Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 301

Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Abdominal pain in women

Probability diagnosis
Primary dysmenorrhoea

Mittelschmerz

Pelvic/abdominal adhesions

Endometriosis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• internal iliac claudication

Neoplasms including cancer

• ovary
• uterus
• other pelvic structures

Infection:

• PID
• pelvic abscess
• appendicitis

Other:

• ectopic pregnancy

Pitfalls (often missed)


Endometriosis/adenomyosis

Torsion of ovary or pedunculated fibroid

Constipation/faecal impaction
Pelvic congestion syndrome

Misplaced IUCD

Nerve entrapment

Referred pain (to pelvis):

• appendicitis
• cholecystitis
• diverticulitis
• UTI

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Drugs

Spinal dysfunction (referred pain)

UTI

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Can be very relevant. Consider various problems and sexual dysfunction.

Key history
The pain should be linked with the menstrual history, coitus and the possibility of an early
pregnancy. For recurrent and chronic pain, it is advisable to instruct the patient to keep a diary
over two menstrual cycles. Risk factors in the past history should be assessed, for example:

• IUCD (salpingitis, ectopic pregnancy)


• infertility (endometriosis, salpingitis)
• tubal surgery (ectopic).
Key examination
Use the traditional abdominal and pelvic examination to identify the site of tenderness and
rebound tenderness, and any abdominal or pelvic masses. The pelvis should be examined by
speculum (preferably bivalve type) and bimanual palpation.

Proper assessment can be difficult if the patient cannot relax or overreacts, if there is
abdominal scarring or obesity, or if extreme tenderness is present. It is therefore important,
especially in the younger and apprehensive patient, to conduct a gentle, caring vaginal
examination with appropriate explanation and reassurance.

Key investigations
• FBE/ESR/CRP
• Urine MC
• Chlamydia PCR
• Cervical swabs MC
• Serum β-HCG
• Vaginal and/or pelvic ultrasound
• Laparoscopy if appropriate

Diagnostic tips
• Think of endometriosis and ovarian cysts in any woman with lower abdominal pain.
• Recurrent pain related to menstruation is typical of dysmenorrhoea or endometriosis.
• Ectopic pregnancy remains a potentially lethal condition so always be ‘ectopic minded’.
• A position β-HCG plus an empty uterus and an adnexal mass are the classic diagnostic
features of ectopic pregnancy.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Abdominal pain, acute in adults

Probability diagnosis
Acute gastroenteritis

Acute appendicitis

Mittelschmerz/dysmenorrhoea

Irritable bowel syndrome

Biliary colic/renal colic

Peptic ulcer

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• myocardial infarction (esp. inferior)


• splenic infarction
• ruptured AAA
• dissecting aneurysm aorta
• mesenteric artery occlusion

Cancer:

• of bowel with large or small bowel obstruction

Infection:

• acute cholecystitis
• acute salpingitis
• peritonitis/spontaneous bacterial peritonitis
• ascending cholangitis
• intra-abdominal abscess
Other:

• pancreatitis
• ectopic pregnancy
• small bowel obstruction/strangulated hernia
• sigmoid volvulus
• perforated viscus (esp. perforated peptic ulcer)

Pitfalls (often missed)


Acute appendicitis (atypical)

Myofascial tear/muscle wall pain

Pulmonary causes:

• pneumonia
• pulmonary embolism

Faecal impaction (elderly)

Acute diverticulitis

Herpes zoster

Acute hepatitis

Inflammatory bowel disease

Rarities:

• porphyria
• lead poisoning
• haemochromatosis
• haemoglobinuria
• Addison disease
Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes (ketoacidosis)

Drugs (e.g. NSAIDS, iron tablets, narcotics, cytotoxics)

Anaemia (sickle cell)

Spinal dysfunction (referred)

UTI (inc. urosepsis)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


May be very significant. Consider Munchausen syndrome, sexual dysfunction and abnormal
stress.

Key history
Pain has to be analysed according to the usual SOCRATES features. In respect to associated
symptoms and signs, special attention has to be paid to anorexia, nausea or vomiting, micturition,
bowel function, menstruation and drug intake.

Key examination
A useful checklist is:

• general appearance
• oral cavity
• vital parameters incl. temperature, pulse
• abdominal examination: inspection, auscultation, palpation and percussion (in that order)
• rectal examination
• inguinal region
• vaginal examination (if appropriate)
• urine analysis
Key investigations
• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• Serum lipase or amylase
• Urine MC
• LFTs
• H. pylori tests
• Faecal blood

Consider:

• imaging including plain X-ray, ultrasound, IVU, CT scan and others according to
suspected conditions
• upper GI endoscopy

Diagnostic tips
• Upper abdominal pain is caused by lesions of the upper GIT.
• Lower abdominal pain is caused by lesions of the lower GIT or pelvic organs.
• Early severe vomiting indicates a high obstruction of the GIT.
• Acute appendicitis features a characteristic ‘march’ of symptoms:
o pain → anorexia, nausea → vomiting.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Abdominal pain, acute in children

Probability diagnosis
Infant ‘colic’ (2–16 weeks)

Gastroenteritis (all ages)

Mesenteric adenitis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Infection:

• acute appendicitis (mainly 5–15 years)


• pneumonia (esp. right lower lobe)
• pyelonephritis
• peritonitis

Cancer:

• colon cancer (rare)

Other:

• intussusception (peaks at 6–9 months)


• bowel obstruction
• coeliac disease
• strangulated inguinal hernia

Pitfalls (often missed)


Child abuse

Constipation

Torsion of testes

Lactose intolerance

Peptic ulcer
Infection: mumps, tonsillitis, pneumonia (esp. right lower lobe), EBM, UTI, hepatitis

Adnexal disorders in females (e.g. ovarian)

Rarities:

• Meckel diverticulitis
• Henoch–Schönlein purpura
• inflammatory bowel disease
• sickle crisis
• lead poisoning

Masquerades checklist
Diabetes mellitus

Drugs

UTI

Psychogenic consideration
Important cause

Key history
Differentiate the severe problems demanding surgery from the non-surgical ones. About 1 in 15
will have a surgical cause for pain. The causes are often age specific so a family history is
important.

Key examination
• Note general appearance, vital signs and oral cavity
• Abdominal examination: inspection, auscultation, palpation and percussion (in that order)
• Rectal examination is mandatory: look for constipation including impacted faeces
• Examine lungs, especially if lower lobe pneumonia suspected
• Consider gentle abdominal palpation with a soft toy
Key investigations
• Rule out urinary infection with urinalysis. Blood, protein and leucocytes may all be
present with acute appendicitis. Nitrites are more specific for UTIs
• FBE/ESR/CRP
• Scanning according to findings
• Imaging (e.g. oxygen/barium enema) as appropriate

Diagnostic tips
• Consider mesenteric adenitis in a flushed febrile child with an URTI or tonsillitis.
• Vomiting occurs in at least 80% of children with appendicitis and diarrhoea in about
20%.
• A pale infant with severe colic and vomiting indicates acute intussusception.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Abdominal pain, chronic or recurrent in


adults

Probability diagnosis
Irritable bowel syndrome

Mittelschmerz/dysmenorrhoea

Constipation

Peptic ulcer/gastritis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• mesenteric artery ischaemia


• AAA

Cancer/neoplasia:

• bowel/stomach cancer
• pancreatic cancer
• ovarian tumours

Infection:

• hepatitis
• recurrent PID

Pitfalls (often missed)


Adhesions

Appendicitis

Biliary disease: gallstones, sludge

Food allergies
Hernia

Lactase deficiency (i.e. lactose intolerance)

Constipation/faecal impaction

Chronic pancreatitis

Coeliac disease

Inflammatory bowel disease

Crohn disease

Endometriosis

Diverticular disease

Subacute obstruction (cancer, adhesions, etc.)

Rarities:

• tropical infections (e.g. hydatids, melioidosis, strongyloides)


• uraemia
• lead poisoning
• porphyria
• sickle cell anaemia
• hypercalcaemia
• Addison disease

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Drugs

Spinal dysfunction

UTI
Is the patient trying to tell me something?
A strong possibility: consider hypochondriasis, anxiety, sexual dysfunction, Munchausen
syndrome.

Key history
This includes a detailed pain analysis, especially associated features such as micturition, bowel
function, menstruation, diet and psychological features. Note relevant past history (incl.
abdominal surgery), drug intake, travel, family history. Enquire about ‘red flags’ for organic
disease (e.g. weight loss, fever, nocturnal pain or diarrhoea, progressive symptoms).

Key examination
• General appearance including psyche and vital parameters
• Abdominal examination: inspection, auscultation, palpation, percussion (in that order)
• Rectal examination
• Vaginal examination (if appropriate)
• Office urine test

Key investigations
• Urinalysis including MCU
• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• Lipase/amylase
• LFTs
• U&E
• Plain abdominal X-ray
• Other imaging (e.g. ultrasound, IVU) according to findings and intuition
• Endoscopy as appropriate

Consider

• H. pylori testing
• coeliac disease

Diagnostic tips
• Consider gallstones and duodenal ulcer if the patient is woken (e.g. at 2–3 am) with
abdominal pain.
• Be very mindful of constipation, especially in the elderly, and be skilled at digital rectal
examination.
• Avoid repeated investigations unless a new symptom develops and the patient becomes
unwell.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Abdominal pain, recurrent in children


Probability diagnosis
Non-organic recurrent abdominal pain (RAP)

Constipation

Recurrent viral illness (mesenteric adenitis)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Infection:

• recurrent urinary infection/ureteric reflux


• parasitic infection of gut (e.g. pinworm, strongyloides, whipworm)
• tuberculosis

Cancer:

• colon cancer (rare)

Other:

• hydronephrosis

Pitfalls (often missed)


Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD)

Childhood migraine equivalent (periodic syndrome)

Food allergy (incl. lactose intolerance)

Gastritis/oesophageal reflux
Rarities:

• Meckel’s diverticulum
• Temporal lobe epilepsy
• Sickle cell disease
o Henoch-Schönlein purpura
o irritable bowel syndrome (IBS)

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Drugs

Spinal dysfunction

UTI

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Highly likely as non-organic (functional) RAP is common. Consider anxiety and depression.

Key history
RAP, which is three distinct episodes of abdominal pain over 3 or more months, occurs in 10%
of school-aged children. In only 5–10% will an organic cause be found. A very careful history
includes the site, radiation, onset, duration and periodicity of the pain, and aggravating, relieving
and associated factors. Ask if the pain wakes the child at night, interferes with activities and is
associated with anorexia, vomiting, diarrhoea, dysuria or weight loss, or is related to food.
Family history of abdominal pain, migraine, IBD or IBS. Enquire about social history, school
difficulties, stressors and anxiety.

Key examination
• Usual systematic examination including rectal examination
• Growth chart is important
Key investigations
• Urine analysis and M&C
• FBE/ESR/CRP
• Plain abdominal X-ray to assess any faecal retention
• Ultrasound for suspected kidney tract or ovarian pathology

Diagnostic tips
• Avoid the trap of excessive investigations.
• In approximately 90% of RAP patients referred to hospital no underlying cause is found,
but take the problem seriously.
• Talk to the child alone, if possible.
• Organic disease is indicated by pain distant from the umbilicus and/or waking with pain
at night, associated with vomiting, loss of appetite or weight, change in bowel habit,
failure to thrive and inability to undertake normal activities.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Abdominal swelling (generalised)

Probability diagnosis
Pregnancy

Obesity

Constipation, esp. chronic

Irritable bowel syndrome

Enlarged bladder

Fibroid uterus/ovarian tumour/cyst

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• CCF (ascites)
• aortic aneurysm

Infection:

• intrabdominal abscess
• peritoneal tuberculosis
• hydatid cyst
• clostridial intra-abdominal infection

Cancer:

• ovary, stomach, colon, other


• carcinomatosis peritonei

Other:

• ascites (several causes)


• intestinal obstruction (large bowel)
• acute gastric dilatation
Pitfalls (often missed)
Hepatomegaly, splenomegaly

Hydronephrosis

Massive lymphadenopathy/lymphosarcoma

Rarities:

• chronic idiopathic pseudo-obstruction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider pseudocyesis.

Consider the classic five:

• fat
• flatus
• fluid
• faeces
• fetus

Key history
• Is the swelling intermittent, variable or progressive (the most serious)?
• Associated symptoms, especially gastrointestinal, menstrual (?pregnancy)
• Red flags, especially weight loss, fever, pain, lymph nodes
• History of alcoholism, hepatitis, kidney disease, heart disorder
• Past history of abdominal surgery, cancer

Key examination
• General appearance
• Vital signs
• Abdomen (inspection, palpation, auscultation, percussion)
• Rectal and vaginal examination
• Tests for ascites (if present)
• Dipstick of urine
Key investigations
• FBE and ESR/CRP
• Urinalysis
• U&E and LFTs
• Plain abdominal X-ray, ultrasound (best)
• Pregnancy test in females with amenorrhoea
• Specialised imaging according to findings, e.g. CT scan

Diagnostic tips
• Be alert for pregnancy in women of childbearing age, especially teenagers and
perimenopausal women.
• Be alert for constipation, especially in the elderly.
• Weight loss with abdominal swelling suggests malignancy.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Amenorrhoea

Probability diagnosis
Pregnancy

Perimenopause/menopause

Constitutional delay of puberty

Breast feeding

Physiological e.g. excessive exercise, weight loss

Drugs esp. iatrogenic

Polycystic ovarian syndrome

Serious disorders not to be missed


Infection:

• Severe systemic illness


• Pelvic inflammatory disease

Cancer:

• Cellular—lymphoma, leukaemia, myeloma


• Pituitary tumours e.g. prolactinoma
• Ovarian tumours/cancer

Other:

• Brain injury

Pitfalls (often missed)


Imperforate hymen (haematocolpos)

Anorexia nervosa
Primary ovarian failure

Hyperprolactinaemia

Rarities:

• Congenital adrenal hyperplasia


• Genital malformations
• Gonadal dysgenesis
• Asherman’s syndrome
• Turner’s syndrome

Masquerades checklist
Drugs e.g. OCP, cytotoxics, metoclopramide, antipsychotics, valproate

Anaemia

Thyroid/other endocrine: adrenal, pituitary disorders

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider eating disorders, pseudocyesis

Key history
Take menstrual (if any) history i.e. primary or secondary amenorrhoea, including age of
thelarche, detailed menstrual history and associations. Ask about strenuous exercise activities.

Systems review to include endocrine/pituitary features, e.g. headache, galactorrhoea, visual


defects, weight changes, fatigue, voice changes, cold/heat intolerance, libido and other. Past
medical history including obstetric and gynaecological surgery.

Drug history esp. OCP, LARCs, other hormones, opioids and those mentioned above under
drugs as masquerades. Also document family, psychological and social history.

Key examination
General features:

• appearance of patient
• vital signs
• physical features incl. BMI, skin, body hair distribution, signs of virulisation (i.e. note
any secondary sex characteristics)
• brief neurological assessment incl. visual fields
• breast examination
• pelvic examination

Key investigations
First line:

• HCG/pregnancy test
• FBE
• U&E
• FSH/LH
• TFTs
• prolactin

Consider:

• testosterone
• oestradiol
• chromosomal analysis
• ultrasound e.g. ovary
• CT/MRI pituitary fossa

Diagnostic tips
Consider anorexia nervosa, heavy dieting, PCOS, delayed puberty, imperforate hymen,
pregnancy and drugs (iatrogenic and social).

Hypothalamic amenorrhoea is usually functional and caused by weight loss, psychological stress
or excessive exercise.

Consider a serious intracranial disorder if headache and visual disturbance.


Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Amnesia, total or partial

Probability diagnosis
Severe anxiety/stress

Major depression esp. post ECT

Ageing/dementia

Head injury

Alcohol excess incl. Korsakoff syndrome

Iatrogenic e.g. ECT, cardiac bypass surgery

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Cerebral haemorrhage/subarachnoid
• Cerebral infarction esp. vertebrobasilar

Infection:

• Cerebral e.g. meningitis, abscess


• Viral encephalitis e.g. Herpes Simplex
• Syphilis
• HIV/AIDS

Tumor/cancer:

• Cerebral tumour
• Paraneoplasia

Other:

• Anoxia/hypoxia
• Hypothermia
• Electrolyte disturbance esp. hyponatraemia
• Dehydration
• Post-ictal state

Pitfalls (often missed)


Transient global amnesia

B 1 deficiency incl. alcohol abuse

Dissociative fugue states

Depersonalisation disorder

Rarities:

• Wernicke’s encephalopathy
• Carbon monoxide poisoning

Masquerades checklist
Depression esp. major

Diabetes: hypoglycaemia

Drugs: various e.g. Cannabis, amphetamines (see list)

Anaemia

Thyroid/other endocrine: hypercalcaemia/hypothyroid?

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Conversion reaction (hysterical fugue)

Psychogenic amnesia/malingering

Key history
A careful history is required recording the nature of memory loss incl. onset, duration,
fluctuation and associations. Interview family members and check for possible bizarre behaviour.
The key history should incl. past medical history including diabetes, hypertension,
cerebrovascular disease; drug history esp. alcohol, smoking or illicit drugs (cannabis,
amphetamines, opioids, solvent sniffing), lithium, barbiturates, benzodiazepines, anticonvulsants,
digoxin, OTC drugs, etc.; and psychiatric history, incl. severe anxiety, stress, depression, fugue
features, dissociation or personality disorder.

Key examination
• General features: appearance of patient incl. central cyanosis, hydration status, vital signs
• Psychiatric assessment and mental state examination
• Neurological examination

Key investigations
First line:

• urinalysis
• blood sugar
• pulse oximetry
• FBE & ESR
• LFTs (γGT)
• Others according to history and findings

Consider:

• blood gases
• TFTs
• syphilis serology
• CXR
• imaging: cerebral CTscan or MRI

Diagnostic tips
Consider memory loss as a presenting feature of severe stress, anxiety or depression (which can
present as pseudo dementia in the elderly).
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Antisocial behaviour in adults

Probability diagnosis
Functional: no medical or mental component

Drugs: alcohol, illicit (see list) or prescribed

Alcohol: acute or chronic

Antisocial personality disorder esp. cluster B

Affective (mood) disorders

Drug withdrawal incl. alcohol, hypnotics

Mental impairment

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Cerebrovascular disease including SAH


• Acute coronary syndromes

Infection:

• Encephalitis/meningitis
• HIV/AIDS
• Septicaemia

Tumours:

• Cerebral tumours

Other:

• Post ictal (epilepsy)


• Delirium
• Subdural haematoma
• Psychosis: schizophrenia, bipolar, paraphrenia
• Schizotypal personality disorder

Pitfalls (often missed)


Head injury

Fluid and electrolyte imbalance

Dementia esp. early

Rarities:

• Neurosyphilis
• Prion disease e.g. CJD
• Premenstrual dysphoria syndrome

Masquerades checklist
Depression—major

Diabetes: hypoglycaemia

Drugs: iatrogenic/social–illicit

Thyroid/other endocrine: hyper/hypothyroid

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider conversion disorder (hysterical fugue)

Malingering/fabrication

Severe anxiety/panic

Key history
• Nature of behaviour and precipitants, associations
• Psychiatric history: anxiety, OCD, depression, hypomania, personality traits, fugue
features
• Past, family and psychosocial history, developmental history, epilepsy, Parkinson
disease, family history
• Drug history: prescribed (see list), OTC, alcohol, social/illicit drugs (see list)
Key examination
This is limited.

• General features: appearance and behaviour of patient, vital signs


• General respiratory, neurological and cardiovascular examination
• Pulse oximetry
• Mental state examination

Key investigations
First line:

• urinalysis
• blood glucose
• FBE
• U&E

Consider:

• LFTs (γGT)
• ECG
• TFTs
• KFTs
• cerebral imaging

Diagnostic tips
Pay close attention to drug use esp. alcohol, caffeine, narcotics and amphetamines e.g. ‘ice’

Prescribed drugs: major and minor tranquilisers, anti-Parkinson, cardiogenic, corticosteroids.

Non-prescribed drugs: marijuana, LSD, opioids, amphetamines, ecstasy, cocaine, gamma


hydroxybutyrate (‘fantasy’), solvents e.g. petrol sniffing.

Cluster B antisocial personality disorders incl. histrionic, narcissistic and borderline.


Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Arm and hand pain (excluding fractures)

Probability diagnosis
Dysfunction of the cervical spine (lower)

Disorders of the shoulder

Medial or lateral epicondylitis

Overuse tendonopathy of the wrist

Carpal tunnel syndrome

Osteoarthritis of the thumb and DIP joints

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• angina (referred)
• myocardial infarction
• axillary vein thrombosis
• arm claudication (left arm)

Infection:

• septic arthritis (shoulder/elbow)


• osteomyelitis
• infections of tendon sheath and fascial spaces of hand
• sporotrichosis (‘gardener’s arm’)

Neoplasia/cancer:

• Pancoast tumour
• bone tumours (rare)

Pitfalls (often missed)


Entrapment neuropathies (e.g. median nerve, ulnar nerve)
Pulled elbow (children)

Foreign body (e.g. elbow)

Rarities:

• polymyalgia rheumatica (for arm pain)


• complex regional pain syndrome I
• thoracic outlet syndrome
• erythromelalgia
• Kienböck disorder

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Spinal dysfunction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Highly likely, especially with the so-called RSI syndromes.

Key history
Include an analysis of the pain and a history of trauma, particularly unaccustomed activity. In
children ask about pulling the child up by the arms or a fall on an outstretched arm. Ask for
relationship of pain to any sleep disturbance.

Key examination
Inspect the arm as a whole with both arms free of clothing and compare both sides. It may be
necessary to examine a variety of joints including the cervical spine, shoulder, elbow, wrist and
various joints of the hand.

Key investigations
• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• Consider ECG, nerve conduction studies, plain X-ray according to rule ‘if in doubt, X-ray
and compare both sides’, ultrasound for soft tissue injuries (e.g. tendonopathy)
Diagnostic tips
The working rule for arm pain causing sleep disturbance:

• thoracic outlet: patient cannot fall asleep


• carpal tunnel syndrome: wake in middle of night then settles
• cervical spondylosis: wakes patient with pain that persists.

Always keep regional pain syndrome in mind for persistent burning pain in hand following
injury, trivial or severe.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Arthralgia/arthritis in children

Probability diagnosis
Juvenile idiopathic arthritis (incl. still disease and psoriasis)

Viral polyarthritis (e.g. parvovirus, rubella)

Growing pains (leg)

Irritable hip (transient synovitis)

Traumatic arthritis

Reactive arthritis (post-infective)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular (haematological disorders):

• thalassaemia
• sickle cell anaemia
• haemophilia

Infection:

• rheumatic fever
• septic arthritis
• osteomyelitis
• meningococcaemia
• tuberculosis
• HIV

Cancer:

• leukaemia
• lymphoma
• neuroblastoma

Other:
• juvenile rheumatoid arthritis

Pitfalls (often missed)


Hip disorders:

• Perthes disease
• slipped upper femoral epiphysis

Osteochondritis dissecans

Henoch-Schönlein purpura

Kawasaki syndrome

Rarities:

• scurvy
• rickets
• periodic fever syndrome

Masquerades checklist
Drugs (e.g. penicillins, cotrimoxazole)

Spine: juvenile ankylosing spondylitis

Key history and features in childhood


Arthralgia (joint pain) is a common problem in childhood. The complaint demands respect
because of the many serious problems causing it. Arthritis may be part of an infectious disease
such as rheumatic fever, rubella, varicella, human parvovirus, influenza or other viral infection
and is seen with Henoch-Schönlein purpura. Actually viral polyarthritis is very common in
children. An FBE is helpful as it may show lymphopaenia, lymphocytosis or atypical
lymphocytes.

Diagnostic tips
• Acute onset monoarticular arthritis associated with fever is septic until proved otherwise.
• 5% of all children complain of recurrent limb pain, which often awakens them from their
sleep. A careful history and physical examination are essential and perhaps simple basic
investigations may be appropriate.
• Growing pains and post-activity musculoskeletal pain are relatively common.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Arthralgia/arthritis

Probability diagnosis
Osteoarthritis

Viral polyarthritis (e.g. hepatitis, parvovirus)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Infection:

• rheumatic fever
• endocarditis
• tuberculosis
• brucellosis
• pyogenic (septic) arthritis: gonococcus, Staphylococcus, Kingella kingae
• HIV arthropathy
• dengue fever

Cancer:

• bronchogenic carcinoma
• leukaemia/lymphoma
• secondary malignancy

Other:

• rheumatoid arthritis (RA)


• connective tissue disorders: SLE, scleroderma, polymyositis and dermatomyositis, other

Pitfalls (often missed)


Spondyloarthropathies (e.g. psoriasis)

Fibromyalgia syndrome

Polymyalgia rheumatica
Crystal deposition:

• gout
• pyrophosphate (pseudogout)

Haemarthrosis

Dengue fever

Lyme disease

Ross River virus

Avascular necrosis

Rarities:

• other vasculitides (e.g. polyarteritis nodosa)


• haemochromatosis
• sarcoidosis
• Whipple disease
• hyperparathyroidism
• familial Mediterranean fever
• amyloidosis
• pigmented villonodular synovitis

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes (?arthropathy)

Drugs: uncommon but some implemented

Thyroid disorder

Spinal dysfunction (spondyloarthropathies)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Always a consideration with pain.

Psychogenic factors aggravate chronic arthritic conditions.


Key history
There is such a multitude of causes of arthralgia that a skilful history to cover many angles is
required. Note the pattern of joint involvement (monoarticular or polyarticular), immediate and
more recent history, family history and drug use.

Enquire whether the joint pain is acute or insidious and confined to specific joints or fleeting as
in rheumatic fever.

Key examination
A systematic examination of the affected joint or joints should look for signs of inflammation,
deformity, swelling and limitation of movement.

Searching for associated systemic disease such as connective tissue disorders and infection
demands examination of the chest, heart and abdomen.

