PFD File
PFD File
PFD File
BY
PREPARED BY
TM
2018 - 2019
I
II
Scanned by CamScanner
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
U
The prompt response as well as help from Mr. Shirish Pandit, Mr. M.G.Ganu and Mr. A.K.
Nagarch during providing certain information, documentation and data related to the production,
processes and details of manufacturing is duly appreciated.
I must thank our Technical Directors namely Prof. (Dr.) Jay Samant, Dr. (Mrs.) Anuradha
Samant, and our empanelled experts Mr. Vinaykumar Kurakula, Mr. B. S. Lole, Dr. J.B. Pishte
and Prof. (Dr.) Bhaskar N. Thorat for their able and timely contributions in the EIA studies and
report preparation. Despite their busy schedules in the universities, colleges and own professions,
they were always available, on time, for the necessary inputs; field visits and discussions.
My staff of the EIA Study Cell here must receive a commendation and credit for all the in-house
management and inputs during the monitoring, report preparation and presentations. The In-house
experts of various functional areas have contributed their best.
Last but not the least, the contributions from my non-technical staff members and laboratory team
is also duly appreciated here.
Chartered Engineer
Chairman & MD
Equinox Environments (India) Pvt. Ltd. (EEIPL); Kolhapur
III
CAUTION
The information, data, figures, flow charts and drawings in respect of manufacturing processes,
mass balance, chemical reactions, production lay-outs and instrumentation details included in this
Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Report are the sole property of The Dharamsi Morarji
Chemical Company Limited (TDMCCL), Plot No. 105 in MIDC Industrial Area, P.O.
Dhatav, Taluka: Roha, District: Raigad, State: Maharashtra. Some of the products, reactions
and process methodologies may be patented.
The style and format of this EIA Report as well as the data, processing and presentations of
various environmental features, environmental management planning; designs; drawings; plates;
calculations, demonstrations on attributes towards pollution control and abatement aspects etc. are
the intellectual property of M/s. Equinox Environments (India) Pvt. Ltd. (EEIPL); Kolhapur.
Under no circumstances, any part of this report may be used; reproduced; translated; recorded or
copied in any form and manner except by the Govt. authorities requiring this report for taking
decisions, based on details and information provided in same, during the Environmental
Clearance procedure carried out as per EIA Notification No. S.O. 1533 (E) dated 14.09.2006 as
amended from time to time.
Chartered Engineer
Chairman & MD
Equinox Environments (India) Pvt. Ltd. (EEIPL); Kolhapur
Environmental and Civil Engineers, Consultants& Analysts
ISO 9001 : 2015 & QCI-NABET accredited Organization
IV
CERTIFICATE
Declaration by Expert contributing to the EIA in respect of proposed expansion of existing
commodity chemicals and speciality chemicals manufacturing unit by “The Dharamsi Morarji
Chemical Company Limited (TDMCCL)” located at Plot No. 105 in MIDC Industrial Area, P.O.
Dhatav, Taluka: Roha, District: Raigad, State: Maharashtra.
We, hereby, certify that we were a part of the EIA team in the following capacity that developed
the above EIA.
Involvement
Sr. Functional
Name of the expert/s (Period & Signature
No. Areas
Task**)
1 WP* Prof. (Dr.) Bhaskar N.
Thorat
V
Involvement
Sr. Functional
Name of the expert/s (Period & Signature
No. Areas
Task**)
4 AP* Dr. Sangram Ghugare
7 GEO*
Mr. Vaibhav Survase
10 NV*
11 LU* Mr. Vinay Kumar Kurakula
VI
Sr. Functional Involvement
No. Areas Period Task
1 WP January 2018 – 1. Detailed study of the production process and operations there
December 2018 under was carried out initially. There under, mass balance of raw
materials, intermediates and final products was conducted along
with the chemists and experts from the Industry.
2. The different chemical reactions involved in manufacturing were
understood and quantification of effluents, emission & residues
was done.
3. Overall water budgeting and effluent generation statistics was
carried out. Categorization of effluent streams based on
characterization done. Based on probable characteristics of the
effluents, separation of various effluent streams in the industry
(depending up on strengths and flow rates) was done.
4. Verification of water supply source and its adequacy was
evaluated.
5. Planning of water quality monitoring in the study area was done
and requisite information was provided to the Lab for
undertaking the assignment.
6. For the environmental clearance, exercise was done towards
preparation of the application, EIA report which included project
framing and report preparation in line with policies, guidelines
and legislation related to water pollution followed by defending
of the project before expert committee at MoEF; for obtaining
actual environmental clearance.
2 EB January 2018 - 1. Planning of survey time table and schedule toward monitoring of
July 2018 ecological & biodiversity status of the study region.
2. Selection of terrestrial and aquatic ecological sites based on
criteria namely location of project, likely sources of pollution,
wind directions in different seasons and location of water bodies
w.r.t their distances from site and direction of flow when
applicable, aerial distances of the sampling sites from project.
3. Interaction with local residents for obtaining information about
various species of animals and birds usually observed their
existence and importance in the study region.
4. Study of terrestrial fauna by sighting, noting pug-marks, calls,
sounds, droppings, nests and burrows etc.
5. Collection of samples from nearby water body for studying the
aquatic flora and fauna.
6. Conducting ecological & wildlife surveys and preparation of
status reports.
7. Interaction with Govt. offices and agencies for certain secondary
data and information pertaining to region specific issues.
8. Review of rules, legislation and criteria towards knowing and
understanding inclusion in the study region of any eco-sensitive
zones, wild life sanctuaries, reserves etc.
9. Collection, compilation and presentation of the data as well as
incorporation of same in to the Draft EIA report.
VII
Sr. Functional Involvement
No. Areas Period Task
3 SE February 2018 - 1. Collection of data on socio-economic aspects in study area
July 2018 through surveys.
2. To evaluate the parameters defining socio-economic conditions
of the population.
3. Analysis of the identified social attributes like population
distribution, availability of public utilities etc. through
secondary sources and literature like district census handbook.
4. Public opinions and recording of events for future
industrialization in the study area.
5. Collection of socio-economic data from secondary sources like
taluka offices, Collectorate, agriculture dept. irrigation dept.,
central ground water board etc.
6. Compilation of primary and secondary data and its inclusion in
EIA report.
7. Study of sociological aspects like human settlement,
demographic and infrastructural facilities available in study area.
4 AP December 2018 1. Involved in detailed study of mass balance w.r.t. raw materials
- December & products especially from view point of process emissions.
2018 2. Different emissions were analyzed and line of action to control
them was decided. Accordingly, along with interaction with the
process experts from the industry scrubber types and media were
decided.
3. Also, solvent recovery plant/system was given a priority thought
from pollution control and economy point of views.
4. Carried out study of the type and capacity of the boiler and its
operations including type and nature of the fuels to be used.
Accordingly, composition of probable stack emissions & their
control measures were thought of.
5. Planning and designing of APC equipment / systems was done
from viewpoints of efficiencies, capital as well as O & M cost &
suitability.
5 AQ February 2018 - 1. Designing of Ambient AQM network for use in prediction
December 2018 modeling and micro metrological data development
2. Sec. metrological data collection
3. Development and application of air quality models in prediction
of pollutant dispersion,
6 HG February 2018 - 1. Collection, analysis and evaluation of data pertaining to surface
July 2018 hydrology of the region. Hydrogeological studies, data
processing; analysis and evaluation, Ground water table
measurement and monitoring network methodology preparation.
2. Planning and scheduling of groundwater sampling stations in the
region.
3. Computation of ground water recharge, flow rates and allied
data.
4. Determination of impact of withdrawal of groundwater. Studies
w.r.t. artificial recharge and rainwater harvesting. Contribution
to the EIA report preparation.
7 GEO February 2018 - 1. Study of geology & general geological configuration of the
July 2018 region as well as sub-surface geology. Ancillary studies and
data analysis w.r.t. demography, climatic conditions, land uses
and soils
2. Geological and geo-morphological analysis and evaluation.
Preparation of drainage map , geo-morphological map,
Stratigraphy and lithology studies. Evaluation and analysis of
preliminary geological explorations in the region including
VIII
Sr. Functional Involvement
No. Areas Period Task
study of structural, physical & Indian geology.
8 SHW February 2018 - 1. Under SHW study, mass balance of raw materials and products'
June 2018 was checked and verified thoroughly. It included detailed study
of process operations under proposed manufacturing activities.
Further, a detailed survey of manufacturing operations including
their mass balance analysis was conducted through actual site
visits and interactions with experts from the industry. This being
commodity chemicals and speciality chemicals manufacturing
unit involved in all the manufacturing were studied in detailed
manner.
2. Solid wastes generation in different steps of manufacturing was
identified and their quantification done was checked.
3. Identification of various hazardous wastes generated through
manufacturing process, their quantification categorically was
done through study of process reactions.
4. Verification was done towards the practices of storage and
disposal of HW under proposed facility which included checked
of the steps towards procurement of CHWTSDF memberships,
maintain of records of the waste generation and forwarding to
the disposal facility, notices and directions received from MPCB
in this regard. Also it was checked that the planning towards
handling of these wastes and their storage were done as per
CPCB and MoEF guidelines.
5. The dedicated areas demarked and developed in the industrial
premises for HW were checked for their adequacy and
functional sufficiency.
6. Had an interaction with process people and management
towards possibilities of recycling and reuse of solid wastes in
order to reduce their quantities which included study of
planning, collection and segregation methodologies.
9 RH February 2018 - 1. All the necessary literature for processes storage of hazardous
June 2018 chemicals for proposed was studied before visit.
2. A walk through survey of the entire proposed hazardous areas
was done.
3. Company has prepared HAZOP report for processes. Suggested
to carry of similar HAZOP studies for all new production plants
and implement recommendations to minimize risk of accident
due to process upsets.
4. Verification of adequacy of on-site emergency preparedness
plan for proposed unit.
5. Identification of probable emergencies and procedures for
preparedness for handling the same was verified.
6. Adequacy of proposed setup for higher production was
guaranteed by the client.
7. Adequacy of disaster management plan prepared was checked.
8. It was suggested to carry out quantities risk analysis.
10 NV February 2018 - 1. Detail study of manufacturing process and identification of
June 2018 probable noise and vibration sources was done. In proposed unit,
prominently the noise sources were production plant, boiler area.
Also, DG set was one of such locations having high potential for
noise.
2. Verification of noise levels Monitoring (both work zone and
ambient) in the industrial premises and study region done by the
Lab team during primary data generation for EIA.
IX
Sr. Functional Involvement
No. Areas Period Task
3. Verification of Planning and designing of noise attenuation
measures. Apart from the separation, insulation, isolation
techniques implemented in-hose, outside measures like planning,
designing and implementation of Green Belt was done. Therein,
plants having prominent role in noise attenuation were
implemented.
4. Site visit was done for verification of sampling locations,
ambient noise monitoring stations and the data collected
5. Evaluation of impact of noise sources on surrounding
community especially in light of – (a) characteristics of noise
sources (instantaneous, intermittent or continuous), (b) the time
of day at which noise occurs, (c) the location of noise w.r.t.
noise sensitive land use implemented.
11 LU February 2018 - 1. Land use land cover mapping using NRSC Satellite image,
June 2018 2. Satellite image processing, Image classification, Technical
analysis and study for setting up of facility, planning of storage
facility.
12 SC February 2018 - 1. Involvement physical analysis & characterization of the soils.
June 2018 2. Assessment of fertility and productivity of soils in the region.
3. Evaluation / prediction of impacts on soils due to various liquid,
gaseous & solid pollutants.
4. Studies w.r.t. soil salinity & reclamation management in the
region.
5. Interpretation of soil analysis, results and data including
comparison of same with standard soil classification.
6. Collection, study and evaluation of soil information from data
obtained from secondary sources & its interpretation.
X
Declaration by the Head of the Accredited Consultant
Organization/authorized person.
I, Dr. Sangram Ghugare, hereby confirm that the above mentioned experts prepared the final
EIA in respect of proposed expansion of existing commodity chemicals and speciality
chemicals manufacturing unit by “The Dharamsi Morarji Chemical Company Limited
(TDMCCL)” located at Plot No. 105 in MIDC Industrial Area, P.O. Dhatav, Taluka: Roha, District:
Raigad, State: Maharashtra.
I also confirm that the consultant organization shall be fully accountable for any mis-leading
information mentioned in this statement.
Signature:
XI
ABBREVIATIONS
AAQM Ambient Air Quality Monitoring
AGL Above Ground Level
ARL Above Roof Level
AP Air Pollution
AM Arithmetic Mean
AQ Air Quality
ALOHA Areal Locations of Hazardous Atmospheres
ACGIH American Conference Government of Industrial Hygienists
APC Air Pollution Control
BRICS Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa
BIS Bureau of Indian Standards
BOD Biochemical Oxygen Demand
BEES Battelle Environmental Evaluation System
CAGR Compound Annual Growth Rate
CCE Chemistry And Chemical Engineering
CGWB Central Ground Water Board
CMD Cubic Meter per Day
CO Carbon Monoxide
CO2 Carbon Dioxide
CEC Cation Exchange Capacity
COD Chemical Oxygen Demand
CPCB Central Pollution Control Board
CHWTSDF Common Hazardous Waste Treatment, Storage & Disposal Facility
CREP Corporate Responsibility For Environmental Protection
CER Corporate Environment Responsibility
CETP Common Effluent Treatment Plant
CTE Consent to Establish
CTO Consent to Operate
CWC Central Water Commission
dB (A) Decibel (Ambient)
DG Diesel Generator
DIRD Directorate of Irrigation Research and Development
DO Dissolved Oxygen
ESC Enterprise Social Commitment
EAC Expert Appraisal Committee
EB Ecology And Biodiversity
EC Electrical conductivity
EC Environmental Clearance
ESA Ecologically Sensitive Area
EEIPL Equinox Environments (India) Private Limited
EIA Environmental Impact Assessment
EMC Environmental Management Cell
EMP Environmental Management Plan
EPA Environmental Protection Act
EHS Environment, health and safety
ETP Effluent Treatment Plant
FO Furnace Oil
FAE Functional Area Expert
XII
FDI Foreign Direct Investment
GDP Gross Domestic Product
GPS Global Positioning System
GC Gas Chromatography
GEO Geology
GMP Good Management Practice
GSDA Ground Water Surveys and Development Agency
HVS High Volume Air Sampler
HG-GEO Hydro Geology and Geology
HAZOP Hazard and Operability Study
HIRA Hazard Identification and Risk Analysis
HDPE High Density Polyethylene
HSD High Speed Diesel
IAEC Indian Atomic Energy Commission
IMD India Metrological Department
IRS Indian Remote Sensing
IS Indian Standards
IDLH Immediately Dangerous to Life or Health
ISO International Organization For Standardization
KL Kilo Liter
KLPD Kilo Liter per Day
KVA Kilo Volt Ampere
LC Land Cover
LDO Light Diesel Oil
LU Land Use
LUP Land Use Planning
MSEDCL Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company Limited
MSEB Maharashtra State Electricity Board
MSDS Material Safety Data Sheet
MIDC Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation
MoU Memorandum of understanding
MEE Multiple Effective Evaporator
MoEFCC Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change
MPCB Maharashtra Pollution Control Board
MCLS Maximum Credible Loss Scenario
MSL Mean Sea Level
MT Metric Tone
MS Mild Steel
N North
NPC Noise Pollution Control
NAAQS National Ambient Air Quality Standards
NW North - West
NFPA National Fire Protection Association
NOx Oxides of Nitrogen
NTU Nephelometric Turbidity Unit
NBSS National Bureau of Soil Survey
NV Noise and Vibration
OHS Occupational Health Hazards and Safety
OHC Occupational Health Center
O&M Operation and Maintenance
XIII
OHSAS Occupational Health and Safety Assessment Series
OSHA Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PM Particulate Matter
PEL Permissible Exposure level
PHA Preliminary Hazard Analysis
PHA Process Hazard Analysis
PPE Personal Protective Equipment
PP Project Proponent
R&R Rehabilitation and Resettlement
R&D Research and Development
SSP Single Superphosphate
SEIAA State Environment Impact Assessment Authority
SPCB State Pollution Control Board
SC Soil conservation
SE Socio - Economics
SHW Solid and Hazardous Waste
SAR Sodium Adsorption ratio
SO2 Sulphur Dioxide
SPM Suspended Particulate Matter
SS Suspended Solids
STP Sewage Treatment Plant
SOP Standard Operating Procedure
SW South - west
TDMCCL The Dharamsi Morarji Chemical Company Limited
TG Turbo Generator
TDS Total Dissolved Solids
TFH Thermic Fluid Heater
ToR Terms of Reference
TPH Tones Per Hour
USEPA US Environmental Protection Agency
VOC Volatile organic component
WPC Water Pollution Control
WHC Water Holding Capacity
W West
ZLD Zero Liquid Discharge
XIV
CONFIGURATION OF REPORT
Chapter 1 - Introduction
This chapter is an introductory chapter, presenting the background information of the project, its
location, objective of the project and scope of the study and documentation.
This chapter deals with the technology and process to be used for the proposed expansion
project. It also deals with the sources of pollution and mitigation measures under existing and
expansion activity.
In this chapter the study of various attributes of environment such as Air, Water, Noise, Soil,
Land Use Pattern, Geology, Hydro-geology and Ecology is carried out so as to know the existing
environmental status. Also, the present social status is discussed to know if there are any
sensitive issues in the area.
This chapter presents the conclusion drawn by studying the impact considering both the pre -
project and post - project scenario. It describes the sum impact of the proposed expansion project
and mitigation measures for abatement of the pollution.
Various alternatives in terms of site selection and technology to be used are discussed in this
chapter and the environment friendly and best suited technology is selected for the expansion
project.
This chapter deals with the planning of Environmental Monitoring Program both during
construction phase and operational phase to assess the performance of pollution control
equipments to be installed.
This chapter illustrates the possible risk area under the proposed expansion project and the safety
and disaster management plan prepared to mitigate the same.
XV
Chapter 8 - Project Benefits
This chapter describes the predictable benefits due to proposed expansion project of commodity
chemicals and speciality chemicals manufacturing unit.
This chapter deals with the protection and mitigation measures for abatement of pollution after
execution of the project. It also deals with the roles and responsibilities of the environmental
management cell for proper implementation of the Environmental Management Plan.
In this chapter the name and brief resume of the consultant organization engaged in preparation
of the EIA report is presented.
XVI
CONTENTS
1.1 Introduction 1
1.2 The Project & Proponents 1
1.3 Achievements of TDMCCL 2
1.4 The Place 2
1.5 Project Importance to the Country & Region 2
1.6 Scope of the Study 4
1.6.1 Details of Regulatory Scoping carried out as per Terms of Reference 4
17-54
CHAPTER 2 - PROJECT DESCRIPTION
XVII
2.7.6 Odour Pollution 51
2.7.7 Land Pollution 51
2.7.8 Anticipated Occupational Health Hazards and Safety 51
2.8 Operation and Maintenance Cost 52
2.9 Green Belt Development Plan 52
2.10 Rain Water Harvesting Aspect 52
55-120
CHAPTER 3 - DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT
3.1 Introduction 55
3.2 Land Use and Land Cover (LU & LC) 55
3.2.1 Scope of work 55
3.2.2 Study Area 55
3.2.3 Purpose of Land Use Mapping 57
3.2.4 Methodology for LU & LC Study 57
3.2.5 Satellite Data 59
3.3 Land Use Studies 61
3.3.1 Topographical Features 61
3.3.2 Eco-Sensitive Map 63
3.3.3 Land Use Map Analysis 63
3.3.4 Land Use of Study Area 64
3.3.5 Settlement Map 66
3.4 Soil Characteristics 68
3.4.1 Soil Quality: Present status 68
3.4.2 Methodology 68
3.4.2.1 Methodology of Data Generation 68
3.4.2.2 Sources of Information 69
3.4.3 Soil Types 69
3.4.4 General Observations 74
3.5 Drainage and Geomorphology 81
3.5.1 Drainage 81
3.5.2 Geomorphology 83
3.6 Geology And Hydrogeology 83
3.6.1 Introduction 83
3.6.2 Geology 85
3.6.2.1 Study area: EIA Aspect of geology 85
3.6.3 Hydrogeology 85
3.6.3.1 Study area: EIA Aspect of hydrogeology 88
3.6.3.2 Ground water Resources 88
3.6.3.3 Groundwater Quality 90
3.7 Meteorology 91
3.7.1 Introduction 92
3.7.2 Methodology 92
3.7.2.1 Methodology of Data Generation 93
3.7.2.2 Sources of Information 93
XVIII
3.7.2.3 Wind Pattern at Project Site during Study Period 93
3.8 Air Quality 93
3.8.1 Introduction 93
3.8.2 Methodology 94
3.8.2.1 Selection of Sampling Locations 94
3.8.2.2 Frequency & Parameters for Sampling 94
3.8.3 Presentation of Results 95
3.8.4 Observations based on Period of October 2017 to December 2017 97
3.9 Water Quality 99
3.9.1 Introduction 99
3.9.2 Methodology 99
3.9.2.1 Methodology of Data Generation 99
3.9.3 Sampling Procedure for Primary Data Generation 100
Presentation of Ground Water Results for Survey from October 2017 - 101
3.9.4
December 2017
3.9.4.1 General Observations 104
3.10 Noise Level Survey 105
3.10.1 Introduction 105
3.10.2 Identification of Sampling Locations 106
3.10.2.1 Ambient Noise Monitoring Stations 106
3.10.2.2 Method of Monitoring 107
3.10.3.3 Standards for Noise Levels 107
3.10.3 Presentation of Results 109
3.11 Socio-Economic Profile 109
3.11.1 Introduction 109
3.11.2 Methodology 110
3.11.3 Results and discussion 110
3.11.4 General observation in the study area through SIA survey 112
3.11.5 Conclusion 113
3.11.6 Suggestions 113
3.12 Ecology 113
3.12.1 Study area 113
3.12.2 Methodology 114
3.12.3 Ecology 115
3.12.3.1 Field Observation 115
3.12.3.2 Questionnaire findings 115
3.12.4 Biodiversity 116
3.12.4.1 Field Observation 116
3.12.4.2 Questionnaire findings 116
Environmental Impact of Proposed Project on Ecology and 118
3.12.4.3
Biodiversity in the region
3.12.5 Recommendations 118
3.12.5.1 Green Belt 118
3.12.5.2 Corporate Environment Responsibility (CER) Activity 119
3.12.6 General observations and Recommendations 119
XIX
121-165
CHAPTER 4 - ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES
XX
4.7.1. Decommissioning Phase 164
4.7.2 Planning for Decommissioning of the TDMCCL Project 164
166-170
CHAPTER 5 - ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES
XXI
7.7.1 Reaction And Separation Sections of Production Plant 186
7.8 Storage and Handling of Hazardous Raw Materials 188
7.8.1 Hazard Identification 188
7.8.2 Storage of Hazardous Chemicals 189
7.8.3 Main Hazards in Storage of Chemicals 191
7.8.4 Mitigation measures for storage of chemicals in warehouse 193
7.8.5 Storage of Toxic Chemicals 195
7.8.6 Storage of Acids and Alkalis 195
7.8.7 Handling of the Materials / Process Equipment 197
7.9 Quantitative Risk Analysis 202
7.9.1 National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) Rating 202
7.9.2 Quantification of Hazards due to Storage of Hazardous Materials 203
7.9.3 Fire Protection 207
7.9.3.1 Fire Load 208
7.10 Occupational Health Center 209
7.11 Safety Health And Environment Policy 210
7.12 Onsite Emergency & Disaster Management Plan 210
7.13 Off Site Disaster Control Plan 211
7.14 EHS Policy 211
7.15 Quality Policy 211
XXII
10.1 Introduction 222
10.2 Project at a Glance 222
10.3 Process Description 223
10.3.1 Products and Byproducts 223
10.3.2 Raw Material 225
10.4 Manufacturing Processes, Flow Charts And Mass Balance of The Products 226
10.5 Sources of Pollution and Mitigation Measures 227
10.5.1 Water Pollution 227
10.5.2 Air Pollution 228
10.5.3 Noise Pollution 228
10.5.4 Solid Waste 228
10.5.5 Hazardous Waste 229
10.5.6 Odour Pollution 229
10.6 Rainwater Harvesting Aspect 229
10.7 Green Belt Development 230
10.8 Environmental Monitoring Program 230
10.9 Environmental Management Plan 230
10.10 Conclusion 230
XXIII
DESCRIPTION
Sr. No. PAGE No.
Enclosure - I Standard ToR Letter 242-249
Enclosure - II Certificates and Other Documents 250-254
Appendices
Appendix A Plot Layout Plan 255
Appendix B Statutory Permissions 256-279
Appendix C Land Lease Agreement 280-302
Appendix D Chemical name of Products with CAS Number 303-304
Appendix E Details on manufacturing processes, processes flow charts, 305-394
product-wise raw materials, mass balance for each product
Appendix F Certificate of Merit for Water Resource Management 395
Appendix G Water Permission Letter 396-412
Appendix H Certificate of Merit for Efficient Waste Management 413
Appendix I CHWTSDF Membership Letter 414
Appendix J Heat Pump Based Effluent to Distilled Water Convertor 415
diagram
Appendix K Process Hazard Analysis of BSCl plant, Process Hazard 416-430
Analysis of DES plant and Process Hazard Analysis of
SVS plant
Appendix L Layout of Benzene storage tank and Ammonia storage tank 431-432
Appendix M Fire hydrant layout Plan 433
Appendix N Hazard and Operability Study (HAZOP) study of Sulphuric 434-510
Acid plant
Appendix O Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) 511-551
Appendix P Impacts under Accidental Scenarios 552-575
Appendix Q Hazard Identification and Risk Analysis (HIRA), 576-667
Immediately Dangerous to Life or Health (IDLH),
Maximum Credible Loss Scenario (MCLS)
Appendix R Health Check-up Reports 668-678
Appendix S On Site Emergency Plan 679-737
Appendix T EHS policy 738
Appendix U Quality policy 739
Appendix V List of ESA Villages, List of Flora & Fauna Observed in 740-743
Study Area
Appendix W Photographs of Ecology & Biodiversity and Socio 744-747
Economics Survey
Monitoring Reports
Annexure - I Soil Monitoring Report 748-751
Annexure - II Meteorological Data 752-775
Annexure - III Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Report 776-800
Annexure - IV Ground water Monitoring Report 801-804
Annexure - V Surface water Monitoring Report 804-808
Annexure - VI Noise Monitoring Report 809
XXIV
LIST OF TABLES
XXV
Table No. Name of Table Page No.
3.2 List of major industries near TDMCCL Industry 56
3.3 Source of Satellite Data 59
3.4 Source of Topographical Data 61
3.5 Area Statistics for Land Use & Land Cover Classes 64
3.6 Analytical Techniques for Soil Analysis 69
3.7 Soil Sampling Locations 71
3.8 Existing Soil Characteristics 73
3.9 Standard Soil Classification 80
3.10 Meteorological Parameters 93
3.11 AAQM Locations Details 94
3.12 AAQ Parameters and Monitoring Frequency 94
3.13 Summary of AAQ Levels for Monitoring Season [October 2017 to 95
December 2017]
3.14 National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) Specified by CPCB 97
Notification (New Delhi, the 18th November, 2009)
3.15 Monitoring Locations for Ground Water 99
3.16 Monitoring Locations for Surface Water 99
3.17 Summary of Ground Water 101
3.18 Summary of Surface Water 103
3.19 Noise Sampling Locations 106
3.20 Ambient Noise Level Standards 108
3.21 Standards for Occupational Exposure 108
3.22 OSHA Standards for Occupational Exposure 108
3.23 Ambient Noise Levels 109
3.24 Details of Sample Size 110
3.25 Study villages, Villages from the Western Ghats ESA and their 114
distance from project site
4.1 Identification of impacts on environment due to operation activities for 122
proposed expansion project of TDMCCL
4.2 Process Product Modifications for pollution Control and Impact 124
Minimization
4.3 Predominant Wind Directions 132
4.4 Baseline Concentrations 133
4.5 Human Health Impact of Process Emissions 134
4.6 Quantification of pollution from waste water 138
4.7 Quantification of impact due to discharge of untreated effluent into 139
Nalla
4.8 Quantification of impact due to Contaminated Nalla with untreated 139
effluents into Kundalika River
4.9 Permissible Exposure In Case of Continuous Noise 145
4.10 Standards in Respect of Ambient Noise Levels 146
4.11 Occupational Health and Safety 148
4.12 Application of the Battele Environmental Evalution System (EES) for 158
TDMCCL
4.13 Identification of RED Flags to the Potential Areas in BEES for 161
XXVI
Table No. Name of Table Page No.
TDMCCL
4.14 Identification of Impacts Due to Decommissioning activities of 165
TDMCCL project
6.1 Trees with Good Canopy for Noise Attenuation 173
6.2 Health Care Facility Equipment 175
6.3 Budgetary Allocation 176
6.4 CER Implementation Schedule 177
6.5 Environmental Monitoring During Project Operation Stage 179
6.6 Implementation of Environmental Monitoring Program 181
6.7 The Details of Management Plan During Worst Case Scenario 181
7.1 Classification of Chemicals 185
7.2 TLV and IDLH values 188
7.3 List of Flammable solvents Stored in Warehouse 190
7.4 List of Solvents for proposed products and its storage on site 191
7.5 List of Toxic Chemicals (In drums and Warehouse) 195
7.6 List of Acids and Alkalis stored in Tanks/drums 195
7.7 NFPA Rating of Raw Material 202
7.8 Risk Assessment - Worst Case Scenarios and Mitigation Measures 203
7.9 Details of fire Extinguishers 207
7.10 Details of Fire Load 209
7.11 Details of Occupational Health Monitoring 209
8.1 Yearly Expenses incurred on CER & Social Welfare (In INR) 213
9.1 Environmental Management cell 214
9.2 Summary of Recommendations 216
9.3 Compliance against the Consent Condition 219
10.1 Salient Features of TDMCCL Project site 222
10.2 List of Products 224
10.3 List of Byproducts 225
10.4 List of Collective quantity of Raw material required per batch 225
10.5 Solid Waste Details for Existing and Expansion Activities 228
10.6 Hazardous Waste Details for Existing and Expansion Activities 229
XXVII
LIST OF FIGURES
XXVIII
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 INTRODUCTION
The Proposed expansion project - The Dharamsi Morarji Chemical Company Limited
(TDMCCL) is located at Plot No. 105 in MIDC Industrial Area, P.O. Dhatav, Taluka: Roha,
District: Raigad, State: Maharashtra.
This report is made in the overall context of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)
Notification No. S. O. 1533 (E) dated 14.09.2006 and amendments thereto issued by the
Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC); New Delhi. As per the said
notification the project comes under Category B, listed at item 5 (f). In light of draft
notifications dated 10.03.2014, 04.09.2015, 27.02.2017 and 03.10.2018 in respect of ESA
(Ecologically Sensitive Area) of Western Ghats and due to applicability of general
conditions, the category of the project change from Category “B” to Category “A”. The EIA
report is prepared by incorporating required information with regards to the project as
mentioned in the Standard Terms of Reference (ToR) issued by MoEFCC, New Delhi vide
letter No. IA-J-11011/74/2018-IA-II (I) to TDMCCL on 3rd May 2018.
1
INTRODUCTION…1
Indian Chemical Council (ICC) granted permission to TDMCCL for use of Responsible
Care Logo, for a period of one year from August, 2016 to July, 2017.
Indian Chemical Council (ICC) awarded Certificate of Merit to TDMCCL for Water
Resource Management in Chemical Industry on 30th September, 2015.
Indian Chemical Council (ICC) awarded Certificate of Merit to TDMCCL for Efficient
Waste Management in Chemical Industry on 30th September, 2016.
The proposed expansion will be carried out at existing set up of TDMCCL. Total plot area
acquired by TDMCCL 88355 m2 (8.84 Ha), the total built up area is 40925 m2 (4.09 Ha). For
more details about area break-up refer Chapter - 2 (Table 2.3). (Refer Figure 1.1 and
Figure 1.2)
Every business needs to reconcile innovative technologies and novel products to achieve
sustainability, stability and to set new horizons.
These new products and processes are outcome of the intellect, hardship and integrity of
in-house built R&D team.
This project will provide additional employment for the local communities.
The additional monetary gains to the organization will provide opportunity for the
implementation of corporate social activities. This will result into overall improvement of
the standard of living of the society.
As all the processes are environment friendly, it will help in conservation of natural
resources and environment protection.
Some of the products are import substitutes. Hence, it will contribute in saving of foreign
exchange.
Some of the products will attract additional export business which will boost the chemical
sector and economy.
Amongst the proposed products, some are pharmaceutical intermediates which will
contribute and support growth of the healthcare sector.
This project will provide additional business to the supporting commercial enterprises.
This project will improve the overall growth and sustainability of the organization, which
in turn contribute to the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) of our country.
2
INTRODUCTION…1
3
INTRODUCTION…1
The TDMCCL has submitted a duly filled online Form-I application to MoEFCC, New Delhi
on 27.02.2018 for grant of Terms of Reference (ToR). This EIA report has been complied
with the Standard ToR issued by the MoEFCC. The summarized details of same are provided
in following table -
iv. List of raw materials required and their Refer Chapter 2, Section 2.6.3.1,
source along with mode of transportation. Table 2.18, Pages 34-35, Section
2.7.2.2, Table 2.27, Pages 46
v. Other chemicals and materials required Refer Chapter 7, Section 7.8.6,
with quantities and storage capacities. Table 7.6 Pages 195-196,
Appendix - E for product wise
raw materials, Pages 305-394
vi. Details of Emission, effluents, hazardous Refer Chapter 2, Effluent Details -
waste generation and their management. Section 2.7.1.2, Table 2.22, Page
4
INTRODUCTION…1
5
INTRODUCTION…1
6
INTRODUCTION…1
7
INTRODUCTION…1
8
INTRODUCTION…1
9
INTRODUCTION…1
iv.Surface water quality of nearby River (100 Refer Chapter 3, Section 3.9,
m upstream and downstream of discharge Pages 99-105
point) and other surface drains at eight
locations as per CPCB / MoEF&CC
guidelines.
v. Whether the site falls near to polluted Not Applicable
stretch of river identified by the CPCB /
MoEF&CC, if yes give details.
vi. Ground water monitoring at minimum at 8 Refer Chapter 3, Section 3.9,
locations shall be included. Pages 99-105
vii. Noise levels monitoring at 8 locations Refer Chapter 3, Section 3.10,
within the study area. Pages 105-109
viii. Soil Characteristic as per CPCB guidelines. Refer Chapter 3, Section 3.4,
Pages 68-81
ix. Traffic study of the area, type of vehicles, Refer Chapter 2, Table 2.26, Page
frequency of vehicles for transportation of 45, Table 2.27 Page 46
materials, additional traffic due to proposed
project, parking arrangement etc.
x. Detailed description of flora and fauna Refer Chapter 3, Section 3.12,
(terrestrial and aquatic) existing in the study Page 113-120
area shall be given with special reference to
rare, endemic and endangered species. If
Schedule-I fauna are found within the study
area, a Wildlife Conservation Plan shall be
prepared and furnished.
xi. Socio-economic status of the study area. Refer Chapter 3, Section 3.11,
Page 109-113
7. Impact and Environment Management
Plan
10
INTRODUCTION…1
11
INTRODUCTION…1
ix. Action plan for the green belt development Refer Chapter 2, Section 2.9, Page
plan in 33 % area i.e. land with not less 52
than 1,500 trees per ha. Giving details of
species, width of plantation, planning
schedule etc. shall be included. The green
belt shall be around the project boundary
and a scheme for greening of the roads used
for the project shall also be incorporated.
12
INTRODUCTION…1
iv. Annual report of health status of workers Refer Chapter 7, Section 7.10,
with special reference to Occupational Pages 209-210, Appendix - R for
Health and Safety. Health Check-up Report, Page
668-678
9. Corporate Environment Policy
i. Does the company have a well laid down Refer Chapter 9, Pages 214-221
Environment Policy approved by its Board
of Directors? If so, it may be detailed in the
EIA report.
ii. Does the Environment Policy prescribe for Not Applicable
standard operating process / procedures to
bring into focus any infringement /
deviation / violation of the environmental
or forest norms / conditions? If so, it may
be detailed in the EIA.
iii. What is the hierarchical system or Refer Chapter 9, Section 9.2, Page
Administrative order of the company to 214-215
deal with the environmental issues and for
ensuring compliance with the
environmental clearance conditions?
Details of this system may be given.
13
INTRODUCTION…1
14
INTRODUCTION…1
15
INTRODUCTION…1
13. Risk assessment for storage and handling of Chapter 7, Section 7.8, Pages 188-
hazardous chemicals / solvents. Action plan 201
for handling & safety system to be
incorporated.
14. Arrangements for ensuring health and Chapter 7, Section 7.8.5, Page 195
safety of workers engaged in handling of
toxic materials.
16
Chapter 2
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
2.1 TYPE OF PROJECT
The proposed project by The Dharamsi Morarji Chemical Company Limited (TDMCCL)
is an expansion project of existing commodity chemicals and speciality chemicals
manufacturing unit from 31384 MT/M to 32510 MT/M capacities (Increase by 1126
MT/M). The promoters have vast experience in this field and are well aware of the
manufacturing processes w.r.t. various products. They have made thorough study of entire
project planning as well as implementation schedule.
(iii) Fine chemicals - as the commodity chemicals, they are chemical substances
characterized by their chemical structure, but on the contrary of commodity
chemicals, they are produced in a small quantity; fine chemicals can be used as
components in the formulation of speciality chemicals; for example active
ingredients of pharmaceutical drugs are fine chemicals, but the pharmaceutical drug
is a speciality chemical; examples of applications of fine chemicals are
pharmaceuticals industry, agriculture, photography chemicals and electronic
chemicals; they are produced by batch plant and in general their cost is relatively
high.
17
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
The global specialty chemicals market is expected to attain a size of $582.3 billion in
2017-18 and is forecasted to reach $782.2 billion by 2023, registering a compound
annual growth rate (CAGR) of 5.1% during 2018-2023. The major factors driving the
market growth are increasing demand of these chemicals in emerging economies,
ongoing technological advancements in the market of these chemicals and increasing
penetration of end use industries.
In the base case scenario, with current initiatives of industry and government, the Indian
chemical industry could grow at 11% p.a. by 2017-18. However, the industry could
aspire to grow much more and its growth potential is limited only by its aspirations. In
such an optimistic scenario, high end-use demand based on increasing per capita
consumption, improved export competitiveness and resultant growth impact for each
sub-sector of the chemical industry could lead to an overall growth rate of over 15% p.a.
by 2017-18 (~6% of global industry). This has a potential for further upside in the future
considering India’s increasing competitiveness in manufacturing.
