0% found this document useful (0 votes)
3 views86 pages

Commercial & Res.Devlpt.

Download as doc, pdf, or txt
Download as doc, pdf, or txt
Download as doc, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1/ 86

Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

TABLE OF CONTENTS

CHAPTER ONE.......................................................................................................................2
1.0 INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................2
1.1 Background to the Project....................................................................................2
1.2 The Project Brief....................................................................................................3
1.3 Legal and Administrative Framework................................................................3
1.4 Scope of the Report................................................................................................4
CHAPTER TWO.....................................................................................................................6
2.0 PROJECT JUSTIFICATION......................................................................................6
2.1 Introduction............................................................................................................6
2.2 Need for the Project...............................................................................................6
2.3 Project Alternatives...............................................................................................7
2.3.1 No Project Option.............................................................................................7
2.3.2 Delayed Project Option....................................................................................8
2.3.3 Alternative Site/ Location Option....................................................................8
CHAPTER THREE...............................................................................................................10
3.0 DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT ENVIRONMENT...................................................10
3.1 Site Location.........................................................................................................10
3.2 Site Coverage, Boundary and Adjoining Developments..................................13
3.4 The Site Topography...........................................................................................18
3.5 Existing Drainage System...................................................................................18
3.6 Climatic Condition...............................................................................................19
3.6.1 Pattern of Climate and Meteorology of the study area................................19
3.6.2 Temperature.....................................................................................................20
3.6.3 Rainfall..............................................................................................................21
3.6.4 Sunshine hours.................................................................................................22
3.6.5 Relative Humidity (RH)...................................................................................23
3.6.6 Wind Speed and wind direction......................................................................23
3.7 Geology.................................................................................................................24
3.8 Vegetation.............................................................................................................25
CHAPTER FOUR..................................................................................................................27
4.0 PROJECT CONCEPT...............................................................................................27
4.1 Design Parameters...............................................................................................27
4.2 Assets and Constraints to Planning....................................................................28
4.2.1 Location of the Project Site...........................................................................28

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page i


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

4.2.2 Contiguous Activities around the Project Site................................................29

4.2.3 Development Plan Strategies..........................................................................29


4.3 Population Projection..........................................................................................29
4.4 Required Project Infrastructure/Utilities..........................................................31
4.5 Proposed Land Uses in the Commercial and Residential Development Plan 35
CHAPTER FIVE....................................................................................................................41
5.0 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT......................................................41
5.1 Introduction..........................................................................................................41
5.2 Legal and Administrative Framework..............................................................41
5.2.1 Federal Government Interventions................................................................42
5.2.2 Lagos State Regulatory Interventions...........................................................44
5.2.3 World Bank’s Intervention.............................................................................46
5.3 Concept of Environmental Impact Assessment....................................................46
5.4 Objectives of Environmental Impact Assessment................................................48
5.5 Potential Impact Identification.............................................................................49
5.5.1 Impact on Air Quality and Noise..................................................................50
5.5.2 Impacts on Water Environment and Hydrology..........................................51
5.5.3 Impact on Soil and Land................................................................................52
5.5.4 Impacts on Biological Environment (Flora & Fauna)................................53
5.5.5 Impacts on Waste Generation.........................................................................54
5.5.6.1 Impacts on Transportation..........................................................................56
5.5.6.2 Impacts on Water and Electricity Consumption.........................................57
5.5.6.3 Infrastructure Developments.....................................................................58
5.5.6.4 Housing Provision.......................................................................................59
5.5.6.5 Impacts on Employment...........................................................................59
5.5.6.6 Visual Appearance/Aesthetics....................................................................60
5.5.6.7 Urban Developments................................................................................60
5.5.6.8 Revenue Generation..................................................................................60
5.5.6.9 Impacts on Health and Safety...................................................................62
5.5.6.10 Public Safety and Security of Life and Property.......................................63
5.5.6.11 Sewage treatment and disposal...................................................................63
5.6 Impacts Rating.........................................................................................................69
5.7 Impact Mitigation....................................................................................................72
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION...................................................................81

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page ii


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

1.0 INTRODUCTION

1.1 Background to the Project

1.2 The Project Brief

1.3 Legal and Administrative Framework

1.4 Scope of the Report

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.


Page 1
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

CHAPTER ONE
1.0 INTRODUCTION

1.1 Background to the Project


Housing is a place to dwell in; a social unit of residence for individuals and families. Universally,

it has been regarded as one of the essential human needs such that it is a pre-requisite for the

survival of the modern man, besides food and clothing. Housing as a unit of the urban

environment, has a profound influence on the health, efficiency, social behaviour and general

welfare of the human society. Therefore, the need to provide adequate housing in any society

cannot be under estimated.

The recurrent nature of housing need and the unending desire by man for housing tend to confirm

the widely held impression that there is hardly any society today that has been able to cope

satisfactorily with its housing requirements. Thus, if a society is self-sufficient at a time in

housing needs, development will over time render current abundance insufficient in the future.

This invariably confirms that the need for housing changes from time to time.

Many developed countries have overcome in a substantial way housing shortage in terms of

numbers and quality of dwellings, while nearly all developing countries are still facing shortages

in dwelling units and deficiencies in the quality of housing. In an attempt to solving these

problems, emphasis is usually placed on the available units which even various governments have

not been able to meet up with across time and space.

In Lagos State, the need to ensure easy accessibility to housing by the populace has largely

informed development of various housing programs and policies by the state government. These

among others include: direct construction approach; Public Private Partnerships (PPP) approach;

urban renewal and regeneration program; establishment of new towns; provision of site and

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.


Page 2
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

service scheme as well as private estate development programs; all of which relate to land uses as

well as land title; a right which accompanies ownership .

To this end, one of the legal framework that grants titles in Land to the people and communities

of Lagos state, is the State government’s Village Excision process. This process requires (among

other things) that a proposed Site Layout should be prepared by the village with considerations

and approval of the Lagos state Ministry of Physical Planning and Urban Development

(MPP&UD).

Therefore, this report has been prepared in partial fulfillment of getting Land excision by our

Client.

1.2 The Project Brief


Our client, Prince Walee Olatunde Balogun Agbaje, in support of the efforts of the Lagos state

government to continuously spur and sustain environmental quality by increasing housing supply

in Lagos State, through housing delivery projects and the development of public places which can

allow several public events occasion for the benefit of Lagos state residents, is partly proposing

316 family units Commercial and Residential Development on the site which has to be made in

partial fulfillment of meeting the village excision requirements in Lagos state. This spatial

development project is proposed to be sited along Association Avenue/ Abayomi Abass Street,

Ikotun, Alimosho Local Government Area of Lagos State.

In view of the provision of the Commercial development and Residential development (governing

conditions for development of event centres and residential uses in Lagos state),

CONTEMPORARY CONSULTANTS GROUP LIMITED ( herein after referred to as the

consultant) has therefore been commissioned to prepare a on the aforesaid parcel of land.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.


Page 3
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

1.3 Legal and Administrative Framework


The proposed Commercial and Residential Development for Prince Walee Olatunde Balogun

Agbaje has been carried out within the ambit of the laws, standards and provisions of commercial

and residential development.

In accordance to the Regulations, all considerations for road network, open spaces, population

requirements, infrastructural and social services inter alia, conform to the provisions of the

subsisting guidelines.

1.4 Scope of the Report


This report covers the following:

i. Assessment of the baseline environmental condition (physical, social and economic)

of the project area;

ii. Evaluation of the site potential and constraints to planning;

iii. Presentation of the design parameters and factors influencing the planning concept;

iv. Presentation of the detailed components in the proposed Commercial and

Residential Development ;

v. Analysis of the infrastructural requirements and provisions in the proposed

Commercial and Residential Development ; and

vi. Assessment of the anticipated environmental impacts of the proposed development.

These include the direct or indirect, cumulative, short term and long term effects.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.


Page 4
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

2.0 PROJECT JUSTIFICATION

2.1 Introduction
2.2 Need for the Project

2.3 Project Alternatives

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.


Page 5
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.


Page 6
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

CHAPTER TWO

2.0 PROJECT JUSTIFICATION

2.1 Introduction
Recognizing the fact that public sector efforts cannot effectively address an expanding housing

deficit all alone as well as the reality of an escalating cost of construction, while it is also a fact

that a certain percentage land area is needed to be devoted to commercial development in a town,

the state government has then resolved to establish a framework within which the private sector

can effectively address housing shortages and events places. This is articulated in the expansion

of private sector role in housing and event centres delivery system, infrastructure financing and

development in Lagos state.

This policy change has thus informed the project proponents (Prince Walee Olatunde Balogun

Agbaje) of the need to develop an exclusive commercial and residential development in an

aesthetically pleasing and enabling environment. It is no doubt that the proposed Commercial and

Residential Development, at completion will accommodate a significant portion of the increasing

population, and cater for part of the housing shortages and commemoration of ceremonies in

Lagos state.

2.2 Need for the Project


As a unit of environment, housing has a profound influence on the health, efficiency, social

behaviour and general welfare of the society and thus the need to provide adequate housing in a

sustainable environment cannot be over-emphasized. However, it is imperative to note that the

realization by the state government that it cannot alone provide adequate housing to the ever

growing population has informed the involvement of private sector in the housing delivery in the

state. To this end, several housing projects have been completed by Private developers.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.


Page 7
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

The location of the project is along Along Association Avenue/ Abayomi Abass Street, Ikotun,

Alimosho Local Government Area, of Lagos State, where it is hoped that it will serve to

complement the existing commercial uses, residential, public and other uses that is available in

the area, and will, to a large extent support government efforts towards meeting the shortage of

housing provision in the Lagos metropolis.

2.3 Project Alternatives


There are always several options to any project plan. This could include an outright

termination of the project plan, a delay in its implementation and/or an alteration to the

implementation plan.