Key investigations
• FBE
• EBR & CRP
• Uric acid
• Urine analysis
• Joint X-rays
• Synovial fluid analysis and culture
• RA factor
• Autoantibodies (ANA, dsDNA, ENA), anti-CCP antibody (for RA)
• Other tests according to findings of tests for infection (e.g. specific serology, blood
culture)

Diagnostic tips
• The commonest cause of arthritis is osteoarthritis (OA).
• Other causes of monoarthritis include crystal deposition disease, sepsis, trauma and
spondyloarthritis.
• The pain of inflammatory disease is worse at rest and improved by activity.
• There should be no systemic manifestations with OA.
• With polyarthritis (usually PIPs) and rash consider viral arthritis or a drug reaction.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Back pain, lower

Probability diagnosis
Vertebral dysfunction especially facet joint and disc (mechanical pain)

Musculoligamentous strain/sprain

Spondylosis (degenerative OA)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• ruptured aortic aneurysm


• retroperitoneal haemorrhage (anticoagulants)

Neoplasia/cancer:

• myeloma
• pancreas
• metastases (e.g. lung, breast, prostate)

Infection:

• vertebral osteomyelitis
• epidural/subdural abscess
• septic discitis
• tuberculosis
• pelvic abscess/PID
• pyelonephritis

Other:

• osteoporotic compression fracture


• cauda equina compression

Pitfalls (often missed)


Spondyloarthropathies:
• ankylosing spondylitis
• reactive arthritis
• psoriasis
• bowel inflammation

Sacroiliac dysfunction

Spondylolisthesis

Spinal canal stenosis

Claudication:

• vascular
• neurogenic

Paget disease

Prostatitis

Endometriosis

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Spinal dysfunction

UTI

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Quite likely. Consider lifestyle, stress, work problems, malingering, conversion reaction.

Key history
Routine analysis of pain (SOCRATES approach), especially intensity of pain and its relation to
rest and activity and also diurnal variation. Ask about pain on standing, sitting and walking with
types of claudication (if any).

Review family history, occupational history, drug history, psychosocial history and ask
questions about red flags that are alarm symptoms of serious disease.
Key examination
Follow the LOOK, FEEL, MOVE, MEASURE clinical approach with an emphasis on
palpation—central and lateral.

The movements with normal ranges are:

• extension 20°–30°
• forward flexion 75°–90°
• lateral flexion (left and right) 30°.

Perform a neurological and vascular examination of the lower limb/s with pain.

Key investigations
This should be conservative, especially in the absence of red flags. Basic screening is:

• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• urinalysis
• serum alkaline phosphatase
• PSA in males 50–75 years
• plain X-ray if chronic pain and red flags.

Reserve CT scan, MRI or radionuclide scan for suspected serious disease (malignancy and
infection).

Diagnostic tips
• Continuous pain (day and night) points to neoplasm (esp. malignancy) or infection.
• Pain (and stiffness) at rest, relief with activity indicates inflammation (e.g.
spondyloarthropathy).
• Pain provoked by activity with relief at rest indicates mechanical (vertebral) dysfunction.
• Pain in the periphery of the limb can be discogenic causing radicular pain or spinal cord
stenosis causing neurogenic claudication or vascular causing intermittent claudication.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Back pain, thoracic

Probability diagnosis
Musculoligamentous strains (mainly postural)

Vertebral dysfunction

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• myocardial infarction
• dissecting aneurysm
• pulmonary infarction
• epidural haematoma (blood-thinning agents)

Neoplasia/cancer:

• myeloma
• pancreas
• lung (with infiltration)
• metastatic disease (e.g. lung, breast)

Infection:

• epidural/subdural abscess
• infective discitis
• pleurisy
• infectious endocarditis
• osteomyelitis
• pyelonephritis

Other:

• pneumothorax
• osteoporosis
Pitfalls (often missed)
Angina

Gastrointestinal disorders

• oesophageal dysfunction
• peptic ulcer (penetrating)
• hepatobiliary
• pancreatic

Herpes zoster

Spondyloarthropathies

Costochondritis:

• Tietze syndrome

Fibromyalgia syndrome

Notalgia parasthetica

Polymyalgia rheumatica

Chronic infection:

• tuberculosis
• brucellosis

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Spinal dysfunction

UTI

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Yes, quite possible with many cases of back pain.

Key history
Take a history analysing pain characteristics to differentiate between chest pain due to vertebral
dysfunction (musculoskeletal strain) and that caused by myocardial ischaemia.

Also drug history, family history, occupational history and questions about red flags that point to
serious disease.

Key examination
The LOOK, FEEL, MOVE, MEASURE clinical approach applies to the thoracic spine. The
emphasis is on palpation-central and laterally.

The movements and their normal ranges are:

• extension 30°
• lateral flexion (right and left) 30°
• flexion 90°
• rotation (right and left) 60°.

Key investigations
Consider:

• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• alkaline phosphase
• A plain X-ray is the main investigation, which may exclude the basic skeletal
abnormalities and diseases such as osteoporosis and malignancy. If normal and disease is
suspected a radionucleide scan or MRI is advisable.

Diagnostic tips
• The commonest site of pain is the costovertebral articulations of the spine.
• Pain of the thoracic spine origin may be referred anywhere to the chest wall.
• The older patient should be regarded as having a cardiac cause until proved otherwise.
• Thoracic back pain is frequently associated with cervical lesions that refer to the upper
back.
• The thoracic spine is the commonest site in the vertebral column for metastatic disease.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Breast lumps in women

Probability diagnosis
Fibrocystic disease (mammary dysplasia) (32%)

Fibroadenoma (23%)

Cancer (22%)

Cysts (10%)

Breast abscess/periareolar inflammation

Lactation cyst (galactocele)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• thrombophlebitis (Mondor disease)

Infection:

• mastitis/breast abscess
• tuberculosis

Cancer:

• carcinoma
• ductal carcinoma in situ
• Paget disease of the nipple
• sarcoma
• lymphoma
• mastitis carcinomatosa

Other:

• phyllodes tumour
Pitfalls (often missed)
Duct papilloma

Lipoma

Mammary duct ectasia

Fat necrosis/fibrosis

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider anxiety or cancer phobia (esp. if family history) and possibility of a ‘pseudo lump’ (e.g.
part of normal or prominent chest wall anatomy). If doubtful re-examine after next period or
refer.

Key history
Family history of breast disease and past history including trauma, previous breast pain and
details about pregnancies (complications of lactation such as mastitis, nipple problems and milk
retention).

Note any nipple changes or discharge that may indicate carcinoma.

Key examination
• Careful examination of both breasts with inspection looking for any asymmetry, skin
discolouration, tethering, peau d’orange or visible veins.
• Examine the nipples for retraction or ulceration and variations in level.
• Examine lymph nodes in a sitting position with the patient’s hands on hips.
• Palpation using the pulps of the fingers should systematically cover the six areas of the
breast: the four quadrants, the axillary tail and the region deep to the nipple and areola.

Key investigations
• The basis of investigation of a new breast lump is the triple test, which is:
o clinical examination (above)
o imaging: mammography ± ultrasound
o working rule for imaging: <35 years ultrasound; >35 years mammogram +
ultrasound
o fine needle aspiration ± core biopsy
Diagnostic tips
• Mammary dysplasia, which is the most common breast lump, is a common cause of cysts
especially in the premenopausal phase.
• Over 75% of isolated breast lumps prove to be benign but clinical identification of a
malignant tumour can only definitely be made following aspiration biopsy or histological
examination of the tumour.
• A ‘dominant’ breast lump in an older woman should be regarded as malignant.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Breast pain (mastalgia)

Probability diagnosis
Pregnancy

Cracked or inflamed nipple

Cyclical mastalgia:

• benign mammary dysplasia

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• acute coronary insufficiency


• thrombophlebitis (Mondor disease)

Infection:

• mastitis
• breast abscess

Cancer:

• breast (uncommon presentation)


• mastitis carcinomatosa

Pitfalls (often missed)


Pregnancy

Chest wall pain (e.g. costochondritis)

Pectoralis muscle spasm

Referred pain, esp. thoracic spine

Bornholm disease (epidemic pleurodynia)


Herpes zoster

Mechanical:

• bra problems
• weight change
• trauma

Rarities:

• hyperprolactinaemia
• nerve entrapment
• mammary duct ectasia
• sclerosing adenosis
• ankylosing spondylitis

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Drugs (e.g. OCP, HRT, marijuana)

Spinal dysfunction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Yes. Fear of malignancy. Consider psychogenic causes.

Key history
Relate the pain to the menstrual cycle and determine whether the patient is pregnant or not.

Key questions:

• Could you be pregnant?


• Is your period on time or overdue?
• Is the pain in both breasts or only one?
• Do you have pain before your periods (cyclical mastalgia) or all the time during your
cycle (non-cyclical mastalgia)?
• Do you have pain in your back or where your ribs join your chest bone?
Key examination
• Systematic breast palpation to check for soreness or lumps including regional lymph
nodes
• Underlying chest wall and thoracic spine (T3–T6)

Key investigations
• Pregnancy test
• Mammography (>40 years) and ultrasound
• FNA/excision biopsy for lump with localised pain
• Consider CXR and ECG

Diagnostic tips
• Consider cancer or candida if constant (prickling) breast pain.
• Consider a rare florid form of breast cancer, ‘mastitis carcinomatosa’, if red, hot area.
• Watch for abscess if a lactating woman has unilateral breast pain and ‘flu’ symptoms.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Breast, nipple discharge

Probability diagnosis
Pregnancy

Physiological

Intraduct papilloma

Lactation/lactation cysts

Mammary dysplasia

Serious disorders not to be missed


Infection:

• acute mastitis/discharging breast abscess


• areolar abscess (infected gland of Montgomery)
• tuberculosis abscess

Cancer:

• intraduct carcinoma
• invasive carcinoma
• Paget disease of nipple

Other:

• hyperprolactinaemia

Pitfalls (often missed)


Mammary duct ectasia

Drugs (e.g. chlorpromazine, metoclopramide, OCP, cimetidine, opiates, amphetamines, CCBs,


tricyclic antidepressants, phenothiazine)

Rarities:
• mammary duct fistula
• mechanical stimulation

Masquerades checklist
Drugs (as above)

Endocrine: hyperprolactinaemia, hypothyroidism

Key history
Family history of breast disease and past history including previous breast lumps, pain or nipple
discharge. Note association with pregnancy, postpartum and lactation. Investigate drug intake
including OTC preparations and illicit drugs especially opioids.

Key examination
• Careful examination of the breast, particularly the nipples and ductal area
• Examine associated lymph node regions

Key investigations
Select from:

• pregnancy test
• swab of any purulent discharge
• cytology of discharge
• prolactin level
• excision biopsy of discharging duct area.

Discuss imaging (e.g. mammography, ultrasound, galactography) with consultant

Diagnostic tips
• If the discharge is bilateral then serious breast disease is unlikely—consider mammary
dysplasia and pregnancy.
• Bloodstained discharge is caused by intraduct papilloma (commonest) and intraduct
carcinoma.
• Green-grey discharge: consider mammary dysplasia and mammary duct ectasia.
• Yellow discharge: intraduct carcinoma (serous), mammary dysplasia and pus from a
breast abscess.
• Milky-white discharge (galactorrhoea): lactation, lactation cysts, hyperprolactinaemia
and drugs.
• Consider malignancy in women with a new breast discharge (>40 years) and bloody
discharge.
• Nipple discharge in a male is always abnormal.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Calf pain

Probability diagnosis
Simple muscular cramp

Muscle soreness (post exercise)

Muscle injury esp. gastrocnemius tear

Claudication esp. vascular (intermittent)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Deep venous thrombosis


• Peripheral vascular disease
• Superficial thrombophlebitis
• Popliteal artery entrapment

Infection:

• Cellulitis

Other:

• Achilles tendon rupture


• Neurogenic claudication
• Deep posterior muscle compartment syndrome

Pitfalls (often missed)


Referred pain: knee, spine

Ruptured Baker’s cyst

Superficial posterior compartment syndrome

Nerve entrapment e.g. tibial, sural


Stress fracture of fibula

Rarities:

• Hypocalcaemia→cramps
• Motor neurone disease

Masquerades checklist
Diabetes

Drugs e.g. beta blockers

Thyroid/other endocrine: hypocalcaemia

Spinal dysfunction: L5 referred

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Possibly muscle tension

Key history
A history of the features of the pain-quality, onset (acute or slow), ‘tearing’ or ‘popping’ sound,
relation to activity and associations esp. back or knee pain.

Document any preceding sporting activity, travel, immobilisation, varicose veins or


claudication—neurogenic or vascular pattern.

Key examination
• Calf muscle examination incl. Achilles tendon, functional stress, swelling or bruising
• Lumbosacral spine and knee of affected side
• Veins and arteries of leg esp. peripheral pulses
• Neurological—sensation, power, reflexes esp. ankle

Investigations
Nil for most cases.

Consider:
• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• muscle enzymes
• imaging e.g. ultrasound, D-dimer, venography, angiography

Diagnostic tips
Neurogenic claudication is muscular pain starting proximal and radiating distal on walking, and
persists for a while after resting. Vascular claudication starts in the calf, radiates proximal and
abates on rest.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Chest pain in adults

Probability diagnosis
Musculoskeletal (chest wall) incl. costochondritis

Psychogenic

Angina

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• myocardial infarction/unstable angina


• aortic dissection
• pulmonary embolism/infarction

Neoplasia/cancer:

• lung cancer
• tumours of spinal cord and meninges

Infection:

• pneumonia/pleuritis (pleurisy)
• mediastinitis
• pericarditis
• myocarditis

Pneumothorax

Pitfalls (often missed)


Mitral valve prolapse

Oesophageal spasm

Gastro-oesophageal reflux

Biliary colic
Peptic ulcer

Herpes zoster

Fractured rib (e.g. cough fracture)

Spinal dysfunction

Precordial catch (‘stitch’ in side)

Rarities:

• pancreatitis
• Bornholm disease (pleurodynia)
• cocaine inhalation (can ↑ ischaemia)
• hypertrophic cardiomyopathy

Masquerades checklist
Depression (possible)

Anaemia (indirect)

Spinal dysfunction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider functional causes, especially anxiety with hyperventilation, opioid dependency.

Key history
This needs to be meticulous because of the life-threatening causes. Analyse the pain into its usual
characteristics with the SOCRATES system.

Note family history drug history, psychosocial history and past history, especially if
immunocompromised (e.g. diabetes or metabolic syndrome).

Key examination
• General appearance
• Vital signs
• Peripheral circulation
• Careful examination of cardiovascular and respiratory systems
• Upper abdominal palpation
Key investigations
• Base tests available to the GP are ECG, cardiac enzymes and CXR and in most instances
help confirm the diagnosis.
• Otherwise specialist investigations including imaging are confined to hospitals and
cardiology centres.

Diagnostic tips
• Consider chest pain as due to a coronary syndrome until proved otherwise.
• The history remains the most important clinical factor in the diagnosis of ischaemic heart
disease and other conditions.
• With angina a vital clue is the reproducibility of the symptom.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Chest pain in children

Probability diagnosis
Musculoskeletal (chest wall pain):

• cough strain (10%)


• injury
• muscle strain
• costochondritis
• precordial catch syndrome (stitch in side)
• asthma

Note: Most cases are unknown (21%).

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• ischaemic pain: structural cardiac conditions


• arrhythmias (e.g. PSVT)

Infection:

• pericarditis
• myocarditis
• pneumonia
• herpes zoster

Other:

• pneumothorax
• POTS syndrome

Pitfalls (often missed)


Kawasaki syndrome

Breast disorders

Rarities:
• Bornholm disease
• oesophagitis or gastric pain

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Psychogenic: stress, anxiety, depression (10%).

Key history
• Usual features of the pain including aggravating and relieving factors such as movement,
exercise, rest, swallowing, breathing and eating.
• Note associated symptoms such as fever, cough, dizziness, overexertion, syncope and
recent viral illness.
• Note family history, especially cardiac disease including unexplained sudden death,
recent stressful events and drug history.

Key examination
• Vital signs especially pulse (including nature) and temperature
• Palpation of chest wall to determine any tenderness or signs of injury
• Basic cardiovascular and respiratory examination

Key investigations
• No investigation usually required
• Consider ECG and CXR

Diagnostic tips
• Most cases of chest pain in children are of unknown aetiology and probably psychogenic.
• Chest pain is more common in adolescents.
• Less than 5% of cases are caused by cardiac disease.
• Myocardial ischaemia is rare in children but consider it in any child with exercise-
induced pain, adolescents with longstanding diabetes and children with sickle cell
anaemia.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Chronic constipation

Probability diagnosis
Simple constipation: low-fibre diet, poor fluid intake, lifestyle and bad habit

Slow transit (idiopathic) constipation

Normal transit (irritable bowel syndrome)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Intrinsic neoplasia: colon, rectum or anus, especially colon cancer

Extrinsic malignancy (e.g. lymphoma, ovary)

Hirschsprung (children)

Pitfalls (often missed)


Impacted faeces

Local anal lesions (e.g. anal fissure)

Drug/purgative abuse

Hypokalaemia

Depressive illness

Acquired megacolon

Diverticular disease

Rarities:

• lead poisoning
• hypercalcaemia
• hyperparathyroidism
• dolichocolon (large colon)/megarectum
• Chagas disease
• systemic sclerosis

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes (rarely)

Drugs (opiates, iron, others)—see list

Thyroid disorder (hypothyroidism)

Spinal dysfunction (severe only)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


May be functional (e.g. depression, anorexia nervosa).

Key history
Define what exactly the patient means by constipation. The history should include stool
consistency, frequency, ease of evacuation, pain on defecation and the presence of blood or
mucus. A dietary and drug history is important.

Key examination
• The important aspects are abdominal palpation and rectal examination
• Test perianal sensation and the anal reflex
• Perform sigmoidoscopy

Key investigations
• Basic tests are FBE/ESR, occult blood in stool
• Consider serum calcium, potassium, CEA and TFTs
• If appropriate refer for sigmoidoscopy or colonoscopy and radiological studies (e.g. CT
colonography, bowel transit studies)
Diagnostic tips
• Alarm symptoms are rectal bleeding, recent constipation in those >40 years and family
history of cancer.
• Bleeding suggests cancer, haemorrhoids, diverticular disorder and inflammatory bowel
disease.
• Beware of hypokalaemia causing constipation in the elderly patient on diuretic treatment.
Drugs selected associated with constipation: analgesics, opioids esp. codeine, TCAs,
antacids esp. aluminium hydroxide, Ca channel blockers, SSRIs, cough mixtures, anti-
cholinergics, benzodiazepines.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Confusion, acute in adults

Probability diagnosis
Hypoxia

Hypoglycaemia

Alcohol excess

Drug withdrawal incl. alcohol, hypnotics

Head injury

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Cerebral insufficiency incl. TIAs


• Acute coronary syndrome
• Cardiac arrhythmias
• Subdural or extradural haematoma

Infection:

• Any systemic infection esp. sepsis


• Cerebral e.g. meningitis, abscess
• HIV/AIDS

Tumor/cancer:

• Cerebral tumour

Other:

• Kidney failure
• Hepatic failure
• Respiratory failure e.g. COPD
• Electrolyte disturbance
• Dehydration
• Post-ictal state
• Psychosis

Pitfalls (often missed)


Iatrogenic-drugs incl. serotonin syn.

Hyperparathyroidism

Hypo/hyper-calcaemia

Sleep apnoea

Rarities:

• Fat embolism
• Wernicke’s encephalopathy
• Prion disorders esp. CJS
• Vitamin deficiency e.g. B1 and B12

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes: ketoacidosis, hypoglycaemia

Drugs (see list)

Thyroid/other endocrine—hyper/hypothyroid?

Urinary tract infection—nocturia

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


A consideration if nil findings.

Key history
A careful history is required incl. an interview with family members and witnesses.

Investigate the onset and circumstances of the behaviour, any possible bizarre behaviour. Past
medical history including diabetes, hypertension, cerebrovascular disease. Drug history esp.
alcohol or illicit drugs, prescription and OTC drugs.
Check thyroid status, esp. hyperthyroidism.

Key examination
• General features: appearance of patient incl. evidence of central cyanosis, hydration
status, vital signs incl. BMI
• Head and neck
• General respiratory and cardiovascular examination
• Possible source of infection
• Neurological examination
• Mental state examination

Key investigations
First line:

• urinalysis
• blood sugar
• pulse oximetry
• FBE
• ESR
• U&E
• calcium

Others according to history and findings

Consider:

• CXR
• ECG
• cardiac enzymes
• TFTs
• LFTs (γGT)
• CT scan
• CSF analysis

Diagnostic tips
Pay close attention to drug use, esp. alcohol, psychotrophics, narcotics, illicit agents,
anticholinergics, digoxin, corticosteroids, benzodiazepines esp. if desperate request for drugs.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Cough, chronic in children

Probability diagnosis
Asthma

Recurrent viral bronchitis

Acute URTIs

Allergic rhinitis

Croup

Serious disorders not to be missed


Asthma

Cystic fibrosis

Inhaled foreign body

Tracheo-oesophageal fistula

Pneumonia
Chronic cough: age related causes to consider

Milk inhalation/reflux
Early months of
Asthma
life
Acute viral bronchiolitis

Asthma

Bronchitis

Whooping cough

(pertussis)
Toddler/preschool
Cystic fibrosis
child
Croup

Foreign body inhalation

Tuberculosis

Bronchiectasis

Asthma
Early school
Bronchitis
years
Mycoplasma pneumonia
Asthma

Adolescence Psychogenic

Smoking
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Cough

Probability diagnosis
Upper respiratory infection

Postnasal drip/sinusitis/rhinitis

Smoking

Inhaled irritants

Acute bronchitis

Chronic bronchitis/COPD

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• left ventricular failure

Cancer:

• lung cancer
• larynx

Infection:

• tuberculosis
• pneumonia
• influenza
• lung abscess
• HIV infection
• SARS (coronavirus)

Other:

• asthma
• cystic fibrosis
• foreign body
• pneumothorax

Pitfalls (often missed)


Atypical pneumonias

Gastro-oesophageal reflux (nocturnal)

Smoking (children/adolescents)

Bronchiectasis

Whooping cough (pertussis)

Interstitial lung disorders (e.g. idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis)

Sarcoidosis

Masquerades checklist
Drugs (e.g. ACE inhibitors, beta blockers, inhaled steroids, sulfasalazine)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Anxiety and habit.

Key history
Determine the nature of the cough, especially associated symptoms such as the nature of the
sputum, breathlessness, wheezing and constitutional symptoms. Haemoptysis See ‘Haemoptysis
(in adults)’. History of smoking habits, past and present, and occupational history are essential.
Past history, especially respiratory and drug intake.

Key examination
• General examination including a search for enlarged cervical or axillary glands
• Careful examination of the lungs and cardiovascular system with inspection of sputum
Key investigations
More applicable if haemoptysis

• FBE/ESR/CRP
• Sputum cytology and culture
• Respiratory function tests
• Plain CXR and others as appropriate

Diagnostic tips
• Postnasal drip is the commonest cause of a persistent or chronic cough especially at
night.
• Cough may persist for many weeks following a URTI.
• Cough is the cardinal feature of chronic bronchitis.
• Unexplained cough >50 years is bronchial carcinoma until proved otherwise (esp. if a
history of smoking).
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Crying and fussing in infants

Probability diagnosis
Normal/hunger

Infantile ‘colic’

Teething

Viral URTI/illness

Otitis media

Constipation

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Cardiac failure

Infection:

• Meningitis/encephalitis
• Gastroenteritis
• Other systemic infection

Other:

• Gastro-oesophageal reflux/oesophagitis
• Injury esp. non-accidental, birthing

Pitfalls (often missed)


Severe nappy rash

Constipation

Cow’s milk intolerance


Lactose intolerance

Balanitis (males)

Rarities:

• Bowel obstruction/pyloric stenosis


• Intussusception
• Other congenital e.g. oesophageal atresia

Masquerades checklist
Urinary tract infection

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


?hunger ?soiled napkin ?tiredness ?family dysfunction ?inattention

Key history
Obtain detailed account from parents of the crying pattern and duration, as well as the
circumstances of discomfort incl. feeding, time relationship to feeds and associations,
particularly vomiting or possetting, presumed abdominal discomfort, constipation, bowel actions
and fever. Establish if breastfeeding or providing other milk and food. Ask about recent
immunisation.

Key examination
• General features: appearance of the child, growth parameters and vital signs
• Abdominal examination esp. inspection, palpation and auscultation
• Examine skin looking for evidence of eczema and napkin rash
• Examine the ears, fontanelles
• Also assess the child’s temperament and coping abilities

Key investigations
Nil for most cases

Consider:

• urinalysis
• MCU
• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• stool analysis
• referral for upper GIT investigation

Diagnostic tips
The normal pattern is for crying to start increasing around 2 weeks of age, to peak around 2
months and then settle down 3–4 months of age.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Deafness and hearing loss

Probability diagnosis
Impacted cerumen

Serous otitis media (glue ear)

Otitis externa

Otitis media

Congenital (children)

Presbyacusis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Neoplasia:

• acoustic neuroma
• temporal lobe tumours (bilateral)
• otic tumours

Infection:

• generalised infections (e.g. mumps, measles)


• meningitis
• syphilis

Other:

• perforated tympanic membrane


• cholesteatoma
• perilymphatic fistula (post-stapedectomy)
• Meniere syndrome

Pitfalls (often missed)


Foreign body
Temporal bone fracture

Otosclerosis

Head injury

Barotrauma

Noise-induced deafness

Rarities:

• Paget disease of bone


• multiple sclerosis
• osteogenesis imperfecta

Masquerades checklist
Diabetes

Drugs (see list)

Thyroid disorder (hypothyroidism)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Unlikely.

Key history
Onset and progression of any deafness, noise exposure, drug history, swimming or diving, air
travel, head injury and family history. A recent or past episode of a generalised infection would
be relevant and the presence of associated aural symptoms such as ear pain, discharge, tinnitus
and vertigo. Enquire about the effect of noise.

