Performance Optimization of Combined Cycle Power Plant Considering Various Operating Parameters
Performance Optimization of Combined Cycle Power Plant Considering Various Operating Parameters
Performance Optimization of
Combined Cycle Power Plant
Considering Various Operating
Parameters
Sachin Kumar*
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Jagannath University,
124103 Jhajjar, Haryana, India
*skmtech11@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Combined cycle power plants are popular in thermal engineering field for
their higher efficiency as compared to normal cycles such as Rankine and
Brayton Cycle. But main disadvantages of the cycle are waste heat rejection
and low work output. To overcome these difficulties a heat recovery system is
used in present work to recover waste heat of Brayton cycle as a steam
generator for Rankine cycle in a combined Gas-Vapor cycle. In present
work, effect of factors such as “compression ratio”, “inlet air temperature”
and “turbine inlet temperature” on cycle efficiency was calculated. It was
found that cycle efficiency increases with increase in these factors. It was
found that optimum value of compression ratio is 12-18 for maximum output
of combined cycle. Whereas inlet air temperature has adverse effect on cycle
efficiency so it should be kept lower while increase in turbine inlet
temperature increases the cycle’s work output and hence efficiency. Optimum
values of turbine inlet temperature were found in range of 1600-1700 K
Nomenclature:-
AP = Approach Point
PP = Pitch Point
T = Temperature
___________________
ISSN 1823-5514, eISSN 2550-164X Received for review: 2020-03-18
© 2021 Faculty of MechanicalEngineering, Accepted for publication: 2020-11-10
Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM), Malaysia. Published: 2021-01-15
Sachin Kumar
Introduction
22
Performance Optimization of Combined Cycle Power Plant
23
Sachin Kumar
Design principle
An open circuit gas turbine cycle has a compressor, a combustor, and a
turbine. In this type of cycle, the inlet turbine temperature and flue gas
temperature are kept in ranges of 900-1400 °C, and, 450 to 650 °C
24
Performance Optimization of Combined Cycle Power Plant
Working Principle
A combined cycle power plant consists of a Brayton cycle at the first stage
and a Rankine Cycle on a later stage is shown in Figure 1. In the first stage
air as a fuel is compressed isentropically in an air compressor and then sent
to the combustion chamber where compressed air is heated by fuel. The hot
gas is then made to flow over turbine blades which in turn generate electricity
and the exhaust is passed to the heat recovery steam generator. The output as
steam from the steam generator is now used as working fluid for the second
stage i.e. in the Rankine cycle, to generate electricity. At the second stage,
the steam output from the steam generator is now passed to the steam turbine
which in turns generates electricity and the exhaust of the steam turbine is
passed to the condenser where it condensed in the form water and again fed
to the steam generator with the help of water pump as shown in Figure 1.
25
Sachin Kumar
TP = TDRUM + PP (1)
TEO = TDRUM - AP (2)
26
Performance Optimization of Combined Cycle Power Plant
The steam generated for each kg/sec of exhaust gases can be determined by
applying mass and energy conservation principles across the super-heater and
evaporator.
(3)
The WHRB, being considered is a non-firing boiler. Therefore the heat
transfer is predominantly by convection. It is customary to neglect the
radiative heat transfer, particularly because the reduction in heat transfer due
to soot deposition/ fouling etc. is also ignored and it is assumed that these
two approximately compensate each other. The heat across each section of
the boiler can be estimated as follow:
(4)
(5)
(6)
The flue gas temperature in the stack can also be estimated based on the heat
balance across economizer.
(7)
Mathematical Modeling
The effect of all these parameters was studied to establish the combined cycle
work output and efficiency. For a given compressor isentropic efficiency
27
Sachin Kumar
c and pressure ratio rc , other state variables for the incoming and outgoing
streams can be calculated. The inlet and outlet humidity ratios will be the
same. The energy balance yields the compressor work wc and compressor
outlet temperature.
C pc
c
Cvc (13)
where Cpc and Cvc can be determined from the following relations:
C pc C pa wai C pw
(14)
Cvc Cva wai Cvw
(15)
28
Performance Optimization of Combined Cycle Power Plant
cp CP0 CPT
1 CP2T CPT
2
3
3
CP4T 4 CPT
5
5
(19)
T
ha C pa dt
0 (20)
C C C C
ha C0T 1 T 2 2 T 3 3 T 4 4 T 5 CH
2 3 4 5 (21)
For the expansion ratio of the gas turbine, “re” temperature at the exit of the
turbine isentropic process can be calculated by:
( g 1)
g
Tgos Tgi (re )
(22)
The actual temperature Tgo at the exit of the turbine can be calculated by:
Tgi Tgo
T (23)
Tgi Tgos
The energy balance yields the turbine work wT given by the following
relation:
(24)
Change in enthalpy of air after adding fuel in the combustion chamber is:
29
Sachin Kumar
Pump work:
(28)
hFW h f
hFW h f (29)
p
(32)
W .D net
SC
QSC
(33)
PGT PSC PCC
CC
Qin M f LHV
For the present study, the pressure ratio of gas turbines varied from 8 to 20
bar. With an increase in compression ratio, compressor exit temperature
increases which result in the decrement of fuel consumption keeping the inlet
temperature of the turbine constant (Figure 3). In the present work capacity
of the blade material of the turbine for bearing thermal stress was kept on
mind for deciding values of the inlet gas temperature of the turbine. The main
purpose of the study is to focus on the recovery of waste heat of gas turbine
30
Performance Optimization of Combined Cycle Power Plant
exit which can be utilized to generate steam in steam turbines and further
generate electric power by implementing heat recovery steam generator.
