How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History?

- Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History?

And a big update from me...
CULTURE CRITIC
JUL 17, 2024

226 26 Share

The Round City of Baghdad and House of Wisdom — when razed by the

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 1 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

Mongols, the Tigris ran black with ink...

First, an Update From Me

I started posting on X / Twitter because I felt there wasn’t enough educational content on
the topics that interested me: like architecture, visual arts, or cultural and religious history.

I wanted to present these in a visually-gripping way, communicating what I think should

get everyone excited about them — regardless of one’s background. Everything from the
delights of vernacular architecture to the perplexing mysteries of Mont-Saint-Michel.

To paraphrase Thomas Aquinas, “wonder is the desire for knowledge.” I wanted to take the
beauty and wonder of the old world, and explore how it might relate to modern life.

X remains the best place to do this in a short-form context, but I started a newsletter to
expand to longer formats. The mission: deliver an engaging, 5-minute “inbox cleanser” to
readers’ mailboxes every week.

Now, I’m moving to Substack because I want to go further and build a community around
these ideas that we’re collectively passionate about.

Support the Mission

Since January, I’ve published one article every Wednesday. The next step is to dedicate
even more time to writing, with a second email each week.

My premium content is a natural extension of the Wednesday topics, only deeper. Teaming
up with my friend Evan Amato, we’re now doing deep-dives every Saturday morning —
expect the topics to vary as usual:

We’ve done everything from breaking down Dante’s 9 levels of Purgatory to

interviewing the personal architect of King Charles.

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 2 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

My Wednesday content isn’t going to change — that will always be free. But if you want to
help keep it free for everyone, please support the mission with an upgrade.

It’ll help make this my full-time mission, and get beautiful, cultural content into everyone’s
mailbox.

This Saturday, I’m diving into the life of Leonardo da Vinci: why his infinite curiosity was his
greatest strength — and his Achilles’ heel...

alvaroleitao@gmail.com Subscribe

Note: anyone already subscribed to premium via Beehiiv will be transferred over to
Substack automatically — you don’t need to do anything.

Temples to Wisdom

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 3 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

Only truly civilized cultures dedicate themselves to building up a storehouse of knowledge.

That’s why libraries are the trademark of civilization — and the their destruction reflects
the downfall of culture.

Here’s a look at three of the greatest libraries in history that suffered dramatic ends:

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 4 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

What knowledge and cultural treasures were lost with them?

And what do these stories teach us about our own advanced, yet precarious
civilization?

Royal Library of Ashurbanipal

Near modern-day Mosul, Iraq lie the ruins of one of the world’s first great libraries — a
library not destroyed by fire, but preserved by it.

Assyria’s last great king, Ashurbanipal, came to the throne in the 7th century BC and
established his personal library at Nineveh. By exerting his military force to gain material
for his library, Ashurbanipal accumulated over 30,000 clay cuneiform tablets.

Although Ashurbanipal’s relentless pursuit of books (in reality, clay tablets) may have been
motivated by a desire to gain a fighting edge through occult knowledge, the library
contained more than spellwork and astronomy: it was also a hub for medical knowledge,

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 5 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

literature, and more.

In 612 BC, Babylonian forces attacked and burned Nineveh. Fortunately, though, the
library’s riches weren’t lost to history.

Instead of destroying the recorded knowledge of the library, the fire baked the clay tablets
even harder, ensuring that they survived for almost 2,600 years. Without this accident of
history, we wouldn’t have such treasures as the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Enuma Elish —
both of which are touchstones of ancient culture that come to us through Ashurbanipal’s
great library.

Great Library of Alexandria

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 6 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

The ancient world had many libraries, most of which focused on preserving a local
people’s traditions. But as the first universal library, the Library of Alexandria, was the first
that sought to consolidate knowledge from the entirety of the known world.

The library became an emblem of Egypt’s prestige after its founding in the 3rd century BC.
Egyptian agents journeyed to major cities to purchase as many books as possible, and
every ship that docked in Alexandria was required to lend its books to the library to copy.
Surrounded by its own campus that housed visiting scholars and over 100 staff librarians,
the Library of Alexandria quickly outshone every other center of learning in the known
world.

Unfortunately, the library was eventually destroyed — in part by a fire, in part by civil unrest
during the reign of Emperor Aurelian, and in part (according to legend) by Caliph Omar’s
conquest of Alexandria in 642 AD.

Fortunately, Alexandria’s librarians had assiduously copied texts to send elsewhere around
the world, and for that reason, much of the library’s contents are not completely lost.

