m5 - Met445 - Ree - Note
m5 - Met445 - Ree - Note
m5 - Met445 - Ree - Note
Module 5
Syllabus
Bio Mass Energy- Biomass conversion technologies –Bio Gasification, Bio ethanol,
Biodiesel , Biogas production from waste biomass, factors affecting biogas
generation Bio Gas-KVIC and Janata model ,Hydrogen Energy – various routes for
production of Hydrogen energy,
Economic Analysis – Initial and annual cost, basic definitions, present worth
calculations, repayment of loan in equal annual installments, annual savings,
cumulative saving and lifecycle cost, economic analysis of add on solar system,
payback period(derivation)
INTRODUCTION
Biomass refers to solid carbonaceous material derived from plants and animals.
These include residues of agriculture and forestry, animal waste and discarded
material from food processing plants. Biomass being organic matter from terrestrial
and marine vegetation, renews naturally in a short span of time, thus, classified as a
renewable source of energy. It is a derivative of solar energy as plants grow by the
process of photosynthesis by absorbing CO2 from the atmosphere to form hexose
(dextrose, glucose, etc.) expressed by the reaction
Biomass does not add CO2 to the atmosphere as it absorbs the same amount of carbon
in growing the plants as it releases when consumed as fuel. It is a superior fuel as the
energy produced from biomass is ‘carbon cycle neutral’. Biomass fuel is used in over
90% of rural households and in about 15% urban dwellings. Agriculture products rich
in starch and sugar like wheat, maize, sugarcane can be fermented to produce ethanol
(C2H5OH). Methanol (CH3OH) is also produced by distillation of biomass that
contains cellulose like wood and bagasse. Both these alcohols can be used to fuel
vehicles and can be mixed with diesel to make biodiesel.
BIOMASS RESOURCES
1. Concentrated wastes:
Municipal solid
Sewage wood products
Industrial waste
Manure at large lots
2. Dispersed waste residue:
Renewable Energy Engineering, Mod 5, AJT, CCET Page 1
Crop residue
Logging residue
Disposed manure.
3. Harvested biomass:
Standing biomass
Biomass energy plantations
The biomass sources are highly dispersed and bulky and contain large amount of
water (50 to 90%). Thus, it is not economical to transport them over long distances,
and as such conversion into usable energy must take place close to the source, which
is limited to particular regions. However, biomass can be converted to liquid or
gaseous fuels, thereby increasing its energy density and making transportation
feasible over long distances.
BIOMASS Classification
Biomass resources for energy production are widely available in forest areas, rural
farms, urban refuse and organic waste from agro-industries. India produces over 550
million tonnes of agricultural and agro-industrial residues every year. Similarly, 290
million cattle population produces about 438 million tonnes of dung annually.
Energy crops
Energy farming refers to the cultivation of fast growing plants which supply fuel
wood, biomass that can be converted into gaseous and liquid fuels like biogas,
vegetable oil and alcohol. To harvest biomass for power generation, energy plantation
is done on degraded or wastelands which are saline, wind eroded lands in arid areas
and water-logged lands.
Energy farming is promoted by MNRE in nine different agro-climate regions,
namely, Garhwal (U.P.), Gwalpahar (Haryana), Udaipur (Rajasthan) and
Shantiniketan (West Bengal).The other four centres are Madurai (Tamil Nadu),
Calicut (Kerala), Raipur (Chhattisgarh), Bhubaneswar (Orissa). These centres
produce quality seedlings of about 35 tree species through clonal propagation. These
fast growing fuel wood species produce 20–25 tonnes of biomass per hectare per
year. The Biomass Research Centre Lucknow found the ‘Kubabul’ tree that grows
well on saline and rocky soils, provides wood of high calorific value
(4500 kcal/kg).
Animal waste
Animal waste, an organic material with combustible property, is a rich source of fuel.
Dung cakes prepared with animal waste are used for cooking in rural and semi-urban
areas. It is also a raw material for biogas plants.
Urban waste
Urban waste is of two types: (i) Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) which includes
human excreta, household garbage and commercial waste. (ii) Liquid Waste from
domestic sewage and effluents from institutional activities.
As per MNRE estimate about 42 million tonnes of solid waste (1.15 lakh tonnes per
day) and 6000 million cubic metres of liquid waste are generated every year in urban
areas. At present MSW is dumped in sanitary landfill, where fuel gas is produced
which is a valuable source of renewable energy. Sewage is suitably processed to
produce biogas.
