Harvesting Colors

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 29

Department of Education

Region VI – Western Visayas


Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

HARVESTING THE RAINBOW: EXPLORING SUSTAINABLE CRAYON CRAFTING


WITH NATURAL AND ORGANIC PIGMENTS

A Research Proposal Presented to


the Senior High School Faculty
Balasan National High School
Balasan, Iloilo

In Partial Fulfillment of the


Requirements for Practical Research 2 – Quantitative Research
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Adaniel, Brant A.
Agustin, Angela
Berbana, Cleo Marie P.
Biona, Janwin L.
Daga-as, Sid A.
Fuentes, Regine B.
Gabo, Jhon Xander J.
Gonzales, Irish Shane M.
Maningo, Sofia Paula
Quillan, Kristine Mae V.
Valenzuela, John Paul S.

August 2023
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Chapter 1

INTRODUCTION

Background of the Study

Crayons are a popular art supply for children of all ages. They are easy to use

and can be used to create a variety of colorful artworks. However, traditional crayons

are made with wax and petroleum products, which can be harmful to the environment

and human health. Children are particularly vulnerable to the health risks associated

with crayons. When children ingest crayon wax, it can cause stomach upset, vomiting,

and diarrhea. Additionally, inhaling crayon dust can irritate the respiratory system and

lead to breathing problems.

Crayons are an important educational tool for young children. They help children

to learn about colors, develop their fine motor skills, and express their creativity. The

researchers propose to use Coconut wax, a natural, renewable resource that is

healthier and safer to use for crayon making than paraffin and beeswax. Paraffin wax is

a petroleum product that is non-renewable and can produce harmful fumes when

burned. Beeswax is a natural product, but it can be difficult to obtain sustainably.

Coconut wax, on the other hand, is a renewable resource that is produced without the

use of pesticides or herbicides. Coconut wax is also harder than Paraffin wax, this

means that coconut wax crayons are less likely to break or crumble.

1
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

For color red, orange, yellow, blue, violet, and green, the researchers will use

annatto seeds, carrots, turmeric, blue ternate, and moringa. When producing the brown

color, the researchers will mix red and green. Eco-lors Crayons offer a safe and

sustainable alternative to traditional crayons. They are natural pigments that are derived

from plants. They are non-toxic and biodegradable, making them a safer and more

environmentally friendly option than Traditional Crayons.

Day Care centers in the Philippines are often poorly funded and lack access to

basic resources. This can make it difficult for them to provide children with quality

educational materials, including crayons. This study proposes to develop a method for

producing Eco-lors crayons that is suitable for use in Day Care centers.

There is a growing interest in using plant-based crayons as an alternative for

traditional crayons. Several studies have shown that plants can be used to create

crayons that are just as bright and vibrant as the present crayons.

A study conducted by Berk, et al. (2022), found that plant-based crayons are just

as effective as traditional crayons for promoting children's creativity and cognitive

development. The study also found that plant-based crayons are safer for children to

use, as they are less likely to cause allergic reactions or other health problems if

ingested. Plant-based crayons are more sustainable than traditional crayons and

produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions and require less energy to produce (Li, et al.,

2021). They also found that plant-based crayons are just as durable and long-lasting as

2
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

traditional crayons since they are less likely to break or crumble when dropped (Liu, et

al., 2022).

While there is evidence that plant-based crayons can be used to create high-

quality and safe crayons, more research is needed to develop practical and affordable

methods for producing plant-based crayons.

This study aims to fill this gap in the literature by developing a method for

producing Eco-lors crayons that is suitable for use in Day Care center. The study will

also investigate the performance of Eco-lors crayons in terms of colors, durability, and

usability.

Conceptual Framework of the Study

This study is framed within the context of providing a sustainable and safe

alternative to crayons used in early childhood education, specifically in Day Care center.

The framework incorporates various elements, including environmental impact, health

and safety concerns, and educational benefits, all revolving around the core concept of

utilizing plant-based pigments in crayon production.

