Issues and Challenges in Banking Sector
Issues and Challenges in Banking Sector
Issues and Challenges in Banking Sector
Abstract
India's banking system differs greatly from other Asian countries due to the nation's distinct
geographic, social, and economic features. India is a country with a sizable population, a vast territory,
a varied culture, and stark regional variations in income. The Indian banking sector stands at a pivotal
juncture, undergoing dynamic transformations amidst a backdrop of technological advancements,
regulatory reforms, and evolving consumer behaviours. This study explores the Indian banking
sector's evolution, challenges, and opportunities. It uses an in-depth analysis of secondary data,
including annual reports, literature, and internet resources. The study concludes that the banking
sector has undergone significant transformations due to technological advancements, regulatory
reforms, and consumer behaviour shifts. The Reserve Bank of India regulates operations, while digital
technologies, strategic fintech collaborations, and customer-centric approaches are prevalent. Despite
challenges like non-performing assets, technological disruptions, and competition, the sector presents
growth opportunities and requires collaboration between regulatory bodies, financial institutions, and
stakeholders for resilience and sustainability.
Keywords: Banking Sector, Challenges, Sustainable, Opportunities, Management
Introduction
A bank is a type of financial institution that primarily deals with deposit collection and loan
distribution. The nature of loans and deposits differs greatly. The RBI (Reserve Bank of India), the
nation's central bank, oversees banks. With its combination of foreign, private, and public banks,
India's banking sector reflects the country's diverse economy. Based on the Narasimham Committee's
recommendations, the banking industry underwent concurrent reforms in 1991 in compliance with
the liberalization policy. Like the industrial sector, banking was heavily regulated and protected by
the RBI before 1991. Reforming the banking industry has become essential to advancing the
liberalization agenda and facilitating the expansion of the private sector. Like the industrial sector,
banking was heavily regulated and protected by the RBI before 1991. Reforming the banking industry
became essential to advancing the liberalization agenda and facilitating the expansion of the private
sector.
24
Shodh Samarth- Research Journal of Commerce, Management & Economics
The Presidency Bank's Act of 1876 established the Bank of Calcutta, Bank of Bombay, and
Bank of Madras, marking the beginning of modern banking in India. The Imperial Bank of India was
established in 1921, and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) was established in 1934. The Banking
Regulations Act of 1949 gave the RBI broad authority to oversee and manage banks. In 1960, the
RBI required mandatory mergers of weak banks with strong ones, leading to 85 banks in 1969. The
Narsimham Committee report in 1992 recommended extensive changes for the banking industry,
leading to a 4% growth rate until the 1990s. Indian banking is divided into three phases these are:
Phase 1: Pre-Independence Phase
Before India's independence, nearly 600 banks existed, with the Bank of Hindustan being the first to
be established in 1770. The Oudh Commercial Bank was the first commercial bank. 19th-century
banks like Allahabad Bank and Punjab National Bank are still in operation today. The Bank of Bengal,
Bank of Madras, and Bank of Bombay merged to form the Imperial Bank, which later evolved into
the State Bank of India.
Phase 2: Post-Independence Phase
Following its independence, India's banking system continued to develop essentially in the same way.
The Indian government decided to nationalize the banks in 1969 in compliance with the 1949 Banking
Regulation Act. Among the fourteen banks that were nationalized was the Reserve Bank of India
(RBI). The Indian government admitted that many communities were experiencing financial
exclusion in 1975. Between 1982 and 1990, it set up banking institutions with specialized functions
to keep up with the growth of India's financial services industry. NABARD (1982): To assist with
agricultural endeavors: The National Housing Board (1988) financed housing projects; SIDBI (1990)
funded small-scale companies; and EXIM BANK (1982) promoted import and export.
Phase 3: LPG Era (1991-Date)
There was a radical shift in the Indian economy starting in 1991. India opened its doors to private
investment by the government. The RBI approved ten private banks. Thanks to this deregulation,
several well-known brands have persisted to this day, including HDFC, Axis Bank, ICICI, DCB, and
IndusInd Bank. Two more banks were granted licenses in the early to mid-2000s: Kotak Mahindra
Bank (2001) and Yes Bank (2004). In 2013–14, licenses were also granted to IDFC and Bandhan
banks.
Literature Review
S. Praveen Kumar and J. Pavithra (2017), according to their research on Recent Trends in the
Indian Banking Sector, the banking industry supports both boom and recession by serving as the
backbone of the country's economy. They also concluded that, following 1991, a few banking industry
25
Shodh Samarth- Research Journal of Commerce, Management & Economics
trends and developments were credited, and a few reforms were implemented to enhance their
offerings to better satisfy clients.