Industrial waste
Energy recovery from industrial waste was taken up in 1994. Projects are
implemented with technical assistance of national laboratories. Projects developed
under this programme are:
Pulp and Paper Industry Effluent, Starch and Glucose Industry Waste, Palm Oil
Industry, Distillary Waste and Tanneries Waste. Each project is aimed to treat its
waste for the production of bio-energy which can be used for power generation.
Charcoal
Charcoal is a smokeless dry solid fuel with high energy density. Modern charcoal
retorts (furnaces) operate at about 600°C to produce charcoal from 25–35% of dry
biomass feed. It contains 75–80% carbon and is useful as a compact fuel. It can be
burnt to provide heat for domestic, commercial and industrial applications.
Briquetting
Biomass briquetting is densification of loose biomass into a high density solid fuel.
Biomass of any form such as cotton sticks, rice husk, coconut shells, saw dust and
wood chips can be converted into briquetts. It reduces the volume-to-weight ratio,
thus making transportation easy for efficient commercial and industrial use. The
calorific value is about 3500 kcal /kg. Biomass briquettes can replace ‘C’ grade coal
used in industrial boilers.
Vegetable oil
Vegetable oils such as rapeseed, palm, coconut and cotton seed oil can substitute
diesel as engine fuel. Jajoba trees cultivated in marginal lands produce oil seeds.
Jajoba oil is considered liquid gold like crude oil as it can be processed into a wide
range of products like motor oil, lubricants, mono-unsaturated alcohols and oil of
cosmetic value. Euphorbia species produce latex which after water removal gives
light hydrocarbon oil.
BIOGAS
Biogas can be produced by digestion of animal, plant and human waste. Digestion is
a biological process that takes place in a digester with anaerobic organism in absence
of oxygen at a temperature between 35°C and 70°C. In rural areas, household biogas
plants operate from cow and buffalo dung which provides gas for cooking and
lighting. Biogas is a mixture of CH4 (55% to 65%), CO2 (30% to 40%), H2, H2S and
N2 (< 10%) having a calorific value between5000 and 5500 kcal / kg.
PRODUCER GAS
Producer gas is obtained by partial combustion of wood or any cellulose organic
material of plant origin. It is a mixture of a few gases and its constituents are CO2
Biomass Densification
Drying: Low moisture results in improved density and durability of the fuel. For most
biomass densification processes, the optimum moisture content is in the range of 8%–
20% (wet basis). Most compaction techniques require a small amount of moisture to
"soften" the biomass for compaction. Above the optimum moisture level, the strength
and durability of the densified biomass are decreased.
Addition of a Binding Agent: The density and durability of densified biomass are
influenced by the natural binding agents of the material. The binding capacity
increases with a higher protein and starch content. Binding agents may be added to
the material to increase binding properties. Commonly used binders include vegetable
oil, clay, starch, cooking oil or wax.
Steaming: The addition of steam prior to densification can aid in the release and
activation of natural binders present in the biomass.
Mechanical Densification
The method of densification depends on the type of residues and the local situation.
Many non woody bio mass suffers from major disadvantage of having low bulk
densities for efficient utilization. In physical method of conversion, biomass is
densified into solid briquettes or pellets.
Pellets: Pellets are very high in density. They are easier to handle than other densified
biomass products, since infrastructure for grain handling is used for pellets. Pellets
are formed by an extrusion process, using a piston press, where finely ground
biomass material is forced through round or square cross-sectional dies and cut to a
desired length. The standard shape of a biomass pellet is a cylinder, having a length
smaller than 38 mm (1.5 in.) and a diameter around 7 mm (0.3 in.).
Cubes: Cubes are larger pellets, usually square in shape. Cubes are less dense than
pellets. Cube sizes range from 13–38 mm (0.5–1.5 in.) in cross section, with a length
ranging 25–102 mm (1–4 in.). The process involves compressing chopped biomass
with a heavy press wheel, followed by forcing the biomass through dies to produce
cubes.
Pucks: They are produced using a briquetter and are resilient to moisture. Pucks have
a similar density as pellets, with the advantage that they require lower production
costs compared to pelletization.
