minimum transportation time.
1.1.2 Priority Level 2 - Mobile substation equipment is to be transported within 24-48
hours.
1.1.3 Priority Level 3 - Mobile substation equipment is to be transported per scheduled
work plan.
3.1 Substation Maintenance & Construction Supervision shall contact Substation Work
Methods for mobile substation equipment availability.
3.2 When Substation Work Methods releases mobile substation equipment for use, Substation
Maintenance & Construction Supervision shall contact Equipment Operators/Riggers
Supervision or contractor to arrange transportation.
NEW YORK
Telephone
Location Contact Title
Office Cell Home
Supv
Equipment
Central Josh Pierie 315 452-7534 315 657-2759 315 692-4781
Operators/
Riggers
Supv
Kevin Equipment
West 716 831-7496 716 207-9229 716 685-6040
Urbanski Operators/
Riggers
Supv
Equipment
East Robert Renna 518 433-3325 518 312-1841 518 588-2317
Operators/
Riggers
NOTE: Alternate Contact for the above is Don Stamer (home 716-667-2460 / cell 716-479-9043)
NEW ENGLAND
Telephone
Location Contact Title
Office Cell Home
Mike Substation
Waltham 781 907-3117 413 374-1956 508 867-5440
Dembkowski Coordinator
Westboro Dan Parent Supv TLS 508 389-2400 508 768-7081 401 639-4969
Telephone
Location Contact Title Company
Office Emergency
New
Internal contacts will coordinate contractors, if required
England
Clark Rigging &
Dave Clark VP 716 433-4600 716 695-4860
West Rental
Rig-All
Rusty Williams Owner 315 732-4138 315 723-7776
Incorporated
Central
Clark Rigging &
Dave Clark VP 716 433-4600 716-695-4860
Rental
John Wozniczka President 315 374-5911
JPW Riggers 315 374-5911
David Schwalm VP 315 374-5912
Rig-All
Utica Rusty Williams Owner 315 732-4138 315 723-7776
Incorporated
John M. Mullins
Albany Marty Mullins Owner Rigging & 518 273-0771 518 469-9483
Hauling Inc.
7.1 Equipment Operators/Riggers Supervision shall notify Substation Work Methods of the
completed moves of mobile substation equipment.
7.2 E-mail Substation O&M Services (no name is required).
7.2.1 Substation O&M Services is a pick on the To List
7.3 Fax
7.3.1 New England - 508 421-7880
7.3.2 New York - 315 428-3121
7.4 If an outside contractor moves mobile equipment Substation Maintenance & Construction
and Substation Work Methods Supervision shall make the notification.
7.5 Sample notification: “Mobile Substation 5W was moved from Gardenville Storage Yard to
Inghams Substation on 7/17/06”.
8.1 Pre and Post trip inspection of the tractor and any associated trailer shall be performed by
the driver.
9.1 Fleet Management maintains emergency blanket permits (Type 6) for tractors and trailers
that allow the movement of mobile substation equipment in emergencies.
9.1.1 New York Permits
9.1.2 Emergency - State of Emergency declared by the Governor or other official and
major power outages).
a. Maximum Gross Weight – 116,000
b. Length – 79' 11", Height – 13' 6'', Width – 13" 0'
9.1.3 Radius - Routine Moves – Annual (for use during daytime hours only).
a. Maximum Gross Weight – 108,000
b. Length – 79' 11", Height – 13' 6'', Width – 12" 0'
9.1.4 Blanket - Regular Blanket Permit – Annual (for use during daytime hours only)
a. Maximum Gross Weight – 100,000
b. Length – 79' 11", Height – 13' 6'', Width – 10" 0
9.1.5 NYS DOT Contacts: Mr. Will Morris or Mr. Tom Golden, North Wolf Road Office,
Albany, NY. Business Hours -1 888 783-1685, After Hours – 1 607 937-0590
(Operations Center)
9.1.6 For emergency or scheduled work, NYS DOT requires two (2) hours to respond
to route planned.
9.2 If movement of equipment via the New York State Thruway is required, prior approval
must be received from the NYS Thruway Authority.
9.2.1 NYS Thruway Contact: Ms. Shannon Van Steenburg or Ms. Sherry Allen, NYS
Thruway Authority, Albany, (518) 436-2990.
9.2.2 Blanket letters, for emergency use only, may be issued.
a. A separate letter is required for each tractor-mobile combination is required.
b. The Thruway Authority, (518) 436-2816, must be contacted the first
business day following use for billing purposes.
c. All normal permit information (tractor plate, total length/width/height, axle
loading and spacing etc. is required.
10.1 There are blanket permits to move oversized over weight loads up to 130,000 lbs. as
construction equipment.
10.2 Reducible load permits for tractors with gross weight of 55,000 lbs are used. Reducible
loads up to 90,000 lbs may be hauled on the Massachusetts Turnpike or any part thereof.
NE WEIGHT # OF
TYPE HEIGHT WIDTH LENGTH REG. #
MOBILE # (LBS) AXELS
193 SUB 58930 11'11" 7'11" 27' 2 SM4793
1754 TRANS 68350 10"5" 9'6" 34'1/4" 2 SM2988
1755 TRANS 68350 10"5" 9'6" 34'1/4" 2 SM2990
4230 TRANS 106500 13'6" 10' 34'11" 3 SM12681
5264 SUB 38795 11'10" 7'11" 21'10" 217007
5266 SUB 36000 12' 7'11" 19'6" 217071
5616 SUB 2 NOT
5806 SUB 45000 12'6' 2 REGISTERED
6845 SUB NOT
6846 SUB REGISTERED
7661 TRANS 102500 13'6" 8'6" 48' 3 SM61564
CIR
7662 14800 13' 8' 20' SM61565
SW
7703 REG 82000 13'4" 10'6" 39'4" 2 17281
7704 TRANS 97040 12'8" 12'8" 46'5" 3 SM17282
8244 GR TR 40955 11' 7'8" 34'9" 2 SM6918
CIR
9030 13'2" 8'6" 20'4" 1 33783
SW
CIR
9031 13'2" 8'6" 20'4" 1 33784
SW
9734 SUB 66779 8' 27' 2 97637
9879 SUB 94600 13'6' 8'6" 48' 3 SM27650
9890 SUB 85500 13'6" 8'6" 40'3" 3 SM27813
CIR
7131-1
SW
7131B/1243 TRANS 106000 13'6" 9'11" 42'6" 3 39411
INTRODUCTION
This procedure shall be followed for projects that will be administered per the Project Management
Playbook to ensure that National Grid substation projects are commissioned into service in a consistent
manner and without risk to personnel safety, substation equipment, or system stability.
PURPOSE
The purpose of this procedure is to:
Define the electrical testing and testing documentation requirements for the project.
Define the procedures for approval and energization for new substations or substation additions.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Project Managers, Distribution Operations, Transmission Operations, Substation Work Methods,
Substation Maintenance & Construction, Protection, Telecom and Operations (PTO), Work Delivery,
and Construction organizations involved in Substation Project Commissioning shall ensure that all
appropriate sections within this procedure are complied with.
Project Management will be responsible to notify the appropriate groups/departments that the
substation project has been completed and energized, in order for the appropriate maintenance task to
be turned on in CMMS.
COORDINATION
Project Managers shall ensure that Commissioning and Energization roles and responsibilities are
defined and assigned to specific individuals at the time of the initial project meeting as required based
on the scope and complexity of the project. Specific maintenance and relay procedures that shall be
followed for the testing and documentation requirements for the project shall be identified at that time.
REFERENCES
National Grid Substation Maintenance Standards – SMS
National Grid Substation Maintenance Procedures – SMP
National Grid System Protection – Relay Procedures PR’s
Engineering Document PR.09.03.000 - Project Execution
Investment Recovery Document Substation Decommissioning Procedure SMP 471.03.2
Remote Terminal Unit Commissioning Test Procedure
Meter Commissioning and Site Verification Guideline
DEFINITIONS
OFF-LOAD Testing - Testing that is performed prior to energization (out
of service tests) documented through the use of the
ACCEPTANCE CERTIFICATE (Appendix E) by
TRAINING
The Owner will define any required training based on type of apparatus being installed and /or changes
in operating procedures.
The Installer shall conduct any necessary training on new equipment for the Owner’s personnel. This
training is limited to on-site discussions and demonstrations during the initial tests and/or during the
commissioning energization process.
DOCUMENT CONTENTS
Table of Contents
2.0 GENERAL..................................................................................................................................... 6
20.0 TRAINING................................................................................................................................... 26
23.0 SUBSTATION WORK ORDER SUMMARY AND EQUIPMENT/RELAY DATA FORMS ............. 31
Note: Individuals are selected during the project kick-off / project outage planning meeting to perform
the requirements of this procedure and may be management or representative individuals.
1.1 CONSTRUCTOR
National Grid employees or contractor responsible for the project physical installation and
connection of structural components, electrical apparatus, and/or associated control,
protection, and metering systems
1.2 CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR
A National Grid management employee (System Delivery Supervisor, PTO Supervisor,
Substation Supervisor, etc.) assigned to coordinate and oversee all construction activities
of the CONSTRUCTOR and TESTER. The CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR will ensure
the project is constructed according to established specifications and be a liaison with the
ENERGIZATION COORDINATOR.
1.3 ENERGIZATION COORDINATOR
A National Grid management employee designated by Substation Work Methods
responsible to ensure all tests have been performed and results received are complete
and acceptable for the operation and energization of the system. In addition, ensures
Transmission Outage Application (TOA) is in affect or submitted for the energization of
installed electrical apparatus or systems.
The position is supported internally by National Grid Test personnel from Relay, Telecom,
Meter, and Substation Maintenance & Construction as required to ensure the collection of
required data and reports necessary to certify the substation and apparatus are ready for
service.
The ENERGIZATION COORDINATOR may request from the appropriate department
management the individuals for the respective area of responsibilities to be assigned.
1.4 OWNER
Is defined as a National Grid or designated representative responsible for the project.
1.5 PROJECT MANAGER
A National Grid or designated representative responsible for all aspects of the project as
outlined in the Project Management Playbook.
1.6 TESTER
National Grid Testers from Relay, Telecom, Meter, Substations Maintenance &
Construction or TEST CONTRACTOR employees that verify the proper installation of
electrical apparatus and components as well as performing all required startup testing and
documentation as required by National Grid. Testing includes, but is not limited to,
electrical apparatus and equipment acceptance testing, electrical testing, and the testing
of associated control, protection, and metering systems.
1.7 APPLICATION COORDINATOR - Transmission
Initial System Control Center contact person with the construction/field for outage requests
(TOAs). Initial management for all TOAs submitted. Reviews TOAs for accuracy, correct
limits, completeness and for obvious conflicts before submitting to the OUTAGE
COORDINATOR for processing. Arranges switch persons, makes notifications to other
departments, Muni's and affected major customers. Assists applicants with project TOA
requests. Reviews and assists the ENERGIZATION COORDINATOR with energization
procedures/TOAs.
1.8 OUTAGE COORDINATOR – Transmission
Reviews & Processes all Transmission TOAs by communicating with the ISO daily &
performing formal detailed studies on ALL submitted Transmission TOAs prior to formal
submission to the ISO. Assists the project team with input into the outage plan identifying
load at risk, constraints, key generation needs, conflicts and performs informal studies on
complex outage plans. Works with the ISO, key generators, Distribution Dispatch &
affected Divisions in evaluating emergency restoration times and identifies risks to the
system and area customers. Approves TOAs &/or communicates TOA conflicts back
through the Application Coordinator. Assists the ENERGIZATION COORDINATOR by
identifying high level constraints & available outage windows.
2.0 GENERAL
All substation apparatus and components must be installed, tested, and commissioned in accordance
with National Grid Procedures. When these procedures do not specifically address specific tests, the
manufacturer’s recommendations or standard industry practices shall be followed.
Specific approvals must be obtained for any procedural deviation or alternate tests requested by
contacting the appropriate National Grid Procedures Administrators.
Final on site commissioning and energization shall be performed or witnessed by National Grid
Personnel.
d. Summary of the Installer’s company experience over the past five years
e. Sample test reports using ProTest Software for relay testing over the past
five years.
6.1.13 Participate in the development of and execution of Secondary Circuit Isolation
Plans (See Appendix U).
6.1.14 Complete applicable tasks identified on the Testing and Commissioning Matrix
provided by the OWNER.
9.1 The OWNER reserves the right to witness all test activities.
9.2 Technical Inquires / Variances / Approvals
9.2.1 As technical questions arise the TESTER shall contact the CONSTRUCTION
SUPERVISOR. The CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR may delegate this
requirement on a case-by-case basis to a member of the project team. The
CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR shall maintain the list of inquiries and problems
along with resolutions as part of the project documentation requirements.
9.3 Relay Settings Modifications
9.3.1 There shall be no changes to any relay settings without the explicit approval of
the OWNER’s Protection Engineer. Any recommended changes by the TESTER
shall be submitted in writing with a detailed explanation for the modification prior
to making any modifications to installed components.
11.1 Control Building and Yard resistance and continuity tests shall be discussed and agreed to
prior to the start of construction for test requirements and who will perform.
11.2 Ground Grid and Grounding
11.2.1 Ground Grid Resistance test - Perform a ground grid resistance test using a
Biddle-Megger Ground Earth Resistance Model DET test set or its equivalent.
11.2.2 Ground Grid continuity to equipment - Verify each piece of equipment in the yard,
such as transformers, breakers, regulators, etc. has two grounds connected and
measure the resistance to ground using a low resistance ohmmeter.
11.2.3 Ground Grid continuity to structures - Verify that each structure such as columns
and stands has one ground lead connected and measure the resistance to
ground using a low resistance ohmmeter.
11.2.4 Ground Grid continuity to Control Building - Verify that the grounding system in
the control building is connected to the station ground grid and equipment such
as control panels, cabinets, raceways, battery racks, etc. inside the building are
grounded.
11.2.5 Ground Grid continuity to fence - Verify that the fence is properly grounded per
National Grid grounding specification and swinging gates, barbed wire, metal
fabric, etc. are properly grounded.
11.3 AC Station Service Checks
11.3.1 Overcurrent Protection - Verify Fusing and circuit breaker settings.
11.3.2 Voltage - Measure voltage and record if it is within plus 2.5% minus 2.5% range.
On a 120 volts base, this is plus 2.5% (123 volts) minus 2.5% (117 volts).
11.3.3 Phase Rotation - Verify phase rotation and phase placement on switchboards.
11.3.4 Transfer Switch - Verify settings, proper operation, and phasing of transfer switch
for dual service installations, see Emergency Generator section for requirements
for emergency generators.
a. CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR shall obtain operating requirements and
settings from local substation management.
11.4 Emergency Generator
11.4.1 Test per manufacturer’s requirements and latest version of SMP and record
results on Inspection Card.
a. SMP 405.01.2 Emergency Generator Procedure
b. SMP 405.01.3 Emergency Generator Inspection Card
11.5 DC Station Service
11.5.1 Battery Eyewash - Check that the battery eyewash station is within 25 feet of the
battery installation, filled and ready for use. Make sure area immediately beneath
eye wash station is clear of obstructions and designated with floor tape markings.
11.5.2 Battery and Charger and alarms - This testing is performed under section 12.2.
11.5.3 DC Panel Board - Check that the panel is labeled with voltage and all circuits are
identified. Verify overcurrent protection fuse and breaker sizes.
11.5.4 Ground Test - Test for and clear station battery grounds. Battery grounds must
be monitored throughout the construction and commissioning process. The
battery shall be tested for grounds at the beginning of each work day and
whenever a new DC circuit is energized.
11.5.5 For dual battery installations, verify that there are no cross connections between
batteries. The battery shall be tested for cross connects at the beginning to each
work day and when a new DC circuit is energized.
11.6 Control Building Power and Lighting
11.6.1 Check that the power panels are all labeled with voltage and circuit information.
11.6.2 Check all receptacles for correct grounding and polarity; check GFI operation.
11.6.3 Check that all building lighting is functioning.
11.6.4 Check that all building emergency lighting is functioning.
11.6.5 Check that any special building power receptacles are properly wired with correct
grounding and polarity.
11.7 Yard Power and Lighting
11.7.1 Check that the power panels are all labeled with voltage and circuit information
11.7.2 Check all receptacles for proper grounding and polarity; check GFI operation.
11.7.3 Check that all yard lighting and photo, time clock are functioning and can be
operated locally and if EMS, controlled remotely.
11.7.4 Check that yard lighting has proper light distribution at night.
11.7.5 Check that all emergency lighting is functioning
11.7.6 Check that all cabinet heaters are functioning.
11.7.7 Check that any special power receptacles are properly wired with correct
grounding and polarity.
11.8 Control Building HVAC
11.8.1 Check that building ventilation fans and controls are functioning, control settings
made, and any fire or smoke detector shutdown circuits function.
11.8.2 Check that building heaters and controls are functioning, control settings made,
and any fire or smoke detector shutdown circuits function.
11.8.3 Check that air conditioning is commissioned per manufacturer’s requirements
controls are functioning, control settings made, and any fire or smoke detector
shutdown circuits function.
11.9 Control Building Fire Equipment, Fire Alarms, Smoke Alarms
11.9.1 Fire and Smoke alarms - Check that the fire and smoke alarms function and
alarm to the RTU if so equipped.
11.9.2 Fire Extinguishers - Check that fire extinguishers are installed and properly
labeled.
12.4.1 Circuit Breakers, Line Reclosers, Vacuum Switches, Sectionalizers and other
circuit interrupting devices -
a. The mechanism for all circuit interrupting devices shall be inspected per:
SMP 401.20.2 Circuit Breaker Mechanism Procedure
SMP 401.20.3 Circuit Breaker Mechanism Inspection Card
b. Vacuum Circuit Breakers will be tested per:
SMP 401.03.2 Vacuum Circuit Breaker Procedure
SMP 401.03.3 Vacuum Circuit Breaker Inspection Card
c. Gas Puffer Circuit Breakers will be tested per:
SMP 401.06.2 Gas Puffer Circuit Breaker Procedure
SMP 401.06.3 Gas Puffer Circuit Breaker Inspection Card
d. For other types of circuit interrupting devices, refer to SMS 400.00.1 to find
the correct procedure and inspection card.
12.4.2 Power Transformers - Refer to the specific version of SMP 402.xx.x for the type
of Transformer being tested.
a. Transformers shall be received per:
SMP 402.11.2 Power Transformer Installation and Acceptance Procedure
SMP 402.13.2 Power Transformer Delivery Inspection Procedure
SMP 402.13.3 Power Transformer Delivery Inspection Card
b. Transformers 15 MVA and above shall be tested per:
SMP 402.01.2 Transformer 15 MVA and Above Procedure
SMP 402.01.3 Transformer 15 MVA and Above Inspection Card
c. Transformers 2.5 to 14.9 MVA and other smaller transformers shall be
tested per:
SMP 402.02.2 Transformer 2.5 to 14.9 MVA Procedure
SMP 402.02.3 Transformer 2.5 to 14.9 MVA Inspection Card
12.4.3 Instrument Transformer
SMP 403.01.2 Instrument Transformer Procedure
SMP 403.01.3 Instrument Transformer Inspection Card
12.4.4 Voltage Regulating Equipment - Test per the following SMP. If the substation has
a paralleling scheme test, ensure that the scheme maintains a difference of no
more than two (2) step positions. The OWNER will supply all settings for the
voltage regulating device.
SMP 404.01.2 Step Voltage Regulator Procedure
The TESTER shall test relay and control circuits per this section. This section establishes the minimum
tests to be performed for testing of protective relays and related equipment for new installations and
does not contain step-by-step procedures for performing the tests.
16.1 Current Transformer
16.1.1 Polarity
16.1.2 Ratios
16.1.3 Excitation
16.1.4 Insulation
16.1.5 Confirm CT location for proper over-lapping of protective zones
16.2 Current Circuits
16.2.1 Location of grounds, insulation test
16.2.2 Secondary signal injection
a. A test current should be applied as close to the CT terminals as practical.
The test should be made from each set of current transformers and include
all phase-to-phase-to-neutral combinations. A check should be made at all
devices for the presence or absence and polarity of current for each test
condition.
16.2.3 All circuits will be marked as tested on elementary drawings (yellow highlighter)
16.2.4 All changes will be marked on elementary and wiring diagrams (green for remove
/ red for add)
16.2.5 Volt-Ampere Burden
a. The test should be made at a point as close to the CT terminal as practical.
A suggested applied current is 3 amperes. The test should include all
phase-to-phase-to-neutral connected burden.
16.3 Voltage Transformer
16.3.1 Polarity
16.3.2 Ratios
16.3.3 Insulation
16.3.4 Confirm VT location for proper voltage sensing of protective zones
16.4 Voltage Circuits
16.4.1 Location of grounds, insulation test
16.4.2 Secondary signal injection
16.4.3 All circuits will be marked as tested on elementary drawings (yellow highlighter)
16.4.4 All changes will be marked on elementary and wiring diagrams (green for remove
/ red for add)
16.5 Ground Relay Polarizing Circuits
16.5.1 Current polarizing sources, low voltage / high current test
16.5.2 Potential polarizing sources, in-service test
16.5.3 All circuits will be marked as tested on elementary drawings (yellow highlighter)
16.5.4 All changes will be marked on elementary and wiring diagrams (green for remove
/ red for add)
16.6 Other Transformer Protection
The following must be confirmed by field test:
16.6.1 Fault Pressure
16.6.2 Low Oil
16.6.3 Hot Spot CT properly wired
16.6.4 Over Temperature
16.6.5 Buckholtz Relay
16.6.6 Pressure Relief
16.6.7 Rotation
16.6.8 Water Flow
16.6.9 Other as designed
16.7 Circuit Breakers and Other Interrupting or Insulation Devices
The following are performed in conjunction with the Substations Department
16.7.1 Trip and trip-free, close and anti-pump
16.7.2 Auxiliary switches - Adjusted to proper operating position
16.7.3 Timing
16.8 Dual Trip Coils on Circuit Breakers
16.8.1 Individual test of trip coils
16.8.2 Simultaneous tests of trip coils
16.9 Relays
16.9.1 All testing to be executed in Doble Protest
16.9.2 Sample test plans and data structure will be provided by the local relay office
16.9.3 Electronic test files will be returned to the local relay office
16.10 Relay and Control Circuits (Wiring)
16.10.1 Confirm all wiring circuit checking / ringing / tracing has been completed
16.10.2 Grounds (if any) location and insulation test has been completed
16.11 Relay and Control Circuits (Functional)
16.11.1 Contact logic, functional test of all contact combinations
16.11.2 All DC contact logic chains will be marked (yellow highlighter) as tested on
schematic drawings
16.11.3 All changes will be marked on elementary and wiring drawings (green for remove
/ red for add)
16.11.4 Pilot channels
16.11.5 Transfer Trip
16.11.6 Reclosing
16.11.7 Lockout devices
16.11.8 Breaker failure functional test
16.11.9 Verify all protection (relay or auxiliary device) alarms to EMS
16.11.10 Verify that communication circuit will continue to operate with loss of AC power
16.11.11 Test for proper Alarm and Annunciator Targets
16.12 Power Line Carrier
16.12.1 Line trap - frequency
16.12.2 Line trap - ground behind trap
16.12.3 Line tuning equipment – alignment to specified frequency - VSWR - re-verify
when the line is energized and carrying load.
