EIA ereje
EIA ereje
EIA ereje
PREPARED BY
Bright star management and environmental consultancy plc
st
Address: In Labu 01 Sara build 1 floor Addis Ababa
Submitted to GelanSub City Environmental Protection Authority
JANURY , 2025
Gelansub-city , Ethiopia
0
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
Contents
ABBREVIATIONS............................................................................................................4
Executive Summary...........................................................................................................5
Chapter 1............................................................................................................................7
1. Introduction....................................................................................................................7
1.2 Approach to the Study................................................................................................8
1.2.1 Objective of the Study.............................................................................................8
1.2.2 Methodologies Employed.......................................................................................9
1.2.3 Limitations of the Study........................................................................................11
1.3 Environmental Scoping............................................................................................11
1.3.1. Limits of the Study Area......................................................................................11
1.3.2. Valued Environmental Components within the Study Area................................12
1.3.3. Report Structure..............................................................................................12
Chapter 2..........................................................................................................................13
2. Legal and Policy Framework.......................................................................................13
2.1 Economic Development Policies and Strategies.....................................................13
2.1.1 The National Economic Development Strategy....................................................13
2.1.2 Ethiopian Investment Strategy..............................................................................14
2.1.3 Policy and Legislation on the Sector....................................................................15
2.1.4 Export Sector Development Program..................................................................15
2.2 Environmental Policies and Strategies....................................................................16
2.2.1. The Constitution..................................................................................................16
2.2.2 The Conservation Strategy of Ethiopia (CSE).....................................................16
2.2.3 The Environmental Policy of Ethiopia.................................................................17
2.2.7. Sectoral Policies and Strategies..........................................................................18
2.2.8. Ethiopian Water Resources Management Policy................................................19
2.2.9. Legislative Instruments........................................................................................20
2.2.10. International Conventions and Protocols.........................................................25
2.3 Institutional Framework..........................................................................................26
2.3.1. National...............................................................................................................26
2.3.2 Regional................................................................................................................26
2.3.3 Gelansub-city Gelanworeda district....................................................................27
Chapter 3..........................................................................................................................28
3. Project Descriptions.....................................................................................................28
3.1 Background to the Company and/or the Project Owner.........................................28
3.1.1 Project Goal.........................................................................................................28
3.1.2 Location................................................................................................................28
3.2. Project Objectives and Justification.......................................................................28
3.2.1. Project Objectives...........................................................................................28
1
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
2
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
3
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
4
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
ABBREVIATIONS
ADLI Agricultural Development led-Industrialization’
ASL Above Sea level
CSE Conservation Strategy of Ethiopia
EA Environmental Assessment
EIA Environmental Impact Assessment
EISR Environmental Impact Study Report
EMB Environmental Management Branch
EMP Environmental Management Plan
CEFCC Commission of Environment, Forest and Climate Change
EPC Environmental Protection Council
EPE Environmental Policy of Ethiopia
ETB Ethiopian Birr, the National Currency
FDRE Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia
5
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
Declaration
Environmental and Social Impact assessment Report for Concrete Pole production Project Location:
Gelansub-city Sida Awash woreda district
Declaration of the Proponent Concrete Pole confirms that the content of this report are a true
representation of the Environmental and Social Impact assessment Report of the Concrete Pole project.
Name: ______________________________
Signature: __________________________
Declaration of the Consultant Bright star management and environmental consultancy plc. the
registered firm of experts by the Environmental, Forest and Climate Change Commission of Ethiopia,
confirm that the contents of this report are a true representation of the Environmental and Social Impact
assessment Report of the Concrete Pole project.
Name: ____________________________
Signature: __________________________
6
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
Executive Summary
This Environmental and social Impact Assessment study of proposed Concrete Pole products manufacturing plant
located at Oromia regional state, Sheger City administration, Gelan sub-city Sida Awash woreda promoted by
Dereje Abera has been conducted by Bright star management and environmental consultancy plc.
The project will require initial investment capital of 5.00million ETB on plot area of 1.2951 hectare in
Gelan sub-city Sida Awash woreda district Sub City industrial zone, and it is supposed to create job
opportunities 72 Permanent (Skilled 42& Unskilled 30). This report presents the results of an
environmental and social impact assessment of Concrete Pole products manufacturing plant to be
envisaged on the land obtained through lease basis by micro enterprise transformation. The site is
considered to be a suitable location for this project as it is within an acceptable operational distance from
Addis Ababa city centers and has access to the main road and vehicles.
The company will apply an environmentally-sound technology to manufacture a Concrete Pole products
manufacturing electric material and other purposes from qualified billets raw materials local and
imported from abroad.
The purpose of the study is to generate sufficient information on significant impacts that enable the
preparation of an environmental and social impact assessment and mitigation measures which will be used
to determine things under what conditions a project should proceed.
The Methodologies employed in identifying, predicting and analyzing the impacts for this project is simple
cause-effect matrices. To achieve these objectives the assessment collected baseline data firstly through
desktop studies on a: national level; regional, and then finally physical inspection of the site and
surrounding areas. These were to identify and analyze impacts in order to fully prioritize them and develop
efficient and appropriate mitigation measures.
As per the environmental policy and regulatory of Ethiopia, undertaking environmental and social impact
assessment (ESIA) is a prerequisite for granting a license to operate for major development projects.
Accordingly, this environmental and social management plan (ESMP) has been undertaken in order to
identify adverse and positive effects on the natural, social, including on the cultural, environment and put
in place an environmental management system to minimize the adverse effects likely to result during the
implementation and operation of the factory. The potential anticipated adverse impacts of the project
7
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
during its implementation are dust and air emissions, solid and liquid wastes, and occupational health and
safety among others that can affect the environment and human health.