Combustion
Combustion is the process of burning in presence of oxygen to produce heat (utilised
for cooking, space heating, industrial purposes and for electricity generation), light
and by-products. The combustion of biomass is more difficult than other fuels since it
contains relatively higher moisture content. Biomass is free from toxic metals and its
ash. This method is very inefficient with heat losses to 30 to 90% of the original
energy contained in the biomass.
Incineration
Incineration is the process of burning completely the solid biomass to ashes by high
temperature oxidation. The terms incineration and combustion are synonymous, but
the process of combustion is applicable to all fuels, i.e., solid, liquid and gaseous.
Incineration is a special process where the dry Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) is
incinerated to reduce the volume of solid refuse (90%) and to produce heat, steam
and electricity. Waste incineration plants are installed in large cities to dispose off
urban refuse and generate energy. It constitutes a furnace with adequate supply of air
to ensure complete combustion upto a capacity of 1000 tonnes/day.
Incineration is a waste treatment process that involves
the combustion of organic substances contained in waste materials. Incineration and
Thermo-chemical conversion
It is a process to decompose biomass with various combinations of temperatures and
pressures. Thermo-chemical conversion takes the following two forms:
(i) Gasification
(ii) Liquefaction
.
Gasification
It is the process of heating the biomass with limited oxygen to produce 'low heating
value' or by reacting it with steam and oxygen at high pressure and temperature to
produce 'medium heating value gas'. The output gas is known as "producer gas", a
mixture of H2 (15-20%), CO (10 to 20%), CH4 (1 to 5%), CO2 (9 to 12%) and N2 (45
to 55%). As compared to solid mass the gas is more versatile; it can be burnt to
produce heat and steam, or used in I.C. engines or gas turbines to generate electricity.
Liquefaction
Biomass can be liquefied through fast or flash pyrolysis, called "pyrolytic oil" which
is a dark brown liquid of low viscosity and a mixture of hydrocarbons. Pyrolysis
liquid is a good substitute for heating oil. Biomass can also be liquefied by "methanol
synthesis". Gasification of biomass produces synthetic gas containing a mixture of H2
and CO. The gas is purified by adjusting the composition of H2 and CO. Finally, the
purified gas is subjected to liquefaction process, converted to methanol over a zinc,
chromium catalyst. Methanol can be used as liquid fuel.
Pyrolysis
Biomass is heated in absence of oxygen, or partially combusted in a limited oxygen
supply, to produce a hydrocarbon, rich in gas mixture (H2, CO2, CO CH4 and lower
hydrocarbons), an oil like liquid and a carbon rich solid residue (charcoal).
The pyrolitic or ‘bio-oil’ produced can easily be transported and refined into a series
of products similar to refining crude oil. There is no waste product, the conversion
efficiency is high (82%) depending upon the feedstock used, the process temperature
in reactor and the fuel/air ratio during combustion.
BIOCHEMICAL CONVERSION
There are two forms of biochemical conversions:
1. Anaerobic digestion
2. Ethanol fermentation
Anaerobic Digestion
This process involves 'microbial digestion' of biomass and is done in the 'absence of
oxygen'. The process and end products depend upon the micro-organisms cultivated
under culture conditions. (An anaerobe is a microscopic organism that can live and
grow without external oxygen or air; it extracts oxygen by decomposing the biomass
at low temperatures upto 65°C, in presence of moisture). This process generates
mostly methane (CH4) and CO2 gas with small impurities such as hydrogen sulphide.
The output gas obtained from anaerobic digestion can be directly burnt, or
upgraded to superior fuel gas (methane) by removal of CO2 and other
impurities. The residue may consist of protein-rich sludge and liquid effluents
which can be used as animal feed or for soil treatment after certain processing.
Ethanol Fermentation
Fermentation is the process of decomposition of organic matter by micro-organisms
especially bacteria and yeasts. It is a well established and widely used technology for
the conversion of grains and sugar crops into ethanol (ethyl alcohol). Ethanol can be
produced by decomposition of biomass containing sugar like sugarcane, cassava
sweet sorghum, beet, potato, corn, grape, etc. into sugar molecules such as glucose
(C6H12O6) and sucrose (C12H22O11).
Ethanol fermentation involves biological conversion of sugar into ethanol and CO2.
Ethanol can be blended with gasoline (petrol) to produce gasohol (90% petrol and
10% ethanol).
Gasifiers
Gasifiers (essentially a chemical reactor) is an equipment which can gasify a variety
of biomass such as wood waste, agricultural waste like stalks, and roots of various
crops, maize cobs etc. In a gasifier, the biomass (as it flows) gets dried, heated,
pyrolysed, partially oxidised and reduced.