16.12.4 Transceivers - frequency
16.13 Transfer Trip
16.13.1 Transceivers - frequency
16.13.2 Communication circuits - frequency response
16.13.3 Verify that communication circuit will continue to operate with loss of AC power
16.13.4 Supply Control Centers with DTT or POTT channel changes so the EMS System
displays can be updated.
16.14 Transient Fault Records
16.14.1 Analog inputs
16.14.2 Digital inputs
16.14.3 Time clock
16.14.4 Remote communications
16.14.5 Distance to Fault Relaying
20.0 TRAINING
For all tests including Doble Engineering equipment, paper and electronic test results shall be provided
to OWNER. The TESTER shall document all test results for each test requirement outlined in this
specification. The test readings shall become benchmarks for all future evaluations.
21.1 Report Formats
21.1.1 The OWNER will specify at the initial meetings the acceptance and electrical
tests documentation and reporting requirements for paper and/or electronic test
results.
21.1.2 The CONSTRUCTOR shall complete all electrical apparatus and equipment
installation forms as outlined and specified by the OWNER.
21.1.3 The TESTER shall complete all electrical apparatus an equipment test results
forms for each test requirement outlined and specified by the OWNER.
21.2 Nameplate Data
21.2.1 The CONSTRUCTOR/TESTER shall ensure that the nameplate data is collected
and documented using PR.02.00.027 Substation Work Order Summary for
equipment being installed or removed from service.
21.2.2 Equipment Data Forms (EDF) may be requested to be completed by the
OWNER to collect additional nameplate information for each new primary device,
electrical apparatus, secondary devices, or protection relays installed.
21.3 Test Results
21.3.1 Each test result shall include:
a. The date of the test
b. Name and contact information of the individual making the test
c. A description of the test performed
d. The system or device tested
e. Test equipment used with the hardware identification number and
certification date
f. The results with any discrepancies or irregularities identified
g. The initial technical test data shall be provided to the OWNER on bond
paper for distribution
21.4 Relay Settings
21.4.1 The TESTER shall apply all approved protective relay settings and return to the
OWNER the setting sheet or electronic setting data as a certified
document/record.
a. The TESTER shall log protective relay setting and logic setting requests
upon receipt. Revisions shall be tracked. Upon completion, the TESTER
shall sign the cover sheet and return to the OWNER the completed forms
and the “as left” relay settings file downloaded from the protective relays.
b. OWNER will specify the format of the “as left” setting file to be saved. The
saved file will normally be the same filename as the setting file followed by
_r which designates that this is a downloaded file. Example Andover
3_87T3 TD/OC_01_01_2009_r.mdb
21.5 As-Builts Test Records
21.5.1 At the conclusion of the project, the TESTER shall provide four (4) certified
copies of all test records for work performed. This includes conductor insulation
tests, ground resistance, circuit continuity, primary or secondary equipment tests
etc. The test data records shall be supplied in a bound indexed binder format.
21.5.2 In addition to the required hard copies, all the records and documents including
test results shall be in an electronic DVD or CD format. Four (4) copies of the
electronic disks (DVD or CD) shall be provided.
21.5.3 A copy of the Protest Database that was used for protective relay testing will be
turned over to the owner when requested for periodic review during the project
and at the completion of the project.
21.5.4 OWNER has the right to request and the TESTER will provide test results or
database during the course of the project.
21.6 As-Builts Drawings
21.6.1 As-Builts are defined as specified changes noted on construction drawings that
identify changes per field modifications or observations.
21.6.2 The CONSTRUCTOR/TESTER shall return one copy of every drawing issued,
even if no field changes are made on the drawing. Follow Engineering Document
PR.02.00.005 Field Change Mark-Up and As-Built Drawings Procedure.
21.6.3 Mark-Up Requirement
a. As-Builts need to be submitted to the Station Engineering & Design
Manager
b. As-Builts must be legible
c. As-Builts must be made with red and green colors only. Additions should be
noted in red. Deletions should be noted in green.
d. Do not use white out to cover areas of the drawing. This makes it difficult to
determine what is changing.
e. Do not use highlighters to color photocopies
f. Original hand as-builts should be submitted
g. Use “stamped” sets for the returned as-builts
h. One copy of every drawing issued shall be returned, even if no field
changes are made on the drawing.
i. As-builts from both Relay & Control and Stations should be on the same set
of drawings (or at a minimum submitted at the same time).
j. A second complete set of drawings including as-builts information shall be
kept in the substation for reference until drawings are issued by
Engineering and the substation set replaced.
k. The individual responsible for the work should sign and date as-builts. That
way, if questions arise we know whom to contact.
l. As-Builts must be complete and thorough
1. Make sure that changes reflected on one drawing are also shown on
associated drawings. (Single Line, AC/DC, Wiring, Panel Fronts,
Physicals, etc.)
21.12.2 In addition to the required hard copies, all the records and documents supplied
by the TESTER, including test results, may be requested in electronic DVD or
CD format. Number of copies shall be determined by OWNER.
For all tests including Doble Engineering equipment, paper and electronic test results shall be provided
to OWNER. The TESTER shall document all test results for each test requirement outlined in this
specification. The test readings shall become benchmarks for all future evaluations.
APPENDIX G - Current Transformer Excitation Form
APPENDIX H - Single Phase Secondary Current Injection Form
APPENDIX I - Three Phase Secondary Injection Form
APPENDIX J - In-Service Load Checks Form
APPENDIX K - AC Potential Circuit Secondary Injection Form
APPENDIX L - AC Potential Circuit In-Service Form
APPENDIX M - Functional Trip Test Form
APPENDIX N - Scheme Test Form
APPENDIX O - Relay Operating Test Form
APPENDIX P - Relay Test Lead Form
APPENDIX Q - Wave Trap / Line Tuner Form
APPENDIX R - Equipment Data Form
APPENDIX S - Open Link / Lifted Lead Log Form
APPENDIX T - Point-To-Point Wire Check
23.1.5 The CONSTRUCTOR/TESTER shall complete the required Forms upon the
installation of the apparatus in an operating position and submit the data.
23.1.6 All completed Forms shall be submitted to the CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR.
23.1.7 CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR shall ensure completed forms are submitted
for the project folder and a copy provided to Substation Work Methods
(equipment forms) or Protection Standards & Support (relay forms) for updating
the CMMS database.
24.1 Requirement
24.1.1 Power Equipment Decommissioning worksheets are required for all apparatus to
be removed from service and disposed of as defined for the project.
24.2 The Owner shall:
24.2.1 Supply the blank Power Equipment Decommissioning worksheets to the
CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR.
24.3 Filling Out Form
24.3.1 A Power Equipment Decommissioning form shall be filled out by the
CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR for each individual piece of apparatus removed
for disposal as defined by the construction project.
24.4 The Construction Supervisor shall
24.4.1 Notify Investment Recovery and Substation Work Methods to coordinate
arrangements for apparatus disposal.
24.5 Reference
24.5.1 Refer to Investment Recovery & Recycling Services SMP 471.03.2 - Substation
Equipment Decommissioning Procedure and SMP 471.03.3 - Substation
Equipment Decommissioning Check-List
The ENERGIZATION COORDINATOR shall ensure that all of the following steps have been completed for the
energization phase of the project.
□ EC1- Ensure the Commissioning and Energization Team Member list is completed.
□ EC2- Collaborate with the OUTAGE COORDINATOR to develop the Outage Plan.
□ EC3- Coordinate with the CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR, TESTERS, and OUTAGE
COORDINATOR the necessary construction, testing, and operating requirements for initial
energization.
□ EC4- Determine and inform all concerned parties the method of voice communication to be used
during the commissioning / energization process.
□ EC5- Ensure appropriate personnel are scheduled to perform the removal of personal protective
grounds, releasing of corresponding EOP G014 Clearances, and to perform the required switching
to energize or de-energize apparatus.
□ EC6- Confirm all personal grounds are removed and grounding switches, if applicable, have been
opened checked opened, and locked in the open position.
□ EC7- Verify all circuit breaker air, SF6, or hydraulic pressures are normal.
□ EC8- Verify operations counters on all apparatus used for energization have been recorded.
□ EC9- Confirm automatic reclosing has been disabled from circuit breakers used for energizing
apparatus or circuits
□ EC10- Be present and witness the initial energization or operation of equipment.
□ EC11- Ensure initial energization of equipment is performed in accordance with the energization
sequence per the Outage Plan.
□ EC12- Ensure all primary and secondary connections have been made and Clearance released in
order to initiate the Outage Plan.
□ EC13- Ensure load and power flows after initial energization are performed.
□ EC14- Verify voltage regulation and parallel schemes are operational.
□ EC15- Verify DGA sample is taken before energizing.
□ EC16- All transformers shall be allowed to remain energized after initial energization before
applying load to the transformer. Deviations from these times must be discussed with Substation
O&M Services prior to energization and development of the energization sequence.
□ EC17- Ensure additional DGA samples are taken within 1 week of initial energization and monthly
thereafter for the first three months
□ EC18- Have full responsibility to hold the release of the new facility to the Control Center until any
and all issues associated with the initial energization have been satisfied
□ EC19- Coordinate the amendment of the initial Outage Plan if required, with the consent of
OUTAGE COORDINATOR.
□ EC20- Ensure all training required is completed for new apparatus
□ EC21- Ensure all reports are submitted by TESTER in paper and electronic format
□ EC22- Ensure a setting sheet or electronic setting data is submitted by TESTER
□ EC23- Ensure As-Built Test Records are completed and submitted
□ EC24- Ensure As-Built Drawings are completed and submitted
□ EC25- Ensure Change and Addition or Equipment Data Forms are completed and submitted
□ EC26- Ensure Power Equipment Decommissioning Worksheets are completed and submitted.
□ EC27- Ensure Acceptance Certificate – Part 1 OFF-LOAD Inspection and Acceptance Testing
Form is completed and submitted.
□ EC28- Ensure Acceptance Certificate – Part 2 – ON-LOAD Inspection and Acceptance Testing is
completed and submitted.
□ EC30- If applicable ensures station operating diagram has been completed or updated as
necessary.
□ EC31- Turnover facilities to Local Operations which includes all completed acceptance and
inspection/maintenance forms.
□ EC32- Ensure all necessary Relay, DETC, LTC settings are available for installation.
Special Precautions:
Note: The Control Center and Customer Operations designees shall de-energize the facilities
immediately if problems are encountered, or other unusual conditions are detected following initial
energization.
The OWNER, or his Representative, may stop energization from proceeding if such work, in their
estimation, will or may cause OWNER’S system to operate unsatisfactorily or jeopardize service to
its electric customers or if ISONE or NYISO so requires.
Notes:
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
The CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR shall ensure that all of the following steps have been completed
for the commissioning phase of the project.
□ CS1- Coordinate and oversee the physical installation and acceptance testing as required for the
commissioning phase of the project.
□ CS2- Ensure all aspects for job safety are followed for the project, (i.e. Work Area Identification,
PPE, personal protective grounding, Eye Wash Station, Fire Extinguishers, etc.).
□ CS3- Attend project meetings as required.
□ CS4 - Assist in the development of the project Outage Plan and complete all steps assigned.
□ CS5- Ensure the TOA process is followed and coordinates with the CONTROL CENTER and
ENERGIZATION COORDINATOR the appropriate zone of protection required to obtain the
necessary Clearances for testing and commissioning.
□ CS6- Complete work required for initial energization. Note: No work is to proceed on primary
voltage existing facilities until authorization for Clearances have been given or obtained.
□ CS7- Obtain, hold, or ensure Clearance is in place on existing facilities to allow final permanent
connections to be made as required for construction or testing.
□ CS8- Verify required telephone circuits will be available for the project from Telcom engineering.
□ CS9- Participate in the Outage Plan and ensure TOA’s follow TOP-08 lead times.
□ CS10- Ensure all acceptance, electrical, relay testing is identified and who will perform.
□ CS11- Ensure technical inquiries, variances, and approvals are documented and submitted by the
TESTER. Notify appropriate departments or issues and resolutions.
□ CS12- Ensure Change and Addition process is followed and information is submitted online.
□ CS13- Ensure Equipment Data Forms are completed and submitted, if so required.
□ CS14- Ensure all Electrical Apparatus Inspection Cards are completed and submitted.
□ CS15- Ensure all training required is completed for new apparatus.
□ CS16- Ensure Power Equipment Decommissioning Worksheets are completed and submitted.
□ CS17- Ensure As-Built Drawings are completed and submitted.
□ CS18- In conjunction with the TESTER and ENERGIZATION COORDINATOR, perform necessary
corrective work required during initial energization if so required.
□ CS19- Verify settings and proper operation of AC Transfer Switch. Obtain transfer switch operating
requirements and settings from local substation management.
□ CS20- Ensure Standby Generator installed and tested per SMP.
□ CS21- Ensure physical security of yard, doors, and alarms are functioning properly.
□ CS22- Ensure all required tests are completed prior to initial energization.
□ CS23- Coordinate with manufacturer’s field representative when such representative’s presence is
required for initial energization.
□ CS24- Provide personnel during initial energization as required.
□ CS25- Verify all secondary fuses are installed in their respective AC and DC circuits for initial
energization.
□ CS26- Coordinate an onsite walk through with the principle team members as required (PM,
TESTER, ENERGIZATION COORDINATOR) Assist the PM in the preparation of a Punch List.
The Punch List will identify items that require corrective measures or follow-up prior to energization.
□ CS27- Coordinate the completion of the Punch List items and informs the ENERGIZATION
COORDINATOR when the facilities installed are ready for initial energization.
□ CS28- Ensure Punch List (including site walk through) is completed and submitted with corrective
action items completed.
□ CS29- Complete appropriate sections of the Acceptance Certificate – Part 1 OFF-LOAD Inspection
and Acceptance Testing Form is completed and submitted.
□ CS30- Complete appropriate sections of the Acceptance Certificate – Part 2 – ON-LOAD
Inspection and Acceptance Testing is completed and submitted.
□ CS31- Turnover to Local Operations, and others as requested, all completed acceptance and
inspection/maintenance forms.
□ CS32- Ensure CONSTRUCTOR / TESTER site demobilization is completed.
□ CS33- Ensure all electrical equipment, perimeter gates, and control buildings have padlocks
installed as required.
Notes:
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
The TESTER/CONSTUCTOR shall ensure that all of the following steps have been completed during
the construction phase of the project.
□ TC1 - Participate in the initial Project Team Meeting, accepts, and/or assigns responsibilities as
required per the Project Management Playbook.
□ TC2 - Attend project meetings as required to review issues and work completed
□ TC3 - Review Engineering drawings prior to formal review (Page Turn)
□ TC4 - Review formal Engineering drawing issue.
□ TC5 - Create a set of working drawings to keep track of testing and as-built information.
□ TC6 - Participate in a Project Pre-Construction meeting.
□ TC7 - Develop and execute a secondary circuit isolation plane (See Appendix U).
□ TC8 - Coordinate the isolation and testing with the physical installation of the equipment and
construction schedule as required.
□ TC9 - Ensure all aspects for job safety are followed for the work being performed.
□ TC10 - Ensure TESTERS/CONSTRUCTORS are working under appropriate Clearances that
provide adequate work zone protection for the work being performed.
Note: No work is to proceed on primary voltage existing facilities until authorization for Clearances
have been given or obtained.
□ TC11 - Coordinate with the CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR to obtain the required clearances.
□ TC12 - Ensure technical inquiries, variances, and approvals are documented and submitted to the
CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR. Notify appropriate departments of issues and resolutions.
□ TC13 - Ensure Change and Addition process or Equipment Data Forms are completed and
submitted.
□ TC14 - Ensure Relay Data Forms are completed and submitted
□ TC15 - Ensure all training required is completed for new systems and equipment.
□ TC16 - Ensure As-Built Drawings are completed and submitted.
□ TC17 - In conjunction with the CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR, perform necessary corrective
work required during installation or initial energization. Ensure punch list items are completed and
corrective actions items submitted.
□ TC18 - Make final preparations (e.g. remove/add test leads or jumpers, close slide links) required
for initial energization.
□ TC19 - Complete all construction and testing required for initial energization.
Notes:
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
Project Initiation Project Team List Procedure PR.09.01.000 shall be followed to select team members. PROJECT MANAGER and
ENERGIZATION COORDINATOR are to ensure the Commissioning and Energization Team Members are selected at time of Project
Team Meeting.
Project No. CCCCCC Work Order No 9999999999
Description
Sponsor(s)
Project Team List
Issue Date:
Function Name Office Phone Cell Phone Email (if not standard) Location
Project Manager
Electrical Engineer
Civil Engineer
Relay Engineer
Control & Instrumentation
Eng
Meter Engineer
Telecom Engineer
Transmission Line Engineer
Planning Engineer
Asset Sponsor
Design – Civil
Design - Structural
Design - Electrical
Function Name Office Phone Cell Phone Email (if not standard) Location
Design – Primary
Design – Secondary
Design – Admin
Design – Transmission
Design
Regional Environmental
Eng.
Permitting – Environmental
Legal
Substation Work Methods
Business Services
Station Construction
Services
Transmission Line Services
Meter, Relay &/or Testing
Field Supervisor
Power Delivery or O&M
Field Supervisor
Real Estate
Outage Planner
Dispatch/Control Switching
Dispatch/Control EMS
Dispatch/Control RTU
Safety
Function Name Office Phone Cell Phone Email (if not standard) Location
Security
Supply Chain Management
For Contractors acting as team members the Location field shall contain the name of the contracting organization and a full mailing
address.
The Apparatus and/or Relays identified below have been satisfactorily OFF-LOAD tested per the required sections of Substation
Maintenance Procedure SMP 400.80.2 Commissioning and Energization Procedure and conditions specified in the contract. The
Apparatus and/or Relays may now be energized and tested in accordance with PART 2 of the Commissioning Plan. All appropriate
forms, Inspection Cards, and Tests Results have been provided to the ENERGIZATION COORDINATOR.
DESCRIPTION OF APPARATUS and/or RELAYS TESTED DESCRIBE WORK PERFORMED
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
EXCEPTIONS: OUTSTANDING WORK (List items that remain outstanding, remediation plan and responsible party).
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
EXCEPTIONS: OUTSTANDING WORK (List items that remain outstanding, remediation plan and responsible party).
Appendix U - Added
Appendix V - Added
3.1 08/31/12 Accountability - Changed “… Transmission Operations, Substation O&M Services, Substation
O&M, Protection, Telecom and Operations (PTO), Work Delivery, and Construction & Services
organizations involved in Substation …” to “… Transmission Operations, Substation Work Methods,
Substation Maintenance & Construction, Protection, Telecom and Operations (PTO), Work
Delivery, and Construction organizations involved in Substation …”
Section 1.3 - Changed “… designated by Substation O&M Services responsible to …” to “…
designated by Substation Work Methods responsible to …”
Section 1.3 - Changed “… Meter, and Station O&M as required …” to “… Meter, and Substation
Maintenance & Construction as required …”
Section 1.6 - Changed “… Meter, Stations O&M or TEST …” to “… Meter, Substations
Maintenance & Construction or TEST …”
Section 6.1.3 - Changed “… as required (PTO, O&M Services, Control Center …” to “… as required
(PTO, Substation Maintenance & Construction, Control Center …”
Section 10.1.2 - Changed “Refer to National Grid SMS 400.90.1 Approved Test Equipment for
calibration requirements.” to “Refer to National Grid NG-EOP G032 for calibration requirements.”
Section 10.2.2 - Changed “… listed in the SMS 400.90.1 Approved Test Equipment or as approved
…” to “… listed in the NG-EOP G032 or as approved …”
Section 11.11.1 - Changed “Check that all required signage is installed per SMS 400.84.1
Substation Signs and Placards.” To “Check that all required signage is installed per ST.03.06.001
Substation Signs”
Section 11.13.1 - Changed “Substation O&M Services shall coordinate …” to “Substation Work
Methods shall coordinate …”
Section 12.4.7 - Changed “SMP 403.02.3 Coupling …” to “SMP 407.02.3 Coupling …”
Section 12.4.14 - Changed “SMP 417.03.2 Open Air Substation Bus Procedure” to “SMP 417.02.4
Outdoor Open Air Bus Procedure”
Section 21.2.1 - Changed “… using the Substation Work Order Summary - Plant
Additions/Removals form, PR.09.02.A0K, for equipment …” to “… using PR.02.00.027 Substation
Work Order Summary for equipment …”
Section 21.8.1 - Changed “…Management and Substation O&M Services as required.” to “…
Management and Substation Work Methods as required.”
Section 23.1.1 - Changed “… provided to Substation O&M Services (equipment) or …” to “…
provided to Substation Work Methods (equipment) or …”
Section 23.1.7 - Changed “… provided to Substation O&M Services (equipment forms) or …” to “…
provided to Substation Work Methods (equipment forms) or …”
Section 24.1.1 - Changed “… and Substation O&M Services to coordinate arrangements …” to “…
and Substation Work Methods to coordinate arrangements …”
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describes the processes associated with an electric fence. It includes the installation,
inspection and maintenance, and disassembly of an electric fence.
This fence uses an impulse electric fence energizer. The fence is not part of the electric distribution,
electric transmission or electric generation system therefore rules involving working on or near primary
voltages such as clearance and control, minimum approach distances, testing de-energized and
grounding do not apply.
PURPOSE
The purpose of this procedure is to define the procedure for installing, inspecting and maintaining, and
disassembling a TransGard Electric Fence.
ACCOUNTABILITY
This procedure applies to all National Grid personnel who work on National Grid Transmission and
Distribution Substations.
COORDINATION
Not Applicable
REFERENCES
National Grid Safety Handbook
TransGard Fence Systems Installation/Operating Manual
ST.04.18.002 - Animal Deterrents in Electric Substations
SMS 400.85.1 - Substation Wildlife Mitigation Program
User Manual - Fault Finder Handset
DEFINITIONS
Not Applicable
TRAINING
Not Applicable
DOCUMENT CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1.0 GENERAL..................................................................................................................................... 3
2.0 SAFETY........................................................................................................................................ 3
1.0 GENERAL
1.1 Animal intrusions into electric power substations are one of the most common causes of
electric power outages throughout the country and have been one of the most prevalent
and most costly nuisances to the electric utility industry since the earliest days of power
transmission and distribution. The costs associated with these outages are escalating and
will continue to do so.
1.2 An electric fence is a type of animal deterrent in substations. Refer to ST.04.18.002 –
Animal Deterrents in Substations for a listing of animal deterrents. TransGard is the
approved vendor for electric fences.
1.3 This document covers the following processes with an electric fence:
1.3.1 Installation
1.3.2 Inspection and Maintenance of Electric Fence
1.3.3 Disassembly
2.0 SAFETY
2.1 When entering a substation with an electric fence, the following steps shall be done:
2.1.1 Check with Dispatch regarding the EMS automatic alarm.
2.1.2 Turn the electric fence’s power off.
2.1.3 Check to see if the light and meter measuring current for the electric fence are
off. These items are located near the knob that turns the electric fence off.