Key examination
• Inspect the facial structures, skull and ears and the ear with an otoscope. Ensure that the
external auditory canal is clean
• Perform simple office hearing tests including tuning fork tests

Key investigations
• Audiometry and tympanometry
• Swab of any ear discharge for M&C

Diagnostic tips
• People with conductive deafness tend to speak softly, hear better in a noisy environment
and hear well on the telephone. The opposite applies for sensorineural deafness.
• Ototoxic drugs: alcohol, aminoglycosides e.g. streptomycin, neomycin, gentamicin,
tobramycin, chemotherapeutic agents, quinine, salicylates/aspirin excess, diuretics e.g.
ethacrynic acid, frusemide.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Diarrhoea

Probability diagnosis
Acute:

• Gastroenteritis/infective enteritis
• Dietary indiscretion
• Antibiotic reaction

Chronic:

• Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS)


• Drug reactions (e.g. laxatives)
• Chronic infections

Serious disorders not to be missed


Neoplasia/cancer:

• colorectal cancer
• ovarian cancer
• peritoneal cancer

Infection:

• cholera
• typhoid/paratyphoid
• amoebiasis
• malaria
• enterohaemorrhagic E. coli enteritis
• HIV infection (AIDS)

Others

Inflammatory bowel disease:

• Crohn/ulcerative colitis
• pseudomembranous colitis

Intussusception
Pelvic appendicitis/pelvic abscess

Pitfalls (often missed)


Coeliac disease

Faecal impaction with spurious diarrhoea

Lactase deficiency

Giardia lamblia infection

Cryptosporidium infection

Malabsorption states (e.g. coeliac disease)

Vitamin C and other oral drugs

Nematode infections:

• strongyloides (threadworm)
• whipworm
• hookworm

Radiotherapy

Diverticulitis

Post-GIT surgery

Ischaemic colitis (elderly)

Rarities:

• Addison disease
• carcinoid tumours
• short bowel syndrome
• amyloidosis
• toxic shock
• Zollinger–Ellison syndrome
Masquerades checklist
Diabetes

Drugs (see list)

Hyperthyroidism

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Yes, diarrhoea may be a manifestation of anxiety state or irritable bowel syndrome.

Key history
Establish what the patient means by diarrhoea. Analyse the nature of the stools, frequency,
associated symptoms (e.g. abdominal pain) and constitutional symptoms such as fever and
weight loss. Drug history, travel history and family history.

Key examination
• Focus on the general state (esp. of severe gastroenteritis), the abdomen, rectum and skin
• Ideally the stool should be examined (note the presence of blood, mucus or steatorrhoea)

Key investigations
In some instances such as acute self-limiting diarrhoea nil is required. Consider:

• microscopy and culture of stool


• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• C. difficile tissue culture assay
• U&E
• specific tests for organisms
• endoscopy
• selective radiology (e.g. small bowel enema).
Diagnostic tips
• Giardiasis (profuse bubbly diarrhoea) is more common than realised.
• Remember spurious diarrhoea and the rectal examination in the elderly.
• IBS rarely causes nocturnal diarrhoea but causes recurrent pain in the right
hypochondrium.
• Some drugs that can cause diarrhoea: alcohol, antibiotics, digoxin, colchicine, cytotoxic
agents, H 2 -receptor antagonists, iron compounds, laxatives, metformin, sildenafil, statins,
thyroxine.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Diplopia

Probability diagnosis
Binocular:

• Ocular nerve palsy (3,4,6) various causes


• CVA/TIA
• Ophthalmoplegic migraine
• Physiological (disparateness)
• Drug effect e.g. alcohol, benzodiapines

Monocular:

• Eye disorder e.g. cataract, refractive error, cornea

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• CVA/TIA

Infection:

• Intraocular abscess
• Sinusitis
• Botulism
• HIV/AIDS

Tumour/cancer:

• Involving 3, 4 or 6 cranial nerves

Other:

• Facial bone trauma/head injury


• Guillain-Barré syndrome
Pitfalls (often missed)
Any orbital infiltration

Rarities:

• Multiple sclerosis
• Myasthenia gravis
• Orbital myositis
• Cavernous sinus thrombosis
• Wernicke’s encephalopathy

Masquerades checklist
Diabetes: mononeuritis

Drugs e.g. sedatives, opioids, alcohol

Thyroid/other endocrine: hyperthyroid

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


A consideration if nil findings. Some cases are idiopathic.

Key history
A careful history is required to determine nature of diplopia: if one or both eyes, intermittent,
constant or associated pain. Check for other neurological symptoms incl. other cranial nerve
dysfunction, and other associated general symptoms such as weight loss and fever. Check past
medical history incl. diabetes, hypertension and cerebrovascular disease, as well as drug history,
esp. alcohol or illicit, prescription and OTC drugs.

Key examination
• General features: appearance of patient, vital signs
• Inspection of the eyes and neck (goitre)
• Ocular motility
• Visual acuity
• Establish if binocular or monocular
• Perform the cover test
• Cranial nerves in general
• Other basic neurological examination
• Ophthalmoscopy

Key investigations
Nil for most cases

First line:

• urinalysis
• blood sugar
• FBE
• ESR/CRP

Consider:

• TFTs
• imaging if indicated (refer)

Diagnostic tips
Refer urgently if diplopia is binocular, of recent onset and persistent. Other ‘red flags’ incl. any
pupil involvement, pain, proptosis, any other neurological symptoms or signs.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Disturbed or agitated patient

Probability diagnosis
The 4 Ds:

• dementia
• delirium (look for cause)
• depression
• drugs: toxicity, withdrawal

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• CVAs
• cardiac failure
• arrhythmia
• acute coronary syndromes

Neoplasia/cancer:

• cerebral
• cancer (e.g. lung)

Infection:

• septicaemia
• HIV infection
• infective endocarditis

Hypoglycaemia/diabetic ketoacidosis

Bipolar disorder/mania

Schizophrenia states

Anxiety/panic

Subdural/extradural haematoma
Pitfalls (often missed)
Alcohol intoxication/withdrawal

Illicit drug withdrawal (e.g. amphetamines)

Fluid and electrolyte disturbances

Faecal impaction (elderly)

Urinary retention (elderly)

Hypoxia

Pain syndromes (elderly)

Rarities:

• postictal state
• hypocalcaemia
• kidney failure
• hepatic failure
• prion diseases (e.g. Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease)

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes (hypo and hyperglycaemia)

Drugs: iatrogenic/social illicit (see list)

Anaemia

Thyroid disorder (hypo and hyper)

Spinal dysfunction (severe pain in elderly)

UTI
Is the patient trying to tell me something?
Consider anxiety, depression, emotional deprivation or upset, change in environment, serious
personal loss.

Key history
The basis of the history is an accurate account from relatives or witnesses about the patient’s
behaviour. When communicating with the patient, speak slowly and simply, face them and
maintain eye contact. Note the past history and recent psychosocial history, including recent
bereavement, family upsets and changes in environment. Drug history is vital. Perform a mini
mental status examination.

Key examination
• Note the patient’s general demeanour, dress and physical characteristics
• Check vital signs
• Assess the patient’s ability to hear, speak, reason, obey commands, stand and walk
• Look for features of alcohol abuse, Parkinson disease and hypothyroidism
• Examine the neurological systems
• Pulse oximetry (if available)

Key investigations
For delirious or demented patients of unknown cause consider:

• MCU urine
• blood culture
• FBE/ESR
• blood glucose
• U&E, calcium and phosphate
• B12 and folate, vitamin D
• TFTs
• LFTs
• HIV test
• arterial blood gases
• CXR
• cerebral CT scan.
Diagnostic tips
• The cause may be single or multiple.
• Psychiatric causes include panic disorder, mania, major depression and schizophrenia.
• The key feature of dementia is impaired memory.
• The two key features of delirium are disorganised thought and inattention.
• Prescribed drugs that can cause antisocial behaviour: major and minor tranquilisers, anti-
Parkinson, cardiogenic, corticosteroids.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Dizziness/vertigo

Probability diagnosis
Anxiety-hyperventilation

Postural hypotension

Simple faint—vasovagal

Acute vestibulopathy (V)—viral illness

Benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (V)

Motion sickness (V)

Post head injury (V)

Cervical dysfunction/spondylosis

Note: V = vertigo

Serious disorders not to be missed


Neoplasia/cancer:

• acoustic neuroma
• posterior fossa tumour
• other brain tumours, primary or secondary

Intracerebral infection (e.g. abscess)

Cardiovascular:

• arrhythmias
• myocardial infarction
• aortic stenosis

Cerebrovascular:

• vertebrobasilar insufficiency
• brain stem infarct (e.g. PICA thrombosis)

Multiple sclerosis

Pitfalls (often missed)


Ear wax-otosclerosis

Arrhythmias

Hyperventilation

Alcohol and other drugs (incl. illicit, e.g. cocaine)

Cough or micturition syncope

Vertiginous migraine/migrainous vertigo

Parkinson disease

Meniere syndrome (overdiagnosed)

Rarities:

• Addison disease
• neurosyphilis
• autonomic neuropathy
• hypertension
• subclavian steal
• perilymphatic fistula
• Shy–Drager syndrome

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes (hyper and hypoglycaemia)

Drugs (several)

Anaemia

Thyroid disorder (possible)

Spinal dysfunction
UTI (possible)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Very likely. Consider anxiety and/or depression.

Key history
Careful history to determine if the problem is vertigo or pseudovertigo (giddiness, faintness or
disequilibrium). Check for neurological symptoms, aural symptoms and visual symptoms.
Recent history of respiratory infection or head injury. Drug history including illicit drugs and
alcohol (?acute intoxication).

Key examination
• General examination including gait
• Cardiovascular, auditory and neurological examinations
• Hallpike manoeuvre and Epley test
• Forced hyperventilation test

Key investigations
• FBE
• b glucose
• audiometry
• ECG, ?Holter monitor
• Other tests according to history and examination
• Consider MRI, especially if acoustic neuroma or other tumour suspected

Diagnostic tips
• A sudden attack of vertigo in a young person after a recent URTI suggests vestibular
neuronitis.
• Dizziness is often multifactorial, especially in the elderly.
• Commonly prescribed drugs, especially antihypertensives, antidepressants, aspirin and
salicylates, glyceryl trinitrate, benzodiazipines, major tranquilisers, antiepileptics and
antibiotics, can cause dizziness.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Dyspepsia

Probability diagnosis
Irritable upper GIT (functional dyspepsia)

Gastro-oesophageal reflux

Gastritis

Oesophageal motility disorder (dysmotility)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cancer:

• stomach
• pancreas
• oesophagus

Cardiovascular:

• ischaemic heart disease


• congestive cardiac failure

Pancreatitis

Peptic ulcer (PU)

Pitfalls (often missed)


Myocardial ischaemia

Food allergy (e.g. lactose intolerance)

Pregnancy (early)

Biliary motility disorder

Other gall bladder disease


Post vagotomy

Duodenitis

Rarities:

• hyperparathyroidism
• mesenteric ischaemia
• Zollinger–Ellison syndrome
• kidney failure
• scleroderma

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes (rarely)

Drugs, esp. NSAIDs, aspirin

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Anxiety and stress are common associations of which patients are often unaware. Consider
irritable bowel syndrome.

Key history
Clarify the exact nature of the presenting complaint: what the patient means by ‘indigestion’ or
‘heartburn’. Note the relationship of the symptoms to eating. In particular, care should be taken
to consider and perhaps exclude ischaemic heart disease. Analyse the presenting symptom
according to site and radiation, character of discomfort, aggravating and relieving factors and
associated symptoms. Drug history and past history is important, especially NSAID use.

Key examination
• This does not provide the key to the diagnosis, but perform very careful palpation and
inspection
• Look for evidence of anaemia and jaundice

Key investigations
Do not overinvestigate.
• The investigation of choice is gastroscopy, which is indicated for ‘alarm symptoms’ such
as dysphagia, bleeding and unexplained weight loss
• Test for Helicobacter pylori

Diagnostic tips
• Epigastric pain aggravated by any food and relieved by antacids indicates chronic gastric
ulcer.
• Pain before meals relieved by food indicates chronic duodenal ulcer.
• Triple loss of appetite, weight and colour is a feature of cancer of the stomach.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Dysphagia

Probability diagnosis
Functional (e.g. ‘express’ swallowing, psychogenic)

Tablet-induced irritation

Pharyngotonsillitis

GORD/reflux oesophagitis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Neoplasia/cancer:

• cancer of the pharynx, oesophagus (esp.) stomach


• extrinsic tumour

AIDS (opportunistic oesophageal infection)

Stricture, usually benign peptic stricture

Scleroderma

Neurological causes:

• pseudobulbar palsy
• multiple sclerosis
• motor neurone disease (amyotrophic sclerosis)
• Parkinson disease

Pitfalls (often missed)


Foreign body

Drugs (e.g. phenothiazines)

Subacute thyroiditis

Extrinsic lesions (e.g. lymph nodes, goitre)


Upper oesophageal web (e.g. Plummer–Vinson syndrome)

Eosinophilic oesophagitis

Radiotherapy

Achalasia

Upper oesophageal spasm (mimics angina)

Rarities (some):

• Sjögren syndrome
• aortic aneurysm
• aberrant right subclavian artery
• lead poisoning
• cervical osteoarthritis (large osteophytes)
• other neurological causes
• other mechanical causes

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Drugs

Thyroid disorder

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Yes. Could be functional ?globus hystericus.

Key history
Analyse the nature of the symptom: difficulty in swallowing. Its origin is either oropharyngeal or
oesophageal. A careful history includes a drug history and psychosocial factors.

Key examination
• Focus on the patient’s general features, mouth, oropharynx, larynx, neck (esp.
lymphadenopathy and thyroid) and any abnormal neurological features especially cranial
nerve function and muscle weakness disorders
Key investigations
Consider:

• FBE
• oesophageal manometry study (manometry)
• endoscopy ± barium swallow
• CXR.

The primary investigation in suspected pharyngeal dysphagia is a video barium swallow, while
endoscopy is generally the first investigation in cases of suspected oesophageal dysphagia.

Diagnostic tips
• Dysphagia must not be confused with globus hystericus, which is the sensation of the
‘constant lump in the throat’ although there is no actual difficulty swallowing food.
• Mechanical dysphagia represents cancer until proved otherwise.
• Be careful of a change in symptoms in the presence of longstanding reflux (consider
stricture or cancer).
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Dyspnoea, acute and chronic

Probability diagnosis
Bronchial asthma

Bronchiolitis (children)

COPD

Ageing, lack of fitness

Left heart failure/CCF

Obesity

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• acute heart failure (e.g. AMI)


• acute coronary syndromes
• arrhythmia
• pulmonary embolism
• pulmonary hypertension
• dissecting aneurysm
• cardiomyopathy
• pericardial tamponade
• anaphylaxis

Neoplasia:

• bronchial carcinoma, other malignancy

Infection:

• SARS
• avian influenza
• pneumonia
• acute epiglottitis (children)
Respiratory disorders:

• inhaled foreign body


• upper airways obstruction
• pneumothorax
• atelectasis
• pleural effusion
• tuberculosis
• acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS)

Neuromuscular disease:

• infective polyneuritis (Guillain-Barré)


• poliomyelitis

Pitfalls (often missed)


Interstitial lung diseases:

• idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis


• extrinsic allergic alveolitis
• sarcoidosis
• drug-induced interstitial lung disease

Chemical pneumonitis

Metabolic acidosis

Radiotherapy

Kidney failure (uraemia)

Multiple small pulmonary emboli

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes—Ketoacidosis

Drugs (see list)

Anaemia

Thyroid disorder (thyrotoxicosis)


Is the patient trying to tell me something?
Consider functional hyperventilation (anxiety and panic attacks).

Key history
Aim to differentiate between pulmonary causes such as COPD and asthma and cardiac failure.
Assess the rate of development of dyspnoea.

Key examination
• Careful inspection is mandatory. With patient stripped to waist observe for factors such
as cyanosis, clubbing, mental alertness, dyspnoea at rest, use of accessory muscles and
rib retraction
• Use auscultation to differentiate between crackles and wheezes

Key investigations
The two most important are CXR and pulmonary function test including pulse oximetry. Others
include:

• FBE/ESR
• arterial blood gases
• cardiology (e.g. ECG, echocardiography, enzymes and other medical imaging).

Diagnostic tips
• All heart diseases have dyspnoea on exertion as a common early symptom.
• Several drugs can produce a wide variety of respiratory disorders especially pulmonary
fibrosis and pulmonary eosinophilia. The main agents are amiodarone and cytotoxic
drugs.
• The abrupt onset of severe dyspnoea suggests pneumothorax or pulmonary embolism.
• Toxic agents that may cause hyperventilation are salicylate, methyl alcohol, theophylline
overdosage and ethylene glycol.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Dysuria

Probability diagnosis
UTI (esp. cystitis)

Urethritis

Urethral syndrome—abacterial cystitis (female)

Vaginitis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Neoplasia:

• bladder
• prostate
• urethra

Infection:

• gonorrhoea
• chlamydia/others
• genital herpes
• prostatitis

Reactive arthritis

Calculi (e.g. bladder)

Pitfalls (often missed)


Menopause syndrome

Adenovirus urethritis

Prostatitis

Foreign bodies in lower urinary tract


Acidic urine

Acute fever

Interstitial cystitis

Urethral caruncle/diverticuli

Vaginal prolapse

Obstruction:

• benign prostatic hyperplasia


• urethral stricture
• phimosis
• meatal stenosis

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Drugs

UTI

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider psychosexual problems, anxiety and hypochondriasis.

Key history
It is important to determine whether dysuria is really genitourinary in origin and not attributable
to functional disorders, such as psychosexual problems. Disturbances of micturition are
uncommon in the young male and if present suggest sexually transmitted infection (STIs).

Key questions:
• Could you describe the discomfort?
• What colour is your urine?
• Does it have a particular odour?
• Have you noticed a discharge?
• If so, could it be sexually acquired?
• Do you find intercourse painful or uncomfortable (women)?
• Have you any fever, sweats or chills?

Key examination
• General inspection looking for evidence of kidney disease and vital signs
• Abdominal palpation to focus on the loins and suprapubic areas
• The possibility of STIs should be considered and this includes vaginal examination in the
female and rectal and genital examination in the male
• In the menopausal female the cause may be evident from a dry atrophic urethral opening,
a urethral caruncle or urethral prolapse

Key investigations
• Dipstick testing of the urine
• Microscopy or culture (midstream specimen of urine or suprapubic puncture in children)
• Urethral swabs or first pass urine for STIs
• Further investigations depend on findings

Diagnostic tips
• Urethritis causes pain at the onset of micturition and cystitis at the end.
• Suprapubic discomfort is a feature of bladder infection (cystitis).
• Unexplained dysuria could be a pointer to chlamydia urethritis.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Ear discharge (otorrhoea)

Probability diagnosis
Acute otitis media with perforation

Chronic suppurative otitis media

Furuncle (boil) of ear canal

Infected otitis externa

Reactive skin conditions e.g. eczema

Liquified wax

Serious disorders not to be missed


Infection:

• Pseudomonas pyocyanea
• Cholesteatoma
• Herpes zoster oticus
• Mastoiditis

Cancer:

• Malignancy with discharge e.g. SCC

Other:

• Cerebrospinal fluid otorrhoea (fractured temporal bone)


• Necrotising otitis media
Pitfalls (often missed)
Foreign body with infection/liquidisation e.g. insects

Trauma ± blood

Rarities:

• Keratitis obliterans
• Branchial or salivary fistula
• Wegener’s granulomatosis

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Factitious? Consider excessive manipulation of ear canal

Key history
• Nature of discharge: acute or chronic, clear or bloody, offensive
• Associated symptoms, esp. pain in ear or adjacent structures, fever, tinnitus,
dizziness/vertigo, hearing loss
• Use of ear drops and ear toilet
• Previous history of ear problems and ear surgery
• History of water sports, air travel, tropical residence or head injury

Key examination
Look for cause:

• Otoscopic view of ear and canal


• Inspection of surrounding structures e.g. mastoid
• Look for evidence of herpes zoster infection (sensory branch 7th cranial nerve)
Key investigations
First line:

• swab for M & C of ear discharge


• simple bedside hearing tests

Consider:

• X-ray mastoid
• audiometry
• wound swabs (if evidence infection)
• duplex ultrasound
• ankle brachial index
• biopsy
• KFTs

Diagnostic tips
Acute ear discharge is most likely due to otitis externa or perforated ear drum with otitis media.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Ear pain

Probability diagnosis
Otitis media (viral or bacterial)

Otitis externa

Boils and furuncles of canal

TMJ arthralgia

Eustachian tube dysfunction

Serious disorders not to be missed


Neoplasia of external ear

Cancer of other sites (e.g. tongue, throat)

Herpes zoster (Ramsay—Hunt syndrome)

Acute mastoiditis

Cholesteatoma

Necrotising otitis externa


Pitfalls (often missed)
Foreign bodies in ear

Hard ear wax

Trauma including barotrauma

Dental abscess

Referred pain: neck, throat (e.g. tonsillitis)

Unerupted wisdom tooth and other dental causes

TMJ arthralgia

Chondrodermatitis nodularis helicus

Facial neuralgias, esp. glossopharyngeal

Post tonsillectomy:

• from the wound


• from TMJ due to mouth gag

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Spinal dysfunction (cervical)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Unlikely, but always possible with pain. More likely in children. Consider factitious pain.
Key history
Assess the site of pain and radiation, details of the onset of pain, nature of the pain, aggravating
or reliving factors and associated features such as vertigo, tinnitus, sore throat and irritation of
the external ear. Ask about trauma, especially the use of a cotton bud to clean the ear.

Key examination
• The external ear with manipulation of the ear
• Check helix for chondrodermatitis nodularis helicus
• Palpate the face and neck to include the parotid glands, regional lymph nodes and skin
and temporomandibular joint (TMJ)
• Inspect both empty ear canals and tympanic membrane (TM) with the auroscope using
the largest possible earpiece
• Look for causes of referred pain: cervical spine, nose, postnasal space and mouth
including teeth

Key investigations
Seldom necessary.

• Consider hearing tests, audiometry


• Any ear discharge for MC but swabs of no value if the TM is intact

Diagnostic tips
• The pain of otitis media may be masked by fever in babies and young children.
• If an adult presents with ear pain but normal auroscopy, examine possible referral sites,
namely TMJ, mouth, throat, teeth and cervical spine.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Epigastric pain

Probability diagnosis
GORD/gastritis

Gastric ulcer

Duodenal ulcer/duodenitis

Non-ulcer heartburn

Gallstones/biliary colic

Abdominal muscular strain

Irritable upper GIT

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Acute coronary syndromes esp. AMI


• Ruptured abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA)
• Mesenteric artery ischaemia

Infection:

• Cholecystitis
• Hepatitis
• Lower lobe pneumonia
• Ascending cholangitis

Cancer/tumour:

• Cancer of stomach or pancreas


• Metastatic cancer

Other:

• Pancreatitis
• Perforated ulcer/viscus

Pitfalls (often missed)


Oesophageal spasm

Biliary motility disorder

Aerophagy

Rarities:

• Porphyria
• Addison disease
• Sickle cell disease
• Epigastric hernia

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Drugs e.g. NSAIDs, antibiotics, bisphosphonates, alcohol

Spinal dysfunction—referred

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


A consideration if nil findings.

Key history
Clarify the exact nature of the presenting complaint: the nature of the pain/discomfort,
indigestion or heartburn. Analyse any pain according to the SOCRATES formulation. Include
associated general symptoms such as weight loss, fever or vomiting. Examine past medical
history incl. peptic ulcer, diabetes, hypertension and cerebrovascular disease, as well as drug
history, esp. alcohol and NSAID use.

Key examination
• General features: appearance of patient and vital signs
• Abdominal examination, particularly inspection, palpation and auscultation
• Palpate for nodes in the neck (ca. stomach)
Key investigations
Nil for most cases.

First line:

• urinalysis
• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• Helicobacter pylori test
• upper GIT endoscopy
• ultrasound (?gallstones)

Consider:

• cardiac enzymes
• s lipase/amylase
• ECG
• CXR
• oesophageal manometry
• other imaging if indicated e.g. CT or MRI esp. if epigastric mass

Diagnostic tips
Epigastric pain aggravated by any food and relieved by antacids indicates chronic gastric ulcer.
Pain before meals relieved by food indicates chronic duodenal ulcer.

Epigastric pain waking the person soon after falling asleep (e.g. 3am) indicates gastric ulcer or
biliary colic. Pain can be referred from disorders of the heart, lungs, pancreas, biliary tract and
spine.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Epistaxis

Probability diagnosis
Idiopathic: spontaneous from Little’s area

URTI: common cold/flu/sinusitis

Rhinitis: allergic and atrophic

Vestibulitis

Trauma (incl. nose picking, nose injury)

Drugs (e.g. anticoagulants, aspirin)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• hypertension and arteriosclerosis

Infection:

• systemic febrile illness (e.g. malaria)


• HIV/AIDS

Cancer/neoplasia:

• tumours of nose/sinuses/nasopharynx
• intracranial tumours
• leukaemia

Other:

• thrombocytopenia
• coagulopathy (e.g. haemophilia, liver disease)
Pitfalls (often missed)
Exposure to toxic agents

Vitamin deficiencies: C and K

Septal granulomas and perforations

Foreign bodies (esp. in children)

Cocaine abuse

Rarities:

• hereditary haemorrhagic telangiectasia

Masquerades checklist
Drugs: anticoagulants, aspirin, nasal sprays Anaemia: aplastic anaemia

Key history
Recent trauma to nose. Significant past history (e.g. hypertension). Drug and alcohol history (e.g.
anticoagulants). Bleeding or bruising tendency.

