Green Chemistry: E Ect of A Phase Transfer Catalyst Structure On The Alkaline Hydrolysis of Poly (Ethylene Terephthalate)
Green Chemistry: E Ect of A Phase Transfer Catalyst Structure On The Alkaline Hydrolysis of Poly (Ethylene Terephthalate)
Green Chemistry: E Ect of A Phase Transfer Catalyst Structure On The Alkaline Hydrolysis of Poly (Ethylene Terephthalate)
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported Licence.
rsc.li/greenchem
A systematic investigation into the factors which influence catalytic intensive superclean methodologies are utilised,3,6,7 while
activity in 50 simple (mostly) quaternary ammonium- and phos- chemical recycling via depolymerisation requires efficient
phonium halide catalysts for the hydrolysis of poly(ethylene tere- chemical processes on large scale (frequently at high tempera-
phthalate) has revealed the most efficacious constitutional isomer tures);7 however it can produce pure monomers which can be
class and the optimum properties these catalysts should possess. repolymerised to pristine PET for any application, thereby
General guidelines for catalyst design are provided. reducing reliance on fossil fuel-derived virgin PET.3,7 In
addition, in the case of PET, a recent analysis found that CO2
It has been estimated that from 1950 to 2015, 6.3 × 1012 kg of emission saving at end of life treatment is considerably lower
plastics have been synthesised – with a recycle rate of just ca. for chemical recycling than for mechanical recycling.3
9%. Without intervention, by 2050, 12 × 1013 kg of these poly- Chemical recycling methodologies include (inter alia) amino-
mers will either be in landfill or out polluting the natural lysis, alcoholysis, glycolysis and hydrolysis.8 A particularly
world;1 therefore (until replacement of traditional plastics with attractive potential PET recycling methodology is alkaline
sustainable materials is widespread) improvement in both the hydrolysis in the presence of a phase transfer catalyst (PTC).
rate and efficiency of recycling is needed to reduce both the This has the advantages of lower reaction temperatures (typi-
dependence on oil-derived virgin plastic and the contribution cally 80–100 °C) than those required by neutral hydrolysis and
its synthesis/disposal makes to the current climatological and less contamination by oligomers or decomposition of ethylene
ecological emergency. glycol using either neutral or acidic hydrolysis, respectively.8
Poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) polyester is a major con- While phase transfer catalysis9 of alkaline PET hydrolysis to
stituent in certain beverage bottles, textile fibres and food tray/ form (after acidic workup) terephthalic acid is known for over
pharmaceutical packaging, which in 2021 accounted for 12% two decades,8 the PTC characteristics required to bring about
of worldwide solid waste.2 Of the commonly bulk-manufac- efficient promotion of the process are poorly understood.
tured plastics, PET has the highest greenhouse gas (GHG) Attempts to elucidate a consensus model of the contributors to
emissions associated with its production (up to 4.5 kg GHG catalytic activity are confounded by studies using different cat-
per kg PET)3,4 yet it is one of the most amenable for various alysts, loadings (1–100 mol%), PET sources, particle sizes,
‘recycling’ methodologies – which can be broadly categorised temperatures, stirring speeds, NaOH stoichiometry, NaOH
as either incineration or mechanical or chemical recycling. concentrations,10–17 microwave-radiation18 and ultrasound.19,20
Incineration solves the landfill problem and can recover For instance, tetrabutylammonium iodide (TBAI) has been
energy from the materials but it has been determined after a reported as an active catalyst in one study19 at 1 mol% loading
recent study5 by the European Commission’s Joint Research (no control experiment without a catalyst reported), while its
Centre that it is less preferable from a climate change impact bromide analogue has been reported as completely inactive in
perspective. Mechanical recycling is operationally more facile, another study at 24 mol% loadings (conversion identical to
yet amplifies existing degradation and produces recycled PET that of the control).12 Both studies used similar PET sources
of lower value and quality unless complex, more resource and very small particle sizes (ca. 0.25 mm), but different reac-
tion temperatures and NaOH concentration/loadings. The
latter study identified the large, water-insoluble tributyl-
School of Chemistry, Trinity Biomedical Sciences Institute, Trinity College Dublin,
152-160 Pearse St., Dublin 2, Ireland. E-mail: connons@tcd.ie
hexadecylphosphonium bromide as the optimal catalyst.12
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/ The non-PET hydrolysis literature offers clues regarding
10.1039/d4gc05070c ideal catalyst attributes but not conclusions – Herriot et al.21
found that larger symmetrical cations outperformed catalysts Table 1 Alkaline hydrolysis of PET catalysed by symmetrical PTCsa
with one long chain in an SN2 reaction in benzene/water cata-
lysed by ammonium and phosphonium PTCs, while earlier
Starks9c had warned that ammonium PTCs were poor overall
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported Licence.
