Comparative Police System
Comparative Police System
Comparative Police System
Police = The governmental department charged with the regulation and control of the affairs of a community, now
chiefly the department established to maintain order, enforce the law, and prevent and detect crime. (French word)
GLOBALIZATION
= package of transnational flow of people, production, investment, information, ideas and authority.
= growing interpenetration of states, markets, communication and ideas.
= The process of creating transnational markets, politics, and legal systems in an effort to form and sustain a global
economy.
Home Rule = the theory of police service which states that police officers are servants of the community or the
people. This theory prevails in England and United States. It is also the police service which prevails in country with
decentralized form of government. This is likewise the police service theory that should prevail in the Philippines
based on the existing laws, concepts and principles.
b. Modern police service = states that the yardstick of police proficiency relies on the absence of crime.
Deviance Control = is the modern police function which primarily involves the mission to reinforce community values
and laws. This was adopted by Germany, China and Japan.
Civil order control = is not organizationally separated from deviance control but is performed by regular street police
in the country of England and United States.
C. Trial by Ordeal
A judicial practice where in the guilt or innocence of the accused is determined by subjecting him to an
unpleasant, usually dangerous, experience. (In present terminologies, it would mean an employment of a “3rd degree.”)
The word “ordeal” was derived from the Medieval Latin word “Dei Indicum” which means “a miraculous decision.”
This system of policing existed during the time of Norman William The Conqueror (King of France). When he
invaded and conquered England, a military regime of conquers and dictators began and changed the concept of
crime being committed against the state.
A. Shire-Rieve
Shire-Rieve was a policing system during the Norman Period when England was divided into fifty-five (55)
military areas, each headed by a ruler called the Rieve (head-man or lieutenant of the army). The fifty-five (55)
military divisions in England are called shires. The shire-rieve had absolute powers that no one could questions his or
her actions.
Two “Constabuli” or “The Keeper of the Horse” were appointed to each village to aid the Rieve in his duties.
It became the source of the word Constable.
The term “Shire-Rieve” is said to be the origin of the word “Sheriff.”
C. Legis Henrici
An act that was enacted during this period with the following features:
▪ Offenses were classified as against the king and individual.
▪ Policeman becomes public servant.
▪ The police and the citizens have the broad power to arrest. It introduced the system called “citizen’s arrest.”
▪ Grand Jury was created to inquire on the facts of the law. A system which made inquisition onto the facts of
a crime and eliminate the “Anglo-Saxon Trial or “Trial by Ordeal System.”
D. Frankpledge System
A system of policing whereby a group of ten neighboring male residents over twelve years of age were
required to guard the town to preserve peace and protect the lives and properties of the people
B. Statute of 1295
The law that marks the beginning of the curfew hours, which demanded the closing of the gates of London
during sundown.
A proclamation issued by King Richard of England sometime in 1195 that required the appointment of
knights to keep the King’s peace by standing as guards on bridges and gates while checking the people entering and
leaving the cities and towns.
1798 = Marine Police Force was established, salaried constables were being paid by local magistrates.
= initially made up of 220 Constables assisted by 1,000 registered dock workers, and was responsible for
preventing the theft of cargo. = widely regarded as being the first modern police force in the world, in the sense that
they were not government controlled and were responsible for the prevention of crime.
LONDON 1829
Sir Robert Peel = appointed as Home Secretary in 1822
METROPOLITAN POLICE = organized in 1829 by Sir Robert Peel (Metropolitan Police Act of 1829)
= the largest of the police services that operate in greater London (the others include the City of London
Police and the British Transport Police)
= finest police force around the world.