Key examination
• Nasal airways and sinuses
• Skin for evidence of purpura or ecchymoses
• Lymph node areas and abdomen for hepatosplenomegaly
• Vital signs (esp. blood pressure)

Key investigations
Probably none. Consider:

• FBE
• clotting studies
• sinus X-ray
• INR
• CT scan (occasionally).
Diagnostic tips
• Recent onset of persistent bleeding in elderly points to carcinoma.
• Severe epistaxis is often caused by liver disease coagulopathy.
• Difficult-to-control posterior bleeding is a feature of the hypertensive elderly.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Erectile dysfunction

Probability diagnosis
Ageing

Drugs esp. excess alcohol

Diabetes (autonomic dysfunction)

Stress/anxiety/depression

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Generalised arteriopathy esp. lower limbs

Infection:

• Generalised: viral, bacterial

Tumours:

• Pituitary fossa

Other:

• Systemic illness
• Chronic kidney disease

Pitfalls (often missed)


Pelvic trauma

Excessive cigarette smoking

Iatrogenic e.g. prostate surgery, drugs

Thrombosis corpus callosum


Rarities:

• Neurological e.g. MS
• Hypogonadism e.g. Klinefelter’s
• Anatomical e.g. tight frenulum, Peyroine’s disease

Masquerades checklist
Depression including drugs

Diabetes

Drugs: various

Thyroid/other endocrine: several (see history)

Spinal dysfunction e.g. spinal cord pathology, cauda equina lesion

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider psychosexual dysfunction incl. marital disharmony, performance anxiety

Key history
• Nature of onset including nature of sexual relationship
• Ask about nocturnal and early morning erections
• Drug history incl. alcohol, nicotine (4 times risk), street drugs (cocaine, cannabis),
pharmaceutical agents esp. antihypertensives (beta blockers, diuretics), hypolipidaemic
agents, antiandrogens (prostate cancer treatment), antidepressants, antipsychotics, H 2 -
receptor antagonists

Key examination
Genitourinary, cardiovascular and neurogenic examinations are important. This should include a
rectal examination; examination of the vascular and neurological status of the lower limbs; and
genitalia esp. the testicles and penis. Check the cremasteric and bulbocavernosus reflexes.
Key investigations
First line:

• glucose
• FBE
• free testosterone (androgen deficiency)
• thyroxine (hypothyroidism)
• prolactin
• LH
• FSH
• Urinalysis

Consider:

• LFTs esp. GGT (alcohol effect) and KFTs


• nocturnal penile tumescence
• Doppler flow studies

Diagnostic tips
Endocrine causes to consider include androgen/testosterone deficiency, hyperprolactinaemia and
hypothyroidism. Consider pituitary fossa tumour.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Eye, acute and subacute painless loss of


vision

Probability diagnosis
Amaurosis fugax

Migraine

Retinal detachment

Acute glaucoma

‘Wet’ macular degeneration

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• central retinal artery occlusion


• central retinal vein occlusion
• hypertension (complications)
• CVA

Neoplasia:

• intracranial tumour
• intraocular tumour:
o — primary melanoma
o — retinoblastoma
o — metastases

Vitreous haemorrhage

AIDS

Temporal arteritis

Acute glaucoma
Benign intracranial hypertension

Pitfalls (often missed)


Acute glaucoma

Papilloedema

Optic neuritis

Uveitis

Intraocular foreign body

Masquerades checklist
Diabetes (diabetic retinopathy)

Drugs (e.g. quinine, alcohol)

Thyroid disorder (hyperthyroidism)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider ‘hysterical’ blindness, although it is uncommon.

Key history
Past medical history including risk factors for cardiovascular disease and neurology such as
migraine and cerebrovascular disease. Family history and drug history.

Key examination
• Visual acuity: Snellen chart
• Ophthalmoscopic examination, tonometry
• Cardiovascular including carotid arteries

Key investigations
The vast majority of patients should be referred urgently to an ophthalmological service or stroke
unit. Initial tests are:

• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• blood sugar.

Diagnostic tips
• The visual disturbance may be the presenting symptoms of a general medical disorder
such as temporal (giant cell) arteritis, hypertension or diabetes.
• A cherry-red spot on the macula is pathognomonic of retinal artery occlusion.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Eye, gradual loss of vision

Probability diagnosis
Cataract

Chronic glaucoma

‘Dry’, age-related macular degeneration

Gradual retinal detachment

Diabetic retinopathy

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• hypertensive retinopathy
• cerebromacular degeneration

Infection:

• syphilis
• onchocerciasis (filariasis)

Cancer/neoplasia:

• intraorbital tumours
• intracranial tumours
• choroid melanoma

Other:

• optic neuritis (multiple sclerosis)


• Paget disease of skull
Pitfalls (often missed)
Retinitis pigmentosa

Drug toxicity (e.g. quinine, methanol, arsenic)

Rarities:

• choroid retinitis
• vitamin A deficiency
• Leber hereditary optic atrophy

Key history
Past history including risk factors for cardiovascular disease, family history, drug history and
associated symptoms or problems.

Key examination
• Visual acuity, ophthalmoscopic examination, tonometry, although early ophthalmological
referral is recommended

Key investigations
Initial tests are:

• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• blood sugar
• syphilis serology (if clinically indicated).

Diagnostic tips
• Keep the big three causes in mind—cataract, chronic glaucoma and age-related macular
degeneration—and refer for shared care.
• In the older patient whose cataract is not significantly improved with the pinhole test
consider macular degeneration.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Eye, red and tender

Probability diagnosis
Conjunctivitis:

• bacterial
• adenovirus
• allergic

Serious disorders not to be missed


Acute glaucoma

Uveitis:

• acute iritis
• choroiditis

Corneal ulcer

Corneal injury: abrasion/foreign body

Herpes simplex keratitis

Microbial keratitis (e.g. fungal, amoeba, bacterial)

Herpes zoster ophthalmicus

Penetrating injury

Endophthalmitis

Orbital cellulitis
Pitfalls (often missed)
Scleritis/episcleritis

Foreign body (esp. IOFB)

Trauma

Ultraviolet light ‘keratitis’

Blepharitis

Rarities:

• cavernous sinus arteriovenous fistula


• primary tumour of eye

Masquerades checklist
Drugs (hypersensitivity)

Thyroid disorder (hyperthyroidism)

Key history
The five essentials of the history are:

• history of trauma, especially as indicator of intraocular foreign body (IOFB)


• vision
• the degree and type of discomfort
• presence of discharge
• presence of photophobia.

Consider association with spondyloarthropathies.


Key examination
When examining the unilateral red eye keep the following diagnoses in mind:

• trauma
• foreign body, including IOFB
• corneal ulcer
• iritis (uveitis)
• viral conjunctivitis (commonest type)
• acute glaucoma

The four essentials of the examination are:

• testing and recording vision


• meticulous inspection under magnification (slit lamp is ideal)
• testing the pupils
• testing ocular tension

Key investigations
• May include swab of discharge for MC, visual acuity
• ESR/CRP
• HLAB27
• Consider specialist referral

Diagnostic tips
• A purulent discharge indicates bacterial conjunctivitis.
• A clear or mucus discharge indicates viral or allergic conjunctivitis.
• Be alert for the unilateral red eye: think beyond the conjunctivitis trio. It may be a corneal
ulcer, keratitis, foreign body, trauma, uveitis or acute glaucoma.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Facial pain

Probability diagnosis
Dental pain:

• caries
• periapical/dental abscess
• fractured tooth

Maxillary/frontal sinusitis

Herpes zoster (shingles)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• myocardial ischaemia
• aneurysm of cavernous sinus
• internal carotid aneurysm
• ischaemia of posterior inferior cerebellar artery
• temporal arteritis

Cancer/neoplasia:

• cancer: mouth, sinuses, posterior fossa, nasopharynx, tonsils, tongue, larynx


• metastases: orbital, base of brain, bone

Infection:

• orbital cellulitis
• erysipelas
• periapical abscess → osteomyelitis
• acute sinusitis → spreading infection
Pitfalls (often missed)
TMJ dysfunction

Migraine variants:

• facial migraine
• chronic paroxysmal hemicrania

Atypical facial pain

Eye disorders:

• glaucoma
• iritis
• optic neuritis

Chronic dental neuralgia

Facial bone diesease

Parotid gland: mumps, cancer, sialectasis, abscess

Acute glaucoma (upper face)

Cranial nerve neuralgias:

• post-herpetic neuralgia
• trigeminal neuralgia
• glossopharyngeal neuralgia

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Spinal dysfunction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Quite probably. Atypical facial pain has underlying psychogenic elements.
Key history
Diagnosis of virtually all types of facial pain must be based entirely on the history. Include the
typical pain analysis, especially site and radiation.

Key examination
• Palpate the face and neck to include the parotid glands, eyes, regional lymph nodes and
skin
• Inspect the TMJs and cervical spine
• Carefully inspect the nose, mouth (esp. each tooth), pharynx and postnasal space
• Inspect the sinuses with transillumination
• Perform a neurological examination of the cranial nerves

Key investigations
Referral may be appropriate. The association of tumours with neuralgias may have to be
investigated. Radiological investigations to consider include:

• plain X-rays of the paranasal sinuses


• CT scans
• MRI
• orthopantomograms.

Diagnostic tips
• Facial pain never crosses the midline; bilateral pain means bilateral lesions.
• Malignancy must be excluded in the elderly with facial pain.
• Problems from the molar teeth, especially the third (wisdom) commonly presents with
peri-auricular pain and pain in the posterior check.
• Don’t overdiagnose sinusitis: many URTIs may produce mild facial ache (vacuum
effect).
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Falls in the elderly

Probability diagnosis
Environmental hazards e.g. slipping, tripping

Postural hypotension

Postural instability e.g. knees, hips, Parkinson

Visual e.g. glaucoma, macular degeneration

Alcohol: acute or chronic

Medication esp. iatrogenic

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Cerebral insufficiency incl. TIAs, stroke


• Acute coronary syndromes
• Cardiac arrhythmias e.g. sick sinus syndrome
• Subdural or extradural haematoma

Infection:

• Any systemic infection esp. sepsis


• Any febrile illness

Tumour/cancer:

• Cerebral tumour

Other:

• Kidney failure
• Head injury
• Cognitive impairment e.g. dementia, delirium
• Fluid and electrolyte disturbance
Pitfalls (often missed)
Parkinson disease—early onset

Peripheral neuropathy

Gait and foot disorders

Labyrinthine e.g. BPPV, labyrinthitis

Rarities:

• Vitamin deficiency esp. Vit. D


• Cerebellar degeneration
• Post prandial hypotension

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes: hypoglycaemia; neuropathy

Drugs (many—see history)

Anaemia

Thyroid/other endocrine: Addison D, hypothyroid?

Spinal dysfunction esp. myelopathy

Urinary tract infection—nocturia

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Highly likely, consider conversion reaction.
Key history
A careful history is required including an interview with family members and any witnesses to
the fall. Investigate the onset, environment and circumstances of the fall.

Consider seizure and loss of consciousness, and situational factors such as rushing to bathroom,
climbing stairs or ladder. Incl. accounts of any witnesses to the fall.

Questions should incl. any premonitory or associated symptoms e.g. vertigo, lightheadedness,
palpitations, chest pain dyspnoea, visual disturbance, possible unusual or disturbed behaviour.
Gather past and recent medical history incl. diabetes, hypertension, cerebrovascular disease; as
well as a drug history, esp. alcohol or illicit drugs, prescription agents esp. sedatives
antidepressants, hypotensives, hypoglycaemics, antipsychotics, diuretics, NSAIDs. Check
thyroid status.

Key examination
• General features: appearance of patient incl. central cyanosis, hydration status, vital signs
incl. pulse, BP (supine and standing) and temperature
• Look for and exclude obvious extrinsic causes of falls
• Comprehensive CVS examination
• Examine ears, eyes, oral cavity, head and neck, spine, extremities esp. feet
• Neurological examination including muscle features, sensation, coordination, balance and
gait
• Mini mental state examination

Key investigations
First line:

• urinalysis
• blood sugar
• pulse oximetry
• FBE & ESR
• U&E
• ECG (or 24 hour monitor).

Consider others according to history and findings:

• LFTs (γGT)
• TFT
• echocardiography
• spinal X rays
• CT or MRI if indicated
• Doppler studies

Diagnostic tips
Consider rules of 7 in elderly patient: check mental status, eyes, ears, mouth (?dentition,
xerostomia), bladder and bowels, locomotion including feet and medication. Ideally, visit the
home to assess patient’s environment and home support, incl. examination of the medicine
cabinet.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Fever in the returned traveller

Probability diagnosis
Malaria

Viral respiratory illness (e.g. influenza)

Bacterial pneumonia

Hepatitis (may be subclinical)

Gastroenteritis/diarrhoeal illness

Dengue

Serious disorders not to be missed


Malaria

Tuberculosis

Typhoid

Viral haemorrhagic diseases (e.g. Ebola, Lassa)

Encephalitis

Meningococcal meningitis

Melioidosis

Amoebiasis (liver abscess)

HIV seroconversion illness


Pitfalls (often missed)
Ascending cholangitis

Infective endocarditis

Cytomegalovirus

Epstein--Barr virus (glandular fever)

Dengue fever

Lyme disease

Bronchopneumonia

Ross River fever

Rarities:

• chikungunya
• Legionnaire disease
• schistosomiasis
• African trypanosomiasis
• typhus
• Rift Valley fever
• spotted fever
• yellow fever
• other haemorrhagic fevers

Masquerades checklist
Drugs (reaction to antimalarials)

Urinary tract infection

Key history
Ask about itinerary, length of stay, exposure to mosquitoes and possible contact with infectious
diseases. Associated symptoms, especially diarrhoea, abdominal pain, rash and other skin
lesions. Past history, prophylaxis (incl.immunisation) and drug history (incl. antimalarial
therapy).
Key examination
• General features
• Vital signs
• Neck for neck stiffness
• Skin and lymph node sites
• Respiratory and cardiovascular examination
• Abdominal examination, especially liver and spleen

Key investigations
• FBE (?eosinophils)
• ESR
• Blood culture
• Urine MC
• Stool MC
• LFTs
• Thick and thin blood films
• New malaria test
• Dengue serology
• CXR
• Tubercular skin test and interferon gamma release assay (for suspected TB)
• Specific tests for suspected diseases, e.g. Ebola, influenza

Diagnostic tips
• All fever in a returned traveller is malaria until proved otherwise.
• Three causes of a dry cough (in the absence of chest signs) are malaria, typhoid and
amoebic liver abscess.
• Be vigilant for meningitis and encephalitis.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Fever that is prolonged

Probability diagnosis
Pyogenic abscess (anywhere e.g. liver, pelvis)

Pneumonia (viral, bacterial, atypical)

Epstein–Barr mononucleosis

Viral upper respiratory tract infection

Urinary infection (incl. chronic pyelonephritis)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• vasculitides (polyarteritis nodosa, giant cell arteritis/polymyalgia)

Infection:

• HIV/AIDS
• malaria and other tropical diseases
• zoonoses (e.g. leptospirosis, Q fever, listeriosis)
• typhoid/paratyphoid fever
• tuberculosis
• osteomyelitis
• chronic septicaemia/bacteraemia
• infective endocarditis
o Lyme disease
o Syphilis (secondary)

Cancer:

• lymphoma and leukaemia


• solid cancers (e.g. lung, kidney)
• disseminated

Other:
• inflammatory bowel disease (e.g. Crohn)

Pitfalls (often missed)


Connective tissue disorder (e.g. rheumatoid arthritis, systemic lupus erythematous)

Sarcoidosis

Drug idiosyncrasies

Rarities:

• factitious fever

Note: Up to 20% remain unknown. FUO is fever < 38.3°C for at least 3 weeks.

Key history
Include past history, occupation, travel history, sexual history, IV drug use (leads to endocarditis
and abscesses), animal contact, medication and other relevant factors. Enquire about associated
symptoms such as pruritus, a skin rash, abdominal pain and diarrhoea, and weight loss. Note the
fever pattern. The history may need to be repeated.

Key examination
• Note general features and vital signs
• Check skin (rash, vesicles or nodules), eyes, temporal arteries, sinuses, teeth and oral
cavity, heart (note any murmurs), lungs, abdomen (enlarged or tender liver, spleen,
kidney), rectal and pelvic examination, lymph nodes (esp. cervical), urinalysis.

Key investigations
The basics are:

• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• CXR and sinus films
• urine MC
• routine blood chemistry
• LFTs
• blood culture.
Other tests depend on clinical pointers (e.g. specific organisms, lymph node biopsy, HIV,
tuberculosis, connective tissue auto-antibodies).

Diagnostic tips
• Prolonged fever is usually an uncommon presentation of a common disorder (unless
recent travel, esp. to tropics).
• Fever in the elderly is sepsis until proved otherwise (esp. lungs and urinary tract).
• The diagnosis of septicaemia can be easily missed, especially in small children, the
elderly and the immunocompromised.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Fits, faints and funny turns

Probability diagnosis
Anxiety related/hyperventilation

Vasovagal syncope

Postural hypotension

Breath-holding attacks (children)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• dysrhythmias, e.g. SVT


• acute coronary syndrome/silent AMI
• aortic stenosis
• postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS)

Cerebrovascular:

• TIAs

Neoplasia:

• space-occupying lesions

Infections:

• infective endocarditis

Hypoglycaemia
Pitfalls (often missed)
Atypical migraine

Cardiac arrhythmias/long QT syndrome

Simple partial seizures

Complex partial seizures

Atypical tonic--clonic seizures

Drugs/alcohol/marijuana/illicit drugs

Electrolyte disturbances (e.g. hypokalaemia)

Hypoxia

Sleep disorders

Transient global amnesia

Micturition/cough syncope

Rarities:

• atrial myxoma
• Stokes–Adams attacks

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes (hypoglycaemia, ketoacidosis)

Drugs

Anaemia

Endocrine (Addison disease, hypothyroidism)

Spinal dysfunction (cervical spondylosis)


Is the patient trying to tell me something?
Highly likely. Psychogenic-pseudo-seizures and ‘communication’ disorders quite significant.

Key history
Fundamental to diagnosis. A reliable eyewitness account of the ‘turn’ is invaluable. Determine
what the patient means by ‘funny turn’. Evaluate the mental, personal and social factors. Assess
three components: lead-up to the episode, description of the episode and post-episode events.
Consider onset, precipitation factors and associated symptoms; also drug history and past history,
especially substance abuse.

Key examination
• Evaluate mental state, cerebrovascular/cardiovascular status, cervical spine
• Look for evidence of anaemia, alcohol abuse and infection

Key investigations
Consider:

• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• blood sugar
• U&E
• ECG
• 24-hour ambulatory cardiac monitor
• EEG or video EEG
• selected radiology (e.g. carotid duplex Doppler scan).

Diagnostic tips
• The commonest cause of ‘funny turns’ is lightheadedness, often related to psychogenic
factors such as anxiety, panic and hyperventilation. Patients usually call this dizziness.
• Migraine is a great mimic and can cause confusion in diagnosis.
• The more bizarre the description of a ‘funny turn’ the more likely a functional problem is
the cause.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Foot and ankle pain

Probability diagnosis
Acute or chronic foot strain

Sprained ankle

Osteoarthritis (esp. great toe – hallux rigidus)

Plantar fasciitis

Achilles tendonopathy

Tibialis posterior tendonopathy

Wart, corn or callus

Ingrowing toenail/paronychia

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular insufficiency:

• small vessel disease

Neoplasia/cancer:

• osteoid osteoma
• osteosarcoma
• synovial sarcoma
• acral lentiginous melanoma

Infection (rare):

• septic arthritis
• actinomycosis
• osteomyelitis

Rheumatoid arthritis
Peripheral neuropathy

Complex regional pain syndromes

Ruptured Achilles’ tendon

Ruptured tibialis posterior tendon

Pitfalls (often missed)


Foreign body (especially children)

Gout

Nerve syndromes:

• Morton neuroma
• tarsal tunnel syndrome
• deep peroneal nerve

Chilblains

Stress fracture (e.g. navicular)

Erythema nodosum

Rarities:

• spondyloarthropathies
• osteochondritis: navicular (Köhler), metatarsal head (Freiberg), calcaneum (Sever)

Glomus tumour (under nail)

Paget disease

Masquerades checklist
Diabetes

Drugs

Spinal dysfunction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


A non-organic cause warrants consideration with any painful condition.

Key history
Ask about the quality of the pain, its distribution, mode of onset, periodicity, relationship to
weight-bearing and associated features such as swelling or colour change. Enquire about pain in
other joints including sacroiliac joints.

Key examination
• Follow the inspection, palpation, movement and test function approach
• Test active and passive movements of the ankle (talar) joint, hindfoot (subtalar) joint and
mid-foot (midtarsal) joint
• Check the peripheral circulation and perform a neurological examination including
sensation, motor strength and reflexes

Key investigations
Consider:

• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• rheumatoid arthritis tests
• blood glucose
• uric acid
• nerve conduction studies and imaging (e.g. plain X-ray—compare both sides)
• ultrasound
• MRI
• radionuclide scans.

Diagnostic tips
• Good quality plain X-rays are important if there is doubt about the diagnosis of a painful
foot.
• Foot strain is probably the commonest cause of podalgia.
• All the distal joints of the foot may be involved in arthritic disorders.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Haematemesis

Probability diagnosis
Chronic peptic ulcer (stomach and duodenum) 50%

Acute gastric ulcers/erosions 20%

Oesophagitis (incl. GORD)

Mallory--Weiss (emetogenic) syndrome

Drugs: aspirin, NSAIDs, anticoagulants, clopidogrel, NOACs

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• oesophageal varices
• blood dyscrasias, e.g. aplastic anaemia
• vascular malformation/angiodysplasia
• hereditary coagulopathy

Cancer:

• gastric or oesophageal

Other:

• chronic liver disease

Pitfalls (often missed)


Stomach ulcer

Swallowed blood (e.g. epistaxis)


Collagen diseases (e.g. scleroderma)

Rarities:

• ruptured oesophagus
• hereditary haemorrhagic telangiectasia
• scurvy
• ingested poisons (e.g. acid, alkali, arsenic)
• gastric antral vascular ectasia

Key history
• Nature of vomitus from fresh blood to ‘coffee grounds’
• Is bleeding arising from the mouth, nose or pharynx?
• Indigestion, heartburn or stomach pains
• Associated symptoms (e.g. weight loss, jaundice)
• Any bleeding problems
• Drug history including alcohol, NSAIDs, antiplatelet agents, warfarin, steroids

Key examination
• Patient’s general state including circulation, vital signs
• Abdominal examination and rectal examination
• Evidence of liver disease

Key investigations
• Upper GIT endoscopy diagnoses bleeding source in 80%
• FBE
• LFTs including © GT
• Helicobacter pylori tests
• Imaging (e.g. plain erect X-ray, as indicated)

Diagnostic tips
• Melaena occurs in 50% of cases of haematemesis.
• Oesophageal bleeding tends to give vomiting fresh blood.
• ‘Coffee grounds’ vomitus indicates contact with gastric acid.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Haematuria

Probability diagnosis
Infection:

• cystitis (both sexes)/urethrotrigonitis (female)


• urethritis (male)
• prostatitis (male)

Calculi-kidney, ureteric, bladder

Bladder tumour

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• kidney infarction
• kidney vein thrombosis
• prostatic varices

Neoplasia/cancer:

• kidney tumour
• urothelial: bladder, kidney, pelvis, ureter
• prostate cancer

Infection:

• infective endocarditis
• kidney tuberculosis
• acute glomerulonephritis
• blackwater fever (falciparum malaria)

IgA nephropathy

Kidney papillary necrosis

Other kidney disease


Pitfalls (often missed)
Urethral prolapse/caruncle

Pseudohaematuria (e.g. beetroot, porphyria)

Benign prostatic hyperplasia

Trauma: blunt or penetrating

Foreign bodies

Bleeding disorders

Haemorrhagic cystitis

Exercise (esp. long distance running)

Radiation cystitis

Menstrual contamination

Rarities:

• hydronephrosis
• Henoch–Schönlein purpura
• schistosomiasis (bilharzia)
• polycystic kidneys
• kidney cysts
• endometriosis (bladder)
• systemic vasculitides

Masquerades checklist
Drugs (cytotoxics, anticoagulants) UTI

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider artefactual haematuria.
Key history
Is it really haematuria? Red discolouration can be due to haemolysis or red food dye. The history
should include nature of haematuria, associations such as pain, sexually transmitted infections,
dysuria and frequency. Drug history, athletic history, urological history, sexual history, recent
trauma history, travel history.

Key examination
• General examination and vital signs, especially BP
• Cardiovascular examination to exclude possible kidney embolisation
• Abdomen examination especially for a palpable enlarged kidney or spleen
• Suprapubic examination for bladder tenderness or enlargement
• Consider rectal examination in men and vaginal examination in women

Key investigations
• Urine analysis
• Urine MC
• Urine cytology
• FBE/ESR
• Appropriate radiology (e.g. intravenous urogram, intravenous pyelogram, ultrasound.
• Direct imaging (e.g. cystoscopy)

Diagnostic tips
• Macroscopic haematuria is always abnormal except in menstruating women.
• Common sources of macroscopic haematuria are the bladder, urethra, prostate and
kidney.
• Joggers and athletes engaged in very vigorous exercise can develop transient microscopic
haematuria.
• Common urological cancers that cause haematuria are the bladder (70%), kidney (17%),
kidney pelvis or ureter (7%) and prostate (5%).
• The key radiological investigation is the intravenous urogram (pyelogram).
• Sometimes blood in the urine can come from the rectum or vagina.
• Painless frank haematuria is an ominous sign.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Haemoptysis in adults

Probability diagnosis
Acute chest infection:

• URTI (24%)
• bronchitis

Chronic bronchitis

Trauma: chest contusion, prolonged coughing

Cause often unknown (22%)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• pulmonary infarction/embolus
• LHF / pulmonary oedema
• mitral stenosis

Infection:

• lobar pneumonia (rusty sputum)


• tuberculosis
• lung abscess

Cancer/tumour (4%):

• bronchogenic carcinoma
• tumour of the larynx or trachea

Other:

• blood disorders including anticoagulants


Pitfalls (often missed)
Foreign body

Bronchiectasis (13%)

Iatrogenic (e.g. endotracheal intubation)

Spurious haemoptysis (blood from nose or throat)

Rarities:

• idiopathic pulmonary haemosiderosis


• pulmonary AV malformation
• Goodpasture syndrome
• connective tissue disorder

Key history
Presenting symptom clarification—is it haemoptysis, haematemesis or bleeding from the nose or
throat? General symptoms (e.g. weight loss, fever, pain, esp. pleuritic pain). Respiratory and
cardiac history including past history and exposure to TB (e.g. refugees). Drug history especially
smoking, alcohol, anticoagulation.