Eco-lors Crayons are a sustainable alternative to crayons because they are

derived from renewable resources and are biodegradable. Eco-lors Crayons are non-

toxic, making them a safer alternative to traditional crayons, which contains harmful

chemicals.

3
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

The main purpose of this study is to develop a method for producing Eco-lors

Crayons that are sustainable, safe, and affordable. This research aims to investigate the

performance of Eco-lors Crayons concerning their acceptability in Day Care Centers,

color, durability, and usability, thus determining their quality and effectiveness as

coloring materials. Additionally, the study will assess the educational value of Eco-lors

Crayons and develop strategies for their integration into art education in early childhood

settings. Lastly, it will examine the social and economic impact of incorporating Eco-lors

Crayons in Day Care center, considering factors such as child satisfaction and ease of

use.

Independent Variables Dependent Variables

a. Color
Acceptability of Eco-lors
b. Durability
Crayons
c. usability

Figure 1: Paradigm showing the Independent Variables and Dependent Variables


of this study.

Statement of the Problem

4
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

This study examines the viability of introducing sustainable and safe Eco-lors

Crayons to early childhood education, particularly in Day Care centers in brgy. Balanti-

an, Balasan, Iloilo, Philippines. It seeks to develop a practical method for producing

these crayons, assess their performance, and acceptability in Day Care centers.

Specifically, this will attempt to answer the following questions:

1. How do the colors of Eco-lors crayons compare to those of traditional crayons in

terms of vibrancy and appearance?

2. What is the performance of Eco-lors Crayons in terms of durability compared to

traditional crayons?

3. What practical methods can be developed for producing Eco-lors crayons with

minimized usability, suitable for use in barangay Day Cares in the Philippines?

4. What is the level of acceptability of the Eco-lors crayons to the Day Care

teachers and learners?

5. Is there a significant difference in the color, durability, and usability of Eco-lors

crayons when compared to traditional crayons?

Null Hypothesis

There is no significant difference in the acceptability, durability, and usability of

Eco-lors crayons compared to traditional crayons.

5
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Significance of the Study

The outcome of this study is deemed beneficial to the following:

Children. This study is useful as it directly impacts their creative development,

health, and safety. Children are significant stakeholders because they are the end users

of the crayons and will benefit from a more eco-friendly and non-toxic creative

experience.

Parents. This study plays a critical role for this people who purchase art supplies

for their children. This research offers them an opportunity to make informed choices

when buying crayons.

Teachers. In this study, they are vital stakeholders as they can incorporate the

findings of this research into their teaching methods. Sustainable crayon crafting with

natural pigments aligns with educational goals focused on environmental awareness

and creative expression, making it a valuable resource for educators.

Health and Safety regulators. This study is advantageous for government

agencies and organizations responsible for product safety and regulation because they

can influence the standards and regulations regarding art supplies, including crayons.

6
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Environmental Advocates. In this study, it is beneficial to these people,

because this research promotes sustainability and reduces the environmental impact of

crayon production. They may support and promote the adoption of eco-friendly art

supplies in various educational and consumer contexts.

Manufacturers. This study is beneficial to the companies involved in the

production of art supplies, particularly crayons, have a stake in this research. It

challenges them to explore and adopt more sustainable and natural pigment options,

potentially transforming their products and manufacturing processes.

Future Researchers. This study serves as a valuable resource for those who

wish to build upon the existing knowledge in the field of eco-friendly art supplies. They

can use the findings and methodologies as a foundation for further research, potentially

leading to advancements in sustainable crayon production and other related areas of

study.

Scope and Delimitation

This study will involve the creation Eco-lors Crayons using coconut wax and

natural pigments derived from plants. The development process will aim to produce

crayons suitable for use in Day Care centers.

7
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

The research assesses the performance of Eco-lors Crayons with a particular

focus on color, durability and usability. This evaluation aims to determine the quality and

effectiveness of Eco-lors Crayons as coloring materials for Day Care learners. The

study will also investigate the acceptability of Eco-lors Crayons among Day Care

teachers and children. This aspect considers the child-satisfaction and ease of use.

