15IPST013
15IPST013
15IPST013
Abstract— Most small power induction motors need to operate open phase. The power factor and efficiency degrade while the
with single-phase a.c. power supplies that are readily available at peak torque also decreases significantly [1]. Thus, except for
homes, and remote rural areas [1]. These machine are used to low powers (less than ¼ kW in general), the auxiliary winding
drive fans, pumps, air compressors, refrigeration compressors,
air conditioning fans and blowers, saws, grinders and office
is active also during running conditions to improve the
machines [2]. performance. The following are the main types of single-phase
This paper presents a real-time electromagnetic transient induction motors in use today:
model for single-phase induction machines (SPIM). The paper • Split-Phase Induction Motors
starts with the introduction and analysis of unsymmetrical 2- • Capacitor Induction Motors
phase induction machines. Although, main and auxiliary
windings are not symmetric, a technique has been introduced • Shaded-Pole Induction Motors
which facilitates the inclusion of magnetic saturation in this The split-phase motor, sometimes called resistance split-
model. The embedded phase domain approach [3] is utilized for phase, achieves its starting torque by having a higher
incorporation of this model into the network solution of the resistance and possibly lower reactance in the auxiliary circuit,
RTDSTM simulator. Various features of the model such as which is usually wound 90 electrical degrees from the main
embedded breakers are introduced in the paper. The model is winding. At a speed in the region of maximum torque, the
validated using stand-alone numerical simulations and analytical
solutions. Possible configurations of the model such as auxiliary winding is switched off. The switch may be activated
“capacitor-start induction motor” and “capacitor-start by speed (centrifugal), voltage, current, or temperature [2].
capacitor-run induction motor”, are demonstrated. Scenarios The starting torque of these motors is moderate, but the
including stalling of air-conditioning pumps during a fault in starting current is relatively high. Efficiency and power factor
distribution circuits are presented. are moderate, with efficiency ranging from about 40% at 0.1
hp to about 70% at 0.75 hp [1].
Keywords: real-time digital simulation, single-phase induction
machine, saturation, embedded phase domain approach, digital Capacitor induction motors are in the forms of “capacitor-
transient network analyzer, distribution network start motors”, “permanent-split capacitor motors” and “two
value capacitor motors”. In the “capacitor-start” motor the
I. INTRODUCTION starting torque is obtained by the use of a capacitor in series
with the auxiliary winding while starting, then switching the
S mall power motors in distribution networks normally have
to operate with single-phase a.c. power. These machines
are either series connected d.c. machines or single-phase
auxiliary winding out as the motor reaches running speed. The
capacitor causes the auxiliary winding current to lead the main
induction machines (SPIMs). Single-phase induction machines current. These machines are used for hard to start applications
are used to drive fans, pumps, air compressors, refrigeration such as pumps, compressors, etc. up to the rating of 5 hp [2].
compressors, air conditioning fans and blowers, saws, grinders A permanent-split capacitor motor is designed for applications
and office machines [2]. Air conditioning systems used in where starting torque requirements are low, but improved
households generally include a condenser unit, a compressor running performance is required. In this case, the motor is
unit and an air handler fan. Both the compressor unit and the designed to have a capacitor in series with the auxiliary
fan are run by single-phase induction motors. winding all the time [2].
To be self-starting, the induction machine needs a rotating In a “two-value capacitor motor”, a start capacitor is placed
field at zero speed. This in turn implies the presence of two in parallel with the run capacitor. This allows the motor to be
windings in the stator, while the rotor has a standard squirrel designed for optimum running efficiency without sacrificing
cage [1]. The stator first winding is called the main winding efficiency to get starting torque. Two-value capacitor motors
whereas the second winding is called the auxiliary winding have been available for years in the range of 1-10 hp [2].
[1]. SPIMs may run only on the main winding once they In “shaded-pole machines”, the auxiliary winding is usually
started on two windings. A typical case of single-phase single- a simple shorted turn of conductor around one side of each
winding IM occurs when a three-phase IM ends up with an stator pole, called a shading coil. Shaded-pole motors are
simple in construction and are therefore relatively low cost
and reliable. Starting current is relatively high, starting torque
A. B. Dehkordi is with RTDS Technologies Inc., Winnipeg, Canada (e-mail: is relatively low, running current is relatively high, and
dehkordi@rtds.com). efficiency and power factor are low [2]. They are widely used
to drive small fans (1/5 hp and below) because they are low in
Paper submitted to the International Conference on Power Systems
Transients (IPST2015) in Cavtat, Croatia June 15-18, 2015. cost and reliable.