Key examination
• General appearance and vital signs
• Full respiratory and cardiovascular examination including upper airways and mouth
• Check legs for evidence of deep venous thrombosis

Key investigations
• Chest X-ray
• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• Sputum M&C
• Other tests (e.g. CT, bronchoscopy, ECG, echocardiogram, ventilation/perfusion scan)
according to clinical findings
Diagnostic tips
• Blood originating from any area can be aspirated throughout lung.
• Bright red haemoptysis in a young person may be the initial symptom of pulmonary TB.
• Large haemoptyses are usually due to bronchiectasis or TB.
• The commonest causes of haemoptysis are URTI (24%), acute or chronic bronchitis
(17%), bronchiectasis (13%), TB (10%). Unknown causes total about 22%.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Hair loss

Probability diagnosis
Androgenetic alopecia (male pattern baldness)

Alopecia areata (diffuse type)

Telogen effluvian (incl. postpartum)

Anagen effluvian (esp. cytotoxic therapy)

Seborrhoeic dermatitis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Infection:

• tinea capitis
• bacterial folliculitis
• secondary syphilis
• post-febrile state

Cancer:

• treatment for cancer

Other:

• systemic disease (e.g. lupus)

Pitfalls (often missed)


Rarities:

Heavy metal poisoning

Nutritional:

• severe dieting
• malnutrition
• zinc/iron deficiency

Masquerades checklist
Drugs (cytotoxics, anticoagulants, anti-epileptics, amphetamines, anti-thyroid agents, various
hormones, cessation OCP)

Thyroid/other endocrine (hypothyroidism)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Emotional stress → telogen effluvium. Trichotillomania.

Key history
• Onset, duration, quantity and rate of loss
• Localised or generalised loss
• Characteristics of hair (e.g. scales, white bulbs)
• Associated symptoms (e.g. pruritus, scaling, pustules)
• Systems review including fever, acute illness, surgery, stressors
• Endocrine features
• Past history including skin disorders, cancer, thyroid disorders
• Family history of hair loss
• Drug history

Key examination
• General review with emphasis on endocrine system and examination of scalp
• Look for exclamation mark hair, ‘white bulb’ hair, state of bald patch (clean, scaly,
scarred or inflamed) and the unusual pattern of trichotillomania

Key investigations
Consider:

• FBE/ESR
• pituitary hormones (FSH/LH/prolactin/TSH)
• hair pull test
• trichogram
• scalp biopsy
• skin scrapings and hair sample for fungal microsurgery and culture.
Diagnostic tips
• Androgenetic (male pattern and female pattern hair loss) is the most common type.
• Microscopic examination (light or electron) may be required for definitive diagnosis.
• For patchy loss consider alopecia areata and trichotillomania.
• Generalised loss: consider telogen effluvium, systemic disease and drugs.
• In telogen effluvium, the traumatic event has preceded the hair loss by about 2 months
(peak loss at 4 months). ‘White bulbs’ are diagnostic.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Halitosis

Probability diagnosis
• Dietary habits
• Poor oral hygiene
• Oro-dental disease (esp. gingivitis, discharging abscess)
• Dry mouth (e.g. on waking)
• Smoking/alcohol

Serious disorders not to be missed


Malignancy

• lung, oropharynx, larynx, stomach, nose, leukaemia

Pulmonary tuberculosis

Quinsy

Lung abscess

Blood dyscrasias/leukaemia

Uraemia

Hepatic failure

Pitfalls (often missed)


Nasal and sinus infection

Tonsillitis

Mouth breathing

Systemic infection

Appendicitis

Bronchiectasis
GORD/Hiatus hernia

Rarities:

• pharyngeal and oesophageal diverticula


• Sjögren syndrome
• scurvy

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes (acetone)

Drugs (e.g. antidepressants, isosorbide)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Possible manifestation of psychogenic disorder (e.g. depression).

Key history
• General health
• Respiratory history
• Gastrointestinal history including dry mouth and reflux
• Dental history
• Drug history including OTC preparations, alcohol and smoking
• Dietary history: ask about onions, garlic, peppers, curries, spicy salami and similar meats,
strong cheeses and water intake
• Psychosocial history

Key examination
• Orodental inspection, also oropharynx, nose and sinuses
• Respiratory system
• Abdominal examination
Key investigations
• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• Urine analysis
• Blood sugar
• Kidney function tests
• Liver function tests
• X-ray of sinuses
• Consider CT scan sinuses

Diagnostic tips
• If cause is unknown refer to a dental surgeon; consider an ENT opinion.
• Bacterial putrefaction of dental and food debris plus inflammation of the gums are largely
responsible for oral malodour.
• Smoking, alcohol and a dry mouth all aggravate the problem.
• One survey indicated that 87% had an oral cause, 8% ENT and 5% an unidentified cause.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Hallucinations

Probability diagnosis
Drugs: illicit or prescribed

Alcohol: acute or chronic

Schizophrenia

Febrile delirium

Affective (mood) disorders

Drug withdrawal inc. alcohol, hypnotics

Dementias esp. Lewy body disease

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Cerebrovascular disease
• Migraine (luminous)

Infection:

• Encephalitis/meningitis
• Septicaemia
• Any serious febrile illness

Tumours:

• Cerebral tumours
• Cancer treatment

Other:

• Hypoxia
• Liver failure
• Metabolic/electrolyte imbalance
• Dehydration

Pitfalls (often missed)


Major depression

Extreme fatigue

Vitamin deficiency esp. B group

Seizure disorders esp. complex partial

Rarities:

• Narcolepsy
• Post-concussion
• Bereavement
• Multiple sclerosis

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Drugs: iatrogenic/social–illicit

Thyroid/other endocrine: hypothyroid?

Urinary tract infection esp. elderly

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider conversion disorder (hysteria); fabrication.

Key history
A careful history is required, esp. current history incl. general health, febrile illness,
psychological issues, neurological features, nutrition and head injury. Elicit type of hallucination:
auditory, visual, olfactory, tactile, hypnogogic or hypnopomic. Examine past, family and
psychosocial history, as well as any history of cerebrovascular disease, diabetes, hypertension or
migraine. Check thyroid symptoms, particularly for hypothyroidism. Also examine drug history:
prescribed; OTC; alcohol; social esp. marijuana, opioids, amphetamines, LSD, petrol sniffing.

Key examination
• General features: appearance of patient, vital signs
• General respiratory, neurological and cardiovascular examination
• Pulse oximetry
• Mental state examination

Key investigations
First line:

• urinalysis
• blood glucose
• FBE
• U&E

Consider:

• LFTs (γGT)
• ECG
• KFTs
• cerebral imaging

Diagnostic tips
Pay close attention to drugs use, esp. alcohol, caffeine, narcotics and illicit agents

Auditory hallucinations – incl. schizophrenia; depression; bereavement.

Visual: organic disease

Olfactory: complex partial seizures (temporal lobe)

Tactile: drugs (alcohol, opioids e.g. cocaine, amphetamines esp. ‘ice’)


Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Headache

Probability diagnosis
Acute:

• respiratory infection

Chronic:

• tension-type headache
• combination headache
• migraine
• transformed migraine

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• subarachnoid haemorrhage
• intracranial haemorrhage
• carotid or vertebral artery dissection
• temporal arteritis
• cerebral venous thrombosis

Neoplasia:

• cerebral tumour
• pituitary tumour

Infection:

• meningitis (esp. fungal)


• encephalitis
• intracranial abscess

Haematoma: extradural/subdural

Glaucoma

Benign intracranial hypertension


Pitfalls (often missed)
Cervical spondylosis/dysfunction

Dental disorders

Refractive errors of eye

Sinusitis

Ophthalmic herpes zoster (pre-eruption)

Exertional headache

Hypoglycaemia

Post-traumatic headache (e.g. post-concussion)

Post-spinal procedure (e.g. epidural, lumbar puncture)

Sleep apnoea

Rarities:

• Paget disease
• post-sexual intercourse
• cluster headache
• Cushing syndrome
• Conn syndrome
• Addison disease
• dysautonomic cephalgia
Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Drugs (see list)

Anaemia

Thyroid disorder and other endocrine (as above)

Spinal dysfunction (cerviogenic)

UTI

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Quite likely if there is an underlying psychogenic disorder.

Key history
A full description of the pain including a pain analysis should be obtained, especially associated
symptoms. It is useful to get the patient to prepare a diary with a grid plotting the relative pain
intensity with time of day. Family history, psychosocial history and drug history.

Key examination
• Use the basic tools of trade: thermometer, sphygmomanometer, pen torch, diagnostic set
with ophthalmoscope and stethoscope
• Inspect the head, temporal arteries and eyes
• Areas to palpate include the temporal arteries, the facial and neck muscles, the cervical
spine and sinusitis, teeth and TMJs
• Look for signs of meningeal irritation and papilloedema
• A mental state examination is advisable
• Perform a basic neurological examination

Key investigations
Consider:
• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• selective radiography (e.g. skull X-ray, sinus X-ray, CT scan or MRI scan).

Diagnostic tips
• Hypertension is an uncommon cause of headache.
• ‘Combination headaches’, which can last for days, have a mix of components such as
tension, depression, vascular headache and drug dependence.
• A patient >55 years presenting with unaccustomed headache probably has an organic
cause.
• Drugs that may cause headache: alcohol, analgesics (rebound), caffeine,
antihypertensives (several), COCP, corticosteroids, NSAIDs (esp. indomethacin),
vasodilators esp. nitrates, sildenafil.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Hip and buttock pain

Probability diagnosis
Traumatic muscular strains

Referred pain from spine

Greater trochanteric pain syndrome

Osteoarthritis of hip

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• buttock claudication

Neoplasia:

• metastatic cancer
• osteoid osteoma

Infection:

• septic arthritis
• osteomyelitis
• tuberculosis
• pelvic and abdominal infections: pelvic abscess, pelvic inflammatory disease, prostatitis

Childhood disorders:

• DDH
• Perthes’ disease
• slipped femoral epiphysis
• transient synovitis (irritable hip)
• juvenile chronic arthritis
Pitfalls (often missed)
Polymyalgia rheumatica

Fractures:

• stress fractures femoral neck


• subcapital fractures
• sacrum
• pubic rami

Avascular necrosis femoral head

Femoroacetabular impingement (e.g. exostoses)

Torn acetabular labrum

Sacroiliac joint disorders

Inguinal or femoral hernia

Bursitis or tendonitis:

• greater trochanteric pain syndrome


• ischial bursitis
• iliopsoas bursitis

Osteitis pubis

Neurogenic claudication

Chilblains

Rarities:

• haemarthrosis (e.g. haemophilia)


• Paget disease
• nerve entrapments: sciatica ‘hip pocket nerve’, obturator, lateral cutaneous nerve thigh
Masquerades checklist
Depression

Spinal dysfunction incl. spinal stenosis

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Non-organic pain may be present. Patient with arthritis may be fearful of being crippled.

Key history
Pain analysis, especially exact site and pain radiation. Associated symptoms such as limp,
stiffness, night pain, fever. Past history, family history, obstetric history, drug history.

Key examination
• The traditional method of look, feel, move, measure, test function and look elsewhere
• The patient should be stripped to the underwear to allow maximal exposure
• Also examine lumbosacral spine, sacroiliac joints, groin and knee

Key investigations
• Serological tests: RA factor
• FBE, ESR/CRP
• Radiological tests: plain X-ray (AP) of pelvis to show both hip joints; lateral X-ray
(‘frog’ lateral best in children)
• CT or MRI of hip joint
• Needle aspiration of joint if septic arthritis suspected

Diagnostic tips
• True hip pain is felt in the groin, thigh and medial aspect of the knee.
• Disorders of the hip joint commonly refer pain to the knee and thigh.
• Limp has an inseparable relationship with painful hip and buttock conditions.
• Keep in mind the greater trochanteric pain syndrome, especially when middle-aged
women complain of hip pain.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Hirsutism in women

Probability diagnosis
Constitutional (physiological or familial)

Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cancer/tumour:

• virilising ovarian tumour


• adrenal tumours (cancer and adenoma)
• ectopic (paraneoplastic) hormone production (e.g. lung cancer, carcinoid)

Pitfalls (often missed)


Postmenopausal

Rarities:

• porphyria cutanea tarda


• congenital adrenal hyperplasia

Masquerades checklist
Drugs (many incl. phenytoin, danazol, minoxidil, anabolic steroids, cyclosporin, corticosteroids,
OCP, phenothiazines, interferon 〈, penicillamine)

Thyroid/other endocrine (prolactinaemia, Cushing, acromegaly, hypothyroidism)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider anorexia nervosa

Key history
History of age of onset, extent and activity of the hair. Family history and past medical history
including endocrine disorders and drugs especially those listed opposite.

Key examination
• General inspection including distribution and character of the hair growth, endocrine
abnormalities (e.g. Cushing syndrome), skin, abdomen and breasts

Key investigations
• Consider pituitary hormones (e.g. FSH, LH, ACTH, TSH, prolactin)
• Serum thyroxine, testosterone, DHEAS
• Pelvic ultrasound (?PCOS)
• Urinary porphyrins
• Imaging of pituitary and adrenal regions

Diagnostic tips
• Mild longstanding hirsutism does not require investigation.
• Keep in mind possibility of self-medication, especially in athletes (anabolic steroids).
• Red flags include sudden appearance of hirsutism/virilisation and a pelvic or abdominal
mass.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Hoarseness

Probability diagnosis
Viral URTI: acute laryngitis

Non-specific irritative laryngitis (Reinke oedema)

Vocal abuse (shouting, screaming, etc.)

Smoking

Nodules and polyps of cords

Presbyphonia in elderly: ‘tired’ voice

Hypothyroidism

Acute tonsillitis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cancer:

• larynx, lung, including recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy, oesophagus, thyroid

Imminent airway obstruction (e.g. acute epiglottis, croup)

Rare other severe infections (e.g. TB, diphtheria)

Foreign body

Motor neurone disease

Myasthenia gravis
Pitfalls (often missed)
Toxic fumes

Vocal abuse

Benign tumours of vocal cords (e.g. polyps, ‘singer’s nodules’, papillomas)

Gastro-oesophageal reflux → pharyngolaryngitis

Goitre

Dystonia

Physical trauma (e.g. post-intubation), haematoma

Fungal infections (e.g. Candida with steroid inhalation, immunocompromised)

Allergy (e.g. angioedema)

Leucoplakia

Systemic autoimmune disorders (e.g. SLE, Wegener granulomatosis)

Masquerades
Consider:

• drugs: antipsychotics, anabolic steroids


• smoking → non-specific laryngitis
• hypothyroidism, acromegaly

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider:

• functional aphonia
• functional stridor
Key history
Note the nature and duration of the voice change. Enquire about corticosteroid inhalations,
excessive or unaccustomed voice straining, especially singing, recent surgery, possible reflux,
smoking or exposure to environmental pollutants. Elicit associated respiratory or general
symptoms such as cough and weight loss.

Key examination
• Palpate the neck for enlargement of the thyroid gland or cervical nodes
• Perform a simple oropharyngeal examination except if epiglottitis is suspected
• Check for signs of hypothyroidism, such as coarse dry hair and skin, slow pulse and
mental slowing
• Perform indirect laryngoscopy if skilled in the procedure

Key investigations
Consider:

• thyroid function tests


• chest X-ray if it is possibly due to lung carcinoma with recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy
• indirect laryngoscopy (the gag reflex may preclude this)
• a special CT scan to detect suspected neoplasia or laryngeal trauma.

Diagnostic tips
• Acute hoarseness rarely causes any diagnostic problem or concern but the chronic cases
are often cause for concern.
• Remember that intubation causes transient hoarseness.
• Consider gastro-oesophageal reflux disease in the elderly.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Insomnia

Probability diagnosis
Stress and anxiety

Depression

Inappropriate sleep hygiene or lifestyle

Environmental e.g. noisy household

Drug withdrawal inc. alcohol, hypnotics

Biorhythm disruption e.g. shift work, travel

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Peripheral vascular disease


• Congestive cardiac failure

Tumours:

• Pharyngeal

Other:

• Pain syndromes e.g. back, arthritis, CTS, cancer


• Respiratory e.g. asthma, COPD, nasal obstruction
• Post traumatic stress disorder
• Psychosis
• Restless legs/nocturnal myoclonus
Pitfalls (often missed)
Sleep apnoea

GORD

Dementia

Menopausal symptoms

Rarities:

• Macroglossia/tonsillar hypertrophy
• Malnutrition
• Parasomnias e.g. night terrors
• Malnutrition

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Drugs: stimulants, alcohol, beta blockers, SSRIs, steroids

Thyroid/other endocrine: hyperthyroid

Spinal dysfunction

Urinary tract infection: nocturia

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


A consideration if nil findings.

Some cases are normal variant or idiopathic.


Key history
A careful history is required because some patients have unrealistic expectations about the
required amount of sleep they need or have misperceptions of how long they have slept. Explore
lifestyle factors esp. psychosocial reasons, painful conditions, drug use and abuse, appetite,
energy, sexual issues and physical factors. Examine past medical history including diabetes,
hypertension and cerebrovascular disease, as well as drug history, esp. alcohol. Check thyroid
status, esp. hyperthyroidism.

Key examination
• General features: appearance of patient, vital signs including BMI, inspection of the nasal
passages, throat and neck (goitre)
• General respiratory and cardiovascular examination

Key investigations
Nil for most cases. Others according to history and findings.

Consider:

• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• LFTs (γGT)
• TFT
• sleep studies

Diagnostic tips
Pay close attention to drugs use, esp. alcohol, caffeine, narcotics, illicit agents, SSRIs,
benzodiazepines, and esp. if desperate request for drugs.

Be aware of the effects of ageing including carpal tunnel syndrome, arthritis, prostate problems
and incontinence.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Jaundice in adults

Probability diagnosis
Hepatitis A, B, C (mainly B, C)

Gallstones

Alcoholic hepatitis/cirrhosis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Malignancy:

• pancreas
• biliary tract
• hepatocellular (hepatoma)
• metastases

Infection:

• septicaemia
• ascending cholangitis
• fulminant hepatitis
• HIV/AIDS
• leptospirosis

Paracetamol overdose

Rarities:

• Wilson syndrome
• Reye syndrome
• acute fatty liver of pregnancy
Pitfalls (often missed)
Gallstones in common bile duct

Genetic disorders: Gilbert syndrome, Wilson syndrome, galactosaemia, others

Cardiac failure

Primary biliary cirrhosis

Autoimmune chronic active hepatitis

Primary sclerosing cholangitis

Chronic viral hepatitis

Amyloidosis

Haemochromatosis

Viral infections (e.g. CMV, EBV)

Masquerades checklist
Drugs (several, see list)

Anaemia (haemolytic)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Not usually applicable.
Key history
Associated symptoms (e.g. rash, pruritus, fever, arthralgia, weight loss). Medical history. Contact
with people with hepatitis or jaundice. Overseas travel, family history, drug history, IV drug use,
sexual history, occupational history.

Key examination
• General inspection including skin for signs of excoriation
• The abdominal examination is important with a focus on the liver and spleen
• Look for signs of chronic liver disease
• Test for hepatitis flap (asterixis) and fetor, which indicate liver failure
• Include dipstick urine testing for bilirubin and urobilinogen

Key investigations
• The main ones are the standard LFTs and viral serology for infective causes (hepatitis A,
B, C and possibly EBV)
• Consider hepatobiliary imaging, autoantibodies for autoimmune chronic active hepatitis
and primary biliary cirrhosis, tumour markers and iron studies

Diagnostic tips
• All drugs should be suspected as potential hepatotoxins.
• All patients with jaundice should be tested for hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg).
• Clinical jaundice manifests only when the bilirubin level exceeds 50 → mol/L.
• The most common causes of jaundice recorded in a general practice population are (in
order): viral hepatitis, gallstones, pancreatic cancer, cirrhosis, pancreatitis and drugs.
• Haemolytic anaemia leading to jaundice has multiple causes (e.g. autoimmune, malaria,
drugs, hereditary disorders, metabolic defects).
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Knee pain

Probability diagnosis
Ligament strains and sprains ± traumatic synovitis

Osteoarthritis

Patellofemoral syndrome

Prepatellar bursitis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular disorders:

• deep venous thrombosis


• superficial thrombophlebitis

Neoplasia/cancer:

• primary in bone
• metastases

Infection:

• septic arthritis
• tuberculosis

Rheumatic fever

Rheumatoid arthritis

Acute cruciate ligament tear

Juvenile chronic arthritis


Pitfalls (often missed)
Referred pain: back or hip disease

Foreign bodies

Intra-articular loose bodies

Osteochondritis dissecans

Osteonecrosis

Synovial chondromatosis

Osgood–Schlatter disorder

Meniscal tears

Fractures around knee

Pseudogout (chondrocalcinosis)

Gout → patellar bursitis

Ruptured popliteal (Baker’s) cyst

Rarities:

• sarcoidosis
• Paget disease
• spondyloarthropathy

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Spinal dysfunction (referred)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Psychogenic factors relevant, especially with possible injury compensation.
Key history
The history helps diagnosis, especially evaluating the nature of the injury. Define whether the
pain is acute or chronic, dull or sharp, continuous or recurring. Keep in mind age-related causes
and past history.

Key examination
The provisional diagnosis may be evident from a combination of the history and simple
inspection of the joint but the process of testing palpation, movements (active and passive) and
specific structures of the knee joint helps pinpoint the disorder.

Key investigations
Consider:

• FBE/ESR
• connective tissue antibodies
• blood culture
• plain X-ray including special views
• bone scan
• ultrasound
• arthrography: CT scan, MRI (excellent for investigating internal ‘derangement’)
• arthroscopy
• aspiration of fluid for culture or crystal examination.

Diagnostic tips
Examine the hip and lumbosacral spine if examination of the knee is normal but knee pain is the
complaint.

Acute haemarthrosis following an injury should be regarded as an anterior cruciate ligament tear
until proved otherwise.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Leg and ankle swelling

Probability diagnosis
Physiological:

• dependency/gravitational
• prolonged sitting, standing, walking
• hot weather
• pregnancy
• mechanical (e.g. constricting clothing)

Chronic venous insufficiency (varicose veins)

Congestive cardiac failure

Drugs (e.g. calcium antagonists, NSAIDs)

Local trauma

Obesity

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• deep venous thrombosis (DVT)


• inferior vena cava thrombosis
• thrombophlebitis

Infection:

• cellulitis
• tropical infections (e.g. filariasis, hookworm)

Cancer:

• obstruction from pelvic cancer


• localised malignancy
Other:

• kidney disease (e.g. nephrotic syndrome)


• liver disease (e.g. cirrhosis)
• skin allergy (e.g. angioneurotic oedema)

Pitfalls (often missed)


Idiopathic (periodic or cyclic) oedema

Protein-losing enteropathy (e.g. Crohn)

Lipoedema (fat and fluids) of legs

Lipidema (fat) of legs

Rarities:

• malnutrition
• lymphoedema: primary or secondary

Masquerades checklist
Diabetes

Drugs (multiple; see list)

Thyroid/endocrine (hypothyroidism, Cushing syndrome)

Key history
Past history (esp. liver, heart, kidney disease), travel, drugs, occupation, recent trauma.
Circumstances of swelling (e.g. prolonged walking, long journey).

Key examination
• Cardiovascular, abdomen (signs of liver disease), legs including circulation, varicose
veins and evidence DVT
Key investigations
Consider:

• urinalysis (?albumin)
• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• U&E
• KFTs
• serum albumin/LFTs
• TSH
• ultrasound (DVT screen)
• CXR
• pelvic ultrasound
• other radiographs (e.g. CT scan, venogram).

Diagnostic tips
• Not all swollen legs require investigation.
• If the onset of oedema is acute (often <72 hours) suspect DVT.
• Pitting oedema is a feature of venous thrombosis or insufficiency, not lymphatic
obstruction.
• The significance of leg swelling varies according to the age group, whether it is bilateral
or unilateral and whether the onset is sudden or gradual.
• Drugs that can cause leg and ankle swelling include calcium antagonists, NSAIDs,
corticosteroids, glitazones, beta blockers.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Leg pain

Probability diagnosis
Muscle cramps

Nerve root ‘sciatica’

Varicose veins

Osteoarthritis (hip, knee)

Exercise-related pain (e.g. Achilles tendonitis), muscular injury (e.g. hamstring)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• peripheral vascular disease


• arterial occlusion (embolism)
• thrombosis popliteal aneurysm
• deep venous thrombosis
• iliofemoral thrombophlebitis

Neoplasia/cancer:

• primary (e.g. myeloma)


• metastases (e.g. breast to femur)

Infection:

• osteomyelitis
• septic arthritis
• erysipelas/cellulitis
• lymphangitis
• gas gangrene
Pitfalls (often missed)
Osteoarthritis hip

Osgood–Schlatter disorder

Spinal canal stenosis → neurogenic claudication

Herpes zoster (early)

Greater trochanteric pain syndrome

Nerve entrapment (e.g. meralgia paraesthetica)

‘Hip pocket nerve’

Iatrogenic: injection into nerve

Sacroiliac disorders

Complex regional pain syndrome I

Peripheral neuropathy

Rarities:

• osteoid osteoma
• polymyalgia rheumatica (isolated)
• Paget disease
• popliteal artery entrapment
• tabes dorsalis
• ruptured Baker cyst

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Drugs (indirect)

Anaemia (indirect)
Spinal dysfunction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Quite possible. Common with work-related injuries.

Key history
Ask:

• Is the pain acute or chronic onset?


• Did it follow trauma or activity?
• Is it ‘mechanical’ (related to movement)?
• Is it postural?
• Is it related to walking?
• Is the pain arising from bone or from a joint?

Past history, especially cardiovascular, back pain, trauma history.

