S3 1130 Monday Singh
S3 1130 Monday Singh
S3 1130 Monday Singh
in operation. A photograph of the test unit is shown Carbon steel (AISI 1060) coupons with
in Fig. 2. dimensions of 7.5 cm (length) 1.2 cm (width) 0.1
Pressure was measured using a Bourdon cm (thickness) were used for experimentation.
pressure gauge (WIKA make, range: 0 – 100 bar, These coupons were fixed vertically at two
accuracy: ± 1.0% of full scale) and also using a prescribed levels on a solid central shaft which could
WIKA make pressure transmitter (range: 0 – 150 be rotated up to 1450 RPM. A maximum of 6
bar, accuracy: ± 0.5% of full scale). A reflux numbers of coupon (at 60o positions on a discs)
condenser was used to condense any low boiling could be anchored at a particular level. Fig. 3 shows
vapors arising from the sample which were directed the photograph of a test coupon. A SCADA based
Data Acquisition System (AMAR DAS 4.0)
provided by Amar Equipment Pvt. Ltd. (Mumbai,
India) was used to record data.
experimentation. The important properties of the oil the corrosion rate increasing above this temperature
are listed in Table 1. [16], [17].
The higher temperature also promotes chemical
Table 1 Properties of crude oil# reactions among organic species in the soft deposit.
Element Result These reaction rates dominate the rate of formation
API 30.87 of FeS at higher temperatures (> 275 oC). These soft
Viscosity (cP) @ 38 oC 2.631 deposits will subsequently adhere to the FeS layer
Viscosity (cP) @ 200 oC 0.843 due to change in surface characteristics. This will
C (wt. %) 84.22 result in a higher organic content in hard deposit (as
H (wt. %) 12.13 confirmed by TGA).
N (wt. %) 1.33
S (wt. %) 1.83 35
Saturates (wt. %) 25.58 Hard Deposit
30 Soft Deposit
Aromatics (wt. %) 44.38
Wt. of deposits, mg
Resins (wt. %) 27.37 25
C7-Asphaltenes* (wt. %) 1.76
CII 0.38 20
Fe (ppm)** 2.31 15
Mg (ppm)** 1.26
Na (ppm)** 7.16 10
Ni (ppm)** 6.95
5
Si (ppm)** 86.54
V (ppm)** 17.7 0
# Reproduced from [18]; *Estimated using ASTM D 6560 240 250 260 270 280 290 300 310
protocol. **Elemental analysis done using ICP – AES.
Fluid bulk temperature (oC)
Foulant deposit was collected from each coupon
post washing with n-heptane. A part of the deposit Fig. 4. Effect of bulk temperature on formation of
formed was carried away by n-heptane, while a hard and soft deposits at 100 RPM after 80 hours
portion remained strongly adhered to the coupon
surface and could only be removed by scraping. The effect of temperature on hard and soft
These are henceforth referred to as soft and hard deposits was also investigated at 250 RPM and is
deposits respectively. shown in Fig. 5.
In the subsequent sections, influence of bulk
temperature and rotational velocity on the amount of 160
hard and soft deposit formed on a coupon surface is Hard Deposit
140 Soft Deposit
discussed.
Wt. of deposits, mg
120
Effect of bulk temperature 100
The impact of fluid bulk temperature at 100
RPM on the amount of hard and soft deposit is 80
shown in Fig. 4 at 250, 275 and 300 oC. The results 60
presented are for a single representative coupon (C1)
immersed in the test fluid during the above runs. The 40
average coupon surface roughness (Ra) across these 20
three runs was 1.584 μm. The variation in coupon
0
surface roughness between 250 and 300 oC was
0.059 μm. 240 250 260 270 280 290 300 310
The amount of hard and soft deposit formed on Fluid bulk temperature (oC)
the coupon surface increases with temperature. At
250 oC, the soft deposit is one order of magnitude Fig. 5. Effect of bulk temperature on formation of
higher in amount than the hard deposit. The orders hard and soft deposits at 250 RPM after 80 hours.
are comparable at 275 and 300 oC due to increase in
the rate of FeS formation (via a corrosion The trend in hard deposit was found to be similar.
mechanism) at these temperatures. The FeS formed However, a significant increase in amount of hard
is part of the hard deposit (confirmed later by deposit was observed beyond 275 oC. This is due to
characterization). Sulfidic corrosion based fouling the increased attachment of organic content in soft
on carbon steel has been reported as a predominant deposit to the FeS layer formed. At these
mechanism in past works at 260 oC and above with temperatures, the attachment is also preceded by
increased rate of chemical reactions of FeS
formation and chemical species in the soft deposit. of decrease in amount of hard deposit. The
The soft deposit is found to decrease with increase discrepancy in soft deposit values for the two
in temperature. coupons at a shear stress of 0.18 Pa can be attributed
to flow conditions being laminar and applicability of
Effect of RPM equation 1 in this flow regime.
The effect of RPM at a constant temperature on
the amount of hard deposit formed on a coupon 40 C1
surface after 80 hours is shown in Fig. 6. The results
are presented for 2 representative coupons (C1 and 35 C2
Ω = (3)
60 C2
temperature. The increase in volatile fraction is as compared to FeO. Similar spectra were obtained
relatively higher as compared to the increase in for hard deposit samples collected at other
combustible fraction. The organic content is likely temperatures and RPMs’.
to originate from the soft deposit.