The study primarily targets young children within Day Care centers, and its

findings may not be directly applicable to older age groups or different education levels.

The initial hypothesis stating that Eco-lors Crayons does not perform better than

traditional crayons in terms of color, acceptability, durability and usability is set for the

purpose of the study.

Definition of Terms
For a better understanding of the study, the following words and terminologies

are given their conceptual and operational meanings:

Acceptability-- Based on the Cambridge Dictionary (2022), the term

Acceptability is defined as the quality of being satisfactory and able to be agreed to or

approved of.

In this study, Acceptability refers to the acceptability of Eco-lors Crayons in

barangay Day Care centers.

8
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Colors-- Based on the Cambridge Dictionary (2023), Color is a small stick of

colored wax used for drawing or writing.

In this study, Colors refer to the pigments used in the production of crayons.

Day Care Center-- Based on the Cambridge Dictionary (2023), the term Day

Care Center is defined as a place where parents pay to leave their children while the

parents work.

Refers to the educational facilities for children in the preschool age group at

Barangay Balanti-an, balasan iloilo where our research will be conducted.

Durability-- Based on the Cambridge Dictionary (2023), the term Durability is

defined as the quality of being able to last a long time without becoming damaged.

In this study, Durability refers to the quality of the Eco-lors Crayons to a last a

long time without becoming damaged.

usability-- Based on the Merriam Webster (2023), the term usability is defined

as a quality of something that stimulates the olfactory organ.

In this study, usability refers to scent of the Eco-lors Crayons.

Traditional Crayons-- Based on Encyclopedia (2018), the term Traditional

Crayons is defined as crayons that are made of paraffin mixed with various chemical

pigments.

9
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

In this study, Traditional Crayons refers to crayons that are made with wax and

petroleum products, which can be harmful to the environment and human health.

Chapter 2

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

Non-Toxic Crayon – Zero Waste and Eco Friendly

The study proposes a solution to the problem of toxic substances in children's

crayons and pollution caused by traditional crayon manufacturing methods. The

researchers propose creating "Eco-Crayons," a non-toxic, zero-waste, and

environmentally friendly alternative made from beeswax, natural pigments, organic

color agents, and recyclable paper for packaging. This solution addresses four

analytical lenses: technical, business, natural, and human, and it aligns with several

UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Crayons are currently made from

paraffin wax and non-biodegradable plastic wrappers, contributing to plastic pollution

and environmental degradation. Furthermore, these crayons contain hazardous

substances that endanger children's health. To address these issues, Eco Crayons

employs sustainable materials and zero-waste production methods problems. The

innovative manufacturing process uses vegetable waste, beeswax, and natural

coloring pigments, reducing the use of non-renewable resources. The crayons are

10
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

packaged in biodegradable and recyclable paper, which eliminates the need for

plastic. The global market for wax crayons is expected to grow, and the product

meets rising consumer demand for environmentally friendly, sustainable products. We

reduce transportation-related emissions by supporting local agriculture and

beekeeping, resulting in a more sustainable supply chain.

The crayons help to preserve agricultural ecosystems by reducing organic

waste in landfills and increasing soil fertility. The researchers help bee populations

that are important for pollination and agriculture by using beeswax. The use of

biodegradable paper packaging instead of plastic wrappers reduces plastic pollution

in marine ecosystems. By limiting the exposure to toxic substances, these crayons

help protect human health and promote well-being by containing no toxic substances.

They also serve as an educational tool for teaching children about environmental

sustainability and the importance of protecting nature. The researchers offer a

practical, innovative, and long-term solution to the problems associated with

traditional crayons. The Eco Crayons, by aligning with the SDGs, not only promote

children's creativity and learning, but also contribute significantly to global

sustainability efforts. (Chinmayi Ganjur Hari Prasad, Dhyani Pancholi, Nisargkumar

Hiteshbhai Dalwadi, Rajarsh Bhavsar, Umar Abbas).

