DP Unit Planner

Teacher(s) TOK PLC Subject group and course IB CORE

THEORY OF KNOWLEDGE

Course part and topic UNIT 2: KNOWLEDGE AND HISTORY SL or HL/Year 1 or 2 Year 2 Dates 4 Weeks

Unit description and texts DP assessment(s) for unit

This unit focuses on the required Area of Knowledge: History. It will reflect Individual Essay Assignment: Write an essay that addresses one of three
the following TOK Aims: prompts that are based on KQs.
1. Discuss this statement: It is impossible to know who we are
1. Exposing students to ambiguity and uncertainty. without knowledge of the past.
2. Encourage students to be more aware of their own perspectives 2. Discuss this statement: It is unfair to judge the people and
and reflect critically on their own beliefs and assumptions. actions of the past by the standards of today.
3. Engage students with multiple perspectives. 3. Discuss this statement: Imagination is more important in
4. Prompt students to consider the importance of values, history than in any other area of knowledge.
responsibilities and ethical concerns relating to this AOK.

All texts can be found on the detailed planning document linked in the
Resources section at the end of this planner.

INQUIRY: establishing the purpose of the unit

Transfer goals

List here one to three big, overarching, long-term goals for this unit. Transfer goals are the major goals that ask students to “transfer” or apply their
knowledge, skills, and concepts at the end of the unit under new/different circumstances, and on their own without scaffolding from the teacher.

DP UNIT PLANNER 1
 Students will be able to apply their learning in this unit to constructing a balanced response to a Knowledge Question that is based on one of three
aspects of Knowledge and History.

ACTION: teaching and learning through inquiry

Content/skills/concepts—essential understandings Learning process

Highlight any pedagogical approaches used during the unit. Aim for a variety
of approaches to help facilitate learning.

Students will know the following content: Learning experiences and strategies/planning for self-supporting learning:

A basic definition of history and the challenges in finding certainty in ● Lecture

historical study.
● Socratic
The role of bias in historical interpretation, as well as how seminar
multiperspectivity can help to filter the bias. Small
group/pair
The difference between historical research and historiography, and how
work
historiography helps to filter bias.
● PowerPoint
The ethical issues of revisionist history, as well as the personal and shared
lecture/notes
factors that determine what is prioritized in historical instruction.
Individual
Students will develop the following skills: presentations
Group
presentations

DP UNIT PLANNER 2
Students will be able to examine historical events critically, identifying bias Student
and limitations. lecture/leading
Interdisciplinary
Students will be able to discern aspects of history that are factual in learning
comparison to those that are interpretative.
Details:
Students will be able to discern the ways in which historical knowledge is
prioritized based on both personal and shared influences. SCOPE
Students will grasp the following concepts:
● What is history? What are its parameters?
● Paired activity: what do you think should count as history and
Historical knowledge is based on facts and truth, but is also influenced by
bias and personal/shared priorities. what should not? (make a T-chart)
● Evaluate the definition provided. What are the limitations to
Our historical knowledge establishes our shared context of the world. what is considered historical knowledge?
● Discuss as a class what, then, should be placed in
There are multiple perspectives that contribute to a full understanding of
historical events and people and time periods. ● The realm of “history”--there is no need to come to a definitive
answer.

● What creates challenges in gaining certainty about history?

● Video: The Problem of History

● https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-PEVe7mHI 0
● Review of ethical theories + paired evaluation of questionable
research (short presentation)

Discussion: Is certainty about the past more difficult to attain than certainty
about the present or the future? (students will discuss as pairs or groups,
then return to whole class to share their ideas)
o Individual Homework:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ba5_3b_pkVig
B1E RucqV088YZLXKSrcmndz92I1-tK0/edit?usp=sharing

DP UNIT PLANNER 3
 PERSPECTIVE
● Discuss Homework to Segue to Perspective:
○ It could be argued that certainty is based on objective
knowledge.
○ Results in the need to determine which aspects of history
are objective, and which are subjective.