IMPORTANT DATES
1. Municipal Police = includes village, township, city and country police departments, sheriff departments.
The United States police rank model is generally quasi-military in structure. Although the large and varied
number of federal, state, and local police departments and sheriff's office have different ranks, a general model, from
highest to lowest rank, would be:
➢ Chief of Police/Police Commissioner/Superintendent/Sheriff
➢ Deputy Chief of Police/Deputy Commissioner/Deputy Superintendent/Undersheriff
➢ Inspector/Commander/Colonel
➢ Major/Deputy Inspector
➢ Captain
➢ Lieutenant
➢ Sergeant
➢ Detective/Inspector/Investigator
➢ Officer/Deputy Sheriff/Corporal
CANADA
Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) = colloquially known as Mounties and internally as “The Force” = is the
national police force of Canada and one of the most recognized of its kind in the word being a national, federal,
provincial and municipal policing body. It is founded in 1920 by the Merger of Royal Northwest Mounted Police(1873)
with the Dominion Police (1868).
= headed by the Commission under the direction of the Minister of Public Safety Canada.
AUSTRALIA
Australian Police = a progressive and multi-faceted law enforcement organization, taking strong lead in the fight
against 21st century crime.
▪ Commissioner = highest rank
▪ Constable = lowest rank
HONGKONG
Hong Kong Police Force
= is the largest disciplined service under the Security Bureau of Hong Kong. It is the world's second, and
Asia's first, police agency to operate with a modern policing system. It was formed on 1 May 1844.
in 1969, Queen Elizabeth II granted the Royal Charter to the Hong Kong Police Force for their
handling of the Hong Kong 1967 riots — renaming them: the Royal Hong Kong Police Force. Following the transfer of
sovereignty, the Force is once again named the Hong Kong Police Force
Structure HKPF
The Force is commanded by the Commissioner of Police, who is assisted by two deputy commissioners:
a. Deputy Commissioner – Operations = supervises all operational matters including crime and
b. Deputy Commissioner – Management = is responsible for the direction and coordination of force
management including personnel, training, and management services.
Hong Kong Police College = s responsible for all matters relating to training within the Hong Kong Police except
internal security, Auxiliary and Marine Police training. Training provided by the Police College includes recruit and
continuation training, crime investigation training, police driver training and weapon tactics training. The information
technology training, command training, local and overseas management training, some specialist courses and
periodic courses on firearms and first aid are also provided by the Police College.
Service Quality Wing = is responsible for spearheading initiatives to improve services provided to force customers
both external and internal. The wing comprises three branches: Performance Review, Research and Inspections and
Complaints and Internal Investigations (C&II)
Complaints and Internal Investigations (C&II) = includes the Complaints Against Police Office (CAPO) oversees the
investigation and successful resolution of all complaints made both externally and internally against members of the
force.
For Inspector
Academic Requirements
▪ Hong Kong degree, or equivalent; or
▪ An accredited Associate Degree from Hong Kong tertiary institution / A Higher Diploma from a Hong Kong
polytechnic / polytechnic university, or a Diploma from a registered post-secondary college awarded after
the date of its registration, or equivalent; or
▪ A pass in two subjects at Advanced Level in the Hong Kong Advanced Level Examination (2A) plus three
other subjects at Grade C or above in the HKCEE (3O), or a combination of results in five Hong Kong
Diploma of Secondary Education (HKDSE) subjects of Level 3 in New Senior Secondary (NSS) subjects,
“Attained with Distinction” in Applied Learning (ApL) subjects (subject to a maximum of two ApL subjects)
and Grade C in Other Language subjects, or equivalent.
Five passes or above, which may include Chinese Language and English Language, in the HKCEE, or a
combination of results in five Hong Kong Diploma of Secondary Education (HKDSE) subjects of Level 2 in New Senior
Secondary (NSS) subjects, “Attained” in Applied Learning (ApL) subjects (subject to a maximum of two ApL subjects)
and Grade E in Other Language subjects, or equivalent.