Electric utilities have been having occurrences of delayed
voltage recovery following faults on the electrical system In this analysis, stator phase as is the main winding of the
when the load is comprised largely of loads driven by machine and stator phase bs is the auxiliary winding. As
induction machines. Under normal conditions, voltage previously mentioned, they are not identical and they do not
recovers to nominal levels in less than one second after the have the same parameters. The ratio of effective turns between
fault is cleared. In several cases, voltage recovery has been the auxiliary and main windings N bs N as is usually shown by
delayed for over 30 seconds after normal fault clearing in
the symbol a. The rotor windings are symmetric and have
some substations, especially when the air temperature and
similar parameters.
electrical system loading was high [5]. This fault induced
ibs
delayed voltage recovery or FIDVR, is being attributed to
stalling of air conditioner units. Mainly, stalling of the single- N bs vbs
phase induction motor operating the compressor unit. Delayed
θr N as
voltage recovery may lead to a system voltage collapse in the ωr bs
ias
worst case. One of the recent applications of the real-time
simulators has been on the modeling of distribution circuits vas
br
and interaction of air conditioning loads within these networks ar
[6]. as' as
This paper presents development of a single-phase ibr
vbr
induction machine model (SPIM) for real-time digital
Nr
simulation. The paper starts with the introduction and analysis ar' br'
of unsymmetrical 2-phase induction machines. Methods of Nr
transient simulation of single-phase induction machines are iar
discussed. Although, the main and auxiliary windings are not bs' var
symmetrical, a technique has been introduced which facilitates
Fig. 1. Diagram of an idealized two-phase induction machine.
the inclusion of magnetic saturation in this model. The
embedded phase domain approach [4] is utilized for B. Voltage and Flux Linkage Equations and
incorporation of this model into the network solution of the Equivalent Circuits
simulation. Various features of the model such as embedded Based on the above description of a SPIM, voltage and flux
breakers are introduced in the paper. The model is validated linkage equations of a single-phase induction machine are
using stand-alone numerical simulations and analytical developed. The following assumptions are made in this
solutions. Possible configurations of the model such as analysis:
“capacitor-start induction motor” and “capacitor-start • A multi-pole single-phase induction machine is
capacitor-run induction motor”, are demonstrated. Examples, modeled as an equivalent two pole machine. Torque
including stalling of air-conditioning pumps during a fault in and speed are monitored in p.u.
distribution circuits, are presented. • It is assumed that the machine windings produce a
sinusoidal MMF, thus space harmonics are ignored.
II. THEORY AND ANALYSIS OF A SPIM Voltage equations for a two-phase induction machine are
This section briefly describes the analysis and modeling presented in (1). Equation (1) shows the relation between
method of single-phase induction machines. Since the goal is voltage, current and flux linkage vectors of the machine.
incorporation of the model into an electromagnetic transient Stator phases a and b have different resistances due to the fact
program, the coupled electric circuit approach is used for the that stator windings are not symmetrical.
analysis of this electric machine. Some of the previous vabs rs iabs Ψabs
contributions [7]-[9] are outlined and techniques offered in v r
0 0 0 ias Ψ as
this paper are described. as as
vbs 0 rbs 0 0 ibs d Ψbs
A. General Description of a Single-Phase Induction = + (1)
v 0 0 r 0 i dt Ψ
Machine ar r ar ar
v 0 0 0 r i
Ψbr
As mentioned above, a single-phase induction machine br
r br
consists of two stator windings known as the main and vabr r
r
iabr Ψabr
auxiliary windings with the angular space of normally 90°. The relation between flux linkages and currents is shown in
The stator windings are usually asymmetric, i.e. the main and
(2). Here, Ψas and Ψ bs are flux linkages for stator windings a
auxiliary windings do not have the same number of turns and
parameters. The rotor has the standard squirrel cage, which in and b, and Ψar and Ψbr are flux linkages for rotor windings
rotating field theory can be represented by two d- and q-axis
respectively. [ Lss ] and [ Lrr ] are the inductance matrices for
windings. Fig. 1 shows the diagram of an idealized two-phase
induction machine. Windings as and bs represent stator stator and rotor windings, and [ Lsr ] is the matrix for the
windings and windings ar and br represent rotor windings. mutual inductances between the stator and rotor windings. The
The rotor angle is shown by θr and rotor speed is shown by ωr. values of inductances in (2) are functions of rotor position and
saturation. system components are discretized to a Norton equivalent of
Ψabs L L i conductances and current sources which are passed to the
= ss
sr abs where: network solution during a communication interval (T0) every
Ψ abr L T L i abr time-step [11].
