Workbook Answers: AS/A-level English Literature Workbook
Workbook Answers: AS/A-level English Literature Workbook
Workbook Answers: AS/A-level English Literature Workbook
AS/A-level English
Literature Workbook:
King Lear
This Answers document provides suggestions for some of the possible answers that might be
given for the questions asked in the Workbook. They are not exhaustive and other answers
may be acceptable, but they are intended as a guide to give teachers and students feedback.
Chapter 1
Plot and dramatic structure
Plot
1 (a) ‘Nothing, my lord’
(d) Oswald
(h) Edgar
(i) Britain
(k) Suicide
(m) Lear.
Dramatic structure
1
Event Act
A Cordelia sends her soldiers to search for Lear. 4
B Gloucester is blinded. 3
C Edmund persuades Gloucester that Edgar wishes his father was dead. 1
D Edgar gives Albany the letter revealing Edmund and Goneril’s plot 5
against his life.
E Kent argues with Oswald and challenges him to a fight. 2
F Lear meets Poor Tom on the heath. 3
G Lear and Cordelia are reunited and reconciled. 4
H Edgar challenges Edmund and defeats him 5
2 (a)
o Goneril wants to marry Edmund and conspires to kill Albany and later poisons
Regan
o Edmund issues the warrant for the murder of Lear and Cordelia
(c) Answers to 2(b) make it clear that the subplot plays an essential part in the main plot:
characters and events from each ‘plot’ intersect. Also, the audience can see that what
happens to Lear is not unique, because similarly dreadful things happen to Gloucester.
The subplot therefore helps the play explore the darker forces that afflict our common
humanity. Concerns such as blindness/sight (Lear’s moral blindness has a concrete
parallel in the literal blinding of Gloucester), and family and ‘natural’ bonds are also
explored in both plots.
o Lear and Goneril’s bitter quarrel over the conduct of Lear’s retainers in Act 1
AS/A-Level Literature Workbooks: King Lear 4
o Regan and Goneril’s insistence that Lear reduces further his number of knights
o Lear’s death.
(c) Regan sides with Goneril and therefore further infuriates and disappoints Lear. Regan
initially commands Lear to return to Goneril. Both sisters then proceed to tell Lear that he
should not have any knights at all.
(e) Lear begins the passage naively hoping Regan will sympathise with him and agree to
let him stay with her. Regan later angers Lear by refusing to allow Lear to stay and by
siding with her sister. Regan’s stance effectively means Lear is without a home and has
lost the familial ‘bond’ with all three of his daughters.
Chapter 2
Themes
1 Answers will vary, although readers may struggle to justify science, education and the
supernatural as significant themes in the play.
4 Simile: D
Command: A
Animal imagery: E
6 Kent is trying to warn the king that he is behaving foolishly and has failed to see the truth
about his three daughters. The Fool is also criticising Lear for the consequences of his
blindness and predicts Lear’s exile in the storm, overwhelmed by dark thoughts. The Fool
is perhaps also suggesting that the consequences of Lear’s folly are exacerbated by his
status as a king – ‘we’ suggests, perhaps, his loyal subjects.
• A potent visual symbol of the cruelty and violence of the world of the play
8 There is a tragic pity in seeing Gloucester and Lear – two betrayed and fallen fathers –
trying to make sense of their lives. They now see ‘how the world goes’ and seen the errors
of their actions. Perhaps more specifically for this scene, Lear and Gloucester also see the
superficial nature of authority and the inherent corruption and injustice of power.
9
AS/A-Level Literature Workbooks: King Lear 6
10
11 Lear’s time spent in the storm seems to accelerate his decline – the storm ‘invades’ Lear.
The thought of his daughters casting him out in the storm also seems to be tipping Lear
into madness – ‘In such a night / To shut me out? … O, Regan, Goneril, / Your old, kind
father, whose frank heart have you all – / O, that way madness lies.’ However, the storm
has a symbolic function as well – the dramatic natural upheaval is a visual, dramatic
representation Lear’s internal trauma.
13
14 (a)
• 4.6 After Gloucester’s ‘suicide’ attempt, Edgar changes his identity to convince
Gloucester he really did fall off a cliff
• 4.6 Edgar also says to Gloucester that figure with him on the top of the cliff was a
monstrous ‘fiend’
• 4.6 Edgar puts on another accent so that Oswald would not recognise him; he then
kills Oswald to protect his father
• 5.1 Edgar appears in disguise at the enemy camp and gives Albany the incriminating
letter about Edmund and Goneril
• 5.3 Edgar appears ‘armed’ in another disguise; Edmund does not recognise him but
sees that he has good ‘breeding’
• 5.3 Edgar finally appears as ‘himself’, probably by removing a part of his disguise (a
mask or a helmet, usually).
(b) Caius:
Poor Tom:
o Tom guides Gloucester, the blinded aristocrat who needs the commoner to help
him to ‘see’.