Driven by the rapidly growing population and increasing consumer spending, the
specialty chemicals and or commodity chemicals market in emerging economies is
expected to witness a good growth in the coming years. The growing middle-class
population in these economies and rising industrialization in the fields of food,
agriculture, cosmetics and many other manufacturing sectors are creating the demand of
these chemicals in emerging economies. BRICS countries such as China, India and
Brazil especially, are witnessing increased demand of specialty chemicals.
For instance, in 2014, India launched ‘Make in India’ initiative, that has enhanced the
competitiveness of the chemical sector in the country, by permitting 100% foreign direct
investment (FDI) and de-licensing the manufacturing of most chemicals. All these
factors are driving the growth of the specialty chemicals market in emerging economies.
India has a skilled workforce as well as high managerial and technical competence in
comparison to its peers in Asia.
Hence, considering all and the ever-increasing demand for chemical sectorin India and in
abroad as well as changing market conditions for manufacture and sale of products has
prompted the promoters to go for expansion of existing commodity chemicals and
speciality chemicals.
The existing project hasprovided employment opportunities to the skilled and semi-skilled
local populace, especially in small-scale business and other related services. Following table
gives details about the number of workers that have been employed from local area in the
existing unit and also man power will be required for expansion activities. Details are as
follows -
18
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Table 2.1 Details of Manpower
As discussed in Chapter-1, in India around 60% of the total commodity chemicals and
speciality chemicals produce is exported. There is a good demand for products from
manufacturing of commodity chemicals and speciality chemicals, in India as well as abroad.
Here, 80% products of TDMCCL would be consumed in Indian market whereas 20%
products would be exported.
The activities under proposed expansion would be carried out in the existing setup of
TDMCCL located at Plot No. 105 in MIDC Industrial Area, P.O. Dhatav, Taluka: Roha,
District: Raigad. Geographical location of site is 18°25'33.00'' N Latitude, 73°08'31.41" E
Longitude and falls under the Survey of India Toposheet No.: 47 F2, 47 F3 and Western
Ghats Eco-sensitive area (ESA) falling in the state of Maharashtra (1:75000 scale).
Site History :While making selection of site for existing activities of TDMCCL, certain
aspects were taken into consideration prominently as-
19
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
as a joint venture between MIDC and the industries in the area. The Scheme will take
care for effluent collection, treatment and disposal.
7. Availability of Fire Station: Fire station building been constructed along with firemen's.
8. Availability ofCommon Facility Centre: This facility centre houses a post Office and
rest house, many other facilities are planned i.e. Grahak Bhandar, Bank of Maharashtra,
in the centre.
9. No rehabilitation and resettlement required as the site is located in Notified industrial
area.
10. Adequate facility in existing setup for manufacturing of additional quantity of products.
11. Residential Facilities: The Corporation has allotted residential plots to Company for the
residential purpose.
12. Availability of good communication Facilities : In addition to on route long run buses,
the Local routes from Kolad, Mahad, Alibaug, Pen etc. are operated by State Transport
(S.T.) through the industrial Area.
20
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
No. Particulars Details
(ii) Pune International Airport, Lohagaon at 82.74
km
10. Nearest tourist places Nil within 10 km radius
11. Defense installations Nil within 10 km radius
12. Archaeological important Nil within 10 km radius
place/ Historical Monuments
13. Ecological sensitive zones Village Dhatav wherein the MIDC is setup have
appeared in the list of ESA village of Western Ghats
Ecologically Sensitive Area (ESA) Village draft
notification dated 10.03.2014, 04.09.2015,
27.02.2017 and 03.10.2018.
14. Reserved /Protected forest / 1. At a distance of 1.48 km & 1.89 km from the
National Parks/ Wildlife Reserved Forest which was declared under Section
Sanctuary / wetland / estuaries 34 of Indian Forest Act, 1878 by Bombay Castle
/ bioreserves (from Project Gazette No. 3F dated 01.03.1879.
Site) 2. At a distance of 0.44 km & 0.39 km from the
Protected Forest which was declared under Section
28 of the Indian Forest Act No. VII of 1878, as
amended by Acts No. V of 1890 and No. V of
1901 by Bombay Government Gazette No. 1963I
dated 28.02.1907.
15. Nearest streams / Rivers / River Kundalika at 1.25 Km
water bodies (from Project
Site)
Total land area acquired by the TDMCCL is 8.84 Ha (88355m2). Out of this, 4.09 Ha
(40925m2) is built up area. Detailed area statement is as follows -
21
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
2.5 PROJECT OPERATIONS, APPROVALS AND IMPLEMENTATION
Presently, in the existing commodity chemicals and speciality chemicals set up of TDMCCL
the products listed under Table No. 2.17 is being manufactured. The same has been accorded
in valid MPCB Consent to Operate (CTO) in the year 2015 vide Consent order No. Formate
1.0 / BO / CAC - Cell / EIC No RD - 2952 - 15 / 28th CAC / 4541 dated 21.04.2015. Refer
Appendix – B for Copy of valid MPCB CTO w.r.t. existing unit of TDMCCL.
The plot of TDMCCL in MIDC Dhatav, Taluka: Roha, District: Raigad was procured in year
1976 on which existing unit of TDMCCL is established. Refer Appendix – C for Land Lease
Agreement between MIDC Authority and TDMCCL. Subsequently, the existing unit was
commissioned in year 1978. Therefore, it is observed that establishment of existing unit of
TDMCCL in MIDC Dhatav is well before the “EIA Notification No. S.O. 60 (E) dated
27.01.1994 and “EIA Notification No. S.O. 1533 (E) dated 14.09.2006 published by
MoEFCC.In light of fact presented above, it could be seen that, the existing unit did not
attract the condition for procurement of Environmental Clearance (EC) and hence only
MPCB consent was procured in case of TDMCCL. Refer copy of CTO issued by MPCB in
year 1997 which was well before the EIA Notification, 2006 enclosed at Appendix - B.
The proposed expansion project would be implemented only after procurement of all
approvals and permissions namely EC; consents from MPCB, permissions from various other
Govt. departments etc. Detailed investment is as follows -
The average power supply required to the tune of 27000 KW Hr/Day for the existing unit,
presently taken from Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company Limited
(MSEDCL) and the same would be the source for the proposed expansion activities. The
average power supply to the tune of 3000 KW Hr/Day is required for the proposed expansion
activities. In case of a power failure, DG sets of 830 KVA, 1310 KVA and 125 KVA are used
to provide uninterrupted power supply to emergency facilities.
22
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Solar panels are already installed on site which harvests electricity of 335 KWp per day under
existing unit. Management of TDMCCL have planned for harvesting of additional electricity
of 100 KWp per day through solar panels to reduce electricity intake from MSEDCL which is
in process. The detailed electricity break up is as follows -
23
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
24
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
2.6.2 List of Equipments
Following table represents details about the reactors and equipments under existing as well as
proposed activities-
Table 2.7 List of Equipments and Reactors for Sulphuric Acid Plant
25
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
No. Name of Equipment Quantity MOC Capacity/size
42. 98% Acid Storage Tank No.1 1 MS 1200 MT
43. 98% Acid Storage Tank No.2 1 MS 1200 MT
44. 98% Acid Storage Tank No.3 1 MS 1200 MT
45. Battery Acid Tank 1 SS 100 MT
46. 98% S.A. Emergency Tank 1 MS 10 MT
47. Pump Tank for Lorry Filling 1 CF8M 12 m3/hr
48. Pump Tank for Lorry FillingScrubber 1 CF8M 12 m3/hr
49. 98% Acid Lorry Filling Tank No.1 NA NA NA
50. 98% Acid Lorry Filling Tank No.2 NA NA NA
51. Alkali Scrubber 1 MS Rubber Lined ф 2m x 9.6m
52. Alkali Scrubber Pump 1 CF8M 50 m3/hr
53. SO3 Condenser 1 MS 240 m2
54. SO3 Generator 1 MS 80 MTPD
55. SO3 Storage Tank 1 MS 5MT
56. SO3 Mixer 1 MS 2MT
57. SO3 Lorry Filling Tank 1 MS 5MT
65% Oleum Storage Tank
58. 1 MS 150 MT
(Capsule Type 150 MT cap.)
59. 65% Oleum Lorry Filling Tank 1 MS 10 MT
60. 65% Oleum Heat Exchanger 1 SS Tube --
61. 65% Oleum Tower 1 MS 2 MT/hr
62. 23% Oleum Tower 1 MS ф 4m x 11.6m
63. 23% Oleum Heat Exchanger 1 SS Tube --
64. 23% Oleum Storage Tank 1 MS 150 MT
65. 23% Oleum Lorry Filling Tank NA NA NA
Vent Scrubber for 23% and 65% Oleum
66. 1 SS ф 0.4m x 1.5m
(on APT)
67. Instrument Compressor 1 MS 100 CFM
68. Raw Water Pump No.1 1 MS 29 m3/hr
69. Raw Water Pump No.2 1 MS 29 m3/hr
70. Cation Vessel 2 MS 1 KL
71. Anion Vessel 2 MS 1 KL
72. Mixed Bed Vessel 2 MS 1 KL
73. Condensate Water Pump No.1 1 MS 28 m3/hr
74. Condensate Water Pump No.2 1 MS 28 m3/hr
75. LP Dosing Pump No.1 1 SS 1 kg/cm2 g
76. LP Dosing Pump No.2 1 SS 1 kg/cm2 g
77. HP Dosing Pump No.1 1 SS 40 kg/cm2 g
78. HP Dosing Pump No.2 1 SS 40 kg/cm2 g
79. DG Set No - 310 KVA 1 MS 310 KVA
80. DG Set No- 830 KVA 1 MS 830 KVA
81. External Cooling Water Pump 1 CI 50 m3/hr
82. Internal Cooling Water Pump 1 CI 65 m3/hr
83. Caustic Lye Tank 1 MS 5 KL
84. Melter Agitator Gearbox 1 PB 15:1 Ratio
85. HSD Tank Pump 1 MS 5 m3/hr
86. Impure Tank Agitator Gearbox 1 PB 15:1 Ratio
26
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
No. Name of Equipment Quantity MOC Capacity/size
87. Pre Coat Tank Agitator Gearbox 1 PB 15:1 Ratio
88. Delawal Turbine 1 Alloy 500 KW
89. Cooling Water Pump 1 MS 360 m3/hr
90. Cooling Tower for Delawal Turbine 2 Plastic/ND 500 TR
Cooling Tower for 65% Oleum and
91. 1 Plastic 100 + 300 TR
Liquid SO3
92. Scrubber for Lorry Filling Vent 1 SS ф 0.4m x 1.5m
93. HSD Storage Tank 1 MS 10 MT
94. Furnace Oil Storage Tank 1 MS 30MT
95. IAEC Boiler 1 MS 5 TPH
65% Oleum Storage Tank
96. 1 MS 50 MT
(Double walled - 50 MT cap.)
Heat Recovery Unit
97. 1 MS 10 m2
(Ravi industries make)
Table 2.8 List of Equipments and Reactors for Chloro Sulphonic Acid Plant
27
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Table 2.9 List of Equipments and Reactors for Benzene Sulphonyl Chloride Plant
Table 2.10 List of Equipments and Reactors for Sodium Vinyl Sulphamate Plant
28
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
No. Name of Equipment Quantity MOC Capacity/size
7. Reactor R1 - Sulphonator S1 1 MS 10 KL
8. Neutralizer S2 1 SS 15 KL
9. DES Slurry Day Tank 1 SS 1 KL
10. DES Slurry Storage Tank 1 SS 10 KL
11. Caustic Tank 3 MS 30 KL
12. Caustic Pump 1 Alloy 12 m3/hr
13. 98% Acid Scrubber 1 SS 3.278 m
height*324 OD
14. SO3 Service Tank 1 MS Jac 5 MT
15. SO3 Metering Pump 1 SS 180 LPM
16. Concentrator 1 MS 6 MT
17. Sulphate Neutch Tank 1 MS --
18. Filtrate Tank 1 SS --
19. Dilutor 1 PP / FRP 7 MT
20. Carbon Treatment Tank 1 MS 5 MT
21. Carbon Neutch Filter 2 MS --
22. Pp Filtrate Tank 1 PP 2 KL
23. Product Tank No. 1 1 SS 17 KL
24. Product Tank No. 2 1 PP / FRP 6 KL
25. Product Tank No. 3 1 PP / FRP 29 KL
26. Product Tank No. 4 1 SS 30 KL
27. Product Tank No. 5 1 SS 21 KL
28. DM Water Tank 2 SINTEX 2 KL
29. 50% Acid Tank 1 PP / FRP 2 KL
30. Hot Well Tank Pump 2 CI 150 m3/hr
31. Caustic Service Tank 1 MS 1 KL
Table 2.11 List of Equipments and Reactors for Diethyl Sulphate Plant
29
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
No. Name of Equipment Quantity MOC Capacity/size
16. Reactor No. T3 1 HDPE 12KL
17. Alcohol Feed Tank 1 MS 1KL
18. SO3Feed Tank 1 SS 9.7MT
19. PHE 2 SS 48 m2
20. Ammoniation Tank No.1 1 MS 20MT
21. Ammoniation Tank No.2 1 MS 20MT
22. 98% Scrubber Tank MS-Brick
1 3MT
Lined
23. Hot Water Pump 1 CI 65m3/hr
24. Hot Water Tank 1 MS 3KL
25. Water Pump for Ammoniation Tank 1 MS 15 m3/hr
26. Tower No.1 1 GLR 5KL
27. Tower No.2 1 GLR 3KL
28. Reboiler and Tower No.3 1 SS 1KL
29. Vessel and Tower No.5 1 NA NA
30. Condenser No.1 A 1 SS Tube 20 m2
31. Condenser No.1 B 1 SS Tube 20 m2
32. Condenser No.2 1 SS Tube 20 m2
33. Condenser No.3 1 SS Tube 20 m2
34. Condenser No.5 1 NA NA
35. Seal Pot No.1 A 1 PVC 2MT
36. Seal Pot No.1 B 1 PVC 2MT
37. Seal Pot No.2 1 PVC 2MT
38. Seal Pot No.3 1 PVC 1MT
39. DES Storage Tank No.1 1 PP/FRP 20MT
40. DES Storage Tank No.2 1 PP / FRP 20 MT
41. DES Storage Tank No.3 1 PP / FRP 20 MT
42. DES Storage Tank No.4 1 PP / FRP 50 MT
43. Feed Tank 1 MS 13MT
44. DES Intermediate Tank No.1 1 MS 1MT
45. Ammoniated Slurry Feed Tank 1 MS 2KL
46. Sludge Tank No.1 1 MS 10MT
47. Sludge Tank No.2 1 MS 10MT
Table 2.12 List of Equipments and Reactors for Multi Purpose Plant - 1
30
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Table 2.13 List of Equipments and Reactors for Multi Purpose Plant - 2
Table 2.14 List of Equipment and Reactors for Benzene Sulphonic Acid and Other
Sulphonic Acids Plant
31
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Table 2.15 Proposed List of Equipments and Reactors for Multi Purpose Plant - 1 and
Multi Purpose Plant - 2
Quantity
No. Name of Equipment MOC Capacity/size
MPP-1 MPP-2
1. Glass Lined Reactor 2 2 MS Glass Lined 5 KL
2. Glass Lined Reactor 1 -- MS Glass Lined 2 KL
3. Glass Lined Reactor 1 -- MS Glass Lined 3 KL
4. Glass Lined Reactor 1 -- MS Glass Lined 0.65 KL
5. Glass Lined Reactor -- 1 MS Glass Lined 0.1 KL
6. SS Reactor 3 2 SS 5 KL
7. SS Reactor -- 3 SS 1 KL
8. SS Centrifuge 1 1 SS 48”
9. MSRL 1 1 MSRL 36”
10. FBD -- 1 SS 200 Kgs
11. RCVD 1 1 SS 1 KL
12. Multi Mill -- 1 SS 100 Kgs/Hr
13. Sifter -- 1 SS 25 Kgs/Hr
14. Sparkler Filter 1 2 SS 100 Ltrs
15. ANFD -- 1 SS 500 Ltrs
16. Vacuum Pumps 4 4 MS --
17. Steam Ejector System 6 2 MS 200 Kgs Steam/Hr
18. Chilling Plant 1 1 MS 50 TR
4 Lakh
19. Thermopack 1 1 MS
Kcalories/Hr
20. Cooling Tower -- 1 MS 40 TR
21. Alcohol Evaporator 1 -- MS 0.5 KL
The different products presently being manufactured and those considered for manufacture
under expansion & their maximum production quantities are as -
32
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Table 2.17 List of Products and Byproducts
A) List of Products-
33
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Sr. Production (MT/Month)
Name of Products
No. Current Expansion After Expansion
37. 4,4-Dichloro Diphenyl Sulphone 0 10 10
38. Mono Ethyl Aniline 0 70 70
39. 1,3-Benzene Disulphonyl Chloride 0 10 10
40. Menthyl Lactate 0 5 5
Total 18850 1045 19895
B) List of Byproducts-
Note : i)
Description Products Byproducts Total
Existing 14 6 20
Expansion 26 2 28
Total 40 8 48
ii) Production Blocks - Existing: 8 Nos., Expansion: Nil
iii) Manufacturing Capacity - Existing 31384 MT/M + Expansion 1126 MT/M =
After Expansion 32510 MT/M
The details on consumption of raw materials required for existing and proposed
manufacturing activities are as follows-
Table 2.18 List of Collective Quantity of Raw material required per Batch
34
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
35
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
2.6.3.2 Manufacturing Processes, Flow Charts and Mass Balance of the Products
Refer Appendix -E for details on manufacturing processes, processes flow charts, product-
wise raw materials, mass balance for each product.
36
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Sr. No. Name of Products e-factor
37. 4,4-Dichloro Diphenyl Sulphone 0.14
38. Mono Ethyl Aniline 0.12
39. 1,3-Benzene Disulphonyl Chloride 0.13
40. Menthyl Lactate 0.08
37
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Sr. Capacity Name of Products to be
Production Block
No. of Block manufactured
6. Para Chloro Thiophenol
7. Bis (4-Chlorophenyl) Disulphide
8. Thiophenol
9. Diethyl Phthalate
10. Dimethyl Phthalate
11. Dimethyl Aniline
12. Mono Methyl Aniline
13. Diethyl Aniline
14. Sodium Isethionate
15. 4,4-Dichloro Diphenyl Sulphone
16. Mono Ethyl Aniline
8. Benzene Sulphonic Acid and 20 MT/M 1. Benzene Sulphonic Acid/Other
Other Sulphonic Acids Plant Sulphonic Acids
(BSA) 2. Silicon Sulphate
3. Para Chloro Benzene Sulphonic Acid
4. Para Toluene Sulphonic Acid
The basic sources of pollution from the existing and proposed expansion of commodity
chemicals and speciality chemicals manufacturing unit are mainly operations and processes
in the industry, boiler, Thermopack and DG Sets.
Detailed identification and quantification of impacts, due to above mentioned sources,
arepresented under the heads-(1) Water Pollution (2) Air Pollution (3) Noise Pollution (4)
Hazardous Wastes (5) Solid Waste (6) Land Pollution.
Water pollution may be defined as presence of impurities in water in such quantities and of
such nature that impair/restrict use of water for the stated purpose. In short, it can be said that
the water is not potable. Fresh water requirement for the proposed activity shall be taken from
MIDC water supply scheme. In TDMCCL, water shall be required for process, washing
(laboratory, floor andcleaning of equipments), boiler, cooling tower make up as well as for
domestic purpose.
The assignment w.r.t. water pollution (WP) aspect was done by Prof. (Dr.) Bhaskar Thorat
who is an empaneled EEIPL’s Functional Area Expert (FAE) for WP.
1370 CMD fresh water consumption is sanction for existing unit as per valid MPCB CTO
dated 21.04.2015. The daily water requirement in the industry for various operations and
processes has been shown in the following table -
38
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Table 2.21 Total Water Requirement under Existing and Expansion Activities
Total water requirement after expansion for proposed project would be 1592 CMD. Out of
which 220 CMD (14 %) would be treated water from ETP whereas 1372 CMD (86%) would
be fresh water taken from MIDC water supply scheme. Fresh water requirement for project is
met from the MIDC water supply scheme. The MIDC procures water from Kundalika River
and after treatment the same is provided to different industries in the MIDC. Refer Appendix
-F for Certificate of Merit for Water Resource Management in Chemical Industry by Indian
Chemical Council (ICC) and Appendix -G for Water Permission Letter.
From fact presented above, it is observed that through change in product mix additional
permissionis not required for fresh water under proposed expansion. Current permission for
fresh water granted in valid CTO is adequate under proposed expansion.
Total 300 CMD effluent generation from trade and domestic is sanction for existing unitas
per valid MPCB CTO dated 21.04.2015. The details of effluent generation under existing and
proposed expansion are as follows -
Table 2.22 Total Effluent Generation under Existing and Expansion Activities
39
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Effluent generated from existing manufacturing and utility operations is to the tune of 209.6
CMD which is treated in existing ETP of 300 CMD capacity comprising of Primary,
Secondary and Tertiary treatment operations. At present, the treated water from ETP,
achieving prescribed standards is discharged to Common Effluent Treatment Plant (CETP),
Roha.Presently, domestic wastewater is treated in septic tanks followed by soak pits. The
overflow from soak pits is used for gardening purpose.
Industrial effluent generated from spillages, leakages and floor washings from all process
plants, comes to the grit chamber through underground pipelines. Oily mater that floats on the
top is skimmed off. The effluent is then taken to the equalization tanks from where it is sent
to the neutralizer. Lime slurry is prepared in the slurry tank. Lime slurry can be fed to the
equalization tank or to the neutralizer. pH of the effluent is maintained between7-8.
Neutralized effluent is then pumped to the primary clarifier. The clear water from the top of
the clarifier overflows into the two bio-reactors which are in series and sludge from the
bottom of primary clarifier is fed to fully automatic pneumatic filter. Filtrate from the filter is
pumped back to the primary clarifier. Water from bioreactors overflows into the secondary
clarifier. Water from the secondary clarifier is passed through tertiary filter (carbon and sand
filter) by pump. This water is pumped to the CETP through MIDC sewers sludge from the
bottom of secondary clarifier is fed to fully automatic pneumatic filter. Dry filter cake is sent
to Common Hazardous Waste Treatment, Storage & Disposal Facility (CHWTSDF), Taloja,
Mumbai for final disposal. Refer Appendix – H for Certificate of Merit for Efficient Waste
Management in Chemical Industry by Indian Chemical Council (ICC) and Appendix -I for
CHWTSDF Membership Letter.
Under expansion, the management has decided to achieve Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD) by
installation of evaporators and the condensate would be recycled in industrial operations. No
any effluent would be discharged outside the premises. Moreover, for domestic waste water,
Sewage Treatment Plant (STP) of 20 CMD is proposed. The treated water from STP would
be used for gardening.
From fact presented above, it is observed that current ETP has the capacity to treat additional
load from expansionthrough change in product mix.
Refer Figure 2.2 for Photographs of Existing ETP, Figure 2.3 for Flow diagram of ETP and
Figure 2.4 for Layout of ETP of TDMCCL.
40
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
41
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Figure 2.3 Flow diagram of ETP
42
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Figure 2.4 Layout of ETP
43
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
2.7.1.3 Solvent Recovery System
Various solvents are being used during the manufacturing process of commodity chemicals
and speciality chemicals. These solvents are recovered and reused in process. The path of
solvent recovery being followed is presented as follows-
After completion of reaction the solvents are recovered in a distillation unit.
The distillation unit has two condensers (shell and tube type).
The first condenser has cooling tower water, while the second condenser has the chilled
water at 0 - 20 C as coolants.
After the vapors are condensed, the condensate along with un-condensed vapors is passed
through a trap which is cooled externally with chilled water.
The vents of condenser and receiver are connected to scrubber system.
All the reaction vessels and centrifuges are connected to a common line. These fumes and
exhausts are sucked by ID fan and scrubbed by alkali.
The air after scrubbing is let out into the atmosphere and the scrubbed water is sent to
ETP for further treatment.
This wet scrubber absorbs acidic vapors, traces of solvents etc. and purified gas stream is
let out into the atmosphere.
For the acid mist control two No’s of mist eliminators are provided.
Input Quantity
Quantity % of
Sr. Product Quantity recovered
Stage Solvent lost solvent
No. Name of solvent and recycled
(Kg/batch) recovered
(Kg/batch) (Kg/batch)
1. 4,4’ DHDPS Reaction Mesitylene 430 425 5 99
2. 4,4’ DHDPS Isolation Ethanol 400 336 64 85
3. Menthyl
Reaction MCB 300 288 12 96
Lactate
4. 3,3’ DAPS Reaction Ethanol (50%) 250 200 50 80
Air Pollution can be defined as presence in the outdoor atmosphere of one or more air
contaminants (i.e. dust, fumes, gas, mist, odour, smoke or vapour) in sufficient quantities, of
such characteristics and of such duration so as to threaten to be injurious to human, plant or
animal life or to property, or which reasonably interferes with comfortable enjoyment of life
or property.
The assignment w.r.t. Air Pollution (AP) aspect was done by Mr. Yuvraj Damugade who is
an in-house EEIPL’s FAE and also involved in the overall exercise w.r.t. Air Quality and
Modeling studies i.e. AQ aspect w.r.t. the project.
Under existing unit as well as proposed expansion main source of emissions are boiler,
thermopack and DG Sets. Major emissions are in the form of suspended particulate matter
44
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
(SPM), SOx and NOx. The existing boiler (5 TPH capacity) is operated on Furnace oil (FO)
@ 63 kg/hr with adequate stack height of 35 m and Thermic Fluid Heater (TFH, 4 lakhs
Kcal/hr capacity) is operated on High speed diesel (HSD) @ 47 kg/hr with stack height of
30m are provided on site. DG sets of capacities 125, 830 and 1310 KVA are operated on
HSD / Light diesel oil (LDO) @ 210 kg/hr with adequate stack height of 4.20 m, 7.70 m, 7.70
mrespectively above roof level (ARL). DG sets are used
o n l y i n c ase of power failure. Moreover, process emissions are in the form of acidic/
alkaline/solvent vapours emitted from existing. The same is taken care off through seven
scrubbers each of 5 kg/hr capacity. Existing scrubbers will be utilized under expansion
activity.
Existing boiler, TFH and DG sets are sufficient for proposed expansion. Boiler runs
occasionally as steam is available from Sulphuric acid plant only. (Steam generated from
Sulphuric Acid Plant : 335 MTD at 40 kg/cm2 at 4000C)
Sr.
Description Boiler TFH DG Set (3 No.)
No.
1. Stack No. S-7 S-2 S-4, S-5, S-6
2. Capacity 5 TPH 4 lakhs Kcal/hr 125,830,1310 KVA
3. Fuel type FO HSD HSD / LDO
4. Fuel quantity (kg/hr) 63 47 210
5. MoC MS MS MS
6. Shape Round Round Round
7. Stack Height (m) 35 30 4.20,7.70,7.70 ARL
8. Diameter/size (m) 0.35 0.3 0.41,0.41,0.75
9. Calorific Value, in kcal/kg 10000 10500 10000
10. Sulphur Content, % (w/w) 3.5 Max. 1.0 1.0
11. Ash Content, in % (w/w) 0.15 Max. 2.0 --
12. Gas quantity (Nm3/hr) 5390 789 10932
13. Gas Temperature (0C) 165 99 160
14. Exit gas velocity (m/sec) 3.3 3.1 7.1
15. Source of Pollution SPM, SOx and NOx
Distance Qty. of RM
Sr. Raw Material Mode of Truck / Frequency
Travelled Transported
No. (RM) Transport Tanker of vehicles
(km) (MT/M)
1. Sulphur Solid Road Truck 9 / Day 1700 2700
2. Sulphur Molten Road Tanker 2 / Day 130 1000
3. Benzene Road Tanker 1 / 2 Day 130 225
4. Caustic Lye Road Tanker 2 / Week 250 200
5. SDS Road Tanker 2 / Week 200 100 KL/M
6. Liquor Ammonia Road Tanker 1 / Week 130 30
7. Hydrochloride Acid Road Tanker 4 / Week 4 120
8. Phenol Road Truck 1 / Month 130 10
9. Aniline Road Tanker 2 / Month 400 16
Process emissions are in the form of acidic/alkaline/solvent vapours and are controlled
through installation of Scrubbers. Production units are provided with scrubbers. There would
be in allseven scrubbers on site after expansion. Details of same are given in following table-
Disposal/
Scrubber Packing Mode of
Process Scrubbing Recycle/
Sr. Stack Attached No. of Dia. Ht. Material regeneration
Emission Media used Reuse of
No. No. to Process Scrubbers (m) (m) used in of the Packing
scrubbed in scrubber Scrubbed
Plant scrubber Material
media
Disposed
Intalox 5 to10%
SO2, SO3, Washing after
1. 3 SA 1 2 9.63 Ceramic Caustic
Acid Mist with water treatment
Saddles solution
in ETP
Water Berl Washing Dilute
2. 6 BSCl 0.5 2 HCl Water
scrubber : Ceramic with water HCl is
46
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Disposal/
Scrubber Packing Mode of
Process Scrubbing Recycle/
Sr. Stack Attached No. of Dia. Ht. Material regeneration
Emission Media used Reuse of
No. No. to Process Scrubbers (m) (m) used in of the Packing
scrubbed in scrubber Scrubbed
Plant scrubber Material
media
2 Saddles recycled
to CSA
Plant
Sent to
Alkali Berl
Washing ETP
scrubber : 0.5 6 HCl Ceramic Water
with water treatment
1 Saddles
in ETP
Intalox Recycled
Washing Liquid
3. 5 CSA 3 0.9 5.37 HCl Ceramic back to
with water SO3
Saddles CSA Plant
The sources of fugitive emissions identified under existing and expansion activities are - (a)
Process Operations (b) Related Miscellaneous Operations (c) Material Storage (d) Equipment
Leaks (e) Fuel Storage Area
Process operations -Here emissions from loading - unloading, mixing and filling
operations are taken into considerations
Material Loading Emissions - Emissions may occur during material loading in mixing
and filling due to the displacement of organic vapours. Emissions may be emitted from a
mixing tank when the device is uncovered or when a lid is open.
Filling Losses - Emissions from product filling occur during transfer and free-fall into the
receiving container.
An emission control system typically consists of a capture device and a removal device. The
capture device (such as a hood or enclosure) captures the emission-laden air from the
emission area and ducts carry the exhaust air stream to removal equipment such as a recovery
device or a destructive control device. The volatile matter getting release from the storage
tanks, process piping, reactors, fuel storage and combustion are handled by various
preventive measures mentioned as below -
47
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
2.7.3 Solid Waste
Solid wastes from the Industries are categorized as hazardous and non-hazardous. Non-
hazardous waste is defined as the waste that contributesno damage to human or animal life.
However, it only adds to the quantity of waste.
The assignment w.r.t. Solid and Hazardous Wastes (SHW) aspect was done by Mr. Vinay
Kumar Kurakula who is an empanelled EEIPL’s Functional Area Expert (FAE) for
SHW.Details of solid waste generated or to be generated from existing and expansion
activities are given in following table-
Wastes that pose substantial dangers immediately or over a period of time to human, plant or
animal life are classified as Hazardous Wastes (HW). The different types of hazardous wastes
generation details have been shown in following table-
49
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
There is no any major noise generating sources in proposed expansion activities. The noise
generating sources under existing unit are Boiler, Reactors, Compressors and DG Set etc. The
same would be kept in isolated areas. Further, proper acoustic treatments wherever required
would also be provided to have the ambient noise levels as per CPCB standards. Among
these, prominent source of noise would be the Boiler house. The workers would be provided
with earmuffs and other Personal Protective Equipments (PPE’s) which would give the
reduction of 30 dB (A). The DG Sets would also be considered as one of the major sources of
noise generation. However, this is not continuous source. Only in case of power failure, DG
Set would be operated. Isolated and sound insulating structural arrangements would be
provided to DG set. Moreover, as per Noise Pollution Regulation and Control (Amendment)
Rules, 2010 it is enclosed in a canopy. Also, a silencer is provided to it as noise pollution
control equipment.
50
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Table 2.32 Noise Levels within the Industry
Sr.
Noise Area Within the Industry Noise level in dB (A)
No.
1. Sulphuric Acid Plant 54
2. Chloro Sulphonic Acid Plant 54
3. Benzene Sulphonyl Chloride Plant 51
4. Sodium Vinyl Sulphamate Plant 46
5. Diethyl Sulphate Plant 45
6. Benzene Sulphonic Acid and Other Sulphonic Acids Plant 42
7. Biological Treatment Plant 49
8. Maintenance DG shed 61
There are different odours sources in the existing set up, which include raw material and
product storage places, process operations, loading/unloading sections etc. which could give
rise to smell nuisance. To abate the odour problem, the industry has taken following steps in
its existing unit. Under expansion same practice shall be adopted.
All the feed, loading and unloading pumps for products and raw materials are fitted with
mechanical seals instead of glands to reduce leakages through pumps.
The products and raw materials loading and unloading area are provided with fumes
extraction system comprising of circulation pump with blower and scrubber. The bulk
storage tanks are connected to scrubber for taking care of fumes coming out from vent.
The scrubbers are filled with plain water depending on the nature of the fumes.
Adoption of Good Management Practices (GMPs).
Arranging awareness and training camps for workers.
Provision and use of PPE’s like masks by everybody associated with odour potential
prone areas.
Installation of appropriate, adequate and efficient exhaust and ventilation system to
remove and control odour from work zone areas.
Land pollution may occur through a number of actions such as use of untreated effluent for
gardening / irrigation, dumping of solid wastes in an uncontrolled manner and overall
inefficient housekeeping and bad operation practices. Appropriate and adequate management
practices including good housekeeping and periodic monitoring of various attributes
contributing to dust are being undertaken in existing unitand same practice shall be adopted
under expansion activities.
The Occupational Healthand Safety (OHS) hazards anticipated in the plant is mostly due
to chemical exposure hazard and physical hazard due to electrical and mechanical
operations and maintenance works.
Major anticipated occupational health and safety hazards are due to chemical exposure.
Accidental skin or eye irritation andburns, respiratory andpulmonary diseases on
exposure to chemicals orsolvent vapours, inhalation of chemical vapours.
51
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
Liver, Kidney, CNS, CVS functions on chronic exposure.
Accidents resulting from unsafe conditions due to poor housekeeping and not using the
PPE’s.
Accidents due to unsafe practice of operation and maintenance like gas cutting and
wielding may lead to injuries to various parts of the body.
Muscular and skeletal disorders like muscular pains, spinal and joint pains due to
ergonomic problems, lifting with wrong postures etc.
The capital as well as Operational and Maintenance (O & M) cost towards environmental
aspects under proposed activities would be as follows -
Cost Component
Sr.
Description (Rs. Lakhs)
No.
Capital O & M/Year
1. Air Pollution Control (APC) - Scrubbers, Stacks 5 20
2. Water Pollution Control (WPC) - ETP, ZLD 150 150
3. Noise Pollution Control (NPC) 20 --
4. Occupational Health and Safety -- 7
5. Environmental Monitoring and Management -- 1.6
6. Green Belt Development -- 10
7. Other
7a. Sulphur Sediment to MWML -- 13.44
7b. Waste Catalyst to MWML -- 0.5
Total 175 202.54
As mentioned under Table No.2.3; the total plot area of TDMCCL is 88355m2 (8.84 Ha). An
area of 40925m2 is the actual area on which the industrialactivities are carried out. As per
MoEFCC norm 2.95 Ha area (around 4425 trees) is to be brought under green belt which
accounts for 33 % of plot area. But under existing unit only 1000 trees have been planted.
Under expansion, green belt will be augmented by 3500 No. of trees. After commissioning of
the expansion the existing green belt shall be subsequently augmented in phase wise manner.
Thick plantation barrier will be provided on the periphery of the MIDC industrial plot.
Augmentation of avenue tree plantation along all the internal and approach roads shall be
done. Refer Figure 2.7 for Photographs of Existing green belt.
Being a chemical based industry here collection of the rainwater getting accumulated from
direct precipitation on the total roof area is taken in to account. The rainwater thus becoming
available from terraces as well as roofs of various structures and units in the industrial
premises is collected through arrangements of channels and pipes to be provided as per
appropriate slopes at the roof level. The collected rain water is then taken to ground and
either stored in open excavated tanks / ditches in the ground in the premises. The total
amount of water that isreceived in the form of rainfall over an area is called the rainwater
52
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
endowment of that area. Out of this, the amount that can be effectively harvested is called the
water harvesting potential. For the calculation of harvested rain water which would become
available subsequent to rooftop harvesting, a computation method from the ‘Hydrology and
Water Resource Engineering’ has been adopted. There under, “A. N. Khosla’s Formula” has
been followed. The allied calculations are as under -
Now, as per “A. N. Khosla’s Formula”, the average annual accumulation can becalculated by
using the following equation-
R = [P- (t/2.12)]
Where,
R = Average annual accumulation in cm, for the catchment area.
P =The corresponding average annual rainfall or precipitation in cm, over the entire
catchment. (In current case it is 3029 mm i.e. 303 cm)
t=Mean annual temperature in degree centigrade. (In current case it is 26.40C.)
R = [303 - (26.4/2.12)]
= 290.54 say 291 cm
53
PROJECT DESCRIPTION...2
54
Chapter 3
DESCRIPTION OF THE
ENVIRONMENT
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
3.1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter incorporates description of existing environmental status in the 'Study Area'
which is a region within a circle of 10 Km radius with the industry / plant at its center. The
existing environmental condition of the study area is representative of impacts due to all the
industries, units and projects in it and is described with respect to the topography, climate,
hydro-geological aspects, atmospheric conditions, water quality, soil characteristics, flora,
fauna, socio-economic profile, land use and places of archaeological importance. The study
area in respect of proposed expansion project by TDMCCL is located at Plot No. 105 in
MIDC Industrial Area, P.O. Dhatav, Taluka: Roha, District: Raigad. The project site lies
between 18°25'33.00'' N Latitude and 73°08'31.41" E Longitude.
The term Land Use relates to the human activity or economic function associated with a
specific piece of Land, while the term Land Cover relates to the type of feature present on the
surface of the earth (Lillesand and Kiefer, 2000). The knowledge of Land Use Land Cover is
important for many planning and management activities as it is considered as an essential
element for modeling and understanding the earth system. Land use maps are presently being
developed from local to National to Global Scales for Environmental Impact Studies. The
satellite Remote Sensing technology has found its acceptance worldwide for rapid resource
assessment and monitoring, particularly in the developing world. All these advancement have
widened the applicability of Remotely Sensed data in various areas, like forest cover,
vegetation type mapping, and their changes in regional scale. If satellite data is judiciously
used along with the sufficient ground data, it is possible to carry out detailed forest
inventories, monitoring of land Use and vegetation cover at various scales.