2.1.4 Use care when working inside the fence control panel as there are some
components that may be hot, and others that are energized with 120VAC station
power supply even when the switch on the outside of the panel is in the off
position.
2.2 If the fence impedes on the work zone or in the way of the construction & maintenance
activity or blocks easy exit from the work area, disassemble the animal fence by following
the process below.
3.1 Refer to TransGard Installation/Operation Manual for the proper steps to install an electric
fence.
3.2 Leave enough room around structure / components inside the enclosure to allow workers
to easily move about without having to disassemble the fence.
3.3 Be certain that the non-electrified gateway is earth grounded with 3/0 or 4/0 conductor and
that it is tied to the grounding of the substation.
4.1 If a worker is going to come into contact with the fence for the purpose of disassembly,
trouble shooting, or during a maintenance / repair activity, then the use of Stations Control
Tagging is required
4.2 The electric fence shall require inspection and maintenance during bi-monthly substation
V&O inspection routine.
4.3 The following items shall be inspected and maintained:
4.3.1 The meter lights are able to be turned on.
4.3.2 The proper amount of stone is placed on the fence posts, stands, and Gateway
Unit.
4.3.3 The fence is properly aligned and level.
4.3.4 The jumper wires are connected and not damaged.
4.3.5 The fence and its stands are not damaged.
4.3.6 Stone is properly placed under fence to deter animals from intruding.
4.3.7 Insulating post is properly placed on stand.
4.3.8 Proper operation of the fence Energizer utilizing the Speedrite device.
4.3.9 Replace the energizer every three years
5.0 TROUBLESHOOTING
5.1 If a worker is going to come into contact with the fence for the purpose of disassembly or
trouble shooting or during a maintenance/repair activity, then the use of Stations Control
Tagging is required.
5.2 A testing device shall be used to determine if there is enough voltage at the output.
Readings shall be taken around the fence. Straps and jumpers shall also be checked.
Speedrite – Fault Finder Handset shall be used.
5.2.1 Voltage does not register
a. If there is no voltage reading at all:
i. Check the voltage at the Gateway first. If that’s bad, then the
fault is in the controller.
ii. Check that all insulators are present.
iii. Check all panel connections.
5.8.5 Walk the perimeter of the fence enclosure and look for, and listen for faults. You
may see an arc or you may hear the snapping sound of the fault.
5.8.6 Using a Fault Finder Digital Fence Meter (Speedrite) check the voltage on the
first 10 fence panels to the left of the entryway at the end of the tenth section. If
the reading is low at that point, backtrack toward the entryway until you find the
faulty section of fence. If the readings are good on the first 10 sections then
repeat this procedure for the next 10 fence panels. Continue this until the faulty
section is isolated.
5.9 Alternate Procedure for Detecting Faults
5.9.1 Start close to where the energizer lead-out wire connects to the fence.
5.9.2 Press the ‘l’ button
5.9.3 Align and insert the fence into the fault finder slot, ensuring fence wire touches
the fault finder contact. Note the current reading (in amps) in large numbers.
5.9.4 Traveling in the direction of the current flow, work your way along the fence line
taking readings at regular intervals and at all junction points. At a junction, follow
the branch that indicates an abnormal current reading. Each time you take a
reading, compare it with the previous reading (this displays briefly in the top, right
hand corner of the screen each time the handset is turned on).
5.9.5 A significant reduction in current between one point and the next indicates the
presence of a fault between these two points.
5.9.6 Move back in the direction of the previous reading until fault is located.
6.1 If a worker is going to come into contact with the fence for the purpose of disassembly or
trouble shooting or during a maintenance/repair activity, then the use of Stations Control
Tagging is required
6.2 The following steps shall be completed to disassemble an electric fence:
6.2.1 Turn the fence off.
6.2.2 Disconnect the fence from the AC source according to the proper work
procedures.
6.2.3 Place notice at Gateway Unit that panels have been removed and fence is not in
service.
6.2.4 Unground the Gateway Unit’s base from the substation’s ground grid.
6.2.5 Carefully unscrew the jumper wires. Two workers may be needed with one
worker unscrewing the jumper wires inside the fence and the other worker
unscrewing the jumper wires outside the fence.
6.2.6 Rake stone away from the stand bases, fence base, and Gateway Unit’s base.
6.2.7 Two workers shall be required to disassemble the fence. Disassembling the
fence shall be accomplished by completing the following steps:
a. Remove the insulators from the tall stand rods by one worker lifting the
panel over the end of the tall stand rods.
b. The other worker shall lift the panel over the short peg.
d. Continue with steps 6.2.7.a to 6.2.7.c until all necessary fence panels have
been disassembled.
6.2.8 Remove the fence panels and stands from the work area.
6.2.9 If the Gateway Unit requires removal, the following steps shall be completed:
a. Proceed to the left side of the entryway and detach the cable with the green
tape (negative) from the lower aluminum connection block.
b. Detach the cable with the red tape (positive) from the upper aluminum
connection block.
c. Proceed to the right side of the entryway and detach the cable with the
green tape (negative) from the lower aluminum connection block.
d. Detach the cable with the red tape (positive) from the upper aluminum
connection block.
2.0 08/31/12 Originating Department - Changed “Substation O&M Services” to “Substation Work Methods”
Sponsor - Changed “Donald T. Angell” to “Susan Fleck”
ACCOUNTIBILITY - Changed “… on National Grid USA Transmission and Distribution
Substations.” to “… on National Grid Transmission and Distribution Substations.”
REFERENCES - Added “SMS 400.85.1 - Substation Wildlife Mitigation Program”
Section 5.4.1 - Changed “…across the switch, replace (what switch? Replace switch or control
panel)” to “…across the switch, replace.”
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describes the process to be followed in the event of a storm or disaster. It includes how
to assess a substation’s condition prior to re-energization.
PURPOSE
The purpose of this procedure is to define the procedure for re-energizing station equipment after an
emergency.
ACCOUNTABILITY
This procedure will apply to all National Grid personnel that are required to perform substation
inspections and restoration activities in the event of a storm or disaster impacting substation facilities.
All appropriate PPE shall be worn when performing inspections as required by the National Grid
Employee Safety Handbook. All work shall be performed in accordance with the National Grid
Employee Safety Handbook and applicable Work Procedures, utilizing all appropriate safe work
methods.
COORDINATION
Coordination shall occur between Emergency Planning and Substation Work Methods.
REFERENCES
EOP G023 – Inspection of Electric Facilities Following an Earthquake
National Grid Employee Safety Handbook
New England Emergency/Storm Restoration Manual
NY Electric Emergency Procedures Manual EEP.03
DEFINITIONS
N/A
TRAINING
As required and through SEAL Program assignments
DOCUMENT CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1.0 GENERAL.................................................................................................................................. 2
9.0 REPORTING.............................................................................................................................. 9
1.0 GENERAL
1.1 Emergency situations may occur from time to time causing a substation to de-energize. A
substation’s condition must be assessed prior to re-energizing station equipment.
1.2 An emergency situation may be considered any of the following events:
1.2.1 Earthquake
1.2.2 Lightning Storm
1.2.3 Ice Storm
1.2.4 Flood Damage
1.2.5 Other Major Event
2.0 EARTHQUAKES
2.1 The following are guidelines in determining when an inspection must be performed after
an earthquake.
2.1.1 When the magnitude of the earthquake is reported to have been 4.0 or higher as
measured on the Richter scale and facilities are within a 75 mile radius of the
reported epicenter.
2.1.2 When the earthquake, as determined by divisional authority, might have caused
damage or abnormal conditions within your division
2.1.3 When so ordered by higher authority
2.2 Inspections to be performed after an earthquake shall include:
2.2.1 All Electric Substations: equipment, structures, foundations, buses and insulators
shall be visually inspected.
2.2.2 All 230kV and above substations shall be given priority.
2.2.3 All affected substations shall have an infrared inspection conducted as soon as
practicable.
3.1 The following are guidelines for determining when an inspection must be made after a
lightning storm.
3.1.1 An inspection shall be conducted immediately if a substation has experience a
total outage.
3.1.2 An inspection must be conducted during the next business day or as requested
by local supervision when a substation has experience a bus trip and reclose
operation.
3.2 Inspections to be performed after a major lightning storm shall include:
3.2.1 All Electric Substations: equipment, buses and insulators shall be visually
inspected.
3.2.2 All 230kV and above substations shall be given priority.
3.2.3 All affected substations shall have an infrared inspection conducted as soon as
practicable.
4.1 The following are guidelines for determining when an inspection must be made after a
major ice storm.
4.1.1 An inspection shall be conducted immediately is a substation has experienced a
total outage.
4.1.2 An inspection must be conducted during the next business day or as requested
by local supervision when a substation has experience a bus trip and reclose
operation.
4.2 Inspections to be performed after a major ice storm shall include:
4.2.1 All equipment, buses and insulators shall be visually inspected.
4.2.2 All 230kV and above substations shall be given priority.
4.2.3 All affected substations shall have an infrared inspection conducted as soon as
practicable.
4.3 Removal of accumulated ice is not normally required from substation live parts or current
carrying conductors. If required, removal of some ice build up shall be performed with
switch sticks only on de-energized substation apparatus with authorization from local
substation supervision only. Care must be taken during removal of ice build up with a
switch stick to ensure equipment does not get damaged. Other methods for ice removal
require authorization from Substation Work Methods. Minimum approach distances shall
be maintained.
5.1 Ensure substation or affected equipment is de-energized and appropriate Clearances are
established.
5.2 Determine height of initial flood stage.
5.3 Determine equipment affected and prepare assessment with documentation (checklist) of
equipment required.
5.3.1 Primary Components
a. Control Building Enclosure
b. Circuit Breakers
c. Transformers
d. Motor Operators
e. Circuit Switchers
f. Reclosers
g. Station Service Safety Switches
h. DC Cabinets
i. Underground Cable Trench
j. Metal-Clad Switchgear
k. Padmount Transformers
5.3.2 Secondary Components
a. Transformer Gauges/Fault Pressure
PRINTED COPIES ARE NOT DOCUMENT CONTROLLED.
FOR THE LATEST AUTHORIZED VERSION PLEASE REFER TO THE APPROPRITATE DEPARTMENT WEBSITE OR DOCUMENTUM.
File: SMP 400.87.2 Emergency Response Before Re-energization Originating Department: Sponsor:
Substation Work Methods Susan Fleck
III-096
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 97 of 254
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.87.2
Procedure Page 5 of 12
Emergency Response Before Re-energization Version 2.0 – 08/31/12
b. Protection Schemes
c. Auxiliary VT/CT
d. Charger Battery
e. Ancillary Devices
f. Control Switchboards
g. Secondary/Outdoor Junction Box
h. Communication Schemes
i. RTU’s
j. AC/DC Cabinets
k. Station/Revenue Metering
l. HVAC
5.3.3 Civil/Structural Components
a. Oil Containment/Environmental
b. Fence Perimeter
c. Soil/Foundations
d. Crushed Stone
e. Erosion around poles/foundations/conduits/ductbanks
f. Buildings/Structures
5.3.4 Debris/Waste Management
5.4 Process of Cleanup
5.4.1 Evaluate level of cleanup required
5.4.2 Drying out facilities and Components
a. Hand held heaters
b. Portable Generators
c. De-Humidifiers
d. Pumps
e. Fans
5.4.3 Clean and sanitize
a. Using approved chemicals by environmental engineering
5.5 An Action Plan, including energization outage plan, will be developed and the resource
required based on various department assessments.
5.5.1 Review assessments with the following departments as required
a. Customer Operations
b. Substation Work Methods
c. Protection and Control
d. Protection and Telecommunications group
e. Substation Engineering and Design
f. Protection Engineering
g. Transmission/Regional Control Center
h. Transmission and Distribution Planning
i. Materials Management
j. Environmental
k. Corporate Communications
l. Corporate Security
m. Corporate Safety
5.5.2 Re-establish Station Services to main feed only with all secondary branch circuits
open
5.5.3 Re-establish battery charger and establish DC Station Service to main feed only
with all secondary branch circuits open
5.5.4 At this point, primary and secondary repairs will be made concurrently based on
condition assessment results and follow the energization outage plan.
a. This includes but is not limited to Replace/Repair designated equipment or
components
5.5.5 Testing
a. Concurrently Primary and Secondary testing
1. Secondary Testing
i. Set and test protective relays
ii. Establish switchboard DC
iii. Verify panel equipment
iv. Megger all current voltage and control circuits cables
v. Functional Testing of all schemes
vi. Perform in-service checks on equipment as placed in service
vii. RTU’s/Metering verification or testing
viii. DFR’s/Event Recorders/Fault Recorders
ix. Communication Equipment
x. PLC
xi. Alarms and remote controls
2. Primary Testing per the components listed in Section 5.3.1
5.5.6 Station Re-energization
a. Based on the severity of the damage assessment, the local energization
coordinator shall be identified. The person identified shall have the same
duties and responsibilities per SMP 400.80.2 Substation Commissioning
and Energization.
5.6 Process Safety
5.6.1 Evaluate and make recommendations for near and long term solutions
6.1 Following are guidelines for establishing restoration efforts for other major substation
events such as apparatus failures resulting in major system disturbances impacting load
served, high media events, long restoration lead times, and equipment replacements
requiring multiple organizations and resources to complete the restoration.
6.1.1 Substation Work Methods Manager shall assemble the required level of
personnel required for developing a restoration plan for other substation major
events.
6.1.2 Major events are categorized as Level A Major Events involving Critical Facilities
and Level B Events Not Involving Critical Facilities. Refer to Appendix A.
6.1.3 The Substation Work Methods Manager shall designate the appropriate Level for
the disturbance.
7.0 ASSIGNMENTS
7.1 Company substations are included in the emergency planning process. Any substation
equipment affected by an emergency situation will have its restoration performed by the
Substation Operations & Maintenance workers assigned to that Substation’s District
and/or other resources as required. Technical Support is provided by the System
Substation Coordinator when required by District personnel during emergencies. If no area
substation is damaged by the emergency, Substation Maintenance & Construction
workers are typically assigned to check the status of the substations and switchyard
equipment, and to perform switching and tagging operations, to enable repair work to be
done on transmission and distribution lines.
7.1.1 Action Required:
a. The District Emergency Operations Coordinator assigns Substation
Maintenance & Construction Workers to be positioned at critical substations
and switchyards within the District, in advance of foreseen emergency
events, when such assignments will help reduce duration of interruptions.
PRINTED COPIES ARE NOT DOCUMENT CONTROLLED.
FOR THE LATEST AUTHORIZED VERSION PLEASE REFER TO THE APPROPRITATE DEPARTMENT WEBSITE OR DOCUMENTUM.
File: SMP 400.87.2 Emergency Response Before Re-energization Originating Department: Sponsor:
Substation Work Methods Susan Fleck
III-099
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 100 of 254
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 400.87.2
Procedure Page 8 of 12
Emergency Response Before Re-energization Version 2.0 – 08/31/12
8.1 Substation Maintenance & Construction, PTO, and other Field Operations personnel shall
perform and coordinate the following tasks prior to re-energization.
8.1.1 The following tasks shall be assigned as required for substation inspection and
restoration efforts:
a. PTO body for electronic relay data downloads
b. Battery/Charger inspections and replacements
c. Standby generator inspections and repairs
d. Coordinate Standby Generator Fuel Delivery every 24 hours
e. Assess by performing V&O inspection after storm or event
f. Execute switching orders as necessary to restore system configuration
g. Coordinate System spare inventory utilization
h. Perform any emergency repairs/maintenance before restoration of
equipment and circuits
i. Initiate EEP.03,
http://us1infonet/sites/emergency_planning/Documents/NY%20EEPs%200
9/EEP.03.pdf, Restoration Organization as necessary
j. Ensure availability of Mobile Equipment Fleet
9.0 REPORTING
9.1 Any abnormal conditions, emergency situation or indication of change which might result
in an abnormal condition potential damage or outage shall be reported to Customer
Operations Divisional Supervision, Substation Work Methods, Director PTO, and Director
of Distribution Services, System Operations as applicable.
9.2 The following items shall be included in the report.
9.2.1 Inspection start time and date
9.2.2 Facilities inspected
9.2.3 Geographic description of the area inspected
9.2.4 All abnormal conditions, equipment/structures, change or emergency condition
a. NOTE: Should an emergency condition be discovered, appropriate action
to safeguard life, property and the integrity of the electrical system shall be
taken
9.2.5 All conditions or indications which may require engineering, or other evaluation
9.2.6 Completion time and date of the inspection
9.3 Protection Systems
9.3.1 Refer to PR.10.00.004 Procedure for Gathering Post Event Fault Data.
9.3.2 Refer to PR.10.00.003 Procedure for Reporting & Tracking Special Protection
System Failures.
9.3.3 Refer to PR.10.00.001 Disturbance Analysis Procedure.
2.0 08/31/12 Originating Department - Changed “Substation O&M Services” to “Substation Work Methods”
Sponsor - Changed “Donald T. Angell” to “Susan Fleck”
Document - Changed “Substation O&M Services” to “Substation Work Methods” throughout the
document
Section 2.1.1 - Changed “… within a 130 mile radius …” to “… within a 75 mile radius …”
Sections 7.1, 7.1.1.a, 7.1.1.b, 7.1.1.b.ii, 7.1.1.c, and 8.1 - Changed “… Substation O&M …” to “…
Substation Maintenance & Construction …”
Section 10.0 - Changed (expanded)
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describe the methods use to perform Visual and Operational, Diagnostic, and
Acceptance inspections on lead acid batteries used in electrical substations.
PURPOSE
Scheduled equipment inspections are necessary to protect both the public and electric utility workers,
prevent unnecessary customer outages, and maximize equipment operating life. This procedure lists
special tools and equipment required, unusual hazards, and methods used, to inspect lead acid
batteries.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and other Supervisors supervising inspection and maintenance activities.
Substation and other Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities.
COORDINATION
Battery Chargers are inspected at the same time as the battery banks they are connected to. See SMP
406.03.2.
REFERENCES
National Grid USA Safety Handbook
NPCC Regional Reliability Reference Directory 3 Maintenance Criteria for Bulk Power System
Protection
Manufacturer’s Installation, Operating, and Maintenance manuals for the specific equipment to be
inspected.
Manufacturer’s operating manuals for the specific test equipment to be used.
DEFINITIONS
Battery - Group of cells in a common container. Using three cells to create a 6 volt battery
is common in electrical substations.
Battery Bank - Group of cells, or batteries connected in series to create higher voltages. Battery
banks of 24, 48, 120, and 240 volts are common in electrical substations.
Battery Charger - Device that converts station service AC voltage to a precise, stable DC voltage.
Used to maintain the charge on station batteries and supply normal DC station
loads.
Case - Container enclosing a group of battery cells.
Cell - Basic component of a battery or battery bank. In a lead acid battery each cell
generates approximately 2.2 volts.
Equalizing Charge - Charging batteries at slightly higher than the normal float voltage for a period of
time. Use to correct unbalances in charge between cells and remove electrolyte
stratification.
Freshening Charge – Charge applied to a pre-charged battery after installation to bring battery to a fully
charged state.
TRAINING
(Optional Section) List any training requirement(s) (One-Time Training, Annual Training, etc.).
DOCUMENT CONTENTS
Table of Contents
6.0 NPCC - BULK POWER STATIONS - CHARGER AND BATTERY INSPECTION ...................... 5
11.0 APPENDIX B - TORQUE VALUES FOR COMMON BATTERIES AND CELLS ....................... 13
12.0 APPENDIX C - UTILIZING NATIONAL GRID BATTERY BYPASS BOX FOR BATTERY
SYSTEM MAINTENANCE........................................................................................................ 15
The fluid in lead acid batteries (electrolyte) is a mixture of sulfuric acid and distilled water.
Contact with electrolyte can cause blindness, burn skin, and burn holes in clothing. Electrolyte
on skin or clothing should be rinsed off with generous amounts of water. Electrolyte in eyes
should be flushed generously with bottled eyewash solution, or at an eyewash station, and
immediate medical attention sought. Acid proof gloves and aprons and a full face shield shall be
worn when inspecting or working on batteries.
Lead acid batteries emit hydrogen gas, which is explosive. No smoking, open flames or sparks
are allowed in their vicinity. Only insulated tools should be used when working on batteries.
Substation batteries are capably of very high short-circuit currents. Accidentally shorting cells or
batteries can result in severe burns and possibly battery explosions. The use of 1000 volt
disposable cover-up (SC 92008882) should be considered.
Although rare, batteries can explode violently and spew electrolyte and plastic shards from
battery jars in all directions. Battery explosions can be caused by internal or external short
circuits, or the ignition of hydrogen gases.
6.1 This section meets the applicable requirements of NPCC Regional Reliability Reference
Directory 3 Maintenance Criteria for Bulk Power System Protection
6.2 Check charger AC and DC circuit breakers are on.
6.3 Check that there is output voltage on charger DC voltmeter.
6.4 Check that there is output current on the charger DC ammeter.
6.5 Visually check all battery cells for general condition and proper electrolyte level.
7.3.3 Measure and record the overall voltage between the positive and negative ends
of the battery (points where the battery charger and DC supply leads are
connected).
a. Read the voltage immediately after turning off the charger, the battery
voltage will continue to drop.
7.3.4 Turn the battery charger’s AC Circuit breaker on.
7.4 Refer to Appendix B at the end of this document to determine battery type. Voltage should
not be below:
Battery Size Lead Antimony Lead Calcium Lead Selenium
24 volt - 12 cell 25 volts 26 volts 26 volts
48 volt - 23 cell 48 volts 50 volts 49 volts
48 volt - 24 cell 50 volts 52 volts 52 volts
120 volt - 58 cell 120 volts 125 volts 123 volts
120 volt - 60 cell 124 volts 129 volts 128 volts
240 volt - 116 cell 240 volts 240 volts 240 volts
240 volt - 117 cell 242 volts 242 volts 242 volts
240 volt - 120 cell 248 volts 248 volts 248 volts
metal inter-cell connections on top of the battery case. The voltage should
be approximately 2.2 volts.
7.6.2 Record pilot cell temperature.
a. Withdraw the thermometer from the cell only enough to read the
temperature. To avoid electrolyte (acid) drips outside the cell do not
completely remove it.
b. Read and record the temperature.
7.7 Visually inspect all battery cells. Refer to the Substation Batteries and Chargers training
manual for details. Record problems and cell numbers on inspection card/record.
7.7.1 Electrolyte level. Add distilled water to bring electrolyte level to between the low
and high level lines on the jar or case. Record cell numbers and amount added
on inspection card.
7.7.2 If water is added equalize charge the battery bank.
a. If the charger has an equalizing (overcharging) timer set the timer to:
1. - 72 hours for lead calcium and lead antimony batteries.
2. - As specified in the manufacturer's instruction manual for lead
selenium batteries. Normally 4 hours maximum, periodic monitoring
may be required.
b. If the charger has an equalizing (overcharging) switch; turn the switch on.