(c) Through skilful manipulation and masterful control of language, he fools his father into
thinking his brother wants to kills him; he convinces his brother that he should hide and
avoid his father. Edmund then convinces his brother to run away from home and cuts
himself so it looks like he was trying to stop his brother from getting away. Gloucester is
impressed by Edmund’s devotion as a son and says he will inherit the title and estate
rather than Edgar. Later, Edmund betrays his father to Cornwall, who has him blinded as a
result.
(d) They both lie and flatter their father in Act 1 Scene 1. They then conspire together, at
the end of the scene, to ‘do something’ about Lear’s recent rash behaviour. Goneril plots
with Oswald and instructs him to put on a ‘weary negligence’ and tell the other servants to
follow suit in order to provoke an argument with Lear. She writes a letter to Regan,
presumably to tell her of Lear’s unruly behaviour. To avoid having to take Lear into her
own house, Regan goes to Gloucester’s instead.
o the distinctions between the clothes worn by the poor and the clothes worn by the
wealthy
o the suggestion that the wealthy are better able to hide their sins behind their
luxurious clothing
o Regan and Goneril (and wealthy aristocrats in general) do not need their fine
clothes to keep warm – indeed, the clothes seem insufficient even at fulfilling this
basic purpose
15 love test; trappings; sanity; daughter; humanity; stripped away; world; suffering; anarchy;
see; wiser; nothing
16 Answers will vary but will perhaps take into account the religious world view of the play,
caught as it is between the pagan setting, the Christian contexts and a more radical vision
of an indifferent or cruel universe.
Chapter 3
Characterisation
Character overview
1 A = Edmund; B = Goneril; C = the Fool; D = Goneril; E = Regan; F = Gloucester; G =
Edgar; H = Kent; I = Cornwall; J = Oswald
2 (a) Answers may vary. Possible pairings include: Lear / Gloucester; Kent / Oswald;
Albany / Cornwall; Cordelia / Goneril; France / Burgundy; Edgar / Edmund
B = Lear – the final, painful (and misplaced) hope that his daughter survives; this helps to
develop tragic sympathy.
C = Goneril – her ‘monstrosity’ is that she assumes the role of a mother to her own father;
she seeks to manipulate and control the situation.
D = Fool – a typically enigmatic utterance; the wise Fool sees things as they really are and
acknowledges the far-reaching impact of the storm.
E = Cordelia – a prayer, appropriate for the saintly Cordelia; she is sympathetically hoping
for Lear’s recovery.
G = Kent – he is ever-loyal to his King, even to the end; he fatalistically acknowledges that
Lear will not want to suffer any more and should be allowed to die.
• This view certainly holds when considering the villains in the tragedy – Cornwall,
Regan, Goneril, Edmund, Oswald.
• The statement might also apply to Gloucester and Lear, who treat Edgar and Cordelia
very poorly indeed.
• But Gloucester and, to a greater extent, Lear, are changed by their experiences and
show human capacity for redemption.
• Cordelia remains saintly throughout, but her death (along with Lear’s and
Gloucester’s?) perhaps suggests that such virtues have no place in a cruel and
chaotic world.
Lear
1 Answers will vary. All the words could apply to Lear to some extent.
• Lear mistakenly wants to give up the responsibilities of power but, crucially, remain
king.
• The love test is no such thing – it confirms Lear’s vanity and, it seems, he has already
decided to give the best lands to Cordelia.
• He foolishly thinks Cordelia will take part in the love test – her refusal appals him.
• Breaking up his kingdom is likely to (and, indeed, does) result in civil war.
3 1 Lear’s tragic hubris (pride) is made clear; he sees Goneril’s actions as emasculating.
2 One of many of Lear’s curses; the vocabulary confirms his rage and anger.
3 Another image of blindness in the play. Lear is determined not to weep and show
(unkingly) weakness; the hyperbole confirms his strength of feeling; plucking his eyes is
ironic – he is already figuratively blind but doesn’t realise it.
5 Lear is still thinking of himself as king and believes he can easily take back the power
he foolishly gave away. He cannot see that he can no longer do so: Goneril’s authority is
firmly established.
4 Answers will vary. Lear’s fury and pride are in evidence here, but his lack of awareness of
his situation – and his continuing belief in his own power (and Regan’s goodness) heighten
his tragic stature.
A One of the main Spectators will find many instances where we feel pity for Lear, especially in
aims of a tragedy is the second half of the play:
to make the
audience feel pity • Cordelia’s death
(pathos) for the hero.
• Lear’s ‘howl, howl, howl’ speech and his final speech (5.3)
B Another important • The audience – like Kent, the Fool and Cordelia – will be aware that
aim of a tragedy is to Lear makes a fatal error in the first scene.
make the audience
feel terror and fear • The audience are made aware in 5.1 of Edmund’s plans that Lear and
for the fate of the Cordelia will never be pardoned.
hero.
• Edmund’s orders for the execution of Lear and Cordelia (5.3).
C The tragic hero is • Lear is represented as a human and certainly has his shortcomings:
identifiably ‘human’ – he is quick to anger and he demands the ceremonial power of
that is, neither kingship.
entirely good nor
entirely bad – so we
can identify with his
or her plight.