The assignment w.r.t. land use and land cover mapping of study area using LISS IV Satellite
Image has been done by Mr. Vinaykumar Kurakula who is an empanelled Functional Area
Expert (FAE) of EEIPL for LU & LC. The scope of work methodology involved and allied
details are presented in following paragraphs.
Major objective of the assignment was to prepare LU & LC of the study area and
simultaneously demarcating topographic features especially emphasizing drainage map of the
region.
For the present study, an area of 10 Km radius from TDMCCL Plant (which comes about
314.15 m2) has been marked and selected as per guidelines. Also, there are many industries
located in study area. The lists of major industrial units have been tabulated in Table 3.2 and
their sources of pollution have been mentioned in chapter - 4. Existing status of industrial
areas in Raigad district are mentioned in following table -
55
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
No. of
Name of Area No. of Plots No. of Plots Prevailing Rate Per
Units
Area (In Ha.) Developed Allotted m2 (In Rs.)
Production
Mahad 471.96 339 337 295/- 136
Add.Mahad 429.49 139 128 250/- 15
Roha 244.69 129 129 800/- 97
Usar 217.19 2 2 335/- 02
Nagothane 895.33 3 3 875/- 03
Vile Bhagad 764.16 427 417 635/- 0
Taloja 863.19 436 423 6645/- 326
Patalganga 647.62 17 -- 2260/- --
Total 4533.63 149 1439 -- 579
Sr.
Name of the Industry Address
No.
1. Rhodia Specialty Chemicals India Plot No.103/104 MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
Limited (Formaly Albright & Wilson
Chemicals India Ltd.)
2. Anshul Specialty Molecules Limited Plot No.108, 109 & 110 MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.:
Roha.
3. Aryan Pesticides Private Limited Plot No.1, 2, 26 & 27 MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.:
Roha.
4. Bec Chemicals Private Limited Plot No. 24, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
5. Calchem Industries India Limited Plot No. 61 & 62, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
6. Clariant Chemicals India Limited Plot No.113/114, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
7. Excel Industries Limited Plot No.112, 20/1, Os-2, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.:
Roha.
8. Iftex Oil & Chemicals Limited Plot No.22/2, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
9. Kisan Irrigations Limited Plot No. 69/70, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
10. Kores (India) Limited Plot No. 59A, 65b, 66c & 66a, MIDC Area,
Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
11. Lime Chemicals Limited Plot No. 43, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
12. Mark Omega Organic Industries Plot No. 44/45, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
Limited
13. Neelikon Food Dyes & Chemicals Ltd. Plot No. 67, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
14. Pepsico India Holdings Limited Plot100/1, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
15. Rathi Dye Chem Limited Plot No. 40, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
16. Roha Dychem Private Limited Plot No. 42, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
17. Sadhana Nitro Chem Limited Plot No. 47, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
18. Sudarshan Chemical Industries Ltd. Plot No. 46, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
19. Arjun Food Colorants Manufacturing Plot No. 22/1-B, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
Private Limited
20. Unichem Laboratories Private Limited Plot No. 99, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
21. Vidhi Dyestuffs Manufacturing Ltd. 59/B/68, MIDC Area, Dhatav, Tal.: Roha.
56
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Land use study requires data regarding topography, zoning, settlement, industry, forest, roads
and traffic etc. The collection of this data was done from various secondary sources viz.
census books, revenue records, state and central government offices, Survey of India
toposheet etc. and through primary field surveys as well as high resolution multi spectral
satellite image from IRS RESOURCESAT 2 Satellite with LISS IV sensor. The date of pass
of the image is 08.01.2016. The image has a spatial resolution of 5M x 5M. Apart from
LULC Map, topographic features of the region were extracted covering village locations,
streams, roads, river in the satellite image. In addition to this, natural drainage network is also
captured to prepare drainage map as required. The purposes of land use studies are -
The overall methodology adopted and followed to achieve the objectives of the present study
involves the following steps -
Satellite data of IRS Resourcesat-2 sensor is geometrically corrected and enhanced using
principal component method and Nearest Neighborhood resampling technique.
Preparation of basic themes like layout map, transport & settlement map and from the
satellite image by visual interpretation.
Essential maps (related to natural resources) like Land use / Land cover map are prepared
by visual interpretation of the satellite imagery. Visual interpretation is carried out based
on the image characteristics like tone, size, shape, pattern, texture, location, association,
background etc. in conjunction with existing maps / literature.
Preliminary quality check and necessary corrections are carried out for all the maps
prepared.
All the maps prepared are converted into soft copy by digitization of contours and
drainages. In that process editing, labeling, mosaicing, quality checking, data integration
etc. are done, finally Land use areas are measured in Square Kilometers. Refer Figure 3.1
for Google Image showing 10 km radius study area circle.
57
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
58
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Since all the data of the study area were geo-referenced to UTM 43N WGS84 projection
system, the satellite images were also obtained with the same coordinate system from NRSA.
Before image classification was carried out, the satellite image was pre-processed. All the
processing and classification of the satellite images were performed in the ERDAS Imagine
9.1 software. The data was delivered in separate bands of 2, 3 and 4. As such, the first step
was to stack together to get a composite. The scenes were then mosaiced together since the
study area covered parts of both the scenes. Once a satisfactory mosaic was done whereby the
joins were no longer visible and the radiometric resolution of both the scenes were matched.
This subset of the original images was then run through the unsupervised classification tool
of the software to finally create the grouping of classes present in the study area. The location
of TDMCCL industry is shown on satellite image in Figure 3.3 and visual interpretation keys
used for the study are given in Figure 3.4.
59
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
60
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
It includes study of topographic features and land use under which area statistics for Land
Use Land Cover classes and Land Use Land Cover statistics are included.
In the present study, the essential maps generated from topo-sheets are layout map, drainage
map, Contour Map. The maps are prepared to a certain scale and with attributes complying
with the requirement of ToR. The location of entities on the earth’s surface is then specified
by means of an agreed co-ordinate system. For most GIS, the common frame of co-ordinate
system used for the study is UTM co-ordinates system. All the maps are first Geo-referenced.
The same procedure was also applied on remote sensing data before it is used to prepare the
Essential maps. The topographical map (Refer Figure 3.5) of industrial site of scale 1:75000
was obtained from Survey of India.
61
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
62
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Eco-sensitive map is a matter of more concern because the project should not hamper the
natural eco system and surrounding natural resources. The Eco- sensitive map of the project
site was developed on the Maharashtra state map showing all the eco-sensitive area of
Maharashtra state. The proposed expansion unit is in MIDC area, there are no eco-sensitive
areas within the 10 km of proposed expansion unit. The nearest sanctuary is Phansad Wild
life Sanctuary. Although, there are no eco-sensitive areas with 10 km of proposed unit, the
plant management shall take precautionary measures and not to release pollutants that can
damage the surrounding eco system.
The Eco-sensitive map (Refer Figure 3.6) showing Wild Life Sanctuary and National Park in
Maharashtra state.
Figure 3.6 Map showing Wild Life Sanctuary and National Park in Maharashtra
Land use Map Analysis done based on the image color, texture, Tone etc. Following steps are
used to analyze the Land use pattern of project site -
Collection of IRS Resourcesat-2 images and made fused and blended the images for color
combinations using Image interpreter-Utilities and Layer stack option available in
ERDAS.
Identification AOI and made a buffer of 10 km radius.
Enhance the Fused and blended IRS Resourcesat-2 image using the Spatial, Radiometric
and Temporal options in ERDAS.
63
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Rectified the IRS Resourcesat-2 image using Georeferencing technique, Toposheet to get
UTM coordinate system.
Subset the IRS Resourcesat-2 images and Toposheet using 10 Km buffer AOI.
Automatic classifications done for IRS Resourcesat-2 images using maximum iterations
and number of options in unsupervised classification options.
Created the signature file by selecting the more samples of different features with AOI on
Unsupervised classification image.
Export to Vector layer from supervised classification image.
Conducting QC / QA and finalized the data.
Land use map (Refer Figure 3.8) developed was based on the image color, texture, tone and
also ground truth verification data. Ground truth verification was carried out to validate the
results of classified image and reconciliation was carried out with actual location of land
mark features such as water bodies, agriculture land etc.
Table 3.5 Area Statistics for Land Use & Land Cover Classes
Figure 3.7 Graphical Presentation of Land Use & Land Cover Classification
Built Up Area
Crop Land
64
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
65
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Interpretation:
Built Up Area: Built Up Area cover about 5.20 % of area within 10 km radius of study
area. The surrounding villages around the project site are well developed with road,
electricity and water connectivity.
Cropland: 22.61 % of the study are is crop land, the major crop in the area are rice and
wheat.
Fallow land: Fallow land that covers about 3.47% area within 10 km radius buffer. This
fallow land is because of changing of crop type and leaving the land uncultivated to get
fertile. Some of the fallow land is seen because of hilly region where there is lack of
continuous water supply.
Forest land: Forest land covers about 37.93% of area within 10 km radius of study area.
The covers with all type of plant species.
Scrub: It is found that the some part of study area is also covered with dense scrub
covering about 27.45% of total study area.
Mining: The mining area is about 1.64% of study area, mainly rock cutting for
aggregate for construction.
The area has good literacy rate and there is a lot of development taking place in this area. All
the villages are well connected with the roads.
The settlement map shows the location of villages along with the roads and industries as
shown in figure below -
66
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
67
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Soil quality is the capacity of a specific kind of soil to function, within natural or managed
ecosystem boundaries, to sustain plant and animal productivity, maintain or enhance water
and air quality and support human health and habitation. Soil quality reflects how well a soil
performs the functions of maintaining biodiversity and productivity, partitioning water and
solute flow, filtering and buffering, nutrient cycling and providing support for plants and
other structures. Thus, soil quality plays vital role in any particular geographical phenomenon
of ecology as well as physico-chemical environment. Soil quality can indicate the current as
well as future issues related with the water, ecology and life in the particular region. Thus, it
is clearly visible that soil.
Considering this, for studying soils of the region, sampling locations were selected to assess
the existing soil conditions in and around the project area representing various, physiographic
conditions, geology, land form and land use conditions. The physical, chemical
characteristics were determined. The samples were collected by soil auger and other required
equipments, up to a depth of 30 cm. as per standard soil sampling procedure , given in Soil
survey manual, All India soil and land use survey, New Delhi-1970 of Ministry of
agriculture, Govt. of India.
The assignment w.r.t. Soil conservation (SC) has been done by Mr. B. S. Lole who is an
empanelled Functional Area Expert (FAE) of EEIPL for SC.
3.4.2. Methodology
The present study of the soil profile establishes the baseline characteristics and this will help
in future identification of the incremental concentrations if any, due to the operation of the
project. The sampling locations have been identified with the following objectives -
Eight locations in and around the proposed expansion plant boundary were selected for soil
sampling. At each location, soil samples were collected from surface 0 to 30 cm depth and
are homogenized and collected after quartering. The homogenized samples were analyzed for
physical and chemical characteristics. The soil samples were collected during post-monsoon
season. (21st Nov., 2017)
68
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
The samples have been analyzed by NABL accredited laboratory as per the established
scientific methods for physico-chemical parameters. The methodology adopted for each
parameter is described in following table -
In addition to field surveys, other sources of information were National Bureau of Soil
Survey and Land Use Planning (NBSS and LUP) as well as District Census Data from
Census of India, 2011.
The chief soil found in the study region is very shallow, well drained, loamy soils on very
gently sloping undulating and rolling lands with moderate erosion; associated with
moderately deep, well drained, clayey soils on very steeply sloping lands with severe erosion
and moderate stoniness. The study area consists of very shallow, well drained, loamy soils on
very steeply sloping elongated ridges / hills with very serve erosion; associated with shallow
moderately well drained; clayey soils on very gently lands with moderate erosion. Also the
study area consists of very shallow, somewhat drained, loamy soils on moderately steeply
sloping dissected hills and intervening valleys with serve erosion; associated with moderately
deep, moderately well drained, clayey soils on very gently sloping lands with moderate
erosion. (Refer Figure 3.10 and Figure 3.10 for Soil sample location map)
Overall, Eight soil sampling points were selected. The locations are listed in Table 3.7 and
analysis report under Table 3.8.
69
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
70
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
71
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
72
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Location
Sr.
Parameter Unit Ind. Site Dhatav Talaghar Landhar Nivi Udadhavane Ashtami Sambe
No.
(S1) (S2) (S3) (S4) (S5) (S6) (S7) (S8)
A Physical Parameter
1. Soil Texture
a. Sand % 16 18 15 8 18 20 28 29
b. Silt % 27 24 20 22 30 31 34 38
c. Clay % 57 58 65 70 52 57 38 33
2. Bulk Density gm/cc 1.28 1.24 1.31 1.51 1.15 1.18 1.22 1.27
3. Permeability cm/hr 0.52 0.54 0.16 0.13 0.47 0.52 1.55 1.61
4. Water Holding Capacity % 61.18 52.14 55.00 58.30 42.27 37.53 45.61 37.13
5. Porosity % 33.27 54.54 50.40 55.79 47.89 32.58 45.81 39.54
B Chemical Parameter
6. pH (1:5 Aq. Extraction at 24°C) -- 6.71 6.84 7.15 7.22 6.53 7.18 7.33 7.28
Conductivity
7. mS/cm 0.22 0.13 0.14 0.17 0.19 0.23 0.24 0.20
(1:5 Aq. Extraction at 24°C)
8. Cation Exchange Capacity meq/100 gm 46.54 45.21 45.56 47.14 46.08 44.82 45.77 46.92
9. Exchangeable Calcium meq/100 gm 22.44 20.63 25.93 24.89 20.19 24.51 25.51 23.64
10. Exchangeable Magnesium meq/100 gm 13.54 15.87 12.49 13.18 16.31 11.63 10.59 13.20
11. Exchangeable Potassium meq/100 gm 7.23 5.12 5.55 5.97 7.23 7.44 6.01 6.79
12. Exchangeable Sodium meq/100 gm 3.33 3.59 2.59 3.10 2.35 1.24 3.66 3.29
13. Sodium Adsorption Ratio (SAR) -- 0.79 0.84 0.59 0.71 0.55 0.29 0.86 0.77
14. Available Nitrogen as N kg/ha 44.29 47.59 54.60 67.21 71.14 57.18 69.25 70.28
15. Available Phosphorus as P mg/kg 22.18 20.14 16.10 18.25 15.74 19.24 24.15 27.37
16. Water Soluble Chlorides as Cl mg/kg 22.52 23.18 0.01 37.21 44.15 47.18 50.24 27.14
17. Water Soluble Sulphates as SO4 mg/kg 2.74 2.29 3.10 3.25 3.18 3.24 3.30 3.24
18. Aluminum as Al mg/kg Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil
19. Iron as Fe mg/kg 1.18 2.03 5.00 3.09 4.11 4.27 5.12 3.89
20. Manganese as Mn mg/kg 2.11 2.14 7.50 3.27 4.28 4.77 4.81 4.09
73
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Location
Sr.
Parameter Unit Ind. Site Dhatav Talaghar Landhar Nivi Udadhavane Ashtami Sambe
No.
(S1) (S2) (S3) (S4) (S5) (S6) (S7) (S8)
21. Boron as B mg/kg Nil Nil Nil Nil 0.04 0.03 Nil 0.007
22. Zinc as Zn mg/kg 1.14 1.12 1.10 1.54 1.51 1.29 1.11 1.18
23. Chromium as Cr mg/kg Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil
24. Lead as Pb mg/kg 0.92 0.88 1.00 1.14 1.21 1.27 1.18 1.94
25. Nickel as Ni mg/kg Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil 0.002 0.001
26. Arsenic as As mg/kg BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
27. Mercury as Hg mg/kg BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
28. Cadmium as Cd mg/kg Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil
29. Organic Carbon % 1.41 1.52 1.34 1.38 1.27 1.74 1.18 1.62
30. Organic matter % 2.43 2.61 2.31 2.37 2.18 2.99 3.11 2.79
Method of testing: As per SSSA/Soil Analysis by M. L. Jackson/USEP Note: Analysis result for soil are given at Annexure - I.
From the interpretation of field data, physical and chemical data it can be concluded that -
As per the physical data soils are fine texture, having low bulk density, imperatively high water holding capacity and moderately slow to slow
permeability. As per physical characters soils are rated as moderate to good for agriculture. As per chemical characters soil reaction (pH) soils are
neutral and electrical conductivity (EC) is non saline (normal). Organic matter is sufficient. Macro nutrient like nitrogen is very low to low and
phosphorus is low, potassium is low, calcium, magnesium are medium to good and base saturation is moderate to good, sodium is below the limit
to make soil saline or sodic or alkali. Micro-nutrients, Mn (low may cause deficiency), Zn, B, Fe, Al (nil to low, will cause deficiency), SO4 very
low and Cl are high. Cation Exchange Capacity is high indicating moderate to good fertility. Exchangeable Ca is medium to good with medium to
good base saturation, Ex. K is low, and Ex. Na is also low not indicating any alkalinity. Sodium adsorption ratio indicates the soils are normal.
Thus as per analysis of soils data and field observation the land represented by eight samples can be classified as class III e land i.e. moderate soils
on plain to gentle slopes subject to water erosion, as per land capability classification (USDA)
74
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Interpretation -
Physical characteristics - The physical characteristics include Bulk density, grain size
distribution (textural analysis).
Chemical Characteristics - The parameters considered for chemical analysis are - Soil
reaction (pH), Electrical conductivity (EC), Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC)) Cations,
like Calcium, Magnesium, Sodium and Potassium, water soluble sulphates ,and
chlorides, Sodium Adsorption Ratio (SAR), Macro nutrients like Available Nitrogen,
total Organic carbon, organic matter, Available phosphorus, available potassium, Micro
nutrients like Iron, Zinc, manganese and boron. Heavy metals like Chromium(Cr), Lead
(Pb), Nickel (Ni), Arsenic(As), Mercury (Hg) and Cadmium (Cd).
75
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Soil reaction (pH): The nutritional importance of pH is illustrated, thus hydrogen ion
concentration has influence not only on, solubility of nutrients, but also upon facility
with which these nutrients are absorbed by plants, even already in soil solution for
e.g. Fe, Mn and Zn become less available as pH rises from 4.5 to 7. At pH 6.5 to7.0
utilization of nitrate and ammonia nitrogen becomes more available. In case of
phosphorus it becomes less available to plant as pH increases above 8.5, due to its
fixation in exchange complex of soil. For the eight soil sample under consideration
the pH ranges between 6.53 to 7.33 indicating soils are neutral, and suitable for
growing all crops.
Electrical Conductivity (EC): The salt content of the soils are estimated by EC
measurements, and is useful to designate soils as normal or sodic (saline). Electrical
conductivity is expressed as µmhos/cm at 25◦C, µsmhos/ cm or mmhos /cm or sm/cm.
The EC of eight soil samples is between 0.13 to 0.24 µs/cm and are below the limits
to be called as saline and hence the soils are normal for crop growth.
Organic Carbon / Organic matter (%): Although accounting for only a small part
of the total soil mass in mineral soils, organic matter influences physical, chemical,
and biological activities in the soil. Organic matter in the soil is plant and animal
residue which serves as a reserve for many essential nutrients, especially nitrogen.
Determination of organic matter helps to estimate the nitrogen which will be released
by bacterial activity for the next season depending on the conditions, soil aeration,
pH, type of organic material, and other factors. The eight soil samples under
consideration contain 2.18 to 3.11 % organic matter; OM is calculated from organic
carbon estimation. As per crop requirements the soils are having sufficient organic
matter content required for growing crop in next season.
Available Nitrogen (N): Nitrogen is a part of all living cells and is a necessary part of
all proteins, enzymes and metabolic processes involved in the synthesis and transfer
of energy. Nitrogen is a part of chlorophyll, the green pigment of the plant that is
responsible for photosynthesis. Helps plants with rapid growth, increasing seed and
fruit production and improving the quality of leaf and forage crops. The available
nitrogen in the eight samples in question, as per analysis ranges between 44.2 to 71.14
kg/ha showing very low to low nitrogen content for crop growth.
Available Phosphorus (P): Like nitrogen, phosphorus (P) is an essential part of the
process of photosynthesis. Involved in the formation of all oils, sugars, starches etc.
Helps with the transformation of solar energy into chemical energy; proper plant
maturation; withstanding stress. Effects rapid growth. Encourages blooming and root
growth. The phosphorus content of soil of eight samples ranges between 15.74 to
27.37 kg/ha and falls under low category for crop growth.
Available Potassium (K): Potassium is absorbed by plants in larger amounts than
any other mineral element except nitrogen and, in some cases, calcium. Helps in the
building of protein, photosynthesis, fruit quality and reduction of diseases. The
Potassium content of eight soil samples ranges between 37.56 to 51.14 kg/ha and is
very less for crop growth.
Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC): The total amount of exchangeable cations that a
soil can retain is designated as cation exchange capacity (CEC) and usually expressed
as me/100 gm of soil. Determination of amount of cations present in soil is useful,
because CEC influences the availability of adsorbed cations to both higher plants and
soil microorganisms. Thus CEC is directly related to fertility of soils. The CEC of the
eight samples ranges between 45.21 to 46.92 me/100 gm soil. A soil with low CEC
indicates low fertility and soils with high CEC indicates high fertility. Eight soil
76
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
samples are fine textured having high percentage of clay with dominating
montmorrilonitic clay mineral, showing high CEC, in turn fertility is also high.
Exchangeable Calcium (Ca++): Calcium, an essential part of plant cell wall
structure, provides for normal transport and retention of other elements as well as
strength in the plant. It is also thought to counteract the effect of alkali salts and
organic acids within a plant and soil acidity. The exchangeable calcium content of
eight soil samples ranges between 20.19 to 25.93 me/100gm soil, and having high
base saturation percentage (ranging from 43.81 to 56.91%). For normal crop growth a
calcium base saturation percent of soils between 50 to 75% is required.
Exchangeable Magnesium (Mg++): Magnesium is part of the chlorophyll in all green
plants and essential for photosynthesis. It also helps activate many plant enzymes
needed for growth. The magnesium content of the eight soil samples ranges
between10.59 to 16.31 me/100 gm soil, which is further adding to base saturation.
Magnesium base saturation percent of 5 to 15 % is normal.
Exchangeable Sodium (Na+): Though sodium is not an essential plant nutrient, but it
has some role in potassium nutrition. Sodium also has a role in affecting the pH of
soils. Sodium present above a certain limit makes soil alkaline which affect soil
physical condition, and fixing of available phosphorus. Out of the eight samples
sodium ranges between 1.24 to 3.59 me/100gm soil, which is below the content (i.e.
ESP is below 15%) at which soil show, saline alkali or alkaline properties, hence no
adverse effect on soils.
Sodium Adsorption ratio (SAR): Sodium adsorption ratio is ratio of Na+ to under
root of Ca ++Mg++ by 2. SAR values of soil solution along with EC and pH helps in
diagnosing soils as normal, saline, saline-alkali or alkali. The eight soil samples show
SAR values between 1.11 to 1.27 and indicate that samples are normal. (SAR below
13)
Iron (Fe): Iron is essential for crop and other plants for chlorophyll formation. Iron
deficiency likely occurs in soils with high pH, poor aeration, excessive phosphorus, or
low organic matter. It may be produced also by an imbalance of Mo, Cu, and Mn. In
plants, the deficiency shows up as a pale green leaf color (chlorosis) with sharp
distinction between green veins and yellow inter-venial tissues. The iron content of
eight samples ranges between 1.18 to 5.12% and is very low to low. Thus may cause
problem of iron deficiency.
Aluminum (Al): Exchangeable Aluminum (Al) is not present in a plant available
form in soils with a pH above 5.5 and therefore tests for extractable aluminum need
only be done on distinctly acid soils. In soils with a pH range of 4.5 - 5.5 are those
most likely to be affected by aluminum toxicity. In the eight samples the total
Aluminum is nil which is very low.
Manganese (Mn): Is an important plant micro nutrient and is required by plants in
second greater quantity compared to iron, like any other element, it can have limiting
factor on plant growth, if it is deficient or toxic in plant tissue. Manganese is used in
plants as major contribution to various biological systems, including photo synthesis,
respiration and nitrogen assimilation. Mn content in the eight samples ranges between
2.11 to 7.50 mg/kg and is low and may cause deficiency in plants.
Zinc (Zn): Zn deficiency most often is present in sandy soils with neutral or alkaline
pH, or with low organic matter. Total zinc may be high but the availability depends
on other factors. In the present eight samples zinc content ranges between1.10 to 1.14
mg/kg or ppm and are low, considered deficient for crop growth.
Boron (B): There is a very narrow range between deficiency and toxicity in boron.
Deficiencies are more often when organic matter is low and dry weather slows the
77
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
decomposition. Uptake of boron is reduced at pH level higher than 7.0. Plant toxicity
symptoms manifest as leaf tip and marginal chlorosis. Boron toxicity occurs in dry
areas and is generally associated with irrigation water. In the eight samples of the
project the boron content is nil is low and cause deficiency to crops.
Water-Soluble Sulphates as SO4: This test measures readily available sulphur in the
form of dissolved plus absorbed sulphate. Sulphur testing is important where low
sulphur or sulphur-free fertilizers are used, such as high analysis NPK fertilizers.
Retention of sulphate sulphur by the soil is related to its phosphate retention, with
high leaching losses of sulphate being associated with low phosphate retention soils.
This should also be taken into account when considering sulphur fertilizer options. In
the eight samples the water soluble sulphate as SO4 ranges between 2.29 to 3.30
mg/kg and very low.
Water Soluble Chlorides as Cl: The Cl− anion does not form complexes readily, and
shows little affinity (or specificity) in its adsorption to soil components. Thus, Cl−
movement within the soil is largely determined by water flows. Chlorine is an
essential micronutrient for higher plants. It is present mainly as Cl−. Chloride is a
major osmotically active solute in the vacuole and is involved in both turgor and osmo
regulation. In the cytoplasm it may regulate the activities of key enzymes. In addition,
Cl−also acts as a counter anion and Cl− fluxes are implicated in the stabilization of
membrane potential, regulation of intracellular pH gradients and electrical
excitability. In the eight samples the water soluble chloride ranges between 22.54 to
50.24 mg/kg and is high.
Heavy Metals: Soils may become contaminated by the accumulation of heavy metals
and metalloids through emissions from the rapidly expanding industrial areas, mine
tailings, disposal of high metal wastes, leaded gasoline and paints, land application of
fertilizers, animal manures, sewage sludge, pesticides, wastewater irrigation, coal
combustion residues, spillage of petrochemicals, and atmospheric deposition. Heavy
metals constitute an ill-defined group of inorganic chemical hazards, and those most
commonly found at contaminated sites are lead (Pb), chromium (Cr), arsenic (As),
zinc (Zn), cadmium (Cd),), mercury (Hg) and nickel (Ni) Soils are the major sink for
heavy metals released into the environment by aforementioned anthropogenic
activities and unlike organic contaminants which are oxidized to carbon (IV) oxide by
microbial action, most metals do not undergo microbial or chemical degradation and
their total concentration in soils persists for a long time after their introduction
Changes in their chemical forms (speciation) and bioavailability are, however,
possible. The presence of toxic metals in soil can severely inhibit the biodegradation
of organic contaminants. Heavy metal contamination of soil may pose risks and
hazards to humans and the ecosystem through direct ingestion or contact with
contaminated soil, the food chain. (soil-plant-human or soil-plant-animal-human),
drinking of contaminated ground water, reduction in food quality (safety and
marketability) via phyto-toxicity, reduction in land usability for agricultural
production causing food insecurity, and land tenure problems.
Chromium (Cr): Chromium mobility depends on sorption characteristics of the soil,
including clay content, iron oxide content, and the amount of organic matter present.
Chromium can be transported by surface runoff to surface waters in its soluble or
precipitated form. Soluble and un-adsorbed chromium complexes can leach from soil
into groundwater. The leachability of Cr (VI) increases as soil pH increases. Most of
Cr released into natural waters is particle associated, however, and is ultimately
deposited into the sediment. In the eight samples the chromium is nil hence no
chromium contamination.
78
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Lead (Pb): Typical mean Pb concentration for surface soils worldwide averages
32 mg kg−1 and ranges from 10 to 67 mg kg−1. The most serious source of exposure to
soil lead is through direct ingestion of contaminated soil or dust. In general, plants do
not absorb or accumulate lead. However, in soils testing high in lead, it is possible for
some lead to be taken up. Studies have shown that lead does not readily accumulate in
the fruiting parts of vegetable and fruit crops (e.g. corn, beans, squash, tomatoes,
strawberries and apples). Higher concentrations are more likely to be found in leafy
vegetables (e.g. lettuce) and on the surface of root crops (e.g. carrots). Since plants do
not take up large quantities of soil lead, the lead levels in soil considered safe for
plants will be much higher than soil lead levels where eating of soil is a concern
(pica). Generally, it has been considered safe to use garden produce grown in soils
with total lead levels less than 300 ppm. The risk of lead poisoning through the food
chain increases as the soil lead level rises above this concentration. Even at soil levels
above 300 ppm, most of the risk is from lead contaminated soil or dust deposits on the
plants rather than from uptake of lead by the plant. In the eight samples the Lead
ranges between 0.88 to 1.94 mg/kg and within permissible limit.
Nickel (Ni): Nickel is an element that occurs in the environment only at very low
levels and is essential in small doses, but it can be dangerous when the maximum
tolerable amounts are exceeded. It usually takes a long time for nickel to be removed
from air. The larger part of all Ni compounds that are released to the environment will
adsorb to sediment or soil particles and become immobile as a result. In acidic soils,
however, Ni becomes more mobile and often leaches down to the adjacent
groundwater. In the eight soil samples, the nickel content is below the limit i.e. nil.
Arsenic (As): Arsenate can adsorb or co-precipitates with metal sulfides and has a
high affinity for other sulfur compounds. Elemental arsenic and arsine, AsH3, may be
present under extreme reducing conditions. Biotransformation (via methylation) of
arsenic creates methylated derivatives of arsine. As compounds adsorb strongly to
soils and are therefore transported only over short distances in groundwater and
surface water. In the eight samples the arsenic values are below detectible limit and
within permissible limit.
Mercury (Hg): Sorption to soils, sediments, and humic materials is an important
mechanism for the removal of Hg from solution. Sorption is pH dependent and
increases as pH increases. Mercury may also be removed from solution by co-
precipitation with sulphides. Under anaerobic conditions, both organic and inorganic
forms of Hg may be converted to alkylated forms by microbial activity, such as by
sulfur-reducing bacteria. Elemental mercury may also be formed under anaerobic
conditions by demethylation of methyl mercury, or by reduction of Hg (II). Acidic
conditions (pH < 4) also favor the formation of methyl mercury, whereas higher pH
values favor precipitation of HgS (s). In the eight samples the mercury content is
below detectible limit and within permissible limit.
Cadmium (Cd): The application of agricultural inputs such as fertilizers, pesticides,
and bio-solids (sewage sludge), the disposal of industrial wastes or the deposition of
atmospheric contaminants increases the total concentration of Cd in soils, and the
bioavailability of this Cd determines whether plant Cd uptake occurs to a significant
degree. Cadmium is very bio-persistent but has few toxicological properties and, once
absorbed by an organism, remains resident for many years. The eight samples contain
cadmium is nil and within permissible limits.
79
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Comments: From the interpretation of field data, physical and chemical data it can be
concluded that - As per the physical data soils are fine texture, having low bulk density,
imperatively high water holding capacity, and moderately slow to slow permeability. As per
physical characters soils are rated as moderate to good for agriculture. As per chemical
characters soil reaction (pH) soils are neutral and electrical conductivity (EC) is non saline
(normal). Organic matter is sufficient. Macro nutrient like nitrogen is very low to low and
phosphorus is low, potassium is low, calcium, magnesium are medium to good and base
saturation is moderate to good. Sodium is below the limit to make soil saline or sodic or
alkali. Micro-nutrients, Mn (low may cause deficiency), Zn, B, Fe, Al (nil to low, will cause
deficiency), SO4 very low and Cl are high. Cation Exchange capacity is high indicating
moderate to good fertility. Exchangeable Ca is medium to good with medium to good base
saturation, Ex K is low, and Ex Na is also low not indicating any alkalinity. Sodium
adsorption ratio indicates the soils are normal. As observed during field visit of 10 km buffer
area from boundary of proposed expansion plant. From Geomorphologic point of view, the
area consists of slightly undulating plain topography with average elevation ranging from 3 to
15 m AMSL. The Main geomorphic units are: Coastal zone in west, Central zone: Fertile,
low lying land and Hilly zone: highly uneven with forest cover.
In general, area is characterized by slightly undulating and flat terrain. As per soil map of
Maharashtra at 1:500000 scale by NBSS & LUP, the family association observed in the area
are - 1) Very shallow, well drained, loamy soils on very gently sloping elongated ridge hills
with very severe erosion; associated with shallow moderately well drained, clayey soils on
very gently sloping land with moderate erosion. 2) Very shallow, somewhat excessively
drained, loamy soils on moderately steeply sloping dissected hills and intervening valleys
with severe erosion; associated with deep, moderately well drained, clayey soils on very
gently sloping lands with moderate erosion. Thus as per analysis of soils data and field
observation the land represented by eight samples can be classified as class III land i.e.
moderate soils on plain to gentle slopes subject to water erosion, as per land capability
classification (USDA).
80
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
3.5.1 Drainage
The topography of the region governs the drainage pattern of that area. The assignment w.r.t.
geology and hydro-geological studies was conducted by Dr. J. B. Pishte; the empanelled
Functional Area Expert of EEIPL for HG & GEO.
The Roha MIDC is situated in the Kundalika River valley, about 19 km upstream from the
shoreline of the Arabian Sea. It is located on the west side of the Kolad - Roha road along the
left bank of the river. As this project is proposed expansion within the area of MIDC, Roha; it
will constitute a part of the cumulative environmental impact of the entire industrial area. The
geological and hydrogeological studies for EIA with reference to this project were carried out
in the area on the basis of previous literature and observations made during field visits.
The Raigad district is bounded by the Arabian Sea on the west and, on the east, its boundary
runs partly along the foothill zone and partly along the watershed of the major Sahyadrian
scarp. The topographic set up of the district is very uneven and rugged. From the coastline on
the west to the water divide in the east, three topographic divisions can be identified. The
coastline is characterized by alternative bluffs and curved bays having narrow hinterlands.
The central region of the district has many plateau and hills rising from the valleys. The
Eastern part of the district is much rugged merging with the Sahyadris which are running
North South direction. The eastern horizon is marked by Sahyadri hills. Hill slopes are mostly
covered with forests. The plains are under cultivation or plantation. The coastal tract is
mostly marshy land or wasteland. The drainage system in Raigad district consists of six river
basins. All rivers are westerly flowing. (Refer Figure 3.12 for Drainage map) The drainage
system may be divided into three groups as follows -
The Northern region : Drained by river Panvel, Ulhas, Patalganga and Amba
The Central region : Drained by Kundalika, Mandad
The South region : Savitri and its tributaries
The rivers are tidal for a considerable extent and can be divided into two well-marked
sections, above and below the limit of the tide. The upper courses are steep and rugged, with
torrential waters flowing during the monsoon season. Besides the general parallel drainage
pattern of the rivers, the tributary pattern tends, at places, to be rectangular suggesting the
adaptation of the stream to the local rock structure.
81
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
82
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
3.5.2 Geomorphology
The study area forms part of the coastal plain of Raigad district. It is situated in the level land
between low hills ridges bounding the Kundalika river valley in the central region of the
district. The river flows in the NNW direction through the area, corresponding to major
fractures / joints. It drains the narrow central belt of the coastal plain into the Chaul creek
(Refer Figure 3.13 for Geomorphology map). The river course in the study area is
characterized by torrential flows in monsoon, with high carrying capacity and strong erosion
power which has scraped the channel floor making it rocky and rugged (Plate 1).
3.6.1 Introduction
The information presented covers geological and hydro-geological investigations in the study
area. The scope of work includes geological and hydro-geological observations involving
rock types, geological set up, geomorphology, drainage system and investigations involving
groundwater level measurements in dug wells, analyses for quality of ground water,
estimation of rainwater harvesting potential and possible means and methods for it etc. and
preparation of respective maps for presenting in the report. The study of the Geology and
Hydro Geology was done by Dr. J. B. Pishte; the empanelled Functional Area Expert of
EEIPL for HG & GEO.
83
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
84
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
3.6.2 Geology
Geologically the Raigad district forms a part of the Deccan Trap Group of rocks. The entire
district is covered by dark grey to grey and bluish coloured basaltic lava flows and laterites.
The lava flows are spread out in the form of horizontal sheets or beds. (Refer Figure 3.14 for
Geological map) In the Western Ghats the lava flows form innumerable spurs, hills and hill
ranges; bold, flat, topped ridges; lofty peaks and plateaus with impressive cliffs. In the plains
and valleys, the lava flows occur below a blanket of soil of variable thickness. A
characteristic feature of these lava flows is their horizontal disposition and considerable
lateral extent with almost incredible uniformity in their composition and appearance. Two
types of basalts are recognized in Deccan Traps viz. the hard, compact basalt and vesicular /
amygdaloidal basalt. The compact basalt is more common than the vesicular type. The hard,
compact basalt is tough and shows fine to medium grained in texture. Vertical, inclined,
prismatic and columnar joints and horizontal sheet joints are commonly found in this type.
These rocks wither by exfoliation into massive, spheroidal boulders, which are usually seen
on the hill slopes and foothills.
The comparatively softer, amygdaloidal and scoriaceous traps, purple to greenish in colour,
usually showing rounded and elongated or tubular cavities with infillings of secondary
minerals like calcite, zeolites and a variety of secondary quartz. These generally occupy the
lower portion of the ridges and slopes and usually the valleys and plains. At higher altitudes,
hills and plateaus are capped by laterite which a product of weathering of basalt in tropical
climate with alternate seasons of heavy monsoon rains and hot dry summer. Laterite is dark
brown to yellowish in colour and composed of iron oxides and hydroxides. At lower
altitudes, the weathering of basalts give rise to a greyish to dirty green, friable murum, which
on decomposition and decay yield a rich and fertile reddish-brown to coffee brown and black
soil. The laterite on disintegration gives rise to a dusty, reddish to reddish-brown soil. The
entire region in interspersed with a large number of lineaments criss-crossing each other. The
lineaments in the coast are not randomly distributed but appear to be grouped in sets. The
majority of lineaments along the coastal area follow a NNE-SSW and a few N-S trends.
(Power, 1993;.Das, 1999; Das and Mukherjee, 2002c).
The geology of the Dhatav MIDC area is characterized by occurrence of mainly hard
compact basalt with smaller extent of vesicular / amygdaloidal basalt under a thin cover of
soil (Plate 2 & 3). Outcrops and exposures are found mainly along stream courses. The
Kundalika River and its tributaries show many rocky and rugged outcrops in their channels in
the area. There are also found many SE-NW trending linears, which control the course of
west flowing rivers like Amba and Kundalika. These rivers take a sudden SE-NW turn near
the coast. (Power, 1993;.Das, 1999; Das and Mukherjee, 2002c).