This section seeks to identify and evaluate reasonable range of alternatives that could be

considered in order to avoid significant environmental impacts of the project. A range of

reasonable alternatives to the project, or to the location of the project that would feasibly attain

most of the basic objectives of the project are identified. In recognition of the nature of the

project, the following alternatives are considered:

2.3.1 No Project Option


The ‘no project’ option indicates that the proposed development will not be implemented. This

means that the use of the site continues in a marginal manner with substantial under-utilization of

resources. At the moment, the project site is undeveloped. Therefore “no project option” will

ensure that the site continues to exist as it is. This scenario though would protect the current state

of the ecology, but will however encourage encroachment on the land by potential squatter and

informal sector activities which may not be complementary to the surrounding developments of

the subject site. This scenario is not attractive as it would potentially preclude attendant socio-

economic opportunities associated with the site and as such the potentially accruable revenue to
Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.
Page 8
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

both the national economy and returns expected by the investors will not be garnered. In terms

of the social environment, the “no-action” alternative would eliminate the job opportunities,

housing provision to the populace and the local economic inflow. This option is therefore not

attractive.

2.3.2 Delayed Project Option.


This option implies postponing the planned p r o j e c t until a later date. Such options are

usually adopted when prevailing conditions are unfavourable for project implementation such

as during a war, when host communities are deeply resentful of the project, or if the project

is unacceptable or unattractive economically. But none of these conditions are applicable. On the

contrary, both the economic and the political environments are favourably disposed towards the

project. The implication of delaying the project will mean that all processes that have been put

in place for the project design and implementation, contractors and/or workers that

are to be mobilized for this project will have to be put on hold. Also, because of the

inflationary trends in the economy, such a delay may result in unanticipated increase

in project costs, leading to a decrease in final profit accruable from the project. These, and other

related problems make it unattractive to adopt the delayed project option.

2.3.3 Alternative Site/ Location Option


This option deploys the project site to another location. This scenario though would protect the

current state of the ecology, but will however present opportunities to potential squatters if not

developed on time. Furthermore, deploying the site to other activities rather than the intending use

may not bring about the value anticipated. It is therefore of note that the project location is ideal

both in terms of economic and environmental factors.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.


Page 9
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

3.0 DES CRIPTION OF PROJECT ENVIRONMENT

3.1 Site Location

3.2 Site Coverage, Boundary and Adjoining Development

3.3 Existing Developments on Site

3.4 The Site Topography

3.5 Existing Drainage System

3.6 Existing Infrastructural Facilities

3.7 Climatic Condition

3.8 Geology

3.9 Vegetation

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.


Page 10
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.


Page 11
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

CHAPTER THREE

3.0 DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT ENVIRONMENT

3.1 Site Location

The project site is situated along Association Avenue/ Abayomi Abass Str. Ikotun, alimosho

Local Government Area, Lagos State. Lagos State though the smallest in land mass and

indisputably the major commercial nerve centre of the country with the nation largest number of

urban area is situated in the southwestern part of Nigeria ( Figure 3.1 refers). Eti-Osa Local

Government Area, where the project site is situated, is in Lagos central senatorial zone alongside

Apapa, Surulere, Lagos Island.(Figure 3.2 refers).

Source: Contemporary Consultants Group Limited, 2018.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.


Page 12
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd.


Page 13
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Figure 3.1: Location of Lagos State within the Nigeria context

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 14


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Figure 3.2: Location of Eti-Osa within the state context

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 15


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Plate 1: Subject site verged with red polygon on satellite imagery

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 16


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

3.2 Site Coverage, Boundary and Adjoining Developments

As shown in Figure 3.4 below, the site within which the COMMERCIAL and RESIDENTIAL
DEVELOPMENT is to be developed is on a parcels of land with two frontage road which covers
a total land area of about 1343.704 Square metres; land area being 0.134 Hectares respectively. The
survey plan number of the subject site is LE/1237/007/2006/LA and the pillar numbers refers;

Parcel Properties

K5405EV, K5406EV, K5407EV, K5408EV with coordinate 725393.026mN,528792.640mE


respectively.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 17


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

The Survey Plan


Source: Client, 2o22.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 18


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

3.3 Existing Developments on Site

Plate 4: A view along along Association Rood; a Secondary access road to the subject site

Plate 5: A view of the site main entrance

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 19


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Plate 6: A view of the Utility Pole abutting the site as well as alternative power supply (Generator)

Plate 7: View of some physical developments around the subject site

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 20


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

3.4 The Site Topography


As shown in Appendix I, the terrain of the site is generally observed to be flat and gently sloped across

the project site. As observed in the course of the survey and from the soil test made on the site, the top

soil within the project site is predominated by very soft dark grey to light grey gravelly sand at the

depth of about 27m within a high water table.

3.5 Existing Drainage System


At present, there exist around the project site a drainage network system. This alignment generally

follows the road network in most cases (Plate 9 refers). Whenever it rains therefore, water runs-off

through it into the lagoon which is at some distance away from the subject site.

Plate 8: View of existing drainage facility around the subject site.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 21


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

3.6 Climatic Condition

The project site is located within Lagos state and as such lies within the humid zone of the climatic

regions. Its vast expanse of water within Lagos adds to the humidity content of the air which creates

some discomfort in the afternoon heats. Meteorological data collected from the Nigerian

Meteorological department (NIMET) Oshodi Lagos for project area serves as the basis for the climatic

characterization of the area.

3.6.1 Pattern of Climate and Meteorology of the study area.


The project area lies within the Gulf of Guinea in the Central Eastern Atlantic which is largely affected
Plate 10: Existing drainage alignment running around the site
by Inter-Tropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ) generally referred to as the Inter-Tropical Divide (ITD) or

Inter-Tropical Front (ITF). Associated with the movement of the ITCZ are the warm humid maritime

Tropical (mT) air mass with its south-westerly winds and the hot and dry continental (cT) air mass with

north-easterly winds. These air masses determine the dominant seasons and they are responsible for the

different climatic factors that influence the climate. The most important climatic factors that govern the

climate discussed below are temperature; atmospheric pressure; wind speed and direction; relative

humidity and rainfall.

3.6.2 Temperature
Temperature Pattern for the period of 1994-2008 is presented in Figure 3.5. Temperatures within

project site vary between high to very high throughout the year because of the abundant and consistent

insolation experienced throughout the year. However, because of the maritime location of this area,

temperatures are tampered down during the extreme hot weathers experienced between Novembers to

January. Maximum air temperatures of between 32 oC to 34oC are experienced throughout the year.

Minimum temperature of 28oC is recorded during July. Mean annual temperatures ranges from 30.4 oC

to 32oC. Typical variations taken in Lagos from year 2000 to 2007 indicate mean annual minimum

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 22


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

temperatures of 30.2 to 30.5 were observed. Generally, minimum monthly temperatures of between 28
o
C and below are recorded in the months of July and August. However, there are certain periods in July

and August when minimum temperatures exceed 28 oC.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 23


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Figure 3.5: Temperature Pattern for the period of 1994-2008

Source: NIMET (2009)

3.6.3 Rainfall
Rainfall distribution in Lagos State as in all part of Nigeria is bimodal with peaks in June and July and

a two-week break in August. Mean rainfall pattern for the period of 1994-2008 is presented Figure 3.6.

The rainy season begins in March - April, when there is significant precipitation, and last till October

or early November. Rainfall is often at its maximum at night and during the early morning hours. It

rains all year round even in the dry season. This is partly due to the proximity of the state to the lagoon

and other water bodies. However, variations occur in rainfall amount from year to year.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 24


Figure 3.6: Mean Rainfall Pattern for the period of 1994-2008

Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Source:

NIMET

(2009)

3.6.4

Sunshine
hours
The

Sunshine

hours per

month in the project area are influenced by the amount of rainfall such that a low sunshine hour is

usually recorded around July at the peak of the rains while high values are recorded in December,

January and February. The monthly values vary between 51.2 and 165.7 in July and January

respectively as detailed in Figure 3.7.

Figure 3.7: Mean Monthly Sunshine Hours For Lagos.

Source: NIMET (2009)

3.6.5 Relative Humidity (RH)


Lagos State has an average annual relative humidity of 71% which is highest during the rainy season.

In the rainy season, RH rises to about 86% around 9.00 hrs. The high relative humidity experienced in

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 25


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

the State favour luxuriant station growth which produce the Lagos State rich and beautiful vegetation of

the mangrove and rain forest. Figure 3.8 shows the relative humidity taken at 0900hrs and 1500hrs.

Figure 3.8: Relative Humidity taken at 0900hrs and 1500hrs

Source: NIMET (2009)

3.6.6 Wind Speed and wind direction


Wind is turbulent between January and September (3.9 - 5 Knots) and lowest in October through

December (3.5 - 3.9 Knots). The Mean Monthly Wind Speed for Lagos State over a 15 year period is

shown in Figure 3.9.

The wind direction in the dry season (October to January) is predominantly South Westerly, while that

of the rainy season (March-September) is predominantly North Easterly. These winds brings the two

(2) seasons of the year. The prevailing winds/ the North-East Trade Harmattan Winds which blow from

across the Sahara Desert are usually accompanied by dust particles from the northern land mass. The

winds are dry and bring about the cooler nights during the harmattan season. These winds come around

November and end in February. The effect of the North-East Trade Winds are not of strong effect in

the Lagos area due to the effect of water bodies which modify its dryness and increase its humidity

content to about 68 percent in the month of December when humidity is lowest. However, the South

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 26


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

West Monsoon Winds blowing across the Atlantic Ocean onto the Land Mass bringing rains to the

coasts and the hinterland.