sr rr
Interface vs Embedded Approach:
L + Lmas 0
L = las In electromagnetic transient programs, one approach of
ss 0 Llbs + Lmbs incorporating electric machines into the network solution is to
(2) consider a machine an external sub-network to the main
L + L 0
L = lr mr system; receive the terminal voltages at every time-step and
rr 0 Llr + Lmr compute winding currents and inject them back to the network
solution. This method is called interfaced-based approach
M cos(θ ) −M sin(θ )
L = ar r ar r [13], [14]. Another approach, referred to as the embedded
sr M sin(θ ) M cos(θ ) approach, considers the machine as a set of mutually coupled
br r br r
inductances and applies precise implementation of Dommel
The voltage and flux linkage equations in (1) and (2) can be
algorithm to extract the discretized Norton equivalent of the
transferred to stator frame of reference so that the inductances
machine model. This method is computationally more
no longer depend on the rotor position. With that, d- and q-
extensive than the interfaced-based approach as the time-
axis equivalent circuits can be achieved. Note that, due to the
varying inductance matrix of the machine needs to be inverted
asymmetry in stator windings, transforming the above
every time-step. Also, elements of the equivalent admittance
equations to rotor frame of reference does not result in a
matrix need to be sent to the network solution of the RTDS
position-independent inductance matrix [7]-[9].
simulator every time-step. Details of implementing this
In [8], q- and d-axis equivalent circuits are extracted with
method are discussed previously in [3], [4]. This approach
reference to main and auxiliary windings individually, thus the
provides a more numerically stable solution than the
q- and d-axis magnetizing inductances are not equal. Fig. 2
interfaced-based approach [3], [4]. This method also provides
shows the equivalent circuit of the machine using the approach
more flexibility in providing enhancements to the model such
used in [8]. It is usual to have SPIM data available in this
as inclusion of embedded breakers and arbitrary connection of
form.
1 's
the windings and nodes.
ω Ψdr 's
iqss = ias ras llas '
llar r a rar' iqr In this paper, the embedded phase-domain approach is used
for incorporating the single-phase induction machine model
into the network solution of RTDS: The trapezoidal rule of
Lmas d 's vqr' s integration is directly applied to discretize the phase-domain
vas = vqss Ψ
dt qr differential equation of the SPIM described in (1) and (2). As
SPIM inductances are changing with rotor position and
magnetic saturation, equivalent conductance matrix and
's
ω a ⋅ Ψqr history terms are calculated and passed to the network solution
s
ids = ibs rbs llbs '
llbr r rbr' idr's
of the simulator every each time-step.
The “CBuilder” utility of RSCAD software [11] is used for
s Lmbs d 's 's
vdr implementation of this model. This utility allows the user to
vbs = vds Ψ
dt dr implement a model in C language and creates a suitable
assembly code for the target processor.
Fig. 2. Equivalent circuit of an idealized two-phase induction machine Inclusion of the effects of magnetic saturation:
(rotor windings reflected to main and aux. windings). Inclusion of magnetic saturation into the transient
simulation of the SPIM model is one of the contributions of
III. IMPLEMENTATION OF THE SPIM MODEL INTO THE this paper. The rotor of a single-phase induction machine is
ENVIRONMENT OF THE REAL-TIME DIGITAL SIMULATOR
round similar to that of a 3-phase induction machine. The air-
The RTDS simulator is a combination of computer gap is also uniform. This means that similar to a 3-phase
hardware and software designed specifically for the solution induction machine, magnetic saturation can be included by
of power system electromagnetic transients in real time. Each adjusting the magnetizing inductance as a function of total
unit of RTDS is called a rack. Every rack consists of magnetizing flux. However, as a SPIM has unsymmetrical
processors dedicated to the solution of power system network, stator windings (main and auxiliary), magnetizing inductance
power system devices and control components [11]. Each seen from the q- and d-axis Lmq and Lmd are not equal.
simulation time-step is divided into computation intervals and
communication intervals. Similar to other electromagnetic Numerical problems may arise if these magnetizing
transient programs such as EMTP and EMTDC, Dommel inductances are to be adjusted independently. Furthermore, in
algorithm [12] is used for discretization of the system’s contrast to previous work [7]-[9], the implementation of this
differential equation. Subsequently, nodal solution is used for model is done in phase-domain, thus phase domain
calculation of node voltages. Differential equations of power inductances need to be evaluated each time-step as a function
of saturation.
