Wcanrrersru: 6650 Bingle Road Houston, Texas ' 1 1 0 9 2
Wcanrrersru: 6650 Bingle Road Houston, Texas ' 1 1 0 9 2
Wcanrrersru: 6650 Bingle Road Houston, Texas ' 1 1 0 9 2
Septenrber 15,201A To l{hclm It lvlay Concem: From: Brarrdy N. Iones, Marrufacturing Errgineerhrg.
and solenoid part Pleasereview frndings in the attached document regarding FPF-# 22631.4 rtunrber 2232cn-$. Executive Surnmarv: FPP.# 226314 Description Of Failure: .DURING PILOT LINE TESTING THEPODS, HADA STRONG OF WE PULSATION THEPILOT OF L]NE TI-IE SOLENOID PRESSURE NINEFUNCTIONS. REPL.ACED ASSOC]ATED ON WE VALVES ANDTHE TESTING TIIEFAULTY OF RJLSATION WENTAWAY. UPON FURTHER BENCH SOLENOID VALVES A PULSING SOUND COULD HEARD FROM INSIDE THEVALVE. THERE VALVES TOTAL 9 IN DISTINCT BE 8 YELLOW SECTION. ONE BLUE MUX OFFTHE MUX AND OFFTHE SECTION" Actions Taken: 1. 2, 3. Blue andYellow Pod'sarrivedto BingleFacility. solenoids were unplugged All from thelr pie connectors. Idntlfid solnold 23 valvesfroma comparlson original of setoutsto th currentMUX. In an effortto determinewhichsolenoids wer pulsating the rig we performed following on th tests usingtest procedure X-065393-05: A. Electrical: Resistance Test B, Electrical: InsulationTest c. Electrical: voltege, & Dropout voltage) Function Test: (Pull-in D, Hydraulic Function Testwith singlActivatedcoil,with Both Activated coils After performing tests A- D, the coilterminationpoints were inspected, Additional verification tests performed. Presented results customer, to Engineering recommendations Rig. to
4, 5. 6. 7.
Summary Tcst/Insocction Rcsults; tSee :tppendix for e sunmary chert of test/inspectionresrlts.* A. Electrical: Resistance Test B. Electrical: InsulationTest : 1 Failure C. Electrical: Function Voltage, DropOutVoltage):1 Failure Testi (Pull-in & D. Hydraulic Function Testwith Single ActivatedCoil,Both ActivatedCoils:11 Passed, 12 Failed Coil Termination Prints Inspcction: . 7 of the nineteen polarity, on coil B pins 3 and 4. solenoidshadwires crossed,reversed Specifically, the white rvire was solderedto 4 and the blmk wire soldettd to 3. . 6 ofthe sevensolenoidswith reversd polarity failed the leak test. ' F.A"T. results show (no pressurcsignalt'whcn both coilr werc energizcd,however per{ormed ptpedy with a singleactivatcd coil ' Ottly lofthe nvo solenoids that failed the electrical testhad reversed polarity.
HishlyConfidential
5 (as
Exhibit No.
WorldwideCourt
Inc.
Additional Notes: ' 4 of lhe twenty-three identlfldsolenoids were plugged Intothe ortginal# 11 pieconnector, which were idntifid usingsolnoid location and the pi chart.Thesee-connectors were snipped off and sent to Seacon analysis, leaktest was performed thes prior, but not a coil for A on termlnation inspection. connector 11 was alsosentto seacon. Pie # Seacon going perform is to an analysis reason failure possibly to the overuse greaseon the wrongarea. for of due of Results from Seaconare pending. 'The remaining (19) solenoids pointsinsoected. weretested and their coiltermination . Furthertear down of the falledvalves polaritywas not requested. withoutthe reverse In an effort to prove the effect of a solenoid with rcverse potarit-v tretwercnthe two coils on its lunction the following &{tions were tflken: l. 2. 3. 4. Pulleda newsolenoidfromstock. Reversedthe polarity on coil B switching wires 3 iurd 4. Spccificrlly, the wtrite wirc was solderedto pin 4 and the black wire solderedto pin 3. Performed hydraillic fiuction test with Single Activaled coil. Both Coil A arrdCoil B firnctioned properly. Pefornted hydtaulic ftrnction testwith both coils activatedResult: Pressure droppedto 0 psig after 2 seconds ofholding pressure. Solenoidrvasin a "locked" position rvith 0 psig.
The above test proves revene polarity betweencoil A:urd coil B resultsintwo different magnetichelds rvlilchcancel eachother oul. In order to simulate field conditions anrl the alfects ol'a solenoidrvith reverse polaritl, we hoohed the $olenoidup to a Mark II Sf,M with the following results: Rewlts: Coil A Activated: Good Coil B Activated: Good Coil A and B Activated: The pulsaling sound rcported in the field vas heartl. Putl in and <lrop out voltrgc switching quicldp Conclusion: It is evident ttrat reversepolarity between Coil A and Coil B in a 223291)43solenoid valve will not allow tt to properly fimction withboth coils energized.Reversing the polarity crea-tes opposilg rnagneticfields rvith acancehng affect. It is vital to check function with both coils activated. This step is in the solenoid test focedure X-065393{5, ard was in the proceduredLring the assemblyand testing time of the solercids on the DrillMax 2 SparePods. In additio4 the power saving soffware installed on the SEM plays a vibl role iu producing the pulsation in a solenoidwith reverse polarity. It is possible this did not shorv up on out valve test stand at fir$ passbecausethosesolenoids are fad a consant 24V. Corrrctive Action: Solenoid valves,223290{3, ;ue sold individually as sparesand also as part of an upper level. Therefore, the most appropriate conctive action is to identi$ my solenoid fallures or reversed polarity vrfule the \alve is still in productiotl prior to shipping or POD F.A.T. After reviewing the assernblyand test procedure, X-065393-05for Cameronsolenoid ralves au ESR, engineering service request, be sent to rvill engineering requesting the changesbelow. l. Section 6.2: FunctionTest tvith Both Activated Coils, ard Sectim 6.3 Function Testwith One Activated Coit do not luve an amcl)ed appendix clu"rt t0 record rcsults otl A requestwill be nude to add in appendix for the testersto record and review their renrlts. Section 6.2; FunctionTest lvith BothActivated Coils shouldhaveinstructionsto watch for a drop in pressure to 0 PSI. If this happens,it is likety that the solenoidhas re"ersed polarity so the coil tcrmination poinb stronld bc chcckcd.
