A Review of Withering in The Processing
A Review of Withering in The Processing
A Review of Withering in The Processing
Received: August 22nd, 2016; Revised: September 12nd, 2016; Accepted: October 28th, 2016
Purpose: Tea is the most frequently consumed drink worldwide, next to water. About 75% of the total world tea production
includes black tea, and withering is one of the major processing steps critical for the quality of black tea. There are two types
of tea withering methods: physical and chemical withering. Withering can be achieved by using tat, tunnel, drum, and trough
withering systems. Of these, the trough withering system is the most commonly used. This study focuses on the different
types of withering, their effect on the various quality attributes of tea, and other aspects of withering methods that affect
superior quality tea. Results: During physical withering, tea shoots loose moisture content that drops from approximately
70-80% to 60-70% (wet basis). This leads to increased sap concentration in tea leaf cells, and turgid leaves become flaccid.
It also prevents tea shoots from damage during maceration or rolling. During chemical withering, complex chemical
compounds break down into simpler ones volatile flavor compounds, amino acids, and simple sugars are formed. Withering
increases enzymatic activities as well as the concentration of caffeine. Research indicates that about 15% of chlorophyll
degradation occurs during withering. It is also reported that during withering lipids break down into simpler compounds
and catechin levels decrease. Improper withering can cause adverse effects on subsequent manufacturing operations, such
as maceration, rolling, fermentation, drying, and tea storage. Conclusion: Freshly harvested leaves are conditioned
physically and chemically for subsequent processing. There is no specified withering duration, but 14-18 h is generally
considered the optimum period. Proper and even withering of tea shoots greatly depends on the standards of plucking,
handling, transportation, environmental conditions, time, and temperature. Thus, to ensure consumption of high quality tea,
the withering step must be monitored carefully.
Keywords: Biochemical changes, Black tea, Chemical withering, Withering, Physical withering
Figure 1. Major steps in tea manufacturing and the corresponding types of tea.
366
Deb and Jolvis Pou. A Review of Withering in the Processing of Black Tea
Journal of Biosystems Engineering • Vol. 41, No. 4, 2016 • www.jbeng.org
Figure 2. Open trough withering system (Source: Koomber Tea Estate, Goodricke Group Limited, Silchar).
Figure 3. Enclosed trough withering system (Source: Koomber Tea Estate, Goodricke Group Limited, Silchar).
thickness and air is blown in an upward direction from the more convenient for loading and unloading, and it is
bottom to the top layers, and in this way, the bottom layers easier to inspect the progress of the withering process
of the leaves become withered. In order to minimize leaves (Sanyal, 2011).
handling and to reduce leaves damage by avoiding the
leaves turning operation, the provision is made to move the Types of withering
fan both in forward and reverse directions. Therefore, the There are mainly two types of withering: chemical
leaves in the upper layer also become withered as air is withering and physical withering (Baruah et al., 2012;
drawn into the leaf bed. However, during the reverse Fard et al., 2015). Both withering processes are equally
rotation the fan efficiency is drastically reduced to about important and it is difficult to get good aroma and
60% as compared to the efficiency in the forward direction, flavored tea from un-withered or unevenly withered
thus consuming more power (Sanyal, 2011). leaves (Bhatia, 1962; Saijo, 1977; Dev Choudhury and
In the case of using an enclosed trough, leaves are spread Bajaj, 1980; Takeo, 1984; Baruah et al., 2012).