3.6.3 Hydrogeology
Due to plenty of rainfall, moderate to high drainage density and fractured nature of the
basaltic rocks at many places, the area has a good groundwater potential. The groundwater
table in the western part of the district is comparatively shallow and in spite of the presence
of so many coastal inlets and creeks, the occurrence of saline water intrusion into the fresh
water system is few. Safe drinking water is available at almost all the places. The depth of
wells ranges between 3.50 to 8.50 m.
85
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
86
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
The SWL in winter ranges between 1 to 3.50 m and in summer it ranges between 4 to 8.00 m.
Majority of the wells go dry in the summer season due to poor productive aquifer.
Plate 2 Compact basalt with sheet joints in left bank of Kundalika River, Dhatav
87
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
The Dhatav MIDC layout is in a plain terrain close to the foot of hills towards Southwest.
Two streams originating in these hills are relevant to the EIA studies regarding Hydrogeology
and Geology (HG-GEO). The smaller stream passes through the MIDC area while the larger
one called ‘Ganga’ by locals, passes along the western-northern periphery of the MIDC. Both
the streams drain into Kundalika River on the north-eastern side of the MIDC. As the MIDC
is situated within the drainage basins of these two streams, it appears safe to assume that the
impact of the proposed project and other units in this industrial area on hydrogeology and
geology will be limited to these two basins only; and the area beyond these drainage basins is
not likely to be affected by activities in or effluents from the MIDC. (Refer Figure 3.15).
Figure 3.15 Part of Drainage Map showing closer view of streams in the Roha
No open wells or bore wells were found in entire the MIDC area. No wells are found on the
right bank of Kundalika River. Only three open wells, one near Bhavani Mandir (Plate 4),
Roth Khurd (Plate 5) and two in Dhatav village (Plate 6) were observed.
.
During interaction, the residents of the area appeared satisfied with the water supply from
MIDC. They have not used water from the wells since long time. Hence they didn't feel the
need to dig wells for water supply. The population in the villages on right bank of Kundalika
River is dependent on canal water as well as open and bore wells. These sources of water are
not likely to be affected by the effluents from MIDC, if any; as they are situated in a different
drainage basin than that of the MIDC.
88
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
89
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
The water quality in these wells is reported to be good, but the residents are not using
groundwater for any purpose as the water supply from MIDC satisfies their requirements.
Overall, no adverse remarks regarding quality of water were made by the residents.
We could see turtles and fishes in the wells in Dhatav at the time of visit which can be
considered as an indicator of reasonably good quality of water.
Representative samples of groundwater were collected for analysis of quality of water (Plate
4, 5, 6). The report of analyses of these samples is given in Table No. 3.17. It is apparent that
some of the quality parameter viz. TDS, Calcium as Ca, Magnesium as Mg, total hardness and
Coliform bacteria exceed the acceptable limits (IS 10500-2012). This can be considered as
baseline status of the quality of groundwater with reference to this Project.
90
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
91
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
3.7 METEOROLOGY
3.7.1 Introduction
Micro-meteorological data within the study area during the air quality survey period is an
indispensable part of air pollution studies. The meteorological data recorded during the
monitoring period is very useful for proper interpretation of the baseline information as well
as for input to the predictive models for air quality dispersion. Historical data on
meteorological parameters will also play an important role in identifying the general
meteorological status of the region. Site specific data can be compared with the historical
data in order to identify changes, which may have taken place due to the rapid
industrialization in the area.
Temperature
Generally the district experienced moist and humid climate. The climate of the district is
typical of that on the west coast of India, with plentiful, regular and seasonal rainfall during
the monsoon season. Being a coastal district, the diurnal and seasonal variations in
temperature is not large. The mean minimum and maximum temperatures observed are
16.1°C and 40.4°C respectively.
Rainfall
The south- west monsoon commences by about the first week of June and the rains continue
till about the beginning of October. The average rainfall for the district is 3492 mm. The
rainfall increases rapidly from the coast towards the Sahyadri on the eastern border of the
district. Nearly 95 per cent of the annual rainfall is received during the south-west monsoon
season. The rainfall is regular and the variations are from year to year.
3.7.2 Methodology
The methodology adopted for monitoring surface observations is as per the standard norms
laid down by Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) and the Indian Meteorology Department
(IMD). On-site monitoring was undertaken for various meteorological variables in order to
generate the data, which is then compared with the meteorological data generated by IMD
from the Mumbai, IMD station.
92
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Meteorological data has been generated at the site. The meteorological parameters were
monitored for one season i.e. from October 2017-December 2017. Details of parameters
monitored, equipments used and the frequency of monitoring are given in Table 3.10.
Secondary information on meteorological conditions has been collected from IMD station at
Mumbai. Wind speed & direction, temperature, relative humidity, rainfall intensity have been
compiled from IMD station, Mumbai. Also references were taken from book - Climatological
Normals (1971-2000). Similarly, data on cloud cover is compiled from climatologically
tables for the Mumbai IMD Station. Details are tabulated in Annexure - II.
Wind Speed and direction are recorded at site every hour. The predominant wind during the
study season is from North East (NE) direction.
3.8.1 Introduction
The ambient air quality with respect to the study zone of 10 Km radius around proposed
expansion site forms the baseline information. The study area represents mostly rural
environment. The various sources of air pollution in the study area are vehicular traffic,
industrial activities and domestic firewood burning. The impact of these emissions is
reflected in the results of ambient air quality. The major air pollutants released into
atmosphere from the different sources are PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NOx, NH3 and to small extent
CO. However, this again varies with type of the source.
This section describes the selection of sampling locations, parameters, frequency of sampling,
and methodology of sampling and analytical techniques for analysis of collected samples.
Presentation of results for the period October 2017 to December 2017 survey is done
followed by observations. All the requisite monitoring assignments, sampling and analysis
was conducted through the laboratory of M/s. Horizon Services, Pune which is NABL
accredited and MoEFCC; New Delhi approved organization. Study w.r.t. air quality was done
by Mr. Yuvraj Damugade FAEs and Mr. Sangram Patil who is FAA of EEIPL for AQ.
93
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
3.8.2 Methodology
The baseline status of the ambient air quality has been assessed through an ambient air
quality monitoring network. The design of monitoring network, in the air quality surveillance
program, is based on considerations namely - (1) Meteorological conditions (2) Topography
of the study area (3) Representativeness of regional background air quality for obtaining
baseline status and (4) Representativeness of likely industrial impact areas.
Ambient air monitoring was conducted in the study area to assess the quality of air for SO2,
NOx, CO, PM10, PM2.5,VOC, NH3, HCl, Lead, Ozone, Benzene, Benzopyrene, Arsenic and
Nickel.
Ambient AAQM stations were set up at Eight locations with due consideration to the above
mentioned points, details of which are presented below. Monitoring of air quality was done
here over a period of one season. Annexure - III may be referred for AAQM data.
The frequency adopted for sampling is two days per week, 24 hourly for all six ambient air
quality stations. The baseline data w.r.t. air environment, for all the six monitoring stations,
was generated. Details of same are presented in following table -
Duration of Sampling
The duration of sampling for PM10, PM2.5 was once 24 hourly, for SO2, NOx, CO, Lead was
once 8 hourly three samples per day and for VOC, NH3, Ozone, Benzene, Benzopyrene,
Arsenic and Nickel was 8 hourly one sample per day.
The summary of results for analysis of AAQ is presented in Table 3.13 which is based on
observations recorded during one monitoring season (October 2017 - December 2017).
Therein, also various statistical parameters like Arithmetic Mean (AM), 98 Percentile,
Maximum and Minimum values have been presented subsequent to computation from the
data collected. Moreover, the permissible AAQ limits are presented in Table 3.13.
Location
Parameters Roth
Industrial Talaghar Nivi Talavali Washi Varsoli Barshet
with Unit Bk.
Site (A1) (A3) (A4) (A5) (A6) (A7) (A8)
(A2)
Max. 60.10 45.20 70.10 55.10 48.10 72.00 65.90 72.60
PM10
Min. 50.60 37.29 60.40 45.70 45.70 50.80 50.40 68.20
g/m3
Avg. 55.72 40.80 65.59 49.96 47.06 64.16 57.03 70.14
98 % 58.24 42.51 67.11 51.58 48.10 71.00 59.29 71.43
Max. 22.00 11.60 20.50 13.40 13.10 20.90 18.40 22.30
PM2.5
Min. 14.20 8.50 15.50 10.80 10.80 11.90 11.50 18.60
g/m3
Avg. 16.02 10.32 17.39 12.20 12.06 17.55 14.98 20.11
98 % 17.51 11.01 18.61 13.13 13.07 20.55 15.87 21.46
Max. 28.90 17.10 17.80 15.00 13.50 25.00 26.80 19.50
SO2 Min. 18.20 5.00 12.50 11.60 11.60 15.20 14.60 15.10
g/m3 Avg. 22.00 15.34 15.29 13.46 12.72 19.03 20.87 16.69
98 % 23.97 16.14 16.41 14.39 13.45 22.64 22.80 18.30
95
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Location
Parameters Roth
Industrial Talaghar Nivi Talavali Washi Varsoli Barshet
with Unit Bk.
Site (A1) (A3) (A4) (A5) (A6) (A7) (A8)
(A2)
Max. 42.00 23.60 20.80 20.40 17.10 29.40 30.10 25.10
NOx Min. 29.40 8.00 16.20 15.40 15.40 20.50 20.40 20.00
g/m3 Avg. 34.27 20.93 18.45 17.14 16.16 24.54 26.36 22.08
98 % 39.19 22.46 19.70 18.46 17.05 27.82 28.31 24.04
Max. 22.00 9.80 10.00 12.30 9.10 11.20 10.10 12.00
NH3 Min. 16.20 8.20 8.00 7.90 7.90 8.20 8.20 8.40
g/m 3
Avg. 18.60 8.89 9.09 9.65 8.54 9.58 9.22 10.03
98 % 19.86 9.39 9.58 10.50 9.07 10.82 9.71 11.22
Max. 0.089 0.068 0.091 0.090 0.040 0.094 0.100 0.090
CO Min. 0.020 0.010 0.015 0.020 0.020 0.025 0.050 0.025
mg/m3 Avg. 0.059 0.035 0.053 0.051 0.030 0.065 0.075 0.048
98 % 0.082 0.050 0.063 0.063 0.039 0.081 0.086 0.059
Max. 0.990 BDL 0.190 0.690 0.690 0.980 BDL 0.980
Lead
Min. 0.010 BDL 0.029 0.026 0.040 0.065 BDL 0.010
(Pb)
Avg. 0.094 BDL 0.092 0.088 0.111 0.122 BDL 0.119
g/m3
98 % 0.260 BDL 0.119 0.290 0.667 0.349 BDL 0.381
Max. 13.50 15.10 12.80 11.23 10.00 11.20 12.60 10.60
Ozone Min. 9.20 10.40 6.00 8.40 8.40 7.50 7.90 7.50
g/m3 Avg. 10.98 12.20 9.01 9.61 9.09 9.59 9.88 8.67
98 % 12.19 13.56 10.71 10.48 9.94 10.84 11.27 9.45
Max. 0.450 BDL BDL 0.430 0.310 BDL BDL BDL
Benzen Min. 0.370 BDL BDL 0.240 0.240 BDL BDL BDL
e g/m3 Avg. 0.400 BDL BDL 0.332 0.288 BDL BDL BDL
98 % 0.424 BDL BDL 0.365 0.310 BDL BDL BDL
Benzo( Max. BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
a) Min. BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
pyrene Avg. BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
mg/m3 98 % BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
Max. BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
Arsenic Min. BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
mg/m3 Avg. BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
98 % BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
Max. BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
Nickel Min. BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
mg/m3 Avg. BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
98 % BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL
Max. 100.10 40.50 42.00 80.00 68.60 38.90 40.00 36.40
VOC Min. 80.40 30.00 30.50 60.50 60.50 30.10 34.90 30.10
g/m3 Avg. 90.58 35.00 34.79 68.45 64.50 35.75 37.43 33.78
98 % 96.39 37.17 37.84 74.28 68.45 38.47 38.92 35.19
Note -
PM10, PM2.5, NOx, SO2 ,VOC, NH3, HClare computed based on 24 hourly values.
CO is computed based on 8 hourly values
96
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Table 3.14 National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) Specified by CPCB
Notification (New Delhi, the 18th November, 2009)
Zone Station
Parameters Industrial and Residential and
mixed use zone rural zone
A.A. 60 60
PM10 g/m3
24 Hr 100 100
A.A. 40 40
PM2.5 g/m3
24 Hr 60 60
A.A. 50 20
SO2 g/m3
24 Hr 80 80
A.A. 40 30
NOx g/m3
24 Hr 80 80
8 Hr 2 2
CO mg/m3
1 Hr 4 4
A.A. 100 100
NH3 g/m3
24 Hr 400 400
A.A. 0.50 0.50
Lead (Pb) g/m3
24 Hr 1 1
8 Hr 100 100
Ozone g/m3
1 Hr 180 180
Benzene g/m3 Annual 5 5
Benzo(a) Pyrene mg/m3 Annual 1 1
Arsenic mg/m3 Annual 6 6
Nickel mg/m3 Annual 20 20
VOC g/m3 NS NS NS
The observations in respect of results presented in Table 3.13 are given below -
PM10 values at all the eight locations are attributed to windblown dust. The 98 percentile
values at stations viz. Industrial Site, Roth Bk., Talaghar, Nivi, Talavali, Washi, Varsoli and
Barshet are observed between 42.5 g/m3 to 71.4 g/m3 which are below the permissible
value of 100 g/m3 designated for residential/Industrial zones. Average PM10 values ranges
between 40.8 g/m3 to 70.1 g/m3.
All the observed values are within the permissible limits for residential and rural conditions
i.e. 60 g/m3. The average values ranges between 10.3 g/m3 to 20.1 g/m3.
97
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
All the observations are well below the permissible limits of 80 g/m3. Considering the
meteorology of the site, average SO2 concentrations ranges between 12.7 g/m3 to 22.0
g/m3.
All the observed values are within the permissible limits for residential and rural conditions
i.e. 80 g/m3. The average values ranges between 16.2 g/m3 to 34.3 g/m3.
The average concentration of CO at selected monitoring sites was found in between 0.0
mg/m3 to 0.1 mg/m3 which are within the permissible limits of NAAQM standards.
Ammonia (NH3)
All the observations are well below the permissible limits of 400 g/m3. Considering the
meteorology of the site, average NH3 concentrations ranges between 8.5 g/m3 to 18.6 g/m3.
Lead (Pb)
Lead (Pb) concentration at sites Roth Bk. and Varsoli were found to be below detectable
limits (BDL), while average value is 0.1 g/m3 for other each sites.
Ozone (O3)
The average concentrations of O3 at selected sampling sites are in between 8.7 g/m3 to 12.2
g/m3 which are within permissible limits.
Benzene (C6H6)
Benzene concentration at sites namely Roth Bk., Talaghar, Washi, Varsoli and Barshet was
below detectable limits (BDL). At other sites the average benzene concentration was found to
be in the range between 0.3 g/m3 to 0.4 g/m3.
The average concentration of Benzo(a) Pyrene, Arsenic and Nickel was found to be below
detectable limits (BDL) at all sites respectively.
VOC
The average VOC concentration at Industrial site is 90.6 g/m3; due to proximity of other
industries in the MIDC, the industrial site location showed relatively higher value of VOC. At
other sites the average VOC concentration was found to be in the range between 33.8 g/m3
to 68.4 g/m3.
98
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
3.9.1 Introduction
Selected water quality parameters, for surface and ground water resources, within the study
area have been considered for assessing water environment and evaluating impact due to the
proposed expansion project activities. Understanding the water quality is important in the
preparation of environmental impact assessment and to identify critical issues with a view to
suggest appropriate mitigation measures for implementation.
The assignment w.r.t. water pollution aspect was done by Prof. (Dr.) Bhaskar Thorat who
is an empanelled Functional Area Expert (FAE) for WP.
3.9.2 Methodology
Reconnaissance survey was undertaken and monitoring locations were finalized based on (1)
toposheet and drainage map to identify major water bodies and (2) likely areas which can
represent baseline conditions. Sampling and analysis of water samples for physical, chemical
and heavy metals were undertaken through NABL & MoEFCC; New Delhi approved
laboratory of M/s. Horizon Services, Pune. Eight locations for ground water and eight
locations for surface water were selected which are listed below in Table 3.15 and Table
3.16 respectively.
Ground and surface water sources, covered in an area of 10 Km radius from the proposed
expansion site were examined for physico-chemical, heavy metal and bacteriological
parameters in order to assess the effect of industrial and other activities on surface and
ground water. The samples were collected and analyzed as per procedures specified in
‘Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater’ published by American
Public Health Association (APHA). Samples for chemical analysis were collected in
polyethylene carboys. Moreover, samples were collected in sterilized glass bottles for
bacteriological test. Parameters analyzed at the site were pH, temperature, odour, turbidity
and dissolved oxygen using portable water analysis kits. Selected physico-chemical and
bacteriological parameters have been analyzed for projecting the existing water quality status
in the core area. Results for the parameters analyzed in surface water samples, are compared
with Class ‘C’ water as per IS 10500:1991, Revised 2012; “Specifications for Drinking
Water”.
100
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
3.9.4 Presentation of Ground Water Results for Survey from October 2017 - December 2017
Location
Sr. Roth kh. Dhatav 1 Dhatav 2 Roth Bk. Muthavali Malsai Bahe Dhankanhe Limits IS
Parameter Unit (GW1) (GW2) (GW3) (GW4) (GW5) (GW6) (GW7) (GW8)
No. 10500:2012
Open Well Open Open Bore Bore Open Community Bore
Well Well Well Well Well Bore Well Well
1. pH -- 7.34 7.03 7.54 7.63 7.21 7.16 7.35 7.52 6.5-8.5
2. Turbidity NTU 0.20 0.10 0.12 0.22 0.34 0.25 0.19 0.14 001.00
3. Electrical Conductance mS/cm 1.27 1.26 0.77 1.33 1.38 1.45 1.37 1.43 Not Specified
4. Total Dissolved Solids mg/lit 846.26 842.07 515.74 894.33 926.93 971.20 919.97 955.82 500.00
5. Total Suspended Solids mg/lit 28.15 33.02 12.39 15.63 20.9 22.54 15.42 16.87 Not Specified
6. Chemical Oxygen Demand mg/lit 6.59 13.18 12.69 13.65 15.20 18.52 15.76 19.87 Not Specified
7. Biochemical Oxygen Demand mg/lit 3.83 5.11 5.05 5.98 6.11 7.24 6.01 7.50 Not Specified
8. Chlorides as Cl- mg/lit 91.50 87.40 84.26 99.71 100.52 87.19 105.41 85.27 <250.00
9. Sulphates as SO4 mg/lit 80.5 65.40 72.87 83.49 90.18 104.50 83.88 95.92 <200.00
10. Copper as Cu mg/lit 0.001 0.002 0.000 0.005 Nil 0.006 Nil 0.001 <0.05
11. Nickel as Ni mg/lit Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil <0.02
12. Total Chromium as Cr mg/lit Nil Nil 0.06 Nil 0.002 0.004 0.006 Nil <0.05
13. Zinc as Zn mg/lit 0.020 0.030 0.002 0.001 0.003 0.001 0.004 0.001 <5.00
14. Mercury as Hg mg/lit Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil <0.001
15. Arsenic as As mg/lit Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil <0.01
16. Iron as Fe mg/lit Nil 0.06 0.01 0.015 0.013 0.016 0.016 0.012 <0.30
17. Sodium as Na mg/lit 29.64 55.79 32.15 36.51 40.19 28.96 29.74 24.38 Not Specified
18. Potassium as K mg/lit 4.10 5.90 5.63 6.61 7.29 4.26 5.27 5.51 Not Specified
19. Cadmium as Cd mg/lit Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil <0.003
20. Lead as Pb mg/lit Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil <0.01
21. Boron as B mg/lit Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil <0.50
22. Calcium as Ca mg/lit 71.30 92.67 82.57 79.81 76.27 89.79 95.23 91.68 <75.00
23. Magnesium as Mg mg/lit 31.20 20.23 25.63 26.69 28.21 30.39 21.45 32.69 <30.00
24. Total Hardness as CaCO3 mg/lit 306.79 315.02 312.02 309.49 306.90 349.68 326.45 363.88 <200.00
25. Phosphate as PO4 mg/lit 0.12 1.70 1.86 0.74 0.97 1.44 1.69 1.26 Not Specified
101
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Location
Sr. Roth kh. Dhatav 1 Dhatav 2 Roth Bk. Muthavali Malsai Bahe Dhankanhe Limits IS
Parameter Unit (GW1) (GW2) (GW3) (GW4) (GW5) (GW6) (GW7) (GW8)
No. 10500:2012
Open Well Open Open Bore Bore Open Community Bore
Well Well Well Well Well Bore Well Well
26. Fluorides as F mg/lit 0.15 0.12 0.17 0.22 0.25 0.35 0.26 0.24 <1.0
27. Nitrites as NO2 mg/lit 0.034 0.041 0.026 0.012 0.016 0.015 0.036 0.022 Not Specified
28. Nitrates as NO3 mg/lit 0.30 0.40 0.36 0.33 0.41 0.56 0.48 0.44 <45.00
29. Total Nitrogen mg/lit 0.50 0.60 0.45 0.46 0.52 0.63 0.50 0.55 Not Specified
30. Carbonates as CO32- mg/lit Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Not Specified
31. Bicarbonates as HCO3- mg/lit 170.10 163.70 150.69 188.24 193.19 195.41 193.55 185.96 Not Specified
32. Ammonical Nitrogen mg/lit Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Not Specified
No./
33. Total Coliforms 100 ml
60 33 59 62 82 78 56 68 No. /100 ml
No./
34. Fecal Coliforms 100 ml
Present Present Present Present Present Present Present Present Absent
Note - Analysis results for the Ground water are given at Annexure - IV.
102
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Location
Pale Kh. Udhavane Mahadevwa Conflue Roth Bk. Zolambe Dhatav Killa
Sr. Limits IS
Parameter Unit (SW1) (SW2) di (SW3) nce (SW5) (SW6) (SW7) (SW8)
No 10500:2012
Upstream Midstream (SW4) Down Down
stream stream
1. Colour -- Colorless Colorless Colorless Colorless Colorless Colorless Colorless Colorless --
2. Odour -- Agreeable Agreeable Slightly smell Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable
3. pH -- 7.41 7.52 8.15 7.72 7.63 7.77 7.45 7.58 6.5-8.5
4. Conductivity µS/cm 152.25 256.64 1051.38 350.53 296.62 396.37 445.55 589.21 Not Specified
5. Total Dissolved Solids
mg/lit 102.18 172.24 705.62 235.26 199.08 266.02 297.80 393.80 < 500.00
(TDS)
6. Turbidity NTU 0.8 0.9 2.1 1.2 1.1 1.4 0.7 0.5 1.00
7. Total Suspended Solids mg/lit 19.00 24.00 112.00 32.00 30.00 39.00 45.00 59.00 Not Specified
8. Chemical Oxygen Demand mg/lit 13.00 16.00 37.90 20.50 18.50 22.40 15.63 19.98 Not Specified
9. BOD 3 days at 27o C mg/lit 5.00 6.00 13.00 8.50 7.20 9.45 6.21 7.23 Not Specified
10. Ammonical Nitrogen mg/lit NIL NIL 10.50 NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL Not Specified
11. Nitrate as NO3 mg/lit 0.20 0.32 46.56 4.25 2.55 5.18 3.15 4.61 45.00
12. Nitrite as NO2 mg/lit NIL NIL 1.29 0.001 NIL NIL 0.002 0.004 Not Specified
13. Phosphorous as P mg/lit 0.01 0.50 0.90 0.59 0.55 0.60 0.31 0.41 Not Specified
14. Nitrogen as N mg/lit 0.03 0.60 1.10 0.72 0.69 0.78 0.60 0.89 Not Specified
15. Sodium as Na mg/lit 0.02 0.06 0.09 0.07 0.06 0.07 0.05 0.06 Not Specified
16. Potassium as K mg/lit NIL NIL 1.80 0.062 0.052 0.066 NIL 1.20 Not Specified
17. Calcium as Ca mg/lit 10.09 15.23 89.62 29.60 20.29 35.63 19.87 23.54 75.00
18. Magnesium as Mg mg/lit 4.10 7.89 39.63 10.29 8.28 17.79 8.45 11.79 30.00
19. Total Hardness as CaCO3 mg/lit 42.12 70.58 387.33 116.39 84.84 162.37 84.48 107.42 200.00
20. Carbonates as CO32- mg/lit NIL NIL 1.69 NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL Not Specified
21. Bicarbonates as HCO3 mg/lit 27.30 52.16 311.26 76.40 62.59 89.62 74.51 102.53 Not Specified
22. Chlorides as Clˉ mg/lit 2.90 10.00 89.85 17.80 13.52 19.30 25.84 32.19 250.00
23. Sulphates as SO4 mg/lit 13.00 20.00 77.50 32.00 23.18 34.60 22.16 25.69 200.00
24. Iron as Fe mg/lit 0.21 0.23 0.99 0.27 0.25 0.27 0.39 0.48 0.30
25. Copper as Cu mg/lit 0.002 NIL 0.004 NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL 0.05
26. Zinc as Zn mg/lit NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL 5.00
103
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Location
Pale Kh. Udhavane Mahadevwa Conflue Roth Bk. Zolambe Dhatav Killa
Sr. Limits IS
Parameter Unit (SW1) (SW2) di (SW3) nce (SW5) (SW6) (SW7) (SW8)
No 10500:2012
Upstream Midstream (SW4) Down Down
stream stream
27. Arsenic as As mg/lit NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL 0.01
28. Cadmium as Cd mg/lit NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL 0.003
29. Chromium as Cr mg/lit 0.01 0.02 1.60 0.09 0.06 0.11 0.13 0.19 Not Specified
30. Lead as Pb mg/lit NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL 0.01
31. Mercury as Hg mg/lit NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL 0.001
32. Fluoride as Fˉ mg/lit NIL NIL 1.4 NIL NIL NIL NIL 0.8 1.00
33. Boron as B mg/lit NIL NIL 0.20 NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL 0.50
34. Total Coli form No./ 50 75 125 83 79 92 58 84 No. /100 ml
100ml
Note - Analysis results for the Surface water are given at Annexure - V.
Ground water and surface water sources covered within 10 km radial distance from Site were examined for Physico-chemical and bacteriological
parameters in order to assess the effect of industrial and other activities on ground water. The analysis was done as per the procedure laid down in
the standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater (APHA). The salient observations are as indicated below as -
Ground Water
The ranges described here cover all the sampling locations in the study area. The pH values are observed to be in the range of 7.03 to 7.63, which
are well within the limits conforming to the drinking water standards (IS: 10500). Total Dissolved Solids in the ground waters, in the study area as
a whole, are not within the permissible limit of 500 mg/l. This is equally and reflects higher hardness level, in the range of 306.79 - 363.88 mg/l.
Higher levels of Ca, Mg, and Total Hardness were observed almost above the permissible limits. Also the total coliforms and Fecal Coliforms
observed.
104
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Surface Water
The range described underneath encompasses all the sampling locations. The pH values range
from 7.41 to 8.15. They represent neutral to alkaline conditions. Total dissolved solids were
observed to be in the range of 102.18 -393.80 mg/l. The TDS values are within the
permissible limit of 500 mg/l. The COD ranges from 13 to 37.90 mg/l. The Inorganic
constituent like Nitrites, Sodium, Potassium are observed to be within the permissible limits.
It is observed that all the parameters are within the prescribed limits. Except the value of
TDS, Ammonical Nitrogen, Ca, Mg, Fe, B and total Hardness at Mahadevwadi village
exceeds the limit. This indicates that there is no pollution of the surface water bodies other
than Mahadevwadi. The surface water quantity can be stated as good for remaining villages.
3.10.1 Introduction
Under the proposed project, so there would not be much construction activity on the site,
Although, level of construction activities shall not be very high, still some specific sources of
noise like welding, transportation, movement of earth movers, tractors, concrete or asphalt
mixing etc. should be carried out in a controlled manner. Neither the plant nor the
construction workers should be exposed to excessive noise levels.
The physical description of sound concerns its loudness as a function of frequency. Noise in
general is that sound which is composed of many frequency components of various loudness
distributed over the audible frequency range. Various noise scales have been introduced to
describe, in a single number, the response of an average human to a complex sound made up
of various frequencies at different loudness levels. The most common and universally
accepted scale is the ‘A’ weighted scale which is measured as dB (A). This is more suitable
for audible range of 20 to 20000 Hz. The scale has been designed to weigh various
components of noise according to the response of a human ear.
The Environmental Impact of noise can have several effects varying from Noise Induced
Hearing Loss to Annoyance depending on loudness of noise levels. The environmental
impact assessment of noise from the industrial activity, vehicular traffic can be undertaken by
taking into consideration various factors like potential damage to hearing, physiological
responses, annoyance and general community responses.
The study area of 10 km radius with reference to the proposed expansion plant site has been
covered for noise environment. The four zones viz. Residential, Commercial, Industrial and
Silent Zones have been considered for noise monitoring. Some of the major arterial roads
105
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
were covered to assess the noise due to traffic. Noise monitoring was undertaken for 24 hours
at each location.
The main objective of noise pollution impact assessment in the study area is to assess the
impact of total noise generated by industries and vehicular traffic on the human settlements
within 10 km radius. The main objectives of the studies conducted are -
The assignment w.r.t. Noise level survey was done by Mr. Vinaykumar Kurakula who is
an empanelled Functional Area Expert (FAE) of EEIPL for Noise and Vibration (NV).
A preliminary reconnaissance survey was undertaken to identify the major noise generating
sources in the area. Noise generating sources have been identified with respect to the
activities viz. industrial noise and ambient noise due to industries and traffic, which have
impact on sensitive areas. The noise sampling locations have been indicated below as -
The noise survey involved determination of noise levels, in decibels, at following eight
locations in the study area. Noise levels were recorded at every clock hour for a continuous
24-hour period.
Station Name of the Location Distance w.r.t. Plant Direction w.r.t. Plant
Code Point Site (in km) Site
N1 Industrial Site -- --
N2 Warse 2.27 SW
N3 Mahadevwadi 1.16 SW
N4 Dhatav 1.48 ES
N5 Bahe 2.06 NE
N6 Udadhavane 2.40 NW
N7 Roha Town 3.93 NW
N8 Killa 2.31 SE
A noise rating developed by EPA for specification of community noise from all the sources is
the day-night sound level, (Ldn). It is similar to a 24-hour equivalent sound level except that
during the night-time period, which extends from 10 PM to 6 AM, a 10 dB (A) weighing
penalty is added to the instantaneous sound level before computing 24 hour average. This
night time penalty is added to account for the fact that noise during night, when people
usually sleep, is judged more annoying than the same noise during the daytime.
106
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
For noise levels measured over a given period of time interval, it is possible to describe
important features of noise using statistical quantities. This is calculated using the percent of
the certain noise levels exceeding during the time interval. The notation for the statistical
quantities of noise levels is described below -
The Leq is the equivalent continuous sound level that is equivalent to the same sound energy
as the actual fluctuating sound measured in the same period. This is necessary because sound
from noise source often fluctuates widely during a given period of time.
(L10 - L90)2
Leq= L50 + --------------
60
Ldn - The noise rating developed for community noise from all sources is all Day-Nights
Sound Level (Ldn). It is similar to a 24 hr equivalent sound level except during night time
period (10 PM to 6 AM) a 10 dB (A) weighing penalty is added to the instantaneous sound
level before computing the 24 hr average. The Ldn for a given location in a community may
be calculated from the hourly Leq’s, by the equation -
Where Ld is the equivalent sound level during the daytime (6 AM to 10 PM) and Ln is the
equivalent sound level during the nighttime (10 PM to 6 AM).
A detailed noise level survey was undertaken to study the levels of noise, as the high noise
levels may cause adverse effect on human beings and the associated environment. The noise
level monitoring was carried out through M/s. Horizon Services, Pune which is NABL
accredited and MoEFCC; New Delhi approved organization.
MoEFCC has notified ambient air quality standards in respect of noise vide Gazette
notification Dated 14th February, 2000. It is based on the ‘A’ weighted equivalent noise level
(Leq). The standards are given in following table -
107
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Ref: Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) Rules, 14th Feb 2000.
Industrialized countries have specified limits for occupational noise exposure. The
permissible noise exposure limit for industrial workers is primarily concerned with the
harmful aspect of noise and its objective is to protect the hearing of majority of working
people. The American Conference Government of Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH), USA
has prescribed the following permissible noise exposure limits for industrial workers. These
limits are given in Table 3.21 as -
Exposure to continuous or intermittent noise louder than 115 dB (A) should not be permitted.
Exposure to pulse or impact noise should not exceed 140 dB (A).
OSHA Standards -
The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) has also prescribed the
following allowable limits to noise exposure for industrial workers. These are given in the
following Table 3.22 as -
108
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
The ambient noise levels measured are presented in Table 3.23. The table indicates
equivalent noise levels viz. L10, L50, L90, Lday, Lnight and Ldn at different places located within
the study area. Similarly, these values viz. Leq, Lday, Lnight and Ldn are compared with the
limits.
3.11.1 Introduction
Socio-economic (SE) status of any population is an indicator for development of the region.
Any developmental project will have bearing on the living conditions and on the economic
base of population in particular and the region as a whole. Similarly, the proposed expansion
industry will have its share of socio-economic influence in the study area. The section
delineates the overall appraisal of socially relevant attributes.
The data collection, for evaluation of impact of the proposed expansion project on socio-
economic aspects in the study area, has been done through primary household survey and
through the analysis of secondary data available on study area. Survey of selected eighteen
villages within the 10 Km radius of the study area was carried out with the help of an
interview schedule. The villages within a close proximity of the project were given more
weightage as hypothetically these villages are more affected positively or negatively. The
objective of this survey was to understand the current socio-economic status of selected
villages and the perception of the local people about the existing industries located in Roha
MIDC as well as to know their awareness regarding the proposed project by AFCMPL. The
following data was collected in the month of January, 2018 by Dr. A. J. Samant in-house
FAE and Technical Director of EEIPL for SE and Mr. Neeraj D. Powar in -house FAE.
109
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
3.11.2 Methodology
The survey of 18 villages, selected out of 92 villages within the 10 Km radius of TDMCCL,
was carried out with the help of a structured close ended interview schedule, comprising of
36 questions in Marathi. The schedule was administered in month of December, 2017. Simple
random disproportionate sampling technique was used. A total of 180 locals were covered
during the study (Refer Table 3.24).
The villages in the study area are small and most of them are well connected by all weather
roads. The male: female ratio among the respondents was 59:41 respectively. The difference
in the ratio is visible as female members are usually less responsive. Even thought their
availability is more, however educated women employed as teacher (high school), Gram
Panchayat members and PHC-employee are deliberately in target respondent due to their
exposure and education.
110
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Within the sample size, (30%) between 31 to 40 years, (21%) between 21 to 30 years,
(19%) were between the age-group 41 to 50 years, (16%) between 51 to 60 years and
remaining (14%) above 60 years. (Fig.3.17).
A majority of the respondents within the sample size were literate as only (11%) were
illiterate. The literates had up to primary (35%), secondary (32%), higher secondary
(15%), graduate (6%) and post graduate (1%) level education.
Within the surveyed area the respondents were reported to be involved in diverse
livelihood activities such as agriculture, service, agriculture labour and business. Majority
(67%) of the respondents had agriculture as their main occupation. Around (31%) were
involved in diverse services mostly in industries located in Roha MIDC; only few (10%)
carried out business related activities.
Many (62%) of the respondents from the study area had an annual income between Rs.
75,000 to 1,50,000 (25%) of the respondents had their annual income above Rs.1,50,000.
whereas remaining (13%) of the respondents had their annual income below Rs.75,000.
However people are not accurate while revealing their actual income this was observed
from their life style.
Major crops grown in the area, according to respondents are rice (75%), val (42%), vari
(10%), millets (3%) and vegetables (2%). Major fruit orchards in the area, according to
respondents are mango, coconut, cashew nut and supari.
In most villages (76%) the population depended for drinking water in the form of river. On
the other hand (24%) relied on groundwater and other sources as well in the form of wells
and bore wells. According to a majority (85%) of the respondents there is no shortage of
water in the area as it is available sufficiently throughout year.
Though a majority (97%) of the respondents revealed that there was no change in water
quality in their area, remaining (3%) perceived change in water quality which was
attributed to the industrial waste water. This response was stronger by locals from villages
Roth Khurd, Roth Budruk. This is due to close proximity of these villages to MIDC and
nalla passing through these villages into which effluent is discharged by industries. This
was also observed during visit to these villages. Among these, (70%) of the respondents
perceived negative effect on health of locals due to drinking of polluted water e.g.
digestion problems.
When enquired about the negative environmental effects of existing industries in MIDC,
there were mixed opinions from the respondents, (72%) of them said they are experiencing
any negative effect namely air and odour pollution (55%), on health (20%), effect on local
animals (7%), other negative impacts (3%) and loss of cultivable land (17%). Complaints
111
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
about odour and air pollution problem were more by respondents from villages Roth
Khurd, Roth Budruk and Killa. Impacts due to this were breathing problem, eye and throat
irritation. In these village locals have stopped rearing domestic animals due to their health
problems as a result of polluted water. Regarding fish the same was revealed that there is
fish population loss throughout the flow of the river.
(61%) of the respondents expressed that the industries from Roha MIDC provided job
opportunities in the form of unskilled work, daily wage and transport jobs. It was observed
that in most villages, more than 25 persons from each village, in the study area, were
working in one or other industry of MIDC. Most respondents had changed their profession
from traditional farming to working in industries of MIDC. About (63%) of the
respondents said that this employment is not seasonal and lasts for whole year and
therefore is sustainable. According to respondents, (25%) to (50%) of the work force in
Roha MIDC is from outside states like Uttar Pradesh, Bihar due to the low wages accepted
by them.
A large majority of the respondents (82%) were unaware of the proposed project by
TDMCCL. When asked about their opinion on this, mixed opinions were expressed. (43%)
were hopeful about increase in employment (40%) felt that this will further increase the
pollution while (12%) perceived that there would be no change in existing conditions.
When asked about contribution by Industries of Roha MIDC, respondents said that only
Medical van is being provided by some of the industries, many more facilities need to be
provided e.g. development of open spaces for playgrounds, waste water management
system, drinking water facility.
(66%) respondents stated that library / reading room is existed in their village. (47%) of
respondents mentioned that there was a cultural centre for the use of villagers in the
village. (65%) stated that there was madanpam in front of their temples which was utilised
for multiple purposes. PHC centres in working conditions existed in the village according
to (59%) respondent and availability of doctors in the village was mentioned by (84%).