Figure 3.9: Wind Speed

Source: NIMET (2009)

3.7 Geology
The project site falls within the western Nigerian depositional basin, and within the creek pattern of

Lagos Lagoon. The geology is therefore typically sedimentary with the occurrence of recent alluvium

and the coastal plain sands. Locally, the former overlies the latter. The alluvium, which is covered on

the site by some sort of sand-hills, is essentially near surface consolidated organic matter,

unconsolidated sand and clay with some considerable proportions of vegetable matter.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 27


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

3.8 Vegetation
The vegetation types within the project area and its immediate environment are strandline vegetation,

mangrove swamp, and fresh water swamp forest. The coastal strip is a network of island, sandbanks,

creeks and lagoons giving way to swamp and mangrove inland. The strandline vegetation is dominated by

species such as Ipomoea pescaprae, I. stolinfera, Sesuzriumportulacastrum, Dalbergiaecastophyihim,

and Paspalumvaginatum. The commonest mangrove species in the area are Rhizophoraracemosa(tall red

mangrove) and Rhizophora mangle (short red mangrove). These plants are characterized by prop roots which

anchor them in the flooded substratum.

Species identified within the freshwater swamp forest include Symphonaglobulifera, Syzygiumguineensis,

Pandanustogoensis, Musangacecropioides, Alchorneacordifolia, NephrolepisMserrata,

Alstoniaboonei, Elaeisguineensis, Aframomum spp. and Anfhocleistavogelii.

Plate 9: View of existing vegetation on the site.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 28


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

4.0 PROJECT CONCEPT

4.1 Design Parameters

4.2 Assets and Constraints to Planning

4.3 Population Projection

4.4 Required Project Infrastructure/Utilities

4.5 Proposed Land Use Plan

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 29


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

CHAPTER FOUR

4.0 PROJECT CONCEPT


The compliance of the proposed OTESHADE VILLAGE EXCISION with the extant Physical

Planning Regulations, detailing planning standards for layout approval in the state is herein evaluated.

4.1 Design Parameters


The design concept of the proposed layout scheme for OTESHADE VILLAGE EXCISION is mainly

influenced by the need to achieve the set objectives of the project as follows:

i. Provision of high quality dwelling units within a comprehensive and integrated self-

sufficient layout scheme;

ii. Provision of adequate setbacks around all proposed building prototypes at the

commencement of the development of the scheme; and

iii. Emergence of an aesthetically pleasing environment that will guarantee the quality of

life needed for the well-being of the prospective residents;

Towards this end, the Commercial and Residential Development design concept adopted for this layout

attempts to focus on development of a residential Commercial and Residential Development in

consideration of proper ordering of social unit that will be serviced with good road networks that were

designed with principles of legibility and logical movement and serviced as well with sufficient

infrastructural facilities.

The road network as a circulatory system within the plays a very significant role in the concept

definition of the housing scheme as it defines pattern and direction of movement within the proposed

Commercial and Residential Development development.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 30


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

4.2 Assets and Constraints to Planning

Basically, in the course of evolving the design concept of the proposed , certain factors which are very

vital influenced our decisions towards arriving at the final . All these are considered as assets and

constraints to planning, and as stated follows:

i. Location of the project site;

ii. Contiguous activities around the project site; and

iii. The Development Plan Strategies.

4.2.1 Location of the Project Site


The project site falls within an area where residential land use predominates. There exists a network of

road around the project. This road network made this site very accessible and to a large extent,

informed the design concept adopted for the site planning.

Moreover, the location of the project site is within a developing community where infrastructural

facilities are being gradually put in place. The various opportunities offered by the project site location

have been maximally utilized to enhance the final concept of the , while at the same time providing

opportunity in the layout concept for evolving a sustainable development towards:

a) Provision of open spaces, recreational facilities among other facilities within the

scheme;

b) Provision of adequate circulatory system to aid both pedestrian and vehicular

movements in and out of the commercial and residential development; and

c) Provision of drainage alignment to effectively manage the storm water within

and around the project site.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 31


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

4.2.2 Contiguous Activities around the Project Site

Another factor that has been of utmost importance in the course of the adoption of the land use concept

for the scheme is the contiguous activities around the project site. It is of note that the project site is

situated in a developing residential neighbourhood where several private residential housing obtains.

This awareness necessitates the need to relate spatially the proposed development with the existing

development in order to prevent conflicting developments and air pollution within the project area.

4.2.3 Development Plan Strategies

As shown in Appendix I, the development plan strategy for the residential layout incorporates four (4)

building prototypes namely, Prototypes A, B, C and D. Each type according to the layout design

concept will accommodate three hundred and sixteen (316) family units.

4.3 Population Projection


Population projection of the proposed Layout Scheme is based on the permissible density per hectare of

land within Lagos State as stipulated in the Lagos State Physical Planning and Development

Regulations of 2005.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 32


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Table 4.0: Permissible Maximum Number of Dwelling Units and population projection

Prototype Instances No of Level Description Family Range of Average


of Rooms(Bedroom) Units Occupants Occupants
building
28 4 Bedroom 0&1 Semi 28 112 – 224 168
A Detached
10 4 Bedroom 0&1 Terrace 10 40 – 80 60
42 5 Bedroom 0&1 Semi 42 210– 420 315
B Detached
4 5 Bedroom 0&1 Detached 4 20– 40 30
34 5 Bedroom 0,1&2 Semi 34 170 – 340 255
C Detached
60 5 Bedroom 0,1&2 Terrace 60 300 – 600 450
10 2,2&3 Bedroom 0,1&2 Block of Flat 90 210-420 315
D Flat with roadside
parking
8 2,2&3 Bedroom 0,1&2 Block of Flat 48 112 – 224 168
Flat with ground
floor parking
Total 107 3 1174-2348 1761

According to the Lagos State Physical Planning and Development Regulations 2005 Section 19, the

following maximum number of dwelling units is permissible within each of the residential density in

the state.

Table 4.1: Permissible Maximum Number of Dwelling Units


Density Permissible Maximum Number of Dwelling Units

Low 30 units per hectares

Medium 78 units per hectares

High 270 units per hectares.

It is imperative to note that the proposed scheme (which is about 50% of the Site ) is majorly a high

density Commercial and Residential Development. Based on the aforementioned provision and the total

area coverage of 9.6 hectares earmarked for residential development within the scheme, 316 family

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 33


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

units of housing are therefore permissible within the scheme. In consideration of the need to create a

manageable environment and guide against any form of human discomfort, the concept therefore

uphold the above policy while proposing an average human population of about one thousand seven

hundred and sixty one (1761) persons. In view of this, the projected population for the scheme at

completion is as given in Table 4.2 below:

Table 4.2: Projected population at maturity

Total
Density Stipulated No of number of Projected Population at range
Dwelling Units bedrooms of 1 to 2persons per Bed room

High 316 1174 1174-2348

25% Transient Population 293 to 587

Total 1467 to 2935 persons

From the above table, the projected population at maturity according to the proposed residential

housing unit for the site is put at the range of 1,467 to 2,935 persons.

4.4 Required Project Infrastructure/Utilities


In order for the project to be economically viable, user satisfactory and environmentally sustainable,

there is therefore the need to determine the project infrastructure/utility requirements. To this end, the

following infrastructure/utilities are required:

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 34


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

 Water Requirement: The projected water demand for the proposed OTESHADE

VILLAGE EXCISION Layout at maturity is given as follows:

Table 4.3: Water requirement for the proposed estate


Domestic Water Requirement
Projected Population 1468
Per capita water need/day according to WHO 150 litres
standard
Total volume of water needed/day 220,200 litres/day
Water Requirement for Fire Fighting
Sprinkler Pump Flow Rate 2.5 litres/seconds
The Sprinkler pump is expected to work at 30 minutes before the arrival of the fire service.
Therefore,
Hence for 30 minutes 4,500 litres
Total Daily Water Demand 216,000 litres/day

Minimum Capacity of Bulk Water Storage Required

In order to ensure the constant availability of the quantity of water required daily for the smooth

operation of the estate, a bulk water storage facility is required. The storage capacity specification is

given below.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 35


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Table 4.4: Bulk storage tank capacity specification

Total Daily Water Requirement 216,000 litres/day


Capacity of storage facility ¼ of daily water requirement
Storage capacity /day 54,000 litres

Therefore bulk water storage facilities with the minimum capacity of about 280,000 litres shall be

required.

 Energy Requirement: The energy need for the proposed OTESHADE VILLAGE

EXCISION DEVELOPMENT PLAN at maturity is projected as follows:

Table 4.5: Energy Requirement

Projected Population 1468


Energy required per person according to the 128 kilowatts/hr
road map for Power Sector Reform(2002)
Total energy required for the residents 187,904 kilowatts/hr

 Sewage Treatment:

In order to safe guard the environment, the sewage that will be generated by the proposed

OTESHADE VILLAGE DEVELOPMENT must be determined and properly treated to meet

LASEPA tertiary effluent quality before discharge. The following gives the yardstick for sewage

volume generation and sewage treatment plant specification.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 36


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Sewage Treatment Analysis for Occupiers

Estimated Population 1468 - 2935

Flow rate is @ 150 litres/person /day

Required flow rate 220,200 – 440,250m3/ day

Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD) @55g/person/day

BOD requirement/day 80,740kg – 161,425kg/day

Table 4.6: Sewage Treatment Plant Specification

Sewage Treatment Plant Specification

In order to properly and adequately treat the sewage that will be generated by the proposed project at

maturity, the following gives the minimum specification of the Sewage Treatment Plant required.

Capacity

Minimum Daily BOD 80,740kg – 161,425kg/day

Minimum Flow Rate 220,200 – 440,250m3/ day

Table 4.7: Minimum Specification Requirement for Sewage Treatment Plant

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 37


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

4.5 Proposed Land Uses in the Village Excision


The proposed commercial and residential development is a high density development. It feature four

(4) building prototypes where to it applies. Every building is serviced with well laid out roads and

adequate parking facilities to ease pedestrian and vehicular movements. The proposed features the

following landuses.

 Residential use;

 Public / institutional use

 Open space/Recreational use/ agricultural use

 Light industrial use; and

 Circulation.

Residential land use covers about 1.19 hectares of land, and accounts for 59.55% of the total area

coverage of the site. Other major land uses within the scheme include commercial land use, public land

use, recreational/open space, and circulation. Commercial land use covers about 0.34 hectares of land,

public land use (institutional use, utility area, and parking utilities) covers about 0.9 hectares,

recreational /open space covers up to 1.37 hectares, and circulation covers around 5.16 hectares of land.