L width of the coupon, 0.012 m temperature crude oil fouling, Heat Transf.
𝜐 kinematic viscosity of the fluid, m2/s Eng., vol. 30, no. 10–11, pp. 794–804, 2009.
N rotational speed, RPM [11] Wang, W., and Watkinson, A. P., Iron
sulphide and coke fouling from sour oils:
Review and initial experiments, in Proc.
Subscript International Conference on Heat
c coupon surface Exchanger Fouling and Cleaning IX, pp.
23–30, 2011.
[12] Saleh, Z. S., Sheikholeslami, R., and
REFERENCES Watkinson, A. P., Fouling characteristics of
a light Australian crude oil, Heat Transf.
[1] Watkinson, A. P., Deposition from crude Eng., vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 15–22, 2005.
oils in heat exchangers, Heat Transf. Eng., [13] Diaz-Bejarano, E., Behranvand, E., Coletti,
vol. 28, no. 3, pp. 177–184, 2007. F., Mozdianfard, M. R., and Macchietto, S.,
[2] Ishiyama, E. M., Paterson, W. R., and Organic and Inorganic Fouling in Heat
Wilson, D. I., The effect of fouling on heat Exchangers-Industrial Case Study:Analysis
transfer, pressure drop, and throughput in of Fouling Rate, Ind. Eng
refinery preheat trains: Optimization of [14] Behranvand, E., Mozdianfard, M. R., Diaz-
cleaning schedules, Heat Transf. Eng., vol. Bejarano, E., Coletti, F., Orzlowski, P., and
30, no. 10–11, pp. 805–814, 2009. Macchietto, S., A comprehensive
[3] Young et al., Characterization of crude oils investigation of refinery preheaters foulant
and their fouling deposits using a batch samples originated by heavy crude oil
stirred cell system, Heat Transf. Eng., vol. fractions as heating fluids, Fuel, vol. 224,
32, no. 3–4, pp. 216–227, 2011. pp. 529–536, 2018.
[4] Fan, Z., Rahimi, P., McGee, R., Wen, Q., [15] Shank, R. A., and Mccartney, T. R.,
and Alem, T., Investigation of fouling Characterization of crude oil fouling:
mechanisms of a light crude oil using an Defining the coke spectrum, in Heat
alcor hot liquid process simulator, Energy Exchanger Fouling and Cleaning, 2019.
and Fuels, vol. 24, no. 11, pp. 6110–6118, [16] Wang, W., and Watkinson, A. P.,
2010. Deposition from a sour heavy oil under
[5] Crittenden, B. D., Kolaczkowski, S. T., incipient coking conditions: Effect of
Takemoto, T., and Phillips, D. Z., Crude Oil surface materials and temperature, Heat
Fouling in a Pilot-Scale Parallel Tube Transf. Eng., vol. 36, pp. 623–631, 2015.
Apparatus, Heat Transf. Eng., vol. 30, no. [17] Wang, W., and Watkinson, A. P.,
10–11, pp. 777–785, 2009. Deposition From a Sour Heavy Oil Under
[6] Smith, A. D., Analysis Of Fouling Rate And Incipient Coking Conditions: Wall Shear
Propensity For Eight Crude Oil Samples In Effects and Mechanism, Proc. Int. Conf.
Annular Test Section, Int. Conf. Heat Exch. Heat Exch. Fouling Clean., vol. 2015, pp.
Fouling Clean. - 2013, vol. 2013, pp. 1–8, 65–73, 2015.
2013. [18] Singh P., Krishnaswamy S., Ponnani K.,
[7] Rafeen, M. S., Mohamed, M. F., Mamot, M. Verma A., and Rawat J., Crude Oil Foulant
Z., Manan, N. A., Shafawi, A., and Deposition Studies on a Heated Surface
Ramasamy, M., Crude Oil Fouling : Using a Novel Batch Stirred Coupon Test
PETRONAS Refineries Experience, in Heat Rig, Int. J. Chem. Eng., vol. 2022, pp. 1–10,
Exchanger Fouling and Cleaning VII, pp. 2022.
8–12, 2007. [19] Ramchandran, P., Sundar, R., Michael, G.,
[8] Muñoz Pinto, D. A., Cuervo Camargo, S. and Jovancicevic, V., Shear Stress Profile in
M., Orozco Parra, M., Laverde, D., García a Rotating Cage, in International
Vergara, S., and Blanco Pinzon, C., Conference on Corrosion CORCON, pp.
Formation of fouling deposits on a carbon 26–28, 2007.
steel surface from Colombian heavy crude [20] Epstein, N., A Model of the Initial Chemical
oil under preheating conditions, J. Phys. Reaction Fouling rate for Flow within a
Conf. Ser., vol. 687, no. 1, 2016. Heated Tube and its Verification, in 10th
[9] Srinivasan, M., and Watkinson, A. P., international Heat Transfer Conference, pp.
Fouling of some Canadian crude oils, Heat 225–229, 1994.
Transf. Eng., vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 7–14, 2005.
[10] Bennett, C. A., Kistler, R. S., Nangia, K.,
Al-Ghawas, W., Al-Hajji, N., and Al-Jemaz,
A., Observation of an isokinetic temperature
and compensation effect for high-