Seema Malik (2014) researched technological developments in the Indian banking sector. The study
"Changed Face of Banking" discovered that the most valuable innovations are those in the banking
and financial sectors, including retail banking, debit and credit cards, online and mobile banking, free
advisory services, ECS, RTGS, EFT, NEFT, and ATMs, among many other value-added products
and services.
Karigoleshwar (2016), looks at current trends in commercial banking, including cashless
transactions, e-checks, and mobile wallets,) A study titled "Recent Trends in the Banking Sector in
India" discussed various banking product types, their significance to the growth of the economy, and
current trends in the industry, including electronic checks, real-time gross settlement, electronic fund
transfers, De-mat accounts, and points of sale his paper Emerging Trends in Banking Sector: Its
Challenges and Opportunities.
Goyal & Joshi (2012), the study identified key obstacles and opportunities in the Indian banking
industry, including untapped rural markets, growing competition, global economic effects, market
discipline, transparency, HRM initiatives, foreign competition, financial inclusion support, and
environmental concerns.
Goyal K. and Joshi V. (2012), the study highlights the main obstacles and possibilities facing the
Indian banking industry. These include issues with risk management, employee retention, global
banking, market discipline, rural markets, risk management, and social and ethical considerations.
Ayachit M. (2012), the study discusses the use of ICT in improving customer-focused banking
experiences, addressing challenges like automation, biometrics, voice revolution, security, and rural
digital literacy. Solutions include effective communication, high-quality products, multifactor
authentication, and other strategies.
Snehal J. Bhatt, Krishna Gor. (2012), the paper discusses the history of India's banking industry,
focusing on five major phases: pre- and post-independence, pre-nationalization, nationalization, and
post-liberalization. It highlights the importance of marketing in the sector and proposes an abstract
framework linking banks to all customer touchpoints.
Nilesh L. and Baban S. (2014) used secondary data based on bank market capitalization and net
interest margin to report on the performance of the Indian banking sector in their research study.
Manikyam (2014), the paper discusses the evolving banking landscape, reforms, opportunities, and
problems faced by commercial and national banks, focusing on high transaction costs, asset quality
issues, IT revolution, technological upgrades, competition, privacy, security, and global banking.
26
Shodh Samarth- Research Journal of Commerce, Management & Economics
Bhai Lakshmi's (2018), research paper discusses India's e-banking system's potential, challenges,
and opportunities, highlighting its potential in rural markets, customer service, and internet usage,
while also addressing privacy, technology, security, and internet penetration issues.
R. Deepak Sounder & and K. Saranya (2020), in their study titled "A Study on Digital Banking in
India" explained how the banking sector has evolved significantly in the modern era. The online
banking industry faced several significant issues and difficulties because of digital banking. The
banking industry has gradually transitioned from traditional to digital banking and is still working to
provide its clients with longer-term, better services. Users can access financial data on desktop
computers, mobile phones, and ATMs.
Sujatha M. N.V. Haritha and P. Sai Sreeja (2017), the study titled "Recent Trends in the Banking
Sector in India" discussed various banking product types, their significance to the growth of the
economy, and current trends in the industry, including electronic checks, real-time gross settlement,
electronic fund transfers, de-mat accounts, and sales points.
Objectives
• To study the changing scenario of the banking sector in India.
• To identify the challenges for the Indian banking sector.
• To study opportunities for the Indian banking sector.
Methodology
A compilation of secondary research on the Indian banking industry, with particular attention to the
Indian environment, is this study. To finish this, several reports on this subject have been taken into
consideration, annual reports, numerous books, journals, and periodicals have been reviewed, and
online searches have also been conducted.
Structure of the Organised Banking Sector in India
The Reserve Bank of India began operations on April 1, 1935. India's banks are divided into various
categories. Every group has distinct benefits and advantages, as well as specific target markets and
clientele, as well as operational constraints in India. The Reserve Bank of India, the country's
regulatory central bank, keeps a close watch on the banking sector in India. Cooperative banks and
commercial banks make up most of the banking sector.
27
Shodh Samarth- Research Journal of Commerce, Management & Economics
The banking structure in India is organized into different categories of banks, each serving specific
purposes and functions. The banking system in India is broadly classified into two main categories:
scheduled banks and non-scheduled banks. Here's an overview of the banking structure in India:
Scheduled Banks
Commercial Banks:
• Public sector banks (PSBs) are government-owned banks with over 50% stakes, such as SBI
and PNB. Private sector banks are owned by private individuals or corporations like HDFC
and ICICI. Foreign banks are headquartered in foreign countries, with branches in major
Indian cities. Regional Rural Banks (RRBs) are established to provide banking services in
rural and semi-urban areas, focusing on agricultural and rural development, in collaboration
with the Central Government, state governments, and sponsor banks.