RANKS OF HKPF
Commissioner of Police (CP)
Deputy Commissioner of Police (DCP)
Senior Assistant Commissioner of Police (SACP)
Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP)
Chief Superintendent of Police (CSP)
Senior Superintendent of Police (SSP)
Superintendent of Police (SP)
Chief Inspector of Police (CIP)
Senior Inspector of Police (SIP)
Inspector of Police (IP)
Probationary Inspector of Police (PI)
Station Sergeant (SSGT)
Sergeant (SGT)
Senior Constable (SPC)
Police Constable (PC)
TAIWAN
TAIWAN POLICE FORCE = is the unified police force of taiwan
= under the supervision of NATIONAL POLICE AGENCY which is directly under the MINISTRY OF INTERIOR
= under effective civilian control
FUNCTIONS
1) to maintain public order,
2) 2) to protect social security,
3) 3) to prevent all dangers, and
4) ) to promote the welfare of all people.
MYANMAR
Myanmar Police Force = formally known as The People's Police Force (Burmese: Pyi Thu Yae Tup Pwe)
= established in 1964 as independent department under Ministry of Home Affairs. It was reorganized on 1
October 1995.
There are 14 State and Divisional Police Forces and three additional State/Division Police Forces
TRAINING CENTERS
1. Central Training Institute of Myanmar Police Force
2. No.1 Police Training Depot = undertakes Basic Training Course for Police Sergeant for 2 years; Warrant Officer and
Police Sergeants Course for 12 Weeks; and Basic Training Course for Constables for 6 Month
3. No. 2 Police Training Depot = undertakes only Basic Training Course for Constables, which normally takes around 6
months to complete.
SPECIAL BRANCHES
1. Brigade Mobile (BRIMOB) = the most militarized trained to deal with mass demonstrations
= paramilitary role to conduct security stabilization operations and providing security for VIP and vital
facilities
2. Anti-Riot Unit (Pasukan Anti Huru-Hura) = received special anti-riot training
3. Sea and Air Police = responsible patrolling the airspace
4. Plainclothes Unit = assigned in conducting investigations
5. Maritime Police = responsible in protecting the territorial sea
6. Anti-Terrorist Unit = trained in counter-terrorism
7. Forensics = in-charged of laboratory examination of evidence
ROYAL MALAYSIAN POLICE (RMP: Malay: Polis Diraja Malaysia, PDRM) = police force of Malaysia.
RMP Organizations
1. Management Department = the Management Department is tasked with the routine of management and
administration affairs of the RMP. This department is also the nerve centre of the RMP and acts as the support
services platform for the rest of the force.
2. Logistics Department = has the role to provide several equipments needed in RMP
▪ 3. Criminal Investigation Division = deals with the investigation, arrest and prosecution of hard crimes
(murder, robbery, rape etc) and petty crimes (theft, house-breaking etc).
= This department also specializes in gambling, vice and secret societies (triads)
Branches of Criminal Investigation Division
▪ D1 – Administrative Division
▪ D2 – Criminal Record Registration
▪ D3 – Internal Affairs
▪ D4 – Statistics
▪ D5 – Prosecution and Law Divisions
▪ D6 – Technical Assistance Division
▪ D7 – Gambling / Vice / Secret Societies
▪ D8 – Investigation Division / Planning
▪ D9 – Special Investigation Division
▪ D10 – Forensic Laboratory Division
▪ D11 – Sexual Investigation Division
▪ D12 – National Centre Bureau-Interpol Division
4. Narcotics Criminal Investigation Division = this department's function is to fight against dangerous drugs by
enforcing the law to stop and reduce the demand and supply of dangerous drugs.
5. Internal Security and Public Order Department = responsible for traffic control and Search & Rescue (SAR)
operations
6. The Police Field Force (PFF) = organized in battalions and was a para-military units of the Royal Malaysia Police.
Also known as the Jungle Squad
= established in 1948
7. Police Counter-Terrorism Unit = an elite unit of RMP responsible in counter-terrorism operations
8. UNGERIN = Unit Gempur Marin (UNGERIN) (Marine Combat Unit) was established in 2006 and it was fully
operational by the end of 2007
= first name was Unit Selam Tempur due to the pressing need to suppress the pirate attacks alongside the
coastal area of Malacca Straits and open sea area of South China Sea which were continuously widespread from time
to time despite various efforts done to overcome the problem
= members received training from U.S
9. Federal Reserve Unit (FRU) = (Malay: Pasukan Simpanan Persekutuan)
= its role is riot suppression, crowd control, disaster relief & rescue, as well as special operations assistance
= organized in 1955
10. C4-i Implementations System = (abbreviation for Command, Control, Communications, Computer-Integrated) =
based at Police Control Centre in all police contingents in Malaysia.