On the other hand, the envisaged company has significant economic benefits to the country and the local
people as well. Some of these are employment opportunities, provision of market for supply of concrete
pole based Electric Power products for electric material and other purposes, increased economic
activities and government revenue, stimulation to urban development etc.
The negative environmental impacts of the project are also significant unless the proposed mitigation
measures are not taken at the project implementation phase. An environmental management plan and
mitigation measures has been prepared to control the adverse negative impacts associated with the
operation of the factory’s activities for the existing project. It is considered that through good
environmental management during construction and operation phases, the management of environmental
risks and health and safety management, the potential adverse impacts can be mitigated to levels that are
not significant. Finally, the proponent has proposed easily achievable impact monitoring and evaluation
actions with environmental audit plan.
Special consideration should be given to enhancement of positive effects of the project. To address the
management of the identified environmental issues associated with the project as well the team allocated a
budget of ETB 515,000.00 to implement Environmental management and monitoring plan, in consent with
the project proponent.
It can be surmised that the implementation of the project have net positive impacts to the environment of
the immediate and surrounding areas. As a result, the company’s activities can be classified as an
environmental improvement program. The environmental and social impact assessment (ESIA) of the
company has been prepared in accordance with the environmental impact assessment proclamation of the
government of Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia, proclamation number 299/2002 and other legally
binding documents as described in this report.
Generally, the environmental and social impact assessment study report contains findings carried out as
integral part of the safeguards instrument for facilitating the consideration of environmental issues and
submitted to the Gelan sub-city environmental protection Authority for legal approval based on
environmental and social impact assessment guidelines
8
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
1. Introduction
This Environmental and social Impact Assessment study of proposed Concrete Pole manufacturing plant
has increasingly focused on the potential risks to the health of the society and the environment rising from
establishment of new projects. Looking after the environment is essential if we are to sustain living
conditions today and preserve for generations to come. Managing environmental issues has also become a
critical success factor for business. Environmental awareness drives innovations and resource savings,
leading to efficient production and reduced costs. It is the fact that, the level of impact on the society and
the environment, however, varies from project to project. In this regard the paper and paper products
manufacturing factory project have an environmental and health impact if the proposed mitigation
measures are not properly implemented.
The purpose of this report is, to carry out environmental and social impact assessment (ESIA) on this
project particularly concerning environmental management and monitoring plans. As the initial
environmental examination indicates there is a sufficient ground for the requirement of detailed
environmental and social impact assessment for this project. Environmental and social management plan is
necessary to indicate what measure should be taken at the implementation of the project, particularly in
relation to pollution control and human health and safety strategies.
This environmental and social impact assessment (ESIA) is a live document and should always reflect the
varying needs and environmental baseline conditions. Accordingly, the worst-case scenario was
approached in order to ensure the maximum potential impacts are predicted and understood and their
relative mitigation measures are set. Therefore, the promoter undertook this environmental and social
9
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
impact assessment study that enables to identify impacts and adapt alternative optimization/mitigation
measures to effects raised at the project operation stages.
The promoter of the project is sole proprietor business registered in the name of the promoter that is a well-
experienced business person and performance wise. They have been successful in smoothly undertaking
their existing business activities transactions and generated encouraging return over the preceding years.
The promoters’ rich experience and returns of their business engagements serves as spring board for the
project under consideration they are working on.
This report concerns ESIA of promoter which is working in Gelan sub-city Sida Awash wereda
administration on a total area of 1.2951 hectare obtained by lease basis in the industrial zone.
The promoter is an Ethiopian business man of aluminum based Concrete Pole products manufacturing
factory. Its products are confirming to the National and International standards meeting the stringent
demand of the discerning customers has been synonymous with quality.
Accordingly, the worst-case scenario was approached in order to ensure the maximum potential impacts are
predicted and understood and their relative mitigation measures are set. The environmental and social
impact assessment (ESIA) report was mainly prepared to assess the impacts and provide the mitigation
measures for the project activities. This environmental and social impact assessment (ESIA) report is
conducted under the requisites of the environmental impact assessment proclamation (176/2012) and its
Guideline of Oromia Regional state.
10
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
11
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
The factory site location, technologies to be employed, product mix, potential environmental impacts,
capital and operating costs, suitability under local conditions, and institutional, training, and monitoring
requirements were considered in the evaluation of alternatives. The factory impacts were identified using
interviewing Authorities experts and local people, literature review, field visit and pertinent secondary data
and documents. Impacts were first distinguished as either positive or negative. The factory negative
impacts were analyzed to denote their significance based on their characteristics and this was also impacts
per project phase. Significance was judged based on their capacity to change baseline conditions beyond
acceptable standards or legislative provisions.
4 Project justification
The envisaged project in Gelan sub-city Sida Awsh woreda distric is aimed to produce Concrete Pole
products manufacturing materials. Total company premises area is 1,2951 hectrare of land. This electric
material based Concrete Pole products manufacturing will install on 1,2951 hech. Within the compound of
electric material based Concrete Pole products manufacturing there will be a Packing Materials and
recycling activity. The project created job opportunity for over 74 permanent and temporary workers.