Public/ institutional use is about 4.79, recreational/open space is about 15.31%, and circulation is

around 18.82% of the total land area. Land use analysis in table 4.8 below and annexed as appendix I

refer.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 38


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Table 4.8 Site Plan Layout Land Use Analysis

Source: Contemporary Consultants Group Limited, 2018.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 39


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

4.5.1 Residential Land Use

Residential land use as earlier stated accounts for about 60% of the total land area covered by the

scheme. According to the layout design shown in Appendix I, the residential layout features a total of

six (6) blocks (accommodating the known and unknown housing facilities). Concerning the four

building prototypes, each of the proposed buildings obtains in design with due regard to the minimum

setbacks and airspaces .

4.5.3 Public Uses

The area earmarked for public land use in the scheme covers 0.95hectares of land representing a little

below 5% of the total land area. The proposed public uses within the scheme consist of administrative,

communual utility, and parking areas respectively. Other anticipated within this uses include: Gate

House, Power Plant, Water Treatment Plant, and Waste Management Facilities (Appendix I).

4.5.4 Open Space/Recreational Use

In line with the green revolution of the present administration and the need to promote revitalization of

the already depleted ecosystem, about 1.37 hectares representing about 15% of land earmarked for open

space/recreational and gardening use. In an attempt to create a visually appealing view within the

totality of the environment, the design concept has also introduced green verge along the proposed

Right of Ways (ROWs) in some areas.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 40


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

4.5.5 Road Network

The importance of good road network for efficient functioning of any community cannot be over-

emphasized. In view of this, the road alignment within the proposed estate has been carefully made.

The consideration for the road design is largely influenced by the need to provide optimum

interconnectivity within the proposed OTESHADE VILLAGE EXCISION Layout. Thus the need to

ensure the shortest possible distance between the activities centre and residential developments has

been given much consideration as well as the expected intensity of activities in the scheme.

To this end therefore, the design concept incorporates a dual carriageway of 15.5m Right of Way

(ROW) with ample provisions for on-street parking. The proposed Right of Way as well as driveways

of 5.5m (two ways) provide access to all prototype buildings with carriage width wider enough to

accommodate any type of car and mini-van.

4.5.6 Drainages

The proposed drainage network within the scheme mainly consists of secondary drains designed to

collect storm water along the proposed carriageway (underneath the walkways / buried beneath the

laybys where applicable). This will discharge storm water into the nearby primary drain existing at the

North end of the project site, towards the Lagos lagoon. It is on note that the proposed drainage

network within the scheme is designed to drain along the general topography of the site into the higher

level drains.

The details of the profile and invert level of the proposed drainage network are subject to the proposal

of the Engineering and Infrastructural drawings for the proposed drainage alignment.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 41


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

4.5.7 Solid Waste Management via Waste Transfer Point (W.T.P.)

Solid waste management philosophy at the proposed scheme shall be to encourage the four R’s of

waste management i.e. waste reduction, reuse, recycling, and recovery (materials & energy). Waste

generation and reduction campaign strategies shall include regular resident’s awareness meetings to

ensure proper segregation, storage and collection of waste in line with Lagos State Waste Management

Authority (LAWMA) standards. The strategy for solid waste management focuses on the segregation,

storage at source and collection of the waste management system.

 Segregation and Storage at Source

Segregation of waste at source shall be made mandatory for the residents. Segregation or sorting waste

at its source would be practiced in order to encourage reuse/recycling. With segregation at source

recyclables do not lose their commercial value due to cross contamination. Waste generated by

residents shall be segregated as bio degradable, inert cum mixed waste, recyclables and waste from

changing oil.

 Collection

The Recyclables from the estate may be given to the waste itinerant buyers or scavengers, whereas

segregated bio-degradable waste and inert cum mixed waste shall be sent to the nearest landfill site for

processing and final disposal.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 42


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

5.0 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT

5.1 Legal and Administrative Framework

5.2 Concept of Environmental Impact Assessment

5.3 Objectives of Environmental Impact Assessment

5.4 Potential Impact Identification

5.5 Impacts Rating

5.6 Impact Mitigation

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 43


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

CHAPTER FIVE

5.0 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT


5.1 Introduction
The proposed housing project is a physical development within Lagos environment which will no doubt

improve the socio-economic well-being of the society at large. It is however of note that the proposed

development will bring about an urban ecosystem to replace the existing natural environment.

It is in view of this therefore that it becomes imperative for an Environmental Impact Assessment of the

proposed development to be carried out largely with the view to ensuring a sustainable growth within

the totality of the environment.

In recognition of the potential environmental effects that could result from these developmental

projects, it is mandatory for all such major developmental projects to undergo the Environmental

Impact Assessment process prior to their commencement in order to consider all likely impacts of the

project activities on the physical and social environments.

To this end, this Environmental Impact Assessment intends to assess in advance the possible

consequences the proposal may have on the socio-economic and the immediate physical environments

considering also the well-being of the immediate communities and the prospective residents.

5.2 Legal and Administrative Framework


To nib this destructive trend in the bud, many “Safe Our Environment Movements” formed by

environmentally conscious people around the world sprang up in the early 1960s. Their actions led to

the intervention of governments of different countries to enact laws and regulations that will

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 44


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

consciously and proactively check the resultants effects of man’s interaction with nature. Nigeria is not

an exception.

5.2.1 Federal Government Interventions


5.2.1.1 Federal Environmental Protection Agency (FEPA)

Act 58 of 1988 established the Federal Environmental Protection Agency (FEPA) as the chief regulatory body

for environmental protection in Nigeria with the responsibility of ensuring that all industries meet the limits

prescribed in the national guidelines, standards and associated various regulations for environmental pollution

management (e.g., effluent limitation, management of solid hazardous wastes, etc.). From time to time, the

FMEnv (formerly the FEPA) may update the national guidelines and standards.

5.2.1.2 Environmental Impact Assessment Law

Environmental Impact Assessment Act No. 86 of 1992 as enacted by the Federal Government of Nigeria

makes the EIA process mandatory for any major development project and prescribes the procedure for

conducting and reporting ElA.

Environmental Impact Assessment Decree No. 86 of 1992 Laws of the Federation of Nigeria, part 1,

objective (2) states that:

(1) The public or private sector of the economy shall not undertake or embark on public or

authorise projects or activities without prior consideration at an early stages of their

environmental effects.

(2) Where the extent, nature or location of a proposed project or activity is such that is likely to

significantly affect the environment, its environmental impact assessment shall be

undertaken in accordance with the provisions of this Decree.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 45


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

5.2.1.3 Nigerian Urban and Regional Planning Act 88 of 1992


Furthermore, Nigerian Urban and Regional Planning Decree No. 88 of 1992 section 33 also provide

that:

“a developer shall at the times of submitting his application for development submit to an appropriate

Development Control Department a detailed Environmental Impact Statement for an application for:

a. a residential land in excess of 2 hectares;

b. permission to build or expand a factory or for the construction of an office building in

excess of 4 floors or 5,000m2 of lettable space; and

c. Permission for a major recreational development.

5.2.1.4 National Environmental Standards and Regulations Enforcement Agency


(NESREA) Act of 2007

National Environmental Standards and Regulations Enforcement Agency (NESREA) is the

enforcement Agency for environmental standards, regulations, rules, laws, policies and guidelines,

saddled with the following responsibilities:

i. Protection of the environment through enforcement of laws, policies and guidelines for the

development of the environment.

ii. Biodiversity conservation and sustainable development of Nigeria’s natural resources in

general, and

iii. Coordination of environmental technology and liaison with relevant stakeholders within and

outside Nigeria on matters of enforcement of environmental policies.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 46


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

5.2.2 Lagos State Regulatory Interventions


5.2.2.1 Lagos State Environmental Protection Agency Edict, 1996

As part of measures to control developmental activities as it relates to the objective of environmental

protection and sustainability, the Lagos State government under the military rule enacted an edict that

established the Lagos State Environmental Protection Agency (LASEPA) in 1996.

The functions of the Agency among others include:

(a) The monitoring and controlling of disposal of wastes generated within the State;

(b) The monitoring and controlling of all forms of environmental degradation from

agricultural, industrial and government operations;

(c) The monitoring of surface, underground and potable water, air, land and soils within the

State;

(d) Co-operating with Federal, State and Local Governments Statutory bodies and research

agencies on matter and facilities relating to environmental protection (Section 7).

Among other things, the Agency is empowered to make regulations prescribing:

(a) Acceptable standards or criteria to control the pollution level of water, air, noise and land in

line with the policy and guidelines of Federal Government;

(b) Standard for effluent discharge;

(c) Waste management strategy and alternatives etc. (Section 9)

5.2.2.2 Environmental Sanitation Law, 2000

To further strengthen the resolution of the State Government on environmental protection, a Law to

provide for Environmental sanitation in Lagos State was enacted. The Law also established the

Environmental sanitation Corps for the enforcement of the sanitation Law. The provisions state the

general civic duties expected of the residents of the state as regards the general cleanliness of their

immediate environment. It also prescribes various penalties in form of fines for defaulters.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 47


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

5.2.2.3 Physical Planning and Development Regulations, 2005

To stem the tide of environmentally debilitating practices in the bud, the Lagos State Government

through the Ministry of Physical Planning and Urban Development enacted laws and regulations that

will control physical development within her domain. One of such laws is the Lagos State Physical

Planning and Development Regulations of 2005.

Section 6 of the Lagos State Physical Planning and Development Regulations, 2005 states that:

“a developer shall at the time of submitting his application for development submit a detailed Planning

Technical Report in respect of application for:

i. a residential land in excess of ½ hectare or development in excess of 4 floors or 8 family

units:

ii. factory building or expansion of factory building:

iii. office or other commercial buildings:

a. places of worship:

iv. major recreational development covering more than 2000m2:

v. institutional buildings and public buildings:

vi. petrol/gas filling and service stations:

vii. telecommunication tower and stations:

viii. advertisement billboards of unusual sizes and heights, urban furniture:

ix. any other building as specified in the regulations made pursuant to this law.