The Effectivity of Fruits as Natural Colorant for Organic Wax Crayons

11
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Binney’s and Smith's research into nontoxic and colorful drawing tools for kids.

They had already invented a new wax crayon however; it was loaded with carbon black

and too toxic for children. They were certain that the pigment and wax mixing

techniques they had developed could be used for a variety of colors. In 1903, a new

brand of crayons with astounding qualities was introduced - Crayola Crayons. According

to Crayola’s website (2018).

Crayola Crayons: Raw Materials

In a study conducted by Hernandez, et al. (2014). A crayon derives its color from

a pigment, which is a water and oil insoluble product, and it can be natural or synthetic.

The paraffin wax is brought to the plant from the silo and mixed together in a kettle with

one or more pigments and other ingredients.

A method for red-violet pigments extraction from fruits of Malabar spinach

(Basella rubra) with enhanced antioxidant potential under fermentation

According to Kumar, et al. (2015) beat root pigments, composed of mainly

betanin and vulgaxanthin, give a red-to-red violet color when added to food stuffs. There

has been a growing interest on the stability of these beta lain pigments in terms of pH,

temperature, and water activity.

Colored crayons adopting natural pigments as well as manufacturing method

12
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

This study conducted by Xiaoyun et.al (2027), the invention discloses colored

crayons adopting natural pigments as well as a manufacturing method of the colored

crayons. Based on the natural pigments, the colored crayons are prepared from proper

types of natural pigments compounded to replace synthesized pigments, demands of

people for safety and drawing effects are met, and harm to children touching or eating

the colored crayons is avoided.

Turmeric, the Golden Spice

In a study conducted by Prasad (2017), turmeric is used not only as a principal

spice but also as a component in religious ceremonies. Because of its brilliant yellow

color, turmeric is also known as “Indian saffron”. Turmeric, an ingredient in most curries

and mustards, has a history of being used as more than just a spice. Turmeric's deep-

orange pigment has long been used as a dye.

Organic crayons

In a study conducted by the Khind Starfish Foundation, crayons have been used

in schools for more than a century and most of the crayons were made from paraffin

wax (derived from petroleum) which takes decades or even longer to breakdown.

Nowadays, a lot of crayons brand in market using 100% natural wax such as soy wax,

beeswax and vegetable wax and the price is quite expensive, therefore, in this project,

13
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

by mixing the beeswax with treated waste cooking oil is to believe that numbers of

crayons production can be increase hence, reduce the cost of production.

Feasibility of Charcoal as an Alternative Marker Ink

In The study conducted by Cruto (2019), the researchers investigated the viability

of charcoal as an alternative marker ink in terms of absorption, color, and usability. The

charcoal ink was rated Very Good in terms of absorption and color. However, findings

revealed that charcoal obtained a descriptive rating of good for the usability as well as

writing material to some varieties of paper such as pad paper, manila paper, and bond

paper.

Toxic substances in children's crayons and colored pencils: An assessment of

bio accessibility

Toxic elements (TEs) in crayons and colored pencils for children may pose a risk

to their health, including cognitive development, after consumption, through mouthing

and chewing, and eventually accumulation. The goal of this work was to determine the

overall concentration of As, Pb, Cr, Cd, Ni, and Sb in artificial saliva and estimate their

bio accessibility. Sixty colored pencils and crayons from ten different manufacturers

were tested. The total TE content was determined by microwave acid aided digestion

followed by inductively coupled plasma optical spectroscopy (ICP-OES). Artificial

14
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

extraction simulation When it comes to bioavailability, saliva was used to obtain more

reliable results. Colored pencils had greater total TE concentrations than crayons, with

maximum levels of 5.78, 9.36, 9.97, 0.615, and 6.63 mg kg-1 for As, Pb, Cr, Cd, and Ni,

respectively. Sb concentrations were below the detection limit in all samples tested.

This investigation found that the concentrations of As and Pb in numerous samples did

not meet European Union standards. The bio accessibility investigation revealed a

considerable degree of leaching of Cr and as from pencils, although concentrations of

chosen examined TEs were below permissible levels regardless of extracted

percentage. (Ogo-Mraevic, S., Rai, S., Trii, J., Mitrovi, N., & uki-Osi, D.)