Only (6%) respondents did not have toilets but there were to be built in due course due to
government compulsion as compare to this according to the respondent (1%) mention that
all schools did not have toilets. According to (93%) of the respondents there were self help
group in their respective areas for socio-economic upliftment of the locals. However no
specific business was carried out by these self help groups except gathering money and
releasing loans.
There were diverse expectations of the respondents from TDMCCL. About (81%) stressed
on need for better health facility, (13%) demanded domestic waste water management and
(3%) asked for solid waste treatment facilities.
It was observed that most of the villages are well connected by roads having basic facilities
like drinking water (provided by MIDC), educational facilities, toilets and electricity.
Moreover, it was interesting to note that village Dhatav had received an award for Swatch
Bharat Mission. Villages namely Roth Budruk and Roth Khurd which are close to MIDC
were found to be negatively affected by air pollution, odour problem and water pollution. In
some villages like Pui and Khamb, rabbi crops like rice were being cultivated due to easy
availability of water through canal. Direct and indirect job opportunities in MIDC and both
kharif and rabbi crops have uplifted the economic condition of the locals. However, it was
interesting to observe that, locals residing in wadis above villages Pugao, Palle khurd, Killa
and Washi were known to be Adivasis. Most of these were illiterate, economically backward
and dependent on gathering wood for their livelihood. They had no water facility in their
village and this was their demand.
112
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
3.11.5 Conclusion
Most respondents from all villages are dependent on agriculture and working in MIDC for
their livelihood. Major crops grown in the area is rice and wal. A majority of the population
within the sample size had a quantum able income which is mostly due to job opportunities in
MIDC. Cumulative impact due to various industries in MIDC is adversely affecting the
environment in the region. Due to the chemical industries every household had at least one
chemical graduate in their house however they were not satisfied by the payment and are now
migrating to Mumbai, thus the population of workers from other states was increasing.
3.11.6 Suggestions
3.12 ECOLOGY
The in-house Functional Area Experts of EEIPL for EB Prof. (Dr.) Jay Samant, Dr. Rohan
Lad and EB research scholar Mr. Anup Gargate were involved in the present overall
exercise w.r.t. ecology and biodiversity aspects of the study area around TDMCCL project.
The study area in 10 km radius from the project site (314.2 sq km) forms part of Roha and
Mangaon tehsils of Raigad district. About 90 % of the study area falls in Roha while 10 % in
the south comes under Mangaon Tehsil. The climate of the area is predominantly sub tropical
and moderate throughout the year. The area receives annual average rainfall ranging between
13110 mm to 24417 mm and the soil types are dominated by loamy soil which influences the
ecology and biodiversity of the region. The major part of hill forest is mixed, consisting of
evergreen and semi-evergreen type and on hill slopes with moist deciduous type tree cover.
There are barren patches on hilly plateaus, particularly of the main ridges and spurs of the
Western Ghats.
Out of the total of 93 villages within10 km radius of the project site, a total 38 villages (41%)
fall in the Western Ghats ESA (Appendix - V). Out of which 7 villages are located within
the 5 km radius from the project site and remaining 31 villages in 5 km to 10 km radius.
During this study 25 representative villages out of the total 93 villages were field surveyed
for Ecology and Biodiversity (EB) and village questionnaire. This comprised 13 villages
within 5 km radius (Two from ESA) and 12 villages between 5 and 10 km radius (Six from
ESA). The names of the study villages are given in Table 3.25.
113
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Table 3.25 Study villages, Villages from the Western Ghats ESA and
their distance from project site
3.12.2 Methodology
For familiarization of the study area, a preliminary survey was conducted in the study area on
3rd and 4th November, 2017. During EB study, toposheet (surveyed in 1967-68 and updated
during 2005-06), IRS LISS IV satellite imagery and LULC maps based on them are used.
Similarly relevant data from District Census (2011), Raigad District Gazetteer, district forest
report and relevant literature was referred. At time of field visits ground truthing was done for
local Ecology by confirming the LULC maps for major macro and micro habitats in the study
area. The key terrestrial habitats such as hills, grassland, scrub, agriculture land habitats were
identified in the vicinity of all the study villages. Aquatic habitats studied included water-
bodies near villages Killla, Devkhane, Bahe, Mahadevwadi, Pugaon, MIDC area and Pui
Dam and stretch of Kundlika River i.e. up stream, mid stream and downstream of Roha
MIDC. The survey was conducted from early morning till evening on the five days in winter
month i.e. 16 to 20 January 2018. The green belt survey of TDMCCL industrial plot was
carried out on 31 May 2018.
Biodiversity field study involved random method for vegetation and opportunistic sighting
for fauna (Larsen and Viana, 2016). Flora was recorded for identification and species
dominance at level of major tree species. Field binoculars of makes Nikon (12 X 50 - 5.20),
Olympus (7 X 35 - 70) and Minolta (5 X 50 - 70) were used during the observations. The
Book of Indian Birds by Salim Ali (1996) and Birds of Southern India by Grimmet et al.
(2005) for bird and The Book of Indian Reptiles and Amphibians by Daniel (2002) for
herpatofauna and Freshwater Fishes of Peninsular India by Ranjit Daniels (2002) for fish
were referred as field guides. Photo documentation was done during habitat and biodiversity
survey using Canon Power-shot (S X 30 IS HD 35X,14 Megapixels) camera to note present
environmental status of the habitats. Bird survey was conducted following standard point
count method (Altmann, 1974). Extensive Photo documentation was done throughout the
study to record the direct and indirect environmental impacts of industrial activities in Roha
114
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
region on ecology and biodiversity in the area. The data thus collected was used to estimate
diversity and status of threatened bird species.
3.12.3 Ecology
Most of the region is hilly, rugged and in places with slope of the Western Ghats spurs, and
number of hillocks all over the study area forming catchments of numerous streams which
ultimately meet river Kundalika in the basin at the centre of the study area. The undulating
hill slopes and flatter hilltops are cultivated revenue or owned lands habitats admixed with
reserved forests. These areas are scattered with open scrubs and grasslands habitats. The
study area is a mosaic of habitats comprised of hills with forests and scrub, slopes and
lowlands with homesteads and cultivation. Manmade water bodies and swamps in the vicinity
of study villages namely Killla, Devkhane, Bahe, Mahadevwadi, Pugaon, Vaijnath,
Udadavane and Roha MIDC area and medium dam at village Pui and River Kundlika with its
tributaries provide habitat for aquatic biodiversity. The agriculture fields, horticulture farms
and grasslands are spread on either sides of river Kundlika and around MIDC area, and the
forest and scrub areas around villages Pale khurd, Killa, Vaijnath, Mandavshet, Usar,
Landhar, Vandoli and Pingalsai are habitats suitable for terrestrial biodiversity. The study
area is a good mosaic of intermixed rich and diverse macro and micro habitats comprising of
Western Ghats spurs, coastal plains, undulating terrain, manmade wetlands, river basin,
estuarine habitats and mangroves, those support good ecology and biodiversity.
However, during field visits many small water logged areas, totally polluted and highly
eutrophicated are also observed in and around project site and MIDC area. At some wetlands
i.e. near Roha Dychem and Excel industries, effluents and solid wastes are released making
them polluted. Also the chemical industries closely located on the banks of Kundalika River
and her major tributary streams such as Lander nalla are also a potential threat to the ecology
of the wetlands and their biota.
The respondents from the 19 villages reported presence of numerous seasonal waterfalls in
the area. According to few respondents good mangroves habitats were also present earlier in
the littoral part of Kundalika River. Most of these disappeared due to the continuous
discharge of fresh water after Pui dam construction, as the tidal influence of brackish water
was permanently affected. According to the respondents the past habitat status in general in
the area is now qualitatively and quantitatively changed according to their location and
landuse. The multiple weightage given by the respondents revealed that the major habitats in
the area are as forest (84%), scrub (79%), agriculture land (76%), fallow land (63%) and
grassland (54%). The present status of theses habitats as per them suggested decrease in the
forest, grassland and scrub area with increase in agricultural, habitations and industrial area.
115
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
Not much change is reported in fallow lands, plateaus, stony cliffs and waterfall habitats. The
major habitats such as forest, scrub and agriculture tallies with the LULC studies.
In case of some aquatic habitats there are changes in both quality and quantity of the water as
reported by the respondents. Some respondents (37%) reported problems of wetland pollution
and decrease in number of water holes, while deforestation was reported by (25%) and
grassland destruction by (12%). The reasons for this habitat change are attributed in
descending order to Industrialization (54%), forest fire (45%), rapid urbanization (40%), tree
cutting and industrial pollution (27%) each. It is followed by sewage pollution (21%),
agriculture expansion and increase in weeds (14%), grass burning (11%) and stone quarrying
(6%). The present cumulative landuse, as per the respondents is agriculture (78%), industrial
(43%), residential (42%) and infrastructure (20%) and Protected Areas (7%) these
observations are restricted to their village environs.
3.12.4 Biodiversity
In all a total of 589 birds belonging to 15 orders, 30 families and 54 species were recorded
during the brief field survey, out of which 32 species were common resident, 16 species were
not common resident, 3 species were not common winter visitor and 3 species were common
winter visitor. Considering less number of study sites, limited time and few opportunistic
observations, this avian diversity is a good indicator of biodiversity, mainly due to the mosaic
of natural and manmade habitats in the region. Moreover, according to IUCN, 2017 status,
black headed Ibis (Threskiornis melanocephalus) becomes Near Threatened bird species,
which was reported in exceptionally large number at Pugaon village. As per feeding guild
some bird species (14) recorded are dependent on multiple food sources while others depend
on single source. The total 54 bird species recorded comprised of piscivorous (10),
insectivorous (19), carnivorous (15), omnivorous (12), granivorous (5), nectarivorous (7) and
frugivorous (9). This clearly indicates the wide spectrum of food availability in the mosaic of
diverse micro habitats in the study area. Attempt has been made to evaluate the species
diversity index (SDI). The indices calculated revealed Shannon Wiener diversity index (H)
4.71, Evenness (j) 1.18, Simpson Index (D) 0.90 and Species Richness (d) 19.13. Bird species
list is enclosed (Appendix - V). Some butterfly species were also observed with their
associated host plants during field study. (Appendix - V).
are planted mainly for beautification purpose, without any consideration for environmental
trees needs in industrialized area. In agriculture crops grown are ‘Bhat’ - Paddy (Oryza
sativa), ‘Nachani’ - finger millet (Eleusine coracana), ‘Vari’ - jungle rice (Echinochloa
colona), ‘Wal’ - Indian bean (Lablab purpureus), ‘Bajari’ – Perl millet (Pennisetum glaucum)
and local varieties of vegetables. The tree species grown in horticulture are dominated by
Mango (Mangifera indica), Jackfruit (Garcinia indica), Sapodilla (Manilkara zapota),
Cashew (Anacardium occidentale) and Coconut (Cocos nucifera).
According to the respondents wildlife in the area in past included tiger, panther, sloth bear,
hyena, fox, Indian wolf, Indian porcupine, spotted deer, mouse deer, barking deer, Indian
guar, wild boar, giant squirrel, bonnet macaque, common Langur, black naped hare, giant
fruit bat and three-striped palm squirrel. Out of these tiger is now almost missing in the
region. Tiger being ‘rare’ is listed as ‘endangered’, whereas panther, Indian guar and sloth
bear as ‘vulnerable’ and hyena is listed as ‘near threatened’ by IUCN (2015). Habitat loss is
reported as a major cause for dwindling biodiversity in the study area. This is mainly due to
deforestation, traditional agriculture practices like ‘slash and burn” and ‘rab’, manmade forest
fires, agriculture expansion, poaching and, now rapid increase in the impacts of
industrialization, urbanization and associated infrastructure development. It is further
aggravated by diverse types of industrial pollutions from the Roha MIDC and around.
It is learnt that the Indian fox population has drastically gone down as their main food Crabs
is eradicated from fields by local farmers using toxin ‘Foret’. The senior locals observed that
lately the endangered white rump vultures (Gyps bengalensis) have completely disappeared
from this area due to polluted Caracas. It was realised that the knowledge of birds and reptile
species, mainly with the local young and youth, is scanty and restricted to limited common
faunal and floral species only.
In fish diversity, respondents mentioned around 22 local freshwater fish species. It was also
reported that the earlier brackish water fish are no longer found Kundalika river, mainly due
to perennial discharge from Pui dam and river pollution due to industries in the basin. Out of
the introduced fish species Tilapia, Cyprinus, Catla and Rohu are common. It is important to
note that according to IUCN, status (2015), from the local fish one species i.e. Cyprinus
(Cyprinus carpio) is Vulnerable, Aheer (Anguilla Anguilla) is Critically Endangered and two
other species namely Vam (Anguilla bengalensis) and Valshivda (Wallago attu) have become
Near Threatened.
117
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
The study area i.e. 5 km around the proposed project site in Roha MIDC is already occupied
by some large chemical industries mainly dealing with agro chemicals and thus all the macro
and micro habitats in the region are already affected by air, water and soil pollution.
Therefore it is believed that the additional impact of TDMCCL expansion is not likely to
substantially contribute in the existing cumulative pollution load on the ecology and
Biodiversity of the region. However environs of some villages in the radius between 5 km
and 10 km still have good terrestrial and wetland habitats which are relatively less affected in
Borghar, Devkhane and Vashi villages and therefore they need to be protected and conserved
for ecology and biodiversity within.
The environmental impacts were considered for worst case scenario i.e. direct discharge of
untreated wastewater. The factory site is less than 1 km from River Kundlika, and its
tributary, a large perennial stream Landher, that flows directly close and along the entire
south and west border of the TDMCCL industrial plot. Currently more than 20 fish species
are found in river Kundlika, out of which according to IUCN two are Near Threatened, one is
Vulnerable and one is Critically Endangered. Discharge of untreated wastewater, effluents
and surface runoff from the industry in the River, streams and surrounding swamps may
cause negative impact on the aquatic habitat and its littoral biodiversity including fishes.
3.12.5 Recommendations
As per the ToR of TDMCCL (dt. 3-5-2018), 33% of the total plot area of the industry is to be
maintained as Green belt with ‘trees’ planted @ 1500/Ha. According to the norms (CPCB,
2000) the green belt of diverse tree species is required to be all along the periphery of the
total industrial land for environmental protection purpose.
It is observed that the total land acquired by the industry is 8.84 Ha, thus the 33% of land for
green belt comes to about 2.91 Ha with, around 4425 trees to be planted as per the norms.
According to the proponent area of 2.95 Ha is already developed under green belt, which
comes to 33.39 % of the total industrial plot area, with a plantation of about 5000 plants.
However, during site visit it was observed that part of the said existing plantation is of
ornamental plants i.e. shrubs, bushes, lawns, palms and some trees for beautification purpose,
rather than large growing tree species in adequate number for environment protection as
required (CPCB, 2000). Presently parts of the plot periphery are not fully covered by desired
green belt trees, particularly at north-west and south side. Whereas, there is enough scope to
plant new trees in vacant spaces within and all along the periphery of the total plot.
It is noted that green open space on the south and west border of the plot is in fact unmanaged
area covered by wild bushes, shrubs, weed and creepers. The vast area shown for proposed
car parking has few old tall trees which need to be conserved as a part of green belt. Number
of dead, fallen, and uprooted trees and degraded vegetation is observed on the site. The post
monsoon Google earth satellite image (28 October 2017) shows natural growth of weeds all
along the Landhar stream at south boundary which creates illusion of green belt. However the
summer season image (4 January 2017) reflects realistic picture. Considering the existing
118
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
ornamental and sundry vegetation in the green belt, it is suggested to update the required
number of woody trees by planting large saplings of suitable local trees species, all along the
periphery of the industrial plot.
Also as per the ToR (Ref. 5(f):A 7 ix) it is necessary for the proponent to provide details of
species, width of plantation, planning schedule etc. of the green belt plantation, old and
proposed. It must be ensured that this green belt shall be all around the total plot boundary
and a scheme for greening of the roads used for the project shall also be incorporated. This
information is yet to be furnished by the proponent.
It is recommended that for better survival results the new saplings of the tree species should
be over three year old and around 5 feet in height. Provision of drip irrigation by using good
quality recycled water from the industry needs to be made. The adequate number of trees
should be ready and performing their ecological function by the time the proposed industrial
expansion is functional. Preferably no fruit trees to be planted in industrial Green belt as per
the norms to avoid possible harmful chemical contamination of fruits by bioaccumulation and
biomagnifications of toxins. Instead plantation of sturdy indigenous and evergreen mixed
species of trees to be used for environment protection as well as natural beautification.
The three villages in the study area namely 1. Borghar, 2. Vashi and 3. Devkhane are
recommended for adoption by the industry for protection of their ecology and biodiversity,
which is almost in near natural state. Conservation activities such as tree plantation, removal
of weeds and exotics, solid waste and sewage management, environment awareness
campaign involving locals particularly youth and women should be undertaken. Besides
controlling negative impacts of industrial pollution on the village population this would help
improve health of the residents, most of who may be employed in the same industry and
MIDC. This initiative will motivate the locals to protect their own ecology and biodiversity in
and around the villages.
Under CER activity, review of the initiatives implemented by the same and other larger
neighboring industries in the MIDC and their results be considered before finalizing new
CER activities by TDMCCL. These proposed activities needs to be different than routinely
carried out and merely ritual practice by most industries. Thus CER activities by TDMCCL
in environmental protection should be innovative and unique and should to be a role model
for other industries.
1. Natural forests and grassland habitats in the region are being fragmented and degraded
due to deforestation, industrialization and agriculture expansion.
2. The number of water bodies i.e. river, streams, tanks, ponds, marshes in the study area
provide suitable habitat to good biodiversity. Diverse fauna, including migratory birds
gets affected due to polluted water bodies as a result of contamination of both solid and
liquid industrial waste as per the perception of locals and our observations. There is
decline in fish diversity and density in river Kundalika due to industrial effluents.
3. The green belt being critical for industrial pollution control and also mandatory, should be
properly developed and maintained on priority, particularly for health of the workers and
people around the industrial unit.
119
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT…3
4. A phase wise 3 year tree plantation program for around 5000 trees should be carried out
under CER activity. Within 5 Km radius area in selected and active villages. This should
be implemented as (a) thick block plantation of large native tree species for
environmental protection through Carbon sequestration as well as environmental
protection and nature conservation on common lands in villages and (b) Avenue
plantation on village roads, around schools, temples, village ponds, open spaces, grounds,
etc. where protection through people’s participation is ensured.
5. The industry, by involving workers and locals, should demonstrate, encourage, and
promote suitable eco-friendly alternatives green technologies under CER activity in the
identified cooperative villages in the area stressing and demonstrating, rain water
harvesting, solar lighting, organic farming, and such innovative simple to use ‘green
technologies’.
6. It must be ensured that no untreated effluent and seepage from the open sulfur storage is
discharged by TDMCCL industry into Kundalika river directly or through adjoining
Ladhar nala.
120
Chapter 4
4.1 INTRODUCTION
Proposed expansion project may influence the environment of the study area in two phases as
under:
Construction Phase: During the construction period, the impact may be temporary.
Operation Phase: Post construction phase may have long term effects on the
environment.
The activities under proposed expansion shall be carried out in the existing setup of
TDMCCL. No construction of building would be required for expansion. Only work related
to installation of equipments and machineries as required under activities would be done on
site. Hence, no any significant impact on topography is envisaged due to proposed expansion
activities.
Operational phase activities may have impacts - minor or major, positive or negative on
environmental attributes such as land and soils, surface and ground water hydrology, micro
meteorology, land use, water use, water and air quality, ecology, socio economics and noise
environment.
There are number of aspects and reasons in commodity chemicals and speciality chemicals
manufacturing plant, which result into exerting impacts on various environmental disciplines.
Problems related with pollution and related impacts could arise due to – (1) manufacturing
process itself (2) products (3) by products & co-products (4) intermediate products (4)
catalysts used (5) process conditions & configurations (6) raw materials, and (7) the waste
streams.
121
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Table 4.1 Identification of impacts on environment due to operation activities for proposed expansion project of TDMCCL
Sr. Environ-mental Activities / Operation Impact Identification Type of Impact Remark
No. Aspect (Minor / Major)
1. Air Raw material Due to Release of VOCs chemicals during Major The impacts due to boiler operations may have significant
Transportation, loading loading & unloading of raw material, it may (Quantifiable) impacts on the air environment.
and unloading and raw cause impact on air environment. At a glance details of identification and quantification of the
material storage area impact during operation phase at TDMCCL site may be
Production Activity 1)Release of process emission in the form of referred at Chapter 4
Ammonia, HCl 2) VOCs of solvent
Boiler Operation The boiler operations may increase the
(Fuel Burning baseline concentrations of SO2. This may have
Operations –Existing impact on air quality.
boiler of capacity : 5
TPH, TFH – 4 Lakhs
Kcal/Hr, and125, 830,
1310 KVA D.G. Set
2. Water Reactor Section Process water spills may impact on water Major The impacts due to operation activities are significant. The
environment. (Quantifiable) quantification of accidental discharge into nearby water
Effluent Treatment Accidental discharge of untreated effluent in body is given below at Section 4.3.4 of this Chapter.
Plant nearby water body, this may cause impact on
water quality. At a glance details of identification and quantification of the
impact during operation phase at TDMCCL site may be
referred at Chapter 4
3. Noise Production Area Use of Pumps, compressors and reactor blades Minor The impacts due to operation activities are negligible i.e.
are identified sources of Noise pollution and (Quantifiable) insignificant. But, the impact of noise on workers would be
same shall cause increase in noise level significant if the exposure is increased beyond 8 hours
concentrations. without any PPE.
4. Solid & Boiler Operations Ash generation - improper handling, storage Minor The impacts due to operation activities are negligible i.e.
Hazardous and disposal of ash may cause bad aesthetics. (Non- insignificant. The solid and hazardous waste generated
Waste quantifiable) would be properly handled and disposed off as done under
Reactor Distillation residue, Process residue, Spent Minor existing unit
Carbon which would be generated at reactor (Non-
section which may be source of solid and quantifiable) At a glance details of identification and quantification of the
hazardous waste. The improper handling, impact during operation phase at TDMCCL site may be
122
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
123
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Potential problems in above areas and possible approaches to minimize and/ or avoid adverse
impacts through process and product modifications could be enumerated as follows
Table 4.2 Process& Products Modifications for Pollution Control and Impact
Minimization
124
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
125
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
126
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
127
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
128
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
129
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
130
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Major sources of air pollution are Boiler, Thermic Fluid Heater (TFH) and DG sets (3
Nos.)in the industry as well as vehicles used for transportation.
Under existing plant, one boiler of capacity5 TPH, one TFH of 4 Lakhs Kcal/Hr. are
provided with stack height of 35 M and 30 M respectively. Under expansion, no new
boiler would be installed.
Three DG sets of capacity of 125 KVA, 830 KVA, 1310 KVA respectively are provided
on site.
131
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Table 2.25 of Chapter 2 may be referred for details on boiler, TFH and D.G. Sets. The stack
emissions from these shall be particulate matter, SO2, CO, NOX. In addition, the vehicular
exhaust may also contribute to air pollution through release of SO2, CO, NOX.
In order to study the movement of particulate matter release into atmosphere from the source,
Air Dispersion Model – AERMOD developed by the US Environmental Protection Agency
(USEPA) is used. The software helps in knowing details of particulate and gases dispersed in
the downwind direction and finally reaching the ground at farther distance from the source.
The ground level concentrations mainly depend upon the strength of the emission source and
micrometeorology of the study area. No new boiler will be installed under proposed
expansion by TDMCCL. Hence, AERMOD software is not used for understanding increase
in baseline concentrations of ambient air. Site-specific and meteorological collected for one
season for period from Oct. 2017 – Nov. 2017 – Dec. 2017. Refer Figure 4.1 for windrose
Predominant wind directions and wind speeds are tabulated in following table-
The site specific meteorological data and AAQM data werecollected for one season for
period from October 2017 –December 2017.The predominant wind direction and wind speeds
are tabulated in following table.
From the AAQM data, the 24 hourly 98percentile concentrations of PM10, PM2.5, SO2,
NOx, CO,NH3, Pb, O3, BaP, As, Ni, C6H6 and VOC in ambient air, recorded during the
field study conducted for season October, November and December 2017, are considered
as baseline values. For identifying impacts due to operations of existing nearby industries
on the region, the average concentrations of above mentioned parameters in the study
area are considered to be the ‘Baseline Concentrations’ and further determination of
impact, due to proposed activities in the TDMCCL industry on the ambient air quality
will be done.
132
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
B) Fugitive Emissions
The sources of fugitive emissions identified under existing and expansion activities are - (a)
Process Operations (b) Related Miscellaneous Operations (c) Material Storage (d) Equipment
Leaks (e) Fuel Storage Area. Further, there could be fugitive emissions of materials like fine
dust, powder or gases due to escape of unused raw materials, VOCs etc. from various reactors,
storage tanks, pneumatic conveyors etc.
C) Process Emissions
Sources of process emissions under activities of TDMCCL shall be mainly due to mixing and
blending equipment, reactors, filters, separators, product purifiers and packing operations.
The emissions may be in the form of excess and un-reacted gases, VOCs, fume of reactions
etc. which could result during various actions like active product formation process, purging
of vessels before loading and unloading, surface evaporations and filling. More details about
this aspect are given in Chapter 2. The solvents that shall be stored in bulk quantities on
TDMCCL site include Sulphuric Acid, Hydrochloric Acid and Oleum. As such, major
impacts of VOCs due to these materials have been taken into consideration. The VOCs are
found to be responsible in formation of ozone. In presence of nitrogen oxides (NOx) and
sunlight, VOCs react with oxygen in the air to produce ozone, the most toxic component of
the form of pollution commonly known as smog. Ozone attacks lung tissue, and is very
injurious, even in very low concentrations. Following table describes effects of VOCs if
exposed to air.
133
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
134
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
135
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
D) Odour Pollution
There will be different odour prone areas in the TDMCCL industry. They include raw
material & product storage places, process operations, loading /unloading sections etc. which
could give rise to odour nuisance. This nuisance could have very irritating effect on human
beings and animals that get exposed to the smell resulting into coughing, sneezing,
inflammation of upper respiratory track, irritation of eyes, and sensation of nausea. The
unsanitary conditions responsible for odour trouble could give rise to other nuisance like fly
and insect infestation.
Provision of scrubbers is done to control process emissions which are in the form of
acidic/alkaline/solvent vapours.
Regular self-monitoring of the AAQ and work zone air quality is being done by the
industry through approved labs to check and control dust levels/concentrations at certain
places so that same could be kept always below the stipulated norms.
Efficiencies of dust control equipment in the industry shall be monitored regularly (at
least once a month) under performance evaluation.
B) Fugitive Emissions
C) Process Emissions
136
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
C) Odour Pollution
To abate the odour nuisance, TDMCCL has a concrete planning which includes following
steps and actions-
All reactions and storages are being done in nitrogen blanketing. Blanketing helps
reducing the oxygen content in the vapor space of storage tank or process vessel, making
it inert. This eliminates the possibility of fire or explosion, decreases evaporation and
protects tank from structural corrosion damage.
All the feed, loading & unloading pumps for products and raw material are being fitted
with mechanical seals instead of glands to reduce leakages through pumps.
Adoption ofGood Management Practices (GMPs).Arranging awareness and training
camps for workers.
Provision and use of PPEs like masks to everybody work in odour potential prone areas.
Installation of appropriate, adequate and efficient exhaust and ventilation system to
remove and control odour from work zone areas.
Provision of Fume Extraction System with circulation pump, blower & scrubber to
storage areas.
Provision of scrubbers to reactors to control process emissions.
Impact on the climatic conditions, due to the proposed expansion activities under TDMCCL
expansion is not envisaged especially as emissions of flue gases with very high temperatures,
to the atmosphere, are not expected.
Under TDMCCL expansion project, the total water requirement after expansion would be
1592 M3/Day (100% quantity). Out of which, 220 M3/Day (14%) would be recycle water in
process, 1372 M3/Day (86%) would be fresh water taken from MIDC Water supply scheme.
As far as trade industrial effluent is concerned, effluent generated from the existing and
proposed expansion is to the tune of 230.5 CMD. Treatment scheme of effluent is presented
at Chapter -2, same could be referred for more information.
In Table 4.6, quantification of overall pollution load is presented. Moreover, an impact due to
accidental discharge of untreated trade effluents in Kundalika river (surface water) has been
duly identified, quantified and presented in Table No.4.7, 4.8.
137
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
If the above-mentioned effluents are let out in the environment without any treatment, it may
have impact on surface water quality as well as on soil quality. If untreated effluent enters
any surface water body; there could be number of adverse effects. First of all, suspended
particles in it increase turbidity which can reduce amount of light penetration of water
thereby disrupting growth of photosynthetic plants and activities of micro-organisms
especially phytoplanktons and zooplanktons. This could have subsequent adverse effects on
rest of the aquatic community that depend on these components of the food chain. The
suspended particulates when get settled at bottom of the water body, will add undesirable
sediments. Further, due to organic matter in the effluent, dissolved oxygen level in receiving
water body gets depleted immediately as a result of intense oxidation of the organics by
aerobic microbes. Moreover, nitrogen and phosphorus in wastewaters act as nutrients that
help aggravating problems of 'Eutrophication' in the water bodies. Uncontrolled growth of
aquatic weeds, and eruption of algal blooms seriously affect the quality of water and
aesthetics. The channels of streams and waterways may get blocked and algal dominance
could reduce dissolved oxygen levels during night times as a result of respiration; an action
exactly opposite to photosynthesis that releases oxygen by taking CO2 during day time.
Excessive presence of CO2 in the waters may lead to fall in pH as a result of formation of
weak acids and this again could have prominent impact on pH sensitive reactions in the water
body and benthic deposits. Serious fish kill can happen due to depletion of DO levels in
addition to effluent induced toxicity in the receiving waters. Some of the toxins in industrial
wastewaters may have mild effects on the human health whereas the other ones can be fatal.
If such waters are consumed by human beings or animals, diseases and disorders like cancer,
protein urea and kidney damage (excess protein in urine), pulmonary fibrosis, anemia,
reproductive failure or acute poisoning can take place.
Accidental discharge of untreated trade effluent from TDMCCL find its way to nearest nalla
on south direction as per the drainage pattern of premises. Subsequently, from point of
confluence near industry the effluent via nalla discharge shall meet River Kundalika at a
distance of 1.25Km towards North direction.
138
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
a) When untreated effluent mixed into Nallah towards SouthDirection of Project Site
Table 4.7 Quantification of Impact due to discharge of untreated effluent into Nallah
b) When Contaminated Nalla with untreated effluents gets discharged into Kundalika
River
Table 4.8 Quantification of Impact due to Contaminated Nallah with untreated effluents
into Kundalika River
139
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
d) Mitigation Measures –
1. Construction of three KT weirs in the Nallah stretch from Industry to River Kundalikaand
putting baffles in KT weir to control discharge subsequent to ingress of Raw spentwash &
untreated effluent in to the Nallah so as to carry out flow obstruction.
2. Stopping / arresting untreated effluent entry to nallah by diverting flow through leaking
pipe. Lifting the stored volume upstream the KT weir by portable pumps & sending it
back to tank or discharging same on nearby farm land for irrigation.
3. Pumping of contaminated discharge from nallah from first weir to tank & action of
flushing & dilution to subsequent weirs
4. Faster communication to people residing along the nallah & river about ingress of
effluents in the streams followed by an appeal for not consuming the waters for domestic
purposes and animal consumption.
140
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
141
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
B) Ground Water
Water required for existing operations is obtained from the Kundalika River. As ground water
will not be a source of fresh water for the proposed expansion project there will not be any
impact on ground water reserve (quantity in the area).
The ground water quality is dependent on the natural geological formations and can get
affected by industrial discharges under unfavorable geological structural conditions near such
discharges. The subsurface geological features indicate presence of Deccan Trap.
However, quality of ground water could get affected adversely if untreated effluent from the
industry is discharged on land and storage of hazardous waste is done in unlined pits and
yards with adequate and appropriate leachate management. Organics in effluents may impart
BOD & COD to water and increase in ground water TDS concentration could lead to salinity
problems of soils. The hardness increase due to effluent access to ground water is again an
undesirable effect. Introduction of colour to ground water due to contamination of effluents
shall not only be important from aesthetics but same may also have health concern.
Contaminated ground water if utilized by residents of the region for drinking purpose it may
affect the health. High TDS may lead to gastro enteric disorders, problems of urine stone etc.
If utilized for industrial purposes, softening and demineralization may incur huge costs.
Moreover, the pipelines and other metallic infrastructure involved in conveyance can undergo
corrosion, pitting and similar problems due top salt deposition on exposed surfaces.
A) Surface Water
Under expansion, the management has decided to achieve Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD)
by installation of evaporators and the condensate would be recycled in industrial
operations. No any effluent would be discharged outside the premises.
The concepts of advanced mechanization and automation is introduced in an ETP
provided under existing unit so as to optimize power and chemical consumption as well
as to minimize chances of reduced efficiencies due to human errors and non-efficient
operation and maintenance practices.
Domestic effluent would be treated in proposed STP and overflow would be used for
gardening in own premises/ green belt development. Thus, no any untreated / treated
/domestic effluent would be discharged in any nearby water body.
B) Ground Water
No ground water from any bore well / open well to be used for manufacturing processes
and operations in the industry.
Hazardous waste storage yard is made leak proof by providing HDPE liners under
platform of the yard to avoid ground water contamination. Refer Fig. No.2.6 of Chapter 2
for details.
No any hazardous waste would be disposed off in unscientific manner either in the
Industry premises or in the study area after expansion. Industry has already procured
membership of CHWTSDF for disposal of Hazardous waste.
142
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Hazardous waste shall not be stored on site for more than 90 days as per the Hazardous
Wastes (Management Handling & Transboundry Movement) Rules 2008 and amendment
thereat.
No any treated / untreated effluent would be discharged on land in Industrial premises or
study area.
National Geological Monuments or protected / reserved areas of geological interest are not
located within the area of geological influence of the project.
Most of the units in this MIDC are chemical industries which do not require excavations, or
activities leading to ground vibrations etc except at the time of civil construction. Direct
impact on geology of the area is not envisaged; however, accidental leakages of chemicals on
ground surface can enhance the rate of weathering of soil and sub-surface rocks thereby
reducing their bearing capacity. Seismologically the area falls in the Earthquake zone- IV of
India. Considering the seismicity in Maharashtra, this area falls within ‘moderate’ risk zone
indicating a possibility of earthquakes of moderate intensity in the area
During excavations in construction phase of the project, special attention should be given to
geological stability of the foundation of the buildings in the premises and the surroundings.
As the area falls in the moderate risk zone of earthquake, appropriate precautions should be
taken to make the buildings / plant ‘earthquake proof’.
Haphazard and uncontrolled storage of ash on site shall lead to littering and suspension of
the particles in air due to strong wind currents causing problems of air pollution and
aesthetics. Improper utilization / disposal of solid waste would harm soil quality and
fertility of the nearby agricultural fields.
Chemical sludge from waste water treatment, Residues, dust or filter cakes, spent catalyst
is generated as hazardous waste.
The high concentration of metal ions, lead, zinc, chromium and copper in used oil can be
toxic to ecological systems and to human health if they are emitted from the exhaust stack
of uncontrolled burners and furnaces. Some of the additives (zincdialkyl – dithio -
phosphates, molybdenum disulphide, other organo - metallic compounds etc.) used in
lubricants can contaminate the environment severely. Certain compounds in used oils like
PAH can be very dangerous to human and animal health being carcinogenic and
mutagenic. Lubricating oil is transformed by the high temperatures and stress of an
engine's operation. This results in oxidation, nitration, cracking of polymers and
decomposition of organ- metallic compounds. Other contaminants also accumulate in oil
during use - fuel, antifreeze / coolant, water, wear metals, metal oxides and combustion
products.
143
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Trade effluent generated will be treated in ETP. No any effluent is discharged into water
body.
Domestic effluent would be treated in proposed STP and overflow would be used for
gardening in own premises/ green belt development. Thus, no any untreated / treated
/domestic effluent would be discharged in any nearby water body.
Separate area is earmarked for hazardous waste storage. Hazardous waste generated is
stored, bagged and dispatched to CHWTSDF for further disposal. This area is covered
from the top and from the sides and have impervious flooring, so as to prevent
contamination of the surrounding soil environment if any. This same practices shall be
followed under expansion.
4.3.7.2Cumulative impact
Roha has a huge industrial setup. This area is a Chemical Industry Zone as declared by
Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation (MIDC), which was set up in the 1970s, is
located at Dhatav. Roha Industrial Area has many industrial units. Majority of these are
chemical process industries. The late '70s and early '80s saw a major influx of people related
to the chemicals industry which gave a unique cosmopolitan nature to Roha, which was till
then only farming and trading town. Chemical industries are operating in this area since 1970.
As per 8 collected soil samples and their analysis in buffer zone of 10 km, no contamination
was observed indicating no cumulative impact on soils of buffer area.
The criteria on which noise impacts are analyzed depend upon the people who are being
affected. Broadly, there are two types viz. people who are working near the source and the
people who stay near the industry. People working near the source need risk criteria for
hearing damage while the people who stay near the industry need annoyance and
psychological damage as the criteria for noise level impact analysis. It is quite obvious that
the acceptable noise level for the latter case is less than the former case. So, the noise impact
analysis can be of two types namely (1) Noise impact analysis on working environment; and
(2) Noise impact analysis on community.
144
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
For Noise Levels in the industrial unit, the potential noise generating sources are categorized
under three major heads - noise from machinery, noise from sirens / work areas, noise from
transportation. The total noise generated by operations of all equipments in the existing
Industrial Unit would be between 70 to 75 dB(A).Constant exposure to such levels, can result
in damage to ear drums and loss of hearing, high blood pressure, cardio-vascular disease and
stress, heart problems among the workers. It may also disturb psychological condition of the
workers. The actual resultant noise levels outside the factory will be much lesser in the
ambient air after considering attenuation. Therefore, the impact of proposed activities would
be insignificant.
The noise levels in work environment are compared with the standards prescribed by
Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA-USA), which in turn were enforced
by Government of India through model rules framed under Factories’ Act. These standards
were established with the emphasis on reducing hearing loss.
Noise pattern from the source is computed with the help of following formula.
Noise Level at distance r2= (Noise level at distance r1) -20 log (r2/r1).
The noise levels get reduced considerably in the range of 20-30% because of natural
obstructions. The permissible noise levels, for different categories of area, as prescribed by
MoEFCC are given in Table 4.9. The resultant noise levels at the receptor in different
145
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
areas/zones are envisaged to be within permissible limits. If noise levels exceed the limit,
people who stay near the industry get disturbed due to reasons like annoyance and
psychological reasons. The present ambient noise monitored at all villages in the study area is
within reasonable limits. The noise generated from an industry gets attenuated considerably
because of natural barriers like walls, vegetation, houses etc. or gets deflected along the wind
direction.