Also, section 7 of the Regulation states that: “a developer shall at the time of submitting his application

for development permit submit a detailed Environmental Impact Analysis report in respect of

application for:

(i) Oil and gas pipeline depots and installations;

(ii) Refineries;

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 48


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

(iii) Large scale industrial development;

(iv) Roads, rail lines, seaport and airport developments;

(v) Large scale educational institution/facility such as for tertiary institution;

(vi) Developments/production process which may be injurious to the environment;

(vii) Any other development which, in the opinion of the Ministry and Authority, requires the

submission of an Environmental Impact Assessment; and

(viii) Any other project as may be deemed necessary by the Ministry and / or the Authority.

5.2.3 World Bank’s Intervention


Another consideration in the study is the World Bank Guidelines on Environmental Impact Assessment

(EIA). The bank requires an EIA on a proposed activity/facility (i.e. project) from a borrower as a pre-

requisite before granting any financial assistance in the form of loans. The EIA report usually forms a

part of the overall feasibility study or project preparation. The bank has categorization for projects

based on their EIA requirements and it is very similar to that of FMEnv.

Therefore this Environmental Impact Assessment for the proposed OTESHADE VILLAGE

EXCISION is appropriately based on the provisions of the above cited Acts and Regulations.

5.3 Concept of Environmental Impact Assessment

It is essential to have an understanding of what Environmental Impact Analysis is all about; the concept

of Environmental Impact Analysis (EIA) as a philosophy, attempts to capture the totality of values

relevant to decision making as affected by a developmental project and that which stipulates

appropriate measures for avoiding or minimizing the negative effect on the biotic and abiotic system.

According to Jam R. K. et al (1977), Environmental Impact Analysis is “a systematic process of

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 49


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

identification, prediction, evaluation and presentation of the probable/possible consequences of a

proposed action at a stage in the decision making process where serious environmental damage can be

minimized or avoided”.

Likewise, Olokesusi (1992) defined Environmental Impact Analysis/ Assessment as “the process of

identifying, predicting and evaluating the impacts on man’s physical environment and well-being of

programmes, policies, projects, legislature proposals and operation procedures, as well as interpreting

and communicating those impacts”.

Accordingly, Environmental Impact Assessment is an environmental cost benefit analysis of any spatial

development proposal, with a view to enhancing its benefit, while minimizing any adverse

environmental condition that may arise. It is however, essential to note that environmental impact is

any alteration or creation of a new set of environmental conditions, adverse or beneficial, spurred by

physical development actions as it concerns this project.

The overall goal of Environmental Impact Analysis for an investment is therefore to maximize the

socio-economic benefits, while minimizing the environmental damage that such a project would have

had on the people and the surrounding environment. This is substantiated by Section 40 of the 1992

Environmental Impact Assessment Decree which expresses that in determining Environmental Impact

Assessment, decision shall be reached that:-

i. the project or activity will not cause significant adverse environmental effect (thus

permitted);

ii. any such effect can be mitigated and justified in the circumstances (conditions could be

imposed); or where in the opinion of the Agency, the project is likely to cause significant

adverse environmental conditions that cannot be mitigated and justified in the

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 50


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

circumstances, even after mediation and review, then the project or activity cannot be

permitted.

So, in view of the above provision, Environmental Impact Assessment is a civilized and systematic

process of assessing the environmental consequences of major investments and developmental projects.

5.4 Objectives of Environmental Impact Assessment


Environmental Impact Assessment study is designed to evaluate in advance the possible impacts of a

developmental project on the environment before the project is executed. At the same time,

Environmental Impact Assessment proffers alternatives or otherwise to the developmental project

provided it will cause great disorder within the immediate environment.

Therefore, the purpose of this EIA study is to provide information on the nature and extent of

environmental impacts arising from the proposed development and related activities taking place

concurrently. This information will contribute to decisions by the proponent on:

i. the overall acceptability of any adverse environmental consequences that are likely to

arise as a result of the proposed development;

ii. the conditions and requirements for the detailed design and construction of the

proposed project to mitigate against adverse environmental consequences wherever

practicable; and

iii. the residual impacts after the proposed mitigation measures is implemented.

To this end, the objective of the EIA process is to integrate environmental considerations into the

development, design, construction and operation of the proposed project. The EIA process aims at

identifying the likely impacts of the proposed development and assist in the design of mechanisms to

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 51


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

control environmental impacts where necessary. As such, the EIA is an important and fundamental

planning and design tool which provides mechanism to ensure sustainable development within the

totality of the built environment.

In view of the aforementioned therefore, this Environmental Impact Assessment study is thus

prepared:-

i. to highlight the nature of the project in terms of its component services to be rendered

and associated problems;

ii. to determine the nature and magnitude of environmental changes attributable to the

project activities;

iii. to appraise their impacts on the totality of its surrounding environment; and

iv. To highlight and suggest how anticipated impacts could be managed in the light of

available technology in order to achieve the purpose of environmental protection.

5.5 Potential Impact Identification


The primary intention of this EIA is to identify the associated and potential impacts of the proposed

development with the view to proffering measures for mitigating the adverse impacts that may have

been identified. In this section of the report therefore, we present concise information on the impacts

that have been identified as having the likelihood of accompanying the implementation of the project.

The potential environmental impacts are evaluated considering the anticipated effects of the proposed

project on the existing physical and biological conditions of the environment.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 52


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

5.5.1 Impact on Air Quality and Noise


At the inception of the project site, the activities on site will involve land preparation for beaconing of

plots / infrastructure alignment, excavation and commencement of civil works for road construction etc.

During the opening up of the project site for the commencement of work for the construction of access

roads, erection of temporary shelter and buildings, the project will bring about generation and emission

of pollutants into the atmosphere thereby impacting on the air quality of the project environment.

The sources of the anticipated atmospheric pollutants will be from

 Emission of dust during land preparation and site clearance;

 Emission of dust particles during excavation and civil construction works;

 Emission of fumes from heavy duty equipment, vehicular movement and power generating

set; and

 Odour from accumulated wastes/garbage that will be generated.

At the commencement of construction activities which will involve land grading, soil densification and

excavation, such atmospheric pollutants such as dust particles will be generated and dispersed into the

atmosphere. It is however of note that the effects are localized and limited mainly to the construction

stage.

It is also important to note that fumes in form of carbon monoxide and hydrocarbon from burning,

movement of heavy duty equipment and vehicles will be generated and dispersed into the atmosphere,

and so also gaseous emissions and odour from accumulated wastes and garbage at the commissioning

of the project.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 53


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Air pollution can be very harmful to man and so also animals and plant. This can cause respiratory

problems depending on the degree of emissions of these pollutants into the atmosphere. It is however

of note that the anticipated impacts on the environment from this is negligible, temporary, localized and

reversible.

 Impact Severity Rating

The magnitude of the impact will be moderate as the activities will introduce medium concentration of

solid particulate matter and higher decibel of noise into the ambient air. The duration and frequency of

the impact will be minor as these activities will only be for a short time. The areal extent of the impact

will be minor. Given this facts, the sensitivity of the project to the air and noise environment is

adjudged minor.

 Impact Evaluation Discussion

Preparatory activities on site have potential impacts on ambient air quality and noise level within the

immediate area of the project environment. However, the resultant impacts will be major but short

lived due to the nature and character of the area. This impact is classified as an adverse impact of

minor significance.

5.5.2 Impacts on Water Environment and Hydrology


The proposed development may exact adverse impact on the ground and surface water as a result of the

previous factory operations and proposed construction activities when the project commences. During

the construction activities, waste water will be generated and if leaches into ground may cause

moderate impact on ground water quality of the area. The surrounding surface water quality may also

be impacted by uncontrolled disposal of sewage and wastewater from temporary labour camps. Spillage

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 54


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

of oil and grease from the vehicles and wastewater generated from on- site activities may also pollute

the ground and surface water resources.

 Impact Severity Rating

The duration of the potential impact will be moderate. The frequency of the impact on water bodies will

be moderate as the impact will occur intermittently throughout the construction period. Moreover, since

most of the labour would be locally deployed from within the immediate locality of the project area, the

wastewater generated from sanitary activities will be minor. The areal extent of the impact will be

minor as waste water will be properly controlled. In this regard, the sensitivity of the water resource

components is adjudged minor.

 Impact Evaluation Discussion

Impacts on water quality and hydrobiology from the construction of the project will be minor based on

the various extrapolations done earlier. Therefore the impact will have a medium significance on the

surrounding environments.

5.5.3 Impact on Soil and Land


Activities during the construction phase would involve soil densification, excavation and filling.

However, due to its relatively flat terrain, the topography as well as geology is not anticipated to

change due to proposed project.

Impact on soil owing to the project construction activity includes soil erosion, compaction, physical and

chemical effects and contamination of the soil. Erosion of soil may occur on account of removal of

vegetation and excavation activity for construction. Site for the project is vegetated with shrubs, trees

and grasses; hence impact owing to removal of vegetation would be major. Other factors contributing

to soil erosion is increased runoff and decrease in permeability of the soil due to surface paving.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 55


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Use of heavy machinery and storage of material compact the soil. Compaction of soil as well as mixing

of construction material with soil will also lead to reduced infiltration of water, lower rate of

impermeability and increased runoff. Changes in the physical and chemical characteristics of soil will

occur during the construction phase.

Impact Severity Rating

The magnitude of the impact will be minor given the fact that effective mitigation strategies are

developed to curtail drastically the anticipated adverse effects. The duration of the impact will be

moderate; the frequency of the impact will be minor as the occurrence of the impact will spread

throughout the construction phase period. The areal extent of the impact will be minor as construction

activities will be consciously limited to the project site environment. Therefore, the sensitivity of the

soil and land environments within the project site is adjudged minor.