Key examination
• Watch the patient walk and assess the nature of any limp. Note the posture of the back
and examine the lumbar spine. Have both legs well exposed for inspection
• Palpate for local causes of pain and if no cause is evident examine the spine, blood
vessels and bone. Note the temperature of the feet and legs
• Perform a vascular examination including the peripheral pulses and veins
• Consider a neurological examination to test nerve root lesions or entrapment neuropathies
• Examine the joints, especially the hip and sacroiliac joints

Key investigations
Consider:

• FBE and ESR


• radiology: plain X-ray, knee, hip, lumbosacral spine; CT or MRI, bone scan
• electromyography
• vascular studies: arterial tree or venous system.

Diagnostic tips
• Pain that does not fluctuate in intensity with movement, activity or posture has an
inflammatory or neoplastic cause.
• Varicose veins can cause aching pain in the leg.
• Older people may present with claudication in the leg from spinal canal stenosis or
arterial obstruction or both.
• Think of the hip pocket wallet as a cause of sciatica from the buttocks down.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Leg ulcers

Probability diagnosis
Venous insufficiency 52%

Arterial insufficiency 13%

Mixed arterial and venous disease 15%

Pressure sore

Trauma with chronic infection

Systemic disease esp. diabetes

Secondary to peripheral oedema

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Skin infarction (thrombotic ulcer)


• Vasculitis-RA, SLE, scleroderma

Infection:

• Post herpetic ulcer


• Tuberculosis
• HIV/AIDS
• Tropical ulcer
• Post cellulitis

Cancer:

• Primary-SCC, melanoma, malignant change in ulcer


• Secondary-ulcerating metastases

Other:

• Haematological e.g. sickle cell


• Chronic scarring—sun damaged skin
• Pyoderma gangrenosum

Pitfalls (often missed)


Insect and spider bites

Factitious (neurotic excoriations)

Rarities:

• Tropical infections e.g. leprosy


• Myobacterium ulcerans

Masquerades checklist
Diabetes: neurotrophic

Drugs—systemic reaction

Anaemias: hereditary anaemias

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider: Factitious ?dermatitis artefacta ?neurotic excoriation

Key history
Look for a cause: venous—previous DVT, varicose veins; peripheral arterial disease. Seek
history of systemic disease such as diabetes, inflammatory bowel disease, connective tissue esp.
RA. Check for a history of intermittent claudication or ischaemic rest pain; chronic ulcers
including sun damage; tropical residence. Include a drug history, esp. beta blockers,
corticosteroids, ergotamine, nifedipine.

Key examination
• General features: appearance of patient, vital signs esp. temperature
• Full cardiovascular assessment esp. lower limb
• Assess characteristics of the ulcer, esp. shape, edge, floor, discharge, surrounding skin,
regional lymph nodes
• Neurotip or similar for skin sensation
Key investigations
First line:

• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• blood sugar

Consider:

• wound swabs (if evidence infection)


• duplex ultrasound
• ankle brachial index
• biopsy
• KFTs

Diagnostic tips
Be cautious of almenotic melanoma if undertaking biopsy. If the ulcer and site is painful,
consider arterial insufficiency.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Limp in children

Probability diagnosis
Post trauma/intense exercise causing strain syndromes Ill-fitting shoes

Hip disorders, esp. transient synovitis

Heel disorders (12–14 years)

Serious disorders not to be missed

Developmental dysplasia hip (DDH)

Child abuse
Toddlers
Septic arthritis

Foreign body (e.g. needle in foot)

Perthes’ disorder
4–8 years
Transient synovitis

Slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE)

Adolescents Avulsion injuries (e.g. ischial tuberosity)

Osteochondritis dissecans of knee

Duchenne muscular dystrophy


Acute viral infections

Appendicitis

Septic infections:

All groups • septic arthritis


• osteomyelitis
• tuberculosis

Cerebral palsy

Rheumatic fever

Tumour (e.g. osteosarcoma)

Juvenile idiopathic arthritis (oligo articular)

Juvenile rheumatoid arthritis

Spinal disorders:

• discitis
• fracture

Pitfalls (often missed)


Foreign body (e.g. in foot)

Osteochondritis (aseptic necrosis):

• femoral head: Perthes’ disorder


• knee: Osgood–Schlatter disorder
• calcaneum: Sever disorder
• navicular: Köhler disorder

Myalgia = ‘growing pains’

Overuse syndrome (esp. adolescent):

• patellar tendonopathy (jumper’s knee)


Stress fractures (e.g. tibia, femoral neck, navicular)

Key history
Ask about a history of trauma, foci of infection including the skin and any unusual
developmental problems. Trauma, sepsis, synovitis and DDH are perhaps the most common
reasons for a child to limp and refuse to walk. A painless waddling gait suggests DDH or
Perthes’ disorder.

The limp must be considered to be due to a definite organic cause. It is appropriate to focus
initially on the hip. Ask about the relationship of the limp to exercise and footwear.

Key examination
• The hip and the knee joints should be examined carefully if the source of the limp has no
specific localisation
• Get the child to walk and run on the toes and heels. Note the gait and check whether it is
antalgic (painful), hemiplegic (arm held out in a balancing action) or Trendelenburg
(classic for DDH). Look for evidence of muscle dystrophy
• Never forget to examine the soles of the feet and between the toes

Key investigations
Consider:

• FBE and ESR/CRP


• blood culture
• needle aspiration of joint
• radiological: plain X-ray, ultrasound, bone scan, CT or MRI scan.

Diagnostic tips
• Multiple fractures and epiphyseal separations in toddlers are highly suggestive of child
battering—order a skeletal survey if suspected.
• An acute limp may be due to injury, infection (osteomyelitis, septic arthritis), spinal
injuries, a fracture or an irritable hip (synovitis).
• Chronic cases include cerebral palsy, DDH, Perthes’ disorder and chronic SCFE.
• Infections of and around the hip joint are most common in infancy. Classically, the hip is
held immobile in about 30% of flexion with slight abduction and external rotation.
• Hip pathology can cause pain in the knee.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Lymphadenopathy

Probability diagnosis
Localised infection e.g. tonsillitis, URTI, wound, skin

Epstein–Barr mononucleosis

Specific viral e.g. rubella, measles, Coxsackie

Serious disorders not to be missed


Infection:

• Septicaemia
• HIV/AIDS
• Tuberculosis
• Syphilis, esp. secondary
• Toxoplasmosis
• Cytomegalovirus

Cancer:

• Cellular: lymphoma, leukaemia, myeloma


• Secondary metastatic nodes
• Myeloproliferative disorders

Pitfalls (often missed)


Sarcoidosis

Cat scratch disease

Kawasaki disease

Rarities:

• Tropical infections e.g. filariasis, plague


• Localised STIs e.g. granuloma inguinale
• Connective tissue disorders e.g. RA
Masquerades checklist
Drugs e.g. sulphonamides, phenytoin

Key history
Gather patient history of upper respiratory infection, lower respiratory infection, possible Epstein
Barr infection, HIV, cytomegalovirus and other infections such as tuberculosis. Consider red
flags such as weight loss, fever, night sweats, history of cancer and increasing size of lumps or
lump. Note any response to antibiotics given for infection.

Key examination
• General features: appearance of patient, vital signs esp. temperature
• Palpate abdomen for evidence of splenomegaly and hepatomegaly
• Note the consistency of lumps: soft, firm, rubbery or hard
• Careful palpation of lymph node areas and matching the site of any lymphadenopathy
with a map of areas drained by the nodes

Key investigations
First line:

• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• CXR
• lymph node biopsy

Consider relevant serology according to suspected infection:

• Paul Bennell test


• syphilis
• HIV
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Menorrhagia

Probability diagnosis
Dysfunctional uterine bleeding (DUB)

esp. ovulatory

anovulatory

Fibroids

Cervical or endometrial polyps

Complications of hormone therapy

Adenomyosis/endometriosis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Disorders of pregnancy:

• ectopic pregnancy
• abortion or miscarriage

Neoplasia/cancer:

• cervical cancer
• endometrial cancer
• oestrogen-producing ovarian tumour (cancer)
• leukaemia
• benign tumours (polyps, etc.)

Endometrial hyperplasia Infection:

• PID
• tuberculosis endometritis
Pitfalls (often missed)
Genital tract trauma

IUCD

Adenomyosis/endometriosis

Pelvic congestion syndrome

SLE

Rarities:

• endocrine disorders (e.g. thyroid, adrenal, hyperprolactinaemia)


• bleeding disorder
• liver disease

Masquerades checklist
Depression (association)

Diabetes

Drugs (OCP, HRT)

Anaemia (association)

Thyroid disorder (hypothyroidism), other endocrine

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider exaggerated perception. Note association with anxiety and depression.
Key history
This should be detailed to determine the exact amount of bleeding (e.g. number of tampons and
pads used and the degree of saturation). Follow a menstrual calendar over 3+ months. Take a
drug history, especially smoking. Questions need to be directed to rule out pregnancy or
pregnancy complications, trauma of genital tract, medical disorders (e.g. bleeding disorder,
endocrine disorders, cancer of the genital tract and complications of the OCP).

Key examination
General physical to rule out anaemia, evidence of a bleeding disorder and any stigmata of
relevant medical or endocrine disease. Specific examinations include:

• speculum examination
• Pap smear
• bimanual pelvic examination.

Key investigations
Careful selection is based on history, patient’s age, abnormal pelvic examination findings and
suspicion of disease.

Consider:

• FBE
• iron studies
• pregnancy testing
• TFTs
• coagulation screen
• SLE antibodies
• ultrasound
• hormones: LH and FSH (?ovulation).

Hysteroscopy and D&C remain the gold standard for abnormal uterine bleeding.

Diagnostic tips
• Self-reporting of heaviness of bleeding is unreliable.
• Acute ‘flooding’ most often occurs in pubertal girls prior to regular ovulation.
• Ovulatory DUB is the most common single cause.
• Peak incidence of ovulatory DUB is late 30s and 40s (35–45 years)
• Peak for anovulatory DUB is 12–16 years and 45–55 years (i.e. puberty and menopause).
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Mouth conditions, bleeding and painful gums

Probability diagnosis
Factitious: excessive brushing

Gingivitis/periodontal (gum) disease

Trauma: poor-fitting or partial dentures

Drugs: warfarin overdose, phenytoin

Serious disorders not to be missed


Oral cancer/benign neoplasms (e.g. epulis, SCC)

Blood dyscrasias (e.g. AML)

General coagulation defects

HIV/AIDS

Acute herpetic gingivostomatitis

Pitfalls (often missed) but uncommon


Acute necrotising ulcerative gingivitis (Vincent infection)

Autoimmune disease (e.g. lichen planus, SLE)

Hereditary haemorrhagic telangiectasia

Malabsorption

Nutritional deficiency (e.g. scurvy)

Hormonal (e.g. pregnancy)


Key clinical features
Erythematous bleeding gums are a common worldwide problem, which is almost always a
localised inflammation associated with poor dental hygiene. Systemic problems usually as part
of a bleeding diathesis need to be considered.

Acute necrotising ulcerative gingivitis (Vincent infection or trench mouth), which is caused by
anaerobic organisms, is rarely seen but is more common in undernourished or ill young adults
under stress. Haematological disorders such as coagulation defects, acute leukaemia and
agranulocytosis need to be excluded. Investigation may not be necessary but consider:

• FBE
• ESR
• wound swab
• autoimmune screen
• INR.

Consider dental referral.


Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Mouth conditions, sore tongue

Probability diagnosis
Geographic tongue (migratory glossitis)

Atrophic glossitis

Trauma (bites, teeth, hot food/drink)

Aphthous ulceration

Herpes simplex virus (children)

Fissured tongue

Disorders not to be missed


Cancer

HIV

Pitfalls (often missed)


Anaemia: iron, vitamins B6 and B12, folate deficiency

Glossopharyngeal neuralgia

Lichen planus

Fissured tongue (rarely causes soreness)

Median rhomboid glossitis

Hand, foot, mouth infection

Behçet syndrome

Crohn disease
Coeliac disease

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes (Candida)

Drugs (mouthwashes, aspirin)

Anaemia (various)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Possible with glossodynia.

Key clinical features


Enquire about trauma, dental problems, nutrition, drugs and associated general symptoms. The
cause is usually obvious upon examination but there are some obscure cancers. The causes are
similar to that of a sore throat or mouth. Investigation may include:

• FBE
• serum vitamin B12, folate and ferritin levels
• swab and biopsy of a suspicious lesion.

Diagnostic tips
• Look for evidence of trauma, especially from a sharp tooth or dentures.
• When taking a history, take note of self-medications, especially sucking aspirin, a history
of skin lesions (e.g. lichen planus) and consider underlying diabetes or other
immunosuppression.
• Any non-healing or chronic ulcer requires urgent referral.
• Glossodynia (painful tongue) characteristically presents with a burning pain on the tip of
the tongue, without physical signs.
• Consider depressive illness as an underlying cause.
• Shared care with a dental or oral medical specialist is important.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Mouth conditions, ulcers

Probability diagnosis
Recurrent aphthous ulceration

Trauma (e.g. rough tooth, biting)

Acute herpes gingivostomatitis

Candidiasis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cancer:

• SCC
• leukaemia

Agranulocytosis

HIV

Syphilitic: chancre or gumma

Tuberculosis
Pitfalls (often missed)
Aspirin burn

Inflammatory bowel disease (e.g. Crohn)

Herpes zoster virus

Glandular fever (EBV)

Lichen planus

Coxsackie virus:

• herpangina
• hand, foot and mouth disease

Epstein–Barr mononucleosis

Immunosuppression therapy

Lupus erythematosus

Rarities:

• Behçet syndrome
• pemphigoid and pemphigus vulgaris
• erythema multiforme
• radiation mucositis

Masquerades checklist
Diabetes (Candida)

Drugs (see list)

Anaemia (iron-deficiency)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Unlikely.
Key history
Take a history of trauma, skin problems, stress, dental problems, drugs, allergy and possible
infections, including herpes simplex, Candida albicans, sexually transmitted diseases and
Coxsackie virus infection. Consider an immunosuppressive disorder.

Key examination
The examination should focus on the patient’s general health, dental status, characteristics of the
ulcer, cervical lymphadenopathy and the skin in general

Key investigations
Depending on the clinical picture investigations may include:

• FBE
• ESR
• swabs for M&C
• autoantibody screen
• syphilis serology
• blood sugar
• vitamin B12 and folate levels
• biopsy.

Diagnostic tips
• Non-healing ulcers warrant biopsy to exclude squamous cell carcinoma.
• Remember to enquire about medication such as phenytoin, cytotoxics,
immunosuppressants, carbimazole.
• A blood dyscrasia may be possible.
• Consider inflammatory bowel disease and coeliac disease in your considerations.
• Aphthous ulcers are usually 3–5 mm in diameter; minor ones have an erythematous
margin.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Nail abnormalities

Probability diagnosis
Fungal infection: onychomycosis

Onycholysis:

• trauma to nail bed


• trauma from biting
• trauma from habit picking

Onychogryphosis

Paronychia

Psoriasis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Melanoma

Iron deficiency: koilonychia

Liver disease: leuconychia

Endocarditis: splinter haemorrhages

Chronic kidney failure: white bands, half-and-half nail

Glomus tumour

Bowen disorder/squamous cell carcinoma


Pitfalls (often missed)
Atopic dermatitis (pitted nails)

Lichen planus

Pyogenic granuloma (usually with ingrowing toenails)

Drug effects (e.g. tetracycline)

Pseudomonas infection

Connective tissue disorders (e.g. SLE)

Arsenic (Mees stripes)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider onychotillomania, where patients pick and self-mutilate their nails, resulting in parallel
transverse grooves (washboard deformity or habit-tic nails).

Key history
Enquire about a history of severe stress or illness and possible onychotillomania, be it excessive
nail biting, picking or cleaning. Ask whether the hands are frequently in wet work (e.g.
dishwashing, soaps and detergents) or dirt.

Key examination
Careful examination of nails: look for associated skin disease (e.g. psoriasis, atopic dermatitis,
tinea pedis, lichen planus)

Key investigations
• Nail clippings for culture and histology
• FBE and ESR
• Consider LFTs and CXR
Diagnostic tips
• Clubbing is an abnormality of the fingertips rather than nails.
• Crumbly white nails are not always caused by fungus.
• Skin disorders that can involve nails include atopic dermatitis, psoriasis, epidermolysis
bullosa, exfoliative dermatitis and lichen planus.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Nasal drip (rhinorrhoea)

Probability diagnosis
Upper respiratory tract infection esp. common cold

Rhinitis: acute infective, allergic, vasomotor

Vasomotor stimulation e.g. cold wind, smoke, irritants

Sinusitis→post-nasal drip

Senile rhinorrhoea

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Cluster headache

Infection:

• Chronic infective granulomas e.g. TB

Cancer/tumour:

• Malignancy: nasal fossa, sinus, nasopharynx

Other:

• CSF rhinorrhoea—post head injury


• Wegener’s granulomatosis

Pitfalls (often missed)


Nasal foreign body e.g. in toddlers

Trauma ± blood

Adenoid hypertrophy
Illicit drugs e.g. cocaine, opioids esp. heroin

Inhaled irritant gases or vapour

Rarities:

• Choanal atresia
• Barotrauma

Masquerades checklist
Drugs: topical OTC→rhinitis medicamentosa; narcotics

Hypothyroidism

Key history
Elicit nature of discharge: watery, mucoid, bloody, ?offensive and volume. Is it acute or chronic,
intermittent or continuous? Associations: respiratory symptoms, nasal blockage, post-nasal drip,
headache, local pain. Check for possible influence of physical factors: wind, cold, irritants,
smoke. Also check for presence of allergic rhinitis or sinusitis. Ask if there is a possible history
of head trauma, nose problems or nasal surgery. Also take a drug history, including OTC
medications esp. sympathomimetics, illicit drugs, prescribed drugs.

Key examination
Look for cause. Inspect nose and nasal cavity with a Thudicum speculum or large auriscope.
Note the position of the septum, nature of nasal mucosa and look for polyps or other tumours.

Key investigations
Usually none required. Consider:

• micro/culture of discharge
• X-ray sinuses
• CT scan
• allergy testing

Diagnostic tips
Beware of persistent blood-stained discharge esp. if unilateral and obstruction. Clear discharge
following direct facial or head injury may represent CSF leakage from a skull fracture.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Neck lumps

Probability diagnosis
Lymphadenitis (reaction to local infection)

• acute: viral or bacterial


• chronic: MAIS (atypical tuberculosis), viral (e.g. EBM, rubella)

Prominent normal lymph nodes

Goitre

Sebaceous cyst

Lipoma

Sternomastoid tumour (neonates)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• carotid body tumour or aneurysm

Infection:

• ‘collar stud’ abscess (atypical TB)


• tuberculosis of cervical nodes (‘King’s evil’)
• HIV/AIDS of nodes
• actinomycosis

Cancer/tumour

• lymphoma (e.g. Hodgkin)


• leukaemia
• thyroid nodule (adenoma, cancer, colloid cyst)
• metastatic nodes
• salivary gland tumours
Pitfalls (often missed)
Parotitis

Thyroglossal cyst

Lymphatic malformation ‘cystic hygroma’ (children)

Cervical rib

Rarities:

• sarcoidosis
• branchial cyst (child)
• torticollis

Key history
This depends on the age of the patient but should include in all ages a history of upper
respiratory infection, lower respiratory infection, possible Epstein–Barr, HIV, cytomegalovirus
and tuberculosis infection. Consider red flags such as weight loss, dysphagia, history of cancer
and increasing size of the lump. Note any response to antibiotics given for a throat or upper
airways infection.

Key examination
• Careful palpation of lymph nodes areas and matching the site of any lymphadenopathy
with a ‘map’ of areas drained by the nodes
• Examine the lump according to the classic rules of look, feel, move, measure, auscultate
and transilluminate
• Palpate the midline anterior area for thyroid lumps and the submental area for
submandibular swellings
• Note the consistency of the lump: soft, firm, rubbery or hard

Key investigations
• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• CXR
• TFTs (of thyroid swelling)
• Fine needle aspiration biopsy of thyroid nodules
• Lymph node biopsy
Thyroid and primary tumours: imaging techniques (if necessary to assist diagnosis) include:

• ultrasound
• axial CT scan (esp. in fat necks)
• MRI scan (distinguishes a malignant swelling from scar tissue or oedema)
• tomogram of larynx (malignancy)
• barium swallow (pharyngeal pouch)
• sialogram
• carotid angiogram.

Diagnostic tips
• The 20:40 guideline rule according to age:
o 0–20 years: congenital, inflammatory, lymphoma, TB
o 20–40 years: inflammatory, salivary, thyroid, lymphoma
o >40 years: lymphoma, metastases.
• The 80:20 rule: most neck lumps (80%) are benign in children while the reverse applies
to adults.
• Causes of neck swelling are lymph nodes (85%), goitre (8%), others (7%).
• Suspicious lymph nodes are >2.5 cm diameter especially if firm or hard and less mobile.
• Consistent rules: hard—secondary carcinoma; rubbery—lymphoma; soft—sarcoidosis or
infection; tender and multiple—infection.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Neck pain and stiffness

Probability diagnosis
Vertebral dysfunction, incl. acute torticollis

Traumatic ‘strain’ or ‘sprain’, incl. ‘whiplash’

Cervical spondylosis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• angina
• subarachnoid haemorrhage
• arterial dissection

Neoplasia/cancer:

• primary tumour
• metastasis
• Pancoast tumour

Infection:

• osteomyelitis
• meningitis
• atypical infection, e.g. tetanus, leptospirosis

Vertebral fractures or dislocation


Pitfalls (often missed)
Disc prolapse

Myelopathy

Cervical lymphadenitis

Fibromyalgia syndrome

Outlet compression syndrome (e.g. cervical rib)

Polymyalgia rheumatica

Ankylosing spondylitis

Rheumatoid arthritis

Oesophageal foreign bodies and tumours

Paget disease

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Thyroid disorder (thyroiditis)

Spinal dysfunction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Highly probable. Stress and adverse occupational factors relevant.

Key history
General pain analysis, especially the nature of onset, its site and radiation, and associated
features. Past history of neck pain and trauma. Check for presence of radicular pain in arm and
paraesthesia or numbness, and for weakness in the arm.
Key examination
• Follow the process for examination of any joint or complex of joints: look, feel, move,
measure, test function, look elsewhere and X-ray
• Three objectives of the examination: reproduce the patient’s symptoms, identify the level
of the lesion or lesions, determine the cause (if possible)
• Perform a neurological examination if radicular pain, weakness or paraesthesia is present
in the arm

Key investigations
Consider:

• FBE
• ESR
• rheumatoid arthritis factors
• radiology can include several modalities but MRI is the investigation of choice for
radiculopathy, myelopathy, suspected spinal infection and tumours.

Imaging should be selected conservatively and plain X-ray is not indicated in the absence of red
flags and major trauma.

Diagnostic tips
• The commonest cause of neck pain is idiopathic dysfunction of the facet joints without a
history of injury.
• Strains, sprains and microfractures of the facet joints, especially after a whiplash injury,
are difficult to detect and are often overlooked as a cause of persistent pain.
• ‘One disc—one nerve root’ is a working rule for the cervical spine.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Palpitations

Probability diagnosis
Anxiety

Premature beats (ectopics)—atrial and ventricular

Sinus tachycardia, e.g. fever, exercise

Supraventricular tachycardia

Drugs (e.g. stimulants)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Myocardial infarction/angina

Arrhythmias:

• atrial fibrillation or flutter


• ventricular tachycardia
• bradycardia/heart block
• sick sinus syndrome
• torsade de pointes

Long QT syndrome

Wolff–Parkinson–White (WPW) syndrome

Electrolyte disturbances:

• hypokalaemia
• hypomagnesaemia
• hypoglycaemia (type 1 diabetes)
Pitfalls (often missed)
Fever/infection

Pregnancy

Menopause

Drugs (e.g. caffeine, cocaine)

Mitral valve disease

Aortic incompetence

Hypoxia/hypercapnia

Rarities:

• tick bites (T1–5)


• phaeochromocytoma

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes (indirect)

Drugs (see list)

Anaemia

Thyroid disorder, hyperthyroidism

Spinal dysfunction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Quite likely. Consider cardiac neurosis, anxiety.
Key history
Ask the patient to describe the onset and offset of the palpitations, the duration of each episode
and any associated features. Then ask the patient to tap out on the desk the rhythm and rate of the
heartbeat experienced during the ‘attack’. If the patient is unable to do this, tap out the cadence
of the various arrhythmias to find a matching beat.

An irregular tapping ‘all over the place’ suggests atrial fibrillation, while an isolated thump or
jump followed by a definite pause on a background of a regular pattern indicates premature beats
(ectopics), usually ventricular.

Take a past history and family history including caffeine intake, smoking, alcohol, social drugs
such as marijuana or cocaine, and prescribed drugs (β blockers, antipsychotics, antidepressants,
thyroxine, digoxin, nifedipine, sympathomimetic).

Key examination
• The ideal time to examine the patient is during the palpitations. If not, the examination is
usually normal
• The cardiovascular examination should assess the pulse rate, rhythm, volume and
character
• The general examination should investigate features suggestive of anaemia, anxiety,
tremors, dyspnoea and thyroid disease
• Look for evidence of mitral valve prolapse

Key investigations
A checklist includes:

• FBE
• TFTs
• serum glucose
• urea, electrolytes and magnesium
• ECG
• cardiac enzymes
• echocardiography
• Holter monitoring.
Diagnostic tips
• A relatively non-specific symptom.
• Consider hyperthyroidism as a cause of atrial fibrillation or sinus tachycardia even if the
clinical manifestations are not apparent.
• Arrhythmia of sudden onset suggests paroxysmal supraventricular tachycardia (PSVT),
atrial flutter/fibrillation or ventricular tachycardia.
• Common triggers for premature beats and PVST are smoking, anxiety and excessive
caffeine.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Paraesthesia and numbness

Probability diagnosis
Diabetic peripheral neuropathy

Nutritional peripheral neuropathy esp. alcohol, B 12 , folate

Hyperventilation with anxiety

Nerve root pressure e.g. sciatica, cervical spondylosis

Nerve entrapment esp. carpal tunnel syndrome

Neurotoxic drugs

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• CVA/TIA
• Peripheral vascular disease

Infection:

• AIDs
• Lyme disease
• Leprosy
• Some viral infections

Tumour/cancer:

• Disseminated malignancy
• Cerebral/spinal cord tumours

Other:

• CKF: uraemia
• Guillain–Barré syndrome
• Trauma to spinal cord
• Marine fish toxins e.g. toadfish, Ciguatera
Pitfalls (often missed)
Migraine variant with focal signs

Multiple sclerosis/transverse myelitis

Hypocalcaemia

Rarities:

• Chronic inflammatory polyneuropathy


• Charcot–Marie–Tooth syndrome
• Amyloidosis
• Heavy metal toxicity e.g. lead

Masquerades checklist
Diabetes

Drugs e.g. cytotoxic agents, interferon (see list)

Anaemia: pernicious anaemia

Thyroid/other endocrine: hypothyroid?