Table 4.10Standards in Respect of Ambient Noise Levels
Noise monitoring is done regularly in the noise prone areas and within the industry where
workers will get exposed.This same practices will be followed under expansion.
Use of heavy duty muffler systems on high noise generating equipment.
Proper oiling, lubrication and maintenance would be carried out for the machineries and
equipment to reduce the noise generation.
Personal protective devices such as ear muffs, ear plugs, masks will be strictly enforced
for the workers engaged in high noise prone zones.
During each shift of 8 hours duration, maximum permissible limits of 115 dB(A) shall
never be exceeded, in the work zone, even for a short duration.
Thus, it can be stated that noise impact due to the proposed expansion activities could be
significant on Working Environment without control measures, while the noise impact on
community would be negligible.
The vegetation and drainage of any region are related to each other and reflect inter-locking
or inter-connectivity between the same. The healthy vegetation shows well developed
drainage pattern.
In Roha taluka wherein the MIDC has been setup, important hill system is there. Heavy
rainfall situations are there. The first major land use is crop land and forest land, within 10
Km radius buffer. This crop land and forest land is because of Western Ghat influenced area
around study area. Some of the fallow land is seen where there is lack of continuous water
supply.
In study area, Kundalika River is flowing from eastdirection to west and a nallah is flowing
from Southto North direction towards N and meets the Kundalika River. These two servers as
major water source for the cropland in the study area. As it can be seen in the drainage maps,
there are many small drains connecting to the Kundalika River. The land acquired for
146
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
expansion project of TDMCCL is located in Roha MIDC, which is a notified industrial area.
River Kundalika is located 1.25 Km from project site. The existing drainage pattern shall not
be disturbed due to TDMCCL’s proposed expansion project.
Implementation of TDMCCLs project in the notified industrial area (Roha MIDC, Roha)
shall not have any substantial impact on the overall land use pattern of the study area. The
project shall come up on a well-defined and developed plot in the industrial area.
The study area i.e. 5 km around the project site in Roha MIDC, which is already occupied by
large chemical industries mainly dealing with production of agro and industrial chemical and
thus all macro and micro habitats in the region to an extent are already affected by air, water
and soil pollution. Therefore the additional impact of TDMCCL is not likely to substantially
contribute in the existing cumulative pollution load on the ecology and Biodiversity of the
region. However, some areas in the radius between 5 km and 10 km radius, having good
terrestrial and wetland habitats, are relatively less affected (eg.Vaijnath, Landhar) and
therefore need to be protected and conserved for its ecology and biodiversity within.
The possible environmental impacts were considered for worst case scenario (direct
discharge of untreated wastewater into river Kundalika). The factory site is about 1.25 km
from River Kundalika. Currently more than 20 fish species are found in river Kundalika, out
of which 2 are near Threatened, one is vulnerable and one is critically endangered to this
area. Discharge of untreated wastewater (sewage/ effluents) in the river and surrounding
swamps will cause increased adverse impact on the aquatic habitat and its biodiversity
including fishes.
Natural forests and grassland habitats in the region are being fragmented and degraded
due to deforestation, agriculture expansion and industrialization.
The number of water bodies like river, streams and water tanks in the study area provide
suitable habitat to biodiversity. Avifauna including migratory birds particularly gets
affected due to polluted wetlands as a result of contamination of solid and liquid
industrial waste from Roha MIDC; particularly there is decline in fish diversity in river
Kundalika due to industrial effluents.
The green belt being mandatory should be maintained on top priority for pollution
control, particularly for health of the workers and people around the industrial unit.
The industry to adopt latest advanced technology for energy and water conservation and
treatment of wastes.
The pollution control measures as per the EMP should strictly be implemented by the
industry.
147
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Sr. Reason For Health Hazard Work Place Control To Precautionary engineering
No. Anticipated prevent the Controls provided
Hazards Hazard
1 Toxicity, Due Skin Irritation, Production Supplied air mask The condensers would be
to Exposure, Decreased area, while handling provided with Chilled water
Spillage, muscle strength, Solvents Ammonia. & Chilled Brine circulation
Leakage, Headache, Handling Avoidance of to avoid the emissions.
emissions Drowsiness, area employees with Spill control training.
Long Term premedical Hazard communication:
Exposure: conditions for Training willbe conducted,
Kidney, Liver handling Ammonia/ PPE usage, Training &
Damage Respirators Educating the usage of
approved by PPE's
NIOSH. EN or All the operations shall be
equivalent IS carried out in closed
Spill control conditions, with scrubbing
materials like systems for emissions .
sorbent pads and Have following alarm and
booms. interlock system
HAZOP study. Utility failure alarm
Setting up a Agitator failure alarm
Standard Operating High temperature alarm
Procedures (SOP) Alarm for High rate of
for all critical addition of limiting
operations, reactant which is added
reactions and at controlled rate.
separations. Raw material (limiting
reactant) addition rate
should be controlled by
flow control loop. (FT,
FIC, FCV). Controlling
parameter being reactor
temperature.
FCV and/or On-Off valve
should be interlocked with
the reaction mass
temperature and agitator
tripping.
Hot work Permit:
It is absolutely essential to
establish Hot work permit
system for any hot work
to be carried out in the
factory, especially in the
areas which store
flammable solvents of
Class A.
148
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Sr. Reason For Health Hazard Work Place Control To Precautionary engineering
No. Anticipated prevent the Controls provided
Hazards Hazard
2 Exposure to Commodity and Production All the solid Hazard communication
Finished specialty area chemicals training will be conducted,
Products chemicals &finished products PPE usage. Training &
handling shall be Educating the usage of
done without PPE's
Manual All The operations shall be
Intervention, carried out in closed
directly handled in conditions, Oncology
closed conditions Products handling shall be
by vacuum done in isolators with
conveying. powder scrubbing systems
Respirators for finished products with
approved by detoxification liquids.
NIOSH. EN or Have alarm and interlock
equivalent IS. system, Hot work Permit as
Full face mentioned under point 1
protection. above.
Emergency shower
and eye wash
Spill control use of
materials like
sorbent pads and
booms.
HAZOP study.
SOP for all critical
operations,
reactions and
separations.
3 Physical Contact with Production Good Effective Interlocksfor
injuries rotating parts area, housekeeping, Reactors.
-Slip, trip and Mechanical Circuit breakers, Have alarm and interlock
falls workshop, Effective work system, Hot work Permit as
-electric shocks, electrical permit system. Fire mentioned under point 1
Fire Panel hydrant system. above.
Boards HAZOP study.
SOP for all critical
operations,
reactions and
separations.
Further,
All the employees are provided with personal protective equipments like safety helmets,
goggles, face shields, heat resistance shoes, dust asks/respirators, self contained breathing
apparatus, breathing air masks etc.
Mock drills as per ‘On site Emergency Plan’ as approved by Chief Inspector of factories
are conducted for fire hydrant systems, firefighting equipment. All the emergency
systems are placed in good working condition. Same is made available during emergency
conditions by adopting the effective preventive maintenance. Emergency preparedness of
teams as per the onsite emergency plan shall be ensured by conducting the effective
training through mock drills including evacuation plans.
149
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
There are no historical places in the study area and hence no impact is envisaged under
expansion project.
Battelle Environmental Evaluation System (BEES) has been used for evaluation of impacts
arising out of different project activities. The BEES is a simple yet very effective
methodology for conducting environmental impact analysis. It is based on a hierarchical
assessment of environmental quality indicators. The system incorporates classification
consisting of four levels-
Level I: Categories,
Level II: Components,
Level III: Parameters, and
Level IV: Measurements.
Each Category (Level I) is divided into several components, each Component (Level II) into
several parameters, and each Parameter (Level III) into one or more measurements. The
Environmental Evaluation System (EES) identifies a total of four (4) categories, twenty (20)
components and eighty six (86) parameters.
BEES assessment for environmental impacts due to the proposed expansion activities of
TDMCCL is based on commensurate "environmental impact units (EIU)". Two EIU scores
are produced, one 'with' and another 'without' the proposed project activities. The difference
between the two scores is a measure of the environmental impact. The scores are based on
magnitude and importance of specific impacts.
In addition to the EIU scores, the EES labels major adverse environmental impacts with a
"red flag." These flags point to fragile elements of the environment, for which more detailed
studies are warranted.
150
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Table 4.12 shows a complete list of categories, components, and parameters of the Battelle
EES. Column 1 shows the four (4) categories, Column 2 shows the twenty (20) components,
and Column 3 shows the eighty six (86) parameters.
The BEES methodology is based on assigning importance unit to each of the parameters.
Collectively, these "importance units" are referred to as "parameter importance units" or
PIUs. Parameters have been assigned important weights by an interdisciplinary team of
experts based on the ranked-pair wise comparison techniques. A total of 1000 PIUs are
distributed among the 86 parameters based on value judgments. The individual PIUs are
shown in Column 4 of Table 4.13, the summation component PIUs are shown in Column 5,
and the summation category PIUs are shown in Column 6. Effectively, for each parameter i,
its (PIU)i represents a weight wi
Values of Vi = Vi, 0 are obtained for conditions 'without' the project, and Vi = Vi, 1 for
conditions 'with' the project. The condition 'without' the project represents the current
condition, while that 'with' the project represents the predicted future condition. The
environmental impact EIis evaluated as follows:
For EI> 0, the situation 'with' the project will better than 'without' the project, indicating that
the project has positive environmental benefits. Conversely, for EI< 0, the situation 'with' the
project is worse than 'without' the project, indicating that the project has negative
environmental benefits, i.e. certain negative impacts. A large negative value of EI indicates
the existence of substantial negative impacts.
The assigned weights or PIU's represent the relative importance of each parameter within the
overall system. Once established, they should be kept constant; otherwise, the environmental
impact assessment would be difficult to replicate.
The potential problem areas are represented by those parameters for which the Vi value
changes significantly in the adverse direction, as measured by the following relation (in
percent)-
ΔVi (%) = 100 (Vi,0 - Vi,1) / Vi, 0
These parameters are tagged with 'red flags' to indicate potential problems which may
warrant more detailed attention. For parameters in the ecology category, a minor red flag
applies when 5% <ΔVi< 10%; a major red flag when ΔVi> 10%. In all other categories, a
minor red flag applies when ΔVi< 30% whereas a major red flag when ΔVi ≥ 30%. The EES
can be applied for the evaluation of project impacts, to select specific alternatives, or during
the planning process to minimize potential adverse impacts of proposed projects. In the latter
case, a feedback loop is used to continually modify the project through successive iterations.
Projects developed with the help of EES are expected not only to minimize environmental
impacts, but also help improve selected portions of the environment
151
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Environmental quality assessment for the proposed expansion project of TDMCCL has been
undertaken through evaluation of relevant environmental parameters. These parameters
represent various components and categories of environment namely-
1. Biological Environment
2. Environmental Pollution
Water
Air
Soil
Noise
3. Aesthetics
4. Human Interest
Functional relationship (value functions) has been developed for each of the selected
parameter, resulting in parameter measurement with environmental quality.
The exhaustive list of parameters and associated PIUs used for impact assessment of the
activities of TDMCCLare presented in Table -4.13
Though the BEES is considered to be the best available environmental evaluation technique,
conflicting conclusions among decision makers could arise in the interpretation of evaluated
results. The primary factors giving rise to such difference in opinion are at uncertainty and
subjectivity in the allocation of PIUs to different environmental parameters and uncertainty
caused by the aggregation of individual parameter scores to yield the final project score under
different project impact scenarios. It is, therefore, necessary to take into account such
variability and uncertainty while inferring the impact of a development project on the
surrounding environment.
In order to study the influence of variation of PIU allocation on project evaluation, sensitivity
analysis was performed by varying the PIUs for all environmental categories from 0 to 1000
with step size of 50 units. While performing the sensitivity analysis, the aggregate of PIUs
allocated among these categories was kept fixed at 1000 units. This gave rise to numerous
environmentally beneficial, indifferent or adverse decisions.
152
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Total plot area of the industry is 88355 Sq. M. Total Green belt developed and to be
developed is on an area of 2.95 Ha i.e. 33% of Plot area.Augmentation of green belt would be
done in phase wise manner.
a) Natural Vegetation
Natural vegetation in the study area comprises Banyan, Sag, Peepal, Umbar, Tamarind,
Drumstick, Babhul, Neem, Ain, Kinjal, Kumbh, Bhokar, Palas, Katesavar, Behada, Hirda,
Karanj, Pangara, Bahava, Apta, Arjun, Tamhan, Anjani, Jambhul, Amba, Shirish, Ranbiba,
Shisav, Karwand, and Gulmohar. In the acquired area, the industry would do some land
leveling. There would be no any trees to be cut under the expansion project implementation.
Green Belt development, on an area of about 33 % of the total plot, is implemented as per the
guidelines of MoEFCC and CPCB and as per the plan mentioned in chapter 2nd section 2.9.
Apart from this green belt development, open areas around the offices &buildings would be
covered with the grasses, shrubs & plants for landscaping. Outskirts of the area would be
planted with fast growing trees as indicated in the Environmental Management Plan. In
totality, green belt development on the acquired area would imply positive benefits in terms
of the extensive plantation and proper planning of same as indicated in a separate chapter on
the green belt development plan.
b) Crops
In the study area, under 10 Km radius crops like paddy, Finger millet, jungle rice, beans,
Pearl millet and vegetables common crops. Also, mango, jackfruit, sapodilla, cashew,
coconut and garcinia etc were observed in study area. The project would not have any
significant negative impact on crops. As the treated effluent would be recycled for process
operations and boiler and thermic fluid heater are provided with adequate stacks.
c) Species Diversity
No negative impacts are envisaged due to the proposed project activities on local species
diversity. Infact, plantation of variety of species, as induced in the Environmental
Management Plan, would improve ecosystem of the area. This will improve the local
ecosystem marginally.
No adverse effect on food & web cycle is expected. However, due to green belt plan in the
acquired area, improvement in the food web index is expected.
However, no negative impacts are envisaged due to the expansion project since there will not
be any adverse effects like loss of habitat, fragmentation of habitat or contamination of
habitat. However, plantation of variety of the species, as induced in the Environmental
Management Plan, would improve the ecosystem of the area marginally.
153
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
i) Plant Species
Plant species noted in the study area are normal species found in semi-arid zone. No negative
impact on these species is expected.
No critically endangered wild animal species are found in the study area. Animals observed
in study area are Indian Wolf, Common Mongoose, Common Langur, Indian Hare, Three
Striped Palm Squirrel, Bonnet Macaque etc. These are normal species found in the
Maharashtra Zone. No negative or positive impact on these species is expected.
No pest or parasitic species are found in the area. Hence, no any negative or positive impact
is envisaged.
a) Natural Vegetation
The existing quality of natural vegetation is good. No harmful aquatic weeds are observed in
the surface waters.
b) Species Diversity
As effluent from existing as well as expansion project would not be discharged directly to
any water body, the diversity of any aquatic plant or animal species will not get affected.
As the aquatic life is not going to be affected there will not be any impact on the food and
web index.
Parameters for the above-mentioned category are divided into four parts as (1) Water, (2)
Soil, (3) Air, (4) Noise
Impacts of the proposed expansion project activities on these components are summarized
below:
4.5.2.1 Water
Parameters which represent the water environment are mainly pH, COD, BOD, TDS, Oil&
Grease. Trade industrial effluent generated from expansion industrial activities shall be
230.5M3/Day. This effluent shall be segregated in existing ETP comprising of primary,
secondary and tertiary treatments. Treated water from ETP is recycled back in process for
cooling.
154
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Domestic effluent after expansion would be treated in proposed STP. Thus, no any untreated /
treated /domestic effluent would be discharged in any nearby water body.
4.5.2.2 Soil
Analysis of soil in the acquired area shows that it is good for cultivation. In case of the study
area, the soil chemistry will not change because no any untreated/ treated/ domestic effluent
would be discharged on land. Moreover, the hazardous and solid waste generated would be
properly stored in lined area and disposed off by forwarding it to CHWTSDF as done under
existing unit.
No change in the land use pattern of study area is expected. The expansion will be carried out
in existing premises which is located in MIDC area. Thus, the designated land use is solely
for the industrial purpose.
b) Soil Chemistry
Soil observed is neutral, mostly clayey loams. This indicates presence of clay material. The
porosity varies between 33.57–54.54, which can be categorized as moderate. pH index
indicates neutral nature of the soil. The bulk density is observed 1.15 to 1.51 gm/cc. Soils
from this study area have EC values below the limits to be called as saline and hence the soils
are normal for crop growth. The water retention capacity is observed in range of 37% to 61%,
which can be stated as moderate to good. The Sodium Adsorption Ratio (SAR) is in the range
of 1.11 to 1.27
c) Soil Erosion
Development of the green belt plan as mentioned in chapter 2ndprevents the soil erosion from
the project premises. Also, grassland on the open lands helps arresting the erosion of soil.
Thus, there will not be any soil erosion from the acquired area.
4.5.2.3 Air
The average concentration of PM10, PM2.5,SO2 & NOx monitored at site is 58.24g/M3,
17.51g/M3, 23.97g/M3 and 39.19g/M3 respectively. These are well within the limits
specified by MPCB / CPCB.
4.5.2.4 Noise
Major sources of the noise generation are Boiler, Reactors & Compressors; Fans and Pumps,
Vehicles, D. G. Sets. All the machinery including pumps and compressors are lubricated and
well fixed to minimize noise. The D.G Set sunder existing unit are enclosed in separate
canopy. However, this would not be a continuous source of noise as the same would be
operated in case of electricity failure. Isolation, insulation, separation techniques would be
adopted under the expansion activities to reduce noise effects on the work environment as
well as on the ambient noise levels. Prevention of noise with the plans suggested in EMP
would suffice the control of noise pollution.
155
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
4.5.2.5 Vibration
No major source of vibration would be present in the industry under existing and proposed
operations.
4.5.3 Aesthetics
a) Landscape
Topography & landscape of the area indicates plain terrain. Changes would occur in the form
of general leveling and digging for construction purposes. Debris arising from the
construction would be utilized for filing of low-lying area. Thus, even if some changes may
occur in the topography of the area, it would bring out positive impact in the form of leveling
and landscaping.
b) Green Belt
Natural vegetation and its diversity will increase due to green belt development.
There will not be any effect on the visual quality of the air.
There will not be any effect on the visual quality of the water body present in the study area.
e) Sound
There might be small increase in the noise levels around the existing project site. This is
taken care by proper isolation, insulation, separation techniques and provision of green belt
development plan as suggested above.
Human interest will not be affected negatively. The proposed expansion project activities will
provide direct and indirect employment to residents of nearby locality. As such, the overall
effect will be positive.
a) Community Health
The TDMCCL project would not have any impact on health and sanitation of the study
region. The domestic effluents from proposed expansion activities would be treated in
proposed STP and overflow would be used for gardening in own premises. Also, there will be
zero discharge w.r.t. trade effluent. Hence, sanitation in the study area as well as acquired
area would not have any positive or negative impact.
156
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
b) Employment
The existing project has provided employment opportunities to the skilled and semi-skilled
local populace, especially in small-scale business and other related services.
c) Economy
The economy of the study area would have somewhat positive impact due to the expansion
project activities. Through, primary and secondary level employment as well as contractual
jobs becoming available, the overall economy of the study area would impart positive effects
on it. The small contract jobs at local level would improve the economy at the micro level. It
was observed that majority of the population within the sample size had considerable income
which is mostly due to job opportunities in MIDC.
Due to requirement of raw materials and dispatch of products to market, transportation in the
project area would be increased. The local transporters would be benefited primarily. Further,
common communication facilities are available in project area since the area is well
developed MIDC area.
e) Education
All the required education facilities up to postgraduate levels are available at the Roha. From
the socio-economic survey of 10 Km study area, it was observed that the literates had up to
primary (35%), secondary (32), higher secondary (15%), graduate (6%) and post graduate
(1%) level education. However, it was interesting to observe that, locals residing in wadis
above villages Pugao, Pallekhurd, Killa and Washi were known to be Adivasis. Most of these
were illiterate, economically backward and dependent on gathering wood for their living.
f) Water Supply
The plot being located in the Roha MIDC, the water required for proposed operations would
be taken from MIDC water supply scheme. Further, drinking water is supplied to near by
villages through MIDC water supply scheme, Roha.
g) Occupational Health
Occupational health is usually the concern in case of routine industrial operations. Regular
health checkup camps and facilities such as doctors, dispensary, hospitals, ambulance etc. are
the prerequisites of a good program. The present unit has all such facilities and amenities.
The proposed infrastructure and practices in TDMCCL unit would suffice for the
requirements towards occupational health & safety measures under the expansion project.
Moreover, the industry would adopt measures suggested in the EMP. Thus, no occupational
health problem would anticipated under the proposed expansion project.
157
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Table 4.12 Application of BEES for Impact Evaluation due to TDMCCL, Roha MIDC,
Raigad
Categories Components Parameters Parameter Importance Units (PIUs) V i,0 V i,1 ΔVi W iΔVi
Parameter Component Category Without With
PI\Wi PIUs PIUs Project Project
1 2 3 4 5= 6= 7 8 9=8- 10=9X4
Sum of 4 Sum of 5 7
Biological Species & 1. Terrestrial 14 240 0.5 0.5 0 0
Environment Populations browsers and
(Ecology) (Terrestrial grazers
Flora, 2. Terrestrial crops 14 0.6 0.6 0 0
Terrestrial (Farm land)
Fauna, 3. Terrestrial natural 14 0.5 0.6 0.1 1.4
Aquatic Biota) vegetation.
(Grass, Flowers,
Trees & Shrubs.)
4. Terrestrial pest 14 0.6 0.6 0 0
species
5. Terrestrial upland 14 1.0 1.0 0 0
birds
6. Aquatic 14 0.7 0.7 0 0
commercial
fisheries.
7. Aquatic natural 14 0.6 0.6 0 0
vegetation
8. Aquatic pest 14 0.5 0.5 0 0
species
9. Fish 14 0.6 0.6 0 0
10. Water fowl 14 140 0.6 0.6 0 0
Habitats & 11. Terrestrial food 08 0.8 0.8 0 0
Communities web index
12. Land use 10 0.7 0.7 0 0
13. Terrestrial rare 15 0.3 0.5 0.2 3.0
and endangered
species.
14. Terrestrial species 10 0.8 0.8 0 0
diversity
15. Aquatic food web 08 0.7 0.7 0 0
index
16. Aquatic rare & 08 0.5 0.5 0 0
endangered
species
17. River 10 0.5 0.5 0 0
characteristics
18. Aquatic species 10 0.6 0.6 0 0
diversity
19. Habitat Removal, 08 0.7 0.7 0 0
Contamination of
Habitat (Aquatic
Biota)
20. Terrestrial Fauna - 13 100 0.4 0.4 0 0
Fragmentation of
Terrestrial Habitat,
Environmental Water 21. Basin hydrologic 20 402 0.6 0.5 - 0.1 - 2.0
Pollution loss (alteration of
hydraulic regime,
alteration of
surface runoff,
158
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Categories Components Parameters Parameter Importance Units (PIUs) V i,0 V i,1 ΔVi W iΔVi
Parameter Component Category Without With
PI\Wi PIUs PIUs Project Project
1 2 3 4 5= 6= 7 8 9=8- 10=9X4
Sum of 4 Sum of 5 7
alteration of
aquifers)
22. BOD (Water 28 0.6 0.5 -0.1 -2.8
Quality - WQ)
23. Dissolved Oxygen 33 0.8 0.8 0 0
(WQ)
24. Fecal Coliforms 10 0.6 0.6 0 0
(WQ)
25. Inorganic carbon 26 0.6 0.6 0 0
(WQ)
26. Inorganic nitrogen 26 0.6 0.6 0 0
(WQ)
27. Inorganic 26 0.6 0.6 0 0
phosphate (WQ)
28. Pesticides (WQ) 10 0.3 0.3 0 0
29. pH (WQ) 25 1.0 1.0 0 0
30. Stream flow 30 0.8 0.8 0 0
variation
(alteration of river,
nalla, channel)
31. Temperature. 33 1.0 1.0 0 0
32. TDS (WQ) 10 0.8 0.7 0.1 -1.0
33. Toxic substances 10 0.7 0.7 0 0
(WQ)
34. Turbidity (WQ) 25 312 0.6 0.6 0 0
Air 35. CO2(Air Quality- 8 0.8 0.8 0 0
AQ)
36. Nitrogen oxides 7 0.8 0.8 0 0
(AQ)
37. Particulate matter 14 0.6 0.5 0 0
(AQ)
38. Photochemical 3 1.0 1.0 0 0
oxidants (AQ)
39. Sulfur dioxide 10 0.6 0.5 -0.1 -1.0
(AQ)
40. Other (process & 10 52 0.7 0.6 -0.1 -1.0
fugitive emissions
Land 41. Land use 10 0.6 0.7 0.1 1.0
(Soil) 42. Soil erosion 6 0.8 0.8 0 0
43. Soil Quality 12 28 0.7 0.7 0 0
Noise 44. Noise 10 10 0.8 0.8 0 0
Aesthetics Land 45. Surface material 6 158 0.8 0.8 0 0
Cultural 46. Relief and 16 1.0 1.0 0 0
topographic
character
47. Width and 10 32 0.8 0.8 0 0
alignment
Air 48. Odor and visual 3 0.7 0.6 -0.1 -0.3
49. Sounds 2 5 0.8 0.8 0 0
Water 50. Appearance 16 1.0 1.0 0 0
51. Land &water 16 1.0 1.0 0 0
interface
52. Odor &floating 10 0.8 0.8 0 0
materials
159
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Categories Components Parameters Parameter Importance Units (PIUs) V i,0 V i,1 ΔVi W iΔVi
Parameter Component Category Without With
PI\Wi PIUs PIUs Project Project
1 2 3 4 5= 6= 7 8 9=8- 10=9X4
Sum of 4 Sum of 5 7
53. Water surface 10 1.0 1.0 0 0
area
54. Wooded & 10 62 0.8 0.8 0 0
geologic shoreline
Biota 55. Animals- domestic 5 1.0 1.0 0 0
56. Animals – wild 5 0.6 0.6 0 0
57. Diversity of 12 0.7 0.8 0.1 1.2
vegetation types
58. Variety within 8 30 0.8 0.9 0.1 0.8
vegetation types
Manmade 59. Manmade objects 9 9 0.8 0.8 0 0
Objects
Composition 60. Composite effect 10 0.7 0.7 0 0
61. Unique 10 20 1.0 1.0 0 0
composition
Human Educational / 62. Archaeological 6 200 1.0 1.0 0 0
Interest Scientific 63. Training in new 13 0.5 0.7 0.2 2.6
(Social, Packages technologies& skill
Cultural) development
64. Ecological 9 0.8 0.8 0 0
Effects on crops,
Reduction of farm
land
65. Geological 10 1.0 1.0 0 0
66. Hydrological 10 48 0.7 0.7 0 0
Historical 67. Architecture and 5 1.0 1.0 0 0
Packages styles
(Infrastructure 68. Conflicts with 10 0.9 0.9 0 0
and services) projects of urban ,
commercial or
industrial
development
69. EventsRecreation 10 1.0 1.0 0 0
70. Persons 12 1.0 1.0 0 0
71. Religions and 10 1.0 1.0 0 0
Cultures
72. Western frontier 8 55 1.0 1.0 0 0
Cultures 73. Indians 13 1.0 1.0 0 0
160
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
Categories Components Parameters Parameter Importance Units (PIUs) V i,0 V i,1 ΔVi W iΔVi
Parameter Component Category Without With
PI\Wi PIUs PIUs Project Project
1 2 3 4 5= 6= 7 8 9=8- 10=9X4
Sum of 4 Sum of 5 7
Life Patterns 82. Employment 16 0.7 0.9 0.2 3.2
(Economy) opportunities
(Creation of new
economic
activities.
Generation of
Temporary &
Permanent Jobs)
83. Income for state & 5 0.5 0.6 0.1 0.5
private sector.
84. Saving for 5 0.6 0.7 0.1 0.5
consumers and
private consumers
Savings in foreign
currency for the
state.
85. Housing. 5 0.6 0.6 0 0
(Commercial value
of properties,
Electricity tariff)
86. Social interactions 5 46 0.6 0.6 0 0
(Conflict due to
negotiations & / or
compensation
payments,
Political conflicts,
Demonstration
and Social
Conflicts.
The Battelle EES Environmental Impact Analysis Cumulative Index Ei +4.7
Table4.13 Identification of RED Flags to the Potential Problem Areas in BEES for
TDMCCL
Parameters PIUs V i,0 V i,1 ΔVi ΔVi, r # Red Flag
Wi Without With
Project Project
1 2 3 4 5 = 4-3 6 = 5/3 X 7
100
21.Basin hydrologic loss (alteration 20 0.6 0.5 -0.1 -17% Minor
of hydraulic regime, alteration of
surface runoff, alteration of
aquifers)
22. BOD (Water Quality - WQ) 28 0.6 0.5 -0.1 -17% Minor
32. TDS (WQ) 10 0.8 0.7 -0.1 -12% Minor
39. Sulphur Di-oxide (AQ) 10 0.6 0.5 -0.1 -17% Minor
40. Other (Process Emissions) 10 0.7 0.6 -0.1 -14% Minor
48.Odor& Visual 3 0.7 0.6 -0.1 -14% Minor
161
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
# ‐ In the Battelle EES, the potential problem areas are represented by those parameters for
which the Vi value changes significantly in the adverse direction, as measured by the following
relation (negative values, in percent)
ΔVi, r = 100 [V i,1 ‐ V i,0] / V i,0.These parameters are tagged with 'red flags' to indicate
potential problems which may warrant more detailed attention. For parameters in the
ecology category, a minor red flag applies when 5% <ΔVi,r ≤ 10%, and a major red flag
when ΔVi,r> 10 %. In all other categories, a minor red flag applies when ΔVi,r ≤ 30% or
ΔVi ≤ 0.1, and a major red flag when ΔVi,r> 30% or ΔVi> 0.1.
The potential problem areas mentioned in above Table 4.13 would be having adverse impact
due to project activities under expansion. The various mitigation measures to minimize the
impact on different parameters are presented below-
1. Basin Hydrologic Loss
This parameter that comes under 'Environment Pollution' category. For the present and
proposed expansion activities in TDMCCL water is taken from MIDC Water supply scheme.
The existing and proposed activities considered together shall require water quantity to the
tune of 1592 M3/Day. Out of this total requirement 220 M3/Day would be recycle water in
process for cooling whereas 1372 M3/Day (86%) would be the fresh water taken from
Kundalika River. Hence the treated water from ETP after achieving prescribed standards will
be recycled back into process for cooling.
To minimize the negative impact up to some extent, TDMCCL has planned to reduce its fresh
water demand by about 14% through recycling the treated effluent. Thus, the industry shall
reuse 220M3/day of its treated effluent for cooling tower make up and in process operations.
This step shall facilitate the benefits namely; achieving 'Zero Discharge' of trade effluent in
the environment and saving in fresh water demand.
2. B.O.D.
Through the manufacturing operations under expansion in TDMCCL project, effluents would
be generated from process, laboratory, washing, cooling and boiler blow downs etc. The total
effluent generated from various operations and processes in proposed expansion project shall
be treated in existing ETP of 300 CMD capacity comprising of Primary, Secondary and
Tertiary treatment operations. At present, the treated water from ETP, achieving prescribed
standards is discharged to Common Effluent Treatment Plant (CETP), Roha. Presently,
domestic wastewater is treated in septic tanks followed by soak pits. The overflow from soak
pits is used for gardening purpose.
Under expansion, the management has decided to achieve Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD) by
installation of evaporators and the condensate would be recycled in industrial operations. No
any effluent would be discharged outside the premises. Moreover, for domestic waste water,
Sewage Treatment Plant (STP) of 20 CMD is proposed. The treated water from STP would
be used for gardening.
Green belt development and complete utilization of the treated domestic wastewater for the
plantation therein shall prevent any degradation of the ground as well as surface water
162
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
quality. As a result of actions described above, there shall not be any discharge of treated or
untreated effluents in any water body. This shall avoid adverse impact of the industry on
environment especially due to the organic pollution of attributes such as water and land.
3. TDS
This parameter comes under water component of environmental pollution category. It has got
importance since during manufacturing processes various salts are used as raw materials in
considerable quantities. Moreover, many times salts are generated as intermediate or end
products of number of chemical reactions. Subsequently, through procedures of product
finishing, refining or purifying, effluents containing huge concentrations of TDS are
generated. If such effluents of high TDS are discharged on land or in surface waters or if they
find access to ground water, serious negative impacts could result. The TDS in surface and
ground water may increase, the water could become hard, the soils can become saline. These
changed properties of water, land and soils, in turn, could demand costly measures for
making them useful or fit for consumption towards various purposes. More details about this
aspect have been described in earlier sections of this chapter while stating impacts and their
mitigation measures.
4. SO2
The SO2shall get released to atmosphere as stack emissions due to burning of fuel. There the
quantum of SO2emission shall be of more concern. In light of such event, the mitigation
measure in the form of adequate stack height of 35M, 30 Mhas been considered.
This parameter comes under 'Environmental Pollution' Category (Component – Air). There
would be process emissions in the form of sulphur dioxide, HCl as well as VOCs as process
and fugitive emissions. Same are controlled through installation of scrubbers and fume
extraction systems. Further, the scrubbed material shall be forwarded to secondary uses or
sent to ETP. Thus, no any process emissions shall be let out into ambient air.
This parameter comes under 'Aesthetics' category for component of air in the BEES.
Although, there would be the minor predicted negative impact (14% as shown in Table 4.18)
of this parameter, due consideration for same is equally important. This is because the said
parameter is related with aesthetics in respect of ambient air in the industrial premises and in
surrounding region. The odor may be because of fugitive emissions from different process
operations during manufacturing as well as unhygienic and poor storage conditions in the
industrial premises of waste materials (discarded product batches, spent organics & catalysts,
mother liquor etc.), sludge, solid and hazardous wastes. Odour nuisance would be controlled
by curbing emissions responsible for same at the source itself. Further, provision of scrubber,
efficient ventilation and exhaust systems, proper O & M as well as good house-keeping shall
exercise adequate control on factors responsible for odour nuisance.
163
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
When a plan for decommissioning of the TDMCCL plant would be confirmed, initially a
detailed survey of the site and entire plant shall be carried out. Detailed photography and
videography shall be done. A review of all documents shall be taken and thorough checking
shall be done w.r.t. permissions from all concerned Govt. authorities for the
decommissioning. If required, competent personnel shall be arranged at the site to supervise
the entire assignment.
1. Number and types of buildings like administration building (2 storeyed) and security
office in RCC and brick work, manufacturing plant in MS &RCC, allied piping, staging
and supports etc.
2. All electrification infrastructure with cables and cable trays, transformers, poles and
lighting, underground cable trenches, etc.
For demolishing RCC structure, no any blasting is recommended as the site is in Roha MIDC
and surrounded by other chemical industries. Same would be done by using hydraulic
breakers. Fabricated structure would be dismantled by gas cutting.
Inventory of left over hazardous chemicals after shutdown would be done. These chemicals
based on their characteristics would be scientifically collected and disposed off for authorized
re-processor or forwarded to CHWTSDF. This would be done also for safe disposal of used /
unused chemicals from the industry. The decommissioning would be done by detoxification
followed by dismantling activity under trained manpower and expert supervision.
A) Detoxification
For detoxification of reactor, column, bulk storage tanks following in-situ methods are
suggested -
a. Hot Water/ Air Purging: Hot air /water shall be purged through the units until specified
criteria are met.
b. Dilute Acid Wash: Some of the equipment and pipelines shall be given acid wash to
detoxify them. Dilute HCl (5-10%) is suggested for this purpose.
c. Water Wash: Finally a thorough water wash of the equipment and pipelines is
recommended, before they are dismantled from their supports.
The used water shall be diverted to ETP for its treatment and safe disposal.
164
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES …4
B) Dismantling
All the equipment, pipelines and structural components shall be dismantled only after in-situ
detoxification has been carried out as specified above. The pipelines would be dismantled
first followed by the equipment and finally by the structure. The dismantling of the units will
begin from the topmost floor and proceed towards the ground floor. Large equipment shall be
dismantled in sections wherever possible. The dismantled metal components would be
disposed off by sale to authorized parties. Demolition of RCC buildings would be done
manually and debris generated would be used for filling low lying areas.
After dismantling and disposal of all dumps to disposal sites, there would be necessity to
check soil contamination due to leakages and spillages. The top soil samples in industrial site
be analyzed and the quality would be checked.
165
Chapter 5
ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES
ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES (TECHNOLOGY AND SITE)…5
5.1 INTRODUCTION
While preparing EIA report, it is necessary that one should consider project alternatives and
their relative potential impacts on the environment. Selection of alternative would be thus
more critical in an industrial development where time, money, environment and natural
resources are at stake. Hence, selection of alternative must be both practical and rational,
taking into consideration the constraint of the proposed expansion projectby TDMCCL.
The product will require certain raw materials. The raw materials for existing and proposed
activities listed in Chapter - 2 are adopted because of their purity and desirable form. It
avoids a probability of discards or non-specification outcome. It also follows the mass
balance more faithfully than when impurities are involved.
To reduce the carbon footprint by our business operations, we aim to use renewable energy
sources for the process requirements, wherever necessary. We have plans to use all the latest
available energy efficient and environmental friendly technologies to contain or minimize the
impact on Environment.
TDMCCLis utilizing the heat generated during Sulphur Burning as a heating source for
generation of steam in waste heat Boiler. Here, TDMCCL generates about 300-330 MT of
steam daily. It is a green technology as no new fuel burning is done for steam generation
thereby reducing the green house gases. After in-house utilization of steam generated from
waste heat boiler, about 60 MT/day of steam is supplied to immediate neighboring industries.
Here, once again there is reduction of green house gas emissions as no additional fuel like
FO,Coal etc. burning is done by neighboring industries for generation of steam.This activity
helps reduce the carbon footprint equivalent to 13 MT per day.
Expansion Activity
(Reference: ICC data assuming sub bituminous coal used for generation of electricity 96.07
Kg by CO2/GJ)
2. Dedicated equipments -
Most of major products are manufactured in dedicated equipments hence no washings are
required. This reduces the effluent load.
166
ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES (TECHNOLOGY AND SITE)…5
3. Solar Power-
TDMCCL have installed a 335 KWp capacity Solar Power Plant in May 2016. All future
installation’s roofs will be south-wardly inclined to install more solar panels for higher solar
power generation.