5.5.4 Impacts on Biological Environment (Flora & Fauna)


One of the major environmental impacts of the proposed development is the clearing of the existing

natural vegetation to pave way for the development. The depletion of vegetation within the project site

to give way for housing and associated infrastructural facilities (e.g. roads) is a major environmental

issue. It is of note that the vegetation within the project site which over the years has not been tampered

with predominantly consist of shrubs and grasses. These plant species do not only harbour different

terrestrial animals, but also serves as a medium for feeding and breeding.

There is no doubt that the depletion of the existing natural vegetation and subsequent loss of the fauna

habitat is a negative impact and irreversible.

Furthermore, the depletion of natural vegetation within the project site will bring about disequilibrium

of the existing ecosystem. Therefore, the depletion of the natural vegetation as a result of the bush

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 56


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

clearing arising from site preparation for construction and associated infrastructure (roads) will

endanger both terrestrial animals and plants, and this considered an irreversible negative impact.

 Impact Severity Rating

The magnitude of the impact will be major as there will be loss of vegetation and habitats of terrestrial

fauna within the project environment. The duration will be major as this is irreversible in spite of the

fact that there are plans to replace the lost natural vegetation by soft landscaping. The areal extent of

the impact will be minor as tree felling will be restricted to the project site. The sensitivity of the flora

and fauna components of the area is adjudged major.

 Impact Evaluation Discussion

Impacts on the biological resources through vegetation clearance and subsequent loss of terrestrial

biota will have moderate impact on the local ecology of the area. The duration will be minor as there

are plans to regenerate the lost vegetation.

5.5.5 Impacts on Waste Generation


The proposed development will generate large volume of wastes throughout its life span. Right from

the construction stage through the completion of the proposed development, large volume of both solid

and liquid wastes will be generated.

Composition of wastes to be generated however will depend largely on the stage of activities at which

they occur. During the construction stage, much of the wastes that will be generated will include

rubbles, packages, polythene products, sawn dust, etc. However, at the completion of the estate, aside

the human wastes that will be generated, garbage, waste paper and packages will also be generated.

Various wastes that will be generated at different stages of the project are given in Table 5.1.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 57


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Table 5.1: Anticipated Wastes to be generated.

Stage Associated Waste Waste Composition Dimension


Activities
Constructi - Site Clearing & Solid - Rubbles from the High magnitude
on Preparation Construction work. and short term.
- Soil - Food packages
densification consumed by workers.
- Excavation and - Cement and paint
Civil packages
Construction - Sawn wood/plank.
Works. - Construction materials.
Liquid - Human wastes (feaces Low magnitude and
urine, waste water) short term.
- Run off/waste water
from concrete mixing,
painting and civil
construction works.
Commenc Domestic Solid - Packages, waste paper High magnitude
ement of activities from the garbages, used and long term.
operation residents. containers, etc.
Liquid - Human waste - feaces, High magnitude
urine, waste water from and long term.
laundries, showers and
sinks.

 Impact Severity Rating

The magnitude of the impact will be minor given the fact that effective and proper waste management

plan will be put in place to curtail the anticipated effects. The duration of the impact will be moderate

as the occurrence of the impact will spread throughout the construction phase period. The areal extent

of the impact will be minor as construction activities will be consciously limited to the project site

environment.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 58


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

 Impact Evaluation Discussion

Impacts of waste generation through solid and liquid waste disposal will last throughout the duration of

the construction period and will have minor impacts on the project’s immediate environment. This

impact is classified as an adverse impact of minor significance.

5.5.6 Impacts on Socio-Economics

5.5.6.1 Impacts on Transportation

The main transportation impacts of the proposed project will be reflected in terms of increase in the

number of vehicular movement from the construction activities and residents of the apartments at

completion.

Primarily, transportation of materials and work force to the site will be by road thereby bringing about

increase in traffic. Increase in traffic may create an artificial congestion, potential delays, accident and

inconvenience for pedestrians and residents within the locality. The movements within and around the

project site will be every day of the week and apart from the traffic congestion, this could bring about

emission of pollutants.

Emission of Pollutants (noxious gases such as carbon monoxide (CO), hydrocarbons (HCs), sulphur

dioxide (SO2)) associated with movement of heavy duty equipment and vehicles will be generated and

dispersed into the atmosphere.

Emission of such contaminants is capable of damaging human health and so also animals and plants.

Apart from emissions from exhausts, the traffic situation could impose physiological and psychological

stresses on neighbours within the immediate vicinity of the site in addition to significant man-hour

losses in traffic.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 59


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

It is however of note that the anticipated traffic impacts on the environment is negligible, insignificant,

localized and reversible.

 Impact Severity Rating

The increased presence of heavy duty trucks associated with construction activities could cause traffic

build up in the area. Given the fact that the area is not yet built up, these activities would bring about

increase in the ambient noise level within the area. This scenario could lead to physiological disorder

on the site and off site workers in the project area. However, the magnitude of impact will be minor.

Traffic situation as observed during reconnaissance survey reveals that the additional vehicular traffic

that will be generated due to the project operation will be adequately accommodated considering the

existing and the proposed roads in the area. The duration of the impact will be major. The areal extent

will be minor.

 Impact Evaluation Discussion

Given the minor level of anticipated impacts on transportation and the sensitive human receptor, the

impact will persist for a long time. However, the overall effect of the project on the transportation

sensitivity of the project environment components is adjudged moderate (significance of the impact is

moderately adverse).

5.5.6.2 Impacts on Water and Electricity Consumption


High volume of water will be required daily within the scheme right from the construction stage

through the occupation of the scheme by prospective residents. The magnitude of anticipated activities

at completion of the scheme will require large volume of water daily so as to meet up with the demand

for domestic and other purposes.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 60


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

At completion of the project, a relatively large volume of water will be required on daily basis.

Therefore, the project would exert adverse impact on the public water reticulation which at the moment

not within the reach of the immediate environment of the project site.

Also, Electricity will be supplied to the proposed development at completion through the Power

Holdings Company of Nigeria (PHCN) facilities. Therefore, considering the magnitude of the project,

adequate electrical installations would be provided to meet the electricity demand of the project as

facilities on ground are not sufficient to cater for the electricity demand of the proposed development.

 Impact Severity Rating

The frequency of the impact will be major, as the impact will occur throughout the operation period.

The impact of increase in both water and electricity consumption will be minor as the project will make

provision for water and electrical facilities. The anticipated effect of water and electricity consumption

will be minor. The areal extent of the impact will be minor.

 Impact Evaluation Discussion

Impacts of water and electricity consumption as a result of OTESHADE VILLAGE EXCISION

layout will be minimal. Therefore, the anticipated impact on water and electricity is adjudged minor.

5.5.6.3 Infrastructure Developments


The project site is situated within a developing community near Jonaith Hotel, along Lekki-Epe

expressway, Eti-Osa Local Government Area, and as such lack sufficient infrastructural facilities. The

scheme, however, in its design concept provided opportunity for infrastructure development to enhance

quality of life of would be residents.

Anticipated infrastructural facilities of the proposed development will include well laid roads,

boreholes, electrical installations, recreational facilities among others. To this end, the scheme will

impact positively on the much needed infrastructural facilities within and around the project area.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 61


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

5.5.6.4 Housing Provision


Housing as a social phenomenon is essential to the survival of the human race. It is a known fact that

one of the problems facing highly urbanized community like Lagos is acute shortage of qualitative

housing units to provide shelter for the increasing population.

Therefore, the proposed OTESHADE VILLAGE EXCISION layout will, at completion increase the

number of housing units in the project area, and thus to a large extent address housing shortage both in

terms of quality and quantity in the area. This invariably would improve the housing stock within the

state and at the same time decongesting the metropolis.

5.5.6.5 Impacts on Employment


One of the positive impacts of the proposed development is the creation of employment opportunities.

It is estimated that the proposed development right from the inception till the maturity i.e. completion

of the project, will provide thousands of jobs for both skilled and unskilled workforce.

At inception, during the conceptual design, numbers of professionals will be engaged. These will cut

across architects, mechanical and electrical engineers, town planners, estate surveyors, land surveyors,

etc. Also, construction and post construction stage of the project will witness employment of lots of

artisans that will be engaged for one service or others.

The multiplier effect of the employment opportunities that will be created by the project will transcend

the engagement of just the work force, but to the economy development of Lagos State vis-à-vis the

increase in per capita income of the anticipated work force to be engaged, income tax to be paid, and

the enhanced standard of living of the engaged work force.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 62


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

5.5.6.6 Visual Appearance/Aesthetics


At completion, the proposed development will create an aesthetic view within the immediate

environment. The proposed estate provided with well laid out roads, articulated green areas, rows of

well finished buildings etc will at completion create a visually appealing view internally and externally

thereby bringing about an aesthetically pleasing environment.

5.5.6.7 Urban Developments


According to the United Nations, Lagos metropolis is the 6 th largest megacity in the world with an

estimated population of 15 million and an annual growth rate of 5.3%. To this end, Lagos metropolis

was proclaimed as having the highest rate of urbanization in the world.

This scenario has no doubt put pressure on the available infrastructural facilities in the State. Coupled

to this also, is the emergence of filthy settlement/developments to accommodate the ever growing

population in the State.

The proposed OTESHADE VILLAGE EXCISION layout will promote urban development of the

project site environment hitherto an under developed parcel of land, adequate provision to

accommodate the anticipated population as a result of the project has however been made. The

development, therefore, will ensure the emergence of urban settlement provided with the necessary

infrastructural facilities.

5.5.6.8 Revenue Generation


The proposed housing development is estimated to generate hundreds of millions of naira annually to

the coffers of various Government Agencies. This amount is outside the returns on investment to the

proponent of the development. The anticipated accruable revenue to government will include:-

 Personal income tax from employees to be engaged

 Company tax

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 63


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

 Value added tax

 Ground rent

 Development levies

 Infrastructural development charges

 Development permit fees

 Electricity and telephone bills etc.

It is important to note that beside hundreds of millions of naira directly accruable from the proposed

development, several millions of naira will also be made indirectly from the project from such sources

as:

 Expenses incurred by the people to be engaged as a result of increase in per capita

income

 Adverts rates

It is therefore imperative to state that the proposed development has a multiplier effect on the economy.