Classification of gasifiers :
Biomass gasifiers may be classified as follows:
In such a gasifier (where fuel and air move in counter current manner) air enters
below the combustion zone and the 'producer gas' leaves near the top of the gasifier.
The gas produced contains tar and water vapour and the ash content is almost nil.
These gasifiers are suitable for stationary engines (which use tar free fuels like
charcol).
Cross draft gasification is one of the simplest types of gasification; the reactor for this
gasification is much like the updraft gasifier in that the fuel will enter from the top
and the thermo-chemical reaction will occur progressively as this fuel descends into
the reactor. The crucial difference is that the air will be entering the gasifier from the
side of the reactor, rather than from the top or the bottom. The start-up time for this
reactor is relatively short, and high temperatures can be attained using this type of
gasification.
In this type of gasifier, the gas produced passes upwards in the annular space around
the gasifier that is filled with charcoal. The charcoal acts as an insulator and a dust
filter. These gasifiers are suitable for power generation upto 50 kW.
Cross draft gasification isn’t seen very often in commercial processes mainly because
other gasification methods offer more flexibility with respect to fuel types; this type
of gasification doesn’t handle fuel that has a high tar content and bridging can be a
consequence of the particle size of the fuel.
BIOGAS
The main source for biogas is wet cattle dung.
Some of the other sources are:
Sewage
Crop residue
Vegetable wastes
Water hyacinth
Alga
Poultry droppings
Pig-manure
Ocean kelp
It is a clean but slow-burning gas and usually has a heating value about 18 kJ/m3. It
can be used directly in cooking, reducing the demand for firewood.
When functioning well, the bacteria convert about 90% of the feedstock energy
content into biogas (containing about 55% methane), which is a readily useable
energy source for cooking and lighting. The sludge produced after the manure has
passed through the digester is non-toxic and odourless. Also, it has lost relatively
little of its nitrogen or other nutrients during the digestion process thus, making a
good fertiliser.
Biogas Applications
Biogas is a flammable fuel gas usually with 60% CH, and rest CO2. The gas can be
upgraded by removal of CO2 with water scrubbing and the gas with high heating
value can be used in I.C. engine.
The main applications of biogas are:
Cooking.
Domestic lighting and heating.
I.C. engines.
Fuel cells-electricity can be produced by using biogas in a fuel cell with air
oxidant. The electrolyte is usually potassium hydroxide (KOH).
Biogas Technology
Biogas is produced from wet biomass through a biological conversion process that
involves bacterial breakdown of organic matter by micro-organisms to produce CH4,
CO2 and H2O. Theprocess is known as ‘anaerobic digestion’ which proceeds in three
steps.
1. Hydrolysis (Stage 1)
2. Acid formation (Stage 2)
3. Methane formation (Stage 3)
Hydrolysis
In this stage, the complex compounds, such as fats, proteins and carbohydrates are
broken into small size compounds through the effluence of water and enzymes called
"Hydrolysis". The rate of hydrolysis depends on bacterial concentration, quality of
substrate, pH (between 6 and 7) and temperature (30°C–40°C) of digester contents.
Acid formation
Decomposed simple organic material is acted upon by acetogenic bacteria and
converted into simple acetic acid.
In this stage, the soluble glucose and nutrients are converted into simpler volatile
fatty acid and acetic acid as byproduct, which accounts for 70 per cent of methane
by-product with the help of acid forming bacteria.
Reaction of acidification:
Methane formation
During this stage, the methane producing bacteria converts the organic acid into
biogas having its main constituent as "methane".
Reactions of methane formation:
The methane content of biogas is about 60% which provides a high calorific value to
find use in cooking, lighting and power generation.
Solid-to-water ratio
Cattle dung (gobar) contains about 18% solid matter and the remaining 82% is water.
Anaerobic fermentation proceeds at a faster rate if the slurry contains about 9% solid
matter. Digester feed is prepared by mixing water in the ratio 1: 1 by weight to reduce
the solid content. To increase the solid matter, crop residues and weed plants may be
mixed with the feed stock.
Normally, 7 to 9 parts of solid in 100 parts of the slurry is considered ideal. It is
recommended that 4 parts of the cattle dung to be mixed with 5 parts of water.