The evaluation of catalysts characterised by 3 longer chains Table 3 Alkaline hydrolysis of PET catalysed by 2-chain PTCsa
is outlined in Table 2. The tripentylmethylammonium species
11 facilitated the formation of 2 in appreciable yield (entry 1).
The partially soluble, finely dispersed homologue 12 is
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported Licence.
Table 4 Alkaline hydrolysis of PET catalysed by 1-chain PTCsa Table 5 Alkaline hydrolysis of PET catalysed by benzylated PTCsa
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported Licence.
Open Access Article. Published on 11 October 2024. Downloaded on 10/21/2024 5:16:00 PM.
1c 24 11 Soluble 17.1
2c 25 13 Soluble 26.9
3c 26 17 Soluble 32.8
4c 27 19 Soluble 29.7
5d 28 24 Insoluble 42.9
6d 29 32 Insoluble 53.4
a
Reaction conditions as outlined in Scheme 1. b Determined by 1H
NMR spectroscopy using 4-iodoanisole as an internal standard.
c
Formation of an emulsion as the reaction progressed was observed.
d
Severe adherence of the PET flakes to each other was observed.
No. of carbon Solubility under Yieldb
Entry Catalyst atoms reaction conditions (%)
1 30 10 Soluble 5.6
studied 9b,23 – (entries 1 and 2) exhibited little activity under 2 31 13 Soluble 8.8
these conditions. The considerably more lipophilic 3 32 19 Soluble 43.6
4 33c 19 Soluble 19.7
ammonium salt 32 was shown to be a more suitable catalyst 5 34 23 Insoluble 75.9
(entry 3), while its phosphonium variant 33 decomposed 6 35 23 Insoluble 68.7
(entry 4). Extension of the π-system was generally advantageous 7 36c 23 Insoluble 14.6
8 37 25 Insoluble 57.7
(i.e. catalysts 34–38 entries 5 and 6) unless either a phos- 9 38 27 Insoluble 19.2
phonium salt (entry 7) or an anthracene unit (entry 9) was 10 39 25 Insoluble 40.5
involved. An interesting phenomenon was observed here: cata- 11 40 16 Soluble 18.9
12 41 20 Soluble 33.4
lysts of increasing size no longer immediately became less 13 42 22 Soluble 47.5
active when insoluble. For instance, both the insoluble 14 43c 26 Insoluble 81.4
naphthyl-substituted catalysts 34 and 35 show improvements 15 44c 24 Insoluble 53.3
16 45 28 Soluble 39.2
compared to the soluble, benzyl analogue 32 (entries 3, 5 and 17 46 30 Insoluble 60.5
6). It is clear that the introduction of aromatic substituents
a
changes the behaviour of these systems relative to aliphatic Reaction conditions as outlined in Scheme 1. b Determined by 1H
NMR spectroscopy using 4-iodoanisole as an internal standard.
analogues. The dioctylisoquinolinium salt 39 (entry 10) was a c
Catalyst decomposition.
moderately effective catalyst which lacked the activity of
simpler systems mentioned above – so investigations along
these lines were halted and attention switched to novel diben-
zylated systems. from the impressive performance of the insoluble 43 (entry
As expected, the small, soluble salt 40 did not excel as a 14). Bis-naphthyl/bis-biphenyl analogues of 40 and 42 (i.e.
catalyst (entry 11); however its dipropyl- and dibutyl-analogues 44–46, entries 15–17) proved to be serviceable catalysts, yet all
(41 and 42, entries 12 and 13, respectively) showed significant were inferior to 43.
improvements. Once again, the immediate penalty paid from The evaluation of miscellaneous systems is outlined in
an efficiency standpoint when catalysts in previous classes Table 6. The simple trimethylanilinium species 47 showed
became wholly insoluble in the reaction medium is not of the little activity (entry 1) while both pyridinium salts 48 and 49
same magnitude in this class of promoters – as can be seen and the tetraphenylphosphonium salt 50 decomposed (entries
1 47 9 soluble 7.0
2 48c 6 soluble 4.1
3 49c 13 insoluble 14.0
4 50c 24 insoluble 6.5
5 51 10 soluble 5.3
a
Reaction conditions as outlined in Scheme 1. b Determined by 1H
NMR spectroscopy using 4-iodoanisole as an internal standard.
c
Catalyst decomposition.
these reactions due to catalyst decomposition. Scheme 2 PET hydrolysis catalysed by 17 under concentrated
Conclusion 1 (vide supra) predicts that if the solubility of an conditions.