To this end, it is important to note that not only the Lagos State Government will benefit from the

proposed development, but also Federal Inland Revenue Services (FIRS), Power Holdings Company of

Nigeria (PHCN), Nigerian Customs Services, Lagos State Internal Revenue Services etc.

 Impacts Severity Rating

The magnitude of the impacts of the proposed development on socio-economic activities will be major

as the project is huge thereby generating a lot of employment opportunities, change in the present

urban landscape, provide housing, and potentially present a veritable source of internal revenue to the

local and state governments. The duration will be major as the project will go on for a long time. The

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 64


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

areal extent of the impact will be major as it will not be limited to the economy of the immediate

vicinity.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 65


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

 Impact Evaluation Discussion

Impacts on the local economy as a result of the impact of the proposed development on socio-

economic indicators will be moderate and so also the duration.

5.5.6.9 Impacts on Health and Safety


Project workers during the various construction activities will be exposed to loud noise levels

especially around operation area where heavy equipment and generating plants are being used. This

could cause long-term health effects such as hearing impairment. Similarly, workers could be exposed

to harmful levels of emissions from the various equipment and machinery that will be used for the

project which could lead to health effects on project workers.

 Impact Severity Rating

The magnitude of the impact will be minor given the fact that noise emission issues will be most

insignificant within 150m radius of the project location. Noise emissions will be reduced by distance

and diffusion into background noise levels. The duration of the impact will be moderate. The

frequency of the impact will be moderate, as the impact will spread throughout the construction

period. The areal extent of the impact will be minor. Noise will be limited to the immediate vicinity

(within a 50m radius) of the project site. Given the number of anticipated project personnel and the

duration (overall) of project activities, the impact on the sensitivity of the workforce is adjudged

minor.

 Impact Evaluation Discussion

The fact that the noise issues will be limited to only the immediate environment of the construction

area is an indication that the project is deemed to have a minor significance with regards to health

impacts of noise and air emissions.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 66


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

5.5.6.10 Public Safety and Security of Life and Property


The proposed development will bring about the loss of serenity pervading the project site as a result of

influx of people into the project site. This development could threaten the safety of residents in the

area as a result of uncontrolled movement of people in and out of the project site. Therefore, if adequate

security measures are not in place to monitor the movement and activities around the project site,

criminally minded people could make use of the opportunity of influx of people to the project site to

unleash terror in the area. Besides, the construction activities if not carried out with best practices could

also threaten the security and safety of workers on site.

 Impact Severity Rating

The magnitude of the impact will be minor. The duration of the impact will be minor. The frequency

of the impact will be moderate, as the impact will spread throughout the construction period. The areal

extent of the impact will be minor. Security of lives and properties will be limited to the immediate

vicinity of the project site. The impact is adjudged minor.

 Impact Evaluation Discussion

Impacts on the security of lives and properties as a result of the proposed development will be minimal

and limited only to the immediate environment of the project site.

5.5.6.11 Sewage treatment and disposal


Sewage generated by the proposed project will be collected and pumped to the wastewater treatment

plant. The construction of a dedicated sewage treatment facility for the development will ensure proper

treatment of effluents before being finally discharged. The potential long-term issue relates to improper

maintenance of the sewage collection and treatment system such that inadequately treated effluents

become discharged to the receiving water body. Improper disposal of sludge is also a potential issue.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 67


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

 Impact Severity Rating

The magnitude of the impact will be minor given the fact that effective and proper management of

effluents will be put in place to reduce to the barest minimum the effect of the impacts. The duration of

the impact will be major as the impacts will occur throughout the project life cycle. The frequency of

the impact will be major. The areal extent of the impact will be minor.

 Impact Evaluation Discussion

Impacts of sewage generation through waste water will last throughout the proposed development

lifetime. This will have major impacts on the project immediate environment if effluents are not

properly treated before being discharged. The impact is adjudged major.

To capture the anticipated impacts, magnitude, frequency, duration and areal extent of the possible

impacts of this project, summary matrixes of predicted impacts are presented in table 5.2 below.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 68


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Table 5.2: Summary Matrix of Predicted Impacts Due To Residential Development.


S/N Environmental Project activities & Nature of Impacts Magnitude of Impacts Duration & Areal
Components Sources of Impacts Extent of Impacts
Pre-construction Phase
1 Ambient Air -dust spread from site -reduction in visibility Minor and temporary Impacts will be confined to
Quality preparation -eye irritation negative short distances, as suspended
-emission of hazardous gases -difficulty to breath Impact. coarse particles will settle
from vehicle exhaust during within a short distance from
mobilization of men, activities venue.
equipment and materials.
2 Ambient Noise Noise generated from -raising of ambient Minor and negative Temporary impacts during
Level pre-construction activities like noise level leading to impact near noise pre-construction phase.
erection of sheds, storage hearing impairment. generation source Baseline noise level will be
facilities, site camps and within project area. within standards during this
operation of equipment No significant phase and will not extend
impact at sensitive beyond 150m radius from the
receptors project site.
6 Soils Pre-construction Activity such -Alteration of soil Insignificant negative Impacts are confined to short
as land preparation and structure and texture Impact on the soil distances.
clearing, deposition of debris -alteration of drainage structure and stability
& other waste. pattern
7 Ecology -Clearing of existing Habitat disturbance Minor negative Impacts are confined to short
(Flora and vegetation during pre-construction Impact distances.
Fauna) -displacement of existing activities
terrestrial animals
8 Socio- Increased job opportunities. -employment Overall positive Impacts will be beyond the
economy Economy related to opportunities Impact project area.
commercial, real estate -income generation
development, material supply
etc.
Traffic -Heavy duty Truck movement -increase traffic Minimum negative Impacts may be felt 300m
Pattern -movement of men and volume Impact radius of the project

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 69


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

materials -delay in movement


-site visitation by regulators. -traffic congestion

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 70


Construction Phase
1 Ambient Air -digging,
trenching & -reduction in visibility Minor negative Impacts are temporary during
Physical PlanningQuality
Technical Report
excavation of Commercial
activities -eyeand Residential Development
irritation Impacts inside construction phase. Impacts
leading to release of -pollution of air proposed project will be confined to short
particulate matter and dust -reduction in air premises and beyond distances, as suspended
amalgam into the quality the site. coarse particles will settle
environment. -difficulty to breath within a short distance from
-material handling activities venue.
-release of hazardous gases
and fumes (CO, NOx,,CO2 etc)
Operation & Maintenance Phase
from vehicles and equipment
S/N Environmental Project activities & Sources Nature of Impacts Magnitude of Duration & Areal Extent of
on site.
Components of Impacts Impacts Impacts
1 Ambient Air Particulate -pollution of ambient Minor negative Recurrent negative impact
2 Noise Noise generated from -raising of ambient Minor negative Temporary impacts during
Quality and gaseous air impact inside that will occur throughout the
construction activities, noise level leading to impact near noise construction phase. High
emissions from Diesel project site and operation & maintenance
movement of heavy duty hearing impairment, generation sources intensity noise activities e.g
Generator downwind of the phase. Impact will be felt
vehicles and operation of difficulty in sleeping inside premises. Piling activities envisaged.
sets development within 150m radius of the
construction equipment even during the day. No significant Baseline noise level will be
project premises.
impact at sensitive within standards during this
2 Noise Noise from -increase in ambient Minor negative Recurrent negative impact
receptors phase and will not extend
vehicle movement noise level impact inside & that will occur throughout the
beyond 150m radius from the
and operation of outside project area. operation &maintenance
project site.
diesel generator sets No significant impact phase. Noise level will be
3 Water quality - Surface runoff from project -pollution & Significant negative Impact will be within 150m,
during power failure. at sensitive receptors. within 120m from the source
site contamination of impact to surface water and will be temporary and
of noise.
- Improper waste & debris surrounding water quality as the site abuts localized during construction
3 Water -sewage and wastewater -pollution of water Minor negative Impacts on surface water will
disposal bodies. a surface water. period.
Quality generation sources Impact. be recurring and may go
- Discharge of sewage from -pollution of ground -Significant negative
-tapping of ground water as a -reduction of ground beyond 300m.
labour camp water through impact to ground water
source of water supply water quantity &
-Leakage and improper use of percolation & seepage. quality.
-disposal of solid waste into quality.
chemicals and fuel/oil.
lagoon.
4 Land use and Land -change in visuals of Minor negative Temporary impact that will
4 Soils Storage and disposal of solid -distortion in soil Minor negative impact Impacts are confined to short
Aesthetics Development the project Impact not be beyond 150m radius
and other wastes and composition, texture distances
environment from the project site.
handling of liquid chemicals and structure.
5 Topography -cutting, compaction, filling - No Significant Region is relatively flat and
- Pesticides Use -contamination of soil
and Geology and leveling. Impacts hence no impacts due to
and land surfaces.
topography.
6 Ecology -landscaping activities -beautification of the significant positive Impact will be felt within the
6 Soils Construction -alteration in soil Significant negative Impacts are confined within
(Flora and - natural re-vegetation site environment impact project site and immediate
Activity like trenching, texture and structure Impact on the soil site and may be permanent.
Fauna) environment
excavation, piling deposition pattern structure and stability
7 Socio-economy -provision of accommodation -positive socio- Overall positive Impacts will be profound and
of debris & other waste. -contamination of top
-employment opportunities economic impact Impact may go beyond the borders of
& subsoil
Nigeria.
-removal of soil
Contemporary
8 Consultants
Traffic Group Ltd.
Generation of trips and -increase
fertility in traffic significant negative Page 71
Increase in traffic level within
Pattern parking needs volume Impact 500m radius of the site.
Decommissioning Stage
Physical S/N Environmental
Planning Project activities & Commercial
Technical Report Sources Nature
andofResidential
Impacts Development
Magnitude of Duration & Areal Extent of
Components of Impacts Impacts Impacts
1 Ambient Air -emission of dust from -reduction in visibility Minor negative Impacts are temporary during
Quality demolition activities. -eye irritation impact inside decommissioning phase.
-pollution of air proposed project Impacts will be confined to
-reduction in air quality premises and outside short distances, as coarse
-difficulty to breath the site. particles will settle within
short distance from activities
area.
2 Noise Noise generated from -raising of ambient Minor negative Temporary impacts during
demolition activities and noise level leading to impact near noise demolition phase. Baseline
operation of hearing impairment, generation sources noise level will be within
demolition equipment difficulty in sleeping inside premises. standards during demolition
even during the day. No significant phase.
impact on ambient
noise levels at
sensitive receptors
3 Water quality -Surface runoff from project -pollution & Minor negative Impact will be temporary and
site. contamination of water impact as there is will be much localized during
- Improper debris disposal body. surface water near the demolition period.
5.6 -Leakage of chemicals and -pollution of ground development.
fuel/oil. water through -Minor impact to
percolation & seepage. ground water quality
4 Land use and Land -change in visuals of Land availability Impact will be within 150m
Aesthetics Reclamation the project environment radius.
6 Soils Demolition - Minor negative Impacts are confined to short
Activities like dismantling Impact distances.
etc
7 Ecology (Flora Habitat disturbance during -alteration in soil Minor negative Impacts will be within the
and Fauna) demolition activity texture and structure Impact decommissioning area.
pattern
8 Socio-economy Job opportunity. -boost in employment Overall positive Impacts will be beyond the
. opportunities Impact project area.
-skill acquisition
-exposure to modern
and best practices
Traffic -Heavy duty Truck -increase in vehicular Minimum negative The site is in a developed area
Pattern movement volume Impact which may cause congestion
-movement of men and -difficulty in vehicular and increase in movement
materials movement arising from time. Impacts will not go
Contemporary Consultants Group
-site Ltd.
visitation by regulators. wrong parking, beyond 300m radius of the Page 72
obstruction etc. activity area.
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Impacts Rating