Temperature
Temperature affects bacterial activity; methane formation is optimum in the
temperature range 35°–38°C. Biogas production decreases below 20°C and stops at
8°C. In cold regions a solar canopy is built over the biogas plants to maintain the
desired temperature.
In hot regions, another micro-organism called ‘thermophilic’ is utilised for anaerobic
fermentation in the temperature range 55°C– 60°C. Gas production rises with the
increase in average ambient air temperature. As the temperature increases, the total
retention period decreases and vice-versa. However, the total gas production remains
practically the same. The rate of gas production 'increases' with the increase in
temperature but the percentage of methane 'decreases'.
Seeding
Cattle dung contains both acid forming bacteria and methane forming bacteria. Acid
forming bacteria multiply fast, while the methane forming bacteria grow slowly. To
Renewable Energy Engineering, Mod 5, AJT, CCET Page 18
start and accelerate fermentation, seeding of methane forming bacteria is required.
Accordingly, a small quantity of digested slurry rich in methane-forming bacteria is
added to freshly charged digester.
pH value
pH denotes the acidity and alkalinity of the substrate. The pH less than 7 is called
'acidic' and pH more than 7 is called 'alkaline' and pH solution of 7 is called 'neutral'.
Measure of pH value indicates the concentration of hydrogen ions. Micro-organisms
are sensitive to pH of the digested slurry. For optimum biogas production, pH can be
varied between 6.8 and 7.8. At pH of 6.2, acid conditions prevail which restrain the
growth of methanogenic bacteria. Control on pH should be exercised by adding alkali
when it drops below 6.6.
Nutrients concentration
The major nutrients required by the bacteria in the digester are C, H2, O2, N2, P and S.
To maintain proper balance of nutrients an extra raw material, rich in P and N2,
should be added along with cattle dung to obtain maximum gas production.
Toxic substance
The presence of ammonia, pesticides, detergents and heavy metals are considered as
toxic substances to micro-organisms, since their presence reduces fermentation rate.
Retention time
The period for which the biomass slurry is retained inside the digester is called
‘retention time’. This period ranges from 30 days to 50 days depending upon the
climatic conditions. Generally it is observed that maximum gas production takes
place within 'first four weeks' and it tapers off gradually.
It refers to the volume of digester divided by the volume of slurry added per day.
Thus, a 120 litre digester which is fed at 5 litres per day would have a retention time
of 24 days. It is optimized to achieve 80% complete digestion considering ambient
temperature.
BIOGAS PLANTS
Biogas plants converts’ wet biomass into biogas (methane) by the process of
"anaerobic fermentation". The bacteria called "anaerobe" carrier out digestion of
biomass without oxygen and produces methane (CH4) and carbon dioxide (CO2).
The biogas plant is a device that converts cattle dung and other organic matter into
inflammable gas called biogas and into good quality organic manure under anaerobic
conditions.
2. Gas holder. Its function is to keep the gas for subsequent use. The gas connection
for use is taken from the top of the gas holder. In some designs of biogas plants, it
may be separable from the digester whereas in other designs it may be an integral
part of the digester.
3. Inlet. An inlet is provided to add the mixture of dung and water to the digester,
and is sloped accordingly.
4. Outlet. The provision of an outlet is made to take out the digested portion of
slurry.
5. Slurry mixing tank. This tank carries out mixing of the dung with water for
induction in the digester, through the inlet.
6. Gas outlet pipe. It is used for taking out gas from the gas holder and is connected
to its top. The other end of the pipe is connected with the device using biogas.
Gas holder
The gas holder is a drum constructed of mild steel sheets. This is cylindrical in shape
with concave. The top is supported radically with angular iron. The holder fits into
the digester like a stopper. It sinks into the slurry due to its own weight and rests
upon the ring constructed for this purpose. When gas is generated the holder rises and
floats freely on the surface of slurry. A central guide pipe is provided to prevent the
holder from tilting. The holder also acts as a seal for the gas.
Advantages:
Gas pressure is constant.
Less scum problem.
No danger of explosion since there is no possibility of mixing of biogas and
external air.
No gas leakage problem.
Disadvantages:
High cost.
High maintenance cost.
There is a loss of heat through gas holder.