An integrated analytical study of crayons from the original art materials collection

of the MUNCH museum in Oslo

According to Matinero (2015), integrated use of complementary spectroscopic

and hyphenated mass-spectrometry techniques allowed the compositional profiles of

the crayons to be traced providing the identification of the inorganic and organic

pigments, the fillers/extenders, and the binders. All crayons resulted to be oil- based

and the binder was identified to be a mixture of a drying oil (safflower or linseed oil).

The Organic Artist: Make Your Own Paint, Paper, Pigments, Prints and More from

Nature

15
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

In the study conducted by Nicholas N. (2015). Using ancient traditions, artist and

primitive arts demonstrates how to reconnect with nature in order to manufacture and

use your own all-natural art supplies. The Organic Artist invites you to return to the days

when art was created using only natural materials such as charcoal and birch bark. This

book tries to encourage creativity by connecting you to your organic beginnings by

immersing you in the natural environment. This book covers the notions of awareness

and perception, which are fundamental to the creative process, as well as a wide range

of suggestions for using nature as resources for art. Readers will improve their drawing

skills as well as increase their appreciation for the visual arts and the natural landscape.

Some of the projects and skills covered include the following: Making paper and wild ink

Working with soapstone, clay, wood, and rawhide Printmaking and stenciling Natural

pigments and dyes Camouflage and body painting Nature journaling Learn to find

satisfaction in the natural process of transformation.

Recent researches on natural pigments stabilized by clay minerals: A review

In the study conducted by Shue Li, Bin Mu, Xiaowen Wang, Aiqin Wang (2021),

pigments derived from plants are frequently stabilized by the integration of co-pigment

molecules, the development of supramolecular complexes, and the encapsulation or

loading of nano-carriers. Clay minerals, inspired by Maya blue, are used as promising

nano-carriers to stabilize natural pigments due to their unique structural properties,

16
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

abundant reserves, low cost, and eco-friendliness. Clay minerals' distinct structural and

physicochemical properties allow for the stabilization of these natural hues. This study

covers the most recent research and provides insight into the use of natural or synthetic

clay minerals to improve the environmental stability of natural colors collected from

diverse fruits, vegetables, and flowers. Based on our cognition and accumulation while

reviewing the material as well as for the development and prospective applications of

hybrid materials made of clay minerals and natural pigments.

Natural edible pigments: A comprehensive review of resource, chemical

classification, biosynthesis pathway, separated methods and application

According to the study of Shen, N., Ren, J., Liu, Y., Sun, W., Li, Y., Xin, H., &

Cui, Y. (2023). Natural edible pigments with high safety and low toxicity typically offer a

variety of nutritional and pharmacological properties, and they have a large market

application value. However, there has been no thorough study of the resources,

chemical classifications, and applications. Furthermore, extraction methodologies and

biosynthetic pathways, both of which are critical for obtaining high-yielding and high-

purity natural food pigments from natural resources, are currently absent. As a result, a

full examination of natural edible pigments is required. For the first time, we present a

systematic summary of the resources, chemical classifications, biosynthetic processes,

extraction and separation methods, and application of natural edible pigments. Our work

17
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

will serve as a reference and inspiration for future industrial use of natural materials of

natural edible pigments.

Compositions for eco-friendly crayon and methods for preparing the same

In the study conducted by Jaejin Go (2017), the present invention is related to a

method for preparing an eco-friendly crayon that includes: a) adding a pigment and food

coloring agent while melting beeswax by heating; b) cooling the beeswax to block and

then pulverizing the blocked beeswax; c) melting carnauba wax by heating; d) mixing

the pulverized beeswax obtained in step b with the carnauba wax obtained in step.