E A tragedy • Lear’s tragic decline is a classical one: he begins as king, he loses his
describes the hero’s authority, he becomes mad and he is isolated on the heath. Forces
fall from status and loyal to him also lose the war in Act 5.
prosperity to
desolation, isolation
and, often, madness.
This reversal of
fortune can be called
peripeteia.
F The tragic decline • Lear cannot ‘see’ that power can’t be separated from responsibility, or
is brought about in that Goneril and Regan will become terrible leaders.
part by a tragic flaw
or error of judgement • Hubris (excessive pride) prevents the King from seeing his errors –
in the hero, known as even when Kent and Cordelia reveal them.
hamartia.
7 Answers could consider how Lear begins the play as a furious, proud king but, through
suffering, he sees the errors he has made and has learnt about suffering, poverty and
justice. Though diminished in Act 5, he is kinder and humbler. Lear’s changes therefore
correlate with Aristotle’s ideas about peripeteia (decline) and anagnorisis (moments of
clarity and understanding).
Cordelia
1 (a) I loved her most, and thought to set my rest / On her kind nursery
LEAR on CORDELIA
(b) [You] are most rich being poor … Thee and thy virtues here I seize upon
FRANCE on CORDELIA
LEAR on GONERIL
(d) The barbarous Scythian, … shall to my bosom / Be as well neighboured, pitied and
relieved, / As thou.
LEAR on CORDELIA
(e) Thou shalt never have my curse. / Thy tender-hafted nature shall not give / Thee o’er
to harshness.
LEAR on REGAN
(f) She shook / The holy water from her heavenly eyes
GENTLEMAN on CORDELIA
• ‘Thou are most rich being poor’ (recalling the Bible, Corinthians, 6.10) 1.1.252
AS/A-Level Literature Workbooks: King Lear 14
• ‘Patience and sorrow strove / Who should express her goodliest’ 4.3.16–17
• ‘When thou dost ask me blessing I’ll kneel down / And ask of thee forgiveness’ 5.3.10–
11
• ‘Upon such sacrifices, my Cordelia, / The gods themselves throw incense’ 5.3.20–21
3 (a) She kisses him in the hope that it would revive him.
(b) She reflects on his age and frailty and the level of suffering such an old man has had
to endure. She emphasises in particular the hardships Lear experienced on the heath:
‘dread-bolted thunder’, and that he had to share a hovel with pigs. Interestingly, she says
she would not have treated her enemy’s dog so cruelly.
(c) Cordelia is addressing her father as a king and therefore confirming he has the right
to be king (and hence justifying her invasion). In many ways, she is ignoring his abdication
in the first scene.
(e) Kneeling holds enormous symbolic value in the play and in wider Renaissance
contexts. Kneeling is a sign of loyalty, reverence and submission. It also holds religious
connotations as well and would be a powerful stage image when performed. Here it is
used to symbolise mutual reconciliation as both Cordelia and Lear wish to show their
loyalty and reverence. Cordelia wishes to ‘give back’ Lear’s royalty; Lear feels he must
kneel before Cordelia as he acknowledges he is just a senile old man seeking forgiveness.
(f) Cordelia is expressing unconditional love for her father and is forgiving all the harm
and injuries he has caused her. This again might be seen to confirm Cordelia as a saintly
figure of Christian forgiveness – or, perhaps, as a character who is maintaining the
patriarchal status quo.
Takes an initial lead role in planning how to respond to their father’s behaviour. GONERIL
Suggests they lock the doors on Lear to teach him a lesson. REGAN
(b) Goneril initially takes a lead role in the sisters’ relationship and appears to be the
dominant sister. Regan seems happy to go along with Goneril’s initial plans. However,
Regan’s sadism soon starts to reveal itself in Act 2, as she urges Cornwall to inflict more
punishment on Kent and joins with her sister in their verbal onslaught on Lear in Act 2
Scene 4. Modern productions often place a particularly sexual element to Regan’s sadism.
• They lust after Edmund and take a ‘lead’ role in their (apparent) seduction of him.
• Goneril emasculates Albany and reduces his authority; for example in Act 5 Scene 3:
‘the laws are mine not thine’.
• Goneril dominates the men around her – Lear, Oswald, Albany and the Fool – in Act 1
Scene 4.
(b) Jacobean ideals of femininity required women to be quiet and submissive and so
many in a Jacobean audience are likely to have been shocked and horrified at Goneril and
Regan’s subversion of accepted codes of feminine behaviour.
3 Answers will vary here, but the perspective does perhaps ask us to see the daughters in a
different way: as powerful women rebelling against a strict patriarchy and who must be
shown to be punished as a result.
Gloucester
1 Possible answers include:
Brave and Placing himself in great danger, Gloucester helps Lear on the heath: ‘I have
courageous o’erheard a plot of death upon him. / There is a litter ready … Take up, take
up, / And follow me’
The blinding scene: ‘I am tied to the stake and I must stand the course’ 3.7.53
Suicidal ‘O you mighty gods, / This world I do renounce and in your sights / Shake
patiently my great affliction off.’