Cooperative Banks:
• Urban Cooperative Banks (UCBs): These banks operate in urban and semi-urban areas. They
are usually small-sized banks catering to the financial needs of a specific community or
locality.
28
Shodh Samarth- Research Journal of Commerce, Management & Economics
• State Cooperative Banks (SCBs) and District Central Cooperative Banks (DCCBs): These
banks operate at the state and district levels, respectively, and work in association with urban
cooperative banks to support agricultural and rural credit.
Non-Scheduled Banks: These banks do not fulfill the criteria set by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
for scheduled banks. They are smaller and operate in limited areas.
Development Banks: Institutions like the Industrial Development Bank of India (IDBI) and the
National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD) are examples of development
banks. They focus on providing financial assistance for industrial and agricultural development,
respectively.
Payment Banks and Small Finance Banks: These are specialized banks introduced by the RBI to
promote financial inclusion. Payment banks focus on providing basic banking services, while small
finance banks cater to the financial needs of small and marginal customers, including small
businesses.
Central Bank: The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is the central bank of the country. It formulates and
implements monetary policy, issues currency, regulates and supervises the banking system, and acts
as a banker to the government.
The banking structure in India is continually evolving to meet the changing economic landscape and
the diverse financial needs of the population. The RBI plays a crucial role in regulating and
supervising the banking sector to ensure stability and growth in the economy.
Changing Scenario of the Banking Sector in India
In response to the evolving financial landscape, Indian banks are actively undergoing digital
transformation to enhance the customer experience and streamline operations through the adoption
of mobile banking, internet banking, and digital payment systems. Fintech collaboration has gained
prominence as traditional banks partner with fintech firms to incorporate innovative solutions in
payments, lending, and risk management. Regulatory reforms by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
aim to fortify the banking sector, addressing issues such as non-performing assets (NPAs), bolstering
cybersecurity, and improving governance. Efforts to manage NPAs are complemented by guidelines
to strengthen overall asset quality. Initiatives like the Unified Payments Interface (UPI) have
revolutionized payments, promoting seamless and instant fund transfers. Financial inclusion remains
a focal point, with payment banks and small finance banks contributing to efforts to bring unbanked
populations into the formal banking system. The credit landscape emphasizes responsible lending,
with a balance between credit growth and prudent risk management. A customer-centric approach is
evident, utilizing data analytics for personalized services and improved customer engagement.
Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) considerations are gaining significance, leading banks
to adopt sustainable and responsible banking practices. Despite the challenges posed by economic
29
Shodh Samarth- Research Journal of Commerce, Management & Economics
uncertainties and global events, resilience and adaptability are key attributes enabling banks to
navigate changing conditions. The banking sector in India has been experiencing various changes and
evolving due to technological advancements, regulatory reforms, and shifts in consumer behavior.
Some general trends and changes or developments in the banking sector in India:
Aspect Previous Status Current Status Changes/Developments
Diversification
Ownership Dominance of Public Emergence and growth of
with Private
Structure Sector Banks private banks
Banks
Extensive use of
Technology Limited Introduction to mobile
technology and
Adoption Digitalization banking, UPI, etc.
digital banking
Increased focus
Financial Limited reach to Implementation of PMJDY
on rural and
Inclusion rural areas and Aadhar linkage
unbanked areas
Rising NPAs, Continued focus Stringent measures,
NPAs and
concerns about credit on asset quality Insolvency and Bankruptcy
Credit Quality
quality management Code (IBC)
Stricter regulatory
Regulatory Evolving regulatory Continuous updates and
norms and
Framework environment reforms by the RBI
compliance
Growing
Fintech Adoption of fintech for
Fintech Integration partnerships with
Integration various services
fintech companies
Gradual
expansion and
Payment Banks Introduction to the
integration of Enhancing financial inclusion
and Small new banking
payments and and services|
Finance Banks category
small finance
banks
Increasing Increasing
Global Participation in international
collaboration with collaboration with
Integration financial markets
global banks global banks
30
Shodh Samarth- Research Journal of Commerce, Management & Economics
Emphasis on
Customer Traditional Banking Enhanced customer
customer-centric
Services Services experience and service
services
Advanced risk
Evolving risk
Risk assessment and Integration of technology
management
Management management into risk management
practices
practices
31
Shodh Samarth- Research Journal of Commerce, Management & Economics
maintaining these ratios can be challenging, particularly for banks dealing with high NPAs
and economic uncertainties.
• Governance and Risk Management: Ensuring effective governance and risk management
practices is crucial for the stability of the banking sector. Issues related to corporate
governance and risk management, if not addressed, can lead to financial instability and erode
public trust.
• Financial Inclusion: Despite significant progress, there are still challenges in achieving
comprehensive financial inclusion, especially in rural and remote areas. Banks need to
develop sustainable models to reach the unbanked and underbanked populations.