18
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Chapter 3
METHODOLOGY
Purpose of the Study and Research Design

This research aims to contribute to the field of early childhood education by

developing a method for producing Eco-lors Crayons—a sustainable and safe

alternative to traditional crayons. The primary objectives are to assess the performance

of Eco-lors Crayons in terms of color, durability, and usability, and to investigate their

acceptability in Day Care centers. The study also seeks to explore the educational value

of Eco-lors Crayons, develop integration strategies into art education, and examine the

potential social and economic impact of their implementation in barangay Day Cares.

The research design for this study aligns with a developmental research

approach. This approach emphasizes the systematic development and improvement of

Eco-lors Crayons with a focus on practical application. The developmental research

design involves multiple stages, including planning, development, and evaluation. In this

case, the study encompasses the creation of Eco-lors crayons using coconut wax and

19
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

natural pigments, followed by an assessment of their suitability for use in Day Care

centers.

Locale of the study

This study will be conducted at Quillan’s Residence, Zaragosa, Balasan, Iloilo

which is more conducive for the study for its suitability and abundance of resources,

particularly plants. The choice of this locale is strategic in ensuring a rich source of

natural materials for the production of plant-based crayons.

Materials

In this study, the researchers will use Coconut wax, Annatto seeds (for red),

Carrots (for orange), Turmeric (for yellow), Blue ternate (for blue), Moringa (for green)

and a mixture of red and green pigments (for brown) for Plant-Based Crayons

(Experimental Group). On the other hand, Traditional Crayons (Control Group) will use

the product Crayola. Crayon molds, wax melting pot, stirring utensils, measuring tools,

protective gear (gloves and aprons), and storage containers for crayons will be involve

in the process.

20
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Procedures

To have more reliable and valid results, the procedures below must be strictly

followed.

1. Preparation Phase

a. Plant Selection

Identify and collect plant materials (annatto seeds, carrots, turmeric, blue

ternate, moringa, and violet pigment source) from the local environment.

b. Extraction

Extract pigments from plant materials through methods such as boiling,

grinding, or soaking.

c. Crayon Mold Preparation

Clean and prepare crayon molds for plant-based.

2. Crayon Crafting

Begin by melting coconut wax in a wax melting pot over low heat. Allow

the wax to fully liquefy, ensuring a smooth consistency. Integrate the previously

extracted plant pigments into the melted coconut wax. Stir the mixture thoroughly

to achieve a uniform distribution of pigments for each desired color. Once the

pigments are evenly incorporated, carefully pour the colored wax mixture into

crayon molds. Ensure precision to prevent spillage and achieve well-defined

21
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

crayon shapes. Allow the filled molds to cool and solidify at room temperature or

in a controlled cooling environment. This process typically takes around 30

minutes to ensure the crayons have set completely.

3. Determine the Color, Durability, usability, and Acceptability of the Eco-lors

Crayons.

a. Color and Vibrancy Assessment

i. Conduct controlled drop tests for both Traditional Crayons and Traditional

Crayons to simulate accidental drops during regular use.

ii. Record observations on any breakage or damage incurred during the drop

tests.

iii. Assess the color retention of both Eco-lors Crayons and Traditional Crayons

by examining any changes in color intensity after the drop tests.

b. Durability Testing

i. Evaluate any noticeable usabilitys emitted during and after the durability testing

processes for both Eco-lors Crayons and Traditional Crayons.

ii. Record observations on breakage or damage incurred during the drop tests to

assess overall durability.

c. Acceptability Assessment

i. Distribute both Eco-lors Crayons and Traditional Crayons to Day Careteachers

and children in the selected centers.

22
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

ii. Ensure an adequate supply for a meaningful assessment.

iii. Collect feedback through surveys to assess the acceptability of Eco-lors

Crayons.

Data Analysis

The chosen methods aim to address the research questions and objectives

effectively, providing valuable insights into the acceptability of sustainable and Eco-lors

Crayons in Day Care center.

Descriptive Data Analysis

Descriptive statistics, including mean, median, and standard deviation, will

summarize color features for Eco-lors and traditional crayons.

Descriptive statistics will quantify breakage rates and damage observations,

providing insights into the durability of both types of crayons.