12
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
Section 7: Potential Environmental and Social Impacts & Proposed Mitigation Measures
The scoping concerns identifying the project location and its area coverage, sensitive environmental
components from field observation and prescreening reviews as well as the final report. The study includes
detailed characterization of existing status of environment in an area around project for various identified
environmental components air, noise, and water, land, biological and socio-economic.
are considered, together with specific sectorial laws on environment, land use and health & safety. The
policies, regulations and administrative framework within which the project is to be implemented with
respect to environmental management and protection are reviewed in this section. The review includes the
sector-specific Environmental and Policies and Regulations of, National policies regarding socio-economic
issues and the Administrative framework of various agencies with the implementation of the proposed
project
15
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
The use of non-renewable resources shall be minimized and where possible their availability extended
(e.g. through recycling) among the others
16
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
priority areas of the policy are in the field of Information, Education and Communication (IEC) of
health to create awareness and behavioral change of the society towards health issues, emphasis on
the control of communicable diseases, epidemic, and on diseases that are related to malnutrition and
poor living condition, promotion of occupational health and safety, development of environmental
health, rehabilitation of health infrastructures, carrying out applied health research provision of
essential medicines, expansion of frontline and middle level health professionals.
17
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
country’s social and economic development activities are carried out in manner that will protect the
welfare of human beings as well as sustainability of the project, to develop and utilize the resource
bases on which they depend for survival. Roles and responsibilities of the EPA
The EPA is the Competent Agency at the Federal level in Ethiopia. It is, therefore, the
responsibility of this authority in the EIA process to:
Ensure that the proponent complies with requirements of the EIA process;
Maintain co-operation and consultation between the different Sectorial agencies throughout the
EIA process;
Maintain a close relationship with the proponent and to guidelines on the process; and Evaluate
and take decisions on the documents that arise from the EIA process. At the regional
level, the Federal EPA has devolved responsibility to the Regional equivalent of EPA. The regional
authorities should ideally establish an EPA-type institution to deal with environmental issues at
the regional level.
It states that the proponent shall undertake an environmental impact assessment, identify the likely
adverse impacts of his project, incorporated the means of their prevention or containment, and
submit to the Authority or the relevant Zonal environmental agency the environmental impact study
report together with the documents determined as necessary by the Authority or the relevant
regional environmental agency. This Proclamation has addressed the minimum contents to be
18
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
Accordingly, this EIA study report is prepared to harmonizing and integrating environmental,
economic, cultural and social considerations in the implementation of the project under the
custodianship of the EIA Proclamation No.181/2011. Article 12 of the Proclamation addresses the
EIA report review procedures. This article states three decisions to be given after the review process.
The first is approving the project without conditions and issue authorization. The second is to
approve the project with conditions and issue authorization. The last decision is to refuse the
implementation of the project. Article 21 of the Proclamation requires that the environmental impact
statement be make available to the public and solicit comments on it. Monitoring of the
implementation of an authorized project in terms of commitments made in the report and conditions
of authorization is a requirement as stipulated in Article 15 of the proclamation.
The Proclamation advocates a “polluter pays” principle and sets out requirements for managing
hazardous waste including, a permitting system for generating, keeping, storing, transportation,
treatment or disposal of hazardous wastes. Operators dealing with hazardous waste have to prevent
any damage to the environment and human health. Chemicals need to be registered, packed and
labeled according to the relevant standards. In addition, the Proclamation states the various types of
environmental standards. However, no standard values were established in the law.
The law requires urban administrations to collect, transport, recycle, treat and disposal of municipal
waste safely.
The EPA together with the Regional Environmental Agencies (REAs) is required to monitor and
evaluate the adequacy of municipal waste management systems and ensure the effectiveness of
19
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
implementation. All premises to which the public has access have to be provided with adequate and
suitable toilets and containers and other facilities for the disposal of waste.
In general, to ensure workers safety and job security the need to respect the proclamation that has
been clearly stated in the document is vital and mandatory. The Occupational Health and Safety
Guideline were developed as a follow-up to the labor Proclamation and provide guidance on
occupational health and safety requirements.
21
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
According to; Article 9(4) of the constitution of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia provides
that once an international agreement is ratified through the accepted or established procedure, it
automatically becomes an integral part of the law of the land. Consequentially, the convention and
the Protocol are the laws of this land. Therefore; the following international conventions and
protocols are relevant to the propose garment manufacturing project.
Ethiopia ratified this convention through proclamation No. 97/1994 on May 2/1994. This convention
takes into account the fact that climate change has trans-boundary impacts. The basic objective of
this convention is to provide for agreed limits on the release of greenhouse gases into the
23
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
atmosphere so as to prevent the occurrence of climate change. It also aims to prepare countries to
minimize the impact of climate change, should it occur.
The basic objective of the convention is to combat the negative impact on the environment and
human beings resulting from ozone depleting substances by reducing the amounts released and
eventually banning their commercial use through internationally agreed measures. The Montreal
protocol entered into force in 1989 to facilitate the implementation of this convention.
Ethiopia ratified and become party to the Vienna convention and the Montreal protocol in January
1996. The National Meteorological services agency has been mandated for the coordination and
supervision of implementation of this convention.
The objective of the convention is to combat desertification and mitigate the effects of droughts in
countries experiencing serious drought and or desertification, particularly in Africa. Ethiopia has
ratified the convention through its proclamation no. 80/1997.
The objective of the Basel convention is to control and regulate the Trans boundary movement of
hazardous wastes. The Bamako convention of 1991 plays a similar role at the level of the African
continent. Ethiopia ratified the Basel convention through its proclamation No. 357/2002. Its
amendment was ratified through proclamation No. 356/2002. The country has also ratified the
Bamako convention through proclamation No. 355/2002.
In the year 2002, Ethiopia fully accepted and ratified the Stockholm convention on persistent organic
pollutants by proclamation No. 279/2002 designed to ban the use of persistent organic pollutants.
The Commission of Environment and Forestry has the full mandate to implement the convention at
the national level.