The cycle compression ratio has a direct effect on gas turbine outlet
temperature. As the compression ratio increases, gas turbine outlet
temperature decreases which makes lesser heat available for pressurized
water in HRSG (Figure 4).
1200
Gas turbine outlet temperature (K)
1000
800
600
400
200
0
8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Gas turbine com pression ratio
Figure 4: Effect of the compression ratio of the gas turbine on gas turbine
outlet temperature.
31
Sachin Kumar
570
560
Work obtained in cycle(KJ)
550
540
530
520
510
500
8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Gas turbine com pression ratio
32
Performance Optimization of Combined Cycle Power Plant
45
3.6
Fuel injected in Kg per 100 Kg of air
3.5
3.4
3.3
3.2
3.1
3
275 280 285 290 295 300 305 310 315 320 325
Am bient air tem perature (K)
33
Sachin Kumar
For the design conditions if the TIT is fixed then, as the gas turbine
inlet temperature will keep on increasing then the fuel requirement will
decrease. But due to the increase in the ambient temperature the mass flow
rate of the air to the compressor also decreases which leads to lesser work
output and lesser efficiency (Figure 8). Inlet air cooling may bring the
ambient air to the designed condition.
580
Work obtained from combined cycle
560
540
520
(KJ)
500
480
460
440
275 280 285 290 295 300 305 310 315 320 325
Inlet air tem perature(K)
34
Performance Optimization of Combined Cycle Power Plant
38.4
35
Sachin Kumar
Conclusion
In present work, waste heat of gas turbine was used to generate electricity by
implementing heat recovery steam generator. Fuel consumption of power
plant can be reduced by increasing compression ratio keeping inlet
temperature of gas turbine constant, which in turn, decreases the gas turbine
outlet temperature resulting less available heat for steam generator. With
increase in compressor ratio, the cycle’s work output and efficiency increases
significantly and reaches to a maximum value at compression ratio 18 bar. It
was observed that an increase in pressure ratio lower the fuel consumption
and thus less energy consumption was occurred thus increased cyclic
efficiency was obtained. Inlet ambient air temperature has adverse effect on
cycle’s efficiency and should be kept below 270 K. Turbine inlet temperature
has remarkable effect on cycle’s efficiency. It was observed that when
turbine inlet temperature reaches to 1500 K then cycle’s efficiency and work
output increases effectively and from results it is clear that cycle reaches to
maximum efficiency at 1700 K.
References
[1] Y. S. H. Najjar & M. Akyurt, “Combined cycle with gas turbine engine”,
Heat Recovery Systems & CHP, vol 14, no. 2, pp 93-103, 1994.
[2] J.H. Horlock, “Combined power plants present, and future”, Joumal of
Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power, vol. 117, pp 608-616,1995.
[3] M. De Lucia, C. Lanfranchi, & V. Boggio, “Benefits of compressor inlet
air cooling for gas turbine cogeneration plants”, ASME Journal for Gas
Turbine and Power, vol. 118, pp 598-603, 1996.
[4] M. Mostafavi, A. Alaktiwi & B. Agnew, “Thermodynamic analysis of
combined open-cycle-twin-shaft gas turbine (Brayton cycle) and exhaust
gas operated absorption refrigeration unit”, Applied Thermal
Engineering, vol. 18, pp 847-856, 1998.
[5] T. Heppenstall, “Advanced gas turbine cycles for power generation: a
critical review”, Applied Thermal Engineering, vol. 18, pp 837-846,
1998.
[6] P.A. Pilavachi, “Power generation with gas turbine systems and
combined heat and power”, Applied Thermal Engineering, vol. 20, pp
1421-1429, 2000.
[7] Yousef S. H. Najjar, “Effcient use of energy by utilizing gas turbine
combined systems," Applied Thermal Engineering, vol. 21, no. 4, pp
407-438, 2001.
[8] Manuel Valdés, M Dolores Durán nd Antonio Rovira, “
Thermoeconomic optimization of combined cycle gas turbine power
plants using genetic algorithms”, Applied Thermal Engineering, vol. 23,
no. 17, pp 2169-2182, 2003.
36
Performance Optimization of Combined Cycle Power Plant
37
Sachin Kumar
38