Refer to the chargers instruction manual to insure the charger will
automatically stop the equalizing charge after a set period of time.
c. If the charger does not stop equalizing charging automatically return before
the maximum equalize time to shut the equalizing charge off.
d. The charger’s DC ammeter reading should increase when the charger is
put on equalizing charge.
7.7.3 Plate buckling. Wavy plates and separators.
7.7.4 Sulfating. Sparkling crystals on plates and separators.
7.7.5 Hydration. Dull grey material embedded on separators.
7.7.6 Accumulation of sediment in bottom of jar. Sediment touching battery plates
requires immediate attention.
7.7.7 Leaking or damaged jars or cases. Leaking jars or cases require immediate
attention.
7.7.8 Check each jar/case to be clean and dry.
a. Clean the tops of jars and case with a solution off 1 gallon of water mixed
with 1 pound baking soda. Do not allow the baking soda solution to enter
the battery cells. It will neutralize the electrolyte and destroy the cell.
7.7.9 Check Flame arrestors and dust caps.
a. Clean and dry flame arrestors and caps as necessary. Do not use baking
soda solution on flame arrestors. Use distilled water.
7.7.10 Replace any missing or damaged flame arrestors and dust caps.
7.7.11 Check each terminal for corrosion.
a. Clean corrosion off inter-cell conductors with the stiff bristled synthetic
brush or green Scotchbrite and baking soda solution. Caution the corrosion
byproducts are corrosive. Do not use a metal bristled, wire brush.
b. Rinse or wipe the baking soda solution residue off with clean water and
rags.
c. Apply a thin coat of heated No-Ox-Id battery terminal grease to any inter-
cell conductors that have been cleaned, with the paint brush. The No-Ox-Id
must be heated to a cream like consistency to avoid applying excessive
amounts that will collect dirt and dust.
d. Connections with sever corrosion should be bypassed with the battery
jump-out box, disassembled, cleaned and painted with No-Ox-Id. (See the
Substation Batteries and Chargers training manual for details on using the
battery jump-out box.)
e. Any connections that have been loosened should be retorqued with a
torque wrench. See Appendix B at the end of this document for common
battery torque values.
7.7.12 Record “as left” overall visual condition of battery bank on inspection card.
7.8 Check rack and floor for paint and cleanliness and grounding.
7.8.1 Wire brush, prime, and paint any chipped or corroded areas on the battery rack.
7.8.2 Wire brush and paint any chipped or corroded areas on the floor under the
battery with acid proof paint. Paint floor areas that are unpainted.
7.8.3 Battery jars and cases should be insulated from the rack with rubber or plastic
strips.
7.8.4 Battery jars and cases should not touch each outer.
7.8.5 Battery rack should be grounded to station ground with 4/0 ground wire.
7.9 Replace damaged of missing “Danger Explosive Gas” signs.
8.1 Perform battery charger diagnostic inspection before performing battery diagnostic
inspection.
8.1.1 The short amount of time the battery is on equalize during the charger inspection
will not affect battery test results.
8.2 Perform all of the steps listed in Visual and Operations Inspections above.
8.10.1 If the charger has an equalizing (overcharging) timer set the timer to:
a. 72 hours for lead calcium and lead antimony batteries.
b. As specified in the manufacturer's instruction manual for lead selenium
batteries. Normally 36 hours maximum, periodic monitoring probably will be
required.
8.10.2 If the charger has an equalizing (overcharging) switch; turn the switch on. Refer
to the chargers instruction manual to insure the charger will automatically stop
the equalizing charge after a set period of time.
8.10.3 If the charger does not stop equalizing charging automatically return before the
maximum equalize time to shut the equalizing charge off.
8.10.4 The charger’s DC ammeter reading should increase when the charger is put on
equalizing charge.
1.50
POS
However, due to their very high input
impedance, a parallel resistor jumper WAVETEK HD110
lead must be fabricated and used. If OFF AC
the resistor lead is not used the multi- C20V200
1000 1000
200
20V
meter will indicate grounds when D2
NEG
2
200m 200m
ACA
DCA
10A 10A
2m 2m
200u 200u
20M
The resistor jumper lead is fabricated 2M200K 2K200
20K
using a 100k ohm resistor. 100k ohm
resistors are available at Radio Shack
and other electronic component
NEG
positive grounds.
12.0 APPENDIX C - UTILIZING NATIONAL GRID BATTERY BYPASS BOX FOR BATTERY
SYSTEM MAINTENANCE
It is a mandatory practice that battery maintenance be performed in a manner that insures all substation
DC equipment remains energized during the work. Any exceptions to this practice must be approved by
Protection. This approval will include documented mitigation steps necessary (including none) for
maintenance allowed that will subject the station to a momentary DC outage.
It is a mandatory that construction and repair of the Battery Bypass Box will only be performed by the
National Grid Lab. The Lab contact information:
National Grid USA
Engineering Laboratory
7437 Henry Clay Blvd., Bldg. #1
Liverpool, NY 13088-3504
315-460-2491
Within the various substation maintenance departments at National Grid there exist many
fixtures/switches/cables constructed in the past to support battery maintenance. This equipment
consists of some or all of the components that exist in the Training Center/Engineering Laboratory
developed Battery Bypass Box. The Battery Bypass Box and steps outlined below in this SMP is the
only permitted manner to remove specific cells/straps in a battery bank from service for
maintenance/replacement. It is recognized that there are maintenance areas where different
colors/symbols are used to signify positive (red, white, +) and negative (black, -) polarity. The labeling
of the leads on Battery Bypass Box can be ordered or changed to match what has been adopted in the
area.
The following are steps on how to utilize the Battery Bypass Box in order to perform necessary
maintenance tasks. This procedure assumes that Battery Bypass Box will have leads that are labeled
white for positive polarity and black for negative polarity.
12.1 Take a multimeter and place in continuity test mode. Place the Battery Bypass Box switch
in the OFF position and confirm open with the meter.
12.2 The black lead connection must be closest to the negative post at the end of the battery
string. This most negative point has the connection that goes directly to the DC panel or
disconnect switch. Connect black lead of the Battery Bypass Box as close as possible to
the battery equipment being bypassed.
12.3 The white lead connection must be closest to the positive post at the end of the battery
string. This most positive point has the connection that goes directly to the DC panel or
disconnect switch. Connect white lead of the Battery Bypass Box as close as possible to
the battery equipment being bypassed. (See Figures 1-4)
12.4 Confirm that the Battery Charger output current is less than 35 amps. If the charger output
current is greater than 35 amps then review the application with O&M Services before
proceeding.
12.5 Turn off the battery charger.
12.6 Take a multimeter measurement to confirm that battery cell voltage being bypassed does
not exceed 22 volts for a 60 cell (120VDC) bank, 8 volts for a 24 cell (48VDC) bank or 4
volts for a 12 cell (24VDC) bank. These limits are set in order to not expose the operating
equipment to voltage levels any lower than the limits set when sizing batteries at the
location.
12.7 Check that the Battery Bypass Box green light has come on. The green light will only light
when the Battery Bypass Box has been connected properly.
12.8 Place the Battery Bypass Box switch in the on position.
12.9 Remove the first intercell connection within the Battery Bypass Box connections. The
green light will now go out.
12.10 After the first strap has been removed, check the string voltage >105 volts on a 120VDC
bank, >40 volts on a 48VDC cell bank, or > 20 volts on 24VDC bank. If the measured
value does not meet these minimums then reinstall the strap and investigate the cause.
12.11 Perform necessary maintenance work. At the end of the work when the final strap is
reinstalled the green light will again light. Investigate if the light does not come on prior to
taking any of the next steps.
12.12 If the maintenance is going to involve removing cells on a temporary basis from the bank
then remember to readjust the float voltage on the charger.
12.13 If the maintenance consists of permanent replacement of a cell confirm that the new cell
has same Amp Hour rating and has undergone a freshening charge.
12.14 Place the Battery Bypass Box switch in off position. Mbite or micro-ohm (10 amp rated
unit) test the cells and connections that were bypassed to confirm good readings.
12.15 Remove the Battery Bypass Box white and black lead connections.
12.16 Turn the Battery Charger on. Check battery string voltage good.
Examples – Battery Bypass Switch Connections
The National Grid mobile equipment fleet includes battery trailers for that can be utilized in order to
remove the entire station battery (60 cell 120Volt) (24 cell 48 volt) from service for the maintenance or
replacement of battery.
13.1 This Appendix applies to utilizing these battery trailers.
13.2 It is standard practice that the cutover be performed in a manner where all substation DC
equipment remains energized.
13.3 Protection must be contacted and determine the mitigation steps necessary in order to
approve a cutover that will subject the station to a momentary DC outage.
13.4 Cutting Over Substation DC system from Station Battery to Battery Trailer
13.4.1 Verify Battery Trailer is prepared to go into service.
a. O&M Services approval of install if battery trailer is being installed in a
station where existing battery bank has a rating > 350 AH.
b. AC connection to Battery Trailer has been done. Battery Trailer blower (if
equipped with one) is running.
c. Loss AC and Low DC Charger alarm contacts on Battery Trailer have been
connected into station battery alarm circuit if possible.
d. Station service AC breaker being utilized is at least 40 amps. If 40 amps or
greater breaker can not be utilized and trailer has no alarm connection then
charger current limiting circuit must be adjusted to insure station AC
breaker will not trip due to charger load.
e. Charger switch is on correct tap setting (240VAC or 208VAC) for station
AC. Charger AC and DC breakers are closed and output voltage within 1
volt of 135 for 60 cell bank or refer to SMP 406.3.2 for other values. If
battery charger is not on then close DC breaker first then close the charger
AC breaker. Monitor trailer voltage until its value reaches those listed
above before proceeding.
f. All Battery Trailer DC disconnects are in the open position. With a multi
meter verify there is continuity across the DC disconnect fuses.
13.4.2 Install battery trailer cables from existing DC system to open battery trailer
disconnect switch.
a. Choose the 50 amp Disconnect \ Twist Lock cable connection only for
mobile equipment or stations that have a existing DC fused safety switch or
single DC panel main breaker of 50 amps or less.
b. When choosing location for connecting battery trailer cables to station DC
system consider how will accomplish the transfer of substation DC back to
the battery bank utilizing an open disconnect (even if temporary) after work
is complete. Typical battery bank replacement/major maintenance work
should consist of the installation of a safety switch with dual lugs on the DC
system side to facilitate future battery trailer installations.
13.4.3 Match the DC system voltage and Battery trailer DC voltage at the open Battery
Trailer switch that will be making tie.
a. Verify match in battery polarity across open disconnect switch of trailer with
multi-meter. Put meter probes across blades on DC System Voltage side
of open switch and note the polarity (+,-). Move the probes directly across
the open switch to the Battery Trailer DC voltage side and confirm the
meter is reading the same polarity.
b. Match the DC voltage values on each side of the open switch to be within
.1 (1/10th) of a volt with a multi-meter. This can be accomplished by
adjusting the float voltage on the battery trailer charger.
13.4.4 Tie the two DC systems together by closing the Battery Trailer switch.
13.4.5 Turn the substation battery charger off. (AC breaker then DC breaker)
13.4.6 Disconnect the station battery from the DC system by opening the existing
Station Battery Safety Switch or by lifting and taping the positive and negative
leads from the battery output posts.
13.4.7 Check Station DC voltage good, Battery Trailer Charger has no alarms, and
Battery Trailer Charger DC output is less than charger rating.
13.5 Cutting Over Substation DC from Battery Trailer to Station Battery
13.5.1 Verify that Station Battery is prepared to go into service.
a. Charger AC and DC breakers are closed and output voltage within 1 volt of
135 for 60 cell bank or refer to SMP 406.3.2 for other values.
b. If the Station Battery is a new installation that it and the charger passed
required acceptance testing including alarms.
c. With a multi meter verify there is continuity across the battery Safety Switch
fuses that are going to be used.
13.5.2 Verify that there is an open safety switch (even if installed temporary) that the
Station Battery DC is tied into on one side and the station DC system is tied into
the other side.
13.5.3 Match the DC system and Station Battery DC at the open safety switch that will
be making the tie.
a. Verify match in battery polarity across open safety switch with multi-meter.
Put meter probes across blades on DC System Voltage side of open switch
and note the polarity (+,-). Move the probes directly across the open switch
to the Station Battery DC voltage side and confirm the meter is reading the
same polarity.
1.5 05/03/07 NPCC A-4 - Bulk Power Stations - Charger and Battery Inspection
Added Section
Replaced – EOP with SMP 1 place
SMP 406.02.2
SUBSTATION
Version 1.3
MAINTENANCE Date 02/27/2009
PROCEDURE Page 1 of 10
NICKEL-CADMIUM BATTERY
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describe the methods use to perform Visual and Operational, Diagnostic, and Acceptance
inspections on nickel-cadmium batteries used in electrical substations.
PURPOSE
Scheduled equipment inspections are necessary to protect both the public and electric utility workers,
prevent unnecessary customer outages, and maximize equipment operating life. This procedure lists
special tools and equipment required, unusual hazards, and methods used, to inspect nickel-cadmium.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and other Supervisors supervising inspection and maintenance activities.
Substation and other Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities.
REFERENCE
National Grid USA Safety Handbook
NPCC Regional Reliability Reference Directory 3 Maintenance Criteria for Bulk Power System Protection
Manufacturer’s Installation, Operating, and Maintenance manuals for the specific equipment to be
inspected.
Manufacturer’s operating manuals for the specific test equipment to be used.
DEFINITIONS
Battery - Group of cells in a common container. Using three cells to create a 6 volt
battery is common in electrical substations.
Battery Bank - Group of cells, or batteries connected in series to create higher voltages.
Battery banks of 24, 48, 120, and 240 volts are common in electrical
substations.
Battery Charger - Device that converts station service AC voltage to a precise, stable DC
voltage. Used to maintain the charge on station batteries and supply normal
DC station loads.
Case - Container enclosing a group of battery cells.
Cell - Basic component of a battery or battery bank. In a lead acid battery each cell
generates approximately 1.42 volts.
Equalizing Charge - Charging batteries at slightly higher than the normal float voltage for a period
of time. Use to correct unbalances in charge between cells and remove
electrolyte stratification.
Freshening Charge – Charge applied to a pre-charged battery after installation to bring battery to a
fully charged state.
Printed copies of this document are not document controlled. Refer to the National Grid INFONET,
Substation Services website, for the latest version. Controlled copies are maintained in Documentum.
File SMP406.02.doc
III-132
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 133 of 254
SMP 406.02.2 v1.3
NICKEL-CADMIUM BATTERY
02/27/2009
ASSOCIATED EQUIPMENT
Battery Chargers are inspected at the same time as the battery banks they are connected to. See SMP
406.03.2
PROCEDURE CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1. TEST EQUIPMENT REQUIRED...................................................................................2
2. SPECIAL TOOLS REQUIRED. .....................................................................................2
3. MATERIALS REQUIRED. ..........................................................................................3
4. SPECIAL SAFETY EQUIPMENT REQUIRED. ...............................................................3
5. UNUSUAL HAZARDS................................................................................................4
6. NPCC - BULK POWER STATIONS - CHARGER AND BATTERY INSPECTION ..............4
7. VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL INSPECTION.................................................................4
8. DIAGNOSTIC INSPECTION. .......................................................................................6
9. ACCEPTANCE INSPECTION .......................................................................................7
10. APPENDIX A - TESTING FOR BATTERY GROUNDS WITH A MULTI-METER ..............8
11. RECORD OF REVISIONS............................................................................................9
2
III-133
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 134 of 254
SMP 406.02.2 v1.3
NICKEL-CADMIUM BATTERY
02/27/2009
3. Materials Required.
3.1 V&O Inspection
1) PDA with National Grid V&O software installed.
2) Inspection card/record from last V&O inspection.
3) Replacement bottles of eyewash solution.
4) Bulk eyewash solution for larger eyewash stations.
5) Danger sign “EXPLOSIVE GAS”.
6) Cleaning solution -three parts water and one part boric acid.
7) Wire brush for use on battery rack and floor.
8) Scotchbrite green industrial abrasive pads.
9) Distilled water.
10) No-Ox-Id battery terminal grease.
11) Small hot plate to heat No-Ox-Id.
12) Small paint brush to apply No-Ox-Id.
13) Battery jump-out box (See Batteries and Chargers training manual).
14) Spare battery inter-cell straps (type varies by battery and manufacturer).
15) Spare battery inter-cell bolts, nuts and washers (types vary by battery and
manufacturer).
16) Spare vent caps (type varies by battery and manufacturer).
17) Spare battery thermometer. (Do not use thermometers containing mercury or that have
been used in Lead Acid batteries).
18) Metal primer and paint for battery racks.
19) Acid proof paint for floor.
3.2 Diagnostic Inspection
a) All of the above plus:
b) Inspection card/record from last Diagnostic inspection.
3.3 Acceptance Inspection.
a) All of the above.
3
III-134
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 135 of 254
SMP 406.02.2 v1.3
NICKEL-CADMIUM BATTERY
02/27/2009
5. Unusual Hazards
The fluid in nickel-cadmium batteries (electrolyte) is a mixture of potassium hydroxide and
distilled water. Contact with electrolyte can cause blindness, burn skin, and burn holes in clothing.
Electrolyte on skin or clothing should be rinsed off with generous amounts of water. Electrolyte in
eyes should be flushed generously with bottled eyewash solution, or at an eyewash station, and
immediate medical attention sought. Chemical proof gloves and aprons and a full face shield shall
be worn when inspecting or working on nickel-cadmium batteries.
Substation batteries are capably of very high short-circuit currents. Accidentally shorting cells or
batteries can result in severe burns and possibly battery explosions. Only insulated tools should
be used when working on batteries. The use of 1000 volt disposable cover-up (SC 92008882)
should be considered.
Nickel-cadmium batteries may emit small amounts of hydrogen gas during charging.
Although rare, batteries can explode violently and spew electrolyte and plastic shards from
battery jars in all directions. Battery explosions can be caused by internal or external short
circuits.
4
III-135
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 136 of 254
SMP 406.02.2 v1.3
NICKEL-CADMIUM BATTERY
02/27/2009
5
III-136
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 137 of 254
SMP 406.02.2 v1.3
NICKEL-CADMIUM BATTERY
02/27/2009
c) Apply a thin coat of heated No-Ox-Id battery terminal grease to any inter-cell
conductors that have been cleaned, with the paint brush. The No-Ox-Id must be
heated to a cream like consistency to avoid applying excessive amounts that will
collect dirt and dust.
d) Connections with sever corrosion should be bypassed with the battery jump-out box,
disassembled, cleaned and painted with No-Ox-Id. (See the Substation Batteries and
Chargers training manual for details on using the battery jump-out box.)
e) Any connections that have been loosened should be retorqued with a torque wrench.
See manufacturer's instruction manual for battery torque values.
8) Record “as left” overall visual condition of battery bank on inspection card.
7.6 Check rack and floor for paint and cleanliness and grounding.
1) Wire brush, prime, and paint any chipped or corroded areas on the battery rack.
2) Wire brush and paint any chipped or corroded areas on the floor under the battery with
acid proof paint. Paint floor areas that are unpainted.
3) Battery jars and cases should be insulated from the rack with rubber or plastic strips.
4) Battery jars and cases should not touch each outer.
5) Battery rack should be grounded to station ground with 4/0 ground wire.
7.7 Replace damaged of missing “Danger Explosive Gas” signs.
8. Diagnostic Inspection.
8.1 Perform battery charger diagnostic inspection before performing battery diagnostic inspection.
1) The short amount of time the battery is on equalize during the charger inspection will not
affect battery test results.
8.2 Perform an MBite test on the battery.
1) The primary purpose of the MBite test is to find strap and connection problems.
2) Battery banks over 130 volts must be tested in sections. Do not make MBite connections
until the procedure has been reviewed in the MBite manufacturer’s instruction manual or
the Substation Batteries and Chargers training manual.
3) Refer to the Substation Batteries and Chargers Training Manual or manufacturer’s
instruction manual for operation of the MBite test set and details on MBite testing.
4) Do voltage and resistance (strap) tests on each cell before moving to the next cell. If the
battery has inter-cell connections that are insulated, with the only bare spot in the
middle, put both probes on this spot when doing the strap test.
a) It is not necessary to test cell impedances.
5) If test probes are not ‘dug in” firmly oxide on conductors and/or battery grease can result
in bad readings.
6) Be sure to wait for the MBite display reading to settle before pushing the test button.
Wait for the “beep” before releasing the test button and moving to the next test. If the
button is released early the test results won’t be captured.
6
III-137
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 138 of 254
SMP 406.02.2 v1.3
NICKEL-CADMIUM BATTERY
02/27/2009
9. Acceptance Inspection
9.1 If batteries are supplied without electrolyte follow manufacturer's instructions for adding
electrolyte.
1) If electrolyte is added cell oil may need to be added after the commissioning charge is
performed.
9.2 Perform battery charger inspection before performing battery inspection.
9.3 Refer to the manufacturer’s operating and installation manuals to see if a commissioning
charge is required.
9.4 Perform all of the steps listed in Visual and Operational, and Diagnostic Inspections above.
7
III-138
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 139 of 254
SMP 406.02.2 v1.3
NICKEL-CADMIUM BATTERY
02/27/2009
POS
impedance, a parallel resistor jumper
lead must be fabricated and used. If
the resistor lead is not used the multi- WAVETEK HD110
ACA
DCA
10A 10A
2m 2m
using a 100k ohm resistor. 100k ohm 200u
20M
200u
100k OHM
RESISTOR V- COM A 10A
With the leads connected to the
POS
8
III-139
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 140 of 254
SMP 406.02.2 v1.3
NICKEL-CADMIUM BATTERY
02/27/2009
9
III-140
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 141 of 254
SMP 406.02.2 v1.3
NICKEL-CADMIUM BATTERY
02/27/2009
10
III-141
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 142 of 254
SMP 406.03.2
SUBSTATION
Version 1.8
MAINTENANCE Date 02/27/2009
PROCEDURE Page 1 of 12
BATTERY CHARGER
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describes the methods use to perform Visual and Operational, diagnostic, internal, and
acceptance inspections on battery chargers used in electrical substations.
PURPOSE
Scheduled equipment inspections are necessary to protect both the public and electric utility workers,
prevent unnecessary customer outages, and maximize equipment operating life. This procedure lists
special tools and equipment required, unusual hazards, and methods used, to inspect battery chargers.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and other Supervisors supervising inspection and maintenance activities.
Substation and other Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities.
REFERENCES
National Grid USA Safety Handbook
NPCC Regional Reliability Reference Directory 3 Maintenance Criteria for Bulk Power System Protection
Manufacturer’s Installation, Operating, and Maintenance manuals for the specific equipment to be
inspected.
Manufacturer’s operating manuals for the specific test equipment to be used.
DEFINITIONS
Battery - Group of cells in a common container. Using three cells to create a 6 volt
battery is common in electrical substations.
Battery Bank - Group of cells, or batteries connected in series to create higher voltages.
Battery banks of 24, 48, 120, and 240 volts are common in electrical
substations.
Battery Charger - Device that converts station service AC voltage to a precise, stable DC
voltage. Used to maintain the charge on station batteries and supply normal
DC station loads.