Figure 5.1 Solar power plant installed on site of TDMCCL
167
ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES (TECHNOLOGY AND SITE)…5
BEFORE AFTER
5. Biogas Plant-
TDMCCL installed a biogas plant in which canteen waste and colony kitchen waste is
consumed for biogas generation. This biogas is used in canteen.
Instead of RO/ MEE TDMCCL is going to achieve ZLD unit where neutral effluent after
primary clarifier shall be feed to the unit.This effluent will be concentrated to about 25 to
30% TDS level and dried further to get solid residue. Heat pump is used to concentrate the
effluent by evaporation. Water Vapor is then condensed and recycled. Apart from the
electrical energy provided for heating the effluent, heat pump also utilizes the heat released
during condensation of water vapor for evaporating the inlet effluent water. This technology
is the best example of conservation and effective utilization of energy. The concentrated
stream will be subjected for drying in de-moisturizer. The installation and commissioning of
this facility will be completed within short period.
168
ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES (TECHNOLOGY AND SITE)…5
In most cases, industrial process water is passed through ETP, RO and Multi effect
Evaporator (ME) process. Typically, RO reject is passed through the ME. Steam inside ME
process is generated by direct heating principle. It is done by equipment like boilers, electric
heaters, solar water heater or high vacuum pump systems. No matter how efficient these
systems are, the efficiency or COP (coefficient of performance) is always less than 1; since
there are some losses in the process of heating. It is also important to note that all the above
equipment uses some conventional source of heat energy which is expensive and the cost is
increasing day by day. For example, Steam boilers or Hot water generators use High Speed
Diesel as the source of heat. Since these sources of heat or fuels are often expensive, the
operating costs of such systems are mostly on the higher side.With regards to this context,
progressive revelations suggested what if we could use some form of vacuum system clubbed
with a heat pump system which could recover up to 95% water in distilled form from waste
effluents.
Our system does exactly the same; it works on principle of evaporation and condensation
clubbed with a vacuum system to get distilled water. Typically, hot side of heat pump is
connected to the evaporator coils inside a “vacuum evaporation chamber”. Heat pump
maintains the Freon gas’s temperature in the evaporator coil at around 105°C to 110°C.
Waste water is sprayed on the evaporator coils at a constant rate, if effluents are viscous in
nature then they are stirred inside the vacuum chamber which is surrounded by evaporator
coils. Water evaporates after getting in touch with hot coils and vapours are formed. Vapours
are then sucked into a condensing chamber (condensing chamber is connected to the cooling
side of heat pump) through blowers. Finally, the water gets condensed on the cooling coils
and is drained out into a fresh water tank. The condensed water that we get is free soluble
metals, oils, caustic minerals, chemicals and other impurities.
The wet slurry which is formed post evaporation is passed on to a dryer where we get
powdered form waste, hence achieving 100% zero liquid and zero water discharge status. The
Heat pump based effluent to distilled water convertor system finds application in Industrial &
Commercial facilities like FMCG, Automotive - Paints shop applications & Industrial
washing machines, Pharmaceutical - API & Formulation units, Textiles, Chemicals, Hotels,
Hospitals, Luxury Resorts & Spas, Serviced Apartments, Residential Training centre’s and
many other types of facilities.
60% -70% reductions in operating cost compared to the ETP, RO & ME setup
Single stage unit with water recovery up to 95% in distilled form
Concentrate can be converted in dry powder for easy disposal
Average payback can be as attractive as 1 to 1.5 year
Accelerated depreciation benefits up to 80%
Higher manpower productivity
Economic Life of ~15 years (As per ASHRAE)
Refer Appendix - J for Heat Pump Based Effluent to Distilled Water Convertor diagram.
169
ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES (TECHNOLOGY AND SITE)…5
Used catalyst of sulphuric acid plant is sent to Mumbai Waste Management Ltd (MWML) for
disposal at MPCB approved designated site at Taloja. Our organization is registered member
of MWML. Mumbai Waste Management Ltd. is an approved agency by MPCB.
170
Chapter 6
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING
PROGRAM
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
6. 1 INTRODUCTION
With knowledge of baseline conditions, monitoring program will serve as an indicator for any
deterioration in environmental conditions due to operation of the project. This will enable in
taking up suitable steps, in time, to safeguard the environment. Monitoring is an important
tool for control of pollution since efficiency of control measures can only be determined by
monitoring.
The details of proposed mitigation measures that have been suggested in order to achieve
economic development due to the proposed expansion of TDMCCL project without harming
the nature are as follow -
171
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
expected. The following attributes which merit regular monitoring based on the
environmental setting and nature of project activities are listed below -
Apart from the ambient air and source monitoring during operation stage of TDMCCL
project, following recommendations are also suggested -
Air pollution control equipment would be interlocked with the process as per the
guidelines of CPCB
If the emissions exceed the standards, the corresponding units of the plant which are
contributing the excessive pollutant load are stopped till the qualities of pollutant
discharged from those units are brought down to the required level
In case of failure of pollution control equipment, the production process connected to it
would be stopped
Under no circumstances, the emissions shall exceed the limits mentioned in the consent
letter
Online monitoring system would be installed under proposed expansion project
In case of power failure, alternate electric source would be provided which would be
sufficient to operate the APC equipment continuously.
The total water requirement after expansion project would be 1592 m3/day. Out of which
220 m3/day treated effluent recycle whereas 1372 m3/day would be the fresh water
taken from the MIDC water supply scheme. The MIDC procures water from Kundalika
River and after treatment the same is provided to different industries in the MIDC. For
detail water requirement refer Chapter - 2.
The effluent generated from existing activities is already handled and treated as per CREP
guidelines. After commissioning of expansion activity same shall be handled and treated as
per CREP guidelines. Refer Chapter - 2 for effluent generation and disposal. Salient features
of the water management aspect are -
The industry has provided effluent collection, treatment and disposal facilities. Proper
operation and maintenance of same is done to achieve desired results.
No untreated industrial effluent is allowed to be disposed off on land or in any surface
water body.
The pipeline and storage tanks meant for effluent conveyance and storage are checked
periodically to avoid any leakages. Leakage, if any, will harm the surrounding soil and
172
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
water environment significantly. High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) & stainless steel are
used as pipeline and valves material respectively.
Flow meter is already installed at ETP inlet and Outlet to record the daily flow of the
water. Same practice shall be followed under expansion activities.
Pumps in the ETP are supplied with alternate electric supply source in case of power
failure.
Vital aspects of the noise pollution and its mitigation measures are mentioned in Chapter - 4.
Moreover, people working in close vicinity of high noise generating equipments would be
provided with PPE such as ear plugs, ear muffs etc.
Industry would take care while procuring major noise generating machines/ equipments
to ensure that manufacturers have taken adequate measures to minimize generation of
noise.
Thick bushy trees would be planted in and around the industrial area to intercept noise
transmission to the nearby villages.
Allocation of work would be managed so that no worker would be exposed to noise more
than 90 dB (A) for more than 8 hours.
Creating awareness about noise pollution among the workers.
The overall noise levels in and around the plant area would be kept well within the
standards by providing noise control measures including acoustic hoods, silencers,
enclosures etc. on all sources of noise generation.
Monitoring shall include developing a sampling strategy to identify employees to be
included in the hearing conservation program. Each employee being monitored shall be
notified of the results. Employees may observe the monitoring by the Industry. The
Industry shall establish and maintain an audiometric testing program that shall be
performed by a qualified person at no cost to the employees.
Record keeping will include maintaining audiometric test records by the industry for
duration of the affected employment.
There are no chances of change in the soil characteristics due to air pollutants and suspended
particulates from the proposed expansion activity. There would be no any discharge of
untreated domestic or industrial effluent from proposed or existing activities.The solid and
173
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
hazardous waste is being stored in dedicated area provided on site. Same practice shall be
adopted after expansion.
Trouble with dust in work zone and ambient atmospheres would be controlled in unit by
certain dedicated measures. An action plan have been prepared and implemented in the
existing unit that includes following. Same measures would be followed after expansion.
There are different odour sources in the industry.The raw materials& product storage places,
process operations, loading/unloading sections etc. could give rise to smell nuisance. To
abate the odour nuisance, following steps are being taken under existing unit-
All the feed, loading & unloading pumps for products and raw materialsare fitted with
mechanical seals instead of glands to reduce leakages.
The products and raw materials loading & unloading area are provided with fumes
extraction system comprising of circulation pump with blower and scrubber. The bulk
storage tanks are connected to scrubber for taking care of fumes coming out from vent.
Separate dispensing room wherein transferring of powered raw material is done.
Adoption of Good management practices (GMPs).
Arranging awareness and training camps for workers.
Provision and use of PPEs like masks by everybody associated with odour prone areas.
Installation of appropriate, adequate and efficient exhaust and ventilation system to
remove and control odour from work zone areas.
All the equipments and machinery used would be maintained properly and would be kept
clean. The quality of stack emission depends very much on the operating parameters of plant.
Improper combustion of fuel in the boiler increases unburnt carbon particles in the exhaust
flue gases therefore proper maintenance is an important factor. The lubricants used for
various equipment and fuel-handling areas would contribute to the pollution aspect. It would
be taken care of, at the source, by looking after possible spillage, drippings, leakage etc. in
the plant.
174
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
As per the requirement of Factory Act, there is provision made for of Occupational Health
Centre (OHC). There under, a qualified visiting doctor has been appointed.
Regular medical checkup of employees is carried out and records are maintained.
An ambulance is available all the time i.e. 24X7.
Workmen Compensation Policy and / or Public Liability Insurance as well as Mediclaim
Health Policy have been done for all the workers (temporary and permanent) in the
Industry and which is renewed every year.
Following equipment and gadgets have been kept in the OHC of TDMCCL.
Sr.
Instrument Use
No.
1. Stethoscope Used to hear sounds from movements within the body,
like heart beats, intestinal movement, breath sounds etc.
2. Reflex testing hammer To test motor reflexes of the body
(padded)
3. Sphygmomanometer To record the patient’s blood pressure
(Blood pressure meter)
4. A thin beam electric To see into the eye, body’s natural orifices etc. and to
torch test for pupillary light reflex etc.
5. A watch / stopwatch Used in recording rates like heart rate, respiratory rate,
etc.; for certain tests of hearing
6. A measuring tape For size measurements
7. A weighing machine To record the weight
8. Tuning forks To test for deafness and to categorize it
9. Kidney dish As a tray for instruments, gauze, tissue etc.
10. Thermometer To record the body temperature
11. Gas cylinders Supply of oxygen, nitrous oxide, carbon dioxide etc.
12. Oxygen mask or tubes Delivering gases up to the nostrils to assist in oxygen
intake or to administer aerosolized or gaseous drugs
175
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
Sr.
Instrument Use
No.
13. Vaporizer To produce vapours
14. Instrument sterilizers Used to sterilize instruments in absence of an autoclave
15. Dressing drums Storage of gowns, cotton, linen etc.
16. Syringe of different For injections and aspiration of blood or fluid from the
sizes and needles body
17. Otoscope To look into the external ear cavity
In order to run existing and expansion project, 210 nos. manpower are required.Out of which
75 % are employed from local populace.
The planning for CER shall be started with the identification of the activities/projects
and may be undertaken in the periphery of Industrial area.
Corporate Environment Responsibility Action Plan shall be prepared based on the casual
approach to the project; based accountability approach, integrated with the social and
environment concerns related to the business of the integrated project complex.
Selection of activities under CER shall be made to ensure that the benefits reach the
smallest unit i.e. village, panchayat, block or district. CER planning shall be done for
long-term sustainable approach.
Long term CER plan should be broken down into medium term and short term plans.
Each of these plans shall clearly specify.
Rs. 25.00 Lakhs (2.5 % of Capital Investment - Rs.10.00Crs.) have been earmarked for CER
activities. Activities to be undertaken under CER have been considered based on SE survey
conducted in the study area.
Total
Sr.
CER Activity Details Amount Rs.
No.
(In Lakhs)
1. Provision for Environment For creating environment awareness in
awareness campaign & locals; particularly youth generation and 2.5
Conservation of the socially active members
ecology and biodiversity
2. Tree Plantation and No of Trees in villages = 5000 for 3 Years
Maintenance Cost of Tree Plantation/Village = 5
15
(3 Villages: Landhar, Lakhs
Vaijnath and Tamhanshet) Total cost of Tree Plantation in 3
176
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
Total
Sr.
CER Activity Details Amount Rs.
No.
(In Lakhs)
villages= Rs. 5 Lakhs / Village x 3 = 15
Lakhs
3. Implementation of rain Roof Top Harvesting in 2 Villages
water harvesting Total 20 RWH Sets (500 Lit RCC Tank;
Piping; Plumbing, Filter etc.) 5
20 RWH Sets x Rs. 25,000 / Set = Rs. 5
Lakhs
4. Promotion of Government Participation & Promotion of Govt.
Missions (Central/State) Missions namely - Pradhanmantri Vidya
Laxmi Karyekram (Literacy Promotion),
2.5
Save the Girl Child, Swatch Bharat
Abhiyan, Digital & Cash Less Economy
etc.
Total 25
For implementing the above mentioned CER plan, a CER committee will be formed in the
industry. A senior official will be the chairman, environment officer will be the secretary and
representatives from village grampanchayat will be the members. These activities shall be put
in action and completed in a period of 3 years after commissioning of project.
177
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
General Guidelines
1. Green belt of adequate width and density would be provided to mitigate the effects of
noise.
2. Plantation activities shall be done according to naturally occurring vegetation. Exotic
species shall be avoided.
3. Provision of shrubs and thick trees at storage and disposal places of the solid waste would
be made.
4. Additional trees would be planted along the roads, around solid waste storage area as well
as along the periphery.
5. All the necessary steps would be taken & care would be observed under the project
regarding proper maintenance of the industrial premises.
6. Use of e-mail and other modern communication systems would be followed to conserve
the papers and attain speedy interaction in daily business activitiesor Use of recyclable
papers, if possible, would be done.
7. Promoting measures of energy and water conservation, wherever possible, would be
adopted.
8. Activities like slide shows or expert’s lectures on Local Biodiversity shall be arranged for
the staff to make them aware about the plant and animal species found nearby; also it will
reduce unnecessary human-wild conflict. This will eventually reduce the damage to
biodiversity by the employees.
178
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
179
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
180
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
Implementation
Sr.
Attribute Time Period Schedule
No
Immediate Progressive
1. Air Pollution Control Before commissioning of the Plant * ----
2. Water Pollution Before commissioning of the Plant * ----
Control
3. Noise Control Before commissioning of the Plant * ----
4. Solid Waste Stage wise ---- *
Management
5. Green Belt Stage wise * *
Development &
Rainwater Harvesting
6. Ecological Aspects Stage wise ---- *
7. Socio - economic Stage wise ---- ----
Aspects
Table 6.7 The Details of Management Plan During Worst Case Scenario
No. Aspect Scenario Recommendations Responsibility
1. Air Increase in 1. Installation of online monitoring Environmental
concentration levels of system and continuous checking of Engineer
PM10 & PM2.5 beyond parameters
limits due to non- 2. Provision of backup filter bags.
functioning of APC due 3. Provision of D.G. Set for
to clogging / burning of uninterrupted power supply in case of
filters bag. power failure for operation of APC
continuously.
4. Immediate shut down of the industry
should be taken if APC is under
maintenance for more than 8 hours.
Manufacturing would be started only
when APC is operating efficiently.
5. Immediate vicinity residents, schools
& hospital should be warned of
181
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
182
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM...6
In addition to above management plan, the industry shall conduct monthly meeting of all
responsible persons along with top management for taking review on environmental
safeguards, accidents and implementation of mitigation measures. The persons who shall be
present for the meeting are Top Management, Departmental Heads, Safety Officer,
Environment Officer, Environment Chemist or any authorized person. During this, finalization
of budget required for environmental management would also be done and approval of same
would be taken from top management. The agenda of meeting would be as follows -
183
Chapter 7
ADDITIONAL STUDIES
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
The proposed project site is situated in MIDC Industrial Area, P.O. Dhatav, Taluka: Roha.
Hence, as per Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification No.S.O.1533 (E) dated
14th September 2006; and amendment thereat, the proposed project does not requires
conducting of public hearing. The EIA report has been complied by incorporating required
information with regards to the project as mentioned in the Standard Terms of Reference
(ToR) issued by MoEFCC, New Delhi vide letter No. IA-J-11011/74/2018-IA-II (I) to
TDMCCL on 3rd May 2018.
The techniques of risk impact analysis differ in detail from case to case, but nevertheless
always follow the same basic principles, viz. the identification of a full and representative set
of failure cases which could cause major disasters. Determination of geographical area in
which more than a specified level of damage could occur in each failure case. Each of these
steps involves considerable analysis. The Preliminary Hazard Analysis (PHA) is performed
as the first step in a Hazard Assessment. It starts with the type of accident involving toxic,
flammable, explosive material. The procedure specifies system elements (plant components
such as storage tank) or event (overloading of a tank) that can lead to a hazardous condition.
1. Identify hazards and nature of hazard in the process, storage and handling of hazardous
chemicals.
2. Carry out Qualitative risk analysis for the process and suggest mitigation measures.
3. Carry out Quantitative risk analysis of the storage of hazardous chemicals and estimate
the threat zones for Most Credible and Worst case scenarios.
4. Suggest mitigation measures to reduce the risk / probability of the accident to the
minimum.
5. Incorporate these measures for ensuring safe operations and safe layout and for effective
preparation of On-site and Off-site emergency plans.
6. Suggest Guidelines for On-site and Off-site emergency plan.
184
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
7.5 METHODOLOGY
B] Hazard Assessment
C] Recommendations
185
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
The manufacturing processes are described earlier in the 2nd chapter. Basically these involve
reactions like Sulphonation, Chlorosulphonation, Condensation, Oxidation, Quenching,
Absorption, Recrystallization, Hydrolysis, Dehydration, Diazotization, Distillation and
Recovery of solvents (used as reaction media), Un-reacted components, Neutralization,
Purification of the product etc. In such commodity chemicals and specialty chemicals
production plants, in the reaction section, separation sections are the major hazards. The
186
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
1. Fire
2. Explosion and toxic release
3. Exposure to hazardous chemicals
4. Wrong operation
5. Failure of utilities and failure of safety systems
Minimum risk is of most importance and this can be achieved by selecting an intrinsically
safe process and optimizing operating process parameters near to the atmospheric conditions.
But this is not possible most of the time. Hence, it is necessary to install safe guards and build
in perfect operating procedure that will minimize chances of accident to the minimum. Also
types of reaction taking place during the process are of prime importance. It may be
exothermic or endothermic. The sulphonation reaction will be carried out predominately as
most of the products are sulphur based. These reactions are hazardous. It is known that
Sulphonation is highly exothermic reactions and even less exothermic reactions. Other than
sulphonation various reactions are also involved in the production premises.
Refer Appendix - K for Process Hazard Analysis of BSCl plant, Process Hazard Analysis of
DES plant and Process Hazard Analysis of SVS plant.
It is known that highly exothermic reactions and even mildly exothermic reactions can lead to
the uncontrollable rise in temperatures and pressures in the reactors and ultimately to the
conditions of run-away reaction, (mostly in highly exothermic reactions and which use
solvents as reaction media or and flammable and explosive chemicals) and this results in
catastrophic explosion and fire.
Hazards Identified
Mitigation Measures
Setting up a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for all critical operations, reactions and
separations.
Once the SOP and operating parameters have been finalized, strictly following it, 24 x 7,
particularly for batch operations without any change of procedure.
Must have in built system to check that the procedures (SOPs) are not violated at any time
and no short cuts are taken in batch processes. Manufacturing and production of
commodity chemicals and speciality chemicals are in majority batch processes.
Have following alarm and interlock system (essential for highly exothermic reactions and
alarms recommended for all exothermic reactions).
187
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
Alarm for High rate of addition of limiting reactant which is added at controlled rate.
Raw material (limiting reactant) addition rate must be controlled by flow control loop
Flow Transmitter (FT), Flow Indicator Controller (FIC), Flow control valve (FCV).
Controlling parameter being reactor temperature.
FCV and / or On-Off valve must be interlocked with the reaction mass temperature and
agitator tripping.
Release of hazardous or toxic gases like SO3 fumes involving from storage of Oleum and
sulphonation. The exposure to these gases can be harmful, in case of leakage, through flange
joints to the workers in the plant and to the environment, if these are released into the
atmosphere.
1. Installation of efficient scrubbers / absorbers and ensuring proper operation as per design
conditions.
2. The appropriate Personal Protective Equipments (PPEs) and breathing devices must be
readily available and all the operators and staff must be trained in use of these PPEs.
3. Emergency instructions, in local languages must be displayed prominently near the work
place.
4. It is also recommended to install gas leak detectors for highly toxic gases at appropriate
locations.
This is another area of major concern for fire, explosion and exposure to and release of toxic
liquids and gases and there is risk of persons, outside the factory limits getting affected.
1. To identify the hazardous materials handled and stored at the plant site. Based on the
hazardous properties, conditions of storage.
2. Quantify the hazards in case of major fire, explosion or toxic release by visualization of
Maximum Credible Accident Scenarios.
3. Incorporate the results of QRA for safe layout of hazardous chemicals storage in tank
188
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
farm as well as in the warehouse and factory layout, in addition to the requirements of
statutory rules and regulations.
4. Suggest mitigation measures to reduce the risk / possibility of the accident to the
minimum.
5. Incorporate all these measures to arrive at Safe Disaster Management Plan, On-site and
Off-site Emergency preparedness plan, if there is any possibility of off-site emergency.
For storage and handling of the potentially hazardous material also.
Hazard analysis is the process of determining the release probabilities and quantities,
emission or release rates, the routes / pathways by which the released substances could reach
the receptors, the fate of the substances in environmental media through which they are
transported or moved and the characteristics of the receptors at risk.
For the manufacture of above products number of organic / inorganic chemicals are used. Out
of these, hazardous raw chemicals have been characterized into -
1. Flammable solvents
2. Toxic and hazardous chemicals
3. Corrosive chemicals
Products manufacturing under existing and proposed expansion activities involve handling of
number of raw materials and hazardous chemicals. Raw materials required in less / small
quantities are stored in drums, bags and carboys.
Warehouse Storage
Hazard Identification
Major hazards involved in storage of flammable liquids in the containers, like drums are Fires
and vapour explosion due to leakage of liquids coming in contact with ignition source. The
extent of a fire or explosion hazard depends on the amount of flammable vapour given off
from a liquid which is determined by -
Other physical properties of the liquid give additional information on how vapour / air
mixtures may develop and also on the potential hazards. These physical properties include -
flashpoint, auto-ignition temperature, viscosity, lower explosion limit and upper explosion
limit.
189
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
Generally, a liquid with a flashpoint below the ambient temperature of the surroundings will
give off sufficient vapour to mix with the air and be ignited. The lower the flashpoint of a
liquid, the higher is the risk.
Health hazards
Flammable liquids can pose a health hazard if they are ingested; come into contact with skin
or eyes, or their vapours are inhaled. For example, methanol is toxic as well as flammable.
Information on the health hazards of a particular liquid, and on any specific precautions
required, must be obtained from the Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) or from the supplier.
Mitigation Measures
The storage is as per the rules and regulations of Petroleum Act, The petroleum Rules 2002.
Lot of vegetation and growth of trees around the storage must be removed. The fencing
around the tank needs to be relooked and can be reduced as per the rules. And there must be
no growth of vegetation and trees inside the fencing.
Refer Appendix - L for layout of Benzene storage tank and Ammonia storage tank.
190
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
Table 7.4 List of Solvents for proposed products and its storage on site
Storage
Sr. Consumption
Product Name Solvent Name Tank Cap.
No. (MT/Yr.)
(MT)
1. 4-Methyl Mercapto Acetophenone O-Dichloro Benzene 72 4
2. 4,4-Dihydroxy Diphenyl Sulphone Mono Ethylene Glycol 255 5
3. 4,4-Dihydroxy Diphenyl Sulphone Mesitylene 180 5
4. Menthyl Lactate Heptane 36 3
5. 3,3-Diamino Diphenyl Sulphone SDS 27 3
The main hazards from the storage of flammable liquids are fire and explosion, involving
either the liquid or the vapour given off from it. Fires or explosions are likely to occur when
liquid or vapour is released and comes into contact with a suitable ignition source, or
alternatively, when a heat or fire source comes into contact with the container.
1. Proper and adequate training to the operators, contract works on the hazards and
precautions SOP they must follow while handling and transferring flammable liquids.
Making sure that they don’t lose the fear of hazards involved in handling of flammable
solvents and toxic chemicals and consequence of the accident.
3. Hot Work Permit: It is absolutely essential to establish Hot work permit system for any
hot work to be carried out in the factory, especially in the areas which store flammable
solvents of Class A and this must be strictly followed for any hot work carried out.
4. It is essential that no maintenance work is done until the potential hazards of the work
have been clearly identified and assessed; the precautions needed have been specified in
detail; the necessary safety equipment has been provided; and adequate and clear
191
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
7. The VICES principles - There are five general principles for ensuring that the risks of
fire and explosion, from the storage of flammable liquids in containers, are controlled and
minimized. An aid to remembering these five principles is the acronym ‘VICES’. There is
no order of priority of the principles implied by the use of the acronym.
i. Ventilation - Good ventilation means vapours given off from a spill, leak, or release,
will be rapidly dispersed. A good standard of ventilation is required in buildings or
rooms used for storing flammable liquids, to disperse the vapours from any small
releases. The ventilation arrangements need to take into account the heavy nature of
the vapours and to ensure adequate air movement at high and low levels. Five air
changes per hour are normally sufficient to ensure vapour levels in the store are kept to
a low level. For small buildings, the simplest method of ensuring adequate ventilation
is to provide fixed, permanent openings.
ii. Ignition - Ignition sources will be removed from the storage area, by flame proof
electrical fittings, no sparking by ensuring permit system during maintenance work,
Declaration of No Smoking and No Naked Flame area will be followed.
iii. Containment - Use of proper containers, providing spill kit, proper drainage of
spillage to safe place, collection and recycle , Containers will be stored in at ground
level (singly or in stacks). This enables leaks or releases to be quickly seen, and allows
for any vapours to be dispersed effectively by natural ventilation.
v. Separation - Flammable liquids will be stored well away from other processes and
general storage areas. If necessary the storage will be separated by a physical barrier,
wall or partition.
192
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
8. Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) is maintained for each chemical to which workers are
exposed in the facility; Instructions have been followed as per the MSDS for handling
chemical and products.
9. Employees are trained for handing risks of each chemical being stored.
10. Spill cleanup kits have been provided in all areas where chemicals must be stored. A
written down procedure have been formulated and training imparted to employee for spill
control and cleaning.
11. Adequate and proper personal protective equipment have been provided and enforce to
use while working.
12. All chemicals are stored safely and securely. Chemicals have been stored away from
forklift traffic areas.
13. Drums / carboys of chemicals are stored in designated place in warehouse, separated by at
least one meter and have been arranged based upon the compatibility / non compatibility
properties. Provision of two gates for the warehouse is applied.
14. Sufficient fire extinguishers DCP Type & CO2 Type & Foam Type have been provided
inside the warehouse & at the entry.
Periodic retraining will normally be required. The training must include the following aspects-
Warehouse Design
Warehouse for the storage of chemicals in drums of the area must be constructed as per the
IS code 3594 and other relevant standards. Major points are from the code are given below -
193
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
1. Roadways around warehouse must be minimum 5 meters wide and compound gates
minimum 4.5 m wide
2. Floor areas - Warehouse must be divided to have maximum 750 m2 area by separating
walls. Dimensions Length x Width not exceeding 40 meter
3. Floors must have 2 hrs. fire resistance
4. Buildings used for storage of hazardous and extra-hazardous goods must be preferably of
single storied structure and in no case must exceed 2 stories in height
5. In no case must a storage building exceed 1S m in height
6. Floor Drainage - The floors must be of watertight construction and Scuppers of not less
than 20 cm sq. cross sectional area must be provided at no more than 6 m intervals or as
required to take care of maximum water discharge from hydrant / sprinkler system.
7. External Drainage - External drains of not less than 25 cm width and 30 cm depth must be
provided along the side of each building and so constructed that any flow of water from
the building be directed to a suitable ground tank or reservoir or public drainage system in
the vicinity not leading to a natural water source. No external drainage of warehouses
storing hazardous goods must be connected to public drainage system which leads
directly to a natural water source.
8. Every storage / warehouse building must have a minimum of two exit doorways, and at
the rate of one exit doorway per every 30 m length of the external walls of the building.
9. The means of exit as well as the exit ways, travel distances, etc. must be as per the
guidelines given in IS 1641:1988. If used for storage of hazardous goods, it must conform
to Type I of IS 1642:1989.
1. Dividing warehouse into fire compartments, by suitably designed firewalls, to limit the
spread of fire.
2. Limiting the quantity of hazardous chemicals stored.
3. It is safe practice to store explosive, self igniting, oxidizing and organic peroxides
separately, preferably in different compartments.
4. Storage of chemicals must be planned by categorizing these based on their hazardous
properties, like toxicity, flammability, explosibility for which MSDS needs to be critically
studied.
5. Based on the above, proper segregation of materials must be achieved.
6. Installation of smoke, fire and toxic gas leak detectors.
7. It must be easily possible to reach and attend toxic chemical leakage.
8. There must be enough space, and pathways for easy approach and escape.
9. Having all flameproof fittings inside the warehouse.
Adequate fire fighting arrangements inside the ware house and fire hydrant line is
available. Fire hydrant layout is appended at Appendix - M
194
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
195
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
196
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
Hazard Identification
Leakage HCL storage tank particularly will cause serious environment pollution problem and
may harm the workers in the factory, as TLV for HCL gas is = 3-5 ppm only.
Mitigation Measures
Following mitigation measures are suggested to minimize possibility of major leak from
HCL tank and air pollution in particular. But these are applicable and relevant for all
acid storage tanks.
HCL storage tank leakage can create serious risks, not only to people on-site, but also to the
emergency services, to the general public off-site and to the environment. The greatest risk of
significant harm is a large spill or leak from tanks or pipe work or associated plant. The main
causes of such incidents include -
When selecting the location of acid storage tanks, the consideration must be given to the
distance of the proposed tank farm from -
The tanks are aboveground and must be installed on the foundation (and the supports for
horizontal tanks). These must normally be of concrete with the required load bearing strength
and thickness.
197
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
Dyke walls
The tanks must be covered with the dyke walls. The purpose of the dyke wall is to -
1. Atmospheric tanks must have separate vent and overflow lines. The overflow must be
sized to prevent any pressure build up within the tank in the event of an overfill. The
overflow diameter must be equal to or greater than the inlet diameter. Normally, the
overflow is at least 100 mm (4 inches) in diameter and at least 350 mm below the vent
base. It must terminate as close to the ground as possible within the bund or other
contained area. To prevent fuming, a dip leg and small water lute can be used.
2. To prevent release of fumes into the atmosphere, vent lines of bulk acid tanks must feed
into a scrubber unit. The scrubber must be designed to cope with the fumes given off and
the pressures generated during the filling of the tank. The scrubber must be so designed
that HCL fumes escaping must be within the norms set by the statutory authorities.
3. Water, sodium hydroxide solution or dilute acid solution can be used as the scrubbing
medium. Provision must be made to monitor the pH of the scrubbing solutions.
4. Piping: While designing the piping and piping routing it is advisable to have minimum
flange joints. The line must be so routed to avoid walkways and joints over the walk
ways.
5. All pipe lines of acid, being of High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) MOC, must be
protected against foreseeable impact from vehicles or mobile plant.
198
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
Mitigation Measures
Dyke walls
Spill Protection Good practice suggests that the storage tank must be provided with a
retaining dike or other suitable secondary containment with a capacity of at least 110% of the
capacity of the storage tank. Where the storage tank might be a part of a tank farm, the dike
must normally be sized for at least 110% of the capacity of the largest tank in the tank farm.
Diked areas are primarily intended for emergency containment of major leaks. The floor must
be impervious and may have crushed limestone on top for neutralizing minor leaks must they
occur. Suitable materials of construction must be concrete, concrete block, or similar
materials, and could include polypropylene sheet linings or epoxy and polyester coatings.
Provision must be made for removing any accumulated rainwater that is not dissipated
through normal evaporation. The diking must be constructed to permit prompt recovery by
pumping directly into tank cars or transports, flushing the residue with copious quantities of
water to suitable treatment facilities in order to minimize personnel safety problems. See
"Spill and Vapor Control" section for additional recommendations.
Sulphuric Acid can be handled and used safely by following proper precautions based on
known effects of the chemical on personnel and equipment. Sulphuric acid is a very strong
acid which can severely burn skin and eyes and may be fatal if swallowed. Fumes from
sulfuric acid systems including SO2, SO3 and hydrogen are irritating and dangerous. They can
injure the lungs and mucous membranes if inhaled.
The principal health hazard from sulphuric acid is through contact of the acid with body
tissues, which can be severely burned, depending upon the length of contact and strength of
acid. Adequate protection must be provided to persons working with sulfuric acid.
1. Full face shield, hard hats, goggles and protective gloves are usually required during
routine operations which involve the handling of sulfuric acid. (Never wear contact lenses
when handling sulfuric acid)
2. Gloves must always be inspected prior to their use, and, if damage is suspected and not
visible, they must be tested with air pressure. Special arm protectors or glove inserts can
also be worn to prevent this from happening.
3. For full protection during tank car or transport unloading and during maintenance, each
workman must be fully clothed. He must wear goggles under a full face shield, a hard hat,
rubber safety boots, a rubber covered jacket and pants, and rubber gauntlet gloves. Tops
of the boots must be covered by the trousers. For emergency situations, a complete rubber
suit and rubber hood, with rubber gauntlet gloves and rubber safety boots, are
recommended.
4. In situations where fumes or mist from sulfuric acid are present, a NIOSH approved
respirator must be worn. Self-contained breathing equipment approved by NIOSH must
199
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
always be on hand and is required to be worn when working in areas of reduced oxygen
content such as when servicing empty sulfuric acid tanks.
5. Protective clothing must be washed and preferably neutralized after each use and checked
to insure that it is free of pinholes and tears.
6. The maintenance of all protective clothing and equipment must be a continuing operation
to ensure their ready availability for use in an emergency.
First Aid
1. Bodily Contact - Contaminated clothing must be removed under the shower and the
application of water must be continued for at least 15 minutes. If burns can still be felt,
consult a physician. Do not use burn ointments or alkali’s as they may hinder further
treatment. If acid enters the eyes, they must be washed thoroughly with water for at least
15 minutes. Consult a physician at once. If a physician is not immediately available, it is
advisable to continue the irrigation for another 15 minutes.
2. Ingestion - In case of ingestion and if the individual is conscious, have him drink large
amounts of lime water or milk of magnesia. If these are not readily available, drink large
amounts of water immediately to dilute the acid. Consult a physician at once. Do not give
emetics or baking soda. Inhalation if exposed to mist or vapors arising from sulfuric acid,
the individual must be removed at once to an uncontaminated area and a physician called.
The individual must be kept under observation until the possibility of developing a delayed
pulmonary reaction is no longer present. If oxygen inhalation apparatus is available,
oxygen may be administered under the direction of a physician.
3. Safety Showers and Eyewash Fountains - Continuous flow safety showers and eyewash
fountains must be conveniently located and clearly marked. Their location and use must be
known and understood by all personnel. Periodic inspections, preferably on a weekly
basis, must be made to insure that they are in proper working order at all times. It is
recommended they be equipped with both visible and audible alarms so that those in the
areas are alerted when someone may need assistance. Water temperature must be
approximately 27 °C (80 °F) to permit long periods of washing without adding to the
victim's discomfort.
1. Water must be in the form of a quick acting safety shower, protected against freezing, and
installed wherever sulfuric acid is handled.
2. Showers must provide deluge water rather than spray.
3. Eyewash fountains must also be provided.
4. The pathways to these water supplies must always be kept free and clear.
Environmental effects resulting in damage to plant and animal life can occur from releases of
sulfuric acid. Every effort must be taken to prevent discharge of this chemical into the
environment. Regulatory and / or disaster control agencies must be notified, as may be
applicable, of significant releases into the environment water, and neutralized with a lime
slurry, limestone, soda ash or other alkaline material. Care must be taken when adding water
or a neutralizer to a spill of sulfuric acid, as the chemical reaction will be immediate and can
200
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
be quite violent. Fumes from the reaction can be extensive and, if not handled properly, will
add to the severity of the situation. To minimize the reaction and fuming, the spill can be
covered with earth, sprayed with water and neutralized. The resulting slurry or residue can be
removed and transferred to an approved disposal site. Any remaining material can then be
further neutralized and flushed with water in accordance with local regulations. Major spills
may be handled in a similar manner, however, special assistance and / or procedures may be
required. In this case, evacuate the area, contain the spill or stop the leak if possible.
Refer Appendix - N for Hazard and Operability Study (HAZOP) study of Sulphuric Acid
plant.
With respect to Thionyl Chloride following precautions are special because of peculiar
dangers for man and environmental. It reacts violently with water. Contact with water
liberates toxic gas. Hence the drums of Thionyl Chloride are separately stored in a separate
area which is not covered with sprinkler system and in water tight containers. Spill Kit and
absorbing material used for removing the spill will be readily available in ample quantity.
Workers controlling the spill wear proper PPEs to strictly avoid contact with skin, as this is
very corrosive chemical. All other workers will evacuate the warehouse and / or area where
the spill has occurred. Siren will be sounded and higher authorities will be informed to take
necessary action. Actions to be taken in case of spill will form an important part of Onsite
Emergency Plan and mock drill.
Mitigation Measures
1. Thionyl Chloride reacts with water violently releasing toxic gases like SO2. Hence drums
will be stored in dry place and ensure that there is no water seepage or leakage etc. in the
area where drums are stored.
2. Operator vigilance and frequent checking of drum quality and condition and installation
of leak detectors is highly recommended.
3. Spill kits, recommended PPEs will be available all the time in sufficient quantities and in
an easily accessible place. Only trained operators will deal with leakages and alert
authorities.
4. No manual handling of even small quantities is recommended. If and when unavoidable,
it will be ensured that all the precautions necessary against sudden failure of the container
have been taken.
5. All necessary PPEs will be used while manually transferring of handling Thionyl
Chloride.
6. Use local ventilation exhausts conditions, if not possible use breathing apparatus,
recommended PPEs.
7. Workers need to be properly informed and trained to handle this.
8. As far as possible use suitable air operated pump to transfer Thionyl Chloride from the
work place to the user end.
9. Eye and shower facilities must be installed at the nearest possible position and it must be
ensured that it is always in working condition.
10. Spill kit must be kept handy to absorb small leaks and disposal.
201
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
Sr.
Name of Chemical NH NF NR
No.