24
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
The objectives of the convention are to control international trade in endangered species and to
ensure that international trade in non-endangered species is carried out in a manner which ensures
stable markets and economic benefits for the exporting countries as well as to control and regulate
illegal trade in such non endangered species, fossils and/ or their derivatives. Ethiopia ratified the
convention through proclamation No.l4/1970. The mandate to implement the convention at federal
level is the responsibility of the Ethiopian wildlife protection and development organization
25
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
Cement
Cement is adhesive substances of all kinds or the binding materials for aggregate used in
building and civil engineering construction. Cements of this kind are finely ground powders
that, when mixed with water, set to a hard mass (concrete). Setting and hardening result
from hydration, which is a chemical combination of the cement compounds with water that
yields submicroscopic crystals or a gel-like material with a high surface area. Because of,their
hydrating properties, constructional cements, which will even set and harden under water, are
often called hydraulic cements. Cement clinker is made by heating in a rotary kiln at high
temperature. The products of the chemical reaction aggregate together as molten minerals at the
9 sintering temperature. The sintering temperature for modern cements is about 1450 °C.
Aluminum oxide and iron oxide are present as a flux and contribute little to the cement
strength. However, there are two mostly used for the construction of building materials. The
26
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
cement used in the manufacture of pre-stressed concrete poles shall be Ordinary Portland Cement
(OPC) conforming to the characteristics of fast condensation time and high operational strength.
Cement shall be stored at site in well covered sheds in such a manner as to prevent deterioration
due to moisture or due to intrusion of foreign matters.
Reinforcing steel bars are used for reinforcement of concrete structures, manufacture of
anchor bolts, etc. The amount of carbon has a great effect on the performance of steel. If
amount of carbon is higher, the strength of steel will be higher, the rigidity is higher and
the hardiness is lower. If the carbon content is low, the strength of steel will also be low,
the rigidity will be low, but the toughness and plasticity will be better. At present, the
steel of concrete cement products business can be divided according to the chemical
component into high-carbon steel C>0.6%.
The low carbon steel and high carbon steel mainly is used in the structure of reinforced
concrete and prestressed concrete. Recent years the carbon content of parent metal of
prestressed concrete steel wire used widely in cement products is high, contains C0.7%~
0.8%. As the number of annular and longitudinal bar of pole has been stipulated by national
standard regarding to the small diameter, low loading pole, when designing consumption
of steel and choosing the materials varieties, the economical factor can be only considered. The
practical experience has proved that the low carbon cold draw steel wire for low voltage, low
loading capacity pole is most safe and economic. Conversely, the pole with higher bearing
capacity used in middle and high voltage transmission and transformation using high
carbon steel wire is very safe and economic. Reinforced Concrete is a common building
material for construction facilities and structures. While concrete has high compressive
strength, it has limited tensile strength. To overcome these tensile limitations, reinforcing bars
are used in the tension side of concrete 10 structures due to this the application of reinforcing
steel has a great effect on the improving of various performance indexes of concrete pole.
27
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
Steel wire is important material for concrete pole manufacturing. It is made of carbon steel
which is used for weaving, and baling in general. It used for home use and the construction.
Steel wire is obtained by means of thermal annealing; endowing it with the properties it
needs for its main use - setting. The physical property of annealed metals is relatively soft
and can be cut and shaped more easily. They bend easily when pressure is applied. As a rule,
they are heated and allowed to cool slowly. In addition to steel wire round bar is also
another important raw material which is used to make cage skeleton of the concrete pole.
Electrode/steal wire
In concrete pole manufacturing we can use steel wire or electrodes alternatively. The
welding electrodes are metal wires with baked on chemical coatings. It is used for arc
welding purpose. The coating protects the metal from damage, stabilizes the arc, and
improves the weld. The diameter of the wire, less the coating, determines the size of the
welding rod.
Aggregate
28
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
Fine aggregates are the aggregates whose size is less than 4.75 mm sand is generally
composed of rounded particles, and may or may not contain clay or other impurities. It is
obtained from the 11 banks and beds of rivers. River sand is a particle size that is too large
to have any cationic exchange capacity.
Admixtures
It is a chemical ingredient in concrete other than Portland cement, water, aggregate that
are added to the mix immediately before and during mixing. The main reasons of using
admixture are to reduce the cost of concrete construction; to modify the properties of
hardened concrete; to ensure the quality of concrete during mixing, transporting, placing,
and curing and to overcome certain emergencies during concrete operations. Moreover,
admixtures should not contain calcium chloride or other chlorides and salts which are
likely to promote corrosion of prestressing steel.
Water
Water is the other important material for concrete pole manufacturing. The concrete
solidifies and hardens to rock-hard strength through a chemical process called hydration.
The water reacts with the cement, which bonds the other components together, creating a
robust stone-like material. The water used for pole production should be free from
chlorides, sulphates, other salts and organic matter. Potable water will be generally suitable.
The materials and inputs required for the production of concrete pole can be made available
by the local markets are cement, aggregate, sand/fine aggregate and steel bar (Ethiopian
Quality). Besides, the Reinforcement bar, electrode, and admixture importing from abroad
as long as there is no problem of securing foreign exchange in sufficient amount. Hence, the
materials and inputs to be used for the same is sourced from domestic and foreign
country
Utilities
(b) Water
Another utility required by the project is water. Water is another crucial utility required in the
production process of concrete pole. It is assumed that the total water cost required by the project will
be Birr 300,000 annually.