‘No further, sir; a man may rot even here.’ 5.2.8
Adulterous ‘Yet was his [Edmund’s] mother fair, there was good sport at his making, and
the whoreson must be acknowledged.’ 1.1.21–23
Gloucester’s pain and despair reflect Lear’s. Gloucester is suicidal through much of the
second half of the play – especially after his blinding and upon learning of Edmund’s
treachery in Act 3 Scene 7. Being led by his disguised son Edgar, Gloucester prays to the
pagan gods that he wishes to ‘renounce’ this world and to ‘shake’ his ‘great affliction off’ by
ending his own life. In Shakespeare’s time, Christians saw suicide as an unforgivable sin
against God, but Shakespeare may well be exploiting the pagan setting of the play in
refusing to condemn Gloucester’s desires: indeed, here Gloucester is praying to the gods
themselves for assistance. Gloucester’s suffering is presented in a sympathetic light,
especially in the euphemism to ‘shake patiently’ his suffering away. In the chaos and
nihilism which characterises much of the play, perhaps suicide is an inevitable, and
understandable, human response.
4 (a)
o It is too dangerous for his own servants to help and support him.
o the gods ostensibly do not answer the various prayers uttered in the play
o Gloucester – not the gods – is to blame for his own suffering and death.
Edmund
1 A soliloquy is a dramatic convention by which a character, alone on stage, utters his or her
thoughts aloud. This can be useful for providing details of plot and motivation. It often also
creates a relationship between the audience and the character as they are given intimate
access to thoughts, schemes and motivations.
• He cuts himself to make it appear as though he was trying to stop Edgar from getting
away.
• He seduces Goneril.
• He seduces Regan.
• He plots the best way to have them killed so he can become king.
3 (a) Goneril: Having plotted with Edmund and murdered her sister, her scheme has
unravelled. She therefore commits suicide.
(b) Regan: A jealous Goneril poisons Regan upon discovering her affair with Edmund.
(d) Lear: Although escaping the killer sent by Edmund, Lear’s dies from grief over
Cordelia’s death (see above).
4 (a) Edmund opposes Nature to Custom/Society. Nature’s laws are here shown to be, in
effect, the laws of the jungle and beasts. In a level playing field, and without any moral
restraints, the most ruthless will survive.
(b) The ‘plague of custom’ here primarily refers to the laws which prohibit men born out
of wedlock from inheriting their father’s estate.
(c) Edmund is playing with the word ‘base’ and its auditory chimes with ‘bastard’. He
appears to be rejecting and criticising aristocratic contempt for the low-born. The repetition
might suggest Edmund’s obsession with his own status in contrast with Edgar and his
larger disgust with the social order.
(d) Edmund suggests that ‘legitimate’ children are conceived during dull lovemaking of a
marriage bed (and are therefore stale themselves). Bastards, meanwhile, are conceived in
the lively ‘sport’ and pleasure of adultery.
(f) They may have been shocked at Edmund’s bold, sinful command to the gods. This
concluding statement confirms Edmund’s villainy.
Edgar
1 Edgar: The legitimate son of Gloucester; embodies heroic, loyal qualities; gullible; lives.
Quotation Aspect of
character
(1–6)
A Why I do trifle thus with his despair / Is done to cure it. 3
B A most toad-spotted traitor… / This sword, this arm and my best spirits are 5
bent / To prove upon thy heart … / Thou liest.
C Whose nature is so far from doing harms / That he suspects none 1
D Friends of my soul, you twain, / Rule in this realm and the gored state sustain. 6
E Take the basest and most poorest shape / That ever penury in contempt of 2
man / Brought near to beast.
F I’se try whether your costard [head] or my baton be the harder. Ch’ill be plain 4
with you.
The Fool
1 Possible answers include:
• ‘This fellow has banished two on’s daughters and did the third a blessing against his
will’ 1.4.100–102
• ‘e’er since thou mad’st thy daughters thy mothers; for when thou gav’st them the rod
and putt’st down thine own breeches’ 1.4.163–165
AS/A-Level Literature Workbooks: King Lear 19
• ‘The hedge-sparrow fed the cuckoo so long / That it’s had it head bit off by it young’
1.4.206–207
2 Hamlet; Macbeth; integrated; Richard Armin; medieval; Will Somers; uncle; satirises;
Cordelia; relief; truth; mothers; devastation
Chapter 4
Writer’s methods: Language and
imagery
1 (a) Simile: suggests mankind’s powerlessness against the cruelty of the gods
(d) Metaphor: contrasts with Lear’s heightened emotional response to the death of his
daughter
(e) String of adjectives: the extent of Lear’s changes and his altered perception of himself
(h) Imperative: Goneril is a very powerful woman who exerts absolute control over events
and other characters
(i) Metaphor: archery conceit; Lear has already made up his mind and will not be
convinced otherwise
(j) Invocation: echoes of Edmund’s soliloquy; Lear is calling upon the goddess Nature to
support his curse of Goneril and her future children
2 (a)–(c) Answers will vary, but may share similarities with the answers above.