= this unit is assigned to patrol the city and the suburbs.
11. The Marine Operations Force or (Malay: Pasukan Gerakan Marin) = tasked with maintaining law and order and
coordinating search and rescue operations in the Malaysian Maritime Zone and on the high seas
12. Royal Malaysian Police Air Wing Unit or Unit Udara PDRM (UUP) = is a special unit of Royal Malaysia Police with a
vital role in maintaining national security with thorough surveillance and patrol from the air
13. Special Branch = This department is responsible for collecting intelligence for national security
14. Traffic Unit = responsible in maintaining the flow of traffic
15. Commercial Crimes Investigation Department = this department's main function is to investigate, arrest, and
prosecute offenders committing white collar crimes such as fraud, breach of trust, cyber-crimes, forgery,
counterfeiting etc
RANKS OF RMP
INSPECTOR-GENERAL OF POLICE = equivalent of director general (Philippines)
POLICE CONSTABLE = equivalent of police officer 1 (Philippines)
Singapore
Francis James Bernard = formed the skeleton force as the heritage of Singapore Police Force in 1819.
▪ Singapore Police Force (SPF) is the main agency task with the maintaining law and order in the city-state. It
is formerly known as Republic of Singapore Police. Organized with split staff (15) and line functions (13)
roughly modeled after the military. Headquarters at New Poenix Park in Novena. The highest rank is
Commissioner of Police and the lowest is Police Constable.
▪ Section 7 of Police Force Act of 1857 = constitution of the SPF
Recruitment/training
▪ High school graduates who were interested in law enforcement as a career can be recruited and those who
are selected for officers had to be approved by the Public Service Commission.
▪ Career development course were encouraged for officer and senior officers are required to travel oversees
for training such as in Police Staff College in Britain, FBI Nat’l Academy in US and Police Academy in Japan.
▪ Nine (9) months training. Newly appointed officer will be placed on a one year probation period.
RANKS OF SPF
Commissioner of Police = equivalent of director general in the Philippines
Constable = equivalent of Police Officer 1 in the PNP
ORGANIZATION OF NPA
1. National Public Safety Commission = a government body responsible for the administrative supervision of the
police. Under the jurisdiction of the Prime Minister
2. Japan National Police Agency (NPA) = a totally gunless police force, except for its special attack team.
3. Regional Police Bureau = exercise control and supervision over regional police offices and provides support with
the prefectural police.
Director General = heads each Regional Bureau acting upon orders from the Commission General of the
NPA.
Regional Police Bureau = the local organizations to carry out part of the NPA’s functions. There are about 7 Bureaus
in the major cities except for Tokyo and Hokkaido where in Tokyo, Metropolitan Police department (headed by
Superintendent General) has long been established and shares the same location with the NPA. Prefectural Police
has the whole of Hokkaido under its jurisdiction.
4. Prefectural Public Safety Commission (PPSC) = administrative commission functioning under the representative
system which supervise the prefectural police. Under the Jurisdiction of the Governor. Though not empowered to
give order to the Commission.
5. Koban = a system of policing adopted in Japan, a substation near major transportation hubs and shopping areas
and in residential districts which forms the first line of police response to the public.
Kinds of police
1. People’s Armed Police (PAP), 1980’s deals with domestic disturbances, acts as riot police and guard’s government
compounds and foreign embassies. Usually handles border defense but is called sometimes to back up local police.
2. State Security Police = (1983) safeguards state security, prevent foreign espionage, sabotage and conspiracies.
Under the Ministry of State Security and directly accountable to the State council.