30
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
1. TECHNOLOGY
1.1. Production process of concrete pole
Poles can be produced from steel, wood, concrete and other materials. The study explicates the state of
art of technology of using a high strength concrete mix with a low water content that is spun in a high
speed rotating mould to form a smooth, dense, blemish free concrete pole. Spun concrete pole
manufacturing process comprises of the following sections:
Pre-production
production
Quality assurance
Manufacturing of both pre-stressed and reinforced concrete poles begins with receiving product
specifications from customers and preparing suitable concrete pole sample design containing the
aggregate mix design type, type of pole, height, strength, diameter and others for the customers to
choose. After the customers chose the desired pole design specifications, samples are produced for
display. Specific type of Reinforcement bar is cut to make the desired cage assembly. Reinforcement
bars are pre-stressed with pre tensioned jacks (only for pre-stressed concrete poles). Then concrete mix
will be poured. Mould is assembled in order to spun the mould containing the concrete mix together
with the reinforced or pre-stressed bars.
After one or one and half hour later, the spun concrete is left to preset for further stress transfer. Then
the poles can be cured with the suitable method before or after de-molding. Basic pole information are
then capped and marked on the poles. Finished poles are then checked of their quality and to be stored
on the yard assisted by the over head cranes and will be ready for transportation and dispatching
31
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
Verification of the strength of the fixed pole is carried out at a distance of 0.1 H.from the
base for various types of poles with height, diameter, weight and so on. The fixed end must
have sufficient continuity in the sense that under maximum stress it must not present
appreciable sags. In addition, fixing the end must be done in such a way that it does not
cause buckling in the fixed pole portion. The test consists of not only a pulling force of the
value tension on the top but also for taller poles ,a second pulling force of another tension
applied from the second height from the top and to the force of the wind distributed along
the pole.
32
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
The production process of the plant requires manual and machine operations which includes the
following activities. The total cost of machinery and equipment is Birr 33 million. The list of the
necessary machinery and equipment are listed in Table 6.1.
Aggregate
Sr.No Major Machinery
machinery cost
1) Reinforcement bar cutting machine
2) Button heading machine
3) Pre-tensioning jack
4) Concrete mixing machine
5) Concrete pump
6) Auxiliary machinery and equipments
7) Over head hoist cranes
39,349,922.00
8) Gantry
9) Boiler
10) Compressor
11) Generator
12) Concrete pole mould
13) Centrifugal spinning machine
33
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
In this project estimation the machinery is required. It include machineries like Reinforcement bar cutting machine,
Button heading machine, Pre-tensioning jack, Concrete mixing machine, Concrete pump, Auxiliary machinery and
equipments, Over head hoist cranes, Gantry, boiler, Compressor, Concrete pole mould, Centrifugal spinning and etc
The project is assumed to operate one shift of 8 hours each day efficiently.
It is presumed that in the 1st year, the capacity utilization will be 60% followed by 70% in the
next year and 80% in the subsequent years.
Manufacturing process line will run in 80% capacity utilization rate after two year of project
implementation. Considering the manufacturing process involved i.e. the time required for
mastering the skill of assembling and maintenance work, the plant will operate at 60% of its
installed capacity during the first year of operation. Then, it is planned to increase to 70%, 80%
during the second year and fourth year and then after respectively. The detail production
program is shown in Table 5.2 and Table 5.3
34
500 Dan ,11m 3,000.00
800 Dan ,11m 2,500.00
300 Dan ,12m 2,000.00
Total 24500
As clearly indicated above, the project has the capacity to produce up to 24,500 concrete
poles that has different diameter and length sizes in year
A utility pole is a column or post typically made out of wood used to support overhead power
lines and various other public utilities, such as electrical cable, fiber optic cable, and related
equipment such as transformers and street lights. It can be referred to as a transmission pole,
telephone pole, telecommunication pole, power pole, hydro pole, telegraph pole, or telegraph
post, depending on it purpose. The PLC will produce 14,700 different size pose in the first
year, 17,150 in the second year and 19,600 in the third year of project operational years
4.7. Utilities
A number of utilities would be put in place in order to ensure smooth functioning of the project. The
project will become a fully automated production facility and electricity is the main power to be used
at all of its construction and operational phases. In average the annual electric consumption of the
factory will be estimated to be 9640 MW. The Company will receive fresh water from the municipality
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
of the town water office or it will have their own borehole. The annual water consumption of the
proposed project will be estimated to be 1.2951 hectare
The two important utilities required are electric power and water
Project Owner
2
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
5.1.3. Climate
The climate of the town is characterized by two distinct seasonal weather patterns. The main
wet season, locally known as Sumer, extends from June to September, contributing about 70% of
the total annual rainfall. A minor rainy season, locally known as winter, contributes moisture to
the region from mid-February to mid-April. The remaining months are dry season. The average
elevation in Gelan sub-city Sida awsh woreda district sub city lies 1900m above sea level, and
hence has a fairly favorable climate and moderate weather conditions. The highest temperature
of the town is 29.3 co while the lowest is 7.1co which is the temperature of Semi temperate. The
highest mean annual rainfall is 95mm and the lowest mean annual rain fall is 48mm.
3
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
5.1.5. Hydrology
The main water source of the project is ground water through boreholes. As a result, there won’t
be a water problem in the area. The water table is close and the recharging rate is quite high.
According to the information obtained from the town administrator the main water supply for
the project is water pipeline prepared for the investment site.