enclosed by the raised sides of the trough and a cover on top
of the bed is used. In this system, a fan is forcing air only in the Chemical withering
forward direction, and simultaneously air is passing through
Chemical withering begins immediately after the tea
both the top and bottom of the leaves using a damper. As the
leaves are plucked from the bushes. Chemical withering
handling of the leaves is less, the chances of leaves damage
is independent of the rate of moisture removal and is a
in enclosed troughs are much lower. In addition, the leaves
function of temperature and time. During the process,
do not get affected from the sudden variation in conditions
the complex chemical compounds are breaking down
of the outside environment. However, open troughs are still
into simpler compounds. The dehydration shock during
more popular in tea processing factories because they are
367
Deb and Jolvis Pou. A Review of Withering in the Processing of Black Tea
Journal of Biosystems Engineering • Vol. 41, No. 4, 2016 • www.jbeng.org
chemical withering triggers enzymatic ripening and Proteins and amino acids
produces floral flavor in the tea leaves (Sakata et. al., 2004). Amino acids are formed during withering by approximately
It is reported that for making good quality black tea proper 1.2% breakdown of proteins and are involved in aroma
chemical withering is highly necessary (Bhatia, 1962; Saijo, formation. This breakdown occurs because of the
1977; Dev Choudhury and Bajaj, 1980; Takeo, 1984). The peptidase present in the tea shoots (Bhatia, 1962; Perera
optimum duration for chemical withering has been and Wickremasingh, 1972; Motoda, 1979; Sanyal, 2011).
reported to be 14 h (Ullah, 1984). Experimental studies Peptidase increases the levels of free amino acids
have shown that the withering time beyond 20 h leads to particularly those of glutamine, glutamic acid, aspartic acid,
the deterioration of the quality of black tea (Owuor, and valine, serine, lysine, alanine, thromine, phenylalanine, and
Orchard, 1989), and hence, withering time should be tyrosine (Senderson and Graham, 1973; Tomlins and
limited to 18 h (Owuor and Orchard, 1992; Omiadze et al., Mashingaidze, 1996; Panda, 2011; Sanyal, 2011). Pheny
2014). lacetaldehyde, which is formed and reduced to alcohol, is
reported to be involved in the improvement of tea aroma.
Physical withering In contrast, formaldehyde, acetaldehyde, isobuty raldehyde,
Physical withering refers to the removal of moisture isovaleraldehyde, 2-methylbutanal, and methional are
from the tea leaf. During this process, the turgid leaf reported to cause poor flavor in tea (Senderson and
becomes flaccid. This process also leads to the concentra- Graham, 1973). The partial breakdown of proteins to amino
tion of sap in the cells of the tea leaf. The desired level of acids acts as a precursor for aroma.
moisture can be removed by passing air through the piled
leaves. Studies have shown that during physical withering Carbohydrates and simple sugars
the moisture content of green leaves is reduced to 60-70% There is a conversion of carbohydrates to simple sugars
(Yamanishi, et al., 1966; Omiadze et al., 2014, Jabeen et al., during withering. Simple sugars content increases and
2015). Time, temperature, and relative humidity are the carbohydrate content gradually decreases (Roberts, 1962).
major factors affecting physical withering (Obanda et al., Simple sugars formed from the breakdown of carbohydrates
2004). Tocklai (Tea Research Association, Assam, India) react with amino acids to produce the flavor in black tea
has reported that physical withering requires shorter (Dev Choudhury and Bajaj, 1980; Sanyal, 2011).
duration as compared to chemical withering. Thus, physical
withering is regulated at a slower rate for a longer period to Lipids and fatty acids
achieve withering in the same duration as that required for
During the withering process, lipids and fatty acids
chemical withering. This can be regulated by monitoring
are broken down into simpler compounds and volatile
the airflow rate and changing the air temperature during
compounds are formed. There are mainly two types of fatty
withering of tea leaves.