(a)
o LEAR: ‘The little dogs and all … see, they bark at me’ 3.6.60–61
(b)
o LEAR: ‘We two alone will sing like birds i’th’cage’ 5.3.9
(c)
o LEAR: ‘Come not between the dragon and his wrath!’ 1.1.123
(d)
• Suggesting how humans can be reduced to the status of animals if we lack ‘sight’, love
and goodness.
7 (a) Of course, Shakespeare does not provide us with specific dates, and there are plenty
of anachronistic references in the play. However, according to Geoffrey of Monmouth (a
source for Shakespeare), Leir’s (Lear’s) reign would have occurred around the eighth
century BC, around the time of the founding of Rome: a distant, almost mythical past.
o Apollo 1.1.161
o Juno/Jupiter 2.2.211–212
o Hecate 1.1.111
o 1.4.267 – Lear is asking Nature to assist him in a curse for his daughter.
o 1.2.1 – Edmund is calling on Nature to help him in his efforts to climb the social
hierarchy.
o 4.4.15 – Cordelia is asking Nature to provide her with a restorative aid for her
father.
(d) Answers will vary. Readers can agree or disagree. Perhaps to a modern audience the
gods appear a long way from being just in this play.
o the ways in which Lear is addressed by other characters: ‘Royal Lear’; ‘my liege’
o other words associated with kingly authority: ‘power’; ‘invest’; ‘majesty’; ‘coronet’.
o pronoun use: the ‘we’ is no longer the royal ‘we’ but the unification of Lear and
Cordelia
o other noteworthy differences with the previous passage: pronoun use; Edmund
adopts the language of command; tone of forgiveness rather than anger; the
contrasting use of lists.
9 Blank verse is unrhymed verse written in iambic pentameter. Iambic pentameter is a type
of rhythm in which each line has five stressed syllables alternating with five unstressed
syllables. This forms the following rhythmde-DUM de-DUM de-DUM de-DUM de-DUM, or:
• other patterns: ‘drenched our steeples, drowned the cocks’; compounded adjectives:
‘thought-executing’
• line breaks formed with a range of extreme or violent words: blow, fires, thunder
• caesura (‘… head!’) announcing structural change of focus from the wind to the
thunder
• shortened final line (iambic trimeter) bringing the verse to an abrupt conclusion.
11
Letters Prose
(a) Perhaps the prose here indicates the lines are to be delivered at speed and possibly
hints at the comic potential of Edmund duping Edgar and his father. Also, a possible
contrast with the intense drama of the royal court in the preceding scene.
(b) The switch to prose may be significant here as Lear begins to realise his common
humanity with the poorest and most deprived.
(c) The switching perhaps indicates Lear’s mental state, although at this particular point
Lear does adopt a more formal register as he denounces injustices and inequality in a
highly significant speech.
(d) Again, Shakespeare may be suggesting that these lines are to be delivered at speed
– and possibly hinting at a comedic intention in Edmund’s soliloquy as he expresses
incredulity at the gullibility of those around him.
14 Lear is, at this point, at the height of his madness. The focus of Lear’s obsessive fury in
this passage is, initially, on Gloucester’s adultery but it soon switches to a misogynistic
rant against Goneril and Regan and women in general. The passage is littered with words
associated with intense fear and loathing of women’s sexual desires, such as ‘lecher’,
‘copulation’, ‘luxury’ and ‘soiled’. As throughout the play, Shakespeare here deploys bestial
imagery (A) as, ‘down from the waist’ (B), women are referred to metaphorically (A) as
‘centaurs’ (B). Lear may well be articulating Jacobean, patriarchal concerns about the
emasculating effects of sexually powerful women (D and E).
Of course, Lear cannot consciously be aware of Goneril and Regan’s lust for Edmund. So
this is perhaps an example of what critic Maynard Mack called the ‘insight’ into the truth
that only madness brings. Indeed, the language in this passage charts Lear’s mental
deterioration (C) – his peripeteia (A) – as Shakespeare switches, mid-speech, from blank
verse to prose (A). Lear’s language ultimately breaks down. A list (A) outlines a hellish
vision of female genitals as the source of burning sexually transmitted diseases: ‘the
sulphurous pit, burning, scalding, stench, consumption’. This is then followed by angry
non-verbal vocalisations (A) ‘Fie’ and ‘pah’. These suggest Lear is struggling to articulate
his ideas as well as contributing to the overall dramatic impact of an angry but impotent
king (E).
Chapter 5
Contexts
1 (a) Gender roles; Monarchy and King James; Madness; Social hierarchy; Tragedy
2 (a)
(b)
o He sees ‘better’.
o He seeks forgiveness from Cordelia for the way he has treated her.
(c)
o King Lear does not have a single clear tragic villain (such as Claudius in Hamlet).
o Instead, Edmund, Goneril, Regan and Cornwall all variously play a key role in
Lear’s destruction, but especially his two daughters.
(d)
o Lear’s love test also led to his estrangement from Cordelia and mistreatment from
Goneril and Regan.