Spinal dysfunction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider conversion reaction (hysteria), severe anxiety disorder. Some cases may be idiopathic.

Key history
Analyse symptoms: the nature, distribution, onset and associated neurological symptoms (motor,
sensory), such as vertigo, seizures, vision. Check for other associated general symptoms such as
fever, weight loss, pruritus, rash, weakness.

History of diabetes, migraine, cancer, spinal problems, injury, possible bites, fever/sweating and
other symptoms. Take a travel and diet history, incl. nutrition and alcohol. Gather a drug history,
particularly cancer therapy, interferon, colchicine, thalidomide, statins, alcohol or any illicit
drugs.
Check the patient’s occupational history, e.g. exposure to lead, and psychiatric history, esp.
anxiety states.

Key examination
• General health and nutritional status.
• Focused neurological especially sensory, motor function, reflexes.
• Look for ‘glove and stocking’ distribution, muscle wasting e.g. thenar eminence.
• Peripheral vasculature.

Key investigations
First line:

• urinalysis
• blood sugar
• FBE
• ESR/CRP

Consider:

• serum calcium
• B 12 and folate
• LFTs (γGT)
• U&E
• TFTs
• KFTs
• nerve conduction studies

According to clinical findings (refer):

• imaging e.g. spine, carotid vessels, CT or MRI, angiography


• specific blood tests for infection
• lumbar puncture (CSF protein, oligoclonol I g G, etc)

Diagnostic tips
Take a detailed drug history including the above, alcohol and OTC medications. Intermittent
perioral paraesthesia indicates hypocalcaemia associated with hyperventilation. In many cases of
peripheral neuropathy or a sensory symptoms, the diagnosis is not only elusive but may not be
identified.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Pelvic pain

Probability diagnosis
Gynaecological disorders, for example:

• endometriosis
• dysmenorrhoea/mittelschmerz
• pelvic adhesions
• ovarian cyst – torsion, pressure or rupture

Musculoskeletal disorders

Irritable bowel syndrome

Referred spinal pain

Serious disorders not to be missed


Neoplasia/cancer:

• lower bowel
• cervix and uterus
• ovary

Vascular:

• internal iliac artery → claudication

Infection:

• osteomyelitis
• pelvic inflammatory disease
• pelvic abscess

Ectopic pregnancy

Strangulated hernia (femoral or inguinal)


Pitfalls (often missed)
Endometriosis

Constipation/faecal impaction

Paget disease

Stress fractures (incl. SCFE)

Prostatitis/prostatodynia

Misplaced IUCD

Hernia in evolution (e.g. inguinal)

Nerve entrapment

Rectum: proctitis or prolapse

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Spinal dysfunction

UTI

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Functional disorders possible. Psychosexual dysfunction. Pelvic congestion syndrome.

Key clinical features


As it is almost always seen in women rather than men the focus will be taking a history of pain
associated with periods, ovulation and sexual intercourse. It is invariably linked at times with
lower abdominal pain (see ‘Lower abdominal pain and pelvic pain in women’).

In men it is related to trauma, sporting injuries, prostatic disorders and hernias. Examination of
the abdomen and pelvis is important, especially rectal and vaginal examinations.
Key investigations
Consider and select from:

• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• urine MC ± chlamydia PCR
• STI tests
• pregnancy test
• plain X-ray
• vaginal or pelvic ultrasound
• colour Doppler US imaging
• colonoscopy/flexible sigmoidoscopy
• laparoscopy if appropriate.
• cutaneous pain mapping

Diagnostic tips
• The incidence of chronic pelvic pain (CPP) is 15% in 18–50 year old women.
Endometriosis causes 33% and adhesions 24%.
• CCP in women is the reason for 40% of gynaecological laproscopies and 15% of
hysterectomies.
• Pelvic congestion syndrome is regarded as a type of ovarian dysfunction causing
unilateral pain, deep dyspareunia and postcoital aching.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Pruritus ani

Probability diagnosis
Chronic dermatitis + ‘itch-scratch’ cycle + stress

Seborrhoeic dermatitis (esp.), eczema

Antibiotic treatment

Contact dermatitis: clothing and perfumed toiletries

Irritation from excessive moisture and faecal discharge/soiling (esp. elderly)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Crohn disease

Anorectal carcinoma

Extramammary Paget disease

Sexually transmitted infections, e.g. syphilis

Other disorders
Candidiasis

Tinea cruris

Pinworm (threadworm) (esp. children)

Psoriasis (look for fissures in natal cleft)

Overzealous hygiene (e.g. OCD)

Post-diarrhoea esp. chronic or recurrent

Local anorectal conditions (e.g. piles, fissures, fistulas, skin tags, warts)
Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Drugs (esp. antibiotics)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Psychological factors: stress and anxiety, fear of cancer.

Key history
This includes past history, especially chronic dermatoses (esp. seborrhoeic dermatitis and contact
dermatitis), diabetes, chronic diarrhoea (e.g. Crohn disease, coeliac disease) and psychological
disorders. Enquire about lifestyle factors such as excessive sweating, sports activity and habit
scratching.

Key examination
• General inspection of skin and anorectal area. Skin changes can vary from minimal signs
to marked pathology that can show linear ulceration, maceration or lichenification
• A full anorectal examination is necessary

Key investigations
• Blood glucose
• Urinalysis
• Local skin scrapings and microscopy to detect organisms
• Stool examination (for ova and parasites)

Diagnostic tips
• Pruritus ani is worse at night, during hot weather and after exercise.
• It is seen typically in adult males with considerable inner drive, often at times of stress
and in hot weather when sweating is excessive.
• In children pinworm infestation should be suspected.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Pruritus, generalised

Probability diagnosis
Psychological/emotional

Old, dry skin (senile pruritus)

Atopic dermatitis (eczema)

Contact (allergic) dermatitis

Varicella (chicken pox)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cancer:

• lymphoma/Hodgkin
• leukaemia: CLL
• multiple myeloma
• other cancer, e.g. mycosis fungoides

Scabies (severe infestation)

Chronic kidney failure

Primary biliary cirrhosis/other causes (e.g. jaundice)

Pitfalls (often missed)


Pregnancy

Tropical infection/infestation

Polycythaemia rubra vera

Polyarteritis nodosa

Lichen planus
Generalised sensitivity (e.g. fibreglass, bubble bath)

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Drugs (several types; see list)

Anaemia (iron deficiency)

Thyroid (hyper and hypo) disorders

Spinal dysfunction (nostalgia paraesthetica)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Quite likely: consider anxiety, parasitophobia.

Key history
Enquire about nature and distribution of itching. Consider pregnancy, liver disease and
malignancy of the lymphatic system, particularly Hodgkin lymphoma. A careful review of any
drug history is important. Note any associated general symptoms such as fever.

Key examination
• General examination of the skin, abdomen and lymphopoietic systems

Key investigations
Consider:

• FBE/ESR/CRP
• urinalysis
• pregnancy test
• iron studies
• kidney function tests
• TFTs
• blood sugar
• chest X-ray
• skin biopsy
• stool examination (for ova and cysts)
• lymph node biopsy (if present)
• skin testing.

Diagnostic tips
• The itching of polycythaemia may be triggered by a hot bath and lasts for at least 1 hour.
• Pruritus can be the presenting symptom of primary biliary cirrhosis and may precede
other symptoms by 1–2 years.
• The itch of Hodgkin lymphoma (in 30%) may be unbearable.
• Drugs that can cause pruritus: aspirin, barbiturates, morphine, cocaine, penicillin, other
antibiotics, anticytotoxics.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Pruritus, localised skin

Probability diagnosis
Atopic dermatitis (eczema)

Contact dermatitis (irritant and allergic)

Urticaria

Insect bites/infestations

Psoriasis

Simple pruritus (cause not found)

Other disorders
Infection/infestations:

• scabies
• pediculosis (scalp, body, pubic)
• tinea cruris
• Candida intertrigo
• bed bugs

Non-infection:

• pityriasis rosea
• lichen planus
• dermatitis herpetiformis
• asteatosis (dry skin)
• prickly heat (miliaria/heat rash)
• Grover disease
• chilblains
• seborrhoeic dermatitis (usually mild)

Consider (rare):

• myeloproliferative disorders
• cutaneous T-cell lymphoma
Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Drugs

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Psychogenic including dermatitis artefacta.

Key history
Includes past history, especially chronic dermatoses (particularly atopic dermatitis and contact
dermatitis), diabetes and psychological disorders. Enquire about exposure to infestations such as
‘backpacker’ lodgings, scabies and sexual contact. Drug history is important.

Key examination
• General and localised examination of the skin
• Note any scratch marks
• Look for evidence of insects such as scabies, lice and bed bugs, the violaceous rash of
lichen planus and the vesicles of dermatitis herpetiformis

Key investigations
• FBE/ESR
• Blood sugar
• Microscopic examination of skin scrapings
• Skin biopsy

Diagnostic tips
• Pruritus is a feature of dry skin, common in the elderly.
• An intense localised itch is suggestive of scabies or bed bugs.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Purpura

Probability diagnosis
Simple purpura (easy bruising syndrome)

Senile purpura

Corticosteroid-induced purpura

Immune thrombocytopenic purpura

Henoch–Schönlein purpura

Serious disorders not to be missed


Malignant disease:

• leukaemia
• myeloma

Aplastic anaemia

Myelofibrosis

Infection:

• septicaemia
• meningococcal infection
• infective endocarditis
• measles
• typhoid
• dengue/chikungunya
• other tropical haemorrhagic viral infections

Disseminated intravascular coagulation

Thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura

Fat embolism
Kidney failure

Pitfalls (often missed)


Haemophilia A, B

von Willebrand disease (vW)

Post-transfusion purpura

Trauma (e.g. domestic violence, child abuse)

Rarities:

• hereditary telangiectasia (Osler–Weber–Rendu syndrome)


• Ehlers–Danlos syndrome
• scurvy
• Fanconi syndrome

Masquerades checklist
Drugs:

• chloramphenicol
• corticosteroids
• sulphonamides
• quinine/quinidine
• thiazide diuretics
• NSAIDs
• cytotoxics
• oral anticoagulants/heparin

Anaemia:

• aplastic anaemia

Psychogenic factors
Factitious purpura (intentionally pinching skin)

Key history
Include family history, drug history and features of the purpura such as post trauma or
spontaneous, recurrent episodes of bleeding and whether any bleeding is out of proportion to the
trauma.

Key examination
• Detailed examination of the skin, lips and oral mucosa, lymph node areas, abdominal
examination with emphasis on spleen and liver
• Urinalysis searching for blood (microscopic or macroscopic) is important

Key investigations
FBE and blood film

• If coagulation defect suspected:


o - prothrombin time i.e. INR
o - activated partial thromboplastin time
o - fibrinogen level
o - thrombin time.
• If platelet pathology suspected:
o - platelet count
o - platelet function analyser (PFA-100).
• If inherited disorders suspected:
o - factor VIII
o - vW factory activity
o - vW factor antigen.

Diagnostic tips
• Platelet abnormalities present as early bleeding following trauma.
• Coagulation factor deficiencies present with delayed bleeding after initial haemostasis is
achieved by normal platelets.
• A normal response to previous coagulation stresses (e.g. dental extraction, circumcision
or pregnancy) indicates an acquired problem.
• If acquired, look for evidence of MILD: malignancy, infection, liver disease and drugs.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Rectal bleeding

Probability diagnosis
Haemorrhoids/perianal haematoma

Anal fissure

Colorectal polyp

Diverticulitis

Excoriated skin (anal pruritus)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• ischaemic colitis
• angiodysplasia (vascular ectasia)
• anticoagulant therapy

Infection:

• enteritis (e.g. Campylobacter, Salmonella)

Cancer/tumours:

• colorectal, caecum
• lymphoma
• villous adenoma

Other:

• inflammatory bowel disease (colitis/proctitis)


• intussusception

Pitfalls (often missed)


Rectal prolapse
Anal trauma (accidental/non-accidental)

Villous adenoma

Rarities:

• Meckel diverticulum
• solitary ulcer of rectum

Key history
Nature of the bleed, including fresh versus altered blood, mixed with faeces and/or mucus, in
toilet bowl or on underwear. Quantity of bleeding: slight, moderate or torrential. Associated
symptoms (e.g. weight loss, constipation, diarrhoea, pain, weakness, presence of lumps, urgency,
unsatisfied defecation, recent change of bowel habit).

Key examination
• General inspection (evidence of anaemia) and vital signs
• Abnormal examination, anal inspection, digital rectal examination, proctosigmoidoscopy

Key investigations
• FBE and ESR
• Stool M&C
• Faecal occult blood
• Colonoscopy
• Consider abdominal X-ray, CT colonography, angiography, small bowel enema
(depending on clinical findings)

Diagnostic tips
• Black, tarry (melaena) stool indicates bleeding from upper GIT: rare distal to lower
ileum.
• Frequent passage of blood and mucus indicates a rectal tumour or proctitis.
• If substantial haemorrhage, consider diverticular disease, angiodysplasia or more
proximal lesions (e.g. Meckel diverticulum, duodenal ulcers).
• New bleeding age >55 years demands colonic investigation.
• 80% of rectal tumours are within fingertip range.
• In young adults, diagnosis is likely to be haemorrhoids or a fissure.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Scrotal pain

Probability diagnosis
Trauma including haematoma, haematocele

Torsion of a testicular appendage

Varicocele

Epididymitis

Post vasectomy

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• testicular torsion

Infection:

• acute epididymo-orchitis/orchitis
• fulminating necrotising cellulitis (Fournier’s gangrene)
• psoas abscess
• tuberculosis

Cancer:

• testicular neoplasm

Other:

• strangulated inguinoscrotal hernia


• acute hydrocele
Pitfalls (often missed)
Referred pain (e.g. spine, ureteric colic, abdominal aorta)

Rarities:

• idiopathic scrotal oedema


• polyarteritis nodosa
• filariasis

Key history
Determine any pre-existing predisposing factors such as lumps or history of trauma. Check travel
history, sexual history.

Key examination
• Examine and contrast both sides of the scrotum, including the inguinal and femoral
hernial orifices, the spermatic cord, testis and epididymis
• Examine the patient standing and supine
• A painful testis should be elevated gently to determine if the pain improves

Key investigations
Useful investigations include:

• FBE
• urine analysis, microscopy and culture
• Chlamydia detection tests
• ultrasound
• technetium-99m scan.
Diagnostic tips
• Torsion of the testis is the most common cause of acute scrotal pain in infancy and
childhood.
• Think of it with lower abdominal pain and/or vomiting.
• A varicocele can cause testicular discomfort—examine the patient in the standing
position.

Red flags:

• sudden onset pain


• non-reductible hernia
• erythema of scrotum or perineum
• systemic vascular symptoms, e.g. hypotension, pallor.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Shoulder pain

Probability diagnosis
Cervical spine dysfunction (referred pain)

Rotator cuff tendonopathy ± a tear

Adhesive capsulitis (glenohumeral joint)

Glenoid labral tears

Bicipital tendonopathy

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• angina
• myocardial infarction

Neoplasia/cancer:

• Pancoast tumour
• primary or secondary in humerus

Infection:

• septic arthritis (especially children)


• osteomyelitis

Axillary vein thrombosis

Rheumatoid arthritis

Intra-abdominal pathology, e.g. bleeding


Pitfalls (often missed)
Polymyalgia rheumatica

Cervical dysfunction

Gout/pseudogout (uncommon)

Osteoarthritis of acromioclavicular joint

Winged scapula--muscular fatigue pain

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes esp. adhesive capsulitis

Drugs, e.g. steroids, anabolic steroids

Thyroid disorder (rarely)

Spinal dysfunction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Shoulder is prone to (uncommonly) psychological fixation for secondary gains, depression and
conversion reaction.

Key history
A careful history should generally indicate whether the neck or the shoulder (or both) is
responsible for the patient’s pain. Enquire about features of movement:

• stiffness and restriction


• excessive movement/instability
• weakness
• rough versus smooth.
Key examination
• Examine the cervical spine then the affected shoulder
• Follow the protocol of inspection, palpation, movement, special tests for tendonopathies
• Look for impingement and a painful arc with adduction
• Undertake resisted movements for each tendon:
o - adduction for supraspinatus
o - internal rotation for subscapularis
o - external rotation for infraspinatus
o - elbow flexion for biceps

Key investigations
Consider:

• ESR (polymyalgia rheumatica)


• rheumatoid factor and anti-CCP
• ECG (if ischaemic heart disease suspected)
• imaging according to history and examination (e.g. high resolution ultrasound).

Diagnostic tips
• Consider dysfunction of the cervical spine, especially C4--5 and C5--6 levels, as a cause
of shoulder pain.
• Modern ultrasound is the investigation of choice for painful disorders of the rotator cuff.
• An older person presenting with bilateral shoulder girdle pain has polymyalgia rheumatic
until proved otherwise.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Skin ulcers

Probability diagnosis
Traumatic ulcer

Decubitus (related to trauma)

Venous insufficiency

Arterial insufficiency

Mixed venous and aterial

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• post-thrombophlebitis
• arterial insufficiency
• skin infarction (thrombolytic ulcer)
• vasculitis:
o — rheumatoid arthritis, SLE, scleroderma

Infection:

• tropical ulcer
• tuberculosis
• Mycobacterium ulcerans
• postcellulitis
• chronic infected sinus
• AIDS

Malignant:

• squamous cell carcinoma


• Marjolin ulcer (SCC)
• basal cell carcinoma (rodent ulcer)
• malignant melanoma
• ulcerating metastases
Haematological:

• spherocytosis
• sickle cell anaemia

Neurotrophic:

• peripheral neuropathy (e.g. diabetes)


• peripheral nerve injuries (e.g. leprosy)

Other causes:

• pyoderma gangrenosum (diagnosis of exclusion)


• insect and spider bites

Masquerades checklist
Anaemia

Diabetes

Drugs (e.g. illicit drugs)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider artefactual ulceration, i.e. factitious.

Key history
A careful history helps determine the cause of the ulceration. Relevant history includes previous
deep venous thrombosis or pulmonary embolism, diabetes, rheumatoid arthritis, inflammatory
bowel disease, chronic skin ulcers and arterial insufficiency, including a history of intermittent
claudication and ischaemic rest pain.

A drug history is important, considering especially beta-blockers and ergotamine, which can
compromise the arterial circulation, corticosteroids, and NSAIDs, which affect healing.

Key examination
• Any ulcer should be assessed for the following characteristics: site, shape, size, edge,
floor, base, discharge, surrounding skin, regional lymph nodes
• Assess the circulation: venous and arterial

Key investigations
The following should be considered, according to the clinical findings:

• full blood count


• ESR, CRP
• random blood sugar
• rheumatoid factor tests
• duplex Doppler ultrasound
• swab for specific organisms
• biopsy, especially if SCC suspected.

Diagnostic tips
• The great majority of leg ulcers are vascular in origin due to arterial insufficiency or
venous hypertension.
• If clinical findings don’t provide the diagnosis, ordering the ankle brachial index (ABI) is
essential if pulses are not palpable to exclude arterial disease. Duplex Doppler ultrasound
is the key investigation for venous disease.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Skin, acute skin eruptions

Probability diagnosis
Varicella (chicken pox)

Measles

Rubella

Erythema infectiosum (‘slapped cheek’ disease)

Roseola infantum

Other viral exanthema (e.g. enterovirus)

Hand, foot and mouth disease

Pityriasis rosea

Herpes zoster (shingles)

Drug reaction (see list)

Impetigo

Herpes simplex

Allergic rash (incl. contact dermatitis)


Serious disorders not to be missed
Vascular:

• Henoch–Schönlein purpura
• Stevens-Johnson syndrome
• other vasculitides

Infection:

• purpura of meningococcus
• primary HIV infection
• folliculitis (e.g. pseudomonas, staphylococcus)
• secondary syphilis
• scarlet fever

Other:

• erythema nodosum

Pitfalls (often missed)


Guttate psoriasis

Epstein--Barr virus (EBV) mononucleosis

Arbovirus infection (e.g. dengue, Ross River fever,

Barmah Forest virus, Japanese encephalitis)

Scabies

Kawasaki disease

Eczema herpeticum

Zoonoses (e.g. listeriosis, Q fever)

Rarities:

• filovirus haemorrhagic diseases (e.g. Ebola, Marburg virus)


• erythema multiforme
Key history
Should be adapted to patient’s age as viral exanthema common in children. Site and mode of
onset of rash, mode of progression and past history (e.g. eczema). Constitutional disturbance
(e.g. pyrexia, pruritus). Drug history and exposure to irritants. Diet including unaccustomed
food. Herald patch (pityriasis rosea). Contact with infectious diseases including child care
centres and school. Overseas travel. Bleeding or bruising tendency.

Key examination
Skin of whole body

• Nature and distribution of the rash including lesion characteristics


• Nails and soles of feet
• Scalp, mucous membranes and oropharynx
• Conjunctivae and the lymphopoietic system (?lymphadenopathy, ?splenomegaly)

Key investigations
Many diagnoses are clinical. Consider:

• FBE/ESR/CRP
• EBV test
• HIV test
• serology for rubella, parvovirus, syphilis and other suspected infections
• viral and bacterial cultures.

Diagnostic tips
• Be vigilant for the deadly meningococcal septicaemia, which may present as an
erythematous rash initially prior to the development of purpura.
• Prescribed drugs are a common cause of rash, especially toxic erythema. Examples are
antibiotics, especially penicillin, thiazides, anti-epileptics, allopurinol, NSAIDs and other
anti-arthritic agents.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Skin, pigmented lesions

Probability diagnosis
Naevi: congenital and acquired

Seborrhoeic keratoses

Solar keratoses

Freckles

Lentigines

Serious disorders not to be missed


Pigmented squamous cell carcinoma

Pigmented basal cell carcinoma

Melanoma:

• lentigo maligna
• superficial spreading melanoma
• nodular melanoma
• acral lentiginous melanoma

Other disorders
Haemangioma (thrombosed)

Dermatofibroma

Pyogenic granuloma

Foreign body granuloma

Talon noir (black heel)

Becker naevus
Common melanocytic naevi:

• congenital
• acquired
o — junctional → compound → intradermal
o — halo
o — blue
o — spitz
o — dysplastic melanocyte

Key history
Establish the history of the lesion and associated features. Family history, especially of
melanoma. Determine history of past residential (geographic) areas, sun exposure, history of
sunburn and the practice of preventive measures.

Key examination
• Systematic examination of the skin especially searching for melanoma
• Starting at the head, examine the hairline, backs of the ears, neck, back and backs of the
arms. Pull down the underwear to expose the buttocks, examine the backs of the legs and
feet. Then examine the front of the body including the anterior surfaces of the legs
• Apply the ABCDE system to a suspicious lesion: Asymmetry, Border, Colour, Diameter,
Evolution and/or Elevation

Key investigations
• Photography to monitor dysplastic naevi
• Dermoscopy
• Excision biopsy

Diagnostic tips
• Most pigmented lesions are benign but one-third of all melanomas arise in pre-existing
naevi, many of which are dysplastic.
• Melanoma is extremely rare before puberty.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Skin, vesicular rash

Probability diagnosis
Herpes simplex

Herpes zoster

Varicella (chicken pox)

Hand, foot and mouth disease

Dermatitis: contact, atopic

Insect and arachnoid bites

Molluscum contagiosum

Burns

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• Allergic vasculitis

Infection:

• Bullous impetigo (scalded skin syndrome)


• Scabies
• Anthrax

Cancer:

• Associated e.g. lymphoma, leukaemia

Other:

• Erythema multiforme
Pitfalls (often missed)
Pompholyx

Pemphigus/pemphigoid

Dermatitis herpetiformis

Fixed drug eruption e.g. sulphonamides

Trauma e.g. skin friction, thermal, acid, caustic

Rarities:

• Porphyria cutanea tarda


• Epidermolysis bullosa acquisita

Masquerades checklist
Drugs e.g. penicillamine, barbiturates

Key history
Ask about recent and general health esp. any infections and associated symptoms of infectious
diseases. Check for any recent travel history or history of skin trauma, bites or stings, as well as
drug intake esp. antibiotics. Is there a family history of bullous disorders?

Key examination
General examination of skin and mucus membranes including mouth looking for hand, foot and
mouth infection and pompholyx.

Key investigations
Unlikely to be helpful.

Consider:

• FBE
• wound swabs (if evidence infection)
• viral studies and patch testing
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Sore throat

Probability diagnosis
Viral pharyngitis

Epstein–Barr mononucleosis (glandular fever)

Streptococcal (GABHS) tonsillitis

Chronic sinusitis with postnasal drip

Oropharyngeal candidiasis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• angina
• myocardial infarction

Neoplasia/cancer:

• cancer of oropharynx, tongue

Blood dyscrasias (e.g. agranulocytosis, acute leukaemia)

Infection:

• acute epiglottitis (children and adults)


• peritonsillar abscess (quinsy)
• pharyngeal abscess
• diphtheria (very rare)
• HIV/AIDS

Pitfalls (often missed)


Foreign body (e.g. fish bone)

Epstein—Barr mononucleosis (glandular fever)


Candida:

• common in infants
• steroid inhalers

STIs:

• gonococcal pharyngitis
• herpes simplex (type II)
• syphilis

Irritants (e.g. cigarette smoke, chemicals)

Reflux oesophagitis → pharyngolaryngitis

Tonsilloliths

Cricopharyngeal spasm

Kawasaki disease

Chronic mouth breathing

Aphthous ulceration

Thyroiditis

Glossopharyngeal neuralgia

Rarities:

• scleroderma
• Behçet disease
• sarcoidosis
• malignant granuloma
• tuberculosis
Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes (Candida)

Drugs (e.g. NSAIDS, cytotoxics)

Anaemia (possible)

Thyroid disorder (thyroiditis)

Spinal dysfunction (cervical referred pain)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Unlikely, but the association with depression is significant.