Equalizing Charge - Charging batteries at slightly higher than the normal float voltage for a period
of time. Use to correct unbalances in charge between cells and remove
electrolyte stratification.
Float Voltage - Voltage required to maintain the battery at full charge. Battery chargers are
set to this voltage. Float voltages need to be set accurately to avoid under or
overcharging batteries.
Lead Antimony - One of the three commonly used types of lead acid batteries used in
substation applications. The others are lead calcium and lead selenium.
Printed copies of this document are not document controlled. Refer to the National Grid INFONET,
Substation Services website, for the latest version. Controlled copies are maintained in Documentum.
File SMP406.03.doc
III-142
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 143 of 254
SMP 406.03.2 v1.8
BATTERY CHARGER
02/27/2009
Lead Calcium - One of the three commonly used types of lead acid batteries used in
substation applications. The others are lead antimony and lead selenium.
Lead Selenium - One of the three commonly used types of lead acid batteries used in
substation applications. The others are lead antimony and lead calcium.
PDA - Personal Digital Assistant. Pocket size computer.
ASSOCIATED EQUIPMENT
Batteries are inspected at the same time as battery chargers they are connected to. See SMP 406.01.2.
PROCEDURE CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. TEST EQUIPMENT REQUIRED...................................................................................2
2. MATERIALS REQUIRED. ..........................................................................................3
3. UNUSUAL HAZARDS................................................................................................3
4. NPCC - BULK POWER STATIONS - CHARGER INSPECTION ......................................3
5. VISUAL AND OPERATIONAL INSPECTION.................................................................3
6. DIAGNOSTIC INSPECTION. .......................................................................................5
7. ACCEPTANCE INSPECTION.......................................................................................7
8. APPENDIX A..........................................................................................................10
9. RECORD OF REVISIONS..........................................................................................11
2
III-143
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 144 of 254
SMP 406.03.2 v1.8
BATTERY CHARGER
02/27/2009
2. Materials Required.
2.1 V&O Inspection
1) PDA with National Grid V&O software installed.
2) Inspection card from last V&O Inspection.
2.2 Diagnostic Inspection
1) All of the above plus:
2) Inspection card from last diagnostic inspection.
3) Two 375 watt cabinet strip heaters and leads to load charger during alarm and ripple
tests.
2.3 Acceptance Inspection
1) All of the above.
3. Unusual Hazards
Filter capacitors in battery chargers may be charged up to full battery voltage even with the
chargers AC and DC switches off. Filter capacitors are typically large, round, two-terminal
cylinders.
Battery chargers will have full battery voltage on side of the DC switch/circuit breaker if connected
to the battery. If the DC switch is closed internal sections of the charger will have full battery
voltage even if the AC switch is off.
Lead acid batteries emit hydrogen gas, which is explosive. No smoking, open flames or sparks
are allowed in their vicinity. Only insulated tools should be used when working on them.
Substation batteries are capable of very high short-circuit currents. Accidentally shorting cells or
batteries can result in severe burns and possibly battery explosions.
3
III-144
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 145 of 254
SMP 406.03.2 v1.8
BATTERY CHARGER
02/27/2009
4
III-145
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 146 of 254
SMP 406.03.2 v1.8
BATTERY CHARGER
02/27/2009
6. Diagnostic Inspection.
6.1 Perform battery charger diagnostic inspection before performing battery diagnostic inspection.
6.2 Perform all of the steps listed in Visual and Operations Inspections above.
6.3 Test equalizing timer switch and record equalizing voltage.
1) Turn the chargers equalize switch or timer on. Current indicated on the charger’s
ammeter should increase.
a) The current should not be higher than 90% of the DC circuit breaker rating. Example:
DC circuit breaker is 20A. 90 times 20 =1800. Throwaway the last two digits. Current
should not be more than 18 amps. If the current is over the limit refer to the
manufacturer’s instruction manual and adjust the current limiting setting.
b) If the chargers ammeter reads over 3/4 full scale the charger may be in the current
limiting mode. Wait 15 minutes, if the ammeter doesn’t drop below 3/4 full scale do
not adjust the equalizing voltage. Note on the inspection card/record that the charger
may be current limiting on equalize.
2) Turn the digital multi-meter on and select DC voltage and a range higher that the overall
battery voltage to be measured (Range selection is not necessary if the multi-meter is
auto-ranging).
3) Measure and record the overall voltage between the positive and negative ends of the
battery (points where the battery charger and DC supply leads are connected).
5
III-146
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 147 of 254
SMP 406.03.2 v1.8
BATTERY CHARGER
02/27/2009
4) Lead Acid Batteries - Refer to Appendix A at the end of this document to determine
battery type. Voltage should be within 1 volt of:
Battery Size Lead Antimony Lead Calcium Lead Selenium
24 volt – 12 cell 29 volts 28 volts 28
48 volt – 23 cell 55 volts 54 volts 54
48 volt – 24 cell 57 volts 56 volts 56
120 volt – 58 cell 138 volts 135 volts 136
120 volt – 60 cell 143 volts 140 volts 140
240 volt – 116 cell 277 volts 271 volts 271
240 volt – 117 cell 279 volts 273 volts 274
240 volt – 120 cell 286 volts 280 volts 281
X
5) Nickel-Cadmium (NICAD) Batteries – Refer to the manufacturers Instruction Manual.
6) Adjust the equalizing voltage if necessary. Normally there will be a small, screwdriver
adjustment accessible on the front panel. Be careful not to turn the float voltage
adjustment by mistake. Refer to the Substation Batteries and Chargers training manual
and/or the manufacturer’s instruction book for further information.
7) Record the final equalizing voltage on the inspection form/record.
8) Turn the battery charger’s equalizing timer or switch off.
6.4 Test Ground detection circuit – non microprocessor based chargers.
1) Connect a10k (10,000) ohm, 10 watt or greater resistor from the positive terminal of the
battery to station ground.
2) If the battery charger has ground detector lamps the positive lamp should light.
3) If the charger has a ground detection voltmeter the meter will show voltage when the
switch is in the positive position.
4) Connect a10k (10,000) ohm, 10 watt or greater resistor from the positive terminal of the
battery to station ground.
5) If the battery charger has ground detector lamps the negative lamp should light.
6) If the charger has a ground detection voltmeter the meter will show voltage when the
switch is in the negative position.
a) Resistors may be available a Radio Shack and are available from electronic
distributors such as Newark Electronics.
6.5 Test Ground detection circuit – microprocessor based chargers.
1) Access the battery ground setting through the chargers menu system.
2) Verify the alarm is set to 20k ohms (20,000 ohms).
a) Use 10k (10,000) ohm, 10 watt or greater resistor to test the ground detection circuit.
b) Test the positive ground detection by connecting the resistor from positive to
ground.
c) Test the negative ground detection by connecting the resistor from negative to
ground.
d) Resistors may be available a Radio Shack and are available from electronic
distributors such as Newark Electronics.
6
III-147
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 148 of 254
SMP 406.03.2 v1.8
BATTERY CHARGER
02/27/2009
7. Acceptance Inspection.
7.1 Perform battery charger inspection before performing battery inspection.
7.2 Set the battery ground detection setting to 20k ohms (20,000 ohms).
a) This step is normally only required on microprocessor based chargers.
b) A separate menu step may be needed to activate the ground detection alarm after it
is entered.
7.3 Perform all of the steps listed in Visual and Operations, and Diagnostic Inspections above.
7.4 Set and test low and high DC voltage alarms, battery ground alarm, and high voltage shut
down.
1) Refer to the manufacturer’s literature and the Substation Batteries and Chargers training
manual for more detail.
2) Microprocessor based charger alarms and settings are made through the chargers menu
system and display.
a) A separate menu step may be needed to activate alarms and settings after they are
entered.
3) Not all chargers have all of the features listed below. Refer to the manufacturer’s
literature.
4) If the features are installed in the charger, and not connected, note this on the inspection
card.
7
III-148
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 149 of 254
SMP 406.03.2 v1.8
BATTERY CHARGER
02/27/2009
8
III-149
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 150 of 254
SMP 406.03.2 v1.8
BATTERY CHARGER
02/27/2009
9
III-150
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 151 of 254
SMP 406.03.2 v1.8
BATTERY CHARGER
02/27/2009
8. Appendix A
x
10
III-151
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 152 of 254
SMP 406.03.2
BATTERY CHARGER
02/27/2009
9. Record of Revisions
Revision Changes
02/72/2009 Procedure
Changed – NPCC A4 – Charger Check to NPCC - Bulk Power Stations……
Reference
Added – NPCC Regional Reliability Reference Directory 3 Maintenance Criteria for Bulk
Power System Protection
NPCC - Bulk Power Stations - Charger Inspection
Added –This section meets the applicable requirements of NPCC Regional Reliability
Reference Directory 3 Maintenance Criteria for Bulk Power System Protection
11
III-152
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 153 of 254
SMP 406.03.2
BATTERY CHARGER
02/27/2009
12
III-153
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 154 of 254
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 406.11.2
Procedure Page 1 of 16
Locating Battery Grounds Version 2.0 – 04/01/10
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describes the methods used to locate substation battery grounds.
PURPOSE
This procedure lists special tools and equipment required, unusual hazards, and methods used, to
locate substation battery grounds.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and other Supervisors supervising inspection and maintenance activities.
Substation and other Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities.
COORDINATION
Not Applicable
REFERENCES
National Grid USA Safety Handbook
Manufacturer’s Installation, Operating, and Maintenance manuals for the specific equipment to be
inspected.
Manufacturer’s operating manuals for the specific test equipment to be used.
DEFINITIONS
Battery - Group of cells in a common container. Using three cells to create a 6 volt battery is
common in electrical substations.
Battery Bank - Group of cells, or batteries connected in series to create higher voltages. Battery
banks of 24, 48, 120, and 240 volts are common in electrical substations.
Battery Charger - Device that converts station service AC voltage to a precise, stable DC voltage.
Used to maintain the charge on station batteries and supply normal DC station
loads.
Battery Ground - The positive, negative or both sides of the stations battery, or its associated
circuits, have a connection to station ground with an impedance of less than
1 megOhm.
Case - Container enclosing a group of battery cells.
Cell - Basic component of a battery or battery bank. In a lead acid battery each cell
generates approximately 2.2 volts.
TRAINING
Not Applicable
DOCUMENT CONTENTS
Table of Contents
2.1 The fluid in lead acid batteries (electrolyte) is a mixture of sulfuric acid and distilled water.
2.1.1 Contact with electrolyte can cause blindness, burn skin, and burn holes in
clothing.
2.1.2 Electrolyte on skin or clothing should be rinsed off with generous amounts of
water.
2.1.3 Electrolyte in eyes should be flushed generously at an eyewash station and
immediate medical attention sought.
2.1.4 Acid proof gloves and aprons and a full face shield shall be worn when inspecting
or working on batteries.
2.2 Lead acid batteries emit hydrogen gas, which is explosive.
2.2.1 No smoking, open flames or sparks are allowed in their vicinity. Only insulated
tools should be used when working on batteries.
2.3 Substation batteries are capably of very high short-circuit currents.
2.3.1 Accidentally shorting cells or batteries can result in severe burns and possibly
battery explosions.
2.3.2 The use of 1000 volt disposable cover-up (SC 92008882) should be considered.
2.4 Although rare, batteries can explode violently and spew electrolyte and plastic shards from
battery jars in all directions.
2.4.1 Battery explosions can be caused by internal or external short circuits, or the
ignition of hydrogen gases.
Normally a combination of the following methods will be used to located DC grounds depending on the
individual circumstances and criticality of the DC circuits involved.
3.1 Interruption
3.1.1 Interruption is the monitoring of the circuits ground status while opening sections
of the circuit. Monitoring shall be done using the test setup shown in Appendix D
of this document.
3.1.2 Interruption is a fast method for determining the subsection, or area, of the circuit
containing the ground. The disadvantages are possible interruption of tripping
and unanticipated operations of control schemes or protective relays.
3.2 Signal Tracing
3.2.1 Signal Tracing consists of injecting an AC signal into the ground path and tracing
it with a special AC current clamp and/or headphones. The signal will only
appear on wires that are in the ground path. The injected signal is very low level
and should not affect control circuits or protective relays.
3.2.2 Signal tracing can be done with the circuit energized and is relatively fast. The
disadvantage is as the impedance of the ground goes up is more difficult to find.
Hard (metal to metal) grounds are easy to trace. Locating grounds of 10,000
ohms or more is difficult, 100,000 ohms or more may not be possible. Multiple
high resistance grounds will be difficult, or impossible, to find with this method.
3.3 Insulation Impedance testing.
3.3.1 Insulation impedance testing (megger) is done with the wires to be tested de-
energized and isolated. Although it can be used on any wire its primary use is to
test cable runs and bundles.
3.3.2 High impedance grounds can be easily identified. However the difference
between hard (metal to metal) and grounds of 10s of thousands of ohms can not
be distinguished. Impedance testing with a multi-meter after megger testing can
be used to determine the values. Insulation impedance testing is also effective in
identifying intermittent grounds caused by moisture and deteriorated insulation.
The megger will often show relatively low values after the alarm has cleared in
these cases.
3.3.3 Disadvantages are the circuits must be de-energized and isolated for relatively
long periods of time and if isolation is not done properly damage to electronic
control circuits and protective relays or unanticipated operations may occur.
3.4 Mechanical Testing
3.4.1 Mechanical testing may be done once the ground has been located to a relatively
small area. Movement of swing panels, doors or wire bundles may help identify
grounds caused by insulation chafing. This may be the only way to identify some
intermittent grounds.
4.1 Notify the System Operator that you will be investigating a battery ground following
Substation Maintenance Procedure SMP 406.10.2 and that it will impact station alarms
only.
4.2 Verify Battery Ground by one or more of the following:
4.2.1 Battery grounds may be intermittent; previously reported battery grounds may not
be present at time of testing.
a. Intermittent battery grounds may be due to moisture.
4.2.2 If the battery charger has ground detector lamps record if the positive or negative
lamp is lit.
4.2.3 If the charger has a ground detection voltmeter record the voltages with the
meter switch in both the positive and negative ground positions.
a. If the voltmeter reads voltage when the switch is in the positive position the
battery has a positive ground.
b. If the voltmeter reads voltage when the switch is in the negative position the
battery has a negative ground.
4.2.4 Whether, or not, the charger has indicates a ground use the multi-meter and the
test setup shown in Appendix D, at the end of this document, to record the
battery positive and negative voltages to ground.
a. Measured voltage from positive post to ground indicates a negative ground
on system and measured voltage from negative post to ground indicates a
positive ground on system.
b. Resistor with test leads is required to get meaningful results.
c. Turn off the charger’s AC circuit breaker.
d. Turn off the charger’s DC circuit breaker.
e. Wait 10 minutes and then use a multi-meter to record the battery positive
and negative voltages to ground measured across the connected resistor
jumper.
f. Turn on the charger’s DC circuit breaker.
g. Turn on the charger’s AC circuit breaker.
h. Categorize the measured positive and negative voltage results based on
table below.
5.1 While shutting off of DC circuits at the DC circuit breaker/fuse panel is an efficient method
of narrowing the search area it can only be utilized after the risk is confirmed to be
reasonable.
5.2 Before interruption DC circuits must be confirmed by both DC circuit breaker/fuse position
labeling and the current station DC one-line print.
5.3 If these two sources of information conflict, then use the DC schematic and field checking
to resolve the conflict.
5.4 Circuits should only be shut off for the time necessary to verify the ground status utilizing
procedure in Appendix D (less than a minute).
5.5 At a substation with single pole breakers or individual fuses in the DC circuits always turn
off the Positive side first then the Negative side. To return the circuit to service put the
Negative on first then the Positive.
6.1 The following signal tracing test equipment is available within National Grid USA and is
known to have reasonable success rate locating battery grounds.
6.1.1 Biddle Groundbuster – Catalog # 246100
6.1.2 Megger Battery Ground Fault Locator – Catalog #835140
6.1.3 ELECTROM - GDL-201
6.2 Use this equipment, and its associated instruction manual, to attempt to find ground.
6.3 This may not be successful since effectiveness diminishes when ground impedance
values are above 10k ohm.
6.4 If there are multiple high impedance grounds success will also be unlikely.
6.5 Use of one of these test sets It is required to determine if Signal Tracing will be able to
pinpoint a battery ground to a specific circuit or area.
6.6 Appendices A, B, and C provide information about each signal tracing equipment and how
to determine if success is likely.
8.1 Repair of grounds that require DC interruption of protective or control schemes, require
the removal of the associated equipment from service.
8.1.1 Normal equipment outage application process is required.
8.2 Battery grounds should be repaired immediately, when ever possible.
8.3 When the battery ground is less than 10k Ohms repairs shall be completed within thirty
days.
8.3.1 Unless multiple grounds, each above 10 k Ohms, can be conclusively identified
the 30 day time frame applies.
8.3.2 If there is no existing follow up work order.
a. Enter a follow up work order, priority 4, into AIMMS to document the
problem and repair.
8.4 When the battery ground is more than 10k Ohms repairs shall be completed within six
months.
8.4.1 If there is no existing follow up work order.
a. Enter a follow up work order, priority 3, into AIMMS to document the
problem and repair.
RECEIVER
TRANSMITTER
9.1 The Megger BGFT Transmitter outputs an adjustable (0-50V, 1.7 Amp max, 20HZ) AC
signal. Its CT clamp Receiver detects the presence of this signal in wires on the DC
system.
10.1 The Meggar BGL has a Transmitter which outputs an (3.5 volt, 110 mA max, 25HZ) AC
signal and an integrated Receiver with CT clamp for detecting this signal at locations on
the DC system.
10.2 Steps to utilize equipment and evaluate results it may give:
10.2.1 Set the Power Toggle switch to Off, Function Toggle Switch to Resistance, and
Memory Toggle switch to Normal.
10.2.2 Insert transmitter Output Cable, 3 wires with leads on one end, and round
connector on other, into the Output connector.
10.2.3 Connect the other end of the Output Cable (source leads) at battery location.
a. Green and Black boot to bare metal ground, Red boot to DC battery cable
connection polarity, positive, or negative, that has a ground.
10.2.4 Connect the power cord and turn the Power switch ON. (Unit can also operate
using battery, if tested charged).
10.2.5 Connect CT clamp cable to the CT and to the Input Sensor connector on the
Transmitter.
10.2.6 Clamp on current probe around the polarity battery cable, positive, or negative,
that has the ground
a. The current probe red marking should face toward the battery
10.2.7 If the Meter shows 10k ohms or less the test set may be able to locate the
ground.
a. If the meter shows greater than 10k ohms ensure the ground connection is
making good contact on a bare grounded surface.
b. If he measured value remains greater 10k ohms stop the test and
document on Inspection Card (SMP 406.10.3).
10.3 At the DC Panel, with the receiver red marking facing toward the battery, determine which
DC circuit has the largest signal.
10.3.1 Record all measurements taken on the Inspection Card (SMP 406.10.3).
10.3.2 The signal current may split into multiple circuits or wires indicating more than
one ground.
10.3.3 Trace each circuit or wire with a ground signal, moving away from the Battery/DC
Panel and attempt to locate the ground(s).
11.1 The Electrom-GDL-201 Transmitter generates a low current, audio frequency (AF) signal
when a connection exists between the two leads.
POS 1.50
WAVETEK HD110
OFF AC
C20V200
1000 1000
200
20 V
D2
NEG
2
200m 200m
2 2
200m 200m
POS
20m 20m
ACA
DCA
10A 10A
2m 2m
200u 200u
20M
2M200K 2K200
20K
NEG
100k OHM
RESISTOR V- COM A 10A
POS
NEG
POS
NEG
STATION
GROUND
12.1 Digital multi-meters can be used to test for battery grounds if no ground detection is
provided in the charger.
12.2 However, due to their very high input impedance, a parallel resistor jumper lead must be
fabricated and used. If the resistor lead is not used the multi-meter will indicate grounds
when none are present.
12.3 The resistor jumper lead is fabricated using a 100k ohm 5 Watt resistor. 100k ohm
resistors are available at Radio Shack and other electronic component suppliers.
12.4 With the leads connected to the positive battery terminal as shown you are testing for
negative grounds.
12.5 Move the resistor and meter leads from the positive to the negative battery terminal. This
will test for positive grounds.
12.6 With this setup, voltages less than 10% of the battery voltage (12 volts for 120-volt battery)
indicate no significant grounds. Full battery voltages indicate hard (metal to metal)
grounds. Voltages in-between indicate resistive grounds.
SMP 408.01.2
SUBSTATION
Version 1.3
MAINTENANCE Date 09/18/2008
PROCEDURE Page 1 of 8
CAPACITOR BANK
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describes the methods used to perform Visual and Operational, Thermographic,
Mechanism, and Diagnostic on capacitor banks used in electrical substations.
PURPOSE
Scheduled equipment inspections are necessary to protect both the public and electric utility workers,
prevent unnecessary customer outages, and maximize equipment operating life. This procedure lists
special tools and equipment required, unusual hazards, and methods used, to inspect capacitor banks.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and other Supervisors supervising inspection and maintenance activities.
Substation and other Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities.
COORDINATION
New England - Worcester Lab – Thermographic Inspection.
Relay Department needed to check Bank Guard Relaying - Diagnostic Inspection (If applicable).
REFERENCES
National Grid USA Safety Handbook
SMP 408.01.4 Working On Substation Capacitor Banks
Manufacturer’s Installation, Operating, and Maintenance manuals for the specific equipment to be
inspected.
Manufacturer’s operating manuals for the specific test equipment to be used.
DEFINITIONS
PDA - Personal Digital Assistant. Pocket size computer.
Bleed down Resistor - High-value (megohms) internal resistor connected across a capacitor.
Provides a current path to discharge the capacitor when power is removed.
Bank Guard Relay - Relay that monitors the neutral current ,or voltage ,on some Y connected
capacitor banks. Excessive neutral current, or voltage, indicates failed
capacitor units or other phase related problems.
Impedance Relay - Relay that measures phase voltages and currents and computes phase
impedance. Most sensitive method of detecting failed capacitor units or other
phase related problems.
Halo - Manufacturer’s trade name for hot-stick ammeter.
Printed copies of this document are not document controlled. Refer to the National Grid INFONET,
Substation Services website, for the latest version. Controlled copies are maintained in Documentum.
File SMP408.01.doc
III-170
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 171 of 254
SMP 408.01.2 v1.3
CAPACITOR BANK
09/18/2008
2. Materials Required.
2.1 V&O Inspection
1) PDA with National Grid V&O software installed.
2) Inspection data from last V&O inspection.
3) Binoculars.
2
III-171
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 172 of 254
SMP 408.01.2 v1.3
CAPACITOR BANK
09/18/2008
3. Unusual Hazards
Capacitor units used in modern substation capacitor banks contain bleeder resistors to discharge
them when de-energized. Even with bleeder resistors capacitors may be remain charged up to 5
minutes. Failed units or even pieces of internal plate material from blown-up units may remain
charged for several days. Before working on, or near, capacitor units they should be discharged,
between terminals (2 bushing) or terminal to case ground (single bushing). Use a ground lead
and insulated hot-stick to discharge capacitors. When grounding units hold ground on for a slow
count of 5.