Rating of the anticipated environmental impacts of the proposed OTESHADE VILLAGE EXCISION is carried out using a

checklist method based on the following criteria:

Score Nature of Impact

0 Negative Impact/High Magnitude.

1 Negative Impact/Low Magnitude

2 Neutral Impact.

3 Positive Impact/Low Magnitude.

4 Positive Impact/High Magnitude.

Rating
Below 40%: Not Acceptable.

41% - 60%: Critical Considerations.

61% and above: Acceptable.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 73


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Table 5.3: Impact rating


Potential Impact Negative Positive
Low High Neutral Low High
Air pollution. 2
Noise impact. 2
Water pollution. 1
Soil erosion and degradation. 1
Influx of temporary residents/fun seekers. 2
Land Use Compatibility 3
Employment opportunities. 4
Living Environment 4
Investment opportunities 4
Traffic generation 2
Existing road facilities. 3
Inner city decongestion 3
Recreational facilities. 4
Provision of Housing 4
Property appreciation. 4
Revenue generation. 4
Safety and Security of Life. 3
Health Impact. 3
Solid Waste Generation. 0
Liquid Waste Generation 0
Utilities/infrastructure development 4
Aesthetics. 4
Flora. 0
Fauna. 0
2 - 8 15 36

Total = 61

Score of the Proposal x 100


Marks Obtainable 1

= 61 x 100
96 1

≈ 63.5%

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 74


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

From the foregoing, the proposed development scores 61 from the total obtainable score of 96 in the

rating of its anticipated impact on the environment. This indicates therefore that the proposed

development has an approximate of 63.5% for its total rating on its possible positive impacts on the

environment.

From the analysis given above, the proposed development will impact both on the immediate and

farther environments positively, and thus make it acceptable.

5.7 Impact Mitigation


This section of the study proffers mitigation measures on the earlier identified impacts due to the

proposed project. Detailed plan of activities intended at reducing or totally eliminating the identified

negative impacts of the project on the environment are therefore enumerated. This, however, will be

carried out in the phases of the project development as stated in Table 5.4.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 75


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Table 5.4: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures

Preconstruction Phase
Environmental Summary of Impact Mitigation measures
Component
Ambient Air Pollution i. Making sure that the vehicles are in good condition to reduce gas
Quality emission
ii. Periodically watering the project area especially during the dry
season to keep the dust level down.
Ambient Noise Increase in noise level i. Use of well-maintained vehicles and equipment fitted with silencers.
Level
Soils Distortion in soil Pre-construction debris will be collected and suitably placed, used on
structure and texture/ site or disposed properly.
contamination
Ecology Depletion of flora, i. Hunting and fishing activities by workers should be controlled or
(Flora and Fauna) depletion and discouraged.
displacement of fauna ii. Rapid and aggressive re-vegetation will be carried out to replace
(terrestrial & aquatic) lost vegetations.
Traffic Pattern Congestion and traffic (i) The construction contractor will provide additional traffic control
obstruction wardens around the project site.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 76


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Construction Phase
Environmental Summary of Impact Mitigation measures
Component
Ambient Air Ambient air pollution i. Making sure that the vehicles are in good condition to reduce
Quality gas emission
ii. Periodically watering the project area especially during the
dry season to keep the dust level down.
iii. Slowing down the vehicles carrying the construction
materials within the built up areas.
iv. Properly wrapping the material truck container with plastic
cover to avoid dust spreads and other materials during the
mobilization.
v. Establishment of load limit of trucks to avoid over loading.
vi. Providing and using the safety equipment such as nose
mask, noise cover for employees who work near the dusty
location such as the heavy equipment operator, etc.
vi. Optimization of working schedule and work to help
minimize several material vehicle mobilization trips.
vii. Implement an Effective Journey Management
System.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 77


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Noise Increase in ambient I. Use of well-maintained


noise level Equipment fitted with silencers.
ii. Providing noise shields near the
heavy construction operations

Water i.Pollution and (i) Storage floors will be made of concrete.


resources contamination of (ii) Proper drainage of project site and immediate environment
i. Surface water water sources.
(iii)Drainage from warehouse/storage locations is collected
ii. Ground water ii.Reduction in the
ground water quantity. separately with trap for oil or fuels.
(iv)Solid waste such as oil-filters, metals and tires, etc, will be
stored in a designated place to be sold or recycled by a third
party.
(v) Prevented of oil spills from getting into the water body.
(vi) Sewage and waste water from labour camp on site must be
properly treated to meet LASEPA tertiary effluent discharge
standard before discharge into receiving water body.
(vii) A wastewater channel from the site would be connected
to the septic tank
(viii) Borehole for water supply should be properly done to
avoid geological distortion.

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 78


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Ambient Air Ambient air pollution vi. Optimization of working schedule and work to help
Quality minimize several material vehicle mobilization trips.
vii. Implement an Effective Journey Management System
Plan.

Noise Increase in ambient i. Use of well-maintained equipment fitted with silencers.


noise level ii. Providing noise shields near the heavy construction
operations
iii. De-commissioning activities will be limited to daytime
hours only.
Water i.Pollution and (i) Storage floors will be made of concrete.
resources contamination of (ii) Proper drainage of project site and immediate environment
i. Surface water water sources. (iii)Drainage from Storage locations is collected separately
ii. Ground water ii.reduction in the with trap for oil or fuels.
ground water quantity. (iv)Solid waste such as oil-filters, metals and tires, etc, will be
stored in a designated place to be sold or recycled by a third
party.
(v)Oil or fuel spills will be prevented from getting into the
water body.
(vi) Sewage and waste water from labour camp on site must be
properly treated to meet LASEPA tertiary effluent discharge
standard before discharge into receiving water body which
abuts the site southward.
(vii) A wastewater channel from the site would be connected
to the septic tank

Contemporary Geological
Consultantsand
Groupi.Ltd.
Distortion in soil i. Appropriate drainage will be built to accommodate the Page 79
surface water movement from the rain and wind.
Soil texture & structure
Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

6.0 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION

Over the past years, Lagos State Government has put in place various measures to ensure the provision
of adequate housing units for her teeming population. It is of note that as much as the government’s
program on housing is on-going, for Commercial and Residential Developments development, so also,
the right of the natives to the inheritance of their fatherland is being regarded in Lagos state by the
Lagos state government.

It is imperative to note that the State Government’s policy on Housing/Estate development has gone a
long way to encourage private partnership initiatives at the delivery of exclusive commercial and
residential developments within Lagos metropolis. In the last 20 years, various schemes, and
Commercial and Residential Developments have emerged also in the state to decongest the metropolis,
and thereby stimulating rapid development of the suburbs.

It is in view of this that one cannot but appreciates the efforts of the state government through her
policies and programs. However, these are not expected to default the statutory provisions guiding
development proposals in the State to ensure sustainable development within the totality of the built
environment.
For this project development, due to the sub-soil investigation, it is highly recommended in the soil test
report that where deep foundation (non-displacement pile) is considered, it should terminate at about
the depth of 28m.

This, inter alia, obtains as one of the numerous precautions to notice in view of proper construction
supervision. The success and sustainability of this project begins with paying attention to preliminary
site preparations, the details of engineering interventions in view of site’s peculiarities and government
policies, as concerned best practices.

In conclusion, it is imperative to state that the proposed scheme has been evaluated, and thus adjudged
to conform to the applicable regulations guiding layout approval in the State. Lastly, the proposed
Commercial and Residential Development, rather than exerting adverse impacts on both its immediate
and farther environments, will serve as a complement to the emerging developments within the axis. In

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 80


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

view of this, the proposed private residential scheme is therefore recommended for Lagos state
government approval through her agencies.

APPENDIX 1
The Proposed OTESHADE VILLAGE EXCISION DEVELOPMENT PLAN

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 81


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 82


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

APPENDIX II
Proposed OTESHADE VILLAGE EXCISION Development Plan
Showing on Satellite Image Data

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 83


Physical Planning Technical Report Commercial and Residential Development

Contemporary Consultants Group Ltd. Page 84

You might also like