ca-insureconomy-2024
ca-insureconomy-2024
ca-insureconomy-2024
Measuring the value of the property and casualty insurance industry to the economy
CANADA
IB C
Insurance Bureau
of Canada
InsurEconomy 2024
The InsurEconomy report is published by Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC) and presents statistics on the P&C insurance industry’s
importance and economic contribution to Canada and its provinces. Data in the report is sourced from IBC, Statistics Canada and
MSA Research Inc., with other supporting information collected from secondary sources.
IBC commissioned Statistics Canada to use their input-output model to simulate the P&C insurance industry’s 2022 direct, indirect and
induced impacts on output and employment at the national and provincial levels. IBC provided the 2022 estimate of P&C insurance
industry output used in the model shocks.
The most recent data available is used for the major P&C issues highlighted within the report.
In some instances, figures may not add up to the listed total due to rounding.
In Canada, P&C insurance carriers and brokerages directly The P&C insurance industry contributes substantially
created 145,000 jobs in 2022. For every 100 P&C insurance to Canada’s tax revenue. In 2022, the industry directly
jobs, a further 105 jobs were generated due to supply contributed nearly $4 billion in federal taxes (Exhibit 5)
chain impacts and the multiplier effect of employees’ and more than $8 billion in provincial taxes and levies,
re-spending of earnings. The total number of jobs which brought the industry’s total tax contribution to a
attributable to the P&C insurance industry was estimated slightly more than $12 billion.
to be 297,000.
Those working for life and health (L&H) and P&C insurance
carriers in Canada in 2022 earned an hourly compensation
that was 34% above the national average (Exhibit 2),
reflecting their productivity. On average, labour
productivity at an insurance carrier was 84% higher than
at the average industry in Canada (Exhibit 4).
However, primary insurance carriers do not work in isolation. Although the nature of the P&C insurance industry remains relatively
Insurance carriers depend on the distribution channels and consumer stable over time, and despite the challenges with natural catastrophes
education services of insurance brokerages and agents. Brokers and over the last few years, the business strategy continues to evolve to
agents work directly with consumers to select insurance coverages reflect the changing risk and regulatory environment in which the
that most accurately match the consumer’s budget and risk profile. industry operates.
21.7%
14.1%
4.6%
9.2%
4.7%
55%
Operating expenses including employee compensation Investment Profit Source: IBC analysis
with data from MSA
Taxes and Levies Underwriting Profit
Research Inc. (Based
Profit Margin on 10-year average)
Claims paid to policyholders
1
Statistics Canada. (2009). User’s Guide to the Canadian Input-Output Model.
2
See Appendix for the methodology used by Statistics Canada to compute the direct, indirect and induced impacts.
Utilities
Mining and oil and gas extraction
[52] Finance and insurance
[5241] Insurance carriers
Information and cultural industries
Holding companies
[5242] Agencies, brokerages and other insurance related activities
Professional, scientific and technical services
Wholesale trade
Manufacturing
Construction
All industries
Real estate, rental and leasing
Transportation and warehousing
Health care and social assistance
Administrative and support, waste management and remediation services
Arts, entertainment and recreation
Retail trade
Educational services
Other private services
Accommodation and food services
Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Dollars Per Hour, 2022
Source: Statistics Canada.
Note: See Appendix for 2022 North American Industry Classification System
All industries
Health care and social assistance
Educational services
(5241) Insurance carriers
(5242) Agencies, brokerages and other insurance related activities
(52) Finance and insurance
Accommodation and food services
Management of companies and enterprises
Retail trade
Other services (except public administration)
Public administration
Arts, entertainment and recreation
Real estate and rental and leasing
Professional, scientific and technical services
Administrative and support, waste management and remediation services
Information and cultural industries
Wholesale trade
Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
Manufacturing
Utilities
Transportation and warehousing
Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
Construction
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
Women Men
Source: Statistics Canada.