The outlet pipe, which should be flexible, requires regular attention
The design of this plant is of Chinese origin but it has been introduced under the
name “Janata biogas plant” by Gobar Gas Research Station, Ajitmal in view of its
reduced cost. This is a plant where no steel is used, there is no moving part in it and
maintenance cost is low. This model have a higher capacity when compared with
KVIC model, hence it can be used as a community biogas plant. This design has
longer life than KVIC models. Substrates other than cattle dung such as municipal
waste and plant residues can also be used in janata type plants.
Constructional features.
This plant consists of the following parts:
1. Foundation
2. Digester
3. Dome
4. Inlet Chamber
5. Outlet Chamber.
6. Mixing Tank
7. Gas outlet pipe.
Foundation: The foundation is the amply compacted base of the digester made of
cement concrete and brick ballast. Its construction is so carried out that it may
provide a stable foundation to the digester walls and bear full load of slurry filled in
the digester. It should be waterproof so that no percolation or water leakage takes
place.
Digester: It is underground cylindrical wall portion made of bricks, sand and cement.
It is this place where fermentation of dung takes place. It is also sometimes called
Dome: It is a hemispherical roof of the digester; has a fixed height and forms the
critical part in the construction of Janata gobar gas plant. The gas gets collected in the
space of the dome and exerts pressure on the slurry in the digester.
Inlet chamber: An inlet chamber has a bell mouth shape and is made of bricks,
cement and sand. It has its top opening at the ground level. Its outlet wall is made
inclined/slopy to enable the daily cattle dung feed to move easily into the digester.
Outlet chamber: It is that part of the plant through which digested slurry moves out
of the digester at a predetermined height. It has a small rectangular cross-section and
above this it becomes larger to a defined height. For easy cleaning of the digester two
steps are provided in it which enables a man to climb down. Its top opening is also at
the ground level. Just near the top opening is provided a small outlet through which
the digested/spent slurry flows to a compost pit.
Mixing tank: It is this tank where dung and water are mixed properly in the ratio of
1:1 to make slurry which is then poured into the inlet chamber.
Gas outlet pipe: It is a small piece of G.I. Pipe which is fitted at the top of the dome
for conveying the gas to the points of use. A valve is fitted at its end to regulate the
flow of gas to the gas connections.
Working: Cattle dung slurry prepared in 1: 1 ratio with water is fed upto the level of
second step in the outlet tank. As the gas generates and accumulates in the empty
portion of the plant, it presses the slurry of the digester and displaces it into the outlet
'displacement chamber'. The slurry level in the digester falls whereas in the outlet
chamber it starts rising. This fall and rise continues till the level in the digester
reaches the upper end of the outlet opening and at this stage the slurry level in the
outer tank reaches the height of discharge opening.
Gas outlet pipe: A nipple is fitted on the top of the dome, which is connected to a
GI pipe. The gas reaches the kitchen through this pipe.
Inlet: The pipe through which fresh dung and water enters the plant is called Inlet
pipe. This pipe is connected to a small tank for mixing dung and water.
Outlet: The portion of the plant where the slurry accumulates after coming out of
the digester is called outlet tank. It is in two parts. The first bottom part is small
and rectangular, which is connected to the dome opening, while the other part of
outlet tank is dome shaped. A small slurry discharge hole is provided in the outlet
tank. The volume of the dome upto the hole is equivalent to the gas storage
volume. Only the amount of gas equivalent to this volume can be used in a burner
or lamp. The main function of this part is to provide pressure for release of gas
from the dome. The level of slurry rises upto the outlet hole in this tank when the
plant is full with gas.
Advantages:
This plant requires less space being mainly underground.
Its cost is reduced as the surface area is minimised by joining segments of two
different diameter spheres at their bases.
It is 30 per cent economical as compared to Janata biogas plant.
An economic analysis can also provide a calculation of total cost of a project over its
lifetime and it allows a cost comparison of competing projects and technologies.
A project may involve a capital or initial cost and operating and maintenance (O&M)
costs. The capital cost is an account of the initial investment, and it may include labor
and other expenses occurring at the start of the project. Operating and maintenance
costs are due to expenses to keep the system running in proper conditions over its
lifetime. O&M costs can be fixed (such as regular maintenance costs) or variable
depending on the use of a commodity (such as electricity cost of operating an electric
motor). The sale value of the system at the end of its lifetime is called salvage value
or scrap value. The total cost of a system is sum of the capital and O&M costs. This
total should be obtained considering the changes in the value of the money by time.