acids: saturated fatty acids and unsaturated fatty acids. It has
been previously reported that the levels of saturated fatty
Biochemical changes during chemical acids decrease during withering, but their effects on
withering black tea aroma are unknown (Selvendran et al., 1969;
Chemical withering plays a vital role in increasing the level Wright and Fishwick, 1979). Whereas, the effects of
of caffeine content (Sanderson, 1964), polyphenol oxidase unsaturated fatty acids on black tea aroma are much
activity (Ullah and Roy, 1982), amino acids, and sugars more documented, and the aroma formed from the
(Owuor and Orchard, 1989; Tomlins and Mashingaidze, breakdown of unsaturated fatty acids contributes to a
1997). Chemical withering results in the reduction of negative odor effect. It has been reported that grassy
chlorophyll content (Wickremasinghe, 1975) and leads to the aroma released from the withering trough is the result of
formation of different kinds of volatile flavor compounds aroma compounds produced from fatty acids (Takeo and
(Mahanta and Baruah, 1989; Ravichandran and Parthiban, Tsushida, 1980; Tomlins and Mashingaidze, 1997).
1998). The breakdown of proteins into amino acids during
chemical withering is one of the most important biochemical Catechins and enzyme activity
changes occurring during the process (Hussain et al., 2006).
Moisture removal during withering leads to an increase in
368
Deb and Jolvis Pou. A Review of Withering in the Processing of Black Tea
Journal of Biosystems Engineering • Vol. 41, No. 4, 2016 • www.jbeng.org
the concentration of cell sap. As a result, the concentration highly necessary to form a good amount of caffeine in
of enzymes increases and results in the formation of high black tea. Teas with low levels of caffeine content show
molecular units from low molecular subunits. The withering inefficient creaming properties (Roberts, 1963; Bhatia,
of tea leaves activates the activity of catechol oxidase of 1964; Dev Choudhury and Bajaj, 1980; Tomlins and
phenol oxidase. Consequently, the oxidative reactions Mashingaidze, 1997), and these types of teas do not
take place, which are responsible for the quality of black receive good market value. Normally physically withered
tea (Omiadze et al., 2014). Catechin content decreases leaves show comparatively more caffeine concentration
during withering (Bokuchava and Skobeleva, 1980) and than forced physically withered tea leaves (Senderson
theaflavins (TF) and thearubigins (TR) (Omiadze et al., 2014) and Graham, 1973; Dev Choudhury and Bajaj, 1980;
are formed. TF and TR are the key parameters for brightness, Bhuyan and Mahanta, 1989; Tomlins and Mashingaidze,
briskness, color, and strength of black tea. 1997; Sanyal, 2011). Generally, in tea processing factories
during rainy days, the withering process is achieved with
Volatile flavor compounds (VFC) the application of hot air, and this makes the tea incapable
During withering, the levels of amino-acid derived of showing good creaming liquor. Therefore, it is always
aldehydes like methyl butanol, phenyl-acetaldehyde, and preferred to wither tea leaves normally below 38°C (Dev
n-hexanol increase, but carotenoid levels decrease (Panda, Choudhury and Bajaj, 1980).
2011). VFCs highly influence the quality and aroma of black
tea. There are mainly two types of VFC: Group I VFC, such Carotenoids
as hexanal and E-2-hexenal, and group II VFC, such as Carotenoids get degraded and volatile flavor compounds
linalool and geraniol. Group I VFC imparts inferior aroma, are formed during withering and fermentation (Hazarika
whereas group II VFC contributes to a positive effect on aroma. and Mahanta, 1983; Sanyal, 2011). Carotenoids are the
Research indicates that withering reduces the total amount of yellow pigments present in the green leaves, which assist
group I VFC, and increases the total amount of group II VFC with photosynthesis. Carotenoids degradation was found to
(Sanyal, 2011; Zheng et al., 2016). be more significant during physical withering as compared to
chemical withering.