• Economic Slowdown and External Shocks: The Indian economy is subject to both domestic
and global economic fluctuations. Economic slowdowns and external shocks, such as the
global financial crisis or the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, can affect the banking
industry's performance.
• Regulatory Changes and Compliance: The banking industry operates under a regulatory
framework set by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and other regulatory bodies. Frequent
regulatory changes can pose challenges for banks in terms of compliance, implementation,
and adaptation to new guidelines.
• Liquidity Management: Maintaining optimal liquidity levels is crucial for the smooth
functioning of banks. Balancing liquidity requirements with profitability goals and regulatory
compliance is an ongoing challenge.
• Global Economic Uncertainties: Global economic uncertainties, trade tensions, and
geopolitical issues can impact India's economy and, consequently, the banking industry.
Banks need to be resilient and adaptable to navigate such uncertainties.
It's important to note that the challenges faced by the banking industry are dynamic, and the industry
continually evolves to address these issues. Regulatory bodies and financial institutions work
collaboratively to find solutions and ensure the stability and growth of the banking sector.
Opportunities Faced by the Indian Banking Industry
The term "opportunity" in the context of the Indian banking industry refers to favourable
circumstances, situations, or prospects that have the potential to contribute positively to the growth,
development, and sustainability of banks and financial institutions in India. These opportunities arise
from various sources, including, but not limited to:
• Digital Transformation: The ongoing digital revolution presents an opportunity for banks to
adopt innovative technologies, enhance customer experiences, and streamline operations
through digital channels.
32
Shodh Samarth- Research Journal of Commerce, Management & Economics
33
Shodh Samarth- Research Journal of Commerce, Management & Economics
Bhatt, S. J., & Gor, K. (2012). Recent Trends in Marketing Strategy in the Banking Sector. IBMRD's
Journal of Management and Research.
Goyal, K. A., & Joshi, V. (2012). Indian Banking Industry: Challenges & Opportunities. International
Journal of Business Research and Management, 3(1), 18-28.
Jain, S. K., & Kulkarni, D. (2012). Banking in India: Challenges and Opportunities. Journal of
Business Research and Management, 3(1).
Kamboj, D. (2017, December 30). Trends and Challenges in the Indian Banking Sector. Scholarly
Research Journal for Interdisciplinary Studies, 4(37). https://doi.org/10.21922/srjis.v4i37.10791
Karigoleshwar (2016). Emerging Trends in Banking Sector - Its Challenges and Opportunities.
Scholarly Research Journal for Humanity Science & English Language, 6/26, 7480-7488.
Kumar, K. (2020). Critical Analysis, Challenges & Opportunities of Indian Banking Sector. SSRN
Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3643324
Kumar, Manoj. (n.d.). Banking Sector Reforms in India. International Research Journal of
Commerce. Retrieved from http://www.asiatradehub.com/india/banks.asp
Kumar, M., & Pavithra, J. (2017). Recent Trends in the Indian Banking Sector. International Journal
of Pure and Applied Mathematics, 116(18), 529-534.
Limbore, N. V., & Mane, B. S. (2014). A Study of the Banking Sector in India and Overview of
Performance of Indian Banks Concerning Net Interest Margin and Market Capitalization of Banks.
Review Of Research, 3(6).
Malik, S. (2014). Technological Innovations in Indian Banking Sector: Changed Face of Banking.
International Journal of Advance Research in Computer Science and Management Studies, 2(6), 122-
128.
Mishra, K. K. (2020, January 1). Critical Analysis, Challenges & Opportunities of Indian Banking
Sector.
Nataraj, G., & Ashwani. (2018, July 24). Banking Sector Regulation in India: Overview, Challenges
and Way Forward. Indian Journal of Public Administration, 64(3), 473–486.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0019556118783065
Purbey, U. K. (2020, October 1). Customer Satisfaction in Indian Banking Services: Problems and
Solutions. International Journal of Advanced Academic Studies, 2(4), 134–137.
https://doi.org/10.33545/27068919.2020.v2.i4c.342
R. Deepak Sounder, & K. Saranya. (2020). A Study of Digital Banking in India. Aegaeum Journal,
8(8), 1599–1608.
Roy, S., Mahar, K., Chandra Sekhar, S., &Mahabub, B. S. (2023, October 31). Indian Banking
Industry: Challenges and Opportunities. International Journal of Management and Development
Studies, 12(10), 08–15. https://doi.org/10.53983/ijmds.v12n10.002
34
Shodh Samarth- Research Journal of Commerce, Management & Economics
Sharma, H., & Tiwari, S. (2023, May 27). Indian Banking Sector. VEETHIKA-An International
Interdisciplinary Research Journal, 9(2), 1–3. https://doi.org/10.48001/veethika.2023.09.02.001
35