4
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
5.3.2. Education
The participation rate of the Gelansub-city Sida awash woreda district Sub City population’s in
different educational levels is greater than the regional level. However, rapid population growth,
which results in increasing the size of the school age population, continuous challenging the
government’s effort of meeting one of the sustainable development goal. According to the town
administration educational office, the town has 13 Kindergarten, 16 primary schools, and 3
secondary schools. As per the observation and consultation with the local Government it is
recognized that there are no schools, near by the project site. So, it obvious that the schools‟
children and school facilities are not being impacted by the factory
6.1Positive Impacts
The envisaged project promotes the socio-economic goals and objectives stated in the strategic
plan of the Oromia National Regional State. At the same time, therefore, it helps diversify the
economic activity of the region. The other major benefits are listed as follows:
5
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
6.2Negative impacts
A project with the magnitude of the proposed manufacturing of aluminum based Concrete
Electric Pole products manufacturing is expected to have environmental impacts on certain
aspects of biophysical and socio-economic environment of the project area both during
preconstruction, construction, operation and decommissioning stages. The impacts of the
project were assessed and are generally grouped into those affecting soil, water resources, air
quality, flora and fauna, community and their economic activities, vegetation and forests, land
acquisition and landscape, noise and human health impacts of packaging materials/carton and
printing manufacturing project are indicated below.
6
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
stability; soil contamination. During the project implementation, the fertile soil layer damage and
disorganization of the stability is mainly expected during the preparatory and construction
works, which will be related to the vehicle movement, land works and arrangement of
permanent and temporary infrastructure on the dam placement territories.
8
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
Speed Diesel) will take place. The anticipated key air emissions from the project would be
particulate matter, oxides of nitrogen (NO2), (SO2) and Carbon monoxide (CO). Emission of PM10,
PM2.5, NO2, SO2 from D.G set and Vehicular traffic and also dust emission from vehicular
movement may pollute the ambient air quality which in turn cause breathing problem to the
patients and student and employees.
10
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
electricity sparingly since high consumption of electricity negatively impacts on these natural
resources and their sustainability.
On the other hand, occupational health hazards can vary from site to site according to the
technologies and adopted methods. However, the project activities could prove harmful to
human health with the lack of proper measures.
This section describes the environmental mitigation measures during construction, operation
and demolition phase of the proposed project. Mitigation is the implementation of measures
designed to reduce the undesirable effects of a proposed project on the environment. The
companies and also as an individual’s all have an important role to play in protecting the
environment, which is very sensitive to change and once damaged can take a long time to
recover.
12
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
community and soil removed from the construction site will be distributed over the project land.
The landscaping plan should seek to avoid the use of non-native and potentially invasive species.
13
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
Excavation can be avoided during rainy season and check dams shall be provided to prevent
construction runoff from the site to the surrounding water bodies.
Transport vehicles and construction machineries will be properly maintained to reduce air
emissions and machinery’s will be periodically checked for pollutant emissions against
stipulated norms.
14
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
the construction worker. Instruction of personnel on health and safety issues during acceptance
on the job and later, several times a year; corresponding warning, prohibiting and directing sign-
boards must be arranged at the construction areas for personnel and local population, for health
and safety purpose; and standard medical kits must be delivered to construction sites at
sections, potentially dangerous for health and safety. Maximal implementation of safety rules
during execution of transport operations; and regular on-site risk assessment should be
conducted in order to determine risk factors for population and to develop corresponding risk
management plan. Personnel medical insurance must also be provided.
Using clean fuel and proper maintenance of the vehicles will also minimize the NO2, SO2 from the
exhaust of the vehicles. Location of DG sets and other emission generating equipment should be
decided keeping in view the predominant wind direction so that emissions do not effect nearby
residential areas. Using low Sulphur diesel will minimize the emissions from D.G set. Informatory
sign shall be provided to encourage vehicle owners to maintain their vehicle and follow the
emission standards fixed by Government Authorities. Development of adequate green belt at and
around the project site will help in reducing the impacts on the flora and fauna as the plant
15
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
species will act as air emissions sink. Thus, the impact on the terrestrial ecology of the area
would be minimized during the operational phase of the project
The domestic wastewater resulting from the administrative building and workers facilities
should be collected in a separate septic tank. Once the collection tank reaches its full capacity, it
should be transferred to a planned wastewater treatment stations (if available) or to a
wastewater disposal site approved by the EPA.
Water used in vehicle and plant servicing areas, vehicle wash bays and lubrication bays such as
oil and fuel products should be collected and connected to the drainage system via an oil/grease
trap. Washing water generated from the action of vehicles washing should be conveyed to a local
network or to a septic tank or can be biologically treated in a constructed wetland or other
filtration system.
The industrial wastewater treatment plant purifies the wastewater generated from production
processes while consuming large quantities of energy and water for production processes during
Aluminum frame and profile manufacturing that burdens the environment. As the environmental
impact from industrial wastewater treatment is hard to evaluate using only one of these
parameters, several appropriate parameters shall be selected to meet the local conditions.
Hence, the promoter should construct ETP to treat industrial wastewater.
16
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
The recommended mitigation measures to be adopted at the main site include restricting
unattended public access by proper fencing; using adequate safety barrier and signs; Proper
labeling storage of chemicals, oils and fuel; Promote safety education through training about the
fundamentals of occupational health and safety procedures; Provide appropriate personal
protective equipment such as gloves, masks, ear plugs, gas detectors, brightly colored working
overalls equipped with light reflecting stripes, safety boots, safety helmets, etc.; provide fire
extinguishers at different locations of the operational site and develop and emergency response
plan in case of fire explosion; Provision of electrical grounding, spark detection and prevention;
and elimination of external ignition sources; and to prevent fire risks equip with fire
extinguishers of a quantity and type suitable for the expected fire risk, in an accessible location
close to the store and communicate to the main office or emergency system is recommended.