(e)
o The powerful, pitiful poetry of King Lear has been much commented upon,
especially in heightened tragic moments (Lear on the heath; his meeting with
Gloucester; his reunion with Cordelia; and the final, unbearable ‘Never, never,
never, never, never’ speech).
(f)
o The play contains plentiful references to the gods and divine justice.
(g)
o The play’s treatment of suffering, mortality, cruelty, sin and forgiveness all
perhaps encourage the audience to reflect upon these aspects of the human
condition.
4 (a)
o Lear’s decision to effectively give up being king (and insist on the trappings of
privileges of power) would therefore be seen to be an affront against God. A king
is born a king.
o Other ‘good’ characters (notably Cordelia) therefore continue to see him as king,
despite his abdication.
(b)
o Oswald ambitiously serves the evil Goneril without any moral scruples of his own.
(c)
(d)
o Some scholars have argued that James may have specifically requested the
performance of King Lear at his court to show how dividing a country leads to
political instability and civil war.
(e)
o The issue over who should rule Britain runs through the play: Goneril as the
eldest in normal circumstances would become queen. But Queen Goneril would
have had an ambitious sister (and brother-in-law). Cordelia would also no doubt
have made a better queen. The divided kingdom in King Lear and concerns over
who should rule would no doubt have turned contemporary audiences towards
Elizabeth’s recent succession crisis.
Quotation Context
A–D
ALBANY: [to Edgar] Methought thy very gait did prophesy / A royal nobleness A
EDGAR: The country gives me proof and precedent / Of Bedlam beggars, who, C
with roaring voices / Strike in their numbed and mortified bare arms / Pins, wooden
pricks, nails
EDMUND: Let me, if not by birth, have lands by wit B
LEAR: ’Tis our fast intent / To shake all cares and business from our age, / A
Conferring them on younger strengths
KENT: [on Oswald] That such a slave as this should wear a sword, / Who wears no B
honesty. Such smiling rogues as these / Like rats oft bite the holy cords atwain
LEAR: Plate sin with gold, / And the strong lance of justice hurtles breaks; / Arm it D
in rags, a pygmy’s straw does pierce it.
LEAR: Unaccommodated man is no more but such a poor, bare, forked animal as A, B
thou art. Off, off, you lendings …
LEAR: I’ll see their trial first. Bring in their evidence. / [to Edgar] Thou robed man of D
justice, take thy place.
EDMUND: Well, then, / Legitimate Edgar, I must have your land. B
LEAR: Poor naked wretches … How shall your houseless heads and unfed sides C
… defend you / From seasons such as these? O, I have ta’en / Too little care of
this.
KENT: [to Cornwall] Call not your stocks for me; I serve the king, / On whose A, B, D
employment I was sent to you. / You shall do small respect … Stocking his
messenger.
GENTLEMAN: [on Lear] A sight most pitiful in the meanest wretch, / Past speaking A
of in a king.
(b) Kent is clearly appalled by Oswald’s behaviour. He calls him a ‘smiling rogue’ who
has no honesty. Oswald represents the ‘new man’ of the Jacobean age, an emerging class
who were motivated by self-interest. Kent confirms this in a later simile, likening Oswald to
a ‘rat’ who bites ‘the holy cords’ of feudal family and community traditions apart. Oswald
AS/A-Level Literature Workbooks: King Lear 28
and Edmund are shown unsympathetically, so the play might therefore be criticising the
social phenomenon of the ‘new man’.
6 King Lear has always been considered Shakespeare’s bleakest play. Samuel Johnson,
writing in the eighteenth century, was so shaken by a reading of Cordelia’s death that he
could not bear to return to Shakespeare’s original. He admired Tate’s version. The
sensibilities of the eighteenth-century audiences were very different: they seemed
particularly sensitive to violence and horror and needed reassuring that justice is at work in
some way. Cordelia’s invasion from France would have borne some uncomfortable
parallels with Britain’s wars with France in this period.
7 (a) Each interpretation and performance is affected by social and historical contexts. We
seem much more inured to violence and horror. As critic Nutall argues, modern audiences
even expect to be ‘uncomfortable’ when going to the theatre.
o make real and physical the play’s figurative exploration of sight and blindness
o be a potent symbol of the inherent violence and cruelty of the world of King Lear.
8 (a) Tragedy and the tragic hero; King James’s court; Divine Right of Kings; madness;
Great Chain of Being
(b) Tragedy and tragic villain; Machiavellian villain; Great Chain of Being; the ‘new man’
of Jacobean age; Nahum Tate
• machiavellian villains
Chapter 6
Critical approaches
1 (a)–(c) Answers will vary.
2 (a) Johnson assumes that justice is a natural outcome – that the universe and society
are inherently ‘just’ and moral places. Therefore, Cordelia’s death is unnatural because it
is unjust.
(b) Answers will vary but could perhaps consider some of the play’s core concerns about
suffering and its determinedly bleak world-view. It is also interesting to note that all
Shakespeare’s heroines die …
5 (a) The poor are represented in the play by ‘Poor Tom’, on the whole. They are shown to
be the conscience of the play. They suffer and are shown to be the victims of injustice.