2.
Highly Confidential
cAM_ClV_0374341
of of moreaware tlr imDor&mce coil the requested make valveroonrtochnicians will Thechrnges
polarity.
confidential Highly
tnterim Instmction$ the Rig: to Theseinstructions weresentto the rig for an interim testing sorution. September 10,2010 SubjeclFieldSolenoid ValveTest Refereuce: pie Cameron SK-122178-62 connector doc: chart This procedure to verifv correctoperations solenoid is of coilsfor eachfunction. Botlt coils uA",and"8" for eachfinction mustbe operated together determine to oorst operation. Steps: 1. 2. 3. I. 5. 6. Rcmovc powcrfrompods pong anddiscomect Openup bleeder hoss from directpild funclions. Tum power backon to ALL SEMS (BlueA, BlueB, yellw A & yellow B) Perfonn firnction tests bothpods for usingsK- 122 7962pi connector I chart. Allow function stayir theenergized for a mitirnumof30 seconds. to state Venteach function erfter 30second before the hold going nextfirnction. to NOTE: Whilefiring eachPodfunction observe a stead5r that streamof hydraulic ffuid flows from port. eachbleeder Thereshould NO oscillations pulsirqof solenoids, be or Closebteeder ports,andreconnect directpilot hoses aftereachfirnctionhasbeen terifi.ed. 1. Switchto oppmitePOD, andperform abovesteps, the Jasorr Lue Van Manager Field Service Camcron Dri.llingSystcms
HighlyConfidential
cAM_CrV_o374343
Appendix
confidentid Hishty
i 1t?9td8524i
1'1rJAJ.lg3ltttl6
Eothcoiisa:th*sC
Pin # -1 cni 4lrfl'.u rei'irsEd
*ignsl
:
:
r'l109St0f2-?3
i'l 1|]99F$I?-0S
'l1tjS5;"11[rt1
1!099fE_{:-96 111bi8161+l 1r!6!1:3S3: I i 11516161-F.i ;i115i816145 :1116t113> ! 118896852-t5 Spai! rrot ci*rp o:.chrng naorp,'p$ 3, 6ogCesrulition.llp s,iqns ur.ch cf
HighlyGonfidential
CAM_CtV_0374345
B.
Ilydrirulic F.A.T Results * iad valves denoted rvith a letter '6Sttinclicates a valve with n switched polarity.
L?
O /-\
h
A
tl\\dtvzt/g
Highlyconfidential
cAM_CrV_0374346
C. Electrical TestResults
CAMERON
{}ti Piata
lorll t&,
Flt{ao. tdt
{.'4id
fie)
u!,71(gsa-48 qryPlbt"/vl
!ll
I
t,t-t.s:Lytbt.0
/owLg4i^,
'lia'l##iA
ltnqqhF.;sa-,|^
qt^gc\
.I:
-lr.
*__-_*j
LUJ"rfLLil:tl ttl\XqqqTh-riL
!.2!.tn
lmLl5f-0\
.?ta
N
tEcgtn
t6A.
I fr.rsr hnbrl'5 I
t.r
| ?rl
HighlyConfidential
CAM_ClV_03721i147
cAMEnOil
{Gontinued) App$itix Z - TestProtocols
IiBihd
LJ3lfta (c!tq
Fff ({tat
lmffiiAsFBnd fd3*b.Qi
H
lmdihR.*.& (c.xl&onQ
Pqt!t (fN)
a{s
ada
krl
lr{143
g!
qb tl.g. L.ta.6
LlL
qqC^d
2Ltl
-s{
.Jrt,3
L|0. t)
1q.a lq
\.?
un7
40.A
no13.
qqq
(n^u
'\4,1t 4t r.lrt I
l
{n.}.
11q
Ll
W
ffa --l{L
1:t
33.
Qk!--L,, d,L=1.-,.
" 1
ua. -.fi?
qn.l
'u6 1
Jl11*
t.l0
1tq
qql
4.irl tcq
9Qe
ffi
qgl
O
-e091 --&a
_3tq I lg_
--!D,L
+ff,
-9._,i3 q.iq
9.ln
qcq
LA_
_*1L.
4n,^
u..D.l
_40r.
8.:_
n
..i8,t. LtA.L
ut! I
146
t l,L
Ri-
o 94q 191?1_,
cn
--&l'l
d'd@dd,rteD!, ;,:..1-c^\,fu.--"-d;.r---dd,:d!!
w@.*p
tu;i;;;#" !! i.d$rik&J
J"o'us**t
-r'drrd'
d':Mrlsstrrff
r\
d4'db
.,llfrtdll:rN3Bsj1lr-00'800'l@-so'0bq?gail
confidential Hishly
cAM_CtV_0374348
CAMERO,N
----'-f*$gg-..''s---..!reaaii,b-h-h:r I Yr::^S,k*nt.el-.V.alae--*
d#i &turrb
brti&!q,rtr4!51drdaf jfr*Fi46dIriEfr.:dhtbrud.r
4|warril
HighlyConfidential
cAM-crv-'3 r434s