3
III-172
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 173 of 254
SMP 408.01.2 v1.3
CAPACITOR BANK
09/18/2008
4
III-173
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 174 of 254
SMP 408.01.2 v1.3
CAPACITOR BANK
09/18/2008
5. Pre-Peak Inspection
5.1 Perform V&O Inspection Items
5.2 Read and record the capacitor currents on banks rated 35 KV and below.
1) If the capacitor bank is on line (energized).
a) Read and record the capacitor current in each phase with the hot-stick ammeter.
b) If the bank is wye connected and has a single, grounded neutral (insulated structure)
read and record the neutral current with the hot-stick ammeter.
c) If capacitor bank is fuseless (internally fused) check each unit for current with the
hot-stick ammeter. Measure current just above the bushing connector.
2) If the capacitor bank is off line read and record the capacitor and neutral currents in step
4.10.
3) Currents should be very similar.
a) Use the hot-stick ammeter readings, not the station ammeters to compare phase's
currents.
b) Refer to Appendix A at the end of this document for more information on evaluating
readings.
c) Refer to Appendix B at the end of this document for more information on calculating
expected readings.
6. Thermographic Inspection
6.1 Inspect all high voltage connections.
6.2 Inspect all capacitor units.
6.3 Record connections or capacitor units significantly hotter or colder than adjacent units.
5
III-174
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 175 of 254
SMP 408.01.2 v1.3
CAPACITOR BANK
09/18/2008
6
III-175
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 176 of 254
SMP 408.01.2 v1.3
CAPACITOR BANK
09/18/2008
7
III-176
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 177 of 254
SMP 408.01.2 v1.3
CAPACITOR BANK
09/18/2008
05/23/2007 Document
Added - Documentum Version # to headers
Added - File name to footer
09/18/2008 Introduction
Removed – Internal Inspection from list of inspections.
Coordination
Added – "If Applicable" to Relay Department
8
III-177
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 178 of 254
SUBSTATION MAINTENENCE Doc. # SMP 499.01.2
Procedure Page 1 of 28
Protective Grounding Version 2.0 – 12/14/12
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describes the methods used to isolate, test de-energized and ground electrical
apparatus for inspection, maintenance and repair.
PURPOSE
Grounding of electrical apparatus provides protection from accidental energization of apparatus and
lines, and from static and induced voltages. Grounds also provide visual confirmation that apparatus
and lines are de-energized.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and other Supervisors supervising inspection and maintenance activities.
Substation and other Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities.
COORDINATION
Not Applicable.
REFERENCES
National Grid Safety Handbook
EOP G014 Clearance and Control Procedure
SMP 408.01.4 – Working On Substation Capacitor Banks
SMS 499.09.1 – PPE for Switching Indoor Substations Standard
SMP 499.10.1 – Substation Work Area Identification
SMP 499.10.2 – Substation Work Area Identification Procedure
Manufacturer’s Installation, Operating, and Maintenance manuals for the specific equipment to be
inspected.
Manufacturer’s operating manuals for the specific test equipment to be used.
DEFINITIONS
Apparatus - Devices or equipment, other than cables, lines and their
associated hardware, used to transmit or distribute electrical
energy.
Authorized Person - A person designated by a Departmental Manager, or their
designee, who has successfully been tested and has
demonstrated proficiency and understanding of Clearance and
Control (EOP G014). A person who is undergoing on-the-job
training and who, in the course of such training, has demonstrated
an ability to perform duties safely at his or her level of training and
who is under the direct supervision of an Authorized Person is
High Speed Grounding Switch - Automatically closing switch used to, deliberately apply a fault,
usually to a transmission line, and force remote tripping, to protect
apparatus.
Insulation - Covering applied to energized conductors or live parts that are
designed to withstand at least the full voltage that is applied in
normal operation.
Protective Ground - Device used to establish an equi-potential zone or ground
conductors for the protection of workers.
Grounds At Remote Locations - Grounds installed at locations other than the work site.
Higher Authority - An Authorized Person at the same or higher level of Management
above the Clearance Person who is holding the Clearance and is
knowledgeable in the work to be performed.
Qualified Person - A person knowledgeable in the construction and operation of
electric power generation, transmission, substation, and/or
distribution apparatus involved along with the associated hazards
in specific duties pertaining to electric operations.
Source of Inadvertent Energization - Source of primary voltage that could energize the work area if a
disconnecting device were to be closed
System Operator - Person authorized by the company to write and issue Switching
Orders.
Three Phase Ground - Ground with three phase ends connected to a common ground
end.
Weather Cover - Covering applied to energized conductors or live parts that are
designed to protect the conductor or live part from the effects of
weather. It may have some insulating value but is not designed to
withstand the full voltage that is applied in normal operation.
TRAINING
Workers who have not been trained in or performed grounding operations on high voltage apparatus in
the preceding year shall not perform the below tasks unless on site training is done.
Initial training for this activity is normally accomplished through:
Attending Training Course NS9081 – SMP 499.01.2 Protective Grounding Maintenance Procedure
Performing Approved On-The-Job Training
DOCUMENT CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1.0 HAZARDS.................................................................................................................................. 6
24.0 APPENDIX A - NEW YORK LOCATIONS REQUIRING MORE THAN SINGLE 2/0
GROUNDS............................................................................................................................... 20
25.0 APPENDIX B - NEW ENGLAND LOCATIONS REQUIRING MORE THAN SINGLE 4/0
GROUNDS............................................................................................................................... 25
1.0 HAZARDS
1.1 Great care and attention are required during testing and grounding operations to avoid
inadvertently attempting to ground a live conductor.
1.2 The immediate area should be carefully examined for energized conductors and evaluated
to ensure grounding can be accomplished safely.
1.3 Testing and grounding procedures should be strictly followed.
2.1 Class 2 Rubber Gloves and fire retardant clothing are required for all testing and
grounding operations.
2.2 In addition, Arc Flash Ensembles are required in indoor substations for specific work
activities that include testing and grounding. Refer to SMP 499.30.2 - Substation Personal
Protective Equipment.
3.1 Lines and apparatus may be worked ungrounded and treated as dead only if National Grid
Management can demonstrate:
3.1.1 That the installation of grounds is impracticable.
3.1.2 Conditions resulting from the installation of grounds would present greater
hazards than working without grounds.
3.1.3 And the following conditions are met:
a. The apparatus or lines have been isolated and tested de-energized under
the provisions of this document and other referenced procedures.
b. There is no possibility of contact with any other energized source.
c. The hazard of induced voltage is not present.
3.2 Exceptions from, or deviations to, normal grounding procedures require agreement and
approval, by concurrence, of the:
3.2.1 Manager of Substation Maintenance & Construction,
3.2.2 Manager Substation Work Methods,
3.2.3 Or their designees.
5.1 Portable wire conductor type grounds that have been faulted shall be cut up and
discarded.
5.2 Grounding Trucks or Ground and Test (G&T) Carts that have been faulted shall be
completely disassembled, inspected, and repaired. They shall be inspected by a
substation supervisor before reassembly and use.
5.3 Permanently installed grounding switches
5.3.1 Refer to Substation Maintenance Bulleting 409.09.N.001 Substation Ground
Disconnects > 69kV for guidance for grounding switches used in substation for
overhead circuit applications that have been subjected to fault conditions.
5.3.2 Grounding switches for Underground Cable Systems and Gas Insulated
Substations (GIS) that have been faulted shall be visually inspected and tested
for contact resistance.
a. Test results shall be approved by a substation supervisor before the
grounding disconnects are returned to service.
6.1 Only devices listed in the National Grid Approved Tools and Equipment Catalog shall be
used to test de-energized before grounding.
7.1 Minimum conductor size of conventional grounds is 4/0 copper in New England.
7.2 Minimum conductor size of conventional grounds is 2/0 copper in New York.
7.3 Refer to Appendix A and Appendix B of this document for locations where, multiple
grounds per phase, or wire sizes larger than the minimum size are required.
8.1 Grounds and grounding devices shall be visually inspected before each use for:
8.1.1 Fraying of wire at terminations.
8.1.2 Damaged or deteriorated connections.
8.1.3 Damaged of deteriorated heat shrink, if used.
8.1.4 Tightness of bolted connections, if used.
8.1.5 Any other physical damage
8.2 Live Line Tools used for testing or grounding shall be visually inspected before each use
for:
8.2.1 Physical damage. Live Line Tools with any sign of damage should be sent to the
manufacturer, Worcester Lab or New York Lab for evaluation and possible repair.
8.2.2 Unauthorized modifications. (Cut short etc.).
8.2.3 Cleanliness. Clean with approved Live Line Tool wipes if necessary.
8.2.4 Within required electrical test (HiPot) date period (Inspection Date Sticker).
9.1 Joint use of grounds shall be permitted only with the knowledge and consent of each
Clearance Person for whom the apparatus is tagged.
9.2 Jointly used grounds must be within the Tagged Areas of all Clearance Persons using
them.
9.3 Each Clearance Person shall attach a Ground Device Identification Ticket (GDIT) to the
jointly used grounds.
9.4 Each Clearance Person shall include the jointly used grounds on their list of ground
locations and GDIT numbers documented on the Field Clearance and Control Form.
9.5 The first Clearance Person to clear off shall remove their Ground Device Identification
Ticket (GDIT) and leave the ground attached.
9.6 The last Clearance Person to clear off is responsible for the removal of the ground.
9.7 Grounds shall never be removed if they are tagged with another person’s Ground Device
Identification Ticket (GDIT).
10.1 General.
10.1.1 The Clearance Person shall determine the required number and locations of
grounds.
10.1.2 All three phases shall be grounded.
10.1.3 Grounds shall be placed as close to the work area as reasonably possible.
10.1.4 Grounds shall be placed between the work area and all possible sources of
inadvertent energization, wherever possible.
a. If multiple sources of inadvertent energization feed the work area, for
example a substation bus, it is not necessary to ground each source.
10.1.5 The preferred work practice is to work between grounds.
a. This provides the best protection and further defines the limits of the work
area.
10.1.6 Work between a ground and a possible source of inadvertent energization (past
the ground and toward the potential source) shall only be done within 10
conductor feet of the phase end of the ground.
10.2 Grounding through protective shutters in cubicles or other enclosures.
10.2.1 Only grounding trucks or other devices approved and/or supplied by the
apparatus manufacturer shall be used to ground through protective shutters.
a. Exceptions must be approved by the Manager Substation Maintenance &
Construction and the Manager Substation Work Methods.
10.3 Capacitors and Capacitor Racks and Structures – Additional Requirements.
10.3.1 Review SMP 408.01.4 – Working On Substation Capacitor Banks before
grounding or working on substation capacitor banks.
10.3.2 Use additional substation grounds to ground any ungrounded structure that will
be within minimum approach distance during the work.
a. This includes ungrounded structure that could be fallen into.
b. Sections may be grounded in series by grounding each section to the
section below until a connection to the ground grid is reached.
10.3.3 Use additional substation grounds to ground any ungrounded bus sections that
will be within minimum approach distance during the work.
a. This includes bus sections that could be fallen into.
10.3.4 Use an additional substation ground to ground across any neutral sensing
devices in wye connected banks.
10.3.5 Use an additional substation ground to ground neutral in ungrounded wye
connected banks.
Grounding through disconnects or circuit breakers is the least preferred method and should only
be considered when all other options have been evaluated.
11.1 Grounding through a disconnect or circuit breaker shall be thoroughly discussed and
documented during the Job Brief.
11.1.1 Refer to local agreements for additional work procedures that may be required
for grounding through circuit breakers and disconnects.
11.2 Grounding through circuit breakers.
11.2.1 The breaker shall be verified closed by means of the mechanical indicator
(trip/close flag).
11.2.2 Tripping shall be disabled.
11.2.3 The circuit breaker shall be tagged with a locally applied hold tag.
11.3 Grounding through disconnects.
11.3.1 Disconnects shall be visually verified to be closed.
11.3.2 The disconnect shall be inspected for overheating, mechanical wear, and to
otherwise be in good condition.
11.3.3 The mechanism shall be de-coupled and locked closed on motor operated
disconnects.
a. Shunt tripping shall also be disabled on circuit switchers, if applicable.
11.3.4 Gang operated disconnects shall be locked closed.
11.3.5 Single blade disconnects shall be verified fully closed and properly latched.
11.3.6 The disconnect(s) shall be tagged with a locally applied hold tag
12.1 The Clearance Person shall order the point of grounding tested and grounded by two
Authorized Persons. At least one of the persons must be on the Authorized Person List.
12.2 One of the persons performing the grounding shall notify the Clearance Person that the
grounds have been installed and give him the numbers of the Grounding Device
Identification Tickets (GDIT) used.
12.3 The Clearance Person shall identify the grounds by GDIT number and location and order
the grounds removed by Two Authorized Persons. At least one of the persons must be on
the Authorized Person List.
12.4 One of the persons removing the grounds shall notify the Clearance Person that the
grounds have been removed and give him the numbers of the associated Ground Device
Identification Tickets.
12.5 If necessary, the System Operator may be used to relay these communications.
13.1 Wait 5 minutes after de-energizing a capacitor bank before testing de-energized and
grounding.
13.2 Two Authorized Persons are required to test and ground. At least one of the
persons must be on the Authorized Person List.
13.3 The Clearance Person may act as one of the two required persons
13.4 Testing shall be in the presence of, and the responsibility of the Clearance Person.
13.4.1 Exception Grounds At Remote Locations.
13.5 Only devices listed in the National Grid USA Approved Tools and Equipment Catalog shall
be used to test de-energized before grounding.
13.6 No more than 9 grounding points (a group) shall be tested de-energized at one time and
then only if they are with in 10 feet of each other, or are on bushings or taps of the same
apparatus.
13.7 The tester shall be tested both before and after testing each group of grounding points to
verify that it is working correctly.
13.7.1 Tests shall be made on the same voltage range as the normal energized voltage
of the points to be tested and this range shall be used to test de-energized.
13.7.2 The tester shall be tested by: (listed in order of preference).
a. Testing on known live source of the same voltage as the points to be tested
de-energized.
b. Tested with a test source designed to test high voltage testers that is listed
in the Approved Tools and Equipment Catalog.
c. Tested with the self-test button or feature incorporated in the tester.
d. Testers that appear to be acting abnormally should not be used. They
should be sent to the manufacturer, Worcester Lab or New York Lab for
evaluation and possible repair.
13.8 The exact points where the grounds will be applied shall be tested de-energized.
13.9 If either of the two persons required to test de-energized and ground leave the immediate
area of testing and grounding, or the testing and grounding process is otherwise
interrupted:
13.9.1 Any ungrounded points shall be retested before additional grounds are applied.
13.10 Ground and Test (G&T) Cart or Grounding Trucks.
13.10.1 Ensure SMP 499.01.3 Ground and Test (G&T) Cart Checklist is reviewed and
completed for proper set up and inspection instructions prior to the installation of
G&T or Grounding Trucks.
13.10.2 Manually opening shutters is prohibited.
13.10.3 Verify if substation is posted as having been identified as having incident energy
above 8 cal/cm2 and ensure proper level of PPE is worn before testing, installing,
or removing G&T Cart.
13.10.4 Class II rubber gloves shall be worn used when installing (jacking in) or removing
(jacking out) grounding trucks.
13.10.5 Class II rubber gloves and a Live Line Tool shall be used when attaching or
removing leads from installed grounding trucks.
13.10.6 Preferred method.
a. Remove ground leads from the truck.
b. Install bushings ((source/load), if equipped.
c. Install insulating caps on ground connection points on the truck that will not
be used, if equipped.
d. Install (jack in) the grounding truck into the cubicle.
e. Test de-energized on the points on the truck that will be grounded.
f. Attach the ground leads to system ground.
g. Attach the ground leads to the truck with an approved Live Line Tool.
13.10.7 If the connections from the ground leads to the ground truck are bolted.
a. Remove ground leads from the truck.
b. Install (jack in) the grounding truck into the cubicle.
c. Test de-energized on the points on the truck that will be grounded.
d. Withdraw the grounding truck sufficiently to de-energize the truck and close
shutters.
e. Maintain minimum approached distance and safely connect the ground
leads.
f. Attach the ground leads to system ground.
g. Attach the ground leads to the truck.
h. Install (jack in) the grounding truck into the cubicle.
13.11 Permanently installed grounding switches in Gas Insulated Substations (GIS).
13.11.1 Grounding switches shall only be operated and tagged under a System
Operator’s order.
13.11.2 If it is not possible to test de-energized do to the GIS construction:
a. The Clearance Persons and one other Authorized Person shall review the
One-Line diagram and visually verify that the correct isolating disconnects
are open before closing the grounding switch.
14.1 Grounding Device Identification Tickets shall be used for all grounding devices.
14.2 A separate GDIT shall be used for each ground connection.
14.3 Grounding Device Identification Tickets may be attached for the System Operator or the
Clearance Person
15.1 The Clearance Person shall maintain a list of all grounds attached, including those at
remote locations on the Field Clearance and Control Form.
15.1.1 This list shall include the specific locations and Ground Device Identification
Ticket (GDIT) numbers.
16.1 All of the ground clamp ends of a group of grounds shall be attached first.
16.1.1 Class II rubber gloves shall be used.
16.1.2 The point of attachment shall be visually verified to be connected to the ground
grid.
16.1.3 The connection points in order of preference are:
a. Jug handle specifically installed for grounding.
b. Structure directly connected to the ground grid.
c. Structure connected to the ground grid through bolted structure
connections.
16.1.4 Connection to galvanized or painted structure.
a. Ensure the grounding location is properly grounded.
b. Remove paint, oxidation, or galvanization to ensure a good ground source.
c. Set screws used for mechanically holding the ground end clamp to the
ground source connection shall be screwed in after the clamp end is
tightened, if equipped. Caution must be exercised not to over tighten the
set screws.
16.2 All of the phase ends of a group of grounds shall be attached second.
16.2.1 Live Line Tool and Class II rubber gloves shall be used.
16.2.2 Phase ends shall be a suitable size, and design, for the bus, pad or wire.
16.3 All of the phase ends of a group of grounds shall be removed first.
16.3.1 Live Line Tool and Class II rubber gloves shall be used.
16.4 All of the ground clamp ends of a group of grounds shall be removed second.
16.4.1 Class II rubber gloves shall be used.
16.5 A live line tool of sufficient length shall be used to maintain the distances listed in the
Minimum Approach Distance Table.
16.5.1 For specific grounding applications in NE, if a grounding Live Line Tool of
sufficient length to maintain the distances listed in the Minimum Approach
Distance Table is not available, a shorter Live Line Tool may be used providing:
a. The distances listed in the Minimum Approach Distance Table are
maintained until the conductor has been tested de-energized.
b. The insulated portion of the Live Line Tool is at least 4 feet 6 inches long.
c. The worker maintains at least 2 feet of clearance from the conductor to be
grounded.
This section shows a limited number of examples of grounding procedures for metal clad
substations. For work not included here refer to the general testing and grounding requirements in
the other sections of this SMP
18.1 For Work from circuit breaker to cable terminations – stations without load side
disconnects.
18.1.1 Test and ground at the riser terminals.
T1 T2
a. Sections 13 and 16.
18.1.2 If a grounding truck is available use it to test
R15
R25
18.2 For work at the circuit breaker cubicle terminals – stations without load side disconnects.
18.2.1 Rack out all breakers on the bus section.
18.2.2 Exception – breaker that will be used for
grounding the bus, if necessary. T1 T2
R15
R25
a. See Sections 13 and 16.
b. If grounding studs are available test and R215
ground the feeder at the grounding
studs.
R40
R30
R20
R10
c. If there are no grounding studs test and
ground the feeder as close to the work
as possible.
18.2.4 Test and ground the bus section.
a. See Sections 13 and 16.
18.2.5 If a grounding truck is available use it to test and ground the bus side circuit
breaker terminals.
18.2.6 The grounding truck may be installed in an adjacent breaker position or the bus
tie position.
a. See Section 13.10.
18.2.7 If a grounding truck is not available test the bus dead.
a. See Section 13
b. Test and ground an adjacent feeder.
c. Close the feeder breaker to ground the bus.
d. Remove tripping from the breaker for the duration of the work.
e. Tag the breaker with a locally applied hold tag
18.3 For work between the load side disconnects and the cable – stations with load side
disconnects and grounding studs.
18.3.1 Test and ground the feeder.
a. See Sections 13 and 16.
T1 T2
b. If grounding studs are available test and
ground the feeder at the grounding
studs.
R15
R25
c. If there are no grounding studs test and
R215
ground the feeder as close to the work
as possible.
18.3.2 Test at cubicle before removing covers from
R40
R20
R30
R10
grounding studs. See Section 13.
18.3.3 Remove the covers from the grounding studs
using an approved insulated tool adequate for
thee voltage level.
18.3.4 Retest at grounding studs. See Section 13.
18.3.5 Apply grounds to grounding studs.
18.3.6 See Section 16.
18.4 For work on the load side disconnects or between the circuit breaker and load side
disconnects – stations with load side disconnects and grounding studs.
18.4.1 Test and ground the feeder.
a. See Sections 13 and 16.
T1 T2
b. If grounding studs are available test and
ground the feeder at the grounding studs.
R15
R25
R30
R10
terminals.
a. See Section 13.10.
18.4.3 If a grounding truck is not available.
a. Test at cubicle before removing covers
from grounding studs. See Section 13.
b. Remove the covers from the grounding studs using an approved insulated
tool adequate for thee voltage level.
c. Retest at grounding studs. See Section 13.
d. Apply grounds to grounding studs. See Section 16.
18.5 For work on a bus section – stations with load side disconnects.
18.5.1 Include the transformer bank feeding the bus
section if possible.
18.5.2 Open and truck out the bus tie circuit breaker. T1 T2
R15
R25
a. See Sections 13 and 16.
R215
18.5.4 Close the associated transformer breaker.
a. Remove tripping from the breaker for
R40
R20
R30
R10
the duration of the work.
b. Tag the breaker with a locally applied
hold tag.
18.5.5 Optional - If a grounding truck is available use
it to test and ground the bus-side transformer
circuit breaker terminals. See Section 13.10.
18.5.6 If a grounding truck is not available:
a. Test the bus dead. See Section 13.
b. Test and ground a feeder on the bus.
c. See Sections 13 and 16.
d. Close the feeder breaker to ground the bus.
e. Remove tripping from the breaker for the duration of the work.
19.1 Permanently installed grounding switches shall only be operated and tagged under a
System Operator’s order.
19.2 The System Operator will order the Ground Device Identification Ticket (GDIT) applied
and removed and maintain a list of the locations and GDIT numbers used.
20.1 After clearance to go to work is received grounded taps may be removed from apparatus
bushings and pulled away.
20.2 The grounds must remain on the taps until they are reconnected to the bushings and work
is complete.
20.3 It is not necessary to apply grounds to the bushing connectors
21.1 Grounds may be temporarily removed from apparatus when required for electrical testing.
21.2 If grounded taps are to be removed from the apparatus bushings and pulled back isolating
the equipment from the system to facilitate testing, it is not necessary to place additional
grounds on the bushings before attaching, moving, or removing test set leads.
