Book Review A TALE OF TWO CITIES
Book Review A TALE OF TWO CITIES
Book Review A TALE OF TWO CITIES
Overview:
Published in 1859, A Tale of Two Cities is one of Charles Dickens' most iconic novels.
Although I have seen screen adaptations of Oliver Twist and A Christmas Carol before, A
Tale of Two Cities was the first of Charles Dickens’ novels I’ve read. I was not
disappointed. A Tale of Two Cities is a beautiful story of two lovers and their circle of loyal
friends and family in the time of the French Revolution. There is a diverse cast of characters
from varying classes, ages, professions and ideologies across two nations. Although the
maiden Lucie, her father Dr Manette, and her husband Charles Darnay, are the central
characters of the plot, the narrative sweeps back and forth between Paris and London, from
character to character, giving you an intimate feel for the diversity of people’s experiences
and lives in the world of the 1760s to 1790s.
The most extraordinary and captivating character’s story is of course the story of Dr Manette,
who was imprisoned for 18 years in the Bastille and close to lost his mind in the process. His
character’s arc, from the lowest of lows to the highest of highs (and, briefly, rapidly down
again), is the most satisfyingly plotted in the novel. Other characters won my heart in their
several ways, most of all the heroic Sydney Carton but also the wonderful pantomime villain,
the terrifying Madame Defarge. Some characters, though, could have done with being given
more attention and development, such as Barsad and Cly.
The book also evokes its setting in the time of the French Revolution quite expressively. It
exposes the injustices and outrages of the ancien régime, and then lays bare the horrors of the
French Revolution and its bloody, fevered Reign of Terror. A roguish Revolutionary Tribunal
condemns scores of the denounced to the Guillotine daily. Drunken, liberated Citizens dance
the frenzied Carmagnole through the streets of Republican Paris. The cream of the
overthrown nobility—gentle men, women and children—are corralled in La Force Prison like
cattle awaiting slaughter.
It’s a simplistic, picture book representation of the pre- and post-Revolutionary conditions in
France, but it’s what the story calls for—A Tale of Two Cities is, after all, basically a
Victorian YA novel penned by a consummate writer and storyteller, not a serious work of
literature.
My only criticisms of the book would be that the dialogue of some of the characters is
somewhat contrived and unrealistic, although this is forgivable in pre-modern, Victorian
literature. The Second Book (of three) also drags a bit, but the Third Book (which includes
the storming of the Bastille and Darnay’s imprisonment and trial) more than makes up for it.
I was not ready for it, I was not expecting it, but the final line of the book is one of the most
powerful and moving I’ve read in any book: “It is a far, far better thing that I do than I have
ever done; it is a far, far better rest that I go to than I have ever known.” Those who’ve read
the book know. As the climax of the events leading up to that line, and as the climax of the
arc of the character who spoke it, it just hits the right spot. Since I finished the book yesterday
I’ve been reciting it over and over in my head, so perfect it was. The perfect, if tragic, ending
to a wonderful story.