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 7 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

What was tragically lost, however, was the library’s revolutionary system of organization. A
librarian named Callimachus had catalogued it by subject, author, with a summary of each
book's contents — the first time this was ever done in the West. It was 120 papyrus rolls of
information, essentially a detailed guide of the entire intellectual world of antiquity. If we
could have just one document back, it would be that.

Even more, Alexandria lost its role as a centralized hub of knowledge. Previously, scholars
would travel there from all over the world to seek knowledge. After the library’s
destruction, there was no longer a de facto hub for scholars to obtain the knowledge they
sought.

House of Wisdom

As the remnants of the Classical world dimmed in the West, a new world arose in the
Middle East. The Islamic Golden Age, a period of study and flourishing for the Islamic
world from the 8th to 13th centuries, raised the world’s next great library: the Library of
Baghdad.

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 8 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

This “House of Wisdom” benefited from the Translation Movement, a push to translate the
world’s great texts (predominantly Greek classics) into Arabic. The movement represented
the intellectual world centralizing in the Abbasid Empire, and the Library of Baghdad was
at the center of that world.

The House of Wisdom was a hub of practical knowledge as well as the liberal arts. Its
scholars put their studies to use as architects, engineers, civil servants, and physicians.

This Islamic Golden Age was hastened to an end on Feb 13, 1258, when the Mongol army
entered Baghdad and pillaged the city. Though some 40,000 books had been saved from
the city before the attack, the invaders threw so many books into the Tigris that the river
was said to run black with ink…

Generations to Build, a Moment to Destroy

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 9 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

The Course of Empire: Desolation, Thomas Cole (1836)

Collected knowledge is the mark of a civilization’s greatness. It’s the repository of skills
and wisdom that it can draw from to design new buildings, overcome new problems, and
create new works of history-defining art.

At the same time, libraries are among the most fragile institutions in culture. A single
attack can wipe out a civilization’s centralized collection of knowledge.

But whether it’s because of riots, civil unrest, or invaders ripping apart priceless books to
make sandals out of the leather covers, destruction occurs when people forget the value
of knowledge that doesn’t immediately serve them.

When a culture focuses exclusively on knowledge that serves it in the present, it loses
touch with its tradition and extended knowledge of the past, and the intangible (yet very
real) value of eternal wisdom.

Remember: texts through history weren't generally lost in fires. They were lost because
they weren't copied enough in the first place — cultures need a reason to preserve them.

Alexandria's scrolls were at risk long before disaster struck, because successors to
Ptolemy didn't share his commitment to knowledge, and the library fell into disuse.
Classical culture had already fallen to a far worse fate than fire — apathy.

Art of the Week

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 10 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

The Course of Empire: Destruction, Thomas Cole (1836)

The great English-American painter Thomas Cole created a series of five paintings to
describe the rise and fall of an imaginary empire: from its origins in a bucolic valley, to its
zenith as a Hellenistic metropolis.

The fourth image in the series depicts the civilization’s downfall at the hands of a fleet of
enemy ships. The city’s statues are broken, its buildings are in flames, and its people are
seized and slaughtered.

Cole’s grim depiction shows what he believed to be the eventual fate of all great
civilizations. In contemplating the painting, there’s no escaping the question: is it possible
to build a culture that doesn’t eventually fall?

Or is the work of culture to prolong the inevitable for as long as possible?

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 11 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

This Saturday, I’m diving into the life of Leonardo da Vinci: why his infinite curiosity was his
greatest strength — and his Achilles’ heel.

Join the premium list to read it, and support the mission:

alvaroleitao@gmail.com Subscribe

226 Likes · 24 Restacks

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 12 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

26 Comments

Write a comment...

Bobby M. Jul 17 Liked by Culture Critic

Glad you’re building a community here on Substack. Once Elon gave the green light for porn
to run ramped on his platform I had to delete my account. Not many places to go on the
internet anymore who want to safeguard their soul. Godspeed!
LIKE (8) REPLY SHARE

1 reply

Blinked & Passed Blinked & Passed Jul 17 Liked by Culture Critic

Insightful and informative. Agree with the point of the problem of only focusing knowledge
related to the present. Only when we contemplate our past and what’s always true can we
find way out / directions for a better future.
LIKE (8) REPLY SHARE

2 replies by Culture Critic and others

24 more comments...

© 2024 Culture Critic ∙ Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 13 of 14
How Much Knowledge Was Lost to History? - Culture Critic 8/7/24, 06:51

© 2024 Culture Critic ∙ Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice

Substack is the home for great culture

https://www.culture-critic.com/p/how-much-knowledge-was-lost-to-history Page 14 of 14