3. Prison Police = a part of the correctional arm of the overall police system stationed in prisons and correction units.
This is under the leadership of the Ministry of Justice.
4. Judicial Police = responsible for maintaining the security and order in courts and serving instruments and some
also executing death sentences.
5. Quasi parapolice (“Cheng guan”) = operate in many places and hired by officials to help carry out some unpopular
actions such as collecting taxes and fines and ousting peasants from seized land.
Branches of UN
1. UN general Assembly = This is the main decision- making and representative assembly in the UN through its
policies and recommendations. It is composed of all member states , is headed by a president elected from the
member states, and meets from September to December
FUNCTIONS
a. Preventive Action = consist of provisional measures to prevent a conflict from worsening, and may involve the
deployment of PEACEKEEPING AND OBSERVER missions
b. Enforcement Action = consist of deployment of air, sea and land forces
Five Permanent Members of Security Council
1. China
2. France
3. Russia
4. United Kingdom
5. United States
*The other 10 members are rotating or elective members for a period of two years by the General Assembly
3. International Court of Justice = Located in the Hague, Netherlands. This branch is responsible for the judicial
matters of the UN.
4.Secretariat = Its main responsibility is providing studies, information, and other data needed
5. Economic and Social Council = consists of 45 members elected by the General Assembly for a 3 year term.
6. Trusteeship Council = assists the security council and the general assembly in the administration of the
International Trusteeship System
UN CHARTER = it is closest to a constitution that basically governs the relations of international persons. Technically,
it is a Treaty.
TREATY = an international agreement concluded between states in written form and sworn by international law,
whether embodied in a single instrument or in two or more instruments and whatever its particular designation.
INTERPOL
▪ Interpol (1923) = (International Criminal Police Organization) is the police forces organization that primarily
manifest global or international cooperation in addressing transnational crime. Its headquarters was initially
located in Vienna Austria (it is where Interpol was founded) but at present it is transferred to Lyon France.
▪ INTERPOL = is the world’s largest international police organization, with 190 member countries. It exists to
help create a safer world by supporting law enforcement agencies worldwide to combat crime.
▪ It aims to facilitate international police co-operation, and supports and assists all organizations, authorities
and services whose mission is to prevent or combat internal crime.
▪ = the organization of law enforcement agencies worldwide that serves as transmission or communication
line for the exchange of information, data and request for assistance between and among the member
countries.
▪ It focuses on: (1) Combat crimes and transnational crimes; (2) protect minorities against the dominant
groups; and (3) Maintain law enforcement regardless of race or religion.
INTERPOL’ s Structure
▪ General Assembly
▪ Executive Committee
▪ General Secretariat
▪ National Central Bureaus
▪ Advisers
▪ The Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files.
Executive Committee = consisting of 13 members elected by the General Assembly and comprises the president,
three vice –presidents and nine delegates covering the four regions.
It is the INTERPOL’s select deliberate organ which meets three times a year, usually in March, July and
immediately before the General Assembly.
9 Delegates
▪ Pieter Jaap AALBERSBERG (The Netherlands)
▪ Fath ELRAHMAN Osman (Sudan)
▪ Emmanuel GASANA (Rwanda)
▪ Francisco GIL MONTERO (Spain)
▪ Nobuyuki KAWAI (Japan)
▪ Tariq KHOSA (Pakistan)
▪ Sanna PALO (Finland)
▪ Marcos VASQUEZ MEZA (Chile)
▪ Timothy A. WILLIAMS (United States)
General Secretariat = (Lyon, France) operates 24 hours a day, 365 days a year and is run by the Secretary General. It
Works with Officials of more than 80 countries side-by-side using four official languages: Arabic, English, French and
Spanish. It consists of seven (7) regional offices across the world namely:
• Argentina,
• Cameron,
• Cote D’Ivoire,
• Kenya,
• El Salvador,
• Thailand, and
• Zimbabwe.