In order to conserve water, recycling and reusing waste waters, installing water-conserving
automatic taps and toilets should be used. Moreover, any water leaks through damaged pipes
and faulty taps will be fixed promptly by qualified staff. In addition, the proponent will be
sensitized to use water efficiently by reducing water delivery in taps, installation of low flow
devices or aerators on taps and Install water efficient plumbing. Press action taps and flush
valves shall be used to minimize water wastage Sensors on urinals, which ensure flushes, occur
only when required in public areas of the proposed project.
7.4. Training
Training shall be provided in the Factor’s policy and practices for both employee and other
external stakeholder grievance mechanisms, relevant to their exposure and responsibilities for
managers, all other employees, contractors and visitors, which shall include as a minimum:
• Expected behaviors and accepted practices when interacting with employees and
stakeholders in order to avoid a grievance in the first instance;
• Routes available for employees and other external stakeholders to lodge a grievance; and
• Roles and responsibilities for handling and resolving grievances
The factory training program helps to acquire better theoretical knowledge and practical skills
as trainee are aided by practical works in the manufacturing process. Hence, training is believed
to bring efficient implementation of the company manufacturing activities and also the skills of
trainee of the area as it is least developed. To this effect, to realize its objectives, the factory has
planned to provide both on job and off job training. It believes that it is through training and
18
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
The most reliable way to ensure that the plan will be integrated into the overall project planning
and implementation is to include the plan as an integral component of the project. This will
ensure that it receives funding and supervision along with other investment components. For
optimal integration of EMP into the project, there should be link for Funding; Management,
Training and Monitoring.
The purpose of the first link is to ensure that proposed actions are adequately financed. The
second link helps in embedding training, technical assistance, staffing and other institutional
strengthening items in the mitigation measures to implement the overall management plan. The
third provides a critical path for implementation and enables sponsors and the funding agency to
evaluate the success of mitigation measures, as part of project supervision and as a means to
improve future projects. For every use discussed in the above sections, the implementing agency
as well as staffing, equipment, phasing and budgeting have been presented as far as possible. All
required funds will be channeled through the project authority. All developmental activities will
bring some impacts associated with its origin, which can be broadly classified as reversible,
irreversible, long and short-term impacts. In this section an endeavor has been made to identify
various Environmental Impacts associated with the proposed project both during construction
and operational phase.
Based on the possible worst-case emissions and waste generation from the proposed project and
also taking into consideration the baseline Environmental status at the proposed project site, the
19
Environmental Impact Assessment Report
environmental factors that may likely be affected (Impacts) are assessed. Both instrumental
(positive) and detrimental (negative) impacts are accounted for this purpose. The prediction of
impacts helps in the preparing a sound Environmental Management Plan which has to be
executed during operational and construction phase to minimize the adverse impacts on the
environmental quality.
The potential impacts on the environment from the proposed project are identified based on the
nature of the various activities associated not only with the project implementation and
operation, but also on the current status of the environmental quality at the project site. The
tables below comprise the impacts predicted, proposed mitigation measures, responsible body
for the mitigation measures and the estimated cost of mitigation measures (where applicable) as
a result of project location, design, construction and operation.
20
Table 5: Environmental Management Plan at Construction Phase
Project Project Adverse Proposed Mitigation Measures Institutional Cost Estimates
Stage (Birr)
Activity Impacts Responsibilities
21
Project Project Adverse Proposed Mitigation Measures Institutional Cost Estimates
Stage (Birr)
Activity Impacts Responsibilities
Site clearing, Sprinkle with Water around dust generation areas.
excavation activities, kept the road clear of dusty materials;
disturbance of land Air Pollution properly maintain transport vehicles and
Construction
22
Project Project Adverse Proposed Mitigation Measures Institutional Cost Estimates
Stage (Birr)
Activity Impacts Responsibilities
Construction related activities will be confined
only to project site area,
Site clearing, Provide proper drinking water, sanitation and first
excavation activities, aid
Instruction of personnel on health and safety
disturbance of land
Health and issues
surface & construction
Safety Arrange warning, prohibiting and directing sign-
of the factory
Construction
23
Project Project Adverse Proposed Mitigation Measures Institutional Cost
Stage Estimates
Activity Impacts Responsibilities (Birr)
24
Project Project Adverse Proposed Mitigation Measures Institutional Cost
Stage Estimates
Activity Impacts Responsibilities (Birr)
25
Project Project Adverse Proposed Mitigation Measures Institutional Cost
Stage Estimates
Activity Impacts Responsibilities (Birr)
The impact assessment should consider each phase of the development, including:
Construction: this includes all potential changes that occur on site from the initial point of access;
Operation: this encompasses all phases of the site development once operational; and
Decommissioning: this includes any permanent changes that are made to the site following cessation of the industrial
activity.
26
8.2Environmental Monitoring Plan
An environmental monitoring plan provides feedback about the difference between actual environmental
scenario and the impacts of the project on the environment and helps to judge the adequacy of the
mitigation measures in protecting the environment. The purpose of environmental monitoring is to
evaluate the effectiveness of implementation of Environmental Management Plan (EMP) by periodically
monitoring the important environmental parameters within the impact area, so that any adverse effects are
detected and timely action can be taken.
The environmental monitoring plan for the proposed project has been developed in view of the
institutional, scientific and fiscal issues pertaining to the project. For each component, suitable
measurable environmental indicators which are appropriate to the impact mechanism and scale of
disturbance and have a low natural variability, broad applicability and an existing data series have been
defined. Environmental monitoring is carried throughout project operation to detect changes in the key
environmental quality parameters, which can be attributed to the project.