Chlorophyll
A high amount of chlorophyll content is not desirable Roles of withering in different types of tea
during black tea production. It has been reported that processing
high chlorophyll content at the time of fermentation and The withering step plays a vital role for quality black
drying produce inferior liquor quality with a grassy tea manufacturing (Dev Choudhury and Bajaj, 1980). At
aroma (Tomlins and Mashingaidze, 1996; Sanyal, 2011). the same time withering is less important for producing
About 15% of chlorophyll degradation has been reported plain teas, which are mainly produced in Kenya and Malawi,
to occur during withering (Sanyal, 2011). Although high (Hilton, 1975; Owuor and Orchard, 1989; Orchard, 1991).
chlorophyll presence induces inferior liquor quality, However, it is recommended that there should be less
degradation of chlorophyll is recommended by proper handling of tea leaves during withering to minimize cell
withering, but high levels of chlorophyll degradation damage, so that negative effects on the subsequent step of
should be avoided. The conversion of chlorophyll to oxidation can be avoided (Sanyal, 2011). Nevertheless,
phaeophytin during fermentation and drying results in turn over treatment of leaves along with solar withering is
the black color of the CTC tea (Dev Choudhury and Bajaj, found to be necessary for the development of aroma
1980; Taylor et al., 1992; Tomlins and Mashingaidze, constituents in pouching tea. Research suggests that the
1997; Sanyal, 2011). withering process should be carried out below 38°C for
quality black tea, but for oolong tea, withering at 40°C
Caffeine results in more volatile compounds compared to normally
Caffeine is a very good stimulator of the central nervous withered leaves at ambient temperature. The withering step
system (Sanyal, 2011). The creaming property of black tea is not performed during production of green tea.
is an indication of caffeine content. Sufficient withering is
369
Deb and Jolvis Pou. A Review of Withering in the Processing of Black Tea
Journal of Biosystems Engineering • Vol. 41, No. 4, 2016 • www.jbeng.org
370
Deb and Jolvis Pou. A Review of Withering in the Processing of Black Tea
Journal of Biosystems Engineering • Vol. 41, No. 4, 2016 • www.jbeng.org
temperature. Therefore, it is necessary to understand the recognition. Food Research International 41(5):500-504.
various aspects of withering process and control the process Choudhury, R. 1970. Withering, serial No 185, K2 file, November
parameters to ensure high quality of manufactured tea. 1970, Tocklai Experimental Station, Assam, Indian.
Dev Choudhury, M. N. and K. L. Bajaj. 1980. Biochemical
changes during withering of tea shoots. Two and a Bud
Conflict of Interest 27:13-16.
Fard, F. S., H. R. Ghassemzadeh and S. B. Salvatian. 2015.
The authors have no conflicting financial or other Impact of withering time duration on some biochemical
interests. properties and sensory quality attributes of black tea.
Biological Forum-An International Journal 7(1):1045-1049.
Ghodake, H. M., T. K. Goswami and A. Chakraverty. 2006.
References Mathematical modeling of withering characteristics of
tea leaves. Drying Technology: An International Journal
Baruah, A. M. 2003. Fermentation characteristics of some 24(2):159-164.
Assamica clones and process optimization of black tea Gupta, R. and S. K. Dey. 2010. Development of a productivity
manufacturing. Journal of Agricultural and Food measurement model for tea industry. ARPN Journal of
Chemistry 51:6578-6588. Engineering and Applied Sciences 5:16-25.
Baruah, D., L. P. Bhuyan and M. Hazarika. 2012. Impact of Hazarika, M. and P. K. Mahanta. 1983. Some studies on
moisture loss and temperature on. biochemical changes carotenoids and their degradation in black tea manufacture.
during withering stage of black tea processing on four Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 34:1390-
Tocklai released clones. Two and a Bud 59(2):134-142. 1396.
Belitz, H. D., W. Grosch and P. Schieberle. 2009. Food Heneberry, M. 2006. The little black book of tea: The essential
chemistry, 4th revised and enlarged edition. Springer, guide to all things tea. Peter Pauper Press, New York.
Berlin 938-970. Hilton, P. J. 1975. Manufacture of tea in Central Africa. Tea
Bhagat, R. M., R. D. Baruah and S. Safique .2010. Climate and Research Foundation of Central Africa, Mulanje, Malawi.
tea [Camellia sinensis (L.) O. Kuntze] production with Hussian, I., F. Khan, Y. Iqbal and S. J. Khalil. 2006. Investigation
special reference to North Eastern India: a review. of heavy metals in commercial tea brands. Journal of
Journal of Environmental and Research and Development Chemical Society of Pakistan 28:246-251.