The cash flow during the life of a project can be indicated by a cash flow diagram as
shown below. The horizontal line gives time series in years, and the vertical arrows
show the cash flows. There is n number of years. The negative arrows indicate
expenditures and positive arrows indicate incomes. At time zero, the capital cost
occurs. Annual expenditures such as operating and maintenance costs occur at each
time interval. The salvage value represents an income that occurs at the end of the
lifetime of the system.
Simple Interest
Simple Interest (S.I.) is the method of calculating the interest amount for a particular
principal amount of money at some rate of interest.
To calculate the SI for a certain amount of money (P), rate of interest (R) and time
(T), the formula is:
SI = (PTR)/100
Here,
Where,
Amount (A) is the total money paid back at the end of the time period for which it
was borrowed.
The total amount formula in case of simple interest can also be written as:
A = P(1 + RT)
Here,
Compound Interest
Compound interest is the interest calculated on the principal and the interest
accumulated over the previous period. It is different from simple interest, where
interest is not added to the principal while calculating the interest during the next
period.
Let P represent the present value of money and F the single future value of money.
What is the value of a present amount of money in a future time? Let i represent the
As an example of the use of Eq. (A), assume you deposit $1000 in a bank account
that pays an annual interest rate of 6 percent. What is the value of this amount in 4
years?
What happens if the money is compounded monthly instead of annually? In this case,
the monthly interest rate is i = 0.06/12 = 0.005, and the number of time period is n =
4 × 12 = 48. Then, from Eq. (A),
The difference in future value of money for annual and monthly compounding cases
is negligible for most applications.
In today’s world we deal with problems that involve annual/monthly equal payments
such as home mortgage payments, vehicle loans or loans for consumer electronic
goods. The following relationships hold good for problems involving such uniform
series:
The periodic income or expenditure is called uniform series amount, and denoted by
U. It may be expressed as a function of the present value as
………………………………..(B)
………………………………..(C)
………………………………..(D)
The life cycle cost can be evaluated in different ways. The net present value method
is based on expressing all expenses and benefits that will occur over the lifetime of
the project on the present time basis P. Summing all the benefits and subtracting from
the expenses on the present time gives the net present value of the project. The
greater the positive value or the smaller the negative value represents a desirable
project from an economic point of view.
The life cycle cost of a project can also be calculated using the levelized annual cost
(or levelized annual value) method. The net cost (or benefit) of the project is
expressed by equal annual amounts over the lifetime of the project. Each
benefit/expense of the project occurring at different times is expressed by a uniform
series amount U. The net value of U is calculated by adding benefits and subtracting
expenses on an annual basis.
Cost-Benefit Analysis
In general, a project option may involve costs and benefits in economic terms. Some
projects only involve costs with no monetary benefits. For example, the installation
of an environmental control technology requires cost consumption but it may not
yield any monetary benefit. The benefits in this case are due to reduction in certain
pollutants. Of course, indirect economic benefits of reducing pollutants are not
accounted for.
A life cost analysisresults in the total cost of the project expressed in present term or
annual cost term. Renewable energy projects are beneficial to the environment but
they are also intended to be financially attractive to the investors. Therefore, the
economic benefits are expected to outweigh the cost of the project.
A comparison of benefits and costs associated with a project can be made using a
cost-benefit analysis. The net present value calculated by adding all the benefits and
subtracting from all the expenses at present time basis is used to determine whether
the project is acceptable.
If this ratio is greater than unity, the project is acceptable. If it is less than unity, it is
unacceptable.
Of course, the unknown here is the number of years n, which is equal to the payback
period ndpb. Solving for the payback period, we obtain
Here, P is the present value of the total cost of the project and its calculation, in
addition to capital cost, may involve operating and maintenance expenses and salvage
value of the investment, U represents annual savings due to the project, and i is the
interest rate. This payback period is called discounted payback periodndpb because the
time value of money is considered.
In most engineering applications, the time value of the money is neglected and a
simple payback period is calculated from
Here, “Investment” represents the total cost of the project, and it is the simple sum of
all the costs associated with the project over its lifetime. Usually only initial cost is
considered. Again U represents annual savings. It can be shown that the simple
payback period nspb is shorter than the discounted payback period ndpb, and thus it
underestimates the actual value. As the interest rate gets smaller, the difference
between the two payback periods also gets smaller. The simple payback period nspb is
primarily used in engineering calculations, and the discounted payback period ndpb is
rarely used.
Prepared By