active, soluble catalyst is reduced to the point of heterogeneity,
that activity would be negatively impacted, while the opposite
would be expected if an active, finely dispersed catalyst is ren- soluble under the reaction conditions or being finely dis-
dered soluble. To test this, the insoluble iodide variant of the persed. Once a catalyst is insoluble and aggregating, a further
Open Access Article. Published on 11 October 2024. Downloaded on 10/21/2024 5:16:00 PM.
highly active, soluble catalyst 17 (i.e. 52) and the soluble chlor- increase in lipophilicity is deleterious – as are reductions in
ide analogue of the less active finely dispersed homologue 18 lipophilicity if the catalyst is soluble. Benzylated catalysts
(i.e. 53) were synthesised and evaluated (Table 7). The hetero- exhibited interesting behaviour which may indicate that
genous iodide 52 proved markedly inferior to 17 (entries 1 and π-stacking can allow largely insoluble ammonium salts to
2) while the soluble, more lipophilic cation containing (than possess considerable activity. After evaluation of over 50 cata-
17) catalyst 53 accelerated the PET depolymerisation more lytic systems, a picture emerged in which it is perhaps unwise
efficiently than all other catalysts evaluated in this study to search for a ‘universal’ optimum catalyst for the acceleration
(entries 3 and 4). of alkaline PET hydrolysis, but rather that the practitioner
Finally, since the reaction is heterogeneous and the flakes should design the catalyst and the reaction conditions together
relatively large (relative to powders), we reasoned that the – as the solutes in the aqueous medium and the reaction
simple adaptation of reducing the volume of water in the reac- temperature will alter the ability of the medium to solubilise
tion by 50% would bring about significant improvements in the catalyst – with dramatic consequences regarding catalyst
efficacy – as both hydroxide/catalyst concentration would be efficacy. While a given catalyst for one set of conditions may
doubled while the PET flakes would be in contact with a prove optimal, alteration of those conditions may shift the
greater proportion of the bulk solution – and the reaction solubility equilibrium such that a larger or smaller homologue
would generate less aqueous waste. Accordingly, we repeated of the original catalyst may be better suited. Other factors such
the standard PET hydrolysis with half the volume of aqueous as the PET source and particle size are no doubt also similarly
solvent and with only 1 mol% of the benchmark bromide cata- relevant. Further investigations along these lines are
lyst 17. The result was the isolation of TPA in near quantitative underway.
yield after 3 h (Scheme 2).
In summary, the first systematic investigation into the influ-
ence of the structure on activity in simple quaternary Data availability
ammonium- and phosphonium-based catalytic systems for
alkaline PET hydrolysis has revealed that catalysts incorporat- The data supporting this article have been included as part of
ing 2 longer aliphatic chains and a smaller hydrophilic cation the ESI.†
generally outperform other constitutional isomers. Optimum
catalysts were as lipophilic as possible while either remaining
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts to declare.
Table 7 Manipulation of catalyst solubility and activity via the halide
counteriona
Acknowledgements
This study emanated from research conducted with the
support of The Science Foundation Ireland Research Centre
for Pharmaceuticals (SSPC) under grant number 12/RC/
2275_P2 and Science Foundation Ireland under grant number
19/FFP/6527. For the purpose of Open Access, the author has
No. of carbon Solubility under Yieldb
Entry Catalyst atoms reaction conditions (%) applied a CC BY public copyright licence to any Author
Accepted Manuscript version arising from this submission.
1 17c 16 Soluble 81.9
2 52 16 Insoluble 58.4
3 18c 18 Finely dispersed 70.6
4 53 18 Soluble 88.9 References
a
Reaction conditions as outlined in Scheme 1. b Determined by 1H
NMR spectroscopy using 4-iodoanisole as an internal standard. c Data 1 R. Geyer, J. R. Jambeck and K. L. Law, Sci. Adv., 2017, 3,
from Table 3. e1700782.
R. C. Brown, V. S. Cecon, J. B. Curley, G. W. Curtzwiler, B. Serafinova, Rocz. Chem., 1965, 39, 1223; (c) C. M. Starks,
S. Dong, S. Gaddameedi, J. E. García, I. Hermans, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1971, 93, 195.
M. S. Kim, J. Ma, L. O. Mark, M. Mavrikakis, 10 V. A. Kosmidis, D. S. Achilias and G. P. Karayannidis,
O. O. Olafasakin, T. A. Osswald, K. G. Papanikolaou, Macromol. Mater. Eng., 2001, 286, 640.
H. Radhakrishnan, M. A. Sanchez Castillo, K. L. Sánchez- 11 J. Das, A. B. Halgeri, V. Sahu and P. A. Parikh, Indian
Rivera, K. N. Tumu, R. C. Van Lehn, K. L. Vorsth, J. Chem. Technol., 2007, 14, 173.
Open Access Article. Published on 11 October 2024. Downloaded on 10/21/2024 5:16:00 PM.