4(4):10171028. Jabeen, S., S. Alam, M. Saleem, W. Ahmad, R. Bibi, F. S. Hamid
Bhatia, I. S. 1962. Chemical aspects of withering. Two and a and H. U. Shah. 2015. Withering timings affect the total
Bud 9:26-30. free amino acids and mineral contents of tea leaves
Bhatia, I. S. 1964. The role of chemistry in tea manufacture. during black tea manufacturing. Arabian Journal of
Two and a Bud 11:109-l 17. Chemistry doi: 10.1016/j.arabjc.2015.03.011
Bhuyan, L. P. and P. K. Mahanta. 1989. Studies on fatty acid Jolvis Pou, K. R. 2016. Fermentation: The Key Step in the
composition in tea Camellia sinensis. Journal of the Processing of Black Tea. Journal of Biosystems Engineering
Science of Food and Agriculture 46:325-330. 41(2):85-92.
Bokuchava, M. A. and N. I. Skobeleva. 1980. The biochemistry Katiyar, S. K. and H. Mukhtar. 1996. Tea in chemoprevention
and technology of tea manufacture. CRC Critical Reviews of cancer: epidemiologic and experimental studies.
in Food Science and Nutrition 12:303-370. International Journal of Oncology 8:221-238.
Burton, S. J. A. 1995. Leaf handling project, part of B.Sc Kumar, S. and K. R. Jolvis Pou. 2016. Assessment of bio-energy
degree in Environmental Management, Silsoe College, potential in tea industries of India. Asian Journal of
Cranfield University, U.K. Agriculture and Rural Development 6(5):83-89.
Chaturvedula, V. S. P. and I. Prakash. 2011. The aroma, taste, Mahanta, P. K. and S. Boruah. 1989. Relationship between
colour and bioactive constituents of tea. Journal of process of withering and aroma characteristics of black
Medicinal Plants Research 5(11):2110-2124. tea. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture
Chen, Q., J. Zhao and S. Vittayapadung. 2008. Identification of 40:461-468.
the green tea grade level using electronic tongue and pattern Motoda, S. 1979. Formation of aldehydes from amino acids
371
Deb and Jolvis Pou. A Review of Withering in the Processing of Black Tea
Journal of Biosystems Engineering • Vol. 41, No. 4, 2016 • www.jbeng.org
by polyphenol oxidase. Journal of Fermentation Technology Sakata, K., M. Mizutani, S. Ma and W. Guo. 2004. Improvement of
57:395-399. flavour quality of CTC black tea by glycosidases in tea leaves.
Obanda, M., P. O. Owuor, R. Mangoka and M. M. Kavi. 2004. International Journal of Tea Science 3:167-173.
Changes in thearubigin fractions and theaflavin levels Sanyal, S. 2011. Tea manufacturing manual. Tea Research
due to variations in processing conditions and their Association, Tocklai Experimental Station, Jorhat.
influence on black tea liquor brightness and total color. Selvendran, R. R. 1969. Metabolism of nucleotide and phosphate
Food Chemistry 85:163-173. esters in tea shoots during black tea manufacture. Tea Quality
Omiadze, N. T., N. I. Mchedlishvili, J. N. Rodrigez_Lopez, M. O. 40:93-98.
Abutidze, T. A. Sadunishvili, and N. G. Pruidze. 2014. Sharangi, A. B. 2009. Medicinal and therapeutic potentialities of
Biochemical processes at the stage of withering during tea (Camellia sinensis L.)-A review. Food Research
black tea production. Applied Biochemistry and International 42 (5-6):529-535.