21.3 If grounded taps are NOT to be removed from the apparatus bushings, the test leads shall
be attached before the grounds are removed.
21.3.1 The apparatus shall be considered as energized until the grounds are re-
installed.
21.3.2 Grounds shall be re-installed before test leads are moved or removed.
21.4 Class II rubber gloves and a Live Line Tool shall be used to install and remove
conventional grounds.
21.5 Class II rubber gloves shall be used to remove and reinstall links on Gas Insulated
Substation (GIS) ground switches.
24.0 APPENDIX A - NEW YORK LOCATIONS REQUIRING MORE THAN SINGLE 2/0 GROUNDS
25.0 APPENDIX B - NEW ENGLAND LOCATIONS REQUIRING MORE THAN SINGLE 4/0
GROUNDS
ALL
Station/Bus kV Ground Station/Bus kV Ground
AUBURN ST 115 2-4/0 RAILYARD 115 2-4/0
BRAYTON PT G1 115 2-4/0 SALEM HARBOR 115 2-4/0
BRIDGEWATER 115 2-4/0 SANDY POND 115 2-4/0
EVERETT 115 2-4/0 SOUTH ST 115 2-4/0
FRANKLIN SQ 115 2-4/0 TEWKSBURY 115 2-4/0
GOLDEN HILLS 115 2-4/0 WEST FARNUM 115 2-4/0
HARTFORD AVE 115 2-4/0 WOONSOCKET 115 2-4/0
MELROSE 115 2-4/0
PERRY ST 115 2-4/0
1.5 07/12/07 Attaching And Removing Conventional Grounds - All of the ground clamp ends …………
Added - Class II rubber gloves shall be used.
Grounding Trucks.
Added - Class II rubber gloves shall be worn used when installing (jacking in) or removing (jacking
out) grounding trucks.
Added - Class II rubber gloves and a Live Line Tool shall be used when attaching or removing
leads from installed grounding trucks.
Grounding In Metal-Clad Switch Gear
Corrected – References to other Sections.
Installing and Removing Grounding Trucks
1.7 06/23/08 Section 16 – 16.1, 4) Connection for galvanized or painted structures. 16.5, 1) Specific grounding
applications in NE.
Section 22 – Replacement Ground Set cables to be low temp clear jacketed.
Consolidated Ground Lead Tables.
1.8 09/18/08 APPENDIX A – New York Locations Requiring More Than Single 2/0 Grounds.
Corrected – Alphabetical Order.
SMP 499.02.2
SUBSTATION
Version 1.2
MAINTENANCE Date 06/23/2008
PROCEDURE Page 1 of 8
INTRODUCTION
This procedure describes the methods used to properly ground mobile substations before placing them in
service.
PURPOSE
Mobile substations must be properly grounded when installed to protect both the public and electric utility
workers and to ensure proper operation of protective devices.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and other Supervisors supervising inspection and maintenance activities.
Substation and other Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities.
REFERENCES
National Grid USA Safety Manual
EOP 499.10.2 - Substation Work Area Identification Procedure
PROCEDURE CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1. GENERAL ..................................................................................................... 1
2. GROUNDING WHEN INSIDE SUBSTATION ..................................................... 2
3. GROUNDING WHEN OUTSIDE SUBSTATION .................................................. 2
4. TYPICAL GROUNDING WHEN INSIDE SUBSTATION....................................... 4
5. TYPICAL GROUNDING WHEN OUTSIDE SUBSTATION ................................... 5
6. GROUND PAD DETAIL .................................................................................. 6
7. TYPICAL MATERIALS ................................................................................... 7
8. RECORD OF REVISIONS ................................................................................ 8
1. General
1.1 The qualified person in charge of the work at the job site shall be responsible for the
compliance with this procedure and shall ensure the mobile substation is properly grounded
before energizing the unit.
1.2 For Mobile Substation installations where the minimum clearance from unguarded live parts,
as specified in the National Grid USA Safety Handbook, to personnel on foot can not be
maintained
1) Barricades (vinyl fencing, barricade tape, signs that indicate overhead energized
conductors etc.), are required.
a) See SMP 499.10.2 - Substation Work Area Identification Procedure.
Printed copies of this document are not document controlled. Refer to the National Grid INFONET,
Substation Services website, for the latest version. Controlled copies are maintained in Documentum.
File SMP499.02.doc
III-206
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 207 of 254
SMP 499.02.2 v1.2
MOBILE SUBSTATION GROUNDING
06/23/2008
2
III-207
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 208 of 254
SMP 499.02.2 v1.2
MOBILE SUBSTATION GROUNDING
06/23/2008
4) Portable, protective ground mats shall be installed under all operating handles and
control cabinets.
a) Bond to the trailer frame or mobile grounding system using at least #2 wire and
connectors approved by their manufacturer for the wire size and the connection type
b) Do not connect portable, protective ground mats directly to the ground rods.
3.2 Grounding To The Station Ground Grid.
1) The mobile must be located within 50 feet of the station ground grid connections.
2) Substation ground grid.
3) At least two points on the trailer shall be bonded to the station ground grid.
a) Route two ground wires back into the substation yard for connection to the station
ground grid.
b) Bond to the trailer frame or mobile grounding system using 4/0 wire and connectors
approved by their manufacturer for 4/0 wire and the connection type.
4) All metal on, or part of, the trailer, except high voltage parts, shall be verified to be
welded or bonded to the trailer frame and have a conductive, high-current path to the
station ground grid.
5) Portable, protective ground mats shall be installed under all operating handles and
control cabinets.
a) Bond to the trailer frame or mobile grounding system using at least 2/0 wire and
connectors approved by their manufacturer for the wire size and the connection type.
b) Do not connect portable, protective ground mats directly to the station ground grid.
6) The trailer should also be tied to transmission counterpoise or distribution feeder ground
using 4/0 wire and connectors approved by their manufacturer for 4/0 wire and the
connection type, if possible.
3.3 Appendix A at the end of this document shows a typical installation.
3.4 Temporary Fence
1) Temporary chain-link fencing at least 7 feet high is required if energized mobile
equipment is located outside the normal substation fence.
a) Bond all posts and gates together with 4/0 wire.
b) Drive ground rods every 20 feet around perimeter and connect to post/gate bond
loop.
c) At least one ground rod should be at the entrance gate.
2) Install "Danger-High Voltage Within-Keep Out" Signs at eye level on:
a) The center of all gates.
b) The unhinged side of single gates 1 foot from gate post.
c) On each side of fence at least every 50 feet.
3
III-208
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 209 of 254
SMP 499.02.2 v1.2
MOBILE SUBSTATION GROUNDING
06/23/2008
4
III-209
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 210 of 254
SMP 499.02.2 v1.2
MOBILE SUBSTATION GROUNDING
06/23/2008
5
III-210
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 211 of 254
SMP 499.02.2 v1.2
MOBILE SUBSTATION GROUNDING
06/23/2008
6
III-211
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 212 of 254
SMP 499.02.2 v1.2
MOBILE SUBSTATION GROUNDING
06/23/2008
7. Typical Materials
Inside Outside Stores
Item #
1 1 2007728 Anderson VHCS
Burndy YA2C
7
III-212
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 213 of 254
SMP 499.02.2 v1.2
MOBILE SUBSTATION GROUNDING
06/23/2008
8. Record of Revisions
Revision Changes
8
III-213
Docket No. DE 19-064
Substation Policies - N Grid
Page 214 of 254
SUBSTATION MAINTENANCE Doc. # SMP 499.06.2
Procedure Page 1 of 4
Substation Underground Power Circuit Version 1.0 – 02/28/11
Locating
INTRODUCTION
This procedure covers the requirements for the identification of underground (UG) power circuits at
National Grid USA owned and operated substations.
PURPOSE
The purpose of this procedure is to define the process for contacting district personnel to assist in the
effort to identify or verify UG power circuits in Substations and may be applicable for other UG facilities
such as control circuits, telephone circuits, or gas lines. The assistance may be providing access to
local documents, drawings, or sketches used to record installed facilities, to provide escort services to
contracted agencies as required, or to assist in the marking or staking of UG facilities for project or
emergency requirements in order to prevent inadvertent operation or damage to substation equipment
from work activities in proximity of underground power circuits, control circuits, telephone circuits, or
gas lines.
ACCOUNTABILITY
This procedure will apply to all National Grid personnel and National Grid contracted personnel that are
required to evaluate, located, and mark substation underground power circuits, control circuits,
telephone circuits, or gas lines.
COORDINATION
Coordination may be required between one or more of the following departments: Substation
Engineering, Telcom Engineering, Gas Engineering, Substation Performance Supervisor, and Damage
Prevention personnel.
REFERENCES
National Grid Employee Safety Handbook
DEFINITIONS
Not Applicable
TRAINING
Not Applicable
DOCUMENT CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1.1 If the substation drawings do not show the routing of underground power circuits operating
at voltages greater than 600V (herein referred to as underground power circuits and the
work foreseen under the project is expected to be in the vicinity of the underground power
circuits, an investigation shall be made to document the existence and location of the
underground power circuits during the preliminary engineering phase of the project. This
investigation shall focus on the project work area and where feasible cover the area within
the substation fence and extend to five feet beyond the substation fence perimeter.
1.2 To facilitate the investigation, the Substation Engineer assigned to the project will send
two sets of full size substation conduit plan drawings to the designated District personnel
with project work areas identified.
1.2.1 At least four weeks turnaround time shall be given for review by the District
personnel.
1.2.2 The review to be undertaken by District personnel shall include comparison of
District records to the plans.
1.2.3 District personnel shall place special emphasis on locating the underground
power circuits in the project work area and ALL underground distribution feeder
getaways within the substation fence.
1.2.4 Any missing or incorrect information on the conduit plans shall be marked up to
scale and returned to the project substation engineer.
a. Red shall be used for additions and green for deletions.
Once the District personnel complete the review and return of the plan drawings to the Substation
Engineer actions shall be taken as follows:
2.1 It shall be the responsibility of Substation Engineering to update all documents reviewed
and returned by District with comments.
2.1.1 This shall be done electronically with the information obtained by the
investigation.
a. This will insure Substation Engineering maintains the most up to date
drawings available.
2.1.2 These updated drawings will be issued as part of the primary drawing package
for the project. If civil foundation drawings are issued in advance, these updated
drawings shall be included as part of the sub-surface electrical drawings
accompanying the civil drawing package.
3.1 It is the responsibility of National Grid construction personnel and/or Contractors to have
all sites inspected by Dig Safe and perform a risk assessment for underground hazards.
3.1.1 This is to ensure actions are in accordance with other corporate standards and
local regulations.
3.2 Upon completion of construction at any location or when making changes actions shall be
taken as follows:
3.2.1 It is the responsibility of the parties involved, whether it is construction or District
personnel, to furnish accurate field changes promptly to Substation Engineering.
a. This will facilitate updates of drawing records to reflect actual ‘As Built’
conditions.
4.1 For substation emergencies that require immediate identification of underground power
circuits or control circuits:
4.1.1 Contact District personnel for coordination of the locating and marking
requirements based on local agreements.
4.1.2 Local District records shall be reviewed and used by local District personnel or
provided to Dig Safe or Damage Prevention personnel for use in underground
facilities investigations and marking requirements.
4.1.3 If local conduit plans are deemed accurate but electronic methods fail to locate
underground power circuits, test holes may be required to locate the exact
location. Follow the Employee Safety Handbook, Electrical Safety-Related Work
Practices, section 1.15.10.
4.1.4 Changes to local District records or drawings shall be marked and forwarded to
Substation Engineering by the person making the changes.
a. Any missing or incorrect information on the conduit plans shall be marked
up to scale.
b. Red shall be used for additions and green for deletions. All field notes shall
be in a color other than red or green.
4.2 Substation Engineering to update all documents returned by District. This will insure
Substation Engineering maintains the most up to date drawings available.
INTRODUCTION
This procedure details the requirements for fall protection that shall be used when employees are
working four feet or more above a lower level in electrical substations.
PURPOSE
Fall protection is required by National Grid USA Safety Rules to protect employees from possible injury,
or death, and by state and federal regulations.
This procedure is designed to ensure employees are trained and knowledgeable in fall protection in
accordance with National Grid USA Safety Rules and OSHA regulations and to recognize fall hazards
associated with substation work activities.
ACCOUNTABILITY
Substation and other Supervisors supervising inspection and maintenance activities.
Substation and other Workers performing inspection and maintenance activities.
COORDINATION
Not Applicable
REFERENCES
National Grid USA Safety Handbook
Code of Federal Regulations 29 CFR 1910.269 Electric Power Generation, Transmission, and
Distribution; Electric Protective Equipment.
Code of Federal Regulations 29 CFR 1926.500 Subpart M – Fall Protection
29 CFR 1926.104
Manufacturer’s Operating and Maintenance manuals for the specific fall protection equipment to be
used.
DEFINITIONS
Attachment Point - A secure point to fasten lifelines, lanyards, or deceleration devices
on a harness or climbing belt
Anchorage Point - A secure point of attachment for lifelines, lanyards, or deceleration
devices
Climbing Belt (Safety Strap) - A belt with two D Rings designed to secure the employee about
the waist. Climbing belts are not acceptable or to be used as part
of a personal fall arrest system. Single D Ring climbing belts are
not allowed.
Body Harness - Straps which may be secured about the employee in a manner
that will distribute the fall arrest forces over at least the thighs,
Step bolt - A bolt or rung attached at intervals along a structural member and
used for foot placement during climbing or standing. Step bolts
may also be called "pole steps."
Step ladder - A self-supporting portable ladder, non- adjustable in length, with
flat steps and a hinged back.
Substation Structure - An assembly of steel/wood poles or fabricated steel designed and
constructed to support substation electrical components,
conductors, and hardware.
Toe board - A low protective barrier placed to prevent the fall of materials to a
lower level, or when used without a guardrail, to prevent an
employee's feet from slipping over the edge of a surface.
Unprotected sides and edges - Any side or edge of a surface, except at entrances to points of
access, where there is no wall or guardrail system.
Wall Opening - An opening at least 30 inches high and 18 inches wide, in any wall
or partition, through which persons may fall.
Walking and working surface - Any surface, within the scope of this standard, on which
employees perform or gain access to their job duties or upon
which employees are required or allowed to walk or work while
performing assigned tasks.
Work Positioning - A work method used with equipment designed to position the user
at an elevated work site in order that he/she may have free use of
both hands not intended to arrest a fall unless also equipped for
fall arrest.
TRAINING
Initial training is required for all employees that may perform work in substations that requires fall
protection (more than four feet above a lower level).
If in the performance of the annual work, an employee has not used Fall Protection equipment, they
must have refresher training before the application and use of fall protection systems.
Refresher training is required if a specific fall protection system has not been used within the last 12
months by the employee. Refresher training on the specific equipment shall be conducted prior to the
use.
DOCUMENT CONTENTS
Table of Contents
18.0 VAULTS/NETWORKS.............................................................................................................. 17
1.1 Fall Protection must be used when fall hazards have been identified in performing
substation related work unless deemed infeasible.
1.1.1 Infeasible means that it is impossible to perform the construction work using a
conventional fall protection system (i.e., guardrail system, safety net system, or
personal fall arrest system) or that it is technologically impossible to use any one
of these systems to provide fall protection.
1.1.2 The appropriate management representative and the lead person shall be
involved in this determination. The determination shall be documented on the Job
Brief form.
1.1.3 The determination shall be documented by the appropriate management
representative using the Hazardous Condition reporting process and shall be
communicated to all Substation Managers, Substation Construction & Services,
and Substation O&M Services.
2.0 SAFETY
3.1 Fall protection or fall arrest systems shall be utilized by employees working in substations:
3.1.1 When working in an elevated position more than four feet above the ground or a
lower level.
3.1.2 While working on a walking/working surface with an unprotected edge which is
four feet or more above a lower level.
3.2 Fall protection may by accomplished by the use of a guardrail system, a fall restraint
system, or fall arrest system.
4.1 Only approved materials, equipment, and systems, including anchorage connectors, shall
be used in fall protection applications.
4.1.1 These can be found in the Distribution Engineering Services Web Page for
Approved Tool and Equipment Catalog.
a. Infonetus - Engineering an Asset Management - Distribution Engineering
Services -Tools Catalog
4.1.2 Only approved fall protection equipment shall be used and shall not be modified.
5.1 Any exceptions to or deviations from this procedure will require the approval of the
Manager of the Substation Department involved or their designees.
6.1 A full body harness provides the greatest protection during a fall.
6.2 Climbing belts are not acceptable or to be used as part of a personal fall arrest system.
6.3 Acceptable systems to arrest an employee in a fall form a working level include a full body
harness with suitable combinations of:
a) Anchorage points b) Drop Line
c) Connector d) Deceleration Device
e) Lanyard f) Rope Grab
g) Life Line h) Retractable Life Line
7.1 Store harness and other fall protection equipment in a clean dry area away from direct
sunlight and allow to air dry if exposed to water.
8.1 All fall protection equipment shall be inspected prior to each use.
8.1.1 A fall protection harness must be properly selected, fitted and adjusted for the
specific user.
a. The preferred attachment point when using fall arrest systems with a
harness shall be the rear centered attachment point.
8.1.2 Webbing and Straps, including Shock Absorbing Lanyards, shall be inspected
for:
a) Cuts b) Chemicals
c) Kinks d) Distortion
e) Abrasions f) Excessive Wear
g) Burns h) Loose, cut, missing stitching
8.2 Buckles, D-Rings, Snap Hooks and Other Hardware Shock Absorbing Lanyards
8.2.1 Cracks
8.2.2 Corroded or nicked areas
8.2.3 Distortion
8.3 Snap Hooks
8.3.1 Snap Hooks shall be the locking type with a self-closing, self-locking keeper
which remains closed and locked until unlocked and pressed open for connection
or disconnection.
8.3.2 Never attach a lanyard back to itself unless specifically allowed by the
manufacturer.
8.3.3 Snap Hooks may not be attached to each other.
8.3.4 Never attach multiple lanyards together.
8.4 Self Retracting Lanyards shall be inspected for:
8.4.1 Proper operation of the locking mechanism.
8.4.2 Physical damage.
8.4.3 Condition of lanyard and attaching devices
8.5 Anchorage Points
8.5.1 When used as part of a fall arrest system, the anchorage point must be capable
to withstand a force of 5000 pounds per attached employee and must be
independent of any anchorage used to support or suspend platforms.
a. See recommended attachment / anchorage points in Appendix C.
8.5.2 Climbing on bushings or insulators or their use as an anchor point for a fall arrest
system is not permitted.
8.5.3 The use of bushings on transformers for work positioning is not allowed.
9.1 Any fall protection equipment that has arrested a fall or sustained damage shall be
removed from service and tagged “Defective - Do Not Use” and nature of defect indicated
on the DNU Tag.
9.2 Fall protection equipment shall only be repaired by the original manufacturer or a vendor
approved by the National Grid USA.
9.3 Fall protection equipment may be returned to service after recertification by the original
manufacturer or facility approved by original manufacturer.
b. The hook can be installed using a Live Line Tool. The hook and other fall
arrest components shall not violate minimum approach distances of any
live conductors.
10.7.4 Self Retracting System
a. The preferred method for attachment of the Self Retracting System is to
anchor the device at shoulder level or above.
b. When used for fall protection Eye Bolts or lifting eyes on the cover of a
transformer or lifting eyes of bushings may serve as an anchorage point for
a fall protection system until the fall arrest system is installed. The
retracting assembly of the self-retracting lanyard is attached to the eyebolt
or lifting eyes while the other end is attached to the harness. All self-
retracting systems must meet ANSI standard Z359.1.
10.8 Eye Bolt / Lifting Eyes
10.8.1 All of these may serve as an anchorage point for fall restraint or until fall arrest
systems are installed.
10.8.2 Only approved eye bolts or manufactured devices specifically designed for fall
protection shall be used for an anchorage point.
10.9 Manufactured Devices
10.9.1 Only approved manufactured devices specifically designed for fall protection
shall be installed for use as part of a fall protection system.
a. Approved devices such as eye bolts, flange, or step bolts shall be installed
to provide a suitable anchorage point.
10.10 Portable Mounting Base
10.10.1 Designed to be mounted on a manhole cover for the installation of the portable
fall arrest pole assembly.
a. This system is composed of slotted leg extensions mounted to the standard
mounting plate for use with the portable fall arrest pole. The movable leg
extensions are secured on transformer manhole covers by the use of four
(4) manhole cover bolts.
b. This system is normally used with older transformers that do not have
permanently installed mounting plates or guard rail systems.
10.11 Safety Nets
10.11.1 Safety nets are not used at National Grid substation applications.
11.0 TRANSFORMERS
The following work methods are approved for working on circuit breakers.
12.1 Properly secured ladders
12.1.1 See following section on ladders.
12.2 Aerial Lifts, Bucket Trucks
12.2.1 See following section on aerial lifts.
12.3 Adjustable Circuit Breaker Fall Protection Tower
12.3.1 Preferred fall protection system when working on top of typical transmission oil
circuit breakers.
12.3.2 Mounts on a portable base plate that is installed on the circuit breaker main
support beam or a mounting plate permanently anchored to the circuit breaker
foundation.
12.3.3 Uses a retractable lanyard to the tower anchor ring
12.3.4 A second portable fall arrest tower may need to be installed when working on top
of multiple phase tanks.
12.3.5 Employees must be attached to a fall arrest system at all times when working on,
or traversing the top of the circuit breaker from one work position to another.
12.4 Horizontal life line with structure to structure attachment points
12.5 The use of bushings on circuit breakers for work positioning or fall arrest is not allowed.
13.1 Free climbing a substation structure is not allowed. The following work methods are
approved for climbing substation structures.
13.2 Vertical life line
13.3 Dual Climbing Lanyards
13.4 Buck Hook or Sheppard’s Hook
13.5 Substation structures may be used as an anchorage point for a personal fall arrest
system.
13.5.1 Several hook devices are available that can be secured to substation structure
above a transformer, circuit breaker or other substation apparatus.
a. Hook devices may be installed using a Live Line Tool. The hook and other
fall arrest component shall not violate minimum approach distances of any
energized conductors.
b. The hook device must be used in conjunction with a self-retracting lanyard.
13.5.2 Refer to appendix C for anchorage points on substation structures.
14.0 LADDERS
or
14.5.3 Ladder spur feet are dug into mud, snow or ice;
or
14.5.4 The ladder base is supported by a fixed barrier (i.e. curb or structure).
14.6 Working from ladders does not require the use of a fall arrest system.
14.7 When using a properly secured extension ladder, an employee that is belted in with a
safety strap may step off the extension ladder to attach a fall restraint or fall arrest system.
14.7.1 The safety strap shall encompass a ladder rung and one side rail at a minimum.
If additional stability is desirable, the safety strap may be placed around both side
rails if it is also placed around a rung to prevent falling.
14.7.2 This method of work positioning shall prevent the worker from a fall to no more
than two (2) feet.
14.8 Portable ladders used to access to an upper landing surface must extend a minimum of
three (3) feet above the landing surface, or where not practical, be provided with grab rails
and be secured against movement while in use.