Key history
First determine whether the patient has a sore throat, a deep pain in the throat or neck pain.
Enquire about relevant associated symptoms such as a metallic taste in the mouth, fever, upper
respiratory infection, postnasal drip, sinusitis, cough and other pain such as ear pain. Note
whether the patient is an asthmatic and uses a steroid inhaler or is a smoker or exposed to
environmental irritants.

Key examination
• On inspection note the general appearance, look for toxicity, the anaemic pallor of
leukaemia, the nasal stuffiness of infectious mononucleosis or the halitosis of a
streptococcal throat
• Palpate the neck for soreness and lymphadenopathy and check the sinus area
• Then inspect the oral cavity and pharynx

Key investigations
Consider:

• throat swab
• FBE
• mononucleosis test
• blood sugar
• biopsy of suspicious lesions.

Diagnostic tips
• Tonsillitis with a covering membrane may be caused by Epstein–Barr mononucleosis.
• Admit if any suspicion of epiglottitis—and do not examine the throat.
• The triad-hoarseness, pain on swallowing and referred ear pain → pharyngeal cancer.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

The febrile child

Probability diagnosis
Viral URTI infection incl. common cold, pharyngitis, tonsillitis

Otitis media

Acute bronchitis

Roseola

Gastroenteritis

Post immunisation

Serious disorders not to be missed


Infection:

• Bacterial
• Meningitis/encephalitis
• Septicaemia/bacteraemia
• Epiglottitis
• Pneumonia
• Oteomyelitis/septic arthritis
• Tuberculosis
• Orbital cellulitis
• Abscess
• Viral
• Epstein—Barr mononucleosis
• Exanthemata eg measles, varicella e.g. fifth disease, hand-foot-mouth disease
• Bronchiolitis/croup
• HIV/AIDS

Cancer:

• Leukaemia/lymphoma
• Neuroblastoma/sarcoma
Other:

• Acute appendicitis

Pitfalls (often missed)


Tuberculosis

Rheumatic fever

Endocarditis

Tropical infections e.g. malaria

Atypical infections e.g. zoonoses

Henoch Schonlein purpura

Kawasaki disease (persistent fever)

Heatstroke/hot car

Masquerades checklist
Drugs e.g. penicillin, antihistamines

Urinary tract infection

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


?parental ?Munchaussen by proxy
Key history
Obtain detailed account from parents of the symptoms and circumstances, esp. associations such
as vomiting, diarrhoea, sweating, cough, wheeze, headache, other pain, cognition, photophobia
and urinary symptoms. Ask about immunisation (past and recent), infectious contacts, animal
contact and travel. Past history: ?splenectomy.

Key examination
• General features: appearance of the child, interaction and level of activity, colour,
hydration, chest movement and vital signs including peripheral perfusion.
• Examine skin looking for evidence of rashes, vesicles and purpura.
• Examine the ears and throat.
• Basic neurological signs, esp. neck stiffness and fontanelles.

Key investigations (only if necessary)


First line:

• FBE/ESR
• urinalysis
• MCU

Consider:

• CXR
• blood culture
• lumbar puncture

Diagnostic tips
Fever is regarded as a temperature >38° (rectal or tympanic). Most fevers in children are caused
by viruses and are self limiting. Distinguish between focal causes, e.g. tonsillitis, and no apparent
focus when a more detailed history and examination is required. Be very mindful of septicaemia
and endocarditis.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

The subfertile couple

Probability diagnosis
The couple:

• ageing
• sexual technique incl. dyspareunia

Female factors approx. (40%):

• ovulation disorders e.g. ovarian failure, PCOS


• other causes amenorrhea or hypomenorrhea
• tubal disease e.g. endometriosis

Male factors (approx. 40%):

• defective sperm
• anti-sperm agents e.g. cytotoxic, anabolic steroids

Serious disorders not to be missed


Infection:

• STIs → tubal or epididymal blockage


• Pelvic inflammatory disease
• Endometrial TB

Tumours:

• Uterine fibroids/cancer
• Pituitary or adrenocortical

Other:

• Systemic illness
• Cervical stenosis
• Diet/obesity
Pitfalls (often missed)
Unreceptive cervical mucus

Rarities:

• Anatomical congenital disorders e.g. uterine, Fallopian


• Chromosomal abnormalities e.g. Klinefelter syndrome, Turner syndrome

Masquerades checklist
Depression incl. drugs

Diabetes

Drugs: various

Thyroid/other endocrine: several incl. hyper/hypothyroid, prolactinaemia

Spinal dysfunction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider psychosexual dysfunction incl. technique

NB: unexplained 20–25%

Key history
In men: sexual function, past history incl. testicular problems e.g. mumps orchitis, undescended
testes; medical problems e.g. diabetes, STIs, genitourinary surgery; occupational e.g. exposure to
heat, pesticides; drugs e.g. chemotherapy, illicit agents, alcohol, smoking, antihypertensives.
Frequency and timing of intercourse (both). In women: past history incl. previous fertility,
obstetric, menstrual, STIs and PID, genitourinary surgery and abdominal surgery esp.
appendicitis, peritonitis, abortion, IUCD use, body weight, drugs e.g. smoking, alcohol, OCP,
anabolic steroids. Symptoms of ovulation and endometriosis

Key examination
Both: body habitus, general health, secondary sex characteristics, urinalysis.

Men: external genitalia including testes (normal range 15–35 ml) and penis, PR.

Women: genitalia and breasts, thyroid status, vaginal and pelvic examination.
Key investigations
Men:

• semen analysis

Consider:

• FSH & LH
• testosterone
• sperm function tests e.g. antibodies
• testicular ultrasound
• chromosomal analysis

Women:

• basal body temperature chart and cervical mucus diary


• s. progesterone (mid luteal)
• anti-Mullerian hormone
• rubella status
• transvaginal ultrasound

Consider:

• thyroid status
• s. prolactin
• FSH and LH
• coeliac antibodies
• chlamydia test
• hysterogram
• hysteroscopy/laparoscopy
• CT pituitary fossa
• reproductive gene screening e.g. cystic fibrosis, fragile X
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Tinnitus

Probability diagnosis
Ear wax or debris

Sensorineural hearing loss (esp. noise induced)

Otosclerosis

Ageing

Ear infection (e.g. viral cochleitis)

Meniere syndrome

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• arteriovenous malformation
• carotidovenous fistula
• arterial bruits (esp. carotid)
• venous hum (jugular)

Infection:

• suppurative otitis media

Cancer/tumour:

• acoustic neuroma (unilateral)

Other:

• head injury
Pitfalls (often missed)
Impacted wisdom tooth

Temporomandibular injury/dysfunction

Alcoholism

Rarities:

• superior canal dehiscence


• glomus jugulare tumour
• syphilis

Masquerades checklist
Anaemia (severe)

Depression

Drugs (aspirin, NSAIDs, loop diuretics, marijuana, quinine, aminoglycosides)

Spinal dysfunction

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Consider if subjective tinnitus.

Key history
• Recent onset or longstanding
• Pulsating or non-pulsating
• Head injury
• Exposure to loud noise
• Upper respiratory infection
• Otitis externa

Key examination
• Otoscope of ear
• Cardiovascular (esp. auscultation neck)
Key investigations
• Audiogram
• Tympanogram (middle ear function)
• FBE
• MRI or CT scan (esp. if head injury)

Diagnostic tips
• Think otosclerosis in young.
• Tinnitus may precede other symptoms of Meniere syndrome by months.
• Non-pulsative and continuous → inner ear.
• Venous hum → jugular vein.
• Vascular symptoms → organic disorder.
• Stress and anxiety exacerbate tinnitus.
• Associated depression may lead to suicide.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Tiredness/chronic fatigue

Probability diagnosis
Stress and anxiety

Inappropriate lifestyle and psychosocial factors

Depression

Viral/postviral infection

Sleep-related disorders (e.g. sleep apnoea)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• cardiac arrhythmia
• cardiomyopathy
• incipient CCF

Infection:

• hidden abscess
• HIV/AIDS
• hepatitis B and C/others

Cancer

Other:

• anaemia
• haemochromatosis
Pitfalls (often missed)
‘Masked’ depression

Food intolerance

Coeliac disease

Chronic infection (e.g. Lyme disease, TB)

Fibromyalgia

Lack of fitness

Drugs: alcohol, prescribed, withdrawal

Menopause syndrome

Pregnancy

Neurological disorders:

• post-head-injury
• CVA
• Parkinson disease

Kidney failure

Metabolic (e.g. hypokalaemia, hypomagnesaemia)

Chemical exposure (e.g. occupational)

Rarities:

• hyperparathyroidism
• Addison disease
• Cushing syndrome
• narcolepsy
• multiple sclerosis
• autoimmune disorders
Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Drugs (many)

Anaemia

Thyroid disease, other endocrine (as above)

Spinal dysfunction

UTI

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Highly likely.

Key history
• Analysis of presenting complaint including associations
• General questions covering red flags, weight change, general discomfort, aches or pains,
fever, unusual lumps or bumps (lymph nodes), bleeding, rashes or pruritus, sleep patterns
including snoring, apnoea
• Symptoms review especially gastrointestinal, cardiovascular and neurological
• Drug history including self-medication, OTCs, alcohol, antianxiety, antipsychotics,
antidepressants
• Psychological: stresses, anxiety, depression, sexual problems
• Social including relationships, abuse or bullying
• Diet and exercise

Key examination
General inspection noting facial features, skin appearance and colour, hyperpigmentation,
conjunctivae

• Vital signs
• Anthropometric measurements
• Basic respiratory and cardiovascular
• Abdominal examination with focus on masses and inguinal lymphadenopathy
• Urinalysis
Key investigations
• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• Blood sugar
• Serum electrolytes, calcium, magnesium
• Kidney function tests
• Liver function tests
• Iron studies
• Faecal occult blood
• Thyroid function tests
• CXR

Diagnostic tips
• Be alert to depression including masked depression.
• Ask the patient what they believe is the cause of their tiredness.
• Be alert for the classic endocrine traps: hypothyroidism and Addison disease.
• Tiredness in absence of red flags is unlikely to have an organic cause.
• Investigations are likely to be therapeutic and reassuring rather than diagnostic.
• Learn how to undertake a brief, good physical examination and practise effective time
management.
• Do not overlook a sleep disorder.
• Believe the patient’s symptoms.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Tremor

Probability diagnosis
Benign essential (familial) tremor

Senility

Physiological

Drugs: adverse effects, withdrawal

Parkinson disease (incl. drug-induced PD)

Anxiety/emotional

Alcohol

Serious disorders not to be missed


Vascular:

• cerebral infarction → Parkinsonism

Infection:

• meningoencephalitis
• tertiary syphilis

Cancer/tumour:

• cerebral tumour (frontal lobe)

Other:

• toxicity from organ failure (kidney, liver, lungs)


Pitfalls (often missed)
Cerebellar disease

Multiple sclerosis

Alzheimer dementia

Uraemia of kidney failure

CO 2 retention of respiratory failure

Hepatic failure

Rarities:

• hepatolenticular degeneration (Wilson disease)


• lesion of midbrain (red nucleus)

Masquerades checklist
Drugs (withdrawal e.g. opioids, stimulants, illicit agents, benzodiazepines, caffeine, alcohol;
adverse reactions e.g. sympathomimetics, ® agonists, lithium, phenothiazines, valproate,
amiodarone; alcohol) Thyroid/other endocrine: (hyperthyroidism, hypoglycaemia,
phaeochromocytoma)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Anxiety (esp. hyperventilation), conversion disorder (‘hysteria’).

Key history
• Nature of the tremor: resting, intention, postural (action), pill-rolling, flapping (asterixis),
hysterical, mixed
• Family history of tremor
• Evidence of cognitive changes or other neurological problems
• Systems review: respiratory, cardiac, liver, kidneys
• Drug history: prescribed, OTC, illicit drugs, alcohol, caffeine
Key examination
• General appearance and vital signs
• Respiratory, cardiac, abdominal (esp. liver) and neurological examination

Key investigations
According to above:

• FBE and ESR


• thyroid function tests (?hyperthyroidism), LFTs, pulse oximetry/blood gases
• drug screen
• MRI.

Diagnostic tips
• Essential tremor eased by a small quantity of alcohol.
• Triad of essential tremor: postural or action tremor, head tremor, positive family history.
• Look for Parkinson tetrad: resting tremor, bradykinesia, rigidity, postural instability.
• Look for cerebellar tetrad: intention tremor, dysarthria, nystagmus, ataxic gait.
• Typical drugs that induce Parkinsonism are phenothiazine, butyrophenones, reserpine.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Urinary incontinence

Probability diagnosis
Stress incontinence

Cystitis

Overactive bladder (detrusor instability)

Outflow obstruction e.g. prostatism

Post pelvic surgery

Enuresis

Serious disorders not to be missed


Infection:

• Prostatitis
• Chronic UTI

Cancer/tumour:

• Bladder

Other:

• Dementia
• Fistula
• Ectopic urethra
Pitfalls (often missed)
Neurogenic: multiple sclerosis, neuropathy, others

Interstitial cystitis (women)

Rarities:

• Bladder calculus
• Post pelvic fracture

Masquerades checklist
Diabetes: polyuria

Drugs (see list in history)

Endocrine: diabetes insipidus

Spinal dysfunction incl. cauda equina lesion

Urinary tract infection

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Functional (?psychogenic)

Key history
Focus on the duration and patterns of voiding, bowel function, drug use, obstetric and pelvic
surgery history. A voiding diary is helpful to pinpoint the cause. Use of a severity index
questionnaire is very helpful. Obstructive symptoms in men with detrusor overactivity. Consider
a sleep related problem. Check drug history: diuretics, alcohol, sedatives, antidepressants, α-
adrenergic blockers e.g. prazosin, caffeine, psychoactive agents, anticholinergics, calcium
channel blockers e.g. nifedipine.

Key examination
Based on neurological, pelvic and rectal examinations
Key investigations
First line:

• urinalysis
• MSU
• KFTs

Consider (based on specialist referral):

• cystoscopy
• cystometry
• urodynamic studies
• selective imaging e.g. ultrasound, micturating cystourethrogram, IVU

Diagnostic tips
Classify incontinence into the main categories: stress, urge and continuous (overflow).
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Vaginal discharge

Probability diagnosis
Normal or excessive physiological discharge

Vaginitis:

• bacterial vaginosis (40–50%)


• candidiasis (20–30%)
• Trichomonas (10–20%)

Serious disorders not to be missed


Neoplasia:

• cancer (cervix, uterus, vagina)


• fistulas

STIs/PID (i.e. cervicitis):

• gonorrhoea
• Chlamydia
• herpes simplex—types 1 and 2

Sexual abuse, esp. children

Tampon toxic shock syndrome (staphylococcal infection)

Streptococcal vaginosis (in pregnancy)


Pitfalls (often missed)
Chemical vaginitis (e.g. perfumes)

Retained foreign objects (e.g. tampons, IUCD)

Endometriosis (brownish discharge)

Ectopic pregnancy (‘prune juice’ discharge)

Poor toilet hygiene

Pelvic fistula

Genital herpes (possible)

Cervical polyp

Bartholinitis

Atrophic vaginitis

Threadworms

Latex allergy (e.g. condoms)

Masquerades checklist
Diabetes

Drugs

UTI (association)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Needs careful consideration; possible sexual dysfunction.
Key history
The history should include:

• nature of discharge: colour, odour, quantity, relation to menstrual cycle, associated


symptoms
• exact nature and location of irritation
• sexual history: arousal, previous STIs, number of partners and any presence of irritation
or discharge in them
• use of chemicals, such as soaps, deodorants, pessaries and douches
• pregnancy possibility
• drug therapy
• associated medical conditions (e.g. diabetes).

Key examination
• Inspection with good light includes viewing the vulva, introitus, urethra, vagina and
cervix
• Look for the discharge and specific problems such as polyps, warts, ectropion, prolapses
and fistulas
• Full pelvic examination in a postmenopausal woman

Key investigations
• pH test with paper of range 4–6
• Amine or ‘whiff’ test
• Wet film microscopy of a drop of vaginal secretions
• Full STI workup including high vaginal swab

Diagnostic tips
• Vaginal discharge is an uncommon symptom before puberty.
• It is common to overlook the problems caused by hygienic preparations including
deodorant soaps and sprays and contraceptive agents especially spermicidal creams.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Vomiting

Probability diagnosis
All ages: acute gastroenteritis, motion sickness, drugs, various infections

Neonates: feeding problems

Children: viral infections/fever, otitis media, UTI

Adults: gastritis, alcohol intoxication, pregnancy, migraine

Serious disorders not to be missed


Bowel obstruction:

• oesophageal atresia (neonates)


• pyloric obstruction <3 months
• intestinal malrotation
• intussusception
• malignancy (e.g. oesophagus, stomach)

Infection:

• botulinum poisoning
• septicaemia
• meningitis/encephalitis
• infective endocarditis
• others (e.g. acute viral hepatitis)

Malignancy

Intracranial disorders: malignancy, cerebellar

haemorrhage, PICA infarction

Acute appendicitis

Acute pancreatitis

Acute myocardial infarction (e.g. painless)


Pitfalls (mainly adults)
Pregnancy (early)

Organ failure: liver, kidney (uraemia), heart, respiratory

Labyrinthine disorders: Meniere syndrome, labyrinthitis

Poisoning: food, chemicals

Gut motility disorders: achalasia

Paralytic ileus

Substance abuse (e.g. opioids, ecstasy)

Radiation therapy

Hypercalcaemia

Functional obstruction: diabetic gastroparesis, idiopathic gastroparesis

Masquerades checklist
Depression (possible)

Diabetes (ketoacidosis)

Drugs (multiple)

Anaemia (possible)

Thyroid and other endocrine disorders (Addison disease)

UTI esp. pyelonephritis

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Possibly: extreme stress and anxiety (e.g. panic attacks). Consider bulimia (self-induced
vomiting) and functional (psychogenic).
Key history
Nausea and vomiting have a wide range of potential causes emanating from every body system.
A careful history is essential with an emphasis on drug intake, possible psychogenic factors
including self-induced emesis, weight loss, other GIT symptoms or symptoms suggestive of
systemic disease.

Key examination
• If fever is present possible sources of infections (e.g. middle ear, urinary tract and
meninges) should be checked
• A careful abdominal examination is appropriate in most instances, searching for scars
indicative of previous surgery
• Consider a neurological examination
• Be mindful of the possibility of pregnancy
• Always assess the patient’s condition including the level of hydration

Key investigations
Look for the cause and also consider biochemical abnormalities resulting from fluid and
electrolyte loss. Consider:

• pregnancy test
• urine analysis and MC
• stool MC
• endoscopy
• drug toxicity studies
• blood glucose
• radiology of GIT.

Diagnostic tips
The common cause of acute nausea and vomiting in most age groups is gastroenteritis.

• Drug ingestion is a common cause of nausea and vomiting so check for prescribed drugs
and illicit street drugs such as heroin and ecstasy.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Vulvar discomfort and irritation

Probability diagnosis
Atopic dermatitis/seborrhoeic dermatitis

Chronic vulvovaginal candidiasis

Irritant contact dermatitis (e.g. douches, bubble baths)

Allergic contact dermatitis (e.g. perfumes, topical antimicrobials)

Fissuring from the above dermatoses

Trauma: ‘dry’ coitus

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cancer:

• squamous cell carcinoma


• lymphomas, etc. → pruritus
• melanoma

Infection:

• streptococcal vulvovaginitis
• herpes simplex virus; herpes zoster

Other:

• vulval vestibular syndrome (provoked vestibulodynia)


Pitfalls (often missed)
Lichen sclerosus

Urinary incontinence → ammoniacal vulvitis

Faecal soiling

Tinea cruris

Trichomonal vaginitis

Atrophic vaginitis

Aphthous ulcers

Dysaesthetic vulvodynia

Psoriasis

Lichen planus

Infestations:

• threadworms
• pubic lice
• scabies

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Drugs (e.g. antibiotics)

Spinal dysfunction (?dysaesthesia)

UTI

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Common: psychosexual problems.

Key history
• Appropriate history including atopic skin diseases.
• Gynae-urological history (e.g. oestrogen status, faecal or urinary incontinence, vaginal
discharge, ‘thrush’)
• Check allergens and irritants (e.g. panty liners, soap, bubble bath, perfumes, condoms,
douches)
• Sporting activity (e.g. bike riding and costumes)
• Check psychosexual history (e.g. dyspareunia, partnership issues, depression)

Key examination
• General health
• Inspection of vulva and rest of skin, scalp nails
• Vaginal examination

Key investigations
• Vaginal swab
• Pap smear
• Consider need for vulval biopsy and patch testing

Diagnostic tips
• The previously named vulvar vestibular syndrome or vestibulitis is now termed provoked
vestibulodynia, whereby a vestibule tender to pinpoint pressure and variable erthythema
is found, typically, in young nulliparous women.
• Always biopsy a focal lesion on the vulva.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Weight gain

Probability diagnosis
Exogenous obesity

Alcohol excess

Fluid/oedema

Drugs

Genetic polymorphisms

Serious disorders not to be missed


Cardiovascular:

• cardiac failure

Hypothalamic disorders (hyperphagia):

• craniopharyngiomas
• optic gliomas

Insulinoma

Liver failure

Nephrotic syndrome
Pitfalls (often missed)
Pregnancy (early)

Postmenopause

Endocrine disorders:

• hypothyroidism
• Cushing syndrome
• insulinoma
• acromegaly
• hypogonadism
• hyperprolactinaemia
• polycystic ovarian disease

Idiopathic oedema syndrome

Klinefelter syndrome

Congenital disorders:

• Prader–Willi syndrome
• Laurence–Moon–Biedl syndrome

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Drugs (e.g. OCP, steroids, pizotifen, sulphonylureas, insulin)

Thyroid disorder (hypothyroidism) and other endocrine (as above)

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


Yes: the reasons for obesity should be explored.
Key history
Ascertain food and beverage intake including typical daily meals. Exercise, drug, psychological
and family history.

Key examination
• Measure body weight and height and calculate BMI, waist circumference, waist–hip
circumference, upper arm circumference
• Assess the degree and distribution of body fat and the overall nutritional status
• Search for evidence of diabetes, atherosclerosis, hypothyroidism, Cushing syndrome and
signs of alcohol abuse

Key investigations
These are more appropriate if patient unwell:

• anthropometric measurements as above, especially BMI and waist circumference


• FBE
• blood lipids
• glucose (fasting)
• LFTs
• U&E

Consider TFTs, serum cortisol, ECG and CXR.

Diagnostic tips
• The onset of obesity can occur at any age.
• Abdominal obesity gives a higher cardiovascular risk at any rate.
• Ask the patient what they believe is the cause of their weight gain/obesity.
Murtagh's Diagnostic Strategies

Weight loss

Probability diagnosis
Stress and anxiety (e.g. redundancy, divorce)

Depressive illness

Non-coping elderly/dementia

Eating disorders: anorexia nervosa/bulimia nervosa

Serious disorders not to be missed


Chronic heart failure

Malignant disease, including especially:

• stomach
• pancreas
• lung
• myeloma
• caecum
• lymphoma

Infection:

• HIV infections (AIDS, AIRC)


• tuberculosis
• hidden abscess
• infective endocarditis
• brucellosis
• others e.g. overseas acquired infection
Pitfalls (often missed)
Drug dependence (esp. alcohol)

Malabsorption states:

• ?intestinal parasites/infestations
• coeliac disease

Other GIT problems (e.g. inflammatory bowel disease)

Chronic kidney and hepatic failures

Connective tissue disorders (e.g. SLE, RA)

Dementia

Rarities:

• malnutrition
• Addison disease
• hypopituitarism

Masquerades checklist
Depression

Diabetes

Drugs: adverse effects/substance abuse (see list)

Anaemia

Thyroid disorder (hyperthyroidism, Addison disease)

UTI

Is the patient trying to tell me something?


A possibility. Consider stress, anxiety and depression. Anorexia nervosa and bulimia are special
considerations.
Key history
Document the weight loss carefully and evaluate the patient’s recordings. Determine food intake
and obtain the help of an independent witness such as a spouse or parent (if possible). Food
intake may be reduced with psychogenic disorders and cancer but increased with endocrine
disorders such as diabetes and hyperthyroidism, and with steatorrhoea.

Document drug history.

Key examination
Consider:

• vital parameters (e.g. BMI, pulse, BP, temperature, urine analysis (dipstick))
• thyroid and signs of hyperthyroidism
• abdominal examination (e.g. organomegaly, masses)
• rectal examination
• look for acid dental erosion on surface upper teeth (bulimia).

Key investigations
Consider:

• FBE
• ESR/CRP
• thyroid function tests
• U&E
• HIV
• blood sugar
• faecal occult blood
• CXR
• endoscopy upper GIT
• specific imaging (e.g. CT scan abdomen).

Diagnostic tips
Any loss of more than 5% of body weight is significant.

• The most common cause in adults of recent weight loss is stress and anxiety.
• Two conditions commonly associated with weight loss are anaemia and fever; they must
be excluded.
• Ask patients what they believe is the cause of their weight loss.
• An anxiety state and hyperthyroidism can be difficult to differentiate clinically.
• Drug use causing weight loss includes opioids, amphetamines, alcohol, laxatives,
digoxin, cytotoxics, NSAIDs, theophylline.

You might also like