Microbiology 50(4):394-397. Takeo, T. and T. Tsushida. 1980. Changes in lipoxygenase
Orchard, J. E. 1991. Technical Report 1988-91. ODA TCO, Tea activity in relation to lipid degradation in plucked tea
Research Foundation of Kenya, P.O. Box 820, Kericho, shoots. Phytochemistry 19:2521-2522.
Kenya, 126. Takeo, T. 1984. Effect of the withering process on volatile
Owuor, P. O. and J. E. Orchard. 1989. Withering, annual compound formation during black tea manufacture.
report. Tea Research Foundation of Kenya 89-102. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 35:84-87.
Owuor, P. O. and J. E. Orchard. 1992. Effects of storage time in Taylor, S., D. Baker, P. Owuor, J. Orchard, C. Othieno and C.
a two-stage withering process on the quality of seedling Gay. 1992. A model for predicting black tea quality from
black tea. Food Chemistry 45:45-49. the carotenoid and chlorophyll composition of fresh
Owuor, P. O., T. Tsushida, H. Horita and T. Murai. 1987. Effects of green tea leaf. Journal of the Science of Food and
artificial withering on the chemical composition and quality Agriculture 58:185-191.
of black tea. Tropical Science 27:159-166. Tomlins, K. I. and A. Mashingaidze. 1997. Influence of
Panda, H. 2011. A complete book on cultivation and manufacture withering, including leaf handling, on the manufacturing
of tea. Asia Pacific Business Press Inc., Delhi 24-42. and quality of black teas-a review. Food Chemistry
Perera, K. P. W. C. and R. L. Wickremasinghe. 1972. Properties of 60(4):573-580.
tea polyphenol oxidase. Tea Quarterly 43:153-163. Ullah, M. R. and P. C. Roy. 1982. Effect of withering on the
Ravichandran, R. and R. Parthiban. 1998. Changes in enzyme polyphenol oxidase level in the leaf. Journal of the
activities (polyphenol oxidase and phenylalanine ammo- Science of Food and Agriculture 33:492-495.
nia lyase) with type of tea leaf and during black tea Ullah, M. R. 1984. A reappraisal of withering process in black
manufacture and the effect of enzyme supplementation of tea manufacture. I. Physical and chemical withers and
dhool on black tea quality. Food Chemistry 62(3):277-281. their effects on tea liquors. Two and a Bud 31:20-24.
Roberts, E. A. H. 1962. The chemistry of tea manufacture. Journal Wickremasinghe, R. L. 1975. Tea. Advances in Food Research
of the Science of Food and Agriculture 9:381-390. 24:229-286.
Roberts, E. A. H. 1963. The phenolic substances of manufactured Wilkie, A. S. 1995. Leaf handling study. TRF QNL 120:26-38.
tea. X. The creaming down of tea liquors. Journal of the Wright, A. J. and M. J. Fishwick. 1979. Lipid degradation during
Science of Food and Agriculture 14:700-705. manufacture of black tea. Phytochemistry 18:1511-1513
Sanderson, G. W. and H. N. Graham. 1973. On the formation of Yamanishi, T., A. Kobayashi, H. Sata, H. Nakanura, K. Oswa, A.
black tea aroma. Journal of Agricultural and Food Uchida, S. Mori and R. Saijo. 1966. Flavour of black tea.
Chemistry 21:576-585. Part IV. Changes in flavour constituents during the
Sanderson, G. W. 1964. The theory of withering in tea manufacture of black tea. Agricultural and Biological
manufacture. Tea Quarterly 35:146-163. Chemistry 30:784-792.
Saijo, R. 1977. Mechanisms of developing black tea aroma Yan, S. H. 2007. NIR evaluation of the quality of tea and its
with special reference to alcoholic compounds. Japan market price. Spectroscopy Europe 19(2):16-19.
Agricultural Research Quarterly 11:216-220. Zheng, X. Q., Q. S. Li, L. P. Xiang and Y. R. Liang. 2016. Recent
advances in volatiles of teas. Molecules 21(338):1-12.
372