(b) Lear ignored the poor when he was in power. He realises that society is unfair and
that kings have too much ‘pomp’ and wealth. A fair society can be brought about by those
who have a ‘superflux’ of wealth.
(c) Those who administer justice hypocritically commit crimes themselves. There is no
difference in the sins committed by the poor and wealthy, except the rich can hide their
crimes behind ‘furred gowns’.
6 (a) His powers are given to him by a monarchical society. He probably inherited the role,
so the power comes from family as well.
(b) It preserves power within a family. Siblings are likely to disagree over the inheritance.
The eldest child may not be the best suited to rule.
(c) With the exception of Edgar and Cordelia, all the royal and aristocratic characters
make catastrophic errors of judgement, conduct unspeakable acts of violence, betray their
family and immorally and ambitiously seize power.
(d) Events in Act 5 seem to indicate this collapse: war, murder, suicide, the destruction of
a royal dynasty. Spectators will have to decide for themselves whether or not Edgar is able
to restore governance and what form of governance this will take – will it be more of the
same?
7 (a) Most of the play describes the terrible consequences of Lear’s refusal to govern, to
rule as God has ordained. A monarch cannot decide whether or not to rule. So it can be
argued that King Lear is a conservative play, warning its audiences of the consequences
of going against established conventions of governance.
(b) The knights are unruly and disruptive and might demonstrate what happens when
symbols of power become separated from actual authority to rule. Tennenhouse: ‘When
he resigns his throne, the retainers operate only as symbols of a power once located in
Lear … It has to be a significant moment, then, when the king’s own retainers [become] a
disruptive social force where once they would have opposed such a force in the name of
political order.’
(c) Gloucester disinherits his legitimate son and therefore does not obey the rule of
primogeniture, central to monarchical and aristocratic power structures. He is clearly
punished as a result.
(d) Gloucester renounces Edmund, the bastard son; Gloucester renews his loyalty to his
king; Cordelia renews loyalty to her king and affirms the patriarchy by re-establishing the
‘natural’ father/daughter relationship.
(e) Edgar and Albany are (largely) loyal, conventional, traditional noblemen who pose no
challenge whatsoever to the established status quo. The system of government, we might
assume, will be ‘back to normal’ after the tumultuous events of the play.
10 (a) Goneril is admonishing Lear for the ‘debauched’, ‘disordered’ and ‘bold’ behaviour of
Lear and, especially, his knights in her ‘graced palace’. To a modern audience, at least,
this might seem a reasonable request of Goneril.
(b) Although it will depend enormously on how it is performed, Goneril is a long way from
being cruel or unpleasant in the way she speaks. Her speech is measured and assured.
She beseeches Lear to understand, calls him sir, asks him (politely?) to ‘disquantity your
train’.
(c) Lear, the arch-patriarch, believes her behaviour is unnatural because she is not
treating her father as a daughter should – that is, loving, respectful, grateful and loyal.
(d) He angrily calls her a ‘devil’ and a ‘Degenerate bastard’. She, in his eyes at least, is
aligning herself with evil. Whether or not Lear is being unreasonable here is open to
debate, but modern audiences certainly may view his behaviour unsympathetically.
(e) Answers will vary. Feminist critics might draw a distinction between how Goneril’s
behaviour is interpreted by (the hero) Lear and how she might be interpreted, in this scene
AS/A-Level Literature Workbooks: King Lear 31
at least, by the audience. Is Goneril being punished by Lear and the patriarchy for being
powerful and in control?
11 Answers will vary, but may consider Lear’s followers’ persistent (misguided?) loyalty, even
to an ostensibly mad king who has just been shouting ‘kill’. Lear views the world as filled
with ‘fools’ and appears to therefore subvert any notion of a social hierarchy. He appears
to be aware that he has been merely playing the role of a king.
12 Answers will vary, but may consider Goneril’s (feminine) associations with disease. Lear is
reduced to impotent cursing. Regan and Goneril’s use of language indicates they are
clearly in command in this scene and Lear’s loss of male authority contrasts with Act 1
Scene 1.
Chapter 7
Boosting your skills
Tackling question types
1 A AO1; B AO5; C AO4; D AO1; E AO3; F AO1; G AO5: H AO2; I AO3.
4 (a) This type of question will also ask you to look at a particular aspect of the play, such
as a theme or, in this case, a character. However, you will need to examine this aspect in
the light of the given statement. Ultimately, you are being asked to provide your own
perspective on the statement.