1. Aluminum Chloride 3 0 0
2. Calcium Hydroxide 2 0 0
3. Iron Metal 1 2 1
4. Menthol 2 2 0
5. Para Nitro Aniline 2 1 0
6. Para Toluene Sulphonyl Chloride 3 1 2
7. Phenol 4 2 0
8. Phosphorous Pentoxide 3 0 2
9. Phthalic Anhydride 3 1 0
10. Potassium Carbonate 2 0 0
11. Red Phosphorus 1 1 1
12. Sodium Carbonate 2 0 1
13. Sodium Hydroxide 3 0 1
14. Sodium Nitrite 3 0 1
15. Sulphur precipitated 2 1 0
16. Urea 2 1 0
17. Acetyl Chloride 3 3 2
18. Aniline 3 2 0
19. Benzene Sulphonyl Chloride 2 1 2
20. Chlorosulphonic Acid 3 0 2
21. Hydrochloric Acid 3 0 1
22. Hydrochloric Acid 30 % 2 0 1
23. Hydrogen Peroxide 2 0 1
24. Lactic Acid 3 1 0
25. Mesitylene 0 2 0
26. Methane Sulphonic Acid 70 % 3 0 0
27. N-Butyl Amine 3 3 0
28. Nitric Acid 70 % 4 0 0
29. Nitric Acid 30 % 3 0 1
30. Phosphorous Trichloride 4 0 2
31. Silicon oil 0 1 0
32. Sulphur Trioxide 3 0 2
33. Sulphuric Acid 3 0 2
34. Thionyl Chloride 4 0 2
35. Benzene 2 3 0
36. Chlorobenzene 2 3 0
37. Ethyl Alcohol 2 3 0
38. Methyl Alcohol 1 3 0
39. Xylene 2 3 0
202
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
Sr.
Name of Chemical NH NF NR
No.
40. Sulphur Trioxide 3 0 2
Worst case scenarios for leakage / spillage of hazardous raw materials using ALOHA
software are done. This is summarized in following table -
Table 7.8 Risk Assessment - Worst Case Scenarios and Mitigation Measures
203
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
204
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
205
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
Many of the following mitigation / safety measures are already been installed and are in place
as plant is operational, the rest will be adopted -
1. QRA results of pool fire in case of Chlorobenzene, Sulphur Trioxide and Ethanol, i.e.
in the case of flammable solvents stored in the tank, the threat zones estimated for the
radiation effects are within or less than 10 meters in all the scenarios considered.
Because of less quantity stored.
2. However flame lengths estimated are in the range of 10 to 11 meters, which can cause
escalate the fire situations because of heating of the nearest tank.
3. Automatic Sprinkler system will be provided to counter this effect.
4. Tanks will be placed within the well designed dyke wall of 6 m by 12 meters to contain
and recover the spillage.
5. QRA results for toxic chemicals indicate that the threat zones as estimated based on
PAC values and other recommended values, workers inside the warehouse and factory
will be affected and on-site emergency plan will have to be put in action and if
necessary also Off site emergency plan will have to be activated, if the leakage gets
unnoticed for a long period of time like 30 to 60 minutes.
6. It is recommended to provide close watch on all the toxic chemicals stored for leak
detection by the alert staff.
7. Adequate training and retraining needs to be provided for the workers, including
contract workers.
8. Along with smoke detectors, adequate number of toxic gas leak detectors must be
installed inside the warehouse.
9. All manual handling of drums must be avoided.
10. Special and all recommended PPEs must be used while handling of toxic chemicals,
particularly suspect and confirmed carcinogenic chemicals.
11. Adequate spill kits in adequate quantities must be readily available inside the
warehouse and plant to deal effectively with spillages.
12. Boards in local language must be displayed instructing workers to effectively deal with
spillages and leakages.
206
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
The hazard of fire is very essential to identify because the direct impact of fire or explosion is
on the worker or the operator who is actually operating in the accident areas. So to prevent
the fire, number of fire extinguishers, smoke detectors have already been implemented in
respective unit areas. Details of same are as follows -
207
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
Fire Load = (M x C) /A
Where, M= Combustible quantity in Kg
C= Calorific value of combustible in kcal/Kg
A= Total Area in sq mtr
363 KL (290.4 MT, 290400 Kg), Calorific value: 7098.47 kcal/Kg, Total Area: 88355 m2
Fire Load = (290400 x 7098.47) / 88355 = 23330.8 Kcal / m2
Benzene -
23 KL (19.78 MT, 19780 Kg), Calorific Value: 10111 kcal/Kg, Total Area: 88355 m2
Fire Load = (19780 x 10111)/88355 = 2263.5 Kcal / m2
Diethyl ether -
(50 MT, 50000 Kg), Calorific Value: 10277.24 kcal/Kg , Total Area: 88355 m2
Fire Load = (50000 x 10277.24)/88355 = 5815.9 Kcal / m2
208
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
Sulphur -
(5000 MT, 5000000 Kg), Calorific Value: 2198.8 kcal/Kg , Total Area: 88355 m2
Fire Load = (5000000 x 2198.8)/88355 = 124429.8 Kcal / m2
HSD -
(1.935 MT, 1935 Kg), Calorific Value: 10707.45 kcal/Kg , Total Area: 88355 m2
Fire Load = (1935 x 2198.8)/88355 = 234.49 Kcal / m2
Furnace Oil -
(47.5 MT, 47500 Kg), Calorific Value: 10500 kcal/Kg, Total Area: 88355 m2
Fire Load = (47500 x 10500)/88355 = 5644.8 Kcal / m2
Refer Appendix - Q for Hazard Identification and Risk Analysis (HIRA), Immediately
Dangerous to Life or Health (IDLH), Maximum Credible Loss Scenario (MCLS).
OHC has been provided as per factories act. Health checkup of all employees and contract
labors have been carried out before employment and at regular intervals and record for the
same are maintained. It is ensured that adequate stock of critical anti-dote for toxic chemicals
are always kept in the OHC.
Company has prepared well designed health check up plan for its employees and contract
workers. Health check-up parameters have been identified based upon the chemicals to which
workers are likely to be exposed. Some of the parameters are given below -
209
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
Note: Antidote for the chemicals can be suggested by the health officer and appropriate
actions shall be taken.
1. Receive recommendations from the Safety Committee and evaluate them for
implementation.
2. Inspect the scene of accidents and investigate cases thereof.
3. Present reports to the Safety Committee of safety activities.
4. Study reports and recommendation from the Factory Inspector and implement
recommendation.
5. Organize safety captions; arrange safety posters and the display thereof.
6. Arrange and distribute safety literature with a view to promote safety consciousness.
7. Liaison with labor institutions, Factory Inspector and other bodies. Promote safety
measures with a view to improve methods, appliances, apparel etc.
8. Ensure that the contractor and his employees working in the premises of the company
observe safe method of work.
9. Maintain a register recording minutes of committee Meeting and show the register to
Factory Inspector during his visit to the Factory.
The company has 85 skilled and 100 unskilled workers presently employed. There is OHC
center at the site fulfilling all the requirements of the factory act, based upon the number of
workers employed. The same facilities will be expanded for additional workers, likely to be
employed after expansion. Special medical tests need to be included in the pre employment
and six monthly and annual medical checkups of the workers, as numbers of toxic chemicals
as well as suspect and confirmed carcinogenic chemicals are handled. This has to done in
consultations with the experienced and professional doctor and it has to be ensured that stock
210
ADDITIONAL STUDIES…7
of necessary anti-dote for toxic chemicals will be always available at OHC It will be ensured
that adequate stock of critical anti-dote for toxic chemicals will be always kept in the OHC.
Refer Appendix - S for On-site Emergency Plan has already been incorporated for existing
plant.
Industry has clearly defined EHS policy and it must be known to all employees and must be
properly displayed.
Industry has clearly defined Quality policy and it must be known to all employees and must
be properly displayed.
211
Chapter 8
PROJECT BENEFITS
PROJECT BENEFITS…8
Any industrial activity helps in improving the social status of the locality. Existing project by
TDMCCL has helped in improvement of infrastructure and social structure in the command
area and has lead to sustainable development. Also, after expansion, community that inhabit
in the nearby areas will be benefited directly or indirectly by this expansion project.
Following benefits due to the proposed expansion project are expected.
Due to a number of actions and planning proposed by the TDMCCL management, status of
physical infrastructure in command area of the industry is bound to improve. Thus there shall
be a positive impact on this aspect. Following are certain steps that the industry would take -
Benefits of TDMCCL projects in improving overall socioeconomic status of the study area
are as under -
Presence of TDMCCL has created enormous potential towards creating employment in the
region. Both primary and secondary jobs and contract jobs are created which principally
benefit the local residents. As much as 75% of the nearby villagers have been employed
under existing set up of TDMCCL. Same practice shall be continued under the expansion
projects also.
The people residing in the nearby areas are benefited from CER activities being carried out
by the project proponents such as assistance to educational facilities in the study area that
have helpedin enhancing the literacy rate. Subsequent to expansion an amount of Rs.
25.00 Lakhs is earmarked for CER activities in study area.
Due to the awareness programs, taken up by the Industry, people residing in nearby areas
have been benefited. This includes education, ecology and biodiversity conservation,
environment awareness etc.
The industry shall organize various campaigns and workshops regarding medical and
health check up for workers/labours. This will help improve overall health status.
The details about CER already undertaken by TDMCCL through existing unit are as
follows-
212
PROJECT BENEFITS…8
Table 8.1 Yearly Expenses incurred on CER & Social Welfare (In INR)
An amount of Rs. 25.00 Lakhs have been earmarked towards proposed activities under CER
plan. The same is about 2.5% of Capital investment Rs. 10.00Crs. Detailed CER plan have
been at chapter 6. (Section 6.6)
In any industrial activityall three types i.e. skilled, semi skilled and unskilled people are
required. In TDMCCL preference is given for employment to local people based on
qualification and requirement. Under existing unit 75 - 80 % of employees are from local
populace.As TDMCCL has planned for expansion of existing commodity chemicals and
speciality chemicals availability of employment may further enhance. Hence, it can be stated
that by the existing and proposed activities in TDMCCL, employment potential certainly will
have positive impact for all the three classes namely - skilled, semi-skilled and unskilled.
After execution of the project the above mentioned benefits shall accrue. Apart from this
other tangible benefits which could result are mentioned below-
After expansion, the industry will meet the national interest of economical growth through
sustainable development, as the there is a good demand of products in India as well as
abroad. Out of the total products more than 60 - 75 % of the products will be exported.
First Aid Training and fire safety training will be given to all the workers.
Insurance Policies for the workers will be made available.
Improvement in the aesthetic through green belt development.
The ground water recharging shall be done by arresting rain water.
213
Chapter 9
ENVIRONMENTAL
MANAGEMENT PLAN (EMP)
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN...9
9.1 INTRODUCTION
The EMP aims at controlling pollution at source with available and affordable technology
followed by treatment measures. Waste minimization and waste recycling measures are
emphasized. In addition to the Industry specific control measures, the proposed expansion
industry would adopt following guidelines -
The EMP is prepared based on the existing environmental status of the project location and
the anticipated impacts of the project activities on environment.
214
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN...9
Managing Director
Effective implementation of Management Plan
Factory Incharge
Explaining all the activities within their units related
to Health, Safety and Environment (HSE)
Members of the Environmental Management Cell would be well qualified and experienced in
the concerned fields. Some of the routine tests of waste water such as pH, solids, temperature
etc. would be carried out in the laboratory to be established on proposed project site. Also,
for additional tests of water, waste water, soil, air etc. services of accreditated laboratories as
well as that of a consultant would be hired.
Checking/Corrective Action
Implementation
Monitoring & Measurement
Implementation of EMP in the plants
Non-conformance and Corrective and
Document Control
Preventive Action
Operational Control
Records
Emergency Preparedness/Response
EMS Audits
215
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN...9
The mitigation measures suggested for proposed expansion unit in Chapter - 4 would be
implemented. This will reduce the impact on environment due to the proposed expansion
project. To facilitate easy implementation, the recommendations suggested are grouped in
different phases. The important measures are implemented in earlier unit and some few are
planned under expansion project.
216
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN...9
217
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN...9
218
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN...9
Following compliance against the consent conditions after commissioning of project would
be observed under the Water (Prevention & Control of Pollution) Act, 1974, Air (Prevention
& Control of Pollution) Act 1981, Hazardous Waste (Management, Handling &
Transboundary Movement) Rules 2010.
219
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN...9
BOD Incubator
COD reflux assembly
Refrigerator
Thermometer
pH meter
Stop watch
Distilled water plant
Pipette box
Titration set
Relevant chemicals and glass wares
Noise Levels
Sound level meter in different scales like A, B and C with slow and fast response options.
Soil Characteristics
Following activities are undertaken by TDMCCL under existing unit and same practice shall
be followed after commissioning of expansion activity towards CREP norms -
As there is minimum quantity of effluent generated; TDMCCL have single stream for
effluent treatment process.
Installation of Heat Pump Based Effluent to Distilled Water Convertor for Zero
Discharge of effluent. The installation and commissioning of this facility will be
completed within short period.
220
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN...9
Proper infrastructure for handling and storage of hazardous waste. As per nature it would
be forwarded to CHWTSDF / Authorized Re-processor.
For control of air pollutants APC Equipment must be provided. To control the process
emissions scrubbers to be provided.
Post project implementation: Environmental Monitoring & Environmental Auditing to be
carried out regularly.
Environment Management Cell and Certification System
221
Chapter 10
10.1 INTRODUCTION
This EIA report has been prepared for proposed expansion of existing commodity chemicals
and speciality chemicals manufacturing unit by TDMCCL located at Plot No. 105 in MIDC
Industrial Area, P.O. Dhatav, Taluka: Roha, District: Raigad, State: Maharashtra. The
company has taken into consideration the need to meet the demands of the international
market; the proponents of the industry have planned to go for expansion of manufacturing of
proposed commodity chemicals and speciality chemicals manufacturing unit.
This report is made in the overall context of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)
Notification No. S.O.1533 (E) dated 14.09.2006 and amendments thereto issued by the
Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC); New Delhi. As per the
provision of “EIA Notification No. S.O. 1533 (E)” dated 14.09.2006; amended on
25.06.2014, the proposed project comes under Category - “B”. But in light of Draft
Notification of the Eco-Sensitive Areas (ESA) for Western Ghats published by
MoEFCC dated 10.03.2014, 04.09.2015, 27.02.2017 and 03.10.2018 therein village Dhatav,
wherein the Roha MIDC is setup have appeared in the list of ESA villages for Western Ghats.
Accordingly, the category of the project changes from ‘Category - B’ to ‘Category - A’.
Existing capital investment of TDMCCL is Rs. 84.07 Cr. For the proposed expansion, capital
investment will be Rs.10.00 Cr. Total capital investment will be Rs. 94.07 Cr.
222
SUMMARY & CONCLUSION...10
The details of products that are being manufactured under existing as well as those to be
manufactured under expansion are presented in the following table -
223
SUMMARY & CONCLUSION...10
224
SUMMARY & CONCLUSION...10
B) List of Byproducts -
The details of raw material consumption w. r.t existing and proposed expansion products are
presented in following table. Moreover, product-wise of raw materials required for existing
and proposed activity, are presented at Appendix - E.
Table 10.4 List of Collective quantity of Raw material required per batch
225
SUMMARY & CONCLUSION...10
Refer Appendix - E for details on manufacturing processes, processes flow charts, mass
balance for each product.
226
SUMMARY & CONCLUSION...10
Total water requirement after expansion for proposed project would be 1592 CMD. Out
of which 220 CMD (14 %) would be treated water from ETP whereas 1372 CMD (86 %)
would be fresh water taken from MIDC water supply scheme. Fresh water requirement for
project is met from the MIDC water supply scheme. The MIDC procures water from
Kundalika River and after treatment the same is provided to different industries in the
MIDC. Refer Appendix - F for Certificate of Merit for Water Resource Management in
Chemical Industry by Indian Chemical Council (ICC) and Appendix - G for Water
Permission Letter.
From fact presented above, it is observed that through change in product mix additional
permission is not required for fresh water under proposed expansion. Current permission for
fresh water granted in valid CTO is adequate under proposed expansion.
Effluent generated from existing manufacturing and utility operations is to the tune of 209.6
CMD which is treated in existing ETP of 300 CMD capacity comprising of Primary,
Secondary and Tertiary treatment operations. At present, the treated water from ETP,
achieving prescribed standards is discharged to Common Effluent Treatment Plant (CETP),
Roha. Presently, domestic wastewater is treated in septic tanks followed by soak pits. The
overflow from soak pits is used for gardening purpose.
Industrial effluent generated from spillages, leakages and floor washings from all process
plants, comes to the grit chamber through underground pipelines. Oily mater that floats on the
top is skimmed off. The effluent is then taken to the equalization tanks from where it is sent
to the neutralizer. Lime slurry is prepared in the slurry tank. Lime slurry can be fed to the
equalization tank or to the neutralizer. pH of the effluent is maintained between 7-8.
Neutralized effluent is then pumped to the primary clarifier. The clear water from the top of
the clarifier overflows into the two bio-reactors which are in series and sludge from the
bottom of primary clarifier is fed to fully automatic pneumatic filter. Filtrate from the filter is
pumped back to the primary clarifier. Water from bioreactors overflows into the secondary
clarifier. Water from the secondary clarifier is passed through tertiary filter (carbon and sand
filter) by pump. This water is pumped to the CETP through MIDC sewers sludge from the
bottom of secondary clarifier is fed to fully automatic pneumatic filter. Dry filter cake is sent
to CHWTSDF, Taloja, Mumbai for final disposal. Refer Appendix - H for Certificate of
Merit for Efficient Waste Management in Chemical Industry by Indian Chemical Council
(ICC) and Appendix - I for CHWTSDF Membership Letter.
Under expansion, the management has decided to achieve Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD) by
installation of evaporators and the condensate would be recycled in industrial operations. No
any effluent would be discharged outside the premises. Moreover, for domestic waste water,
STP of 20 CMD is proposed. The treated water from STP would be used for gardening.
From fact presented above, it is observed that current ETP has the capacity to treat additional
load from expansion through change in product mix.
227
SUMMARY & CONCLUSION...10
Under existing unit as well as proposed expansion main source of emissions are boiler,
thermopack and DG Sets. Major emissions are in the form of suspended particulate matter
(SPM), SOx and NOx.
The existing boiler (5TPH capacity) is operated on Furnace oil (FO) @ 63 kg/hr with
adequate stack height of 35 m and Thermic Fluid Heater (TFH, 4 lakhs Kcal/hr capacity)
is operated on High speed diesel (HSD) @ 47 kg/hr with stack height of 30 m are
provided on site.
DG sets of capacities 125, 830 and 1310 KVA are operated on HSD / Light diesel oil
(LDO) @ 210 kg/hr with adequate stack height of 4.20 m, 7.70 m, 7.70 m respectively
above roof level (ARL). DG sets are used only in case of power failure.
Moreover, process emissions are in the form of acidic / alkaline / solvent vapours emitted
from existing. The same is taken care off through seven scrubbers each of 5 kg/hr
capacity. Existing scrubbers will be utilized under expansion activity.
Existing boiler, TFH and DG sets are sufficient for proposed expansion. Boiler runs
occasionally as steam is available from Sulphuric acid plant only. (Steam generated from
Sulphuric Acid Plant : 335 MTD at 40 kg/cm2 at 4000C)
Source of noise generation would be the Boiler House, Reactors, Compressors, DG Set,
Water treatment Plant, ETP etc.
Major source of noise generation would be the Boiler house. Insulation helps in limiting
noise levels. The workers entering inside the plant are protected by earmuffs, which
would give the reduction of 30 dB (A).
D.G. Sets shall be enclosed in a separate canopy to reduce the noise levels.
Green belt is developed to attenuate the noise levels.
Solid wastes generated from the existing as well as expansion activities are categorized as
Hazardous and Non-Hazardous Wastes. Details of solid waste generated / to be generated
from existing & expansion activities are given in following table -
Table 10.5 Solid Waste Details for Existing and Expansion Activities
228
SUMMARY & CONCLUSION...10
Table 10.6 Hazardous Waste Details for Existing and Expansion Activities
Quantity (kg/Day)
Type of
Sr.
Hazardous Category Disposal
No. Existing Expansion Total
Solid Waste
Chemical CHWTSDF,
Sludge from Taloja / Sale
1. 35.3 833 109 942
Waste Water to Authorized
Treatment Party
Residues , Dust Membership
2. 17.1 203 0 203 No. - MWML
or Filter cakes
- HzW - ROH
4000 4000 - 313
3. Spent Catalyst 17.2 0
Lit./Annum Lit./Annum (Valid up to
21.03.2020)
There are different odour sources in the existing set up, which include raw material & product
storage places, process operations, loading / unloading sections etc. which could give rise to
smell nuisance. To abate the odour problem, the industry has taken following steps under its
existing unit. The same practice shall be adopted under expansion.
All the feed, loading and unloading pumps for products and raw materials are fitted with
mechanical seals instead of glands to reduce leakages through pumps.
The products and raw materials loading and unloading area are provided with fumes
extraction system comprising of circulation pump with blower and scrubber. The bulk
storage tanks are connected to scrubber for taking care of fumes coming out from vent.
The scrubbers are filled with plain water depending on the nature of the fumes.
Adoption of Good Management Practices (GMPs).
Arranging awareness and training camps for workers.
Provision and use of PPE’s like masks by everybody associated with odour potential
prone areas.
Installation of appropriate, adequate and efficient exhaust and ventilation system to
remove and control odour from work zone areas.
Being a chemical based industry here collection of the rainwater getting accumulated from
direct precipitation on the total roof area will take in to account.
229
SUMMARY & CONCLUSION...10
The total plot area of TDMCCL is 88355 m2 (8.84 Ha). An area of 40925 m2 is the actual area
on which the industrial activities are carried out. As per MoEFCC norm 2.95 Ha area (around
4425 trees) is to be brought under green belt which accounts for 33 % of plot area. But under
existing unit only 1000 trees have been planted. Under expansion, green belt will be
augmented by 3500 No. of trees. After commissioning of the expansion the existing green
belt shall be subsequently augmented in phase wise manner. Thick plantation barrier will be
provided on the periphery of the MIDC industrial plot. Augmentation of avenue tree
plantation along all the internal and approach roads shall be done. Refer Figure 2.7 for
Photographs of Existing green belt.
The project management will carry out the monitoring regularly and record shall be
maintained of the same. For details w.r.t. post monitoring program to be conducted; refer
Chapter - 9 (Section 9.5).
The Environment Management Plan aims at controlling pollution at source with available and
affordable technology followed by treatment measures. Under the existing unit of TDMCCL
has effectively implemented the EMP. As a part of the EMP, it is essential to formulate an
Environmental Management Cell (EMC). The TDMCCL is already having a cell functioning
under existing project. The cell works under Managing Director of the Industry and
responsible persons from certain departments have been taken as members. For more details,
the separate chapter on EMP may be referred.
10.10 CONCLUSION
Driven by the rapidly growing population and increasing consumer spending, the specialty
chemicals and or commodity chemicals market in emerging economies is expected to witness
a good growth in the coming years. The growing middle-class population in these economies
and rising industrialization in the fields of food, agriculture, cosmetics and many other
manufacturing sectors are creating the demand of these chemicals in emerging economies.
230
SUMMARY & CONCLUSION...10
BRICS countries such as China, India and Brazil especially, are witnessing increased demand
of specialty chemicals.
The proposed expansion project is further beneficial for society without hampering the
environment and thereby accomplishing the aim of sustainable development.
231
Chapter 11
DISCLOSURE OF CONSULTANT
ORGANIZATION
DISCLOSURE OF CONSULTANTS …11
Equinox Environments (India) Pvt. Ltd. (EEIPL) is a major company under the 'Equinox
Group'. It is one of the leading environmental consultants in the country and renders all the
environmental services, under one roof, needed by various industries. EEIPL is an ISO
9001:2015 certified organization (DNV-GL) that has been duly accredited through QCI -
NABET for the Ministry of Environment, Forest& Climate Change (MoEFCC); New Delhi
as recognized and approved ‘Environmental Consultant’ at the National Level. EEIPL
operates through its offices located in Kolhapur, Pune, New Mumbai, New Delhi, Hydrabad
and Baltimore (US). Through the organization, various services are offered that are related to
environmental engineering, pollution control & itsabatement, industrial safety, health
&hygiene. EEIPL's set up comprises of engineers, eminent scientists, chemists, technicians &
associates. Moreover, organization is having back up of a most modern laboratory
infrastructure. NABL accredited lab, also approved by Govt. of India through the MoEF;
New Delhi has received OHSAS 18001:2007 certifications from DNV GL.
The 'Equinox Group' is in the environmental business for last nineteen years and have
rendered services as well as expert consultation to a number of industries such as sugar
factories, power plants, distilleries, foundries, sponge iron & steel plants, textile industries,
bulk drug manufacturing units and chemical industries, food processing & beverage
manufacturing units, asbestos products & roofing, timber and particle board Industries etc.
Further our website -www.equinoxenvi.com- may be visited for additional details regarding
our activities, achievements and list of our esteemed clients as well as our Key Personnel.
232
233
NATIONAL ACCREDITATION BOARD FOR EDUCATION & TRAINING
QUALITY COUNCIL OF INDIA
QCI Office, 6th Floor, ITPI Building, Ring Road, I.P. Estate, New Delhi
Scheme for Accreditation of EIA Consultant Organizations
Accreditation Committee Meeting for Surveillance Assessment held on
February 09, 2018
Prof. B.B. Dhar, Dr. Nalini Bhat , Prof. C.P. Kaushik and Prof. G.J. Chakrapani expressed their inability to
attend the meeting.
Mr. A.K. Jha – Senior Director, Dr.S.K Mishra – Joint Director, Dr. Pawan Kumar Singh – Assisstant
Director and Ms.Meenakshi Arora – Accreditation Officer were present in the meeting.
The following case was discussed and decisions taken as noted below.
The ACO has been assessed as per Version 3 of the Scheme. Result of the 2nd Surveillance assessment
(SA) is given below :
ACO has scored more than 60% marks. Hence, the organization accreditation is continued with
Cat.A.
Sector No.(MoEFCC
NABET
Sl. Cat. Notification dated Sep.
Scheme Sector Description
No. 14, 2006 and
Sectors
Amendments)
Mining of minerals including opencast /
1 1 A 1 (a) (i)
underground mining
2 4 Thermal power plants B 1 (d)
234
3 8 Metallurgical industries both primary & secondary B 3 (a)
4 12 Asbestos milling and asbestos based products A 4 (c )
5 13 Chlor-alkali industry A 4 (d)
Pesticides industry and pesticide specific
6 17 A 5 (b)
intermediates (excluding formulations)
Petro-chemical complexes (industries based on
7 18 processing of petroleum fractions & natural gas A 5 (c)
and/or reforming to aromatics)
Petrochemical based processing (processes other
8 20 than cracking &reformation and not covered under A 5 (e)
the complexes)
Synthetic organic chemicals industry (dyes & dye
intermediates; bulk drugs and intermediates
9 21 excluding drug formulations; synthetic rubbers; A 5 (f)
basic organic chemicals, other synthetic organic
chemicals and chemical intermediates)
10 22 Distilleries A 5 (g)
11 25 Sugar Industry B 5 (j)
Common hazardous waste treatment, storage and
12 32 A 7 (d)
disposal facilities (TSDFs)
Common municipal solid waste management
13 37 B 7 (i)
facility (CMSWMF)
14 38 Building and construction projects B 8 (a)
15 39 Townships and Area development projects B 8 (b)
16 40(ii) Electro Plating and metal Processing A -
17 40(v) Food Processing A -
b. Assessed as per IA norms – for new Sectors of approved ECs and fresh ECs proposed:
235
236
237
238
239
Speed Post
File No. Q-15018/18/20'1 5-CPW
Government of India
M in i stry ot e nvi ro n m,eif o c m ate
Ii
" ",
Bl",.tl"'"i
:l].l: r""" ra n Bh awa n,
Wing'
2nd" Floor Prithvi
Jor Bagh Road, Aliganj'
New Delhi - 110 003'
Dated: 12th November, 2015'
To,
M/s Horizon Services (Anatytical Laboratory)'
Shree K3/4, S. N.10'
Erandawane Housing SocietY'
Opposite Deenanath Mangeshkar Hospital'
Pune-41 1 004, Maharashtra
Subject:Renewa|ofrecognitionor{UsHorizonServiceo(Analytica|Laboratory)'
shreeK3/4,s.N.l0,ErandawaneHousingsociety,oppositeDeenanath
as Environmental
Mangeshkar Hospital, Pune411.004' Iri'aharashira
Labo-ratory under tire Environment (Protection)
Act' 1986 - reg'
Sir,
P|easerefertoyourapp|icationseekingrenewa|ofrecognitionofyourlaboratory
by the competent authority, it has
under Environment (protection)Act,1gg6.As approved
been decided to accord renewal of recognition
to your Environmental laboratory under
Environment(Protection;Act,1986Theterms&conditionsasgivenintheAnnexure-
ll|,lv&Vhavea|readybeenagreedbyyou'Furtheractiontonotifyyour|aboratoryinthe
official gazette is being taken'
YouarerequestedtoparticipateintheAnalytica|QualityControl(AQC)exerctse
pollution control Board and provide quarterly monitoring reports
conducted by the central
of your lab.
|tmaybenotedthatperiodicsurvei||anceof.recognizedEnvironmentalLaboratory
underEnvironment(Protection)Act,lg86willbeund.ertakenbyCentralGovt./CPCBto
assesstheproperfunctloning,systematicoperationandre|iabilityofdatageneratedatthe
laboratory
Your's faithfullY,
546
241
ENCLOSURE - I
STANDARD ToR LETTER
No.IA-J-11011/74/2018-IA-II(I)
Goverment of India
Minister of Enviroment,Forest and Climate Change
Impact Assessment Division
***
To,
Tel.No.2194-63553; Email:shirish.pandit23@gmail.com
Sir/Madam,
This has reference to the proposal submitted in the Ministry of Environment, Forest
and Climate Change to prescribe the Terms of Reference (TOR) for undertaking detailed EIA
study for the purpose of obtaining Environmental Clearance in accordance with the provisions of
the EIA Notification, 2006. For this purpose, the proponent had submitted online information in the
prescribed format (Form-1 ) along with a Pre-feasibility Report. The details of the proposal are
given below:
In this regard, under the provisions of the EIA Notification 2006 as amended, the Standard TOR
for the purpose of preparing environment impact assessment report and environment
management plan for obtaining prior environment clearance is prescribed with public consultation
as follows:
242
STANDARD TERMS OF REFERENCE (TOR) FOR EIA/EMP REPORT FOR PROJECTS/
ACTIVITIES REQUIRING ENVIRONMENT CLEARANCE
243
STANDARD TERMS OF REFERENCE (TOR) FOR EIA/EMP REPORT FOR
PROJECTS/ACTIVITIES REQUIRING ENVIRONMENT CLEARANCE
addition, status of compliance of Consent to Operate for the ongoing Iexisting operation
of the project from SPCB shall be attached with the EIA-EMP report.
d. In case the existing project has not obtained environmental clearance, reasons for not
taking EC under the provisions of the EIA Notification 1994 and/or EIA Notification
2006 shall be provided. Copies of Consent to Establish/No Objection Certificate and
Consent to Operate (in case of units operating prior to EIA Notification 2006, CTE and
CTO of FY 2005-2006) obtained from the SPCB shall be submitted. Further, compliance
report to the conditions of consents from the SPCB shall be submitted.
4) Site Details
i. Location of the project site covering village, Taluka/Tehsil, District and State, Justification
for selecting the site, whether other sites were considered.
ii. A toposheet of the study area of radius of 10km and site location on 1:50,000/1:25,000 scale
on an A3/A2 sheet. (including all eco-sensitive areas and environmentally sensitive places)
iii. Details w.r.t. option analysis for selection of site
iv. Co-ordinates (lat-long) of all four corners of the site.
v. Google map-Earth downloaded of the project site.
vi. Layout maps indicating existing unit as well as proposed unit indicating storage area, plant
area, greenbelt area, utilities etc. If located within an Industrial area/Estate/Complex, layout
of Industrial Area indicating location of unit within the Industrial area/Estate.
vii. Photographs of the proposed and existing (if applicable) plant site. If existing, show
photographs of plantation/greenbelt, in particular.
viii. Landuse break-up of total land of the project site (identified and acquired), government/
private - agricultural, forest, wasteland, water bodies, settlements, etc shall be included. (not
required for industrial area)
ix. A list of major industries with name and type within study area (10km radius) shall be
incorporated. Land use details of the study area
x. Geological features and Geo-hydrological status of the study area shall be included.
xi. Details of Drainage of the project upto 5km radius of study area. If the site is within 1 km
radius of any major river, peak and lean season river discharge as well as flood occurrence
frequency based on peak rainfall data of the past 30 years. Details of Flood Level of the
project site and maximum Flood Level of the river shall also be provided. (mega green field
projects)
xii. Status of acquisition of land. If acquisition is not complete, stage of the acquisition process
and expected time of complete possession of the land.
xiii. R&R details in respect of land in line with state Government policy.
244
STANDARD TERMS OF REFERENCE (TOR) FOR EIA/EMP REPORT FOR PROJECTS/
ACTIVITIES REQUIRING ENVIRONMENT CLEARANCE
245
STANDARD TERMS OF REFERENCE (TOR) FOR EIA/EMP REPORT FOR
PROJECTS/ACTIVITIES REQUIRING ENVIRONMENT CLEARANCE
x. Detailed description of flora and fauna (terrestrial and aquatic) existing in the study area
shall be given with special reference to rare, endemic and endangered species. If Schedule-
I fauna are found within the study area, a Wildlife Conservation Plan shall be prepared and
furnished.
xi. Socio-economic status of the study area.
7) Impact and Environment Management Plan
i. Assessment of ground level concentration of pollutants from the stack emission based on
site-specific meteorological features. In case the project is located on a hilly terrain, the
AQIP Modelling shall be done using inputs of the specific terrain characteristics for
determining the potential impacts of the project on the AAQ. Cumulative impact of all sources
of emissions (including transportation) on the AAQ of the area shall be assessed. Details of
the model used and the input data used for modelling shall also be provided. The air quality
contours shall be plotted on a location map showing the location of project site, habitation
nearby, sensitive receptors, if any.
ii. Water Quality modelling - in case of discharge in water body
iii. Impact of the transport of the raw materials and end products on the surrounding environment
hall be assessed and provided. In this regard, options for transport of raw materials and
finished products and wastes (large quantities) by rail or rail-cum road transport or conveyor-
cum-rail transport shall be examined.
iv. A note on treatment of wastewater from different plant operations, extent recycled and reused
for different purposes shall be included. Complete scheme of effluent treatment. Characteristics
of untreated and treated effluent to meet the prescribed standards of discharge under E(P)
Rules.
v. Details of stack emission and action plan for control of emissions to meet standards.
vi. Measures for fugitive emission control
vii. Details of hazardous waste generation and their storage, utilization and management. Copies
of MOU regarding utilization of solid and hazardous waste in cement plant shall also be
included. EMP shall include the concept of waste-minimization, recycle/reuse/recover
techniques, Energy conservation, and natural resource conservation.
viii. Proper utilization of fly ash shall be ensured as per Fly Ash Notification, 2009. A detailed
plan of action shall be provided.
ix. Action plan for the green belt development plan in 33 % area i.e. land with not less than
1,500 trees per ha. Giving details of species, width of plantation, planning schedule etc. shall
be included. The green belt shall be around the project boundary and a scheme for greening
of the roads used for the project shall also be incorporated.
x. Action plan for rainwater harvesting measures at plant site shall be submitted to harvest
rainwater from the roof tops and storm water drains to recharge the ground water and also to
246
STANDARD TERMS OF REFERENCE (TOR) FOR EIA/EMP REPORT FOR PROJECTS/
ACTIVITIES REQUIRING ENVIRONMENT CLEARANCE
use for the various activities at the project site to conserve fresh water and reduce the water
requirement from other sources.
xi. Total capital cost and recurring cost/annum for environmental pollution control measures
shall be included.
xii. Action plan for post-project environmental monitoring shall be submitted.
xiii. Onsite and Offsite Disaster (natural and Man-made) Preparedness and Emergency Management
Plan including Risk Assessment and damage control. Disaster management plan should be
linked with District Disaster Management Plan.
8) Occupational health
i. Plan and fund allocation to ensure the occupational health & safety of all contract and casual
workers
ii. Details of exposure specific health status evaluation of worker. If the workers' health is being
evaluated by pre designed format, chest x rays, Audiometry, Spirometry, Vision testing (Far
& Near vision, colour vision and any other ocular defect) ECG, during pre placement and
periodical examinations give the details of the same. Details regarding last month analyzed
data of above mentioned parameters as per age, sex, duration of exposure and department
wise.
iii. Details of existing Occupational & Safety Hazards. What are the exposure levels of hazards
and whether they are within Permissible Exposure level (PEL). If these are not within PEL,
what measures the company has adopted to keep them within PEL so that health of the workers
can be preserved,
iv. Annual report of heath status of workers with special reference to Occupational Health and
Safety.
9) Corporate Environment Policy
i. Does the company have a well laid down Environment Policy approved by its Board of
Directors? If so, it may be detailed in the EIA report.
ii. Does the Environment Policy prescribe for standard operating process / procedures to bring
into focus any infringement / deviation / violation of the environmental or forest norms /
conditions? If so, it may be detailed in the EIA.
iii. What is the hierarchical system or Administrative order of the company to deal with the
environmental issues and for ensuring compliance with the environmental clearance
conditions? Details of this system may be given.
iv. Does the company have system of reporting of non compliances / violations of environmental
norms to the Board of Directors of the company and / or shareholders or stakeholders at
large? This reporting mechanism shall be detailed in the EIA report
247
STANDARD TERMS OF REFERENCE (TOR) FOR EIA/EMP REPORT FOR
PROJECTS/ACTIVITIES REQUIRING ENVIRONMENT CLEARANCE
10) Details regarding infrastructure facilities such as sanitation, fuel, restroom etc. to be provided to the
labour force during construction as well as to the casual workers including truck drivers during
operation phase.
11) Enterprise Social Commitment (ESC)
i. Adequate funds (at least 2.5 % of the project cost) shall be earmarked towards the Enterprise
Social Commitment based on Public Hearing issues and item-wise details along with time
bound action plan shall be included. Socio-economic development activities need to be
elaborated upon.
12) Any litigation pending against the project and/or any direction/order passed by any Court of Law
against the project, if so, details thereof shall also be included. Has the unit received any notice
under the Section 5 of Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 or relevant Sections of Air and Water
Acts? If so, details thereof and compliance/ATR to the notice(s) and present status of the case.
13) 'A tabular chart with index for point wise compliance of above TOR.
248
STANDARD TERMS OF REFERENCE (TOR) FOR EIA/EMP REPORT FOR PROJECTS/
ACTIVITIES REQUIRING ENVIRONMENT CLEARANCE
***
249
811
Scanned by CamScanner