14.9 When performing work from a straight or extension ladder, the worker shall assume a
position no higher than the fourth rung from the top.
14.10 After an extension ladder has been raised:
14.10.1 Check to make certain that hooks are fully engaged.
14.10.2 Tie the lift rope securely to one or more rungs of lower section.
14.11 When additional stability is desirable, the safety strap may be placed around both side
rails if it is also placed around a rung to prevent falling. If work from an extension ladder
required the use of two hands to be free, employees shall use a work positioning belt and
safety strap properly attached to the secured ladder.
14.12 Step ladders shall be fully open with braces locked before anyone uses them.
14.12.1 Climb on the side of the step ladder designed for climbing.
14.12.2 The worker shall face the ladder when climbing.
14.12.3 Follow the manufacturer’s safety guidelines.
14.12.4 Straddling or sitting on the top of the step ladder is prohibited.
15.1 Follow appropriate sections of the Safety Handbook when using aerial lifts in substations.
15.2 Fall protection (harness/lanyard) is required when using aerial lifts.
15.2.1 Not required when entering or exiting a bucket in the cradled position.
15.3 Employees may exit elevated work platforms to access the work area provided that fall
protection such as guardrails or a fall arrest system are used while the worker moves
between the lift and the working surface.
15.3.1 Before any such transfer is made, the employee shall be properly tied off to an
adequate support, the pole or structure prior to and in the direction of the
transfer.
15.4 Aerial lifts must be properly grounded.
15.5 Scissors lifts without an approved permanently affixed attachment point are exempt from
wearing harnesses and attachments.
16.1 Roofs
16.1.1 Work on roofs may be conducted with a safety monitor or the installation of
warning lines or a rail systems meeting specific requirements.
a. Top Rail:
Rope, wire, chain, or wood planks shall be installed at a minimum of forty
two (42) inches above the working surface (+ 3” allowance) and supported
so that the lowest point (sag) is no more than thirty nine (39) inches from
the walking/working surface. The support stanchions must be capable of
resisting force without tipping over.
Rope, wire, or chain warning lines shall be flagged no more than six (6 )
foot intervals with high visibility material.
b. Mid Rail:
Required if there is no wall or parapet wall at least twenty one (21) inches
high.
16.1.2 When mechanical equipment is not being used, warning lines shall be erected
around all sides of the work area not less than six (6) feet from the work edge.
16.1.3 When mechanical equipment is being used, warning lines shall be erected not
less than six (6) feet from the roof edge which is parallel to the direction of the
mechanical equipment in operation.
17.1 Climbing or working on communication structures or towers shall require the use of fall
protection similar to those used on substation structures.
18.0 VAULTS/NETWORKS
18.1 Entering vaults is normally performed by the use of permanently mounted steel ladders
and fall protection is not required.
19.1 Fall protection is not required when working on top of tanker vehicles.
19.2 Fall protection is not required when working on the bed of a tractor trailer rig to install or
remove rigging used in transportation activities.
19.2.1 When it is necessary to perform work activities on top of the load, Fall Protection
methods must be used.
19.3 Fall protection shall be used for work activities on top of Mobile Substations.
20.1 Questions and/or clarification regarding this document and proposed changes under the
Exception Approval section of this document shall be forwarded to the Manager of
Substation Engineering & Maintenance Standards.
21.0 RESPONSIBILITIES
22.1 Note: in mounting the SB-SM1, no more than two (2) legs shall point in a single direction.
22.2 Lock onto the man way without disturbing the integrity of the seal.
22.3 Should be used on closed Man ways.
22.4 May be used on round or square man ways.
22.5 May be used on man way sizes from sixteen (16) inches to thirty six (36) inches.
22.6 May be used on a variety of bolt patterns and sizes.
INTRODUCTION
The following document contains rules pertaining to personal protective equipment (PPE) for substation
entry and work requirements. These rules were developed to ensure employee safety and regulatory
compliance and to provide some clarification and consistency for the variety of workers and visitors who
enter indoor or outdoor substations.
PURPOSE
The purpose of this document will identify the minimum PPE required when entering substations or
when performing work activities that expose employees to hazards of electric arcs or flames.
ACCOUNTABILITY
All personnel entering substations or working on or near exposed energized circuits or equipment.
All personnel responsible for implementing the requirements specified in this document.
COORDINATION
Not Applicable
REFERENCES
National Grid Arc Flash Analysis and Mitigation Safety Procedure
National Electrical Safety Code (NESC)
National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 70E Standard
National Grid Employee Safety Handbook
Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) 1910.269
SMP 400.14.2 - Substation Security
ASTM F2413 - Foot Protection
ANSI Z87.1 - Safety Glasses
DEFINITIONS
Arc flash hazard - A dangerous condition associated with the release of thermal
energy caused by an electric arc.
Arc rating - Incident energy on a material or a multilayer system of materials
that results in a 50% probability that sufficient heat transfer through
the tested specimen is predicted to cause the onset of a second-
degree skin burn injury, cal/cm2. Arc ratings are defined as Arc
Thermal Performance Values (ATPVs) or Energy Before
Breakthrough (EBT) and are expressed in cal/cm².
Boundary Distance - The calculated distance in inches that must be observed when
working on or near energized lines or equipment to not exceed the 8
cal/cm2 PPE arc rating. Boundary distance calculated to be less
then the minimum approach distance (below MAD), the proper
working distance must be observed for the appropriate voltage
being worked on.
Designated Work Area - A boundary established through the use of tape barricade, flags,
and other approved barriers within a substation to provide physical
obstruction and to prevent contact with energized lines or
equipment.
Flame Resistant (FR) - The property of a material whereby flaming combustion is
prevented, terminated, or inhibited following application of a flaming
or non-flaming source of ignition, with or without subsequent
removal of the ignition source.
Hazard Risk Category (HRC) - Classification for specifying personal protective equipment. HRC
level is determined by the minimum amount of calories per square
centimeter (ATPV or cal/cm2) a treated garment must pass through
with a 50% probability of a 2nd or 3rd degree burn occurring, thus
the protective level of the treated clothing. The higher the ATPV, the
higher the HRC level attained, the greater the protection.
Incident energy - The amount of energy impressed on a surface, a certain distance
from the source, generated during an electrical arc event. Incident
energy is measured in calories per centimeter squared (cal/cm2).
Personal Protective Equipment - PPE includes hard hat, sturdy work shoe or boot, safety glasses,
and other specialized equipment required for tasks where unique
hazards have been identified per section 1.31 of the National Grid
Employee Safety Handbook.
Qualified Person - A person knowledgeable in the construction and operation of
electric power generation, transmission, substation, and/or
distribution apparatus involved along with the associated hazards in
specific duties pertaining to electric operations.
Switching Ensemble - Includes arc flash coat, bib overall, arc flash hood, Class 2 Rubber
Gloves, EH rated safety foot protection.
Visitor - Persons who do not work in substations normally as part of their job.
TRAINING
Initial - New employee orientation and when new FR clothing requirements are introduced.
DOCUMENT CONTENTS
Table of Contents
1.1 Company approved Flame Resistant (FR) clothing shall be worn when employees control,
operate, or work on energized equipment or circuits and when distance and position will
expose the employee to electric arc or flame hazards.
1.2 For legacy National Grid (Upstate NY, New England) substations worker, the standard FR
clothing shall meet a minimum arc rating of 8 cal/cm² (HRC 2). Additional FR clothing
protection (above HRC 2) is required when performing identified tasks at legacy National
Grid substations.
1.3 Garments worn as outer layers over FR clothing, such as jackets or rainwear, shall also be
made from FR material. Note: These FR garments may be rated less than 8 cal/cm² as
long as an 8 cal/cm² garment is worn underneath.
1.4 The standard arc flash rated switching ensemble shall consist of an arc-rated FR coat, bib
overall, and hood specifically rated for the work to be performed. Refer to Appendix A and
B for Upstate NY and NE substation lists.
1.5 Contractors who may be involved with tasks requiring the implementation of this program
shall be informed by National Grid. Contractors will be required to follow all aspects of
OSHA and The National Electrical Safety Code (NESC), Rule 410 A3 as it applies to the
tasks they perform.
1.6 All persons shall wear the required level of FR clothing when entering a designated work
area where work is being performed on or near energized circuits or equipment.
1.7 Supervisors may require the use of additional flash protection if they determine that the
task being performed warrants it.
1.8 If the clothing creates additional and greater hazards than the possible exposure to the
heat energy of the electric arc, then clothing with an arc rating less than that required can
be worn. [NESC 410 (A) (3) Exception 1]
1.8.1 For identified cases at National Grid, agreement and approval is required by
concurrence of the manager of the operating department involved, and the
Director of Safety (or their designees). If concurrence cannot be achieved
among these parties, they will seek concurrence at the next higher level of
management. The determination shall be documented on the Job Brief form.
3.1 Qualified workers performing substation work activities as part of their routine tasks.
3.2 Employees performing physical work in substation yards are expected to wear the
following:
3.2.1 Protective footwear - Work shoe that meets ASTM F2413 standard for impact
and compression and EH rated (section 1.31 Employee Safety hand book).
3.2.2 Hard Hat (section 1.31 Employee Safety hand book).
3.2.3 Safety Glasses with side shields (section 1.31 Employee Safety hand book).
3.3 Where exposure exists to the hazards of electric arc flash, Flame Resistant clothing shall
be worn.
3.3.1 This clothing shall be in accordance with arc flash analysis.
3.4 Employees shall not wear clothing which will contribute to burn injuries. Only clothing
made from natural fibers shall be worn.
3.4.1 Prohibited clothing in substations includes Acetate, Nylon, Rayon, and Polyester.
3.4.2 These fibers such as acetate, nylon, polyester, polypropylene, and spandex are
not permitted to be worn. These materials melt as a result of arc flash exposure,
form contact with the skin and aggravate the burn injury.
3.4.3 Non-melting, flammable materials (i.e. untreated cotton, wool, or silk, or blends of
these materials) are not arc rated. These garments are permitted to be worn but
do not contribute to the arc rating of the required FR clothing system.
3.5 All protective footwear shall comply with ASTM F2413 - Foot Protection by having the
following:
3.5.1 An impact rating of 75
3.5.2 A compression rating of 75
3.5.3 An electrical hazard (EH) rating
3.6 Appropriate rubber gloves shall be used where required in accordance with section 2 of
the National Grid Employee Safety Handbook.
3.7 Fall protection is required where a fall of four feet or more, to or onto a lower level is
possible.
3.7.1 Fall protection will be in accordance with SMP 499.20.2 - Fall Protection
3.7.2 Only approved FR rated fall protection harnesses shall be used.
3.8 Substations workers must determine if the substation has been posted with the
appropriate signage to ascertain if additional flash protection is required. Substations that
have been identified to have incident energy above 8 cal/cm2 through the arc flash
analysis are to be posted with the proper signage. Employees are to ensure proper arc
flash rated FR clothing is used at those posted substation locations.
3.9 Personal protective equipment appropriate to the fault energy shall be worn when working,
switching, testing energized or de-energized, grounding, or performing other work
activities as described in this procedure.
3.10 Flame Resistant clothing is the minimum requirement for flash protection when operating,
or working on or near, exposed energized primary circuits or equipment.
3.11 All persons shall wear the required level of FR clothing when entering a designated work
area where work is being performed on or near energized circuits or equipment.
Hazard/Risk
Required Minimum Arc
Category Substation Protective Clothing Systems
Rating of PPE (cal/cm2)
(HRC)
Non-melting, flammable materials (i.e., untreated cotton,
Not for Substation
0 wool, rayon, or silk, or blends of these materials) with a
Application
fabric weight at least 4.5 oz/yd2.
FR Clothing (4 cal)
4 cal Arc-rated FR shirt and 4 cal FR pants Not for Substation
1
or Application
4 cal FR coverall
Hazard/Risk
Required Minimum Arc
Category Substation Protective Clothing Systems
Rating of PPE (cal/cm2)
(HRC)
STANDARD ISSUE (8 cal)
8 cal Arc-rated FR shirt and 8 cal FR pants
2 8
or
8 cal FR coverall
ELECTRICAL FLASH ENSEMBLE (20/31* cal)
8 cal Arc-rated FR shirt and 8 cal FR pants and
20/31* cal ensemble (Hood, Switching Coat, Bib Overall)
3 25
or
8 cal FR coverall and 20/31* cal ensemble
(Hood, Switching Jacket, Bib Overall)
ELECTRICAL FLASH ENSEMBLE (40/55* cal)
8 cal Arc-rated FR shirt and 8 cal FR pants and
40/55* cal ensemble (Hood, Switching Coat, Bib Overall)
4 40
or
8 cal FR coverall and 40/55* cal ensemble
(Hood, Switching Coat, Bib Overall)
*The 20 cal/cm² arc-rated ensembles are available for Upstate NY stations and the 31 cal/cm² and 55
cal/cm² arc-rated ensembles are available for New England stations. The 20 cal/cm² arc-rated
ensembles are acceptable for HRC 3 in Upstate NY based on the calculated incident energy data. The
31 cal/cm² arc-rated ensembles are acceptable for HRC 4 in New England based on the calculated
incident energy data. Where the incident energy is listed in New England above 31cal/cm², the 55
cal/cm² arc-rated ensembles must be used.
5.1 For any work activity that currently requires rubber gloves or rubber gloves and sleeves,
FR clothing shall be worn.
5.2 Employees shall wear the standard 8 cal/cm2 FR clothing when working on or near
substation energized circuits or equipment.
5.2.1 NESC includes an exception for secondary systems. For systems below 1000 V,
in lieu of performing an arc hazard analysis, clothing or a clothing system with a
minimum effective arc rating of 4 cal/cm² shall be required to limit the likelihood
of ignition. Minimum standard for substation worker for Upstate NY and NE is 8
cal/cm².
5.3 The appropriate rated arc flash switching ensembles and standard 8 cal/cm2 FR clothing
shall be worn when performing specific work activities in substations identified of having
an incident energy exposure of higher than 8 cal/cm2.
5.3.1 Specific substations are listed in Appendix A for New York North and Appendix B
for New England.
5.4 When performing the following work activities within the arc boundary distance as depicted
in the enclosed tables, the appropriate rated switching ensembles shall be worn for:
5.4.1 Breaker Operations (Metalclad doors open/closed).
5.4.2 Breaker racking operations (in or out).
5.4.3 Operating unguarded (electrically exposed) primary disconnects (Gang, Single
Blade, or fused).
5.4.4 Operating unguarded (electrically exposed) grounding switches.
5.4.5 Operation of Primary Fuses – Metalclad (remove/install).
5.4.6 Removal of Bolted or Hinged Covers of primary compartments to Expose Live
Parts.
5.4.7 Testing live parts de-energized or energized with contact type high voltage
testers.
5.4.8 Application and Removal of Personal Protective Grounds using insulated live line
tools.
7.1 As substations modifications are engineered, the validation of incident energy for the
substation shall be conducted. Substation Engineering & Maintenance Standards shall:
7.1.1 Request a formal analysis by Protection Engineering to validate the incident
energy calculations for the proposed substation changes.
7.1.2 Update the substation lists in Appendix A or B accordingly to add, remove, or
modify the incident energy calculations, boundary, and hazard risk category
(HRC).
7.1.3 Update SMP499.30.2, develop training materials, and roll out changes to
applicable departments.
7.1.4 Ensure substation signs are installed or removed based on the incident energy
analysis.
7.1.5 Notify Corporate Safety of analysis results for required changes to the Arc Flash
Analysis and Mitigation Safety Procedure.
2 Hazard
Incident 8 cal/cm
Voltage Risk
Substations - UNY Energy Boundary Mitigation Comments
(kV) 2 Category
(cal/cm ) (in)
(HRC)
2 Hazard
Incident 8 cal/cm
Voltage Risk
Substations - UNY Energy Boundary Mitigation Comments
(kV) 2 Category
(cal/cm ) (in)
(HRC)
Hanson Aggregate -
Middleville 4.16 8.4 26 3
Hill Street Station 311 4.16 11.6 30 3
Johnson Road Station 352 13.2 10.1 33 3
Liberty Street 94 4.16 14.6 48 3
Menands Station 101 4.16 11.6 38 3
Mill Street Station 748 4.8 13.7 45 3
New Krumkill Station 421 4.16 8.7 28 3
Oakwood Ave 232 13.2 11.0 36 3
Renaissance Drive 229 13.2 14.7 49 3
Riverside Station 288 13.2 16.8 56 3
Station 140 13.2 13.1 43 3
Station 21 4.16 8.7 29 3
Station 212 13.2 8.7 28 3
Station 214 4.16 10.8 35 3
Station 22 4.16 8.9 29 3
Station 25 4.16 18.2 59 3
Station 27 4.16 14.1 47 3
Station 30 4.16 16.4 55 3
Station 31 4.16 14.6 48 3
Station 32 4.16 18.3 59 3
Station 33 4.16 9.2 27 3
Station 34 4.16 9.6 31 3
Station 35 4.16 18.5 60 3
Station 37 4.16 17.1 55 3
Station 38 4.16 17.8 58 3
Station 39 4.16 16.5 55 3
Station 40 4.16 14.0 46 3
Station 41 4.16 10.7 35 3
Station 42 4.16 8.3 27 3
Station 44 4.16 9.5 31 3
Station 45 4.16 9.4 31 3
Station 48 4.16 14.7 49 3
Station 49 4.16 9.9 32 3
Station 50 4.16 16.9 55 3
2
Station 51 4.16 21.6 71 3 16 cal/cm - Open R101;
R201, R301 or R401 before
performing switching in
Substation.
2 Hazard
Incident 8 cal/cm
Voltage Risk
Substations - UNY Energy Boundary Mitigation Comments
(kV) 2 Category
(cal/cm ) (in)
(HRC)
2 Hazard
Incident 8 cal/cm
Voltage Risk
Substations - NE Energy Boundary Mitigation Comments
(kV) 2 Category
(cal/cm ) (in)
(HRC)
2
27 cal/cm - One (1) transformer in
Dyer Street 2 4.16 50.5 173 4 operation during switching
2
34 cal/cm - Two (2) transformers in
Faraday Street 11 4.16 43.1 147 4 parallel during switching
Franklin Square 11 11.5 35.9 122 4
2
17 cal/cm - One (1) transformer in
Glendale 6 4.16 33.8 114 4 service during switching
2
28 cal/cm - Two (2) transformers in
Grafton Street 9 4.16 34.3 115 4 parallel operation
Harris Ave 12 4.16 26.6 89 4
Harris Ave 12 11.5 29.3 72 4
2
23 cal/cm - One (1) transformer in
Lawrence 1 4.16 37.1 124 4 service during switching
2
20 cal/cm - One (1) transformer in
Lynn 21 4.16 40.5 138 4 service during switching
2
22 cal/cm - One (1) transformer in
Malden 5 4.16 46.6 145 4 service during switching
2
Maplewood 16 4.16 36.6 73 4 23 cal/cm - All Tie Breakers are
open during switching
2
25 cal/cm - One (1) transformer in
Melrose 4 4.16 45.9 157 4 service during switching
2
17 cal/cm - One (1) transformer in
Olneyville 6 4.16 30.6 103 4 service during switching
2 Hazard
Incident 8 cal/cm
Voltage Risk
Substations - NE Energy Boundary Mitigation Comments
(kV) 2 Category
(cal/cm ) (in)
(HRC)
Pawtucket 1 107 B71 13.8 26.1 88 4
2
35 cal/cm - All Tie Breakers are
Revere Beach 35 4.16 45.6 116 4 open during switching
2
24 cal/cm - All Tie Breakers are
Sprague Street 36 4.16 32.3 107 4 open during switching
2
34 cal/cm - Open CB140 or CB240
Thorndike 10 4.16 60.1 203 4 during switching
Walnut Street 32 4.16 26.1 88 4
Water Street 31 4.16 25.5 82 4
2
16 cal/cm - Bus fed by TR5, TR2 on
Admiral Street 9 4.16 23.2 78 3 standby
Admiral Street 9 11.5 15.7 36 3
Beverly 12 4.16 14.2 34 3
2
11 cal/cm - One (1) transformer in
Blossom 5 4.16 20.9 70 3 operation during switching
Bridge 6 4.16 10.8 36 3
Dupont 91 13.8 12.8 42 3
East Bridgewater 797 13.8 12.4 41 3
Elmwood 7 23 9.9 32 3
2
13 cal/cm - One (1) Transformer in
Field Street 1 4.16 23.5 79 3 service during switching
Kent Corner 47 4.16 16.5 36 3
Kent County 22 34.5 8.8 54 3
Lawrence 1 B1 13.8 13.1 42 3
Lawrence 1 B2 13.8 12.3 41 3
Lawrence 2 13.8 14.1 44 3
Lawrence Street 53 13.8 9.6 31 3
Lynn 21 13.8 23.5 79 3
Manchester 23 2.4 15.0 50 3
Medford 9 4.16 14.1 47 3
Norman Street 8 23 17.5 58 3
North Quincy 11 13.8 13.5 45 3
Olneyville 6 11.5 10.2 33 3
Pawtucket 1 107 B74 13.8 20.9 71 3
Pawtucket 2 148 4.16 17.3 58 3
Pawtucket 2 148 13.8 17.3 64 3
Perry Street 3 13.2 12.7 42 3
Pine Banks 67 4.16 15.6 52 3
Riverside 8 13.8 11.4 38 3
Rochambeau 37 4.16 16.7 55 3
Salem 1 Peabody
Street 4.16 12.7 40 3
2 Hazard
Incident 8 cal/cm
Voltage Risk
Substations - NE Energy Boundary Mitigation Comments
(kV) 2 Category
(cal/cm ) (in)
(HRC)
Swansea 11 13.8 10.6 35 3
Union Street 348 13.8 8.6 28 3
Walnut 11 4.16 10.3 34 3
Webster 6 4.16 19.7 66 3
West Howard 154 4.16 12.3 40 3
Wilbraham 507 13.8 10.9 36 3
Winthrop 22 4.16 10.6 29 3
2.0 12/06/11 Changed Originating Department “Substation O&M Services” to “Substation Work Methods”
Changed Sponsor “Donald T. Angell” to “Susan Fleck”
Section 2.0 - Completely re-written to coincide with current practices
Section 3.2.1 - Changed “Protective footwear” to “Protective footwear - Work shoe that meets
ASTM F2413 standard for impact and compression and EH rated (section 1.31 Employee Safety
hand book).”
Section 3.2.2 - Changed “Hard Hat” to “Hard Hat (section 1.31 Employee Safety hand book).”
Section 3.2.3 - Changed “Safety Glasses” to “Safety Glasses with side shields (section 1.31
Employee Safety hand book).”
Section 8.0 - Changed Title “APPENDIX A - UPSTATE NEW YORK SUBSTATION LIST” to
““APPENDIX A - UPSTATE NEW YORK SUBSTATION HRC LIST”
Section 8.0 - Replaced Table
Section 9.0 - Changed Title “APPENDIX B - NEW ENGLAND SUBSTATION LIST” to ““APPENDIX
B - NEW ENGLAND SUBSTATION HRC LIST”
Section 9.0 - Replaced Table