AO2:
• Examples of repetition and patterning: ‘No, no, no’; ‘Never, never …’; parallelism
‘Speak what we feel’
• Imagery of animals, torture and suffering: ‘a dog, a horse, a rat’; ‘the rack of this
world’;
• Stage directions: Lear’s attempts to unbutton; Lear’s death; the dead march; the
removal of the bodies
AO3:
• Jacobean attitudes towards monarchy and the Great Chain of Being: Edgar’s loyalty
and (initial) attempts to help Lear; why should ‘a rat have life, / And thou no breath at
all?’; ‘you twain / Rule in this realm’
• Attitudes towards legitimacy and illegitimacy: Edgar is able to claim the throne by
virtue of his legitimate and noble birth
• Varying attitudes towards death: ‘My master calls me, I must say no’; ‘O, let him pass’;
‘Vex not his ghost’; ‘O thou’lt come no more’
• God, religion and justice: why should ‘a rat have life, / And thou no breath at all?’.
AO4:
• The tragic death of the tragic hero: ‘Look there, look there! He dies’
• Sadness and pity (pathos); catharsis: ‘Never, never, never …’; ‘Break, hear, I prithee
break’; ‘Our present business is general woe’
• Lear’s changing tragic stature: Lear’s polite request contrasting with his regal
commands of Act 1, ‘Pray you, undo this button: thank you sir’
• A renewed hope at the end of a tragedy: ‘Friends of my soul, you twain / Rule in this
realm and the gored state sustain’
• A sense of a ‘lesson being learnt’ from the catastrophe: Edgar has learnt a lesson, ‘we
that are young / Shall never see so much’.
AO5: Answers will vary according to your own views, but may make reference to
Johnson’s views on the unnecessary death of Cordelia and Bradley’s attempts to discern a
Christian solace in the ending.
A Spend no more than two minutes planning – it is more important that you use the time
writing a five-page essay.
E Spend the planning time trying to remember how you wrote your recent A-grade
mock essay on a similar theme.
F Do not worry about having a central argument – hopefully you will have thought of
one by the time you write your conclusion.
2 (a) ‘Cruel’ means to deliberately cause pain or suffering to somebody else, and probably
to feel no concern about it as well. ‘Ambitious’ means a strong desire or determination to
achieve – often at any cost.
(b) Edmund is clearly prepared to do anything to become Duke of Gloucester and, later,
King, including killing his own father and half-brother, wilfully seducing Goneril and Regan
and hoping one sister will kill the other.
(c) It is deliberately strongly worded. It would be difficult to claim that Edmund is not
ambitious, but the question is asking you to consider whether or not there is more to him
than ‘just’ ambitious cruelty. Also, a modern audience may well think that Edmund has a
fair point: why should ‘legitimate’ Edgar inherit and not him? Perhaps Edmund is more
deserving of our (modern) sympathy.
(d) Weigh up the evidence, look at both sides and come to a clear argument of your own
in relation to the statement. It is also acceptable for you to agree with some parts of the
statement rather than all of it.
(b) A possible structure could be: E, B, A, D, C. E would make a secure first point on
Lear’s suffering in general; B, A and D are effectively in chronological order showing the
development of Lear’s suffering; the essay could finish with a point comparing Lear with
Gloucester (C).
(b)
o The student is being far too strong in his or her unqualified agreement with the
statement: studying literature should open up critical debates, not shut them
down.
o The student also repeats the words in the question (cruel and ambitious).
o The student should try to find other ways of saying ‘In this essay, I am going to
…’
8 (a) B and C.
Essay-writing skills
1
• The paragraph loses its focus on Kent and becomes a (descriptive) study of Edmund
instead.
(b) Towards the end of the play, Lear finally admits his errors and that he has been ‘a
very foolish, fond old man’.
(c) Lear calls on the storm to destroy the world as he commands it to ‘spout’ until it has
‘drenched our steeples, drowned the cocks’.
3 A:
• There is some attempt to analyse how this context has influenced the play, although
this could be more developed.
• The student shows an awareness of how the play could be read differently over time.
B:
• The contextual point is broadly relevant as the student explores the significance of
Lear’s relinquishing of power.
• Contexts are rather clumsily bolted on and not related to any details from King Lear.
• At the very least, this paragraph would benefit from including at the end a link back to
the play.
4 (a)
• Stage directions: the language indicates the delivery of Lear’s lines is likely to be bitter
and angry; Lear striking his head (foreshadowing madness?).
(c)
Essay practice
1 Answers will vary.
(b) The evidence should be integrated and contextualised (who says it and to whom).
(d) Answers could comment on the language of command ‘Out’, which might also
suggest Cornwall is having some difficulty removing the eye; the adjective ‘vile’ and the
remarkable (figurative?) noun ‘jelly’ heighten the horror of the scene; rhetorical question –
perhaps suggesting Cornwall’s triumph.
(e) The student could have reflected on why it has been included in modern productions
– perhaps reflecting on the thematic significance of the scene as well as the changing
tastes and the modern preference for ‘uncomfortable’ theatrical experiences.
o Fluent and well-structured, with an effective and useful return to Mack at the end
(b) Answers will vary, but should follow the model paragraph and cover most or all of the
bullet points.
4 (a)
(b) A: The argument becomes more subtle and opens up a sensible, balanced critical
discussion.
6 (a)
(b)
(c)
o Gloucester’s gullibility
(d)
o Family
o Nature/natural bonds
o Nothingness.
(e)
o Dramatic irony