Note: See Appendix for 2022 North American Industry Classification System
The P&C insurance industry supports a significant number of jobs, employs a significant percentage of women and pays above-average wages,
all of which contribute to both the economic dynamism of the country and its gender equality.
Utilities
Mining and oil and gas extraction
Real estate, rental and leasing
[5241] Insurance carriers
Information and cultural industries
[52] Finance and insurance
Wholesale trade
Manufacturing
[5242] Agencies, brokerages and other insurance related activities
All industries
Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
Professional, scientific and technical services
Construction
Health care and social assistance
Transportation and warehousing
Administrative and support, waste management and remediation services
Retail trade
Educational services
Arts, entertainment and recreation
Holding companies
Other private services
Accommodation and food services
0 50 100 150 200 250
Real GDP per Hour Worked ($)
Source: Statistics Canada.
Note: See Appendix for 2022 North American Industry Classification System
Exhibit 5: Taxes Contributed by the P&C Insurance Industry to the Provincial Governments, 2022, Canada
$341M
$280M
$308M
$248M Insurance Premium Taxes
RST on Premiums
Taxes on Claims
$2.8B Corporate Income Taxes
$1.6B Taxes on Operations
Payroll Tax
Health Care Levies
$3.0B B – billions
M – millions
Source: IBC
3
Statistics Canada.
4
Statistics Canada.
5
IBC and Équité. (2023). Auto Theft: A National Crisis. auto-theft-public-policy-position-paper.pdf (storyblok.com)
6
Équité. Top 10 Most Stolen Vehicles. Canada’s Most Stolen Vehicles (equiteassociation.com)
7
IBC. (2024). It’s time for the federal government to launch the National Flood Insurance Program. https://www.ibc.ca/issues-and-advocacy/canadians-need-flood-protection
8
IBC analysis with data from PCS, CatIQ, Swiss Re, Munich Re and Deloitte.
9
Grant, Eric. (2012). The Economic and Social Value of Insurance. The Geneva Association, 10.
10
Ibid., 12.
11
Grundl, H., M. Dong, and J. Gal (2016). “The Evolution of Insurer Portfolio Investment Strategies for Long-Term Investing,” OECD Journal: Financial Market Trends. 3.
The 2022 North American Industry Classification System12 defines 5242 – Agencies, brokerages and other insurance-related
insurance carriers and agencies, brokerages and other insurance- activities
related activities as follows: This industry group comprises establishments primarily engaged in
selling insurance or providing services related to insurance.
5241 – Insurance carriers
This industry group comprises establishments primarily engaged 52421 – Insurance agencies and brokerages
in underwriting annuities, insurance policies and reinsurance. The 52429 – Other insurance-related activities.
establishments of this group invest premiums to build up a portfolio
of financial assets to use against future claims. Contributions and Methodology used by Statistics Canada
premiums are set based on actuarial calculations of reserves. This All nominal GDP, employment, personal income and tax values in this
industry group includes direct insurance carriers that are primarily report are provided by Statistics Canada, which used detailed supply-
engaged in underwriting annuities and insurance policies directly to and-use tables and input-output models, unless otherwise stated.
policyholders, and reinsurance carriers that are primarily engaged The results of the models quantify the combined direct, indirect and
in assuming all or part of the risk associated with existing insurance induced economic impacts (total impact):
policies originally underwritten by other insurance carriers.
Industries are defined in terms of the type of risk against which the Direct impacts relate only to businesses, employees and
policyholders are being insured, such as death, loss of employment those self-employed workers in insurance carriers (NAICS
due to age or disability, and property damage. 5241) and agencies, brokers and other insurance-related
activities (NAICS 5242), for example, premium taxes paid
52411 – Direct life, health and medical insurance carriers directly by insurance carriers.
52412 – Direct insurance (except life, health and medical) carriers
Indirect impacts (or supply-chain impacts) are generated by
52413 – Reinsurance carriers the upstream (supply-chain) purchases made by operations
identified in the direct impact phase. For example, operations
in the P&C insurance economy require external legal and
administrative services.
12
Statistics Canada.