For each of the environmental components, the monitoring plan specifies the parameters to be monitored;
location of monitoring sites; frequency and duration of monitoring. The monitoring plan also specifies the
applicable standards, implementation and supervising responsibilities. Various physical, biological and
social components identified as of particular significance in affecting the environment at critical locations
in various stages of the project have been suggested as Performance Indicators (PIs) listed below shall be
the focus for monitoring air quality with respect to PM10, PM2.5 and CO; water quality with respect to
COD, BOD and Coliform count; noise levels around sensitive locations; and replantation success /
survival rate.
As per the EIA guidelines of Oromia Region, environmental monitoring shall be required during
construction and operational phases. The schedule for monitoring ambient air quality, ambient noise
quality, ground water quality, and waste water quality both during the construction and operation phases
of the project is given in table.
27
Table 7: Environmental Monitoring Plan at construction & operational Phases
Project Object of Mitigation Measure Parameters Location Measurements Frequency Responsibil Cost
Monitori to be ity
Stage ng Monitored
28
Project Object of Mitigation Measure Parameters Location Measurements Frequency Responsibil Cost
Monitori to be ity
Stage ng Monitored
Soil
personnel on storage Lab control
pollution
environmental & safety areas
pH
issues
29
Project Object of Mitigation Measure Parameters Location Measurements Frequency Responsibil Cost
Monitori to be ity
Stage ng Monitored
30
Project Object of Mitigation Measure Parameters Location Measurements Frequency Responsibil Cost
Monitori to be ity
Stage ng Monitored
Total 155,000.00
The impact assessment should consider each phase of the development, including:
Construction: this includes all potential changes that occur on site from the initial point of access;
Operation: this encompasses all phases of the site development once operational; and
Decommissioning: this includes any permanent changes that are made to the site following cessation of the industrial
activity.
31
9. Environmental auditing plan and Program
The proponent will propose an independent and objective examination based on checklist
monitoring and auditing system to whether practices complies with the expected standards
set at environmental mitigation output or not. Broadly, kind of testing and verification of
the actual and predicted impacts will be done for the purpose of assessing the accuracy of
predictions and the effectiveness of impact management practices and procedures.
Therefore, to take correction, the proponent has planned to examine the accuracy and
efficiency of impact predictions and mitigation measure proposed in the EIA, i.e. testing
how accurate the environmental impact predictions and how much the mitigation is
effective as comparing them with actual monitored impacts once the project is underway.
Each environmental audit shall be geared towards achieving and examining compliance
with regulatory requirements; identifying current and potential environmental problems;
examining the line management systems, plant operation, monitoring practices and data,
procedures and plans; checking the prediction of the environmental evaluation assessment
and ensure that its recommendations are being implemented and recommending areas of
improvement in operations management.
The company’s internal environmental Audits will follow its quality environmental and
monitoring management plan based on developing checklists. The company will conduct
internal environmental audit once in a year.
10. Conclusion and Recommendation
This chapter presents the key findings and recommendations from the ESIA process based
on the specialist studies and on the environmental suitability of the project and whether
the project should receive environmental authorization.
10.1. Conclusion
The essence of ESIA process is aimed at ensuring informed decision-making and
environmental accountability, and to assist in achieving environmentally sound and
sustainable development. Therefore, negative impacts on the environment and on people’s
environmental rights should be anticipated and prevented, and where they cannot be
altogether prevented, they must be minimized and remedied in terms of “reasonable
measures”. “Reasonable measures” implies that “every person who causes, has caused or
may cause significant pollution or degradation of the environment must take reasonable
measures to prevent such pollution or degradation from occurring, continuing or recurring,
or, in so far as such harm to the environment is authorized by law or cannot reasonably be
avoided or stopped, to minimize and rectify such pollution or degradation of the
environment”.
It is acknowledged that any development will impact on the environment. The proposed
project will have impacts on the biophysical and the social environment. This ESIA
investigated and assessed these impacts as a result of project actions. A key positive impact
pertains to the regional and national economic benefits associated with increased export of
aluminum based Concrete Electric Pole products manufacturing to neighbor countries and
local procurement of goods and services along the supply chain as well as the generation of
foreign revenue from export. These benefits would be experienced at a national and
provincial level. The “no-go” or “do nothing” alternative for the project would have negative
implications for the economy through direct loss of foreign exchange generation and
indirect impacts on the supply chain.
The conclusions of this ESIA are the result of specialist assessments, based on issues
identified within the ESIA study. The evaluation of the impacts indicated that the identified
adverse impacts can be minimized with the implementation of the proposed mitigation
33
measures and appropriate environmental management system. The study, therefore,
forwarded technical and landscape mitigation measures that potentially help to reduce
and/or avoid the negative impacts and fosters the positive ones. Environmental
management plan have been presented along with the mitigation measures.
10.2. Recommendations
This ESIA has been conducted based on the best and latest available information during the
course of the study. The report has been prepared in full compliance with the requirements
of the environmental regulations and laws and has provided information on the nature and
extent of all possible environmental impacts arising from the construction and operation
phases of the proposed Aluminum frame and profile fabrication products manufacturing
plant project.
Overall, based on the findings of this ESIA, it is concluded that, with planned mitigation and
the implementation of best practices to avoid or minimize adverse environmental impacts,
the environmental impacts during all phases are not rated significant, except in the event of
certain worst-cases, for which some environmental impacts could be significant but are
highly unlikely to occur. This report has also clearly demonstrated general acceptability of
the residual impacts and thus the environmentally sensitive receptors in the vicinity of the
new project would be successfully protected.
Thus, it is recommended that the proposed Aluminum frame and profile fabrication
products manufacturing plantproject to be approved on the basis that the project
proponent will continuously adhere to the requirement of the environmental guidelines,
employing mitigation measures to ensure compliance with statutory requirements and
recommended criteria.
34
11.References
35