The key factor in considering saturation is to observe the Features and Capabilities of the Model:
rotor in its natural state as a round rotor, i.e. having equal With the above description, the single-phase induction
magnetizing inductances on both q- and d-axes. This can be machine model is implemented in the environment of RTDS
done by observing all rotor and stator windings from the port simulator. This section describes the capabilities of this model.
of one of the stator windings e.g. stator main winding (see the The basic icon for this component appears as shown in Fig. 4.
equivalent circuit in Fig. 3.). This approach [9], reflects all of The terminals for stator main and auxiliary windings and the
the windings to the main stator winding. Fig. 3 shows the neutral point are respectively shown by M, A and N. Each of
equivalent circuit of the machine using this approach. the main and auxiliary windings have embedded series
Usually, data for single-phase induction machines is breakers that can be controlled independently.
available in both formats shown in Fig. 2 and Fig. 3. A capacitor, a resistor or a combination of resistive and
Parameters can be transferred from one circuit to another capacitive elements can be inserted between nodes A and M,
using the value of Aux. / Main turns ratio ( a ) and can be resulting in a capacitor-start, capacitor-run, two-value
measured using standard no-load, locked-rotor and standstill capacitor motor or other arrangements. Twelve instances of
frequency response tests [10]. In the model developed in this this model can be simulated in real-time using one PB5
paper, the input data for the rotor is in the form of parameters processor [11] of the RTDS simulator.
in the equivalent circuit shown in Fig. 3. Therefore, only one
value for rotor resistance and leakage inductance is required.
If the available data is in the form of equivalent circuit shown
in Fig. 2, then q-axis rotor resistance and leakage inductance is
adequate for the model. D-axis rotor parameters are equal to q-
axis parameters multiplied by ( a 2 ). See [11] for more details.
's
ω Ψdr 's
iqss = ias ras llas llr' r rr' iqr
1 1
rr' -0.01
j ωs ⋅ Lms 2
2 2−s
-0.03
Fig. 5. Steady-state equivalent circuit of a single-phase induction 1.5 2 Time (s) 2.5 3
machine.
RTDS Off-Line Solution
RTDS Analytical Solution 2
15
0
Torque (pu)
Impedance (Ohm)
-2
10
-4
5 -6
-8
0 1.5 2 Time (s) 2.5 3
0 20 40 60 80 100
RTDS Off-Line Solution
Frequency (Hz) 1
Fig. 6. Standstill frequency response of the SPIM from the port of main 0.8
Speed (pu)
winding.
0.6
RTDS Analytical Solution 0.4
0.2
35
Impedance (Ohm)
0
1.5 2 Time (s) 2.5 3
25
Fig. 8. Start-up of the SPIM. (a) Main winding current. (b) Electric
torque. (c) Speed
15
V. EXAMPLE OF STALLING AIR-CONDITIONING COMPRESSOR
5 UNITS AFTER A REMOTE FAULT
0 0.5 1 1.5 2
Slip (pu) This section presents an example of SPIMs of the type
Fig. 7. Impedance vs slip characteristics of the SPIM
typically used in air-conditioning units. The SPIMs stall after
a fault. A small circuit containing two single-phase induction
machines is simulated using the RTDS simulator. As shown in
Fig. 9, a permanent capacitor with the capacitance of 15.4 µF Vm1
signals for both SPIMs eventually reach zero causing stalling Pmac1 Ploss1
Speed (pu)
stay stalled even after the fault is cleared (Fig. 10d). The -0.4
SPIMs stay stalled until one of them is disconnected from the -0.6
VIII. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The author sincerely appreciates the high valued technical
support from the colleagues at RTDS Technologies Inc.
IX. REFERENCES
[1] Ion Boldea, Syed A. Nasar, The Induction Machine Handbook, CRC
Press LLC, 2002, Chapter 23.
[2] Hamid A. Toliyat, Gerald B. Kliman, Handbook of Electric Motors,
CRC Press LLC, 2004, Chapter 2.
[3] A. B. Dehkordi, P. Neti, A.M Gole, and T.L. Maguire, “Development
and Validation of a Comprehensive Synchronous Machine Model for a
Real-Time Environment”, IEEE Trans. On Energy Conversion, vol. 25,
no.1, pp. 34-48, Mar 2010.
[4] A.B. Dehkordi, A.M Gole, and T.L. Maguire, “Permanent magnet
synchronous machine model for real-time simulation”, International
Power System Transient Conference (IPST 2005), Montreal, June, 2005.
[5] B. R. Williams, W. R. Schmus, and D. C. Dawson, “Transmission
voltage recovery delayed by stalled air conditioner compressors,” Power
Systems, IEEE Transactions on, vol. 7, no. 3, pp. 1173–1181, 1992.
[6] K. Prabakar, D. T. Rizy, F. Li, “A study on the effect of distribution
circuit loading on air conditioner motor stall using a real time
simulator,” T&D Conference and Exposition, 2014 IEEE PES, April
2014.
[7] P.C. Krause, O.Wasynczuk, S.D. Sudhoff, Analysis of electric
machinery, New York, IEEE Press, 1995.
[8] P. C. Krause, ”Simulation of Unsymmetrical 2-Phase Induction
Machines, ” IEEE Trans. Power Apparatus and Systems , vol. PAS-84,
No.11, pp. 1025-1037, Nov. 1965.