National Central Bureaus (NCB) = Each INTERPOL member country maintains a National Central Bureau staffed by
National law enforcement officers. The NCB is the designated contact point for the General Secretariat, regional
offices and other member countries requiring assistance with overseas investigations and the location and
apprehension of fugitives.
Advisers = these are experts in a purely advisory capacity, who may be appointed by the Executive Committee and
confirmed by the General Assembly.
Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’ File (CCF) = this is an independent body whose mandate is threefold:
(1) to ensure that the processing of personal information by INTERPOL complies with the Organization’s
regulations,
(2) to advice INTERPOL on any project, operation, set of rules or other matter concerning the information
contained in INTERPOL’S files.
INTERPOL’s Governance = comprises the General Assembly and the Executive Committee, which is headed by the
President.
The President of the Organization is elected by the General Assembly for a period of four (4) years. His role
is to chair the General Assembly and Executive Committee and ensure that INTERPOL’S activities conform with
decisions made at these meetings.
INTERPOL’S NOTICE
1. Red Notice – a notice which is issued to seek the arrest or provisional arrest of wanted persons with a view to
extradition.
2. Blue Notice – this type of notice is issued in order to locate, identify or obtain information on a person of interest
in a criminal investigation.
3. Green Notice – to warn about a person's criminal activities if that person is considered to be a possible threat to
public safety.
4. Yellow Notice – to help locate missing persons, often minors, or to help identify persons who are unable to identify
themselves.
5. Black Notice – a notice issued to seek information on unidentified bodies.
6. Orange Notice – to warn of an event, a person, an object or a process representing an imminent threat and
danger to persons or property.
7. Purple Notice – issued to provide information on modus operandi, objects, devices and concealment methods used
by criminals.
8. INTERPOL–United Nations Security Council Special Notice – is issued for individuals and entities that are subject to
UN sanctions.
The following are channels of global bilateral and multilateral international cooperation against transnational crime:
• Global multi-lateral cooperation via Interpol;
• Bilateral police cooperation agreements with individual states;
• European multilateral cooperation via Europol.
*System of policing that serves as a grass root approach to bring the people and the police together in cooperative
manners:
• Problem Oriented Policing
• Community Oriented Policing
• Cooperative Policing
• Team Policing
IMPORTANT DATES
▪ 1983 (Jakarta) = Endorsement of the model & design of ASEANAPOL logo
▪ 1984 (Kuala Lumpur) = Royal Brunei Police became a member and joined the annual conference
▪ 1996 (Kuala Lumpur) = Vietnam joined as a new member
▪ 1998 (Brunei) = Laos joined ASEANAPOL
▪ 2000 (Myanmar) = Myanmar became the 10th country to joined as a new member
▪ 2005 (Bali) = The setting up of a working group to consider the viability of establishing a permanent
ASEANAPOL Secretariat
= Silver Jubilee Commemoration of ASEANAPOL
▪ 2008 (Brunei) = The Royal Malaysia Police was chosen as a host of permanent ASEANAPOL Secretariat
▪ 2009 (Vietnam) = Adoption of Terms of Reference (TOR)
▪ 2010 = On 1st January 2010 commencement of ASEANAPOL Secretariat in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
ORANIZATION
1. ASEANAPOL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE = comprise of deputy heads of delegation attending the annual ASEANAPOL
conference. It provides a summary reports of the activities of the Secretariat to the Head of the Delegation
2. ASEANAPOL PERMANENT SECRETARIAT = is on rotational basis with member countries taking turn to host the
ASEANAPOL conference and automatically assume the role of the secretariat for the current year.
= headed by executive director and assisted by 2 directors
Tenure of Services
a. Executive Director - 2 years
b. Directors - 3 years (one for Police Services and one for Plans and Programs
*During the 29th ASEANAPOL Conference in Hanoi, Vietnam in 2009, the Terms of Reference on the
establishment of ASEANAPOL Secretariat was finally endorsed. Kuala Lumpur was made the permanent seat.
*The ASEANAPOL Secretariat started its operation fully on January 1, 2010.