● Paired activity: shared and personal knowledge--factors that

might influence the perspective of an historian.
● So what parts of history are objective?
● Reading: Understanding the Role of Bias and Sources
○ After completing the reading, students will discuss with
their partner how facts in history are different from
interpretations. Students will prepare to share their
conclusions with the whole class.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1iiHz2H3OkKEiYZgJ7
gUPjBeXQPVGN98Sj7Oe4aoma10/edit?usp=sharing

● Video: History on Trial - Deborah Lipstadt and the fight for historical
truth https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A5PREFWXTgI&t=151s
○ The idea that all history is relative just doesn’t hold, but
perspective does play an important role in how we view
events and people from the past.
● Activity: Point of View vs. Multiperspectivity
○ Discuss the difference between Point of View
and Multiperspectivity
○ Students will pair up and evaluate a set of
documents using both approaches, and will
consider what kinds of questions a
Multiperspectivity approach presents that a

DP UNIT PLANNER 4
 Point of View approach does not.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1o3WLtK
EzsAWKwd
vxFDH9PenqlBg8mp7-twkk-cJqQE0/edit?usp=sh
aring

METHODS AND TOOLS

● In order to deal with issues that result from perspective

and/or bias, historians utilize historiography techniques.
● Historical Research vs. Historiography
● Historical Research:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OQqiNyQVfy c&t=4s
● Historiography:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pB3xb1_gp4 Y
● Ways to be impartial in the study of history (Power Point)
Textbook Passage Activity: Example passage from textbook:
how impartial is this?
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kmENPKQKnz_aI54
ExOVxZVpVckLyIs-I514GQNBBXbc/edit?usp=sharing

ETHICS

● So considering the perils of bias, and the difficulty of being

impartial--even in a textbook--what ethical issues do we need
to keep in mind in regards to the study of history?
● Is it ethical to “revise” history? (Power Point)
● Influence of politics on how history is interpreted.
● Revisionist History Activity
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1m6mgHbTxWyNpy
GWFuVWC8vDyLeKrjiHGzhWndLwVAEY/edit?usp=sharing

DP UNIT PLANNER 5
 ● Who determines the version of history we hear?
● Who gets to be a “hero” and what is determined an
“atrocity?”
● Influence of Texas or California on US textbooks--NY Times
comparison
● https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KPyEXPYP
rGCGvkMpzEmDOQMMJJfsZowCwwB-1ANL1CA/e dit?usp=sharing

Formative assessment:

● Comparison chart of certainty in history vs. natural science

● Review of documents from a point of view approach vs.
multiperspectivity approach.
● Evaluation of textbook passage to determine level of
impartiality
● Evaluation of revisionist history examples.

Summative assessment:

Individual Essay Assignment: Write an essay that addresses one of three

prompts that are based on KQs.

1. Discuss this statement: It is impossible to know who we are

without knowledge of the past.
2. Discuss this statement: It is unfair to judge the people and actions
of the past by the standards of today.
3. Discuss this statement: Imagination is more important in history
than in any other area of knowledge.

DP UNIT PLANNER 6
 https://docs.google.com/document/d/1fS1l3cqL_3k88a6HA9UdsJX3kZ0
CaW5iSKn64HdWqlc/edit?usp=sharing

Differentiation:

Affirm identity—build
self-esteem Value prior
knowledge

Scaffold learning
Extend learning

Details: This unit will extend the learning that all students have already
received in their IB HOTA classes, taking the skills and knowledge they have
gained through their history instruction and viewing it through a different
lens.

Approaches to learning (ATL)

Highlight any explicit approaches to learning connections made during the unit. For more information on ATL, please
see the guide.

Thinking Social
Communication Self-management Research

Details: Students will not only reflect on their own perspectives of history, but practice analyzing and evaluating the perspectives of others by
differentiating and critiquing historical knowledge as it is presented in the world.

DP UNIT PLANNER 7
Language and learning TOK connections CAS connections
Highlight any explicit language and learning Highlight any explicit TOK connections made Highlight any explicit CAS connections. Provide a
connections made during the unit. For more during the unit. brief note in the “details” section explaining how
information on the IB’s approach to language and students engaged in CAS for this unit, if
learning, please see the guide. applicable.

Activating background Personal and shared knowledge Creativity

knowledge Scaffolding for new Ways of knowing Activity
learning Areas of knowledge Service
The knowledge framework
Acquisition of new learning through practice Details:
Demonstrating proficiency Details:
N/A
Details: N/A

Details: In this unit students will be reading

various passages, as well as conducting their own
research in order to evaluate the use of language
in the context of historical knowledge.

Resources
List and link (if applicable) any resources used in this unit.

Resources linked above.

REFLECTION: considering the planning, process and impact of the inquiry

DP UNIT PLANNER 8
What worked well What didn’t work well Notes/changes/suggestions:
List the portions of the unit (content, assessment, List the portions of the unit (content, assessment, List any notes, suggestions, or considerations for
planning) that were successful planning) that were not as successful as hoped the future teaching of this unit

DP UNIT PLANNER 9