Descriptive analysis of participant feedback will be conducted to evaluate and

compare the perceived usabilitys of Eco-lors and traditional crayons.

23
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

T-tests for means comparison will explore variations in acceptability scores

among Day Care teachers, children, and different age groups.

T-tests for means comparison will investigate variations in durability scores

between Eco-lors and traditional crayons.

Comparative Data Analysis

Color, Durability, and usability Comparison: ANOVA will assess significant differences in

color, durability, and usability among different age groups.

24
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

References:

Bandyopadhyay, S., & Mukherjee, D. K. (2012). Natural food colorants and color

additives. Natural Product Communications, 7(4), 499-524.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9776543/

Binney, E., & Smith, C. R. (1903). Crayons (Patent No. US709133). United States

Patent and Trademark Office. https://www.uspto.gov/

Carle, R., Weiser, H., & Winterhalter, P. (1997). Carotenoids in fruits and vegetables: A

critical review. Food Reviews International, 13(1), 23-97.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9025559/

Cruto, J. W. (2019). Feasibility of charcoal as an alternative marker ink. Unpublished

master's thesis, Western Kentucky University.

25
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Environment Energy Leader. (2021). Mizuiro introduces 'Plant-Based Crayons’.

Retrieved from https://www.environmentenergyleader.com/2021/07/mizuiro-

introduces-plant-based-crayons/

Hernandez, M. J., Fernandez, M. J., & Casas, J. A. (2014). Study of the composition of

artists' oil colours through a non-invasive analytical technique. Journal of Cultural

Heritage, 15(4), 409-414.https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/col.22883

Hewlings, S. J., & Mehta, A. S. (2017). Turmeric: The golden spice. Nutrition Reviews,

75(1), 65-75. https://www.webmd.com/vitamins/ai/ingredientmono-662/turmeric

Khind Starfish Foundation. (2021). Organic crayons. Retrieved from

https://www.jenstronginphotography.com/ontheedgeofthesalishseablog

Kumar, P. P., Lakshminarayana, N., & Naidu, M. M. (2015). A method for red-violet

pigments extraction from fruits of Malabar spinach (Basella rubra) with enhanced

antioxidant potential under fermentation. LWT-Food Science and Technology,

64(2), 656-662. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25892806/

Matinero, C. (2015). An integrated analytical study of crayons from the original art

materials collection of the MUNCH museum in Oslo. Heritage Science, 3(1), 34.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/350494245_An_integrated_analytical_s

26
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

tudy_of_crayons_from_the_original_art_materials_collection_of_the_MUNCH_m

useum_in_Oslo

Nicholas, N. (2015). The Organic Artist: Make Your Own Paint, Paper, Pigments, Prints

and More from Nature. Quarry Books.

Ogo-Mraevic, S., Rai, S., Trii, J., Mitrovi, N., & uki-Osi, D. (2022). Toxic substances in

children's crayons and colored pencils: An assessment of bioaccessibility.

Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 29(34), 52406-52417.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/355281758_Toxic_elements_in_childre

n's_crayons_and_colored_pencils_Bio

Shue Li, B. Mu, X. Wang, & A. Wang. (2021). Recent researches on natural pigments

stabilized by clay minerals: A review. Natural Products and Bioprospecting,

11(5), 419-431.

Suwimontep, W., Devahastin, S., & Chiranthanakul, K. (2012). Chemical constituents

and dyeing properties of Clitoria ternatea flowers. Natural Science, 4(4), 306-311.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/248390954_Chemical_composition_an

d_anti-proliferative_properties_of_flowers_of_Clitoria_Ternatea

Xiaoyun, L., Yang, Y., & Wang, T. (2027). Colored crayons adopting natural pigments

as well as a manufacturing method of the colored crayons (Patent No.

27
Department of Education
Region VI – Western Visayas
Schools Division of Iloilo
BALASAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Senior High School
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

US20270025824A1). United States Patent and Trademark Office.

https://www.uspto.gov/

28

You might also like